|
--- |
|
license: cc-by-4.0 |
|
task_categories: |
|
- text-classification |
|
language: |
|
- en |
|
tags: |
|
- SDQP |
|
- scholarly |
|
- citation_count_prediction |
|
- review_score_prediction |
|
dataset_info: |
|
features: |
|
- name: paperhash |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: s2_corpus_id |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: arxiv_id |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: title |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: abstract |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: authors |
|
sequence: |
|
- name: name |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: affiliation |
|
struct: |
|
- name: laboratory |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: institution |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: location |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: summary |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: field_of_study |
|
sequence: string |
|
- name: venue |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: publication_date |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: n_references |
|
dtype: int32 |
|
- name: n_citations |
|
dtype: int32 |
|
- name: n_influential_citations |
|
dtype: int32 |
|
- name: introduction |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: background |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: methodology |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: experiments_results |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: conclusion |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: full_text |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: decision |
|
dtype: bool |
|
- name: decision_text |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: reviews |
|
sequence: |
|
- name: review_id |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: review |
|
struct: |
|
- name: title |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: paper_summary |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: main_review |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: strength_weakness |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: questions |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: limitations |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: review_summary |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: score |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: confidence |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: novelty |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: correctness |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: clarity |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: impact |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: reproducibility |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: ethics |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: comments |
|
sequence: |
|
- name: title |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: comment |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: references |
|
sequence: |
|
- name: paperhash |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: title |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: abstract |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: authors |
|
sequence: |
|
- name: name |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: affiliation |
|
struct: |
|
- name: laboratory |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: institution |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: location |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: arxiv_id |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: s2_corpus_id |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: intents |
|
sequence: string |
|
- name: isInfluential |
|
dtype: bool |
|
- name: hypothesis |
|
dtype: string |
|
- name: month_since_publication |
|
dtype: int32 |
|
- name: avg_citations_per_month |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_score |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_confidence |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_novelty |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_correctness |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_clarity |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_impact |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: mean_reproducibility |
|
dtype: float32 |
|
- name: openreview_submission_id |
|
dtype: string |
|
splits: |
|
- name: acl_ocl_train |
|
num_bytes: 2553475339 |
|
num_examples: 42060 |
|
- name: acl_ocl_validation |
|
num_bytes: 805703352 |
|
num_examples: 9013 |
|
- name: acl_ocl_test |
|
num_bytes: 806719943 |
|
num_examples: 9014 |
|
download_size: 2084737209 |
|
dataset_size: 4165898634 |
|
configs: |
|
- config_name: acl_ocl |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/acl_ocl_train-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/acl_ocl_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/acl_ocl_test-* |
|
- config_name: openreview-full |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/openreview_full_training-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/openreview_full_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/openreview_full_test-* |
|
- config_name: openreview-iclr |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/iclr_training-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/iclr_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/iclr_test |
|
- config_name: default |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/iclr_training-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/iclr_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/iclr_test-* |
|
- config_name: openreview-iclr |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/iclr_training-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/iclr_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/iclr_test-* |
|
- config_name: openreview-neurips |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/neurips_training-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/neurips_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/neurips_test-* |
|
- config_name: openreview-public |
|
data_files: |
|
- split: train |
|
path: data/openreview_public_train-* |
|
- split: validation |
|
path: data/openreview_public_validation-* |
|
- split: test |
|
path: data/openreview_public_test-* |
|
--- |
|
|
|
Datasets related to the task of Scholarly Document Quality Prediction (SDQP). |
|
Each sample is an academic paper for which either the citation count or the review score can be predicted (depending on availability). |
|
|
|
|
|
## ACL-OCL Extended |
|
A dataset for citation count prediction only, based on the [ACL-OCL dataset](https://huggingface.co/datasets/WINGNUS/ACL-OCL/tree/main). |
|
Extended with updated citation counts, references and annotated research hypothesis |
|
|
|
## OpenReview (Last Update: 1.1.2025) |
|
A dataset for review score and citation count prediction, obtained by parsing OpenReview. |
|
Due to licensing the dataset comes in different formats: |
|
|
|
### Datasets without parsed pdfs of submissions (i.e. the fields introduction, background, methodology, experiments_results, conclusion, full_text are available) |
|
1. **openreview-public**: Contains full information on all OpenReview submissions that are accompanied with a CC BY 4.0 license. |
|
|
|
### Datasets without parsed pdfs of submissions (i.e. the fields introduction, background, methodology, experiments_results, conclusion, full_text are None) |
|
1. **openreview-full**: Contains all OpenReview submissions, splits generated based on publications dates. |
|
2. **openreview-iclr**: All ICLR submissions from the years 2018-2023 (training) and 2024 (validation and training). |
|
3. **openreview-neurips**: All NeurIPS submissions from the years 2021-2023 (training) and 2024 (validation and training). |
|
|
|
All datasets without parsed pdfs of submissions can be completed by running code available [here](https://github.com/NikeHop/automatic_scientific_quality_metrics) |
|
|
|
### Overview of Dataset columns |
|
|
|
| Attribute | Type | Explanation | |
|
|--------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------| |
|
| **Basic Paper Info** | | | |
|
| `title` | `str` | The title of the paper. | |
|
| `authors` | `list[Author]` | A list of authors of the paper. | |
|
| `abstract` | `str \| None` | The abstract of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `summary` | `str \| None` | A summary of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `month_since_publication`| `int \| None` | Month passed since the publication date (optional) | |
|
| `publication_date` | `str \| None` | The publication date of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `field_of_study` | `list[str] \| None` | The field(s) of study the paper belongs to (optional). | |
|
| `venue` | `str \| None` | The venue where the paper was published (optional). | |
|
| **ID's** | | | |
|
| `paperhash` | `str` | A unique hash identifier for the paper. (last_name_first_author\|title\|venue)| | |
|
| `arxiv_id` | `str \| None` | The arXiv ID of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `s2_corpus_id` | `str \| None` | The Semantic Scholar (S2) corpus ID of the paper (optional). | |
|
| **Semantic Scholar Metadata** | | | |
|
| `n_references` | `int \| None` | The number of references in the paper (optional). | |
|
| `n_citations` | `int \| None` | The number of citations the paper has received, only accepted papers (optional). | |
|
| `n_influential_citations`| `int \| None` | The number of influential citations the paper has received, only accepted papers (optional). | |
|
| `external_ids` | `dict \| None` | External IDs associated with the paper (optional). | |
|
| **Content** | | | |
|
| `introduction` | `str \| None` | Introduction of the paper if available (optional) | |
|
| `background` | `str \| None` | Background of the paper if available (optional) | |
|
| `methodology` | `str \| None` | Methodology of the paper if available (optional) | |
|
| `experiments_results` | `str \| None` | Experiments & Results of the paper if available (optional) | |
|
| `conclusion` | `str \| None` | Conclusion of the paper if available (optional) | |
|
| `full_text` | `str \| None` | Full text of the paper if available (optional) | |
|
| **Review Data** | | | |
|
| `decision` | `bool \| None` | The decision on the paper (e.g., accepted/rejected) (optional). | |
|
| `decision_text` | `str \| None` | The text explaining the decision (optional). | |
|
| `reviews` | `list[Review] \| None` | A list of reviews for the paper (optional). | |
|
| `comments` | `list[Comment] \| None` | A list of comments on the paper (optional). | |
|
| **Scores** | | | |
|
| `mean_score` | `float \| None` | The mean overall score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `mean_novelty` | `float \| None` | The mean novelty score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `mean_confidence` | `float \| None` | The mean confidence score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `mean_correctness` | `float \| None` | The mean correctness score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `mean_clarity` | `float \| None` | The mean clarity score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `mean_impact` | `float \| None` | The mean impact score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `mean_reproducibility` | `float \| None` | The mean reproducibility score of the reviews (optional) | |
|
| `avg_citations_per_month`| `float \| None` | The average number of citations per month | |
|
| **References** | | | |
|
| `references` | `list[Reference] \| None` | A list of references cited in the paper (optional). | |
|
| **Hypothesis** | | | |
|
| `hypothesis` | `str \| None` | The hypothesis proposed in the paper annotated via an LLM (optional). |
|
|
|
|
|
The attributes of Author, Review, Comment, Reference are the following: |
|
|
|
### Review |
|
|
|
| Attribute | Type | Explanation | |
|
|--------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------| |
|
| `review_id` | `str` | A unique identifier for the review. | |
|
| `review` | `TextReview` | The content of the review, represented by the `TextReview` model. | |
|
| `score` | `float \| None` | The overall score given by the reviewer (optional). | |
|
| `confidence` | `float \| None` | The reviewer's confidence in their assessment (optional). | |
|
| `novelty` | `float \| None` | The novelty score of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `correctness` | `float \| None` | The correctness score of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `clarity` | `float \| None` | The clarity score of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `impact` | `float \| None` | The impact score of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `reproducibility` | `float \| None` | The reproducibility score of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `ethics` | `str \| None` | Ethical considerations noted by the reviewer (optional). | |
|
|
|
### TextReview |
|
|
|
| Attribute | Type | Explanation | |
|
|--------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------| |
|
| `title` | `str \| None` | The title of the review (optional). | |
|
| `paper_summary` | `str \| None` | A summary of the paper being reviewed (optional). | |
|
| `main_review` | `str \| None` | The main content of the review (optional). | |
|
| `strength_weakness` | `str \| None` | A section discussing the strengths and weaknesses of the paper (optional). | |
|
| `questions` | `str \| None` | Questions raised by the reviewer (optional). | |
|
| `limitations` | `str \| None` | Limitations of the paper as noted by the reviewer (optional). | |
|
| `review_summary` | `str \| None` | A summary of the review (optional). | |
|
|
|
### Comment |
|
|
|
| Attribute | Type | Explanation | |
|
|--------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------| |
|
| `title` | `str \| None` | The title of the comment (optional). | |
|
| `comment` | `str` | The content of the comment. | |
|
|
|
### Reference |
|
|
|
| Attribute | Type | Explanation | |
|
|--------------------------|-------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------| |
|
| **Basic Paper Info** | | | |
|
| `title` | `str` | The title of the referenced paper. | |
|
| `abstract` | `str` | The abstract of the referenced paper (default is an empty string). | |
|
| `authors` | `list[str]` | A list of authors of the referenced paper. | |
|
| **IDs** | | | |
|
| `paperhash` | `str` | Paperhash for the reference paper (first_author_last_name\|title) | |
|
| `arxiv_id` | `str \| None` | The arXiv ID of the referenced paper (optional, default is an empty string).| |
|
| `s2_corpus_id` | `str \| None` | The Semantic Scholar (S2) corpus ID of the referenced paper (optional, default is an empty string). | |
|
| **Reference Specific Info** | | | |
|
| `intents` | `list[str] \| None` | The intents or purposes of the reference (optional). | |
|
| `isInfluential` | `bool \| None` | Indicates whether the reference is influential (optional). | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
