id
stringlengths
16
27
vector
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
$meta
stringlengths
239
38.7k
10.1101/19013474
[ 0.13038034737110138, 1.269323468208313, 0.11156543344259262, 0.3091675937175751, -0.6166066527366638, 0.08829014748334885, -0.1684226095676422, 0.15334132313728333, 0.40641602873802185, 0.7064048647880554, 0.5639660954475403, -0.14258790016174316, 0.7997031807899475, -0.4734330475330353, -0.0898890569806099, -0.13191688060760498, -0.5940435528755188, 0.3253948986530304, 0.19862298667430878, 0.11304531991481781, 0.045722972601652145, 0.29048052430152893, -1.1083751916885376, -0.4383646845817566, -0.531308114528656, 0.07952635735273361, -0.15180233120918274, -0.4301896095275879, 1.1716265678405762, 0.7901216149330139, 0.5780118703842163, -0.38937878608703613, 0.3130255341529846, -0.6947262287139893, -0.1400763988494873, 0.309991717338562, 0.40753498673439026, -0.7787161469459534, -0.07927194237709045, -0.6734725832939148, 0.8359735608100891, -0.3046237528324127, 1.0778300762176514, -0.9354987144470215, -0.4746016561985016, -0.444068044424057, -0.29550901055336, -0.1560957133769989, -0.13805165886878967, 0.27845272421836853, -0.24000521004199982, 0.4145411252975464, 0.7428650856018066, -0.39137205481529236, -0.24146133661270142, -0.43013617396354675, -0.5731827616691589, 0.47185957431793213, -0.36050915718078613, 0.11861874163150787, -0.09453441202640533, 0.14847591519355774, 0.4683070182800293, -0.1305336207151413, 0.7914495468139648, 1.3587149381637573, -0.17152561247348785, -0.39885884523391724, 0.07681576907634735, 0.25354233384132385, -0.37311697006225586, 0.4476398229598999, 0.20531363785266876, -0.39178696274757385, -0.3949441909790039, 0.35824596881866455, -0.12391802668571472, -0.37351617217063904, -0.03888532519340515, 0.38198110461235046, -0.5600436329841614, 0.5296306014060974, 0.5702812671661377, 0.2563341557979584, -0.38886818289756775, -0.2770439386367798, -0.14156155288219452, 0.7733741402626038, 0.4451906979084015, 0.6418913006782532, -0.3143358528614044, 0.25493431091308594, 0.2946154773235321, 0.3672406077384949, 0.22788870334625244, 0.3733446002006531, -0.3598228394985199, -0.07582925260066986, -0.00711150374263525, 0.16920675337314606, 0.36640164256095886, 0.4053777754306793, -0.1697525680065155, 1.0012754201889038, -0.7175435423851013, 0.40681326389312744, 0.2339426875114441, 0.08361896127462387, -0.05343896150588989, -0.6572000980377197, -0.119688481092453, 0.005786926485598087, -0.10977856814861298, -1.1600040197372437, 0.897698700428009, 0.33151835203170776, 0.4204583168029785, 0.9816707372665405, -0.7722258567810059, 0.7718703150749207, -0.3888164758682251, -0.4450267553329468, 0.20455168187618256, -0.37498342990875244, -0.5345447659492493, -0.0965946689248085, 0.41733017563819885, 0.6318175196647644, -0.6887969970703125, -0.3979564905166626, -0.1475568264722824, -0.7121949195861816, -0.4871847629547119, 0.9087128639221191, -0.6235844492912292, 0.047938235104084015, 0.5230165719985962, 0.4393988847732544, 0.2855941951274872, -0.4102191925048828, -0.11667245626449585, 0.3406279981136322, -0.22437922656536102, 1.432068943977356, -0.42631399631500244, 1.5721484422683716, 0.04866441711783409, -0.6585169434547424, -0.7633071541786194, -0.2528776526451111, -0.3416112959384918, 0.2776145935058594, 0.10076897591352463, 0.05254914611577988, -0.2958831489086151, 0.3082263767719269, 0.010766999796032906, -0.04172157496213913, -0.10057715326547623, -0.4058202803134918, -0.45406848192214966, 0.3659796416759491, -0.3815424144268036, 0.32821470499038696, -0.3702259659767151, 0.5135472416877747, -0.07230489701032639, 0.22256456315517426, -0.03569355979561806, -0.754690408706665, 0.9731988906860352, -0.09642820060253143, -0.7982244491577148, -0.22966013848781586, 0.673434317111969, 0.5942166447639465, 0.6207395195960999, -0.232216939330101, 0.15263879299163818, 1.2422728538513184, 0.1374235600233078, 0.2845624089241028, 0.1941397488117218, 0.5221022963523865, 0.803408145904541, 0.5231701135635376, -0.5689197778701782, 0.03082836978137493, -0.4162435531616211, -0.44486305117607117, 0.3863241970539093, 0.34039080142974854, -0.29589545726776123, 0.7535825967788696, -0.38189756870269775, 0.46792441606521606, -0.19289933145046234, 1.0236361026763916, 0.23315879702568054, -0.41454586386680603, -0.09617223590612411, 0.4278108775615692, -0.4863073527812958, 0.35448649525642395, 0.3616451621055603, 0.5598800778388977, 0.7435246706008911, 0.9307231903076172, 0.22578191757202148, 0.008165836334228516, 0.7599405646324158, -0.24735678732395172, -0.027576997876167297, 0.14811408519744873, 0.37344855070114136, -0.4037620425224304, -0.7250654697418213, 0.44547832012176514, -0.8065771460533142, -0.37045198678970337, -0.35119423270225525, -0.33823084831237793, 0.5684499740600586, 0.40487775206565857, 0.131434828042984, -0.18074744939804077, 0.569495439529419, 0.3857966661453247, 0.08090180903673172, 0.15530213713645935, -0.02683611586689949, 0.1757814586162567, 0.5286505818367004, 0.4628222584724426, 0.2916642129421234, 0.1779535412788391, 0.4500705599784851, 0.2652752697467804, 0.10973259806632996, -0.008951226249337196, -0.08130715787410736, 0.7018029689788818, 0.49378371238708496, 0.4154917597770691, -0.10354940593242645, 1.1563299894332886, -0.4137970507144928, -0.3195978105068207, -0.3678538501262665, 0.49703770875930786, 0.31485968828201294, 0.5406560301780701, 1.1483821868896484, 0.3222390413284302, -0.7955682873725891, -0.7203362584114075, 0.22700120508670807, -0.12032639235258102, -0.1776195615530014, -0.5420661568641663, 0.21758387982845306, 0.29604372382164, 0.4636261761188507, -0.20303112268447876, 0.5978056192398071, 0.585508406162262, -0.11870414018630981, 0.010754228569567204, 0.3524663746356964, -0.19563263654708862, -1.06952965259552, 0.2752091884613037, -0.4766230285167694, -0.7301053404808044, -1.1144763231277466, 0.4611460864543915, 0.18977224826812744, -0.8784157037734985, 0.14871230721473694, -0.6281257271766663, 0.37861964106559753, -0.1313762366771698, -0.16347157955169678, 0.3049093782901764, 0.34756577014923096, 0.5273869037628174, -0.4183075428009033, 0.052515894174575806, -0.6044538021087646, -0.5287395715713501, -0.459520161151886, -0.3431011736392975, -0.8756102323532104, -0.3206970989704132, 0.10325058549642563, 0.022919636219739914, 0.137404665350914, -0.08508161455392838, -0.3250458240509033, -0.10723551362752914, 0.5540543794631958, -0.21974945068359375, -0.7376987934112549, -0.20557157695293427, -0.42926013469696045, 0.6686554551124573, -0.48153138160705566, 0.23574933409690857, 0.031422555446624756, 0.7379966378211975, 0.0036110267974436283, 0.12490302324295044, -0.6756406426429749, 0.3639671802520752, -0.7575207352638245, 0.0012496805284172297, 0.29347050189971924, -0.4292714297771454, 0.018435154110193253, -0.5862005352973938, -0.630294680595398, -0.04550454765558243, -0.20959675312042236, 0.00691603496670723, -0.3918037712574005, 1.154524564743042, -0.05323377996683121, -1.0870552062988281, 0.15442614257335663, -0.8265572786331177, -0.5548749566078186, 0.33788132667541504, -0.213901087641716, 0.050357066094875336, -0.21830116212368011, 0.3126189708709717, -0.249442920088768, 0.19131726026535034, -0.1796262562274933, -0.1756809651851654, -0.07163230329751968, -0.35067856311798096, -0.06779564917087555, 0.3523010313510895, -0.5431751608848572, 0.7156568765640259, 0.4050588011741638, 0.31306949257850647, -0.06918774545192719, -0.32064729928970337, -0.610966145992279, 0.8270635604858398, 0.49476000666618347, 0.6146539449691772, -0.2177029699087143, 1.1660622358322144, 0.13844436407089233, 0.3100128769874573, 0.1515125036239624, 0.17731483280658722, 0.246404767036438, -0.22742071747779846, -0.18035049736499786, 0.43874090909957886, -0.9073996543884277, -0.2335030883550644, 0.558006227016449, -0.2268819361925125, 0.09985844790935516, -0.6663746237754822, 0.29663699865341187, -0.2713557481765747, -0.058642107993364334, -0.051419470459222794, -0.03123018890619278, -0.28303033113479614, 1.0337939262390137, 0.41880354285240173, 1.0159249305725098, -0.6694850325584412, 0.8334447741508484, 0.3179824650287628, 0.49593234062194824, -0.11068903654813766, -0.16322022676467896, 0.5518904328346252, -0.6330171823501587, 0.959426999092102, -0.4920050799846649, -0.7190986275672913, -0.013147551566362381, -0.6284606456756592, -0.19206880033016205, -0.42440855503082275, -0.7071123719215393, -0.4496019184589386, 0.22100012004375458, 0.09787970781326294, -0.0009185959934256971, 0.26543286442756653, 0.8242844939231873, -0.16098709404468536, 0.5868549346923828, 0.32426220178604126, 0.795001745223999, 0.3603731691837311, -0.9126182198524475, 0.2870652377605438, 0.21460726857185364, -0.4456535279750824, -0.17263107001781464, -0.17260250449180603, -0.9913318753242493, -0.7344041466712952, 0.6706750988960266, -0.42430558800697327, -0.5594801306724548, -0.1403239369392395, 0.04987523704767227, 0.6777837872505188, 0.316641241312027, -0.1131754070520401, -0.4415229558944702, 0.05907731130719185, 0.15329866111278534, -0.7858800888061523, -0.38434261083602905, -1.014181137084961, 0.6706985235214233, 1.5035779476165771, -0.3780309855937958, -0.6463027000427246, -0.9921672344207764, 0.3774911165237427, -0.9400278329849243, -0.1511732041835785, -0.2851996421813965, 0.3870787024497986, 0.07140729576349258, -0.5113984942436218, -0.0660395398736, -0.8447263836860657, 0.05239441245794296, -0.3868500590324402, 0.09283102303743362, -0.2137962132692337, 0.6430537104606628, 0.24274073541164398, 0.8655807971954346, 0.11105586588382721, -0.12433028966188431, -0.26142609119415283, 0.684515118598938, -0.5095803141593933, -0.7845131754875183, 0.27256038784980774, -0.43741366267204285, 0.09416212141513824, 0.07469165325164795, -0.30991461873054504, -0.8304435014724731, 0.09040150791406631, -0.2215796709060669, -0.23176725208759308, -0.7842625975608826, 1.1177031993865967, -0.04597823694348335, -0.24761101603507996, 0.9593089818954468, -0.42696091532707214, -0.8078175187110901, 0.05327590927481651, -0.16172955930233002, -0.6680883169174194, 0.16111941635608673, -0.4293099343776703, 0.1731514036655426, 0.20973655581474304, -0.8890911936759949, 0.17786933481693268, -0.1579831838607788, 0.41752541065216064, -0.3769228160381317, -0.5863757133483887, -0.5337357521057129, -0.30707335472106934, 0.7477487325668335, 0.6548005938529968, -0.878471851348877, 0.8135449290275574, 0.05853863060474396, -0.7032768726348877, -0.36845141649246216, 0.026867393404245377, -0.3666626214981079, -0.04943675547838211, -0.5955932140350342, 0.1730756312608719, 0.1339191049337387, -0.5039138793945312, 0.771858811378479, -0.10813308507204056, -1.0821021795272827, 0.2197241187095642, 0.8542852997779846, -0.229563370347023, -0.38479849696159363, 0.14190681278705597, -0.3050720691680908, -0.7081786394119263, -0.20776191353797913, -0.2136726826429367, -0.5838388800621033, -0.23155370354652405, -0.3576093912124634, -0.10067218542098999, 1.2064012289047241, -0.3524223864078522, -0.029094340279698372, 0.5227392315864563, 0.06111373379826546, -0.5263959169387817, 0.1598433554172516, 0.4842788577079773, 0.355909138917923, 0.14203216135501862, -0.674293577671051, -0.8427061438560486, 0.12473689764738083, -1.1618882417678833, -0.5198164582252502, -0.8273091912269592, 0.589810848236084, 0.29621532559394836, -0.46997615694999695, 0.10273287445306778, 0.326518714427948, 0.5984547138214111, 0.46446993947029114, 0.1405096799135208, -0.24070632457733154, 0.12597225606441498, 0.014191188849508762, -0.6150861382484436, -0.07848743349313736, -0.9714111089706421, 0.2737307548522949, 0.7666150331497192, -0.4142889976501465, 0.044472090899944305, -0.020620400086045265, 0.4280950427055359, -0.1724519282579422, 0.311163991689682, -0.7449382543563843, -0.03559185564517975, 0.6674821376800537, 0.6536465287208557, -0.23691771924495697, -0.4172680377960205, -0.625044584274292, 0.2480543851852417, -0.8154058456420898, 0.5327735543251038, -0.10254430025815964, -0.012218189425766468, 0.3841569423675537, -0.38111412525177, 1.341444492340088, -0.19160479307174683, 0.20956340432167053, 0.26785939931869507, 0.2071605771780014, 0.1085028201341629, 0.8527147769927979, -0.09674660861492157, -0.7960233092308044, -0.6202724575996399, -1.0611244440078735, 0.22015218436717987, -0.3280109167098999, -0.5519788861274719, 0.8421871662139893, -0.012946738861501217, 0.13101603090763092, -0.2269885390996933, 0.949040949344635, 0.725694477558136, -0.12284301966428757, 0.06456253677606583, 0.07208441942930222, 0.45282962918281555, -0.1769334077835083, 0.7532227039337158, -0.2501395046710968, 0.07983657717704773, -0.20540577173233032, -0.3766690492630005, -0.3616223633289337, -0.7653723955154419, -0.7161017060279846, 0.059533778578042984, 0.45740315318107605, -0.36898353695869446, 0.44290825724601746, 0.3777492940425873, -0.13984836637973785, -0.4158690869808197, 0.9204004406929016, -0.04894015192985535, 0.32602035999298096, 1.1542723178863525, -0.4853631258010864, -0.5709898471832275, 0.26184597611427307, -0.030102277174592018, 0.25846368074417114, -0.43665680289268494, 0.9249485731124878, -0.10881403833627701, -0.34521669149398804, 0.34808841347694397, 0.6928658485412598, -0.9176968932151794, -0.02101210132241249, -0.14120326936244965, -0.3324792683124542, 0.18440069258213043, -0.4438592493534088, -0.12666846811771393, -0.27647319436073303, -0.44706615805625916, 0.10851521044969559, -0.4324047863483429, 0.6058986186981201, -0.235264390707016, -0.3608398139476776, 0.670545220375061, -0.24331974983215332, -0.22813187539577484, 0.6907342672348022, -0.42575645446777344, -0.2630111277103424, -0.26162347197532654, 0.1991082727909088, 0.33981260657310486, 0.9013731479644775, 0.08028176426887512, -0.4215288758277893, -0.19568778574466705, 0.28289562463760376, 0.2911941707134247, 0.03627665713429451, -0.33031997084617615, -0.40962716937065125, 0.7671688199043274, -0.24055369198322296, -1.0148931741714478, -1.0523462295532227, 0.29211392998695374, 0.30791088938713074, 0.43163636326789856, 0.4298728406429291, -0.36064332723617554, 0.00175691198091954, 0.46222618222236633, 0.17456673085689545, -0.2895497679710388, -0.620250403881073, -0.3725534677505493, -0.2732359766960144, -0.16660727560520172, -0.9482826590538025, -0.17333891987800598, 0.8251403570175171, -0.7295365333557129, -0.9084445238113403, 0.02707989141345024, 0.6467191576957703, -0.5108956098556519, 0.02339770272374153, 0.11849197000265121, 0.42800694704055786, -0.6010249853134155, -0.6514649391174316, -0.17511138319969177, -0.6785871982574463, 0.18903584778308868, 0.7699319124221802, -0.7032864689826965, -0.09330767393112183, 0.0009572816779837012, -0.15556327998638153, 0.34450405836105347, 0.640826940536499, -0.026803573593497276, -0.49285730719566345, -0.2548563778400421, 0.9630849361419678, 0.409346342086792, 0.3273613452911377, 0.8149324059486389, -0.07880862057209015, 0.17830729484558105, -0.29745328426361084, 0.24334336817264557, 0.171090766787529, -0.26515334844589233, 0.3305530250072479, -0.16723471879959106, -0.7185254096984863, -0.6521714329719543, 0.7304986715316772, -0.5418444871902466, -0.1285693645477295, -0.5765907168388367, 0.6402744650840759, 0.38582587242126465, 0.018229521811008453, 0.022261803969740868, 0.6214564442634583, -0.2700996398925781, -0.08683713525533676, -0.21044905483722687, 0.17660096287727356, -0.15574002265930176, 0.1199893206357956, 0.5898626446723938, 0.02016727812588215, -0.025483863428235054, -1.2780791521072388, 0.06702053546905518, 0.24230831861495972, 0.0069017428904771805, 0.6661252379417419, -0.6681151986122131, 0.33034250140190125, -0.011703288182616234, -0.19804173707962036, 0.35730618238449097, 0.6791794300079346, -0.2270805537700653, 0.8852399587631226, -0.24345237016677856, -0.1190398558974266, -0.40684545040130615, 0.013831669464707375, -1.1887670755386353, -0.26103949546813965, -0.29086077213287354, -1.1897732019424438, -0.1392957717180252, -0.23247773945331573, -0.4882948398590088, 0.2941506803035736, -0.46385884284973145, -0.09201113879680634, -0.03913233056664467, 0.4753611087799072, 0.007648388855159283, 1.4808298349380493, -0.34307658672332764, 0.4435071349143982, 0.36013808846473694, -0.1865188181400299, -1.3030920028686523, 0.5008692145347595, -0.06027580425143242, 0.751721978187561, 0.22296717762947083, -0.28030550479888916, -0.27274736762046814, 0.6693616509437561, -0.7362936735153198, -0.16140864789485931, -0.17446596920490265, 0.2682601511478424, -0.9634042382240295, -0.4053482115268707, -0.13832174241542816, 0.15992417931556702, -0.7030100226402283, 0.4656904637813568, -0.22377760708332062, -0.6764028072357178, -0.9969000220298767, 0.2039211541414261, 0.8974364995956421, 0.11372161656618118, 0.4127486050128937, -0.3014499247074127, 0.33093783259391785, 0.4512995183467865, -0.48923957347869873, -0.06117181479930878, 0.31582367420196533, 0.19329333305358887, 0.1530890315771103, 0.0707123875617981, 0.6151303648948669, 0.17700856924057007, -0.3300369083881378, 0.08201151341199875, 0.6841772794723511, 0.22900137305259705, 0.03777158632874489, 0.08890450745820999, -0.617745041847229, 0.7292043566703796, 0.5872787833213806, -0.2021580934524536, -0.11637792736291885, 0.8870913982391357, 0.13325026631355286, 0.42674025893211365, -0.5361990332603455, 0.39370277523994446, -0.2603052854537964, -0.2329987734556198, 0.18561579287052155, -0.1133965402841568, 0.5640866756439209, 0.3411146104335785, 0.5272060036659241, 0.7890323996543884, 0.4171130657196045, 0.3163352906703949, -0.07321301847696304, 0.32174739241600037, -0.7104641795158386, 0.23958700895309448, -0.06458517163991928, 0.19382482767105103, -0.07247783243656158, -0.048037320375442505, 0.18114328384399414, -0.09723290801048279, -0.1408206969499588, 0.9909871220588684, -0.6213959455490112, 0.16094693541526794, 1.2422196865081787, -0.020381907001137733, -0.788421630859375, -0.24573355913162231, 0.6712099313735962, -0.43319544196128845, -0.4042045474052429, 0.7418869137763977, 0.24950455129146576, -0.003044955665245652, 0.31704258918762207, -0.1215181052684784, 0.30654653906822205, 0.3902702331542969, 0.853933572769165, -0.7986938953399658, -0.3049028515815735, 0.8021871447563171, 0.08015608787536621, -0.08756887167692184, -0.44970202445983887, -0.6397160291671753, 0.08462053537368774, -0.3636597990989685, -0.27014821767807007, -0.19567953050136566, -0.07841123640537262, -0.7855026125907898, -0.14198830723762512, 0.4291868209838867, -0.7704250812530518, -0.7841585278511047, 0.6090668439865112, -0.3740464150905609, 0.1546795815229416, -0.6919258832931519, -0.3265966773033142, 0.2317238599061966, -0.5243175029754639, -0.015243779867887497, -0.7121749520301819, -0.1099545881152153, -0.410651296377182, -0.2714022397994995, 0.47152072191238403, -0.21820467710494995, -0.52716064453125, 0.44510647654533386, -0.23762892186641693, -0.1579286903142929, -0.2915125787258148, 0.31043657660484314, -0.38747918605804443, -0.6815482378005981, 0.8041821122169495, 0.5611608624458313, 0.11669380962848663, -0.54056715965271, 0.2631085515022278, -0.21183902025222778, 0.8990429043769836, 0.21208368241786957, 0.21143360435962677, -0.44874969124794006, 0.20253179967403412, -0.3214113712310791, -0.6861231327056885, -0.19884352385997772, 0.22139737010002136, -0.7755753993988037, -0.6946083903312683, 0.6435865163803101, -0.18197272717952728, -0.29822441935539246, 0.7566434144973755, 0.29892221093177795, -0.1337866187095642, -0.48304590582847595, -0.288350373506546, -0.2094278484582901, -0.8399810791015625, 0.9686216115951538, -0.3546445369720459, -0.24951159954071045, 0.7337437868118286, -0.24506203830242157, 1.0147262811660767, -0.8947817087173462, 4.266007423400879, 0.5395132899284363, 0.6749308109283447, -0.5693929195404053, 0.3237879276275635, 0.9491471648216248, 0.3161327540874481, -0.3035278618335724, 0.27508097887039185, -0.04995834454894066, -0.21282576024532318, 0.2175583392381668, 0.12365812808275223, 0.1822509765625, 0.42901739478111267, 0.8502162098884583, -0.4816140830516815, 0.4970647394657135, -0.7826831340789795, -0.493308424949646, 0.022619659081101418, 0.45004507899284363, -0.09260907769203186, -0.48520997166633606, 0.23161032795906067, -0.5618997812271118, 0.23524506390094757, -0.15523813664913177, 0.1911981701850891, -0.6518530249595642, -0.2973146438598633, -0.9334044456481934, -0.04805406555533409, -0.48814478516578674, -0.11298441141843796, 0.6169472932815552, -0.1407877504825592, -0.4956361651420593, -0.3653668463230133, -0.618908703327179, -0.2526591420173645, 0.2887983024120331, -0.34123337268829346, -0.4044221043586731, -0.18276016414165497, 0.383463591337204, -0.4188053607940674, -0.26601648330688477, 0.0807775929570198, -0.17139862477779388, 1.4370001554489136, -1.2584047317504883, 0.08911024779081345, -0.3807279169559479, -1.2548142671585083, -0.018801840022206306, -0.2509056627750397, -0.9628420472145081, -0.4329782724380493, 0.04250301793217659, 0.5264216661453247, -0.22768789529800415, -0.4136839210987091, 0.2629513740539551, 0.06895799934864044, 0.8334335088729858, -0.4419344663619995, -0.9830760359764099, -0.3415021598339081, -0.27158933877944946, -0.24581263959407806, -0.4553986191749573, -0.2689436674118042, -0.24185916781425476, 0.15161411464214325, 0.543785035610199, 0.016155662015080452, 0.584729015827179, -0.3930068612098694, 0.18429166078567505, 0.3819439709186554, 0.008365198038518429, -0.11174280196428299, -0.06623050570487976, 0.2052050530910492, 1.0109243392944336, -0.5696884393692017, -0.39743345975875854, -0.18131239712238312, 0.5988458395004272, 0.4511004090309143, 0.5474159121513367, -0.44882509112358093, -0.5702031254768372, 0.03868115693330765 ]
{"Title": "Severe volcanic SO 2 exposure and respiratory morbidities in the Icelandic population \u2013 a register study", "Authors": "Carlsen Hanne Krage, Valdimarsd\u00f3ttir Unnur, Briem Haraldur, Dominici Francesca, Finnbjornsdottir Ragnhildur Gudrun, J\u00f3hannsson Thorsteinn, Aspelund Thor, Gislason Thorarinn, Gudnason Thorolfur", "Abstract": "Abstract Background The Holuhraun volcanic eruption September 2014 to February 2015 emitted large amounts of sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ). Objectives The aim of this study was to determine the association between volcanic SO 2 gases on general population respiratory health in the Icelandic capital area some 250 km from the eruption site. Methods Respiratory health outcomes were: asthma medication dispensing (AMD) from the Icelandic Medicines Register, medical doctor consultations in primary care (PCMD) and hospital emergency department visits (HED) in Reykjav\u00edk (population: 215 000) for respiratory disease from 1 January 2010 to 31 December 2014. The associations between daily counts of health events,and daily mean SO2 concentration and high SO2 levels (24-hour mean SO2>125\u00b5g/m3) were analyzed using generalized additive models. Results After the eruption began, AMD was higher than before (129.4 vs . 158.4 individuals per day, p <0.05). Increases in SO 2 concentration were associated with an estimated increase in AMD by 1.05% (95% CI 0.48 - 1.62%) per 10 \u00b5g/m 3 at lag 0-2, 1.51% (95% CI 0.63 \u2013 2.40%) increase in individuals under 18 years of age. PCMD for respiratory causes increased by 1.52% (95% CI 1.04 -2.00%) per 10 \u00b5g/m 3 SO 2 at lag 0-2. For HED, only effect estimated for individuals aged 64 years and older were significantly increased, by 1.541% (95% CI 0.02-3.07%) per 10 \u00b5g/m 3 SO 2 at lag 0-2. Following days with SO 2 levels above 125 \u00b5g/m 3 , AMD and PCMD were increased in all age groups, in AMD mostly so in individuals under 18 by 20.4%(95%CI 4.8 \u2013 23.4%), and adult PCMD visits by 24.1%(95%CI 16.8 \u2013 31.3%). HED was significantly increased in elderly by 26.3% (95%CI 5.56-47.0). Discussion High levels of volcanic SO 2 are associated with increases in dispensing of AMD, and health care utilization in primary and tertiary care. Individuals with prevalent respiratory disease may be particularly susceptible. Funding The study was funded by the Icelandic Ministry of Health.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013474"}
10.1101/19010264
[ 0.38750138878822327, 0.1536768078804016, 0.04050171375274658, -0.02729046531021595, -0.13860167562961578, -0.6870953440666199, -0.21662253141403198, -0.36258208751678467, 1.2002710103988647, 0.10602207481861115, 0.3743770718574524, -0.46556898951530457, 0.24502457678318024, -0.4109083116054535, 0.06193322688341141, -0.19121861457824707, 0.09026210755109787, -0.5645789504051208, -0.16917546093463898, -0.29055145382881165, 0.3952169120311737, 0.1816212385892868, -0.8937050104141235, 0.47619277238845825, 0.36014309525489807, 0.7252674698829651, -0.30924123525619507, 0.16116344928741455, 0.9921044111251831, 0.30280038714408875, -0.7543173432350159, -0.5374232530593872, 0.4246129095554352, -1.1848052740097046, -0.1628100872039795, 0.4167103171348572, 0.6240478157997131, 0.1459442675113678, -0.3999319076538086, -0.45078516006469727, 0.0886533260345459, -0.2181963473558426, 0.41606178879737854, -0.47037720680236816, -0.7558279037475586, -0.2548133134841919, -0.02435317635536194, -0.018184581771492958, -0.07614850997924805, -0.2721157371997833, -0.5608951449394226, -0.08791130781173706, 0.04635535553097725, -0.4663398265838623, 0.0009727588621899486, -0.16453704237937927, 0.9598849415779114, 0.6334623694419861, -1.0543901920318604, 0.21023984253406525, 0.3792482018470764, -0.3690257966518402, 0.5695884823799133, -0.9307978749275208, 1.11998450756073, 1.1954879760742188, -0.03540424630045891, -0.7307454943656921, -0.3899537920951843, -0.1126709058880806, -0.5804380774497986, -0.39164024591445923, -0.16207794845104218, -0.22510282695293427, -0.10268145799636841, -0.5721729397773743, 0.6946234107017517, 0.11149421334266663, -0.18287299573421478, -0.20107817649841309, 0.05997157469391823, 0.3612859547138214, 0.09122070670127869, 0.23702438175678253, -0.13102778792381287, -0.1423892229795456, 0.8757437467575073, 0.49807316064834595, 0.030669864267110825, 0.9315602779388428, -0.14829576015472412, 0.5093017816543579, 0.09415321052074432, -0.3461356461048126, -0.15499256551265717, 1.222423791885376, -0.5470153093338013, 0.2785784900188446, -0.1872415542602539, -0.319480299949646, 0.05929811671376228, 1.3438799381256104, -0.6124868392944336, 0.5749627351760864, -0.5413357615470886, 0.628412127494812, 1.0561059713363647, -0.40123504400253296, -0.6648741364479065, -1.2918182611465454, 0.9555031061172485, 0.07904042303562164, -0.5387005805969238, 0.539124608039856, 1.3540884256362915, 1.0054326057434082, -0.46528175473213196, 0.6900466680526733, -0.7777477502822876, -0.6669976711273193, 0.030055774375796318, -0.34126460552215576, 1.1235933303833008, -0.5799505114555359, 0.5495743155479431, 0.5942667722702026, -0.340952068567276, 0.608733594417572, -0.30879756808280945, 0.0047203777357935905, -0.29759523272514343, -0.11301334947347641, -0.21278086304664612, 0.21498197317123413, 0.34023523330688477, -0.3201807141304016, 0.490212619304657, 0.7433080077171326, -0.022904086858034134, -0.5703257322311401, 0.14761613309383392, -0.14189879596233368, -0.9915752410888672, 1.431735873222351, 0.10136549174785614, 0.6586679816246033, -0.15791313350200653, -2.011579990386963, -0.6026349663734436, 0.1835850477218628, 0.05203564465045929, 0.7981590032577515, -0.10945547372102737, -0.8357949256896973, -0.14011599123477936, 0.8474956750869751, 0.07644949108362198, 0.3138464391231537, -0.16669893264770508, -0.1569686084985733, -0.7621023058891296, 0.44394728541374207, 0.7989214062690735, 0.6596413850784302, -0.44327354431152344, 0.5256016850471497, -0.2746397852897644, -0.054508667439222336, -0.5502139925956726, -0.19499994814395905, 0.4759649634361267, 0.12794709205627441, -0.21725031733512878, -0.12697012722492218, 0.453264981508255, 0.7269275188446045, 0.3321004807949066, 0.07302795350551605, 0.18311218917369843, 0.10802768170833588, 0.018238350749015808, 0.36370861530303955, 0.4640282988548279, 0.1540442705154419, -0.6556338667869568, 0.670358419418335, 0.2325327843427658, -0.17262707650661469, -1.070718765258789, -0.8476389646530151, -0.6153658628463745, 0.2883008122444153, -0.0255951676517725, 0.04505777359008789, -0.15802747011184692, 0.33514484763145447, 0.15968140959739685, 0.29332754015922546, 0.553636372089386, -0.09261418133974075, -0.759109616279602, 0.7244889140129089, -0.006517700385302305, 0.30512815713882446, -0.4703490138053894, 0.2803697884082794, -0.09516403079032898, 0.6220861673355103, -1.1287109851837158, 0.4553317725658417, 0.918018102645874, -0.41904768347740173, -0.6413788199424744, -0.07227034866809845, 1.1789759397506714, -0.5460456609725952, -0.10477424412965775, 0.10655675083398819, -0.45427000522613525, 0.6032323837280273, -0.716805100440979, -0.19360563158988953, 0.29680392146110535, -0.2546118199825287, 0.06645835936069489, 0.6516889333724976, 1.0571134090423584, 0.8443456292152405, -0.6811453104019165, -0.4635779857635498, 0.3673899471759796, 1.0105913877487183, -0.46616774797439575, 0.5539969205856323, 0.3167160451412201, 0.686028778553009, 0.09557080268859863, 0.3732255697250366, -0.18406125903129578, 0.39857327938079834, 0.8416385650634766, -0.2955801486968994, 0.27376818656921387, 0.7191207408905029, -0.003224299056455493, 0.4754819869995117, -1.0379996299743652, -0.12991803884506226, -0.33130931854248047, 0.704505443572998, -0.6925346255302429, 0.9614030718803406, 0.7959767580032349, 0.6745432019233704, -1.0433303117752075, -0.2603946924209595, 0.4504796266555786, 0.21169453859329224, -0.07348256558179855, -0.08635734766721725, -0.19774669408798218, 0.2695850729942322, -0.23556047677993774, -0.03251316025853157, 1.1133627891540527, 0.6715371608734131, 0.36267468333244324, -0.6995661854743958, 0.2064892053604126, -0.4548596143722534, -1.372755765914917, -0.8952264785766602, -0.8237718343734741, -0.8197844624519348, -0.90052330493927, -0.8567183017730713, 0.4280847907066345, -0.18701249361038208, 0.3484511971473694, -0.3909186124801636, 0.11668340116739273, -0.08219163864850998, -0.5008726716041565, 0.2776789963245392, 0.5144723653793335, 0.34717875719070435, -0.9054675102233887, 0.7183809876441956, -0.0971982553601265, 0.28213220834732056, -0.2906736433506012, -0.21794380247592926, -0.22878187894821167, -0.6248749494552612, 0.647138237953186, -1.1862093210220337, 0.04479043558239937, -0.517004132270813, -0.3986993134021759, -0.6897262334823608, -0.033687375485897064, 0.09622342139482498, 0.19574756920337677, 0.1751907616853714, -0.2564742863178253, 0.5754960775375366, 0.5048757195472717, -0.5974600315093994, 0.5167288780212402, 0.5957915782928467, -0.4409812092781067, 0.5568093657493591, -0.36914724111557007, -0.05060454457998276, -0.6399489045143127, 0.37893131375312805, 0.28763502836227417, 0.06395678222179413, -0.07907548546791077, -0.46450579166412354, -1.2996035814285278, -0.28268182277679443, -0.38794997334480286, -0.33452120423316956, -0.23660820722579956, 0.8588802814483643, 0.19262543320655823, -1.4926304817199707, -0.021150080487132072, 0.06955467909574509, -1.0384758710861206, 0.20977219939231873, -0.045757632702589035, -0.1439470499753952, 0.6723313927650452, -0.4259570240974426, -0.4121064841747284, 0.15639247000217438, 0.5777467489242554, 0.44002458453178406, -0.07667376846075058, -0.6751965284347534, -0.4121043086051941, 0.2564708888530731, 0.08755464106798172, 0.2739626467227936, 0.43437469005584717, -0.12193777412176132, 0.3602581024169922, -0.05359014496207237, -0.2756005525588989, 0.0036696300376206636, 0.574357807636261, 0.20382390916347504, -0.3640415072441101, -0.049504391849040985, -0.2963535189628601, -0.503974437713623, 0.598828911781311, -0.031190212815999985, -0.024894127622246742, 0.6041817665100098, -0.27215662598609924, -0.12405930459499359, -0.7200175523757935, -0.24918687343597412, -0.24268880486488342, -0.011681516654789448, 0.7255809903144836, -0.6445163488388062, 0.9874013662338257, 0.27966779470443726, -0.19468577206134796, 1.0347929000854492, 0.00810351874679327, -0.2746926248073578, 0.8084176778793335, -0.2560141980648041, 0.6964654326438904, -0.681614339351654, -0.27693676948547363, 0.49250197410583496, 1.0586239099502563, -0.010867798700928688, 0.41589149832725525, 1.0320024490356445, -0.31224900484085083, 0.4543479382991791, 0.03894948586821556, 0.21515172719955444, 0.12642933428287506, 0.03086296282708645, -0.10608695447444916, -0.249217227101326, -0.8358392119407654, 0.1952701359987259, -0.01809583231806755, 0.25445693731307983, -0.1473291963338852, -0.4079672396183014, 0.7150021195411682, -0.29989659786224365, -0.24084782600402832, -0.38702183961868286, 0.14431646466255188, 0.0807824432849884, -0.8545593023300171, -0.5085256099700928, -0.09622388333082199, -0.3537919819355011, -0.25711655616760254, -0.16857653856277466, 0.5301032662391663, 0.3582974970340729, 0.6081251502037048, -0.49922406673431396, -0.09716013073921204, -0.5711219310760498, -0.04261072352528572, 0.2507503628730774, 0.09837860614061356, 0.29978951811790466, -0.8882311582565308, 0.6299745440483093, -0.41406142711639404, -0.487195760011673, -0.4051381051540375, -0.15682563185691833, -0.3014821410179138, 0.6688761711120605, -0.5448592305183411, -0.8040661215782166, -0.49647220969200134, -0.42020711302757263, -0.058752596378326416, 0.2311985045671463, 0.5355798602104187, -0.58048015832901, 0.29638755321502686, -0.004611776676028967, -0.30915191769599915, -0.20525887608528137, 0.32749632000923157, 0.06387041509151459, 0.3230414390563965, 0.06357783824205399, 1.1839752197265625, 0.3335886597633362, 0.3838387727737427, -0.39465245604515076, 1.0351608991622925, -0.8746684193611145, 0.5530600547790527, -0.39796701073646545, -0.47094541788101196, -0.34027132391929626, -0.6204662919044495, -0.40400582551956177, -0.15755286812782288, 0.4644860029220581, -0.14130531251430511, -0.4298974275588989, 0.4559759795665741, -0.7236159443855286, -0.9886334538459778, 0.7775568962097168, -0.6869052052497864, 0.8251723051071167, 1.495815634727478, -0.29675358533859253, 0.13982047140598297, 0.03713814169168472, 0.20497368276119232, -0.3358262777328491, 1.0887550115585327, 0.5140798091888428, 0.34778374433517456, -0.12906600534915924, -0.7047948837280273, -0.8372640013694763, -0.19001159071922302, 0.4533192217350006, -0.8309338688850403, -0.8451350927352905, -0.29114341735839844, -0.5618124604225159, -1.3034483194351196, -0.06764256209135056, -0.6863463521003723, -0.4665374457836151, -0.7113857269287109, -0.4499920904636383, 0.680841326713562, -0.8935335278511047, -0.1225656121969223, -0.4537196159362793, -0.19853229820728302, 0.33458182215690613, 0.6156610250473022, -0.04782262444496155, 0.41773372888565063, -0.12934765219688416, -1.3036038875579834, 0.47767382860183716, 0.19378800690174103, -1.1011794805526733, -0.456156849861145, -0.5231006741523743, 0.13620853424072266, -0.8687859177589417, -0.13801763951778412, -0.5442748069763184, 0.03823698312044144, -0.3655080497264862, -0.42561858892440796, -0.13816526532173157, 0.32481712102890015, 0.2086208611726761, -0.2177026867866516, 0.6492659449577332, 0.4640352725982666, -1.0411310195922852, -0.2740550637245178, 0.7995203733444214, -0.010353373363614082, 0.2232435792684555, 0.0648912712931633, -0.9219409227371216, -0.2830502986907959, -1.0502867698669434, 0.24761471152305603, -0.5028730630874634, -0.017726467922329903, -0.7089291214942932, 0.21797454357147217, 0.03807977959513664, 0.1353483647108078, 0.441663533449173, -0.2036655843257904, -0.15114037692546844, -0.6531979441642761, 0.25903981924057007, -0.176736518740654, 0.016818135976791382, -0.010346575640141964, -0.19283032417297363, 0.4708208739757538, 1.3608392477035522, 0.2567999064922333, -0.8499950766563416, 0.03485046327114105, 0.141973078250885, 0.1608082503080368, 0.45015454292297363, -0.7404226660728455, -0.49757120013237, -0.2873416543006897, 0.06350928544998169, 0.5201521515846252, -0.40612325072288513, -0.6256006956100464, 0.10237792134284973, -0.6423324346542358, -0.8036514520645142, 0.11145922541618347, -0.5007506012916565, 0.17000004649162292, -0.5195263624191284, 0.3086809515953064, -0.6565244197845459, 0.46079978346824646, 0.0681716799736023, -0.5786536335945129, -0.09391157329082489, 0.18287184834480286, -0.1645360141992569, -0.2307935357093811, -0.7304750084877014, -0.4986235201358795, 0.2932026982307434, -0.029772557318210602, -0.5578545331954956, 0.27641960978507996, -0.29794663190841675, 0.48272761702537537, -0.49661484360694885, 0.6358323693275452, 0.3272759020328522, 0.3026914894580841, -0.40997180342674255, -0.08832952380180359, 0.42468133568763733, 0.40053966641426086, -0.5062502026557922, 0.09670796245336533, -0.05867474153637886, -0.6174094080924988, -0.31877806782722473, -0.057754434645175934, -1.1422483921051025, 0.41132551431655884, 0.08788938820362091, 0.6638666391372681, 0.36768436431884766, 0.3359816074371338, -0.08238930255174637, -0.018223324790596962, 0.190297931432724, 0.6323402523994446, -0.0861705020070076, 0.026984164491295815, 1.3019434213638306, -0.4594321846961975, 0.4239131808280945, 0.6205970644950867, -0.22807253897190094, -0.3155876696109772, -0.26694145798683167, 0.6922673583030701, 0.5791774392127991, -0.6752287149429321, 0.6491273641586304, 0.23739388585090637, -0.8248237371444702, -0.23109868168830872, -0.14211493730545044, -0.18341556191444397, -0.14450140297412872, -0.6798248291015625, -0.06141379848122597, 0.7013969421386719, -0.15544112026691437, 0.4594672918319702, -0.3928496241569519, 0.11148355156183243, 0.030794763937592506, -0.21998733282089233, -0.1570286899805069, -0.5595766305923462, 0.7588015794754028, 1.2832520008087158, -0.07879476994276047, 0.42993849515914917, -0.31444621086120605, 0.5154814720153809, -0.16438597440719604, -0.18343383073806763, -0.17353299260139465, 0.06898768991231918, -0.2073182761669159, 0.01561944093555212, 0.4629998803138733, 0.03775160014629364, 0.11230270564556122, 0.010553441941738129, 0.7310947179794312, 0.4153738021850586, -0.6487749814987183, 0.07856536656618118, 0.5579724907875061, 0.5714104175567627, 0.694834291934967, 0.6606115102767944, 0.3397185504436493, 1.0855865478515625, 0.193937286734581, 0.11944158375263214, -0.9280266165733337, -0.37206584215164185, -0.3590119183063507, -0.14739777147769928, 0.14262470602989197, -0.7418617010116577, 0.08798353374004364, 0.46005627512931824, -0.48581501841545105, -0.05988706648349762, -0.1999669224023819, 0.9512916803359985, 0.22514647245407104, 0.3178398013114929, -0.7598170042037964, 0.35085567831993103, -0.5851332545280457, -0.910755455493927, -0.3608590066432953, -0.9436908960342407, 0.1430114358663559, 1.2329447269439697, -0.7063195705413818, -0.28174301981925964, -0.21975155174732208, 0.8051709532737732, 0.28810086846351624, 0.08252794295549393, -0.774924635887146, -0.7129851579666138, -0.2432880699634552, 0.18371424078941345, 0.06833742558956146, -0.2690213620662689, 1.433333396911621, -0.311104416847229, 0.7895578145980835, 0.9883369207382202, -0.42912551760673523, -0.2134673297405243, 0.26447001099586487, 1.1467069387435913, -1.43656587600708, 0.06026400998234749, -0.6787061095237732, 0.6286704540252686, -1.265475869178772, -0.39851492643356323, -0.1451723426580429, -0.23182858526706696, -0.11055696755647659, 0.5128039121627808, -0.4401129186153412, 0.7775743007659912, 0.729459822177887, -0.06897030025720596, -0.3047448396682739, 1.0718101263046265, 0.880355179309845, -0.5112358927726746, 0.11706430464982986, 0.2382822036743164, -0.43822288513183594, -0.7321215867996216, 0.004512520972639322, 0.6197680830955505, 0.12850242853164673, 0.2835768163204193, 0.18567848205566406, 1.0675480365753174, 0.1618017852306366, -0.3311479687690735, -0.49531370401382446, 0.2913682460784912, 0.3386285603046417, 0.7660248875617981, -0.03038681298494339, -0.8693208694458008, -1.044848918914795, -0.31192266941070557, -0.9835919141769409, -0.8577539920806885, 0.83458012342453, -0.14135214686393738, 0.5717431306838989, -0.40429553389549255, -0.44220858812332153, 0.2852011024951935, 0.6774865388870239, 1.1366233825683594, -0.19024872779846191, -0.10949145257472992, 0.35826605558395386, 0.4813520908355713, 0.12332513928413391, 0.406008243560791, 0.054645463824272156, -0.04951285943388939, -1.0700485706329346, -0.4395446181297302, -0.4670601487159729, -0.09394126385450363, -0.09060735255479813, 0.08605478703975677, -0.68215411901474, 0.03273271769285202, 0.6866278052330017, -0.6594829559326172, -0.7710381150245667, -0.08386173844337463, -0.6401644349098206, -0.37613165378570557, -0.06441599875688553, 0.09035886079072952, -0.2513172924518585, 0.5628038048744202, 0.9115092158317566, -0.5750343203544617, -0.38776153326034546, 0.4802617132663727, 1.1733717918395996, -0.46877503395080566, 0.8339850902557373, 0.38846179842948914, 0.42064088582992554, -0.08182387799024582, -1.029549241065979, 1.286102533340454, 0.44099318981170654, 0.41054028272628784, 0.11004358530044556, 0.1765103042125702, 0.2353411316871643, 1.1476787328720093, 0.78721684217453, -0.41962382197380066, 0.6904329657554626, 0.7498751878738403, -0.1463695466518402, 0.365545392036438, -0.11401940882205963, 0.46102067828178406, 0.5776607394218445, -0.1742488592863083, 0.04491368681192398, -0.0789589062333107, 0.10438048094511032, 0.2615880072116852, -0.5180925130844116, 0.13307498395442963, -1.2271088361740112, -0.8888858556747437, 0.2778775691986084, 0.20847275853157043, 0.9791176319122314, 0.28119179606437683, 0.716606616973877, -0.49368539452552795, 0.1196194738149643, -0.3086467683315277, 0.567966103553772, 1.1769708395004272, -0.5958938002586365, -0.35152357816696167, -0.216141477227211, 0.6504228711128235, 0.14297831058502197, 0.3916844129562378, 0.21139031648635864, -0.879524290561676, 0.20518717169761658, 0.6739210486412048, -0.1257890909910202, -0.32016265392303467, 0.8008289337158203, -0.3253336548805237, -0.00958016887307167, -0.19274002313613892, 0.3531850576400757, -0.5626199245452881, 0.04972663149237633, 1.0871124267578125, -0.9517256617546082, 0.4335669279098511, 0.45317351818084717, 0.80561363697052, 0.9580874443054199, -0.35770583152770996, 0.40352559089660645, -0.701797604560852, 0.8243092894554138, 1.0215035676956177, 0.2752510905265808, -0.46240806579589844, -0.004308938980102539, -0.00578185124322772, 0.04066122695803642, -0.46585601568222046, 0.025472795590758324, 0.29017335176467896, -0.07368117570877075, -0.0308188758790493, -0.497050940990448, -0.5133631229400635, -0.3248549699783325, -0.5187632441520691, -0.9112480878829956, 0.38105085492134094, -0.027208805084228516, 0.31646963953971863, 0.33025771379470825, 0.703487753868103, 0.2799949645996094, -0.2814915180206299, -0.18277519941329956, -0.647138774394989, 0.06255810707807541, -1.4441554546356201, 0.37117767333984375, -0.11156333237886429, -0.09220466762781143, -0.4274349808692932, -1.0379104614257812, 0.1555202752351761, -0.6593267321586609, 0.5288346409797668, -0.8011394739151001, 0.03777043893933296, 0.004648375324904919, 1.0171680450439453, -0.22413143515586853, -0.6116777062416077, 0.35726693272590637, -0.13826334476470947, 0.45779040455818176, -0.5037201642990112, 0.42240220308303833, -0.1982945054769516, 0.4088192284107208, -0.2543463706970215, -0.39449480175971985, 0.028966490179300308, 0.01768009550869465, 0.4247373938560486, -0.5260055065155029, -0.05500582978129387, 0.09742625057697296, -1.0419037342071533, 0.6218386292457581, 1.2323875427246094, -0.03428683802485466, -0.3835611045360565, -1.2925832271575928, 0.5192459225654602, -0.1681748926639557, 0.2206236869096756, -0.5950727462768555, 0.1934862732887268, 0.49364423751831055, -0.2683854401111603, -0.15159273147583008, -1.227537751197815, 3.7866814136505127, 1.590105414390564, 0.8938612341880798, -0.43499866127967834, 0.8903738260269165, 0.7194700837135315, 0.4182072877883911, 0.031496260315179825, 0.0013295203680172563, -0.469387412071228, -0.5181023478507996, 0.18600180745124817, 0.4735361635684967, 0.11274146288633347, -0.11978618800640106, 0.17766951024532318, -1.7798858880996704, 0.089117631316185, -0.17296794056892395, -0.5954958200454712, -1.0328505039215088, 0.28050899505615234, 0.2106126844882965, -0.28687241673469543, 0.7316663265228271, 0.6556307673454285, -0.13930147886276245, 0.01341586746275425, -0.35650503635406494, -0.6649327278137207, -0.4700396656990051, -0.7167654037475586, 0.44390869140625, 0.10151335597038269, -0.3091321587562561, 0.3460567593574524, -0.4539775550365448, -0.5800794959068298, 0.39442819356918335, 0.8362239599227905, 0.06499970704317093, -0.7864290475845337, -0.5499737858772278, -0.4420902132987976, -0.5086339116096497, -0.33143702149391174, -0.8362950086593628, 0.28512653708457947, 0.3977546989917755, -0.07317269593477249, 1.1533366441726685, -1.0850062370300293, 0.8312305808067322, -0.18689335882663727, -0.6221003532409668, -0.5477337837219238, -0.21064293384552002, -1.3775752782821655, -0.584143340587616, 0.6613942980766296, 1.0181137323379517, 0.10128292441368103, -0.5058061480522156, 0.19787627458572388, 0.7292816638946533, 1.3494898080825806, 0.09046024829149246, 0.06857269257307053, -0.35596033930778503, -0.7450718283653259, 0.01936020515859127, -0.3250855803489685, -0.2869110703468323, 0.37503719329833984, 0.7583050727844238, 0.2384672909975052, -0.4832713305950165, 1.052239179611206, -0.5558392405509949, -0.5198823809623718, 0.17693786323070526, 0.4608435332775116, 0.05692253261804581, -0.2913389205932617, 0.027660707011818886, 0.5013798475265503, -0.7303726077079773, -0.5763000845909119, -0.5024555921554565, 0.43719691038131714, -0.33149272203445435, -0.39379554986953735, -0.15752676129341125, 0.6951542496681213, -0.5932344198226929 ]
{"Title": "The Pan-Cancer Landscape of Prognostic Germline Variants in 10,582 Patients", "Authors": "Chatrath Ajay, Przanowska Roza, Kiran Shashi, Su Zhangli, Saha Shekhar, Wilson Briana, Tsunematsu Takaaki, Ahn Ji-Hye, Lee Kyung Yong, Paulsen Teressa, Sobierajska Ewelina, Kiran Manjari, Tang Xiwei, Li Tianxi, Kumar Pankaj, Ratan Aakrosh, Dutta Anindya", "Abstract": "Abstract While clinical data provides physicians with information about patient prognosis, genomic data can further improve these predictions. We analyzed sequencing data from over 10,000 cancer patients and identified hundreds of prognostic germline variants using multivariate Cox regression models. These variants provide information about patient outcomes beyond clinical information currently in use and may augment clinical decisions based on expected tumor aggressiveness. Molecularly, at least twelve of the germline variants are likely associated with patient outcome through perturbation of protein structure and at least five through association with gene expression differences. About half of these germline variants are in previously reported tumor suppressors or oncogenes, with the other half pointing to loci of previously unstudied genes in the literature that should be further investigated for roles in cancers. Our results suggest that germline variation contributes to tumor progression across most cancers and contains patient outcome information not captured by clinical factors.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010264"}
10.1101/19001032
[ 0.3304575979709625, -0.21491512656211853, 0.43724027276039124, -0.01197784673422575, -0.12163416296243668, -0.06891679018735886, -0.6682620048522949, -0.23795466125011444, 0.5723799467086792, 0.36512625217437744, 0.54704350233078, -0.9947238564491272, 0.46285685896873474, -0.437714159488678, -0.015837473794817924, 0.12910953164100647, -0.31991711258888245, -0.19950148463249207, -0.29854616522789, -0.6141209602355957, 0.3490654528141022, 0.21219414472579956, -0.37295135855674744, 0.751529335975647, -0.44841161370277405, 0.5087043046951294, 0.04956551641225815, 0.08409280329942703, 1.0673658847808838, 0.3310588300228119, -0.7302262187004089, -0.1663515567779541, 0.6469668745994568, -1.5952190160751343, -0.08684477210044861, 0.0009263072861358523, 0.5088242888450623, -0.3357575833797455, -1.1906901597976685, 0.0005987731856293976, -0.20699866116046906, 0.2549612820148468, 0.12368591129779816, 0.08746615052223206, -0.6003291606903076, 0.428518682718277, -1.064274787902832, -0.4239617586135864, -0.08657098561525345, -0.3535618782043457, 0.1914866715669632, 0.05827104672789574, 0.0047561852261424065, -0.011325416155159473, 0.2472403645515442, 0.24232900142669678, 0.7054927349090576, 0.481054425239563, -0.5014774203300476, 0.0008140495046973228, 0.14462342858314514, -0.2335767298936844, 0.3897522985935211, -0.8960233330726624, 0.6548382043838501, 0.9509645700454712, 0.310565322637558, -0.2495330423116684, -0.4856393039226532, -0.12432257831096649, 0.36075884103775024, -0.5766006708145142, -0.33637920022010803, -0.7504169940948486, -0.20352233946323395, -1.0004650354385376, 0.7749223709106445, 0.24044403433799744, -0.15065719187259674, 0.03439086675643921, -0.0002639928716234863, 0.1293978989124298, 0.3697790503501892, -0.26367321610450745, -0.45647358894348145, 0.034001901745796204, 0.8773893117904663, 0.5282552242279053, -0.03208933398127556, 0.4919367730617523, 0.39546650648117065, 0.2995442748069763, -0.6419179439544678, 0.1560373455286026, -0.1867167353630066, 1.1579972505569458, -0.4187459945678711, 0.5227973461151123, 0.26961827278137207, 0.15531378984451294, 0.4715666174888611, 0.8098466992378235, -0.1873987764120102, 0.5954224467277527, -0.3031209409236908, 0.8270754218101501, 0.4038219153881073, -0.48939526081085205, 0.13667982816696167, -1.0334558486938477, 0.34366127848625183, -0.0410916768014431, -1.0202383995056152, 0.3919508159160614, 0.4777992069721222, 0.42848628759384155, -0.7145400643348694, 0.9554239511489868, -0.6397874355316162, 0.19141513109207153, -0.5066004395484924, -0.21999746561050415, 0.9780756831169128, -1.0882450342178345, 0.3573257327079773, 0.7200350165367126, 0.1632913202047348, 0.38303232192993164, -0.2981957793235779, -0.3724905848503113, 0.320196270942688, 0.10142668336629868, 0.5476750731468201, -0.11637698858976364, -0.16735681891441345, -0.26777368783950806, 0.3417757749557495, 0.3581145405769348, 0.8307071328163147, 0.028589289635419846, -0.11808530986309052, 0.10197220742702484, -0.9037320613861084, 0.9168445467948914, 0.27398863434791565, 0.4796927869319916, -0.2929413616657257, -1.445151686668396, -0.7008072733879089, 0.23106391727924347, 0.2829255163669586, 0.41976818442344666, 0.22224858403205872, -0.7667365074157715, -0.3780938684940338, 0.8706503510475159, 0.06611956655979156, -0.2606631815433502, -0.04952266439795494, 0.38251927495002747, -1.428737998008728, 0.49556875228881836, 0.0752149447798729, 0.6516448259353638, -0.7197727560997009, 0.7017533779144287, 0.16889004409313202, 0.3767656981945038, 0.1398233324289322, -0.8488876819610596, 0.4851021468639374, 0.028469054028391838, -0.09101483970880508, -0.38992518186569214, 0.26347586512565613, 0.42641329765319824, 0.6201777458190918, 0.34406912326812744, -0.24090707302093506, -0.291347473859787, 0.17145809531211853, 0.6443375945091248, 0.13920360803604126, 0.8596259951591492, -0.3221401274204254, -0.2974819242954254, -0.750504732131958, -0.5259003639221191, 0.012636502273380756, -0.325156033039093, 0.12624509632587433, 0.37669530510902405, 0.14520363509655, 0.40948790311813354, 0.22820515930652618, 0.4184529483318329, -0.5958666205406189, 0.5095025300979614, 0.20377324521541595, -1.0669631958007812, -0.5201247930526733, 0.42093321681022644, -0.115641750395298, 0.3385259807109833, -0.14924123883247375, 0.5081700682640076, 0.615196704864502, 0.10139191150665283, -1.590888261795044, -0.03385455533862114, 1.0381516218185425, 0.21357940137386322, -0.24811747670173645, -0.3398341238498688, 0.7290496230125427, -0.4073946177959442, 0.017698904499411583, 0.11709016561508179, -0.6746444702148438, 0.4068087637424469, -0.3026868999004364, -0.40295106172561646, 0.7383154034614563, 0.46060124039649963, -0.329330176115036, 0.2654092311859131, 0.6080795526504517, 0.712017834186554, -0.5200297832489014, -0.8565803170204163, 0.24990004301071167, 0.23933768272399902, -0.31011050939559937, 0.8244705200195312, 0.19434523582458496, 0.6900922060012817, 0.20459814369678497, 0.3474732041358948, -0.16300776600837708, 0.7556244134902954, 0.5816070437431335, 0.7057386636734009, 1.3829796314239502, 0.06874926388263702, -0.6596840023994446, 0.5861632823944092, -0.4672869145870209, 0.6241179704666138, -0.18499962985515594, 0.6975339651107788, -0.21680180728435516, 0.3675509989261627, 0.17634350061416626, 0.6391627192497253, -0.4820992946624756, -0.6728225350379944, 0.3833811581134796, 0.48808929324150085, 0.08214671164751053, -0.34358224272727966, -0.29741334915161133, 0.07596834003925323, -0.15670177340507507, -0.1464749276638031, 0.491730660200119, 0.7821759581565857, 0.6665092706680298, 0.4586471915245056, 0.31302064657211304, -0.9086366295814514, -0.7690321803092957, -1.0672639608383179, -0.7539815306663513, -1.1798813343048096, -0.8482649326324463, 0.09928667545318604, 1.0926425457000732, -0.4619987905025482, 0.5715572834014893, 0.05478409305214882, -0.32082289457321167, -0.13365009427070618, -0.20980040729045868, 0.23995842039585114, 0.5088955760002136, 0.11573924124240875, -0.7938172817230225, -0.008680645376443863, -0.08082479983568192, 0.5566407442092896, -0.14283853769302368, 0.02637351304292679, 0.003280094126239419, -0.6244378685951233, 0.48958489298820496, -0.7368178963661194, -0.29499104619026184, -0.15457454323768616, -0.010310910642147064, -0.3056694269180298, 0.5333331227302551, 0.17182117700576782, 0.41825199127197266, -0.4026326835155487, -0.6741326451301575, 0.16039857268333435, 0.7826802134513855, -0.5616958141326904, 0.6967505216598511, 0.6488727927207947, -0.25034093856811523, 0.26954206824302673, -0.03008672222495079, 0.19229039549827576, -0.5036505460739136, 0.6037864089012146, 0.20268858969211578, -0.5228983759880066, -0.4655618667602539, -0.37882000207901, -0.46154603362083435, -0.27888983488082886, -0.5700794458389282, -0.023552939295768738, -0.2539069652557373, 0.31374961137771606, -0.364526629447937, -1.3458932638168335, 0.7824806571006775, -0.22979183495044708, -1.6486899852752686, -0.0929274633526802, 0.16716770827770233, 0.39483365416526794, 0.8305240869522095, -0.5083103775978088, -0.19500698149204254, 0.023190846666693687, 0.11238708347082138, 0.7169849276542664, 0.008965023793280125, -0.3846486210823059, -0.03442442789673805, 0.47742441296577454, 0.6034534573554993, -0.4382302165031433, -0.36885306239128113, -0.2072572410106659, -0.39818304777145386, -0.1854199767112732, -0.12177520245313644, 0.5872398614883423, 0.45168665051460266, 0.3059898316860199, -0.11709954589605331, 0.6895679235458374, -0.21366213262081146, 0.05020304024219513, 0.706243634223938, 0.6420326232910156, 0.1788587123155594, 0.7952206134796143, -0.03352993354201317, 0.31090879440307617, -0.7447652816772461, -0.6240659356117249, -0.2722806930541992, 0.09802606701850891, 0.6087934374809265, -0.640612006187439, 0.892446756362915, 0.3033488690853119, -0.6905164122581482, 0.1127687320113182, -0.22754940390586853, -0.10259723663330078, 0.43093356490135193, -0.5593390464782715, 1.3480713367462158, -0.7777349948883057, 0.24048133194446564, 0.9960474967956543, 1.2009869813919067, -0.01934308186173439, -0.15590792894363403, 0.9392861127853394, -0.5512401461601257, 0.33552461862564087, -0.2313976287841797, -0.21445494890213013, 0.2013273388147354, 0.3947182297706604, 0.131803959608078, 0.27565231919288635, -0.4252471923828125, -0.3111230731010437, -0.4458659291267395, -0.46746930480003357, -0.23002447187900543, -0.33381572365760803, 1.1026009321212769, 0.04536551982164383, 0.19703608751296997, -0.21766901016235352, 0.3211774528026581, -0.12346100807189941, -0.28440237045288086, 0.5552510023117065, -0.01748470403254032, -0.6894036531448364, -0.2581630349159241, -0.31237083673477173, 0.23327523469924927, -0.10204858332872391, 0.1294081211090088, -0.8613544702529907, -0.8065915703773499, -0.32406753301620483, -0.14242017269134521, 0.48809289932250977, -0.35370394587516785, 0.2799462676048279, -0.7888384461402893, 0.6326676607131958, 0.27733778953552246, -0.775339663028717, -0.3330563008785248, -0.36010757088661194, 0.26096564531326294, 0.6108773350715637, -0.26258933544158936, -1.013709306716919, -0.38897573947906494, -0.5109652280807495, -0.11384044587612152, -0.5160782933235168, 0.24280676245689392, -0.29929980635643005, 0.7856441140174866, 0.06117589771747589, -0.11141249537467957, 0.22413314878940582, -0.2879255712032318, 0.12529098987579346, 0.07845953106880188, 0.53762286901474, 0.8610288500785828, 0.6919101476669312, 0.4435472786426544, -0.6832243204116821, 0.710094153881073, -0.7995050549507141, 0.3834693431854248, -0.07192538678646088, -0.752162516117096, -1.0560988187789917, -0.06877711415290833, -0.16788095235824585, -0.2800736725330353, -0.10302408039569855, -0.6607472896575928, 0.2511683404445648, 0.2470400333404541, -0.5640592575073242, -0.48241767287254333, 0.9645827412605286, -0.33650460839271545, 0.08720188587903976, 1.0699877738952637, 0.14666983485221863, 0.5940576195716858, -0.0971568301320076, -0.2582172453403473, -0.6466184854507446, 0.8459681868553162, 1.0064162015914917, 0.6164579391479492, 0.5053886771202087, -0.14536139369010925, -0.4753948748111725, 0.1739083230495453, 0.2974555790424347, -0.8844336271286011, -0.20508956909179688, -1.0958701372146606, -0.6770640015602112, -1.0551701784133911, -0.6130596995353699, -0.7961864471435547, 0.08393409848213196, 0.24794314801692963, -0.3528788983821869, 0.2674674689769745, -0.2215626835823059, -1.0761547088623047, -0.8169654011726379, -0.7621729969978333, -0.4821973145008087, 0.2702024579048157, 0.8746995329856873, 0.7533378601074219, -0.35377293825149536, -0.17985762655735016, 0.6521478295326233, 0.09022315591573715, -0.9517766833305359, -0.18993419408798218, 0.4500277638435364, 0.38885998725891113, -0.5030911564826965, 0.007395358290523291, -0.5579700469970703, -0.6606650948524475, -0.23406369984149933, -0.441093385219574, -0.4978831112384796, 0.7744221091270447, 0.22617384791374207, -0.11634306609630585, 0.5075628757476807, 0.1405855119228363, -0.8927605748176575, -0.3817242980003357, 0.4103045165538788, 0.25278234481811523, -0.23453333973884583, 0.3396352529525757, -0.7039611339569092, -1.182166576385498, -0.26186755299568176, 0.33571434020996094, -0.6517263054847717, -0.1054149866104126, -0.10686088353395462, -0.1256112903356552, 0.1818985790014267, 0.6158410310745239, -0.41037967801094055, 0.40449613332748413, -0.10697559267282486, -0.7788225412368774, 0.15660807490348816, -0.6874737739562988, 0.2549374997615814, -0.15125124156475067, -0.4399404227733612, 0.42983853816986084, 0.833686351776123, 0.5754338502883911, -0.5999128818511963, 0.42494574189186096, 0.21737556159496307, 0.05461277440190315, -0.25112128257751465, 0.06265673786401749, -0.5397859811782837, -0.02278171107172966, 0.30256298184394836, -0.2689412236213684, -0.4323550760746002, -1.4163106679916382, 0.3829258382320404, -0.43314558267593384, -0.4676332473754883, 0.4875941574573517, -1.0258073806762695, -0.14253012835979462, -0.5199026465415955, 0.38494959473609924, -0.7728952169418335, 0.8442909121513367, 0.21842710673809052, -0.6076722741127014, -0.17336559295654297, 0.4614029824733734, 0.2719988226890564, -0.22796276211738586, -0.3066650331020355, -0.35463032126426697, 0.39244991540908813, 0.3859975337982178, -0.081085205078125, 0.4944339692592621, -0.6249182820320129, 0.1395188570022583, -0.10924779623746872, 0.019223876297473907, 0.5046604871749878, -0.3428168296813965, -0.712702751159668, -0.8542993068695068, 0.6384731531143188, -0.31164395809173584, -0.21514320373535156, 0.9430469870567322, -0.4660193622112274, -0.40691059827804565, 0.1439637988805771, -0.023473618552088737, -0.7076707482337952, 0.17759442329406738, 0.26788949966430664, 0.4223819971084595, 0.15928800404071808, 0.1265106499195099, -0.19539913535118103, -0.4768525958061218, -0.23848317563533783, 1.0083003044128418, -0.01213901862502098, 0.2669704556465149, 0.6145805716514587, -0.0038943421095609665, -0.12426695972681046, 0.6443886160850525, -0.478487491607666, 0.1514909416437149, -0.20587842166423798, 0.2713255286216736, 0.47484090924263, -0.9995434880256653, 0.49122726917266846, 0.3648125231266022, -0.39512285590171814, -0.49148261547088623, 0.5450723171234131, -0.26432546973228455, -0.09900981187820435, -0.15722617506980896, -0.3036918640136719, 0.9597700238227844, 0.033032286912202835, 0.6019797325134277, -0.21535158157348633, 0.3303907811641693, -0.21366186439990997, -0.9277308583259583, 0.10711509734392166, -0.6139588952064514, 0.16070759296417236, 1.1334433555603027, -0.14853282272815704, -0.4252473711967468, 0.3333933353424072, 0.5022088885307312, -0.4247967004776001, 0.08572542667388916, -0.14075390994548798, -0.26000484824180603, -0.19678743183612823, 0.18812641501426697, -0.18236906826496124, 0.5336965918540955, 0.09028150141239166, -0.5598444938659668, 0.7061007022857666, 0.1440088152885437, -0.5290012955665588, -0.5330843925476074, 0.5710790753364563, 0.618180513381958, 0.19844359159469604, 0.15870259702205658, 0.08550537377595901, 1.0321792364120483, 0.17461629211902618, -0.052521947771310806, -0.8366420269012451, -0.11652803421020508, -0.7183186411857605, -0.866479218006134, -0.15179812908172607, -0.8790900707244873, -0.012620986439287663, -0.0000037277204683050513, -0.32530876994132996, 0.002101802034303546, -0.9566113948822021, 0.11124560236930847, 0.1334863156080246, 0.08212234079837799, -0.34743446111679077, 0.14004023373126984, -0.35053810477256775, -0.6505123376846313, -0.31639307737350464, -1.0811049938201904, 0.49286139011383057, 0.751907229423523, -0.7484399676322937, -0.37087616324424744, -0.4601096212863922, 0.564021110534668, -0.1730414181947708, 0.3111307919025421, -0.37600255012512207, -0.2660876512527466, -0.3196725845336914, 0.8584981560707092, 0.4757443368434906, -0.6799356937408447, 1.7420772314071655, -0.5576491355895996, 0.5924910306930542, 0.32624033093452454, 0.1281779706478119, 0.016754737123847008, 0.19443245232105255, 0.6887179613113403, -0.9717514514923096, -0.2696983516216278, -0.6940091252326965, 0.44046497344970703, -1.4755146503448486, -0.051470834761857986, -0.5202876925468445, -0.6404830813407898, -0.38540053367614746, 0.2768208086490631, -0.0752834752202034, 0.5117954611778259, 0.345022052526474, 0.3851134181022644, 0.4027248024940491, 1.1488934755325317, 0.6307542324066162, -0.27669230103492737, 0.09091337770223618, 0.30951395630836487, 0.47747042775154114, 0.08249695599079132, 0.472251832485199, 0.2945675551891327, -0.2533054053783417, 0.5190920233726501, 0.037790652364492416, 0.6594407558441162, -0.07121811807155609, -0.45070990920066833, 0.30357712507247925, 0.49680095911026, 1.1844602823257446, 0.521839439868927, 0.8290119767189026, -0.4805530905723572, -1.0691864490509033, -0.5548403263092041, -1.2114605903625488, -0.7489076256752014, 0.5319842100143433, -0.060419194400310516, 0.5299039483070374, -0.58504718542099, -0.10516645759344101, 0.5682750940322876, 0.4605562388896942, 0.10255802422761917, -0.3978920876979828, -0.0052087497897446156, 0.7058854103088379, 0.6655073761940002, 0.4880649745464325, 0.76844722032547, -0.15915639698505402, 0.13376037776470184, -0.44735896587371826, -0.3546268343925476, -0.5098772644996643, -0.0007193209021352232, 0.47576117515563965, -0.7155832648277283, -0.3281436264514923, -0.3945121169090271, 0.2419881522655487, -0.33978143334388733, -0.26983362436294556, 0.052688274532556534, -0.6612920761108398, 0.42165428400039673, -0.00822012685239315, 0.6869269609451294, 0.10964562743902206, 0.02707059122622013, -0.0950016900897026, -0.523206889629364, -0.3873247802257538, 0.5103408694267273, 0.5675485134124756, 0.27050429582595825, 0.6133883595466614, -0.16117845475673676, 0.3571438789367676, -0.43457236886024475, -0.42735323309898376, 0.9005289673805237, 0.8080950379371643, 0.06911056488752365, 0.6745995283126831, 0.318070650100708, 0.6815676689147949, 1.057685375213623, 0.668470561504364, -0.6125283241271973, 0.4320094883441925, 0.7169927954673767, -0.1204691007733345, -0.2722005248069763, -0.6304100751876831, 0.28117725253105164, 0.32196691632270813, -0.016258887946605682, 0.2331094741821289, -0.5018361806869507, 0.03982020169496536, -0.159624382853508, -1.115332841873169, 0.485555499792099, -1.2886241674423218, 0.01922750100493431, -0.5102346539497375, 0.1647917777299881, 0.09379161894321442, 0.4621361792087555, 0.26043203473091125, -0.35132190585136414, 0.15650568902492523, -0.12848424911499023, 0.646939754486084, 0.8170964121818542, -0.645393967628479, -0.7303453087806702, -0.4274730384349823, 0.5253629088401794, 0.014337603002786636, -0.07005447894334793, 0.09432651102542877, -0.0971444845199585, 0.2845001816749573, 0.7088750600814819, -0.25036513805389404, 0.00942306313663721, 0.9981807470321655, -0.6449933648109436, 0.0540916882455349, 0.34150075912475586, -0.2434740513563156, -0.7536290287971497, -0.4877975583076477, 0.3302428424358368, -0.7136563062667847, -0.1361417919397354, 0.9557272791862488, 0.47780275344848633, 0.5871611833572388, -0.3061397075653076, 0.17717544734477997, -0.0894048884510994, -0.11041219532489777, 0.32430270314216614, -0.06016087159514427, -0.2797568142414093, -0.1397385150194168, -0.2670959234237671, -0.7149668335914612, -0.22369077801704407, -0.24658064544200897, -0.027449732646346092, -0.4269985258579254, 0.42323702573776245, -0.1708916276693344, -0.32423439621925354, -0.3471575677394867, -0.7982133030891418, -0.4031125605106354, -0.3683116137981415, -0.4644874334335327, -0.3189588189125061, 0.4096503257751465, 0.37524721026420593, 0.13381598889827728, -0.6447420716285706, 0.16650351881980896, -0.20914903283119202, -0.23695410788059235, -0.8987610340118408, 0.5097175240516663, 0.23737387359142303, 0.08038230240345001, -1.116193175315857, -1.6104686260223389, 0.5082665681838989, -0.11942499130964279, 0.2600610852241516, -0.5874373912811279, -0.5237436294555664, 0.42697975039482117, 0.22526372969150543, 0.15796487033367157, -0.45941025018692017, 0.2851729393005371, 0.2754281461238861, 0.8590094447135925, 0.025318657979369164, 0.5588166117668152, -0.29586896300315857, 0.5842289328575134, 0.36388862133026123, -0.08822551369667053, 0.010949036106467247, -0.13485807180404663, -0.23062916100025177, -0.6895951628684998, 0.7108011841773987, -0.47175702452659607, -0.4906916320323944, -0.38952943682670593, 0.7689296007156372, 0.5032972693443298, -0.6812439560890198, -1.112420678138733, 0.2791514992713928, -0.49666664004325867, 0.14170534908771515, -0.6101823449134827, -0.45787113904953003, 0.34277552366256714, 0.38734379410743713, 0.027101192623376846, -1.0180573463439941, 4.046360015869141, 1.3746925592422485, 0.3497042655944824, -0.6086077690124512, 0.4574876129627228, 1.0325456857681274, 0.5722571611404419, -0.15410667657852173, 0.06675300002098083, -0.28205448389053345, -0.5240613222122192, -0.34097573161125183, 0.744771420955658, 0.15582585334777832, 0.2131795585155487, 0.004188776947557926, -1.0712605714797974, 0.08948705345392227, 0.4916733503341675, -0.9949457049369812, -1.056826114654541, 0.08331596106290817, 0.021835988387465477, 0.11827497184276581, 0.6751309037208557, 0.40895408391952515, 0.31476953625679016, -0.02502823993563652, -0.31982743740081787, -0.48264452815055847, -0.017273111268877983, -0.12358804792165756, 0.9934958219528198, -0.23181959986686707, 0.02316182479262352, 0.018816027790308, -0.1939086765050888, -0.39661210775375366, 0.12512333691120148, 0.9135711193084717, -0.011311430484056473, -0.43207332491874695, 0.0045903753489255905, -0.3551173210144043, -0.2680380642414093, 0.1574958860874176, -0.7168307900428772, 0.31831255555152893, -0.12403616309165955, -0.5061898231506348, 0.457842618227005, -0.5733360648155212, 1.1440966129302979, 0.17572692036628723, -0.15241217613220215, 0.007795918267220259, -0.1992315649986267, -1.2585484981536865, -0.6045493483543396, 0.19920922815799713, 1.0166476964950562, -0.20515885949134827, -0.5176001787185669, -0.024310611188411713, 0.27205580472946167, 0.7633292078971863, 0.7937802076339722, -0.026778269559144974, 0.07085596024990082, -0.5711963772773743, -0.36097824573516846, 0.08610411733388901, -0.24668189883232117, 0.2703212797641754, 0.5235655307769775, 0.34034863114356995, -0.3755670487880707, 0.8300264477729797, -0.7614746689796448, -0.2403317242860794, 0.5347337126731873, -0.16404516994953156, 0.06526177376508713, 0.12908460199832916, -0.11501432210206985, 0.24806451797485352, -1.2471678256988525, -0.27904441952705383, -1.2322131395339966, 0.8301055431365967, 0.10845586657524109, -0.18882086873054504, 0.08051667362451553, 0.5755107402801514, -0.7405083775520325 ]
{"Title": "Identifying Ashkenazi Jewish BRCA1/2 founder variants in individuals who do not self-report Jewish ancestry", "Authors": "Tennen Ruth I., Laskey Sarah B., Koelsch Bertram L., McIntyre Matthew H., Tung Joyce Y.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Current guidelines recommend BRCA1 and BRCA2 genetic testing for individuals with a personal or family history of certain cancers. Three BRCA1/2 founder variants \u2014 185delAG (c.68_69delAG), 5382insC (c.5266dupC), and 6174delT (c.5946delT) \u2014 are common in the Ashkenazi Jewish population. We characterized a cohort of more than 2,800 research participants in the 23andMe database who carry one or more of the three Ashkenazi Jewish founder variants, evaluating two characteristics that are typically used to recommend individuals for BRCA testing: self-reported Jewish ancestry and family history of breast, ovarian, prostate, or pancreatic cancer. Of the 1,967 carriers who provided self-reported ancestry information, 21% did not self-report any Jewish ancestry; of these individuals, more than half (62%) do have detectable Ashkenazi Jewish genetic ancestry. In addition, of the 343 carriers who provided both ancestry and family history information, 44% did not have a first-degree family history of a BRCA -related cancer and, in the absence of a personal history of cancer, would therefore be unlikely to qualify for clinical genetic testing. These findings provide support for the growing call for broader access to BRCA genetic testing.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001032"}
10.1101/19004234
[ 0.30374276638031006, -0.4134274125099182, -0.5673732161521912, 0.25450631976127625, -0.20912706851959229, -0.4843755066394806, -0.04421704635024071, -0.4476909339427948, 0.24068637192249298, 0.6534538865089417, -0.5106168985366821, 0.20651932060718536, 0.4443437457084656, 0.013844592496752739, -0.10964731127023697, 0.02923143282532692, -0.5215717554092407, 0.08924362808465958, -0.32607078552246094, 0.5524899959564209, -0.2389703243970871, 1.0865488052368164, -0.6028030514717102, 0.007720058783888817, -0.31177952885627747, 0.3293466567993164, -0.2717020511627197, 0.40242114663124084, 1.4190579652786255, 1.136244297027588, 0.4257484972476959, 0.07372630387544632, 0.4191148281097412, -1.1116209030151367, 0.05419336259365082, -0.020915275439620018, 0.6819957494735718, -0.20285192131996155, -0.11301375925540924, -0.23386992514133453, 0.6508097052574158, -0.10618037730455399, -0.005382557399570942, -0.4406903088092804, -0.8232277631759644, -0.428120881319046, -0.15903633832931519, -0.24613513052463531, 0.09355895966291428, 0.1992313116788864, -0.12219087779521942, -0.13004565238952637, 0.05718265473842621, -0.23882322013378143, -0.6873500943183899, -0.34336820244789124, -0.18513603508472443, -0.5284625887870789, -0.6123344898223877, 0.29098013043403625, 0.2685451805591583, -0.5604755282402039, 0.039245493710041046, -0.9785088896751404, 0.6856314539909363, 0.27044710516929626, -0.11052568256855011, 0.1445806324481964, -0.05884300544857979, -0.2958438992500305, -0.6641547679901123, -0.3652438521385193, -0.08474321663379669, -0.3103380501270294, -0.299911767244339, -0.6503021121025085, -0.04774525761604309, -0.1995362490415573, -0.7580364942550659, -0.36481156945228577, 0.4540024399757385, 0.42497366666793823, 0.7878167629241943, -0.3532405197620392, -0.4246550500392914, -0.10965541750192642, -0.2803674340248108, -0.38901016116142273, 0.5703077912330627, 0.9122093915939331, -0.11839935928583145, -0.054006222635507584, 0.5096421837806702, -0.23555311560630798, 0.21892866492271423, 0.6490543484687805, -0.3133048713207245, -0.08295796811580658, 0.3893481194972992, -0.10414306819438934, 0.8231667280197144, 0.6431272625923157, -0.7939971685409546, 0.9317227602005005, -0.5029842257499695, 1.0278387069702148, 0.31913912296295166, -0.9305037260055542, -0.4108768701553345, -0.4849662184715271, 0.5002728700637817, 0.047698646783828735, -0.7841120958328247, 0.033008307218551636, -0.016855774447321892, 1.0830436944961548, -0.5048420429229736, 0.5811883807182312, -0.10261965543031693, 0.888421893119812, 0.2876400053501129, 0.07594428211450577, 0.8041713833808899, -0.4024185538291931, 0.9269701838493347, 0.01829402707517147, 0.1644940972328186, 0.5380294322967529, -0.16796624660491943, -0.30442139506340027, 0.27370917797088623, -0.47406426072120667, -0.1357477456331253, 0.2383534014225006, -0.34733328223228455, -0.0630631372332573, 0.14160117506980896, 0.09950058162212372, 0.43603816628456116, -0.1584821343421936, -0.6044696569442749, 0.5636214017868042, -0.39013388752937317, 1.4867010116577148, -0.33361029624938965, 0.9287387728691101, -0.709009051322937, -0.6805083155632019, -0.3022940754890442, -0.2616010010242462, -0.07984588295221329, 0.5791337490081787, -0.6494709849357605, 0.6897671818733215, 0.5048332214355469, 0.22883613407611847, -0.2654208540916443, -0.2854065001010895, -0.48388049006462097, -0.10189253091812134, -0.35428833961486816, -0.1457429975271225, 0.33140337467193604, 0.5889753699302673, -0.09828980267047882, 0.7432995438575745, 0.0011649923399090767, -0.14083538949489594, 0.20426248013973236, -0.37917929887771606, 0.8941648006439209, -0.32263481616973877, -0.17392702400684357, 0.22178518772125244, 0.676206111907959, 1.7645294666290283, 0.37680402398109436, -0.31859079003334045, 0.005989894270896912, 1.1753194332122803, -0.005358654074370861, 0.15879076719284058, -0.15288078784942627, 0.7267204523086548, 0.2961375117301941, 0.42053332924842834, 0.4961387813091278, -0.42277899384498596, -0.13973651826381683, -0.4812012314796448, -0.07295328378677368, 0.22756193578243256, -0.41763240098953247, 0.5760807394981384, 0.36435994505882263, -0.640303909778595, -0.49419477581977844, 0.059960950165987015, 0.04367071017622948, 0.09902044385671616, -0.6705518960952759, 0.01770150475203991, -0.10600389540195465, 1.047514796257019, -0.44839757680892944, 0.38269978761672974, 0.3559429347515106, 0.2970430254936218, 0.32683315873146057, 0.12165230512619019, 0.7972939610481262, 0.07031964510679245, -0.057925496250391006, -0.0862557590007782, 0.5973033308982849, 0.093204565346241, -0.7043132781982422, 0.3511652648448944, -0.8439704775810242, 0.3645969331264496, -0.41951078176498413, -0.5291318297386169, 0.38551998138427734, -0.2682840824127197, 0.49838390946388245, -0.07187418639659882, 0.08890268206596375, 0.09235244989395142, -0.405362993478775, 0.2671997845172882, -0.031311895698308945, 0.5257505178451538, -0.36762088537216187, 1.2468549013137817, 0.9116820096969604, -0.3348844349384308, -0.16515015065670013, 0.1431400328874588, 1.0238847732543945, 0.6329671740531921, 0.5779939889907837, -0.15554890036582947, -0.09746130555868149, 0.5260049104690552, -0.5738657116889954, 0.6605286002159119, -0.24246655404567719, -0.2876744270324707, -0.3330208957195282, -0.21564728021621704, 0.17380689084529877, 0.9482054710388184, 0.6992698907852173, 1.0017056465148926, -1.0383167266845703, -0.6183711290359497, 0.6586570739746094, 0.0017527861054986715, -0.5063397884368896, -0.5220433473587036, -0.47066760063171387, 0.4243338704109192, -0.5811054706573486, -0.2110043615102768, 1.4588823318481445, 0.8762266039848328, -0.5781140327453613, -0.6326374411582947, 0.482835054397583, -0.3610582947731018, -0.852255642414093, -0.19278272986412048, -0.7583280205726624, -0.7638159990310669, -0.5602195262908936, 0.12107440084218979, 0.11641589552164078, 0.30217450857162476, -0.021698668599128723, -0.03712988272309303, 0.20825493335723877, 0.48138758540153503, 0.028616972267627716, 0.9580826163291931, 0.5528141856193542, -0.12864084541797638, -1.0906339883804321, 0.4425116777420044, -0.26559045910835266, -0.07076317071914673, -0.13275028765201569, -0.614838719367981, -0.5928777456283569, -0.9487621784210205, 0.31225132942199707, 0.12805107235908508, 0.23306463658809662, 0.593580961227417, -0.07016034424304962, 0.010032424703240395, -0.03514012694358826, 0.1495419591665268, -0.5561785101890564, -0.2879854440689087, -0.2595636248588562, 0.21606144309043884, -0.2106003314256668, 0.2706280052661896, 0.6043299436569214, 0.0994114950299263, -0.331659734249115, 0.8904107213020325, 0.27614912390708923, 0.12541258335113525, -0.7641655206680298, -0.35812318325042725, 0.5299519300460815, -0.6362408995628357, 0.5905168652534485, -0.2528449296951294, -0.8114408850669861, 0.6232860088348389, -0.16705168783664703, -0.42265841364860535, 0.5633398294448853, 0.3276554346084595, 0.24078412353992462, -1.0338630676269531, 0.050849832594394684, -0.2472645789384842, -0.5892460942268372, 0.036994971334934235, 0.3601040840148926, -0.1650635153055191, 0.18006238341331482, -0.4743175804615021, -0.9613457918167114, -0.31096959114074707, -0.4772704243659973, -0.769903838634491, 0.2439032793045044, -0.38789504766464233, 0.3373476564884186, 0.010350189171731472, 0.14247286319732666, 0.5682244300842285, 0.7423589825630188, -0.18156376481056213, -0.5285117626190186, 0.02758432924747467, -0.4157073497772217, -0.22502106428146362, 0.5190420150756836, 0.13508912920951843, -1.0394619703292847, 0.9856409430503845, -0.2789372503757477, -0.32799503207206726, -0.2730397582054138, 0.47870591282844543, 0.17224739491939545, -0.27376043796539307, -0.5678237676620483, 0.059943169355392456, -0.8040860295295715, -0.8138348460197449, 0.14407896995544434, 0.4251028895378113, 0.626547634601593, -0.22790205478668213, 0.36754685640335083, -0.25751224160194397, -0.15330395102500916, -0.3557014763355255, -0.34027764201164246, -0.2312924563884735, 1.0228222608566284, 0.6905297636985779, 0.8280428051948547, -0.7608003616333008, 0.5868404507637024, 1.0657646656036377, 0.8556640148162842, 0.873237133026123, 0.2302786260843277, 0.5652137398719788, -0.49007031321525574, 0.3040911555290222, 0.664311408996582, -0.6018688082695007, 0.19376982748508453, -0.20254608988761902, 0.35854533314704895, -0.0668223649263382, -0.5549187064170837, -0.2135768085718155, 0.422159343957901, 0.6503247618675232, 0.6647818684577942, 0.03093729168176651, 0.6092568039894104, -0.32145869731903076, 0.5310699939727783, 1.0208457708358765, 0.41367191076278687, 0.7660870552062988, -1.1210732460021973, 0.17897385358810425, -0.6481195092201233, -0.16846781969070435, -0.5447199940681458, -1.0067423582077026, -0.5404052734375, 0.023824622854590416, 0.09359493106603622, 0.08718959242105484, 0.1811501532793045, -0.7818066477775574, -0.7257733345031738, -0.04285131022334099, 0.8441604375839233, -0.40319207310676575, -0.5489922165870667, -0.23443040251731873, -0.6497028470039368, -0.13117441534996033, -0.39291054010391235, -0.43049344420433044, 0.5541265606880188, 0.7221401333808899, -0.4915529191493988, 0.047604452818632126, -0.7283242344856262, -0.3395458161830902, -0.5769436955451965, 0.1307467222213745, -0.20709827542304993, 0.005559646524488926, -0.11187432706356049, -0.7490917444229126, -0.3334745168685913, -0.48217734694480896, 0.19841134548187256, -0.8685303330421448, 0.23577091097831726, 0.31135573983192444, 0.9482434988021851, 0.38297727704048157, 0.024217572063207626, 0.9171590209007263, -0.07954243570566177, -1.0950340032577515, 0.12274031341075897, -0.4632053077220917, -0.25211840867996216, 0.1451946198940277, -0.6318842172622681, 0.16393253207206726, 0.4343130886554718, 0.059063930064439774, -0.3497523069381714, -0.19178301095962524, -0.0784667581319809, -0.13010388612747192, -0.1718813180923462, 0.7472090125083923, 0.37201303243637085, 0.18634693324565887, 1.7117033004760742, -1.0552406311035156, -0.4283558130264282, 0.04573114588856697, 0.023353436961770058, -0.506505012512207, 0.021930484101176262, 0.6594386100769043, -0.019225137308239937, 0.19605401158332825, -0.08299703896045685, 0.2720341086387634, -0.019374672323465347, 0.14820145070552826, -0.012674246914684772, 0.07297500967979431, 0.3089483678340912, -0.9213534593582153, 0.10830128937959671, -0.12374281883239746, -1.141217589378357, -0.005230079870671034, -0.4806670546531677, -0.6358475089073181, -0.2474920153617859, 0.13025227189064026, -0.3377978503704071, 0.1813209056854248, -0.4551016092300415, 0.1839442402124405, -0.2832264006137848, -0.07070125639438629, 0.1540258824825287, -0.49090665578842163, -0.5820127129554749, -0.265100359916687, 0.5014887452125549, -0.9841791987419128, -0.20494171977043152, -0.6041003465652466, -1.0203008651733398, -0.40822887420654297, -0.6482567191123962, 0.6147711873054504, -0.6053221225738525, -0.8529855608940125, -0.34527337551116943, 0.1390826255083084, 1.290999412536621, -0.17362864315509796, -0.20632284879684448, 0.1282554715871811, -0.5142130255699158, -0.3232158422470093, -0.015325618907809258, 0.5562820434570312, 0.5544753074645996, 0.3937462270259857, -0.019137227907776833, -0.8836762309074402, -0.3464033901691437, -1.0406280755996704, 0.48606228828430176, -0.2737380862236023, -0.1813361942768097, -0.04438895732164383, -0.41543853282928467, 0.22791731357574463, -0.28313136100769043, -0.06737430393695831, 0.4699571132659912, -0.5210725665092468, -0.26693716645240784, 0.7459432482719421, 0.07550432533025742, -0.159884512424469, -0.26752594113349915, -0.6644602417945862, 0.44357120990753174, 0.9805924892425537, 0.0076942746527493, -0.2801181375980377, -0.1970328390598297, 0.1999000757932663, 0.5353778004646301, 0.3541943430900574, -0.590720534324646, -0.6923999190330505, 0.10836809128522873, 0.21842536330223083, -0.5431942343711853, -0.36473381519317627, -1.0647697448730469, 0.2665442228317261, -0.1832895129919052, 0.12691140174865723, -0.343060702085495, -0.6830251216888428, 0.18586991727352142, -0.12757381796836853, 0.9534987211227417, 0.16622577607631683, 0.22391758859157562, 0.5655531287193298, -0.48234179615974426, -0.19176456332206726, -0.20576710999011993, -0.02999616600573063, -1.5743995904922485, -0.714022159576416, -0.5805729031562805, 0.6563728451728821, -0.22996942698955536, -0.6076430082321167, -0.010381928645074368, 0.22867777943611145, -0.3530656695365906, 0.29178866744041443, 0.9387789964675903, 0.7576055526733398, -1.1467595100402832, 0.09821764379739761, 0.7024784088134766, 0.8959154486656189, 0.156156525015831, 0.45197737216949463, -0.3008004426956177, -0.5244613885879517, 0.35932448506355286, -0.046138111501932144, -0.22588779032230377, -0.6763665080070496, 0.19405511021614075, 0.2619490623474121, 0.8253096342086792, -0.15140505135059357, 0.8077464699745178, 0.02013944648206234, -0.7807096242904663, -1.0357412099838257, 0.4871094822883606, 0.17023810744285583, -0.1732756495475769, 0.9588118195533752, -0.555279016494751, 0.27571743726730347, 0.3162024915218353, -0.11520149558782578, 0.6937572360038757, -0.6520273685455322, 0.9515155553817749, 0.0691203698515892, -1.7423683404922485, 1.2570527791976929, -0.13703493773937225, -0.25897589325904846, -1.0738592147827148, 0.22523564100265503, -0.6737025380134583, -0.3835676610469818, -0.17955224215984344, -0.07350808382034302, 0.4066839814186096, 0.01898358017206192, 1.002099871635437, -0.5192899703979492, 0.022979900240898132, -0.12880976498126984, 0.09813559800386429, 0.8911637663841248, -0.6565640568733215, -0.24188460409641266, 0.6890819072723389, -0.3318912982940674, 1.3389108180999756, 0.3933767080307007, -0.011399422772228718, -0.20430625975131989, 0.41513925790786743, 0.7253367900848389, -0.11017055809497833, 0.4045392870903015, -0.02286878041923046, -0.009906894527375698, 0.22220411896705627, -0.029716886579990387, -0.2546066343784332, 0.5743954181671143, 0.7522597908973694, -1.0477361679077148, -0.45527008175849915, 0.6594473719596863, 0.1823323518037796, 0.8428118228912354, -0.15182024240493774, -0.17974711954593658, 0.4648551940917969, 0.337740957736969, 0.6195200085639954, -0.25152483582496643, -0.22461384534835815, -0.49229809641838074, -0.3859025537967682, -0.2808245122432709, -0.3692888617515564, -0.06397546827793121, 0.3257009983062744, -0.9842387437820435, -1.2085150480270386, 0.3787546753883362, 0.8815297484397888, 0.5086743235588074, 0.0823526456952095, -0.18874046206474304, 0.40254223346710205, -0.9243490695953369, -1.0683319568634033, -0.23179836571216583, -0.16701765358448029, -0.04399542883038521, 1.812960147857666, -0.5780943036079407, -0.2919704020023346, 0.48747965693473816, -0.4990745484828949, 0.5721215605735779, 0.4557943344116211, -0.22734777629375458, -0.2997717559337616, 0.11464956402778625, 0.654815673828125, 0.30519023537635803, -0.29626965522766113, 0.9064083695411682, -0.8303117752075195, 0.4051446318626404, 0.062332432717084885, -0.12427343428134918, -0.11966919153928757, -0.4189153015613556, 0.2257010042667389, -0.38765037059783936, -0.7033492922782898, -0.39805272221565247, 0.6121874451637268, -0.9514065384864807, -0.2628325819969177, -0.044023819267749786, -1.0365954637527466, -0.2867067754268646, 0.5877526998519897, -0.292030930519104, -0.011491618119180202, -0.5835629105567932, -0.4865248203277588, -0.2552025616168976, 0.41745197772979736, 0.14497725665569305, 0.02772558480501175, 0.32596781849861145, 0.31573137640953064, 0.3824014663696289, -0.7091882228851318, 0.4823678135871887, 0.4648605287075043, -0.13719941675662994, 0.6524486541748047, -0.7479092478752136, 0.054043058305978775, 0.6376062035560608, -0.5055379271507263, -0.4809999167919159, 0.9294087886810303, -0.18895035982131958, 0.836412787437439, 0.46914976835250854, -0.37211623787879944, -0.223480224609375, -0.9349968433380127, -1.2958108186721802, -0.6038299202919006, 0.9279038310050964, -0.7407197952270508, -0.004206191748380661, -0.15978005528450012, -0.8397260904312134, 0.34474846720695496, 0.4649941027164459, 0.4575039744377136, 0.35489898920059204, 0.5291298031806946, -0.12058813869953156, 0.3634321689605713, 0.19145338237285614, -0.35654300451278687, -0.06104785576462746, 0.8438645005226135, -0.7820918560028076, -0.5232535600662231, 0.03765140101313591, 0.47703877091407776, 0.055628933012485504, -0.11163146048784256, -0.3689502477645874, 0.20775598287582397, -0.06989707797765732, -0.42481091618537903, -0.465312123298645, 0.1790362149477005, -0.0683906078338623, 0.0276851337403059, 0.35243192315101624, 0.508192241191864, -0.13735997676849365, -0.13925622403621674, 0.24576161801815033, -0.5573574900627136, -0.6609103083610535, -0.0018162333872169256, 0.5329367518424988, -0.03450047969818115, 0.6081029772758484, -0.00470680883154273, -0.07720240205526352, 0.1126137375831604, -0.300814151763916, 0.440285861492157, 0.8121066689491272, -0.7493296265602112, 0.6105031967163086, -0.20523639023303986, 0.16996432840824127, 0.8000864386558533, 0.3873193562030792, -0.4871480166912079, 0.3654291033744812, 0.1281702220439911, 0.44703298807144165, 0.39287713170051575, -0.3300460875034332, -0.1020723506808281, 0.07855386286973953, -0.4321451187133789, 0.11134791374206543, 0.5490418672561646, 1.172346830368042, -0.16713622212409973, 0.42387279868125916, 0.3888517916202545, -0.09721840173006058, -0.5712903738021851, 0.22656850516796112, -0.42190295457839966, 0.9798418283462524, 0.1458076685667038, -0.09123993664979935, -0.3439789116382599, 0.16078805923461914, 0.18808506429195404, -0.0007269293419085443, 0.28247830271720886, -0.9816376566886902, 0.34653711318969727, -0.6896922588348389, 0.4111846685409546, -0.338215708732605, 0.3576165437698364, 0.4539746046066284, -0.2229682356119156, 0.587057888507843, -0.27191489934921265, 0.12817449867725372, 0.017854809761047363, 1.1056671142578125, -0.2940590977668762, -0.29533651471138, -0.06388191878795624, -0.4211500883102417, 0.14334015548229218, -0.13796965777873993, 0.4291177988052368, -0.09094201773405075, 0.2762114107608795, -0.1450415998697281, 1.1108222007751465, 0.34914150834083557, 0.3220406174659729, 0.7696489691734314, -0.5496501922607422, 0.049006056040525436, -0.14710597693920135, -0.14897224307060242, -0.38856634497642517, -0.46433213353157043, -0.20138408243656158, 0.0003088926896452904, -0.4315648674964905, -0.22587652504444122, -0.21965692937374115, -0.24199196696281433, -0.27468341588974, 0.7738862633705139, -0.3452805280685425, -0.013711271807551384, -1.0964417457580566, -0.35714805126190186, -0.8571316599845886, -0.11692982912063599, 0.03733044117689133, -0.03358343243598938, 0.28612345457077026, -1.0635894536972046, -0.4434894323348999, -0.24776965379714966, -0.6264267563819885, 0.18661510944366455, -1.1742515563964844, 0.3128039538860321, 0.298748642206192, -0.25632861256599426, -0.921603798866272, -1.0203824043273926, -0.11778953671455383, -0.019694223999977112, -0.2364034503698349, -0.9158294796943665, 0.1607050746679306, -0.016326196491718292, 0.3216055929660797, -0.2750832438468933, -0.23115655779838562, 0.10946430265903473, -0.2769356966018677, 1.132827877998352, -0.3708861470222473, 1.000882625579834, -0.04007449373602867, 0.38865020871162415, -0.11738112568855286, -0.45235273241996765, 0.4202978312969208, 0.49292537569999695, -0.36051705479621887, 0.6850576400756836, -0.032442301511764526, -0.1309620440006256, -1.0427056550979614, 0.8605860471725464, 0.31051331758499146, -0.3828968107700348, 0.15639512240886688, -0.05633733049035072, -0.9563314318656921, -0.6278851628303528, 1.1382255554199219, -0.12011433392763138, 0.05122069641947746, -0.3740712106227875, 0.03597866743803024, 0.656181275844574, -1.27751886844635, 3.9638354778289795, 1.1008710861206055, 0.49179068207740784, 0.10546448826789856, 0.3230578303337097, -0.0054795993492007256, 0.5014318227767944, -0.11467626690864563, 0.21136437356472015, -0.5187746286392212, 0.20459266006946564, 0.1784491240978241, -0.5039312243461609, 0.1612321138381958, -0.30120187997817993, 0.7452223300933838, -0.8352662920951843, -0.05382426455616951, -0.026080422103405, -1.060285210609436, -0.6579548120498657, 1.1939475536346436, -0.1215546652674675, 0.4205285906791687, 0.30283164978027344, 0.7247966527938843, 0.3267449140548706, 0.021415971219539642, 0.8133296966552734, -0.1392122060060501, 0.010708245448768139, -1.0433589220046997, -0.2634207010269165, -0.6634606122970581, -0.4706634283065796, 0.3432687222957611, 0.3528415858745575, -1.0033575296401978, 0.1836378276348114, -0.7065896391868591, 0.2196332961320877, 0.5477591753005981, 0.026087410748004913, -0.20422649383544922, -0.032102420926094055, 0.19740448892116547, -1.2240861654281616, 0.24209003150463104, 0.3898642361164093, -0.6732841730117798, 0.7768464088439941, -0.7046125531196594, -0.41792938113212585, -0.13412576913833618, -0.9241853356361389, -0.7547479271888733, -0.7651821374893188, -0.3267573118209839, 0.5937095284461975, 0.3813297748565674, 1.224629282951355, -0.13376347720623016, -0.07780129462480545, -0.715533971786499, 0.34285810589790344, 0.27674853801727295, 0.3258887529373169, 0.367010235786438, 0.0756373405456543, -0.385849267244339, 0.5282238125801086, -0.5494873523712158, -0.858977735042572, 0.15873003005981445, 1.121682047843933, 0.45851218700408936, -0.5546337366104126, 1.2072713375091553, -0.33252087235450745, -0.7522998452186584, 0.1163100153207779, 0.2655376195907593, 1.0882525444030762, -0.09904645383358002, 0.1030656099319458, 1.3843928575515747, 0.02559026889503002, -0.761055052280426, -0.6658074259757996, -0.06556559354066849, 1.3452210426330566, -0.6743630766868591, -0.1638752967119217, 0.027893604710698128, -0.2467385232448578 ]
{"Title": "Time to death and its Predictors among Adult TB/HIV Co-Infected Patients in Mizan Tepi University Teaching Hospital, South West Ethiopia", "Authors": "Wondimu Wondimagegn, Dube Lamessa, Kabeta Teshome", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Tuberculosis (TB) and Human Immuno Deficiency Virus (HIV) co-infection represents a complex pathogenic scenario with synergistic effect and leads to about 300,000 HIV-associated TB deaths in the world in 2017. Despite this burden of death, time to death and its predictors among TB-HIV co-infected patient was not adequately studied; and the existing evidences are inconsistent. Therefore, this study was aimed to determine time to death and identify its predictors among adult TB/HIV co-infected patients. Method Retrospective cohort study was conducted by reviewing registers of randomly selected 364 TB/HIV co-infected patients enrolled in health care from July 2, 2007 up to July 1, 2017 at Mizan Tepi University Teaching Hospital. The hospital was located in Bench Maji Zone, South West Ethiopia. Data were collected from March 1 through 31, 2018, entered to Epi data 3.1 and exported to SPSS version 21. Each patient was followed from date of TB treatment initiation till death, loss to follow up and treatment completed. On the other hand, events other than death were considered as censored. After checking the proportional hazard model assumption, Cox-regression was used to identify the predictors. In bivariable analyses, P-value\u22640.25 was used to identify candidate variables for multivariable analysis. The 95% CI of hazard ratio (HR) with respective P-value <0.05 was used to declare significance in the final model. Result All the 364 patients were followed for 1,654 person months. There were 83 (22.8%) deaths and most 38 (45.8%) were occurring within the first two months of anti-TB treatment initiation. The overall incidence rate and median survival time were 5.02 per 100 person months (95% CI: 4.05, 6.22) and 10 months respectively. Statistically significant better survival was observed among patients: with CD4 \u2265 200 cells/mm 3 (P<0.001), who had a history of cotrimoxazole preventive therapy (CPT) use (P<0.001), who disclose their HIV status (P<0.001) and with working functional status (P<0.001). Not using CPT (adjusted hazard ratio [AHR] =1.72; P=0.023), bedridden functional status (AHR=2.55; P=0.007), not disclosing HIV status (AHR=4.03; P<0.001) and CD4 < 200 cells/mm 3 (AHR=6.05; P<0.001) were predictors of time to death among TB/HIV co-infected patients. Conclusion The median survival time was 10 months and poor survival was associated with low CD4 count, not using CPT, not disclosing HIV status and having bedridden functional status. Close monitoring of bedridden and low CD4 count patients, prompt CPT initiation and encouraging HIV status disclosure are recommended.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004234"}
10.1101/2019.12.08.19013979
[ 0.062097035348415375, 0.3851606249809265, -0.5392109155654907, 0.3210325241088867, -0.6062707304954529, -1.075263500213623, -0.09664017707109451, 0.14352770149707794, -0.27198514342308044, 0.410266637802124, 0.003406921634450555, -0.29278406500816345, 0.6010708808898926, -0.517525851726532, 0.37400445342063904, 0.21859492361545563, -0.8454171419143677, 0.010794758796691895, -0.3231261074542999, -0.8967351317405701, 0.4212400019168854, 0.3322082459926605, -0.4196692407131195, 0.12217333167791367, -0.4482891261577606, 0.09016603231430054, 0.301852822303772, -0.19578923285007477, 1.4020676612854004, 0.4420205056667328, -0.1385820508003235, -0.7259097695350647, 0.7839288115501404, -0.5647635459899902, -0.32746896147727966, -0.08341033011674881, 0.9569848775863647, -0.2572948932647705, -0.4912741482257843, -0.39015719294548035, 0.4578726887702942, 0.7580611705780029, -0.04885962978005409, -0.41557371616363525, -0.41671329736709595, -0.5386446118354797, -0.48422157764434814, -0.5360134243965149, -0.04788191244006157, -0.24609260261058807, -0.28603777289390564, 0.32565656304359436, 0.13649378716945648, -0.41718894243240356, 0.016705390065908432, -0.41978946328163147, 0.28283166885375977, -0.10373755544424057, -0.31511035561561584, -0.4045795500278473, 0.6984208226203918, -0.26107698678970337, 0.40135011076927185, -0.7595247030258179, 0.7324420213699341, 0.7233944535255432, -0.0162938442081213, 0.13216863572597504, -0.015969904139637947, -0.00103990756906569, -0.3754776120185852, 0.9453169107437134, -0.09025711566209793, -0.8160335421562195, 0.33254849910736084, -0.6005963683128357, 0.20806154608726501, -0.43125611543655396, 0.19064514338970184, -0.3104092478752136, -0.15809839963912964, -0.38439252972602844, -0.4714873731136322, 0.3603638708591461, 0.12301228195428848, 0.006552889943122864, 0.6082117557525635, 0.3475302755832672, 0.16343112289905548, -0.3591793477535248, 0.1831132173538208, 0.11488035321235657, 0.09599445015192032, 0.659691333770752, -0.08809585869312286, 0.7566937804222107, -0.29855313897132874, -0.11508473753929138, 0.4718933403491974, -0.07897516340017319, -0.22206489741802216, 1.1263036727905273, -0.4571130573749542, 1.1102499961853027, -0.6807783842086792, -0.4568295478820801, 0.22019074857234955, -0.5898323059082031, 0.23036687076091766, -0.7775161862373352, 0.09814193844795227, 0.6386513710021973, -0.11895494163036346, 0.29789969325065613, -0.3461439609527588, 0.2724141478538513, -0.17148301005363464, 0.5509148240089417, -0.06679046154022217, -0.015931153669953346, -0.6547250747680664, 0.09428470581769943, 0.5314255356788635, -0.45606935024261475, 0.3442149758338928, -0.15358248353004456, 0.27640724182128906, -0.014581713825464249, -0.10618177801370621, -0.925736129283905, -0.45952871441841125, -0.5648639798164368, -0.6990596652030945, 0.9312184453010559, -0.0825493186712265, 0.027310596778988838, -0.10244043171405792, 0.32996997237205505, -0.24098564684391022, 0.008424701169133186, -0.8006695508956909, -0.21569949388504028, 0.07098739594221115, 1.3819036483764648, -0.4304289221763611, 0.500937819480896, -0.7341017127037048, -0.9834736585617065, -0.2841540575027466, -0.7230278849601746, 0.14210359752178192, -0.4312381446361542, 0.16658730804920197, 0.42521023750305176, 0.23230211436748505, 0.21630844473838806, -0.5829867124557495, 0.6747750043869019, -0.7854244709014893, 0.44302305579185486, 0.17758101224899292, 0.1651635318994522, -0.677573025226593, 1.134253740310669, -0.3775724470615387, 0.32791611552238464, 0.21722279489040375, 0.12522533535957336, 0.16820435225963593, -0.551863968372345, 0.2657325267791748, 0.34217047691345215, -0.25593215227127075, -0.8138439059257507, -0.6480139493942261, 0.6407414674758911, 1.2379573583602905, 0.1176777109503746, -0.19992749392986298, 0.008543654344975948, 0.0672491192817688, -0.857444167137146, 0.9105703830718994, 0.5511075854301453, -0.07780425250530243, -0.16185207664966583, -0.246891051530838, -0.08615722507238388, 0.4000556766986847, 0.2227669209241867, 0.28376367688179016, 0.9910399317741394, -0.5404811501502991, 0.06879737973213196, -0.7074726819992065, 0.19966262578964233, -0.3266943097114563, -0.031257905066013336, -0.273601770401001, -0.3885982930660248, 0.03494268283247948, 0.8906715512275696, -0.4857312738895416, 0.33896544575691223, -0.5985830426216125, 0.5829574465751648, 0.5350058674812317, 0.6256406307220459, -0.4324204921722412, 0.2962643802165985, -0.27998086810112, 0.6324611306190491, 0.17832639813423157, 0.7285186648368835, 1.0392975807189941, -0.23756057024002075, 0.471943199634552, 0.43365907669067383, 0.3428231179714203, -0.13517169654369354, 0.6685368418693542, -0.022583942860364914, 1.2343380451202393, -0.012848813086748123, -0.38446465134620667, 0.47343483567237854, 0.3494892418384552, 0.35886886715888977, 0.2776261270046234, -0.3467003405094147, -0.17699503898620605, 0.43874603509902954, -0.4142056703567505, 0.2807338535785675, 0.7738004326820374, 0.13084158301353455, 0.38106870651245117, 0.59589022397995, 0.05177592486143112, -0.1689848005771637, 0.07616136223077774, 0.5093417167663574, 0.847501814365387, 0.8046765923500061, 0.08264593034982681, -0.0800091028213501, -0.4158671200275421, 0.27397727966308594, -0.4231281876564026, -0.2353040724992752, -1.184356927871704, 0.901890218257904, 0.06397101283073425, 0.17231974005699158, -0.7453293800354004, -0.6339618563652039, 0.16282609105110168, 1.0927890539169312, -0.3387340307235718, -1.0479015111923218, -0.44011959433555603, -0.14611099660396576, 0.224895179271698, 0.1477009654045105, 1.1956896781921387, 0.9760115146636963, 0.26438844203948975, 0.0578855499625206, -0.38262441754341125, -0.6264057159423828, -1.2278932332992554, -0.8843370676040649, -1.0382145643234253, -0.3992927670478821, -1.089443325996399, -0.9074979424476624, 0.16266769170761108, -0.7295007109642029, 0.44648823142051697, -0.09782557934522629, -0.011843216605484486, -0.17594727873802185, 0.12094902992248535, 0.9277504086494446, 0.5687347650527954, 0.22031454741954803, -1.4272509813308716, 0.587381899356842, -0.3237040340900421, 0.3279968798160553, -0.1192001923918724, -0.5453783869743347, -0.48558780550956726, -0.8465922474861145, 0.34145188331604004, -0.5288965106010437, -0.24821852147579193, -0.024014277383685112, -0.20789110660552979, 0.4263285994529724, 0.02690993808209896, 0.1697394847869873, 0.14046624302864075, 0.4252738058567047, -0.23503170907497406, 0.5665217041969299, 0.12588493525981903, -0.0302748940885067, 1.037781834602356, 0.15159858763217926, -0.883754312992096, 0.8013656735420227, -0.07000485807657242, 0.347223162651062, -0.3202773928642273, 0.5004781484603882, 0.2113863229751587, -0.24227964878082275, -0.003960833884775639, -0.5560454726219177, -0.34614717960357666, 0.9044802188873291, -0.1001327782869339, -0.7420157194137573, -0.05139932781457901, 0.47732824087142944, 0.3608792722225189, -1.168009638786316, -0.3081910312175751, -1.0184516906738281, -1.0135204792022705, 0.26758527755737305, -0.18528558313846588, 0.6833289861679077, 0.13485485315322876, 0.3018074631690979, -0.9188657999038696, 0.12871596217155457, -0.3666934072971344, 0.5776314735412598, 0.12649865448474884, -0.7152336835861206, -0.04271724447607994, 0.3313608169555664, 0.23071905970573425, 0.6084935069084167, 0.4576038718223572, -0.3734280467033386, -0.011955463327467442, -0.20682936906814575, -0.34999656677246094, 0.039872895926237106, 0.7623025178909302, -0.11105745285749435, 0.47361433506011963, 0.10854214429855347, -0.7639520764350891, 0.020667409524321556, 0.4773894250392914, 0.19542455673217773, 0.12437188625335693, -0.27089276909828186, 0.19589702785015106, 0.599186897277832, -0.6786237359046936, -0.5019960403442383, 0.7353970408439636, 0.32309016585350037, 0.5054146647453308, -0.9000145792961121, 0.12141909450292587, -0.40266168117523193, -0.13133133947849274, 0.24143491685390472, -0.2564336657524109, -0.5830391049385071, 0.4182727634906769, -0.20875002443790436, 1.393509030342102, -1.0655502080917358, 0.3399442434310913, 0.6848912835121155, 0.21662767231464386, 0.3413355350494385, 0.30790001153945923, 0.10290839523077011, -0.09803404659032822, 0.29217463731765747, -0.018737254664301872, 0.41882482171058655, 0.6541233658790588, -0.19333311915397644, -0.510661780834198, 0.1676856130361557, -0.5628544092178345, -0.18671467900276184, 0.19122947752475739, 0.20700703561306, 0.3255990147590637, -1.059262752532959, 1.175750494003296, -0.2956636846065521, 0.6081591248512268, 0.5916959047317505, 0.05727092921733856, -0.055131617933511734, -0.6812689900398254, 0.4117336571216583, 0.09679003059864044, -0.421538382768631, 0.4633423388004303, 0.2175072729587555, -0.21019555628299713, 0.02754812315106392, -0.2900947332382202, 0.18068987131118774, -0.5045420527458191, -0.5653436183929443, -0.5880298614501953, 0.24954532086849213, -0.5995017290115356, 0.43777698278427124, -1.5239365100860596, -0.031904418021440506, -0.16384102404117584, -0.8108515739440918, 0.12469643354415894, -0.8031032681465149, 0.8971958160400391, 0.5205175876617432, -0.20764878392219543, -0.14785346388816833, -0.1646517515182495, -0.21923348307609558, 0.5410663485527039, -0.17318092286586761, 0.02053620107471943, 0.14473305642604828, 0.3170396685600281, 0.2310616374015808, -0.5386735796928406, -0.5379672050476074, -0.09631215780973434, -0.0020833020098507404, -0.14157085120677948, 0.08169275522232056, 0.6179031729698181, 0.3909643292427063, 0.010623243637382984, 0.25529617071151733, 0.6302609443664551, -0.9260990619659424, 0.7843319773674011, -0.45768672227859497, -0.6166683435440063, -0.1698269248008728, 0.024085132405161858, -0.40936633944511414, -0.02157982811331749, -0.2997027337551117, -0.7839599847793579, -0.5339844822883606, 0.7306733727455139, -0.653814971446991, -1.2596479654312134, 0.3422912061214447, -0.36321428418159485, 0.6555654406547546, 0.5016605257987976, -0.7984036803245544, -0.33354488015174866, 0.050484657287597656, 0.41417285799980164, -1.2091867923736572, 0.39100921154022217, 0.033140599727630615, 0.18129095435142517, 0.4063872992992401, -0.8017491698265076, -0.1446441411972046, -0.5829702615737915, -0.0440092459321022, -0.4608112871646881, -0.036156512796878815, -0.35323455929756165, -0.1364663988351822, -0.21478457748889923, 0.1733769178390503, -0.4632583260536194, 0.3688555359840393, 0.6865864396095276, -0.5988198518753052, 0.6172583699226379, -0.5985862016677856, -0.16952939331531525, -0.07811139523983002, -1.2061678171157837, 0.3254413604736328, 0.6767653822898865, 0.2292369306087494, 0.8259328603744507, -0.19832858443260193, -0.7221718430519104, 0.04567384347319603, -0.029043955728411674, -0.5173584818840027, -0.4951239824295044, -0.08480903506278992, -0.7739956974983215, 0.2511528730392456, -0.5223993062973022, -0.3844321370124817, -0.2971932291984558, -0.437885582447052, -0.4037565290927887, -0.22307199239730835, 0.31985217332839966, -0.1494072675704956, -0.8864338397979736, 0.9186535477638245, -0.11384975910186768, -1.144011378288269, -0.4015651345252991, 0.15616030991077423, -0.15478338301181793, -0.021230317652225494, -0.051800914108753204, -0.6859635710716248, -0.011780714616179466, -0.7124879956245422, 0.9911882877349854, -1.146230697631836, -0.02966994047164917, -0.29215195775032043, -0.6318629384040833, 0.1185307726264, 0.12093061953783035, 0.49529382586479187, 0.23112232983112335, -0.06363743543624878, -0.46659284830093384, 0.10175591707229614, -0.5492619276046753, -0.8132923245429993, -0.6296888589859009, -0.7533466815948486, -0.3926520049571991, 0.790617823600769, 0.31213831901550293, -0.7620916366577148, 0.5645453929901123, 0.3292348086833954, 0.064985491335392, 0.12662824988365173, -0.28348231315612793, -0.57642662525177, -0.180251345038414, 0.5734447240829468, -0.04431559890508652, 0.2849489450454712, -0.8056859970092773, 0.7340973615646362, -0.4598604440689087, 0.21536408364772797, -0.47856083512306213, 0.17293572425842285, 0.6295674443244934, -1.0102014541625977, 0.6667174696922302, -0.19162073731422424, 0.7177591323852539, 0.23605823516845703, 0.29484450817108154, 0.31895652413368225, 0.024540459737181664, -1.3292196989059448, -0.4639410972595215, -0.3553290367126465, -1.0830157995224, 0.2620670199394226, -0.9120988845825195, 0.13159584999084473, 0.32514962553977966, 0.2693740427494049, -0.42063847184181213, -0.6540509462356567, 0.6503209471702576, 0.5413278341293335, 0.1190195307135582, -0.8014668822288513, -0.12753421068191528, -0.4531242847442627, 0.4755263030529022, 0.30042678117752075, 0.32744815945625305, -0.35688185691833496, 0.34120404720306396, -0.2783774137496948, -0.6418924927711487, -1.0048941373825073, -0.287869930267334, 0.4491003453731537, 0.8933008313179016, -0.15457843244075775, 0.47835755348205566, -0.11426058411598206, 0.08873096853494644, -0.25099804997444153, 0.4871472716331482, -0.5382674932479858, -0.24582913517951965, 0.711790919303894, 0.3890828490257263, -0.48263615369796753, 0.8699214458465576, 0.10855348408222198, -0.44978439807891846, -0.0450347401201725, 0.32308441400527954, 0.689297616481781, -0.9325858354568481, 0.07331141829490662, 0.2300315648317337, -0.4838869273662567, -0.7410664558410645, 0.671571671962738, -0.436566025018692, 0.049571361392736435, -0.3271111845970154, -0.24915102124214172, -0.08806006610393524, 0.1652987152338028, 0.3757270872592926, 0.32021060585975647, 0.7299574017524719, 0.052837856113910675, 0.7412995100021362, 0.1553022563457489, -1.0136336088180542, 0.38183173537254333, 1.033083200454712, -0.15398700535297394, -0.12968887388706207, -0.8861706256866455, -0.3611240088939667, 0.056145038455724716, -0.6509217023849487, 0.13654187321662903, 0.23266832530498505, 0.37009453773498535, 0.1764441579580307, 0.05110714212059975, 0.7597795724868774, 0.28809523582458496, -0.05809374526143074, 0.8108832836151123, -0.0012938122963532805, -1.0124564170837402, 0.016340196132659912, 0.48614177107810974, 0.4247705042362213, 0.2896890342235565, -0.3717304766178131, -0.08159393817186356, 0.6848247647285461, 1.098738670349121, -0.24096029996871948, 0.282605916261673, -0.5398367047309875, -0.6753231883049011, -0.4022503197193146, 0.46209773421287537, -0.3536117672920227, -0.7421804666519165, 0.502780556678772, -0.6853051781654358, -0.4317205548286438, 0.14343442022800446, 0.7336265444755554, -1.0141510963439941, -0.4694429934024811, -0.40007567405700684, -0.42778411507606506, -0.9902973175048828, 0.4537886381149292, 0.1697172075510025, -0.7551630735397339, 0.26322436332702637, 0.44813933968544006, -0.2379889339208603, 0.1125713661313057, 0.40295326709747314, -0.09638606011867523, -0.09346587210893631, 0.8167418241500854, -0.4917469918727875, 0.24538619816303253, -0.2283829003572464, 0.45122453570365906, 0.028389230370521545, -0.2702030539512634, 0.5471274256706238, -0.5832325220108032, 0.7989267706871033, 0.4622463583946228, 0.21594615280628204, -0.11471434682607651, -0.1175522431731224, -0.021793054416775703, -0.1095615029335022, -0.12094423919916153, 0.5986311435699463, 0.7576577663421631, -0.48704302310943604, -0.1452203392982483, -0.1713273525238037, -0.43855538964271545, -0.02270357497036457, -0.7646920680999756, -0.1635255217552185, 0.5064678192138672, 0.25262290239334106, -0.2097417265176773, 0.6200631856918335, 0.8126924633979797, -0.1719176173210144, 0.14516635239124298, 0.6979123950004578, -0.580527126789093, -0.34423115849494934, -0.7116349339485168, 0.1913778930902481, 1.0145384073257446, -0.48427659273147583, 0.29246923327445984, -0.21599048376083374, 0.35296788811683655, 0.14650534093379974, -0.062272075563669205, -0.09049596637487411, 0.192101389169693, 0.22929278016090393, -0.04836225137114525, 0.7396310567855835, 0.09288299828767776, -0.7879636883735657, -0.14414027333259583, -0.5197268724441528, -0.8036717772483826, 0.17191199958324432, -0.9144595265388489, 0.0807272270321846, -0.47912299633026123, -0.5033671855926514, 0.4964134991168976, 0.39830347895622253, 0.5078394412994385, 0.1018834188580513, 0.4991826117038727, 0.2187703549861908, -0.04652726277709007, -0.5051281452178955, 0.6127745509147644, -0.29954323172569275, 0.20152032375335693, -0.6072880625724792, -0.7407669425010681, 0.8193259835243225, 0.45380064845085144, 0.21213579177856445, -0.1476197987794876, -0.6626135110855103, -0.14756642282009125, -0.2242177128791809, -0.2923191785812378, -0.9154052734375, 0.32947179675102234, -0.9580971002578735, 0.12745580077171326, -0.5043312311172485, 0.4449627995491028, -0.0052968356758356094, 0.9516520500183105, 0.29219189286231995, -0.19152110815048218, -0.7180044054985046, 0.049872640520334244, 0.6533498167991638, -0.1602216213941574, 0.1379370540380478, -0.011958850547671318, 0.551205039024353, -0.0678120031952858, -0.023888546973466873, 0.7347479462623596, 0.24382394552230835, 0.6636508703231812, 0.19692736864089966, -0.2512643337249756, 0.8272871375083923, 0.53803551197052, 0.44283801317214966, 0.9888468384742737, 0.9131473898887634, -0.11501828581094742, -0.03623780608177185, 0.29538482427597046, -0.6709592938423157, 1.1984280347824097, -0.025408418849110603, 0.09953699260950089, 0.02981043979525566, 0.2599700689315796, -0.3202272355556488, -0.2115807980298996, -0.4811795949935913, 0.1252661645412445, -0.255945086479187, -0.5889058113098145, -0.4007553458213806, 1.223699688911438, 0.7618179321289062, 0.004554304294288158, 0.45026811957359314, -0.25706255435943604, -0.08060179650783539, 0.5479114651679993, 0.03707112371921539, -0.14629679918289185, -0.005026562605053186, -0.10285349190235138, 0.31594306230545044, 1.014564037322998, -0.09800459444522858, 0.33835840225219727, 0.26931533217430115, -0.40673768520355225, -0.24660909175872803, 0.8802191019058228, 0.3083328604698181, -0.49622347950935364, 0.6046154499053955, 0.11226797103881836, -0.8360578417778015, -0.613362729549408, -0.33339282870292664, -1.050672173500061, 0.25496891140937805, 0.3134855628013611, -0.5331807732582092, -0.12505219876766205, 0.4532219469547272, -0.5680372714996338, 0.036461956799030304, 1.3885424137115479, 0.32713693380355835, -0.45029640197753906, 1.0736913681030273, 0.3094324767589569, 0.46534085273742676, 0.19080321490764618, 0.05204106867313385, -0.39653393626213074, 0.5849714875221252, -0.29079267382621765, 0.19170290231704712, 0.3157907724380493, -0.07914625108242035, -0.531710147857666, 0.5454519987106323, -0.1357315331697464, 0.08243653923273087, -0.6629429459571838, -0.1256808638572693, 0.2042604684829712, -0.29874858260154724, -0.23391227424144745, 0.6371006965637207, 0.024263910949230194, -0.452720046043396, -0.3216482698917389, -0.27754536271095276, -0.6139482855796814, -0.17476415634155273, 0.10225297510623932, 0.8690751791000366, -0.5291270017623901, -0.1731542944908142, -0.02865518443286419, -0.3165717124938965, -0.09394165873527527, 0.006741768680512905, -0.4113619923591614, 0.10783367604017258, 0.6321365237236023, 1.0200928449630737, -0.26313525438308716, 0.8048834800720215, -0.36263394355773926, 0.3595389127731323, -0.18680988252162933, 1.309614658355713, -0.4134708642959595, 0.9390906691551208, 0.0365193709731102, -0.09514891356229782, 0.682786762714386, 0.738896369934082, -0.046424947679042816, 0.022490257397294044, -0.4374634325504303, 0.33572715520858765, 0.14836670458316803, -0.43681180477142334, -0.6746710538864136, 0.3998429775238037, 0.3390614092350006, -0.43086230754852295, 0.035354722291231155, -0.8079902529716492, 0.3799475431442261, -0.8230507969856262, 0.5182984471321106, 0.3319258689880371, 0.23954111337661743, 0.028852643445134163, -0.3245636522769928, 0.025596657767891884, -0.27914291620254517, 4.15881872177124, 1.4654284715652466, 0.5383284091949463, -0.4624599814414978, 0.23447228968143463, 0.09494227916002274, 0.7758177518844604, 0.011338542215526104, 0.32274264097213745, -0.4208688735961914, -0.2609427273273468, 0.5583540797233582, 0.36267340183258057, -0.8417460322380066, 0.6080371737480164, 1.0134410858154297, -0.3869349956512451, 0.058781858533620834, -0.2549580931663513, -0.4968945384025574, -0.6666660308837891, 0.5657483339309692, -0.4679083526134491, -0.5777825117111206, -0.26976898312568665, -0.613101601600647, -0.5937475562095642, -0.3803139626979828, -0.060620248317718506, -0.22121304273605347, -0.09919341653585434, -0.9206098914146423, 0.7664558291435242, -0.5225759148597717, -0.23172064125537872, 0.3760201632976532, 0.8207988739013672, -0.07484056055545807, 0.1342584192752838, -0.1733955591917038, -0.11241815239191055, -0.36721551418304443, -0.24192208051681519, -0.37696000933647156, -0.5043228268623352, 0.25601813197135925, -0.0838235542178154, 0.16326941549777985, 0.7087605595588684, -0.3384777903556824, 0.9469212889671326, -0.5847558975219727, -0.24705365300178528, -0.586682915687561, -0.8904407620429993, -0.4230187237262726, -1.1281747817993164, -1.1577008962631226, 0.25485116243362427, -0.0804324671626091, 0.8031863570213318, -0.005885655991733074, -0.5955874919891357, -0.3200094401836395, -0.12604300677776337, 0.5598388314247131, 0.11861249059438705, 0.4156530499458313, -0.08246314525604248, 0.45182374119758606, 0.2184607833623886, 0.4479767084121704, -0.5648674964904785, 0.543122410774231, 0.8366300463676453, 0.006218414753675461, -0.3791043758392334, 0.6003847122192383, -0.4217522442340851, -0.1690567135810852, -0.30604982376098633, 0.6449280381202698, 0.45691943168640137, 0.07098492234945297, 0.601479709148407, 0.35196730494499207, -0.5617114901542664, -0.643498420715332, -1.2397364377975464, 0.9915381073951721, 0.26601526141166687, 0.5081948637962341, -0.4127322733402252, 0.06594456732273102, -0.3608739376068115 ]
{"Title": "Planning sEEG implantation using automated lesion detection: retrospective feasibility study", "Authors": "Wagstyl Konrad, Adler Sophie, Pimpel Birgit, Chari Aswin, Seunarine Kiran, Lorio Sara, Thornton Rachel, Baldeweg Torsten, Tisdall Martin", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective A retrospective, cross-sectional study to evaluate the feasibility and potential benefits of incorporating deep-learning on structural MRI into planning stereoelectroencephalography (sEEG) implantation in paediatric patients with diagnostically complex drug-resistant epilepsy. This study aims to assess the degree of co-localisation between automated lesion detection and the seizure onset zone (SOZ) as assessed by sEEG. Methods A neural network classifier was applied to cortical features from MRI data from three cohorts. 1) The network was trained and cross-validated using 34 patients with visible focal cortical dysplasias (FCDs). 2) Specificity was assessed in 20 paediatric healthy controls. 3) Feasibility for incorporation into sEEG implantation plans was evaluated in 38 sEEG patients. Coordinates of sEEG contacts were coregistered with classifier-predicted lesions. sEEG contacts in seizure onset and irritative tissue were identified by clinical neurophysiologists. A distance of <10mm between SOZ contacts and classifier-predicted lesions was considered co-localisation. Results In patients with radiologically-defined lesions, classifier sensitivity was 74% (25/34 lesions detected). No clusters were detected in the controls (specificity 100%). Of 34 sEEG patients, 21 patients had a focal cortical SOZ. Of these there was co-localisation between classifier output and SOZ contacts in 62%. The algorithm detected 7/8 histopathologically-confirmed FCDs (86%). Conclusions There was a high degree of co-localisation between automated lesion detection and sEEG. We have created a framework for incorporation of deep-learning based MRI lesion detection into sEEG implantation planning. Our findings demonstrate that automated MRI analysis could be used to plan optimal electrode trajectories.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.08.19013979"}
10.1101/19005140
[ -0.3109874725341797, 0.7288888096809387, -0.034606851637363434, 0.5747905969619751, -0.7863052487373352, -0.3850759267807007, -0.11038805544376373, 0.24245724081993103, 0.6169866323471069, 0.8428877592086792, -0.08903516829013824, -0.8322664499282837, 0.1996982842683792, 0.4020461142063141, 0.10189415514469147, 0.19734813272953033, -0.5755595564842224, 0.09768872708082199, 0.5634145140647888, 0.6075944900512695, 0.3088701665401459, 0.5237139463424683, -0.9561687707901001, 0.00960139837116003, -0.7295185327529907, 0.06614426523447037, 0.009341662749648094, 0.27875810861587524, 0.7232292890548706, 0.8398396372795105, 0.13792133331298828, -0.944623589515686, 0.19047963619232178, -0.7551320195198059, -0.00009488195064477623, 0.1461867392063141, 1.0282031297683716, -1.014243245124817, -0.03796521574258804, -0.45061346888542175, -0.14084893465042114, -0.07362096011638641, 0.4663456380367279, -0.892055094242096, -0.525196373462677, 0.15687035024166107, -0.42877259850502014, -0.40670046210289, -0.5898281335830688, 0.042383622378110886, -0.6780473589897156, -0.15242142975330353, 0.07415197789669037, -0.03298191353678703, 0.12756024301052094, -0.13035008311271667, 0.3623553216457367, -0.5266299843788147, 0.0058349985629320145, -0.06035308167338371, -0.1039266437292099, -0.8870296478271484, -0.042776912450790405, -1.2538368701934814, 0.3679311275482178, 0.753214955329895, -0.49483397603034973, 0.040861789137125015, -0.32248979806900024, -0.2605152130126953, 0.23352384567260742, -0.08143161982297897, -0.9211222529411316, -0.5128045082092285, -0.15937349200248718, -0.1860620677471161, -0.0915495902299881, -0.04188181832432747, 0.1192479208111763, 0.08769524097442627, -0.21978212893009186, 0.6397624015808105, 0.44116589426994324, 0.20639756321907043, -0.8711615204811096, -0.1435837298631668, -0.01746251806616783, 0.2886643409729004, 0.828980565071106, 0.4174427092075348, 0.07597508281469345, 0.3814518451690674, 0.1886882483959198, 0.4126805365085602, 0.025481240823864937, 1.0414605140686035, -0.10362781584262848, 0.18057382106781006, -0.0605042427778244, -0.3810262978076935, 0.8881546258926392, 1.2072162628173828, 0.07537287473678589, 1.2600654363632202, -0.5462678670883179, 0.3365913927555084, 1.3468365669250488, -0.4778836965560913, 0.16310852766036987, -0.9924108386039734, 0.026106305420398712, -0.315897136926651, -0.07421963661909103, -0.3144861161708832, -0.30378371477127075, 0.07702668756246567, -0.23768046498298645, 0.3204697072505951, -0.27908840775489807, 1.3556619882583618, -0.0817926675081253, -0.29604026675224304, 0.7491782903671265, -0.5423827767372131, 0.32075875997543335, -0.3969409465789795, -0.002783791162073612, 0.7703524827957153, -0.7514414191246033, -0.14863920211791992, 0.6075111031532288, -0.4108646512031555, 0.016411075368523598, 0.17653648555278778, 0.6099558472633362, 0.08549527078866959, 0.639643132686615, 0.6947911381721497, 0.5250955820083618, 0.27509453892707825, -0.04123946279287338, 0.549491286277771, -0.41607537865638733, 1.2444347143173218, -0.24726809561252594, 0.13127589225769043, -0.812620997428894, -0.50531005859375, -0.38680511713027954, 0.00399711774662137, -0.4900932312011719, 0.9890027046203613, 0.10672152042388916, 0.37397080659866333, 0.12865865230560303, 0.03665264695882797, 0.6611089706420898, 0.4145490527153015, -0.7997149229049683, 0.5415840744972229, -0.6097320914268494, -0.20946501195430756, 0.2646746337413788, 0.6042701601982117, -1.7895570993423462, 0.6594364047050476, -1.0415842533111572, 0.28046634793281555, -0.476759135723114, -0.5187129378318787, 0.831729531288147, 0.5504977107048035, -0.5209658741950989, 0.24542883038520813, 0.6176804304122925, 0.8855690956115723, 0.6651724576950073, 0.14264704287052155, 0.6560518145561218, 0.8307164907455444, -0.5273480415344238, -0.681756317615509, 0.025470059365034103, 0.9412938356399536, 0.13743294775485992, 0.3354787826538086, -0.5258859992027283, -0.6473936438560486, -0.6163191199302673, -0.5919471383094788, 0.5010494589805603, 0.05687935650348663, -0.362388014793396, 0.2976498007774353, -0.15576419234275818, 0.059809066355228424, 0.3462944030761719, 0.11834990978240967, -0.13006342947483063, 0.1838270127773285, -0.1699044406414032, -0.10468590259552002, 0.41446900367736816, 0.267286479473114, -0.458965927362442, 0.5171900391578674, -0.032666802406311035, 0.46320801973342896, -0.6995811462402344, 0.0722862035036087, 1.2879669666290283, -0.07878424227237701, -0.6215376853942871, -0.13733415305614471, 0.5819557905197144, -0.6554891467094421, -0.3855735659599304, 0.43154841661453247, -0.2713054120540619, -0.04966317489743233, -0.3808237314224243, 0.3022492825984955, 0.2902170419692993, -0.09791409969329834, -0.3415036201477051, -0.08174097537994385, 0.6662576198577881, 0.6818365454673767, -0.6059647798538208, 0.13434402644634247, 0.4135880172252655, 0.5978931188583374, 0.1903129667043686, 0.47253188490867615, 0.6603382229804993, -0.032321128994226456, 0.736111044883728, 0.3571118414402008, 0.15479762852191925, 0.6311837434768677, 0.37076959013938904, 0.5528563261032104, 0.5817248821258545, 0.1839940994977951, -0.6570453643798828, 0.363996684551239, -0.41860219836235046, -0.23939289152622223, -0.745180070400238, 0.22166678309440613, -0.6465625762939453, 0.9009678363800049, 0.37982654571533203, 0.9912631511688232, -0.7522187232971191, 0.043481893837451935, 0.6333824992179871, 0.3697871267795563, -0.6776517629623413, -0.36586031317710876, 0.5689415335655212, 0.5398061275482178, 0.12934890389442444, 0.730229377746582, 0.6794096231460571, 0.30154287815093994, -0.37461167573928833, 0.371428519487381, -0.5324510931968689, 0.3015294373035431, -1.3689850568771362, -0.3605976998806, -0.5649366974830627, -0.5279207825660706, -0.48083019256591797, 0.4059022068977356, -0.016114037483930588, -0.27366024255752563, -0.04228983446955681, 0.15251028537750244, 0.34085819125175476, -0.306002676486969, 0.5438021421432495, 0.40384969115257263, 0.4239917993545532, 0.5808458924293518, -1.0529201030731201, 0.3834669589996338, -0.5899589657783508, -0.0021553505212068558, -0.4730575680732727, -0.518184244632721, -1.4561625719070435, -0.4735870361328125, 0.22972489893436432, -0.2885802984237671, 0.3921099901199341, -0.12447739392518997, 0.09499068558216095, -0.6314979195594788, 0.010188351385295391, -0.23877131938934326, -0.5594035983085632, -0.8203651309013367, -0.9351913332939148, 1.2704720497131348, 0.2908679246902466, 0.09488075226545334, -0.03980221599340439, -0.060289788991212845, -0.10435838997364044, 0.2815536856651306, 0.3744748830795288, 0.6991115212440491, -0.24972836673259735, 0.5203540325164795, 0.3024041950702667, -0.5887863636016846, 0.20780232548713684, 0.1455574333667755, -0.9999741315841675, -0.1058608815073967, -0.34071263670921326, -0.6394877433776855, -0.12849083542823792, -0.010718563571572304, 0.26873788237571716, -1.6334444284439087, 0.4523375630378723, -0.814339280128479, -0.9508713483810425, 0.0011939882533624768, 0.1440064162015915, 0.5756559371948242, -0.27638158202171326, -0.109072744846344, -0.7597002983093262, -0.7154630422592163, -0.3662869334220886, 0.25749480724334717, -0.08545243740081787, -0.9825080633163452, 0.37239181995391846, 0.4631122946739197, -0.35577392578125, 0.6372473239898682, 0.11648055166006088, 0.6774144768714905, 0.045535072684288025, -0.23873691260814667, 0.4493163824081421, -0.04224052652716637, 0.6943142414093018, -0.15442198514938354, 0.14951848983764648, 0.3899397552013397, -0.2525120675563812, 0.7288699150085449, 0.6855840086936951, -0.15688928961753845, 0.39088550209999084, 0.7067635655403137, -1.3332360982894897, 0.36710885167121887, -0.9041680693626404, -0.9311245679855347, 0.2826645076274872, 0.0983361080288887, 0.4427095353603363, -0.6914859414100647, 1.2781437635421753, -0.5855472683906555, -0.09538249671459198, 0.474086195230484, 0.12844833731651306, -0.632789671421051, 0.830315887928009, 0.2111964225769043, 1.1006526947021484, -0.9138739705085754, 0.18114759027957916, 0.2032666653394699, 1.1838042736053467, 0.8161160945892334, 0.22902122139930725, 0.3885253965854645, -0.5642892718315125, 0.15023653209209442, -0.209197998046875, -0.884865403175354, 0.3995758295059204, -0.19220978021621704, 0.5607677698135376, -0.27282172441482544, -1.2383034229278564, -0.3514840602874756, 0.7519693374633789, 0.5003390312194824, 0.6246536374092102, -0.3146873712539673, 0.7904284596443176, -0.8508164882659912, 0.6653631925582886, 0.6240333318710327, 0.6069234013557434, 0.36735156178474426, -1.2678946256637573, 0.3566471338272095, -0.04353363811969757, -0.6242787837982178, -0.2515767514705658, -1.135826826095581, 0.13736681640148163, -0.3945113718509674, 0.4732590615749359, 0.5861071944236755, -0.44001030921936035, -0.5624861121177673, -0.06672080606222153, 0.1872318685054779, 0.1663462221622467, 0.30086275935173035, 0.09640361368656158, -0.0743367075920105, 0.005435375031083822, -0.12116961181163788, -0.52201247215271, -0.23516450822353363, 0.8190420269966125, 1.0949453115463257, -0.22334229946136475, -0.9021010398864746, 0.44328567385673523, -0.11986177414655685, -0.5908532738685608, 0.6135080456733704, -0.22317251563072205, -0.23285259306430817, -0.09587442874908447, -0.24633456766605377, -0.08951716870069504, -0.1972612738609314, 0.5451464056968689, -0.3271229565143585, 0.4532689154148102, 0.15883472561836243, 0.11374664306640625, 0.8267390131950378, 0.7452210187911987, 0.09154491126537323, -0.014346545562148094, -0.48045986890792847, 0.37131354212760925, 0.05632224306464195, -0.11848824471235275, 0.5334922075271606, 0.5947404503822327, -0.1570790559053421, -0.2831813395023346, -0.8722403049468994, 0.45040929317474365, -0.04259262606501579, -0.18547731637954712, 0.1258152276277542, -0.3720047175884247, 0.896041989326477, -1.0247156620025635, -0.33087441325187683, 1.2861275672912598, -0.5223523378372192, -0.5180667638778687, 0.3073446452617645, -0.6458680629730225, -0.650733470916748, 0.28967276215553284, -0.42048507928848267, 0.6529106497764587, 0.08888385444879532, -0.41317179799079895, 0.9504367113113403, 0.21314150094985962, 0.05522969365119934, -0.21466559171676636, -0.17331990599632263, -0.3273337185382843, -0.670031726360321, 0.008004071190953255, -0.31217485666275024, -0.7689612507820129, 0.6772097945213318, -0.02292671985924244, -0.38737764954566956, -0.4761827886104584, 0.050640277564525604, -0.18326237797737122, 0.14544786512851715, -0.27047353982925415, 0.3245864510536194, 0.37400832772254944, 0.4469277858734131, 0.784821093082428, -0.5727872848510742, -1.025254249572754, -0.597642183303833, 0.8104839324951172, -0.5926761031150818, -0.7888815402984619, 0.2002369463443756, -0.4432901442050934, -0.0275275781750679, -0.05254822596907616, 0.3685956299304962, -0.8758737444877625, 0.2391488254070282, -0.3131820261478424, -0.24427974224090576, 0.22007063031196594, 0.0980200245976448, 0.5167564749717712, -0.06459860503673553, 0.530480146408081, -0.6197049021720886, 0.3685363233089447, 0.5678942203521729, 0.2785959541797638, 0.35842782258987427, -0.48733192682266235, -0.6475939750671387, -0.6684865355491638, -1.1948367357254028, 0.023933107033371925, -0.7817717790603638, -0.08558925241231918, 0.06630462408065796, -0.14773212373256683, -0.05907484516501427, 0.07060972601175308, -0.10478992760181427, 0.08235013484954834, 0.10186126828193665, 0.06986557692289352, 0.1847228705883026, -0.04930220916867256, -0.3179227411746979, 0.27405279874801636, -0.9071357846260071, -0.2317376732826233, 1.3136084079742432, 0.17638076841831207, -0.1015438660979271, -1.033655047416687, 0.050306983292102814, -0.10466910898685455, -0.6625407338142395, -0.26310673356056213, -0.45233723521232605, -0.031991664320230484, 0.2072003334760666, -0.20317839086055756, -0.5843487977981567, -0.8842509984970093, 0.4392554759979248, -0.4023469388484955, 0.17867057025432587, 0.31903892755508423, -0.2127467691898346, 0.5836235284805298, -0.14724569022655487, 1.0519347190856934, 0.08052247762680054, -0.6348682045936584, 0.48235803842544556, 0.05014348030090332, -0.7570121884346008, 0.5615044832229614, -0.3008842468261719, -1.0524529218673706, -0.21670272946357727, -0.6139385104179382, 0.4287385046482086, 0.37488535046577454, -0.4179736077785492, -0.006055003497749567, -0.7570809125900269, 0.5314781665802002, -1.5059503316879272, 0.7678545117378235, 0.4568953216075897, -0.40876510739326477, -0.6799144744873047, 0.41780945658683777, 1.3017343282699585, 0.10274634510278702, 0.24098394811153412, 0.6183447241783142, -0.1465059071779251, -0.6211872696876526, -0.5088841915130615, -0.5824472904205322, -0.8476356863975525, -0.09100233018398285, -0.0386647954583168, 0.9435426592826843, -0.05747673660516739, 0.7534046769142151, 0.15783825516700745, -0.5559992790222168, -0.383696049451828, 0.6059620976448059, -0.5222019553184509, 0.18499384820461273, 0.6288810968399048, -0.14108116924762726, -0.4424038529396057, 0.1942254900932312, 0.3651426434516907, 0.17668567597866058, -0.5671407580375671, 0.4063427448272705, 0.32283487915992737, -0.9814794063568115, 0.9249118566513062, 0.3267345428466797, -0.3981691896915436, -0.1397533416748047, 0.026399822905659676, 0.23423023521900177, 0.5142143964767456, -0.7517579793930054, -0.004707425832748413, 0.8268830180168152, 0.3225816786289215, 0.6216467618942261, -0.0963379517197609, -0.17396587133407593, 0.6547248363494873, -0.46741998195648193, 0.7120608687400818, -0.42370495200157166, -0.3888038992881775, 0.1030198410153389, -0.01794506423175335, -0.01165792252868414, 0.5409455895423889, -0.04181554168462753, 0.26172834634780884, -0.28400731086730957, 0.5433336496353149, -1.0832254886627197, -0.6854842901229858, -0.8151128888130188, -0.47573432326316833, 0.4588504731655121, 0.09509743750095367, -0.007654571905732155, 0.008426599204540253, -0.006808232981711626, -0.7837892770767212, -0.23168401420116425, -0.5492455363273621, -0.30021360516548157, 1.0024441480636597, -0.6473840475082397, 0.21511603891849518, 0.5546033978462219, 0.22107864916324615, 0.5811560153961182, -0.9435372948646545, -1.0579018592834473, -0.310006320476532, -0.3370296061038971, -0.27209046483039856, -1.1188660860061646, -0.30323919653892517, 0.009656686335802078, -0.11917151510715485, -0.8619378805160522, -0.24275366961956024, 0.8638703227043152, -0.0211271271109581, 0.021883822977542877, -0.27071613073349, 0.31461960077285767, 0.012711661867797375, -0.4754517674446106, -0.3979335427284241, -0.20067669451236725, -0.2390194833278656, 0.45661166310310364, -0.46423837542533875, -0.19911141693592072, 0.16919545829296112, -0.03126279637217522, 0.738512396812439, -0.06358841061592102, -0.13126739859580994, -0.4879278242588043, -0.006928715389221907, -0.13238248229026794, -0.29876193404197693, 0.5126979351043701, 1.4299122095108032, -0.7669618129730225, 0.5673313736915588, -0.5008782148361206, -0.21765820682048798, 0.8002805113792419, -0.3045990765094757, 0.17441287636756897, -0.2082792967557907, -1.185619831085205, -0.5662286281585693, 0.22070527076721191, -0.4417071044445038, -0.6312544345855713, -0.33375316858291626, 0.16436919569969177, -0.024349961429834366, -0.45234215259552, 0.0019522549118846655, 0.23005838692188263, -0.11095499992370605, -0.4585719108581543, -0.3616875112056732, 0.9864862561225891, 0.12853235006332397, -0.16424113512039185, -0.006006525829434395, -0.2465297132730484, -0.033163733780384064, -0.9315616488456726, 0.08511468768119812, 0.5988667011260986, 0.002579368883743882, 0.4938475787639618, -1.1343255043029785, -0.8258018493652344, 0.5709539651870728, -0.8273295164108276, -0.1819046139717102, 0.735102653503418, -0.8617807626724243, 0.16610172390937805, -0.25909265875816345, -0.3155232071876526, -0.41488561034202576, -0.12669728696346283, -0.9041458964347839, -0.63875812292099, 0.6725388765335083, -0.19285812973976135, 0.0546797551214695, -0.43199479579925537, -0.18380330502986908, 0.36878064274787903, -0.15596365928649902, 0.9026492238044739, -0.24447563290596008, 0.4253019094467163, 0.12048005312681198, 0.8668797016143799, 0.4675804674625397, 0.4961874783039093, 0.3388192653656006, 0.07719939202070236, -0.48834946751594543, -0.3583623766899109, 0.2506157159805298, 1.5166971683502197, 0.3650367558002472, 0.2659728229045868, -0.12209147214889526, -0.6440147161483765, 0.04479767754673958, 0.3349152207374573, -0.16095450520515442, -0.04735016077756882, -0.939510703086853, -0.45566636323928833, -0.8608262538909912, 1.1125314235687256, -0.9710327982902527, 0.49873173236846924, -0.6842333078384399, -1.1895498037338257, -0.787749171257019, 0.012225680984556675, 1.1952672004699707, -0.3398439884185791, 0.2978241443634033, -0.5828703045845032, -0.17438384890556335, -0.19564509391784668, -0.1815330982208252, 0.07266846299171448, 0.8072989583015442, 0.45057156682014465, 0.42732203006744385, -0.21959805488586426, 0.6352245807647705, 1.1771794557571411, 0.3982638120651245, 0.3657814562320709, 0.6764265298843384, 0.6766086220741272, 0.44065454602241516, -0.14376667141914368, -0.6666366457939148, 0.4204222559928894, 0.6561161875724792, -0.22399498522281647, 0.0015499393921345472, 0.08267779648303986, 0.568626880645752, 0.13758477568626404, -0.6395416259765625, 0.2585352659225464, -0.0062310537323355675, -1.4827845096588135, 0.4864037334918976, 0.6677746176719666, 0.7850705981254578, 0.19283358752727509, 0.497005432844162, 0.024323677644133568, 0.147439643740654, -0.12651585042476654, -0.06630923599004745, 0.618634045124054, -0.3568103313446045, -0.31092000007629395, -0.012444399297237396, -0.047619886696338654, -0.6097350120544434, -0.034823574125766754, 0.37228161096572876, 0.2663763761520386, 0.5226300358772278, 0.7323138117790222, 0.1342727541923523, 0.3600415289402008, 1.3236618041992188, -0.7707480788230896, -0.7597005367279053, -0.30762267112731934, 0.1670568585395813, -0.36782243847846985, -0.4002406895160675, 1.273375153541565, 0.12565958499908447, -0.6155741214752197, -0.09655175358057022, 0.38225236535072327, 0.0637630969285965, 0.3852023482322693, 1.0080928802490234, -0.362850159406662, 1.1877844333648682, 0.5744828581809998, -0.20431722700595856, 0.2578866183757782, -0.32130134105682373, -0.5574321150779724, -0.2895875871181488, -1.0033326148986816, 0.2657375633716583, -0.20768433809280396, -0.5636471509933472, -0.11799746006727219, 0.6388435363769531, -0.2931421995162964, -0.014301848597824574, -0.9364613890647888, -0.15026266872882843, -0.1520344763994217, -0.03770923987030983, -0.26577943563461304, 0.4382803738117218, 0.1262488067150116, -0.08339391648769379, -0.09730485826730728, -0.6265888214111328, -0.13064195215702057, 0.4214054048061371, -0.6166077852249146, 0.9749978184700012, -0.024113157764077187, -0.33467966318130493, 0.16288994252681732, -1.0109137296676636, -0.2334253340959549, 0.3459881544113159, 0.05336550250649452, -0.6540778875350952, -0.22883622348308563, 0.020580627024173737, 0.030742846429347992, -0.06584247201681137, -0.3764812648296356, -0.5410891175270081, 0.44838258624076843, 1.066931128501892, -0.0018976631108671427, 0.950231671333313, -0.2983114719390869, 0.19267120957374573, 0.3932081162929535, -0.13962334394454956, -0.16984593868255615, -0.3829098641872406, -0.6376801133155823, -0.23522917926311493, -0.1505952924489975, -0.2364964783191681, -1.3676577806472778, -0.05078085884451866, 0.2059568613767624, -0.4023798108100891, 0.09634432941675186, -0.5389048457145691, -0.533487856388092, -0.2713076174259186, 1.269633173942566, -0.2431684285402298, -0.5312007665634155, -0.04053598269820213, 0.17156724631786346, 0.14943060278892517, -1.2640928030014038, 3.928022623062134, 0.6837722063064575, 0.6195195317268372, -0.45566436648368835, 0.24588340520858765, 0.13296134769916534, 1.190495252609253, 0.3959364891052246, 0.14864951372146606, 0.3178180456161499, -0.7164463996887207, -0.20476514101028442, 0.6195533275604248, -0.4593737721443176, 0.43678179383277893, 0.5975717306137085, -0.5941567420959473, 0.09015404433012009, -0.07727628946304321, -0.6402524709701538, -0.42239871621131897, 0.040473733097314835, -0.023913787677884102, 0.614365816116333, 0.18588683009147644, -0.13388356566429138, 0.46329960227012634, -0.08638134598731995, 0.7695587873458862, -0.24525205790996552, 0.32591524720191956, -0.7006728649139404, 0.8832757472991943, -1.1059045791625977, -0.46417638659477234, 0.27049246430397034, -0.031785763800144196, -0.6886029839515686, 0.07423818111419678, 0.23282144963741302, -0.20069295167922974, -0.1959727257490158, -0.0063847764395177364, -0.59064120054245, -0.3505808413028717, 1.0925743579864502, -0.7904835343360901, 0.3179241120815277, 0.9972261786460876, 0.18448233604431152, 0.6634514927864075, -1.0472413301467896, 0.038424864411354065, 0.2244788408279419, -0.3614118695259094, 0.20034807920455933, 0.03604985773563385, -0.2701413631439209, -0.33094334602355957, -0.04777205362915993, 1.16822350025177, -0.23373225331306458, -0.2738080620765686, 0.03707816079258919, 0.6283162832260132, -0.01920090988278389, 0.6413699388504028, -0.41385218501091003, -0.0681365579366684, -0.9494691491127014, -0.730261504650116, -0.1548120379447937, -0.842243492603302, -0.170463427901268, 1.2273683547973633, 0.6419616937637329, -0.6388087272644043, 0.9339265823364258, -0.7138758897781372, -0.4282711446285248, 0.011441005393862724, -0.01965891383588314, 0.41322600841522217, 0.4189700782299042, -0.18614594638347626, 1.208827018737793, -0.32337063550949097, -0.6610614061355591, -0.35927191376686096, 0.1361595094203949, 0.6007609367370605, -0.07497023791074753, -0.32299622893333435, -0.2595975399017334, 0.11724212765693665 ]
{"Title": "Opioid Overdose in Ohio: Comprehensive Analysis of Associated Socioeconomic Factors", "Authors": "Park Chihyun, Crawford Sara, Lopez Rocio, Seballos Anna, Clemenceau Jean R., Coy Tyler, Atluri Gowtham, Hwang Tae Hyun", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective Our study focused on identifying socioeconomic factors associated with death by opioid overdose in Ohio communities at the census tract level. Materials and Methods A large-scale vital statistic dataset from Ohio Department of Health (ODH) and U.S. Census datasets were used to obtain opioid-related death rate and socioeconomic characteristics for all census tracts in Ohio. Regression analysis was performed to identify the relationships between socioeconomic factors of census tracts and the opioid-related death rate for both urban and rural tracts. Results In Ohio from 2010-2016, whites, males, and people aged 25-44 had the highest opioid-related death rates. At the census tract level, higher death rates were associated with certain socioeconomic characteristics (e.g. percentage of the census tract population living in urban areas, percentage divorced/separated, percentage of vacant housing units). Predominately rural areas had a different population composition than urban areas, and death rates in rural areas exhibited fewer associations with socioeconomic characteristics. Discussion Predictive models of opioid-related death rates based on census tract-level characteristics held for urban areas more than rural ones, reflecting the recently observed rural-to-urban geographic shift in opioid-related deaths. Future research is needed to examine the geographic distribution of opioid abuse throughout Ohio and in other states. Conclusion Regression analysis identified associations between population characteristics and opioid-related death rates of Ohio census tracts. These analyses can help government officials and law official workers prevent, predict and combat opioid abuse at the community level.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005140"}
10.1101/19007922
[ -0.17640456557273865, 0.2585466802120209, 0.10089488327503204, 0.13650107383728027, 0.16467496752738953, -0.23189838230609894, -0.29827800393104553, 0.5161154270172119, -0.5516543984413147, 1.4128451347351074, -0.27523618936538696, -0.17309154570102692, 0.5879399180412292, -0.43051889538764954, 0.26010778546333313, 0.09639672935009003, -0.4621184468269348, 0.20510773360729218, -0.18692971765995026, 0.5530343651771545, 0.8428847789764404, 0.5680142641067505, -1.2626153230667114, -0.28585901856422424, -0.705795168876648, 0.35911285877227783, 0.5302218794822693, -0.6510300636291504, 1.5618643760681152, 0.48835232853889465, -0.030104748904705048, -0.2391464114189148, 0.6643481254577637, -0.6767683029174805, 0.09051661193370819, 0.05543315038084984, 0.49144625663757324, -0.5680363774299622, 0.12865050137043, -0.47800928354263306, 0.7577322125434875, -1.0155537128448486, 0.4999450147151947, -0.6674275994300842, -0.7224346399307251, 0.08008991181850433, -0.27674826979637146, -0.13055066764354706, -0.19833368062973022, -0.39598676562309265, -0.8399216532707214, -0.2824941575527191, -0.47278615832328796, -0.18448276817798615, -0.091859832406044, 0.07043279707431793, 0.07806514948606491, 0.14140810072422028, -0.6937355995178223, 0.8116205930709839, 0.19262667000293732, -0.6137028336524963, 0.47909390926361084, -1.17787766456604, 0.7139403223991394, 0.4573707580566406, -0.01755501888692379, -0.5268330574035645, -0.156460240483284, 0.15558162331581116, -1.0495927333831787, -0.8693714737892151, 0.10076040774583817, -0.48170748353004456, -0.34053924679756165, 0.19563494622707367, 0.5627759099006653, -0.15579119324684143, -0.19503480195999146, -0.24316774308681488, 0.1802407205104828, -0.04184550419449806, -0.13350319862365723, 0.09828871488571167, -0.4958351254463196, 0.02368824928998947, 0.5688195824623108, 0.19603335857391357, -0.39776110649108887, 0.4479132890701294, 0.11221615970134735, 0.06237247958779335, 0.8931509852409363, 0.21942561864852905, 0.4943852424621582, 1.2643883228302002, -0.5482205748558044, 0.36139115691185, -0.03906231373548508, -0.5279061794281006, 0.43924838304519653, 1.0622390508651733, -0.29329895973205566, 0.6703951954841614, -0.8306481838226318, 0.7903406023979187, 1.061691164970398, -0.029124191030859947, -0.635464072227478, -0.8585806488990784, -0.07065270841121674, 0.13582538068294525, -0.5700731873512268, 0.053671836853027344, 1.0151402950286865, 0.42957279086112976, 0.3824782371520996, 0.5184013247489929, -0.7184953093528748, 0.15232889354228973, -0.6302703619003296, 0.40064212679862976, 0.8156461715698242, -0.09393691271543503, 0.11772797256708145, 0.2152424305677414, 0.254609078168869, 0.8561909794807434, -1.548017144203186, -0.3126187026500702, -0.17373856902122498, -0.5877905488014221, -0.0012168398825451732, 0.8668649792671204, -0.13172581791877747, 0.286251038312912, 0.01213419996201992, 1.3080159425735474, 0.05213945358991623, -0.09137333929538727, -0.2147449254989624, -0.16023755073547363, -0.2647784352302551, 1.1302506923675537, -0.21688875555992126, 1.3101588487625122, -0.9314947724342346, -0.7565097212791443, -0.9206677079200745, 0.03780275583267212, -0.3357788622379303, 0.1723063886165619, -0.13156744837760925, -0.13681910932064056, -0.10408639162778854, 0.31374573707580566, 0.1219167411327362, -0.15815497934818268, 0.09167329967021942, -0.06304331123828888, -1.1110073328018188, -0.39485687017440796, -0.572228729724884, 1.2794400453567505, -0.8543447256088257, 0.9602532982826233, -0.8350416421890259, 0.859237551689148, 0.41498568654060364, -0.8186664581298828, 0.46559667587280273, -0.1353682279586792, -0.3520539104938507, -0.06291276216506958, 1.0229212045669556, 0.935998797416687, 0.38555899262428284, -0.6372811794281006, 0.8359845876693726, 0.3596900999546051, -0.10012451559305191, 0.11398916691541672, 0.16401861608028412, 0.17336496710777283, 0.01485571637749672, 0.33483412861824036, -0.20749226212501526, -0.31699031591415405, -0.2605011761188507, 0.21069510281085968, -0.16440828144550323, 0.7135155200958252, -0.7848545908927917, 0.8865346908569336, 0.12927661836147308, 0.6611124873161316, -0.4557386636734009, 0.782199501991272, 0.16939444839954376, -0.2959156632423401, -0.24569383263587952, 0.23981566727161407, -0.2742287218570709, 0.24871529638767242, -0.8890919089317322, 1.726051688194275, -0.4654906392097473, 0.603564441204071, -1.010992169380188, -0.08437550812959671, 0.7963131666183472, -0.2186410278081894, -0.04027549549937248, -0.0924585610628128, 0.30426308512687683, -0.02384883724153042, -0.5735790729522705, 0.4544312059879303, -0.25375691056251526, -0.33776387572288513, -0.2459084391593933, -0.5900011658668518, 0.37434104084968567, 0.2847541272640228, 0.8434498906135559, 0.2538408041000366, 0.7246487140655518, 0.7312109470367432, -0.5786674618721008, 0.021664651110768318, 0.4541105031967163, 0.8804191946983337, 0.10443837940692902, 1.0416085720062256, 1.0648736953735352, -0.687050461769104, 0.31556081771850586, 0.24172428250312805, 0.02661209926009178, 0.7873825430870056, 1.3055633306503296, 0.7703712582588196, 0.1829647421836853, 0.2771841585636139, -0.12526336312294006, 0.2886846363544464, -0.047147415578365326, 0.5728983879089355, 0.27557674050331116, 0.2923498749732971, -0.55088210105896, 0.8618576526641846, 0.46189427375793457, 0.06495245546102524, -0.7534574866294861, -0.13437823951244354, 0.14741140604019165, -0.2581773102283478, -0.4823121428489685, -0.5264778733253479, -0.05959942564368248, 0.38770267367362976, 0.008915774524211884, -0.7102773785591125, 0.5756514668464661, 0.7096149325370789, 0.32663238048553467, 0.41591978073120117, -0.27991175651550293, -0.3115384876728058, -0.7628113031387329, -0.990136444568634, -0.9388970136642456, -0.8713781833648682, -0.7236178517341614, -0.032171446830034256, 0.1295451819896698, -0.31770268082618713, -0.3496280312538147, -0.22482556104660034, -0.31372183561325073, 0.14058297872543335, -0.01747531071305275, 0.2950457036495209, 0.6210764646530151, -0.06907530128955841, -0.8840320706367493, 0.0222715362906456, -0.19084057211875916, 0.7126426100730896, 0.322818785905838, -0.7918335795402527, -0.5345284938812256, -0.14590252935886383, 0.7032026648521423, -0.5172902345657349, 0.1073712632060051, -0.5893861651420593, -0.06141059473156929, -1.2160202264785767, -0.1806780993938446, 0.3898128867149353, 0.2681596279144287, -0.04625004902482033, -0.771234929561615, 1.4108200073242188, -0.12625569105148315, 0.1151885911822319, 0.6570236086845398, 0.14056091010570526, 0.04240957275032997, 0.09688065201044083, -0.01100674457848072, -0.01145840808749199, -0.8396363258361816, 0.41289058327674866, 0.994101345539093, -0.5196592807769775, -0.2133060246706009, -0.5514357686042786, -0.9389169812202454, 0.11524514108896255, 0.29227766394615173, -0.5532228946685791, 0.4652404189109802, 1.1074775457382202, -0.10887246578931808, -1.157677173614502, 0.38270294666290283, 0.06265556067228317, -1.1884864568710327, 0.6854305267333984, -0.9048639535903931, 0.49304667115211487, 0.4453280568122864, -0.11597559601068497, -0.675076425075531, 0.2605563998222351, 0.5414460301399231, 0.4434274435043335, 0.4787369966506958, -0.23038245737552643, 0.2657198905944824, 0.3745439648628235, -0.1892840415239334, 0.26214849948883057, 0.24810536205768585, -0.2152957320213318, -0.08768756687641144, 0.11679580807685852, -0.5549380779266357, 0.017041509971022606, 0.7290224432945251, -0.1604325771331787, -0.29912498593330383, 0.7198918461799622, -0.1372275948524475, -0.04458114504814148, -0.3317924439907074, 0.16862276196479797, -0.2398025542497635, -0.2836892008781433, -1.1310995817184448, 0.909848690032959, -0.3037537634372711, -0.6413670182228088, 0.6342931389808655, -0.05369415879249573, 0.3973137140274048, -0.5494580864906311, 0.5408058762550354, 0.0946868434548378, 0.29922834038734436, -0.22216245532035828, -0.11027007550001144, -0.9128438234329224, 0.236782506108284, 1.1218253374099731, 1.5196938514709473, -1.0263060331344604, -0.19818979501724243, 0.38453418016433716, 1.2319546937942505, 0.6966733932495117, 0.31349706649780273, 0.6355553865432739, -0.4387769103050232, -0.165641650557518, -0.8664008378982544, 0.2998947501182556, -0.2040722817182541, 0.34658291935920715, 0.31374630331993103, -0.21420545876026154, -0.9402526617050171, -0.586819589138031, 0.21187373995780945, 1.2472981214523315, -0.07096569985151291, 0.10668060183525085, -0.10340055078268051, -0.5852022767066956, -0.13974444568157196, 0.972842812538147, 0.23713688552379608, 0.507149875164032, -0.8722562789916992, -0.14079426229000092, -0.6076004505157471, -0.4501032531261444, 0.3922041058540344, -0.7258970141410828, -0.45598357915878296, -0.2507776618003845, -0.022789377719163895, 0.15691831707954407, -0.45999667048454285, -0.1596778780221939, -0.9694312810897827, 0.36448392271995544, 0.49470198154449463, 0.06232014670968056, -0.4493187665939331, 0.2763638198375702, 0.01187087595462799, -0.8202454447746277, -0.19614222645759583, -0.8388444185256958, 0.9428626894950867, 0.8850349187850952, -0.1252134144306183, -1.0223073959350586, -0.4528568685054779, -0.5997028946876526, -0.9892488718032837, 0.6654552221298218, 0.09875935316085815, -0.522947371006012, 0.1194116622209549, -0.6827341318130493, -0.5910094380378723, -0.31852951645851135, 0.07384909689426422, -0.48631995916366577, 0.3691960871219635, -0.06900476664304733, 0.8925496935844421, 0.5318490862846375, 0.6019651293754578, 0.22851359844207764, 0.6360989809036255, -0.7663822174072266, 0.05628334358334541, -0.8199068307876587, -0.584949254989624, -0.031248664483428, -0.5327373743057251, -0.5262529850006104, -0.22705191373825073, -0.8258329033851624, -0.46229445934295654, -0.6015545725822449, 0.2882530391216278, 0.1713680773973465, -0.2038630247116089, 1.3804306983947754, -0.1993400603532791, -0.15096959471702576, 1.3535112142562866, -0.1691007912158966, -0.35369545221328735, 0.2890087068080902, -0.20420418679714203, -0.9716081023216248, 0.754793107509613, -0.18408288061618805, 0.18621672689914703, -0.48902997374534607, -0.0740170031785965, 0.2493596374988556, -0.17235204577445984, 0.10526332259178162, -0.4192388653755188, -0.38911548256874084, -0.32005220651626587, -0.29492372274398804, -0.4286572337150574, -0.5537338256835938, -0.762340784072876, 0.291058748960495, 0.309139221906662, -0.0015499276341870427, 0.1451675444841385, -0.41870516538619995, -0.39998704195022583, -0.423115611076355, -0.4925832450389862, -0.05184542387723923, -0.3351271450519562, 0.5598313212394714, 0.5366776585578918, -0.33102676272392273, -1.0701464414596558, -0.40208959579467773, 0.8733568787574768, -0.7131240963935852, -0.3662147521972656, 0.06235946714878082, -0.29719308018684387, -0.3006892502307892, -0.32472169399261475, -0.39029037952423096, -0.11724162101745605, -0.30176058411598206, -0.05817476660013199, 0.47726720571517944, 0.1618833988904953, -0.6302013993263245, -0.008081292733550072, 0.4682915508747101, 0.07834836840629578, -0.7648116946220398, -0.3386661112308502, 0.3456161320209503, -0.27376607060432434, -0.02813931182026863, -0.22337639331817627, -1.0665258169174194, -0.22610343992710114, -1.0386790037155151, 0.8624342083930969, -0.6539523005485535, 0.05665770545601845, -0.1332188844680786, -0.971047043800354, 0.1759050339460373, 0.4686628580093384, 1.3001208305358887, 0.38893309235572815, 0.070433609187603, -0.21134792268276215, 0.2810710072517395, -0.1620982140302658, 0.24811768531799316, -0.9675703644752502, -0.5015845894813538, 0.4550813138484955, 0.8065075278282166, 0.09720559418201447, -0.49126869440078735, 0.6091262102127075, 0.008586146868765354, 0.4578983783721924, 0.23182685673236847, -0.026130598038434982, 0.08915131539106369, 0.018837040290236473, 0.6646726727485657, 0.1998698115348816, 0.12825046479701996, -1.0519139766693115, 0.3953998386859894, -0.34459277987480164, 0.7787255048751831, 0.09961075335741043, -0.268518328666687, 0.4629083573818207, -0.15349708497524261, 1.530224323272705, -0.9672527313232422, 0.5014505386352539, 0.05370236188173294, -0.27198556065559387, -0.38347628712654114, 0.46892058849334717, -1.5932118892669678, -0.30646416544914246, -0.6944772601127625, -1.0265473127365112, 1.0683408975601196, -0.43138015270233154, -0.021833179518580437, -0.09436150640249252, -0.5011085271835327, 0.5487138032913208, -0.4774346649646759, 1.3463608026504517, 1.1499803066253662, -0.3160107135772705, -0.26332077383995056, 0.24291890859603882, 0.34353262186050415, -0.2064715027809143, 0.3083450496196747, 0.5319575071334839, -0.42130547761917114, -0.49292051792144775, -0.6634748578071594, -0.21544264256954193, -0.3801310956478119, -0.10467755794525146, 0.4364017844200134, -0.10143429785966873, 0.6981092095375061, 0.5933205485343933, 0.04715058580040932, -0.545648455619812, 0.09238842129707336, 0.1630096584558487, -0.12049899995326996, 1.0964609384536743, 0.30838945508003235, 0.02737717516720295, -0.37089312076568604, 0.5853374004364014, 0.41407954692840576, -0.846189022064209, -0.4095236361026764, 0.19754093885421753, 0.2170042097568512, -0.6550670862197876, 0.5168492794036865, -0.34039828181266785, -0.8126266002655029, -0.629412829875946, 0.0037255357019603252, -0.54493647813797, -0.012588745914399624, -0.06396368891000748, -0.011079748161137104, 0.8341414928436279, -0.0419374480843544, 0.7086305022239685, -0.523810863494873, 0.20797844231128693, -0.12772399187088013, 0.1411651074886322, -0.003991624340415001, -1.2904661893844604, 0.8133501410484314, 0.40881553292274475, -0.41124430298805237, 0.17840836942195892, 0.11005635559558868, -0.2209048867225647, 0.26523643732070923, -0.31730031967163086, 0.2938179075717926, -0.987072765827179, -0.430178165435791, -0.16362039744853973, 0.6931646466255188, 0.031110787764191628, 0.12671084702014923, 0.3427579700946808, 0.8078104257583618, -0.3889918625354767, -0.7636433243751526, -0.952476978302002, 0.013985956087708473, 0.570435106754303, 0.8368102312088013, 0.1299094706773758, 0.4081801772117615, 0.9935140013694763, 0.18087396025657654, -0.5300664305686951, -0.49129873514175415, -0.6068882346153259, -1.051649570465088, -0.7229247689247131, -0.3707050085067749, -0.6847667098045349, 0.34574440121650696, 1.0164045095443726, -0.10811882466077805, -0.7330487966537476, -0.1355706751346588, 0.7885037064552307, 0.22117672860622406, 0.48889002203941345, -0.3679662048816681, 0.20528073608875275, -0.7939831614494324, -0.08407627791166306, 0.026153944432735443, -0.5657899975776672, -0.04002602770924568, 1.1611939668655396, -0.5111836194992065, 0.3764980435371399, -0.21478478610515594, 0.22074323892593384, 0.7007652521133423, 0.45600008964538574, -0.8141342401504517, -0.870520293712616, -0.3275572955608368, 0.4505366086959839, -0.39106032252311707, 0.24451091885566711, 0.3012608587741852, -0.36001455783843994, -0.07728087902069092, 0.32366740703582764, -0.3280366361141205, -0.3413228988647461, 0.1698547750711441, 0.7940532565116882, -0.2849413752555847, -0.4717428386211395, -0.21968325972557068, 0.5133026242256165, -0.5048976540565491, -0.10522796958684921, -0.4086386561393738, -0.12060286849737167, -0.1180567517876625, -0.3237655460834503, -0.6388224959373474, 1.0352281332015991, -0.04738052934408188, 0.739854097366333, -0.22821709513664246, 0.3497495949268341, -0.07743552327156067, 0.2158350646495819, 0.4151170551776886, 0.19725462794303894, -0.22032660245895386, -1.2578586339950562, 0.23458625376224518, 0.1525179147720337, -0.11121006309986115, -0.19584296643733978, 0.2861860394477844, 0.21768660843372345, 0.004862002097070217, 0.3357461392879486, 0.2716371715068817, 1.1222779750823975, 0.6290280222892761, 0.7754785418510437, -0.31235453486442566, -0.4235144555568695, -0.9639419913291931, -0.5332241654396057, -1.524860143661499, 0.045477770268917084, -0.3107803165912628, -0.32858729362487793, -0.08066447079181671, -0.8028666973114014, 0.0634785071015358, -0.48732230067253113, 0.08618072420358658, 0.6830500364303589, -0.3402695655822754, 0.6294233798980713, 0.07583349943161011, 0.40503886342048645, -0.16299328207969666, -0.8046755790710449, 0.3519233465194702, -0.4400148391723633, -0.7217230796813965, -0.3521311581134796, 0.2817336618900299, 0.8632129430770874, 0.29489994049072266, -0.2876638174057007, -0.5164597034454346, -0.03801651671528816, -0.013932650908827782, -0.03907133266329765, 0.0753108561038971, 0.08339987695217133, -0.7636085152626038, -0.09497427940368652, 0.07372908294200897, 0.09864038228988647, -0.8614286780357361, 0.5358474850654602, 0.3077948987483978, -0.44614818692207336, -0.1060480996966362, 0.098933145403862, 1.0266448259353638, -0.06017213314771652, 0.6191486120223999, -0.20169401168823242, 0.44119125604629517, 0.0949438065290451, -0.10817739367485046, 0.7077413201332092, 1.0043842792510986, 0.22593992948532104, -0.22329311072826385, 0.056168023496866226, 0.16735877096652985, 0.8752579092979431, 0.19280430674552917, -0.0221622996032238, 0.2019105851650238, 0.4021957516670227, 0.08319991081953049, 0.560418426990509, -0.866839587688446, 1.1025400161743164, -0.13608749210834503, -0.16892653703689575, 0.03603344410657883, 0.3195371627807617, 0.47443437576293945, -0.07924433797597885, -0.676398515701294, 0.058336593210697174, -0.6938226819038391, -1.140254259109497, -0.24315010011196136, 0.32166948914527893, 1.168990135192871, 0.3298117220401764, -0.23548080027103424, 0.8502228856086731, 0.922439455986023, 0.48473671078681946, -0.2437434196472168, 0.999039888381958, -0.15184783935546875, -0.20674847066402435, -0.2614848017692566, 0.3817688226699829, -0.3966722786426544, -0.1943509727716446, 0.47806063294410706, -0.7321761846542358, 0.320917546749115, 0.8771119713783264, -0.6899785995483398, 0.13415053486824036, 1.2883586883544922, -0.32103607058525085, -0.19316977262496948, -0.7726477980613708, 0.4498629570007324, -0.15480881929397583, -0.2823925018310547, 1.011807918548584, -0.08862864226102829, 0.03722314536571503, -0.08780714124441147, 0.11689496785402298, 0.5140112042427063, 0.418513685464859, 0.7896289825439453, 0.018265970051288605, 0.3541204035282135, 0.9092130661010742, 0.2358199954032898, 0.4128830134868622, -0.22841839492321014, -0.40910136699676514, -0.16270922124385834, -0.5331807136535645, -0.2931910753250122, 0.14386720955371857, -0.14490753412246704, -1.1194007396697998, 0.2479318380355835, -0.28834864497184753, -0.3461277186870575, -0.2633216083049774, -0.797709584236145, -0.09554296731948853, 0.32302460074424744, -0.7520785331726074, 0.10547496378421783, 0.32435643672943115, -0.4082561135292053, -0.1886652708053589, -0.39898237586021423, -0.22298847138881683, 0.6413553953170776, -0.5555377006530762, 0.3833047151565552, -0.06515566259622574, 0.10498543083667755, -0.6955338716506958, -0.9917652606964111, -0.19986079633235931, -0.20716877281665802, -0.20448890328407288, -0.703414797782898, -0.03385204076766968, -0.007629993837326765, 0.5595136880874634, 0.0014472634065896273, 0.41955146193504333, -0.4660637676715851, 0.31135034561157227, 0.8999261260032654, -0.1173250824213028, 0.29061514139175415, 0.7511659264564514, -0.1355050504207611, -0.4357319474220276, 0.19297680258750916, 0.11321958154439926, 0.2711104452610016, -0.19028322398662567, -0.753875732421875, -0.2529631555080414, -0.023744847625494003, -1.0308178663253784, 0.0435621440410614, -0.11370357871055603, 0.3236227333545685, -0.10784406214952469, -0.17978273332118988, -0.9346161484718323, -0.8494220972061157, 0.8331186771392822, -0.8384631872177124, 0.04580565169453621, 0.3439585268497467, -0.10619547218084335, 0.9422549605369568, -0.23677803575992584, 3.847654342651367, 0.5362733602523804, 0.8005990982055664, 0.0711505115032196, 1.0798426866531372, 0.7918598055839539, 0.5572911500930786, -0.13119393587112427, 0.35260871052742004, -0.11536960303783417, -0.7942188382148743, 0.3726077377796173, -0.5621760487556458, -0.06159153953194618, 0.48270824551582336, 0.594711422920227, -1.3514070510864258, 0.3208529055118561, 0.017574656754732132, -0.926999568939209, -0.9222288727760315, 0.35089653730392456, 0.24699248373508453, 0.1396923065185547, 0.16228699684143066, 0.3043622672557831, -0.361507385969162, -0.9583216905593872, -0.29114753007888794, -0.23463945090770721, -0.13172022998332977, -0.4113319218158722, 0.30781200528144836, -0.8273336291313171, -0.0035946944262832403, 0.6500450372695923, 0.12783490121364594, -0.6545354723930359, 0.2940709590911865, -0.09260563552379608, -0.13450504839420319, 0.6465609073638916, -0.3352464735507965, -0.20551767945289612, -0.7814076542854309, 0.6287318468093872, -0.6031287908554077, 0.8729540109634399, 0.339264452457428, -0.36501485109329224, 0.5604892373085022, -0.5168890357017517, 0.29321327805519104, -0.9512941241264343, -0.9768074154853821, -0.4252818822860718, -0.2535519301891327, -1.3060777187347412, -0.20256072282791138, 0.44634097814559937, 0.655071496963501, -0.38446804881095886, 0.27584126591682434, 0.6453870534896851, 0.6652710437774658, 0.07912647724151611, 0.41703689098358154, -0.10172396153211594, -0.2929379343986511, 0.07772994041442871, -0.21459130942821503, 0.1801309585571289, -0.6820392608642578, 0.08946134150028229, 1.1942859888076782, 0.13291166722774506, -0.718619704246521, 0.397696316242218, -0.7103992700576782, -0.40623781085014343, 0.542959988117218, -0.26121780276298523, 0.5503722429275513, -0.5303008556365967, 0.4181878864765167, 1.1665629148483276, -0.16100068390369415, -0.1967901885509491, -0.7435048222541809, 0.04607739672064781, 0.554308295249939, -0.33540064096450806, -0.34569433331489563, 0.598638653755188, -0.07055669277906418 ]
{"Title": "Using compartmental models to simulate directed acyclic graphs to explore competing causal mechanisms underlying epidemiological study data", "Authors": "Havumaki Joshua, Eisenberg Marisa C.", "Abstract": "1 Abstract Accurately estimating the effect of an exposure on an outcome requires understanding how variables relevant to a study question are causally related to each other. Directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) are used in epidemiology to understand causal processes and determine appropriate statistical approaches to obtain unbiased measures of effect. Compartmental models (CMs) are also used to represent different causal mechanisms, by depicting flows between disease states on the population level. In this paper, we extend a mapping between DAGs and CMs to show how DAG\u2013derived CMs can be used to compare competing causal mechanisms by simulating epidemiological studies and conducting statistical analyses on the simulated data. Through this framework, we can evaluate how robust simulated epidemiological study results are to different biases in study design and underlying causal mechanisms. As a case study, we simulated a longitudinal cohort study to examine the obesity paradox: the apparent protective effect of obesity on mortality among diabetic ever-smokers, but not among diabetic never-smokers. Our simulations illustrate how study design bias (e.g., reverse causation), can lead to the obesity paradox. Ultimately, we show the utility of transforming DAGs into in silico laboratories within which researchers can systematically evaluate bias, and inform analyses and study design.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007922"}
10.1101/19007419
[ -0.1726817637681961, 0.5151323080062866, -0.32254111766815186, 0.5509547591209412, -0.3328137993812561, -1.237337350845337, 0.2985546290874481, -0.07486681640148163, 0.4741590619087219, 0.661210834980011, -0.8984277844429016, -0.3701570928096771, 0.06433666497468948, -0.6394343972206116, 0.11208978295326233, 0.011731689795851707, -0.8897509574890137, -0.22919555008411407, -0.4326315224170685, -0.2174922525882721, 0.9124521017074585, 0.33994412422180176, -1.0220351219177246, 0.18847157061100006, -0.3066530227661133, 1.1032357215881348, 0.14631783962249756, 0.2798915505409241, 1.4280139207839966, 0.07745937258005142, 0.3333551585674286, 0.05054008960723877, -0.6102913022041321, -1.045821189880371, -0.20127196609973907, 0.5766269564628601, 0.9602802395820618, -0.4879325330257416, 0.07130595296621323, -0.40165799856185913, 0.47285717725753784, -0.033320195972919464, 0.01531415618956089, -1.0288777351379395, -0.6846076846122742, -0.46805673837661743, -0.4978146255016327, 0.020770547911524773, -0.0074403537437319756, -0.20491620898246765, -0.4492073953151703, 0.0019185047131031752, -0.19334718585014343, 0.38590678572654724, -0.24138563871383667, -0.5082272887229919, 0.721237063407898, 0.35222360491752625, -0.45129677653312683, 0.01588575541973114, 0.05784579738974571, -0.3244098424911499, 0.0814424380660057, -0.990251362323761, 0.7324763536453247, 0.46251705288887024, -0.4198439121246338, -0.37524721026420593, -0.19558358192443848, -0.07213400304317474, -0.8948375582695007, 0.018869567662477493, -0.06041046231985092, -0.43425869941711426, -0.27048438787460327, -0.14639677107334137, -0.2343902438879013, -0.1937888264656067, 0.38418611884117126, -0.35604509711265564, 0.1556902676820755, -0.04335692524909973, -0.5363109707832336, 0.7827328443527222, 0.42049285769462585, -0.28120413422584534, 0.6076357960700989, 0.6701475977897644, 0.16314005851745605, 0.17031733691692352, 0.3225609064102173, 0.3867760896682739, 0.5126222968101501, 0.2614276111125946, 0.3141547441482544, 1.0435634851455688, 0.09240229427814484, -0.14617256820201874, 0.4775356650352478, 0.14686501026153564, 1.1049259901046753, 0.5400989055633545, 0.037915900349617004, 0.8415273427963257, -0.5931821465492249, 0.5407751202583313, 0.41623803973197937, -0.32068267464637756, -0.28716781735420227, -0.3889017701148987, 0.6301381587982178, -0.19116249680519104, -0.10816984623670578, 0.2700670659542084, 0.12416134029626846, 0.5123812556266785, -0.24305443465709686, 0.5944119691848755, -0.6435547471046448, -0.26259735226631165, -0.7016056776046753, 0.044516421854496, 1.0259536504745483, -0.34886443614959717, 0.6475442051887512, 0.180152028799057, -0.20270425081253052, 0.7686394453048706, -0.23831495642662048, -0.3136906325817108, -0.5553066730499268, -0.5238600373268127, 0.17668959498405457, 1.0872228145599365, -0.46228474378585815, -0.38436341285705566, -0.07436810433864594, 0.6136919260025024, -0.4222928583621979, -0.7813502550125122, -0.7345355153083801, 0.3570597171783447, -0.536781370639801, 1.629788875579834, -0.2601030468940735, 0.7227405309677124, -0.22705842554569244, -1.430653691291809, -0.4256609082221985, -0.6455827355384827, -0.3393118679523468, 0.5409428477287292, 0.15004348754882812, -0.2876022756099701, -0.5573321580886841, 0.17939919233322144, -0.07249762117862701, -0.1847989857196808, -0.6178815960884094, -0.3608362674713135, -0.10603153705596924, -0.16444671154022217, -0.46124589443206787, 0.4628589451313019, -0.7286261916160583, 0.8297577500343323, 0.07033906877040863, 0.24280452728271484, 0.9609369039535522, -0.27270883321762085, 0.6971905827522278, 0.356052041053772, -0.1520312875509262, -0.2332686483860016, -0.16720513999462128, 1.0009711980819702, 1.231016993522644, 0.29358214139938354, 0.5596095323562622, 0.7747105360031128, 0.09456945210695267, -0.4238658547401428, -0.34800052642822266, -0.2387336641550064, 0.21012887358665466, 0.05369902029633522, -0.37265685200691223, -0.9841811656951904, -0.08174706250429153, -0.6325416564941406, -0.09491971880197525, 0.5570669174194336, -1.177761197090149, 0.5712511539459229, 0.014777041040360928, 0.2705380916595459, -0.043106257915496826, 0.43416860699653625, 0.2180597186088562, 0.053990963846445084, -1.1246238946914673, 1.4968279600143433, 0.0015066778287291527, 0.43136101961135864, -0.5120490789413452, 0.07805575430393219, 0.05037499964237213, 0.4220844507217407, -1.1247446537017822, 0.32534778118133545, 0.2698870599269867, 0.1406259387731552, -0.5502669215202332, 0.06894292682409286, 0.8658466339111328, -0.7184985280036926, 0.16903235018253326, 0.7630235552787781, 0.10917074233293533, 0.2113526612520218, 0.05191688612103462, -0.1544741541147232, 0.8939951062202454, 0.07127648591995239, 0.23435133695602417, 0.054592572152614594, 0.7551746964454651, 0.5630112290382385, 0.0397229939699173, -0.5257259607315063, 0.15071429312229156, 0.675750195980072, -0.1895233541727066, 0.42575719952583313, 0.6653060913085938, 0.3138250708580017, 0.27543607354164124, 0.6097066402435303, 0.08733117580413818, 0.21796683967113495, 0.2169758528470993, 0.16105970740318298, 1.2170014381408691, 0.4142630398273468, -0.43336594104766846, 0.9664375185966492, 0.04904281720519066, -0.2053419053554535, -0.19356685876846313, -0.05727862939238548, -0.7234885692596436, 1.1143946647644043, 0.3148099184036255, 0.19698256254196167, -1.1988857984542847, -0.7673248648643494, -0.053989920765161514, 1.0209451913833618, -0.07106951624155045, -0.6566400527954102, -0.0697643831372261, -0.5026460289955139, 0.8697153925895691, -0.21178294718265533, 0.4938572943210602, 0.946933388710022, 0.9710819125175476, 0.20353570580482483, -0.23645612597465515, -0.4495752155780792, -1.1054950952529907, -1.171298623085022, -1.1073780059814453, -0.5348074436187744, -0.8632399439811707, -0.31975364685058594, -0.4535920321941376, -1.406209111213684, 0.5674383044242859, -0.19958627223968506, 0.196552112698555, -0.5796747207641602, 0.05188078060746193, 0.3925679922103882, 0.3176535964012146, -0.010432875715196133, -0.1614968329668045, 0.9321420192718506, -0.46224862337112427, 0.9815989136695862, -0.01147447805851698, -0.48085924983024597, -0.1763009876012802, -0.8917136788368225, 0.6171594858169556, -0.5952467918395996, -0.16628289222717285, 0.3739739954471588, -0.5043073296546936, -0.687382698059082, 0.06095233932137489, 0.12329917401075363, 0.1410447359085083, -0.1828957051038742, -1.182778239250183, 0.5275435447692871, 0.24219734966754913, 0.16495215892791748, 0.5439392924308777, 0.8649877309799194, -0.2579936981201172, 0.9427579045295715, 0.027866289019584656, -0.3521452844142914, -0.9320168495178223, -0.05122923105955124, -0.2689669132232666, -0.3440694212913513, -0.5136882662773132, -1.3890750408172607, -1.3703575134277344, -0.11176668852567673, -0.050748128443956375, -0.45678773522377014, -0.44373852014541626, 0.5261983871459961, 0.07229980826377869, -1.3526580333709717, -0.11375805735588074, -1.1767867803573608, -1.107668399810791, 0.35577791929244995, -0.34199070930480957, 0.7338551878929138, 0.7339356541633606, 0.3853251039981842, -0.8289735317230225, -0.404295414686203, 0.7421134114265442, 0.8476848602294922, 0.7119543552398682, -0.14002004265785217, -0.39998647570610046, 0.31692689657211304, 0.02775478921830654, 0.6537205576896667, 0.08814766258001328, -0.4468037486076355, -0.12819811701774597, 0.3352384567260742, -0.41761448979377747, 0.18990030884742737, -0.02418358251452446, -0.2289375364780426, 0.7326149940490723, 0.6264230012893677, -0.6941094994544983, -0.14640183746814728, 0.6610057353973389, 0.47336775064468384, -0.0002140674478141591, 0.18183493614196777, 0.08930082619190216, 0.037409715354442596, -0.7038823962211609, -0.5553604960441589, -0.002572117606177926, 0.20799176394939423, 0.3721199631690979, -0.7372982501983643, 0.76557856798172, 0.11347877979278564, -0.23721477389335632, 0.6812475323677063, 0.22673624753952026, -1.0999599695205688, 0.8927042484283447, -0.16451196372509003, 1.4706971645355225, -0.843233585357666, 0.5622047781944275, 0.5799739956855774, 0.9751724004745483, 0.4422360360622406, 0.2027186155319214, 0.46462708711624146, -1.0242832899093628, -0.06871581077575684, 0.46841540932655334, -0.41756367683410645, -0.2503668963909149, 0.8341581225395203, -0.2162172794342041, 0.12183976918458939, -0.8898807764053345, -0.7605074644088745, 0.6569540500640869, 0.3024367690086365, 0.25031912326812744, -0.46156394481658936, 1.0901647806167603, -0.3245036005973816, -0.04558490589261055, 0.318403959274292, 0.45713648200035095, 0.385255366563797, -0.2927933633327484, 0.43421119451522827, -0.3363133370876312, -0.5473188161849976, 0.7637310028076172, 0.056664545089006424, 0.015351667068898678, 0.06816773861646652, 0.7306521534919739, 0.04518195986747742, -0.5001551508903503, 0.0335988812148571, -1.0117535591125488, 0.8901437520980835, 0.40216320753097534, 0.297533243894577, -0.46138373017311096, -0.18691977858543396, 0.25548145174980164, -0.697265088558197, -0.37140926718711853, -0.7271521091461182, 0.7870521545410156, 0.901286780834198, -0.6339413523674011, -0.45154324173927307, -0.014630838297307491, 0.209506556391716, -0.14754129946231842, -0.0990108847618103, 0.5295178890228271, 0.519006073474884, 0.5426508784294128, -0.3241215944290161, 0.2044047862291336, -0.14627386629581451, -0.6862534284591675, -0.5076653957366943, 0.1182221993803978, 0.17464810609817505, 0.35121434926986694, 0.746985673904419, 0.4371086657047272, -0.6177647113800049, 0.7816962003707886, -1.1832188367843628, 0.5421985983848572, -0.13405179977416992, -0.45511099696159363, -0.8736075758934021, -0.30603569746017456, 0.28800931572914124, 0.15669015049934387, -0.3252141773700714, -0.05117368325591087, 0.08470971137285233, 0.7828894257545471, -0.5832960605621338, -0.8019346594810486, 1.0878061056137085, -0.551976203918457, 0.2616749107837677, 0.7644540071487427, -0.2640594244003296, -0.5034820437431335, -0.93744295835495, -0.02020491100847721, -0.6733455061912537, 0.9435667395591736, -0.13061337172985077, 0.22830338776111603, -0.3187522292137146, -0.39389118552207947, -0.08113455772399902, -0.5174309015274048, -0.008844356052577496, -0.8049854636192322, -0.5597307682037354, -0.6456695199012756, -0.33403319120407104, -0.8590701222419739, -0.7209408283233643, -0.2402239590883255, 0.6451997756958008, -0.6672245860099792, -0.7602330446243286, -0.36988919973373413, -0.379294216632843, -0.39157599210739136, -0.045377619564533234, -0.8761546015739441, 0.40832388401031494, -0.47213202714920044, 0.49828147888183594, 1.447957158088684, -0.48264002799987793, -0.7927474975585938, 0.1017218679189682, 1.2251852750778198, -0.640079140663147, -0.21028180420398712, -0.021898966282606125, -0.2647389769554138, -0.49489104747772217, -0.3058335781097412, 0.04630312696099281, -0.4151330292224884, 0.3491654694080353, -0.7558750510215759, -0.13716915249824524, 0.6374126076698303, 0.21238455176353455, -0.8636279702186584, 0.9134200811386108, -0.04159704968333244, -1.1060469150543213, -0.11645964533090591, 0.458406925201416, -0.0078353863209486, 0.01528838835656643, -0.2522837221622467, -0.4924909472465515, -0.4034164249897003, -0.2323792278766632, -0.0972209945321083, -1.073691725730896, -0.015504736453294754, -0.3335132598876953, 0.09436379373073578, 0.482587993144989, 0.34428927302360535, 0.3751883804798126, -0.28344082832336426, -0.7823337912559509, -0.38818085193634033, -0.14812049269676208, -0.07268641889095306, -0.9890757203102112, 0.3973962962627411, 0.04711495339870453, 0.7466977834701538, 1.1218291521072388, 0.1536383032798767, -0.6796534657478333, 0.4546351432800293, 0.07087209075689316, 0.7375105619430542, 0.4825608432292938, -0.9696478843688965, -0.5239606499671936, 0.3839038908481598, -0.0006725825369358063, -0.10871437191963196, -0.32863155007362366, -0.6158872246742249, -0.15671880543231964, -1.1581684350967407, 0.014930973760783672, -0.7092328667640686, -0.66273033618927, 0.01612139120697975, -0.2725541889667511, 0.6043100953102112, -0.9493674039840698, 0.1199573203921318, -0.13936635851860046, 0.2600284516811371, 0.14124315977096558, 0.4686161279678345, -1.665523886680603, -0.7216880917549133, -1.0293405055999756, -0.620237410068512, 0.25748366117477417, -0.3079128563404083, 0.3438800573348999, 0.3617601990699768, 0.3100353479385376, -0.15440888702869415, -0.4052227735519409, 0.7423502802848816, 0.27751362323760986, 0.33396589756011963, -0.13242043554782867, 0.5383289456367493, -0.15788570046424866, -0.09743644297122955, 0.7874268889427185, -0.09072508662939072, -0.6108651757240295, -0.026420682668685913, 0.00546145299449563, -0.6787165999412537, -0.4787311255931854, -0.17905625700950623, 0.12515763938426971, 0.8746740221977234, -0.7901945114135742, 0.3522111475467682, 1.2286120653152466, -0.4781290590763092, -0.6887823939323425, -0.010823813267052174, -0.7953763008117676, 0.37229928374290466, 1.5470831394195557, -0.43691545724868774, -0.47693338990211487, -0.1494625210762024, 0.5745146870613098, 0.1402231752872467, -0.1589929759502411, 0.521802544593811, -0.29396137595176697, -0.8210292458534241, -0.08592664450407028, 0.6756017804145813, -0.31558945775032043, -0.4979006052017212, 0.8299858570098877, 0.3326948285102844, 0.5395131707191467, -0.22282296419143677, -0.008794710971415043, 0.6509149670600891, -0.3375653028488159, 0.4015626907348633, 0.35651054978370667, 0.23068179190158844, 0.16473643481731415, 0.2947308123111725, 0.20814649760723114, -0.06788060069084167, 0.4540521502494812, 0.6057530641555786, -0.1936185359954834, 0.27496370673179626, -0.1404780149459839, 0.5415545105934143, 0.15444546937942505, -0.2618899941444397, 0.18548527359962463, -0.2725977599620819, 0.2661072909832001, 0.2761252522468567, 0.8165063858032227, -0.24680191278457642, -0.521217405796051, 0.02671177126467228, 0.4133124053478241, 0.06822070479393005, -1.5589584112167358, -0.6619121432304382, 0.23786833882331848, 0.2048608809709549, 0.8727967143058777, 0.2392444759607315, 0.3971298635005951, 1.3095104694366455, 0.548339307308197, 0.4184439182281494, -0.8091903328895569, -0.7301038503646851, -0.8990440964698792, -0.6276258826255798, 0.4947040379047394, -0.8860902190208435, -0.07717276364564896, 0.32469305396080017, 0.061735041439533234, -1.1121641397476196, -0.061860159039497375, 0.4886487126350403, -0.24093297123908997, -0.7113670706748962, -0.9006415009498596, 0.09278430789709091, -0.5057995915412903, -0.06392291188240051, -0.09493294358253479, -0.7020543813705444, 0.25777876377105713, 0.8947547078132629, -0.9961159825325012, -0.22249765694141388, 0.0578165277838707, 0.7335594892501831, -0.4615905284881592, 0.9076622128486633, -0.9062325954437256, -0.45247843861579895, -0.05068743973970413, 0.33420655131340027, 0.37847432494163513, -0.7796732783317566, 0.9186195731163025, -0.42671579122543335, 0.5641478896141052, 0.4039323627948761, 0.285518616437912, -0.4134659767150879, 0.36364027857780457, 0.6189890503883362, -0.73539137840271, 0.09907538443803787, -0.35840705037117004, 1.0591907501220703, -0.2625984847545624, -0.4262045621871948, -0.3881724774837494, 0.13796378672122955, -0.019104253500699997, -0.4017893970012665, -0.020508039742708206, 0.7000675201416016, 0.1913706511259079, 0.36237233877182007, 0.23222604393959045, 0.5497046113014221, 0.24238958954811096, 0.1440747231245041, 0.26630699634552, 0.4269373118877411, 0.1414533108472824, -1.1626460552215576, 0.5350057482719421, 0.2983412444591522, -0.367551326751709, -0.16060009598731995, 0.12830448150634766, -0.39774566888809204, -0.6685161590576172, 0.1863064169883728, 1.120680570602417, 0.4892033338546753, 0.0012208655243739486, 0.20440444350242615, 0.6198233962059021, -0.42321333289146423, -0.3520090579986572, 0.23285247385501862, -1.31047785282135, -0.7280653119087219, 0.8579146862030029, -0.5517027974128723, -0.011700830422341824, -0.43931761384010315, -0.4538722038269043, 0.4612111747264862, 0.5740750432014465, 0.21632367372512817, -0.3886513113975525, 0.5554910898208618, 0.5295717716217041, 0.40951600670814514, 0.6682037711143494, -0.7497256398200989, 0.12822696566581726, 0.034261591732501984, -0.25605055689811707, -0.1870575100183487, 0.1559738665819168, -0.030939480289816856, 0.33655044436454773, -0.5525786876678467, -0.5025404095649719, 0.8224431872367859, -0.033522285521030426, -0.46231624484062195, -0.4650440514087677, 0.43145662546157837, -0.7105974555015564, 0.41517749428749084, -0.8040856719017029, 0.1642301380634308, -0.001233247690834105, 0.7486534118652344, 0.693655252456665, -0.9622445702552795, -0.6881125569343567, 0.2382327914237976, 0.5533721446990967, -0.7798584699630737, 0.6796834468841553, -0.14378710091114044, 0.3187811076641083, 0.1440221667289734, -0.04573260620236397, 0.4288996458053589, 0.6559237837791443, 0.6029742360115051, -0.27391481399536133, -0.38511618971824646, 0.571686863899231, 0.4506412744522095, 0.496970534324646, 0.373237282037735, 0.6005704402923584, 0.3612942397594452, 0.013460208661854267, 0.5305704474449158, -0.32476741075515747, 0.6734910607337952, 0.14809992909431458, -0.09241897612810135, 0.29183778166770935, 0.001657578512094915, -0.0044259182177484035, 0.11602906137704849, -0.5314803719520569, 0.505126953125, -0.35193541646003723, -0.5673209428787231, -0.006242268718779087, 0.6498016119003296, 0.37271153926849365, -0.1290147304534912, 0.6969315409660339, -0.0866238996386528, 0.7207832932472229, 0.1860707700252533, -0.035430680960416794, 1.0567878484725952, -0.3213921785354614, -0.020980576053261757, -0.043888118118047714, 0.5466516017913818, -0.3508009910583496, -0.46798157691955566, 0.4816698431968689, -0.24578851461410522, -0.871902585029602, 0.48423534631729126, 0.17896410822868347, -0.5090492963790894, 1.1166532039642334, -0.9415572285652161, -0.25154396891593933, 0.00790546927601099, -0.01660332642495632, -0.3483909070491791, -0.5776854157447815, 1.169995665550232, -0.5379654765129089, 0.21095505356788635, 0.7385225892066956, -0.4317920207977295, -0.035831551998853683, 0.7910334467887878, -0.25824207067489624, 0.10241396725177765, 1.7632817029953003, 1.0490866899490356, 0.05647951737046242, 0.24887500703334808, 0.002450784435495734, 0.06059449166059494, 0.2196538746356964, -0.0625373125076294, 0.18914645910263062, 0.0932827889919281, -0.9922113418579102, -0.28954294323921204, -0.2596018612384796, -0.13656337559223175, -0.524749755859375, -0.0010790490778163075, -0.1308717280626297, 0.39760833978652954, -0.6527689695358276, -0.04581878334283829, 0.05714534968137741, 0.08062716573476791, 0.12002433836460114, 0.3017422556877136, 0.004869272466748953, -0.9682382941246033, 0.3458617627620697, -0.8026633858680725, 0.43783676624298096, 0.7719818353652954, -0.8695653676986694, -0.002494689542800188, -0.9554058313369751, -0.5483247637748718, -0.3022031784057617, 0.28030648827552795, -1.1864748001098633, -0.3982597887516022, 0.5234262943267822, -0.2038879096508026, 0.790760338306427, -0.44957292079925537, 0.29062166810035706, -0.08288286626338959, 1.341301441192627, -0.2880392074584961, 0.8405125737190247, 0.5875613689422607, -0.06550376862287521, 0.03919711336493492, -0.035235267132520676, 0.08706188201904297, 0.023870093747973442, 0.007574348244816065, -0.47046729922294617, 0.48323512077331543, 0.5725966095924377, -0.8742023706436157, 0.11150508373975754, 0.4228600263595581, 0.43165767192840576, -0.180399090051651, -1.0506916046142578, 0.00006833289080532268, -1.0588997602462769, 1.364092469215393, -0.8326916694641113, 0.657545268535614, -0.40728759765625, -0.09634435921907425, 0.43509653210639954, -0.9103164076805115, 3.691028356552124, 1.3825968503952026, 0.6176305413246155, -0.1033121794462204, 0.7846338748931885, 1.2690763473510742, 0.5161938667297363, -0.8423305749893188, 0.15857544541358948, -0.14552001655101776, -0.35192030668258667, 0.6567400097846985, -0.0406268835067749, -0.073098324239254, 0.5230186581611633, 0.6895962953567505, -0.8962059617042542, -0.302532434463501, -0.4490627646446228, -0.7503576278686523, -0.9420126676559448, 0.37684082984924316, 0.9542818069458008, 0.13258691132068634, 0.6273143291473389, -0.5221372246742249, -0.36712267994880676, 0.150978222489357, 0.09658210724592209, -0.4622964859008789, -0.27500051259994507, -0.8192649483680725, 0.4315608739852905, -0.4226616621017456, 0.6939900517463684, 0.4652779996395111, 0.247331440448761, -0.1062886193394661, 0.3228892683982849, 0.2644125819206238, -0.0779569074511528, -0.5689566135406494, -0.2695140540599823, -1.0403242111206055, 0.0849888026714325, -0.23525464534759521, -0.56382817029953, 0.0014470014721155167, -0.17241881787776947, -0.7857046127319336, 0.7470270991325378, -1.9466935396194458, 0.4977049231529236, -0.164896160364151, -0.884270429611206, -0.6616637706756592, -0.4626394212245941, -1.4092029333114624, 0.43388524651527405, 0.4890631139278412, 0.42267045378685, 0.4553760290145874, -0.19034288823604584, -0.35821476578712463, -0.008795412257313728, 0.19209247827529907, 0.6840099692344666, 0.2722563147544861, -0.06766905635595322, 0.20153219997882843, -0.3814446032047272, -0.20032437145709991, -0.6823447942733765, 0.34409695863723755, 0.7185399532318115, -0.14332863688468933, -0.5151826739311218, 0.8718040585517883, -0.8957906365394592, -0.5969083905220032, 0.089337058365345, 0.21688605844974518, -0.02042940817773342, -0.27267077565193176, 0.8048425912857056, 1.1802141666412354, -0.715050458908081, -0.2472497671842575, -1.0733017921447754, 0.7871890068054199, 0.529824435710907, -0.7018081545829773, 0.1270894557237625, 0.19626082479953766, -0.6733047366142273 ]
{"Title": "Patterns of Autism Symptoms: Hidden Structure in the ADOS and ADI-R instruments", "Authors": "Lefort-Besnard J\u00e9r\u00e9my, Vogeley Kai, Schilbach Leonhard, Varoquaux Ga\u00ebl, Thirion Bertrand, Dumas Guillaume, Bzdok Danilo", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT We simultaneously revisited the ADI-R and ADOS with a comprehensive data-analytics strategy. Here, the combination of pattern analysis algorithms and an extensive data resources (n=266 patients aged 7 to 49 years) allowed identifying coherent clinical constellations in and across ADI-R and ADOS assessments widespread in clinical practice. The collective results of the clustering and sparse regression approaches suggest that identifying autism subtypes and severity for a given individual may be most manifested in the social and communication domains of the ADI-R. Additionally, our quantitative investigation revealed that disease-specific patterns of ADI-R and ADOS scores can be uncovered when studying sex, age or level of FIQ in patients.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007419"}
10.1101/19005462
[ -0.24828296899795532, 0.3528888523578644, 0.5555689930915833, 0.5074566602706909, -0.5729597210884094, 0.005214478820562363, 0.10800113528966904, 0.23851081728935242, 0.14087043702602386, -0.08486581593751907, -0.04461168497800827, -0.5239871740341187, -0.07552929222583771, -0.11043629795312881, -0.15170136094093323, -0.15557347238063812, -0.7406537532806396, -0.4803628623485565, -0.20942962169647217, 0.001632427447475493, 0.5779495239257812, 0.8902385234832764, -0.5006489753723145, -0.07271219789981842, -0.40070998668670654, 0.8335826396942139, 0.11525958776473999, -0.5578712224960327, 1.002978801727295, 0.5836798548698425, -0.5424631237983704, -0.9383643269538879, 0.48040592670440674, 0.1361982822418213, -0.584264874458313, -0.04916301742196083, 0.8367757797241211, -0.5561410784721375, 0.13808710873126984, -0.24298571050167084, 0.191274955868721, 0.6316670179367065, 0.8298335671424866, -0.8858976364135742, -0.2915915250778198, -0.05210602283477783, -0.18299105763435364, 0.6338943243026733, 0.9403032064437866, 0.06261243671178818, -0.7017078995704651, -0.1446170210838318, 0.23789899051189423, -0.2239135056734085, 0.09412075579166412, -0.39996010065078735, 0.8126025199890137, -0.7047961354255676, -0.7934857606887817, -0.24679911136627197, -0.232351616024971, 0.2479829341173172, 0.7154886722564697, -0.8051325082778931, 0.26422446966171265, 0.9065268635749817, -0.5439093112945557, -0.7150176763534546, -0.4726305603981018, 0.1385095715522766, 0.3063773512840271, 0.49202725291252136, -0.12499760091304779, -0.1331699639558792, -0.3955189883708954, -0.21875111758708954, 0.014694935642182827, -0.44552549719810486, 0.5017014741897583, -0.019253453239798546, -0.3171585202217102, 0.2049017995595932, 0.721049427986145, 0.007561268284916878, -0.11593884229660034, 0.05534449219703674, 0.13792267441749573, 0.0839577317237854, 0.19505803287029266, 0.17652453482151031, 0.10504890233278275, 0.572327196598053, -0.2797851860523224, -0.00020349747501313686, 0.33535876870155334, 0.9676615595817566, -0.3918379843235016, 0.003407018957659602, 0.043617475777864456, -0.28529977798461914, 0.6476231813430786, -0.11859434843063354, -0.1427403837442398, 0.7781912088394165, -0.4340590238571167, 0.3806180953979492, 0.8601123094558716, -0.40730923414230347, -0.6347548961639404, -0.0035537388175725937, 0.25653892755508423, -0.17357949912548065, -0.29535356163978577, -0.4135023057460785, 0.09023776650428772, 0.6801285147666931, 0.02757800742983818, 0.5502346158027649, -1.1196461915969849, 0.24186332523822784, 0.37740659713745117, -0.007852836512029171, 0.31536808609962463, -0.6862944960594177, 0.453302264213562, 0.13321003317832947, 0.1092386394739151, 0.46657857298851013, -0.8317787647247314, -0.4692312777042389, -0.3365804851055145, -0.5453466176986694, -0.06112233176827431, 0.8796461224555969, 0.7180799245834351, -0.005682678893208504, 0.2813773453235626, 0.34626898169517517, 0.47150224447250366, -1.1356509923934937, -0.8405247330665588, -0.03188807889819145, -0.21791264414787292, 0.9260555505752563, 0.4214152693748474, 0.664713442325592, -0.36615875363349915, -1.1142281293869019, -0.748643696308136, -0.16337008774280548, -0.2924788296222687, 0.33593469858169556, -0.1708497554063797, -0.2041478008031845, 0.24461759626865387, 0.5562286972999573, -0.44665467739105225, 0.3872580826282501, -0.8817736506462097, 0.5890652537345886, 0.33692827820777893, -0.13224482536315918, -0.29714733362197876, 0.20190982520580292, -1.1594703197479248, 0.42951905727386475, -0.5687026381492615, 0.14287611842155457, 0.04275139793753624, -0.13858671486377716, 0.7707855105400085, 0.16705715656280518, -0.014186199754476547, -0.16250872611999512, -0.2524127662181854, 0.7386617660522461, 0.7731791734695435, 0.43200889229774475, -0.011432242579758167, 0.7398278117179871, -0.39305809140205383, -0.4366630017757416, 0.8085115551948547, 0.6004396677017212, 0.1256076842546463, 0.2695368826389313, -0.5495147109031677, -0.41120290756225586, -0.2990185022354126, -0.2268618792295456, -0.281185120344162, 0.17985370755195618, -0.9910520315170288, 0.8366735577583313, -0.014066822826862335, -0.2036941647529602, -0.24617668986320496, 0.2904578149318695, 0.33489638566970825, -0.19467055797576904, -0.7319299578666687, 1.3742868900299072, -0.6149982213973999, 0.28378811478614807, 0.3850535750389099, 0.545237123966217, 0.3597644865512848, 0.2827930748462677, -0.08443593233823776, 0.20278750360012054, 0.9967957139015198, -0.09304989874362946, -0.5198589563369751, 0.8849582672119141, 0.19837041199207306, 0.10504696518182755, -0.3578498661518097, 0.5669981837272644, -0.757745087146759, 0.16998398303985596, -0.19361001253128052, -0.44716793298721313, 0.5082599520683289, 0.771539032459259, -0.22145317494869232, -0.05650504305958748, 0.5474759936332703, 0.37668728828430176, 0.036837272346019745, 0.06962822377681732, 0.9564677476882935, 1.0114516019821167, 0.10767804086208344, 0.4970380663871765, 0.9709998965263367, 0.17702825367450714, 0.02613133192062378, 0.2204158753156662, 0.3049892485141754, 0.19558285176753998, 0.22978851199150085, 0.2031344175338745, 0.5033591985702515, 0.10316270589828491, -0.5197041034698486, 0.9516944885253906, -0.40430691838264465, 0.007491968106478453, 0.12075150012969971, 0.777069091796875, -0.597374439239502, 0.7889755964279175, 0.300405889749527, -0.13944344222545624, -0.7532385587692261, 0.03651027753949165, 0.4166196584701538, 0.32356059551239014, -0.024242721498012543, -0.8186691403388977, 0.3243188261985779, 0.4245021641254425, -0.04122741147875786, -0.1979789137840271, 0.7468054890632629, 0.5829896926879883, 0.08598503470420837, 0.9305860996246338, 0.04062835872173309, -0.6489769816398621, -0.6546896696090698, -0.6586421132087708, -0.6979415416717529, -0.9224940538406372, -0.738757848739624, 0.497266560792923, 0.24737830460071564, -0.3376478850841522, 0.5843459367752075, -0.15855585038661957, -0.09221700578927994, -0.02974833734333515, -0.20827727019786835, 0.6672782897949219, 0.6458777189254761, 0.15727807581424713, -0.7324199080467224, -0.7609899640083313, 0.2272443324327469, 0.6127143502235413, -0.06759355962276459, -0.15212945640087128, -0.03621359169483185, -1.0030224323272705, 0.7329289317131042, -0.8076654076576233, -0.30210989713668823, -0.137387216091156, -0.07492931187152863, -0.43578052520751953, 0.37623026967048645, 0.2796010673046112, 0.21092160046100616, 0.3192049562931061, -0.911158561706543, 0.8308585286140442, -0.36101362109184265, 0.13985063135623932, 0.620808482170105, 0.07774177193641663, -0.1890341341495514, 0.23218755424022675, -0.3412966728210449, 0.3396432101726532, -0.909024715423584, -0.07323036342859268, -0.09150125831365585, -0.5803990364074707, -0.016959229484200478, -0.8228182196617126, -0.6634250283241272, -0.4204551875591278, -0.4612125754356384, -0.1544332504272461, -0.6088059544563293, 0.28175270557403564, -0.0065086339600384235, -1.259158730506897, -0.21437720954418182, -1.0566165447235107, -0.1937747597694397, 0.3903767168521881, 0.22430843114852905, 0.10728321969509125, -0.5016949772834778, 0.5485620498657227, -0.37531983852386475, -0.0053533571772277355, 0.40928560495376587, 0.7468772530555725, -0.022405805066227913, 0.41992834210395813, 0.012825816869735718, 0.08771706372499466, -0.2966153621673584, 0.24540993571281433, 0.22714351117610931, -0.2415999472141266, -0.15186256170272827, 0.017930833622813225, -0.3502649962902069, 0.15514904260635376, 0.7713451385498047, -0.0268904659897089, 0.39275509119033813, 0.3585864305496216, -0.1408911943435669, 0.22125130891799927, 0.17610211670398712, 0.064344123005867, -0.5240415930747986, -0.3977077305316925, 0.020448803901672363, -0.305116206407547, -0.8563544750213623, -0.7829180359840393, 0.601751983165741, 0.07305610179901123, 0.5238897800445557, -0.19458267092704773, 0.7937474846839905, 0.25329577922821045, -0.28608447313308716, 0.5692908763885498, -0.5680403113365173, -0.07755380123853683, 0.8043206334114075, 0.38194507360458374, 1.4524643421173096, -0.4111393988132477, 0.7280891537666321, 0.2929154634475708, 0.8732298612594604, 0.07416952401399612, -0.1833966076374054, 0.27751538157463074, -0.17512142658233643, 0.7567722201347351, 0.5810720920562744, 0.22746631503105164, 0.6264012455940247, 0.21978574991226196, 0.47884055972099304, -0.06267353892326355, -0.5307037234306335, -0.6702888607978821, -0.026684608310461044, 0.4356424808502197, 0.5169249773025513, 0.10456600040197372, 0.7979057431221008, -0.6977680921554565, 0.6122599244117737, 0.3282563090324402, 1.2658578157424927, 0.13877683877944946, -0.7458734512329102, 0.5602430701255798, 0.6048394441604614, -0.9272366166114807, 0.2915477156639099, -0.568224310874939, 0.023267224431037903, -0.3472161889076233, 0.489081472158432, 0.26560094952583313, -0.7023820281028748, -0.22495120763778687, -0.7828918695449829, -0.03775542974472046, -0.33187732100486755, 0.08429143577814102, -0.6524580717086792, -0.2338816225528717, -0.35037198662757874, -0.7446960806846619, 0.1772257387638092, -0.656842827796936, 0.5597696304321289, 0.8372583389282227, 0.031161215156316757, -1.242226481437683, -0.6797310709953308, -0.14569459855556488, -0.09101205319166183, -0.9211071729660034, 0.49734148383140564, -0.17306116223335266, 0.39949560165405273, -0.4639863073825836, -0.3103265166282654, 0.22922451794147491, -0.011107675731182098, 0.5830175876617432, 0.17815802991390228, -0.11256623268127441, 0.6939826607704163, 0.2689286768436432, 0.8327251076698303, -0.20225787162780762, 0.3356850743293762, -0.7537645101547241, 1.0199806690216064, -0.20114761590957642, -0.20650796592235565, -0.40397822856903076, -0.26842907071113586, 0.4285683333873749, 0.02853657864034176, -0.731856107711792, -0.840872585773468, -0.02923002652823925, 0.6974601745605469, -0.03480461612343788, -0.7478516697883606, 0.7824355959892273, -0.6333447694778442, 0.07631226629018784, 1.1034830808639526, -0.5826702117919922, -0.33110377192497253, -0.17535828053951263, -0.3196028769016266, -0.5189566016197205, 0.5327621698379517, 0.089475616812706, 0.08927083015441895, 0.3441343903541565, -0.6035367250442505, -0.10085871070623398, -0.7139034867286682, 0.4096699655056, -0.7487742304801941, -0.21099194884300232, -1.0939977169036865, -0.05527915805578232, -0.12031649053096771, -0.2984704077243805, -0.7998730540275574, 0.9179426431655884, -0.15497204661369324, -0.8576259613037109, -0.8766893148422241, 0.08531295508146286, -0.1508803367614746, 0.010492407716810703, -0.4537832736968994, -0.2632230520248413, -0.057431500405073166, -0.35359129309654236, 0.5131522417068481, -0.478885293006897, -0.16405946016311646, 0.013889403082430363, 0.598629355430603, -0.7518280744552612, -0.5242988467216492, 0.31136244535446167, -0.3818742632865906, -0.49559304118156433, -0.6638811230659485, 0.1639358103275299, -0.8645868897438049, -0.434531569480896, 0.08786576986312866, -0.4411526918411255, 0.3367455303668976, 0.7484302520751953, -0.1282508820295334, 0.7444191575050354, -0.09791295230388641, -0.21729402244091034, -0.3101588189601898, 0.3078429698944092, -0.3588889241218567, 0.4612346589565277, -0.4699913561344147, -1.013045310974121, -0.3821132183074951, -1.1268867254257202, 0.20748871564865112, -0.7919678092002869, -0.3692588210105896, -0.535313606262207, -0.3660455644130707, 0.04158143699169159, 0.22950361669063568, 0.27510279417037964, 0.5254658460617065, -0.054661113768815994, -0.5930460691452026, 0.08597242087125778, -0.14998173713684082, -0.5881514549255371, 0.04246320202946663, -0.7465690970420837, 0.04535780847072601, 0.37436577677726746, -0.20168949663639069, 0.049427878111600876, 0.5035265684127808, 0.20495152473449707, -0.016346942633390427, 0.22683407366275787, -0.6768655180931091, -0.20659472048282623, -0.5490734577178955, 0.8863895535469055, -0.24178795516490936, 0.0016950663411989808, -0.34223514795303345, 0.7073171734809875, -0.6946213841438293, 0.08416590839624405, -0.33253201842308044, -0.268086314201355, 0.13616861402988434, -0.06754259765148163, 0.7834179997444153, -0.2674897313117981, 0.24880938231945038, 0.25523674488067627, -0.28641530871391296, 0.036273129284381866, 0.8423112630844116, -0.9339478611946106, -0.31314972043037415, -0.36827731132507324, -0.14829076826572418, 0.11020240932703018, 0.06491527706384659, -0.35815665125846863, 0.3783770203590393, 0.013356870971620083, -0.04693623259663582, -0.07326075434684753, 0.30752280354499817, 1.0926483869552612, -0.8191576600074768, -0.5475572943687439, 0.187875896692276, 0.010057453997433186, 0.037471599876880646, 0.2042602002620697, 0.41093674302101135, 0.2426108568906784, -0.12976616621017456, -0.581393837928772, -0.24121752381324768, -0.5008410215377808, -0.30845382809638977, 0.00404119910672307, 0.8152853846549988, -0.1955929547548294, 0.17148788273334503, 0.5787004828453064, -0.3509601354598999, -0.3218438923358917, 0.7182174324989319, -0.0783003494143486, 0.36051857471466064, 0.8414059281349182, 0.01895831897854805, -1.6960941553115845, 0.37291350960731506, -0.2991725206375122, 0.011408467777073383, 0.2264212965965271, 0.21143801510334015, 0.08320996165275574, -1.3444774150848389, 0.23044109344482422, 0.12513644993305206, -0.046615369617938995, -0.2559329867362976, 0.06848490983247757, -0.4546995460987091, 0.06578439474105835, -0.12601390480995178, -0.3755357563495636, 0.604166567325592, 0.37362462282180786, 0.4319448173046112, -0.07517784833908081, -0.19610120356082916, -0.05587378144264221, 0.01380863320082426, 0.2670518159866333, -0.16947442293167114, -0.10750512778759003, 0.5396257042884827, -0.1587291955947876, -0.19248495995998383, -0.33483055233955383, 0.3321825861930847, 0.10489040613174438, 0.09745550155639648, -0.1217217817902565, -0.4193800687789917, -0.6924111247062683, -0.4348677694797516, -0.2560695707798004, 0.45602598786354065, -0.304505318403244, -0.2210683822631836, 0.7189109921455383, 0.11448003351688385, -0.8480731248855591, -0.6655737161636353, -0.5793105959892273, 0.3025645315647125, -0.02072521299123764, 0.13776791095733643, -0.06052840128540993, 0.38619035482406616, 0.2946832478046417, 0.26241031289100647, -0.10045729577541351, -0.5973279476165771, -0.42183080315589905, -0.7452290058135986, 0.6119879484176636, -1.1000127792358398, -0.01682857982814312, 0.32433807849884033, -0.1219647154211998, -0.48387640714645386, 0.2642292380332947, 1.0836644172668457, -0.29648125171661377, -0.09508739411830902, -0.3370648920536041, -0.11188087612390518, -0.5338162779808044, -0.8203421831130981, -0.36336836218833923, -0.4619885981082916, 0.42782318592071533, 0.3980412483215332, -0.34261783957481384, -0.49164339900016785, -0.26011520624160767, 0.6912297606468201, -0.2873080372810364, 0.41132208704948425, -0.27769967913627625, -0.04383499175310135, 0.7288942337036133, 0.4368792474269867, -0.13325369358062744, -1.1373255252838135, 0.6755795478820801, -0.5366678833961487, 0.6011459231376648, 0.27918127179145813, 0.2915497124195099, 0.3387390673160553, 0.5356965661048889, -0.11050274968147278, -0.736541211605072, -0.26951494812965393, -0.011080969125032425, 0.5428640842437744, -0.6565406918525696, -0.49949708580970764, -0.7628493309020996, 0.22604896128177643, 0.38294196128845215, -0.05705416575074196, 0.026378465816378593, 0.9239983558654785, -0.07633871585130692, 0.06552238762378693, -0.08487915247678757, 0.5010181665420532, 0.6513358950614929, 0.4055023491382599, 0.5001842975616455, -0.018114609643816948, 0.12320947647094727, -0.933152973651886, 0.06282752752304077, -0.27919742465019226, -0.08019254356622696, 0.800205409526825, 0.320608526468277, 0.1363191157579422, -0.07716038078069687, -0.09619959443807602, -0.00018758123042061925, 0.6752185821533203, 0.7029948234558105, 0.3661479651927948, -0.22513790428638458, 0.1616644412279129, -0.32427942752838135, -0.058199819177389145, -0.5024744868278503, -0.8108395934104919, 0.5010147094726562, -0.4744633138179779, -0.41099750995635986, -0.8285369277000427, -0.7121418714523315, 1.0004619359970093, -0.44305655360221863, 0.33162370324134827, -0.10581007599830627, 0.9122540950775146, 0.3240962326526642, 0.00010998561629094183, 0.3586239814758301, -0.08167176693677902, -0.002924479078501463, 0.13894182443618774, -0.09970250725746155, -0.46558713912963867, 0.5459312796592712, 0.33974236249923706, 0.5738087892532349, 0.042910974472761154, -0.05101313069462776, 0.04535920172929764, -0.3857411742210388, 0.32798710465431213, -0.5404117107391357, -0.36652225255966187, -1.5268192291259766, -0.3905416429042816, -0.8047971725463867, -0.3505658507347107, -0.09252940118312836, 0.3446263372898102, 0.26936817169189453, -0.8682989478111267, -0.1911858171224594, 0.4492446184158325, 0.6719626188278198, -0.1308499127626419, -0.1634695827960968, 0.6490595936775208, 0.07393485307693481, -0.6072872877120972, -0.14486323297023773, 0.6257851123809814, 0.4257906675338745, -0.11019638925790787, -0.20257903635501862, 0.004173086490482092, -0.09237012267112732, 1.111648440361023, -0.2283705323934555, 0.25210097432136536, 0.5643512606620789, -0.34477201104164124, 0.006232402753084898, -0.36085814237594604, -0.5510054230690002, 0.4559187889099121, -0.008752652443945408, -0.504557728767395, 0.45022597908973694, 0.12008770555257797, 0.3456292748451233, 0.1664409190416336, -0.6083866953849792, 0.045320842415094376, -0.7677392959594727, 0.001714489539153874, 0.20273996889591217, -0.06722444295883179, 0.8204297423362732, 0.2683994472026825, 0.5346097350120544, 0.4633597135543823, 1.2248460054397583, 0.25082340836524963, 0.5314881801605225, 1.3368499279022217, -0.38842856884002686, -0.3665425479412079, -0.49404221773147583, 0.32667988538742065, 0.07967223227024078, -0.06695982068777084, 0.07760657370090485, -0.06836362183094025, -0.5734691619873047, 0.7396653890609741, 0.5136114358901978, 0.03096107952296734, 0.7594246864318848, -0.04371402785181999, -0.5093309879302979, -0.13176916539669037, -0.12096133083105087, -0.425232470035553, 0.3640556037425995, 0.5128163695335388, -0.09235338121652603, 0.38699963688850403, 0.02029580995440483, 0.11270058155059814, 0.14502301812171936, 0.7225419878959656, -0.3397117853164673, -0.4095875024795532, -0.05557959899306297, 0.7705574035644531, -0.13285477459430695, 0.08724696934223175, -0.12760289013385773, -0.5722523927688599, -0.21107839047908783, -0.377541720867157, 0.3788503408432007, -0.15601910650730133, 0.48526808619499207, -0.3833257853984833, -0.3622964918613434, -0.48825690150260925, -0.6713039875030518, -0.9724016785621643, 0.005144743248820305, -0.29367586970329285, -0.2623331546783447, -0.016252310946583748, 0.21103796362876892, 0.2981860637664795, -0.32504186034202576, 0.005733375437557697, -0.6042354702949524, -0.5728459358215332, 0.030726803466677666, 0.08999594300985336, 0.5974527597427368, -0.02436690963804722, -0.7731955647468567, -0.646587073802948, -0.7663376927375793, -0.013750712387263775, -0.013997799716889858, -0.4155521094799042, -0.3570460081100464, -0.3116072118282318, 0.6873443722724915, -0.04251358285546303, 0.8098620176315308, -0.2788444459438324, -0.5182337760925293, -0.019387809559702873, 0.9575170874595642, 0.18709738552570343, -0.015534231439232826, 0.32369759678840637, -0.4130783677101135, 0.03035774454474449, -0.3859527111053467, -0.1389029622077942, -0.5850852131843567, -0.16392973065376282, -0.5027551651000977, 0.11736569553613663, -0.09839729219675064, -0.5343886017799377, 0.6361979842185974, 0.7991735935211182, -0.15249435603618622, -0.32427820563316345, -1.2615187168121338, -0.24564659595489502, -1.0522524118423462, 0.9947566390037537, -0.0932367816567421, -0.21679839491844177, 0.3444826900959015, -0.3138734996318817, 0.5518078804016113, -0.604043185710907, 4.291050434112549, 1.095085859298706, 0.6158720254898071, -1.2682377099990845, 0.6553349494934082, 0.7885336875915527, 0.5210445523262024, 0.6870920658111572, -0.01658475585281849, -0.344984233379364, -0.07521340250968933, 0.15206460654735565, 0.32679682970046997, -0.4760286808013916, 0.6397442817687988, 0.6437609195709229, -0.7168633341789246, -0.04540074244141579, -0.5413918495178223, -0.5021554231643677, -0.9395273327827454, -0.28374427556991577, 0.46688151359558105, 0.3542279303073883, -0.2380133420228958, -0.5256430506706238, 0.5182626247406006, -0.23681996762752533, -0.05183099955320358, -0.4904547333717346, 0.1082448810338974, -0.7309100031852722, -0.05028701573610306, -0.59217369556427, -0.2484939992427826, 0.6361058950424194, -0.17195989191532135, 0.27984732389450073, 0.030170222744345665, -0.45574280619621277, -0.5585113167762756, 0.019323483109474182, 0.11478520184755325, -1.2689158916473389, 0.32483893632888794, 0.3470168113708496, -0.5616833567619324, 0.3262411952018738, 0.1355993002653122, 0.018383709713816643, 1.1333322525024414, -1.2958041429519653, 0.262605756521225, 0.07179426401853561, -0.5968778133392334, -0.3411869704723358, -0.28490403294563293, -1.2609490156173706, 0.7454009056091309, 0.35082772374153137, 0.2044132947921753, 0.12974876165390015, -0.12212163954973221, 0.5314534902572632, 0.11517615616321564, 0.8630085587501526, 0.5644114017486572, -0.007913284935057163, 0.017262551933526993, -0.06881970912218094, 0.4805333614349365, -0.6864445209503174, 0.15976832807064056, -0.19066369533538818, 1.2540924549102783, 0.14224614202976227, 0.36043310165405273, 0.5085611939430237, -0.07421861588954926, -0.6529628038406372, 0.4259614050388336, 0.5121051073074341, 0.3034851849079132, -1.0184822082519531, 0.40704625844955444, 0.6695089340209961, -0.5115602612495422, -0.5613175630569458, -0.15713681280612946, 0.6160487532615662, 0.26751217246055603, 0.9152354598045349, 0.26834836602211, 0.4003654420375824, -0.62772536277771 ]
{"Title": "Increased Frequency of Acute Illness and Hospitalizations in Infants and Toddlers with Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia", "Authors": "Tseng Teresa, Seagroves Amy, Koppin Christina M., Keenan Madison, Putterman Elana, Nguyen Eugene, Chand Sanjay, Geffner Mitchell E., Chang Todd P., Kim Mimi S.", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose Infants and toddlers with classical congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) are at high risk for adrenal crisis and associated sequelae. To better understand acute illness at this early age, we determined the frequency and severity of acute illness and hospitalizations between 0-4 years of age, both within CAH and compared to controls. We also evaluated the impact of pre-hospital stress-dose hydrocortisone on Emergency Department (ED) visits and hospitalizations. Methods We performed a retrospective study of 40 CAH youth and 27 age-matched controls at a tertiary center. Characteristics of acute illnesses during the first 4 years of life were recorded, including fever, vomiting, diarrhea, ED visits, hospitalizations, abnormal electrolytes, and stress-dose hydrocortisone usage. Results CAH youth had more frequent illnesses requiring stress-dosing when they were younger than 2 years old [4.0 (1.0-6.0)] compared to when they were 2-4 years old [3.0 (1.0-4.0), P < 0.05], with the most illnesses during their first year of life. As well, CAH infants and toddlers had more hospitalizations younger than 2 years old compared to 2-4 years old (36 vs 2). 25% (3/12) of CAH youth with abnormal electrolytes in the ED did not receive any stress-dosing (oral/IM) prior to the ED, and only 25% (3/12) had received intramuscular hydrocortisone at home. CAH youth had more frequent ED visits (7.4 times as many) and hospitalizations (38 to 0) compared to controls. Conclusions Very young children with classical CAH are at high risk for acute illness and hospitalizations during their first 2 years of life, and do not receive adequate stress-dosing prior to the ED despite appropriate education. Our findings underscore the need for earlier recognition of acute illness in this vulnerable population and improved education regarding administration of stress-dose hydrocortisone to prevent morbidity.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005462"}
10.1101/19002162
[ -0.17098040878772736, 0.452219158411026, -0.6686934232711792, 0.762990415096283, -0.3413316309452057, -0.04197391867637634, -0.2050967812538147, -0.019528895616531372, 0.403057724237442, 0.5530084371566772, 0.5131011009216309, -0.14515072107315063, 0.7541583180427551, -0.32471194863319397, -0.16809001564979553, -0.29944249987602234, -0.46826469898223877, -0.3312660753726959, -0.3243842124938965, 0.6941257119178772, -0.298599511384964, 1.0420386791229248, -0.3675425350666046, 0.3422614336013794, -0.6574721932411194, 0.19995371997356415, 0.32561028003692627, -0.3758752644062042, 0.988675057888031, 0.9034594297409058, 0.3682100772857666, -0.30036965012550354, -0.12175717949867249, -0.11836376041173935, -0.27358806133270264, -0.15559951961040497, 0.006939826998859644, -0.6604151129722595, -0.20455504953861237, 0.3046683073043823, -0.10872052609920502, 0.014833486638963223, 0.67647385597229, -0.6922298669815063, -1.1442444324493408, -0.5069481134414673, -0.07110389322042465, 0.20607703924179077, 0.5863459706306458, -0.04891667887568474, -0.6566557884216309, -0.04101869836449623, -0.7071688771247864, -0.9384286999702454, 0.2240990400314331, -0.21922346949577332, -0.48929303884506226, -0.7198550701141357, -0.42920780181884766, 0.20361828804016113, -0.4748457670211792, -0.19440820813179016, 0.34433504939079285, -0.956314742565155, 0.2709925174713135, 1.0574262142181396, -0.25046682357788086, -0.5708195567131042, -0.26080453395843506, -0.2325044423341751, 0.3765157461166382, -0.20155341923236847, -0.6557766795158386, -0.07499854266643524, -0.09530163556337357, -0.4124795198440552, 0.19684390723705292, -0.055415891110897064, 0.0903221070766449, -0.3591800630092621, 0.40247759222984314, -0.22006383538246155, -0.07361311465501785, -0.13592763245105743, 0.006349029019474983, -0.42659085988998413, 0.4847605228424072, -0.2911871671676636, 0.4575876295566559, 0.3430076539516449, -0.3768499493598938, 0.5005887150764465, 0.20161724090576172, 0.12391790747642517, 0.2442937195301056, 1.0568865537643433, -0.8262457847595215, 0.004418722819536924, 0.9023705124855042, 0.12817081809043884, 0.37110528349876404, 0.5307409763336182, -0.3027200996875763, 0.7307364344596863, -0.4043003022670746, 0.44610461592674255, 0.6318760514259338, -0.3211207985877991, -0.5944164991378784, -1.255403757095337, 0.05515467748045921, 0.13921311497688293, -0.20217008888721466, -0.3944643437862396, 0.303818941116333, 0.45446741580963135, -0.5928645133972168, 0.47323375940322876, -0.42772918939590454, 0.8538029789924622, 0.13087497651576996, -0.1201472282409668, 0.3015764057636261, -0.7163487076759338, 1.1049039363861084, 0.24267002940177917, 0.4877665042877197, 0.9481801390647888, -0.8532530069351196, 0.2385871261358261, 0.4801049530506134, 0.16834993660449982, -0.21883316338062286, 0.4977276623249054, -0.32740914821624756, -0.1707489788532257, 0.5210484266281128, 0.6365551352500916, 0.895548403263092, -0.02659808099269867, -0.6741546988487244, 0.13005384802818298, 0.20488481223583221, 0.802639901638031, 0.13407263159751892, 1.114842414855957, -0.690680205821991, -0.954220175743103, -1.0869940519332886, 0.11953399330377579, -0.1865738481283188, 0.8718774914741516, 0.15498892962932587, 0.6765977740287781, -0.2615632116794586, 0.5131489634513855, -0.5928553342819214, 0.35883790254592896, -1.515484094619751, 0.4906380772590637, -0.3208760917186737, 0.00952549371868372, 0.11034966260194778, 0.4241960048675537, -0.6825563907623291, 0.750055730342865, -0.37802696228027344, 0.10631586611270905, 0.23446597158908844, -0.29972440004348755, 1.1681523323059082, 0.56451815366745, -0.47744619846343994, -0.25412115454673767, 0.5570719242095947, 1.0493485927581787, 0.4165860712528229, 0.30696094036102295, 0.12375010550022125, 0.8840982913970947, -0.43558329343795776, -0.014859624207019806, 0.28748807311058044, 0.2558929920196533, 0.4096185564994812, 0.5165130496025085, -0.19953860342502594, -0.8222514390945435, -0.2022508680820465, -0.3521350920200348, 0.5073769688606262, 0.46002623438835144, -0.7367245554924011, 1.2037078142166138, 0.09297627955675125, 0.1603998988866806, -0.3874073028564453, 0.13289152085781097, 0.5307687520980835, 0.2792016863822937, -0.9600282907485962, -0.09349250048398972, 0.21045386791229248, 0.6152352690696716, -0.4011007845401764, 0.6621745228767395, 0.6751560568809509, 0.4027227461338043, -0.05409762263298035, 0.09624294191598892, 0.7278159260749817, 0.2566794455051422, -0.714707612991333, -0.02025904320180416, 0.7327988743782043, 0.24543966352939606, 0.04827122390270233, 0.11741811037063599, -0.16393889486789703, -0.2994711995124817, -0.6629176735877991, 0.1601041555404663, 0.12588568031787872, 0.22806069254875183, 0.002854755613952875, 0.13799193501472473, 0.9665917158126831, 0.1169477328658104, -0.30552950501441956, -0.4749157428741455, 0.7201318740844727, 0.08941887319087982, -0.2716306447982788, 0.9656066298484802, 0.5840091109275818, 0.1960117518901825, 0.12929776310920715, 0.6459595561027527, 0.577250599861145, 0.35813963413238525, 0.33422616124153137, 0.22712461650371552, 0.21018923819065094, 0.3921569883823395, -0.6199239492416382, 0.5243678092956543, -0.4216981530189514, -0.22360776364803314, -0.1386219561100006, 0.36084768176078796, -0.4421255886554718, 0.12210559099912643, 0.5266377925872803, 0.06970557570457458, -0.827734112739563, -0.08493588119745255, 0.33621788024902344, -0.19272205233573914, -0.6493440866470337, 0.03087260015308857, 0.12414932996034622, 0.5417848825454712, -0.1719682216644287, -0.12343411147594452, 0.36999791860580444, 0.4675237238407135, -0.21896928548812866, -0.04881199449300766, 0.2951848804950714, 0.10116469115018845, -0.8037455081939697, -0.0032027822453528643, -0.6874423027038574, -0.6491135954856873, -0.22741682827472687, -0.10218136012554169, -0.18547381460666656, -0.2814261019229889, 0.4637926518917084, -0.467106431722641, 0.012792770750820637, -0.1876981556415558, -0.06296131014823914, 0.9922430515289307, -0.35322216153144836, -0.08245320618152618, -1.1988584995269775, 0.17850685119628906, -0.4413827657699585, 0.30002927780151367, 0.41531071066856384, -0.15773814916610718, -0.41785934567451477, -0.37051862478256226, 0.26926189661026, -0.8904444575309753, -0.2670208215713501, -0.4363763928413391, -0.28941190242767334, 0.0879330188035965, 0.36630064249038696, -0.32335275411605835, -0.1883232295513153, -0.49073338508605957, -0.6954529881477356, 0.7085358500480652, -0.10736041516065598, 0.26279374957084656, 0.49178722500801086, 0.3301527500152588, -0.5162544846534729, 0.21361136436462402, 0.22475308179855347, 0.9979485273361206, -0.45592156052589417, -0.15297989547252655, 0.3284687399864197, -0.783332347869873, -0.02943486161530018, -0.3868727684020996, -0.4022846221923828, -0.34216663241386414, -0.6746318340301514, 0.14436635375022888, -0.2145041823387146, -0.0153809180483222, -0.025257648900151253, -1.1129481792449951, 0.027398353442549706, -0.7720159292221069, -0.36196625232696533, -0.019294418394565582, -0.27059218287467957, 0.2945176661014557, -0.13338524103164673, -0.14898237586021423, -0.8235256671905518, -0.16785645484924316, -0.07645834982395172, 0.2770576775074005, 0.7897713780403137, -0.40930408239364624, -0.160355344414711, -0.16060452163219452, -0.81297767162323, 0.7242702841758728, 0.2668609917163849, -0.121328204870224, -0.3131701946258545, -0.16835592687129974, -0.17440876364707947, 0.7203535437583923, -0.00022237878874875605, -0.1298055648803711, 0.13473264873027802, 0.3728308379650116, 0.024652259424328804, 0.35586509108543396, -0.2108784317970276, 0.5315095782279968, 0.14260686933994293, 0.41262125968933105, -0.4378543496131897, 0.17842428386211395, -0.5821580290794373, -0.9269486665725708, 0.7347299456596375, 0.13903926312923431, 0.9681273102760315, -0.4314984679222107, 0.6050906777381897, 0.05231401324272156, 0.43035581707954407, 0.15095707774162292, -0.61832594871521, -0.47884538769721985, 0.46318456530570984, 0.0837760865688324, 0.2001807540655136, -0.9971402287483215, 0.5023825764656067, 0.2541608512401581, 0.46008896827697754, 0.36015117168426514, -0.3092981278896332, 0.3255108594894409, -0.6124549508094788, 0.6289541721343994, 0.20917366445064545, 0.07945962250232697, 0.6184545159339905, -0.28361180424690247, -0.29263579845428467, -0.26547300815582275, -0.547206461429596, 0.23503506183624268, 0.5450307726860046, 0.2303982377052307, -0.10504233092069626, -0.33713066577911377, 0.9427626729011536, -0.30509164929389954, 0.4216877222061157, 0.8544378280639648, 1.0303767919540405, -0.21474367380142212, -0.7747976183891296, -0.09067989140748978, 0.01376821007579565, -0.05798166245222092, -0.48649564385414124, -0.6779483556747437, 0.033496856689453125, -0.03662993013858795, 0.13188034296035767, 0.17572562396526337, -0.37109315395355225, -0.3279527723789215, 0.041549935936927795, -0.050380878150463104, 0.7957813739776611, 0.04362127557396889, -1.2091615200042725, 0.39157262444496155, 0.21103793382644653, -0.38553163409233093, -0.26928120851516724, -0.4122582674026489, 0.3468863368034363, 1.2849760055541992, -0.5143883228302002, -0.9810055494308472, -0.36311274766921997, -0.34872934222221375, -0.13853955268859863, 0.7906605005264282, -0.123020701110363, -0.8735044598579407, 0.2998966574668884, -0.25251704454421997, 0.04597823694348335, 0.01693473942577839, 0.2917538285255432, 0.14381811022758484, 0.2778671383857727, -0.29723894596099854, 1.2887791395187378, 0.1503722071647644, 0.8999136090278625, 0.2949393689632416, -0.055506668984889984, -0.47253572940826416, 1.1616275310516357, -0.09712733328342438, -0.9041374325752258, 0.025578776374459267, 0.009858768433332443, -0.08546366542577744, -0.14866165816783905, -0.21509958803653717, 0.23253633081912994, -0.26724010705947876, -0.2559422552585602, -0.25658321380615234, -0.010310250334441662, 0.7475408315658569, -0.38640516996383667, -0.09823273867368698, 1.3542128801345825, -0.5407765507698059, -0.33331650495529175, -0.7067093849182129, -0.4226723909378052, -0.2908693552017212, 1.0103838443756104, -0.1498425453901291, 0.11146913468837738, 0.3994429111480713, -0.662114143371582, 0.4210534691810608, -0.455294132232666, -0.4041218161582947, -0.11111436784267426, -0.10317990183830261, -0.7749981880187988, -0.3092949092388153, 0.1512010246515274, -0.2147999107837677, -0.9465450048446655, 0.9391447305679321, -0.11848218739032745, -0.14989027380943298, -0.48837459087371826, -0.06973236054182053, -0.1514866054058075, 0.3103088438510895, -0.11481747776269913, -0.20271489024162292, -0.2500731647014618, -0.4282258450984955, -0.14099319279193878, -1.065029263496399, -0.8958843350410461, 0.3023695647716522, 0.7945425510406494, -0.9568215012550354, -0.3600133955478668, -0.31766584515571594, -0.0413210466504097, -0.8127281665802002, -0.5555472373962402, 0.2144528031349182, -0.537345290184021, 0.6692206263542175, -0.07574908435344696, 0.06748338043689728, 1.2480041980743408, -0.7965080738067627, 0.5011566877365112, -0.027968978509306908, -0.12250758707523346, -0.4332886040210724, -0.038597069680690765, -0.08299770206212997, -0.247093066573143, 0.7829315662384033, -0.37985527515411377, -0.41703110933303833, 0.006095374468713999, -1.477677345275879, 0.3691622018814087, -0.8657994866371155, -0.41629981994628906, -0.16229718923568726, -0.6816097497940063, -0.4576702415943146, 0.42615482211112976, -0.04954681918025017, -0.24481093883514404, 0.329454243183136, 0.2557620108127594, 0.5964633226394653, 0.07014285773038864, -0.2565518915653229, 0.37239956855773926, -0.6054242849349976, -0.05480009689927101, 0.5839270353317261, 0.3227599859237671, -0.2977173924446106, -0.11349757760763168, -0.18837381899356842, 0.2650890052318573, 0.488086462020874, -0.593192458152771, -0.5786297917366028, -0.362077921628952, 0.23393002152442932, 0.3860488831996918, 0.33189263939857483, -0.06906680762767792, 0.5016991496086121, -0.5430160164833069, 0.7216774821281433, -0.48696234822273254, -0.35684603452682495, -0.2089284360408783, -0.468945175409317, 0.6740926504135132, -0.40916627645492554, 0.13435250520706177, 0.31694185733795166, -0.11497705429792404, -0.27963295578956604, 0.5612510442733765, -0.2936458885669708, -0.6244368553161621, -0.8231382966041565, 0.17522408068180084, -0.045652490109205246, 0.07233438640832901, 0.10973010212182999, 0.20822012424468994, -0.1262119859457016, 0.19628337025642395, -0.15600091218948364, -0.019428681582212448, 0.6271405816078186, -1.0275031328201294, -0.5784550309181213, -0.20853254199028015, -0.11894765496253967, 0.6603822112083435, 0.007991760037839413, 0.4130711257457733, 0.13499408960342407, 0.5562670230865479, -0.11760051548480988, -0.5527024865150452, -0.856762170791626, -0.011908161453902721, 0.4849754869937897, 0.4320489466190338, -0.14814791083335876, 0.13258254528045654, 0.37916886806488037, -0.12230024486780167, -0.07996569573879242, 0.5627106428146362, -0.15833818912506104, 0.05530325695872307, 0.6546761393547058, -0.604570209980011, -0.7295803427696228, -0.03610847517848015, -0.22522221505641937, 0.40406009554862976, -0.07849809527397156, 0.2441491335630417, 0.3805999755859375, -0.9010089635848999, 0.8804433941841125, 0.23483248054981232, -0.023417994379997253, -0.5164554715156555, -0.16497103869915009, -0.09493027627468109, 0.5481880903244019, -0.5479425191879272, -0.5675411224365234, 0.9408777952194214, -0.06652423739433289, 0.8593479990959167, -0.5665377378463745, 0.22238843142986298, -0.16162832081317902, -0.37200865149497986, 0.7312363982200623, -0.11489200592041016, 0.3726431131362915, 0.07876648008823395, 0.11748619377613068, 0.676169753074646, -0.13465315103530884, -0.3895505964756012, 0.1915677934885025, 1.0978996753692627, -0.006824653595685959, -0.8875117301940918, -0.8691413402557373, -0.14113737642765045, 0.35063961148262024, 0.4965464770793915, 0.27311116456985474, 0.15472620725631714, 0.5996920466423035, -0.0204737801104784, -0.7527464628219604, 0.07663581520318985, -0.332608163356781, -0.3256871700286865, 0.5483342409133911, -0.054428886622190475, 0.3454011082649231, 1.2340131998062134, -0.029684782028198242, 0.17146305739879608, -0.7271909117698669, -1.1241618394851685, -0.12413317710161209, 0.11851351708173752, 0.15482258796691895, -0.15212811529636383, 0.6068443655967712, 0.7018314599990845, -0.34511950612068176, -0.4785003960132599, 0.00797481369227171, 1.0117162466049194, -0.06400291621685028, -0.3027842044830322, -0.14164043962955475, -0.06319807469844818, 0.16090930998325348, -0.7979092597961426, -0.4598553776741028, -0.5746333003044128, 0.3714151978492737, 0.4372258484363556, -0.30943018198013306, -0.23888592422008514, 0.36737361550331116, 0.06001988798379898, 0.5302686095237732, -0.2339807152748108, -0.4140963852405548, -0.30515971779823303, 0.6582237482070923, 0.5818064212799072, 0.2017878293991089, -0.05308782309293747, 0.7829418182373047, -0.5384950637817383, 0.527628481388092, -0.47227948904037476, -0.49372491240501404, 0.381532222032547, -0.3107718527317047, -0.20989398658275604, -0.377877801656723, -1.2394278049468994, -0.7829629778862, 0.8278626799583435, -0.918228805065155, -0.13275228440761566, -0.4247119724750519, -0.2996521592140198, 0.21883465349674225, -0.056431256234645844, -0.4379027187824249, 0.40486985445022583, -0.6521021723747253, 0.16017892956733704, -0.25680506229400635, 0.7704510688781738, 0.09259720146656036, 0.7479683756828308, 0.359501451253891, -0.01570042036473751, -0.19832588732242584, -1.5679782629013062, 0.21547842025756836, -0.04332040622830391, -0.5040799975395203, 0.18600943684577942, -0.923339307308197, -0.2389906942844391, -0.1569160372018814, -0.47856205701828003, -0.42840951681137085, 0.9617800712585449, 0.4557984173297882, 0.9941703081130981, 0.46587052941322327, -0.07658461481332779, -0.08852630853652954, -0.28946101665496826, -0.8659722805023193, -0.657952606678009, 0.48106569051742554, -0.434935599565506, -0.11884185671806335, -0.48869451880455017, -0.3125693202018738, -0.23113742470741272, 0.09808991104364395, 0.30328842997550964, -0.8326262831687927, 0.24074552953243256, 0.16535194218158722, 0.7238946557044983, 0.44602054357528687, 0.22071430087089539, 1.2056390047073364, -0.12529349327087402, -1.0417078733444214, -0.4507414698600769, 0.04675174131989479, 0.6777079105377197, 0.21506385505199432, 0.0203627310693264, 0.20105208456516266, 0.24136818945407867, -0.13177746534347534, 0.6890934109687805, -0.35265541076660156, 0.12268286943435669, -1.1194278001785278, -0.09795478731393814, -0.15283623337745667, -0.24810078740119934, -0.6092001795768738, 0.2666611969470978, 0.04335206001996994, -0.9809279441833496, -0.408904105424881, 0.0703716054558754, 0.6147726774215698, -0.3915382921695709, 0.052867330610752106, -0.08981979638338089, -0.16729864478111267, -0.07700039446353912, -0.650601327419281, 0.5607297420501709, 0.79866623878479, 1.059572696685791, 0.04111124947667122, 0.11879431456327438, 0.37136778235435486, 0.5553818941116333, 0.2860836386680603, 0.4596079885959625, 1.0508451461791992, 0.03205420449376106, -0.17870554327964783, -0.06566330790519714, -0.48889073729515076, 0.684787392616272, -0.03940191492438316, -0.4630073606967926, -0.14371417462825775, 0.6562831401824951, 0.5304884910583496, 0.3009049594402313, -1.1780680418014526, 0.033545542508363724, -0.5452704429626465, -0.6003685593605042, -0.4092508554458618, 0.32815107703208923, 0.9017653465270996, 0.0037887305952608585, 0.5919734239578247, 0.27825596928596497, 0.9487640857696533, 0.3281539976596832, -0.28445443511009216, 0.9423573613166809, 0.13959155976772308, -0.5109285712242126, 0.03621349483728409, -0.12844431400299072, -0.4479380249977112, 0.3489721715450287, -0.09901285916566849, 0.37848877906799316, 0.6691223382949829, 0.6190341711044312, -0.40311673283576965, -0.06628870964050293, 0.6438807249069214, -0.16554023325443268, -0.3245830237865448, -0.7594534754753113, 0.2998233735561371, -0.27033117413520813, -0.3565974235534668, 0.8396711349487305, 0.3579111397266388, 0.036410119384527206, 0.20030230283737183, 0.6972841620445251, 0.25189781188964844, 0.47549161314964294, 0.6683759689331055, -0.2941991686820984, 0.47795045375823975, 0.8715798258781433, -0.9376922845840454, -0.9043262600898743, -0.11996440589427948, 0.22984740138053894, -0.015292963944375515, 0.009835842996835709, 0.2793272137641907, -0.3619965612888336, 0.2605179250240326, -0.5058503746986389, 0.41064539551734924, -0.48357129096984863, -0.06304729729890823, -0.7118483185768127, 0.0074148029088974, -0.6069151163101196, 0.2621435225009918, 0.12629185616970062, -0.0808119997382164, 0.36400413513183594, -0.351913720369339, -0.8657230734825134, -0.21897052228450775, -0.5775895714759827, -0.05828474089503288, 0.09003393352031708, 0.48321789503097534, 0.004554531536996365, -0.5481827855110168, -0.7817251086235046, -0.8271670341491699, 0.09521474689245224, 0.6764837503433228, -0.5154016017913818, -0.7797927260398865, -0.3394695818424225, 0.5779945254325867, 0.02610400691628456, 0.839348316192627, 0.1597362458705902, 0.430062860250473, 0.4966128170490265, 0.7375065684318542, -0.11571767181158066, -0.35464534163475037, 0.21424169838428497, 0.343039870262146, 0.1559617668390274, -1.0853327512741089, -0.3536759912967682, 0.2768796384334564, -1.2163838148117065, 0.15522882342338562, 0.24815934896469116, -0.5734233856201172, -0.32945317029953003, 0.2602890431880951, 0.7827321887016296, -0.49489110708236694, 0.09300268441438675, -0.7735217213630676, -0.8889280557632446, -0.7134241461753845, 1.466478943824768, -0.08004850149154663, 0.13420775532722473, 0.2994230389595032, -0.07408758252859116, 0.422340989112854, -0.3181604743003845, 4.232420921325684, 0.3749309480190277, -0.08002502471208572, -0.7371596097946167, 0.9416486024856567, 0.5527318716049194, 0.5757566094398499, 0.3465406596660614, -0.022369034588336945, 0.10805139690637589, 0.10769958794116974, -0.3961864411830902, 0.13232511281967163, 0.061048541218042374, 0.626769483089447, 0.3110155165195465, -0.24770963191986084, 0.392760306596756, -0.5225465893745422, -0.659393846988678, -0.4190373420715332, -0.4434301257133484, 0.041166651993989944, 0.8789333701133728, -0.1841839849948883, 0.1263391524553299, 1.0924679040908813, -0.1238463968038559, -0.1162194162607193, -0.5226567387580872, -0.2575390040874481, -1.4488306045532227, -0.20634278655052185, -0.6326934099197388, -1.0698716640472412, 0.7085958123207092, 0.23633448779582977, 0.08049868047237396, -0.2798961102962494, -1.0164330005645752, 0.16057582199573517, 0.5414822697639465, -0.6830111742019653, -0.7233969569206238, -0.568109929561615, 0.663767397403717, -0.5125449299812317, 0.35327866673469543, 0.34744468331336975, -0.4416036605834961, 1.0155117511749268, -0.4691319763660431, 0.15505051612854004, 0.28063714504241943, -0.4746655523777008, -0.5603197813034058, 0.04278724268078804, -0.881929874420166, 0.4811577796936035, -0.011985275894403458, 0.7396693229675293, 0.2227960079908371, -0.2621583938598633, 0.481528103351593, 0.33726444840431213, 0.9254952073097229, 0.15621890127658844, -0.3187253773212433, -0.3718108534812927, -0.1700790673494339, 0.5748925805091858, -0.36835917830467224, -0.5612948536872864, 0.3856841027736664, 0.8145139217376709, 0.7821335792541504, -0.4915291666984558, 0.25307777523994446, -0.33223757147789, -0.520288348197937, -0.16032566130161285, 0.3600824177265167, 0.27313312888145447, -0.1147870421409607, -0.41820642352104187, 0.4222542643547058, -0.8253666758537292, -1.225102424621582, -0.45401567220687866, -0.0811782255768776, 0.01924409344792366, 0.369911789894104, -0.499531626701355, -0.06782057881355286, -0.4395865797996521 ]
{"Title": "Post-discharge Acute Care and Outcomes in the Era of Readmission Reduction", "Authors": "Khera Rohan, Wang Yongfei, Bernheim Susannah M., Lin Zhenqiu, Krumholz Harlan M.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background With incentives to reduce readmission rates, there are concerns that patients who need hospitalization after a recent hospital discharge may be denied access, which would increase their risk of mortality. Objective We determined whether patients with hospitalizations for conditions covered by national readmission programs who received care in emergency department (ED) or observation units but were not hospitalized within 30 days had an increased risk of death. We also evaluated temporal trends in post-discharge acute care utilization in inpatient units, emergency department (ED) and observation units for these patients. Design, Setting, and Participants In this observational study, national Medicare claims data for 2008-2016, we identified patients \u226565 years hospitalized with heart failure (HF), acute myocardial infarction (AMI), or pneumonia, conditions included in the HRRP. Main Outcomes and Measures Post-discharge 30-day mortality according to patients\u2019 30-day acute care utilization. Acute care utilization in inpatient and observation units, and the ED during the 30-day and 31-90-day post-discharge period. Results There were 3,772,924 hospitalizations for HF, 1,570,113 for AMI, and 3,131,162 for pneumonia. The overall post-discharge 30-day mortality was 8.7% for HF, 7.3% for AMI, and 8.4% for pneumonia. Post-discharge mortality increased annually by 0.16% (95% CI, 0.11%, 0.22%) for HF, decreased by 0.15% (95% CI, -0.18%, -0.12%) for AMI, and did not significantly change for pneumonia. Specifically, mortality only increased for HF patients who did not utilize any post-discharge acute care, increasing at a rate of 0.16% per year (95% CI, 0.11%, 0.22%), accounting for 99% of the increase in post-discharge mortality in heart failure. Concurrent with a reduction in 30-day readmission rates, 30-day observation stays and visits to the ED increased across all 3 conditions during and beyond the post-discharge 30-day period. There was no significant change in overall 30-day post-acute care utilization (P-trend >0.05 for all). Conclusions and Relevance The only condition with an increasing mortality through the study period was HF; the increase preceded the policy and was not present among those received ED or observation unit care without hospitalization. Overall, during this period, there was not a significant change in the overall 30-day post-discharge acute care utilization.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002162"}
10.1101/19004242
[ -0.532156765460968, 0.3837026357650757, -0.2208387553691864, 0.6458197236061096, -0.6353166103363037, 0.2939005196094513, -0.043138161301612854, 0.9906741380691528, -0.5754497647285461, 0.69026780128479, -0.4656859040260315, -0.7076881527900696, 0.256475567817688, -0.3370544910430908, 0.3410811722278595, 0.7419463992118835, -0.21096846461296082, -0.2996198832988739, -0.1891499161720276, -0.18462972342967987, 0.039257075637578964, 0.1492723524570465, -0.9044100046157837, 0.9247319102287292, -0.44172653555870056, 0.22736383974552155, -0.4135268032550812, -0.40759387612342834, 1.269321084022522, 0.5438915491104126, -0.2813132107257843, -0.20604081451892853, 0.3971397876739502, -0.6294911503791809, 0.01939515396952629, 0.2996740937232971, 0.744552493095398, -0.3277977705001831, 0.28775832056999207, -0.5938485860824585, 0.5991873741149902, 0.08947920054197311, 0.23197370767593384, -0.3924052119255066, -0.6225685477256775, -0.1941002607345581, -0.15218457579612732, -0.7189005017280579, 0.3240414559841156, -0.11991951614618301, -0.489986777305603, -0.1025121882557869, -0.2937704920768738, 0.37150564789772034, 0.10943982005119324, 0.21790389716625214, -0.23024453222751617, 0.05321081355214119, -0.31230857968330383, 0.7799420356750488, 0.519399106502533, 0.10318461060523987, 1.0154625177383423, -1.1303563117980957, 0.9016386270523071, 0.4661576747894287, -0.2961990237236023, -0.26826488971710205, 0.04600220173597336, 0.5769424438476562, 0.04764696583151817, 0.07702460885047913, -0.37450647354125977, 0.3192889392375946, -0.20465487241744995, 0.515965461730957, 0.19777977466583252, -0.6822853088378906, 0.5292128920555115, 0.45668941736221313, -0.007578063290566206, 0.22900883853435516, 0.28333595395088196, 0.6386474370956421, -0.2369774430990219, 0.19855178892612457, 0.18487399816513062, 0.8452439904212952, -0.17131513357162476, 0.07704178988933563, 0.1251133233308792, 0.45329737663269043, 0.226341113448143, 0.15876975655555725, 0.028343744575977325, 0.7799072861671448, -0.14864860475063324, 0.1683727502822876, -0.013976539485156536, -0.35682234168052673, 0.16902080178260803, 0.14218316972255707, -0.10106600821018219, 0.8018763065338135, -0.8399412035942078, 0.6678657531738281, 0.6819732785224915, -0.03341233357787132, -0.7555616497993469, -0.5713688135147095, 0.24546849727630615, -0.22389115393161774, -0.28250426054000854, -0.29423171281814575, 0.6329560279846191, 0.6161139607429504, 0.04209750145673752, 0.3831324279308319, -0.7696568965911865, -0.14601631462574005, 0.16336269676685333, -0.43357279896736145, 0.642474889755249, -0.20534031093120575, 0.07517985999584198, 0.05184692144393921, -0.012286427430808544, 0.4917944371700287, -0.40573930740356445, -0.7338136434555054, -0.4923550486564636, -0.5866483449935913, -0.05147415027022362, 0.14645467698574066, -0.4285265803337097, 0.16014575958251953, -0.4528089761734009, 0.7643980979919434, 0.09742916375398636, -0.044448744505643845, 0.23834852874279022, 0.4420357346534729, -0.5296063423156738, 0.7072436213493347, 0.06950759142637253, 0.902935266494751, -0.9325473308563232, -0.725818395614624, -0.7805300951004028, -0.1689385622739792, -0.27170127630233765, 0.8693243861198425, -0.31790629029273987, -0.28686806559562683, 0.032961245626211166, 0.2778521776199341, 0.0196088757365942, 0.07282312214374542, 0.06441543996334076, -1.1508737802505493, -0.5873743295669556, 0.08723713457584381, -0.35462528467178345, 1.0091105699539185, -0.3719819188117981, 0.720453143119812, -0.20330367982387543, 0.27317944169044495, 0.07623634487390518, -0.5908377170562744, 0.6965705752372742, -0.2496185153722763, -0.4983827471733093, -0.06693515926599503, 0.46545684337615967, 0.2583191692829132, 0.8814982771873474, -0.32681310176849365, 0.08326362073421478, 0.48249638080596924, -0.6311715841293335, 0.3166216015815735, -0.13894397020339966, 0.5403803586959839, 0.4894896149635315, -0.06492571532726288, -0.10594083368778229, -0.14472804963588715, -0.13453105092048645, -0.2604626417160034, -0.27309346199035645, 0.003152841469272971, -0.46514448523521423, 1.1291396617889404, 0.2370353490114212, 0.07169351726770401, -0.5452246069908142, 0.7058517932891846, -0.15668314695358276, 0.2425210326910019, -0.5571199655532837, 1.1243077516555786, 0.093464694917202, 0.14457206428050995, 0.25713515281677246, 1.2286592721939087, 0.11147986352443695, 0.4680783152580261, -0.4155617654323578, 0.8109537959098816, 0.6190288066864014, 0.238057941198349, -0.001533200149424374, 0.4807349145412445, -0.13762229681015015, 0.29827332496643066, -0.05822228640317917, 0.5779493451118469, -0.7151201367378235, 0.08150599896907806, -0.8306071758270264, -0.34880486130714417, 1.1161047220230103, 0.6114696860313416, 0.18285080790519714, 0.164688840508461, 0.6605755090713501, 0.3986407518386841, -0.11783480644226074, -0.409930557012558, -0.048073120415210724, 0.46187177300453186, 0.36178871989250183, 0.5760324597358704, 0.6794449090957642, -0.11208828538656235, 0.33715441823005676, -0.3542695641517639, 0.2201308161020279, 0.47273728251457214, 1.2782840728759766, 0.5066247582435608, 0.18318787217140198, 0.07550148665904999, -0.0074609266594052315, 0.6548871994018555, -0.2997411787509918, 0.7076707482337952, 0.19140248000621796, 0.3945775330066681, -0.6943597197532654, 0.418610543012619, 0.7301862835884094, 0.363783597946167, -0.8226586580276489, -0.20785394310951233, 0.3982468247413635, 0.45475631952285767, -0.524476170539856, -0.07623758167028427, 0.061445996165275574, 0.199589803814888, -0.21229740977287292, 0.11709541827440262, 0.5830848217010498, 0.77378910779953, 0.25734663009643555, 0.6763429641723633, 0.5786892771720886, 0.11639798432588577, -0.7954734563827515, -1.0621428489685059, -0.7952886819839478, -0.8657242059707642, -0.9256296157836914, -0.02720707841217518, -0.056187763810157776, -0.6314724683761597, 0.09963449835777283, 0.19975638389587402, -0.08151540160179138, -0.03823518007993698, 0.22261127829551697, 0.44879236817359924, 0.20196402072906494, 0.3947007954120636, -0.20020614564418793, 0.6366772055625916, -0.09853053092956543, 0.18714450299739838, -0.03767389431595802, -0.5710873007774353, -0.5870192646980286, -0.7666569352149963, 0.7416934370994568, -0.688244104385376, -0.669156014919281, 0.02444179728627205, 0.30462539196014404, -0.4957306683063507, 0.6252155900001526, -0.33138391375541687, 0.42191681265830994, 0.18690501153469086, -1.5941404104232788, 0.27190983295440674, 0.1523851752281189, 0.741115391254425, 0.10829447954893112, -0.028119975700974464, 0.3709088861942291, 0.2634371221065521, -0.9466704726219177, 0.3579707145690918, -0.7262829542160034, -0.20020756125450134, 0.5511983036994934, -0.4751471281051636, 0.044921956956386566, -1.1623539924621582, -0.26740723848342896, 0.0959341898560524, -0.15258505940437317, -0.4304758310317993, -0.33743301033973694, -0.0002250044490210712, 0.11634630709886551, -0.6857226490974426, -0.10026871412992477, -1.0814625024795532, -0.6825653910636902, 0.2982785105705261, -0.2955782413482666, 0.3992014229297638, -0.35696280002593994, 0.12777286767959595, -0.6048085689544678, 0.2757290303707123, 0.6085183024406433, 0.9724733829498291, 0.21598811447620392, -0.1081257313489914, 0.037827178835868835, 0.6740924715995789, -0.27945443987846375, 0.6156945824623108, -0.01696285791695118, -0.37400203943252563, -0.1356700360774994, -0.06278480589389801, -0.26667124032974243, 0.2806550860404968, 0.8876023888587952, 0.3283335566520691, -0.16555902361869812, 0.7575778365135193, 0.23681239783763885, -0.23384901881217957, 0.5478711724281311, 0.9944722652435303, -0.6438959240913391, -0.4293668866157532, 0.3966844081878662, 0.04371031001210213, -0.7179030179977417, -0.8983654379844666, 1.1863222122192383, -0.40554583072662354, 0.6304230690002441, -0.4391041696071625, 0.5901117324829102, 0.07704508304595947, 0.3016293942928314, -0.0787137895822525, -0.06063063070178032, -0.7301152348518372, 0.2826571762561798, 1.0355969667434692, 0.9480985403060913, -1.2975928783416748, 0.6438743472099304, 0.8618054389953613, 0.5987017750740051, 0.35247480869293213, 0.15275470912456512, 0.15651927888393402, -1.3697173595428467, 0.3988979756832123, -0.23573152720928192, 0.0782518982887268, -0.09736447781324387, 0.44002288579940796, 0.3266528844833374, -0.11917664855718613, -0.9299503564834595, -0.677261471748352, -0.39658841490745544, 0.7654504179954529, 0.46004727482795715, 0.05872255936264992, 0.5179826617240906, -0.6708461046218872, 0.3442279100418091, 0.2848775088787079, 0.5012848377227783, 0.15703976154327393, -0.32994115352630615, -0.20642127096652985, 0.2897427976131439, -0.11271030455827713, 0.9306464791297913, -0.9828614592552185, -0.3569890856742859, -0.534701943397522, 0.559905469417572, 0.1676328182220459, -1.2186928987503052, -0.11743216216564178, -0.8215908408164978, 0.09697355329990387, 0.2956799864768982, 0.5049908757209778, -0.4210892915725708, 0.12263578921556473, 0.16297273337841034, -0.6922663450241089, 0.15007644891738892, -0.6478549242019653, 0.8285407423973083, 0.9527415037155151, -0.4984494149684906, -0.641038179397583, -0.9657315015792847, -0.024297403171658516, -0.32872453331947327, 0.46056121587753296, 0.9275961518287659, -0.3328125774860382, 0.3944564163684845, 0.1380888670682907, -0.6380733847618103, -0.4429982900619507, -0.043188583105802536, -0.6208104491233826, 0.2823958098888397, 0.4636780023574829, 0.8374074101448059, 0.4703148901462555, 0.6615965366363525, 0.16018454730510712, 0.3782239556312561, -0.7320220470428467, 0.8185535073280334, -0.6333746910095215, -0.7986747622489929, -0.04836787283420563, -0.5219488143920898, 0.2140355110168457, 0.061363544315099716, -0.7869886755943298, -0.7512469291687012, -0.35218346118927, 0.7185102105140686, 0.14428651332855225, -0.06352780759334564, 0.8257949352264404, -0.8402898907661438, 0.10124391317367554, 0.6872279047966003, -0.014016356319189072, -0.15901526808738708, -0.08079878985881805, 0.26141196489334106, -1.3026667833328247, 0.7832145690917969, 0.26778313517570496, -0.008550812490284443, -0.17598994076251984, 0.11577697098255157, 0.2857767641544342, 0.16844552755355835, 0.4229832589626312, -0.5218627452850342, 0.41291671991348267, -0.2999601364135742, 0.22381474077701569, 0.08308533579111099, 0.37151506543159485, -1.208829402923584, 0.4135901629924774, -0.10405343025922775, -0.20436441898345947, -0.5544242262840271, -0.36713024973869324, -0.5046954154968262, -0.4746694266796112, -0.7911872267723083, 0.3111906051635742, -0.017772870138287544, 0.010555202141404152, 1.161335825920105, -1.0657258033752441, -1.057904601097107, -0.19504284858703613, 0.8134666085243225, -0.7361680865287781, -0.6268585920333862, 0.21372100710868835, -0.22341600060462952, -0.6515645384788513, -0.09948179870843887, -0.14954786002635956, 0.17549408972263336, -0.8648478984832764, -0.3591712415218353, 0.2941722571849823, 0.42698484659194946, -0.24064858257770538, -0.5418163537979126, 0.1498694270849228, 0.07478892803192139, -0.42616185545921326, -0.779052734375, 0.07866272330284119, -0.31152915954589844, -0.4592275321483612, -0.27060189843177795, -0.7540821433067322, -0.7405995726585388, -0.7477363348007202, -0.20947927236557007, -0.5014355778694153, -0.0048726992681622505, 0.21255521476268768, -0.41427525877952576, -0.23410481214523315, 0.39523279666900635, 1.2053405046463013, 0.5047682523727417, 0.16691479086875916, -0.4866524934768677, 0.012588564306497574, -0.377267986536026, -0.27190715074539185, -0.5463116765022278, -0.46329420804977417, 0.18150317668914795, 0.6277360916137695, -0.13515746593475342, -0.5528919696807861, 0.32998126745224, -0.3593851625919342, 1.1019669771194458, 0.21688556671142578, -0.47373294830322266, -0.5971381068229675, 0.12991175055503845, 0.45516085624694824, -0.18264423310756683, -0.48883137106895447, -1.1101220846176147, 0.6452066898345947, -0.8201242089271545, 0.4608696401119232, -0.005463218782097101, -0.5269501805305481, 0.11068090796470642, -0.17084605991840363, 1.076005220413208, -0.48511943221092224, 0.17428243160247803, 0.17446264624595642, 0.2847885489463806, -0.28005218505859375, -0.16458995640277863, -0.8328188061714172, -0.5671258568763733, -0.6511043310165405, -0.877450168132782, 0.3536917269229889, -0.4408830404281616, 0.4588240683078766, 0.7373006343841553, 0.018192818388342857, -0.2270471602678299, -0.6010015606880188, 1.222166657447815, 1.0438328981399536, -0.41725754737854004, -0.2718105614185333, 0.4021821916103363, 0.48587125539779663, 0.06531340628862381, 0.49037036299705505, 0.1199830025434494, -0.15963955223560333, 0.06781122833490372, -0.714210569858551, -0.6739358901977539, -0.4020114541053772, -0.44608747959136963, 0.5429205894470215, 0.14965808391571045, 0.3065454065799713, 0.17351651191711426, 0.4239022433757782, -0.2025800347328186, -0.08490855246782303, 0.4208694398403168, 0.4314444363117218, 0.6440783739089966, 0.9285679459571838, -0.4482691287994385, -0.7023155689239502, 0.4508969187736511, 0.4758802652359009, -0.061909642070531845, -0.7916286587715149, -0.12030661106109619, 0.6291365623474121, -0.48014092445373535, 0.6183457970619202, 0.05484231561422348, -0.8453207015991211, -0.4830820560455322, 0.46346306800842285, -0.1130971759557724, 0.2703181803226471, -0.03569542616605759, -0.6825010776519775, 0.6724077463150024, -0.3423925042152405, 0.15813866257667542, -0.2902517318725586, 0.4329587519168854, 0.10315641015768051, -1.0451234579086304, 1.2843393087387085, -0.6123233437538147, 0.13252206146717072, 0.6418262720108032, -0.1827213168144226, -0.3444354832172394, 0.5701910257339478, 0.7913544774055481, 0.318062961101532, 0.461726576089859, 0.6669608950614929, -0.49514779448509216, 0.0288596972823143, -0.26833537220954895, -0.2329738736152649, -0.21821682155132294, 0.5724362730979919, -0.8014235496520996, 0.8589548468589783, -0.20760023593902588, -1.2059516906738281, -1.103640079498291, -0.013218298554420471, 1.1478919982910156, 0.4295124113559723, -0.257119745016098, -0.0633167177438736, 0.6635121703147888, 0.10487953573465347, 0.060629431158304214, 0.33925312757492065, -0.5220066905021667, -0.6252654790878296, -0.5535814762115479, -0.37466397881507874, -0.591820478439331, 0.13325533270835876, 1.020512342453003, -0.09147369861602783, -0.7468073964118958, 0.26496490836143494, 0.10219377279281616, -0.4166138768196106, 0.16409210860729218, 0.005536763928830624, 0.02653874270617962, -0.4654258191585541, -0.8014580607414246, -0.3816235065460205, -0.5265252590179443, -0.13792017102241516, 0.7701305747032166, -0.2283329963684082, -0.10078532993793488, 0.12945422530174255, 0.4975479245185852, 0.44851163029670715, 0.3413196802139282, -0.6011911630630493, -0.8160340785980225, 0.20969121158123016, 0.6804867386817932, -0.09649524092674255, -0.15125837922096252, 1.1296541690826416, -0.44176986813545227, 0.5103643536567688, 0.2869417667388916, -0.1912344992160797, -0.6394529938697815, -0.19144558906555176, 0.2893480360507965, -0.13861694931983948, -0.6172316074371338, -0.20939475297927856, 0.541401743888855, -0.7553263902664185, -0.24119329452514648, -0.560828447341919, 0.42357999086380005, 0.37951895594596863, -0.1444595605134964, -0.4628106653690338, 0.4887213408946991, 0.43154871463775635, 0.42207926511764526, 0.08297725766897202, 0.15190358459949493, 0.0009427874465472996, 0.19668027758598328, 0.8403788208961487, 0.5997962355613708, 0.1521194726228714, -0.7799938321113586, 0.3882084786891937, 0.8270145654678345, -0.739111602306366, 0.061671316623687744, 0.1309046745300293, 0.18015839159488678, -0.17193646728992462, -0.018778499215841293, 0.44936326146125793, 0.5688250660896301, 0.03822050988674164, -0.020971037447452545, -0.21387086808681488, -0.24918466806411743, -0.4630295932292938, 0.06154310703277588, -1.014838457107544, 0.0054794978350400925, 0.3004534840583801, -0.7071202397346497, 0.048300646245479584, -0.7849884033203125, -0.6883381605148315, 0.502231776714325, 0.11515448987483978, 0.7222428321838379, -0.4441840350627899, 0.28104397654533386, -0.031261637806892395, 0.31838279962539673, -0.044333137571811676, -0.5889788866043091, 0.17232096195220947, 0.020098412409424782, -0.5487149357795715, -0.5165807008743286, 0.8039647936820984, 0.503824770450592, 0.31450000405311584, -0.24492578208446503, -0.4618971049785614, 0.052830252796411514, -0.455426961183548, -0.11317108571529388, -0.0839117169380188, -0.21246789395809174, -0.3863750398159027, -0.439974308013916, -1.5244251489639282, -0.10478604584932327, -0.7168716788291931, 0.05111075937747955, -0.24319703876972198, -1.0930531024932861, -0.5917421579360962, -0.06693430244922638, 0.9262253642082214, -0.024849088862538338, 0.5213006138801575, -0.26255685091018677, 0.30378252267837524, 0.36393097043037415, -0.34054118394851685, -0.04232793301343918, 0.7649316787719727, 0.06506010890007019, -0.016457268968224525, -0.3424140214920044, 0.12258768826723099, 0.6440764665603638, 0.7472698092460632, 0.23413655161857605, 0.6532784104347229, 0.27322956919670105, 0.2580139636993408, 0.33435606956481934, -0.7095856070518494, 0.7835765480995178, 0.056712958961725235, -0.41428935527801514, -0.18714343011379242, 0.6055949330329895, 0.5206793546676636, 0.20017312467098236, -0.47546377778053284, 0.21238744258880615, -1.0685747861862183, -0.14846673607826233, 0.0465816929936409, 0.9265571236610413, 0.9521012902259827, 0.08679591864347458, 0.6794189214706421, 0.3136079013347626, 0.49605029821395874, -0.05071558803319931, -0.04939595237374306, 0.5208083987236023, -1.209234356880188, -0.25312235951423645, -0.8531209826469421, 0.2536703944206238, -0.09667399525642395, -0.08872584998607635, -0.2119773030281067, -0.5516059398651123, 0.12885811924934387, 0.618829071521759, -0.22057950496673584, -0.032215557992458344, 1.1720253229141235, -0.26728108525276184, -0.7278745174407959, -0.11075268685817719, -0.02785920351743698, -0.023083040490746498, -0.555039644241333, 0.5078995227813721, -0.8072457313537598, 0.36622563004493713, -0.27065834403038025, 0.4253543019294739, 0.6832020282745361, 0.15695443749427795, 0.08536458015441895, -0.19135302305221558, 0.513910174369812, 0.7674345374107361, -0.022177064791321754, 0.05710024759173393, -0.6410669684410095, -0.4860018491744995, -0.5377387404441833, -0.5369491577148438, 0.23323173820972443, 0.2882474362850189, -0.3557666540145874, -0.6762917041778564, 0.8523995280265808, -0.08260641247034073, -0.8194484114646912, -0.7838192582130432, -0.5862747430801392, -0.22173142433166504, 0.11415310204029083, -0.5313255786895752, 0.1837010234594345, 0.306509405374527, -1.0609045028686523, 0.4542093873023987, -0.2219904214143753, -0.2704639434814453, -0.12780624628067017, 0.1472090482711792, 0.716472327709198, -0.20499968528747559, -0.29737240076065063, -0.20102456212043762, -0.985435962677002, -0.29531264305114746, 0.28208643198013306, -0.48433917760849, -0.20602816343307495, 0.10695520043373108, 0.4982083737850189, 0.1299501359462738, -0.21750503778457642, -0.08306751400232315, 0.32187604904174805, 0.09198068827390671, 0.9735084176063538, -0.540678858757019, 0.508586049079895, 0.003534369869157672, -0.45120781660079956, -0.39436793327331543, -0.08843743801116943, -0.3356691300868988, -0.21001076698303223, -0.22604615986347198, -0.9740445613861084, -0.09184810519218445, 0.09669876098632812, -0.6770591139793396, 0.15197527408599854, 1.1081539392471313, -0.046063486486673355, 0.013355007395148277, -0.9170436263084412, -0.22486773133277893, -0.9860105514526367, 0.854205310344696, -0.1095692440867424, 0.22431915998458862, 0.0627850592136383, 0.03330076113343239, 0.9403963088989258, -0.568730354309082, 4.0900750160217285, 0.5365868210792542, 0.9892538189888, -0.8046402335166931, 0.2922151982784271, 0.12036759406328201, 0.5141897201538086, 0.31210142374038696, 0.27627572417259216, -0.4170507490634918, -0.42244407534599304, 0.11764190346002579, 0.0011020478559657931, 0.0942496806383133, 0.6149202585220337, 1.0319663286209106, -1.0476161241531372, -0.19042089581489563, 0.20154955983161926, -1.035033941268921, -0.6637391448020935, -0.4215262532234192, 0.44034361839294434, -0.3698769807815552, 0.15773096680641174, -0.4871091842651367, 0.1571323573589325, -0.2634955942630768, 0.11347749829292297, -0.6152020692825317, 0.1904880255460739, -0.8624424338340759, 0.43745800852775574, -0.7487327456474304, -0.19736160337924957, 0.5689902305603027, 0.6587212085723877, -0.30895861983299255, 0.35511359572410583, -0.8269907832145691, -0.5175256133079529, -0.514474630355835, 0.19465172290802002, -0.5463617444038391, -0.06483536213636398, -0.12990505993366241, -0.8197877407073975, 0.5423508286476135, 0.1701127290725708, -0.4254920184612274, 1.0299967527389526, -1.2376339435577393, 0.4649427533149719, -0.8070178627967834, -1.1931437253952026, -0.6784931421279907, -0.5261509418487549, -0.8054373264312744, -0.4316410720348358, 0.15128202736377716, 1.1341907978057861, -0.3091958165168762, -1.096640706062317, 0.6927559971809387, 0.6383903622627258, 0.900872528553009, 0.16168196499347687, 0.4759761393070221, 0.031224168837070465, 0.0028575744945555925, -0.3188258409500122, -1.0579866170883179, 0.1922730654478073, -0.362760066986084, 0.8154635429382324, 0.1983543038368225, -0.3307564854621887, 0.19261649250984192, -0.2281809002161026, 0.13890470564365387, 0.3620995581150055, 0.25754740834236145, 0.029633408412337303, -0.7746164202690125, 0.7306527495384216, 1.2343897819519043, -0.50691819190979, -0.25788626074790955, -1.263006329536438, 0.580432653427124, 0.3928057551383972, 0.3272481858730316, 0.11934901028871536, -0.08260593563318253, -0.5222516059875488 ]
{"Title": "Causal mediation analysis of Subclinical Hypothyroidism in children with obesity and Non-Alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease", "Authors": "Nichols Presley, Pan Yue, May Benjamin, Pavlicova Martina, Mencin Ali, Thaker Vidhu V", "Abstract": "Abstract Context Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease (NAFLD) is a common co-morbidity of obesity and a leading cause of liver disease in children. Subclinical hypothyroidism (SH) occurs with obesity and may contribute to dysmetabolic state that predisposes to NAFLD. Objective To assess the relationship between SH and NAFLD in children with biopsy-proven NAFLD compared to controls. Design and Methods In this retrospective study of cases from a registry of children with biopsy-proven NAFLD and age-matched controls, the association of SH with NAFLD and other cardiometabolic parameters was assessed followed by causal mediation analyses under the counter-factual framework. Results Sixty-six cases and 4067 age-matched controls were included in the study. Children with NAFLD were more likely to be male (74.6 vs 39.4%, p < 0.001), have higher modified BMI-z scores (2.3 \u00b11.6 vs 1\u00b11.6, p < 0.001), and abnormal metabolic parameters (TSH, ALT, HDL-C, non-HDL-C, LDL-C, and TG). Multivariate analyses controlling for age, sex and severity of obesity showed significant association between the 4 th quartile of TSH and NAFLD. Causal mediation analysis demonstrates that TSH mediates 44% of the effect of modified BMI-z score on NAFLD. This comprises of 16.2% (OR = 1.1, p < 0.001) caused by the indirect effect of TSH and its interaction with modified BMI-z, and 26.5% (OR = 1.1, p = 0.01) as an autonomous effect of TSH on NAFLD regardless of the obesity. Conclusions The association of SH and biopsy-proven NAFLD is demonstrated in a predominately Latino population. Further, a causal mediation analysis implicates an effect of TSH on NAFLD, independent of obesity.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004242"}
10.1101/19001073
[ 0.2959556579589844, -0.2792017459869385, -0.33114615082740784, 0.24112215638160706, 0.06001722812652588, -1.045416235923767, -0.37836524844169617, 0.5413489937782288, 0.4116826057434082, 0.9312741756439209, -0.26464220881462097, -0.8810921311378479, 0.4897734820842743, -0.5111715793609619, 0.18796256184577942, 0.1715007871389389, -0.5665762424468994, -0.17041446268558502, -0.44263070821762085, -0.17758776247501373, 0.32846033573150635, -0.03897704556584358, -0.46202346682548523, 0.1337985247373581, -0.6470110416412354, 1.0883898735046387, -0.1303696483373642, 0.12465285509824753, 1.2511146068572998, 0.15616953372955322, -0.18584804236888885, -0.18901945650577545, 0.47598540782928467, -0.4369193911552429, -0.44581446051597595, 0.6040126085281372, 0.5177361965179443, -0.21926023066043854, -0.8254423141479492, -1.2986767292022705, 0.03285638242959976, -0.026824072003364563, -0.17888730764389038, -0.6113538146018982, -0.22694993019104004, 0.1591697484254837, -0.012599573470652103, -0.19402794539928436, 0.03102525696158409, -0.5727356672286987, -0.21241778135299683, -0.09513512998819351, -0.03185523301362991, -0.3236222565174103, 0.10226868838071823, -0.29160308837890625, 0.3314065635204315, 0.6428385376930237, -0.7999414205551147, 0.1632363200187683, 0.7256126999855042, 0.14265890419483185, 0.1042066141963005, -0.8539705872535706, 1.0216597318649292, 0.6502935290336609, -0.2125139683485031, 0.154119074344635, -0.34092941880226135, 0.04446921870112419, -0.35089460015296936, 0.031385354697704315, 0.008559134788811207, -0.8093501925468445, -0.7022982239723206, -0.957647979259491, -0.04359275847673416, 0.6548070907592773, -0.46258488297462463, -0.247815802693367, -0.028645044192671776, 0.08369019627571106, 0.004168674349784851, 0.3588550090789795, -0.012089508585631847, 0.16981101036071777, 1.3780888319015503, 0.7581846117973328, 0.2032005488872528, -0.039334286004304886, -0.14199000597000122, -0.08364728093147278, 0.2673092484474182, 0.3440481126308441, 0.28863582015037537, 1.398261308670044, -0.608721911907196, -0.01147700659930706, 0.4928528964519501, 0.3023138642311096, 0.8284933567047119, 1.6132900714874268, -0.22961169481277466, 0.33837032318115234, -0.9590469002723694, 0.567949652671814, 1.3356338739395142, -0.746399462223053, 0.005222562700510025, -1.2754449844360352, 0.4305660128593445, 0.6700854897499084, -0.5487837791442871, -0.3033633530139923, 0.3557050824165344, 0.6321466565132141, 0.015524033457040787, 0.3545384109020233, 0.11788784712553024, 0.44922351837158203, -0.2923245429992676, 0.21298882365226746, 0.6057752370834351, -0.7727006077766418, 0.4849718511104584, 0.545871376991272, 0.045268069952726364, 0.3368973731994629, -0.1027999073266983, -0.5193321108818054, -0.5039451122283936, -0.5576677918434143, -0.8019829988479614, 0.6026997566223145, -0.32681986689567566, -0.5294378995895386, 0.18414194881916046, 0.8720609545707703, 0.17871883511543274, -0.14242638647556305, -0.40579691529273987, 0.5698920488357544, -0.7393632531166077, 1.056976079940796, -0.7384263873100281, -0.04527004808187485, -0.15236051380634308, -1.8120607137680054, -0.541883647441864, 0.308232843875885, -0.38418033719062805, 0.6078837513923645, -0.004478078335523605, 0.189869686961174, -0.7421405911445618, 0.6414794325828552, 0.015606727451086044, -0.21883785724639893, -0.7430551648139954, -0.008695347234606743, -0.09922660887241364, 0.18996204435825348, -0.5913841724395752, 0.8317016959190369, -0.01355729065835476, 0.7115679979324341, 0.3918364942073822, -0.24068699777126312, 0.5194969177246094, -0.3652270436286926, 0.37762758135795593, 0.3277408480644226, -0.02145514264702797, 0.1731386035680771, 0.39343467354774475, 1.3571140766143799, 0.566895604133606, -0.47709921002388, -0.1978067308664322, 0.0928753912448883, -0.335443913936615, -0.12400611490011215, 0.1003924086689949, 0.6688372492790222, -0.09773522615432739, -0.3560890257358551, -0.5964502096176147, -0.452529639005661, 0.2727925777435303, -0.40863725543022156, 0.47548672556877136, 0.23400337994098663, -0.3857875466346741, 0.8898397088050842, -0.6255094408988953, -0.4164382219314575, 0.32561370730400085, 0.6216624975204468, 0.37694066762924194, 0.4227856397628784, -0.5514615178108215, 0.020117055624723434, 0.0172489695250988, 0.7381330728530884, -0.25336122512817383, 0.8342717289924622, 0.7187994122505188, 0.1795368790626526, -0.6992528438568115, 0.4294630289077759, -0.1548164188861847, -0.21501898765563965, -0.35275664925575256, -0.288959801197052, 1.0114940404891968, -0.7903966903686523, -0.48335665464401245, 0.47433793544769287, 0.3381403684616089, -0.21723881363868713, -0.2629182040691376, -0.3585444986820221, 0.35410013794898987, 0.10061412304639816, -0.5139680504798889, 0.7412364482879639, 0.3074108958244324, 1.0595043897628784, 0.3613327741622925, -0.44530490040779114, -0.16676533222198486, 1.128716230392456, -0.4404374659061432, 0.5856624245643616, 0.3203873038291931, 0.3406967520713806, 0.04793151840567589, 0.48410069942474365, -0.03801442310214043, -0.08686542510986328, 0.20063473284244537, 0.46894198656082153, 0.5243623852729797, 1.165539264678955, -0.5440219640731812, 0.21550969779491425, -0.5368764996528625, 0.6126859784126282, 0.34624922275543213, 0.7112195491790771, -0.5985842943191528, 0.19038061797618866, 0.33339589834213257, 0.5247381925582886, -1.0035537481307983, -0.6446998119354248, 0.205198734998703, 0.3660730719566345, -0.3680341839790344, -0.7167541980743408, -0.5546725392341614, 0.367014616727829, -0.024862293154001236, -0.2171056717634201, -0.059190403670072556, 0.9795532822608948, 0.375057578086853, -0.2640535831451416, -0.09877123683691025, -0.5715913772583008, -0.7975361347198486, -0.5797971487045288, -0.767430305480957, -0.9946408271789551, -1.1806576251983643, -0.7735939621925354, -0.5770936012268066, -0.014454968273639679, 0.5301947593688965, -0.23195335268974304, -0.041642822325229645, -0.18168604373931885, -0.387376606464386, 0.8104661703109741, 0.5856359004974365, 0.5662915706634521, -1.3312735557556152, 0.6441112756729126, -0.6316609382629395, -0.3172241449356079, -0.580945611000061, -0.3773353099822998, -0.5316166877746582, -0.5337844491004944, 0.2853833734989166, -1.1018381118774414, -0.20035459101200104, -0.04481452330946922, -0.3207513391971588, -0.17193715274333954, -0.1773289144039154, -0.20486170053482056, 0.7654829621315002, 0.2956024706363678, -0.17411278188228607, 0.8495790958404541, -0.07598872482776642, -0.4931701123714447, 1.1434048414230347, 0.15586237609386444, -0.7711992263793945, 0.5238656401634216, 0.0561828576028347, -0.3989035487174988, -0.5365971922874451, 0.13236220180988312, 0.31656554341316223, -0.13508503139019012, -0.23438550531864166, -1.0957616567611694, -1.1337074041366577, 0.006368737202137709, -0.27675098180770874, -0.5618508458137512, 0.2840833067893982, 0.2854140102863312, -0.5078833103179932, -1.0189473628997803, 0.12708263099193573, -0.49688005447387695, -1.230661392211914, -0.23450221121311188, -0.44955313205718994, 1.1191076040267944, 0.5578042268753052, -0.26330316066741943, -0.7137994170188904, 0.3272814452648163, 0.21545030176639557, 0.8034863471984863, 0.5071945786476135, -1.0422017574310303, 0.5468132495880127, -0.18077437579631805, -0.3349120020866394, -0.195969358086586, 0.2381727248430252, -0.13673783838748932, -0.5681402683258057, -0.26523444056510925, 0.38681983947753906, 0.09844445437192917, 0.5752158761024475, -0.2837458848953247, 0.014314246363937855, 0.06327717006206512, 0.0179249607026577, 0.8082306385040283, 0.4957910180091858, 0.20639126002788544, 0.38845840096473694, 0.78108811378479, 0.10268432646989822, 0.08393338322639465, -0.401020348072052, -0.7422204613685608, 0.4633726477622986, 0.3252003490924835, 0.40865734219551086, -0.9784142374992371, 0.6516875624656677, -0.7569100856781006, -0.3695918023586273, 0.24144205451011658, -0.15498340129852295, -0.05248599871993065, 0.07987013459205627, -0.8709171414375305, 1.4789754152297974, -0.449000746011734, 0.6263014078140259, 0.351089209318161, 0.1292683482170105, -0.03022877685725689, 0.16672782599925995, 0.6553977131843567, -0.009635941125452518, 0.00756019726395607, -0.1245792955160141, -0.49930134415626526, -0.45235109329223633, -0.28911107778549194, 0.08992895483970642, 0.0632219985127449, -0.29858624935150146, -0.28630495071411133, 0.05849001556634903, 0.1742917150259018, -0.36119744181632996, 0.04247291758656502, 1.3307949304580688, -0.5247796773910522, -0.04501356557011604, 0.5296103954315186, 0.5768288373947144, 0.3078220784664154, -1.1235499382019043, 0.47503766417503357, -0.2257489711046219, -0.30574411153793335, 0.0071615613996982574, -0.4149594306945801, 0.18382537364959717, -0.45385420322418213, -0.3706299364566803, -0.06480889767408371, -0.4761924147605896, -0.11812593787908554, -0.6779584288597107, 0.21004943549633026, 1.0424833297729492, 0.27009689807891846, -1.069075584411621, 0.12237410247325897, 0.2738810181617737, -0.8727539777755737, -0.19668778777122498, -0.10675570368766785, 0.3238522708415985, 0.8838496804237366, -0.7438787817955017, -0.7280702590942383, -0.45264720916748047, -0.6358901262283325, -0.2882618010044098, 0.13286365568637848, -0.19415506720542908, 0.0421055443584919, 0.7471961379051208, -0.22312766313552856, -0.8012017011642456, -0.28618600964546204, -0.6211821436882019, -0.1125989779829979, -0.13337655365467072, 0.4313508868217468, 1.0805052518844604, 1.0035573244094849, 0.12436523288488388, 0.08861806988716125, 1.16681969165802, -0.38668501377105713, 0.6059056520462036, -0.4110889732837677, 0.18242959678173065, -0.195500448346138, -0.36933842301368713, -0.5391147136688232, -0.12057328969240189, 0.421731173992157, -0.2890504002571106, -0.4386903941631317, -0.2285882532596588, -0.07647864520549774, -0.5894643068313599, 0.43074461817741394, 0.1429366022348404, 0.5236822962760925, 1.4611835479736328, -0.6720580458641052, 0.5207492709159851, -0.18250197172164917, 0.8386726975440979, -0.3888147473335266, 0.4176514744758606, 0.3310278356075287, 0.3244193196296692, 0.2212980091571808, -0.9319220781326294, 0.03028247319161892, 0.6873177886009216, 0.06521031260490417, -0.7332248091697693, -0.19901089370250702, -0.24408267438411713, -1.1854588985443115, -0.7729405760765076, -0.16717399656772614, -0.772699236869812, 0.17401471734046936, -0.4883718490600586, 0.20381589233875275, 0.7677319645881653, -0.662022590637207, -0.3479560911655426, -0.21605241298675537, -0.6215992569923401, 0.008220723830163479, 0.26967695355415344, 0.42146915197372437, 0.042210254818201065, -0.3575226068496704, -1.1611523628234863, 0.49158918857574463, -0.03140514716506004, -0.563886821269989, -0.045172616839408875, -0.7334907054901123, 0.1095639243721962, -0.29740503430366516, -0.7455558776855469, -0.5739195346832275, 0.11058962345123291, -0.9160367250442505, -0.4900720417499542, -0.5530185699462891, 0.370099276304245, 0.19251954555511475, 0.053824685513973236, 0.9209586381912231, -0.1482047736644745, -1.5608960390090942, -0.5870147943496704, 1.4694936275482178, -0.5315045118331909, 0.3667512536048889, -0.09087003022432327, -0.4730585813522339, -0.06747855991125107, -1.1478087902069092, 0.2926520109176636, -1.3905516862869263, -0.23622764647006989, -0.5049365162849426, -0.4247187376022339, -0.35985809564590454, 0.35523679852485657, -0.27517977356910706, -0.4145359396934509, -0.5154697895050049, -0.5856127738952637, 0.38330549001693726, -0.8534345030784607, -0.4799292981624603, -0.6107059121131897, 0.1798636019229889, -0.48962390422821045, 0.681469738483429, 0.3724473714828491, 0.08053575456142426, 0.17548638582229614, 0.1328592300415039, 0.5323583483695984, 0.41132691502571106, -0.41801056265830994, -1.0706244707107544, 0.089743472635746, 0.40706947445869446, 1.2224572896957397, -0.1158808246254921, -0.24127662181854248, 0.7858873009681702, -0.522699236869812, 0.22762231528759003, -0.41838937997817993, -0.3987056314945221, 0.10808111727237701, -0.3801323473453522, 0.6571287512779236, -0.18534517288208008, 1.006669521331787, 0.3252008855342865, -0.4736516773700714, -0.0661797896027565, 0.3330223858356476, -0.6766558885574341, 0.34716805815696716, -0.5255603194236755, -0.8354683518409729, 0.4681074321269989, -0.6857998967170715, -0.5112220644950867, 0.11860659718513489, -0.04565182328224182, 0.031771499663591385, -0.4905552268028259, 0.912421464920044, 0.7921988368034363, -0.05202433839440346, 0.07053268700838089, 0.11776886135339737, -0.04164990782737732, 0.26534268260002136, 0.09752673655748367, -0.1891852170228958, -0.23575302958488464, 0.1793273389339447, -0.07581660896539688, -0.33900007605552673, -1.021960735321045, -0.24127532541751862, 0.17621739208698273, 0.3775418996810913, -0.14373938739299774, 0.5569400787353516, -0.015333360061049461, 0.0019402815960347652, -0.18723638355731964, 0.21092668175697327, 0.3674740493297577, 0.21569737792015076, 0.40377646684646606, -0.5130599141120911, 0.2638927102088928, 0.1896699219942093, 0.2406645268201828, 0.03505062311887741, 0.05640712007880211, 0.6214447021484375, 0.1290188431739807, -0.39852088689804077, 0.11471245437860489, 0.05015233904123306, -0.45962879061698914, -0.1512160450220108, 0.6625016927719116, -0.4709504246711731, -0.12350531667470932, -0.29141759872436523, -0.2389732152223587, 0.6741863489151001, -0.048110395669937134, 0.932287335395813, 0.06886452436447144, -0.518145740032196, 0.22663061320781708, -0.12483455240726471, 0.5895563364028931, -0.6952216029167175, 0.41545236110687256, 1.1679446697235107, -0.2727094292640686, 0.20681026577949524, -0.1485907882452011, 0.056696247309446335, 0.3239505887031555, 0.386494904756546, 0.1360258311033249, -0.28721264004707336, 0.34397199749946594, 0.7718081474304199, -0.21615180373191833, 0.39195016026496887, 0.5490561127662659, -0.5203240513801575, 0.9310998320579529, 0.3801937997341156, -0.5004644393920898, -0.15673689544200897, -0.07125739008188248, 0.038661956787109375, 0.663486123085022, 0.3058483302593231, -0.38968220353126526, 0.1723957657814026, 0.272916704416275, -0.023639556020498276, -0.6700363159179688, -0.6224309206008911, -1.0172480344772339, -0.22023607790470123, 0.1648920178413391, 0.36051520705223083, -0.7174206376075745, 0.7768135666847229, -0.008873283863067627, -0.5472622513771057, 0.40751776099205017, 1.2427186965942383, -0.3494567275047302, -0.21873115003108978, -0.7717245221138, 0.26480525732040405, -0.37595799565315247, -0.6765293478965759, 0.4584256708621979, -0.8983069062232971, 0.3536699414253235, 1.4377490282058716, -0.3151527941226959, 0.004534199833869934, 0.09411003440618515, 0.09082578122615814, -0.004795130342245102, 0.09619686752557755, -0.03436891734600067, -0.09044667333364487, -0.5373014807701111, 0.5507137179374695, 0.4880850315093994, -0.20218011736869812, 1.0319805145263672, -1.030719518661499, 0.2692999541759491, 0.36587268114089966, 0.16820888221263885, -0.1983662247657776, -0.0970112755894661, 1.5090794563293457, -0.6332240700721741, 0.014841651543974876, -0.2793659269809723, 0.8846704363822937, -0.963919997215271, -0.2342747300863266, -0.34279903769493103, -0.28311774134635925, 0.6860538125038147, 0.35361817479133606, 0.5958240628242493, 0.6602616310119629, 0.4284086227416992, -0.042912956327199936, 0.1858394742012024, 1.3200832605361938, 0.1942259818315506, -0.43641120195388794, 0.7819637060165405, 0.16794522106647491, 0.19018472731113434, -1.319242000579834, 0.15185539424419403, 1.304203987121582, -0.5833265781402588, -0.45344021916389465, -0.27835813164711, 0.2495383471250534, -0.07569921016693115, 0.24627242982387543, -0.12049561738967896, 0.7233750224113464, 0.24218322336673737, 0.4116538166999817, 0.3011704385280609, -0.3249463438987732, -0.8964477181434631, -0.22310388088226318, -0.9958571195602417, -0.6404814720153809, 0.17762859165668488, -0.21331064403057098, 0.46144890785217285, -0.8075644373893738, -0.1256798952817917, -0.03689034283161163, 0.7379368543624878, 0.8702901601791382, -0.33562546968460083, -0.129379540681839, 0.20579935610294342, 0.6736022233963013, -0.1523485630750656, -0.3998013138771057, -0.1892910748720169, 0.0952267199754715, -0.9681410789489746, -0.22410251200199127, -0.2926734387874603, 0.1478131115436554, 0.3854754865169525, -0.4190838932991028, -0.03947622328996658, 0.33140984177589417, 0.905815839767456, 0.01129766646772623, -0.4889305531978607, 0.6423317193984985, -0.9715206027030945, -0.05723157152533531, -0.15028534829616547, -0.12421559542417526, -0.6367807388305664, 0.5914332866668701, -0.2384651005268097, -0.8505832552909851, -0.4145204424858093, -0.32947516441345215, 0.5716926455497742, -0.8088088631629944, 0.5040069222450256, -0.6392738819122314, 0.07392111420631409, -0.39313867688179016, -0.31291595101356506, 0.8867810964584351, 0.119125597178936, 0.09797274321317673, -0.4339916408061981, 0.01471101026982069, 0.44848230481147766, 0.8790932893753052, 0.5044973492622375, 0.1791677325963974, 1.4526203870773315, 0.7228601574897766, 0.21851621568202972, 0.304203063249588, 0.009973248466849327, 0.4040049612522125, -0.12254723906517029, 0.12872758507728577, 0.20338746905326843, 0.9063686728477478, 0.9007697701454163, 0.17947472631931305, -0.7997934818267822, 0.04477353394031525, -0.5301605463027954, -1.5756357908248901, 0.016262337565422058, -0.09075738489627838, 1.2652281522750854, -0.005526852328330278, 0.5441793203353882, 0.27980121970176697, 0.3945000171661377, 0.07509677112102509, 0.4151276648044586, 0.4723668396472931, -0.11105326563119888, -0.6151358485221863, -0.7646879553794861, -0.018641207367181778, -0.09648256748914719, 0.0798349380493164, 0.5464005470275879, -0.7599741816520691, 0.44837477803230286, 0.381326824426651, -0.05257111042737961, -0.30100908875465393, 1.0180655717849731, -0.0805702954530716, 0.762885332107544, -0.802680492401123, -0.9033276438713074, -0.44994020462036133, 0.6571447253227234, 0.510506272315979, -1.201875925064087, -0.37141337990760803, 0.4137016534805298, 0.6858831644058228, 0.006721549201756716, 1.119119644165039, 0.8120838403701782, 0.2772505581378937, 0.1574905812740326, 0.7298738360404968, -0.16497308015823364, -0.3682430684566498, 0.07266879081726074, -0.015513128601014614, 0.44607013463974, -0.24519173800945282, 0.4274865388870239, -0.14169973134994507, -0.14888961613178253, -0.08387155085802078, 0.2801143527030945, -0.6361371874809265, -0.30173754692077637, -0.8307239413261414, -0.31882020831108093, -0.3344109058380127, 0.2366357445716858, -0.7051292657852173, 0.17275941371917725, 0.7627986669540405, 0.15648964047431946, -0.22722305357456207, -0.020343875512480736, -1.0430958271026611, 0.19288362562656403, -0.5672760605812073, 0.5930674076080322, -0.9180087447166443, -0.47161659598350525, -0.7493528127670288, -1.0924334526062012, -0.17046856880187988, 0.422434538602829, 0.32011041045188904, -0.9354959726333618, 0.601426362991333, 0.6800857782363892, 0.7049767971038818, 0.22566400468349457, -0.5537292957305908, 0.9236448407173157, 0.4162466526031494, 0.28678619861602783, -0.17394445836544037, 1.0724748373031616, 0.17768681049346924, 0.33209237456321716, 0.2737097442150116, -0.12557578086853027, -0.06296592205762863, 0.08603370934724808, -0.9136539101600647, -0.28619810938835144, 0.4421902298927307, -0.33416932821273804, -0.620371401309967, 0.5400265455245972, 1.107156753540039, 0.5059747695922852, -0.4313880503177643, -0.5039905905723572, 0.4745393991470337, -0.9625837802886963, 0.5223544239997864, -0.1091490164399147, 0.3848648965358734, -0.023319635540246964, -0.25594815611839294, -1.139319896697998, -0.5546061396598816, 3.8601088523864746, 1.3611100912094116, 0.5489811301231384, -0.49001941084861755, 0.8369236588478088, -0.13619135320186615, 0.838549792766571, 0.14112314581871033, -0.3780079483985901, -0.06355533003807068, -0.07509002089500427, -0.3650711178779602, -0.12223252654075623, -0.23835031688213348, 0.06992488354444504, -0.12856869399547577, -1.2427763938903809, 0.026398874819278717, 0.024873845279216766, -1.0428013801574707, -0.9400786757469177, 0.2602594792842865, 0.4355849027633667, -0.05367778241634369, 0.03161204233765602, -0.012290487997233868, -0.4061647355556488, 0.51197749376297, 0.19690492749214172, -0.4517658054828644, -0.6695005297660828, -0.8927545547485352, 0.22962680459022522, -0.670259952545166, -0.22130244970321655, -0.11563548445701599, -0.35938480496406555, -0.8368026614189148, 0.0942787453532219, -0.267607718706131, -0.35895952582359314, 0.1225898265838623, 0.1824978142976761, -0.2175561487674713, -0.11792561411857605, -0.36107107996940613, -0.7410836219787598, 0.48885583877563477, 0.8202688694000244, -0.8407419323921204, 0.9389328360557556, -0.3131601810455322, 0.9344654083251953, -0.17130868136882782, -0.5153393745422363, -0.7654098868370056, -0.3024882376194, -0.9529902338981628, 0.1760232150554657, 0.16838209331035614, 0.45244166254997253, 0.2774398922920227, -0.36082783341407776, 0.026942068710923195, 0.7349263429641724, 0.6654762625694275, 0.09995914995670319, 0.31202077865600586, 0.01880042627453804, -0.12043549120426178, 0.26388469338417053, 0.14734169840812683, -0.4108916223049164, 0.7648091316223145, 0.4282459020614624, 0.4995698630809784, 0.04766974598169327, 1.1516964435577393, -0.3916493058204651, -0.4630500078201294, 0.17981846630573273, 0.7458221316337585, 0.3824589252471924, 0.06724681705236435, 0.20651352405548096, 0.245454341173172, -1.0166202783584595, -0.566261351108551, -0.27699020504951477, 0.8516441583633423, 0.3711111843585968, -0.0953315794467926, -0.866008460521698, 0.4869014620780945, -0.7565784454345703 ]
{"Title": "Machine learning to predict early recurrence after oesophageal cancer surgery", "Authors": "Rahman Saqib A, Walker Robert C, Lloyd Megan A, Grace Ben L, van Boxel Gijs I, Kingma Feike, Ruurda Jelle P, van Hillegersberg Richard, Harris Scott, Parsons Simon, Mercer Stuart, Griffiths Ewen A, O\u2019Neill J.Robert, Turkington Richard, Fitzgerald Rebecca C, Underwood Timothy J", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective To develop a predictive model for early recurrence after surgery for oesophageal adenocarcinoma using a large multi-national cohort. Summary Background Data Early cancer recurrence after oesophagectomy is a common problem with an incidence of 20-30% despite the widespread use of neoadjuvant treatment. Quantification of this risk is difficult and existing models perform poorly. Machine learning techniques potentially allow more accurate prognostication and have been applied in this study. Methods Consecutive patients who underwent oesophagectomy for adenocarcinoma and had neoadjuvant treatment in 6 UK and 1 Dutch oesophago-gastric units were analysed. Using clinical characteristics and post-operative histopathology, models were generated using elastic net regression (ELR) and the machine learning methods random forest (RF) and XG boost (XGB). Finally, a combined (Ensemble) model of these was generated. The relative importance of factors to outcome was calculated as a percentage contribution to the model. Results In total 812 patients were included. The recurrence rate at less than 1 year was 29.1%. All of the models demonstrated good discrimination. Internally validated AUCs were similar, with the Ensemble model performing best (ELR=0.785, RF=0.789, XGB=0.794, Ensemble=0.806). Performance was similar when using internal-external validation (validation across sites, Ensemble AUC=0.804). In the final model the most important variables were number of positive lymph nodes (25.7%) and vascular invasion (16.9%). Conclusions The derived model using machine learning approaches and an international dataset provided excellent performance in quantifying the risk of early recurrence after surgery and will be useful in prognostication for clinicians and patients. DRAFT VISUAL ABSTRACT Icons taken from www.flaticon.com , made by \u2018Freepik\u2019, \u2018smashicons\u2019, and \u2018prettycons\u2019. Reproduced under creative commons attribution license MINI-ABSTRACT Early recurrence after surgery for adenocarcinoma of the oesophagus is common. We derived a risk prediction model using modern machine learning methods that accurately predicts risk of early recurrence using post-operative pathology", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001073"}
10.1101/19013987
[ 0.20913229882717133, -0.12065073102712631, -0.7157164216041565, 0.746688723564148, -0.5322832465171814, -0.27518969774246216, -0.25543028116226196, -0.23727163672447205, -0.14344319701194763, 0.09554190933704376, -0.5333852171897888, 0.03738538175821304, 0.36022576689720154, -0.5902056694030762, -0.008630123920738697, 0.2059028446674347, -0.8610084056854248, 0.036147963255643845, -0.21321319043636322, -0.2568070590496063, 0.676435649394989, 0.7340155839920044, -0.7490531206130981, 0.4584214985370636, -0.7085180282592773, 0.3333538770675659, 0.11711668968200684, -0.128081813454628, 1.1888877153396606, 0.38011884689331055, 0.11702922731637955, -0.6320723295211792, 0.8972033262252808, -0.7503703832626343, -0.6339801549911499, -0.20141270756721497, 0.625575602054596, -0.5508217215538025, -0.0006995772710070014, 0.12473180145025253, 0.21278530359268188, -0.33672335743904114, -0.48320263624191284, -0.6005327105522156, -0.839358389377594, 0.026214230805635452, 0.18209314346313477, -0.4771459102630615, 0.05665550008416176, -0.6794754266738892, -0.8097175359725952, -0.16129013895988464, 0.1562536507844925, -0.013278079219162464, 0.569587767124176, -0.23068444430828094, 0.26655104756355286, -0.08719097077846527, -0.5242355465888977, -0.06307189166545868, 0.08730673789978027, -0.32663774490356445, 0.6656519174575806, -1.3264278173446655, 0.1481013298034668, 0.2993691563606262, -0.029079070314764977, -0.012726669199764729, -0.7491243481636047, -0.46443605422973633, -0.7949974536895752, 0.36912044882774353, -0.7420744299888611, -1.0724802017211914, 0.2702541649341583, -0.058873411267995834, -0.0472390353679657, -0.4555109143257141, 0.2752608358860016, -0.926041841506958, 0.4532700777053833, -0.026445653289556503, 0.276592880487442, 0.18690985441207886, -0.3334656357765198, -0.31637832522392273, 0.5251293182373047, -0.316874623298645, 0.5889862775802612, 0.08529385179281235, 0.5522705316543579, -0.17164582014083862, 0.3428005576133728, 0.20171955227851868, -0.4873323142528534, 0.12506288290023804, -0.5451459288597107, 0.0755109190940857, 0.3121298551559448, 0.03055061772465706, 0.595734715461731, 0.9809660315513611, -0.1175515204668045, 0.8843716382980347, -1.1878886222839355, -0.12254823744297028, 0.12531323730945587, -0.06272245943546295, -0.007700891699641943, -0.5091924071311951, -0.24308814108371735, 0.5495278239250183, -0.39608705043792725, 0.2371676117181778, -0.13024255633354187, 0.33541661500930786, -0.37276527285575867, 0.19304685294628143, -0.5260298252105713, 0.7436844706535339, 0.13157770037651062, -0.04308973625302315, -0.023571981117129326, -0.5380706787109375, 0.2052939385175705, -0.4094999432563782, 0.35664889216423035, 0.22491192817687988, -0.18860378861427307, -0.0611661821603775, 0.10558951646089554, -0.9448722004890442, -0.5863190293312073, 1.119652509689331, -0.5919596552848816, 0.09626208245754242, -0.2903420925140381, 0.6255587339401245, 0.08965644240379333, -0.01380318682640791, -0.6311289668083191, -0.06452029943466187, -0.10022854804992676, 1.0414150953292847, 0.2217787355184555, 1.1670455932617188, -1.1111620664596558, -1.25314199924469, 0.06349609792232513, 0.07867775112390518, 0.03848927095532417, 0.27590224146842957, -0.10627701878547668, 0.6511222124099731, 0.20058073103427887, -0.6654853224754333, -0.9144943952560425, 1.3495832681655884, -1.0119346380233765, 0.14722609519958496, 0.1437915414571762, 0.649178683757782, 0.03941326588392258, 1.3272044658660889, -0.5920799970626831, 0.2400985211133957, -0.2632070779800415, 0.010511109605431557, -0.3853534460067749, -0.6861096620559692, 0.002967237029224634, 0.487024188041687, 0.06627102941274643, 0.03728635236620903, 0.3376927375793457, 0.7970942258834839, 0.8150269389152527, 0.9669821262359619, 0.19953583180904388, 0.1044074222445488, -0.26221778988838196, -0.25545811653137207, 0.6539608240127563, 0.815051794052124, -0.46993210911750793, 0.30801892280578613, 0.09541452676057816, -0.8981741666793823, -0.6384952664375305, 0.4777538478374481, -0.11561395227909088, 0.9919543862342834, -1.54703950881958, 0.270161896944046, -0.10447672009468079, 0.5729399919509888, -0.1733383685350418, 0.45076966285705566, 0.6422796249389648, -0.16045145690441132, -0.5358657836914062, 0.5179439783096313, -0.5218572616577148, 0.09326934069395065, -0.5827373266220093, 1.1301409006118774, 0.5069222450256348, 0.510796844959259, 0.033995673060417175, -0.279934287071228, 0.37808501720428467, -0.29459843039512634, -0.13927103579044342, 0.3205636143684387, 0.9931409955024719, -0.7098679542541504, 0.24310436844825745, 0.01151355542242527, 0.23328979313373566, -0.813667356967926, 0.4194789528846741, -0.11610088497400284, 0.6459010243415833, -0.05564253404736519, -0.013218943029642105, -0.004685958847403526, 0.5328385233879089, 0.2917410731315613, -0.28190600872039795, -0.5098798871040344, 0.041926056146621704, 0.7119714617729187, -0.24779553711414337, 0.6702244877815247, 0.5066087245941162, -0.0619187094271183, 0.2824530005455017, 0.6965463161468506, 0.6874063014984131, -0.4112881124019623, 0.7440295219421387, -0.13402102887630463, 0.7683845162391663, -0.5731773376464844, -0.29983049631118774, -0.21518142521381378, 0.06047922745347023, 0.23436839878559113, -0.9929736852645874, -0.17568086087703705, -0.5847944617271423, 0.7981013655662537, -0.09360301494598389, 0.3479980528354645, -0.9089967608451843, 0.06931110471487045, 0.3811269700527191, 0.4583141505718231, -0.10626508295536041, -0.7148681879043579, -0.23897399008274078, -0.026522476226091385, 0.6173340678215027, 0.47356823086738586, 0.8287204504013062, 0.42905792593955994, -0.21312843263149261, 0.29621246457099915, 0.033283624798059464, -0.25887349247932434, -0.4502810537815094, -0.8045522570610046, -1.2174928188323975, -0.17829972505569458, -0.4763408899307251, -0.758599042892456, -0.005879223346710205, 0.20524941384792328, 0.6157575845718384, -0.04258499667048454, 0.7502197027206421, -0.688054084777832, 0.48923712968826294, 0.7338936924934387, 0.5705090165138245, 0.20697548985481262, -1.824766993522644, 0.3208712935447693, -0.2567472457885742, 0.20723149180412292, 0.3408113420009613, -0.5991934537887573, -0.49598193168640137, -1.3091589212417603, 0.31851133704185486, -0.5806278586387634, -0.02936980128288269, 0.4203041195869446, -0.497531533241272, -0.47198548913002014, 0.2717244029045105, 0.172531858086586, 0.39963698387145996, 0.34346118569374084, -0.5720118284225464, 1.0591002702713013, 0.4723261892795563, 0.3218415081501007, 0.9841374754905701, -0.13294202089309692, -0.2519237995147705, 1.1599383354187012, 0.07428207993507385, 0.07638728618621826, -0.7436975836753845, 0.8307505249977112, 0.5445928573608398, -0.30575260519981384, -0.09340685606002808, -0.7402191758155823, -0.7576818466186523, -0.30320683121681213, -0.10064257681369781, -0.8590816855430603, 0.35482916235923767, -0.0662330910563469, 0.05570979416370392, -1.3720378875732422, 0.035525064915418625, -0.7044191360473633, -0.6315373182296753, 0.34378543496131897, -0.37519416213035583, 0.25204187631607056, -0.5566504597663879, 0.11704745143651962, -0.6535593867301941, -0.16012777388095856, 0.4801356792449951, -0.04312752187252045, 0.6352464556694031, -0.5558964610099792, -0.12265795469284058, 0.594404399394989, -0.18053218722343445, 0.5274782776832581, 0.5224446654319763, -0.306337833404541, -0.43476465344429016, -0.31962311267852783, -0.4826701283454895, 0.13238751888275146, 0.84397292137146, -0.7609735131263733, 0.3498745858669281, 0.29877859354019165, -0.5865671634674072, -0.4553764760494232, 0.0553700216114521, 0.1994134783744812, -0.7816011905670166, -0.6137194633483887, -0.08502951264381409, 0.28757035732269287, -0.5212135910987854, -0.6554073691368103, 0.450737863779068, 0.4717372953891754, 0.5230216979980469, -0.9292697310447693, 0.6155996918678284, 0.41794878244400024, -0.023175571113824844, -0.07204888761043549, -0.5755487680435181, -0.9644989967346191, 0.4758484661579132, -0.001431023352779448, 0.3000060021877289, -1.2553596496582031, -0.45027783513069153, 0.6383079290390015, 1.3788564205169678, 0.16867294907569885, 0.18863575160503387, 0.03995288163423538, -0.4970681369304657, 0.38398393988609314, 0.30655187368392944, 0.46482372283935547, 0.26788777112960815, -0.32652774453163147, -0.5452988743782043, -0.32154351472854614, -1.1915700435638428, 0.1566779911518097, 0.5592876672744751, 0.42298266291618347, 0.08444169908761978, -1.0264424085617065, 0.7888096570968628, -0.052429717034101486, 0.5716086030006409, 1.1011006832122803, 0.17540812492370605, -0.39564651250839233, -0.6900785565376282, 0.7828980088233948, -0.12776044011116028, -0.3454993665218353, -0.4424598217010498, -0.1665651649236679, 0.14410309493541718, 0.09246847033500671, 0.3431003987789154, 0.35514354705810547, -0.4986433982849121, -0.2556866705417633, 0.2681853175163269, 0.003609346691519022, 0.2283630520105362, -0.2545582056045532, -0.6968547701835632, 0.031448062509298325, 0.5160011649131775, -0.16102619469165802, 0.2245706170797348, -0.4860239326953888, 0.30286499857902527, 0.635352611541748, -0.7472013235092163, -0.693519651889801, 0.04096858948469162, 0.17004716396331787, -0.4499446153640747, 0.27030467987060547, 0.3610382080078125, -1.0072472095489502, 0.20421047508716583, 0.10093780606985092, -0.020153211429715157, 0.0016750633949413896, -0.016824236139655113, 0.011095323599874973, 0.19900773465633392, 0.45324939489364624, 0.7579402327537537, 0.3324761390686035, -0.3039065897464752, 0.327521413564682, 0.174513578414917, -0.8072031736373901, 0.6851750612258911, 0.09562691301107407, -0.18774542212486267, 0.22940103709697723, -0.3846835196018219, 0.049439456313848495, -0.04646565765142441, -0.4725615084171295, -0.2403893917798996, -0.5906626582145691, 0.8730924725532532, -0.5303211212158203, 0.091791532933712, 0.8607145547866821, -0.45782893896102905, 0.5023213624954224, 0.24796542525291443, -0.16360418498516083, -0.4790211319923401, -0.13787713646888733, -0.06823769211769104, -0.3977390229701996, 0.46621230244636536, -0.2585115432739258, 0.15232504904270172, 0.20593123137950897, -0.3264597952365875, -0.3876059353351593, -0.24989858269691467, 0.15359188616275787, -0.8213481307029724, 0.15187017619609833, -0.34937506914138794, 0.5317692756652832, 0.1306130588054657, -0.22104857861995697, -0.8829182982444763, -0.44940102100372314, -0.03620493412017822, -0.4033755362033844, 0.2360733151435852, 0.32812556624412537, -0.7661903500556946, 0.22734370827674866, -0.809842586517334, 0.544020414352417, -0.07624293863773346, 0.04881971329450607, 1.163400650024414, -0.21035051345825195, -1.203215479850769, 0.16920123994350433, 0.0844983384013176, -0.03948923200368881, -0.3421180844306946, -0.5937421917915344, -1.4127848148345947, 0.06488137692213058, -0.10242775827646255, 0.05040469765663147, -0.1349445879459381, 0.43014079332351685, -0.09158109873533249, -0.1145225465297699, -0.4638846516609192, -0.6096763014793396, -0.2662978768348694, 0.4455864131450653, -0.48076558113098145, -0.8428999781608582, 0.1288437396287918, 0.45483869314193726, -0.4214889407157898, 0.1587476134300232, -0.27070170640945435, -0.7234905362129211, -0.09015277028083801, -0.9869744777679443, 0.963929295539856, -1.602577805519104, -0.04614954814314842, -0.40255555510520935, -0.6066168546676636, -0.18574747443199158, -0.03955691680312157, 0.3520037829875946, -0.43792974948883057, -0.1246250793337822, -0.5809260010719299, -0.08887191116809845, -0.5843468904495239, -0.5327808856964111, 0.2863524258136749, -0.6125611066818237, -0.02944890968501568, 1.1538708209991455, 0.5047240257263184, -0.22294653952121735, 0.5044336915016174, 0.6629049777984619, 0.7580413222312927, 0.7718698382377625, -0.3236595690250397, -0.4774709939956665, 0.23860390484333038, -0.017596542835235596, 0.35646867752075195, 0.15830735862255096, -0.6163167357444763, -0.28312066197395325, -0.1737602800130844, 0.44003167748451233, -1.6020324230194092, -0.027305537834763527, -0.16482681035995483, -0.02149721048772335, 0.7740503549575806, -0.19883373379707336, 0.43644312024116516, 0.45292291045188904, -0.011259125545620918, 0.06938999146223068, -0.0462704598903656, -0.6024797558784485, -0.5373352766036987, -0.5381246209144592, -0.9741316437721252, 0.42241814732551575, 0.403670996427536, 0.20738811790943146, 0.3884292244911194, 0.11127790063619614, -0.3801596462726593, -1.0219849348068237, 0.2969552278518677, 0.5869020223617554, -0.6649700999259949, -1.0641717910766602, -0.17789942026138306, -0.15549972653388977, 0.8137685060501099, -0.1447148621082306, -0.11887504905462265, -0.6321293711662292, 0.31550976634025574, -0.6340258121490479, -0.9023664593696594, -0.701347827911377, -0.23663511872291565, 0.037547335028648376, 0.013112835586071014, -0.447072297334671, 0.8184739351272583, 0.018823090940713882, -0.2521989643573761, -0.33949995040893555, 0.9138067960739136, -0.46090608835220337, -0.16468581557273865, 0.2862204611301422, 0.042790114879608154, -0.7706806659698486, -0.3027184009552002, -0.04445575550198555, -0.538171112537384, 0.5267951488494873, 0.19399379193782806, 0.8751885890960693, -0.7606728672981262, -0.0452846884727478, 0.14467211067676544, 0.23420032858848572, -1.0014630556106567, 0.08752256631851196, -0.26960083842277527, -0.01541267428547144, -0.6988776326179504, -0.2511473000049591, 0.531894862651825, -0.09850712865591049, -0.1733212172985077, 0.5007175803184509, -0.17940866947174072, 0.3948943018913269, -0.02546682022511959, 0.0743134543299675, -0.3127642273902893, 0.29574349522590637, 0.9644542336463928, 0.3846041262149811, 0.36510056257247925, -0.3838624358177185, -0.6058993339538574, 0.42259177565574646, 0.0218956395983696, 0.5907824039459229, -0.8247879147529602, -0.059211183339357376, -0.027852030470967293, 0.3652532398700714, -0.01733214221894741, -0.29037126898765564, 0.3595050871372223, 0.2771691083908081, 0.2629391849040985, -0.45900624990463257, -0.25976699590682983, 0.8573225140571594, 0.21122273802757263, 0.8425351977348328, -0.6204535961151123, 0.18048904836177826, 0.9334424734115601, 0.11178436130285263, -0.04045432433485985, -1.0528570413589478, -1.1942315101623535, -0.7339389324188232, -0.34618234634399414, 0.39086610078811646, -0.7085065245628357, 0.3341924548149109, 0.48763328790664673, -0.6404040455818176, -0.32136210799217224, -0.7535949349403381, 0.8203901052474976, -0.6309024095535278, -0.6532598733901978, -0.3427661955356598, 0.12894628942012787, -0.7583790421485901, 0.2647860050201416, -0.18596716225147247, -1.1548415422439575, -0.38918548822402954, 0.5221452116966248, -0.36303937435150146, -0.22860731184482574, 0.2155430018901825, 0.4446510374546051, -0.01894564926624298, 0.6179353594779968, -0.8693244457244873, -0.3231801986694336, -0.08085144311189651, 0.6275723576545715, 0.21926206350326538, -0.19427824020385742, 0.8312739133834839, -0.6344640254974365, 0.6544362902641296, 0.4274353086948395, -0.39770522713661194, -0.8681961297988892, 0.4299071133136749, 0.17725273966789246, -0.6551656723022461, -0.434475839138031, 0.08627283573150635, 0.33966758847236633, -0.7021124362945557, -0.09573493152856827, 0.20820346474647522, 0.06877005845308304, 0.1519710123538971, -0.018937239423394203, -0.05803874880075455, 0.9508571028709412, -0.36843663454055786, -0.33617231249809265, 0.28943073749542236, 0.7241485714912415, 0.4908563792705536, 0.4236297607421875, 0.19180604815483093, -0.10210540890693665, -0.2462318241596222, -1.0099709033966064, -0.44490036368370056, 0.16161809861660004, 0.12575900554656982, 0.3509948253631592, -0.8415285348892212, 0.6306999921798706, 0.021836677566170692, 0.08015643805265427, 0.1796371191740036, 0.6483404040336609, -0.2141650915145874, -0.7589000463485718, 0.5331487655639648, -0.015307007357478142, -0.4889151155948639, -0.7567946314811707, -0.9043019413948059, -0.38313496112823486, 0.9963482618331909, -0.3443470001220703, -0.5490608215332031, -0.34094110131263733, -0.06049129366874695, -0.3277336359024048, 0.11139966547489166, 0.5605271458625793, -0.17363238334655762, 0.5554071664810181, 0.49369338154792786, 0.5066865682601929, -0.020566189661622047, -0.39377641677856445, 0.09321152418851852, 0.007821609266102314, -1.1123090982437134, -0.3484358787536621, 0.3980896472930908, 0.8472871780395508, 0.6591627597808838, 0.19709308445453644, 0.20051686465740204, 0.08876342326402664, 0.1693381518125534, -0.17518028616905212, -0.14907097816467285, 0.5818356871604919, -0.07763643562793732, -0.0976056158542633, 0.19740843772888184, 0.06617377698421478, 0.47656551003456116, 0.04310488700866699, 0.5342541933059692, -0.4357334077358246, -0.6264805197715759, -0.0044339122250676155, 0.1409968137741089, -0.5837281942367554, 0.8019540309906006, -0.1792382448911667, 0.6471536755561829, -0.2393893599510193, 0.3513653874397278, 0.14705698192119598, 0.3254874050617218, 0.6274105906486511, 0.39977598190307617, 0.13384504616260529, 0.8844664096832275, 0.5092455148696899, 0.5101239085197449, 0.13892298936843872, 0.39336255192756653, 0.15207640826702118, -0.5484951734542847, 0.6233062148094177, -0.5110089182853699, 0.2916741371154785, 0.07683978974819183, 0.1341211497783661, 0.41897714138031006, 0.10389719158411026, 0.6857337951660156, -0.3064339756965637, -0.31899294257164, 0.3059879243373871, -0.10167597234249115, -0.4093968868255615, 0.43950584530830383, 0.5917532444000244, 0.23898302018642426, -0.27794578671455383, -0.23210036754608154, -0.0010643030982464552, 0.6334632635116577, 0.5695003867149353, 0.310569167137146, 0.7775078415870667, -0.0457734651863575, -0.6088853478431702, 0.013603325933218002, 0.6214575171470642, 0.020970044657588005, 0.7429518699645996, 0.8512744307518005, -0.3284916579723358, -0.5897219777107239, 0.6972413063049316, -0.23882491886615753, -0.84096360206604, 0.9802111387252808, -0.053097810596227646, -0.8580831289291382, 0.0401981957256794, -0.10099862515926361, -0.5582042336463928, -0.11400463432073593, 0.6498710513114929, -0.3093549311161041, 0.030732307583093643, 0.3700258433818817, -0.19934476912021637, 0.6447796821594238, 0.3328549861907959, 0.3671971559524536, -0.33619004487991333, 0.8937618136405945, 0.6072797775268555, -0.10137899965047836, 0.30527299642562866, 0.09739992767572403, -0.4817167818546295, 0.1925831139087677, 0.04403716325759888, 0.27853134274482727, 0.47261589765548706, -0.31620603799819946, -0.31370413303375244, 0.77501380443573, -0.527097225189209, 0.06243633106350899, -0.35203471779823303, 0.3306041657924652, -0.18572799861431122, 0.29426053166389465, -0.08809265494346619, 1.1170443296432495, 0.4470386505126953, 0.1479322463274002, -0.16975310444831848, 0.03351793438196182, -0.603356122970581, 0.2728804349899292, -0.11459462344646454, 0.6347357630729675, 0.08277207612991333, -0.41815829277038574, -0.6154689788818359, -0.9371548295021057, 0.2656853497028351, 0.09238507598638535, -0.6190687417984009, -0.5492032170295715, 0.05754704028367996, 0.6022739410400391, 0.326337605714798, 0.6499704122543335, -0.09302757680416107, -0.14152224361896515, 0.8647212982177734, 0.3954370319843292, -0.01792110502719879, 0.8407043814659119, 0.5101633071899414, 0.4125822186470032, 0.18695418536663055, -0.009868213906884193, 0.38051313161849976, 0.10085699707269669, -0.34960129857063293, -0.636673629283905, -0.19638533890247345, 0.0016079556662589312, -0.6672763228416443, 0.3440893888473511, -0.03742095082998276, -0.24234247207641602, -0.12977510690689087, -0.54686039686203, -0.9479832649230957, -0.011615478433668613, 0.7858772873878479, -0.309420645236969, 0.36859652400016785, 0.4346361458301544, -0.3252578377723694, 0.3908029794692993, -0.5825250744819641, 4.1837334632873535, 0.5109241604804993, 0.0016400109743699431, -0.45676860213279724, 0.10929922014474869, 0.6778264045715332, 1.2157065868377686, 0.298671692609787, 0.08518259972333908, -0.04300867021083832, -0.3518652021884918, 0.8522576689720154, -0.26129278540611267, -0.15638747811317444, 0.6143673658370972, 0.4092399775981903, -0.6855494976043701, 0.09841486066579819, -0.5058180093765259, -0.9003990292549133, -0.5028321146965027, 0.4668799042701721, -0.04978441447019577, -0.015451673418283463, -0.035103339701890945, -0.48525482416152954, 0.14364367723464966, 0.6004514694213867, -0.29396119713783264, 0.1021144762635231, -0.15177635848522186, -0.3069067895412445, 0.5549005270004272, -0.7970999479293823, -0.23217885196208954, 0.5091087222099304, 0.3236738443374634, -0.5078204870223999, -0.4252537190914154, -0.18465666472911835, -0.21717588603496552, 0.3300430476665497, 0.05236272141337395, -0.4000178277492523, -0.27546969056129456, 0.1856800615787506, 0.24042236804962158, 0.4301682710647583, 0.683444619178772, -0.24379530549049377, 0.9067221283912659, -0.860673725605011, -0.10391593724489212, -0.04404222220182419, -0.7933421730995178, -0.35392940044403076, -0.012813941575586796, -0.7667484879493713, 0.18578976392745972, 0.1480340212583542, 0.8129758834838867, 0.6745657920837402, 0.2809125483036041, -0.3782868981361389, 0.7519751191139221, 0.19269807636737823, 0.8366932272911072, 0.920905351638794, -0.047715846449136734, 0.12158700823783875, -0.2845273017883301, -0.3063165247440338, -1.0317527055740356, 0.00203789584338665, 0.7959836721420288, 0.818825900554657, 0.37046879529953003, 0.5365103483200073, -0.5859560370445251, -0.502794086933136, -0.15761706233024597, 0.7733674645423889, 0.30519169569015503, 0.691733717918396, 0.177976593375206, 0.5956887602806091, -0.20305253565311432, -0.5479460954666138, -1.0975046157836914, 0.48591113090515137, 0.7131197452545166, -0.16366934776306152, -0.24425743520259857, 0.3630334436893463, 0.0023407917469739914 ]
{"Title": "Personalized Connectome Mapping to Guide Targeted Therapy and Promote Recovery of Consciousness in the Intensive Care Unit", "Authors": "Edlow Brian L., Barra Megan E., Zhou David W., Snider Samuel B., Threlkeld Zachary D., Kirsch John E., Chan Suk-tak, Meisler Steven L., Bleck Thomas P., Fins Joseph J., Giacino Joseph T., Hochberg Leigh R., Solt Ken, Brown Emery N., Bodien Yelena G.", "Abstract": "Abstract There are currently no therapies proven to promote early recovery of consciousness in patients with severe brain injuries in the intensive care unit (ICU). Early recovery of consciousness would benefit patients and families by reducing the likelihood of premature withdrawal of life-sustaining therapy and may decrease ICU complications related to immobility, facilitate self-expression, enable autonomous decision-making, and increase access to rehabilitative care. Here, we present the connectome-based clinical trial platform (CCTP), a new mechanistic paradigm for developing and testing targeted therapies that promote early recovery of consciousness in the ICU. The scientific premise of the CCTP is that personalized brain connectome maps can be used to select patients for targeted therapies that promote recovery of consciousness. Structural and functional MRI connectome maps will identify circuits that may be amenable to neuromodulation. Patients will be selected for clinical trials in the CCTP paradigm based on connectomes that are likely to respond to targeted therapies. To demonstrate the utility of this precision approach, we describe STIMPACT ( S timulant T herapy Targeted to Individualized Connectivity M aps to P romote Re ACT ivation of Consciousness), a CCTP-based clinical trial in which intravenous methylphenidate will be used to promote early recovery of consciousness in the ICU (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03814356). We propose that the CCTP has the potential to transform the therapeutic landscape in the ICU and improve outcomes for patients with severe brain injuries.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013987"}
10.1101/19007955
[ 0.23281608521938324, -0.12444856762886047, -0.3579375743865967, 0.091647207736969, -0.660509467124939, 0.14900104701519012, -0.26337870955467224, 0.06668946892023087, 0.20856577157974243, 0.8666155338287354, 0.12683254480361938, -0.43966710567474365, 0.7808108925819397, -0.27366340160369873, -0.17905685305595398, -0.06186510622501373, -0.8216901421546936, -0.5966013669967651, -0.643440842628479, 0.28219014406204224, -0.3443785309791565, 0.5482336282730103, -0.9534268379211426, 0.009311133995652199, -0.44855618476867676, 0.6835945844650269, 0.11080785095691681, -0.09458430856466293, 1.289339542388916, 0.4675743281841278, 0.5797036290168762, 0.010237668640911579, 0.06175442039966583, -0.3729395866394043, -0.22718527913093567, 0.06133193150162697, 0.5977626442909241, -1.1600866317749023, 0.35849106311798096, 0.015323756262660027, 1.0075440406799316, 0.21247228980064392, 0.6985834240913391, -1.218083381652832, -1.1790722608566284, -0.2749274671077728, 0.7882359027862549, 0.22993691265583038, -0.4957455098628998, -0.37988319993019104, -0.29787251353263855, 0.26545554399490356, -0.11901542544364929, -0.5475642681121826, -0.19096821546554565, 0.19345776736736298, -0.06296706944704056, -0.9733336567878723, -0.6460404992103577, 0.40277424454689026, 0.196641743183136, -0.30369502305984497, 0.5872200131416321, -0.7420302033424377, 0.31129536032676697, -0.23760800063610077, -0.22579292953014374, 0.017947211861610413, 0.11881422996520996, -0.5960630178451538, -0.8382291793823242, 0.04554368183016777, 0.4290638267993927, -0.32454586029052734, -0.8036032915115356, 0.017958899959921837, 0.5746465921401978, -0.5555299520492554, -0.2962538003921509, 0.020540032535791397, 0.5257304310798645, 0.10191154479980469, 0.44771820306777954, 0.08169477432966232, -0.781303346157074, -0.08815637230873108, -0.020826758816838264, 0.3589553236961365, -0.2175929844379425, 0.50539630651474, -0.15301690995693207, 0.4980413019657135, -0.6470184326171875, 0.6273276209831238, 0.4207092225551605, 1.0374374389648438, 0.011448676697909832, -0.6116266250610352, 0.39473721385002136, -0.5564562678337097, 0.8006691336631775, 1.4650416374206543, -0.4325602948665619, 0.24356594681739807, -0.9280506372451782, 0.1949326992034912, 0.3106161057949066, -0.11915119737386703, 0.2607732117176056, -0.8057310581207275, -0.3499287962913513, 0.7302430272102356, -0.298502117395401, -0.5559683442115784, -0.47042128443717957, 0.34760385751724243, 0.5283250212669373, -0.011644774116575718, -0.5082505345344543, 0.16517092287540436, -0.19429679214954376, 0.7852678894996643, 0.14430586993694305, 0.059758007526397705, 0.6859687566757202, 0.10946035385131836, 0.1733790636062622, 1.5200347900390625, -0.2702372372150421, -0.660755455493927, -0.6646296977996826, -0.3012407422065735, -0.7225126028060913, 0.34980112314224243, 0.17446744441986084, 0.3171529173851013, 0.1322464942932129, 0.6053549647331238, 0.7960788607597351, -0.2246222198009491, 0.05980747938156128, 1.1162834167480469, -0.12065912783145905, 0.9776193499565125, 0.44317927956581116, -0.08067985624074936, -0.2524798512458801, -0.843390166759491, -0.4900783896446228, -0.13772130012512207, 0.04557028412818909, -0.05282214656472206, -0.3302616477012634, 0.4761427938938141, -0.04973756521940231, 0.4211854934692383, -0.08135029673576355, 0.4141525626182556, -0.4496336877346039, -0.22303473949432373, 0.09761139750480652, -0.34261801838874817, 0.022657234221696854, 0.7104572057723999, 0.19660525023937225, 0.9891924262046814, 0.563428521156311, 0.03192797303199768, 0.7480330467224121, -0.752055823802948, 0.5044469833374023, -0.02745576575398445, 0.10464202612638474, 0.0689801499247551, 0.0548924095928669, 0.5540612936019897, 0.8113675713539124, 0.03752433508634567, 0.23707903921604156, 0.20887984335422516, -0.016164813190698624, -0.8890812397003174, 1.377419114112854, 0.6536829471588135, 0.7478193044662476, 0.9352827668190002, -0.32805803418159485, -0.13079555332660675, -0.3621774911880493, -0.2915365397930145, -0.13913822174072266, 0.9627077579498291, -0.8539463877677917, 0.2987513244152069, 0.45901966094970703, -0.25695884227752686, -0.750064492225647, 0.05800621956586838, 0.8834643363952637, -0.589768648147583, -0.4338853657245636, 0.6452772617340088, -0.1386977583169937, 0.7827139496803284, 0.4598008394241333, 0.3375205993652344, -0.9370229244232178, 0.3473200798034668, -0.5739621520042419, 0.05792427808046341, 0.3655397593975067, 0.23001797497272491, -0.13850043714046478, -0.3242008686065674, 0.6345059871673584, -0.6523768305778503, -0.3215453326702118, 0.05246413126587868, 0.2532352805137634, 0.02492992952466011, -0.14777731895446777, -0.20804275572299957, 0.2954072058200836, -0.32007402181625366, 0.33557334542274475, 0.4679073393344879, 0.630117654800415, 0.4517063796520233, -0.4948854446411133, 0.16099050641059875, 0.5157945156097412, 0.4032961428165436, -0.1428535133600235, 0.7356212735176086, 0.9334729313850403, 0.356030136346817, 0.1516714245080948, 0.20856690406799316, 0.7246918082237244, 0.14583609998226166, 0.49923762679100037, -0.13686694204807281, 0.9264693856239319, 0.6719646453857422, 0.04512908309698105, 1.1347938776016235, -0.06309214979410172, -0.013357851654291153, 0.025870900601148605, -0.5934141278266907, -0.48494407534599304, 0.6278697848320007, 0.483956903219223, 0.05179592967033386, -0.11820825934410095, 0.35087668895721436, 0.8108189105987549, 0.5679377317428589, -0.45720210671424866, -0.0891946479678154, -0.5266942977905273, 0.4974062740802765, -0.938227117061615, 0.6668562889099121, 0.7617289423942566, 0.5410152077674866, -0.008697735145688057, 0.334872305393219, 0.3823343515396118, -0.22795890271663666, -0.8522269129753113, -0.9844252467155457, -1.535178303718567, -0.4061262011528015, -0.9092388153076172, -0.028339382261037827, -0.6212298274040222, -0.3699582517147064, 0.20087328553199768, -0.09565469622612, -0.2276359647512436, 0.0883917585015297, 0.2219454050064087, 0.3760406970977783, 0.3630742132663727, 0.3684287369251251, -1.6201038360595703, 0.33837568759918213, -0.34995442628860474, -0.01876690424978733, -0.7831825613975525, 0.4392232298851013, -0.04558628052473068, -1.0368623733520508, 0.8875653743743896, -0.10236094892024994, 0.2846304774284363, 0.5638241171836853, -1.414014220237732, -0.8791552186012268, 1.0026180744171143, 0.28565242886543274, 0.8796740770339966, -0.27156350016593933, -0.6162990927696228, 1.267618179321289, -0.07861728966236115, 0.14924301207065582, 0.7168698906898499, 0.3148685693740845, -0.8995732069015503, 1.0360307693481445, -0.13040433824062347, 0.003997019492089748, -1.0133070945739746, -0.19313988089561462, 0.34058576822280884, -0.012660449370741844, -0.16480356454849243, -0.6001516580581665, -0.6389856934547424, -0.25664031505584717, -0.10100223124027252, -0.2459050863981247, 0.6187507510185242, 0.03958864137530327, 0.6951824426651001, -0.9937354922294617, 0.1559150367975235, -1.2793601751327515, -0.5007016658782959, -0.6329252123832703, -0.13578878343105316, 0.02509324997663498, 0.006566149182617664, 0.27621960639953613, -1.0446743965148926, 0.41194307804107666, 0.5289884209632874, 0.15724852681159973, 0.7456541657447815, -0.14613264799118042, -0.21649442613124847, 0.6186164617538452, -0.010857277549803257, -0.06503458321094513, -0.48973527550697327, -0.01044178381562233, -1.0716872215270996, 0.18870797753334045, -0.4427744448184967, -0.5635205507278442, 0.8566014170646667, 0.18388181924819946, -0.15071052312850952, 0.16405177116394043, -0.5398199558258057, -0.053032223135232925, 0.28106483817100525, 0.5607603788375854, -0.223183274269104, 0.7466968297958374, -0.04907110705971718, -0.034317225217819214, -1.2563773393630981, -0.833492636680603, 0.10165563225746155, 1.000921368598938, 0.3000873923301697, -0.9866705536842346, 0.4571883976459503, -0.4203636348247528, -0.2424781620502472, 0.2630303204059601, -0.46327030658721924, -0.398503839969635, 0.6292696595191956, 0.27587705850601196, 1.1207140684127808, -1.0132390260696411, 0.009392245672643185, -0.17640849947929382, 0.9394915699958801, 0.22384659945964813, 0.13383372128009796, 0.06012171879410744, -0.024595957249403, 0.6747294068336487, 0.29392722249031067, -0.6026390790939331, -0.1528317630290985, -0.2026088684797287, 0.18557317554950714, -0.459317147731781, -0.08821211755275726, -0.7590351700782776, 0.17185203731060028, 0.6987489461898804, 0.44837820529937744, -0.054462023079395294, 0.5461771488189697, -0.7765121459960938, -0.1793367862701416, 0.7738974094390869, 0.9277547001838684, -0.06442830711603165, -0.868989884853363, -0.10964463651180267, -0.37082043290138245, 0.13713997602462769, -0.24618564546108246, -0.031237907707691193, -0.28364309668540955, 0.41653475165367126, -0.05781565606594086, -0.059172097593545914, 0.09305556118488312, -0.6806679964065552, -0.17514216899871826, 0.43984073400497437, -0.31507590413093567, -0.2461811602115631, -1.0817887783050537, 0.9565891027450562, -0.24591870605945587, -0.3899815082550049, -0.1841106116771698, -0.5795806050300598, 0.413821816444397, 0.44837215542793274, -0.4016580879688263, -0.434054434299469, 0.22189831733703613, -0.12453127652406693, -0.024988491088151932, -0.1426188349723816, -0.06869305670261383, -0.3110322654247284, 0.24305272102355957, -0.31834080815315247, -0.19445908069610596, 0.05934352055191994, -0.3143748939037323, -0.0705353319644928, 0.12427391856908798, 0.6037932634353638, 1.6672816276550293, 0.1961567997932434, -0.48142072558403015, -0.2679274082183838, 0.19581913948059082, -0.6673447489738464, 0.2978415787220001, -0.008877680636942387, -0.2588807940483093, -0.2993701994419098, -0.7593104839324951, -0.19253003597259521, -0.13905148208141327, -0.07929832488298416, -0.6258302927017212, -0.4064689874649048, 0.5725470185279846, 0.32418930530548096, -0.567602276802063, 0.2012639194726944, -0.2291722297668457, -0.26874256134033203, 0.2694365978240967, 0.2036736011505127, -0.8424400091171265, -0.4914243817329407, -0.03178558498620987, -1.0856465101242065, 0.6432979106903076, -0.613581120967865, 0.1430881917476654, 0.8976784944534302, -1.263144612312317, 0.25034236907958984, -0.14207227528095245, 0.33527857065200806, -0.3124353587627411, -0.5638628005981445, -0.1749117523431778, -0.25563856959342957, -0.5107773542404175, -0.30316734313964844, -1.301422357559204, -0.07457199692726135, -0.18931537866592407, -0.024570966139435768, -0.1718522310256958, 0.19301751255989075, -0.09522729367017746, -0.44444993138313293, -0.08900678157806396, -0.8595438003540039, -0.07963324338197708, 0.47820085287094116, 0.7580990791320801, -0.39123567938804626, -0.7180664539337158, -0.330104261636734, 0.729735791683197, -0.7711876630783081, -0.24563191831111908, -0.15460440516471863, 0.060263872146606445, -0.11096341907978058, -0.48014727234840393, 0.20521126687526703, -0.26085543632507324, 0.5466283559799194, 0.5546148419380188, -0.10946446657180786, 0.25053903460502625, -0.1523706018924713, -0.7416853308677673, 0.7019603848457336, -0.3182556629180908, 0.06613606959581375, -1.6102136373519897, 0.4054555892944336, -0.19400344789028168, 0.43098342418670654, -0.4850313663482666, -0.15144380927085876, -0.15106019377708435, -0.8722871541976929, -0.3882226347923279, -0.5652139782905579, 0.09269756078720093, 0.0875169113278389, -0.40180468559265137, 0.15213902294635773, -0.08120453357696533, 0.6295206546783447, 0.8551826477050781, 0.4567290246486664, -0.6493593454360962, -0.1338546872138977, 0.12949974834918976, -0.16083508729934692, 0.17755219340324402, 0.08530718088150024, -0.4361787438392639, 0.8074414134025574, 1.4324318170547485, -0.49987244606018066, -0.17953117191791534, 0.13472342491149902, 0.48866569995880127, -0.07654967159032822, -0.537152886390686, -0.45070555806159973, 0.12102862447500229, 0.2016562670469284, 0.2295588254928589, 0.03283929079771042, -0.9274188876152039, 1.078802227973938, -0.19965188205242157, 0.7015075087547302, 0.10012629628181458, -0.3039298951625824, -0.3436702787876129, -0.7612556219100952, 1.1930670738220215, 0.2434781789779663, 0.3423718214035034, -0.48514503240585327, -0.26494622230529785, 0.657262921333313, -0.4477965533733368, -0.9171950817108154, -0.2579568028450012, -0.5332364439964294, -1.2510899305343628, -0.4287867844104767, -0.24368801712989807, 0.3146875500679016, 0.02035527303814888, -0.012456187047064304, -0.03329746052622795, 0.12546943128108978, 1.1088612079620361, 0.6041622161865234, -0.1887296587228775, -0.03258134052157402, -0.0033317587804049253, 0.2623615264892578, 0.5261465311050415, -0.06620713323354721, 0.5314562916755676, -0.6178721189498901, 0.6678658127784729, 0.25085675716400146, 0.10995461791753769, -0.44357746839523315, -0.4006367623806, -0.18702761828899384, 0.5684646964073181, -0.16518814861774445, -0.014397322200238705, 0.021886948496103287, -0.45855164527893066, -0.43399980664253235, 0.019278446212410927, -0.08228529244661331, 0.25906893610954285, 0.3908478617668152, -0.23682740330696106, -0.5602714419364929, -0.26132309436798096, -0.1148761659860611, 0.06785591691732407, 0.6880216002464294, 0.4247576892375946, 0.17533192038536072, -1.1573227643966675, -0.18156735599040985, 0.4658307731151581, -0.894237756729126, -0.027370022609829903, 0.3295826315879822, -0.16240674257278442, 0.3951479196548462, -0.1560908854007721, -0.111720971763134, 0.42948076128959656, -0.06491804867982864, 0.46755287051200867, -0.15343134105205536, -0.9075270295143127, -0.19385863840579987, -0.10667198151350021, 0.49006760120391846, -0.4275180697441101, -0.04379831627011299, 0.2758287191390991, -0.4631821811199188, 0.6029350757598877, 0.08579359948635101, -0.6673704385757446, 0.25974270701408386, -0.5846471190452576, 0.7330335378646851, -0.7380831837654114, -0.3721470236778259, 0.29546162486076355, -0.21730853617191315, -0.1864786446094513, 0.24611856043338776, -1.2749298810958862, 0.5878923535346985, -0.7726033926010132, -0.3764675557613373, -0.27492785453796387, -0.1504305750131607, 0.3427848815917969, 0.11994900554418564, -0.36891958117485046, -0.5891501903533936, 0.7469804883003235, 0.5374340415000916, 1.0218242406845093, -0.6760652661323547, -1.2597132921218872, -0.9573550224304199, -0.03266606479883194, -0.02624904364347458, -0.6471278667449951, -0.3897354304790497, 0.2861374318599701, 1.2986799478530884, -0.7792962193489075, 0.697047770023346, 1.3323724269866943, -0.6725199222564697, 0.15410563349723816, -0.8502927422523499, 0.1566222608089447, -0.18020720779895782, -0.7748778462409973, -0.6985405087471008, -0.13361266255378723, 0.6170826554298401, 1.0648446083068848, -0.39271828532218933, 0.6306359171867371, -0.0698443278670311, 0.8568833470344543, -0.3437829613685608, 0.520074725151062, -0.936068594455719, 0.018978631123900414, 0.3693403899669647, 0.7134520411491394, 0.2711807191371918, 0.03782787546515465, 0.16835539042949677, -0.5547259449958801, -0.011607171967625618, 0.4699290990829468, -0.447061687707901, -1.0227597951889038, 0.6165140271186829, -0.06182366609573364, -1.0820286273956299, -1.199220895767212, -0.07709623128175735, 0.10358480364084244, -0.5118337869644165, 0.46271613240242004, -0.09787590801715851, 0.2513720691204071, -0.4683920741081238, -0.10753004997968674, 0.5629189014434814, 1.0928179025650024, 0.13197825849056244, 0.7891853451728821, 0.2781943678855896, 0.5883467197418213, -0.42643895745277405, 0.30228257179260254, 0.16732393205165863, -0.20780959725379944, -0.24677181243896484, -0.7614270448684692, 0.255535364151001, 0.8370440602302551, -0.553832471370697, 0.574203372001648, 0.005706151016056538, 0.47961482405662537, -0.009227512404322624, 0.13055598735809326, 0.3567411005496979, 1.0121722221374512, -0.3988916575908661, -0.602925717830658, 0.16255034506320953, -0.5279566049575806, -0.003833519760519266, -0.4501707851886749, -0.7499402165412903, -0.361632376909256, 0.13374535739421844, -0.5104535222053528, -0.6537197828292847, -0.9693129658699036, -0.547023594379425, 0.32656329870224, -0.3907935917377472, 0.08344176411628723, -0.6674849987030029, 1.0414354801177979, 0.049812860786914825, -0.04126911237835884, 0.18947429955005646, -0.9289747476577759, 0.019056275486946106, -0.09344187378883362, -0.5547627806663513, -0.3247554898262024, 0.42671510577201843, 0.0949520692229271, 0.9292242527008057, 0.033810805529356, -0.1689920425415039, 0.028554582968354225, 0.07451660186052322, 0.49645039439201355, -0.20195402204990387, 0.520578145980835, -0.9030953049659729, -0.47208696603775024, 0.11788109689950943, 0.06200107932090759, -0.6846958994865417, -0.09131301194429398, 0.6169058680534363, -0.5200211405754089, -0.9490582942962646, -0.09237851947546005, 0.6818702816963196, -0.6430384516716003, 0.2320779711008072, 0.09744078665971756, 0.9084938764572144, 0.21647483110427856, -0.3536835014820099, 0.8226675391197205, 0.058319222182035446, 0.395815372467041, -0.25909823179244995, -0.05008605122566223, -0.3034324049949646, 0.767482340335846, -0.4898604452610016, 0.3073296844959259, 0.23804020881652832, 0.25921913981437683, 0.1569235473871231, 0.05339891090989113, 0.0939624235033989, 0.137651726603508, 0.2854655086994171, -0.193288192152977, 0.08615847676992416, -0.9303930401802063, 0.13081543147563934, 0.3447369635105133, 0.41828587651252747, 0.1490340381860733, -0.09292814880609512, -0.6718713641166687, 0.12774422764778137, -0.5986955761909485, 0.4066247344017029, 0.017081115394830704, 0.5228205323219299, 0.08723964542150497, 0.5736498236656189, 0.10276838392019272, -0.38119158148765564, 0.3124254047870636, -0.09482051432132721, -0.3146306276321411, -0.45515236258506775, 0.17295974493026733, -0.17980872094631195, -0.050488412380218506, -0.7075997591018677, -0.33662500977516174, 0.09429887682199478, -0.13968485593795776, 0.16331720352172852, -0.40117910504341125, 0.8471552729606628, -0.20510931313037872, -0.18954263627529144, 0.03776451200246811, 0.07326597720384598, -0.06468026340007782, -0.05167480930685997, 0.4683714210987091, -0.7182384729385376, -0.6678261160850525, -0.19852495193481445, 0.6675055623054504, 0.1322672814130783, 0.6370398998260498, 0.7113862633705139, 0.5190157890319824, 0.25464311242103577, 0.6324954032897949, 0.5832183361053467, -0.20173534750938416, 0.21893683075904846, -0.6419742703437805, 0.5709520578384399, -0.15996073186397552, 0.36622363328933716, 0.3777727484703064, -0.21154466271400452, -0.7973888516426086, 0.5506651997566223, -0.19104254245758057, -0.6395103931427002, -0.04425283893942833, -0.2665005922317505, 0.9428440928459167, 0.26728296279907227, -0.12596651911735535, 0.2626350522041321, 0.2920474410057068, 0.7680666446685791, 0.14244648814201355, -0.21018639206886292, -0.13911691308021545, 0.5478941202163696, -0.5928270816802979, 0.10298138856887817, -0.6857642531394958, -1.1408448219299316, -0.8367862701416016, -0.8038949966430664, 0.2912832200527191, 0.12936216592788696, -0.2260781079530716, -0.5520109534263611, -0.012037649750709534, -0.431284099817276, 0.4486957788467407, -0.35510390996932983, -0.009087328799068928, -0.6512002348899841, 0.17032170295715332, 0.534447431564331, 0.23919479548931122, 0.1331983208656311, -0.036424871534109116, 0.33400142192840576, 0.6697858572006226, -0.25901877880096436, -0.062086623162031174, 0.4158717691898346, -0.6758607625961304, -0.6231558918952942, -0.02713344618678093, 0.08037037402391434, -0.4109894633293152, -0.017315221950411797, 0.47624459862709045, -0.11714091151952744, -0.13076870143413544, -0.8194581270217896, -0.5918606519699097, -0.49967750906944275, 0.678903341293335, -0.6008774638175964, 0.6499515771865845, -0.45867103338241577, -0.6914440393447876, -0.14624768495559692, -0.4001806378364563, 4.073911666870117, 0.7774801850318909, -0.00956231914460659, -0.356751024723053, -0.04265930876135826, -0.11744821816682816, 0.5774378776550293, 0.07956152409315109, 0.5150303840637207, -0.43543121218681335, 0.11262193322181702, 0.6181056499481201, 0.42499297857284546, 1.2095955610275269, 0.5679932236671448, -0.2132841944694519, -0.5551561117172241, 0.5456987023353577, -0.06263373792171478, -1.0284894704818726, -0.5130988955497742, 0.30456414818763733, -0.17668060958385468, 0.08695104718208313, 0.2765123248100281, -0.3807699680328369, 0.017538413405418396, 0.7536090612411499, 0.08825545012950897, 0.03421563655138016, -0.13655146956443787, 0.11488184332847595, -0.19371297955513, -1.0464789867401123, 0.268202006816864, -0.40962356328964233, 0.2236224263906479, -0.4889647364616394, 0.10600946098566055, 0.716362714767456, 0.39834627509117126, -0.5161690711975098, 0.3065113127231598, 0.23383228480815887, 0.2312040776014328, 0.11076252162456512, -0.24068301916122437, 0.6714523434638977, 0.3294949233531952, -0.2518615424633026, 0.6507923603057861, -1.0948004722595215, -0.006643590983003378, 0.4659174978733063, -0.3725653886795044, -0.12679332494735718, -0.21302783489227295, -0.7120444774627686, 0.2682593762874603, 0.9132950901985168, 0.5874083042144775, -0.05966312065720558, 0.5169301629066467, -0.30726107954978943, 0.24904975295066833, 0.646964430809021, 0.8909162282943726, 0.08144813776016235, -0.14088796079158783, -0.2581709623336792, 0.7823628187179565, 0.1237487718462944, -0.5617501139640808, -0.07953513413667679, 0.670853853225708, 0.2716202437877655, -0.7412980794906616, 0.6459295749664307, -0.6159375309944153, -0.9208817481994629, 0.30590540170669556, 0.3252412974834442, 0.21060551702976227, -0.20958098769187927, 0.21840022504329681, 0.8753681778907776, -0.9918014407157898, -0.1661747545003891, -0.6796439290046692, 0.5599956512451172, 0.721727192401886, -0.6307295560836792, -0.09815987944602966, -0.09743800014257431, 0.6582515835762024 ]
{"Title": "PROBLEM BASED LEARNING APPLIED TO PRACTICE IN MEDICAL SCHOOLS IN BRAZIL: A MINI-SYSTEMATIC REVIEW", "Authors": "Bussolaro Frederico Alberto, Thereza-Bussolaro Claudine", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Active learning is a well-established educational methodology in medical schools worldwide, although its implementation in Brazilian clinical settings is quite challenging. The objective of this study is to review the literature in a systematic manner to find and conduct a reflective analysis of how problem-based learning (PBL) has been applied to clinical teaching in medical schools in Brazil. Material & methods A systematic literature search was conducted in three databases. A total of 250 papers related to PBL in Brazilian medical schools were identified through the database searches. Four studies were finally selected for the review. Results Four fields of medicine were explored on the four selected papers: gynecology/family medicine, medical semiology, psychiatry, and pediatrics. Overall, all the papers reported some level of strategic adaptability of the original PBL methodology to be applied in the Brazilian medical school\u2019s curricula and to the peculiar characteristics specific to Brazil. Conclusion PBL application in Brazilian medical schools require some level of alteration from the original format, to better adapt to the characteristics of Brazilian students\u2019 maturity, health system priorities and the medical labor market.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007955"}
10.1101/19013516
[ -0.2984643876552582, -0.16328097879886627, -0.786059558391571, 0.1218162402510643, -0.7594946622848511, -0.5861736536026001, 0.48488762974739075, 0.2543870508670807, 0.20593349635601044, 0.16890230774879456, -0.11392129957675934, -0.21040768921375275, 0.4231153726577759, -0.32216036319732666, -0.14416132867336273, 0.21934661269187927, -0.9362480044364929, -0.32107388973236084, -0.06128285825252533, 0.6654306054115295, -0.24046368896961212, 0.209478497505188, -0.9134085178375244, 0.6333981156349182, -0.4374580681324005, 0.5191973447799683, 0.00038696127012372017, 0.05711724981665611, 0.7432087063789368, 0.452340692281723, -0.15265057981014252, 0.11879538744688034, 0.37541455030441284, -0.8946259617805481, 0.2790055572986603, -0.38805046677589417, 0.2581491470336914, -0.4951724708080292, -0.12236272543668747, 0.160652756690979, 0.023843780159950256, 0.09399621188640594, 0.2318469136953354, -0.8019930720329285, -0.5720429420471191, 0.14078494906425476, 0.14147798717021942, -0.297920823097229, 0.12260119616985321, -0.5687566995620728, -0.6474072933197021, -0.2015458047389984, -0.5192997455596924, -0.03465444967150688, -0.09642194211483002, 0.4213109314441681, 0.3808281421661377, -0.19162622094154358, -1.3664288520812988, 0.9659422039985657, 0.250173419713974, 0.6261513829231262, 0.8319347500801086, -1.0862891674041748, 0.9766552448272705, 0.2541259229183197, -0.47157150506973267, 0.6170833110809326, 0.08256560564041138, -0.8418328166007996, -0.2878182828426361, -0.7967109680175781, -0.45566150546073914, -0.5705438256263733, -0.4185895621776581, -0.2792215645313263, -0.19947278499603271, -0.17479020357131958, 0.0763157457113266, -0.26454195380210876, 0.5167457461357117, 0.49923962354660034, -0.1739000678062439, -0.513337254524231, -0.7589874267578125, 0.2818605303764343, 0.016218146309256554, 0.2706978917121887, 0.27892741560935974, 0.43551406264305115, -0.5088967680931091, 0.7371091842651367, -0.025327391922473907, 0.4296630620956421, 0.5698633193969727, 0.7825572490692139, -0.710719883441925, 0.116400808095932, 0.28174248337745667, 0.24226915836334229, 0.5713371634483337, 0.5287057757377625, -0.17635534703731537, 0.8434141278266907, -0.5409559011459351, 0.48356473445892334, 0.5620620846748352, -0.6716694235801697, 0.12977784872055054, -0.6845665574073792, 0.10927464067935944, 0.011079879477620125, -0.6504612565040588, -0.016676627099514008, -0.12405045330524445, 0.38683706521987915, -0.33815404772758484, 0.7531858086585999, 0.09535228461027145, 0.7664629220962524, -0.08473042398691177, 0.5971653461456299, 0.8020316362380981, 0.09835828095674515, 0.640745222568512, -0.1841510683298111, 0.4278620779514313, 0.14827053248882294, -0.32100367546081543, -0.17252303659915924, 0.4188453257083893, -0.5169370770454407, 0.35798755288124084, 0.3853611648082733, -0.46930408477783203, 0.03525180369615555, 0.5301094651222229, 0.4077286720275879, 0.25736352801322937, 0.0806238129734993, -0.2602185010910034, 0.6722331643104553, -0.1732371300458908, 0.8764040470123291, -0.1432999223470688, 0.7644338011741638, -0.6169118881225586, -0.2519321143627167, -0.8870829343795776, -0.5416271686553955, 0.645308792591095, 0.6657261252403259, -0.05635976418852806, 0.11475730687379837, 0.4052853286266327, 0.23826608061790466, -0.1999472677707672, 0.321879118680954, 0.5499240159988403, -0.1899755448102951, 0.08720120787620544, -0.22155733406543732, -0.44526734948158264, 0.857072114944458, -0.4354763627052307, 0.4838031530380249, -0.07160928845405579, 0.4482315182685852, 0.711702823638916, -0.342520534992218, 0.7066671252250671, 0.16676965355873108, -0.2801870107650757, 0.007819251157343388, 0.5482470393180847, 1.039479374885559, 0.38830891251564026, -0.1848764419555664, 0.31145814061164856, 0.05684578791260719, -0.03704198822379112, -0.06465232372283936, -0.49479445815086365, 0.626554012298584, -0.16509762406349182, 0.1777760535478592, 0.525169849395752, -0.5041821599006653, -0.3843364715576172, -0.7385455369949341, 0.21360795199871063, 0.23414133489131927, -0.7876932621002197, 0.20900608599185944, -0.26685863733291626, -0.5137046575546265, -0.40714967250823975, 0.29866936802864075, -0.1566290408372879, 0.015180321410298347, -0.5199043154716492, 0.04276365786790848, -0.07861629873514175, 1.041704773902893, 0.5520833134651184, 0.15824054181575775, -0.05850416049361229, 0.24175819754600525, -0.179468035697937, 0.2927842438220978, 0.41931405663490295, 0.3121555745601654, 0.061776455491781235, -0.26515358686447144, 0.9018784761428833, -0.09112432599067688, 0.12483834475278854, 0.23745876550674438, -0.8367776870727539, 0.08372155576944351, -0.06578607857227325, -0.05517676845192909, -0.026739727705717087, -0.2947379946708679, 0.1371716558933258, 0.006687293294817209, 0.16660092771053314, 0.2850162386894226, -0.6861101984977722, -0.6532703042030334, 0.5189113616943359, 0.19933727383613586, 0.13194218277931213, 0.8111903667449951, 0.5471921563148499, 0.42232030630111694, 0.25381526350975037, -0.3039453625679016, 0.9478827118873596, -0.14302434027194977, 0.47865089774131775, 0.31296050548553467, 0.5480397343635559, 0.29802459478378296, -0.600659966468811, 0.18427607417106628, -0.21081756055355072, 0.13372114300727844, -0.05958933383226395, 0.42819344997406006, -0.1552877277135849, 0.8209876418113708, 0.8903904557228088, 1.0599453449249268, -0.5108649730682373, 0.39864450693130493, 0.3990439176559448, -0.21778661012649536, 0.09301517903804779, -0.34448039531707764, 0.27807721495628357, 0.4255030155181885, 0.0051239412277936935, 0.16138970851898193, 0.6032396554946899, 0.19404560327529907, -0.09625967592000961, 0.3061467111110687, 0.6632422208786011, -0.26863181591033936, -0.341798335313797, -0.07260312885046005, -1.2862821817398071, -0.8159716129302979, -0.43053191900253296, 0.2474006712436676, 0.7086941003799438, -0.24004524946212769, 0.3950548768043518, 0.4844881594181061, 0.1870349496603012, -0.4947173595428467, 0.2249315083026886, 0.45198938250541687, 0.4355824887752533, 0.056548357009887695, -0.6213410496711731, -0.2914780080318451, -0.45587587356567383, -0.16016404330730438, 0.2743581533432007, -0.45502832531929016, -0.5263499617576599, -0.5347808003425598, 0.14964953064918518, 0.08925211429595947, 0.047169603407382965, 0.4275365173816681, -0.2544262111186981, -0.6157528758049011, -0.23065420985221863, -0.610357940196991, -0.4101687967777252, -0.6440100073814392, -0.43090298771858215, 0.7687991261482239, 0.7193628549575806, 0.5577436685562134, 0.33866700530052185, 0.4011000692844391, 0.4710773527622223, 0.27301025390625, 0.17572885751724243, -0.08024615049362183, -0.8422049283981323, -0.5474261045455933, 0.540132462978363, -0.3966899812221527, -0.11647812277078629, -0.6043484210968018, -1.2785905599594116, 0.6527690887451172, -0.11273259669542313, -0.5428037047386169, 0.18193309009075165, -0.2995629906654358, -0.23964451253414154, -1.6154913902282715, -0.12956000864505768, -0.1888648271560669, -0.7263785004615784, 0.08814217150211334, -0.4394822418689728, 0.11126159131526947, -0.14180956780910492, 0.10719892382621765, -0.018702303990721703, -0.17820347845554352, 0.6393994092941284, -0.5512052774429321, 0.44142574071884155, -0.18903058767318726, -0.35134318470954895, 0.20526324212551117, -0.033704597502946854, 0.7806662917137146, 0.3489682078361511, -0.11160881072282791, -0.1972525417804718, -0.10764051973819733, -0.2172183245420456, -0.09406393766403198, 0.4186059534549713, -0.480281800031662, -0.5208650827407837, 0.8340928554534912, -0.1759890764951706, -0.06933057308197021, 0.06598872691392899, 0.3536754846572876, -0.21487493813037872, -0.3519093692302704, -0.44029757380485535, 0.07982520759105682, -0.77350914478302, -1.0093364715576172, 0.8236870765686035, -0.043939001858234406, 0.9209285378456116, -0.7862870693206787, 0.20080552995204926, -0.6942309737205505, 0.06279938668012619, 0.028951121494174004, 0.12236471474170685, 0.15485431253910065, 0.9875204563140869, -0.12195099890232086, 0.4953962564468384, -1.0191314220428467, 0.6129645109176636, 0.21836994588375092, 0.7771453857421875, 0.45048788189888, -0.33814337849617004, 0.21218760311603546, -0.4848901927471161, 0.2239980548620224, 0.15183638036251068, -0.5356362462043762, -0.016299905255436897, 0.08515110611915588, 0.6030300259590149, -0.01732027344405651, -0.7426764965057373, -0.4031716585159302, 0.38519781827926636, 0.0669904425740242, 0.9054874181747437, 0.09678326547145844, 0.21343623101711273, -0.015823591500520706, 0.06238879635930061, 1.058463454246521, -0.22577017545700073, -0.16731898486614227, -0.3231355845928192, 0.1887742429971695, -0.3532094657421112, -0.3921046853065491, -0.5019790530204773, -1.292201042175293, -0.02328413352370262, -0.12865279614925385, 0.5815504789352417, 0.15015190839767456, -0.20582586526870728, -0.31759753823280334, 0.1923273801803589, -0.41691917181015015, 0.49025753140449524, 0.1528402417898178, -1.0451104640960693, 0.0494965985417366, -0.30092495679855347, 0.13675495982170105, -0.08778056502342224, -0.6666758060455322, 0.591768205165863, 0.8857606649398804, -0.11627442389726639, -0.7801178097724915, -0.014485358260571957, 0.6091684699058533, -0.12000825256109238, -0.1881422996520996, -0.29966700077056885, -0.5963717103004456, -0.24506554007530212, -0.30330079793930054, 0.18831051886081696, -0.5638764500617981, -0.1004420667886734, -0.11600558459758759, -0.09939397871494293, 0.3269827663898468, 0.9154157638549805, 0.5488018989562988, -0.5019010901451111, 0.4137030243873596, 0.4646202027797699, -1.09853196144104, -0.18420445919036865, -0.18916627764701843, -0.7057920694351196, -0.467089980840683, -0.4313421845436096, 0.08309180289506912, -0.09161033481359482, -0.08953601121902466, -0.3374759256839752, -0.4479586184024811, -0.4916051924228668, 0.26787808537483215, -0.13445959985256195, 1.2824459075927734, -0.5572146773338318, -0.21242985129356384, 0.8839076161384583, -0.6562590599060059, -0.7122260332107544, -0.04461158066987991, -0.08282844722270966, -0.6627232432365417, 0.29913079738616943, -0.15312521159648895, -0.1089240163564682, -0.6470022797584534, -0.30073198676109314, 0.13449376821517944, 0.26871249079704285, -0.20475104451179504, 0.19566789269447327, -0.4153320789337158, -0.5937958359718323, -0.6468960642814636, -0.46620503067970276, 0.5395239591598511, -1.0585733652114868, 0.6503939032554626, -0.09759896993637085, -0.7842496633529663, -0.1349371075630188, -0.09639810770750046, -0.21228010952472687, -0.17708170413970947, 0.13898341357707977, -0.08983288705348969, 0.3674032390117645, -0.2944655120372772, 1.1475505828857422, -0.36962890625, -0.4002467095851898, -0.3067287802696228, 0.6277796030044556, -0.8079227209091187, -0.4966319501399994, -0.24108722805976868, 0.599323034286499, -0.01945178583264351, -0.09549928456544876, -0.023269668221473694, -0.4000716507434845, -0.10943340510129929, -0.17322351038455963, 0.17197422683238983, 0.8717209100723267, -0.4048705995082855, -0.4890751838684082, -0.0025162119418382645, -0.4631848633289337, -0.6258231401443481, -0.60524582862854, -0.2639700770378113, 0.1445893794298172, 0.7434430122375488, -0.3259819447994232, -0.3156639635562897, -0.1628989577293396, -1.209348440170288, -0.4098973274230957, -0.6785103678703308, -0.1276709884405136, -0.10626938194036484, -0.36420780420303345, -0.41608500480651855, 0.18429531157016754, 0.009092925116419792, 0.79942387342453, -0.8262453079223633, -0.15616314113140106, 0.24418066442012787, 0.25869789719581604, -0.07090957462787628, 0.10795033723115921, -0.24459035694599152, 0.14949281513690948, 0.9951118230819702, 0.9878180623054504, 0.09234658628702164, -0.24378693103790283, -0.7374779582023621, -0.007890094071626663, 0.2993720769882202, 0.03752966970205307, -0.38221827149391174, 0.5286425948143005, 0.5438156723976135, -0.35022875666618347, -0.3068121671676636, -1.3325307369232178, 0.7592210173606873, -0.29964685440063477, 0.0266916211694479, 0.05849355831742287, -0.32813143730163574, 0.1450895071029663, -0.46485042572021484, 0.6985295414924622, -0.23708930611610413, -0.15296512842178345, 0.36803358793258667, -0.37834349274635315, -0.16684438288211823, 0.1586734801530838, -0.861223578453064, -0.6622284650802612, -1.0345174074172974, -0.9611019492149353, 0.38605910539627075, 0.2558128535747528, -0.3355930745601654, 0.5371559262275696, 0.019036082550883293, 0.02294733002781868, -0.1277531385421753, 0.5447330474853516, 0.09653417766094208, -0.9355782270431519, -0.08863375335931778, 0.2467862069606781, 0.08468460291624069, 0.0021052630618214607, 0.09793499857187271, 0.013268984854221344, 0.15991558134555817, 0.12362600117921829, -0.017218181863427162, -0.2554949223995209, -0.9958341717720032, -0.4534533619880676, 0.4980924725532532, 0.764976978302002, 0.3497201204299927, 0.6514676213264465, 0.8340769410133362, -0.43966764211654663, -0.6297866106033325, 0.30645430088043213, -0.31561052799224854, -0.319420725107193, 1.080834984779358, 0.3885730803012848, -0.49278634786605835, 0.23008674383163452, 0.45589780807495117, 0.8191511631011963, -0.35901737213134766, -0.20619647204875946, 0.32198870182037354, -0.9756644368171692, 0.603177011013031, 0.08600124716758728, -0.9785678386688232, -0.6641439199447632, -0.5440289974212646, 0.08511810004711151, -0.5050793886184692, -0.40999096632003784, -0.3385840952396393, 0.5581022500991821, 0.6153249740600586, 0.8474834561347961, -0.5331313014030457, 0.1929081231355667, 0.21995800733566284, -0.5491015315055847, 0.769516110420227, -0.720193088054657, -0.40327051281929016, 0.5118319988250732, -0.8455345630645752, 0.8119304180145264, 0.5174676179885864, 1.0252494812011719, -0.17022883892059326, 0.5610137581825256, 0.3780174255371094, -0.519123375415802, -0.37834808230400085, 0.23369792103767395, 0.506855845451355, -0.09854354709386826, 0.2819085121154785, -0.282911092042923, 0.8516402244567871, 0.7007362246513367, -0.5071125030517578, -0.3535878658294678, 0.5804375410079956, 0.007288007996976376, 0.29232552647590637, -0.18235953152179718, -0.021322326734662056, 0.3502500355243683, 0.34078720211982727, 0.301437646150589, -0.013076758943498135, -1.0291231870651245, -0.26164349913597107, -0.35037535429000854, -0.452392578125, -0.6316347122192383, -0.42596450448036194, 0.6853994727134705, 0.04337386041879654, -0.9407315850257874, -0.11558864265680313, 1.3139406442642212, -0.13149882853031158, -0.2505231201648712, -0.4531121850013733, 0.5760387778282166, -0.02053442969918251, -0.786941409111023, -0.5323922038078308, 0.012141692452132702, -0.26122912764549255, 1.3510823249816895, -0.7933355569839478, -0.48483332991600037, -0.03393469378352165, 0.2095649689435959, -0.1496962159872055, 0.680119514465332, -0.20346811413764954, -0.21586038172245026, 0.4627998471260071, 0.4981934726238251, 0.6614013314247131, 0.008400890044867992, 0.8084300756454468, -0.2797777056694031, 0.04792399704456329, 0.2601408362388611, -0.22505061328411102, -0.29703953862190247, -0.1737331748008728, -0.011959767900407314, -0.753122866153717, -0.5898008346557617, 0.049895841628313065, 0.28194284439086914, -0.7864246368408203, -0.21583744883537292, -0.23756550252437592, 0.7380582690238953, -0.21426929533481598, 0.2972202003002167, -0.22136878967285156, 0.6607078313827515, -0.03580907732248306, 0.03341425210237503, 0.16532526910305023, 0.9765926599502563, 0.007986936718225479, -0.4343617558479309, 0.8627101182937622, 0.6323251128196716, 0.28232795000076294, -0.816267192363739, 0.5525197386741638, 0.3305804133415222, -0.46527189016342163, 0.6663510799407959, -0.5185387134552002, -0.21007101237773895, 0.41095489263534546, -0.2826436161994934, 0.028099099174141884, 0.9882825016975403, 0.12410270422697067, -0.17658528685569763, 0.35506826639175415, -0.36547982692718506, -0.4866679906845093, -0.03928434103727341, -0.37638744711875916, -0.7285237908363342, 0.777001142501831, -0.5965083241462708, -0.32607606053352356, -0.43319985270500183, -0.668275773525238, 0.6578503251075745, -0.04528893902897835, 0.19486737251281738, 0.012399006634950638, 1.161985158920288, -0.4470985233783722, 0.5108423829078674, 0.5561009049415588, 0.09408393502235413, 0.2712205946445465, 0.20905913412570953, -0.4952937364578247, -0.9118573069572449, -0.3529551029205322, -0.21186861395835876, 0.49252158403396606, 0.1270430088043213, 0.4516051411628723, 0.15982231497764587, -0.34959307312965393, 0.30238401889801025, -0.25851643085479736, 0.18302321434020996, -0.45584216713905334, -0.1051073670387268, -0.38590008020401, 0.5032463669776917, -0.5767502188682556, 0.059948474168777466, 0.23766635358333588, -1.0067626237869263, -0.71760094165802, 0.44779783487319946, 0.5469277501106262, -0.38885170221328735, -0.011712713167071342, -0.4849220812320709, 0.08193933963775635, 0.47538867592811584, -0.8971865177154541, 0.022287989035248756, 0.5723521709442139, 0.16909381747245789, 0.041660062968730927, -0.5496134757995605, -0.39686718583106995, 0.8727184534072876, 0.761957049369812, -0.2224959433078766, 0.2271382063627243, 0.27474474906921387, 0.060861729085445404, 0.5284752249717712, -0.3219699561595917, 0.4601022005081177, 0.7197827696800232, -0.1725880354642868, -0.2740285098552704, 0.38201281428337097, 0.839759349822998, 0.6971102952957153, -0.3922974467277527, -0.2421654611825943, -0.4510687291622162, -0.9319643378257751, -0.04767194390296936, -0.3041122555732727, 1.0246301889419556, -0.11454646289348602, 0.6167691946029663, 0.11447040736675262, 0.15168079733848572, -0.18855643272399902, 0.1615675687789917, 0.2742516100406647, -0.3714982867240906, -0.5898739099502563, -0.4149937629699707, 0.7984197735786438, -0.09152057766914368, -0.37491750717163086, -0.2530154883861542, -0.06480804085731506, 0.7088292241096497, 0.5799626708030701, 0.27536433935165405, 0.07766523957252502, 0.34716862440109253, -0.8636690378189087, -0.251514196395874, -0.22016827762126923, -0.6767458319664001, -0.48238232731819153, -0.3367554545402527, 0.6163949966430664, 0.0685446634888649, 0.5171761512756348, -0.5102793574333191, 0.7823895215988159, -0.13983498513698578, 0.5533794164657593, 0.2943705916404724, -0.5090054869651794, 0.22598443925380707, 0.36436188220977783, -0.3376077115535736, 0.0697229653596878, -0.263992041349411, -0.2674698233604431, 0.5607102513313293, -0.3083800673484802, 0.5484462380409241, -0.16348782181739807, -0.5086321234703064, -0.2316667139530182, 0.020541368052363396, 0.02629607543349266, -0.3864925801753998, -1.4655029773712158, 0.18894746899604797, 0.096502386033535, 0.14738468825817108, 0.693551242351532, 0.02495417185127735, 0.25074663758277893, -0.8100844025611877, 0.20809076726436615, -0.36707067489624023, -0.5815061330795288, -0.24065333604812622, -0.9887999892234802, 1.1538927555084229, 0.25941798090934753, -0.37711411714553833, -0.7369201183319092, -0.8129449486732483, -0.2584378719329834, 0.7205851078033447, 0.029513489454984665, -0.1575024574995041, -0.5970460176467896, 0.42430177330970764, 0.4528408944606781, -0.6596485376358032, -0.952089250087738, -0.004757353570312262, -0.1603240966796875, 1.1525975465774536, -0.2815791070461273, 0.3346201181411743, 0.5898880958557129, -0.24369782209396362, -0.24596981704235077, -0.2545238733291626, 0.134358212351799, 0.4815249741077423, -0.3278282582759857, 0.015118361450731754, -0.07756150513887405, 0.19344376027584076, -0.4813252091407776, 0.35401639342308044, 0.4253395199775696, -0.6332073211669922, 0.49679720401763916, -0.22460995614528656, -0.5847030282020569, -0.2718304991722107, 0.8708633184432983, -0.22194838523864746, 0.42206141352653503, 0.030413804575800896, 0.009034820832312107, 0.47568801045417786, -1.1427048444747925, 4.325218200683594, 0.7524159550666809, 0.1660831868648529, 0.19471865892410278, 0.36129364371299744, 0.2271852046251297, 0.5320233702659607, 0.22707679867744446, 0.6985601186752319, -0.02809254638850689, 0.10883363336324692, 0.4281556010246277, -0.48404815793037415, -0.044196926057338715, 0.15255452692508698, 0.6200351715087891, -1.0842006206512451, -0.27455267310142517, 0.17873716354370117, -0.6773605942726135, -0.4611065983772278, 0.32466864585876465, -0.14932119846343994, -0.004917385522276163, 0.25191783905029297, -0.06580501049757004, 0.4916194677352905, 0.24509590864181519, -0.05144196376204491, 0.3943594992160797, -0.027248399332165718, -1.0018459558486938, -0.22867701947689056, -0.9924764037132263, -0.46486881375312805, 0.3455236852169037, 1.0641852617263794, -0.7538597583770752, 0.07563266158103943, -0.70733243227005, 0.034399934113025665, 0.367030531167984, 0.11631148308515549, 0.11403944343328476, -0.09826826304197311, 0.31131598353385925, -0.8658825159072876, 0.05230272188782692, 0.21531949937343597, -0.333989679813385, 0.4693513810634613, -1.3907288312911987, -0.09809332340955734, -0.25479069352149963, -0.3296184539794922, -0.24396516382694244, -0.3415631353855133, -0.19969965517520905, -0.6852476596832275, 0.04547465965151787, 0.6876784563064575, 0.19774825870990753, -0.22961217164993286, 0.632506787776947, -0.030093885958194733, 0.5252794623374939, 0.46051037311553955, 0.25927481055259705, 0.3713846206665039, -0.1921774297952652, 0.5942139029502869, -0.23686529695987701, -0.4642653465270996, -0.09397390484809875, 0.4692222774028778, 0.3022380769252777, -1.0265361070632935, 0.7364832758903503, -0.6256488561630249, -0.07559764385223389, 1.0120586156845093, 0.6607171893119812, 0.43559303879737854, -0.16691744327545166, -0.5161988735198975, 1.0352942943572998, -0.09686702489852905, -0.7109097242355347, -0.699617862701416, 0.07716049253940582, 1.0621038675308228, -0.610894501209259, -0.09350740909576416, -0.34894630312919617, -0.20507054030895233 ]
{"Title": "Predictors of health related quality of life among diabetic patients on follow up at Nekemte Specialized Hospital, Western Ethiopia: A cross sectional study", "Authors": "Feyisa Bikila Regassa, Yilma Mekdes Tigistu, Tolessa Belachew Etana", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To assess health related quality of life (HRQoL) and its predictors among diabetic patients on follow up at Nekemte Specialized Hospital (NSH) in Western Ethiopia. Design, setting and participants This facility based cross sectional study was conducted among 224 diabetic patients on follow up at one of the public hospitals in western Ethiopia. Main outcome measured HRQoL was measured by using the Medical Outcome Study 36-item Short Form Health Survey from 15 th April to 5 th June. Structured questionnaire was used for data the collection from participants selected by systematic random sampling. Multiple linear regression was used for final model. Result A total of 215 diabetic patients were involved in the study with the response rate of 96%. The mean score of the overall HRQoL of the study participants was found to be 50.30 \u00b1 18.08 with highest mean score in physical functioning and lowest mean score in general health domain. Age, education status, history of smoking, feeling of stigmatized and Body mass index (BMI) were inversely associated while being male, being married, absence of co morbidity and absence of chronic complications related to diabetes mellitus were found to be positively associated with overall HRQoL. Conclusion The overall HRQoL of diabetic patients on follow up at the study area was found to be moderate. General health, mental health, bodily pain and vitality were the most affected domains. Both the mental and physical components need to be considered when caring the diabetic patients on follow up beyond provision of treatment. Strength and limitations of this study The study was the first of its kind in assessing the predictors of health-related quality of life (HRQoL) among both diabetes mellitus type I and type II in Ethiopia. The tools used was validated across different cultures Eight domains of HRQoL and two component summary scores were used to make the measurement more specific. The cross sectional nature of the study design made the result of the study difficult to identify either the cause or the effect comes first.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013516"}
10.1101/19010272
[ 0.3592138886451721, -0.1844763606786728, -0.38407719135284424, 0.6400350332260132, 0.27861320972442627, -0.27336665987968445, -0.15728837251663208, -0.5803275108337402, 0.7732909917831421, 0.48342686891555786, -0.628800094127655, -0.818532407283783, 0.5024879574775696, -0.30836910009384155, -0.13853313028812408, -0.33882588148117065, -0.3493819832801819, -0.6182103753089905, -0.6096117496490479, 0.0994514748454094, 0.04502619802951813, 0.512577474117279, -1.216855525970459, 0.3487711548805237, -0.645300030708313, 0.5143758654594421, 0.18750108778476715, 0.7365553379058838, 1.5453753471374512, 0.2161550521850586, 0.19444285333156586, -0.08767116814851761, 0.5605435967445374, -1.394223928451538, 0.13182221353054047, 0.12372846156358719, 0.40204647183418274, -0.05215834081172943, -0.20747531950473785, -0.3444676995277405, 0.3140532076358795, -0.40009385347366333, 0.5537998080253601, -0.5367329120635986, -0.8581481575965881, -0.3745526671409607, 0.2793251574039459, 0.0950530543923378, -0.08773405104875565, -0.20300547778606415, -0.5875681042671204, 0.20280608534812927, 0.4683340787887573, -0.23366673290729523, 0.1961294412612915, 0.31092599034309387, -0.15566463768482208, 0.22594709694385529, -0.7839385271072388, -0.20464058220386505, -0.2807601988315582, -0.43094295263290405, 0.06374701857566833, -1.5914912223815918, 0.30818971991539, 0.2201307862997055, 0.6292034387588501, -0.2776445746421814, -0.3692731559276581, -0.2501507103443146, -0.2615230977535248, -0.601932168006897, -0.6146029829978943, -0.284809947013855, -0.18961986899375916, -0.5155895948410034, 0.014325574040412903, -0.0814376026391983, -0.39215072989463806, -0.6528379321098328, 0.157544806599617, 0.7862370610237122, 0.15848688781261444, 0.10928782820701599, -0.42395561933517456, -0.5630099773406982, 0.5647295713424683, 0.29468029737472534, 0.380764365196228, 0.7290676832199097, -0.00633264658972621, 0.6182123422622681, 0.7325378060340881, 0.22553040087223053, -0.28843843936920166, 1.1797223091125488, -0.1679321974515915, 0.11884117126464844, 0.05112231522798538, -0.5053117275238037, 0.5253546833992004, 0.7320845127105713, -0.9852092266082764, 1.2253366708755493, -0.3790420889854431, 0.8247042894363403, 0.5224078297615051, -0.8207341432571411, -0.4019090533256531, -0.9434525370597839, 0.5291685461997986, 0.13721323013305664, -1.0460399389266968, 0.02725495584309101, 0.4664944112300873, 0.4133909344673157, -0.20604540407657623, 1.0298868417739868, -0.13264214992523193, 0.009243241511285305, -0.05605665594339371, -0.38564223051071167, 0.5847166776657104, -0.3379395604133606, 0.27658307552337646, 0.41851407289505005, 0.3110540211200714, 0.6572655439376831, -0.8908769488334656, 0.6422876715660095, 0.39751797914505005, -0.611207127571106, -0.31652745604515076, 0.01385277695953846, -0.3248067796230316, -0.7109043598175049, 0.43202540278434753, 0.38201430439949036, 0.5604209899902344, -0.3572922348976135, -0.25346964597702026, 0.6259493827819824, -0.9707478880882263, 1.4798702001571655, -0.18391987681388855, 0.5572757124900818, -0.5796819925308228, -1.2890254259109497, -0.42291533946990967, 0.11322462558746338, -0.4432743191719055, 1.0035851001739502, -0.4078308343887329, -0.0037640463560819626, -0.11339214444160461, 0.4779183566570282, -0.4362407922744751, 0.0513395331799984, -0.22275857627391815, -0.09982846677303314, -0.6298721432685852, -0.20930740237236023, 0.41675814986228943, 0.5627607107162476, -0.47277921438217163, 0.743194043636322, 0.011388018727302551, -0.019682077690958977, 0.24685761332511902, -0.6986516118049622, 0.5840293169021606, -0.11655590683221817, -0.33276835083961487, 0.4529933035373688, 0.4674338698387146, 1.3907781839370728, 0.9983487725257874, -0.4920234680175781, 0.5651500225067139, 0.1101042851805687, -0.24125973880290985, 0.16974373161792755, 0.07069150358438492, 0.8196328282356262, 0.0655522346496582, 0.33289971947669983, -0.14353887736797333, -0.5604962706565857, -0.6241939067840576, -0.40923047065734863, -0.16413085162639618, 0.3627708852291107, 0.13647013902664185, 0.7687654495239258, 0.2177569419145584, -0.273039311170578, -0.6683722734451294, -0.009166923351585865, 0.19995662569999695, -0.06401119381189346, -0.2205542027950287, 0.48171329498291016, -0.05196091905236244, -0.0005885388818569481, -0.4287019371986389, 0.918633759021759, 0.1129080057144165, -0.02292199246585369, -0.8671746253967285, 0.04783789813518524, 0.808624267578125, -0.1375911831855774, 0.08460460603237152, 0.3491009473800659, 0.5730492472648621, -0.14185771346092224, -0.917958676815033, -0.1002979427576065, -0.570536196231842, 0.26252081990242004, -0.36565229296684265, -0.23465315997600555, 0.6224335432052612, -0.24420298635959625, 0.4877607226371765, 0.06104111671447754, -0.29180631041526794, 0.2871266305446625, -0.275394469499588, -0.23381346464157104, 0.2211681455373764, 0.6404180526733398, -0.0024764181580394506, 1.0742954015731812, 0.7014566659927368, 0.5824279189109802, 0.18289829790592194, 0.6007070541381836, -0.13697099685668945, 0.5205878019332886, 0.7243238687515259, 0.10762041062116623, 0.3188008964061737, 0.5493667125701904, -0.20682449638843536, 0.2647969424724579, -0.6586641073226929, 0.00040815846296027303, -0.23965981602668762, 0.40419724583625793, -0.3889094889163971, 0.309878945350647, 1.0014764070510864, 0.8290939927101135, -1.1173409223556519, -0.18451449275016785, 0.46030551195144653, 0.34069234132766724, -0.4956285357475281, -0.4462828040122986, 0.036412596702575684, 0.8372592926025391, -0.24443425238132477, -0.07917575538158417, 1.1893800497055054, 1.4045161008834839, 0.31149837374687195, 0.025833258405327797, 0.2015741616487503, -0.14018601179122925, -0.6317922472953796, -0.7201254963874817, -1.1111080646514893, -0.41135600209236145, -0.7360147833824158, 0.6830959916114807, -0.3972020149230957, 0.0011298514436930418, -0.3944433033466339, -0.27339595556259155, 0.04923265799880028, 0.34906870126724243, -0.22421245276927948, 0.2750382125377655, 0.6630287170410156, 0.3868696689605713, -1.0590667724609375, 0.104545459151268, 0.05109259486198425, 0.12665407359600067, -0.6164793372154236, -0.38077443838119507, -0.3792394995689392, -0.6651837825775146, 0.34709084033966064, -1.0766582489013672, 0.21516211330890656, -0.2939962148666382, 0.36641308665275574, -0.25631800293922424, 0.3747140169143677, -0.13446761667728424, -0.6249643564224243, -0.3222951591014862, -0.9585527181625366, 0.49764811992645264, 0.06871476024389267, -0.007194042205810547, 0.27109846472740173, 0.4691251814365387, -0.3820752799510956, 0.9968986511230469, 0.3061188757419586, -0.08643265068531036, -0.7662523984909058, 0.20155306160449982, 0.7257102131843567, -0.1793525069952011, 0.47153350710868835, -0.8295502662658691, -0.7089347243309021, 0.5365566611289978, 0.02621876262128353, -0.4781784117221832, -0.0018884611781686544, 0.675737738609314, 0.0628611221909523, -0.7894458174705505, -0.06309862434864044, 0.2552483379840851, -0.860885739326477, 0.004699130076915026, -0.2248510867357254, 0.303678423166275, 0.7303057909011841, -0.0431322306394577, -0.7331347465515137, 0.24428634345531464, -0.5454084873199463, 0.7017556428909302, 0.06941493600606918, -0.8036134243011475, 0.1232338473200798, 0.5526467561721802, 0.3015008866786957, 0.183607816696167, 0.41045069694519043, 0.2849171757698059, -0.11825082451105118, 0.0974888950586319, -0.20556388795375824, 0.44528234004974365, 1.421776294708252, -0.3493683636188507, -0.6806328892707825, 0.7710970640182495, 0.004091818816959858, -0.39502260088920593, 0.3937547504901886, -0.13900503516197205, 0.38132569193840027, 0.5107846856117249, -0.5086661577224731, 0.11511851102113724, -0.5450648665428162, -0.6305816769599915, 0.16271983087062836, 0.1604066789150238, 0.5978729128837585, -0.8834900856018066, -0.007851746864616871, 0.35676509141921997, -0.41224798560142517, -0.3522915542125702, -0.10717320442199707, 0.37600433826446533, 1.221298336982727, 0.3907938599586487, 1.4152454137802124, -0.8040181398391724, 0.3146769404411316, 0.5130309462547302, 1.0999159812927246, 0.2375701367855072, 0.3303699493408203, 0.8115777969360352, -0.8361644744873047, 0.10796403884887695, 0.08786053955554962, -0.37744569778442383, -0.1545369178056717, -0.2833229601383209, -0.08671093732118607, 0.5182911157608032, -0.3619053065776825, -0.06204291433095932, 0.2976122796535492, 0.2661789059638977, 0.4149792790412903, -0.07734490931034088, 0.8115067481994629, -0.22694014012813568, -0.026836644858121872, -0.062270887196063995, 0.8115975260734558, 0.8262609839439392, -1.139083981513977, -0.12658224999904633, 0.04711465910077095, -0.2380264550447464, -0.1486179232597351, -0.4822175204753876, 0.11010187119245529, -0.0819624811410904, 0.3202381730079651, -0.47077563405036926, -0.2478099912405014, -0.7750867605209351, -0.43433889746665955, 0.5735928416252136, 0.8031376004219055, 0.4176594018936157, -0.350350022315979, -0.1888158917427063, -0.0947481095790863, -0.3162796199321747, -0.32227885723114014, -0.7309136390686035, -0.04004831984639168, 0.8142332434654236, -0.43828922510147095, -0.7085729241371155, -0.5217558741569519, -0.39766061305999756, -0.8682511448860168, 0.26268628239631653, 0.2064507156610489, -0.5742360353469849, 0.4330517649650574, -0.1896219402551651, -0.23893144726753235, -0.9065777659416199, 0.6214060187339783, -0.8797237277030945, 0.580246090888977, -0.27014315128326416, 1.4443894624710083, 0.49265074729919434, 0.20081672072410583, -0.2526875436306, 0.11751305311918259, -0.6940916180610657, 0.2771807909011841, -0.46408554911613464, -0.22677047550678253, 0.6425817608833313, -0.4331989586353302, -0.21290525794029236, -0.1413874328136444, 0.18798355758190155, -0.0959707722067833, 0.17714162170886993, -0.09840923547744751, -0.2234238237142563, -0.05635297670960426, 1.1132104396820068, -0.19884523749351501, 0.5377659201622009, 1.3175469636917114, -0.7842255234718323, -0.6548337936401367, 0.1195555105805397, -0.29186055064201355, -0.6790451407432556, 0.5257570147514343, 0.4209800064563751, 0.17563334107398987, -0.3135630786418915, -0.5890120267868042, 0.028383396565914154, -0.16456151008605957, 0.9082990288734436, -0.1035131886601448, -0.7398682236671448, -0.14977097511291504, -0.466126948595047, -0.5245107412338257, -0.18850328028202057, -1.067763090133667, 0.0448446124792099, -0.34172406792640686, -0.35673943161964417, 0.7214531302452087, -0.5266451835632324, -0.026845967397093773, -0.9645399451255798, -0.6990870833396912, 0.4930640459060669, 0.006577701773494482, 0.22205016016960144, 0.8988592624664307, -0.6971074938774109, -0.7410414218902588, -0.12621326744556427, 0.7615837454795837, -0.5329636931419373, -0.560369610786438, 0.011856714263558388, -0.6798228025436401, -0.8460649251937866, -0.30202558636665344, 0.19709530472755432, -0.7852123379707336, -0.8933703303337097, -0.5373696088790894, -0.09544263035058975, 0.5481569170951843, 0.08926552534103394, 0.007242574822157621, 0.55888831615448, 0.316595196723938, -0.8243306279182434, 0.028048580512404442, 0.7176077365875244, 0.501768171787262, 0.4557706117630005, -0.2765253484249115, -0.8786194324493408, -0.012547538615763187, -0.8728621006011963, 0.47147971391677856, -0.6191814541816711, 0.33539438247680664, -0.034252237528562546, -0.04266428202390671, 0.17012406885623932, 0.8881390690803528, -0.5709238648414612, -0.038431316614151, -0.24140521883964539, 0.02089076302945614, 0.39865145087242126, -0.17114122211933136, 0.11130436509847641, -0.13610771298408508, -0.19891329109668732, 0.3708857595920563, 0.542377233505249, 0.31213510036468506, -0.15002219378948212, -0.44123584032058716, 0.19699373841285706, 0.7723587155342102, 0.912058413028717, -0.5739322900772095, -0.2626204192638397, 0.2178412675857544, -0.06793210655450821, 0.4259898066520691, -0.6070516109466553, -1.1209032535552979, 0.4887988865375519, -0.3298267126083374, 0.10266029089689255, -0.4969768226146698, -0.4971088171005249, 0.17652714252471924, -0.08127731084823608, 1.3279446363449097, -0.29563286900520325, 0.06943938881158829, -0.0863749161362648, -0.5509408116340637, -0.24944742023944855, 0.3689914047718048, -0.5524823665618896, -0.4896959960460663, -0.7866153120994568, -0.7441862225532532, 0.5928856730461121, -0.1833435297012329, -0.42297953367233276, 0.4575219452381134, 0.03652005270123482, -0.375479131937027, -0.38555726408958435, 0.41683727502822876, 0.6584768295288086, -1.1118955612182617, -0.5088872909545898, 0.4453834593296051, 0.3390744626522064, -0.040419917553663254, 0.3101755678653717, -0.18789303302764893, 0.027809666469693184, -0.14068718254566193, -0.40971851348876953, -1.041579008102417, -1.1810954809188843, -0.08530781418085098, 0.08994774520397186, 1.085809350013733, 0.03315741568803787, 0.8274180293083191, -0.2212495654821396, -0.29132112860679626, -0.403774231672287, 0.5353286266326904, -0.4475908875465393, -0.02644408866763115, 0.8754501342773438, 0.06564977765083313, 0.33706265687942505, 0.5744906067848206, -0.4799913465976715, 0.1145734041929245, -0.05229644477367401, 0.6429110765457153, 0.6305850744247437, -0.7810029983520508, 0.8415895104408264, 0.6970290541648865, -0.38230597972869873, -0.5963537096977234, 0.5025055408477783, -0.22747279703617096, -0.14473757147789001, -0.2168009728193283, -0.5487714409828186, 0.2457834929227829, -0.359882116317749, 0.344766765832901, -0.28462526202201843, 0.22136330604553223, -0.3287406265735626, -0.5478678941726685, -0.18608443439006805, -0.6616466045379639, -0.02893747016787529, 0.9384259581565857, -0.41458988189697266, 0.9848277568817139, 0.3780380189418793, 0.39046192169189453, -0.5054179430007935, 0.4530312716960907, 0.655504584312439, -0.23932859301567078, -0.24375373125076294, 0.28790369629859924, -0.0831158384680748, 0.4005360007286072, -0.218852698802948, -0.20464806258678436, 0.7219520211219788, 0.7814420461654663, -0.49078667163848877, -0.04334188997745514, 1.0710041522979736, 0.22722159326076508, 0.35076192021369934, -0.19139648973941803, 0.009555988945066929, 0.6727471351623535, -0.3403802514076233, 0.2740847170352936, -0.18409819900989532, -0.5935236811637878, -0.6565834283828735, -0.7256457805633545, 0.04383043572306633, -0.7517479062080383, -0.029562870040535927, 0.5591540932655334, -0.6047475934028625, -0.9397929906845093, -0.45852842926979065, 1.0667091608047485, -0.0960431918501854, -0.6083311438560486, -0.4161660373210907, 0.5533832907676697, -0.786591112613678, -0.546470046043396, -0.7846510410308838, -0.4850887060165405, -0.1435292363166809, 0.933364987373352, -0.15608465671539307, -0.5423035025596619, 0.7161903977394104, -0.05485830828547478, -0.02058638259768486, 0.35913920402526855, -0.49371856451034546, -0.4741159975528717, 0.13834400475025177, 0.4923405945301056, 0.3246319890022278, -0.07897937297821045, 1.2852261066436768, -0.0356428436934948, 0.15722601115703583, 0.3246915340423584, -0.4487912058830261, -0.8127782344818115, -0.35484689474105835, 0.09211251139640808, -0.8069467544555664, -0.12702538073062897, -0.26073184609413147, 0.6674754023551941, -1.350442886352539, -0.6648611426353455, -0.38051965832710266, -0.8343722820281982, 0.11483000963926315, 0.7108083963394165, 0.6710397005081177, 0.4343683123588562, 0.10012803226709366, -0.5557242631912231, -0.24674609303474426, 1.0258489847183228, 0.5662064552307129, 0.07898679375648499, 0.6407058238983154, -0.0758480504155159, 0.34606122970581055, -0.8517146110534668, 0.42895010113716125, 0.6132131218910217, -0.7987664341926575, 0.7734217643737793, -0.5561403632164001, 0.37788671255111694, -0.15374444425106049, -0.21940968930721283, -0.13375823199748993, 0.20368565618991852, 0.13108085095882416, 0.9442000985145569, -0.04229971766471863, -0.09391874819993973, -0.36338189244270325, -1.3871381282806396, -1.301946997642517, -1.0559817552566528, 0.9703441262245178, -0.6848172545433044, 0.12096857279539108, -0.38933074474334717, -0.8339202404022217, 0.17293794453144073, 0.31918808817863464, 0.5011560320854187, -0.19207978248596191, 0.42192238569259644, 0.32713356614112854, -0.02415350079536438, 0.04965823143720627, 0.21420173346996307, 0.1009950339794159, -0.012631742283701897, -0.6400132775306702, -0.18579182028770447, 0.33865252137184143, 0.8517642021179199, 0.2786256670951843, -0.07399845123291016, -0.5477766394615173, 0.39214134216308594, 0.18439002335071564, -0.9115067720413208, -0.7828050851821899, 0.62711101770401, -0.3514285981655121, 0.28576797246932983, -0.2624841630458832, -0.007144502364099026, 0.46828871965408325, 0.13226427137851715, 0.36527296900749207, -0.41942664980888367, -0.0947694331407547, -0.3160059452056885, 0.8906636238098145, -0.49967724084854126, 0.49706465005874634, 0.14332149922847748, -0.22775769233703613, -0.6901389360427856, -0.32471999526023865, 0.06368871033191681, 0.17811864614486694, 0.13261069357395172, -0.053705934435129166, -0.2429841011762619, 0.3569851815700531, 0.7437446117401123, 0.7143875956535339, -0.32017990946769714, 0.6836466789245605, 0.5487465262413025, 0.5445401072502136, 0.0732886865735054, -0.3714154362678528, 0.12832944095134735, 0.20068605244159698, -0.536496102809906, -0.034764956682920456, 0.5902968645095825, 0.9336338639259338, -0.5527244210243225, -0.3629715144634247, 0.3806014955043793, -0.556631863117218, -0.9998953938484192, -0.01058411505073309, 0.2419079691171646, 0.8235893249511719, 0.3974945843219757, 0.06421142816543579, 0.1317957192659378, 0.6549208164215088, -0.031254321336746216, 0.20998115837574005, 0.7073881030082703, -0.9877716898918152, 0.2925369441509247, -0.5448466539382935, 0.4306573271751404, -0.05691453441977501, 0.03969878703355789, 0.39374879002571106, -0.6803368330001831, 0.5369998216629028, 0.8527389764785767, 0.13831867277622223, -0.4073205590248108, 0.7602057456970215, -0.09981463849544525, 0.45123326778411865, 0.1757437288761139, -0.18221589922904968, -0.12084963917732239, -0.21238531172275543, 0.8431269526481628, -0.8087486028671265, 0.24644270539283752, 0.060214098542928696, 0.5873023867607117, 0.8031344413757324, -0.009991219267249107, 0.5920679569244385, -0.5535834431648254, 0.06172248721122742, 0.3999350666999817, -0.34779077768325806, -0.1601761281490326, -0.4893605709075928, 0.12419784814119339, 0.01264489721506834, -0.019324133172631264, 0.026160722598433495, 0.03273731842637062, -0.4568416178226471, -0.4395449459552765, 0.7825810313224792, -0.1796562373638153, -0.30165502429008484, -0.7603750824928284, -0.5358682870864868, -0.3982539176940918, 0.08108140528202057, 0.39118608832359314, 0.26145488023757935, 0.6742097735404968, -0.5413433909416199, -0.1550408899784088, -0.5033513903617859, -0.26126042008399963, -0.4269034266471863, -0.8135383725166321, 0.44968411326408386, -0.20123563706874847, -0.3052231967449188, -0.7232309579849243, -1.4653443098068237, -0.01752614416182041, -0.4301990270614624, 0.27409082651138306, -0.9290866255760193, -0.4661159813404083, 0.23088088631629944, 0.9593649506568909, 0.009236149489879608, 0.1820080578327179, -0.09030835330486298, 0.14350296556949615, 0.5390220880508423, -0.8689014911651611, 0.46727511286735535, -0.027699502184987068, 0.23916441202163696, 0.35599711537361145, 0.1400337666273117, 0.42383965849876404, 0.11644747108221054, 0.13271965086460114, -0.5540785789489746, -0.02009756676852703, -0.33587315678596497, -0.6795830726623535, 0.8881053924560547, 0.8627204895019531, -0.503234326839447, -0.44113513827323914, -0.3404592275619507, -0.5991231799125671, -0.2236465960741043, 0.9666317105293274, -0.36371371150016785, 0.22050917148590088, -0.023769747465848923, -0.012543808668851852, 0.4387942850589752, -1.05478036403656, 4.028085231781006, 0.9620375633239746, 1.059994101524353, -0.1771988570690155, 0.7508271336555481, 0.07269181311130524, 0.31773272156715393, -0.004208090715110302, 0.2487790733575821, -0.3723682463169098, -0.13317164778709412, 0.07525093853473663, 0.1423678696155548, 0.21137386560440063, 0.421772837638855, 0.4673888087272644, -1.2414718866348267, 0.06067630648612976, -0.2690480351448059, -1.2987313270568848, -0.4968878924846649, 0.4499845802783966, -0.17243321239948273, 0.31735551357269287, 0.360299676656723, 0.2247038334608078, 0.5589469075202942, 0.1706743836402893, 0.09551219642162323, -0.6771543622016907, 0.07722055166959763, -0.4179230034351349, 0.2915235757827759, -0.30556410551071167, -0.7373454570770264, 0.19621139764785767, -0.07001544535160065, -0.6368571519851685, -0.27756214141845703, -0.11839228868484497, 0.2012612372636795, -0.6009088158607483, -0.08383433520793915, -0.14136847853660583, -0.857694149017334, 0.20260126888751984, -1.0303022861480713, 0.49958667159080505, 0.5710132718086243, -0.43843376636505127, 0.22543372213840485, -0.6123365163803101, 0.5494018793106079, -0.11494223028421402, -0.8804680705070496, -0.328764408826828, -0.5977073907852173, -0.8742310404777527, 0.2748696804046631, 0.8347863554954529, 0.5542824268341064, 0.2712113559246063, -0.5662882924079895, -0.3783165216445923, 0.4746514856815338, 0.32314103841781616, 0.33124595880508423, 0.48632386326789856, -0.029436681419610977, -0.7750371098518372, 0.18620938062667847, -0.4245738685131073, -0.5140548944473267, -0.16198456287384033, 0.7193878889083862, 0.2675393223762512, -0.22497107088565826, 0.786619246006012, -0.7412968873977661, -1.0815576314926147, 0.30240076780319214, 0.3071640431880951, 0.36755871772766113, -0.5024856328964233, 0.30245766043663025, 0.9446183443069458, -0.06289303302764893, -0.040669750422239304, -0.6660150289535522, 0.5858555436134338, 0.844926118850708, -0.7451996207237244, 0.025350777432322502, 0.0913170650601387, 0.14187099039554596 ]
{"Title": "DNA methylation biomarker selected by an ensemble machine learning approach predicts mortality risk in an HIV-positive veteran population", "Authors": "Shu Chang, Justice Amy C., Zhang Xinyu, Marconi Vincent C., Hancock Dana B., Johnson Eric O., Xu Ke", "Abstract": "Abstract Background With the improved life expectancy of people living with HIV (PLWH), identifying vulnerable subpopulations at high risk of mortality is important for clinical care. Evidences showed that DNA methylation (DNAm) is associated with aging and mortality in non-HIV populations. Here, we aimed to establish a panel of DNAm biomarkers that can predict mortality risk among PLWH. Methods 1,081 HIV-positive participants from the Veterans Aging Cohort Study (VACS) were divided into training (N=460), validation (N=114), and testing (N=507) sets. VACS index was used as a measure of mortality risk among PLWH. Model training and fine-tuning were conducted using the ensemble method in the training and validation sets and prediction performance was assessed in the testing set. The survival analysis comparing the predicted high and low mortality risk groups was conducted. The Gene Ontology enrichment analysis of the predictive CpG sites was performed. Results We selected a panel of 393 CpGs for the ensemble prediction model. The prediction model showed excellent performance in predicting high mortality risk with an auROC of 0.809 (95%CI: 0.767-0.851) and a balanced accuracy of 0.653 (95%CI: 0.611, 0.693) in the testing set. The predicted high mortality risk group was significantly associated with 10-year mortality (hazard ratio=1.79, p=4E-05) compared with low mortality risk group. These 393 CpGs were located in 280 genes enriched in immune and inflammation responses pathways. Conclusions We identified a panel of DNAm features associated with mortality risk in PLWH. These DNAm features may serve as predictive biomarkers for mortality risk among PLWH.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010272"}
10.1101/19005157
[ 0.8305104970932007, 0.26298442482948303, -0.5497984290122986, 0.6023836731910706, -0.17345741391181946, -0.39105984568595886, -0.1124497577548027, -0.1690243035554886, -0.31619274616241455, 0.8830544948577881, 0.11341270804405212, -0.23810875415802002, 0.5216842293739319, -1.1338523626327515, -0.07049589604139328, -0.17851139605045319, -1.023633599281311, -0.10530928522348404, -0.3905061185359955, -0.2015785127878189, 0.2621733546257019, 0.8324635624885559, -0.6742576956748962, 0.5482534766197205, -0.6507784128189087, 0.3335554897785187, -0.1516086310148239, 0.29486387968063354, 1.2775040864944458, 0.1407586932182312, -0.540943443775177, -0.47988438606262207, 0.05336611717939377, -1.024446725845337, 0.042254094034433365, 0.03257230669260025, 1.3211991786956787, -0.47533613443374634, -0.36826086044311523, -0.7186261415481567, 0.24164505302906036, -0.05311517044901848, 0.527336597442627, -0.7936810255050659, -0.8833475708961487, -0.17760446667671204, -0.15114542841911316, -0.6721822619438171, -0.41509774327278137, -0.4441119432449341, -0.0043437285348773, 0.21331776678562164, -0.11266093701124191, -0.603274405002594, -0.31342020630836487, -0.48277148604393005, 0.23543384671211243, 0.15571337938308716, -0.4745532274246216, -0.12922751903533936, 1.1319478750228882, 0.23738694190979004, 0.07439465075731277, -1.0588617324829102, 0.3070698380470276, 1.0758492946624756, -0.8190405964851379, 0.10035086423158646, -0.7971070408821106, 0.17102494835853577, -0.7015019655227661, 0.01241436880081892, 0.004810969345271587, -0.8344030380249023, 0.1416851431131363, 0.07563796639442444, 0.09866692125797272, 0.1899898499250412, -0.08015698194503784, -0.6858245134353638, 0.7750980854034424, -0.2740778625011444, 0.27656668424606323, 0.4114302694797516, -0.05927353724837303, 0.15268827974796295, 0.8836121559143066, 0.7740145921707153, 1.016935110092163, 0.05998455360531807, 0.2894909977912903, 0.03229409083724022, 0.6852937340736389, 0.005194997880607843, -0.07394018769264221, 0.7065091729164124, -0.8897333741188049, 0.6163880228996277, 0.4124661684036255, 0.12164460122585297, -0.1868802160024643, 0.7986158728599548, -0.19987809658050537, 0.9915014505386353, -0.8212935328483582, -0.03223855420947075, 0.8570895195007324, -0.3206075429916382, 0.48152464628219604, -1.2489519119262695, 0.5542449355125427, 0.2713278830051422, -0.3855828642845154, 0.6671208739280701, 0.14023452997207642, 0.5364232063293457, 0.1481112837791443, 0.059580061584711075, -0.31558898091316223, 0.0717046856880188, -0.12803804874420166, -0.1278892457485199, 0.35743415355682373, -0.2707293629646301, 0.7962123155593872, -0.03984399512410164, 0.9083298444747925, 0.32510456442832947, -0.2625432014465332, -0.4588187634944916, 0.38342800736427307, -0.06639918684959412, -0.17628560960292816, 0.768957257270813, 0.2129741907119751, 0.21918165683746338, -0.14280858635902405, 0.4402262568473816, -0.012257582508027554, -0.16998884081840515, -0.11274141073226929, -0.30856531858444214, 1.0114562511444092, 1.0288687944412231, -0.26475125551223755, 0.9087879657745361, -0.5791658163070679, -1.1062549352645874, -0.4145800471305847, -0.32980310916900635, 0.08314116299152374, -0.07703500986099243, -0.16053223609924316, 0.6323867440223694, -0.09223020821809769, 0.3622923493385315, -0.5223369598388672, 0.7409086227416992, -0.8936834335327148, 0.07745885103940964, -0.26048412919044495, -0.07332515716552734, 0.08269355446100235, 0.6540976762771606, -0.3919609785079956, 0.34972891211509705, -0.07416371256113052, -0.605674684047699, 0.2975342869758606, -0.6945486664772034, 0.7057510614395142, 0.00036303987144492567, 0.2968629002571106, -0.3261633813381195, 0.1119748130440712, 0.6268332004547119, 0.5233535170555115, 0.336818665266037, -0.25445568561553955, 0.14021599292755127, 0.00523922685533762, -0.9930577278137207, 1.1624972820281982, 0.032012056559324265, -0.3095244765281677, -0.593126654624939, -0.7559154629707336, -0.545881986618042, -0.05587373673915863, -0.2891366481781006, 0.1535361111164093, 0.17490601539611816, -0.6116434931755066, 0.061346739530563354, -0.2802889049053192, 0.4295459985733032, -0.06707490235567093, 0.5541564226150513, 0.16179607808589935, -0.2156347781419754, -0.5546581149101257, 0.10408228635787964, -0.20695769786834717, 0.26770421862602234, -0.5513695478439331, 0.7438400983810425, 1.0660914182662964, 0.5247735381126404, 0.13344144821166992, -0.026503555476665497, 0.33238038420677185, -0.5002025365829468, 0.0202975794672966, 0.2781410217285156, 1.3982396125793457, -0.5664976835250854, 0.607433021068573, 0.501143753528595, -0.2069467008113861, 0.03789261728525162, 0.5532175302505493, -0.6112618446350098, 1.0761489868164062, 0.42263710498809814, 0.4787044823169708, 0.7911052107810974, -0.18843652307987213, -0.20861414074897766, 0.7437647581100464, -0.4356519877910614, -0.6569740772247314, 0.711991012096405, -0.40439099073410034, 0.5220906734466553, 0.7107819318771362, 0.6115281581878662, 0.41075316071510315, 0.39790651202201843, 0.5031217336654663, -0.12492763996124268, 0.07072052359580994, 0.3261495530605316, 0.8325462937355042, 0.4870266020298004, 0.13090911507606506, -0.11418360471725464, -0.9194785356521606, 0.099195696413517, -0.8427658677101135, 0.1327165961265564, -0.811755359172821, 0.8943796157836914, 0.1479671448469162, 0.17395269870758057, -0.7069683074951172, -0.5811657309532166, -0.16707444190979004, 1.0344089269638062, -0.5300458073616028, -1.210553526878357, -0.23304498195648193, 0.15501517057418823, 0.2178364396095276, 0.20355194807052612, 0.7529926896095276, 0.3862656056880951, 0.02383379638195038, 0.3644913136959076, 0.32494890689849854, -0.8351812958717346, -0.9670234322547913, -0.8093885183334351, -0.9975159168243408, -0.724327802658081, 0.04795766621828079, -0.956913948059082, 0.20140282809734344, -0.6066092848777771, 0.3803139328956604, 0.32589083909988403, 0.15701737999916077, -1.5499281883239746, 0.5737727880477905, 0.5839040875434875, -0.007666503079235554, 0.6962346434593201, -1.3721269369125366, 0.2802049219608307, -0.35483071208000183, 0.5330970287322998, -0.4720894992351532, -0.4986352324485779, -0.5225149393081665, -0.5125992298126221, 0.275703102350235, -0.5417699217796326, -0.2071826457977295, 0.24508176743984222, -0.10964541882276535, -0.15625116229057312, 0.6760185360908508, -0.4441884458065033, -0.21286168694496155, 0.1818949431180954, -0.2595025599002838, 0.3827136754989624, -0.2883279621601105, 0.7192190885543823, 1.352697730064392, 0.10559084266424179, -0.44725242257118225, 0.42046552896499634, -0.0669666975736618, 0.5495071411132812, -0.27625489234924316, 0.8131948113441467, 0.5068297982215881, 0.0049211508594453335, 0.04210624098777771, -0.7039058804512024, -0.7403728365898132, -0.22622022032737732, 0.09965796023607254, -1.1927391290664673, 0.04610781371593475, 0.14933054149150848, 0.20865213871002197, -0.8955609202384949, -0.24228419363498688, -0.40287718176841736, -1.7493183612823486, 0.3278714418411255, -0.8646567463874817, 0.1561439335346222, 0.2553401589393616, -0.012789472006261349, -0.6286539435386658, -0.04217641428112984, 0.06370632350444794, 0.4285225570201874, 0.5100046396255493, -0.3059508800506592, 0.21075144410133362, 0.18136395514011383, 0.20085714757442474, 0.020888779312372208, 0.260050892829895, -0.5688323378562927, -0.465859979391098, -0.2321704924106598, -0.35792189836502075, -0.02595825120806694, 0.5815722942352295, -0.2815859317779541, 0.006949577014893293, 0.04041729122400284, -0.12578044831752777, 0.0023197403643280268, 0.9058097004890442, 0.4451758563518524, 0.974118709564209, 0.2848113477230072, 0.12578994035720825, 0.3074681758880615, -0.6012535095214844, -0.7222317457199097, 0.732143759727478, 0.11738970875740051, 0.6881226301193237, -1.6230465173721313, 0.4199080467224121, 0.09748177230358124, 0.33493369817733765, -0.08435992151498795, -0.22787590324878693, -0.037541426718235016, 0.7019881010055542, 0.08907102048397064, 1.216791033744812, -1.4721872806549072, -0.3630708158016205, 0.8557895421981812, 0.9814104437828064, 0.26423487067222595, 0.15125760436058044, 0.31002122163772583, -0.09095180779695511, 0.32207709550857544, 0.2994624376296997, 0.16788747906684875, 0.05041414871811867, -0.33463552594184875, -0.2703101336956024, -0.25757288932800293, -0.7426506280899048, -0.19328351318836212, 0.7171772718429565, 0.8251466751098633, -0.7258995175361633, -0.40123486518859863, 0.5510193109512329, 0.15304914116859436, 0.09850519895553589, 0.8399922251701355, 0.8906497359275818, -0.6883190274238586, -0.733119010925293, 0.38442501425743103, -0.36707034707069397, 0.10178167372941971, -0.4803258180618286, 0.366256982088089, -0.2598913311958313, -0.1965852528810501, 0.09891832619905472, -0.31871429085731506, -0.1411343514919281, -0.02972542680799961, 0.23023568093776703, -0.3298429250717163, -0.011034426279366016, 0.4890671968460083, -0.6908849477767944, 0.023415975272655487, 0.5220603942871094, -1.4001634120941162, -0.07337576895952225, -0.40535011887550354, 0.4676477611064911, 1.11961829662323, -0.4897316098213196, -0.5157690644264221, -0.01928931102156639, -0.44923678040504456, 0.04237964749336243, 0.7499475479125977, -0.17280186712741852, 0.18295158445835114, 0.5750377178192139, 0.476509153842926, -0.04115829989314079, -0.22473730146884918, -0.8352011442184448, -0.4041767120361328, -0.21423539519309998, 0.6342343091964722, 0.8164442777633667, 1.0337514877319336, 0.37125906348228455, 0.23160363733768463, 1.1335543394088745, -0.39682841300964355, 0.436379998922348, -0.8065136671066284, -0.639919102191925, 0.19406592845916748, -0.01210874319076538, -0.2733612060546875, 0.6575666069984436, -0.2177783101797104, -0.8363777995109558, -0.5142678022384644, 0.160141259431839, -0.6693397164344788, -0.0700245276093483, 0.7946255207061768, -0.41124430298805237, 0.2974928617477417, 0.5421755313873291, -0.2981956899166107, 0.1986689269542694, 0.08722295612096786, 0.37517988681793213, -0.6704416871070862, 0.46909669041633606, -0.2781291604042053, 0.25554025173187256, -0.8087095022201538, 0.036348044872283936, 0.0018655837047845125, 0.2089376598596573, -0.034780681133270264, -0.5176371932029724, 0.27125072479248047, -0.0666242465376854, -0.3248606026172638, -0.43342888355255127, 0.28055182099342346, -0.8301025032997131, 0.05005606263875961, -0.03682650998234749, -0.33762913942337036, -0.13493475317955017, 0.05287926271557808, -0.8525577783584595, 0.5835409164428711, -0.9130828380584717, -0.19856227934360504, 0.5171916484832764, -0.20965398848056793, -0.12608091533184052, -0.8279286623001099, -0.907622218132019, 0.5556860566139221, -0.13488419353961945, -0.6232890486717224, -0.4161272346973419, -0.3919050693511963, -0.04911787062883377, -0.3536137044429779, -0.09935575723648071, -0.389404833316803, -0.07124064862728119, -0.4473782777786255, 0.04591900482773781, -0.10003810375928879, 0.6001312732696533, -0.9601534605026245, -0.9473851919174194, 0.932892918586731, -0.3352164328098297, -0.720202624797821, -0.013826616108417511, 0.43277931213378906, 0.41473326086997986, 0.2858935594558716, -0.11812672764062881, -0.3524776101112366, 0.08518107980489731, -0.3688240945339203, 0.4531721770763397, -1.236041784286499, 0.0031726593151688576, -0.5775482058525085, -0.3216811418533325, 0.03181943669915199, 0.23492419719696045, 0.26055726408958435, -0.8142997026443481, -0.087647944688797, -0.5780215859413147, 0.07385949790477753, -0.3183816373348236, -0.6089829206466675, 0.16236251592636108, -0.9309671521186829, -0.7510424256324768, 1.2575278282165527, -0.0893016904592514, -0.37450864911079407, 0.40556949377059937, 0.01142969261854887, 0.23084363341331482, 1.0356179475784302, -0.2835281789302826, -0.6641733646392822, -0.21082644164562225, 0.6041302680969238, 0.2293379306793213, -0.31103289127349854, -0.8150143623352051, 0.6780496835708618, -0.09676330536603928, 0.42914581298828125, -0.47386980056762695, -0.09121676534414291, -0.6637116074562073, -1.4292298555374146, 0.7360175848007202, -0.8739871978759766, 0.4875820279121399, 0.48767903447151184, 0.1529434770345688, -0.36873844265937805, 0.6649700999259949, -0.1807514876127243, -1.2932305335998535, -0.9722098708152771, -0.8777176141738892, 0.24174875020980835, -0.34380728006362915, -0.02728045918047428, -0.1671360731124878, -0.229456827044487, -0.11868947744369507, -1.3816263675689697, 0.8645485639572144, 0.5156311392784119, -0.19888991117477417, -0.28919315338134766, -0.057851240038871765, 0.4347052574157715, -0.06939219683408737, 0.022800778970122337, 0.06339851021766663, 0.09878382831811905, -0.05689898505806923, -0.9429818391799927, -0.7337273955345154, -1.0478236675262451, -0.6569093465805054, 0.02100052312016487, 0.35678422451019287, -0.36446115374565125, 0.12775582075119019, -0.086833655834198, 0.43342673778533936, -0.24683314561843872, 0.7292792797088623, 0.018358033150434494, 0.3641771972179413, -0.3137122094631195, -0.9108854532241821, -0.3531133532524109, -0.1834242343902588, -0.15639923512935638, -0.6216644644737244, -0.022550925612449646, 0.6140714287757874, 0.8405349254608154, -1.157999038696289, -0.13502053916454315, -0.12021166831254959, -0.324795663356781, -0.6154886484146118, 0.2741684913635254, 0.07419168949127197, -0.13348889350891113, -0.43333810567855835, 0.35623106360435486, 0.7551323771476746, -0.3230685293674469, 0.10668584704399109, 0.5247471928596497, 0.6090347170829773, -0.24693332612514496, 0.1404799520969391, -0.38332903385162354, -0.025111868977546692, -0.40923020243644714, 0.8129360675811768, 0.015967631712555885, 0.3993561565876007, 0.14276206493377686, -0.037444114685058594, -0.07961896061897278, 0.3965184688568115, 0.3596523404121399, -1.1357998847961426, 0.27479806542396545, -0.6626095771789551, 0.18973813951015472, 0.06080206111073494, 0.4146374762058258, 0.18035383522510529, 0.6145432591438293, 0.03666667640209198, -0.5834905505180359, 0.12453875690698624, 0.6155310273170471, 0.49320730566978455, 0.48441585898399353, -0.12756139039993286, -0.19690129160881042, 0.536013662815094, 0.723440945148468, 0.01421564631164074, -0.49543237686157227, -1.0436605215072632, -1.1009387969970703, -0.5028399229049683, 0.04518205299973488, -0.5707657933235168, -0.3271235525608063, 1.3192745447158813, -0.9774894714355469, -1.1139518022537231, -0.03601303696632385, 0.976345419883728, 0.10846861451864243, 0.018416447564959526, -0.1571766883134842, 0.0712834820151329, -0.6133505702018738, -0.35542935132980347, 0.22127081453800201, -1.4390097856521606, -0.17173363268375397, 0.8096596002578735, 0.06708890199661255, -0.29722583293914795, -0.73244309425354, -0.09026836603879929, 0.10425323247909546, 0.40460705757141113, -0.17744562029838562, 0.1851559430360794, -0.1913525015115738, 0.8379434943199158, -0.09052495658397675, -0.21883852779865265, 1.1498744487762451, -0.7196730375289917, 0.6759659647941589, 0.254256933927536, -0.348175585269928, 0.15253330767154694, 0.8067739605903625, 1.019166350364685, -0.28823143243789673, -0.6217406988143921, -0.09213908016681671, 0.5413146615028381, -1.0229295492172241, -0.26944541931152344, -0.7630069851875305, 0.10216335207223892, 0.43437325954437256, 0.07380449026823044, -0.26327887177467346, 1.2389047145843506, 0.08512584120035172, -0.2564276456832886, 0.2589029371738434, 0.6055679321289062, 0.19549740850925446, 0.07503470778465271, 0.37803441286087036, -0.019214514642953873, -0.18757832050323486, -0.5593850612640381, 0.37263211607933044, 0.5335425138473511, -0.7286394238471985, 0.38858774304389954, 0.3401980400085449, 0.7699139714241028, 0.42179352045059204, 0.15823377668857574, -0.24425150454044342, 1.1393500566482544, 0.3721765875816345, 0.21024444699287415, 0.8436864018440247, -0.36072033643722534, -1.0385397672653198, 0.3357667028903961, -0.10088111460208893, -0.682647168636322, 0.1945374310016632, -0.7302874326705933, -0.10030127316713333, -0.8077394366264343, -0.8153324127197266, 0.7744454145431519, 0.023439504206180573, 0.10162375867366791, -0.27496618032455444, -0.2313595414161682, 0.32467636466026306, 0.8825267553329468, -0.2622348964214325, -0.013226491399109364, -0.39053013920783997, 0.12194979935884476, -0.8985986113548279, -0.47957083582878113, 0.24938137829303741, -0.1954624205827713, 0.1836913675069809, -0.2919323146343231, -0.28060129284858704, 0.3808051645755768, 0.1472918689250946, -0.4041920006275177, -0.5691310167312622, 0.04371810331940651, -0.43050384521484375, 0.05719916895031929, -0.3784528374671936, -0.42537468671798706, -0.4930705726146698, 0.4296981394290924, 0.24211233854293823, -0.48470598459243774, -0.4231328070163727, -0.31168967485427856, 0.6614671349525452, -0.3153552711009979, 0.5534871220588684, -0.2209288477897644, 0.7549319863319397, -0.38914501667022705, 0.08488363772630692, 0.24118447303771973, 0.2733590006828308, 0.5346221327781677, 0.3436156213283539, -0.012171945534646511, 0.9814716577529907, 0.6245000958442688, 0.45425674319267273, 0.8418508768081665, 0.7230755686759949, 0.37357768416404724, -0.3131714165210724, -0.24345457553863525, -0.08030088990926743, 0.34941890835762024, 0.6208106875419617, 0.3967013955116272, 0.6097366213798523, 0.4456219971179962, 0.6083113551139832, -0.4188198447227478, -0.9195756316184998, -0.003409125842154026, -0.8685294985771179, -0.7802829742431641, -0.00901174359023571, 0.9879342317581177, 0.4705680012702942, -0.18341141939163208, 0.8348141312599182, -0.015346817672252655, 0.31197744607925415, 0.36819422245025635, -0.5536928772926331, 0.4996599555015564, -0.17472271621227264, -0.5998295545578003, -0.6317778825759888, 0.5766103863716125, -0.13915933668613434, -0.1105019673705101, 0.5190101861953735, 0.08948002755641937, -0.1803310513496399, 0.32279741764068604, -0.17072109878063202, -0.18043982982635498, 1.0009294748306274, -0.5878425240516663, -0.4364095628261566, -0.8779570460319519, -0.20008127391338348, -1.0142898559570312, -0.15344475209712982, 0.6728454232215881, -0.43917322158813477, 0.04479074478149414, 0.4072459638118744, 0.46165958046913147, 0.3416125774383545, 0.8659635186195374, 0.843801736831665, -0.10313641279935837, 0.8033933639526367, 0.1345328986644745, -0.05443739518523216, -0.39240798354148865, 0.19016650319099426, -0.6097991466522217, -0.00791292916983366, -0.3266056776046753, 0.7065283060073853, 0.6236479878425598, -0.19387105107307434, 0.6406489610671997, 0.36537232995033264, -0.3895190358161926, -0.2062675505876541, -1.01004958152771, 0.3214641213417053, -0.02199789509177208, -0.09824946522712708, -0.6203101873397827, 0.45470526814460754, 0.4258928894996643, -0.3278537690639496, -0.12958624958992004, 0.0177032258361578, -0.12120261788368225, -0.47095242142677307, -0.488282173871994, -0.04272708296775818, -0.008225364610552788, 0.26586127281188965, -0.02928782068192959, -0.9104307889938354, 0.3390986919403076, 0.3380563259124756, -0.9035916328430176, -0.5707258582115173, 0.8731392621994019, 0.7568594217300415, 0.5916516780853271, 0.21404068171977997, -0.8002296090126038, 0.17943233251571655, 0.49884647130966187, 0.33127954602241516, 0.18834955990314484, 0.5130441784858704, 0.3592740297317505, 0.20990513265132904, 0.17623446881771088, 0.5229597091674805, 0.25533241033554077, 0.057519443333148956, -0.5801999568939209, 0.15825702250003815, -0.3224494755268097, -0.24954712390899658, -0.3782179355621338, 0.6090371608734131, 0.5488199591636658, -0.17209434509277344, -0.339555561542511, -0.905320405960083, -0.31294938921928406, -0.5956412553787231, 0.8001957535743713, -0.2560657262802124, 0.34853917360305786, 0.6925536394119263, -0.6048864722251892, 0.30540844798088074, -0.6831251382827759, 3.9703972339630127, 1.5094726085662842, 0.493473082780838, -0.3835916817188263, 0.5539181232452393, 0.10007794946432114, 0.5435993075370789, -0.3007495105266571, 0.24707195162773132, 0.21883264183998108, -0.2637138366699219, 0.5404500961303711, -0.23866389691829681, -0.8538083434104919, 0.667474627494812, 0.618394672870636, 0.030557187274098396, -0.26557648181915283, 0.02956758625805378, -0.47684726119041443, 0.4192630648612976, 0.5224080681800842, -0.05946316197514534, 0.031196560710668564, 0.8185625076293945, -0.3894558846950531, 0.47687482833862305, -0.2727929949760437, 0.19007113575935364, -0.24201877415180206, -0.3315427601337433, -0.9681374430656433, 0.11352282017469406, -0.5770518183708191, -0.22707702219486237, -0.037796810269355774, -0.6648340821266174, -1.1591088771820068, 0.34325405955314636, -0.14528462290763855, -0.18304146826267242, -0.2774280607700348, -0.4496135115623474, 0.10975416004657745, -0.27574288845062256, 0.21599628031253815, 0.34607839584350586, 0.9720414280891418, 0.1370224952697754, -0.9334871768951416, 1.54327392578125, -1.1989762783050537, -0.5054268836975098, -0.06543058902025223, -1.182827353477478, 0.02888665162026882, -0.39099371433258057, -0.16020968556404114, 0.3005107045173645, -0.10052186250686646, 0.8657134771347046, 0.5413204431533813, -0.5128164887428284, 0.32796511054039, -0.004026405513286591, 0.5170899629592896, 0.13969185948371887, -0.21031081676483154, -0.16879858076572418, -0.12999024987220764, -0.012713013216853142, 0.17840969562530518, -1.0547384023666382, 0.6017822623252869, 0.6098116636276245, 0.20857587456703186, -0.43698927760124207, 0.3787142336368561, -0.21527099609375, -0.12706789374351501, 0.3808235228061676, 0.25439122319221497, 0.5779452323913574, 0.024704890325665474, 0.061404384672641754, 0.8341381549835205, -0.2311234176158905, -0.31518200039863586, -1.0176174640655518, 0.5939126014709473, -0.3401102125644684, -0.40866991877555847, -0.5033131241798401, -0.17982617020606995, -0.37047961354255676 ]
{"Title": "Dose-dependent degeneration of non-cancerous brain tissue in post-radiotherapy patients: A diffusion tensor imaging study", "Authors": "David Szabolcs, Mesri Hamed Y., Bodiut Victor A., Nagtegaal Steven H. J., Elhalawani Hesham, de Luca Alberto, Philippens Marielle E. P., Viergever Max A., Mohamed Abdallah S. R., Ding Yao, Chung Caroline, Fuller Clifton D., Verhoeff Joost J. C., Leemans Alexander", "Abstract": "Abstract Background and purpose Radiation-induced changes in brain tissue may relate to post-radiotherapy (RT) cognitive decline. Our aim is to investigate changes of the brain microstructural properties after exposure to radiation during clinical protocols of RT using diffusion MRI (dMRI). Methods and Materials The susceptibility of tissue changes to radiation was investigated in a clinically heterogenic cohort (age, pathology, tumor location, type of surgery) consisting of 121 scans of 18 patients (10 females). The imaging dataset included 18 planning CTs and 103 dMRI scans (range 2-14, median = 6 per patient) assessing pre-operative, post-operative pre-RT and post-RT states. Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) metrics were estimated from all scans for a region-of-interest based linear relation analysis between mean dose and change in DTI metrics, while partial volume effects were regressed out. Results The largest regional dose dependency with mean diffusivity appear in the white matter of the frontal pole in the left hemisphere by an increase of 2.61 %/(Gy x year). Full brain-wise, pooled results for white matter show fractional anisotropy to decrease by 0.85 %/(30Gy x year); mean diffusivity increase by 9.17 %/(30Gy x year); axial diffusivity increase by 7.30%/(30Gy x year) and radial diffusivity increases by 10.63%/(30Gy x year). Conclusions White matter is susceptible to radiation with some regional variability where diffusivity metrics demonstrate the largest relative sensitivity. This suggests that dMRI is a promising tool in assessing microstructural changes after RT, which can help in understanding treatment-induced cognitive decline.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005157"}
10.1101/19005470
[ 0.6573113799095154, 0.45156484842300415, -0.322746604681015, 0.15204991400241852, -0.3153613209724426, -0.6431468725204468, -0.05197406932711601, -0.12880253791809082, 0.22340020537376404, 1.070286512374878, -0.03044596128165722, -0.94461590051651, 0.2956164479255676, 0.3738344609737396, -0.4301204979419708, -0.4052903950214386, -0.6913878917694092, -0.47887393832206726, 0.05654800310730934, 0.7275557518005371, -0.5288610458374023, 1.1389710903167725, -0.9953734874725342, -0.7154371738433838, -0.8287335634231567, 0.4271674156188965, -0.2133485972881317, -0.320487380027771, 1.5178048610687256, 0.5256051421165466, 0.8184717297554016, -0.16502971947193146, 0.5217893123626709, -1.2448246479034424, 0.30956974625587463, -0.1904110461473465, 0.09897572547197342, -0.927909791469574, 0.5159777402877808, -0.8616577386856079, 0.7063886523246765, -0.49696600437164307, 0.6144490242004395, -0.48712441325187683, -0.5905267000198364, 0.040626347064971924, -0.1996440291404724, 0.6802417039871216, 0.31919747591018677, -0.006387829780578613, -0.3380798101425171, 0.5580782890319824, -0.23415642976760864, -0.6854618787765503, -0.2559669017791748, -0.37951207160949707, -0.1147068440914154, -0.24989940226078033, -0.003986268769949675, 0.29323434829711914, -0.05287278816103935, -0.2575754225254059, 0.6614258289337158, -0.706376314163208, 0.021360570564866066, 0.4236842095851898, 0.17544309794902802, 0.27374744415283203, -0.19625942409038544, -0.352710098028183, -0.19170480966567993, -0.4830554723739624, -0.47065410017967224, -0.37295475602149963, -0.8993594646453857, 0.164455845952034, -0.1313292235136032, -0.9141721129417419, -0.19351743161678314, 0.06325144320726395, 0.21331697702407837, 1.0601518154144287, 0.5148736834526062, -0.27116554975509644, -0.009734881110489368, -0.29835477471351624, -0.3294681906700134, 0.13614921271800995, 0.10086505115032196, 1.1318299770355225, -0.2753615081310272, 0.6156855225563049, -0.03636603802442551, -0.16779476404190063, 0.12895503640174866, 0.6164685487747192, 0.17787818610668182, 0.5010671019554138, -0.06467984616756439, -0.5032917261123657, 0.9083325266838074, 0.7865327596664429, 0.07675526291131973, 0.930250883102417, -0.3141084313392639, 0.814254105091095, 0.638920247554779, -0.5600594282150269, -0.3656913638114929, -0.8997063636779785, 0.2382809817790985, 0.5259122848510742, -0.6080833673477173, -0.12489614635705948, 1.1712197065353394, 0.7936251163482666, 0.6147167682647705, 0.5502519011497498, -0.8591001033782959, 0.7653353810310364, -0.8862466216087341, -0.2805699408054352, 0.5918624997138977, -0.5669113993644714, -0.3559262752532959, -0.5461092591285706, 0.47262513637542725, 0.690759539604187, -0.47529661655426025, 0.44100797176361084, 0.060227926820516586, -0.04804817587137222, -0.862581729888916, 0.5621316432952881, -0.21221646666526794, 0.076322041451931, 0.46780848503112793, 0.5604337453842163, 0.4192017614841461, -0.03727513551712036, 0.025630731135606766, 0.5415762662887573, -0.2809843122959137, 0.9956257939338684, -0.4156372845172882, 0.6076990365982056, -0.09694794565439224, -0.06027673929929733, -0.18754950165748596, -0.24958638846874237, -0.15063217282295227, 0.8841218948364258, -0.15102708339691162, -0.46177440881729126, 0.40599367022514343, 0.2354840785264969, -0.2956782579421997, 0.38450247049331665, -0.8644530773162842, -0.009710468351840973, -0.754500687122345, -0.42538172006607056, -0.08164536207914352, 0.35200127959251404, -0.7226959466934204, 0.7227444648742676, -0.26626962423324585, -0.11493801325559616, -0.2625304162502289, -0.38631901144981384, 0.9714304804801941, -0.06113835796713829, 0.10399671643972397, 0.0255010724067688, 0.32561224699020386, 0.9850255846977234, 0.5450493097305298, -0.23810634016990662, 0.5560066103935242, 0.735162615776062, 0.19350042939186096, 0.07462277263402939, 0.014507670886814594, -0.19587060809135437, 0.3473290205001831, -0.19095270335674286, -0.41532984375953674, -1.033962368965149, -0.1287759691476822, -0.6713401079177856, -0.03986743092536926, -0.24419647455215454, -0.6022260785102844, 0.6813464760780334, 0.012924962677061558, 0.3819565176963806, 0.05751105397939682, 0.5101516246795654, 0.47762784361839294, 0.017866885289549828, -0.7489071488380432, 0.6168513298034668, -0.3249001204967499, -0.33768513798713684, -0.3879833221435547, 0.6411793828010559, 0.7022590041160583, 1.0197826623916626, -0.18588317930698395, 0.40038490295410156, 1.2914735078811646, -0.6961110830307007, -0.047062069177627563, -0.5551264882087708, 0.07637225091457367, 0.281734436750412, -0.7708796262741089, 0.24480585753917694, -0.8074976801872253, -0.2369157075881958, -0.45989587903022766, -0.41126543283462524, 0.6863111257553101, 0.26385870575904846, 0.4125760793685913, -0.021198589354753494, 0.5672654509544373, 0.20301519334316254, -0.48387113213539124, 0.6167970895767212, 0.6043444871902466, -0.010293930768966675, 0.12986820936203003, 0.9122371077537537, 0.6959729194641113, -0.22686947882175446, 0.2089984267950058, 0.10557226836681366, 0.027721554040908813, -0.2203662395477295, 0.44638967514038086, 0.33086273074150085, 0.2373526692390442, -0.02024620771408081, -0.3296687602996826, 0.813788890838623, -0.5551743507385254, 0.3726133406162262, -0.5168052315711975, 0.5339007377624512, 0.13206782937049866, -0.16739532351493835, 0.10448544472455978, 1.0621216297149658, -0.6206395626068115, -0.1966627538204193, 0.16596369445323944, -0.22796028852462769, -0.49844232201576233, -0.49464407563209534, -0.21017654240131378, 0.004768631886690855, -0.46506181359291077, -0.07710424065589905, 1.1890342235565186, 0.7124253511428833, 0.3819543421268463, -0.18628014624118805, 0.36420682072639465, -0.26729485392570496, -1.0685503482818604, -0.07439833879470825, -0.6083333492279053, -0.6501895785331726, -0.46408727765083313, 0.17972376942634583, 0.31608909368515015, -0.6037362217903137, 0.3111172020435333, -0.004877039231359959, 0.19111111760139465, 0.21253344416618347, -0.23340587317943573, -0.06142677739262581, -0.22177213430404663, 0.15034563839435577, -1.1371738910675049, 0.44490107893943787, 0.2509628236293793, 0.08273070305585861, -0.06509622931480408, -0.3710286319255829, -0.6848891973495483, -0.3287617266178131, 0.700486421585083, 0.05168533697724342, 0.20824772119522095, -0.09856316447257996, 0.1341453492641449, -0.020498041063547134, 0.506531298160553, 0.7122294306755066, 0.7174199819564819, -0.08275821805000305, -0.5574579238891602, 0.5531652569770813, -0.2836300730705261, -0.005499233957380056, 0.13599233329296112, 0.19840501248836517, -0.36844852566719055, 0.6070851683616638, -0.5170942544937134, 0.957096517086029, -0.7427337169647217, 0.4223027527332306, 0.5279028415679932, -0.6596029996871948, 0.8000597953796387, -0.5568398833274841, -0.7776612639427185, 0.09444554895162582, -0.10816311091184616, -0.6426849365234375, -0.034076303243637085, 0.35819557309150696, -0.7868059873580933, -1.1287051439285278, 0.19681961834430695, -0.7306973934173584, -0.8564368486404419, -0.3257439434528351, -0.0453287698328495, -0.13041986525058746, -0.49281203746795654, -0.1840796023607254, -0.7976498007774353, 0.20248614251613617, 0.2480652928352356, 0.6607035994529724, 0.25801560282707214, 0.16360636055469513, 0.3919805884361267, 0.32762840390205383, -0.4883677661418915, 0.20044179260730743, 0.9240512847900391, 0.25158175826072693, -0.02850363776087761, -0.22933600842952728, 0.3030867278575897, 0.4042119085788727, 0.6607930660247803, 0.06613711267709732, -0.774468183517456, 0.7249895334243774, 0.225690558552742, 0.9616819024085999, 0.5233911275863647, 0.029875021427869797, 0.18274949491024017, -0.15045052766799927, -0.525297224521637, 0.4157608151435852, -0.7519006729125977, -0.8741267323493958, 0.4678408205509186, 0.19170479476451874, -0.050167180597782135, -0.030670588836073875, 0.8512198328971863, 0.12838266789913177, -0.6614670157432556, 0.08566298335790634, -0.13127368688583374, 0.4069735109806061, 1.32616126537323, 0.8260118961334229, 1.4670473337173462, -0.9659448266029358, 0.32825732231140137, 0.5810886025428772, 1.108070969581604, 0.3840317726135254, -0.7485014796257019, 1.2033945322036743, -0.4320792555809021, 0.322946161031723, -0.002285502152517438, 0.19009952247142792, 0.0828218087553978, -0.4630592465400696, -0.06312774121761322, 0.09880590438842773, -0.14472489058971405, -0.6022241115570068, 0.015054155141115189, 0.9380120635032654, 0.49637696146965027, -0.24797987937927246, 0.8343949913978577, -0.1271957904100418, 0.8238482475280762, 0.32812342047691345, 0.7018046379089355, -0.18968302011489868, -0.8449563980102539, 0.72071772813797, -0.5924394726753235, 0.1557031124830246, -0.12387381494045258, -0.24726353585720062, -0.6907562613487244, -0.18406425416469574, -0.12582537531852722, 0.2675819993019104, -0.7008585929870605, -0.3951404094696045, -0.16298526525497437, -0.3985403776168823, 0.2745031416416168, -0.10912956297397614, -0.20543316006660461, 0.6736817955970764, -0.13904288411140442, -1.0849214792251587, 0.3039368987083435, -0.5456124544143677, 0.48175206780433655, 0.6346279978752136, 0.1897362768650055, -0.7111126780509949, -1.4092175960540771, 0.44810277223587036, -0.1818285882472992, -0.24699649214744568, -0.3506326675415039, -0.05839475989341736, 0.5472182035446167, -0.8398516178131104, -0.04804054647684097, -1.0684925317764282, 0.26446014642715454, -1.1976467370986938, -0.4983280897140503, -0.2129444032907486, 1.2480593919754028, 0.6078844666481018, 0.25338879227638245, 0.10455479472875595, -0.18635916709899902, -0.4502207338809967, -0.004279314074665308, -0.5536002516746521, -0.22852973639965057, -0.15054668486118317, -0.5245810151100159, -0.488067090511322, -0.027614111080765724, 0.014212279580533504, -0.5498715043067932, -0.3247997760772705, 0.7091085910797119, -0.7135060429573059, -0.15584763884544373, 1.2016148567199707, -0.31456276774406433, 0.5120301842689514, 0.9012414216995239, -0.14287766814231873, 0.03181599825620651, -0.5464072227478027, -0.4623892605304718, -0.07640223950147629, 0.09314776211977005, -0.10222060978412628, 0.17787499725818634, 0.21482829749584198, -0.11443129926919937, 0.5411200523376465, -0.5013152360916138, -0.3842400312423706, -0.2359408289194107, 0.052562516182661057, -1.3539482355117798, -0.9957326650619507, 0.23270820081233978, 1.1451562643051147, -0.5913903117179871, 0.5889931321144104, -0.13736805319786072, -0.3985486328601837, -0.3355022072792053, -0.057899922132492065, -0.763767659664154, 0.2103525549173355, -0.18725797533988953, -0.5978410243988037, -0.025035563856363297, -0.6961171627044678, 0.8954823613166809, -0.34360629320144653, -0.9017515778541565, -0.21450594067573547, 0.30499717593193054, -1.0041075944900513, -0.7355399131774902, -0.6689343452453613, -0.16647034883499146, -0.7286829948425293, -0.6004835367202759, -0.2426518350839615, -1.1879044771194458, -0.049396730959415436, -0.3064706027507782, -0.19090038537979126, 1.0466591119766235, -0.45544666051864624, -0.2810817360877991, 0.002197601366788149, 0.04128465801477432, -0.4336264431476593, -0.058839865028858185, 0.17628179490566254, -0.031474772840738297, -0.38347598910331726, -0.23075219988822937, -0.9665055871009827, -0.675176203250885, -1.316367506980896, -0.11455442756414413, -0.8124560713768005, -0.05091782659292221, -0.17245198786258698, -0.04367200285196304, -0.6856772303581238, 0.1469825655221939, 0.5130263566970825, 0.32496821880340576, -0.22978533804416656, 0.0060094487853348255, 0.27723437547683716, 0.16327697038650513, -0.3734097480773926, 0.27175435423851013, -0.9111153483390808, -0.24244950711727142, 0.9069679379463196, 0.002137076575309038, -0.453997939825058, 0.054470885545015335, 0.10101115703582764, -0.22614824771881104, 0.6176691055297852, -0.792082667350769, -0.3738926947116852, 0.5396972298622131, 0.5047920942306519, -0.05464821308851242, -0.7777667045593262, -1.072157621383667, 0.37187835574150085, -0.7695667147636414, 0.5345566868782043, -0.3910258710384369, -0.5848934650421143, 0.07071252912282944, -0.3904664218425751, 1.193239450454712, -0.4503859579563141, 0.2051563411951065, 0.10089900344610214, 0.673772394657135, 0.41938668489456177, -0.11796469241380692, -0.515217125415802, -0.6668082475662231, -0.6411702632904053, -0.21958038210868835, 0.49542275071144104, -0.16055071353912354, 0.23498018085956573, 0.7104310393333435, -0.4283396303653717, 0.7595677375793457, 0.2645559012889862, 0.6771262288093567, 1.2072770595550537, -0.6609463095664978, -0.07600744813680649, 0.01168850902467966, 0.4195024073123932, -0.21692511439323425, 0.882337212562561, 0.3587751090526581, 0.5514971613883972, 0.08050399273633957, 0.3104902505874634, -0.004335539415478706, -0.9229294061660767, -0.36405807733535767, 0.2868649363517761, 0.8445683717727661, -0.2672465443611145, 0.48824551701545715, -0.01981736533343792, -0.8124604225158691, -0.11761489510536194, 0.7826486229896545, 0.764119565486908, 0.12124551087617874, 0.8660959005355835, 0.3878726065158844, -0.47234073281288147, -0.2038470357656479, -0.44171079993247986, 0.9517247676849365, 0.5328931212425232, 0.44438421726226807, -0.5397515296936035, -0.785196840763092, 0.5828889608383179, 0.37884315848350525, -0.01333790086209774, -0.5627351999282837, -0.13760782778263092, -0.44235095381736755, 0.26953038573265076, -0.3694413900375366, -0.24400632083415985, 0.1816069632768631, 0.03614063933491707, 0.0875081717967987, -0.6849446892738342, 0.2461511492729187, -0.4208991825580597, -0.287803053855896, 0.28777816891670227, -0.7190836071968079, 0.46770116686820984, 0.025421863421797752, -0.6773889660835266, -0.20533479750156403, -0.07731011509895325, -0.11040832847356796, 0.06879784911870956, 0.35484597086906433, 0.7137641310691833, -0.48355382680892944, 0.7996515035629272, 0.6840198040008545, 0.10757318139076233, 0.08192165195941925, 0.07629359513521194, -0.5357083082199097, 0.405595064163208, 0.28179821372032166, -0.7120100855827332, -0.7855836749076843, 0.22667483985424042, -0.10282517224550247, 0.30528178811073303, 0.30982473492622375, -0.688843309879303, 0.5658093094825745, 0.11784734576940536, 0.4994893968105316, -0.46650534868240356, -0.5014433264732361, -0.3040270507335663, -0.09054381400346756, 0.013245830312371254, -0.18891683220863342, -0.08583562821149826, -0.24723832309246063, -1.2292593717575073, -1.0848278999328613, -0.2718414068222046, 0.3569504916667938, -0.42399415373802185, -0.01693463884294033, -0.20807859301567078, 0.27976202964782715, -0.7683727145195007, -0.7710954546928406, -0.22118379175662994, -0.14767685532569885, -0.15594224631786346, 0.6096662282943726, -0.6701210141181946, -0.16409678757190704, 0.0956016406416893, 0.5914246439933777, 0.5469979047775269, -0.4542192816734314, 0.3006265163421631, -0.4593019485473633, -0.1430971324443817, 0.8946458697319031, -0.2545199692249298, 0.5052115321159363, 0.6654989719390869, -1.1521672010421753, 0.5551167130470276, -0.167441263794899, -0.5629657506942749, 0.21338845789432526, -0.7045274376869202, 0.3724827170372009, -0.28138867020606995, -0.5164050459861755, -0.35203003883361816, 0.5377506017684937, -0.26307412981987, -0.8208208680152893, -0.31792256236076355, 0.3591988682746887, 0.26376113295555115, -0.3810136616230011, -0.38169899582862854, 0.40192803740501404, -0.026673313230276108, 0.04658918082714081, -0.38362258672714233, 0.6056427955627441, 0.197286918759346, 0.053994763642549515, 0.5214371681213379, 0.4376130700111389, 0.23553688824176788, -1.5706284046173096, 0.15852364897727966, 0.24671682715415955, -0.016796400770545006, 0.6529050469398499, -0.6231988072395325, 0.05020270496606827, -0.4678838551044464, 0.2933024764060974, 0.01200861670076847, 0.8872031569480896, 0.88472580909729, 1.0257017612457275, -0.36481544375419617, -0.42816460132598877, -0.2976838946342468, -0.30332985520362854, -0.9679258465766907, 0.18321838974952698, 0.31321898102760315, -0.3115791976451874, -0.19928143918514252, -0.8292308449745178, -0.617932915687561, 0.6614418029785156, 0.07341273128986359, 0.3873272240161896, -0.03815897926688194, 0.27449777722358704, 0.07381170243024826, 1.041061282157898, -0.08885928988456726, 0.19163382053375244, 0.6862130761146545, -0.0434524342417717, -0.15838007628917694, -0.329635351896286, 0.4086938798427582, 0.6521263122558594, -0.13705381751060486, -0.5573797821998596, -0.42449331283569336, 0.29503530263900757, -0.42812633514404297, -0.6841326355934143, -0.002290582051500678, 0.15924617648124695, -0.45282915234565735, -0.12049121409654617, -0.21821744740009308, -0.27612248063087463, -0.052826177328825, 0.10454421490430832, -0.16950739920139313, -0.23968087136745453, -0.8404995799064636, -0.2525118887424469, 0.977562427520752, 0.24239949882030487, 0.2436625212430954, -0.13344162702560425, 0.27262207865715027, 0.4798966646194458, -0.35594406723976135, 0.16938018798828125, 0.7056764364242554, -0.22420726716518402, 0.11698909848928452, 0.2574927508831024, 0.6135721206665039, 0.29370200634002686, -0.5749693512916565, -0.292170912027359, 1.160319447517395, 0.2515999376773834, -0.11949288100004196, 0.30663299560546875, -0.5567312240600586, 0.47716182470321655, -0.018146609887480736, -0.21010592579841614, -0.2647586166858673, 0.6710596680641174, 0.981461226940155, 0.07242483645677567, -0.2905769944190979, 0.6611022353172302, -0.7381875514984131, -0.3897246718406677, -0.2636062204837799, 0.14939522743225098, 1.0840493440628052, 0.2554125487804413, 0.31804007291793823, 0.6086502075195312, 0.6709253787994385, 0.21359631419181824, -0.2472948133945465, 0.7823907136917114, -0.4106104075908661, 0.3263155221939087, -0.4332464933395386, 0.870553731918335, -0.9392491579055786, -0.0626852810382843, 0.34674572944641113, -0.05399586260318756, -0.11456817388534546, 0.4665302634239197, -0.8883750438690186, 0.061153847724199295, 1.1779088973999023, -0.41795653104782104, 0.4870683252811432, -0.5771932005882263, 0.18979254364967346, 0.16667000949382782, -0.5755417943000793, 0.5106604099273682, -0.40536296367645264, 0.01558668538928032, 0.1462799459695816, 0.5765591263771057, 0.8844714164733887, 0.5870614647865295, 0.8649259209632874, -0.33317843079566956, 0.46076878905296326, 0.3194214105606079, 0.03586956858634949, -0.2453647404909134, -0.5675216913223267, 0.3421124219894409, -0.47200778126716614, -0.10525825619697571, -0.35502415895462036, 0.23236025869846344, 0.15657980740070343, -0.8672851324081421, 0.2726556062698364, 0.0623965710401535, -0.38239389657974243, -0.5920025706291199, -0.24030783772468567, -0.3355645537376404, 0.7182841300964355, -0.07553505897521973, 0.6552484035491943, -0.33699655532836914, -0.5992670655250549, -0.06989012658596039, -0.37238579988479614, -0.7428042888641357, -0.2391381561756134, -0.48125627636909485, 1.3623586893081665, 0.015008440241217613, -0.015521323308348656, 0.1382909119129181, -1.0525152683258057, -0.12923233211040497, 0.2861354947090149, -0.5457928776741028, -0.6547324657440186, -0.2024296522140503, 0.7715799808502197, 0.5666468143463135, 0.23316361010074615, 0.14554709196090698, 0.23631860315799713, -0.0306034367531538, 0.5785791277885437, 0.05239621922373772, -0.22070097923278809, -0.7720153331756592, 0.004719806369394064, 0.146532341837883, -0.5109846591949463, 0.3550444543361664, 0.41666489839553833, 0.14829088747501373, -0.22945307195186615, -0.34104087948799133, 0.10675744712352753, -0.9450075626373291, 0.4575512409210205, 0.4224255383014679, 0.17191071808338165, -0.461205393075943, -0.1863742470741272, -0.6615844368934631, -0.16009095311164856, 1.2221184968948364, -0.1132097914814949, -0.1072990670800209, 0.03272668272256851, 0.7182408571243286, 0.44566309452056885, -1.1516727209091187, 4.08405876159668, 0.6858358383178711, 0.3041994273662567, -0.3788318634033203, 1.0812612771987915, 0.9718406200408936, -0.33671995997428894, -0.34521234035491943, 0.01543864794075489, -0.19429297745227814, -0.3378765881061554, -0.17641113698482513, -0.03558758646249771, 0.34507936239242554, 0.44055840373039246, 0.41424837708473206, -0.38452082872390747, 0.6030252575874329, -0.5092476606369019, -0.47259172797203064, -0.5195178985595703, 0.47960910201072693, -0.5743788480758667, -0.11910367012023926, 0.7085854411125183, -0.2313290238380432, 0.16004259884357452, 0.17052048444747925, 0.2365533709526062, -0.5190220475196838, 0.4882420003414154, -0.4840816259384155, -0.36239302158355713, -0.5128878951072693, -0.19651606678962708, 0.705807089805603, 0.2944153845310211, -1.2227412462234497, -0.13672493398189545, -0.2292250692844391, 0.02600960247218609, -0.15872006118297577, 0.03244319185614586, -0.005576383322477341, -0.21453070640563965, 0.4042990803718567, -0.8491132855415344, -0.1998378187417984, 0.5819120407104492, -0.47842568159103394, 0.5686991810798645, -0.7042660117149353, -0.12856586277484894, -0.47172272205352783, -1.2927123308181763, 0.010143224149942398, 0.5032745599746704, -0.8921284675598145, -0.2888282239437103, 0.2598411738872528, 0.29486265778541565, -0.5518019199371338, 0.18062321841716766, 0.29865890741348267, -0.021790169179439545, 0.7416929602622986, -0.07219462841749191, 0.07648593932390213, -0.1092216745018959, -0.6866936683654785, -0.18138453364372253, -0.4715564548969269, -0.6699287295341492, 0.13938459753990173, 0.2868153750896454, 0.029925189912319183, 0.46668994426727295, 0.5355392098426819, -0.43758878111839294, -0.9974064230918884, 0.6976501941680908, -0.20630422234535217, 0.13440406322479248, -0.40798306465148926, 0.01374586671590805, 0.8903735876083374, 0.20499004423618317, 0.010242930613458157, -0.29400870203971863, -0.0949738398194313, 0.8360483050346375, -0.30262109637260437, -0.007600063923746347, 0.10277394205331802, -0.007490299642086029 ]
{"Title": "Influenza-associated mortality for different causes of death during the 2010-2011 through the 2014-2015 influenza seasons in Russia", "Authors": "Goldstein Edward", "Abstract": "Abstract Background There is limited information on the volume of influenza-associated mortality in Russia. Methods Using previously developed methodology (Goldstein et al., Epidemiology 2012), we regressed the monthly rates of mortality for respiratory causes, circulatory causes, and for certain infectious and parasitic diseases (available from the Russian Federal State Statistics Service (Rosstat)) linearly against the monthly proxies for the incidence of influenza A/H3N2, A/H1N1 and B (obtained using data from the Smorodintsev Research Institute of Influenza (RII) on levels of ILI/ARI consultations and the percent of respiratory specimens testing positive for influenza A/H3N2, A/H1N1 and B), adjusting for the baseline rates of mortality not associated with influenza circulation and temporal trends. Results For the 2010/11 through the 2014/15 seasons, influenza circulation was associated with an average annual 11106 (95% CI (4321,17892)) deaths for circulatory causes, 4552 (3744,5360) deaths for respiratory causes, and 343 (63,624) deaths for certain infectious and parasitic diseases, with influenza A/H3N2 being responsible for the majority of influenza-associated respiratory deaths and influenza B making a substantial contribution to influenza-associated mortality for circulatory causes. Conclusions Influenza circulation is associated with a substantial mortality burden in Russia, particularly for circulatory deaths. Those results support the potential utility of influenza vaccination (with the role played by influenza B in circulatory mortality pointing to the benefit of quadrivalent influenza vaccines), as well as of administration of antiviral drugs for high-risk individuals during periods of active influenza circulation.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005470"}
10.1101/19002204
[ 0.535319447517395, -0.1931162178516388, 0.2753675580024719, 0.5308201909065247, -0.8043051362037659, -0.5015597939491272, 1.024431586265564, -0.2629473805427551, 0.3524930477142334, 0.6846849322319031, -0.14524932205677032, -0.5964339375495911, 0.524721086025238, -0.6483749151229858, 0.09110765904188156, -0.04789172112941742, -0.99587082862854, 0.3328178822994232, 0.2053786814212799, -0.6312015652656555, 0.6286457777023315, 0.2829350233078003, -0.8591309189796448, 0.7184898257255554, -0.6353585124015808, 0.48140114545822144, -0.01064395997673273, 0.24536865949630737, 1.797593355178833, 0.29092884063720703, 0.09968088567256927, -0.9064390659332275, 0.346174418926239, -1.007781744003296, 0.08915300667285919, -0.25635263323783875, 1.190301537513733, -0.14469070732593536, -0.047886643558740616, -0.17980296909809113, -0.14406321942806244, -0.17489424347877502, 0.0020967796444892883, -0.34377673268318176, -0.28577694296836853, -0.8199121952056885, -0.39682525396347046, -0.27236834168434143, -0.4700574278831482, -0.2350037544965744, 0.19676001369953156, 0.2675004005432129, 0.12172377109527588, -0.9311283230781555, 0.2767220437526703, 0.08760549873113632, -0.29482564330101013, -0.16080829501152039, -0.9166620373725891, 0.1049802228808403, 0.4454309940338135, 0.1295587569475174, 0.6353920102119446, -1.5671309232711792, 0.37656348943710327, 0.262431800365448, -0.15697985887527466, -0.5316377282142639, -0.48684626817703247, -0.3732580840587616, -1.1056737899780273, -0.22598612308502197, -0.2766045331954956, -1.2666513919830322, -0.03598131239414215, 0.023505639284849167, 0.42659151554107666, 0.08034148812294006, 0.30590909719467163, -0.390347421169281, 0.5381944179534912, 0.39807283878326416, -0.045790862292051315, 0.3631574511528015, -0.8327519297599792, -0.30322161316871643, 0.5950377583503723, 0.386748731136322, 0.4725259244441986, -0.4407409131526947, 0.42026153206825256, 0.19268490374088287, -0.06897325813770294, -0.0026340459007769823, -0.15681113302707672, 1.0924502611160278, -0.33526352047920227, -0.3021707534790039, 0.5262094140052795, 0.3836666941642761, 0.8516896963119507, 0.9540073871612549, -0.06096712499856949, 1.4442534446716309, -0.7632452249526978, 0.5267537236213684, 0.16622936725616455, -0.9392478466033936, -0.9178791046142578, -1.0734246969223022, 0.2105317860841751, 0.4533105492591858, 0.1750655174255371, -0.024463431909680367, 0.4213847219944, 0.730135440826416, -0.21500447392463684, 0.8088500499725342, -0.24868524074554443, 0.583077609539032, -0.48675307631492615, -0.0023546896409243345, 0.15711423754692078, -0.3493148982524872, 0.23468704521656036, -0.4932518005371094, 0.5359535813331604, 0.6722238063812256, 0.017482275143265724, -0.212999165058136, -0.27662843465805054, -0.8147518634796143, -0.04524882137775421, 0.2900876998901367, -0.3686679005622864, -0.15182335674762726, 0.2820459008216858, 1.1070512533187866, -0.36325693130493164, -0.5252714157104492, -0.24386988580226898, 0.34698182344436646, -0.8346087336540222, 0.8665117621421814, 0.1348227709531784, 0.5521387457847595, 0.10145800560712814, -1.3453752994537354, -0.223486065864563, 0.7935821413993835, -0.197928324341774, 0.3595697581768036, 0.46574243903160095, -0.32233309745788574, -0.4019622504711151, -0.33182650804519653, -0.6330195665359497, 0.38599181175231934, -0.032728079706430435, -0.12645992636680603, -0.5532011389732361, 0.835041344165802, -0.2869203984737396, 0.7184956669807434, -0.21874889731407166, 0.5707185864448547, 0.74166339635849, -0.4602763056755066, 0.5490689873695374, -0.9490727782249451, 0.27135950326919556, 0.8315196633338928, -0.13516302406787872, -0.4106118679046631, 0.7105650305747986, 1.16715669631958, 1.283316731452942, 0.063682422041893, 0.888700008392334, 0.045937687158584595, -0.1972312331199646, -0.5779153108596802, 0.6004402041435242, 1.0113939046859741, -0.834243655204773, 0.10199404507875443, -0.5146054625511169, -1.1309902667999268, 0.20433713495731354, 0.017752261832356453, -0.3012165129184723, 0.2839314341545105, -0.8406181931495667, 1.0243154764175415, 0.2337576299905777, 0.38023293018341064, -0.3810511827468872, 0.9394120573997498, 0.7390495538711548, -1.1020145416259766, -0.4598403573036194, 0.9997660517692566, 0.05824240669608116, 0.1672816276550293, -0.18876558542251587, 0.5597092509269714, 0.284640908241272, -0.43783053755760193, -0.06365173310041428, -0.04857457056641579, 0.6009158492088318, 0.26527339220046997, -0.14800310134887695, 0.5148204565048218, 1.2418521642684937, -0.5729644894599915, -0.49859753251075745, -0.5238919258117676, -0.1704121232032776, 0.11116011440753937, 0.13936422765254974, -0.536081075668335, 0.7037039399147034, 0.1306825578212738, 0.6283512711524963, 0.7296854853630066, -0.1589450091123581, 0.6244634389877319, -0.4188486337661743, -0.7010383009910583, 0.04588012769818306, 1.120765209197998, 0.08961992710828781, 0.6802933216094971, 0.4312227666378021, 0.5743420124053955, 0.5252814888954163, 0.15701349079608917, 0.19307859241962433, -0.4089033007621765, -0.2385476976633072, 0.8246779441833496, 0.9193949699401855, 0.7513676881790161, -0.4078198969364166, 0.34991544485092163, 0.1869729459285736, 0.0019086733227595687, 0.09656193852424622, 0.7524178624153137, -0.2944176495075226, 0.4886168837547302, -0.2933412492275238, 0.8475814461708069, -0.6519040465354919, -1.0595574378967285, 0.27998390793800354, 0.5273653864860535, -0.35140642523765564, -0.9702926278114319, -0.13459202647209167, 0.42274200916290283, 0.06026960536837578, -0.27253228425979614, 0.8779599070549011, 0.6399719715118408, -0.1277187466621399, 0.8351449966430664, 0.513085126876831, -0.15591450035572052, -0.06483117491006851, -0.8330403566360474, -1.7933330535888672, -0.862372636795044, -0.9762552380561829, -0.4307585656642914, 0.030630221590399742, -0.7272700667381287, -0.012165684252977371, -0.38150376081466675, 0.44283270835876465, -0.5558568239212036, 0.40528467297554016, 0.4921243190765381, 0.2564651370048523, 0.04049384593963623, -1.2281121015548706, 0.24147509038448334, 0.30396339297294617, 0.296938419342041, 0.14006191492080688, 0.08454729616641998, -0.7432733774185181, -0.5343825221061707, 0.7347901463508606, -0.9378814101219177, 0.24999873340129852, 0.9167667031288147, -0.6269739270210266, -0.3082517981529236, 0.5567977428436279, -0.11956098675727844, 0.15905165672302246, -0.35895711183547974, -0.8397810459136963, 0.8271030187606812, 0.8563234210014343, 0.27159520983695984, 0.5240552425384521, 0.33779773116111755, -0.5689893364906311, 0.7035132646560669, 0.16623905301094055, -0.2517423927783966, -1.019456148147583, 0.07357465475797653, 0.737682044506073, -0.7884952425956726, 0.25773435831069946, -0.16585786640644073, -1.2960838079452515, -0.560836672782898, 0.1646437793970108, -0.24121560156345367, -0.5921863317489624, 0.1377994567155838, -0.2500954270362854, -1.482651948928833, -0.3108396828174591, -0.5354874730110168, -0.833289623260498, -0.05801121145486832, -0.35407423973083496, 0.3324717879295349, -0.2297060638666153, -0.42023736238479614, -0.4498346149921417, 0.03965926170349121, 0.7988343834877014, 0.2769985795021057, 0.5363950729370117, -0.6198139190673828, -0.954796552658081, 0.05038857460021973, -0.03171178326010704, 0.2602298855781555, 0.09357111901044846, -0.8044458031654358, -0.018740572035312653, -0.2912465035915375, -0.27259039878845215, 0.6817353963851929, 0.6436807513237, -0.006985731888562441, 0.49845054745674133, 0.3826858401298523, -0.08519778400659561, -0.2386583834886551, 0.5140087008476257, 0.779567539691925, -0.09715963155031204, 0.36269235610961914, 0.35060158371925354, 1.3508273363113403, -0.8966019153594971, -0.7463239431381226, 0.02740863896906376, -0.32350629568099976, 0.5272860527038574, -0.8194231986999512, 0.7133299112319946, -0.5114348530769348, 0.24947351217269897, 0.19417348504066467, -0.07954318076372147, -0.18394538760185242, 1.115441918373108, -0.00658315559849143, 1.559617042541504, -1.1833747625350952, -0.1007441058754921, 0.6966114044189453, 0.7131268382072449, 0.07447710633277893, -0.3893108665943146, 0.07352424412965775, -0.3785203695297241, 0.44907498359680176, 0.4220682680606842, 0.2826438844203949, -0.16703446209430695, 0.12214241921901703, -0.5526267886161804, 0.31163308024406433, -0.7938085198402405, -0.42367491126060486, 0.03817209601402283, 0.6224621534347534, -0.03935699164867401, -0.45881837606430054, 1.0161263942718506, -0.0925336480140686, 0.08890140056610107, 0.09894697368144989, 0.05271957069635391, -0.46803441643714905, -0.6745765209197998, -0.08497576415538788, -0.4165571630001068, -0.6380507349967957, -0.23731987178325653, 0.5952264070510864, -0.43466949462890625, -0.057005465030670166, 0.433388888835907, -0.37432417273521423, -0.3907119631767273, -0.8219724297523499, -0.3704815208911896, 0.14021113514900208, -0.1837954968214035, -0.28155189752578735, -0.7821903228759766, 0.6518920660018921, -0.1059960424900055, -0.6397886872291565, -0.08677031844854355, -0.36635181307792664, 0.10657516866922379, 0.36316239833831787, -0.18079932034015656, -1.013649582862854, -0.2578662931919098, -0.36240488290786743, -0.3026244342327118, -0.045463621616363525, 0.0028886033687740564, -0.3315320909023285, -0.08568864315748215, 0.3538939356803894, -0.512042224407196, -0.8285695314407349, -0.5823633670806885, -0.7426977157592773, 0.16295640170574188, 0.16741861402988434, 0.9110473990440369, 0.5172517895698547, 0.9448935389518738, 0.22309646010398865, 0.8008070588111877, -0.806229829788208, 0.31484562158584595, -0.713712215423584, -0.7637368440628052, -0.3129987120628357, -0.07329235970973969, -0.1929486095905304, 0.10303881764411926, -0.2630091607570648, -0.2932335436344147, 0.25712740421295166, 0.14566272497177124, 0.08752662688493729, -0.4231523871421814, 1.2273590564727783, -0.1694527119398117, 0.28604260087013245, 0.643171489238739, -0.2374328076839447, -0.02046128176152706, 0.16636331379413605, -0.05355105549097061, -0.7245028614997864, 0.34813082218170166, 0.06068672984838486, 0.4352395534515381, -0.6086462736129761, -0.241486057639122, -0.3015497624874115, 0.8347615003585815, 0.4937138855457306, -0.3518235981464386, 0.1267281323671341, -1.0056586265563965, -0.5478531718254089, -0.3860633969306946, -0.6700841188430786, -0.8587405681610107, 0.5645032525062561, -0.14898614585399628, -0.4391590654850006, -0.6571313142776489, 0.7460132241249084, -0.6461729407310486, 0.041544217616319656, -1.022721290588379, -0.07630868256092072, -0.5364466905593872, 0.0502677746117115, 0.8013497591018677, -0.06487741321325302, -0.5278719067573547, 0.33024609088897705, 0.3897421360015869, -0.7106311321258545, -0.37140196561813354, -0.4091915488243103, 0.14310267567634583, -0.38325899839401245, 0.002339024096727371, 0.524840772151947, -0.3622693419456482, 0.24957910180091858, -0.32804790139198303, -0.5696842074394226, 0.33739984035491943, -0.09840548783540726, -0.7715752124786377, 0.8892561197280884, -0.1255834698677063, -0.8879337906837463, -0.6785998344421387, 0.46719902753829956, 0.20767484605312347, 0.1314479559659958, -0.2814324200153351, -0.11965012550354004, -0.6395787596702576, -1.4968844652175903, -0.09814874827861786, -0.9938634634017944, 0.3101644217967987, -0.2918570637702942, -0.25412240624427795, 0.04732628911733627, -0.022880839183926582, 0.4322584867477417, 0.2938467860221863, -0.3670419454574585, -0.5786758661270142, 0.7238683104515076, 0.1809099316596985, -0.0033001983538269997, -0.20119352638721466, -0.1839596927165985, 0.29865092039108276, 0.21969929337501526, -0.02546336129307747, 0.1346137970685959, 0.6577826738357544, 0.02712417207658291, 0.32441607117652893, 0.9444377422332764, -0.3732048571109772, -0.7228177189826965, 0.43679386377334595, 0.43662235140800476, 0.18528804183006287, -0.24751761555671692, -1.38076651096344, 0.29866719245910645, -1.0067763328552246, 0.3110426068305969, -0.3158457279205322, -0.4087117612361908, -0.5465173125267029, -0.6674609184265137, 0.7181506752967834, -0.4268048107624054, 0.9566701054573059, 0.5844532251358032, 0.0232005026191473, 0.21440182626247406, 0.4241721034049988, -0.8463567495346069, -0.05237499251961708, -0.8708863258361816, -1.1721223592758179, -0.0019174044718965888, 0.18496105074882507, 0.32620859146118164, 0.44928473234176636, 0.14653359353542328, -0.0016664672875776887, -0.41446009278297424, 1.2652817964553833, 0.30214723944664, -0.6993322968482971, -0.6638590097427368, -0.1491595208644867, 0.24920059740543365, -0.15043959021568298, 0.1703602373600006, 0.07406893372535706, -0.7908962965011597, 0.2566099464893341, -0.3576034903526306, -0.9189673066139221, -0.5933612585067749, -0.7586256861686707, 0.024351568892598152, 0.7178001999855042, 0.42555275559425354, 0.10319339483976364, 0.035234592854976654, -0.12369397282600403, -0.656396746635437, 0.8413866758346558, -0.6819236874580383, 0.2357635796070099, 0.6591082811355591, -0.08115608990192413, -0.4481803774833679, -0.10207928717136383, -0.44249606132507324, -0.26528337597846985, -0.35653412342071533, 0.03535410389304161, 0.5695852041244507, -0.8733627200126648, 0.9973130226135254, 0.3683922588825226, -0.7930451035499573, -0.7424454689025879, 0.280765563249588, 0.06092271953821182, 0.35021305084228516, -0.5151206851005554, -0.23549982905387878, 0.29737165570259094, -0.5108320116996765, 0.1822001338005066, 0.047548793256282806, -0.48531481623649597, -0.10245739668607712, -0.7382773160934448, -0.16472746431827545, -0.6903978586196899, -0.416152685880661, 0.08412996679544449, -0.8893665671348572, 0.4963129758834839, 0.523445188999176, 0.5149557590484619, 0.6453871130943298, 0.13562460243701935, 0.3051520884037018, -0.6318824887275696, -0.4234282672405243, 0.09379161149263382, 0.42778611183166504, 0.03083362802863121, 0.01238316111266613, -0.49951353669166565, 1.0145336389541626, 0.0348421111702919, -1.1693917512893677, -0.6065433621406555, 0.6702008247375488, 0.6102262139320374, 0.5231472253799438, -0.4792356491088867, -0.04104889929294586, 0.6681534647941589, 1.2923030853271484, -0.03651592507958412, -0.6853320598602295, -0.6849312782287598, -0.8212152123451233, 0.030242715030908585, 0.4927451014518738, -0.8508722186088562, -0.3772316873073578, 0.9065729379653931, -0.5780842304229736, -0.7908451557159424, -0.7072713971138, 1.0690895318984985, -0.22854772210121155, -0.5320537090301514, -0.6816134452819824, 0.22666332125663757, -0.36319053173065186, -0.15493623912334442, 0.07300692796707153, -1.021020770072937, -0.491234689950943, 1.150648593902588, -1.0430972576141357, -0.5292930006980896, 0.6182958483695984, 0.3931368589401245, -0.06199844926595688, 0.6329559683799744, -1.07832932472229, -0.3625164330005646, -0.22406060993671417, 0.6341502666473389, 0.4752223491668701, 0.09549787640571594, 0.6990849375724792, 0.07970577478408813, 0.7021824717521667, 0.3285260796546936, 0.2030068188905716, -0.41118499636650085, 0.46549302339553833, 0.3854360282421112, -0.5768405795097351, -0.40350833535194397, -0.25596362352371216, 0.3809390366077423, -0.906329333782196, -0.5481046438217163, -0.9358325600624084, -0.005601182579994202, -0.10107233375310898, 0.5304475426673889, -0.030546313151717186, 0.5710809826850891, 0.062164995819330215, -0.02237219549715519, 0.6715056300163269, 0.32432326674461365, 0.41705745458602905, 0.07567374408245087, 0.22913537919521332, -0.14877568185329437, -0.19278797507286072, -0.6757481098175049, 0.3009936213493347, -0.31218528747558594, -0.6387584209442139, 0.23563237488269806, -0.7203214168548584, 0.48461204767227173, 0.4479442238807678, 0.16265574097633362, 0.6848291158676147, 0.9796721935272217, 0.49189019203186035, 1.015805721282959, 0.27133214473724365, -0.3549021780490875, -1.3289517164230347, -0.12342455238103867, -0.9831509590148926, -1.1723390817642212, 0.7986605763435364, -0.32885968685150146, -0.14678075909614563, -0.44506707787513733, -1.095725178718567, 0.46352419257164, 0.18718338012695312, 0.013271214440464973, -0.007829854264855385, 0.9344807863235474, 0.2609020173549652, 0.17173735797405243, 0.17888298630714417, 0.2456943392753601, 0.5053108930587769, 0.30674049258232117, -0.9926593899726868, -0.3548683226108551, -0.16472700238227844, 0.15441687405109406, 0.7605962157249451, -0.1413106620311737, -0.21694587171077728, 0.5673813223838806, 0.42371729016304016, -0.5344441533088684, 0.635193943977356, 0.8416610360145569, -0.2883843183517456, 0.2082943469285965, -0.6929318308830261, 0.05520947277545929, -0.04021332785487175, 0.708604633808136, 0.6523664593696594, -0.43762508034706116, -1.0418206453323364, -0.06821689754724503, 0.7019364237785339, -0.8348469138145447, 0.21234579384326935, -0.6632437705993652, 0.7490119338035583, -0.2737653851509094, 0.24030795693397522, 0.4976818859577179, 1.3756840229034424, 0.45808109641075134, 0.013248168863356113, -0.39365580677986145, 0.6237980723381042, 0.9674318432807922, 0.48381033539772034, 0.3671422004699707, 0.24760453402996063, 0.20520082116127014, 0.1069665253162384, 0.19517634809017181, -0.9695756435394287, 0.39773058891296387, 0.6179031729698181, -0.5425359010696411, 0.2439492791891098, -0.20613165199756622, 0.47122716903686523, -0.279782772064209, -0.8206823468208313, 0.7057832479476929, -0.13575631380081177, -0.2662886679172516, -0.05609876289963722, 0.8588031530380249, 0.8702123761177063, 0.38906481862068176, 0.48100462555885315, -0.032549045979976654, 0.9154702425003052, 0.20069029927253723, -0.06677702814340591, 1.1887856721878052, -0.3262636959552765, -1.1775387525558472, -0.24765388667583466, 0.6720078587532043, 0.07872571796178818, 0.21936936676502228, 0.15034836530685425, -0.7812309861183167, -0.37833648920059204, 0.7215961217880249, 0.25508663058280945, -0.5518676042556763, 0.24485625326633453, -0.41821587085723877, -0.19550608098506927, -0.1299777626991272, -0.12487675994634628, -1.1814979314804077, -0.5173182487487793, 0.43557849526405334, -0.6333386301994324, 0.058822013437747955, 0.3429856300354004, 0.5926941633224487, 0.7636649012565613, 0.6147842407226562, 0.9154683947563171, -0.14921127259731293, 0.6686434149742126, 0.39362141489982605, 0.17833451926708221, 0.2706294357776642, 0.41651296615600586, 0.03405407443642616, -0.0721464455127716, -0.08172508329153061, 0.5235720872879028, 0.5906563401222229, -0.1899208426475525, -0.2567240297794342, 0.07916560769081116, -0.2956368625164032, -0.2417115867137909, -1.2463096380233765, -0.08103597909212112, -0.22611410915851593, 0.1854429394006729, 0.127380833029747, 0.5841068029403687, 0.21362464129924774, 0.9309898018836975, -0.4227903485298157, -0.13304100930690765, -0.36852169036865234, -0.19592738151550293, -0.03709060326218605, -0.02630063332617283, 0.10051635652780533, -0.6943602561950684, -0.11445492506027222, -1.1784639358520508, -0.5148077011108398, 0.3134160339832306, 0.002217033412307501, -0.9486782550811768, 0.22557410597801208, 0.15685619413852692, 0.635023832321167, 0.4027804732322693, -0.40086495876312256, 0.17705698311328888, 0.4186480641365051, 0.5637189149856567, -0.41758057475090027, 0.599115252494812, 0.12640529870986938, 0.11077294498682022, 0.10671281069517136, -0.2410927265882492, 0.5403314232826233, 0.11778588593006134, -0.882261335849762, -0.5206471681594849, -0.025311267003417015, -0.4077194333076477, -0.3139582872390747, 0.33302369713783264, 0.7561835646629333, -1.086127758026123, -0.08711741119623184, -0.7961785197257996, -0.20917361974716187, -0.5986252427101135, 1.4426448345184326, -0.43331238627433777, 0.658807635307312, 0.4941138029098511, -0.5199600458145142, 0.8349073529243469, -1.0313597917556763, 3.7265243530273438, 1.0501275062561035, 0.4343266785144806, -0.22924546897411346, 0.054594650864601135, 0.08503089100122452, 0.9850988984107971, -0.830683708190918, 0.08993425220251083, 0.07571476697921753, -0.31759199500083923, 0.6985318064689636, -0.47591736912727356, -0.7294108271598816, 1.0058187246322632, 0.27779921889305115, -0.9013177156448364, -0.38830432295799255, 0.5494171977043152, -0.7651075124740601, -0.25012874603271484, 0.5709228515625, -0.06420335173606873, 0.10696390271186829, 0.40734946727752686, -0.5136008858680725, 0.5281752347946167, 0.025669151917099953, -0.39312562346458435, -0.6917789578437805, 0.273160457611084, -0.57550448179245, 0.016099244356155396, -0.7248042821884155, 0.06054045632481575, 0.7742131948471069, -0.040461618453264236, -0.5300968289375305, -0.2165115773677826, -0.27861541509628296, 0.3825265169143677, 0.23610228300094604, -0.2959684133529663, 0.2271384745836258, -0.5809386968612671, 0.49353471398353577, -0.5802931785583496, 0.4115152060985565, 0.9667073488235474, -0.7641964554786682, 0.8159496784210205, -0.7336379885673523, -0.05416160076856613, -0.028331223875284195, -1.14820396900177, -0.7753747701644897, -0.40396156907081604, -0.6388029456138611, -0.18867391347885132, 0.5880252122879028, 0.8303598165512085, 0.3946804106235504, 0.028886141255497932, -0.06733286380767822, -0.34482070803642273, 0.025267688557505608, 0.5643471479415894, 0.363432914018631, 0.003364479634910822, -0.020832747220993042, -0.026257114484906197, 0.9268089532852173, -0.5505509972572327, 0.21151000261306763, 0.46314072608947754, 0.8456266522407532, -0.6740152835845947, 0.4754392206668854, 0.4185273349285126, -0.35536760091781616, -0.2671199440956116, 0.07706379890441895, 0.4257507920265198, 0.2418830245733261, 0.5015305876731873, 1.2649248838424683, -0.611333966255188, 0.0055203852243721485, -1.1206529140472412, 1.076278805732727, 0.9334472417831421, -0.6288365721702576, -0.05310113728046417, 0.32151398062705994, 0.3997330963611603 ]
{"Title": "Reliability and validity of the UK Biobank cognitive tests", "Authors": "Fawns-Ritchie Chloe, Deary Ian J", "Abstract": "Abstract UK Biobank is a health resource with data from over 500,000 adults. The participants have been assessed on cognitive function since baseline. The cognitive tests in UK Biobank are brief and bespoke, and are administered without supervision on a touchscreen computer. Psychometric information on the tests is limited. The present study examined their concurrent validity and short-term test-retest reliability. A sample of 160 participants (mean age=62.59, SD=10.24) completed the UK Biobank cognitive assessment and a range of well-validated cognitive tests (\u2018reference tests\u2019). Fifty-two participants returned 4 weeks later to repeat the UK Biobank tests. Correlations were calculated between UK Biobank tests and the reference tests. Four-week test-retest correlations were calculated for UK Biobank tests. UK Biobank cognitive tests showed a range of correlations with their respective reference tests, i.e. those tests that are thought to assess the same underlying cognitive ability (mean Pearson r =0.53, range=0.22 to 0.83, p \u2264.005). Four-week test-retest reliability of the UK Biobank tests were moderate-to-high (mean Pearson r =0.55, range=0.40 to 0.89, p\u2264.003). Despite the brief, non-standard nature of the UK Biobank cognitive tests, some showed substantial concurrent validity and test-retest reliability. These psychometric results provide currently-lacking information on the validity of the UK Biobank cognitive tests.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002204"}
10.1101/19004259
[ -0.41338086128234863, 0.06743792444467545, -1.2419342994689941, -0.059941403567790985, 0.08403055369853973, -0.5249749422073364, 0.013512933626770973, -0.04155106469988823, 0.024051547050476074, 1.1484500169754028, 0.1579195111989975, 0.2925070524215698, 0.5581789612770081, 0.09084779024124146, 0.2507967948913574, -0.10224934667348862, -0.6350348591804504, -0.47071537375450134, -0.5777546167373657, -0.6054556965827942, -0.2700737416744232, 0.7868158221244812, -0.1560145765542984, -0.04030715301632881, -0.7844488024711609, 0.1984497457742691, -0.27805089950561523, -0.166731059551239, 1.3465123176574707, 0.19454927742481232, 0.2671864926815033, 0.0729282945394516, -0.05184914171695709, -0.9005048871040344, -0.08727000653743744, -1.095821499824524, 0.621496319770813, -1.4395803213119507, 0.26189520955085754, -0.03803408890962601, 0.26188620924949646, 0.13316167891025543, -0.18601170182228088, -0.8059501647949219, -0.45282113552093506, -0.48179107904434204, 0.256208598613739, 0.016005370765924454, -1.1185771226882935, 0.2236831784248352, 0.03947998583316803, -0.7836388945579529, -0.22312872111797333, -0.29675647616386414, 0.9528329968452454, -0.6346299648284912, 0.07673109322786331, 0.06955455243587494, -0.35887137055397034, 0.5297430753707886, 0.9003012180328369, 0.32606518268585205, 0.8673946261405945, -0.9326926469802856, 0.9451936483383179, 0.5392869710922241, 0.12543977797031403, -0.36973994970321655, -0.7049672603607178, -0.06802129000425339, -0.9554049372673035, -0.18602733314037323, -0.14988034963607788, -0.162353053689003, 0.06221771240234375, -0.20182771980762482, 0.5477393269538879, -0.6771724224090576, -0.359951913356781, -0.24883119761943817, 0.6354430317878723, 0.6624139547348022, 0.2855016887187958, 0.24723728001117706, -0.7529737949371338, 0.2586801052093506, 0.034376438707113266, 0.27819299697875977, 0.18317866325378418, 0.3829006552696228, 0.33277976512908936, 0.4170011878013611, -0.3107193410396576, 0.6496742963790894, 0.07992018014192581, 0.6296700239181519, 0.16221772134304047, 0.3582518398761749, 0.2541006803512573, 0.38483116030693054, 0.6191763281822205, 0.7976805567741394, -0.011953407898545265, 0.36634719371795654, -0.8796505928039551, 0.7251173257827759, 0.7551561594009399, 0.03436540812253952, 0.24853985011577606, -0.8107351660728455, -0.4744435250759125, -0.001002475735731423, -0.3184816241264343, -0.36871376633644104, -0.17544423043727875, 0.6971690058708191, 0.7771070599555969, 1.0444916486740112, -0.06464134901762009, 0.6238396167755127, 0.30586883425712585, 0.6571665406227112, -0.1597738265991211, -0.5971189737319946, 0.12632927298545837, -0.7175554633140564, 0.6496078372001648, 0.12555184960365295, -0.344931036233902, 0.050205960869789124, -0.003070143051445484, -0.5220678448677063, 0.06393075734376907, 0.8834338188171387, 0.13180941343307495, -0.29027059674263, 0.6993569135665894, 0.5307574272155762, -0.3352915048599243, -0.17204149067401886, -0.463715136051178, 0.611063539981842, -0.015813885256648064, 0.5967792272567749, -0.33465811610221863, 0.3402249217033386, -0.7166879177093506, -0.0661308616399765, -0.6246728301048279, -0.25935855507850647, 0.08934472501277924, 0.11780054867267609, 0.3794960677623749, -0.04146496206521988, 0.5358065962791443, -0.8010246157646179, -0.5208909511566162, 0.20512138307094574, 0.11372982710599899, 0.0793859139084816, -0.30216357111930847, 0.3563997149467468, -0.8491069078445435, 1.3161871433258057, -0.829778254032135, 0.5953410267829895, 0.5456939935684204, 0.29313185811042786, 0.7041953206062317, -0.544039785861969, 0.3975923955440521, 0.56289142370224, -0.15942181646823883, -0.35536202788352966, -0.15809056162834167, 0.22113050520420074, 0.9350714683532715, -0.02344844490289688, 0.3183891177177429, -0.11876199394464493, 0.49350258708000183, -0.3713691234588623, 0.23660904169082642, 1.1795462369918823, -0.18393656611442566, -0.35909149050712585, -0.6930351257324219, -0.573180079460144, -0.653623104095459, -0.6474591493606567, -0.18005025386810303, 0.8270342946052551, -0.7114408612251282, 0.355260968208313, -0.14028675854206085, 0.13697701692581177, 0.5330843329429626, 0.022746821865439415, -0.15491367876529694, -0.7278092503547668, -0.7996987700462341, 0.6601378321647644, -0.592787504196167, 0.858161211013794, 0.02169649675488472, 0.9834614396095276, 0.6251040101051331, 0.4391219913959503, -0.000227109354455024, 0.4316515028476715, 0.31518056988716125, 0.2770061194896698, -0.6657354831695557, -0.05178249627351761, 1.0391508340835571, -0.7363625764846802, -0.40782779455184937, 0.009640284813940525, -0.45445963740348816, 0.32327812910079956, 0.2924489378929138, -0.19246242940425873, 0.3535701632499695, -0.41257643699645996, -0.9298906922340393, -0.38214045763015747, 0.7254348993301392, 0.36191341280937195, -0.16818909347057343, -0.1901022344827652, 0.666817843914032, 0.43017634749412537, 0.41472160816192627, 0.6149237751960754, 1.032118558883667, 0.5119592547416687, 0.6260295510292053, 0.859320878982544, 0.8413867950439453, 0.37881407141685486, 0.6959747076034546, 0.19619545340538025, 1.038169503211975, 0.41902872920036316, -0.7421463131904602, 0.6066900491714478, 0.03343698009848595, 0.40124544501304626, 0.6506893038749695, -0.08075051754713058, -0.5663864612579346, 1.0792988538742065, 0.15103162825107574, 0.5790983438491821, -0.8284372091293335, -0.16352850198745728, 0.447020024061203, 0.15921787917613983, -0.4408668577671051, -0.8065094947814941, 0.17710518836975098, 0.3571909964084625, 0.11203526705503464, -0.20821867883205414, 0.908571183681488, -0.23191019892692566, 0.3780952990055084, 0.42013901472091675, 0.27963003516197205, 0.06364049762487411, -0.7830988764762878, -0.7681024074554443, -1.2400850057601929, -0.30950844287872314, -0.9547377228736877, 0.5874596238136292, -0.41414591670036316, -0.895110547542572, 0.5048430562019348, -0.17744894325733185, 0.34347835183143616, 0.10513370484113693, 0.24315381050109863, 0.09093815088272095, 0.17882181704044342, 0.07948742061853409, -0.3335627019405365, 0.03596137464046478, 0.13324150443077087, 0.21943260729312897, 0.07350637018680573, -0.3787514269351959, -0.6138792634010315, -0.7687041759490967, 0.9156327247619629, -0.41812342405319214, -0.0058952877297997475, 0.5175327658653259, -0.6032351851463318, -0.7134250402450562, 0.26002371311187744, -0.16025054454803467, -0.45812126994132996, 0.2025986611843109, -1.0691418647766113, 0.7634305357933044, -0.4797094762325287, 0.33861836791038513, 0.3917011618614197, 0.2103411704301834, -0.43246039748191833, 0.9455152153968811, 0.9045953154563904, 0.0680570974946022, -0.9825631380081177, 0.5689095258712769, 0.9976836442947388, -0.6082153916358948, 0.5079185962677002, -0.14814165234565735, -0.9871980547904968, -0.5602324604988098, 0.5547531247138977, -0.17747153341770172, -0.34755146503448486, 0.2536464333534241, 0.4626467823982239, -1.2676136493682861, 0.12719492614269257, -0.6854513883590698, -0.9151380658149719, -0.13555505871772766, -0.1392444670200348, 0.4560621380805969, 0.7185341119766235, 0.5546891689300537, -0.8639727830886841, -0.31318724155426025, 0.27509579062461853, 0.2586899399757385, 0.5760154724121094, -0.8673803806304932, -0.04745939373970032, -0.003838615259155631, 0.30308955907821655, 0.5822585225105286, -0.39559459686279297, -0.902363121509552, -0.5397542119026184, 0.1888241320848465, -0.3364305794239044, 0.7694888710975647, 0.5028802156448364, -0.44521796703338623, 0.6565119028091431, 0.6821557283401489, -0.2022331953048706, -0.1297614425420761, -0.18989995121955872, 0.7779681086540222, -0.4752761125564575, -0.011018229648470879, 0.034037996083498, 0.24834047257900238, -0.4871043860912323, -0.1174401268362999, 0.7619991302490234, -0.3298141658306122, 0.9269161224365234, -0.8432329893112183, 0.28701066970825195, -0.24272456765174866, -0.10770108550786972, 0.6745741367340088, -0.1468479186296463, -0.12944650650024414, 1.4035534858703613, -0.22973695397377014, 0.9199095368385315, -1.1855708360671997, 0.8975667357444763, 0.44071686267852783, 0.7765401005744934, 0.7105343341827393, -0.119672991335392, 0.128938227891922, -0.8973004817962646, 0.38608482480049133, -0.2665509581565857, -0.5860869288444519, -0.12952257692813873, -0.7731838226318359, -0.3412837088108063, 0.2436373084783554, -0.5652574300765991, 0.021902533248066902, 0.1094995066523552, 0.31130245327949524, 0.22629089653491974, 0.08131114393472672, 0.7368946075439453, 0.15358351171016693, -0.5059682726860046, 0.892145574092865, -0.06010189279913902, 0.5834733247756958, 0.1477527916431427, -0.0015739547088742256, -0.0924268439412117, -0.0230230875313282, -0.4683607816696167, 0.15282823145389557, -0.575200080871582, -0.18113866448402405, -0.3420119285583496, 0.44160139560699463, 0.01886206492781639, -0.40166226029396057, 0.19350744783878326, 0.4465689957141876, -0.19462352991104126, 0.012692514806985855, -0.5108752846717834, 0.024067142978310585, -0.355800986289978, 0.04926763102412224, 0.5753620266914368, -1.4461625814437866, 1.0789659023284912, 0.43766048550605774, -0.644419252872467, -0.9226429462432861, -0.14045099914073944, 0.1087588220834732, -0.4571841359138489, -0.10126418620347977, -0.04411125183105469, 0.17806792259216309, -0.7108486890792847, -0.39493346214294434, -0.6120678782463074, -0.7542584538459778, -0.07669586688280106, -0.05124552547931671, -0.27009403705596924, -0.3915047347545624, 0.43647125363349915, 0.31377753615379333, 0.4600682258605957, -0.32151758670806885, 0.13882075250148773, -0.4619736969470978, 0.5144176483154297, -0.20001961290836334, -0.44386690855026245, -0.014921777881681919, 0.40406444668769836, 0.04669830948114395, -0.33739450573921204, 0.011387020349502563, -0.3383079767227173, -0.38869714736938477, 0.5290687680244446, 0.29887256026268005, -0.34294742345809937, 0.4817429184913635, -0.4734247624874115, -0.4816938638687134, 0.6428328156471252, 0.008272715844213963, 0.32185131311416626, -0.4201955795288086, 0.007271068636327982, -0.41705915331840515, 0.3382599949836731, -0.5720200538635254, -0.13261844217777252, 0.16392450034618378, -0.31848204135894775, 0.7045367360115051, 0.40305274724960327, 0.9997629523277283, -0.6247193813323975, -0.09552595019340515, -0.3547024130821228, -0.3400046229362488, -0.4146508574485779, -0.6650397181510925, -0.3916163146495819, 1.0081164836883545, -0.5731111764907837, -0.09141510725021362, 0.0038915355689823627, -0.27194568514823914, 0.0387704037129879, -0.19207565486431122, -0.03700599446892738, -0.32344210147857666, -0.6023911237716675, 0.261288046836853, 1.6104220151901245, -0.3886035084724426, 0.033743008971214294, -0.5183430314064026, 0.7073869109153748, -0.20041826367378235, -0.5227600932121277, 0.02981685847043991, 0.02847694419324398, -0.027888577431440353, 0.2004183679819107, -0.2967624366283417, -0.569146454334259, 0.9737664461135864, 0.08862438797950745, -0.003246943699195981, 0.298239529132843, -0.35017240047454834, -0.9410816431045532, 0.40887486934661865, 0.3729308843612671, -0.028765864670276642, -1.1129364967346191, -0.17715197801589966, 0.11485889554023743, 0.721156656742096, -0.4749051630496979, -0.3114754855632782, -0.6087942123413086, -1.227077841758728, 0.2553691864013672, -0.1254749894142151, -0.3102629482746124, -0.4453393816947937, -0.17086701095104218, 0.029865656048059464, 0.7107729315757751, 0.15272113680839539, 0.176508828997612, 0.20973975956439972, -1.0810980796813965, 0.7017066478729248, -0.042194757610559464, -0.24339322745800018, 0.0028268154710531235, 0.031118759885430336, 0.6313528418540955, 1.192375898361206, 1.0884294509887695, -0.23088224232196808, 0.02977096289396286, -0.7864425182342529, 0.36964598298072815, 0.13670697808265686, 0.17723901569843292, -0.7855197787284851, -0.0679650530219078, 0.33779194951057434, 0.29501014947891235, -0.2255132794380188, -0.7998949289321899, 1.2809181213378906, -0.5067106485366821, 0.7029688358306885, -0.7568414807319641, -0.4982924163341522, -0.65142422914505, -0.5245587229728699, 1.3446259498596191, -0.43917056918144226, -0.34701791405677795, -0.40358680486679077, 0.24240712821483612, 0.51114422082901, -0.35383009910583496, -1.3548749685287476, 0.10087840259075165, -1.2437530755996704, -0.8649941682815552, -0.22583091259002686, -0.4605376720428467, -0.12384042888879776, -0.098613440990448, -0.2165127396583557, 0.2930504083633423, -0.5325608253479004, 0.856926679611206, 0.7685308456420898, -0.6595544219017029, 0.45679205656051636, -0.14850890636444092, 0.543378472328186, 0.29715603590011597, 0.20864848792552948, -0.12311084568500519, -1.108506202697754, 0.6816859841346741, -1.0596394538879395, -0.39003148674964905, -0.7366569638252258, -0.49026086926460266, -0.10597963631153107, 1.0006930828094482, -0.6017586588859558, -0.13986194133758545, 0.3005460798740387, -0.159760519862175, -0.8311169147491455, 0.03880045935511589, 0.1484229415655136, 0.13944146037101746, 0.2933107912540436, -0.7006680965423584, -0.7582225203514099, 0.2630615532398224, -0.7242540121078491, 0.1736459881067276, 0.2338208109140396, 0.008460388518869877, 1.0244115591049194, -0.702646791934967, 0.35891053080558777, 0.17892783880233765, -0.8653377294540405, 0.08063222467899323, -0.22762539982795715, -0.20631852746009827, 0.09783390164375305, -0.46455422043800354, -0.6960277557373047, 1.0357465744018555, 0.8014471530914307, 0.7044242024421692, -0.12878018617630005, -0.7368541359901428, 0.2043626606464386, -0.08692074567079544, 0.01835261471569538, -0.2910875082015991, 0.5330364108085632, 0.4468771517276764, 0.10855469852685928, 0.16114769876003265, 0.5037297010421753, 0.32905519008636475, -0.4959341585636139, -0.011710762046277523, 0.39192986488342285, -1.3096786737442017, 0.22858716547489166, -0.05542711913585663, 0.3078782856464386, 0.2856837213039398, 0.21232476830482483, -0.39165717363357544, 0.5421767234802246, -0.6863996386528015, -1.3290361166000366, -0.03393612429499626, 0.4405975937843323, 0.09212211519479752, 0.08939792215824127, -0.997365415096283, 0.06085207313299179, 0.8224073052406311, 0.8589252829551697, 0.3600023686885834, -0.1106952652335167, 0.02152908779680729, -0.4812141954898834, -0.5181484222412109, -0.21451032161712646, -0.08080874383449554, 0.1644536256790161, -0.076497383415699, 0.0996207520365715, -0.3272194564342499, -0.3835756778717041, 0.33378562331199646, -0.13140206038951874, 0.20850008726119995, -0.6021637916564941, 0.4837926924228668, -0.3564448654651642, -0.3961302936077118, -0.13055217266082764, -0.18864093720912933, -0.2013528048992157, 0.2582831084728241, -0.4160603880882263, -0.14294102787971497, -0.9523147940635681, -0.12168051302433014, -0.5034268498420715, 0.5866446495056152, -0.8018328547477722, -0.04651118069887161, -0.41639581322669983, 0.8497502207756042, 0.5107138752937317, -0.049007151275873184, -0.23976227641105652, -0.20584429800510406, -0.3554280698299408, 0.033582381904125214, -0.0924573764204979, -0.15255925059318542, 0.40793904662132263, 0.2069701999425888, -0.3440178632736206, -0.5791955590248108, 0.24549704790115356, 0.950797438621521, -0.6484136581420898, 0.134219229221344, -0.3982055187225342, 0.23287846148014069, -0.5434074401855469, -0.13627564907073975, 0.3417763113975525, 0.296291708946228, 0.5370221138000488, 0.6306688785552979, 0.7901968955993652, 0.5382464528083801, 0.2040032148361206, 0.6643533110618591, 0.5009333491325378, 0.42820537090301514, -0.12081832438707352, -0.9154007434844971, -0.20655697584152222, 0.1105792224407196, -0.4185277223587036, 0.03708560764789581, -0.6014202237129211, 0.0671282485127449, -0.04372304677963257, -0.03889397904276848, 0.00277759600430727, 0.9860110878944397, 0.03153705969452858, -0.76796555519104, -0.10620507597923279, -0.3100922703742981, 0.1643034964799881, 0.03935779631137848, -1.267735242843628, -0.7438383102416992, 0.48113134503364563, -0.4835653007030487, -0.27761638164520264, -0.8508946299552917, -0.43757301568984985, 0.1523745357990265, 0.23464122414588928, 0.18738996982574463, 0.24546052515506744, 0.7128341794013977, -0.42782753705978394, 0.7521164417266846, 0.1568136215209961, -0.15527817606925964, -0.5520164966583252, 0.6461457014083862, -0.4976458251476288, 0.023231899365782738, 0.43615981936454773, 0.24606579542160034, 0.39365509152412415, -0.32076355814933777, -0.7463898658752441, -0.5861191153526306, 0.34706899523735046, 0.1779281347990036, 0.5023230314254761, 0.3685009181499481, 0.09516975283622742, -0.0772363618016243, 0.35093265771865845, -0.4394720196723938, -0.29244518280029297, 0.2848212718963623, 0.594731867313385, -0.6961369514465332, -1.0178903341293335, 0.5092270970344543, 0.11058615893125534, 0.062487680464982986, -0.04785417765378952, -0.657680332660675, 0.3777729868888855, 0.16542474925518036, -0.2653675675392151, 0.2978425920009613, 0.9136754274368286, 0.6282557249069214, 0.02957392856478691, -0.3586446940898895, 0.49278056621551514, 0.1773551106452942, 0.6561078429222107, 0.35321351885795593, 0.463229775428772, 0.09490156918764114, -0.28412681818008423, -0.1780402809381485, -0.7926995754241943, 0.45117613673210144, 0.17502525448799133, -0.642341136932373, 0.031928353011608124, -0.2760533094406128, 0.4039309024810791, 0.1941983699798584, -0.262376606464386, 0.9501960277557373, 0.6827396750450134, -0.8075578808784485, -0.2949676215648651, 0.7486878037452698, 0.8581477403640747, 0.5513399839401245, -0.005178553983569145, -0.30289509892463684, 1.0124725103378296, -0.02816721610724926, -0.3695017695426941, 0.52763432264328, -0.12023566663265228, -0.5750589966773987, -0.34301504492759705, 0.5327862501144409, 0.948161244392395, -0.1588560789823532, -0.23637612164020538, 0.04204561561346054, 0.29441261291503906, 0.5759345889091492, 0.10863076895475388, -0.35811734199523926, 0.43858176469802856, -1.038511037826538, -0.4804125130176544, 0.7224494218826294, -0.08151035010814667, -0.6871873736381531, -0.5698872804641724, 0.24579906463623047, -0.05992940440773964, -0.4194432199001312, 0.2575157582759857, 0.16649891436100006, -0.16600504517555237, 0.2718568742275238, 0.395227313041687, -0.811837375164032, 0.18481659889221191, 0.7516549825668335, -0.23295098543167114, -0.2421492040157318, 0.33319759368896484, -0.668681800365448, -0.2741343379020691, 0.29143673181533813, 0.12842687964439392, -0.19799329340457916, -0.10720463842153549, -0.14598055183887482, 0.15952344238758087, 0.08622395247220993, -0.195138081908226, -0.6161020994186401, -0.5890604853630066, -0.6754781603813171, 0.3187742829322815, 0.13174575567245483, 0.22204355895519257, -0.3358992636203766, 0.040193941444158554, -0.1930355280637741, -0.4588793218135834, -0.0759868323802948, 0.6961149573326111, -0.6868327260017395, 0.4508119523525238, 0.2761465609073639, -0.9298007488250732, -0.2172982543706894, -0.9352796077728271, -0.3772598206996918, 0.3588113784790039, 0.06978444755077362, -0.6527695059776306, -0.20153358578681946, 0.29057595133781433, 0.590018630027771, 0.03236263245344162, -0.23113764822483063, -0.4395242929458618, 0.41805320978164673, 0.803297221660614, 0.21595178544521332, 0.7295260429382324, -0.05813099816441536, 0.082382932305336, -0.4591773450374603, 0.11386293172836304, 0.15654374659061432, -0.06252478808164597, -1.0689257383346558, -0.15432573854923248, 0.3929326832294464, -0.27440887689590454, -0.8660224080085754, -0.019855327904224396, 0.5069358944892883, -0.16398711502552032, -0.03579201176762581, -0.8843936324119568, -0.3685593008995056, -0.742595911026001, 0.7013033032417297, -0.37754541635513306, -0.1645006537437439, 0.0012851790525019169, -0.13885217905044556, 0.5217233300209045, -0.786189079284668, 4.089389324188232, 0.9483184814453125, 0.7964715957641602, -0.25317615270614624, 0.5608618855476379, 0.5328010320663452, 0.6345975995063782, 0.3411732316017151, 0.35182493925094604, -0.006172819063067436, 0.20535191893577576, -0.9368045926094055, -0.6111907958984375, -0.4559151232242584, 0.21637465059757233, 0.7772932648658752, -0.5968140363693237, 0.057339880615472794, -0.23689627647399902, -0.7032581567764282, 0.2541912794113159, -0.020379688590765, -0.35191091895103455, 0.837397575378418, -0.18537871539592743, 0.12273792177438736, 0.12600348889827728, 0.18351586163043976, -0.13888968527317047, 0.18631792068481445, -0.41332802176475525, -0.4360702931880951, 0.6491769552230835, -1.0621358156204224, -0.6099647879600525, 0.4918106198310852, 0.21119315922260284, -0.4608597755432129, -0.46295425295829773, -0.17785876989364624, 0.5668770670890808, -0.2803743779659271, 0.010055159218609333, -0.032285116612911224, -0.5209677815437317, 0.9931803941726685, -0.22582876682281494, -0.04931042343378067, 0.4288025498390198, 0.016950491815805435, 1.0844082832336426, -0.7572500109672546, 0.2724350392818451, -0.5126928687095642, -0.9395149946212769, -0.10933881253004074, -0.43950214982032776, -0.8944462537765503, -0.12020277976989746, -0.06563492864370346, 0.037021081894636154, 0.13235945999622345, 0.30887576937675476, -0.29530787467956543, 0.41732552647590637, 0.6187676191329956, 0.34837812185287476, 0.3415363132953644, 0.24750611186027527, -0.18174578249454498, 0.45213234424591064, -0.5113377571105957, -0.14602752029895782, -1.2828494310379028, 0.5073492527008057, 1.0614244937896729, 0.11299765110015869, 0.7091295719146729, 0.02976728416979313, -0.7191116213798523, -0.18752890825271606, 0.0043729995377361774, 0.01120269950479269, -0.4896676242351532, 0.48506277799606323, 0.8560702204704285, -1.0879499912261963, -0.4749765396118164, -1.478804588317871, 0.03409719467163086, 0.6540802121162415, -0.45670926570892334, 0.5098437666893005, -0.005462367553263903, 0.2445104569196701 ]
{"Title": "Applications of qualitative grounded theory methodology to investigate hearing loss: Protocol for a qualitative systematic review", "Authors": "Ali Yasmin H K, Wright Nicola, Charnock David, Henshaw Helen, Ferguson Melanie A, Hoare Derek J", "Abstract": "ABTRACT Introduction Hearing loss is a chronic condition affecting 11 million individuals in the UK. People with hearing loss regularly experience difficulties interacting in everyday conversations. These difficulties in communication can result in a person with hearing loss withdrawing from social situations and becoming isolated. While hearing health loss research has largely deployed quantitative methods to investigate various aspects of the condition, qualitative research is becoming more widespread. Grounded theory is a specific qualitative methodology that has been used to establish novel theories on the experiences of living with hearing loss. Method and analysis The aim of this systematic review is to establish how grounded theory has been applied to investigate the psychosocial aspects of hearing loss. Methods are reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis Protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015 checklist. Studies included in this review will have applied grounded theory methodology. For a study to be included, it can apply grounded theory as an overarching methodology, or have grounded theory methodology embedded amongst other methodologies. These studies can be in the form of retrospective or prospective studies, before and after comparison studies, RCTs, non-RCTs, cohort studies, prospective observational studies, case-control studies, cross-sectional studies, longitudinal studies, and mixed method studies. Purely quantitative studies, studies that have not applied grounded theory methodology, articles reporting expert opinions, case reports, practice guidelines, case series, conference abstracts, and book chapters will be excluded. Studies included will have adult participants (\u226518 years) who are either people with an acquired hearing loss, their family and friends (communication partners), or audiologists. The quality of application of grounded theory in each study will be assessed using the Guideline for Reporting and Evaluating Grounded Theory Research Studies (GUREGT). Ethics and dissemination As only secondary data will be used in this systematic review, ethical approval is not required. No other ethical issues are foreseen. The International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews ( http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO ) holds the registration record of this systematic review. Findings will be disseminated via peer reviewed publications and at relevant academic conferences. Findings may also be published in relevant professional and third sector newsletters and magazines as appropriate. Data will inform future research and guideline development. Prospero registration number PROSPERO CRD42019134197 Strengths and limitations of this study This systematic review is the first to provide a comprehensive critique of the use of grounded theory to investigate hearing loss. The search strategy was formed in collaboration with an information specialist at the University of Nottingham. The PRISMA-P guidelines have directed the considerations and layout of this protocol. Because experiences and articulations of hearing loss are influenced by age, only adult (\u226518 years) participants (people with hearing loss, communication partners, audiologists) will be considered. The search will not include grey literature. The studies included will only have samples of individuals with hearing loss, rather than full deafness.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004259"}
10.1101/19007435
[ 0.13280414044857025, 0.3748992681503296, 0.3945407569408417, 0.644402801990509, 0.06991786509752274, 0.11161400377750397, -0.6264702677726746, 0.09316737949848175, 0.21113093197345734, 0.7721683979034424, -0.4850950837135315, -0.5247057676315308, 0.07999876886606216, -0.8263323903083801, -0.2740495502948761, -1.064605474472046, 0.4712807834148407, 0.5598249435424805, 0.1844465285539627, 0.05565938726067543, 0.11375365406274796, 0.060844313353300095, -0.7745805978775024, 0.869269847869873, 0.013267629779875278, 1.6536387205123901, -0.294552206993103, 0.23660394549369812, 1.5327801704406738, 0.2530082166194916, -0.4998546242713928, 0.2644974887371063, 0.21615536510944366, -0.9077872633934021, -0.1126137375831604, -0.2182285487651825, 0.7624136209487915, -0.4205484688282013, -0.7371851801872253, 0.0008091556956060231, 0.010209484025835991, 0.5519475936889648, 0.010417808778584003, 0.14390327036380768, -0.20268923044204712, -0.19310107827186584, -0.14544406533241272, 0.04333639517426491, -0.038548678159713745, 0.18109656870365143, -0.6176623106002808, 0.13119922578334808, 0.8535345792770386, -0.4669925570487976, -0.17045311629772186, -0.3390065133571625, 0.2762780487537384, -0.62855464220047, -0.9627748727798462, -0.031807128340005875, 0.013191860169172287, 0.10281461477279663, 0.6499112844467163, -0.4587702453136444, 0.6328389644622803, 1.242300271987915, 0.2496488392353058, -0.28655627369880676, 0.5093316435813904, -0.34156548976898193, -0.18791350722312927, -0.3230248689651489, -0.5468447208404541, -1.0630358457565308, -0.6666752696037292, -0.08341463655233383, 0.3542304039001465, 0.11988038569688797, -0.22269684076309204, 0.6843923926353455, 0.9570828080177307, 0.39950093626976013, -0.19416114687919617, -0.680802047252655, -0.9103181958198547, 0.16761775314807892, 0.30975615978240967, 1.1519567966461182, -0.09655975550413132, 1.1084953546524048, -0.9980736970901489, 0.5122807025909424, -0.7572429180145264, 0.015113797970116138, -0.09765797853469849, 1.2438430786132812, -0.7493246793746948, -0.08972235769033432, -0.25303804874420166, -0.04959431290626526, 0.7511154413223267, 0.5817137360572815, -0.3298768997192383, 1.0846431255340576, 0.10072783380746841, 0.780574381351471, 0.9157490134239197, 0.019317105412483215, -0.9227112531661987, -0.7929168343544006, 0.7049556374549866, 0.1972499042749405, -0.2844022810459137, -0.26390084624290466, 0.679332971572876, 0.513088583946228, -0.3840429186820984, 0.6362465023994446, -0.4775090217590332, 0.050351742655038834, 0.7416970133781433, 0.26525041460990906, 0.8512079119682312, 0.15616972744464874, -0.15287598967552185, -0.11348412185907364, -0.2327532023191452, 0.4757893979549408, -0.09724216908216476, 0.21653886139392853, 0.1131686195731163, -0.6305304765701294, -0.5197248458862305, -0.028488216921687126, 0.12810981273651123, 0.1109846755862236, -0.27045607566833496, 0.8297467827796936, 0.5993069410324097, -0.4229770004749298, 0.19935962557792664, 0.9175594449043274, -1.0379353761672974, 1.1079871654510498, 0.22737061977386475, 0.8107210993766785, -0.5303211212158203, -1.6499707698822021, -0.5878455638885498, -0.09689301997423172, -0.06257706880569458, 0.02884588949382305, -0.21854986250400543, -0.8027339577674866, -0.14018131792545319, 1.2332276105880737, 0.04491157829761505, -0.13220733404159546, 0.06695278733968735, 0.42098450660705566, -0.3231014013290405, -0.651057243347168, 0.5075806379318237, 0.8135424852371216, -0.4532480537891388, 0.986815869808197, 0.20745345950126648, 0.04030025005340576, -0.025915762409567833, -0.785698413848877, 0.955794632434845, -0.16649092733860016, 0.08880621194839478, 1.2414745092391968, -0.05843023210763931, 0.9209274649620056, 0.4975643754005432, -0.1893017292022705, 0.309608519077301, -0.06213480234146118, 0.2938796877861023, 0.0841355100274086, -0.24921554327011108, 0.6253969669342041, -0.19745123386383057, 0.823640763759613, -0.4244263172149658, -0.7265357375144958, 0.18447601795196533, -1.0075844526290894, 0.098629429936409, -0.3197718858718872, -0.7856281995773315, 0.3029803931713104, 0.1228119507431984, -0.046687569469213486, -0.5843539237976074, 0.5872277617454529, -0.00763768469914794, -0.7364305257797241, -0.16224025189876556, 0.6343848705291748, 0.928555428981781, 0.3437062203884125, 0.474871963262558, 0.19786526262760162, 0.36982452869415283, 0.37767699360847473, -0.7167811989784241, 0.12602423131465912, 0.9338366985321045, -0.11681132018566132, -0.47907376289367676, 0.014260946772992611, 0.48147881031036377, -0.6151525378227234, -0.07626549154520035, 0.20546820759773254, -0.17019367218017578, -0.038289494812488556, -0.4889770746231079, -0.37333589792251587, 0.0935359075665474, 0.27535945177078247, -0.006789252627640963, 0.977749764919281, 0.3654392957687378, 0.8276023268699646, 0.33363720774650574, -0.09007740020751953, 0.6620580554008484, 0.6995095014572144, -0.38535401225090027, 0.7295680046081543, 1.0345803499221802, 0.7644616961479187, 0.06580517441034317, 0.30457770824432373, -0.15551762282848358, 0.16972921788692474, 0.5917966961860657, 0.4671361744403839, 0.5672496557235718, 0.5037407279014587, -0.19265882670879364, 0.3498465120792389, -0.15043245255947113, 0.23151399195194244, -0.4664158225059509, 0.9700893759727478, -0.36568692326545715, 0.5749870538711548, 1.033098816871643, 0.660383939743042, 0.12587040662765503, -0.5408629775047302, 0.49302101135253906, -0.1331309676170349, -0.08723527938127518, 0.456788569688797, -0.7659780979156494, 0.4950956702232361, -0.20200665295124054, 0.26877468824386597, 0.6325021982192993, 0.5054435729980469, 0.001446972251869738, -0.32486918568611145, 0.27236613631248474, -0.20583337545394897, -0.9835183620452881, -0.6198245882987976, -1.0119343996047974, -1.0855568647384644, -1.108218789100647, -0.22979339957237244, 0.7137604355812073, 0.01782701537013054, 0.38485151529312134, 0.6172949075698853, -0.0626954510807991, -0.19233471155166626, -0.5220358967781067, 0.706706702709198, 0.2617984712123871, 0.25016629695892334, -0.7240336537361145, 0.44443243741989136, -0.368522047996521, -0.1257176548242569, -0.8479008078575134, 0.07808531075716019, -0.25770267844200134, -0.5124070048332214, 0.18411973118782043, -0.04509655013680458, 0.2283514142036438, 0.33404141664505005, 0.31775814294815063, -0.010276096872985363, -0.4565752148628235, 0.013700314797461033, 0.43843451142311096, -0.34785598516464233, -0.9273096919059753, 0.6786252856254578, 0.06490932404994965, 0.39041396975517273, 0.6890432238578796, 0.5832680463790894, -0.3134446442127228, 0.3475869297981262, 0.006807941012084484, 0.9249725937843323, -1.2097296714782715, 0.44502776861190796, 0.5861164331436157, 0.3034707307815552, -0.03704678267240524, -0.9262444376945496, -1.2087737321853638, 0.5952522158622742, 0.5157830715179443, -0.19341053068637848, 0.8627989292144775, 0.8457234501838684, -0.37718939781188965, -1.6462600231170654, 0.6112281680107117, -0.3430849015712738, -0.4068033695220947, -0.03485969826579094, 0.30672159790992737, 0.18829062581062317, 0.9304332733154297, 0.05291617289185524, -0.11418437957763672, 0.8458054065704346, -0.38572293519973755, 0.4994843304157257, 0.4339110553264618, -0.18099570274353027, 0.48786428570747375, 0.008022916503250599, 0.18736931681632996, 0.45113298296928406, 0.23820820450782776, 0.748397946357727, -0.891472578048706, -0.09828953444957733, -0.05611467733979225, -0.1995101273059845, 0.9026834964752197, 0.34718596935272217, -0.13867054879665375, 0.24795754253864288, 0.010234222747385502, 0.10190857201814651, 0.04322497919201851, -0.08512818068265915, -0.18699845671653748, 0.221036896109581, 0.117964006960392, -0.1361158788204193, -0.6107749342918396, -0.7645219564437866, -0.10041996836662292, 0.18758459389209747, 0.7579237222671509, -0.1207311600446701, 0.7266976833343506, 0.6119680404663086, -0.7633295059204102, -0.025344427675008774, -0.41928762197494507, 0.1273764669895172, 0.6624717116355896, -0.081112340092659, 0.8629499673843384, -1.0805100202560425, 0.529970109462738, 0.6429566144943237, 0.7029299139976501, 0.48359477519989014, 0.43104875087738037, 0.41378602385520935, -0.5900956988334656, 0.041298847645521164, -0.24837952852249146, -0.4677067697048187, 0.31643345952033997, -0.45796477794647217, 0.7108117341995239, 0.4684251844882965, -0.5873504877090454, -0.3650165796279907, -0.3741512894630432, 0.3666454553604126, 0.34414732456207275, 0.39342421293258667, 0.20680221915245056, -0.2546115815639496, 0.34493187069892883, 0.1792030781507492, 0.596203088760376, 0.06930403411388397, -0.6803604364395142, 0.3665728271007538, -0.3258185386657715, -1.0303624868392944, 0.3012197017669678, -0.9637649059295654, -0.33829039335250854, 0.2771461009979248, 0.08048438280820847, -0.0036279025953263044, -0.509078860282898, 0.2482667714357376, -0.16967284679412842, -0.3029666841030121, 0.5662355422973633, -0.4370659589767456, -0.8233565092086792, 0.25283774733543396, 0.21189121901988983, -0.8447355628013611, -0.06677887588739395, -0.5281392931938171, 0.038184214383363724, 0.6019213795661926, -0.9086982011795044, -0.7735207080841064, -0.23145101964473724, -0.6450051665306091, -0.10707244277000427, -0.4335253834724426, -0.10219869017601013, 0.196779265999794, 0.28478044271469116, -0.3708207309246063, -0.05569976940751076, 0.38945460319519043, -0.5517849326133728, -0.0554882176220417, -0.5474904179573059, -0.028401527553796768, 0.887604296207428, 0.5727973580360413, 0.1346985101699829, -0.2850789427757263, 0.020162131637334824, -0.8326205015182495, 0.07459597289562225, -0.3392765522003174, -0.8323853611946106, -0.14807167649269104, -0.6713226437568665, 0.6106985807418823, -0.1017410084605217, -0.027205342426896095, -0.21154572069644928, 0.14441077411174774, 0.25654080510139465, -0.7920293211936951, -0.46988528966903687, 0.025851083919405937, -0.7790864706039429, 0.13780446350574493, 1.5143167972564697, -0.7932603359222412, -0.269464373588562, -0.4202985167503357, 0.2642640471458435, -0.6263163089752197, -0.026737403124570847, -0.01836666837334633, -0.04932485893368721, 0.6985851526260376, -0.24277308583259583, -0.45312803983688354, 0.04199489578604698, 0.393760085105896, -0.6607234477996826, -0.8089233040809631, -0.516237735748291, -0.388337641954422, -0.566149890422821, 0.6827272176742554, -1.0863912105560303, -0.23840376734733582, -0.23934361338615417, -1.2584500312805176, 0.0030600132886320353, 0.02753608487546444, -0.6365373730659485, -0.5997111797332764, -0.2610439956188202, -0.3067832887172699, 0.584119975566864, 0.40081655979156494, 0.714427649974823, 0.6115583777427673, -1.2398008108139038, 0.05736946314573288, -0.6418222784996033, -0.8626694679260254, -0.2957322299480438, 0.4066183269023895, 0.08156347274780273, -0.7806825041770935, -0.19745193421840668, -0.2474490851163864, -0.5573306679725647, -0.15516464412212372, 0.07006870955228806, 0.4943492114543915, 0.37879854440689087, 0.8874344825744629, -0.1473022997379303, 0.5810370445251465, 0.21606455743312836, -1.1315028667449951, -0.21649013459682465, 0.9711908102035522, 0.32023361325263977, 0.4884456694126129, -0.23702523112297058, -0.8631728291511536, -0.04949062317609787, -0.8668996095657349, 0.12548553943634033, -0.494680255651474, 0.5434800386428833, -0.46141311526298523, -0.4386739730834961, -0.1964842528104782, 0.5245888829231262, 0.3495030701160431, 0.08166041970252991, -0.7522040605545044, -1.2606165409088135, 0.019020095467567444, 0.00556182349100709, -1.078635811805725, -0.1336904615163803, -0.513314962387085, 0.11109983921051025, 1.3135706186294556, 0.33812403678894043, -0.056295059621334076, 1.2666845321655273, -0.5206195712089539, 0.13090074062347412, -0.4188416600227356, -0.5924766063690186, -0.17538507282733917, -0.43853017687797546, 0.6797683238983154, -0.45036187767982483, -0.2391877919435501, -1.2136465311050415, 0.36060479283332825, -0.535527229309082, 0.1402888298034668, 0.17314013838768005, -0.22711125016212463, 0.4363285303115845, 0.08696837723255157, 1.1446382999420166, -0.2823134958744049, 0.0732833668589592, 0.05601779371500015, -0.11847929656505585, -0.10139130055904388, 0.5459691286087036, -0.16501355171203613, -0.6469168066978455, -1.1458154916763306, -0.7156074047088623, 0.5096699595451355, -0.556926965713501, -0.5310484170913696, 0.24013933539390564, 0.390100359916687, -0.10360442847013474, 0.04796837642788887, 1.4304639101028442, 0.8207422494888306, -0.5539287328720093, -0.2975994944572449, -0.19040237367153168, 0.5507761836051941, -0.03460121154785156, -0.7495290637016296, 0.7862685918807983, -0.16061708331108093, -0.530619204044342, -0.010129820555448532, 0.12892453372478485, -0.8052902221679688, 0.5128527879714966, -0.13523384928703308, 0.8473191857337952, 0.7710201144218445, -0.0013876559678465128, 0.8423246145248413, -0.5569369792938232, -0.6198692917823792, 0.5830766558647156, 0.15327343344688416, 0.3124164640903473, 0.5605836510658264, -0.16514086723327637, 0.09807179868221283, 0.5455459356307983, -0.20718245208263397, 0.13144803047180176, -0.16598199307918549, 0.5877279043197632, 0.16079537570476532, -1.3953558206558228, 0.47593191266059875, 0.1640082448720932, -0.5865147709846497, -0.6988239288330078, 0.48643171787261963, -0.18867407739162445, -0.05442182719707489, 0.3014422655105591, 0.38640812039375305, 0.34155353903770447, -0.2270456999540329, 0.14130523800849915, -0.49319133162498474, -0.07609806209802628, 0.2634865343570709, -0.9239253401756287, -0.4230722188949585, -0.6228982210159302, 0.48194774985313416, 0.9872953295707703, -0.7763692140579224, 0.4497855603694916, -0.3357623815536499, 0.5845369100570679, 0.20511889457702637, -0.5576778650283813, 0.16339538991451263, 0.11032434552907944, -0.9422410726547241, -0.36740440130233765, 0.33181434869766235, -0.058850307017564774, 0.6880950331687927, -0.6715306043624878, 1.2309081554412842, 0.7505087852478027, -0.8661067485809326, 0.22103863954544067, 0.4428841471672058, 0.8551647663116455, 0.2179640382528305, -0.08926474303007126, 0.04154311120510101, 0.44241687655448914, -0.23195163905620575, 0.6738200187683105, -0.7728242874145508, -0.022452883422374725, -0.9765135645866394, -0.1754169911146164, -0.26659104228019714, -0.24321019649505615, 0.03726506605744362, 0.44131162762641907, 0.20871001482009888, -0.3407498002052307, -0.7240808606147766, 0.46008846163749695, 0.17303164303302765, 0.459293931722641, -0.3922613561153412, 0.48878902196884155, -0.7109686732292175, -1.2124345302581787, -0.7242826223373413, -0.3590816557407379, 0.31725531816482544, 0.4336342215538025, -0.7518661022186279, 0.15638919174671173, -0.026415180414915085, 0.0018827260937541723, 0.2022881656885147, 0.39709794521331787, -0.8738518357276917, -0.8800783157348633, -0.8202542662620544, 0.7208886742591858, 0.6158823370933533, -0.05882766470313072, 0.5887948274612427, -0.14059501886367798, 0.6281493902206421, 0.4436754286289215, 0.38388583064079285, -0.35875046253204346, 0.05513639375567436, 0.21942058205604553, -1.1771392822265625, -0.32833170890808105, -0.1798633486032486, 0.4555175006389618, -1.1074258089065552, -0.15683959424495697, -0.6436254382133484, -0.2838729918003082, 0.4205247759819031, -0.22572816908359528, 0.006412339396774769, 0.21269194781780243, -0.01950559765100479, 0.04466049373149872, -0.2659480571746826, 1.143344521522522, 0.5399835109710693, -0.43327781558036804, 0.6633901000022888, -0.10293152928352356, -0.13963636755943298, -0.7339670658111572, 0.6884868144989014, 0.8402040600776672, -0.1708308607339859, 0.5673415064811707, 0.034315772354602814, 0.49834027886390686, 0.17188967764377594, -0.3235113024711609, -0.7500027418136597, 0.4401797950267792, 0.28464677929878235, 0.24083372950553894, 0.06427303701639175, -0.21140791475772858, -0.7803710699081421, -0.7209346890449524, -0.9829241633415222, -0.8082069158554077, 0.10908176004886627, -1.0172638893127441, 0.14698916673660278, -1.3187673091888428, -0.6461040377616882, 0.661421000957489, -0.5592457056045532, 0.17260271310806274, 0.3519032597541809, -0.12636686861515045, 0.37549373507499695, 0.5341475009918213, 0.4229910671710968, 0.601133406162262, 0.13372373580932617, 0.27906087040901184, -0.6104559302330017, 0.21665209531784058, 0.23535457253456116, 0.6012865900993347, 0.20471492409706116, -0.24951426684856415, -0.2356753796339035, -0.07234262675046921, 0.1572735756635666, -0.9279495477676392, -0.2789645791053772, -0.11464908719062805, -1.172663688659668, 0.10203547030687332, -0.3004036545753479, -0.22695237398147583, -0.31231409311294556, -0.02240716852247715, -0.06915721297264099, -0.8785614371299744, -0.8809820413589478, -0.25647908449172974, 0.2666548192501068, -0.384298175573349, 1.0076658725738525, 0.44404178857803345, -0.3480302393436432, -0.18327610194683075, -1.052030324935913, 0.7074119448661804, 0.5315298438072205, -0.023575272411108017, -0.1824931800365448, 0.10650745034217834, 0.13405679166316986, 1.1897135972976685, -0.03956746309995651, -1.137973666191101, 0.677639365196228, 0.940064549446106, 0.21155168116092682, 0.5535303354263306, -0.3507499396800995, -0.25942203402519226, 0.5784754753112793, -0.37037205696105957, 0.03950019180774689, 0.35277774930000305, -0.045785680413246155, 0.5833399295806885, -0.04423337057232857, 0.15493100881576538, -0.293204128742218, -1.1108670234680176, -0.051855266094207764, -0.9735175371170044, 0.8170713186264038, 0.18610736727714539, 0.49751386046409607, 0.22955569624900818, 0.8257391452789307, -0.22774648666381836, 0.3811323642730713, 0.5572892427444458, -0.898499608039856, 0.01773151382803917, -0.9286561012268066, 0.24829694628715515, -0.09773605316877365, 0.2338915318250656, 0.3060234487056732, -0.32253530621528625, 0.2634984850883484, 0.5309427380561829, -0.8044313788414001, 0.08477780967950821, 0.45941680669784546, 0.08589275926351547, 0.1674291044473648, -0.6726959943771362, -0.47687095403671265, -0.9991815686225891, -0.22833774983882904, -0.2773400843143463, -0.7062579393386841, 0.049583107233047485, 0.10080045461654663, 0.644307017326355, 0.5263052582740784, 0.5301132798194885, 0.40248578786849976, -0.05817112699151039, 0.23807403445243835, 0.38612601161003113, 0.1977214515209198, 0.14944986999034882, -0.435270756483078, -0.3417541980743408, 0.255081444978714, -0.9988816380500793, -0.6116017699241638, 0.4141598641872406, -0.5592697858810425, -0.6919636130332947, 0.3284801244735718, 0.5500146746635437, -0.9395303726196289, -1.0305310487747192, 0.038928236812353134, 0.08050647377967834, -0.3362942934036255, 0.11253216117620468, 0.4212096929550171, 0.22555725276470184, 0.29318323731422424, -0.3925245702266693, -0.3959745168685913, -0.28910815715789795, -0.16287314891815186, -0.6953721642494202, 0.4389525353908539, -0.3747349679470062, 0.2629171311855316, -1.1137783527374268, -0.9593200087547302, -0.2700807452201843, 0.025980232283473015, -0.6420562863349915, -0.709362804889679, -0.5283045172691345, 0.09447197616100311, 0.3369700312614441, 0.07591350376605988, -0.592735230922699, 0.2189454436302185, 0.05080091580748558, 0.7022286057472229, -0.019639605656266212, 0.6862037181854248, -0.2115195095539093, -0.09365583956241608, -0.051583029329776764, -0.6858072876930237, -0.08292708545923233, 0.10679063200950623, -0.2019355595111847, -0.38202977180480957, 0.2863430380821228, -0.20597414672374725, -0.9543762803077698, 0.363674521446228, 0.962226390838623, 0.06308811157941818, 0.33440953493118286, -1.0151548385620117, -0.24014092981815338, -0.29212841391563416, -0.27753835916519165, -0.09172114729881287, 0.23641781508922577, -0.1749134063720703, -0.06944026798009872, 0.21465909481048584, -0.9322310090065002, 3.8672003746032715, 0.9820557236671448, 1.2103345394134521, 0.5270497798919678, -0.03559665381908417, 0.042742058634757996, 0.5993125438690186, 0.22494709491729736, -0.22733373939990997, 0.26795458793640137, 0.150647833943367, 0.3041309118270874, 0.4438103437423706, 0.08772315829992294, 0.3686293065547943, 0.6569510102272034, -1.1746799945831299, 0.5029592514038086, 0.07069635391235352, -0.8393431901931763, -0.9658042192459106, -0.47200247645378113, -0.19349975883960724, -0.29468268156051636, 0.478564977645874, 0.3388911187648773, -0.5751648545265198, 0.5126656293869019, -0.5182839632034302, -0.29521751403808594, -0.3123197555541992, -0.09162010252475739, 0.46263331174850464, -0.8105761408805847, -0.2291073501110077, 0.054464999586343765, -0.2045964151620865, -0.5683896541595459, 0.613423764705658, -0.3096309304237366, 0.837788999080658, -0.5808842778205872, 0.0518224723637104, -0.1320345103740692, 0.5144656896591187, 0.27032533288002014, -0.7886568903923035, 0.6976451277732849, 0.7898948192596436, 0.05831000208854675, 0.27328935265541077, -0.9059554934501648, 0.412388414144516, -0.6968775391578674, -0.28985846042633057, -0.29650989174842834, -0.4789881706237793, -0.8514084815979004, -0.530323326587677, 0.3476383686065674, 0.3674107491970062, -0.11483810096979141, 0.03151491656899452, -0.5716651678085327, 0.5084109306335449, 0.5167037844657898, 0.5143176317214966, 0.44998490810394287, -0.17278705537319183, -0.42050907015800476, 0.31455299258232117, -0.7522478699684143, 0.17074477672576904, -0.08278802782297134, 0.2908051609992981, 0.6816580891609192, -0.19770678877830505, 1.0586254596710205, -0.046795524656772614, -0.08607000857591629, 0.8282210826873779, 0.14079618453979492, -0.4888420104980469, 0.03730528801679611, -0.2831265330314636, 0.39933276176452637, -1.3041276931762695, -0.4787038564682007, -1.3087222576141357, 0.3190811276435852, 1.0426045656204224, -0.4534780979156494, 0.3800606429576874, 0.013234191574156284, -0.05935056135058403 ]
{"Title": "Genetic Diversity of the cagA gene of Helicobacter pylori strains from Sudanese Patients with Different Gastroduodenal Diseases", "Authors": "Hassan Hadeel Gassim, Idris Abeer Babiker, Hassan Mohamed A., Altayb Hisham N., Yasin Kyakonye, Beirage Nazar, Abdel Hamid Muzamil M.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background There is an increase in the prevalence of Helicobacter pylori infection in Sudan, accompanied by a high incidence of upper gastrointestinal malignancy. The cytotoxin-associated gene cagA gene is a marker of a pathogenicity island (PAI) in H. pylori and plays a crucial role in determining the clinical outcome of Helicobacter infections. Objective This study aimed to determine the frequency and heterogeneity of the cagA gene of H. pylori and correlate the presence of cagA gene with clinical outcomes. Materials and methods Fifty endoscopy biopsies were collected from Fedail and Soba hospitals in Khartoum state. DNA was extracted using the Guanidine chloride method followed by PCR to amplify 16S rRNA and cagA gene of H. pylori using specific primers. DNA amplicons of cagA gene were purified and sequenced. Bioinformatics and statistical analysis were done to characterize and to test the association between cagA gene and gastric complications. Results CagA gene was detected in 20/37(54%) of the samples that were found positive for H. pylori . There was no association between endoscopy finding and the presence of the cagA gene (p = 0.225). Specific amino acid variations were found at seven loci related to strains from a patient with duodenitis, gastric ulcer, and gastric atrophy (R448H, T457K, S460L, IT463-464VA, D470E, A482Q, KNV490-491-492TKT) while mutations in cancerous strain were A439P, T457P, and H500Y. Conclusion Disease-specific variations of cagA of H. pylori strains, in the region of amino acid residues 428-510, were evident among Sudanese patients with different gastroduodenal diseases. A novel mutation (K458N) was detected in a patient with duodenitis, which affects the positive electrostatic surface of cagA . Phylogenetic analysis showed a high level of diversity of cagA from Sudanese H. pylori strains.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007435"}
10.1101/19005165
[ 0.15546005964279175, -0.023372694849967957, -0.1092057004570961, 1.1042933464050293, -0.6911664009094238, -0.712461531162262, 0.3662049472332001, -0.6801130771636963, 0.2721056640148163, 0.9695857763290405, 0.1511223018169403, -0.6183111071586609, 0.4854944050312042, -0.4237692058086395, -0.2054041177034378, 0.06100037321448326, -0.5642671585083008, 0.21973255276679993, -0.6749525666236877, 0.4747762680053711, 0.6081621646881104, 0.2668617367744446, -0.5856135487556458, 0.41664761304855347, -1.2287484407424927, 1.1319068670272827, 0.008663024753332138, 0.11464712768793106, 1.0061336755752563, 0.8656078577041626, 0.4029128849506378, -0.5175597667694092, 0.2274872213602066, -0.3128988444805145, -0.43044859170913696, -0.2227027267217636, 0.3856427073478699, -1.1473267078399658, 0.1281798779964447, 0.05899123474955559, 0.030423523858189583, 0.34242382645606995, 0.5666528344154358, -0.9865761995315552, -0.3502037823200226, 0.1196201741695404, -0.06731364876031876, 0.032173264771699905, 0.020167602226138115, -0.7129423022270203, -0.9298229217529297, -0.44825980067253113, -0.07886715233325958, -0.13766297698020935, -0.01794258877635002, -0.37809139490127563, 0.11923268437385559, 0.0312645360827446, -0.4203079342842102, -0.41639161109924316, 0.4268234074115753, -0.09110964089632034, 0.9274153709411621, -0.9034914374351501, 0.2267996072769165, 0.7995699644088745, 0.17591527104377747, -0.408291220664978, -0.8645244240760803, -0.5714129209518433, -0.5742842555046082, 0.26632240414619446, -0.468544602394104, -0.24558661878108978, -0.8673757314682007, -0.21511568129062653, -0.03403434529900551, 0.33558544516563416, -0.4739242494106293, -0.4432574212551117, -0.06781467795372009, -0.31688326597213745, 0.3428829610347748, 0.03271112218499184, 0.5193954110145569, -0.15126027166843414, 0.33656856417655945, 0.15090814232826233, 0.0587528832256794, 0.6410411596298218, 0.40902233123779297, -0.09270960092544556, 0.03629431128501892, -0.02101306803524494, 0.03604310378432274, 0.9607502222061157, -0.22062967717647552, 0.016606871038675308, 0.6278746128082275, -0.045488182455301285, -0.06447965651750565, 0.9090161919593811, -0.46396830677986145, 1.151009440422058, -0.5734199285507202, 0.3374932110309601, 1.2570310831069946, -0.17830893397331238, -0.058086175471544266, -1.1898425817489624, -0.4201270639896393, 0.03455755487084389, -0.4416564404964447, -0.12789027392864227, 0.5027526021003723, 0.16044311225414276, -0.018602684140205383, 0.32617756724357605, -0.9921802282333374, 0.7894285917282104, 0.6838898658752441, -0.12005365639925003, 0.6650908589363098, -0.3268851339817047, 0.20878946781158447, -0.19909723103046417, 0.9547247886657715, 1.1785693168640137, -0.6584979891777039, 0.012869738042354584, -0.49931600689888, -0.053370483219623566, -0.4050399661064148, 0.8091339468955994, 0.03453553095459938, 0.1028561070561409, 0.8635797500610352, 1.0794590711593628, -0.07216871529817581, -0.3663259446620941, -0.29828202724456787, 0.15371903777122498, -0.33744269609451294, 0.56596440076828, -0.09026654809713364, 1.105974555015564, -0.8695816993713379, -0.750278890132904, -0.19435541331768036, 0.07635381072759628, 0.023674892261624336, 0.600540816783905, 0.5626217722892761, -0.1385626494884491, -0.30804482102394104, -0.041359808295965195, -0.7173430323600769, 0.5603665113449097, -1.3356012105941772, 0.5375177264213562, -0.6255519390106201, 0.6617142558097839, 0.5435224771499634, 0.8516449332237244, -0.829346776008606, 0.645919680595398, -0.3470146656036377, 0.16147412359714508, 0.06917915493249893, -0.0038122907280921936, 0.4559888541698456, 0.3847084641456604, -0.5585497617721558, -0.18433521687984467, 0.41666799783706665, 0.9309067130088806, 0.4285344183444977, 0.5976359844207764, -0.14938896894454956, 0.688578188419342, -0.9691208004951477, -0.1874040961265564, 0.4585612118244171, 0.5688632130622864, -0.17974473536014557, 0.530026376247406, 0.0807579830288887, -1.1821924448013306, -0.31908106803894043, -0.074857696890831, 0.19876635074615479, 0.8070940971374512, -0.9533558487892151, 1.4953142404556274, -0.18371126055717468, -0.07189597934484482, -0.358926922082901, 0.6352570652961731, 1.2710169553756714, -0.1574818193912506, -0.6366164088249207, 0.6023746728897095, -0.42280587553977966, 0.15026116371154785, -0.31210729479789734, 0.8454331159591675, -0.24783417582511902, 0.3353617787361145, 0.07481661438941956, -0.15273745357990265, 0.42625418305397034, 0.06599978357553482, -0.39355355501174927, 0.5179243087768555, 0.5491883158683777, -0.8859168887138367, -0.42024433612823486, -0.15689468383789062, -0.08558250218629837, -0.4595477283000946, -0.3069091737270355, 0.42102694511413574, 0.6322693228721619, 0.13828080892562866, -0.017068523913621902, 0.7784298658370972, 0.9171524047851562, -0.30015599727630615, -0.26990535855293274, -0.3920513987541199, 0.48986029624938965, 0.985313892364502, -0.06124294921755791, -0.03871525451540947, 0.7182074785232544, -0.4905966520309448, 0.8380222916603088, 0.2936916649341583, 0.5209224224090576, 0.0861847996711731, 0.2677701413631439, 0.19208002090454102, 0.6161171793937683, 0.24639925360679626, -0.30919477343559265, 0.8322872519493103, 0.2496436983346939, -0.40781065821647644, 0.23692317306995392, 0.5931522846221924, -0.4978942573070526, 0.861018717288971, 0.08601636439561844, -0.29536280035972595, -0.7387935519218445, -0.1638031154870987, 0.3730182945728302, 0.14837469160556793, 0.11825544387102127, -0.5129898190498352, -0.3377339243888855, 0.49741822481155396, -0.585395336151123, 0.4562520980834961, 0.707736611366272, -0.036555927246809006, -0.6653280854225159, 0.313648521900177, 0.43140050768852234, 0.056987788528203964, -0.4527147710323334, -0.2828456461429596, -1.0687779188156128, -0.6249768137931824, -0.5450961589813232, 0.8554446697235107, -0.5610746145248413, -0.31113922595977783, 0.47629955410957336, 0.7245342135429382, 0.23255431652069092, -0.22620266675949097, 0.3543010950088501, 0.7128860354423523, -0.3821043074131012, -0.0820167288184166, -1.2845076322555542, 0.5409818887710571, -0.5146893262863159, 0.24854539334774017, 0.18340645730495453, -0.22150924801826477, -1.1635462045669556, -0.6769639253616333, 0.42428258061408997, -0.3298654556274414, -0.030313272029161453, -0.0663946121931076, -0.9311293363571167, -0.3692511022090912, -0.11607791483402252, -0.2643512487411499, 0.15534071624279022, -0.6631397604942322, -0.6716268658638, 0.9172511100769043, -0.19524908065795898, 0.6612005233764648, 0.9833821058273315, -0.027591556310653687, -0.16904768347740173, 0.4778481125831604, 0.3908875286579132, -0.054144710302352905, -0.9786263108253479, 0.07206007838249207, 0.09129258990287781, -0.47269317507743835, 0.018114112317562103, -0.0008530012564733624, -0.9036732316017151, -0.22869588434696198, -0.38340988755226135, -0.42692285776138306, -0.05307348072528839, 0.3400518596172333, 0.25472956895828247, -1.4968496561050415, 0.5018017292022705, -0.9300339221954346, -0.5523915886878967, 0.36995595693588257, -0.22745005786418915, 0.08404805511236191, -0.29892072081565857, 0.10580120980739594, -0.500701367855072, -0.29379531741142273, -0.3190325200557709, 0.3569410443305969, 0.6112915873527527, -0.05064421519637108, -0.4888889789581299, -0.19783470034599304, -0.5611819624900818, 0.7892796993255615, -0.1734447181224823, -0.44409897923469543, -0.6872261762619019, -0.28553634881973267, 0.026085222139954567, 0.5136419534683228, 0.8403446078300476, -0.4916360378265381, 0.0604730024933815, 0.10997776687145233, -0.6591161489486694, -0.00970814935863018, -0.038693711161613464, -0.005969401448965073, -0.06473467499017715, -0.10645647346973419, -0.7817338705062866, 0.7477006316184998, -0.4679998755455017, -0.7735971212387085, 0.08722031116485596, 0.37001532316207886, 0.760937511920929, 0.38507989048957825, 0.9071387052536011, 0.5589926242828369, 0.1196109727025032, 0.0941755622625351, -0.4318239986896515, -0.38936853408813477, 0.8457065224647522, -0.3665326237678528, 0.5582249164581299, -0.8064866065979004, 0.2907044291496277, 0.273662269115448, 0.47954341769218445, 0.037618186324834824, -0.477157860994339, 0.5609887838363647, -0.9453575015068054, 0.4638766050338745, 0.27086585760116577, 0.07879934459924698, 0.11958319693803787, -0.03831017389893532, 0.05806947499513626, -0.3578798472881317, -0.897524893283844, 0.14556603133678436, 0.11338743567466736, 0.508992612361908, 0.35542693734169006, -0.09894072264432907, 1.2212086915969849, -0.5158187747001648, 0.5234723687171936, 0.22769515216350555, 1.0098615884780884, 0.08952966332435608, -0.7484962344169617, 0.504074215888977, 0.042065151035785675, -0.12921254336833954, -0.1005529910326004, 0.0012065002229064703, 0.3204517364501953, -0.04961536452174187, 0.15206952393054962, 0.00939360074698925, 0.35653623938560486, -0.2555735409259796, 0.04926328361034393, 0.42414337396621704, 0.025200840085744858, 0.15482769906520844, -0.8515149354934692, -0.055401820689439774, -0.4338674247264862, -0.09070140868425369, -0.08830419927835464, -0.095174141228199, 0.4510766565799713, 0.5308699011802673, -0.7748520970344543, -1.1119729280471802, 0.4524533450603485, -0.44272857904434204, -0.4698806405067444, 0.04463578760623932, -0.7238677144050598, -0.7715988755226135, 0.0776827409863472, 0.05358255282044411, 0.2093217968940735, -0.8163881301879883, 0.11873277276754379, -0.12636619806289673, 0.9844935536384583, 0.1343771070241928, 0.8518573045730591, 0.07225263863801956, 0.9088437557220459, 0.31463027000427246, -0.020014803856611252, -0.2533869445323944, 0.9947475790977478, -0.06964047998189926, -1.0258572101593018, 0.2202061414718628, 0.17471227049827576, -0.16905497014522552, -0.3800131380558014, -0.4527680277824402, -0.062079522758722305, -0.4725440442562103, -0.019548188894987106, -0.21910130977630615, -0.23142887651920319, 1.027631163597107, -0.10935255885124207, -0.16226737201213837, 1.0934369564056396, -0.30979493260383606, -0.4386489987373352, -0.529170036315918, -0.4956902861595154, -0.4130047559738159, 0.32873305678367615, 0.11612352728843689, -0.06294658780097961, 0.1867595613002777, -1.030338168144226, 0.25142762064933777, -0.20875558257102966, 0.29420721530914307, -0.3840011954307556, 0.15555202960968018, -0.8521273732185364, -0.18795570731163025, 0.12892724573612213, 0.3867220878601074, -1.0100656747817993, 0.11187952011823654, -0.6153590679168701, -0.41766467690467834, -0.43813660740852356, 0.23895181715488434, -0.8110784888267517, 0.4566205143928528, -0.2760111391544342, -0.30870282649993896, -0.8157355189323425, -0.1532309502363205, -0.004295040387660265, -0.1699599176645279, -1.0430488586425781, -0.16829971969127655, 0.7815299034118652, -0.8047618865966797, -0.4989096224308014, -0.6820983290672302, 0.1653866469860077, -0.11401823163032532, -0.36239302158355713, 0.016147295013070107, -0.35923829674720764, 0.6069508194923401, -0.6164019107818604, -0.6101786494255066, 0.841456413269043, -0.5695599913597107, -0.18571797013282776, 0.9630556106567383, 0.1743389517068863, -0.4299525320529938, -0.1286793053150177, 0.25609296560287476, -0.37325531244277954, 0.7697123885154724, -0.39318448305130005, -0.7019320726394653, -0.15498574078083038, -1.2483981847763062, -0.029208514839410782, -0.717553436756134, -0.2174726277589798, 0.11586437374353409, -0.5943107008934021, 0.24165667593479156, 0.30097997188568115, 0.17911508679389954, -0.38559800386428833, -0.1535952091217041, -0.13780540227890015, 0.07035032659769058, 0.022970566526055336, -0.6267788410186768, 0.34838876128196716, -0.8012529611587524, -0.016204459592700005, 0.6302689909934998, 0.4661191403865814, 0.17145581543445587, 0.23417887091636658, -0.3938717246055603, -0.008094949647784233, 0.03322281688451767, -0.3501216769218445, -0.6645472645759583, 0.3833514153957367, 0.7703410387039185, -0.09484129399061203, -0.05998260900378227, -0.7177034020423889, -0.11842413246631622, -0.9066272377967834, 0.8586226105690002, -0.5062506198883057, -0.1438966542482376, -0.20380060374736786, -0.279869943857193, 0.8698977828025818, -0.9850411415100098, -0.15606428682804108, 0.8429981470108032, -0.41967183351516724, 0.1331709325313568, 0.8246320486068726, -0.2723114788532257, -1.1898458003997803, 0.012413122691214085, -0.7094295024871826, -0.08446186035871506, -0.012388703413307667, 0.4590115547180176, 0.5418441295623779, 0.6890971660614014, 0.28350338339805603, -0.5211454629898071, 0.03145788982510567, 0.15669043362140656, -0.7930586338043213, -0.3960971236228943, -0.43977275490760803, -0.0776476338505745, 0.3354007601737976, 0.0871346965432167, 0.5583544373512268, -0.22986304759979248, -0.044399626553058624, -0.3596353530883789, -0.3031085133552551, -0.31683817505836487, 0.19640016555786133, -0.2544841170310974, 0.6440014243125916, -0.2573240101337433, 0.30790942907333374, 0.3063119053840637, -0.2117110788822174, -0.45011433959007263, 0.6661022901535034, -0.4512895345687866, 0.22541245818138123, 0.5160987973213196, -0.691689670085907, -0.5079935193061829, -0.7411192059516907, 0.33539000153541565, -0.26832830905914307, -0.24957820773124695, -0.1171489953994751, 0.5297054648399353, -1.1565265655517578, 0.7491766810417175, 0.3526904881000519, -0.31308165192604065, -0.7809451222419739, 0.03551590070128441, 0.08922678232192993, 0.3578874468803406, -0.6682325005531311, -0.3434562683105469, 0.885657012462616, 0.034274935722351074, 0.463218092918396, -0.5068374276161194, -0.2149198055267334, 0.07185418158769608, -0.6067261099815369, 0.16856180131435394, 0.050812091678380966, 0.5054671168327332, 0.5240119695663452, -0.22799864411354065, 0.28894105553627014, -0.07990530878305435, -0.0905258059501648, 0.5244746804237366, 0.8543183207511902, 0.4807468056678772, -0.7071739435195923, -0.16828615963459015, -0.39116108417510986, 0.4464697539806366, -0.5550334453582764, 0.3282656967639923, -0.29231905937194824, 0.4972337484359741, 0.3947174549102783, -1.008467435836792, -0.6334918737411499, -0.09738114476203918, 0.08793044835329056, 0.7318107485771179, -0.3631284236907959, -0.08965031802654266, 0.5216482281684875, 0.4932379424571991, 0.48021361231803894, -0.8182540535926819, -1.1125409603118896, -0.5233046412467957, 0.5013982057571411, 0.6589261889457703, -1.0923216342926025, -0.3027142882347107, 0.7895882725715637, -0.5259724855422974, -0.556948721408844, -0.36358439922332764, 0.9554414749145508, -0.4898989796638489, -0.32309913635253906, -0.33119311928749084, 0.5904290080070496, -0.6632819175720215, -0.1736883819103241, -0.5980899333953857, -0.7301210165023804, -0.1722765564918518, 0.7660422921180725, -0.329346626996994, -1.0013169050216675, 0.4758150279521942, 0.21679814159870148, 0.395486444234848, 0.23162207007408142, -0.02091040462255478, -0.23229146003723145, 0.10703663527965546, 0.5506109595298767, -0.1162719577550888, -0.2369919866323471, 0.18783295154571533, -0.0559387132525444, 0.5420108437538147, -0.4566234052181244, -0.3443894684314728, 0.08408589661121368, -0.2724452018737793, -0.15837766230106354, -0.7192177772521973, -0.758881688117981, -0.8604195713996887, -0.27557751536369324, -0.5789292454719543, 0.3326687812805176, -0.2188383787870407, 0.13248446583747864, 0.3294414281845093, 0.017486773431301117, -0.6012969613075256, 0.06484146416187286, -0.18047304451465607, 0.5480298399925232, 0.18832333385944366, 0.46957162022590637, -0.27846866846084595, 0.10687911510467529, 0.014117893762886524, 0.12096711993217468, -0.015309982933104038, -0.5143059492111206, -0.18159447610378265, 0.02327234297990799, -0.19932317733764648, 0.08715549111366272, -0.5326782464981079, 0.2447102963924408, -0.1331331878900528, -0.32913219928741455, -0.09940335899591446, 0.6808239221572876, 0.45003005862236023, -0.032741300761699677, 0.15175668895244598, 0.14828717708587646, -0.3687584698200226, -0.00022359473223332316, -0.3530474603176117, -0.5126487016677856, 0.22004587948322296, -0.23146024346351624, 0.18010252714157104, -0.07697924971580505, -0.22107690572738647, 0.37729546427726746, -0.11088375747203827, 0.7977613806724548, 0.3340393602848053, 0.7974857687950134, -0.06445899605751038, 0.9813178777694702, 0.18855004012584686, 0.02668585069477558, 0.5120940208435059, -0.21132205426692963, -0.4880809187889099, -0.314491331577301, 0.3397979438304901, 0.11907626688480377, 1.0621405839920044, 0.24584180116653442, 0.1028628721833229, 0.2649129629135132, -0.11908890306949615, 0.17661763727664948, -0.6248551607131958, 0.25861456990242004, -0.3533935546875, -0.2018226981163025, 0.3267253339290619, 0.05550757423043251, -0.722085177898407, 0.48615121841430664, 0.3083217740058899, -0.6288421154022217, -0.5579233765602112, 0.26879164576530457, 0.3695748746395111, -0.2366107702255249, -0.14587914943695068, -0.08927794545888901, 0.15708580613136292, -0.38226282596588135, -0.1528746783733368, 0.6081332564353943, 0.5768640041351318, 0.006367420312017202, -0.19514130055904388, -0.9675888419151306, 0.30073118209838867, 0.49408844113349915, 0.32961809635162354, 0.6505767107009888, 0.9454307556152344, 0.08101866394281387, -0.6360388398170471, 0.033927347511053085, -0.4317944347858429, 0.8628543019294739, -0.21065586805343628, 0.33908799290657043, 0.5657593607902527, 0.7971947193145752, 0.32792362570762634, -0.38329967856407166, -0.9506150484085083, 0.42552006244659424, -0.4285271465778351, -0.8567867875099182, -0.5263413786888123, 0.5234259963035583, 0.35898441076278687, 0.28436025977134705, 0.6740807294845581, 0.7210452556610107, 0.18893496692180634, 0.07695889472961426, 0.003567823674529791, 0.690100371837616, 0.4395325183868408, -0.5471192002296448, 0.011312118731439114, 0.5781686902046204, -0.1571321189403534, 0.7960835695266724, 0.5283054709434509, 0.2799527049064636, -0.18270090222358704, 1.0048986673355103, -0.0865720883011818, 0.09562689810991287, 0.193820521235466, -0.34427857398986816, 0.6150209903717041, -0.24813231825828552, -0.04663388431072235, -0.23776613175868988, -0.6855937838554382, 0.4740232229232788, 0.24417760968208313, 0.08755835890769958, 0.0066575962118804455, 0.27874448895454407, 0.5023970603942871, 0.5180389285087585, 0.1326688528060913, -0.4354758858680725, 0.2622509300708771, 0.5479623079299927, -0.7095466256141663, 0.12613119184970856, -0.23832398653030396, -0.08621811121702194, 0.17295660078525543, -0.5647149085998535, 0.28756842017173767, -0.23868334293365479, 0.5608461499214172, -0.8369207382202148, 0.5784556269645691, -0.5189154744148254, -0.5460471510887146, -0.2582061290740967, -0.09067084640264511, -0.35998284816741943, 0.1876702457666397, 0.05555818974971771, 0.28437766432762146, 0.6275965571403503, -0.342566579580307, 0.07741884142160416, -0.23692625761032104, -0.574937641620636, 0.20152457058429718, -0.03436897322535515, 0.3476217985153198, 0.2205025851726532, -0.45756733417510986, -0.6869189143180847, -1.1122561693191528, 0.3764754831790924, 0.25740593671798706, -0.240322083234787, -0.7785943150520325, -0.10801267623901367, 0.39827102422714233, 0.6197556257247925, 0.19194871187210083, -0.5907953381538391, 0.39642077684402466, -0.006575609091669321, 0.6600143909454346, -0.034237783402204514, 0.03595440834760666, 0.3290731906890869, 0.6473259925842285, 0.2642800807952881, -0.492341548204422, -0.554553210735321, 0.022728458046913147, -1.143517255783081, -0.3859751522541046, -0.056191083043813705, 0.046032216399908066, -0.6885477304458618, 0.8442884087562561, 0.4286816120147705, 0.1421874314546585, -0.33512261509895325, -0.7431542277336121, -0.4183998107910156, -0.4097577631473541, 1.493080973625183, -0.40242332220077515, 0.3073195815086365, -0.0644601508975029, -0.15313400328159332, 0.7418854236602783, -0.5990384817123413, 4.213427543640137, 0.5651050209999084, 0.41694870591163635, -0.1920180767774582, 0.5185757279396057, 0.1898082196712494, 0.5356284976005554, -0.13192440569400787, 0.5142081379890442, 0.6267521977424622, 0.0564897395670414, 0.9517650604248047, 0.35915637016296387, 0.4616212844848633, 0.5086247324943542, 0.011140052229166031, -1.0842978954315186, 0.5728446245193481, -0.7425074577331543, -0.6664931178092957, -0.32889845967292786, 0.27359992265701294, -0.49736788868904114, -0.17664268612861633, -0.21937952935695648, 0.03232152760028839, 0.5268113613128662, 0.3638875186443329, -0.03171512857079506, -0.6133002042770386, 0.09314144402742386, -0.538000226020813, -0.01633329503238201, -0.7977091073989868, -0.5447840094566345, -0.058158647269010544, 0.06742072105407715, -0.5583755970001221, -0.29104238748550415, 0.39938706159591675, -0.09904322028160095, 0.1137908473610878, -0.32192444801330566, 0.03519151359796524, -0.4514707624912262, 0.022777728736400604, -0.31891393661499023, -0.1928911805152893, 0.5129202604293823, -0.62115079164505, 0.9663289189338684, -0.7249414324760437, 0.33079180121421814, 0.11604422330856323, -0.5361545085906982, -0.7181820273399353, -0.680340588092804, -0.596377968788147, 0.6035445332527161, -0.2712685465812683, 0.7326141595840454, 0.4204042851924896, -0.05781053379178047, -0.04822266846895218, 0.48915916681289673, 0.26032498478889465, 0.6116476058959961, -0.381574809551239, -0.4352811276912689, -0.09812811762094498, 0.20732563734054565, 0.3730233311653137, -1.228366494178772, 0.6202030181884766, 1.0251953601837158, 0.6128533482551575, -0.6456196308135986, 0.5301879644393921, -0.19157840311527252, -0.40183064341545105, 0.3426443636417389, 0.375099241733551, 0.42736345529556274, 0.10416042059659958, 0.12476585805416107, 0.7711635231971741, -0.1676117181777954, -0.2764667570590973, -0.5751884579658508, 0.17093703150749207, 0.06356586515903473, 0.2679162621498108, 0.019742386415600777, -0.15438099205493927, 0.26336151361465454 ]
{"Title": "The consistent burden in published estimates of delirium occurrence in medical inpatients over four decades: a systematic review and meta-analysis study", "Authors": "Gibb Kate, Seeley Anna, Quinn Terry, Siddiqi Najma, Shenkin Susan, Rockwood Kenneth, Davis Daniel", "Abstract": "Abstract Introduction Delirium is associated with a wide range of adverse patient safety outcomes. We sought to identify if trends in healthcare complexity were associated with changes in reported delirium in adult medical patients in the general hospital over the last four decades. Methods We used identical criteria to a previous systematic review, including studies using DSM and ICD-10 criteria for delirium diagnosis. Random effects meta-analysis pooled estimates across studies, meta-regression estimated temporal changes, funnel plots assessed publication bias. Results Overall delirium occurrence was 23% (95% CI 19%-26%) (33 studies). There was no change between 1980-2019, nor was case-mix (average age of sample, proportion with dementia) different. There was evidence of increasing publication bias over time. Discussion The incidence and prevalence of delirium in hospitals appears to be stable, though publication bias may mask true changes. Nonetheless, delirium remains a challenging and urgent priority for clinical diagnosis and care pathways.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005165"}
10.1101/19013524
[ 0.3481023907661438, 0.35660648345947266, 0.09047168493270874, 0.2115885317325592, -0.06443005055189133, -0.11681615561246872, -0.6676527857780457, 0.243027463555336, 0.026648564264178276, 0.5347123146057129, -0.49291789531707764, -0.3766886591911316, 0.19404011964797974, 0.3752119541168213, -0.27191486954689026, -0.12478967756032944, -0.4123478829860687, -0.7515941262245178, 0.036858368664979935, -0.1337433159351349, 0.4960741698741913, 0.3656885325908661, -1.1267741918563843, 0.14418314397335052, -0.14549076557159424, 0.9388852119445801, 0.3309018909931183, -0.06319613009691238, 1.870369791984558, 0.15324603021144867, 0.18065159022808075, -0.659837007522583, 0.5682119727134705, -1.5324174165725708, -0.3611268401145935, -0.1032254546880722, -0.10504680126905441, 0.13282667100429535, -0.7957330942153931, -0.8075453042984009, 0.9643793106079102, -0.3020414710044861, 0.4304406940937042, -0.38627639412879944, -0.9740319848060608, 0.1575293391942978, -0.24223244190216064, 0.15587259829044342, 0.011623200960457325, -0.05174962803721428, -0.0018113654805347323, -0.32794809341430664, 0.16657428443431854, -0.06538937240839005, 0.07779768109321594, -0.43043506145477295, 0.5014804005622864, -0.14756518602371216, -0.13148517906665802, 0.012129171751439571, 0.017132451757788658, -0.11017104983329773, -0.18090465664863586, -0.678243100643158, 0.16453345119953156, 0.9162973761558533, -0.2327367514371872, -0.2954326272010803, -0.3520702123641968, -0.31076374650001526, -0.4268657863140106, -0.3961653709411621, -0.4802735447883606, -0.3583918511867523, -0.5947761535644531, -0.5474674701690674, 0.2277746945619583, -0.697005569934845, -0.6173516511917114, -0.1219748854637146, 0.8101826310157776, 0.6470622420310974, 0.710945188999176, -0.06689182668924332, -0.7072982788085938, -0.036175645887851715, 0.0353170670568943, 0.04031996801495552, 0.1449018120765686, 0.9606003761291504, -0.09609974175691605, 0.26486870646476746, 0.41754963994026184, 0.583332896232605, 0.18797612190246582, 0.7102453112602234, -0.13292257487773895, -0.13730159401893616, 0.016871076077222824, -0.34797608852386475, 0.797920286655426, 1.063190221786499, -0.40275222063064575, 0.3781745135784149, -0.3504793345928192, 1.0445122718811035, 1.100353717803955, 0.2575811743736267, -0.9222424030303955, -0.40411141514778137, 0.4676506817340851, -0.5605325102806091, -0.44336649775505066, 0.43532100319862366, 0.6834973692893982, 0.3078487813472748, 0.25525081157684326, 0.6330073475837708, -1.4866843223571777, -0.06110706180334091, -0.32624977827072144, 0.7210760116577148, 0.6523270606994629, -0.5272430181503296, 0.6369084119796753, -0.28589341044425964, -0.3971390426158905, 0.2793624699115753, -0.674867570400238, 0.5242745876312256, 0.07003229856491089, -0.7903982996940613, -0.052858591079711914, 0.8043684959411621, -0.4909123480319977, -0.1310313642024994, 0.78050297498703, 0.9890083074569702, 0.8277130722999573, -0.34600991010665894, 0.23944395780563354, -0.20043666660785675, -1.2338789701461792, 1.4218131303787231, 0.017124608159065247, 0.13818874955177307, -0.7690964341163635, -1.012589931488037, -0.14452721178531647, 0.10671692341566086, -0.31632110476493835, 0.37788721919059753, -0.5158553719520569, -0.021309122443199158, 0.30664756894111633, 0.15688052773475647, -0.984294593334198, -0.007871921174228191, 0.10180804878473282, 0.2245430201292038, -1.45371675491333, 0.02579239010810852, 0.3889850676059723, 1.1348718404769897, -0.49602010846138, 0.5249021649360657, 0.0026571685448288918, -0.14575374126434326, 0.5154446363449097, -0.3200152516365051, 0.8621858954429626, 0.4319878816604614, -0.07460370659828186, 0.3898119032382965, 0.29809287190437317, 0.1435093879699707, -0.1465340554714203, -0.4636741578578949, 0.20284351706504822, 0.5825402736663818, 0.7482343316078186, 0.8122343420982361, 0.7184675931930542, 0.4559354782104492, 0.2487943470478058, 0.38106057047843933, 0.052186042070388794, -0.394100159406662, -0.5059307813644409, 0.4454459846019745, -0.4575299322605133, 0.6763328909873962, -0.14634518325328827, 0.6432453989982605, 0.14984481036663055, -0.0887007936835289, -0.1574690192937851, -0.293427437543869, -0.1377483457326889, -0.5049786567687988, 0.030284417793154716, -0.09167185425758362, -0.4579322636127472, 0.4033450782299042, -0.8346605896949768, 0.10807929188013077, 0.3749088943004608, 0.3864065110683441, -0.8766801357269287, 0.5505396127700806, 1.2408592700958252, -0.5165604948997498, -0.7388416528701782, -0.5013157725334167, 0.09961488842964172, -0.5689349174499512, 0.17649081349372864, 0.23152297735214233, -0.8905662894248962, 0.4492601454257965, 0.7591920495033264, -0.6718701124191284, 0.7344332933425903, -0.08929070085287094, 0.09346655011177063, -0.3455505669116974, -0.14713171124458313, 0.6927602887153625, -0.7007778286933899, -0.09859880805015564, 0.3644768297672272, 0.4631770849227905, 0.03240581601858139, 0.6990779042243958, 0.3650253713130951, 0.2626424729824066, 0.07193917036056519, 0.6643555164337158, 0.39255455136299133, 0.9707861542701721, 1.3602585792541504, 0.5268599390983582, 0.17586573958396912, 0.046877264976501465, -0.7334309220314026, 0.4477742314338684, -0.17383705079555511, -0.2016582041978836, -0.278337687253952, 0.45397090911865234, 0.15377885103225708, 0.7316116094589233, 0.05747256055474281, 0.6117208003997803, -0.4990176260471344, -0.4522571861743927, 0.2733410894870758, 0.1698438972234726, -0.4404808580875397, -0.08168300241231918, -0.412378191947937, -0.31902605295181274, -0.8773106932640076, -0.26104968786239624, 0.6039167642593384, 1.0653451681137085, 0.2118086814880371, 0.48372283577919006, 0.16391529142856598, -0.5263157486915588, -0.669441819190979, -0.21313107013702393, -0.889493465423584, -0.7434908151626587, -0.4525519013404846, 0.3909491002559662, 0.376537024974823, 0.4430340826511383, 0.24765096604824066, 0.15108880400657654, 0.055651839822530746, 0.9568909406661987, -0.5090591907501221, 0.06668781489133835, 0.4826005697250366, -0.4015814960002899, -0.182192862033844, 0.2283436357975006, 0.041560109704732895, 1.0330740213394165, -0.19878321886062622, -0.6829387545585632, -0.4867028295993805, -1.3476349115371704, 0.4649924337863922, 0.28044593334198, 0.3659855127334595, 0.631443440914154, -0.5669916272163391, -0.2497609406709671, -0.09101902693510056, -0.24770651757717133, 0.11092294007539749, -0.05911976844072342, -1.070405125617981, 0.046991027891635895, -0.22410447895526886, -0.12326862663030624, 0.42156505584716797, 0.515037477016449, -1.1346633434295654, 0.3042542636394501, -0.06653036922216415, 0.3116507828235626, -0.9177988767623901, 0.42754194140434265, 0.5669643878936768, 0.09847227483987808, 0.21714600920677185, -0.09019776433706284, -0.8774072527885437, -0.13855765759944916, 0.21113349497318268, -0.2020871937274933, -0.16715337336063385, 0.8104722499847412, 0.4873444139957428, -1.088673710823059, 0.31731870770454407, -0.5393327474594116, -0.7475404739379883, -0.07859650999307632, 0.16734978556632996, 0.17755331099033356, 0.2791959345340729, -0.37436461448669434, -0.6929083466529846, -0.19385400414466858, -0.1687077134847641, 0.38676732778549194, -0.1022781953215599, -0.44125184416770935, 0.12198159098625183, 0.2714685797691345, 0.017949948087334633, -0.3962927758693695, 0.7190716862678528, -0.7620792388916016, 0.23240652680397034, -0.11794287711381912, 0.35066282749176025, 0.08170217275619507, 0.502379834651947, -0.2816437780857086, -0.4113992750644684, 0.7757197618484497, -0.33419594168663025, -0.11813140660524368, -0.1708950400352478, -0.45175033807754517, -0.10039918124675751, 0.13241152465343475, -0.6446858048439026, 0.20753952860832214, -0.6838054060935974, -0.6708045601844788, 0.24223850667476654, 0.4801807701587677, 0.7001004219055176, -0.43180930614471436, 0.15718139708042145, 0.2946246862411499, -0.6988502740859985, 0.48195880651474, 0.12504614889621735, -0.2146390676498413, 0.4177398383617401, 0.34829244017601013, 0.6204179525375366, -0.787807822227478, 0.048280905932188034, 0.2787819802761078, 1.0797709226608276, 0.7359280586242676, 0.859909176826477, 0.9703365564346313, -0.29744184017181396, -0.06321541965007782, -0.14620941877365112, -0.4985734224319458, 0.2038278728723526, -0.08187783509492874, 0.37385085225105286, -0.27727267146110535, -0.616052508354187, -0.5733903050422668, 0.24250414967536926, 0.6607123017311096, -0.2342224419116974, 0.0820540189743042, 0.9180085062980652, -0.6110992431640625, 0.32912954688072205, 0.580238938331604, 0.3414232134819031, 0.8132187128067017, -0.8652732372283936, -0.07158870249986649, -0.07608544826507568, -1.3879764080047607, 0.19325825572013855, -0.4959896206855774, -0.23282140493392944, -0.21263229846954346, 0.334332674741745, -0.5499265789985657, -0.6132422685623169, -0.6092464327812195, -0.07555980980396271, -0.041909657418727875, 0.13482092320919037, 0.004931034054607153, -0.762463390827179, 0.10901718586683273, 0.39641305804252625, -0.30735495686531067, -0.2442561239004135, -1.3391834497451782, 0.47638338804244995, 0.04385180026292801, -0.6093279123306274, -0.5716862082481384, 0.15886598825454712, -0.45832526683807373, -0.15165495872497559, 0.3777807652950287, 0.3564196228981018, -0.22273828089237213, -0.37788185477256775, -0.25385740399360657, 0.04748677462339401, -0.41066786646842957, -0.9019367098808289, -0.5181077122688293, 0.6614473462104797, 0.48928260803222656, 0.6026188135147095, 0.22014948725700378, -0.12764006853103638, -0.16961920261383057, 0.42540135979652405, -0.3041684329509735, 0.7960184812545776, -0.258055716753006, 0.1882348358631134, 0.08398178219795227, -0.3701817989349365, 0.23582777380943298, 0.12395788729190826, 0.2794960141181946, 0.1661715805530548, -0.12794716656208038, 0.059922948479652405, -0.9022724628448486, -1.1557400226593018, 0.7442095279693604, 0.4154275059700012, 0.2501622438430786, 0.2716715633869171, 0.024434769526124, -0.19227904081344604, 0.09433900564908981, 0.04426748678088188, -0.5391177535057068, 0.07065968960523605, 0.2697719633579254, 0.44344624876976013, 0.6261919736862183, -0.1046350821852684, 0.18749061226844788, -0.4589346945285797, 0.1527991145849228, -0.5241252779960632, -0.43312278389930725, -0.2785307466983795, -0.15169407427310944, -0.03335833549499512, -0.599536120891571, -0.5333371758460999, -0.09789635241031647, 0.2808132767677307, -0.010182204656302929, 0.20124462246894836, 0.010716317221522331, -0.7752169966697693, -0.4103280305862427, -0.3598955273628235, 0.15324100852012634, 0.38236987590789795, 0.5128076672554016, 0.8906127214431763, -0.4400561451911926, -0.6565613150596619, -0.08399108052253723, 0.3361752927303314, -0.18741591274738312, -0.07366618514060974, 0.1533166468143463, -0.7154054045677185, -0.03019387647509575, -0.3177776336669922, 0.6398603916168213, -0.40687116980552673, -0.29029589891433716, -0.730685293674469, -0.037729330360889435, 0.3886164128780365, -0.34737056493759155, 0.006809670943766832, 0.1580812931060791, -0.2027294784784317, -0.8800427317619324, 0.1489267200231552, 0.6583086252212524, 0.39692258834838867, 0.7420508861541748, -0.050477560609579086, -1.349241852760315, -0.531218945980072, -0.566148042678833, 0.9036515951156616, -0.5092824697494507, 0.09815201163291931, 0.2254636585712433, 0.0566478967666626, 0.33504894375801086, 0.39295342564582825, 0.3210536241531372, 0.6379610896110535, 0.22194266319274902, -0.6296283006668091, 0.43996965885162354, -0.4367673099040985, -0.12102030217647552, 0.42348945140838623, -0.21866194903850555, 0.5310969352722168, 0.8241921663284302, -0.05314446985721588, -0.4310629665851593, -0.13660520315170288, 0.6251493096351624, 1.2095975875854492, 0.07059825956821442, -0.6328409910202026, 0.3119448125362396, 0.25405794382095337, 0.38188594579696655, -0.9943252205848694, -0.3122110962867737, -1.136170506477356, 0.33662253618240356, -0.32036280632019043, 0.1177658811211586, 0.26849061250686646, -0.24002708494663239, 0.15686434507369995, -0.2787507176399231, 0.8051813840866089, -0.11118806153535843, 1.0815997123718262, -0.30301588773727417, -0.0711163654923439, 0.3879956901073456, 0.8624157309532166, -0.33981919288635254, -0.089748315513134, -0.9017477631568909, -0.6054002642631531, 0.7489600777626038, -0.1899881511926651, -0.22704671323299408, 0.4380776584148407, -0.17441749572753906, 0.021065305918455124, -0.42341703176498413, 0.8600716590881348, 0.72458416223526, -0.5675689578056335, 0.37784087657928467, -0.10104462504386902, 0.40992969274520874, -0.16893735527992249, 0.15464617311954498, 0.2307094931602478, -0.21921825408935547, -0.5798209309577942, 0.5527894496917725, -0.4724178910255432, -0.8878607153892517, 0.13410012423992157, 0.42421579360961914, 0.38929423689842224, 0.17042623460292816, 0.985909104347229, -0.8657054901123047, -0.8359132409095764, 0.2783956229686737, 0.42855891585350037, 0.3078477382659912, -0.03759751096367836, 0.4213715195655823, 0.41928938031196594, -0.39395612478256226, 0.5065869092941284, -0.6151316165924072, -0.04016172140836716, -0.18319736421108246, 0.9070942401885986, 0.9216488599777222, -1.146989107131958, 0.5383779406547546, 0.35088908672332764, -1.041161060333252, -0.6045612096786499, -0.6987301707267761, -0.5730567574501038, -0.18050499260425568, 0.11920559406280518, -0.45787984132766724, 0.20186202228069305, -0.594792366027832, 0.4033268094062805, -0.0429089218378067, 0.45199987292289734, 0.24856463074684143, -0.07368014007806778, -0.5644187927246094, -1.0366781949996948, 0.7201266288757324, 1.3353826999664307, -0.25892698764801025, 0.18825799226760864, 1.076082468032837, 0.09580505639314651, 0.5227919220924377, -0.026196597144007683, 0.4438669681549072, -0.05619923397898674, -0.38797518610954285, -0.21711935102939606, -0.1294449418783188, 0.10238439589738846, 0.21403373777866364, 0.4706873297691345, 0.5230399966239929, 0.19207501411437988, -0.6936741471290588, -0.6653993725776672, 0.8296312689781189, 0.04619058966636658, 0.3508632779121399, 0.5454732775688171, 0.7145344018936157, 0.6058489680290222, -0.5975590944290161, 0.806318461894989, -0.9229314923286438, 0.1528627872467041, -0.8137816190719604, -0.5401954650878906, -0.5493113398551941, -0.5173457860946655, 0.46836575865745544, 0.20058561861515045, -0.34234270453453064, -0.445595383644104, -0.20624646544456482, 0.586984395980835, 0.5294390320777893, 0.5153121948242188, -0.6557571887969971, -0.24193423986434937, -0.601807177066803, -0.9866600632667542, -0.31470274925231934, -0.8966003060340881, -0.30414432287216187, 0.7835401892662048, -0.32097041606903076, -0.31557703018188477, -0.42527419328689575, 0.4175804853439331, 0.3897111415863037, 0.7055549025535583, -0.09343134611845016, -0.7288376688957214, -0.41200676560401917, 0.1225690096616745, -0.5033056735992432, -0.2065856009721756, 0.744594395160675, -0.6282824873924255, 0.25543761253356934, 0.7212051153182983, -0.6162874102592468, -0.4118500351905823, -0.13730263710021973, 0.6512669324874878, -0.322823166847229, -0.003428436117246747, 0.14599457383155823, 0.6117221713066101, -1.4572315216064453, -0.5866067409515381, -0.2016351968050003, -0.7253392934799194, -0.7619020938873291, 0.4672072231769562, -0.7969781160354614, 0.5646147727966309, 0.31997400522232056, 1.0419299602508545, -0.2842044532299042, 0.364037424325943, 0.981351375579834, -0.058869827538728714, -0.30988189578056335, 0.24906428158283234, 0.10266001522541046, -0.10613963007926941, 0.5123627781867981, 0.006854546722024679, -0.021738365292549133, 0.6908535361289978, -0.01948726363480091, 0.16824877262115479, -0.003257444826886058, -0.27950841188430786, -0.20343180000782013, 0.5691543817520142, -0.036097727715969086, 0.1759117990732193, -0.14822335541248322, -0.5076799988746643, -0.6054791212081909, -1.0515406131744385, -1.0615750551223755, -0.5169351696968079, 0.6655769944190979, -0.9116125702857971, 0.28478139638900757, -0.37558627128601074, -0.15308856964111328, 0.04538758471608162, 0.8682681322097778, 0.1548416167497635, 0.5080947875976562, 0.15540607273578644, -0.037408582866191864, 0.5626721382141113, -0.02985258772969246, 0.3549192249774933, -0.33278322219848633, 0.36206477880477905, -0.7212745547294617, -0.2243964523077011, -0.40846213698387146, 0.43584468960762024, -0.28342536091804504, -0.027306921780109406, -0.7781809568405151, 0.31537967920303345, 0.2647426724433899, -0.8542186617851257, -0.6339429020881653, 0.355590283870697, -0.2901860177516937, -0.5223855376243591, -0.6021570563316345, 0.27808254957199097, 0.18025822937488556, -0.39828091859817505, 0.6249110102653503, 0.04717707633972168, -0.4831148087978363, 0.8130795955657959, 0.634350597858429, 0.30058082938194275, 0.3978181779384613, 0.2305019199848175, 0.4150347113609314, -0.027078580111265182, -0.23983457684516907, 0.012212145142257214, 0.12130387127399445, -0.5300711393356323, 0.3735409080982208, 1.0278568267822266, 1.0391026735305786, 0.485060453414917, 0.6194854974746704, -0.7921656370162964, -0.29098010063171387, 0.39679768681526184, -0.21751274168491364, -0.053656816482543945, -0.3424205183982849, 0.004623655695468187, 0.24337536096572876, -0.6020714044570923, -0.31064537167549133, 0.05353611707687378, 0.7440215945243835, 0.6054489612579346, -0.20339196920394897, 0.4149773418903351, -1.23039710521698, -0.11842743307352066, -0.2732967734336853, 0.0005070302286185324, 0.6173168420791626, 0.28559964895248413, -0.08987845480442047, 0.17858992516994476, 0.7434579730033875, 0.2680683135986328, -0.0880555510520935, 0.1318134069442749, -0.6514617204666138, 0.536092221736908, -0.6286603212356567, 0.7151196599006653, 0.10131222754716873, -0.08545074611902237, -0.13298040628433228, -0.855575442314148, -0.6923524737358093, -0.00825413316488266, -0.9755750298500061, 0.754776120185852, 0.8870449066162109, -0.2666858732700348, 0.027754327282309532, 0.1968526393175125, 0.10740718245506287, -0.6672024726867676, -0.4829707443714142, 0.8122960925102234, -0.7683624625205994, -0.16233085095882416, 1.0157009363174438, 0.31927016377449036, 0.6952152252197266, -0.12848307192325592, 0.5731204152107239, -0.5032254457473755, 0.2831268608570099, 0.20852747559547424, 0.17301681637763977, -0.4373382329940796, -0.2605946362018585, -0.18447743356227875, -0.4713355302810669, -0.19396944344043732, -0.7409014105796814, 0.6360928416252136, -0.5937984585762024, -0.4767325520515442, 0.3032573163509369, -0.3298204243183136, -0.6029375791549683, -0.8498110175132751, -0.8957949280738831, -0.14919665455818176, -0.6661949157714844, -0.14864788949489594, 0.7527877688407898, 0.25315865874290466, -0.10701724886894226, -0.7592392563819885, 0.19744017720222473, -0.8021525144577026, 0.2478688359260559, -1.1145083904266357, 0.27788257598876953, 0.38357973098754883, -0.23227600753307343, -0.5146966576576233, -1.376636266708374, -0.06303516775369644, -0.6864182353019714, -0.44820675253868103, -0.6328330636024475, -0.36702483892440796, -0.2007877677679062, 0.7296593189239502, 0.4051077663898468, 0.09349489957094193, -0.05490749701857567, -0.12465529888868332, 0.47447359561920166, -0.8441664576530457, 0.6752604842185974, -0.015249030664563179, 0.046302709728479385, -0.2984969913959503, 0.20140805840492249, 0.6305590271949768, 0.09004516154527664, -0.08899416029453278, -0.9021649360656738, 0.8418546319007874, -0.04277448728680611, -0.947041392326355, 0.4953885078430176, 0.46713632345199585, -0.4354008436203003, -0.4001554846763611, -0.49631986021995544, -0.12979631125926971, -0.5716825127601624, 0.5434786677360535, -0.28874191641807556, -0.1819181740283966, 0.23072203993797302, -0.1968812346458435, 0.3753659427165985, -1.1933618783950806, 4.063908576965332, 1.3156108856201172, 0.6140791773796082, -0.5287247896194458, 0.4968048334121704, 1.1994960308074951, -0.035233158618211746, 0.3481369614601135, 0.3886519968509674, 0.2368190884590149, -0.37565046548843384, 0.5607489943504333, 0.1335575431585312, 0.07073372602462769, 0.7091954350471497, -0.11549239605665207, -0.893900990486145, -0.0887451246380806, -0.11427874863147736, -0.7914072871208191, -0.6096400022506714, 0.3655908703804016, 0.049867384135723114, 0.14195290207862854, 0.22268983721733093, 1.0114003419876099, 0.8273199200630188, 0.11210237443447113, -0.009062804281711578, -0.6660115718841553, -0.28774818778038025, -0.04900236427783966, 0.9348787069320679, -0.07819146662950516, -0.33530768752098083, -0.03668511286377907, -0.05257844924926758, -0.8153737783432007, -0.38666677474975586, 0.1190090999007225, 0.5994739532470703, -0.288945734500885, -0.3105066120624542, -0.340002179145813, -0.47718730568885803, -0.14594143629074097, -0.0850008949637413, -0.1254623979330063, 0.6199014782905579, -0.09184858202934265, 0.18522746860980988, -0.7842521071434021, 0.5585704445838928, -0.01485465932637453, -0.8593089580535889, 0.4098489284515381, -0.06486035138368607, -1.3259373903274536, 0.5790401101112366, 0.05718393623828888, 0.8182238340377808, -0.5058903694152832, 0.1208144798874855, -0.21648196876049042, 0.5776407122612, -0.0626136064529419, -0.13796308636665344, 0.42554089426994324, -0.5866034030914307, -0.30366629362106323, 0.251005083322525, -0.6466950178146362, -0.3715903162956238, -0.7856531739234924, 0.7964434623718262, 0.04429793730378151, -0.31143718957901, 0.5587199330329895, 0.06492237001657486, -0.7207295894622803, 0.07796544581651688, -0.526772677898407, 0.5023110508918762, -0.5282199382781982, 0.16716477274894714, 0.49643388390541077, -0.11778371781110764, -0.840126097202301, -0.29348987340927124, 0.3056037127971649, 0.8408191800117493, -0.17626874148845673, -0.06706762313842773, 0.872333288192749, 0.17609383165836334 ]
{"Title": "HIV-1 founder variant multiplicity is determined by the infection stage of the source partner", "Authors": "Villabona-Arenas Ch. Juli\u00e1n, Hall Matthew, Lythgoe Katrina A., Gaffney Stephen G., Regoes Roland R., Hu\u00e9 St\u00e9phane, Atkins Katherine E.", "Abstract": "Abstract During sexual transmission, the large genetic diversity of HIV-1 within an individual is frequently reduced to one founder variant that initiates infection 1 . Understanding the drivers of this bottleneck is crucial to develop effective infection control strategies 2 . Genetic characteristics of the potential founder viruses and events in the recipient partner are both known to contribute to this bottleneck, but little is understood about the importance of the source partner 3 . To test the hypothesis that the source partner affects the multiplicity of HIV founder variants, we developed a phylodynamic model calibrated using genetic and epidemiological data on all existing transmission pairs for whom the direction of transmission and the infection stage of the source partner are known. Our results demonstrate the importance of infection stage of the source partner, and not exposure route, in determining founder variant multiplicity. Specifically, acquiring infection from someone in the acute (early) stage of infection increases the risk of multiple variant transmission when compared with someone in the chronic (later) stage of infection. This study provides the first direct test of source partner characteristics to explain the low frequency of multiple founder strain infections and can inform clinical intervention study design and interpretation.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013524"}
10.1101/19001115
[ -0.3178175687789917, 0.46944355964660645, -0.47240757942199707, -0.10741176456212997, -0.15532644093036652, -0.2520781457424164, -0.46207883954048157, 0.11538293957710266, 0.1541842371225357, 0.8230298757553101, 0.18618418276309967, -0.32046598196029663, 0.20920924842357635, 0.29546838998794556, -0.11201954632997513, -0.5767484307289124, -1.1183868646621704, 0.5181043148040771, 0.06193164363503456, 0.4377449154853821, 0.04209154471755028, 1.355964183807373, -0.9327405095100403, -0.44054844975471497, -0.42273464798927307, 0.6053085327148438, -0.3700962960720062, 0.31645727157592773, 1.7466915845870972, 0.8217419981956482, 0.3622221052646637, -0.8485813140869141, 0.5114244818687439, -0.4513522982597351, -0.23450832068920135, 0.15428794920444489, 0.21614009141921997, -0.28570759296417236, 0.286508709192276, -0.4791102707386017, 1.1083788871765137, -0.5143821835517883, 0.9076687693595886, -0.10685838013887405, -0.8967478275299072, -0.3054143488407135, 0.26765313744544983, 0.30376607179641724, -0.30235767364501953, 0.022735245525836945, -0.3490956127643585, -0.13943693041801453, 0.4305950999259949, 0.02488393895328045, -0.5084239840507507, -0.043963439762592316, -0.24207866191864014, -0.5321033000946045, -0.1552114635705948, 0.2047688513994217, 0.09624171257019043, -0.28251272439956665, -0.006413384806364775, -0.6856861114501953, 0.7743602395057678, 0.8520649075508118, 0.26106759905815125, -0.11993949860334396, 0.22850622236728668, -0.24552716314792633, -1.0088551044464111, -0.6720319986343384, -0.6453179717063904, -0.03461860120296478, -0.3446055054664612, 0.08200624585151672, 0.04753279685974121, -0.10412292182445526, -0.8919296860694885, 0.20341525971889496, -0.20024800300598145, -0.06498253345489502, 0.11236188560724258, 0.14232979714870453, -0.22851257026195526, 0.3361814320087433, 0.5052050352096558, -0.09130397439002991, -0.1420353651046753, 0.8252459168434143, -0.02382277138531208, 0.16125982999801636, 0.524074912071228, -0.1588633507490158, 0.33697232604026794, 0.6294440031051636, 0.22165291011333466, 0.2548934519290924, 0.15137505531311035, -0.31816646456718445, 0.2206023782491684, 0.9894014596939087, -0.5681547522544861, 1.2440500259399414, -0.6749590039253235, 0.8369235396385193, 0.1554972380399704, -0.5986500978469849, -0.454916387796402, -1.3668607473373413, -0.18984928727149963, -0.08923283219337463, -0.5667805671691895, -0.5642768144607544, 1.1787686347961426, 0.7111065983772278, -0.15469512343406677, 0.5704041123390198, -0.5709313750267029, 0.5534881949424744, -0.5428829193115234, 0.12174669653177261, 0.19019943475723267, -0.2822456359863281, 0.5498605966567993, -0.562686562538147, 0.5625079274177551, 0.33110174536705017, -0.6057674884796143, -0.4491443336009979, -0.4044229984283447, -0.7360824942588806, -0.8517705202102661, 0.5649099349975586, -0.18938423693180084, 0.22016461193561554, 0.6830474138259888, 0.4755282402038574, -0.08903942257165909, -0.10574411600828171, 0.001207357388921082, 0.43864932656288147, -0.24963539838790894, 1.4630253314971924, -0.2656240165233612, 0.8220460414886475, -0.9803999066352844, -1.0469493865966797, -0.2738651931285858, 0.14178423583507538, 0.05353664234280586, 0.08948204666376114, -0.4146450459957123, 0.48140066862106323, -0.08278969675302505, -0.26626718044281006, -0.2535404562950134, 0.1804163157939911, -0.528935968875885, -0.4966484308242798, -0.48680782318115234, -0.8012297749519348, -0.40422913432121277, 0.7969764471054077, -0.33976951241493225, 0.5684348940849304, -0.07103732973337173, 0.1565764844417572, -0.3757159411907196, -0.47342437505722046, 0.8973289728164673, 0.028430186212062836, -0.3528378903865814, 0.6123172044754028, 0.16505514085292816, 1.4619028568267822, 0.4578012228012085, -1.1000537872314453, 0.8056262731552124, 0.5017180442810059, -0.06646707653999329, -0.4312916100025177, 0.297174870967865, 0.35248056054115295, 0.6076077818870544, 1.0876564979553223, 0.4427441358566284, -0.25907251238822937, -0.5272142887115479, -0.12041913717985153, 0.175170436501503, 0.7453386187553406, -0.11701594293117523, 0.6210408806800842, 0.08093257248401642, -0.5901035666465759, -0.6140792369842529, 0.7752735018730164, 0.09443670511245728, -0.1456495225429535, -0.4359133541584015, -0.0285805631428957, -0.6785209774971008, 0.7826829552650452, -0.2878930866718292, 0.5902441143989563, 0.018847903236746788, 0.7343459725379944, -0.5109677910804749, 0.5089050531387329, 0.20422151684761047, -0.27963384985923767, -0.0206319410353899, -0.13361398875713348, 0.8395430445671082, 0.34536564350128174, -0.5987319946289062, 0.2663238048553467, -0.5314242243766785, -0.43706148862838745, -0.05963585153222084, -0.5970040559768677, 0.499477356672287, -0.2094239443540573, 0.30769988894462585, -0.47008150815963745, 0.5890432000160217, 0.29915037751197815, 0.11980529129505157, 0.3392549455165863, 0.8738465309143066, 0.2222694754600525, 0.025141093879938126, 1.23780357837677, 0.8255944848060608, 0.11091678589582443, 0.03384137898683548, 0.13993211090564728, 0.41504403948783875, 0.30670878291130066, 0.7582665085792542, -0.14121797680854797, 0.3210068643093109, 0.5547863841056824, -1.1026076078414917, 1.1252902746200562, -0.48457807302474976, -0.06351906806230545, -0.043441783636808395, 0.2917174696922302, -0.13690735399723053, 0.8831967711448669, 0.5040624737739563, 0.761163055896759, -0.6152693629264832, 0.1923549324274063, 1.0512586832046509, -0.010813411325216293, -0.42475539445877075, -0.8288267850875854, -0.516323447227478, 0.3918817639350891, 0.22259807586669922, 0.03127731755375862, 1.3216581344604492, 1.045639157295227, -0.2872023284435272, 0.17790934443473816, 0.2457307130098343, -0.3657298684120178, -0.9649838209152222, -0.6225126385688782, -0.5640672445297241, -0.8691431879997253, -0.9453480243682861, 0.4864330291748047, 0.28709185123443604, -0.7756485342979431, -0.08558490127325058, -0.06355981528759003, -0.5894456505775452, 0.2501956522464752, -0.021829910576343536, 1.2502694129943848, 0.48522478342056274, 0.01251217257231474, -0.7716206312179565, 0.22966662049293518, -0.1319900006055832, -0.44316768646240234, 0.22064308822155, -0.18176043033599854, -0.8076778054237366, 0.201353058218956, 0.5450424551963806, -0.3003315329551697, -0.07195775955915451, 0.7323335409164429, 0.05537710711359978, -0.08547279238700867, 0.4113961458206177, 0.6187503933906555, 0.13107237219810486, -0.1625266820192337, -0.25706997513771057, 0.8442259430885315, -0.39719414710998535, 0.0505223423242569, 0.9493883848190308, -0.10323534905910492, -1.026016354560852, -0.03602389246225357, -0.017367476597428322, -0.18731079995632172, -0.5839588046073914, 0.31398993730545044, 0.31795990467071533, -0.7766306400299072, 0.6379717588424683, -0.33280059695243835, -0.6485180854797363, -0.1613687425851822, 0.308569073677063, 0.5042587518692017, 0.3569367229938507, 0.3772522211074829, 0.44358375668525696, -1.108859658241272, 0.11316938698291779, -0.5002458095550537, -0.45423418283462524, 0.016310762614011765, 0.11778008937835693, 0.16481643915176392, 0.34313374757766724, -0.27340197563171387, -0.7222174406051636, -0.3452756702899933, -0.14889034628868103, -0.4515857696533203, 0.9655848145484924, -0.2818059027194977, 0.08167164027690887, 0.8833675980567932, -0.1965259462594986, 0.6500771641731262, 0.22634153068065643, -0.29049384593963623, -0.26479238271713257, 0.06105268374085426, -0.3895825743675232, 0.5475537776947021, 0.9295571446418762, 0.5020068883895874, -0.22860026359558105, 0.7644813656806946, -0.2612867057323456, -0.7118749618530273, -0.00843073520809412, 0.015689728781580925, 0.30342817306518555, 0.3351055681705475, -0.07664935290813446, 0.6004417538642883, -0.4965433180332184, -0.5520179271697998, 0.6472554802894592, 0.6073474884033203, 0.6848487854003906, -0.7553523182868958, 0.2568671703338623, 0.1269608587026596, 0.3815503418445587, -0.44439029693603516, 0.15846729278564453, -0.2965889275074005, 0.9529703855514526, 1.0956255197525024, 0.6823095679283142, -1.2389317750930786, 0.4859920144081116, 0.8569306135177612, 0.9451972246170044, 0.8472604155540466, 0.5169535279273987, 0.4840817451477051, -0.27378082275390625, 0.2031528204679489, 0.6758399605751038, -0.7565500736236572, -0.7138956785202026, -0.439965158700943, 0.19943509995937347, -0.20380444824695587, -1.030127763748169, 0.05443248152732849, 0.15382258594036102, 0.8406710028648376, 0.1560841053724289, -0.30550169944763184, 0.6394520401954651, -0.48477989435195923, 0.6410543918609619, 0.7023687362670898, 0.8913002014160156, 0.629615068435669, -1.0827324390411377, 0.12042003124952316, -0.6400730609893799, -0.46293455362319946, 0.6638273000717163, -0.65611732006073, -0.18944647908210754, -0.6576394438743591, 0.2471676468849182, -0.21257250010967255, 0.02545887790620327, -0.3459910750389099, -0.7231161594390869, 0.23623467981815338, 0.8781301379203796, 0.6438902616500854, -0.7280048727989197, -0.280499130487442, -0.19279657304286957, -0.012586038559675217, -0.437354177236557, -1.5807240009307861, 1.5210679769515991, 0.25546398758888245, -0.0863058939576149, -0.9750336408615112, -0.572150707244873, -0.19811402261257172, -0.588238537311554, 0.4039107859134674, -0.14089302718639374, -0.06796657294034958, -0.3421798050403595, -0.581447422504425, -0.4757761061191559, 0.339680552482605, 0.25532418489456177, -0.966332197189331, 0.017949797213077545, -0.056593384593725204, 0.47629889845848083, 0.25917038321495056, 0.26826533675193787, 0.08258355408906937, -0.06296782940626144, -0.3863198161125183, 0.28144675493240356, -1.0860024690628052, -0.5192584991455078, -0.5429279804229736, -0.5374224781990051, 0.13586479425430298, -0.132837176322937, 0.028256554156541824, -0.5481953024864197, -0.17209360003471375, -0.3603891134262085, -0.6988182067871094, -0.6677049994468689, 0.6668645143508911, -0.03374646231532097, 0.12248752266168594, 0.8530651330947876, -0.5791471004486084, -0.5829790234565735, -0.33841702342033386, -0.18968142569065094, -0.887152910232544, 0.4666752517223358, 0.5528504848480225, 0.18303127586841583, 0.6455603837966919, 0.19257253408432007, 0.5683818459510803, 0.14768002927303314, 0.5430813431739807, -0.557026207447052, -0.2669087052345276, 0.1044367328286171, -0.6512681841850281, 0.03509026765823364, 0.08572861552238464, -1.1040356159210205, 0.4634034037590027, -0.6824456453323364, -0.6564105153083801, -0.6054078936576843, -0.18445007503032684, -0.39435094594955444, -0.44277527928352356, -0.5151134133338928, 0.004706109408289194, -0.6318032145500183, -0.03499551862478256, 0.6445479989051819, -0.2785317003726959, -0.7155588269233704, -0.13530279695987701, -0.11051949113607407, -0.625750720500946, -0.31898292899131775, 0.2030128538608551, -0.7084787487983704, -0.5222029685974121, -0.7550950646400452, -0.07980254292488098, -0.7946416139602661, -0.7075860500335693, 0.5828668475151062, 0.4457772970199585, 1.426942229270935, -0.03055640123784542, -0.5171448588371277, -0.25508520007133484, -0.1853497177362442, 0.12410539388656616, -0.11817355453968048, 0.8745030760765076, 0.14199917018413544, 0.3102497458457947, -0.19288629293441772, -0.9637153744697571, -0.3285946846008301, -1.3834961652755737, 0.2885497510433197, -1.256996989250183, 0.22270090878009796, 0.34073901176452637, -0.5468423962593079, 0.7606552243232727, 0.3312333822250366, 0.10403817892074585, 0.6069923043251038, -0.022088533267378807, -0.588452160358429, 0.2484283596277237, -0.085232675075531, -0.5292915105819702, -0.20218007266521454, -1.6131353378295898, 0.299560010433197, 0.5473077297210693, -0.16915062069892883, -0.7048354148864746, 0.23912674188613892, 0.4667944312095642, 0.30033114552497864, 0.3683365285396576, -0.32231077551841736, -0.49094778299331665, 0.4781566262245178, 0.9749220609664917, -0.384414404630661, -0.3811495006084442, -0.20512646436691284, 0.7998199462890625, -0.12616485357284546, 0.0508115291595459, -0.2614702582359314, -0.4371718764305115, 0.4883166551589966, -0.24965833127498627, 0.85768723487854, 0.04407346248626709, 0.5210818648338318, -0.16600078344345093, -0.33465108275413513, 0.06385062634944916, 0.3630433976650238, -0.12247899919748306, -1.390071988105774, 0.10789436101913452, -0.6274935007095337, 0.5226864218711853, -0.2647615671157837, -0.5080997943878174, 0.2826835811138153, -0.2632305324077606, 0.04992286488413811, 0.2639051377773285, 0.9060083627700806, 0.6451247930526733, -0.7716740369796753, 0.028564026579260826, 0.5358717441558838, 0.5646025538444519, -0.6282833218574524, 0.7468186020851135, -0.7547876238822937, 0.07373739778995514, 0.03200123831629753, 0.4115482270717621, -0.5717593431472778, -0.9601706862449646, 0.24685244262218475, 0.16043733060359955, 0.3462333083152771, -0.7148039937019348, 0.6158748269081116, -0.15663422644138336, -0.17384280264377594, -0.6293990015983582, 0.25599604845046997, 0.5328224897384644, -0.06052299961447716, 0.25067856907844543, -0.5736279487609863, 0.050049345940351486, 0.9238469004631042, 0.2822777330875397, 0.007805018685758114, -0.324185311794281, 0.8264488577842712, -0.08090224117040634, -1.8938130140304565, 0.4428762197494507, -0.24790093302726746, -0.2685946226119995, -0.5196542739868164, -0.4540889263153076, -0.49352672696113586, 0.7164145708084106, -0.18885360658168793, -0.025513598695397377, 0.08178219944238663, -0.5400548577308655, 1.0562551021575928, -0.10162060707807541, -0.11710809916257858, -0.1617344468832016, -0.19507046043872833, 0.5711634159088135, -0.17917031049728394, -0.12900030612945557, 0.1897483915090561, 0.30759188532829285, 0.4613889753818512, 0.5568553805351257, -0.08105596899986267, 0.5898539423942566, 0.8402518033981323, 0.5961723327636719, -0.288082093000412, 0.10069207847118378, 0.3880314826965332, 0.6647095680236816, 0.20424406230449677, -0.2895369827747345, -0.10269882529973984, 0.4367240071296692, 0.42595624923706055, -1.4902544021606445, -1.250174641609192, 0.2888958752155304, 0.003648072946816683, 0.642008900642395, -0.24458587169647217, -0.19347596168518066, 0.9296663403511047, 0.6698348522186279, 0.2576623857021332, -0.6865511536598206, -0.2587231993675232, -1.123779058456421, -0.3336697220802307, -0.09434320032596588, -0.2413514256477356, 0.07780476659536362, 0.32893607020378113, -0.09032681584358215, -1.413495659828186, 0.10707654803991318, 0.9290862679481506, 0.2293752133846283, 0.616969883441925, 0.13873884081840515, 0.16692660748958588, -0.4682543873786926, -0.7246549725532532, -0.20607560873031616, 0.002086547203361988, -0.20149728655815125, 0.931603193283081, 0.13284437358379364, 0.6532792448997498, -0.12983202934265137, 0.24052922427654266, 1.0166789293289185, 0.4756183922290802, 0.10618279874324799, -0.4393940567970276, -0.9622209668159485, 0.3146457374095917, 0.10702364146709442, 0.5462020635604858, 0.3472483456134796, -0.3510809540748596, 0.1999281942844391, -0.2668311595916748, -0.42235827445983887, -0.3951931297779083, 0.346242219209671, 0.39234602451324463, -0.9815053343772888, -0.315141499042511, -0.6616190075874329, 0.9693691730499268, -0.8418645858764648, 0.29133713245391846, -0.7902439832687378, -0.1317712664604187, -0.45065566897392273, 0.5252105593681335, 0.008472652174532413, 0.3235779106616974, -0.31070786714553833, 0.43297407031059265, -0.4737776517868042, 0.5754317045211792, -0.32509171962738037, 0.5794171094894409, 0.12310414761304855, 0.10956244170665741, 0.7511187791824341, -1.250350832939148, 1.1307262182235718, 0.26180338859558105, -0.7361266613006592, 0.6539530754089355, -0.7070249915122986, -0.4143235981464386, 0.07177790999412537, 0.4131526052951813, 0.01491477806121111, 0.1965424120426178, -0.13361866772174835, 0.7991923093795776, 0.03155403211712837, -0.06610572338104248, 0.06909534335136414, -0.43071243166923523, -1.6389182806015015, -1.0470852851867676, 0.5531070828437805, -1.0791200399398804, 0.24292385578155518, -0.11471793055534363, -0.5525714159011841, 0.12657460570335388, -0.3646913766860962, 0.14349277317523956, 0.10720768570899963, 0.7921967506408691, 0.00485997786745429, 1.0844721794128418, -0.6404445767402649, -0.01045894157141447, 0.3968683183193207, 0.1446201652288437, -0.6188175678253174, -1.2467153072357178, 0.3350825011730194, 0.011343605816364288, 0.02794480137526989, -0.13096898794174194, -0.4208894371986389, -0.30413898825645447, 0.30855312943458557, -0.606096625328064, -0.2406356781721115, 0.3961695730686188, -0.8973560333251953, -0.2641070485115051, 0.8112344145774841, -0.49326422810554504, -0.5213281512260437, 0.12951990962028503, 0.0889376550912857, -1.0968612432479858, -0.8140495419502258, 0.03318755701184273, 0.5700849890708923, 0.282918244600296, 0.20942050218582153, -0.58100426197052, 0.9309327006340027, 0.2151714265346527, -0.45310425758361816, 0.45003652572631836, 0.3031509220600128, 0.18762359023094177, 0.2598423659801483, 0.6618942022323608, 0.07502289861440659, 0.560122549533844, -0.3184554874897003, -0.8577388525009155, 1.0202299356460571, -0.4874838590621948, -0.08478791266679764, 0.44447383284568787, -0.8704460263252258, 0.5830773711204529, -0.34796658158302307, -0.43404823541641235, -0.0638885647058487, 0.14244599640369415, 1.1898003816604614, 0.14125597476959229, -0.7605230808258057, 0.45332229137420654, 0.33598756790161133, -0.6722679734230042, -0.38007858395576477, -0.815095841884613, 0.40459001064300537, -0.12668243050575256, -0.07127106189727783, -0.5956202745437622, 1.0949382781982422, 0.33693593740463257, 0.01493907067924738, 0.40591922402381897, 0.07625570148229599, 0.8525283336639404, -0.4785101115703583, 0.23707817494869232, -0.7786188721656799, -0.23892860114574432, 0.4602242112159729, -0.02521216683089733, 0.5930031538009644, 0.027746306732296944, -0.5895341038703918, 0.5362367033958435, 0.8875433802604675, 0.08354941010475159, -0.24934086203575134, -0.5268083810806274, -0.28000137209892273, -0.12356235831975937, -0.5185868740081787, 0.27375665307044983, -0.21412411332130432, 0.025965746492147446, 0.40631964802742004, -0.15913651883602142, 0.2884191572666168, 0.6417104601860046, 0.9441733360290527, -0.4488193988800049, 0.3761976361274719, 0.8689581155776978, -0.40298762917518616, -0.20816363394260406, -0.40161216259002686, -0.12032779306173325, 0.1611577421426773, -0.7116779685020447, -0.3265800476074219, -0.22612465918064117, -0.16681326925754547, -0.7288691401481628, 0.006526815239340067, -0.010797884315252304, -0.46966928243637085, -0.829299807548523, -0.01896405592560768, -0.43003612756729126, 0.5540187954902649, -0.3634491264820099, -0.009995202533900738, -0.004031297750771046, -0.42407265305519104, 0.08382356911897659, 0.11766303330659866, -0.02191169001162052, 0.19206644594669342, -0.8512641787528992, 0.17059138417243958, -0.52452152967453, -0.8113453388214111, -0.9677193760871887, -0.6765277981758118, -0.2448047697544098, -0.06834153085947037, 0.05203181132674217, -0.8963434100151062, -0.11260543018579483, 0.8104167580604553, 0.7812949419021606, 0.2738285958766937, -0.7204424738883972, -0.6948916912078857, 0.07300835847854614, 0.7583169937133789, 0.22806371748447418, 0.3388971984386444, -0.7992021441459656, 0.7044149041175842, -0.01271157804876566, -0.3987768292427063, 0.10108564794063568, 0.307677298784256, -0.6677166223526001, -0.7395930290222168, -0.14334894716739655, -0.39694488048553467, -0.687352180480957, 0.1845061480998993, 0.6375500559806824, -0.45397570729255676, -0.16787748038768768, 0.24487513303756714, -0.6338752508163452, -0.6790119409561157, 1.2350691556930542, 0.12413721531629562, 0.2750369906425476, -0.18739239871501923, 0.41956865787506104, 0.4225267767906189, -0.4584304690361023, 3.8363051414489746, 0.6831655502319336, 1.019935131072998, -0.48915913701057434, 0.8761999607086182, -0.007908112369477749, 0.44014012813568115, -0.4450121819972992, 0.17753204703330994, -0.4130053222179413, -0.01842048577964306, 0.19192342460155487, 0.4076773524284363, -0.2892768085002899, 0.30569884181022644, 0.5661040544509888, -0.43001607060432434, 0.630233883857727, 0.1652582287788391, -0.7034959197044373, -0.6945149898529053, 0.9996039271354675, 0.3015344440937042, 1.0891201496124268, 0.2572373151779175, 0.4563921391963959, 0.5868239998817444, -0.7262529134750366, 0.22960950434207916, -0.28300875425338745, -0.18916013836860657, -1.2259511947631836, -0.4191528856754303, -0.11994040012359619, -0.6204913258552551, 0.4609261453151703, 0.20654484629631042, -0.5987836718559265, -0.20998188853263855, -0.5274814367294312, -0.026091042906045914, 0.731177031993866, -0.6457960605621338, -0.008735690265893936, -0.3076224625110626, 0.012586874887347221, -0.4398975372314453, 0.4556669294834137, 0.7646598219871521, -0.41067054867744446, 0.43051281571388245, -0.5747249722480774, 0.15146788954734802, -0.058428436517715454, -0.7087351679801941, -0.698894739151001, -0.6599288582801819, -0.8732719421386719, 0.6334519386291504, 0.17169387638568878, 0.8307489156723022, -0.013608353212475777, -0.20257143676280975, -0.10687360167503357, 0.05806589499115944, 0.844197690486908, 0.23806315660476685, -0.5360479354858398, -0.17603543400764465, -0.25009071826934814, 0.6269679069519043, -0.9202898144721985, -0.6530439257621765, 0.08374481648206711, 0.07186013460159302, 0.8136682510375977, -0.4605962336063385, 0.7630688548088074, -0.7814634442329407, -0.44275036454200745, -0.35616233944892883, 0.15274718403816223, 0.9227653741836548, -0.16726209223270416, 0.12169754505157471, 0.7697679996490479, -0.033785343170166016, 0.1242755651473999, -0.4296877384185791, 0.5693917870521545, 1.1942007541656494, 0.3980136811733246, -0.39251118898391724, 0.0791124701499939, 0.06578925997018814 ]
{"Title": "Forecasting the impact of population ageing on tuberculosis incidence", "Authors": "Ku Chu-Chang, Dodd Peter J", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Tuberculosis (TB) disease reactivates from distant latent infection or recent (re)infection. Progression risks increase with age. Across the World Health Organisation Western Pacific region, many populations are ageing and have the highest per capita TB incidence rates in older age groups. However, methods for analysing age-specific TB incidence and forecasting epidemic trends while accounting for demographic change remain limited. Methods We applied the Lee-Carter models, which were originally developed for mortality modelling, to model the temporal trends in age-specific TB incidence data from 2005 to 2018 in Taiwan. Females and males were modelled separately. We combined our demographic forecasts, and age-specific TB incidence forecasts to project TB incidence until 2035. We compared TB incidence projections with demography fixed in 2018 to projections accounting for demographic change. Results Our models quantified increasing incidence rates with age and declining temporal trends. By 2035, the forecast suggests that the TB incidence rate in Taiwan will decrease by 54% (95% Prediction Interval (PI): 45%-59%) compared to 2015, while most age-specific incidence rates will reduce by more than 60%. In 2035, adults aged 65 and above will make up 78% of incident TB cases. Forecast TB incidence in 2035 accounting for demographic change will be 39% (95% PI: 36%-42%) higher than without population ageing. Conclusions Age-specific incidence forecasts coupled with demographic forecasts can inform the impact of population ageing on TB epidemics. The TB control programme in Taiwan should develop plans specific to older age groups and their care needs.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001115"}
10.1101/19014043
[ 0.05106321722269058, 1.2052233219146729, 0.16374173760414124, -0.03244520351290703, -0.39377808570861816, -0.6595897078514099, -0.8429065942764282, -0.22887814044952393, -0.1650964915752411, 0.9176772832870483, -0.28342798352241516, -0.025357561185956, 0.23869505524635315, 0.19832894206047058, -0.40579214692115784, -0.7538901567459106, -0.8804714679718018, -0.12615877389907837, 0.9531331062316895, -0.03610583767294884, 0.04013000428676605, 0.964482843875885, -1.1980477571487427, -0.7272893786430359, -1.2973320484161377, 0.744074821472168, 0.47819337248802185, -0.5974353551864624, 1.4393901824951172, 0.5213584899902344, 0.6329859495162964, -0.24823059141635895, 0.3484655022621155, -0.5969818234443665, -0.39629924297332764, -0.23064933717250824, 0.9875287413597107, 0.0248892679810524, -0.38656899333000183, -0.8805643320083618, 1.1506233215332031, -0.3815619647502899, 0.08400177210569382, -0.7685198783874512, -0.6019498109817505, 0.2802908718585968, -0.17435631155967712, 0.4918273687362671, 0.3281940221786499, -0.35472843050956726, 0.036319028586149216, 0.5173299312591553, -0.1725040227174759, -0.8514592051506042, -0.7212644219398499, -0.4537670612335205, -0.39774560928344727, -0.03439861908555031, -0.27087363600730896, 0.28111666440963745, 0.09406232088804245, -0.1750299632549286, 0.4801773428916931, -1.1044080257415771, 0.40240806341171265, 0.5743173956871033, -0.4770141541957855, -0.23262260854244232, -0.13402365148067474, -0.3354814946651459, -0.6594308018684387, -0.36995595693588257, -0.3949740529060364, 0.07954825460910797, -0.21220099925994873, 0.1316775232553482, 0.4595422148704529, -0.772679328918457, -0.2586918771266937, -0.11213476955890656, 0.22262796759605408, 0.44335371255874634, 0.31756553053855896, 0.17704376578330994, -0.7109131217002869, 0.059134647250175476, 1.0182719230651855, 0.08202432841062546, 0.577259361743927, 0.7751144170761108, 0.32435235381126404, 0.17507492005825043, 0.8139715194702148, -0.16423997282981873, 0.39724841713905334, 0.8241344094276428, 0.647392749786377, -0.03269084542989731, 0.11028885096311569, -0.09054938703775406, 1.035546064376831, 1.247188925743103, -0.6664712429046631, 1.1078252792358398, -0.7310692071914673, 0.8571456670761108, 1.122061014175415, -0.5251539349555969, -0.28061389923095703, -0.6588018536567688, 0.025688733905553818, 0.3105209767818451, -0.20337294042110443, -0.17316806316375732, 0.5006694197654724, 0.7060753107070923, 0.7125430107116699, 0.6689016819000244, -0.6617596745491028, 0.2298486828804016, -0.2009398341178894, 0.22987808287143707, 0.1371048092842102, -0.06328706443309784, 0.18313422799110413, -0.40196701884269714, 0.40416786074638367, 0.2378361076116562, -0.5521001219749451, -0.22586524486541748, -0.11495271325111389, -0.9605829119682312, -0.026004064828157425, 1.3994120359420776, 0.47582346200942993, 0.429067999124527, 0.5966565608978271, 0.936019241809845, 0.5208303928375244, 0.17508289217948914, -0.06007112190127373, 0.3003362715244293, -1.1435785293579102, 1.586680293083191, 0.004608959425240755, 0.196420818567276, -0.26425573229789734, -0.2113150954246521, -0.45736339688301086, 0.6223951578140259, -0.7862337827682495, -0.22749385237693787, -0.5060237050056458, -0.1051715612411499, 0.7167938351631165, -0.1591208577156067, -0.7549912333488464, -0.04238802194595337, -0.40567535161972046, -0.0729001984000206, -0.7511761784553528, 0.3497762382030487, -0.37675634026527405, 0.2448674440383911, -0.7380911111831665, 0.6045386791229248, -0.37963929772377014, 0.6144426465034485, -0.08529762178659439, -0.6886521577835083, 1.123017430305481, 0.12982255220413208, 0.10061561316251755, 0.37013813853263855, 0.351236492395401, 0.3292385935783386, -0.22228188812732697, -0.6316600441932678, 0.36381882429122925, 0.049083564430475235, 0.1788576990365982, 0.24396729469299316, 0.058409884572029114, 0.310931533575058, 0.3790917694568634, 0.13647449016571045, -0.26115497946739197, -0.4820559620857239, -0.215101957321167, -0.07224787026643753, 0.3416392505168915, 0.5969007611274719, -0.5600079298019409, 0.6165270805358887, 0.551674485206604, 0.011943620629608631, 0.5896545648574829, 0.6109895706176758, 0.17682327330112457, -0.6850900053977966, -0.12877927720546722, 0.716254711151123, -0.6553623676300049, 0.3574691712856293, -0.8364508748054504, 0.8248611688613892, -0.5607632994651794, 0.4106215834617615, -0.8539833426475525, 0.4621744751930237, 0.5730476975440979, -0.28810152411460876, -0.06219856068491936, -0.034766558557748795, 0.7181578278541565, 0.2812337875366211, -0.37335005402565, 0.0584380067884922, 0.1475859135389328, -0.5355095267295837, 0.4300340414047241, -0.20016540586948395, 0.4976748824119568, 0.15035498142242432, 0.03093288093805313, 0.30138668417930603, 0.47305530309677124, 1.0462623834609985, 0.2891331911087036, 0.8570982217788696, 0.7268908023834229, 0.8611636161804199, 0.1693323850631714, 0.75816810131073, 0.37785449624061584, 0.03325493633747101, -0.26812052726745605, 0.10320327430963516, 0.08564934879541397, 0.3741786777973175, 1.015550971031189, 0.8894841074943542, 0.49039947986602783, 0.9532694220542908, -0.679844319820404, 0.7365450263023376, -0.08731533586978912, 0.254284143447876, -0.4034828841686249, 0.2848237454891205, -0.9714407324790955, 0.7656568884849548, -0.10576748102903366, 0.21002770960330963, -0.733402669429779, -0.32455962896347046, 0.11540482938289642, 0.3209056258201599, -0.323761522769928, -0.6397267580032349, -0.8007672429084778, 0.1367356777191162, -0.12692920863628387, -0.7147760987281799, 0.5063486099243164, 0.6669434905052185, 0.49625128507614136, 0.07774434983730316, -0.06772863864898682, -1.1672728061676025, -1.1938124895095825, -0.06855053454637527, -1.0056127309799194, -0.6470345258712769, -0.4789663851261139, -0.30884891748428345, -0.3112971782684326, -0.5894388556480408, -0.3160722255706787, -0.3748602569103241, -0.8621180057525635, 0.049338120967149734, 0.025121113285422325, 0.3427407443523407, 0.6760779619216919, -0.08276677131652832, -0.8167428970336914, -0.4521999955177307, 0.11589393764734268, -0.04102395847439766, 0.013408215716481209, -0.09606410562992096, -0.2947250306606293, -0.6983439326286316, 1.12062668800354, -0.42318665981292725, 0.04450937733054161, 0.7015064358711243, 0.18332140147686005, -0.6786091327667236, -0.025779196992516518, 0.936176598072052, -0.2268909215927124, -0.14825735986232758, -0.794008731842041, 0.7414796352386475, 0.09677843004465103, -0.35261937975883484, 0.33817583322525024, 0.3051303029060364, -0.43994858860969543, -0.1024627536535263, -0.33666756749153137, -0.49301832914352417, -0.7845485210418701, -0.06485754996538162, 1.0029314756393433, -0.6013094782829285, -0.0014358707703649998, -0.5720341801643372, -0.9747236371040344, -0.46891722083091736, -0.02774702198803425, -0.12282758951187134, -0.05958285555243492, 0.8289453983306885, 0.14718349277973175, -1.362626075744629, 0.4655711054801941, -0.4516856074333191, -0.538934588432312, 0.44606050848960876, -0.16251330077648163, 0.7137512564659119, 0.23369555175304413, 0.11205405741930008, -0.9623903036117554, -0.055555615574121475, -0.05357193946838379, -0.06745858490467072, 0.00907962303608656, -0.543151319026947, 0.4898104965686798, -0.0190153568983078, -0.04275604337453842, 0.47859734296798706, 0.6776577830314636, -0.4458315074443817, -0.23627014458179474, 0.0062820385210216045, -0.8115023374557495, 0.01016329787671566, 0.28912797570228577, -0.15983858704566956, -0.04297081008553505, 0.6663888096809387, -0.3584407567977905, 0.21309953927993774, -0.36766955256462097, -0.3898763358592987, 0.30570340156555176, 0.22870296239852905, -0.8826891779899597, 0.9419481158256531, -0.6023229360580444, -0.40122249722480774, 0.35161733627319336, 0.3253479301929474, 0.04913634806871414, -0.6497560739517212, 0.05320749059319496, -0.05557689443230629, -0.6034026145935059, 0.05048561468720436, 0.35235100984573364, -0.5355697274208069, 0.5200592875480652, 0.9186669588088989, 1.3723359107971191, -1.0973185300827026, -0.2253807783126831, 0.3275463283061981, 1.4331583976745605, 0.8384379744529724, 0.4732101559638977, 0.383532851934433, 0.29588595032691956, 0.09870772808790207, -0.43400371074676514, -0.2289322167634964, 0.09795722365379333, -0.24783101677894592, 0.02753875032067299, 0.0044151414185762405, -0.6143026351928711, -0.5304926633834839, 0.024275077506899834, 0.4671078324317932, 0.3513844907283783, 0.08289577811956406, 0.7531251907348633, -0.5847102999687195, 0.24872343242168427, 1.0152744054794312, 0.33833208680152893, 1.0401674509048462, -0.6641799211502075, -0.2061648815870285, -0.35574203729629517, -0.7942209243774414, -0.16642820835113525, -0.7124980092048645, 0.18721158802509308, -0.6897098422050476, 0.6273215413093567, -0.24981531500816345, -0.7106398344039917, -0.17595212161540985, -0.6246991753578186, -0.1491825431585312, 0.24868912994861603, -0.04167143628001213, -0.025519171729683876, 0.4796094000339508, -0.07288788259029388, -0.29611557722091675, -0.7347165942192078, -1.1846013069152832, 0.749519407749176, 0.7636834979057312, 0.24363787472248077, -0.5839077234268188, -0.2396407127380371, -0.10920461267232895, -0.800660252571106, 0.031975410878658295, 0.3316352665424347, -0.5230880379676819, -0.49561622738838196, -1.39141047000885, -0.6223325729370117, -0.1776040494441986, -0.7147781848907471, -0.35583972930908203, 0.324614018201828, -0.2167017161846161, 0.57411789894104, 0.7820335626602173, -0.3950277268886566, -0.13890838623046875, 0.7440751791000366, -0.30737748742103577, 0.49466732144355774, -0.7799035906791687, 0.04196620360016823, -0.18231935799121857, 0.03931676223874092, -0.11144491285085678, 0.7588784098625183, -0.4377266764640808, -0.20098064839839935, -0.3538001477718353, -0.14434774219989777, -0.6964980363845825, -0.32109907269477844, 1.3093293905258179, 0.12164121121168137, 0.33297911286354065, 0.6516550779342651, -0.9898175597190857, -0.3568769693374634, 0.4555284380912781, -0.32892870903015137, -0.3057125210762024, 0.5951002836227417, -0.6164495944976807, 0.04616532474756241, 0.6328306198120117, -0.20397481322288513, 0.08666437864303589, -0.23201890289783478, -0.325967937707901, -0.1809527426958084, -0.4337015151977539, -0.7851207852363586, -0.1520264446735382, -0.2730213701725006, 0.22394020855426788, -0.8223790526390076, 0.31298574805259705, -0.1884387880563736, -0.029665175825357437, -0.5782955288887024, 0.12953037023544312, -0.644460916519165, 0.26229918003082275, 0.2830679714679718, 0.22654974460601807, -0.4893699884414673, 0.623814582824707, 0.6927682757377625, -0.03165482357144356, -1.0939639806747437, -0.2738490402698517, 0.33230456709861755, -0.23151324689388275, -0.7574796080589294, -0.0631716176867485, -0.2762909233570099, -0.24314799904823303, -0.2745811939239502, -0.21989065408706665, -0.7154784798622131, 0.025519445538520813, -0.09109565615653992, -0.0042982036247849464, 0.44172003865242004, -0.6257854700088501, -0.18421873450279236, 0.6252596378326416, -0.5680885314941406, -0.6257526278495789, -0.15244072675704956, 0.2920342683792114, 0.1606188267469406, 0.33812305331230164, -0.08645229041576385, -0.8633371591567993, 0.05325700715184212, -0.6479994058609009, -0.18582549691200256, -0.8852080702781677, 0.1400412768125534, -0.24723224341869354, -0.5539780855178833, -0.5502832531929016, 0.3835143446922302, 0.5005754828453064, 0.7873184084892273, -0.02862074226140976, -0.9058193564414978, 0.34014058113098145, 0.11453959345817566, -0.0003626147226896137, 0.8985612392425537, -0.9322579503059387, 0.7649400234222412, 0.7110901474952698, -0.1509689837694168, -0.6149687170982361, 0.14138498902320862, 0.1327366977930069, 0.23431003093719482, 0.6584131121635437, 0.11125040799379349, -0.2818002700805664, 0.0004900994244962931, 0.63620924949646, -0.16473399102687836, 0.11576372385025024, -0.8632024526596069, 0.4935479760169983, -0.4327579140663147, 0.5560933351516724, -0.48581236600875854, -0.0107569033280015, 0.26737070083618164, 0.03259531781077385, 1.0213993787765503, -0.6946602463722229, 0.19929219782352448, -0.262288898229599, -0.10424169152975082, 0.4461708962917328, 0.3697951138019562, -0.8401498198509216, -0.09458250552415848, -0.5964486002922058, -0.7345877885818481, 0.6985512971878052, -0.29600101709365845, -0.24485725164413452, -0.011083346791565418, -0.6724405288696289, 1.0378830432891846, 0.22576384246349335, 0.8943666219711304, 0.9281041622161865, -0.7525966763496399, 0.3373222351074219, 0.8264696598052979, 0.22889447212219238, -0.4710092544555664, 0.49350082874298096, 0.533839762210846, 0.39158132672309875, -0.34885719418525696, -0.4030575752258301, -0.6674894690513611, -0.7603704333305359, 0.3766908347606659, 0.3351052701473236, 0.01665670797228813, -0.8283702731132507, 0.5428633689880371, -0.5356135368347168, -0.7779322862625122, -0.18464508652687073, -0.19756291806697845, 0.28554150462150574, 0.469009131193161, 0.7319177985191345, 0.18931984901428223, -0.14889848232269287, 0.18802282214164734, 0.6084963083267212, 0.25344255566596985, 0.344233900308609, 0.42114415764808655, 0.08158329874277115, -0.6380365490913391, 0.18257911503314972, -0.05320383235812187, -0.8653193712234497, -0.3141203820705414, -0.7162385582923889, 0.19225020706653595, 0.25956204533576965, -0.28751519322395325, -0.4077092409133911, 0.3926025629043579, -1.038085699081421, 0.6833863854408264, 0.4045112431049347, -0.26825329661369324, -0.022435810416936874, 0.2347644865512848, 0.4868537485599518, -0.8304024934768677, 0.9695152044296265, 0.6255098581314087, 0.02294924110174179, 0.2698597013950348, -0.3976600766181946, -0.6311202049255371, 0.6613906025886536, -0.7161183953285217, 0.40517520904541016, -0.8747495412826538, -0.06261356174945831, 0.4162476360797882, 0.15800519287586212, 0.3493618369102478, -0.5001592040061951, 0.6258649826049805, 0.8056855201721191, -0.2779262065887451, -0.8733990788459778, -1.16643488407135, -0.11048736423254013, 0.2779656648635864, 0.784392237663269, 0.06080247089266777, 0.08571018278598785, 0.12930941581726074, -0.017842382192611694, 0.500792384147644, -0.751863956451416, -0.662291407585144, -0.3303482234477997, -0.2050958126783371, -0.15565158426761627, -0.4012655019760132, 0.2755131721496582, 0.45475250482559204, 0.09508898109197617, -0.46936020255088806, -0.244222030043602, 0.3359226882457733, 0.005246947985142469, 0.45963576436042786, -0.754466712474823, -0.4064430296421051, -0.27481183409690857, -0.15698441863059998, -0.27839455008506775, -0.572657585144043, -0.1018848791718483, 1.015929102897644, -0.4589986205101013, -0.04501010850071907, -0.8241764307022095, 0.17073921859264374, -0.237300843000412, 0.5224413275718689, -0.7809993028640747, -0.848658561706543, -0.8418626189231873, 0.22801071405410767, -0.5206912755966187, 0.18404273688793182, 0.32883983850479126, -0.17491862177848816, -0.19656801223754883, 0.0022389052901417017, 0.17106914520263672, 0.023193007335066795, 0.3277212679386139, 0.9532018899917603, -0.769166111946106, -0.1678735464811325, 0.035331424325704575, 0.6170005798339844, -0.900610625743866, -0.4060201048851013, -0.4398842453956604, 0.026442207396030426, 0.008828409016132355, 0.25072768330574036, -0.1033707857131958, 0.7403847575187683, 0.2461349070072174, 0.7042270302772522, -0.0795639157295227, 0.6836649179458618, -0.2990202307701111, -0.14789161086082458, -0.2896118760108948, -0.36250773072242737, 0.22178611159324646, -1.2477737665176392, 0.8225212693214417, 0.07503093779087067, 0.045089393854141235, 0.21246416866779327, -0.00463331863284111, -0.32219651341438293, 0.20042532682418823, -0.5492917895317078, -0.742137610912323, 0.6325213313102722, 0.09969419986009598, 0.639038622379303, -0.22091144323349, -0.6248388886451721, -0.6792447566986084, -0.045769140124320984, -1.2093695402145386, 0.05328042060136795, 0.18561092019081116, -0.48220929503440857, -0.2968020439147949, -0.35910576581954956, -0.26504939794540405, 0.04720155522227287, -0.35538530349731445, -0.5166704058647156, -0.010268005542457104, 0.39767375588417053, -0.3837848901748657, 0.4013233184814453, -0.10753634572029114, -0.4478238523006439, -0.1579781174659729, 0.3122354745864868, -0.1831829845905304, -0.02979988604784012, -0.23812003433704376, 0.6032024025917053, 0.47166213393211365, 0.08478368073701859, -0.39784225821495056, 0.23860898613929749, -0.1284690946340561, -0.2002517580986023, -0.2227347195148468, 0.3694780170917511, -0.5825574398040771, -0.528942346572876, -0.269651859998703, -0.1480872631072998, -0.09495760500431061, 0.35867840051651, 0.2972351014614105, -0.3403795063495636, -0.8067558407783508, 0.04138439893722534, 0.31270846724510193, -0.3540341854095459, 0.5178688168525696, -0.28527095913887024, 0.6838512420654297, 0.2738776206970215, -0.07818128168582916, 0.06640427559614182, 0.4382811486721039, -0.3057613968849182, 0.012589707970619202, 0.5921229720115662, 0.27353551983833313, 0.6540378332138062, 0.1419946253299713, -0.7893109917640686, 0.32402610778808594, -0.3777267634868622, 0.2047572284936905, 0.020196590572595596, -0.7368689179420471, 0.6782820820808411, -0.6133856773376465, -0.34961578249931335, 0.22930596768856049, -0.3019545078277588, 0.6939311027526855, -0.0025361867155879736, -0.48294544219970703, 0.7107559442520142, -0.33316072821617126, -0.4873585104942322, 0.07727707922458649, 0.30484285950660706, 0.6480461955070496, -0.18650533258914948, -0.13834403455257416, 0.2524738311767578, 0.8948366045951843, 0.2665983736515045, -0.5599201321601868, 0.6025233268737793, -0.24032831192016602, 0.16733090579509735, -0.4690974950790405, 0.8009217381477356, 0.2079630196094513, -0.7676668763160706, 0.5654289722442627, -0.6891070008277893, 0.07145759463310242, 0.1375720053911209, -0.5478095412254333, 0.25960925221443176, 0.7798662185668945, -0.214533731341362, -0.23181721568107605, -0.15636895596981049, 0.276170939207077, -0.7606629133224487, -0.21758510172367096, 0.43814632296562195, 0.5674347877502441, -0.15471746027469635, 0.20503750443458557, 0.8552177548408508, 0.2452695667743683, 0.7159709334373474, 0.5978075265884399, 0.266743928194046, 0.8310280442237854, 0.764482319355011, 0.10870460420846939, -0.04704911634325981, -0.4337722063064575, -0.10406751185655594, -0.0654122531414032, -0.6923941373825073, 0.03917761892080307, 1.029720425605774, -1.2802685499191284, -0.13755004107952118, -0.23297226428985596, -0.2911127507686615, -0.347181499004364, -0.4053126573562622, 0.040252506732940674, 0.44514086842536926, 0.25686049461364746, -0.7669097781181335, 0.8671970367431641, 0.1311936378479004, 0.26562803983688354, 0.17686210572719574, 0.15832161903381348, -0.21527300775051117, 0.5306679010391235, -0.9190621376037598, 0.3830234706401825, 0.42929425835609436, -0.39459627866744995, -0.6090925931930542, -1.1212973594665527, -0.20578359067440033, -1.146926760673523, 0.21041233837604523, -0.19677792489528656, 0.4413016140460968, 0.4532524645328522, 0.5479705929756165, 0.3188556134700775, 0.3966178297996521, -0.011109935119748116, 0.08422654867172241, 0.9221377372741699, -0.21617738902568817, 0.28763070702552795, -0.18796885013580322, -0.017125602811574936, -0.2776184380054474, 0.08811689168214798, -0.09367764741182327, 0.07754938304424286, 0.03177602216601372, -0.7204896807670593, 0.0071658780798316, -0.6007440090179443, -0.8484630584716797, -0.07604411244392395, 0.25290530920028687, -0.6822143197059631, -0.5437451601028442, 0.13591597974300385, -0.43309929966926575, -0.8977978825569153, 0.5124748349189758, -0.7465572357177734, 0.12606431543827057, 0.23741677403450012, -0.0047249807976186275, 0.6273118257522583, -0.03863462060689926, 4.108824729919434, 0.49537336826324463, 0.4108697474002838, -0.3603064715862274, 1.1536370515823364, 0.5067716240882874, 0.38300642371177673, -0.25492000579833984, 0.4534696340560913, -0.0685090571641922, -0.0814456045627594, 0.6182841062545776, 0.22233682870864868, -0.486972451210022, 0.2341029942035675, -0.0673193633556366, -0.7763768434524536, 0.6032987236976624, -0.08859943598508835, -0.7345372438430786, -0.1743215024471283, 1.0492234230041504, -0.16865138709545135, 0.36688169836997986, 0.5469227433204651, -0.18203802406787872, 0.4577820897102356, -0.28095418214797974, 0.5353775024414062, -0.05438889563083649, 0.1676807999610901, -0.6097152829170227, -0.03846529498696327, -0.30471640825271606, -0.5805085897445679, 0.587901771068573, 0.3706933557987213, 0.15569178760051727, -0.2567095160484314, -0.2803378105163574, 0.5588140487670898, 0.6263986825942993, -0.80352383852005, -0.05580711364746094, -0.758812665939331, 0.3028547167778015, 0.023952333256602287, -0.12313812971115112, 0.5220732092857361, -0.22609394788742065, 0.5666808485984802, -0.784923255443573, 1.1092864274978638, -0.3223916292190552, -1.0265685319900513, -0.27149197459220886, 0.17174337804317474, -1.1177319288253784, -0.21505115926265717, 0.09270800650119781, 0.9880465269088745, -0.2520560026168823, 0.3343966603279114, 0.40803492069244385, -0.4869711399078369, -0.658463180065155, 0.3145250380039215, -0.6282889246940613, -0.21233519911766052, 0.11848516762256622, 0.14327950775623322, -0.37405461072921753, -0.17313316464424133, -0.2732715308666229, 0.7549209594726562, 0.2769109606742859, -0.04699510708451271, 0.8355013728141785, -0.06607576459646225, -0.21968817710876465, -0.18362173438072205, 0.2327854335308075, 0.2354029417037964, -0.07284822314977646, 0.08389453589916229, 0.9281089305877686, -0.20595993101596832, -0.042250849306583405, -0.13078470528125763, 0.27400144934654236, 0.5209386944770813, -0.038271158933639526, 0.4103211462497711, 0.4441632628440857, 0.00805263128131628 ]
{"Title": "Using Paired Agent-Based Simulations To Test Strategies For Limiting The Effects Of Epidemics", "Authors": "Armstrong Margaret, Coelho Fl\u00e1vio Code\u00e7o", "Abstract": "Abstract Agent-based simulations are widely used nowadays in public health research for comparing different strategies for mitigating epidemics and for planning appropriate responses in the aftermath of crises in large urban areas because they can capture fine scale heterogeneities that may have important non-linear effects on the results. Given the costs of implementing strategies, decision-makers have to be convinced that the proposed treatment/procedure leads to a statistically significant improvement. This paper presents an innovative method for constructing paired agent-based simulations where exactly the same set of random effects is applied to simulations with and without the treatment/procedure. Statistical Analysis of Variance distinguishes the sum of squares between groups (BSS) from the sum of squares within groups (WSS). Our aim was to filter out the within sum of squares (WSS) leaving only the sum of squares between the control group and the treatment group (BSS). We propose to filter out the WSS by constructing paired simulations because as is well known, when paired t-tests can be used, they are much more powerful than ordinary t-tests. Pearson\u2019s Chi-squared goodness of fit, the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic and the Kullback-Leibler Divergence are then used to test whether the effect is statistically significant. This procedure has been tested on a case-study on the propagation of the Zika epidemic in Rio de Janeiro in 2015. Author summary Agent-based simulations are emerging as a powerful tool in computational biology because they can capture fine scale heterogeneities that can have important effects on the propagation of epidemics. In silico experiments can be used to test different strategies for mitigating epidemics quickly and inexpensively. Given the inherent variability from one simulation to another, it is difficult to statistically prove their effectiveness. We have developed a powerful method rather like paired t-tests, for testing whether a given treatment is statistically better than the control. We do this by generating paired simulations with exactly the same random variables in the control simulation and the one with a treatment. Using the terminology of analysis of variance, we want to filter out the sum of squares within the group, leaving only the sum of squares between the control and the treatment. This procedure has been applied to a case-study to see whether enclosing and air-conditioning the transport hub in Rio de Janeiro would have slowed down the propagation of Zika.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19014043"}
10.1101/19002212
[ -0.2789836823940277, 0.4130289852619171, -0.37541431188583374, 0.08706995844841003, -0.4648040533065796, 0.16961362957954407, -0.30590584874153137, 0.02989591844379902, 1.1811927556991577, 0.10327302664518356, -0.20168745517730713, -0.07562368363142014, 0.1692669838666916, 0.11588219553232193, -0.2985050678253174, -0.09168438613414764, -0.41723528504371643, -0.2406764179468155, 0.017805738374590874, 0.8387125730514526, 0.45673006772994995, 0.7690542936325073, -0.3128565847873688, -0.4282974302768707, -0.8547055721282959, 0.24288278818130493, -0.28167155385017395, -0.30608367919921875, 1.3420624732971191, 0.6141935586929321, -0.09180653095245361, -0.8292369842529297, 0.8728816509246826, -1.0892329216003418, -0.33718931674957275, -0.19881653785705566, 0.23758262395858765, -0.5101609826087952, -0.3150218725204468, -0.12834571301937103, 0.3268042206764221, -0.31128841638565063, 1.1118488311767578, -0.8755378723144531, -0.2895625829696655, -0.3500095307826996, 0.7862262725830078, 0.2592822313308716, -0.24941770732402802, 0.22451184689998627, -0.17767800390720367, 0.05019836872816086, 0.8644508123397827, -1.1735016107559204, -0.8082641959190369, -0.06613267958164215, 0.14301472902297974, -0.16004903614521027, -0.8304469585418701, 0.4323961138725281, 0.1562090516090393, -0.23742537200450897, 0.579711377620697, -0.6189340353012085, 0.3729994595050812, 0.4859431982040405, 0.016270166262984276, 0.20358312129974365, -0.21520724892616272, -0.8328439593315125, -0.0696500763297081, 0.2547122538089752, -0.7873784303665161, -0.8295397758483887, -0.21540221571922302, -0.4400183856487274, 0.05502129718661308, 0.1034047082066536, -0.6798774003982544, 0.10452493280172348, -0.127400204539299, 0.4727182984352112, 0.3338235914707184, -0.9229510426521301, -0.9230197072029114, 0.0727616623044014, -0.5654003024101257, 0.23847660422325134, 0.6364691853523254, 0.8177036046981812, -0.09020952135324478, 0.4641455113887787, 0.2898269295692444, -0.7920799851417542, 0.03814881294965744, 0.9531179666519165, -0.25043267011642456, 0.3826189935207367, -0.1215466558933258, 0.06806241720914841, 0.46520835161209106, 0.8163803219795227, 0.10793834179639816, 1.2792119979858398, -0.31703516840934753, 0.398704469203949, 0.1716480404138565, -0.73063725233078, -0.7463335990905762, -0.4936617314815521, 0.011921348050236702, -0.05528223514556885, -1.168906807899475, -0.49435296654701233, 0.6913230419158936, 0.484152615070343, -0.14155030250549316, 0.545687735080719, -0.5059548616409302, 0.7984355688095093, -0.09646518528461456, -0.21196384727954865, 0.013167062774300575, 0.11358282715082169, 0.7272800803184509, -0.6842644214630127, 0.4819294512271881, 0.06413626670837402, -0.08181508630514145, -0.2847674489021301, 0.3916669189929962, -0.47733429074287415, 0.06389055401086807, 0.8530858159065247, 0.10150175541639328, 0.658502459526062, -0.009918654337525368, 0.36154991388320923, 0.7223308086395264, -0.5467248558998108, 0.41921180486679077, 0.732275664806366, -0.25955548882484436, 1.4579031467437744, -0.1979704648256302, 0.801811695098877, 0.2887319326400757, -0.5963414311408997, -0.39474621415138245, 0.3904634416103363, -0.3603765070438385, -0.11698272079229355, -0.2525028884410858, 0.21781101822853088, 0.7522761821746826, -0.06925146281719208, -0.3277290463447571, 0.03418344259262085, -0.005606852006167173, -0.05694514885544777, 0.2173297107219696, -0.010658267885446548, -0.49335017800331116, -0.011168094351887703, -0.7529186606407166, 0.496334433555603, -0.24986335635185242, -0.07070423662662506, 0.5955347418785095, -0.23553693294525146, 1.0788919925689697, 0.054917607456445694, -0.13998469710350037, 0.17614887654781342, 0.44445323944091797, 1.0060559511184692, 0.8555518984794617, -0.0018691543955355883, 0.8225107789039612, 0.8112424612045288, -0.3286145031452179, -0.00643386784940958, -0.4870588481426239, 0.8431642055511475, 0.08932135254144669, 0.3098418712615967, -0.14577464759349823, -0.5038002729415894, 0.06911877542734146, -0.15096214413642883, 0.07286383211612701, 0.4973558783531189, -0.3970623016357422, 0.09102971106767654, -0.5964637994766235, 0.23473955690860748, -0.035577207803726196, 1.086972713470459, 1.0822073221206665, -0.3922397792339325, 0.045973408967256546, -0.016839036718010902, -0.19521726667881012, 0.020983349531888962, -0.07433304190635681, -0.010869230143725872, 0.2665312886238098, -0.07777111232280731, -0.3633655607700348, 0.3087175786495209, 0.4883282780647278, -0.1267058253288269, 0.32022446393966675, -0.2833115756511688, 0.6944326162338257, 0.19441340863704681, -0.5021694302558899, 0.8199612498283386, -0.44733476638793945, 0.1328098028898239, -0.027292568236589432, -0.3158971667289734, 0.2380543351173401, 0.15440969169139862, 0.2091481238603592, -0.45791804790496826, 0.23467354476451874, 0.21206341683864594, -0.05348534509539604, 0.14957793056964874, -0.19663332402706146, 0.44760483503341675, 0.4036611318588257, 0.8873194456100464, 0.6076651215553284, 0.2967497408390045, 0.10886892676353455, 0.734336793422699, 0.6533632874488831, -0.08827918022871017, 0.9728192090988159, 0.11222216486930847, 0.5741584897041321, 0.6149214506149292, -0.4900648295879364, 0.7911497950553894, -0.6437820792198181, -0.20208998024463654, -0.6564660668373108, 0.17244789004325867, -0.728620171546936, 1.3938170671463013, 0.7203380465507507, 0.320539265871048, -0.4275487959384918, -0.19240227341651917, 0.28185734152793884, -0.16584567725658417, 0.4564213156700134, -0.6998723149299622, 0.0017323384527117014, 0.20361359417438507, -0.03130358085036278, -0.5838234424591064, 1.1861474514007568, 0.4211586117744446, 0.21320705115795135, 0.5409144759178162, -0.35041117668151855, -0.2903043329715729, -0.8467579483985901, -0.3777009844779968, -0.8716452121734619, -0.6848698854446411, -0.8909776210784912, -0.0528080090880394, 0.42262721061706543, -0.21150299906730652, 0.14455944299697876, -0.6667606234550476, -0.23544920980930328, 0.2607576549053192, -0.17303945124149323, -0.027588175609707832, 0.31266769766807556, 0.36155837774276733, -0.6626648902893066, -0.42652255296707153, 0.40305769443511963, 0.030421532690525055, 0.10573790222406387, 0.530594527721405, -0.771767258644104, -0.7476248145103455, 0.5895946621894836, -0.4663454294204712, 0.15118297934532166, 0.24157510697841644, -0.309891939163208, -0.036388643085956573, -0.6281614303588867, 0.1398257464170456, -0.4795261323451996, -0.2318006455898285, -0.01220346987247467, 0.8570191860198975, 0.026746924966573715, 0.08808225393295288, 0.4250236749649048, -0.02748226933181286, -0.3127237856388092, 0.2992395758628845, -0.09563576430082321, -0.1215408518910408, -1.2017568349838257, 0.12076792865991592, 0.8020052909851074, -0.5551087260246277, 0.4351331889629364, -0.6679471731185913, -0.8503118753433228, -0.04024916887283325, 0.2889203429222107, -0.05613727122545242, 0.1168525442481041, 0.28581666946411133, -0.140459805727005, -1.661378264427185, 0.23213984072208405, -0.6710085868835449, -0.5818678140640259, -0.14746971428394318, 0.19225479662418365, -0.33619412779808044, 0.3658939599990845, 0.1522141396999359, -0.554309070110321, -0.5873191356658936, -0.0731319785118103, -0.4537826478481293, 0.8870611786842346, -0.4459810256958008, 0.24679233133792877, 0.5420767664909363, 0.40871718525886536, 0.8312302827835083, 0.05013446882367134, -0.217391699552536, 0.17036031186580658, 0.5638769268989563, 0.058040913194417953, 0.6092677712440491, 0.5375398993492126, 0.22621095180511475, -0.3628813624382019, 0.585333526134491, -0.3336426913738251, -0.27737098932266235, -0.06848914176225662, 0.48175477981567383, 0.7925372123718262, 0.16782301664352417, -0.5020424127578735, 0.17421364784240723, -1.1856695413589478, -0.7182239294052124, 0.5219472646713257, 0.06151249632239342, 0.459185391664505, -0.2939903140068054, 0.2444172352552414, 0.057790156453847885, 0.28928402066230774, 0.29245781898498535, 0.10091415792703629, -0.024370139464735985, 0.18315336108207703, 0.5583840012550354, 1.0608782768249512, -1.2161110639572144, 0.10348547250032425, 0.6484329700469971, 0.9039486646652222, -0.21655794978141785, -0.336116760969162, 0.27838364243507385, -0.5745147466659546, 0.1563117653131485, -0.30466440320014954, -0.40766164660453796, -0.17699337005615234, -0.9064983129501343, -0.02076740190386772, 0.42559587955474854, -0.24138452112674713, -0.7352210879325867, -0.12066610902547836, -0.014456954784691334, 0.5041437745094299, -0.1013932004570961, -0.04411185905337334, 0.40170541405677795, 0.6999518275260925, 0.37138327956199646, 0.1522807627916336, 0.5883671045303345, -0.4031504988670349, 0.06462787836790085, -0.02605537325143814, -0.45109668374061584, -0.16062110662460327, 0.2160046100616455, -0.24260112643241882, -0.4621676206588745, 0.11872801184654236, -0.6545812487602234, 0.40356335043907166, 0.1583109200000763, 0.40326929092407227, -0.1634690910577774, 0.9015192985534668, -0.29360875487327576, -0.736935555934906, 0.6648355722427368, 0.1585611253976822, -0.4266345798969269, -0.06896869093179703, -0.34227344393730164, 0.18653027713298798, 0.5643677711486816, 0.5880167484283447, -0.11068855226039886, -0.5000032782554626, 0.21361374855041504, -0.8765106797218323, 0.27848854660987854, 0.38756847381591797, -0.17509712278842926, -0.6454201936721802, -0.6117451786994934, -0.48223409056663513, -0.761846661567688, -0.5193589329719543, -0.142519012093544, 0.6220529079437256, -0.244548961520195, 0.9042336344718933, 0.35481923818588257, 0.29612669348716736, -0.08616886287927628, 0.13312560319900513, -0.915781557559967, 0.07925987988710403, -0.8789054751396179, -0.20147860050201416, -0.05963882431387901, 0.29703855514526367, -0.44528481364250183, 0.09310951083898544, -0.46052950620651245, -1.0989598035812378, 0.37387049198150635, -0.20842339098453522, 0.028738437220454216, -0.49273109436035156, 0.6981284022331238, 0.07533974945545197, -0.7891068458557129, 1.5433495044708252, -1.0994515419006348, 0.22793525457382202, 0.35011282563209534, 0.21946370601654053, -0.9246764779090881, 0.23473547399044037, -0.1345580518245697, -0.23945064842700958, 0.6604210138320923, -0.6813899874687195, 0.8371551036834717, 0.13359609246253967, 0.2701587677001953, 0.5976256132125854, 0.1293879747390747, 0.4376596510410309, -0.27245020866394043, -0.4566520154476166, 0.020891770720481873, -1.1726415157318115, 0.20978184044361115, 0.03839621692895889, -0.3730151653289795, -0.38606175780296326, 0.4502317011356354, -0.416135311126709, -0.07712530344724655, -0.1423780918121338, -0.7695675492286682, 0.5562385320663452, -0.06513877213001251, 0.7932184338569641, -0.8214925527572632, 0.3581137955188751, -0.05247735604643822, 0.12462040036916733, -0.4857199192047119, -0.4236772656440735, 0.04945371299982071, -0.512241780757904, 0.03711351379752159, 0.17076726257801056, -0.08099595457315445, -0.6617121696472168, -0.5781925320625305, -0.43339571356773376, 0.18286587297916412, 0.9827567338943481, 0.21004445850849152, -0.39942923188209534, 0.4828122556209564, -0.44047701358795166, -0.49035215377807617, -0.5702208280563354, 0.6608608961105347, 0.37300795316696167, 0.505929708480835, 0.27387768030166626, -0.0635356530547142, -0.755062997341156, -0.8684996962547302, -0.3292052447795868, -0.5610198378562927, 0.07711395621299744, -0.4314802885055542, -0.02873416803777218, -0.5068005323410034, 0.2020244300365448, -0.3040392994880676, -0.2561914920806885, -0.5451748371124268, -0.8128612041473389, 0.5255363583564758, 0.4708961844444275, 0.01451865490525961, -0.5063682794570923, -1.340669870376587, 0.20248593389987946, 0.5470122694969177, 0.1408568173646927, -0.39967504143714905, -0.12329846620559692, 0.07552757114171982, 0.2867893576622009, 0.503165602684021, -0.4608376920223236, -0.1663670539855957, 0.041349686682224274, 0.8866508603096008, -0.2450210154056549, -0.5329717993736267, -0.6273905634880066, 0.21565532684326172, -0.535178542137146, 0.32910916209220886, 0.4346478283405304, -0.3346894383430481, 0.4105353355407715, -0.32173192501068115, 1.0003271102905273, 0.149077370762825, 0.01098706480115652, -0.6699405908584595, -0.22302566468715668, 0.9635217189788818, -0.08379800617694855, -0.2402190864086151, -0.9467267990112305, -0.42878302931785583, -1.0209378004074097, 0.5213492512702942, 0.018237123265862465, -0.03557003289461136, -0.22129841148853302, -0.21594615280628204, 0.4818972647190094, -0.21543703973293304, 0.6908864974975586, 0.7637312412261963, -0.5452691316604614, -0.05734962970018387, 0.5120007991790771, 0.52156662940979, -0.18884019553661346, -0.40974268317222595, 0.014862109906971455, -0.2853321433067322, 0.2959018349647522, -0.2524428963661194, -0.6345516443252563, -0.8451488018035889, 0.016027232632040977, 0.5033755302429199, 0.8474634885787964, -0.5151506662368774, 0.3732937276363373, 0.10891025513410568, -1.1666561365127563, -1.0065151453018188, 0.9352787137031555, 0.8016357421875, 0.34755685925483704, 0.8186595439910889, -0.03401079401373863, -1.0970752239227295, 0.3392745554447174, 0.21640807390213013, 0.7423669099807739, -0.4494805335998535, 0.7921556830406189, 0.1739322394132614, -0.3996993899345398, -0.10725456476211548, 0.04577440395951271, -0.6985859870910645, -1.007033348083496, -0.18191608786582947, -0.26079294085502625, 0.1665775328874588, -0.4410756230354309, 0.05793546512722969, -0.15975573658943176, -0.03963577002286911, 0.7071702480316162, -0.07504776865243912, 0.059000588953495026, -0.43561211228370667, -0.11277376860380173, 0.5104825496673584, -0.877781867980957, -0.5414844155311584, 0.31851446628570557, -0.3932957053184509, 0.5298184752464294, 0.33499836921691895, -0.4258137345314026, -0.12564364075660706, -0.21579156816005707, -0.29179829359054565, 0.08527269214391708, 0.16812776029109955, -0.1493862271308899, 0.11786002665758133, 0.7472310066223145, -0.054633960127830505, -0.6833259463310242, 0.5814980268478394, 0.7637314796447754, -0.8421031832695007, -0.18297408521175385, 0.7045639157295227, -0.43928471207618713, 0.18734826147556305, -0.010401437990367413, -0.5558108687400818, 0.13963936269283295, 0.35373592376708984, 0.07588423043489456, -0.4368712902069092, -0.6093429327011108, -0.6266832947731018, -0.10718080401420593, -1.0919537544250488, -0.4589724540710449, -0.058247726410627365, -0.16132210195064545, -0.6935926079750061, -0.9154208302497864, -0.545067548751831, 1.0037050247192383, -0.21284174919128418, 0.14795361459255219, -0.21784918010234833, 0.6056969165802002, -1.1174415349960327, -0.6131601333618164, 0.22333060204982758, 0.08638407289981842, -0.8759760856628418, 0.6465312242507935, -0.7460494637489319, -0.2759934365749359, -0.2279956340789795, 0.27392375469207764, 0.15547053515911102, 0.5868449211120605, -0.28443512320518494, -0.9953919053077698, -0.3468383550643921, 0.30739226937294006, 0.049263760447502136, -0.13978047668933868, 1.0973130464553833, -0.20253276824951172, 0.5663657784461975, -0.11860372871160507, 0.5000642538070679, 0.4285503923892975, -0.20078368484973907, 0.21334418654441833, -0.6580662727355957, -0.6265740990638733, -0.7533571124076843, 0.36072838306427, -0.9901700615882874, -0.6438537240028381, -0.9754992723464966, -0.12511928379535675, -0.01503753662109375, 0.09170463681221008, 0.20476579666137695, 0.6586371660232544, -0.56260085105896, 0.05482151731848717, -0.10612662136554718, -0.04767413064837456, 0.2558306157588959, -0.14909210801124573, -0.27510565519332886, 0.086491160094738, 0.3644371032714844, -0.800915002822876, 0.2414538413286209, 0.3187108635902405, -0.5568044781684875, 1.0354483127593994, 0.0458645336329937, 0.1100892648100853, 0.07640388607978821, -0.3586979806423187, -0.9248139262199402, 0.6479559540748596, 0.2745410203933716, 0.9597738981246948, 0.14397506415843964, 0.06643107533454895, -0.3638102412223816, -0.5027980208396912, -1.0492987632751465, 0.12767952680587769, 0.5862079858779907, -0.3993247151374817, -0.5791569352149963, -0.10252382606267929, -1.3847177028656006, 0.290863960981369, -0.5788273215293884, 0.06782229244709015, 0.22609689831733704, 0.7605719566345215, -0.9575516581535339, 0.7328017354011536, -0.07927681505680084, 0.29388681054115295, 0.2773300111293793, 0.14120158553123474, -0.3898126780986786, -0.8777891993522644, -0.8834456205368042, 0.2668302655220032, -0.07101603597402573, 0.2299080640077591, -0.27443769574165344, 0.1104058101773262, 0.2919227182865143, 0.8962628841400146, -0.03616834431886673, 0.202045276761055, -0.7468738555908203, 0.07664519548416138, 0.6636367440223694, -0.09559876471757889, -0.5031343698501587, -0.06911532580852509, 0.21705962717533112, -1.0002599954605103, -0.3304547071456909, -0.23266662657260895, 0.45092257857322693, 0.16155429184436798, 0.13893654942512512, 0.06358113884925842, 0.23626434803009033, -0.11295858025550842, -0.10840754210948944, 0.04093402996659279, 0.5820642113685608, -0.3103153705596924, 0.38137292861938477, 0.06036107987165451, -0.4126512110233307, 0.49418187141418457, -0.25079217553138733, -0.5122268795967102, 0.21069049835205078, -0.07753623276948929, 0.11397363245487213, -0.3118734061717987, -1.1803292036056519, 0.5061569809913635, 0.1536998748779297, 0.07574165612459183, 0.25833064317703247, 0.17509353160858154, 0.3846091330051422, 0.6763904690742493, -0.07802177965641022, 0.40884602069854736, -0.5295436978340149, -0.45267435908317566, 0.7598253488540649, -0.5314007997512817, 0.7465500235557556, 0.3292517066001892, 0.46105486154556274, 0.006171233952045441, 0.6649494171142578, 0.5315629839897156, -0.6285783648490906, 0.2349807769060135, 0.09613864123821259, 0.0912722498178482, -0.496310830116272, 0.7556212544441223, -0.04602017626166344, -0.037658173590898514, 0.3267371356487274, -0.8617920875549316, 0.20360636711120605, -0.1109708696603775, -0.35133010149002075, 0.00830250233411789, 0.7849158644676208, 0.13086864352226257, -0.5540892481803894, -0.3005215525627136, 0.6851504445075989, -0.22413858771324158, 0.4584501385688782, 0.11832503229379654, 0.08608350157737732, -0.015400365926325321, 0.3308132588863373, 0.3811347484588623, 0.39632049202919006, 0.19170938432216644, 0.28748777508735657, -0.2885775566101074, 0.33358556032180786, 0.4163013994693756, -0.45842015743255615, 0.35014083981513977, -0.404428094625473, 0.4993916451931, 0.16401666402816772, 0.006244790740311146, 0.25819963216781616, 0.15248708426952362, -0.6820621490478516, -0.706100344657898, -0.11142905801534653, 1.1443928480148315, -0.06008337438106537, -0.708130419254303, 0.14301489293575287, -0.023338794708251953, 0.08321370929479599, -0.9868950247764587, 0.032794564962387085, 0.32723450660705566, 0.4537532329559326, 0.15901966392993927, -0.10224040597677231, -0.546607494354248, -0.04362605884671211, -0.8529987335205078, 0.09545577317476273, 0.106559157371521, -0.3923660218715668, -0.5232510566711426, -0.6774048805236816, -0.0715138241648674, -0.24465720355510712, -0.5232630372047424, -0.6716402769088745, 0.3838156759738922, 0.46240508556365967, 0.7683994770050049, -0.15604624152183533, 0.5278844833374023, -0.6204370856285095, 0.3826495110988617, 0.726872980594635, 0.038923196494579315, 0.8217862844467163, -0.0057673705741763115, -0.2695654332637787, 0.27517908811569214, -0.13854864239692688, -0.40348923206329346, 0.057842206209897995, 0.06994796544313431, -0.3532642424106598, 0.13931810855865479, -0.3680145740509033, -0.43042609095573425, -0.08176586031913757, 0.21629159152507782, 0.3618910610675812, -0.38285520672798157, 0.08918952196836472, -0.6059980988502502, -1.0640050172805786, 0.5897940397262573, -0.5078752636909485, 0.5934029817581177, 0.2978368401527405, -0.3698488473892212, 0.6079766154289246, -0.8744798302650452, 4.247786045074463, 0.5872183442115784, 0.418540358543396, 0.17890813946723938, 1.041821837425232, -0.06101633608341217, 1.0135608911514282, 0.09962525963783264, -0.16483823955059052, 0.19826403260231018, -0.5159707069396973, 1.1993913650512695, -0.013388986699283123, -0.19928431510925293, 0.23762144148349762, 0.2813034951686859, -0.12710611522197723, 0.43622562289237976, 0.3193548321723938, -0.4913393259048462, -0.3796382546424866, 0.7191272377967834, 0.19303832948207855, 0.6241689920425415, 0.45003822445869446, 0.07732196152210236, -0.024319050833582878, -0.4356880486011505, 0.08004901558160782, -0.0861472338438034, 0.928160548210144, -0.19524461030960083, 0.4823164641857147, -0.4541420340538025, -0.4067428708076477, 0.1403147578239441, 0.6364609003067017, 0.2433893382549286, -0.2566836178302765, -0.1250278204679489, 0.8508653044700623, 0.5218302607536316, -0.5467386245727539, -0.5062229037284851, -0.8920192718505859, 0.4763367772102356, -0.9587808847427368, 0.40312430262565613, 1.0117217302322388, -0.29195141792297363, -0.067369744181633, -0.2834559977054596, -0.09681131690740585, 0.2019052803516388, -0.9485080242156982, 0.19730664789676666, -0.25516578555107117, -0.7136920690536499, -0.14063048362731934, 0.3456411361694336, 0.1873287558555603, -0.2394443154335022, 0.44499337673187256, -0.014026411809027195, -0.7629023790359497, 0.21182449162006378, 0.04510560259222984, 0.3271263837814331, -0.21998460590839386, -0.6773805022239685, 0.2968725860118866, -0.32849663496017456, -0.26342615485191345, -0.5909956097602844, 0.24069714546203613, 0.09112316370010376, 0.002643419662490487, 1.0441004037857056, -0.509598970413208, -0.855465292930603, -0.4649274945259094, -0.15480858087539673, 0.04838257282972336, -0.11367783695459366, 0.4282664954662323, 0.21979135274887085, -0.42161330580711365, -0.6124012470245361, -0.20536234974861145, -0.00005082646384835243, 1.1962082386016846, -0.06707636266946793, -0.4514731764793396, 0.662938117980957, 0.06808652728796005 ]
{"Title": "Comparative functional survival and equivalent annual cost of three long lasting insecticidal net (LLIN) products in Tanzania", "Authors": "Lorenz Lena M, Bradley John, Yukich Joshua, Massue Dennis Joram, Mboma Zawadi Mageni, Pigeon Olivier, Moore Jason, Kilian Albert Dr., Lines Jo, Kisinza William, Overgaard Hans J, Moore Sarah J", "Abstract": "Abstract Almost 1.2 billion long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs) have been procured for malaria control. Institutional buyers often assume that World Health Organization (WHO) prequalified LLINs are functionally identical with a three-year lifespan. We measured the lifespans of three LLIN products, and calculated their cost-per-year of functional life, through a randomised double-blinded prospective evaluation among 3,420 study households in Tanzania using WHO-recommended methods. Primary outcome was LLIN functional survival (LLINs present in serviceable condition). Secondary outcomes were 1) bioefficacy and chemical content (residual insecticidal activity) and 2) protective efficacy for volunteers sleeping under LLINs (bite reduction and mosquitoes killed). LLIN median functional survival was significantly different: 2\u00b70 years for Olyset, 2\u00b75 years for PermaNet and 2\u00b76 years for NetProtect. Functional survival was affected by accumulation of holes resulting in users discarding nets. Protective efficacy also significantly differed between products as they aged. The longer-lived nets were 20% cheaper than the shorter-lived product.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002212"}
10.1101/19007963
[ 0.17776525020599365, -0.7599961161613464, -0.39098185300827026, 0.3463859558105469, -0.6619986891746521, -0.5350705981254578, -0.4085235297679901, 0.342617392539978, 0.09364718943834305, 0.5816266536712646, -0.5210344791412354, -0.566667914390564, 0.6348205208778381, 0.25494563579559326, -0.15222127735614777, -0.011328905820846558, -0.8015416264533997, -0.3116168677806854, -0.5235644578933716, -0.03435797244310379, -0.09641016274690628, 0.07520314306020737, -0.5070254802703857, 0.046126700937747955, -0.3717072904109955, 0.7818525433540344, -0.814086377620697, 0.4207663834095001, 1.4287687540054321, 0.9758038520812988, 0.07042684406042099, 0.12438096106052399, 0.3823166489601135, -0.9240591526031494, -0.034567419439554214, -0.25224795937538147, 0.4409138262271881, -0.1722145527601242, -0.6619596481323242, -0.6843277812004089, 0.5441385507583618, -0.25057217478752136, 0.21873578429222107, -0.3966463506221771, -1.0825408697128296, 0.3385562598705292, 0.17632751166820526, -0.14398379623889923, -0.07680670917034149, 0.2671109139919281, -0.002060658298432827, 0.07277411967515945, -0.1556185483932495, -0.4132078289985657, -0.22206909954547882, 0.17618286609649658, -0.5301789045333862, -0.5066784024238586, -0.17184028029441833, 0.055733393877744675, 0.15139898657798767, -0.018978264182806015, 0.6952318549156189, -0.8827025294303894, 0.29400959610939026, 0.15281322598457336, -0.1497274935245514, -0.14253471791744232, 0.01873106136918068, -0.392415314912796, -0.1259782761335373, 0.15842176973819733, -0.5966457724571228, -0.730790913105011, -0.3618426024913788, -0.102510467171669, 0.09549757838249207, -0.8466660976409912, 0.10631047934293747, 0.3163507878780365, -0.19986949861049652, 0.8656291365623474, 0.6077290177345276, -0.22551846504211426, -0.9315420985221863, 0.43288928270339966, 0.03680838644504547, 0.13770705461502075, 0.6217564940452576, 0.5514787435531616, 0.23203034698963165, -0.12929539382457733, -0.024972818791866302, 0.19106590747833252, 0.018932703882455826, 1.1593236923217773, -0.6835736036300659, -0.12258325517177582, -0.17286629974842072, 0.22263582050800323, 0.8304701447486877, 0.688578724861145, -0.5588238835334778, 1.2186943292617798, -0.5005192160606384, 0.32209473848342896, 0.6241666078567505, -0.5723758339881897, 0.12245792895555496, -0.8535449504852295, 0.10352867096662521, -0.2734571695327759, -0.43938887119293213, 0.10314194113016129, 0.9235718250274658, 0.3338179886341095, 0.15163148939609528, 0.7594155073165894, -0.6743749976158142, 1.0783671140670776, 0.20906005799770355, 0.6168885231018066, 1.324827790260315, -0.1396118551492691, 0.03544725477695465, 0.24985335767269135, 0.3880963921546936, 0.2699057459831238, -0.4854121208190918, -0.8319027423858643, 0.8212293386459351, -0.733975350856781, -0.2499842643737793, 0.25718313455581665, 0.01778378151357174, 0.16241037845611572, 0.6717202663421631, 1.1367747783660889, 0.654966413974762, 0.41790178418159485, -0.32613834738731384, 0.4474039375782013, -0.86896151304245, 1.5284348726272583, 0.3159448504447937, 0.6002556085586548, -0.3603421449661255, -1.0449434518814087, -0.6362581849098206, -0.43265607953071594, 0.05485062673687935, 0.07875917106866837, -0.8425646424293518, 0.14115861058235168, -0.45059341192245483, 0.5193171501159668, -0.21242764592170715, -0.2534308135509491, -0.3616631031036377, -0.4710236191749573, -1.170096755027771, 0.02041149139404297, 0.2591218948364258, 0.5796822309494019, -0.8025306463241577, 0.6539272665977478, -0.50047767162323, 0.2916490435600281, 0.4577956795692444, -0.3077290654182434, 1.1246097087860107, -0.28685250878334045, -0.1688843071460724, 0.18090301752090454, 0.8920107483863831, 1.1093603372573853, 0.4685309827327728, -0.3373355269432068, 0.21754974126815796, 0.8211897611618042, 0.23734956979751587, 0.7049663066864014, 0.07624290883541107, 1.0485988855361938, 0.6482957005500793, 0.03687451034784317, 0.08347625285387039, -0.15992935001850128, 0.11161290109157562, -0.2181759625673294, -0.29979440569877625, 0.34902116656303406, -0.2619131803512573, 0.08169949799776077, 0.2465241700410843, -0.32710254192352295, -0.5499329566955566, 0.03672175854444504, -0.2900572717189789, 0.046420108526945114, -0.1352487951517105, 0.21408897638320923, -0.09221424162387848, 1.0121309757232666, -0.10160812735557556, 0.5320544242858887, 0.27735140919685364, 0.1385674625635147, -0.884610116481781, 0.759373664855957, 1.1205037832260132, -0.5205681920051575, -0.42847171425819397, 0.017762841656804085, 0.7496004700660706, 0.03269559517502785, -0.06577941030263901, -0.004143334459513426, -0.6640773415565491, 0.1718694269657135, -0.5993148684501648, -0.8250585198402405, 0.8380967974662781, 0.23882731795310974, 0.669603705406189, 0.01579643413424492, 0.37335488200187683, -0.02681010775268078, -0.17919041216373444, -0.46441081166267395, -0.6564270853996277, 0.06329886615276337, -0.35046908259391785, 0.9483779072761536, 0.45779576897621155, -0.12033027410507202, 0.08982017636299133, 0.0926167368888855, 0.38837435841560364, 0.24532204866409302, 0.47107982635498047, 0.3338600993156433, 0.002477675909176469, 0.6639886498451233, -0.619618833065033, 0.7448989748954773, -0.96966952085495, 0.40525177121162415, -0.050448521971702576, -0.37103956937789917, -0.21317382156848907, 0.09331229329109192, 0.3141075074672699, 0.7304751873016357, -0.582051157951355, -0.1949613094329834, 0.8959478139877319, 0.2843734622001648, -0.6464471817016602, -0.20767226815223694, -0.9805063605308533, 0.12962767481803894, -0.49454599618911743, 0.021527297794818878, 0.8930687308311462, 0.9304453730583191, -0.21311108767986298, 0.3082673251628876, 0.4084707200527191, 0.006788355298340321, -0.8716393709182739, -0.049332428723573685, -0.7767423987388611, -0.7578744292259216, -0.848785400390625, 0.4068438410758972, 0.5688624978065491, 0.60740727186203, 0.3681401014328003, 0.17430716753005981, -0.4018173813819885, 0.19714224338531494, 0.2815120816230774, 0.49209800362586975, 0.5420361161231995, -0.4803321659564972, -0.9811915159225464, 0.41233766078948975, 0.6699047088623047, 0.3538474142551422, -0.20847757160663605, -0.5044355392456055, -0.6346709728240967, -1.1238244771957397, 0.20911046862602234, -0.06588277220726013, -0.10812456160783768, 1.042150616645813, -0.0838596522808075, -0.234688863158226, 0.303755521774292, 0.20680734515190125, 0.11848647892475128, -0.26700928807258606, -0.8662065267562866, 0.5596354007720947, 0.44391068816185, 0.11902619898319244, 0.6675386428833008, 0.07917268574237823, -0.6256757378578186, 0.3591192364692688, -0.4589133560657501, 0.10393624752759933, -0.8747900724411011, -0.08303708583116531, 0.3555086553096771, 0.2337903380393982, 0.6991384625434875, -0.4930756986141205, -0.024249840527772903, 0.30523598194122314, -0.10356643050909042, -0.4662981331348419, -0.2312534600496292, 0.8286206722259521, 0.4847925305366516, -0.9493722319602966, -0.27062055468559265, -0.7713294625282288, -0.857397735118866, 0.27283337712287903, -0.10932794958353043, 0.3963935375213623, 0.3856946527957916, -0.48814576864242554, -0.06570656597614288, 0.3581963777542114, -0.4625556468963623, 0.09834769368171692, 0.162568137049675, -0.7050663828849792, 0.4948423504829407, 0.6175548434257507, -0.016171781346201897, -0.3122679591178894, 0.39138638973236084, -0.8659730553627014, -0.17879176139831543, 0.2573547661304474, -0.3947827219963074, -0.36767318844795227, 0.6284443140029907, 0.13593760132789612, -0.7664389610290527, 0.7205662727355957, -0.5500096678733826, -0.06037083640694618, 0.500826358795166, 0.29761800169944763, 0.1886114776134491, 0.5935972929000854, -0.7403164505958557, 0.3084717392921448, -0.6405192613601685, -1.2591925859451294, 0.5555034279823303, 0.8636875152587891, 0.866254448890686, -0.08590823411941528, 0.13138511776924133, 0.23848477005958557, -0.4335516095161438, 0.4305305480957031, -0.2646254003047943, 0.11417344212532043, 0.47414305806159973, 0.2937007248401642, 0.8327243328094482, -0.9620576500892639, 0.41014254093170166, 0.6220700144767761, 0.9867185950279236, 0.33437392115592957, 0.5256771445274353, 0.5026353597640991, -0.7314877510070801, -0.04927204176783562, 0.040324460715055466, -0.5415765047073364, -0.30721810460090637, 0.15118660032749176, 1.056090235710144, 0.476318359375, -0.7441237568855286, -0.20878702402114868, -0.004007989075034857, 0.42889147996902466, 0.7476374506950378, 0.163686603307724, 1.2431540489196777, -0.5157315135002136, 0.19667261838912964, 0.7863509058952332, -0.028551623225212097, 0.5896375179290771, -0.6583747267723083, -0.1629999727010727, -0.49839434027671814, -0.8629336953163147, -0.4730755090713501, -0.6432434320449829, -0.7067364454269409, 0.45994293689727783, 0.1125921905040741, -0.14860446751117706, -0.8870195746421814, -0.554071843624115, -0.20045579969882965, -0.3642160892486572, 0.8579868078231812, -0.20690549910068512, -0.5734969973564148, -0.626569390296936, -0.30438232421875, -1.051325798034668, -0.0056553068570792675, -0.33084702491760254, 0.7548111081123352, 0.5881192088127136, -0.876036524772644, -0.4702194333076477, -0.824056088924408, -0.13548286259174347, -0.7113611102104187, 0.14999893307685852, 0.012554824352264404, -0.2487667351961136, 0.35521194338798523, -0.6330130696296692, -0.21206460893154144, -0.32219693064689636, -0.5138757824897766, -0.5175067782402039, -0.011489900760352612, 0.571647584438324, 1.067716121673584, 0.765597403049469, 0.5084481239318848, 0.1987694352865219, 0.2039773017168045, -1.0763871669769287, 0.41230499744415283, -0.33910077810287476, -0.32527443766593933, -0.42497116327285767, -0.3062037229537964, 0.27097830176353455, -0.26835897564888, -0.1676735281944275, -0.6308956146240234, -0.015862412750720978, 0.10695245862007141, -0.35997679829597473, -0.0417453907430172, 0.893657922744751, -0.12726888060569763, -0.13011698424816132, 0.962675929069519, -0.2520453929901123, -0.6145864725112915, 0.4455084800720215, -0.277974933385849, -0.5441222786903381, -0.05230856314301491, 0.00535591458901763, -0.23256728053092957, 0.7660845518112183, -0.46430593729019165, -0.1958879977464676, 0.5026928186416626, 0.5536305904388428, 0.2401886284351349, 0.8799579739570618, -0.6825529336929321, -0.27530166506767273, 0.07138274610042572, -0.16708728671073914, -1.1728757619857788, -0.22865349054336548, -0.2071407586336136, -0.2403407096862793, -0.1618223786354065, 0.308303564786911, -0.6980476975440979, -0.5631637573242188, -0.5040419697761536, -0.020045241340994835, -0.40450742840766907, -0.1374635398387909, 0.7888410687446594, -0.7454586029052734, -0.783147394657135, -0.6444598436355591, 0.9993600845336914, -0.9544520378112793, -0.8897126317024231, 0.6839537024497986, -0.2141074240207672, 0.30111709237098694, -0.2528574764728546, 0.5989395380020142, -0.53031986951828, -0.6375946402549744, -0.27230849862098694, 0.4503210186958313, 0.5264672636985779, -0.016521040350198746, 0.18585990369319916, 0.10348009318113327, 0.2834499478340149, -0.5550839304924011, -0.06393501162528992, 0.19813652336597443, -0.22840511798858643, 0.8548693656921387, -0.38232216238975525, -1.087639570236206, 0.029080646112561226, -0.5374975204467773, 0.21951167285442352, -0.6685870885848999, 0.2585543990135193, 0.32900747656822205, -0.19621418416500092, 0.12434027343988419, 0.2718392610549927, 0.31894949078559875, 0.4994722008705139, -0.30474430322647095, -0.5000659823417664, 0.12692739069461823, 0.1946350485086441, -0.31177496910095215, 0.03422052785754204, -1.1584913730621338, 0.3053618371486664, 0.40949302911758423, 0.033912088721990585, -0.32032331824302673, -0.6773956418037415, 0.2276478111743927, 1.1726969480514526, -0.41196706891059875, -0.3880656063556671, -0.27776286005973816, 0.2538350820541382, 0.6426841020584106, -0.8212112188339233, -0.696493923664093, -1.0495636463165283, 1.1525921821594238, -0.20378024876117706, 0.3840963542461395, -0.0784258097410202, -0.33669328689575195, 0.028743578121066093, -0.5395660996437073, 1.5066765546798706, -0.005245397798717022, 1.0070135593414307, -0.09371566027402878, -0.10870879143476486, 0.16878031194210052, 0.09760265797376633, -0.5020236968994141, -1.1169880628585815, -0.5732203125953674, -0.6732931733131409, 0.3915477395057678, -0.2985059320926666, -0.2267664670944214, 0.4388081729412079, -0.09343408793210983, -0.8503767848014832, 0.07313420623540878, 1.3535494804382324, 0.8905192613601685, -1.0736280679702759, -0.47699230909347534, 0.2222324162721634, 0.5191007852554321, 0.38924500346183777, 0.3433343768119812, 0.031683437526226044, -0.1905413120985031, 0.5003159046173096, 0.14078299701213837, -0.5680990815162659, -0.1757487654685974, 0.014423518441617489, -0.7349696755409241, 0.8053693771362305, -0.3078072965145111, -0.024050524458289146, -0.16067610681056976, 0.11140753328800201, -0.563581645488739, 0.6037368774414062, 0.2815154194831848, 0.5586761832237244, 0.8108470439910889, -0.40691158175468445, 0.12229476124048233, 0.4113435745239258, -0.5200116634368896, 0.15974727272987366, -0.14423102140426636, 0.5199400186538696, 0.622841477394104, -1.1800346374511719, 0.8877120614051819, 0.02782128006219864, -0.49819886684417725, -0.8470878601074219, -0.052673015743494034, 0.12085585296154022, 0.013781186193227768, 0.11011261492967606, -0.8226034641265869, 0.33764883875846863, -0.02852446958422661, 0.35203737020492554, -0.42950350046157837, 0.2607261836528778, 0.20475241541862488, -0.8630748391151428, 0.6534047722816467, -0.7955783605575562, -0.22305455803871155, 1.082385778427124, -0.3548951745033264, 0.06885439902544022, 0.8922765254974365, 0.23730653524398804, 0.8215019702911377, 0.3138956129550934, 0.7003008127212524, -0.7216402888298035, -0.043263990432024, -0.4897460341453552, 0.0903271809220314, 0.41974809765815735, 0.5847488641738892, -0.7131070494651794, 1.051085114479065, 0.1912699192762375, -0.8902607560157776, 0.06180906668305397, 0.3125098645687103, 0.20647256076335907, 0.2627476155757904, -0.17476432025432587, -0.04591752961277962, 0.7370489835739136, 0.17268329858779907, 0.1693001240491867, -0.3922485411167145, -0.37822192907333374, -0.7224617600440979, -0.0072786142118275166, -0.4980393350124359, -0.701556921005249, 0.09697947651147842, 0.011277219280600548, -0.24128708243370056, -1.0451358556747437, -0.559218168258667, 0.534946084022522, -0.44505953788757324, -0.6186231970787048, -0.021608006209135056, 0.4333544671535492, -0.40127402544021606, -0.8490694165229797, -0.7031565308570862, 0.12971948087215424, -0.6558091640472412, 0.9168382883071899, -0.6924630403518677, -0.2736150920391083, 0.4740460216999054, 0.08085211366415024, 0.02936669811606407, 0.42804184556007385, 0.0638347864151001, -0.8372839093208313, 0.0173333752900362, 0.7206764221191406, 0.5041086673736572, -0.3086002767086029, 1.4049501419067383, -0.482724666595459, 0.5520188212394714, 0.26608413457870483, 0.2772475779056549, 0.07275450229644775, -0.44327837228775024, -0.07277902215719223, -0.8432305455207825, -0.2865152657032013, -0.3100265860557556, 0.014038469642400742, -1.3378112316131592, 0.035735610872507095, -0.7154871821403503, -0.6066370010375977, -0.20558293163776398, 0.17282339930534363, 0.15214349329471588, 0.5157725811004639, -0.3593055009841919, 0.43837738037109375, -0.07749371230602264, 0.9546384811401367, 0.2901093363761902, -0.5105589628219604, 0.19506008923053741, 0.8638055920600891, 0.22227045893669128, -0.2054821103811264, 0.1696731448173523, 1.0922472476959229, -0.6611146330833435, 0.7233926653862, -0.32830217480659485, 0.7525771260261536, 0.5057942867279053, -0.6548888683319092, 0.4351522922515869, 0.7417728304862976, 0.09767846763134003, 0.5537549257278442, 0.6004372239112854, -0.21044760942459106, -0.6175960302352905, -0.7137159705162048, -1.0588380098342896, -0.5695604681968689, 0.26344695687294006, -1.0217773914337158, -0.4141674041748047, -1.1941337585449219, -0.9300293922424316, 0.6830728650093079, 0.2947511672973633, 0.14153586328029633, -0.3411661386489868, 0.5744064450263977, 0.05887584015727043, 0.46131378412246704, -0.2371288686990738, 0.017330966889858246, 0.10946648567914963, 0.14142638444900513, -0.7347013354301453, -0.6476033926010132, -0.03278951346874237, 0.1729544848203659, 0.31573009490966797, -0.29459354281425476, -1.0301854610443115, 0.48108285665512085, 0.3715866506099701, -0.6760295629501343, 0.008443891070783138, -0.1984761655330658, -0.026874108240008354, 0.014446299523115158, 0.06326229870319366, 0.27307602763175964, -0.47272029519081116, 0.03727204352617264, 0.05660353973507881, -1.0795807838439941, -0.6078394055366516, 0.1323060244321823, 0.5675612092018127, -0.028023943305015564, 0.18501651287078857, -0.5229623317718506, 0.33865004777908325, 0.4365798830986023, -0.8454442620277405, 0.689670741558075, 0.8956009149551392, -0.2584664225578308, 0.34312963485717773, 0.3988267183303833, 0.08935375511646271, 0.7750158309936523, 0.5247176885604858, -0.6196042895317078, 0.4764899015426636, -0.036996278911828995, -0.02734392322599888, 0.3286058008670807, -0.8224816918373108, 0.16769424080848694, 0.2255963236093521, -0.49508586525917053, 0.19660599529743195, 0.08952804654836655, 0.524221658706665, 0.10113227367401123, -0.06505972892045975, 0.37776339054107666, -1.2874970436096191, 0.19195044040679932, -0.17738281190395355, -0.005719395354390144, 0.34117037057876587, 0.021232880651950836, -0.15144895017147064, -0.29477739334106445, 0.9737468957901001, -0.17449429631233215, -0.48484891653060913, 0.062122851610183716, -0.7385154962539673, -0.3238893151283264, -0.21140630543231964, 0.1901395171880722, -0.2571384906768799, -0.007114292588084936, 0.34385818243026733, 0.1109534502029419, -0.327747106552124, -0.15688085556030273, -0.14045734703540802, -0.04724467545747757, 1.4302153587341309, -0.03970944508910179, -0.27485254406929016, 0.20141270756721497, 0.44708141684532166, -0.41433051228523254, 0.06178993359208107, 0.9425904154777527, -0.542050302028656, 0.08526911586523056, -0.44317761063575745, 1.1365007162094116, 0.16752316057682037, -0.22972650825977325, 0.4133552312850952, 0.0687643438577652, -0.5097697377204895, -0.027839120477437973, -0.22078759968280792, -0.44203293323516846, 0.05854099243879318, 0.25355997681617737, -0.651826024055481, -0.17522910237312317, -0.14343072474002838, -0.6715585589408875, -0.305844783782959, -0.66698157787323, 0.7692897915840149, -0.12632913887500763, -0.46190446615219116, -0.7737846374511719, -0.39704838395118713, -0.6043422818183899, -0.21399496495723724, -0.20585878193378448, 0.3510132431983948, 0.4889970123767853, -0.4781070053577423, -0.4124731421470642, -0.6532154083251953, -0.03625626116991043, -0.15328259766101837, -0.6088576316833496, 0.36333316564559937, 0.12955766916275024, 0.2578469514846802, -0.9372634291648865, -1.395735263824463, 0.17092476785182953, -0.2737884521484375, 0.02127406746149063, -0.22966960072517395, 0.1590944528579712, 0.1986628621816635, 0.9735665321350098, -0.1408555954694748, 0.7998720407485962, 0.027584655210375786, 0.09412496536970139, 0.3975463807582855, -0.8177462816238403, 0.6927350759506226, -0.6061581969261169, -0.8707432150840759, 0.2817273437976837, -0.3410649001598358, -0.33963730931282043, -0.01781475357711315, -0.6604891419410706, 0.0648019090294838, 0.38608694076538086, 0.28136229515075684, -0.5826912522315979, 0.3160924017429352, 0.5499688982963562, -0.48951929807662964, -0.2936464548110962, -0.35105717182159424, 0.528364896774292, -0.859697163105011, 0.4110565781593323, 0.05038735643029213, 0.15676556527614594, 0.12634409964084625, 0.4991057515144348, 1.0402709245681763, -1.1272534132003784, 3.9688873291015625, 0.8624140620231628, 0.6914918422698975, -0.2522803843021393, 0.2829684615135193, -0.020244769752025604, 0.4205455780029297, 0.25284746289253235, 0.23365597426891327, -0.10850057005882263, -0.12622730433940887, 0.11337345093488693, 0.5792374014854431, -0.05600970983505249, 0.6574021577835083, 0.4345901608467102, -0.30369529128074646, 0.5747780203819275, -0.22935238480567932, -1.079245686531067, -0.5825946927070618, -0.28891050815582275, -0.5076082348823547, 0.5421692132949829, 0.6538076996803284, -0.12355303019285202, 0.8175122737884521, -0.09368260949850082, 0.6143016815185547, -0.38609012961387634, 0.3711881935596466, -0.24929119646549225, 0.12290609627962112, -1.2195875644683838, -0.4331453740596771, 0.4864693582057953, 0.6417859792709351, -0.9943755269050598, 0.5440340042114258, -0.12408279627561569, 0.12913033366203308, -0.683966875076294, -0.16364338994026184, -0.08014418184757233, -0.6745052933692932, 0.8115094304084778, -0.9160801768302917, -0.10471765697002411, 0.06739960610866547, 0.0011927076848223805, 0.3110485374927521, -0.33714520931243896, 0.2267654538154602, -0.23089911043643951, -0.6431763172149658, -0.3658473491668701, -0.47210371494293213, -1.1178905963897705, 0.49280306696891785, 0.6392254829406738, 1.5800199508666992, -0.12319071590900421, -0.1006307452917099, -0.07614567130804062, 0.3225594758987427, 0.5435832142829895, 0.33160400390625, 0.7215230464935303, 0.040591899305582047, -0.36131569743156433, -0.07526905834674835, -0.8243918418884277, 0.14909029006958008, -0.09390075504779816, 0.7993163466453552, 0.25376424193382263, -0.563839852809906, 0.7475840449333191, 0.07595880329608917, -0.5542382001876831, 0.04516250267624855, -0.12377055734395981, 0.6660683155059814, 0.19008514285087585, 0.05804857984185219, 0.884832501411438, -0.258626252412796, -0.4018826484680176, -0.6195827126502991, 0.4489704966545105, 1.1596710681915283, -0.38990914821624756, -0.07077301293611526, 0.5667413473129272, -0.3197239637374878 ]
{"Title": "Treatment advantage in HBV/HIV coinfection compared to HBV monoinfection in a South African cohort", "Authors": "Maponga Tongai G, McNaughton Anna L, Van Schalkwyk Marije, Hugo Susan, Nwankwo Chikezie, Taljaard Jantjie, Mokaya Jolynne, Smith David A, van Vuuren Cloete, Goedhals Dominique, Gabriel Shiraaz, Andersson Monique I, Preiser Wolfgang, van Rensburg Christo, Matthews Philippa C", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective Prompted by international targets for elimination of hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection, we performed a cross-sectional observational study of adults with chronic HBV (CHB) infection in South Africa, characterising individuals with HBV monoinfection vs. those coinfected with HBV/HIV, to evaluate the impact of therapy and to guide improvements in clinical care as guidelines for antiviral therapy change over time. Design We prospectively recruited 115 adults with CHB, over a period of one year at a university hospital in Cape Town, South Africa. HIV coinfection was present in 39 (34%) subjects. We recorded cross-sectional demographic, clinical and laboratory data. Results Adults with HBV monoinfection were comparable to those with HBV/HIV coinfection in terms of age, sex and body mass. HBeAg-positive status was more common among those with HIV coinfection (p=0.01). However, compared to HBV/HIV coinfection, HBV monoinfected patients were less likely to have had assessment with elastography (p<0.0001) and less likely to be on antiviral treatment (p<0.0001). The HBV monoinfected group was more likely to have detectable HBV viraemia (p=0.04), and features suggesting underlying liver disease including moderate/severe thrombocytopaenia (p=0.007), elevated bilirubin (p=0.004), and APRI score >2 (p=0.02). Three cases of hepatocellular carcinoma were documented, all in patients with HBV monoinfection. Conclusion In this setting, individuals with HBV monoinfection are disadvantaged in terms of clinical assessment and appropriate antiviral therapy compared to those with HIV coinfection, associated with relatively worse liver health. Enhanced advocacy, education, resources and infrastructure are required to optimise interventions for CHB.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007963"}
10.1101/19004267
[ 0.26109129190444946, 0.3260417878627777, -0.17462292313575745, 0.10184773057699203, -0.7483908534049988, -0.4195447266101837, -0.12425548583269119, 0.6879305243492126, 0.2504998743534088, 0.4951201379299164, 0.2873893678188324, -1.1133064031600952, 0.5612053871154785, 0.07340050488710403, 0.31642478704452515, 0.3419555425643921, -0.3207103908061981, -0.30714136362075806, -0.27644824981689453, 0.6346181035041809, -0.23126262426376343, 0.17861232161521912, -0.27521318197250366, -0.06207271292805672, -0.26072752475738525, 0.262825608253479, 0.2395884096622467, -0.3581096827983856, 0.599287748336792, 1.039214849472046, 0.016981659457087517, -0.5227063298225403, 0.6219838261604309, -0.1020367220044136, 0.2574576735496521, -0.2502594590187073, 0.5932146310806274, -1.0291459560394287, -0.16270335018634796, -0.3110092878341675, 0.04586480185389519, -0.5223625302314758, 0.8386303186416626, -0.31002509593963623, -0.634811282157898, -0.3739584982395172, -0.12081597000360489, -0.37846893072128296, 0.2496982365846634, 0.11714638024568558, -0.23648613691329956, 0.4478759467601776, 0.6734209060668945, -0.8101451992988586, 0.19421689212322235, 0.5285382270812988, 0.161514550447464, 0.320405513048172, -0.3337411880493164, 0.14402921497821808, -0.02114098146557808, -0.674345850944519, -0.020489033311605453, -1.378009557723999, 0.8965479731559753, 0.38010871410369873, -0.1029534637928009, -0.10882706940174103, 0.17947477102279663, 0.27598243951797485, -0.6868846416473389, -0.1513003408908844, -0.2879560589790344, -0.24858377873897552, -0.3033858835697174, -0.18298745155334473, 0.7290542721748352, 0.3259859085083008, -0.33783939480781555, -0.5261841416358948, -0.14446048438549042, -0.08297192305326462, 0.4356886148452759, -0.1797768771648407, -0.8496787548065186, 0.24037156999111176, 0.2661365568637848, 0.24538780748844147, 0.3871787190437317, 0.7095154523849487, -0.09844815731048584, -0.4263463616371155, -0.21177011728286743, -0.5796926617622375, -0.30761170387268066, 0.8450714349746704, -0.7622191905975342, 0.2104838341474533, 0.0026823077350854874, -0.12738583981990814, 0.6021743416786194, 0.6397956013679504, -0.5957314372062683, 0.2079046666622162, -0.5276837944984436, 1.1008130311965942, 0.7090897560119629, -0.6220320463180542, -0.05480087548494339, -0.741016685962677, 0.31259843707084656, 0.3605537414550781, -0.6930029988288879, 0.26183268427848816, 1.1314384937286377, 0.49060502648353577, -0.24436143040657043, 1.256630539894104, -0.65131676197052, 0.378793865442276, -0.17200054228305817, -0.3335380554199219, 0.8396751284599304, -0.5945356488227844, 0.16933594644069672, 0.5182213187217712, 0.4284062683582306, 0.6043019890785217, -0.9150381088256836, -0.4079585075378418, 0.29928719997406006, -0.21253621578216553, 0.002476045163348317, 0.6189832091331482, -0.4624822735786438, 0.26851123571395874, -0.26627683639526367, 0.37999552488327026, 0.7972291707992554, -0.26053860783576965, -0.38640478253364563, 0.19202016294002533, -0.37338435649871826, 0.8811213374137878, 0.06811923533678055, 0.4802333116531372, -0.5561224818229675, -1.7005571126937866, -0.33561745285987854, -0.09422622621059418, -0.28651729226112366, 0.8410138487815857, -0.2949047386646271, -0.6800129413604736, -0.5699408054351807, 0.3800874352455139, -0.12308435142040253, 0.5850430130958557, 0.213374063372612, -0.21642382442951202, -0.5694078207015991, 0.1032244861125946, 0.1748894304037094, 1.2102572917938232, -0.6219077110290527, 0.836012601852417, -0.38706979155540466, 0.3231707215309143, 0.411074697971344, -0.6815122365951538, 1.411931037902832, -0.08497308939695358, -0.2640215754508972, -0.36101290583610535, 0.5616028308868408, 0.4696689546108246, 1.352972388267517, 0.08246125280857086, -0.22396476566791534, 0.9100554585456848, -0.5769307613372803, 0.2890219986438751, 0.29189184308052063, 0.5093293786048889, -0.30861443281173706, 0.11465375125408173, -0.16324259340763092, -0.8419634103775024, -0.08672112226486206, -0.06892295181751251, -0.08102232217788696, 0.04581569507718086, -0.5241477489471436, 0.5543084144592285, -0.049232371151447296, -0.35775119066238403, -0.6002068519592285, 0.8126617670059204, 0.5308225750923157, 0.11087389290332794, -0.9408509135246277, 0.3825598657131195, 0.2203225940465927, 0.17711852490901947, -0.18941235542297363, 0.8888115286827087, 0.08745720982551575, 0.32873550057411194, -0.5849909782409668, -0.22487322986125946, 0.8283923268318176, 0.15660449862480164, -0.31034836173057556, -0.6502715349197388, 0.45263493061065674, 0.19963540136814117, -0.487143337726593, 0.05801403149962425, 0.01904718019068241, 0.3528900742530823, -0.12729553878307343, -0.047552689909935, 0.3712570369243622, 0.5840022563934326, 0.11096536368131638, -0.047010116279125214, 0.5765277147293091, -0.44529667496681213, -0.4505808353424072, -0.48027995228767395, 0.11980020999908447, 0.4019976556301117, 0.06742068380117416, 0.3584993779659271, 0.6823652982711792, 1.0466128587722778, -0.12327639013528824, 0.04645735025405884, -0.10083843767642975, 0.38774818181991577, 0.02604963257908821, 0.4992392957210541, 0.642632246017456, 0.20943307876586914, -0.5739437937736511, 0.6800649762153625, 0.2565734088420868, 0.06184849515557289, -0.10843132436275482, 0.33892691135406494, -0.20499394834041595, 0.8434174656867981, 0.20752175152301788, -0.24882785975933075, -1.0912481546401978, 0.011127561330795288, 0.4150863587856293, -0.30585628747940063, -0.4544905722141266, -0.547548770904541, -0.4832894206047058, 1.06013023853302, -0.6486232280731201, -0.37149307131767273, 1.0487490892410278, 0.6798387169837952, -0.1759786754846573, 0.11460801959037781, -0.09682175517082214, -0.45141908526420593, -0.7439175248146057, -0.44371435046195984, -1.065270185470581, -0.6666893362998962, -0.7982720732688904, -0.4617065191268921, 0.478291392326355, -0.6467787623405457, 0.24929179251194, -0.7088649868965149, 0.016723133623600006, 0.10102388262748718, -0.33785104751586914, 0.568865954875946, -0.40418097376823425, 0.025078006088733673, -0.8916486501693726, -0.28349295258522034, 0.5298579335212708, 0.17106784880161285, 0.26557162404060364, -0.22924688458442688, -0.23785623908042908, -0.4819081425666809, 0.3860573172569275, -1.3677793741226196, 0.9794178605079651, -0.2555144429206848, -0.009812172502279282, -0.576763391494751, 0.6817302703857422, 0.15406391024589539, 0.17500588297843933, 0.40555745363235474, -0.40082472562789917, -0.09968066960573196, 0.20244044065475464, 0.11516711115837097, 0.8270866870880127, -0.15224260091781616, -0.12903228402137756, 0.1982526332139969, 0.1421017199754715, 0.35175827145576477, -0.8759203553199768, -0.14590241014957428, 0.2956952452659607, 0.4714377224445343, 0.2098591923713684, -1.1136283874511719, -0.7882315516471863, -0.17477655410766602, -0.35434404015541077, -0.1590273082256317, -0.16745704412460327, 0.731454074382782, 0.9807646870613098, -1.3483705520629883, 0.6510505676269531, 0.11016520857810974, -1.529698371887207, -0.14027278125286102, -0.18050172924995422, 0.034686747938394547, 0.1510850489139557, -0.6738762259483337, -0.2819845974445343, 0.01777762547135353, 0.0023504947312176228, 0.5289742946624756, 0.2916469871997833, -0.8222701549530029, 0.3635973036289215, -0.03998439013957977, -0.21955321729183197, 0.23548439145088196, 0.17712384462356567, -0.19116322696208954, -0.2605625092983246, -0.40681061148643494, -0.08390174806118011, 0.7642808556556702, 0.34600403904914856, 0.25470051169395447, -0.2700151801109314, 0.8009768724441528, 0.0025023247580975294, -0.026964718475937843, 0.016903745010495186, 0.42130398750305176, -0.01196022517979145, 0.16862304508686066, -0.07418311387300491, 0.3697262704372406, -0.42036086320877075, -0.7717099189758301, 0.036945924162864685, 0.09616940468549728, 0.5989716649055481, 0.06952881067991257, 0.9304799437522888, -0.07283315807580948, -0.21348465979099274, -0.4117562472820282, -0.01782533898949623, 0.13591693341732025, 0.9421935677528381, 0.616460919380188, 0.5494600534439087, -0.1488429307937622, 0.1882571578025818, -0.16915759444236755, 0.6622314453125, -0.08342501521110535, -0.4558384418487549, 1.0207513570785522, -0.9830804467201233, 0.3949138820171356, 0.08636429160833359, -0.6253040432929993, -0.10950388014316559, -0.03641815111041069, 0.6436060070991516, 0.08681036531925201, -0.4927443265914917, 0.0524742491543293, -0.030394643545150757, 0.1739325374364853, -0.2306448519229889, 0.08568621426820755, 0.7291558980941772, -0.12993310391902924, 0.6523980498313904, 0.023472975939512253, -0.006643409840762615, -0.11559787392616272, -0.4332873225212097, 0.17637348175048828, -0.23978213965892792, -0.21154260635375977, -0.700358510017395, -0.15296028554439545, -0.18689143657684326, -0.10147430002689362, 0.04822366684675217, -0.1580982655286789, -0.5972029566764832, -0.23945440351963043, -0.7947887182235718, -0.7038522362709045, 0.3099074363708496, -0.571597695350647, -0.4581173062324524, 0.14507359266281128, -0.2135523408651352, -0.5885744690895081, -0.35940778255462646, -0.08347705006599426, 0.13243263959884644, 0.7547030448913574, -0.27674561738967896, -0.4246346354484558, -0.23512782156467438, -0.491456538438797, -0.48113974928855896, 0.41092708706855774, -0.24129575490951538, 0.3491651117801666, 0.3921806216239929, -0.46873342990875244, -0.8171989917755127, -0.48078739643096924, -0.010319875553250313, 0.2872951328754425, 0.14852747321128845, 0.3701425790786743, 1.118874430656433, -0.08439499139785767, 0.5034341812133789, -0.3387298285961151, 1.0072351694107056, -0.4390767812728882, 0.5480157136917114, -0.07160802185535431, -1.1467556953430176, -0.17656460404396057, 0.3374866545200348, -0.44286832213401794, -0.11271829903125763, -0.026294544339179993, -0.2776618003845215, -0.2544940710067749, 0.1711249202489853, -0.4501896798610687, -0.3260096311569214, 0.5532916784286499, -0.9983189702033997, -0.13766731321811676, 1.8290244340896606, -0.7746213674545288, 0.16816191375255585, -0.1229235976934433, -0.022628262639045715, -0.20229342579841614, 0.4498926103115082, 0.05677960813045502, -0.03974836692214012, 0.9750787019729614, -0.2437548190355301, -0.13324972987174988, -0.3708885908126831, 0.17929120361804962, -0.08032113313674927, 0.44411706924438477, -0.4027290940284729, -0.5032864809036255, -0.3242233991622925, -0.3709389269351959, -0.03187037259340286, -0.010768814943730831, -0.3300810158252716, -0.3056647479534149, -0.5392217636108398, -0.4215066730976105, -0.8221197724342346, -0.12099820375442505, -0.00866860430687666, -0.23444992303848267, -0.5960522890090942, 0.1982794553041458, 0.33747661113739014, -0.7015044689178467, -0.06622802466154099, 0.565955638885498, 0.13640989363193512, -1.3019156455993652, -0.029291879385709763, -0.2370418906211853, 0.15473338961601257, -0.07087748497724533, -0.7342144846916199, -0.012205950915813446, -0.798727810382843, -0.07852272689342499, 0.29131972789764404, 0.19246797263622284, 0.6178127527236938, 0.2590092122554779, -0.4291359484195709, 0.6535454392433167, 0.01283321063965559, -0.6964709758758545, -0.729802131652832, 0.3010273575782776, -0.6090744137763977, 0.06179574504494667, 0.10133770108222961, -0.5555347800254822, -0.7755253911018372, -1.1377205848693848, 0.2550685703754425, -0.2763097584247589, -0.04455995932221413, -0.20192107558250427, -0.41374385356903076, -0.019621314480900764, 0.5873890519142151, 0.5819118022918701, -0.1428784430027008, 0.34345561265945435, -0.9158206582069397, 0.1021227091550827, -0.38781943917274475, 0.4844163656234741, -0.10464402288198471, -0.7261444926261902, 0.03126093000173569, 0.6947417259216309, 0.3665926158428192, -0.2582068145275116, -0.600415050983429, 0.27902933955192566, 0.6255403757095337, 0.7982463240623474, -0.17153650522232056, -0.5630434155464172, 0.031840212643146515, 0.2694908678531647, 0.19359047710895538, -0.3002852499485016, -1.119903802871704, 0.8997325301170349, -0.9332610964775085, 0.15114860236644745, 0.4195263385772705, -0.004407872911542654, 0.287318617105484, -0.6962812542915344, 0.9012435078620911, -0.5946906805038452, -0.4107303023338318, 0.42872098088264465, -0.20256124436855316, 0.23136334121227264, 0.06305278092622757, -0.16206328570842743, -0.04257679358124733, -0.3010713458061218, -0.911086916923523, 0.008878631517291069, 0.43425998091697693, -0.047171276062726974, -0.11140549927949905, -0.24449266493320465, 0.11046596616506577, -0.08364198356866837, 1.2449548244476318, 1.0949878692626953, -0.4231388568878174, -0.3475746214389801, -0.08475854992866516, 0.6204946637153625, 0.7803570628166199, 0.18505632877349854, 0.43810057640075684, -0.8775409460067749, 0.4037753641605377, -1.0180046558380127, -0.6349196434020996, -1.0971115827560425, -0.32309257984161377, 0.22796176373958588, 0.9893099665641785, 0.1791185885667801, -0.11775102466344833, -0.16407160460948944, 0.12259234488010406, -0.11141958087682724, 1.1636344194412231, -0.01049381960183382, 0.2798350751399994, 0.6466930508613586, -0.1653444468975067, -1.0402681827545166, 0.8790645003318787, -0.31097573041915894, 0.006489248014986515, -0.32022520899772644, 0.42221003770828247, -0.1319606900215149, -0.9129915833473206, 0.9345104098320007, 0.22895857691764832, -0.6562727689743042, -0.22901831567287445, 0.19130995869636536, -0.0066173323430120945, 0.08685339242219925, 0.11030474305152893, -0.6668573617935181, 0.7137397527694702, -0.3704834580421448, 0.6904218196868896, -0.3662826716899872, -0.3149538040161133, 0.10023398697376251, -0.9232014417648315, 0.47310617566108704, -0.13609471917152405, -0.4646705985069275, 0.6211476922035217, -0.45027026534080505, 0.400337278842926, 0.3040212392807007, -0.30335384607315063, -0.2065703123807907, 0.24976381659507751, -0.38009166717529297, -0.5876094698905945, -0.1903882473707199, 0.0004891235148534179, -0.3090859651565552, -0.12956751883029938, -0.08799702674150467, -0.5646902918815613, 0.7105545401573181, 0.16396959125995636, -0.3978690803050995, -0.6642319560050964, 0.3847009241580963, 0.299222856760025, 0.004159826319664717, 0.6199683547019958, -0.3083793818950653, 0.3529355823993683, -0.18074408173561096, -0.13856364786624908, 0.013680918142199516, -0.5626946687698364, -0.6986597180366516, -0.5094028115272522, -0.24932165443897247, -0.7041282653808594, -0.029503600671887398, 0.8074163198471069, -0.6840177774429321, -0.1651396006345749, -0.2618224024772644, 1.0373839139938354, -0.5648393630981445, 0.14645560085773468, -0.06029092147946358, 0.19483691453933716, -0.8421270847320557, -0.9192463159561157, -0.5780032277107239, -0.7416882514953613, -0.39614138007164, 1.2118184566497803, -0.7226143479347229, -0.17532652616500854, 0.46923118829727173, -0.23314327001571655, -0.24385029077529907, 0.1285296380519867, -0.11487822234630585, -0.679507315158844, -0.3659261465072632, 0.49800482392311096, 0.059816788882017136, -0.00478140776976943, 0.5157475471496582, -0.8768948912620544, 0.7123174071311951, 0.43148019909858704, 0.21938546001911163, 0.11490634083747864, 0.40145495533943176, 0.911551296710968, -0.801647424697876, -0.37791696190834045, -0.7762752175331116, -0.5099957585334778, -0.9303770065307617, -0.13713356852531433, -0.23415541648864746, 0.15706734359264374, -0.2328944206237793, 0.2719951570034027, -0.33069729804992676, 0.5525763034820557, 0.07120727002620697, 0.3766345679759979, 0.29295504093170166, 0.48034346103668213, 0.1820443868637085, 0.4074549973011017, 0.4458693861961365, 0.6362648010253906, 1.042480230331421, -1.0914067029953003, 0.1819147914648056, 0.19413983821868896, 0.0493510439991951, -0.032670844346284866, 0.32647982239723206, 0.9240943193435669, -0.43621960282325745, -0.40419459342956543, -0.4488964378833771, 1.5077035427093506, 0.9118562340736389, 0.5081961750984192, -0.0530998520553112, 0.010508924722671509, -0.8627802729606628, -1.304816484451294, -0.5966811776161194, -0.034229785203933716, 0.4410032033920288, -0.01782725192606449, -0.21477511525154114, -0.10562239587306976, -0.35682499408721924, 0.5983625054359436, 0.33591970801353455, 0.20077656209468842, 0.031018000096082687, 0.24631185829639435, 0.34244635701179504, 0.6050224900245667, 0.18499623239040375, 0.2451486885547638, 0.21171370148658752, -0.09993455559015274, -0.26475557684898376, -0.5011715888977051, 0.46898698806762695, 0.12076633423566818, 0.4654202163219452, -0.25104326009750366, -0.08865570276975632, 0.43889787793159485, 0.14185848832130432, -0.047859661281108856, -0.003641609800979495, 0.09533046931028366, -1.1159693002700806, 0.11928798258304596, 0.3187514841556549, -0.23455961048603058, -0.8279015421867371, -0.11769386380910873, -0.1722266674041748, -0.7513531446456909, -0.5315665602684021, 0.2233511507511139, 0.7160532474517822, -0.334634006023407, 0.24979643523693085, 0.19789227843284607, 0.4873086214065552, -0.5057497620582581, -0.38331320881843567, 0.5098096132278442, 0.5613977909088135, -0.15915831923484802, 0.31746721267700195, 0.5611355304718018, -0.1771647036075592, 0.9665781259536743, 0.23773889243602753, 0.18535815179347992, 0.025238169357180595, 0.5220469832420349, -0.5851399302482605, 0.3714757561683655, 0.047553226351737976, 0.5447523593902588, 0.11871715635061264, -0.47715410590171814, 0.4030137062072754, 0.9446114301681519, 0.696237325668335, -0.5595276951789856, -0.30120813846588135, -0.19704794883728027, -1.349493384361267, -0.36299270391464233, 0.13523544371128082, -0.08414510637521744, 0.7581966519355774, 0.47228023409843445, 0.2982999384403229, 0.08983209729194641, 0.9681522250175476, -0.2729454040527344, 0.3705112040042877, 0.4101400375366211, -0.3446178734302521, -0.7206422090530396, -0.4696168303489685, 0.14650876820087433, 0.10602450370788574, 0.0961947962641716, 0.7519062161445618, 0.25368374586105347, 0.6096710562705994, 0.32131659984588623, -0.5198884010314941, 0.05673624947667122, 0.856678307056427, -0.13282433152198792, -0.1349533349275589, -0.4922918677330017, 0.4176575839519501, -0.2487855702638626, -0.20681822299957275, 0.41047847270965576, -0.5984575748443604, 0.09227285534143448, 0.12170387804508209, 0.5490500330924988, 0.6246559023857117, 0.02280094474554062, 0.6804528832435608, -0.7347684502601624, -0.3156443238258362, 0.43792206048965454, 0.0389680489897728, -0.14904126524925232, -0.051202427595853806, -0.19914411008358002, -0.7205400466918945, 0.2796182632446289, 0.4161703586578369, 0.288819819688797, 0.005690115503966808, -0.5953316688537598, 0.008135867305099964, -0.1098819151520729, 0.2958679795265198, -0.29391220211982727, -0.55445796251297, -0.47929105162620544, 0.02511581778526306, -0.6990864276885986, 0.04310660809278488, 0.41307222843170166, 0.025600358843803406, -0.5086580514907837, -0.09007521718740463, -0.8781622648239136, -0.38273364305496216, -0.3522682189941406, 0.5899204015731812, -0.06105753406882286, 0.3435463607311249, -0.19359517097473145, -0.653971791267395, 0.5816858410835266, -0.2627076506614685, -0.24623987078666687, -1.3969982862472534, 0.45832765102386475, -0.10355052351951599, 0.72100430727005, 0.7144314646720886, 0.30916669964790344, 0.11801724135875702, -0.11925580352544785, 0.41058817505836487, 0.4602494239807129, -0.19977620244026184, 0.10611122101545334, 0.1220313161611557, 0.340181440114975, 0.03329228237271309, -0.22087685763835907, -0.2793957591056824, -0.3932318091392517, -0.21911580860614777, 0.6735185384750366, -0.1001305878162384, -0.9086440205574036, 0.6343691945075989, 0.7924463748931885, 0.3229827880859375, 0.04105927795171738, -0.0306682288646698, -0.4017736613750458, -0.3998557925224304, 0.7094662189483643, -0.47875168919563293, -0.6687608361244202, 0.6382428407669067, 0.09872783720493317, 0.292257159948349, -0.42409205436706543, 4.273014068603516, 1.0368458032608032, 0.44863107800483704, -0.3168528079986572, 0.7191004753112793, -0.3386895954608917, 0.5156155228614807, 0.020034214481711388, 0.02397833950817585, -0.00823846086859703, -0.6484969854354858, 0.27053365111351013, 0.16037286818027496, 0.08532059192657471, 0.3133552074432373, 0.09639973938465118, -0.9506698846817017, 0.26324450969696045, 0.5320672988891602, -0.8469879627227783, -0.5337879061698914, -0.1844927817583084, -0.6908830404281616, -0.007379031274467707, 0.4000237286090851, -0.35962527990341187, 0.08783287554979324, -0.22022569179534912, 0.07257730513811111, 0.031158333644270897, 0.16784311830997467, -0.46910759806632996, 0.2538100779056549, -1.0793654918670654, -0.5053649544715881, 0.6964391469955444, -0.32232221961021423, -0.5953194499015808, -0.12340976297855377, -0.2818869352340698, 0.14056791365146637, 0.6318426728248596, -0.5404717922210693, -0.08885141462087631, 0.20269176363945007, 0.4957297444343567, -0.2927256226539612, 0.22256551682949066, -0.018382474780082703, -1.112349271774292, 0.8106664419174194, -0.44193968176841736, 0.024921616539359093, 0.42475515604019165, -0.8135973215103149, -0.5141353607177734, 0.13814514875411987, -0.6211267113685608, 0.8314134478569031, 0.6388219594955444, 1.058760166168213, -0.28448233008384705, 0.055896323174238205, -0.01735043153166771, 0.4209240972995758, 0.15359991788864136, 0.2791469693183899, -0.1365966647863388, 0.001860817545093596, -0.37248510122299194, -0.17004339396953583, -0.43009984493255615, -0.3462018370628357, 0.00516740046441555, 1.176590085029602, 0.4041137099266052, -0.03039195016026497, 0.4565960168838501, 0.08009107410907745, -0.3893144428730011, 0.27667850255966187, 0.31034141778945923, -0.0818602591753006, -0.4323297441005707, 0.35633283853530884, 0.5918079018592834, -0.38593265414237976, 0.20787860453128815, -0.8557041883468628, -0.05751427263021469, 0.42319679260253906, -0.4603540003299713, 0.33219972252845764, 0.05983322858810425, -0.6529669165611267 ]
{"Title": "A Comparison of Contemporary versus Older Studies of Aspirin for Primary Prevention", "Authors": "Moriarty Frank, Ebell Mark H.", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective This study compares the benefits and harms of aspirin for primary prevention before and after widespread use of statins and colorectal cancer screening. Methods We compared studies of aspirin for primary prevention that recruited patients from 2005 onward with previous individual patient meta-analyses that recruited patients from 1978 to 2002. Data for contemporary studies were synthesized using random-effects models. We report vascular (major adverse cardiovascular events [MACE], myocardial infarction [MI], stroke), bleeding, cancer, and mortality outcomes. Results The IPD analyses of older studies included 95,456 patients for CV prevention and 25,270 for cancer mortality, while the four newer studies had 61,604 patients. Relative risks for vascular outcomes for older vs newer studies follow: MACE: 0.89 (95% CI 0.83-0.95) vs 0.93 (0.86-0.99); fatal hemorrhagic stroke: 1.73 (1.11-2.72) vs 1.06 (0.66-1.70); any ischemic stroke: 0.86 (0.74-1.00) vs 0.86 (0.75-0.98); any MI: 0.84 (0.77-0.92) vs 0.88 (0.77-1.00); and non-fatal MI: 0.79 (0.71-0.88) vs 0.94 (0.83-1.08). Cancer death was not significantly decreased in newer studies (RR 1.11, 0.92-1.34). Major hemorrhage was significantly increased for both older and newer studies (RR 1.48, 95% CI 1.25-1.76 vs 1.37, 95% CI 1.24-1.53). There was no effect in either group on all-cause mortality, cardiovascular mortality, fatal stroke, or fatal MI. Conclusions In the modern era characterized by widespread statin use and cancer screening, aspirin does not reduce the risk of non-fatal MI or cancer death. There are no mortality benefits and a significant risk of major hemorrhage. Aspirin should no longer be recommended for primary prevention. Summary of current evidence and what this study adds What is already known about this subject? The cumulative evidence for aspirin suggests a role in the primary prevention of cardiovascular disease, and in reducing cancer incidence and mortality. However most of the trials of aspirin for primary prevention were set in Europe and the United States and recruited patients prior to the year 2000. The benefits and harms of aspirin should be considered separately in studies performed in the eras before and after widespread use of statins and colorectal cancer screening. What does this study add? This study provides the most detailed summary to date of cardiac, stroke, bleeding, mortality and cancer outcomes to date in the literature. In trials of aspirin for primary prevention from 2005 onwards, aspirin reduced major adverse cardiovascular events but significantly increased the risk of bleeding, with no benefit for mortality or, Unlike older studies, there was no reduction in cancer mortality and non-fatal myocardial infarction. How does this impact on clinical practice? Our study suggests aspirin should not be recommended for primary prevention in the modern era.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004267"}
10.1101/19010280
[ -0.17418687045574188, -0.3021595776081085, 0.2631259858608246, 0.7943859696388245, -0.5903182625770569, -0.2874966859817505, 0.11064837127923965, 0.24865704774856567, 0.22842104732990265, 0.6333229541778564, -0.2962278127670288, -0.8718801140785217, 0.5533258318901062, -0.6106904745101929, -0.08096933364868164, -0.2083555907011032, -0.3850768208503723, -0.13255912065505981, -0.3355412483215332, 0.05189875140786171, 0.40432292222976685, 0.34544962644577026, -0.3544500768184662, 0.8854424953460693, 0.4792795777320862, 1.0737543106079102, -0.4412793517112732, 0.3334767818450928, 1.2283014059066772, -0.20150607824325562, -0.07138901203870773, -0.6940407156944275, 0.5940126180648804, -0.9737274646759033, -0.7023101449012756, 0.09329098463058472, 0.5030742287635803, -0.371282696723938, -0.10634374618530273, -0.26344117522239685, 0.3265296220779419, 0.3640037775039673, 0.609895646572113, -0.6196950078010559, -0.2473459541797638, -0.5746777653694153, -0.9927929639816284, -0.372497022151947, -0.7474859356880188, -0.22363294661045074, -0.3057328164577484, -0.154324010014534, 0.3015817403793335, 0.31774359941482544, 0.22357742488384247, 0.47960737347602844, 0.30039191246032715, 0.028498537838459015, -1.1085131168365479, 0.19203244149684906, 0.0714004710316658, -0.34863168001174927, 0.5010255575180054, -1.56612229347229, 0.6324185729026794, 0.5284891724586487, -0.20125992596149445, -0.31482595205307007, -0.5302173495292664, -0.29705238342285156, 0.4541636109352112, -0.5530034303665161, -0.1632474958896637, -0.06244107335805893, 0.22354398667812347, -0.36377760767936707, 0.6044339537620544, -0.2318933755159378, 0.03260154277086258, 0.07982999086380005, -0.09008581936359406, 0.3215346932411194, -0.05015619099140167, 0.7725223302841187, -0.4664077162742615, -0.3951842188835144, 0.27475905418395996, 0.5803928971290588, -0.04482784867286682, 0.30005592107772827, 0.41410934925079346, 0.19736729562282562, -0.10197123140096664, 0.8085777759552002, -0.388236403465271, 1.0893129110336304, -0.4773782789707184, 0.12415057420730591, -0.3541988730430603, -0.34204795956611633, 0.8519834280014038, -0.27889901399612427, -0.290301650762558, 0.8591329455375671, -0.15939117968082428, 0.3750775456428528, 0.7684738636016846, -0.14966149628162384, -0.377789705991745, -1.0337934494018555, 0.5361596345901489, 0.22506165504455566, -0.0809752568602562, 1.074334979057312, 0.6311697363853455, 0.22380287945270538, -0.28746742010116577, 0.19620849192142487, -0.7178590893745422, 0.1859549582004547, -0.012212788686156273, -0.1578652709722519, 0.47668182849884033, -0.334148645401001, 0.6047642230987549, -0.32102662324905396, -0.046455662697553635, 0.8078552484512329, -0.04752293601632118, 0.012109342962503433, 0.1816544532775879, -0.16256622970104218, 0.12253572791814804, 0.13686417043209076, -0.05098568648099899, -0.3159036338329315, 0.0706920474767685, 0.5629816055297852, -0.04475981742143631, -0.7741082310676575, 0.007673859596252441, 0.5528379082679749, -1.0444202423095703, 0.7618416547775269, -0.14101244509220123, 0.5475795269012451, -0.29658186435699463, -1.7568715810775757, 0.05772565305233002, 0.24748583137989044, -0.3165843188762665, 0.6544134020805359, 0.10665697604417801, -0.851959764957428, 0.12175709009170532, 0.4380371570587158, 0.14169880747795105, 0.715688169002533, -0.2452423870563507, 0.25702425837516785, -0.24065448343753815, 0.15233583748340607, -0.09264009445905685, 1.2183315753936768, -0.7287988662719727, 0.584137499332428, 0.48198744654655457, 0.6037957072257996, 0.6840665340423584, -0.856569230556488, -0.009175319224596024, 0.3134177029132843, -0.6902894973754883, 0.1421419233083725, 0.48451030254364014, 0.7136135101318359, 0.5870528221130371, -0.20996583998203278, 0.9337158203125, 0.4613719880580902, 0.1043204516172409, 0.11457125842571259, 0.2649654448032379, 1.3165642023086548, -0.20988121628761292, 0.1523134559392929, -0.43367883563041687, -0.6563135981559753, -0.18699786067008972, -0.18686865270137787, 0.49962401390075684, 0.21449598670005798, -0.3740161061286926, 1.3622597455978394, -0.528145968914032, 0.5749896764755249, -0.2539842128753662, -0.03518630936741829, 0.19716231524944305, -0.6673677563667297, -0.415292352437973, 1.1488113403320312, 0.05173793435096741, 0.4258219599723816, -0.10300899296998978, 0.4067206084728241, 0.356343537569046, -0.022606132552027702, 0.1428467482328415, 0.6940160393714905, 0.8989706039428711, 0.03149581328034401, 0.46968793869018555, -0.18028958141803741, 0.3244765102863312, -0.7872764468193054, -0.14165520668029785, 0.2997608780860901, -0.5738775730133057, 0.31682729721069336, -0.02987147681415081, -0.345710426568985, 0.3517681360244751, 0.1602293998003006, -0.21836021542549133, -0.4607604742050171, 0.5113623142242432, -0.1674896627664566, 0.3288203775882721, -0.7253709435462952, 0.6137150526046753, 0.597936749458313, 0.28286078572273254, 0.7379368543624878, 0.9383395910263062, 0.23459383845329285, 0.3294064402580261, 0.3562718331813812, 0.23014011979103088, 0.38883981108665466, 0.6791170835494995, 0.39623019099235535, 0.6993996500968933, 0.1960185170173645, 0.2580285966396332, 0.24854464828968048, -0.6340886354446411, 0.21771004796028137, 0.04872797057032585, 0.08003851771354675, -1.3313367366790771, 1.0185436010360718, -0.10246748477220535, 0.6695113778114319, 0.30622705817222595, -0.31518059968948364, 0.6042248010635376, -0.08139871060848236, -0.33426377177238464, -0.6081559062004089, -0.6385620832443237, -0.14047856628894806, -0.2231045663356781, 0.34073498845100403, 1.378383994102478, 0.470634788274765, 0.0664929673075676, 0.29788750410079956, 0.822584331035614, 0.3104012906551361, -0.4894873797893524, -1.1492712497711182, -1.379163384437561, -0.8120518326759338, -0.82379549741745, 0.05104998126626015, -0.024895066395401955, 0.040872663259506226, -0.28303179144859314, 0.18252350389957428, 0.5515915751457214, -0.7027235627174377, -0.4648306965827942, 0.41729533672332764, 1.0313385725021362, 0.16028288006782532, -0.3719777464866638, -0.0539688803255558, -0.24997179210186005, 0.21100014448165894, -0.36448541283607483, -0.9910010695457458, -0.2861226797103882, -1.2158242464065552, 0.10443072021007538, -0.6533886194229126, -0.14874263107776642, -0.20041118562221527, -0.04436010494828224, 0.0851539596915245, 0.048641007393598557, 0.173664391040802, -0.365779310464859, -0.26023274660110474, -1.053145408630371, 0.4054136276245117, 0.7399166226387024, 0.4808870851993561, 0.3407176733016968, 0.5340625643730164, -0.34695425629615784, 0.5045848488807678, 0.5926791429519653, 0.18916963040828705, -0.9689043164253235, 0.3222877085208893, 1.0730818510055542, -0.16588836908340454, -0.10858242213726044, -1.0917786359786987, -1.3003097772598267, -0.32339486479759216, 0.050391700118780136, -0.09601129591464996, 0.018687071278691292, 0.091600202023983, 0.6294781565666199, -0.6193050146102905, -0.1052500456571579, -0.6330034136772156, -0.8900747299194336, 0.39843761920928955, -0.14598341286182404, 0.42769762873649597, 0.11892924457788467, 0.11803746968507767, -0.3421809673309326, -0.20193970203399658, 0.5690772533416748, 0.6905772089958191, -0.23452362418174744, -0.033704470843076706, 0.12467785179615021, 0.4296422004699707, 0.41043156385421753, 0.2431408166885376, 0.5271666646003723, -0.04148516803979874, -0.016028909012675285, 0.03772495314478874, 0.08269211649894714, -0.08608187735080719, 0.46850186586380005, 0.3718547523021698, -0.5292362570762634, 0.2755061388015747, 0.04606335610151291, 0.24657632410526276, 0.40523672103881836, 0.21888884902000427, -0.7731277346611023, 0.6208009719848633, 0.11501551419496536, 0.5528740286827087, -0.7744327783584595, -1.0973237752914429, 0.470872163772583, -0.18463723361492157, 0.8901972770690918, -0.7514693140983582, 0.9081413745880127, 0.2714248299598694, -0.14465489983558655, -0.05138293281197548, -0.1557769924402237, 0.4899262487888336, 1.3479228019714355, 0.8845845460891724, 1.235856056213379, -1.6797341108322144, 0.7117987275123596, 0.8588435649871826, 0.9961691498756409, 0.026472894474864006, -0.0021984362974762917, 0.3310116231441498, -1.366860270500183, -0.21179528534412384, -0.02102200873196125, 0.238361656665802, 0.5231702923774719, 0.3532867133617401, -0.0672738328576088, 0.02518821321427822, -1.1169049739837646, -0.6432836651802063, -0.20850780606269836, 0.2968166172504425, -0.11459112167358398, 0.21406203508377075, 0.5005690455436707, -0.41311123967170715, -0.08271771669387817, -0.030113548040390015, 0.5245552062988281, -0.36744511127471924, -0.3962481617927551, 0.5681336522102356, -0.06878753006458282, -0.7426038980484009, 0.23033428192138672, -0.012232710607349873, -0.704113781452179, -0.016868075355887413, -0.2904958426952362, -0.06376424431800842, -0.7475416660308838, -0.18854577839374542, -0.3236711621284485, 0.8025336861610413, 0.4731634557247162, -0.16872581839561462, -0.8213690519332886, -0.009116891771554947, -0.08204186707735062, -0.18303276598453522, -0.3260827958583832, -0.6612632870674133, 0.02037031762301922, 0.8195308446884155, -0.13139405846595764, -0.8108203411102295, -0.24599343538284302, 0.20554712414741516, -0.8155816197395325, 0.32983455061912537, 0.542457103729248, -1.162660002708435, 0.009208512492477894, -0.24145998060703278, 0.274054616689682, -1.049721360206604, -0.16132472455501556, 0.04060439392924309, 0.05145058035850525, 0.2576589584350586, 0.4456646740436554, 0.17216308414936066, 0.7655588984489441, 0.06444836407899857, 0.4567011296749115, -0.3802834153175354, -0.0821911096572876, -0.2481071650981903, -0.9207820892333984, -0.3239569067955017, -0.5481647253036499, 0.4711785614490509, -0.03180333971977234, 0.0779314786195755, -0.2929683029651642, 0.4006102681159973, 0.2167179137468338, 0.2825457751750946, -0.5299826860427856, 0.6246300935745239, -1.0664304494857788, 0.41141456365585327, 1.2603669166564941, 0.09061439335346222, -0.09934686124324799, -0.4435659646987915, -0.010878262110054493, -1.111070156097412, 0.7162137627601624, 0.3893525004386902, 0.26477089524269104, -0.16579125821590424, -0.23434025049209595, -0.09982181340456009, 0.08598765730857849, 1.0879806280136108, -0.8170414566993713, 0.2770806849002838, -0.6669579148292542, -0.636726975440979, -0.386785089969635, -0.4244910776615143, -0.8129610419273376, -0.4939914345741272, -0.3603096008300781, -0.7093514204025269, -0.027767328545451164, -0.02956167235970497, -0.49177610874176025, -0.23591265082359314, -0.810516893863678, 0.25979650020599365, -0.4895070195198059, -0.5357108116149902, 0.7116883397102356, -0.3535357713699341, -0.5541655421257019, 0.3788192868232727, 1.1512147188186646, -0.0349445715546608, -0.30788886547088623, 0.40725114941596985, -0.20534731447696686, -0.4084261655807495, 0.13135357201099396, 0.06446916610002518, -1.1522303819656372, -0.13824854791164398, 0.15572945773601532, -0.2258933186531067, 0.4058331847190857, 0.12451303750276566, -0.6919461488723755, 0.47667378187179565, 0.3414832055568695, -0.9321143627166748, -0.2575674057006836, 0.4257981777191162, 0.9544336199760437, 0.5564789772033691, -0.4487960636615753, -0.9363040924072266, -1.241403341293335, -0.889744758605957, 0.3387207090854645, -1.3391544818878174, -0.19718444347381592, -0.6946848630905151, -0.04553259164094925, 0.38553205132484436, 0.3102169632911682, 0.6233447194099426, -0.043771445751190186, 0.1733347475528717, -0.7242251634597778, 0.5606754422187805, -0.8667966723442078, -0.33899834752082825, -0.302068829536438, -0.32644546031951904, -0.06620535254478455, 1.1843061447143555, 0.8408113718032837, -0.5327158570289612, 0.288057416677475, -0.051807962357997894, 0.9093378782272339, 0.3699207305908203, -0.5968260169029236, -0.42349106073379517, 0.8765199184417725, 0.38497743010520935, -0.5983712673187256, -0.2063097059726715, -1.3675315380096436, 0.6025760769844055, -0.5086892247200012, 0.9242158532142639, -0.5073067545890808, -0.2633209228515625, -0.4887768030166626, 0.34148967266082764, 0.47384363412857056, -0.8984381556510925, 0.6563002467155457, -0.3180007338523865, 0.01435328833758831, -0.03640556335449219, 0.5729840397834778, -0.036216966807842255, -1.0672481060028076, -0.9698185324668884, -1.2868155241012573, 0.1485503613948822, -0.22785741090774536, 0.5475507378578186, 0.5379966497421265, 0.1636415719985962, 0.08244074881076813, -1.274428129196167, 1.625705599784851, 0.979692816734314, -0.43270477652549744, -0.4245917797088623, 0.23819147050380707, 0.1192655861377716, 0.6317204236984253, -0.29916107654571533, 0.42906898260116577, -0.9951074719429016, -0.20682397484779358, 0.4347379207611084, 0.05012527108192444, -0.8295701742172241, -0.2734847664833069, 0.9174399375915527, 0.48885786533355713, -0.060115087777376175, 0.00945969857275486, 0.03533317148685455, 0.3531966507434845, -0.5944377183914185, 0.8668136596679688, -0.07394633442163467, 0.12936320900917053, 0.7951058149337769, -0.44391968846321106, -0.6755102872848511, 0.6020719408988953, -0.20567578077316284, 0.11946452409029007, -0.39701366424560547, 0.5679652690887451, 0.658258318901062, -1.5377695560455322, 0.6751999258995056, 0.25422826409339905, -0.33219674229621887, -1.2189056873321533, 0.4319257438182831, 0.04103526100516319, -0.09944424033164978, 0.028754910454154015, -0.4922197759151459, 0.7251415252685547, -0.62476646900177, 0.7927046418190002, -0.2837279438972473, 0.45099377632141113, -0.044085096567869186, -0.5177037119865417, -0.6645275354385376, -0.8213385939598083, 0.49497920274734497, 0.8438184857368469, 0.26058998703956604, 0.07258302718400955, -0.0949237123131752, 0.33377957344055176, -0.1671174019575119, -0.02175716683268547, -0.15631335973739624, 0.27282780408859253, 0.21814407408237457, 0.052601493895053864, 0.3561754524707794, 0.5068419575691223, 0.6233852505683899, -0.8459916114807129, 0.5257921814918518, 0.42441344261169434, -1.0972362756729126, -1.101836085319519, -0.26244181394577026, 0.47893431782722473, 1.2494046688079834, -0.20351526141166687, 0.05987474322319031, 0.5090453028678894, 0.5707120895385742, 0.18039561808109283, -0.2562713921070099, -0.028529159724712372, -0.37894412875175476, -0.19418440759181976, 0.2505576014518738, -0.6709398627281189, -0.23548807203769684, 0.446012020111084, -0.4142203629016876, -1.087096095085144, -0.11412961035966873, 0.5834870338439941, 0.09768331050872803, 0.06039184704422951, -0.5432981848716736, 0.08482195436954498, -0.981269359588623, -0.701103150844574, -0.2431856095790863, -0.5672661662101746, 0.369341641664505, 1.0939215421676636, -0.6045306324958801, -0.7216694355010986, 0.030721381306648254, 0.3462628126144409, -0.10260184854269028, 0.38588157296180725, -0.8169471025466919, -0.46499162912368774, -0.12854161858558655, 0.24663755297660828, 0.5656355619430542, -0.2625696063041687, 1.4072039127349854, -0.2507167458534241, -0.09869202971458435, 0.0312548503279686, 0.1771571934223175, -0.7097025513648987, -0.08615346997976303, 0.17472125589847565, -0.4328773319721222, -0.8722414374351501, -0.3676498830318451, 0.8598201870918274, -0.9079685211181641, -0.2685171961784363, -1.1949255466461182, -0.10530757904052734, 0.013477999716997147, 0.3118785321712494, -0.19895975291728973, 0.7948566675186157, -0.17103108763694763, -0.3894686698913574, 0.4468548595905304, 0.24987846612930298, 0.5487042665481567, -0.10647955536842346, -0.146220862865448, -0.08619511872529984, 0.43384066224098206, -0.5275493860244751, 0.144090935587883, -0.27584537863731384, -0.46721258759498596, -0.03415961563587189, -0.008938483893871307, -0.09689952433109283, 0.3841927647590637, -0.11861364543437958, -0.023330755531787872, -0.09897394478321075, 0.0831899344921112, 0.21504640579223633, 0.198923721909523, -0.5925741195678711, -0.6340044736862183, -0.7114018201828003, -0.9336873888969421, -1.1610392332077026, 1.3039054870605469, -0.5597065687179565, -0.11608517915010452, -0.615453839302063, -0.8453202247619629, 0.9845056533813477, 0.53050696849823, 0.3886423110961914, -0.33624351024627686, -0.3408483564853668, 0.6204720735549927, -0.09446408599615097, 0.42408645153045654, -0.29063600301742554, 0.6345553994178772, 0.26372864842414856, -0.5566762089729309, -0.5529192686080933, -0.3452102243900299, 0.1030406579375267, 0.32899361848831177, -0.7960199117660522, -0.09184975177049637, -0.33733245730400085, 0.19570748507976532, -0.9209266901016235, 0.12674124538898468, 0.12663324177265167, -0.66108638048172, -0.3318382799625397, -1.0353341102600098, -0.261631041765213, -0.5749605894088745, -0.011358900927007198, -0.27442002296447754, -0.7006822228431702, -0.5542943477630615, -0.33067256212234497, 0.8617865443229675, -0.4959993362426758, 0.8282397389411926, -0.477867990732193, 0.22188922762870789, -0.5042916536331177, -0.052716415375471115, 0.8983413577079773, 0.8633736371994019, 0.2660527527332306, -0.241160586476326, -0.580175518989563, 0.6615532040596008, 0.6570295691490173, 0.7216219902038574, -0.3323532044887543, 0.75425785779953, 0.3236241936683655, 0.38237693905830383, 0.2017081081867218, -0.4556693434715271, 0.9124411940574646, 0.30332809686660767, -0.024008149281144142, 0.5539982914924622, 0.36441347002983093, 0.4837145209312439, -0.43535998463630676, -0.481115460395813, 0.3852386772632599, -0.4090081751346588, -0.3217737376689911, -0.06585525721311569, 0.5568739175796509, 1.280222773551941, -0.030105356127023697, 0.8393971920013428, -0.4580669403076172, 0.7188273668289185, -0.16580741107463837, 0.006671337876468897, 0.8223808407783508, -0.6375335454940796, -0.4217548966407776, 0.01738908514380455, 0.293201208114624, 0.2268807590007782, -0.21056152880191803, 0.10028572380542755, -0.21588163077831268, -0.5480287075042725, 1.0846620798110962, 0.04541599377989769, -0.5372209548950195, 0.4411960244178772, 0.08349224179983139, -0.13001814484596252, 0.15991689264774323, 0.11910858750343323, -0.6273778080940247, -0.8364089131355286, 0.9021610617637634, -0.8784379363059998, 0.22807994484901428, -0.12811334431171417, -0.5372737050056458, 0.8187790513038635, -0.44960686564445496, 0.8389860987663269, -0.4353717863559723, 0.35749542713165283, 0.6305907368659973, -0.15941660106182098, 0.10161124169826508, -0.23884223401546478, 0.15763095021247864, -0.29208922386169434, -0.5505912899971008, 0.1384309083223343, 0.23002822697162628, -0.7384290099143982, -0.6023619174957275, 0.5996184945106506, -0.6397419571876526, -0.5461792945861816, -0.24263674020767212, 0.0709419921040535, 0.016735738143324852, 0.09439614415168762, -0.2727414667606354, 0.317861944437027, 0.06457603722810745, -0.2528545558452606, -0.02071671187877655, -0.6977163553237915, -0.2719663679599762, -0.2783007323741913, -0.884273111820221, 0.5626093745231628, -0.0033061509020626545, -0.1836710423231125, -0.748647928237915, -1.2730417251586914, 0.3085468113422394, 0.14648300409317017, -0.06969042867422104, -0.7614248991012573, 0.2535136938095093, 0.1445997953414917, 0.5879637002944946, 0.29034683108329773, -0.0730748102068901, -0.09312297403812408, 0.5238329768180847, 0.9604252576828003, 0.03896068036556244, 0.43095478415489197, -0.332744300365448, 0.5411462187767029, 0.11831806600093842, 0.3429819643497467, -0.5508997440338135, -0.15382856130599976, -0.2704768180847168, -0.982224702835083, 0.024972323328256607, -0.6607792377471924, -0.7816070914268494, 0.31405168771743774, 0.8733487129211426, -0.3640778958797455, -0.3479181230068207, -0.5873733758926392, -0.6463972926139832, -0.623741626739502, 1.5536253452301025, -0.21627037227153778, -0.1936606615781784, 0.04189465194940567, -0.6950715780258179, 0.7596305012702942, -1.165055274963379, 3.770073652267456, 1.740393042564392, 0.3017979860305786, 0.1443595141172409, -0.30144357681274414, -0.1142062321305275, 0.4611625075340271, 0.30774468183517456, 0.4317726194858551, 0.6281023025512695, 0.07645224034786224, 1.164833903312683, 0.07430274784564972, -0.1572546660900116, 0.8246433138847351, 1.1986006498336792, -0.9024277925491333, -0.06214426830410957, 0.21687549352645874, -1.353830099105835, -0.9315435886383057, 0.18396256864070892, 0.22947701811790466, 0.3241448998451233, 0.2617703080177307, -0.08600027859210968, -0.16987212002277374, 0.2077002376317978, -0.26696398854255676, 0.11370747536420822, -0.47280195355415344, -0.5127201676368713, 0.9469665884971619, 0.024044467136263847, -0.21295589208602905, 0.13197597861289978, 0.04885831102728844, -0.11907422542572021, -0.13680565357208252, -0.01904044859111309, 0.4581044018268585, -1.0058025121688843, -0.4250131845474243, -0.4419751465320587, 0.08711177855730057, 0.35060974955558777, -0.7206542491912842, 0.2116604894399643, -0.3631645143032074, -0.5235317349433899, 0.9388356804847717, -0.8054660558700562, 0.7583892941474915, -0.3360989987850189, -1.044082522392273, 0.09559063613414764, -0.5332925319671631, -1.0256174802780151, 0.47791382670402527, 0.6396600604057312, 0.9346894025802612, 0.4287000596523285, -0.7219036221504211, -0.14511339366436005, 0.5039581060409546, 0.6673755049705505, 0.27889060974121094, 0.6351022124290466, -0.4982253909111023, -0.5551654696464539, 0.3017857074737549, -0.8106418251991272, -0.20311585068702698, 0.025817953050136566, 0.8228967189788818, 0.7051209807395935, -0.1266058087348938, 0.4440692067146301, -0.6946110129356384, -0.6454361081123352, 0.7423852682113647, 0.1369882971048355, 0.9150527119636536, -0.863113522529602, 0.25686100125312805, 0.4422854483127594, -0.3082450330257416, 0.03541002422571182, -1.372312307357788, 0.7831941246986389, 0.7238062024116516, -0.3650377094745636, 0.5864749550819397, -0.445227712392807, -0.20445667207241058 ]
{"Title": "Brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) Val66Met polymorphism is not risk factor for bipolar disorder", "Authors": "Rai Vandana, Jamal Farhin, Kumar Pradeep", "Abstract": "Abstract Bipolar disorder (BPD) is a psychiatric disease, characterized by the cycles of mania and depression. Several genetic studies investigated BDNF gene Val66Met polymorphism as risk factor for BPD, but results were inconclusive. Therefore, present meta-analysis was performed to reevaluate the BDNF Val66Met polymorphism and BPD association. Four databases (Pubmed, Springer Link, Science Direct and Google Scholar) were searched for eligible studies up to March 31,2018. Pooled odds ratios (OR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated to estimate the strength of the association. All statistical analyses were done by MetaAnalyst and Mix program. Forty studies with a total of 28,787 subjects (10,085 cases and 18,702 controls) were included in this meta-analysis. Overall, pooled analysis indicated that there was no significant association between BDNF Val66Met polymorphism and BPD risk under all five genetic models (OR A vs.G =0.99, 95%CI= 0.94-1.03, p=0.49; OR AG vs. GG = 0.1.02, 95%CI= 0.95-1.07, p= 0.57; OR AA vs. GG = 0.98, 95%CI=0.89-1.08, p=0.75; OR AA+AG vs. GG = 1.0, 95%CI= 0.94-1.06, p= 0.89;OR AA vs. AG+GG = 0.96, 95%CI= 0.89-1.05, p= 0.47). Similarly, no significant association was observed in ethnicity based subgroup analysis in both Asian and Caucasian population. However, significant association was found in subtype analysis between BDNF Val66Met and BPDII (OR AA+AG vs. GG = 1.21, 95%CI= 1.06-1.37, p= 0.003) but not with BPDI. These findings suggested that the BDNF Val66Met polymorphism confer no genetic susceptibility to BPD I but risk for BPDII.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010280"}
10.1101/19001123
[ 0.019340969622135162, -0.22330057621002197, 0.2636789083480835, 0.8343834280967712, -0.0067733414471149445, -0.24102124571800232, -0.2102464884519577, -0.032989390194416046, 0.3057432472705841, 0.6600315570831299, -0.23094694316387177, -1.0587103366851807, 0.20788034796714783, -0.6880622506141663, -0.16485348343849182, -0.5733824968338013, -0.5000888109207153, 0.1605277955532074, -0.33117860555648804, 0.23657472431659698, 0.5618392825126648, 0.44466692209243774, -0.8494773507118225, 0.40931159257888794, -0.44501668214797974, 0.38899362087249756, -0.06381375342607498, 0.19467774033546448, 0.864222526550293, 0.41414907574653625, -0.12826044857501984, -0.295877605676651, 0.2635088562965393, -1.150351643562317, -0.27531349658966064, -0.11696010828018188, 0.6155750751495361, -0.4165654182434082, 0.18379490077495575, 0.05899703875184059, -0.1663876324892044, -0.16422203183174133, 0.929861843585968, -0.7050607204437256, -0.521564245223999, -0.10794144123792648, -0.4206295907497406, -0.0009893294190987945, -0.21168595552444458, -0.11721323430538177, -0.05215493217110634, 0.19073118269443512, 0.4325971305370331, -0.10751663893461227, 0.7133944630622864, -0.2409549504518509, 0.10694724321365356, 0.5090208053588867, -0.5585429668426514, -0.1468050330877304, -0.06993459910154343, -0.2858295738697052, 0.4148114323616028, -1.436545729637146, 0.8100340962409973, 0.4684581756591797, 0.19453881680965424, -0.6284987926483154, -0.4173780083656311, -0.0906561017036438, 0.04346850886940956, -0.19425451755523682, -0.14062035083770752, -0.02467568777501583, 0.03940306976437569, -0.36741578578948975, 0.16235308349132538, -0.14823155105113983, -0.337615966796875, -0.019955193623900414, -0.08894966542720795, 0.7289249300956726, 0.27200284600257874, 0.29974281787872314, -0.36204999685287476, -0.3338949680328369, 0.5823564529418945, 1.1501994132995605, 0.4722353518009186, 0.43033960461616516, 0.22189877927303314, 0.428544282913208, 0.02987939678132534, 0.4571667015552521, 0.13246522843837738, 0.8257927894592285, -0.2760184705257416, 0.10772166401147842, 0.44902926683425903, -0.3734840154647827, 0.3958873748779297, 0.6007949709892273, -0.35206592082977295, 1.496634602546692, -0.11429151892662048, 0.6621257066726685, 0.6285259127616882, -0.40668749809265137, -0.6049373745918274, -0.7820006608963013, 0.6916788816452026, 0.3638303875923157, -1.02411949634552, 0.025506718084216118, -0.0007821221370249987, 0.6618358492851257, -0.019589047878980637, 1.012060523033142, -0.4384778141975403, -0.15886683762073517, 0.0397590696811676, -0.513269305229187, 0.4085581302642822, -0.5169432759284973, 0.062381841242313385, 0.4366545081138611, -0.1567847579717636, 0.7680485248565674, -0.45448482036590576, 0.10750007629394531, -0.08032195270061493, -0.6186825037002563, 0.1652536690235138, -0.18082185089588165, -0.5141720771789551, -0.5127338171005249, -0.00043540538172237575, 0.7599306702613831, 0.03402576223015785, -0.7126563191413879, -0.05892841890454292, 0.5390146970748901, -0.8498170375823975, 1.3386812210083008, -0.1191212385892868, 1.0037263631820679, -0.3087819218635559, -1.4238409996032715, -0.4274718761444092, 0.22076283395290375, -0.4020337462425232, 0.6386364698410034, 0.1516968309879303, -0.10525064170360565, 0.024831430986523628, 0.29543131589889526, -0.2368011474609375, 0.2929523289203644, -0.08629525452852249, -0.23980340361595154, -0.30702462792396545, 0.3906863033771515, -0.09902790933847427, 0.8458393812179565, -0.4512692093849182, 0.7363132238388062, -0.18754959106445312, 0.1736280769109726, 0.06479601562023163, -0.6988022327423096, 0.47898995876312256, -0.06720001995563507, -0.5669640898704529, 0.5451930165290833, 0.2152283787727356, 0.7538676857948303, 1.1205147504806519, -0.13255919516086578, 0.7108278870582581, 0.051850128918886185, -0.40667110681533813, -0.17093461751937866, 0.5141720175743103, 1.2056293487548828, -0.28878214955329895, 0.23958881199359894, -0.7277014255523682, -0.7231699228286743, -0.5150090456008911, 0.13191568851470947, 0.08133790642023087, 0.29915645718574524, -0.4428919851779938, 0.6811127066612244, 0.31941312551498413, 0.28494367003440857, -0.9522449970245361, 0.1261969357728958, 0.14799508452415466, -0.5869033336639404, -0.37323087453842163, 0.7864158153533936, -0.6274893879890442, 0.06181381270289421, -0.16869887709617615, 0.8180364370346069, 0.4735618233680725, 0.549233615398407, -0.6823230981826782, -0.1380414068698883, 0.9201165437698364, 0.09325365722179413, 0.1902932971715927, -0.21356719732284546, 0.7556569576263428, -0.47252708673477173, -0.8242155313491821, 0.18515904247760773, -0.7497215867042542, 0.025589529424905777, -0.49847427010536194, -0.4755706489086151, 0.5758722424507141, 0.25784581899642944, 0.12062878906726837, 0.4088193476200104, 0.35235795378685, 0.4633145034313202, 0.22557131946086884, -0.0455925427377224, 0.24232062697410583, 0.3732911944389343, 0.48549404740333557, 0.7016773819923401, 0.7312672138214111, 1.0417025089263916, 0.6657978296279907, 0.5539207458496094, -0.029063630849123, 0.7687299847602844, 0.6476516723632812, 0.7350786924362183, 0.6761295795440674, 0.5615103244781494, -0.12515796720981598, 0.33181482553482056, -0.6568856835365295, 0.297289103269577, -0.20715101063251495, 0.2746751010417938, -1.1309694051742554, -0.13682007789611816, 0.9481736421585083, 0.2736504375934601, -1.2132691144943237, -0.010357757098972797, 0.9167525768280029, 0.725990891456604, -0.29840677976608276, -0.5011423230171204, -0.14044441282749176, 0.4802328050136566, 0.4763268232345581, 0.12556849420070648, 0.6351393461227417, 1.0837682485580444, -0.17215462028980255, 0.6710030436515808, 0.33408665657043457, -0.05041290074586868, -0.8179511427879333, -0.7635303735733032, -1.3847262859344482, -0.8244304656982422, -0.8878408074378967, -0.12744200229644775, -0.4048466086387634, -0.3104943633079529, -0.03777168318629265, 0.2864985167980194, 0.580735445022583, -0.4423791170120239, 0.0009531152318231761, 0.4011247754096985, 0.5281103849411011, 0.19866515696048737, -0.9092828035354614, 0.32201701402664185, -0.4837128520011902, 0.2234133780002594, -0.6768558621406555, -0.5661805272102356, -0.38503316044807434, -1.202964186668396, 0.4023110866546631, -0.9408589601516724, -0.16294725239276886, -0.7021268010139465, -0.23421846330165863, -0.15956847369670868, 0.4084072411060333, 0.11295127868652344, -0.2202891856431961, -0.25573211908340454, -1.1845139265060425, 0.3973601758480072, 0.35013505816459656, -0.12449423223733902, 0.08169817179441452, 0.6020644307136536, -0.38326388597488403, 0.8637957572937012, -0.0207399632781744, 0.017684530466794968, -0.6025539636611938, -0.19922347366809845, 0.6775230169296265, 0.01588161662220955, 0.3553226590156555, -0.818453848361969, -0.9549776315689087, -0.09610588848590851, -0.06907138228416443, -0.2936072051525116, -0.3478173315525055, 0.08876112848520279, 0.3645431697368622, -0.7049470543861389, 0.039663948118686676, -0.1985958218574524, -1.4854120016098022, 0.5658822655677795, -0.3698034882545471, 0.6240441799163818, 0.5293774604797363, 0.08860712498426437, -0.1577129065990448, 0.033472348004579544, -0.14540062844753265, 0.6815581321716309, -0.0857887789607048, -0.48995649814605713, -0.09912069886922836, 0.37956222891807556, -0.08330433070659637, 0.30645352602005005, 0.2679610848426819, -0.0920429676771164, -0.21020042896270752, -0.05201823636889458, -0.30528485774993896, 0.37815389037132263, 1.156606912612915, -0.12336913496255875, -0.20273423194885254, 0.21684978902339935, 0.1533896028995514, -0.24113230407238007, 0.3690459728240967, -0.3974848985671997, -0.40662169456481934, 0.5558040738105774, -0.5677888989448547, 0.31595247983932495, -0.26031747460365295, -0.8565133810043335, 0.4441913962364197, -0.017164034768939018, 0.6772943735122681, -1.0673537254333496, 0.5223896503448486, 0.5120532512664795, -0.41671738028526306, 0.01596272923052311, 0.3259471356868744, 0.06094783544540405, 1.2528204917907715, 0.03139672055840492, 1.385866403579712, -1.6286598443984985, 0.4132721424102783, 0.5592837929725647, 1.5364603996276855, -0.1291288435459137, 0.34833604097366333, 0.5401613116264343, -1.2257859706878662, -0.24230480194091797, -0.12150603532791138, -0.13332697749137878, 0.43986934423446655, 0.1690312623977661, -0.04244449734687805, 0.27458634972572327, -0.5004634261131287, -0.2830294966697693, 0.19163531064987183, 0.3356615900993347, -0.026699921116232872, -0.2755359411239624, 1.0172290802001953, -0.31379514932632446, 0.16116197407245636, -0.1367420107126236, 1.0157098770141602, 0.10406798869371414, -0.5348382592201233, 0.27336180210113525, -0.25196823477745056, -0.5668282508850098, -0.21357353031635284, 0.002977784490212798, 0.007169998250901699, 0.27313852310180664, 0.6200830340385437, -0.2672382593154907, -0.08554944396018982, -0.04433605447411537, -0.5527084469795227, 0.8009310960769653, 0.3049599230289459, 1.1844358444213867, -0.17541296780109406, -0.16924093663692474, 0.10250240564346313, -0.5986046195030212, 0.18247972428798676, -0.808661699295044, 0.2267007976770401, 0.7447310090065002, -0.2072109878063202, -0.7906127572059631, -0.510423481464386, -0.00811086967587471, -0.5759575963020325, 0.06020683795213699, 0.2937917411327362, -0.730333149433136, 0.47498413920402527, 0.22056055068969727, 0.05411754176020622, -1.0567866563796997, -0.25839757919311523, -0.09849660098552704, 0.4678295850753784, 0.3482961654663086, 1.182724952697754, 0.3175985813140869, 0.9173115491867065, -0.531757652759552, 0.3717106282711029, -0.5042208433151245, 0.24956056475639343, -0.3603886067867279, -0.496873676776886, 0.08211486041545868, -0.12144672870635986, 0.14689289033412933, -0.4911503791809082, -0.5064942240715027, -0.3199780583381653, 0.20124533772468567, 0.18398328125476837, -0.21791599690914154, -0.49195414781570435, 0.9013625383377075, -0.6652835607528687, 0.1261359006166458, 1.0289371013641357, -0.03215263783931732, 0.05022117495536804, -0.2966953217983246, -0.10690179467201233, -0.7249189615249634, 0.5874565243721008, 0.6442626118659973, 0.5821681022644043, -0.22874434292316437, -0.8245253562927246, -0.09784900397062302, -0.024544503539800644, 0.5479298830032349, -0.45392072200775146, -0.5263580083847046, -0.36389341950416565, -0.6177101731300354, -0.7508629560470581, -0.5250449180603027, -0.5729339122772217, 0.1271609663963318, 0.19994696974754333, -0.6072201728820801, -0.3399241268634796, 0.08163998275995255, -0.8408868312835693, -0.7318486571311951, -1.2645188570022583, 0.3443407118320465, -0.5585822463035583, 0.42356276512145996, 1.2148358821868896, -0.8634488582611084, -0.8855428099632263, 0.4241775870323181, 0.9027531743049622, -0.515449583530426, -0.5273338556289673, 0.47253698110580444, 0.3683375120162964, -0.353094220161438, -0.3617183566093445, -0.02791116200387478, -0.6721159815788269, -0.3363647162914276, 0.07503349334001541, -0.5027374029159546, -0.17048482596874237, -0.22354629635810852, 0.0621853768825531, 0.46520018577575684, 0.37449637055397034, -0.9852960109710693, 0.09373217076063156, 0.41264984011650085, 0.21827997267246246, 0.05668575316667557, -0.23798227310180664, -1.3412336111068726, -0.5565323829650879, -0.5320921540260315, 0.29619595408439636, -0.7123246192932129, 0.36684030294418335, -0.5651683807373047, -0.12557531893253326, 0.12555037438869476, 0.6854932308197021, 0.2473812699317932, 0.1598299741744995, 0.2049974799156189, -0.016494276002049446, 0.06056836619973183, -0.7993531823158264, -0.1739889681339264, 0.19487975537776947, -0.44230490922927856, -0.05136828497052193, 0.6652750372886658, 0.5703099966049194, -0.6768801808357239, 0.13361892104148865, 0.14322005212306976, 0.6586028337478638, 0.30044981837272644, -0.17290496826171875, -0.24832125008106232, 0.20172522962093353, 0.3977622985839844, -0.10608047991991043, -0.296557754278183, -1.1364423036575317, 0.6344712376594543, -0.5334614515304565, 0.271066814661026, -0.44382673501968384, -0.6899060010910034, -0.15062333643436432, 0.0425884909927845, 1.4748451709747314, -0.7763173580169678, 0.10681356489658356, 0.07083643972873688, -0.3601539134979248, -0.32521045207977295, 0.543535590171814, -0.2446725070476532, -0.5819862484931946, -0.9322528839111328, -1.0554207563400269, 0.3123522400856018, -0.15423667430877686, -0.33255651593208313, 0.8228293657302856, 0.3952341079711914, -0.3918941617012024, -1.0000630617141724, 0.6985146403312683, 0.59767746925354, -0.8803762197494507, -0.9329549670219421, 0.3476831614971161, 0.13028991222381592, -0.07804248481988907, -0.13217274844646454, 0.1532839834690094, -0.5060041546821594, -0.14897426962852478, -0.09358643740415573, -0.7718959450721741, -0.6693230271339417, -0.4033021032810211, 0.3512900769710541, 1.1480281352996826, -0.18900281190872192, 0.23964695632457733, -0.11609789729118347, -0.00447385199368, -0.29116377234458923, 0.5397135615348816, -0.7562198638916016, 0.563426673412323, 0.6602156162261963, -0.3591524660587311, 0.13209415972232819, 0.6385105848312378, -0.4113319516181946, -0.020596232265233994, -0.1751086711883545, 0.4124060869216919, 0.8539767861366272, -0.6870750784873962, 0.2341160625219345, 0.3770625591278076, -0.11459805816411972, -0.7480773329734802, 0.7182111144065857, -0.6124181151390076, 0.12451213598251343, -0.475992888212204, -0.2943921685218811, -0.015369185246527195, -0.39506953954696655, 0.2534295320510864, -0.19313977658748627, 0.28303512930870056, -0.2671945095062256, -0.5919987559318542, -0.117731012403965, -1.129841685295105, 0.11248385906219482, 1.3463225364685059, 0.08389022946357727, 0.6354745626449585, -0.006745121441781521, 0.46563977003097534, 0.2344220131635666, 0.2675614356994629, 0.4700644612312317, -0.047612499445676804, -0.1726546734571457, -0.07421298325061798, 0.38059645891189575, 0.3061644434928894, -0.1792522519826889, -0.2868385314941406, 0.8281702399253845, 0.09160981327295303, -0.7311794757843018, -0.3754952847957611, 0.3254700005054474, 0.6709423661231995, 0.38643619418144226, -0.3842507600784302, -0.0687660276889801, 0.7380833029747009, 0.013605001382529736, 0.01915009319782257, -0.03091607242822647, -0.739468514919281, -0.7963641881942749, -0.6070098280906677, 0.08452621847391129, -1.1855645179748535, 0.12410790473222733, 0.5042544603347778, -0.5896519422531128, -0.7412210702896118, -0.4296916723251343, 0.8684171438217163, -0.22793836891651154, -0.27684444189071655, -0.5783244371414185, 0.5194440484046936, -1.0630944967269897, -0.2411864995956421, -0.07025805860757828, -0.6495038866996765, 0.2664579153060913, 0.8515065312385559, -0.3396686315536499, -0.26387134194374084, 0.10197855532169342, 0.11603214591741562, -0.5916184186935425, 0.2954011857509613, -0.2717501223087311, -0.8207089900970459, 0.18048666417598724, 0.3346981406211853, 0.3188849687576294, -0.05291152372956276, 1.6590981483459473, 0.11018809676170349, 0.5233442783355713, 0.21347251534461975, 0.49104660749435425, -0.7673742771148682, -0.15812693536281586, 0.2975107431411743, -0.5660542249679565, -0.22894012928009033, 0.2521125376224518, 0.5802842378616333, -1.2282840013504028, -0.6841325163841248, -0.6698822975158691, -0.0940513014793396, 0.09006686508655548, -0.31879425048828125, 0.38119661808013916, 0.9446689486503601, 0.14086240530014038, -0.28597310185432434, -0.015255565755069256, 0.9838445782661438, 0.1473340094089508, -0.03812668099999428, 0.26798149943351746, -0.3081919252872467, 0.3286803960800171, -0.6495874524116516, 0.2450399100780487, 0.21362002193927765, -0.8813061714172363, 0.36171799898147583, -0.5981272459030151, 0.22023095190525055, 0.48204150795936584, 0.039228349924087524, 0.2652139961719513, 0.3309468924999237, 0.31435006856918335, 0.6476902961730957, 0.1461990773677826, -0.42826908826828003, -0.6358346343040466, -1.225707769393921, -1.0615442991256714, -0.5848685503005981, 1.045215129852295, -0.25500714778900146, -0.1356879621744156, -0.4648030698299408, -0.6116331219673157, 0.8626579642295837, 0.05015871673822403, 0.7378400564193726, -0.22779692709445953, 0.05498761683702469, 0.35013797879219055, 0.36050114035606384, 0.281927227973938, 0.1269388347864151, 0.4410508871078491, -0.12266135960817337, -0.3406530022621155, -0.5867172479629517, 0.23268160223960876, 0.47169366478919983, 0.2565028667449951, -0.4686742126941681, -0.2751476764678955, 0.41795116662979126, 0.2996947169303894, -1.0136159658432007, -0.1232820525765419, 0.6701446771621704, -0.32850557565689087, 0.7674174904823303, -0.59827721118927, -0.01634226366877556, 0.2814432382583618, 0.3992713391780853, -0.07360504567623138, -0.8210018277168274, -0.3333774507045746, -0.4768155813217163, 0.7074331641197205, -0.11843489855527878, 0.7131821513175964, -0.46943074464797974, -0.03651942312717438, -0.670786440372467, 0.3107140064239502, 0.6491447687149048, 0.5324087142944336, 0.4984451234340668, -0.234671950340271, -0.6496615409851074, 0.6777531504631042, 1.1918748617172241, 0.4372308850288391, -0.02621905691921711, 0.7548332810401917, 0.210649773478508, 0.8265350461006165, -0.47159498929977417, -0.7611116766929626, 0.48486822843551636, 0.15218552947044373, -0.2919003963470459, -0.01656924933195114, 0.22809246182441711, 0.616547167301178, -0.5263352990150452, -0.34788843989372253, 0.6655542850494385, -0.1773757040500641, -0.7449374198913574, 0.0309018362313509, 0.6346811056137085, 0.6975988149642944, 0.02829461544752121, -0.13531073927879333, 0.4222738742828369, 0.10307605564594269, -0.0563340038061142, 0.25207334756851196, 0.5248977541923523, -0.6072344779968262, -0.5266807079315186, -0.7060412764549255, 0.3862263560295105, 0.4464903771877289, 0.1202012225985527, 0.21876996755599976, -0.3296630382537842, -0.44116145372390747, 0.6744883060455322, -0.35029345750808716, -0.8094200491905212, 0.4104189872741699, -0.23662322759628296, 0.18896107375621796, 0.09524863213300705, -0.16441835463047028, -0.27329251170158386, -0.4853554368019104, 0.8111015558242798, -0.7285106778144836, 0.2159801721572876, -0.035377178341150284, 0.2036222219467163, 0.9427923560142517, -0.16070689260959625, 0.6285749077796936, -0.27035555243492126, 0.5664905309677124, 0.7271051406860352, -0.22314035892486572, 0.024379372596740723, -0.278687983751297, -0.3083319664001465, 0.2483413964509964, -0.0654594823718071, 0.2549140155315399, 0.10987871885299683, -0.6683977842330933, -0.3303878903388977, 0.41997289657592773, -0.33516138792037964, -0.35441774129867554, -0.4113713502883911, -0.05865361914038658, -0.16700609028339386, 0.27202099561691284, -0.09484250098466873, 0.041159387677907944, 0.4765360653400421, 0.20817898213863373, 0.1287257820367813, -0.8242720365524292, -0.12080857902765274, -0.07384403795003891, -1.0108439922332764, 0.44126826524734497, 0.005851530469954014, 0.016006307676434517, -0.8220542073249817, -1.2491505146026611, -0.22463703155517578, -0.4889069199562073, -0.07017037272453308, -0.8384259343147278, -0.22248698770999908, 0.10158681124448776, 0.5344511270523071, 0.04748421534895897, -0.03861827775835991, -0.4931327998638153, 0.034991201013326645, 0.500737190246582, -1.1713337898254395, 0.827665388584137, -0.12759941816329956, 0.6559370160102844, 0.20587921142578125, 0.48074379563331604, 0.23221801221370697, -0.12214425951242447, -0.12228307127952576, -0.19005103409290314, -0.1042570099234581, 0.11713489890098572, -0.3737196624279022, 0.7499188780784607, 0.7000488638877869, 0.10468767583370209, -0.14755147695541382, -0.7033359408378601, -0.7547315359115601, -0.27718624472618103, 1.028832197189331, 0.09109918773174286, 0.3574710488319397, 0.13679735362529755, -0.41556137800216675, 0.5480156540870667, -1.3890796899795532, 4.058859348297119, 1.0228732824325562, 0.4538092315196991, -0.4298616945743561, 0.2570817172527313, -0.003703080816194415, 0.6524982452392578, -0.5391461849212646, 0.3580070436000824, 0.38007572293281555, -0.5218417048454285, -0.0024611246772110462, 0.1470339596271515, 0.061909470707178116, 0.6713348031044006, 0.3657715916633606, -1.3996859788894653, -0.2272701859474182, -0.3884454369544983, -0.9283105134963989, -0.11344277113676071, -0.060452792793512344, 0.19818153977394104, 0.0276352409273386, 0.31626757979393005, -0.3800465166568756, 0.4293821454048157, 0.027648121118545532, -0.4679160714149475, -0.6636645793914795, 0.12193389981985092, -0.5647422671318054, 0.39286577701568604, -0.5208662152290344, -0.6492453813552856, -0.21016554534435272, -0.5026130676269531, 0.16818754374980927, -0.46396732330322266, 0.3645498752593994, -0.33919069170951843, -0.3016967475414276, -0.24278292059898376, -0.44645360112190247, -0.6877550482749939, 0.2729221284389496, -0.8516020774841309, 0.5087624192237854, 0.3312525153160095, -0.4721834063529968, 0.8754913210868835, -0.7706772685050964, 0.9844212532043457, 0.20633552968502045, -0.9997241497039795, -0.0297610554844141, -0.434417188167572, -0.9462536573410034, 0.5668336153030396, 0.5524659752845764, 0.6675282120704651, 0.15187455713748932, -0.5122302770614624, -0.10247189551591873, 0.4432815909385681, 0.6429179906845093, 0.029492558911442757, 0.4454413950443268, 0.008879910223186016, -0.6127347350120544, -0.09358187019824982, -0.5060606598854065, -0.1755504012107849, -0.4498239755630493, 0.704694926738739, 0.7477263808250427, -0.020081114023923874, 0.6642971038818359, -0.4871869385242462, -0.4422256052494049, 0.11840716004371643, -0.16688159108161926, -0.08291704952716827, -0.5331859588623047, 0.0811140388250351, 0.9454473853111267, -0.22094719111919403, 0.41009554266929626, -1.034128189086914, 0.8907117247581482, 0.6235492825508118, -0.6579298377037048, 0.3275432288646698, -0.5361760854721069, 0.1919153928756714 ]
{"Title": "Epigenetic prediction of major depressive disorder", "Authors": "Barbu Miruna C., Walker Rosie M., Howard David M., Evans Kathryn L., Whalley Heather C., Porteous David J., Morris Stewart W., Deary Ian J., Marioni Riccardo E., Clarke Toni-Kim, McIntosh Andrew M.", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective DNA methylation (DNAm) is associated with environmental risk factors for major depressive disorder (MDD) but has not yet been tested for its ability to discriminate individuals with MDD from unaffected individuals. Methods Using penalized regression based on genome-wide CpG methylation, we trained a DNAm risk score of MDD (DNAm-RS) in 1,223 cases and 1,824 controls and tested in a second independent sample of 363 prevalent cases and 1,417 controls. Using DNA from 1,607 unaffected individuals, we tested whether DNAm-RS could discriminate the 190 incident cases of lifetime MDD from the 1,417 individuals who remained unaffected at follow-up. Results A weighted linear combination of 196 CpG sites were derived from the training sample to form a DNAm-RS. The DNAm-RS explained 1.75% of the variance in MDD risk in an independent case-control sample and significantly predicted future incident episodes of MDD at follow up (R 2 =0.52%). DNAm-RS and MDD polygenic risk scores together additively explained 3.99% of the variance in prevalent MDD. The DNAm-RS was also significantly associated with lifestyle factors associated with MDD, including smoking status (\u03b2=0.440, p=<2\u00d710 \u221216 ) and alcohol use (\u03b2=0.092, p=9.85\u00d710 \u22125 ). The DNAm-RS remained significantly associated with MDD after adjustment for these environmental factors (independent association: \u03b2=0.338, p=1.17\u00d710 \u22127 association post-adjustment: \u03b2=0.081, p=0.0006). Conclusions A novel risk score of MDD based on DNAm data significantly discriminated MDD cases from controls in an independent dataset, and controls who would subsequently develop MDD from those who remained unaffected. DNAm-RS captured the effects of exposure to key lifestyle risk factors for MDD, revealing a potential role in risk stratification.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001123"}
10.1101/19005496
[ 0.5099199414253235, 0.8841335773468018, 0.08914715051651001, 0.6818418502807617, -0.6829109191894531, 0.051951467990875244, 0.06361926347017288, -0.10317235440015793, 0.164108008146286, 1.0460941791534424, 0.5768486261367798, -0.07064312696456909, -0.19013114273548126, -0.08013438433408737, -0.16302832961082458, 0.8287597894668579, -0.2671743631362915, -0.07853001356124878, -0.4336986541748047, 0.45037102699279785, -0.3850645124912262, -0.5462107062339783, -0.44264811277389526, -0.023985762149095535, -0.03282253071665764, 0.17308247089385986, -0.5404885411262512, 0.14124563336372375, 1.1111657619476318, 0.38650020956993103, -0.2956082820892334, -0.3342404067516327, 0.6798102855682373, 0.1770031750202179, -0.2570360004901886, -0.17880308628082275, 0.6947121620178223, -0.6645870208740234, -0.17605891823768616, -0.22968707978725433, -0.08732033520936966, 0.5050018429756165, 0.3786872327327728, -0.1470583975315094, -0.14220525324344635, -0.2352098673582077, 0.05546994134783745, -0.3256368339061737, -0.03740725666284561, -0.2854600250720978, -0.35944420099258423, 0.2046092301607132, -0.3059309422969818, -0.4367789030075073, -0.8121333122253418, 0.08148703724145889, 0.20327705144882202, -0.18791672587394714, -0.40568462014198303, 0.6320165991783142, -0.12546026706695557, -0.0978165864944458, -0.1632183939218521, -1.0021613836288452, 0.4215693175792694, 0.8075132369995117, -0.5318525433540344, 0.3893551826477051, -0.06053275242447853, -1.1264891624450684, -0.26241132616996765, 0.1955128014087677, 0.0978236049413681, -0.3431110978126526, -0.2845384180545807, 0.47105780243873596, 0.49008530378341675, 0.024183399975299835, -0.21897798776626587, 0.26882898807525635, 0.4669985771179199, 0.5897542238235474, 0.5737837553024292, -0.19299975037574768, -0.1270008087158203, 0.5586416721343994, 0.06977710872888565, 0.05178194120526314, 0.3660104274749756, 0.025738388299942017, 1.0125982761383057, 0.6597101092338562, -0.6192815899848938, -0.6903508305549622, 0.31366121768951416, 0.19522912800312042, -0.4740414321422577, 0.6615868806838989, 0.45851680636405945, -0.7431843280792236, 0.5378636717796326, 0.6342373490333557, -0.030560573562979698, -0.3172767162322998, -0.545019268989563, 0.6351696848869324, 0.4906156361103058, -0.15396098792552948, 0.37973901629447937, -1.1533411741256714, 0.405009388923645, -0.05272534862160683, -0.468429833650589, -0.08066388219594955, 0.6118025183677673, 0.015363078564405441, 0.25393784046173096, 1.1457160711288452, -0.2889116704463959, 0.3590746819972992, -0.003513205563649535, 0.44827011227607727, 0.15186373889446259, -0.40888598561286926, 0.7546463012695312, -0.16356803476810455, 0.32533133029937744, 0.2609253525733948, -0.6916819214820862, 0.059263188391923904, -0.10234041512012482, -0.16456939280033112, -0.13221020996570587, 1.045546293258667, 0.19877636432647705, 0.11850937455892563, 0.1143266037106514, 0.24589599668979645, 0.7247225046157837, 0.5313116312026978, -0.5620344877243042, 0.20560257136821747, 0.193796768784523, 1.1344220638275146, -0.14348003268241882, 0.3836514353752136, -0.9957860708236694, -0.8808313012123108, -0.4158298075199127, -0.19261081516742706, -0.011311253532767296, 0.7932531237602234, -0.40082070231437683, 0.288546085357666, 0.3520788848400116, -0.10323521494865417, -0.5601818561553955, 0.10092107951641083, -0.5962879657745361, 0.8703433871269226, -0.027079463005065918, 0.3155313730239868, -0.49079611897468567, 0.4751833975315094, -0.3397373855113983, 0.4748593270778656, -0.09593390673398972, 0.04955457150936127, 0.4616628587245941, -0.7092925310134888, 1.074004054069519, 0.169454425573349, 0.2595948874950409, -0.6233924627304077, 0.08011740446090698, 0.6271979808807373, 0.8228650689125061, 0.6302317976951599, -0.1197715550661087, 0.5989578366279602, -0.19681300222873688, 0.4940488040447235, 0.4139232039451599, 0.12403150647878647, 0.4551372826099396, 0.8180099129676819, -0.02300792746245861, -0.3153223395347595, 0.4897642433643341, -0.11715909838676453, -0.005916890222579241, 0.028850475326180458, 0.03028206340968609, 1.2442511320114136, -0.09381986409425735, -0.13103023171424866, 0.26567837595939636, 0.1592431366443634, 0.5802701115608215, -0.4379202425479889, -0.16437868773937225, 0.11130332946777344, 0.21512950956821442, 0.377951443195343, -0.37866854667663574, -0.39171627163887024, 0.3619316816329956, 0.7045842409133911, -0.15662498772144318, -0.29860493540763855, 0.019612884148955345, 0.46222469210624695, -0.2764512896537781, -0.19307033717632294, 0.5719108581542969, 0.1208963617682457, 0.2931864857673645, -0.15315790474414825, 0.6004605293273926, -0.010626396164298058, -0.22120973467826843, -0.16829663515090942, 0.2925308048725128, 0.10060986131429672, -0.34871605038642883, -0.5873187780380249, 0.23609097301959991, 0.4945228695869446, -0.15617866814136505, -0.14319032430648804, 0.13070809841156006, 0.5130602121353149, 0.07059746235609055, 0.42434072494506836, 1.1906317472457886, 0.8448970913887024, 0.3515646755695343, 0.2979390621185303, 0.6067937612533569, 0.5899972915649414, 0.3722103238105774, 0.7504202127456665, 0.5480321049690247, -0.053116049617528915, -0.5880988240242004, 1.4582754373550415, 0.13027773797512054, -0.037892743945121765, -0.030470453202724457, -0.1597428023815155, -0.6494571566581726, 0.8338554501533508, -0.33604031801223755, 0.5335124731063843, -0.840794563293457, 0.5296819806098938, 0.2757808566093445, -0.6325541138648987, -0.6228399276733398, -0.40157994627952576, 0.3942604064941406, -0.2141396552324295, -0.5062744617462158, -0.14711929857730865, 0.7516989707946777, 0.4096231758594513, -0.010215849615633488, 0.026150930672883987, -0.20190373063087463, -0.240897998213768, -0.9274325966835022, -0.16978947818279266, -0.49817103147506714, -0.5221543908119202, -0.3115444481372833, -0.9632551074028015, -0.2308656871318817, -0.7440187335014343, 0.6377315521240234, -0.63503497838974, 0.01670513115823269, -0.33993181586265564, -0.25308921933174133, 0.5448447465896606, -0.07417244464159012, 0.5318716168403625, -1.007048487663269, 0.22905561327934265, -0.1576612889766693, 0.9236047863960266, -0.03461063280701637, -0.5895446538925171, -0.850623369216919, -0.2813253104686737, 0.1499880999326706, -0.5953112244606018, 0.2892928123474121, -0.12740565836429596, -0.5018916130065918, -0.5779582262039185, 0.9272736310958862, 0.1943109929561615, -0.28986719250679016, 0.3334588408470154, -0.34807658195495605, 0.39762547612190247, -0.2740729749202728, -0.28502222895622253, 0.40393775701522827, -0.24839891493320465, -0.27847981452941895, 0.785585880279541, -0.1421867460012436, 0.25143977999687195, -0.4086354076862335, 0.3922410011291504, 0.14235733449459076, 0.1616843193769455, 0.06906769424676895, -0.6515315175056458, -0.7563202977180481, -0.024895010516047478, -0.017416317015886307, -0.4095383584499359, 0.051088061183691025, 0.8476940989494324, 0.3338859975337982, -0.9150820970535278, 0.6075265407562256, -0.6216589212417603, -0.1827259510755539, -0.36891210079193115, -0.5231059193611145, 0.4045509099960327, -0.11743482947349548, 0.3652552366256714, -0.2134832888841629, 0.5388044714927673, -0.3750326633453369, -0.24952739477157593, 0.42349955439567566, -0.8295650482177734, -0.5764073729515076, 0.43375054001808167, -0.2839435040950775, 0.0364084392786026, -0.016863735392689705, -0.6396692395210266, -0.057367973029613495, -0.40361660718917847, -0.12377282977104187, -0.29988712072372437, -0.13289083540439606, -0.22759535908699036, -0.11254765093326569, 0.4118637442588806, -0.17128142714500427, -0.6937735080718994, -0.3170635402202606, 0.09655405580997467, 0.04021288454532623, 0.14372310042381287, -0.33884620666503906, -0.10093512386083603, -0.6135964393615723, -0.1745944619178772, -0.15118086338043213, 0.6533316969871521, 0.46749284863471985, -0.08182989805936813, 0.5508326888084412, 0.10113299638032913, -0.7276980876922607, -0.09888289123773575, 0.06760917603969574, 0.24632005393505096, 0.4036441147327423, 0.24192680418491364, 1.0051603317260742, -0.38999536633491516, -0.5368018746376038, 0.1525035798549652, 0.7351638078689575, 0.4707518517971039, -0.6224263906478882, -0.006446001585572958, -0.004513460677117109, -0.5468513369560242, 0.06061546504497528, -0.4417418837547302, 0.0900714322924614, 0.10747214406728745, 0.5959926247596741, -0.2681652009487152, 0.11035308986902237, -0.8022432327270508, 0.7483322024345398, 0.5262630581855774, 0.22517549991607666, 0.1503862738609314, 0.48602840304374695, -0.8162673115730286, 0.7956296801567078, 0.6085754036903381, 0.3478979468345642, -0.08421433717012405, -0.6410190463066101, 0.39341381192207336, -0.09182795882225037, -0.6259265542030334, -0.34333091974258423, -0.08340920507907867, 0.1478205919265747, -0.12083423137664795, -0.3750642240047455, 0.41075462102890015, -0.4630904197692871, 0.23463945090770721, -0.35033509135246277, -0.027198689058423042, -0.15612637996673584, -0.27124902606010437, -0.8285166621208191, 0.21578264236450195, 0.28843194246292114, -0.7691266536712646, 0.20437993109226227, -0.5664396286010742, 0.004251203965395689, 0.3367055356502533, -0.5428622364997864, -0.1533619910478592, 0.06395264714956284, -0.16739968955516815, -0.11632203310728073, 0.47798246145248413, -0.022779665887355804, 0.2563985586166382, -0.028462843969464302, -0.32652047276496887, 0.07836201786994934, -0.18770553171634674, -0.3702268600463867, 0.09060508012771606, -0.13237054646015167, 0.04277880862355232, 0.9886871576309204, 0.038696371018886566, -0.00621829042211175, -0.1329014152288437, 0.9491397142410278, -0.7704880833625793, 1.3026014566421509, -0.3393002450466156, -0.43738266825675964, -0.0988229364156723, -0.8931206464767456, 0.16196897625923157, 0.060424141585826874, 0.01914329268038273, -0.0324840284883976, -0.29065704345703125, -0.5667741894721985, 0.10049352049827576, -0.5247460603713989, 0.19916053116321564, -0.16105501353740692, 0.43530553579330444, 0.564353346824646, -1.2423334121704102, -0.14882433414459229, 0.018737783655524254, -0.008005420677363873, 0.042848140001297, 0.18379563093185425, 0.06747546792030334, -0.052721209824085236, 0.6668148636817932, -0.5235744118690491, 0.1534210741519928, -0.4548717737197876, 0.03606407344341278, -0.929047703742981, -0.2328421026468277, -0.5071445107460022, -0.18562538921833038, -0.34190621972084045, -0.10385416448116302, -0.6102288365364075, 0.2875876724720001, -0.43566545844078064, -0.8054609298706055, 0.27313560247421265, -0.7892231941223145, 0.10448240488767624, -0.8480232954025269, -0.8436864614486694, -0.3132227659225464, 0.06053736433386803, 0.30314886569976807, 0.6176191568374634, -0.38589248061180115, -0.7549111247062683, 0.5579415559768677, -0.00206041825003922, -1.0676404237747192, -0.09503977745771408, 0.14805488288402557, 0.0724167451262474, -0.2024170160293579, -0.6530572175979614, 0.4242645502090454, -1.0193670988082886, 0.046492770314216614, -0.7783844470977783, 0.29492002725601196, 0.13599373400211334, 0.5127372145652771, -0.33447641134262085, 0.4183104932308197, -0.528142511844635, -0.9177918434143066, -0.006323128007352352, 0.5443305373191833, -0.34066927433013916, -0.15809233486652374, -0.5332845449447632, -0.5268709659576416, -0.1259690225124359, -0.5337655544281006, 0.5219849348068237, -0.5647192001342773, -0.9082568883895874, -0.07465788722038269, -0.9777638912200928, 0.29567670822143555, -0.10451995581388474, -0.6445847153663635, -0.03910547494888306, -0.03022049367427826, -0.6214110255241394, -0.09544413536787033, -0.6169737577438354, 0.4364240765571594, -0.27517586946487427, 0.03810209035873413, -0.1433059722185135, 0.5758522152900696, 0.48810625076293945, -0.24624839425086975, -0.024252785369753838, -0.4289807379245758, 1.306505799293518, 0.32431256771087646, 0.08617644011974335, -1.0077961683273315, 0.05668900907039642, 0.4185545742511749, -0.626112163066864, -0.6910040378570557, -0.3625061511993408, 0.6644842624664307, -0.02014917880296707, 0.8608574271202087, -0.048161111772060394, -0.5842281579971313, -0.46961796283721924, -0.7435619831085205, 0.5727730393409729, -0.8774502277374268, 0.18439239263534546, 1.3009858131408691, 0.2903858721256256, 0.41892799735069275, -0.0899198055267334, -0.8950225114822388, -0.02776540070772171, -0.2696279287338257, -0.9667974710464478, 0.5458855032920837, 0.2774837613105774, -0.2612704932689667, -0.19225552678108215, -0.1750778704881668, -0.15024258196353912, -0.6118754148483276, 0.4823035001754761, 0.9172899723052979, -0.5748142004013062, 0.1438862383365631, -1.1396657228469849, 0.019075879827141762, 1.0928003787994385, 0.5802156925201416, 0.6235814094543457, -0.7369873523712158, 0.3468249440193176, 0.096621073782444, 0.0656462088227272, -0.49249303340911865, -0.434523344039917, 0.09443693608045578, 0.34366822242736816, -0.4703153073787689, 0.32521852850914, -0.559078574180603, -0.3955777585506439, -0.18179745972156525, 1.2535446882247925, -0.062394145876169205, 0.34342145919799805, 0.3187807500362396, -0.3067823052406311, -0.8295159935951233, 0.03547698259353638, -1.0072253942489624, -0.005433207377791405, 0.2554013431072235, 0.18838968873023987, 0.22580714523792267, -0.5735597610473633, 0.658865213394165, 0.5206305384635925, -0.4359171688556671, -0.35174664855003357, -0.0968022570014, -0.25263723731040955, 0.05463689938187599, 0.11833728104829788, -0.4850281774997711, 0.9317402243614197, 0.24568894505500793, -0.08474794775247574, -0.10858664661645889, 0.20339402556419373, 0.2487049251794815, -0.5744754672050476, 0.03241075947880745, -0.08012435585260391, -0.11854304373264313, 0.4987395107746124, -0.4772612154483795, -0.04084889218211174, -0.3124636113643646, -0.4311263859272003, 0.2931916117668152, 0.41871127486228943, 0.0395209938287735, -0.18419548869132996, 0.23941342532634735, 0.2865223288536072, 0.0005054514622315764, 0.41717788577079773, -0.17733711004257202, 0.6589789390563965, 0.5549575090408325, -0.3538476526737213, -0.4069030284881592, -0.6893811225891113, 0.6112641096115112, -0.41933757066726685, 0.6316452026367188, 0.18018311262130737, -0.2759495675563812, 0.21295005083084106, 0.4216929078102112, 0.321103036403656, -0.06728514283895493, -0.25528642535209656, 0.02705611102283001, -0.4118601381778717, 0.00997803546488285, -0.30328378081321716, -0.1894848346710205, 0.5173226594924927, -0.6700875759124756, -0.4703427255153656, 0.5742179155349731, 0.6306881308555603, 0.0012526551727205515, -0.8523582220077515, -0.0475931316614151, 0.48640942573547363, -0.6081539988517761, -1.0405793190002441, 0.06836935132741928, -0.7707918882369995, -0.41834938526153564, 0.5398392081260681, -0.05641036480665207, -0.3704659938812256, 0.3461538851261139, 1.1229499578475952, 0.04818132147192955, 0.32182690501213074, 0.10979912430047989, -0.4041280150413513, 0.20188650488853455, 0.2339591532945633, -0.11132432520389557, 0.49224546551704407, 0.6104257702827454, -0.3353809416294098, 0.5672668814659119, 0.42680823802948, -0.34541186690330505, 0.32895904779434204, 0.10149029642343521, 0.30999332666397095, -0.27897974848747253, -0.559630811214447, -0.24893298745155334, -0.24750283360481262, -0.15359798073768616, 0.20711557567119598, 0.5902369022369385, 0.008991383016109467, 0.5226905941963196, 0.27603399753570557, -0.24244378507137299, 0.2919275760650635, 0.2611660957336426, -0.09824183583259583, 0.6010682582855225, 0.5038266777992249, 0.3793770670890808, -0.21608062088489532, -0.029744960367679596, 0.09812717139720917, 0.08929882943630219, -1.1956738233566284, 0.31688910722732544, 1.3986420631408691, -0.31917816400527954, 0.25815215706825256, 0.4469037353992462, 0.11043376475572586, -0.308231383562088, -0.10939127206802368, -0.4817393124103546, 0.32651472091674805, 0.148437038064003, -0.3581375479698181, 0.234007328748703, -0.1714029312133789, -0.780655562877655, -0.7511711120605469, -0.9414165616035461, -0.6680799722671509, 0.17462292313575745, -0.5876879096031189, 0.14299625158309937, -0.6821972727775574, -0.6060346364974976, 0.1640331894159317, 0.0672241598367691, 0.5220839977264404, -0.5564513802528381, 0.6903153657913208, -0.18943442404270172, 0.3332793712615967, -0.26063987612724304, 0.24293935298919678, 0.1940435767173767, -0.030118098482489586, -1.0481204986572266, -0.9143964648246765, -0.02382039651274681, -0.5645443201065063, 0.3533812165260315, -0.09646367281675339, 0.057305075228214264, 0.2277379184961319, 0.3656436800956726, 0.048918288201093674, -0.6552179455757141, -0.28670594096183777, -1.1173864603042603, -0.13953135907649994, -0.054015565663576126, -0.20552468299865723, 0.1120884120464325, 0.7840479016304016, -0.13439764082431793, -0.8729221820831299, -0.42796480655670166, -0.6380926370620728, 0.17704766988754272, -0.23524868488311768, -0.2969055771827698, 0.08466901630163193, 0.3976213335990906, -0.5431505441665649, -0.7142930030822754, 0.7001518607139587, 0.18900951743125916, 0.13995540142059326, -0.08856043219566345, 0.08604654669761658, 0.035556014627218246, 0.3513464629650116, 0.1377554088830948, -0.1924523115158081, 0.317470520734787, 0.27863749861717224, -0.12377948313951492, 0.011891935020685196, -0.2990315854549408, 0.4893430471420288, 0.23267030715942383, -0.06219635531306267, 0.3628987669944763, 0.43350258469581604, 0.6396196484565735, 0.48566317558288574, -0.31941619515419006, 0.5812797546386719, -1.0981570482254028, -0.10265267640352249, -0.290421724319458, -0.365234375, 0.6483213305473328, 0.23848122358322144, -0.12252449989318848, 0.2895629405975342, 0.4273671805858612, -0.05383766070008278, 0.10462121665477753, 0.8506991267204285, -0.09851910173892975, -0.16961486637592316, 0.04923275113105774, 0.590392529964447, -0.008903184905648232, 0.20313796401023865, -0.15138286352157593, -0.34248796105384827, 0.18209487199783325, 0.2423330843448639, 0.10306049138307571, -0.33656013011932373, 0.35503771901130676, 0.004154563881456852, -0.597997784614563, -0.32223644852638245, 0.13246063888072968, -0.6386542916297913, -0.20049139857292175, 0.975676953792572, -1.2956794500350952, -0.12658078968524933, 0.2922782301902771, 0.3916354179382324, -0.14751237630844116, 1.0711489915847778, 0.36063528060913086, 0.049848057329654694, 0.538837730884552, -0.23669275641441345, -0.46160632371902466, 0.06314234435558319, 0.27966246008872986, -0.6404581665992737, -0.21663595736026764, 0.04777052626013756, 0.08381080627441406, 0.026356622576713562, -0.08344113826751709, 0.2550836503505707, 0.20683714747428894, -0.47099539637565613, -0.6751352548599243, -0.316558837890625, -0.3024734854698181, -0.0027225767262279987, -0.20405878126621246, 0.03430642932653427, -0.33344370126724243, 0.6964440941810608, 0.5741577744483948, -0.2550777196884155, -0.39946383237838745, -0.35852575302124023, -0.2633948028087616, -0.43766239285469055, -0.27392083406448364, -0.32245784997940063, -0.32520368695259094, -0.6497212648391724, -0.9144319295883179, 0.14678865671157837, 0.30963170528411865, -0.5155997276306152, -0.9392952919006348, 0.0993184819817543, -0.050595927983522415, 0.6726279258728027, 0.5627431273460388, -0.30567866563796997, -0.07391718029975891, -0.2787986099720001, 0.735470712184906, 0.40635913610458374, 0.3147721290588379, 0.6657644510269165, 0.28513655066490173, -0.46532559394836426, 0.2431914359331131, -0.05712031200528145, 0.025655390694737434, -0.27463945746421814, -0.7331024408340454, 0.9264214038848877, -0.2779909074306488, -0.7920340299606323, 0.07712411880493164, 0.6040381193161011, 0.6467451453208923, -0.44110941886901855, -0.5351583957672119, 0.09023614227771759, -0.5318266749382019, 0.7045271992683411, -0.13528476655483246, 0.058380529284477234, -0.07096739858388901, 0.22462621331214905, 0.42121267318725586, -0.5941013693809509, 4.47488260269165, 0.34391629695892334, 0.396759957075119, 0.3725713789463043, -0.08652897924184799, 0.5351946949958801, 0.5780810713768005, -0.17314060032367706, -0.3293270766735077, -0.4660141170024872, -0.06684961915016174, -0.06894813477993011, 0.5817903280258179, 0.16652092337608337, 0.41480472683906555, 0.33862194418907166, -0.298069566488266, -0.5940992832183838, 0.6134858131408691, -1.2076575756072998, 0.09450510889291763, 0.18431241810321808, -0.9661434292793274, -0.04711397364735603, 0.26585596799850464, 0.3431655168533325, 0.09199529141187668, 0.0935312882065773, -0.10311830043792725, -1.0052070617675781, -0.4684082567691803, -0.37693578004837036, 0.3640627861022949, -0.8960061073303223, -0.12197421491146088, -0.07585424929857254, 0.23742738366127014, -0.6810744404792786, -0.24550466239452362, -0.4334056079387665, 0.42562803626060486, -0.06603757292032242, 0.30958428978919983, -0.3613777458667755, -0.05872095376253128, 0.32654473185539246, 0.17525897920131683, 0.03527766838669777, 0.6431834697723389, -0.2194608747959137, 0.611609935760498, -0.6744503378868103, 0.4412496089935303, 0.7590134143829346, -0.865332305431366, -0.029224105179309845, 0.006245733704417944, -0.5656390190124512, 0.8243073225021362, 0.3093792200088501, 0.8847038745880127, -0.1576186567544937, -0.40251755714416504, -0.13333646953105927, -0.38328155875205994, 0.7490854263305664, 0.40182316303253174, -0.36545372009277344, -0.005693059880286455, -0.009242509491741657, -0.0407983623445034, -0.04756244644522667, 0.014785735867917538, 0.8014487624168396, 1.7052228450775146, 0.17865309119224548, 0.3480890989303589, 0.18019559979438782, -0.7518916130065918, -0.9441155195236206, 0.517890214920044, 0.4924939274787903, 0.3452928364276886, -0.222776859998703, -0.22886143624782562, 0.8399021625518799, -0.8789383172988892, -0.7586430907249451, -0.9491796493530273, 0.6387105584144592, 0.5776450634002686, -0.07943770289421082, -0.7852644324302673, -0.3021394908428192, -0.08507901430130005 ]
{"Title": "Modified Long-Axis In-Plane Ultrasound Versus Short-Axis Out-of-Plane Ultrasound For Radial Arterial Cannulation: A Prospective Randomized Controlled Trial", "Authors": "Wang Jiebo, Zhang Liangcheng, Huang Qijian, Lai Zhongmeng, Wu Guohua, Lin Lei, Liu Junle, Weng Xianfeng", "Abstract": "BACKGROUND Given a low first-pass success rate of the conventional SAX (short-axis) or LAX (long-axis) approach, ultrasound-guided radial artery cannulation in adults with radial artery diameter less than 2.2 mm may be still challenging. OBJECTIVE To assess the efficacy of modified long-axis in-plane(M-LAIP) versus short-axis out-of-plane (SAOP) or conventional palpation(C-P) approaches for ultrasound-guided radial artery cannulation. DESIGN A prospective, randomized and controlled trial. SETTING Operating room in a tertiary university hospital, from 1 July 2018 to 24 November 2018. PATIENTS A total of 201 patients (age 18 to 85 years, the diameter of the radial artery less 2.2 mm) were included. Patients with history of forearm surgery, ulnar artery occlusion, abnormal Allen test, etc, were excluded from this study. INTERVENTIONS All patients were randomized 1:1:1 to M-LAIP, SAOP or C-P. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES The primary outcome was the cannulation success rate. Secondary outcomes included first location time and cannulation time, number of attempts. RESULTS The cannulation success rate was significantly higher in the M-LAIP group than in the SAOP group or C-P group (first success rate: 80.3% vs 53.8% or 33.8%; p =0.000; total success rate: 93.9% vs 78.5% or 50.8%; p =0.000). First location time (s) was significantly longer in the M-LAIP group compared with the SAOP group (31(28-35[12-44]) vs 15(14-17[10-21]); p =0.000) and the C-P group (31(28-35[12-44]) vs 12(8-13.5 [6-37]); p =0.000). However, the time of cannulation in the M-LAIP group (29(24-45[16-313])) was significantly shorter than that in the SAOP group (45(28.5-135.5[14-346]), p =0.002) and in the C-P group(138(27-308[12-363]), p =0.000). The number of attempts decreased in the M-LAIP group compared with SAOP or C-P group (1.29\u00b10.63 vs 1.8\u00b10.89 or 2.22\u00b10.93, p =0.000). CONCLUSION The M-LAIP procedure for ultrasound-guided radial artery cannulation can offer a higher success rate of the first-attempt and total cannulation, fewer attempts and less time of cannulation. TRIAL REGISTRATION The study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov ( http://www.chictr.org.cn/index.aspx , number: ChiCTR-IOR-17011474).", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005496"}
10.1101/19007971
[ -0.49185696244239807, 0.5265616774559021, -0.23085322976112366, -0.03918728232383728, -0.5963029861450195, -0.4117541015148163, -0.7281274795532227, 0.36260491609573364, -0.15282456576824188, 0.7840823531150818, -0.8678898215293884, -0.526482105255127, -0.14157478511333466, 1.0457746982574463, -0.14432847499847412, -0.4147091805934906, -0.7222080826759338, 0.1039217934012413, 0.0814753919839859, 0.9742074608802795, 0.14167776703834534, 0.9895530939102173, -0.7187862396240234, -0.5851397514343262, -0.8251121044158936, 0.423410028219223, -0.06869503110647202, -0.8101924061775208, 1.5212202072143555, 1.1239405870437622, -0.08164949715137482, -0.6508047580718994, 1.0225751399993896, -1.1000932455062866, -0.1796427220106125, -0.11586843430995941, 0.2572563886642456, -0.24950149655342102, -0.21826580166816711, -0.29782870411872864, 0.4751339852809906, -0.4220863878726959, 0.42649751901626587, -0.9583486318588257, -0.4748411178588867, -0.42639416456222534, 0.02301192283630371, 1.101056456565857, -0.22343292832374573, 0.418459415435791, 0.2710469365119934, 0.6894482970237732, -0.03785623610019684, -0.796506404876709, -0.6934534311294556, -0.14810319244861603, -0.42930954694747925, 0.1095440611243248, -0.10635355114936829, 0.38693293929100037, -0.3393881320953369, 0.2473956048488617, 0.29489266872406006, -0.766315221786499, 0.254293292760849, 1.1707029342651367, -0.5348955392837524, 0.09122949838638306, -0.038871608674526215, 0.06871847808361053, -0.4419352114200592, -0.3242930471897125, -0.4041554033756256, -0.1493125706911087, -0.650558590888977, -0.1303161382675171, 0.10023097693920135, -0.6320740580558777, -0.44392749667167664, 0.6607249975204468, -0.2564410865306854, 0.8701343536376953, 0.22629106044769287, -0.04038230702280998, -1.0556468963623047, 0.7101917862892151, 0.051336463540792465, 0.17305640876293182, 0.3739618957042694, 1.035487174987793, -0.25133344531059265, 0.17408131062984467, 0.20668019354343414, 0.410085529088974, 0.29840248823165894, 0.7601931691169739, -0.18357163667678833, 0.09449664503335953, 0.10540399700403214, 0.14734560251235962, 0.9073424935340881, 0.9028217792510986, 0.14360983669757843, 1.119670033454895, -0.5479289889335632, 0.5047650337219238, 0.7927495837211609, -0.5965065956115723, -0.07450494170188904, -1.0252416133880615, 0.21975085139274597, 0.489623486995697, -0.6821383833885193, -0.28989556431770325, 0.8086423277854919, 0.11190763115882874, 0.5788666605949402, 0.9823264479637146, -0.8643372654914856, 0.9956024289131165, -0.23461616039276123, -0.014120050705969334, 0.4209000766277313, 0.2489367574453354, 0.7223771214485168, -0.5942889451980591, 0.004348315764218569, -0.014124521054327488, -0.303472638130188, -0.26313313841819763, 0.15459300577640533, -0.8548874258995056, -0.5680354833602905, 0.8637277483940125, 0.35377708077430725, -0.08647481352090836, 0.34567564725875854, 0.8127480149269104, 0.6747518181800842, -0.39256301522254944, 0.027982650324702263, 0.7433400750160217, -0.46468251943588257, 1.4681065082550049, 0.2939377725124359, 1.088437795639038, -0.007412740495055914, -0.2095911204814911, -0.15657971799373627, 0.3048902451992035, -0.059945035725831985, -0.017722630873322487, -0.7410717010498047, 0.18636010587215424, 0.2953653037548065, 0.1603667289018631, -0.3655121326446533, 0.31258147954940796, -0.3480343222618103, -0.0747387483716011, -0.011340812779963017, -0.5355439782142639, -0.6311418414115906, 0.07032079994678497, -0.90695720911026, 0.4001392424106598, -0.6277709603309631, 0.40938153862953186, 0.26747432351112366, -0.6145679354667664, 1.7934787273406982, -0.10670388489961624, -0.23955054581165314, 0.31700217723846436, 0.7675843834877014, 0.7115813493728638, 0.2959299087524414, -0.5188841223716736, 0.8606560230255127, 0.5660571455955505, -0.07901192456483841, 0.2844769358634949, 0.13509222865104675, 0.5119190216064453, 0.6239320039749146, -0.11343830823898315, -0.22763854265213013, -0.41858235001564026, 0.008401445113122463, -0.13961608707904816, 0.30745211243629456, 0.2816198766231537, -0.8335365653038025, 0.5922539234161377, 0.24457930028438568, -0.3520399332046509, -0.17250356078147888, 0.8673346638679504, 0.734603226184845, -0.14274540543556213, 0.3180637061595917, -0.12757521867752075, -0.36813804507255554, 0.29159700870513916, -0.6618573069572449, 0.6115140914916992, 0.16522625088691711, 0.25744473934173584, -0.5686986446380615, 0.5096128582954407, 0.7036389112472534, -0.08989271521568298, -0.4013747274875641, -0.4005991816520691, 0.6760388016700745, -0.08668020367622375, -0.26281654834747314, 0.08186879754066467, -0.41915640234947205, -0.31116777658462524, -0.049049362540245056, -0.5916528701782227, 0.6480335593223572, -0.06265416741371155, 0.5171162486076355, 0.5269762277603149, 0.0326261967420578, 0.4880872368812561, 0.04310512915253639, 0.616973340511322, 0.394592821598053, 0.2505413889884949, 0.1748897284269333, 0.9606541395187378, 0.2913169860839844, -0.13584937155246735, -0.4532945156097412, 0.25909945368766785, 0.3040046691894531, 0.013940582051873207, 1.0623407363891602, 0.6078916788101196, 0.6873056292533875, 0.07749126851558685, -0.7249169945716858, 1.1176291704177856, -0.3344724774360657, -0.18778303265571594, -0.8965067267417908, 0.26821842789649963, -0.4358806312084198, 0.7266470193862915, 0.20184791088104248, 0.3287995457649231, -0.07262446731328964, -0.14667534828186035, 0.9145374894142151, -0.49618595838546753, -0.48544156551361084, -0.7936452627182007, -0.7014605402946472, -0.02575218677520752, -0.20931479334831238, -0.4163728654384613, 0.7833777070045471, 1.2346214056015015, -0.29832741618156433, -0.02137991227209568, 0.0034321234561502934, -0.3632865250110626, -1.0779292583465576, 0.006239060778170824, -0.7635002732276917, -0.6328603625297546, -0.8555370569229126, -0.2903924286365509, 0.1899927705526352, -0.47918376326560974, 0.38686442375183105, -0.23450706899166107, -0.4564591646194458, -0.3347635567188263, -0.1911923736333847, 0.3260543942451477, 0.490609347820282, -0.15809474885463715, -0.543133556842804, 0.0012683395761996508, 0.16783976554870605, 0.2538219392299652, 0.03214078024029732, -0.07894159853458405, -0.8813413381576538, -0.7198125720024109, 0.5766178965568542, -0.4125836193561554, 0.3115764260292053, 0.5636144876480103, -0.35019487142562866, 0.13790203630924225, -0.36433839797973633, 0.48875802755355835, -0.1042575016617775, -0.2456551194190979, -0.6484930515289307, 0.13968141376972198, -0.4926213026046753, -0.22767354547977448, 0.39144831895828247, -0.058144040405750275, -0.8439616560935974, 0.48536378145217896, -0.306652307510376, -0.053170230239629745, -1.082281470298767, -0.22038768231868744, 0.9365795850753784, -0.3289279043674469, 0.19521218538284302, -0.625932514667511, -1.1051679849624634, 0.055759984999895096, 0.1732942909002304, -0.07160945236682892, -0.4613087475299835, 0.3483133316040039, 0.09730423241853714, -1.47499680519104, 0.6391699314117432, -0.782123327255249, -0.491072416305542, 0.019887559115886688, -0.014867986552417278, 0.23812833428382874, 0.14285074174404144, 0.16499939560890198, -0.3194829523563385, -0.34860074520111084, 0.15068179368972778, -0.010793526656925678, 0.5284998416900635, -0.5901580452919006, 0.21092571318149567, 0.5957902073860168, -0.1311173439025879, 0.6459325551986694, 0.7470781803131104, -0.8625377416610718, -0.15954241156578064, 0.3886789083480835, -0.24124141037464142, -0.044070541858673096, 0.6968175768852234, -0.4132521152496338, 0.04645184427499771, 0.7720089554786682, -0.6883700489997864, 0.3988196551799774, -0.1795240342617035, -0.07040992379188538, -0.14918237924575806, 0.29410043358802795, -0.36204856634140015, 0.03779425099492073, -0.6377348899841309, -0.6557672619819641, 1.292792797088623, 0.9027841091156006, 0.1939961314201355, 0.14388121664524078, 0.20932847261428833, -0.5736666917800903, -0.43990734219551086, 0.3228457570075989, 0.06969372928142548, 0.26150354743003845, 0.721517026424408, 0.30637896060943604, 1.1594974994659424, -1.2575045824050903, 0.0755717009305954, 0.14715193212032318, 1.2174893617630005, 0.5732299089431763, -0.07434812188148499, 0.9933473467826843, -0.23660366237163544, -0.16784606873989105, 0.19448810815811157, -0.20893990993499756, -0.032142095267772675, -0.4457393288612366, 0.045798271894454956, -0.2961128354072571, -0.2917453944683075, -1.0553101301193237, 0.134870707988739, 0.27853474020957947, 0.5914022922515869, 0.0316559299826622, 0.6560681462287903, -0.6020575761795044, 0.8611807227134705, 0.34922078251838684, 0.6358467936515808, 0.7763753533363342, -0.4568313956260681, 0.2798597812652588, -0.3925330936908722, -1.2032902240753174, 0.171137735247612, -0.9344440698623657, -0.07522664219141006, -0.14956757426261902, 0.17063148319721222, -0.00636525871232152, -0.865402102470398, 0.050115205347537994, -0.34588319063186646, -0.1768953949213028, 0.8285330533981323, -0.07968524098396301, -0.8543480634689331, 0.19942083954811096, 0.5598230957984924, -0.4150678217411041, 0.04689641669392586, -1.023943305015564, 0.9608519077301025, 0.4289376735687256, 0.2811603248119354, -0.2276577651500702, -0.531930148601532, 0.4488430321216583, -0.8109118342399597, 0.3229188621044159, 0.5070852041244507, -0.037378232926130295, 0.20056797564029694, -0.7358515858650208, -0.5374696254730225, -0.3750114142894745, -0.4901583790779114, -0.19181211292743683, -0.16084273159503937, -0.01755572482943535, 1.0868034362792969, 0.7926163673400879, -0.037466078996658325, -0.31390127539634705, 0.40633106231689453, -1.0875931978225708, 0.3791084885597229, -0.7385780811309814, -0.22104273736476898, -0.3007926046848297, -0.06983929127454758, 0.08049535006284714, 0.07709670811891556, 0.178150475025177, -0.9037306308746338, -0.17466652393341064, -0.1356939822435379, -0.3194807767868042, -0.5213007926940918, 1.0396279096603394, 0.2287180870771408, -0.1508966088294983, 0.9094111323356628, -0.5740079879760742, -0.28172269463539124, 0.41502219438552856, 0.12684088945388794, -0.9489883184432983, 0.31857264041900635, -0.37010616064071655, -0.10081766545772552, 0.9089760780334473, -0.6761114001274109, 0.6754973530769348, -0.3901134133338928, 0.10936475545167923, 0.2761431336402893, -0.218632310628891, -0.8444826602935791, -0.32891613245010376, -0.021342521533370018, 0.3594624102115631, -0.7227826118469238, 0.4214510917663574, 0.15544003248214722, -0.26534029841423035, -0.6486114859580994, 0.3179526925086975, -0.8095055222511292, 0.04337073862552643, 0.13712835311889648, 0.16432707011699677, 0.0577983558177948, 0.12504440546035767, 1.0425978899002075, -0.7307454347610474, -0.4918454587459564, -0.2001887708902359, 0.30635643005371094, -0.6383429765701294, -0.8259260654449463, -0.16269686818122864, -0.835139274597168, -0.10076581686735153, -0.8973758816719055, -0.027986424043774605, -0.8898379802703857, -0.5095469951629639, -0.00942409411072731, 0.23518401384353638, 0.9127287268638611, -0.13204845786094666, 0.14934755861759186, -0.06522019952535629, -0.5918745994567871, -0.3614167273044586, -0.12228140234947205, 0.9995021224021912, -0.35694190859794617, 0.4302045404911041, 0.30055826902389526, -0.8882905840873718, -0.5210167765617371, -0.5996623039245605, 0.15778207778930664, -0.8227878212928772, 0.09270244836807251, -0.21018987894058228, -0.12152166664600372, -0.4647219479084015, 0.022742759436368942, 0.6794582605361938, 0.29053062200546265, -0.09889495372772217, -0.7928480505943298, 0.2714729309082031, -0.2856368124485016, -0.02832544408738613, 0.13281553983688354, -1.041670322418213, 0.08577777445316315, 0.8797501921653748, 0.055739764124155045, -0.7883313894271851, 0.09755335003137589, 0.7920047044754028, 0.3501860797405243, 0.08637811243534088, -0.16036881506443024, -0.09169542789459229, 0.09282727539539337, 0.5594338178634644, -0.6638384461402893, -0.7782192826271057, -0.6455609798431396, 0.5072394013404846, -0.5918694734573364, 0.42308613657951355, 0.2273281067609787, -0.23873913288116455, 0.589547872543335, -0.12998028099536896, 1.1095176935195923, 0.25924426317214966, 0.7115558981895447, -0.4371263384819031, -0.21193785965442657, 0.8000824451446533, 0.0514766126871109, -0.5399095416069031, -0.7430773973464966, -0.169265016913414, -1.020336389541626, 0.23937486112117767, -0.08335313946008682, -0.09471258521080017, 0.5010116696357727, -0.20550483465194702, 0.16708128154277802, -0.1385049670934677, 1.0202686786651611, 1.1715112924575806, -0.6435763239860535, 0.5258833169937134, 0.45238542556762695, 0.15523330867290497, 0.23702289164066315, 0.580834686756134, 0.46004965901374817, 0.15904538333415985, 0.3009127378463745, -0.03858446702361107, -0.4116123616695404, -0.5586163997650146, -0.4705567955970764, 0.42882099747657776, 0.9775570034980774, -0.30731597542762756, 0.600399374961853, 0.7005778551101685, -0.6467275023460388, -0.1120210736989975, 0.5587279796600342, 0.45484548807144165, -0.019588815048336983, 0.4523729085922241, -0.20474840700626373, -0.880702018737793, 0.9007537364959717, 0.04731685668230057, 0.2696385383605957, -0.08169811964035034, 0.8761611580848694, 0.12166255712509155, -0.8804461359977722, 0.12145800143480301, 0.18639890849590302, -0.198714479804039, -0.7828241586685181, -0.39020413160324097, -0.15624520182609558, 0.2813122272491455, 0.10782922804355621, -0.11021831631660461, -0.3610476553440094, -0.8115660548210144, 0.6406760215759277, 0.052893269807100296, -0.3006964325904846, 0.2347385436296463, 0.14290060102939606, 0.41426992416381836, -1.3978585004806519, 0.2429172396659851, 0.23189926147460938, -0.16869303584098816, 0.1229250431060791, 0.13329479098320007, -0.2948610186576843, 0.5252915620803833, -0.26032623648643494, 0.15155600011348724, -0.38645806908607483, 0.02141357958316803, -0.1474112868309021, 0.21694336831569672, 0.6874885559082031, -0.1291990876197815, -0.18647006154060364, 0.8261021971702576, 0.1376166045665741, -0.9186591506004333, -0.7115733027458191, 0.46058911085128784, -0.2547571659088135, 0.2535289227962494, -0.015768256038427353, 0.02971070073544979, -0.13772916793823242, -0.3866811692714691, 0.0685877874493599, -0.6613224148750305, -0.6641972064971924, -0.7052701115608215, -0.3367099463939667, -0.01667584851384163, -0.6607128381729126, 0.34223872423171997, 0.22326777875423431, -0.48461708426475525, -1.0136414766311646, -0.21685495972633362, 0.5771988034248352, -0.5457097887992859, 0.24230283498764038, 0.07853633165359497, 0.20507214963436127, -1.1847286224365234, -0.755018949508667, -0.11777476966381073, -0.12546010315418243, -0.18060868978500366, 0.7117182016372681, -0.9396918416023254, 0.20584392547607422, -0.8161152005195618, 0.6629582643508911, 0.49468564987182617, 0.3673820197582245, -0.4936794936656952, -0.7773088216781616, -0.47086048126220703, 0.38840505480766296, 0.08746343851089478, 0.7284699082374573, 1.047019362449646, -0.6228261590003967, -0.021748345345258713, -0.2149774134159088, 0.028888700529932976, 0.03789380565285683, -0.03437426686286926, 0.31023722887039185, -0.9125754237174988, -0.2970615327358246, -0.26674917340278625, 0.6058641672134399, -1.297405481338501, -0.39759209752082825, -0.7141878008842468, -0.020792528986930847, -0.39032676815986633, -0.5608104467391968, 0.07016605138778687, 0.39508897066116333, 0.12379829585552216, 0.7649915218353271, -0.04962366446852684, 0.6086682081222534, 0.28225311636924744, -0.21367627382278442, -0.1342584192752838, 0.302619069814682, 0.5713951587677002, -1.1416627168655396, 0.6737422943115234, 1.0246248245239258, -0.19911374151706696, 0.5343965291976929, -0.3843138813972473, -0.15562616288661957, 0.3156750798225403, -0.10126259177923203, -0.07077369838953018, 0.7585951089859009, 0.3398014307022095, 0.6018792986869812, -0.6101492047309875, -0.6217755675315857, -0.21890170872211456, -0.29942718148231506, -0.6516088843345642, 0.14163383841514587, 0.2450760304927826, -0.5806617140769958, -0.4007025957107544, -0.16508904099464417, -0.8511562347412109, 0.010937094688415527, 0.12349782139062881, -0.5745169520378113, 0.10352082550525665, 0.8280100226402283, -0.4141935706138611, 1.064180612564087, 0.2309519499540329, 0.516586422920227, 0.1765402853488922, 0.09078766405582428, -0.9790511131286621, -0.8698097467422485, -0.41498127579689026, 0.40169692039489746, -0.12140319496393204, -0.14584150910377502, -0.2938815653324127, 0.8785067796707153, -0.775527834892273, -0.25080952048301697, -0.9240506291389465, 0.3851741552352905, -0.5183880925178528, -0.4480005204677582, 0.5083169937133789, 0.2286679595708847, -0.05474887415766716, 0.19026339054107666, -0.0624893456697464, -0.5646634101867676, -0.74416583776474, -0.14154092967510223, 0.6717009544372559, 0.5431181788444519, 0.10616369545459747, -0.1418677568435669, 0.6458500027656555, -0.21377058327198029, -0.3123585283756256, 0.21415267884731293, 0.7172155380249023, 0.14389915764331818, 0.27048465609550476, 0.41119384765625, -0.5168671011924744, 0.6105199456214905, -0.5692840218544006, -0.6412030458450317, 0.6075553297996521, 0.019703848287463188, 0.10511541366577148, 0.32128670811653137, -1.0449916124343872, 0.13478662073612213, -0.24889734387397766, -0.20059338212013245, 0.020932508632540703, -0.006326484028249979, 0.8744845986366272, 0.7558673620223999, -0.24403886497020721, 1.029884696006775, -0.636820375919342, -0.4381354749202728, 0.467732310295105, -0.4023256003856659, 1.1015537977218628, 0.04599819332361221, -0.15023104846477509, 0.00478480476886034, 1.041643500328064, 0.684898316860199, -0.9897142052650452, 0.11096500605344772, -0.0596240870654583, -0.04169975221157074, -1.1207640171051025, 0.8476895689964294, -0.23636619746685028, -0.5450301170349121, -0.10842768847942352, -0.31209784746170044, 0.030692707747220993, -0.02379751205444336, -0.24621422588825226, -0.4100719690322876, 0.7455137372016907, -0.01829865202307701, -0.6097578406333923, -0.05341152846813202, 0.4460026025772095, -0.19970743358135223, 0.2984326183795929, 0.21806037425994873, -0.06339312344789505, -0.045808345079422, -0.31389954686164856, 0.3801668882369995, 0.02985423244535923, 0.3361447751522064, 0.6351518630981445, 0.14696857333183289, 0.1548689752817154, 0.8412147760391235, 0.0040137553587555885, -0.03224487975239754, -0.27582889795303345, 0.00089278444647789, -0.0950779989361763, -0.3679659366607666, 0.02004076912999153, 0.17197822034358978, -0.40836969017982483, -0.647495448589325, 0.11174650490283966, 0.40662747621536255, -0.4069410264492035, -0.9821242690086365, 0.1776101291179657, -0.2110861837863922, 0.2451009452342987, -0.9056927561759949, 0.6902807950973511, -0.020191021263599396, 0.5074047446250916, 0.1391795575618744, -0.2563370168209076, -0.8915395140647888, 0.09984400868415833, -0.44401976466178894, 0.9802893400192261, -0.368028461933136, -0.5110280513763428, -0.8568976521492004, -0.7742056846618652, 0.05304919183254242, -0.168124258518219, -0.42704883217811584, -0.6342368721961975, 0.35695093870162964, 0.8883013129234314, 0.5535610914230347, 0.4479890763759613, 0.396470308303833, -0.18697723746299744, 0.3077545166015625, 0.623700737953186, -0.04578830674290657, 0.022529060021042824, -0.4346067011356354, -0.1258726865053177, -0.38011202216148376, 0.3570500612258911, -0.43288734555244446, 0.17453289031982422, -0.6281587481498718, -0.17583885788917542, 0.16793537139892578, -0.3454459309577942, -0.8024402856826782, 0.49526235461235046, 0.16751569509506226, -0.30582523345947266, -0.38721251487731934, 0.025963015854358673, -0.3604305684566498, -0.6647663116455078, 0.4546183943748474, -0.5415670275688171, 0.14603258669376373, 0.5425629019737244, -0.14245839416980743, 0.3929784297943115, -0.44400233030319214, 4.122004985809326, 0.7187418341636658, -0.10370130836963654, -0.5073441863059998, 1.1697016954421997, 0.14874528348445892, 0.8322616219520569, -0.24315783381462097, -0.004362412728369236, -0.42302417755126953, -0.07475890219211578, 0.36340397596359253, 0.3154506981372833, -0.36912697553634644, 0.3538860082626343, -0.07981382310390472, -0.46064817905426025, 0.3783847689628601, -0.21000732481479645, -0.6019214987754822, -0.41351518034935, 0.8592919707298279, -0.028177611529827118, 0.377280056476593, 0.12475945055484772, 0.09384863823652267, 0.44050508737564087, -0.04487263411283493, 0.5386641025543213, 0.07854339480400085, -0.007334937807172537, -0.5584737062454224, 0.24975146353244781, -0.6911693215370178, -0.7035855650901794, 0.18253323435783386, 0.26246848702430725, 0.1517273336648941, 0.0324057973921299, -0.546938419342041, 0.18057996034622192, 0.6146102547645569, -0.5332335233688354, -0.3751424252986908, 0.04211216792464256, 0.612562358379364, -0.2701853811740875, -0.26743006706237793, 0.6491365432739258, -0.07523699849843979, 0.47144147753715515, -0.3533429801464081, 0.14726710319519043, 0.31446728110313416, -1.161800742149353, 0.27539926767349243, 0.5457508563995361, -1.1363204717636108, 0.27618536353111267, 0.23131325840950012, 0.6684874296188354, -0.23084384202957153, 0.13669557869434357, 0.08231646567583084, 0.024831008166074753, -0.15533144772052765, -0.2098565250635147, -0.7680846452713013, -0.12163109332323074, -0.14746180176734924, -0.06255029141902924, -0.5154482126235962, 0.055620040744543076, -0.4283152222633362, 0.8740772604942322, 0.07509235292673111, 0.021395830437541008, 0.902792751789093, -0.17208419740200043, -0.5094552040100098, 0.2608523368835449, -0.5460801124572754, 0.035750579088926315, -0.6457337737083435, 0.1761980801820755, 0.3325231969356537, -0.09201630204916, -0.3061699867248535, -0.6813856363296509, 0.26673582196235657, 0.6008772850036621, -0.2715781033039093, 0.527421236038208, 0.22300010919570923, -0.0551932118833065 ]
{"Title": "Optimizing the deployment of ultra-low volume and indoor residual spraying for dengue outbreak response", "Authors": "Cavany Sean M., Espa\u00f1a Guido, Lloyd Alun L., Waller Lance A., Kitron Uriel, Astete Helvio, Elson William H., Vazquez-Prokopec Gonzalo M., Scott Thomas W., Morrison Amy C., Reiner Robert C. Jr., Perkins T. Alex", "Abstract": "Abstract Recent years have seen rising incidence of dengue and large outbreaks of Zika and chikungunya, which are all caused by viruses transmitted by Aedes aegypti mosquitoes. In most settings, the primary intervention against Aedes -transmitted viruses is vector control, such as indoor, ultra-low volume (ULV) spraying. Targeted indoor residual spraying (TIRS) has the potential to more effectively impact Aedes-borne diseases, but its implementation requires careful planning and evaluation. The optimal time to deploy these interventions and their relative epidemiological effects are not well understood, however. We used an agent-based model of dengue virus transmission calibrated to data from Iquitos, Peru to assess the epidemiological effects of these interventions under differing strategies for deploying them. Specifically, we compared strategies where spray application was initiated when incidence rose above a threshold based on incidence in recent years to strategies where spraying occurred at the same time(s) each year. In the absence of spraying, the model predicted 361,000 infections [inter-quartile range (IQR): 347,000 \u2013 383,000] in the period 2000-2010. The ULV strategy with the fewest median infections was spraying twice yearly, in March and October, which led to a median of 172,000 infections [IQR: 158,000 \u2013 183,000] over the 11-year study period, a 52% reduction from baseline. Compared to spraying once yearly in September, the best threshold-based strategy utilizing ULV had fewer median infections (254,000 vs. 261,000), but required more spraying (351 vs. 274 days). For TIRS, the best strategy was threshold-based, which led to the fewest infections of all strategies tested (9,900; [IQR: 8,720 \u2013 11,400], a 94% reduction), and required fewer days spraying than the equivalent ULV strategy (280). Although spraying twice each year is likely to avert the most infections, our results indicate that a threshold-based strategy can become an alternative to better balance the translation of spraying effort into impact, particularly if used with a residual insecticide. Author Summary Over half of the world\u2019s population is at risk of infection by dengue virus (DENV) from Aedes a egypti mosquitoes . While most infected people experience mild or asymptomatic infections, dengue can cause severe symptoms, such as hemorrhage, shock, and death. A vaccine against dengue exists, but it can increase the risk of severe disease in people who have not been previously infected by one of the four DENV serotypes. In many places, therefore, the best currently available way to prevent outbreaks is by controlling the mosquito population. Our study used a simulation model to explore alternative strategies for deploying insecticide in the city of Iquitos in the Peruvian Amazon. Our simulations closely matched empirical patterns from studies of dengue\u2019s ecology and epidemiology in Iquitos, such as mosquito population dynamics, human household structure, demography, human and mosquito movement, and virus transmission. Our results indicate that an insecticide that has a long-lasting, residual effect will have the biggest impact on reducing DENV transmission. For non-residual insecticides, we find that it is best to begin spraying close to the start of the dengue transmission season, as mosquito populations can rebound quickly and resume previous levels of transmission.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007971"}
10.1101/19002220
[ 0.06109242141246796, 0.4920058846473694, -1.1295331716537476, 0.16836391389369965, -0.5153725147247314, -0.42111316323280334, -0.1665196269750595, -0.32006365060806274, -0.04173163324594498, 0.835675835609436, 0.1970077008008957, -0.969987154006958, 0.33024242520332336, 0.029623443260788918, -0.7134240865707397, 0.19888663291931152, -0.6430415511131287, -0.730331540107727, -0.759457528591156, 0.051376692950725555, 0.15525782108306885, 0.5764545798301697, -0.4488852024078369, -0.07794205844402313, -0.4528394341468811, 0.22956132888793945, 0.01751689426600933, -0.3547735810279846, 1.5776671171188354, 0.5873273611068726, 0.4772358238697052, -0.6703090071678162, 0.7496108412742615, -0.5406985282897949, 0.10303587466478348, -0.24138472974300385, 0.2742922306060791, -0.5106281042098999, -0.4312905967235565, -0.5683854222297668, 0.5610530376434326, 0.05275692418217659, 0.1957314908504486, -0.27000951766967773, -0.1849260777235031, -0.3121444880962372, 0.13287419080734253, -0.30547380447387695, -0.011615325696766376, 0.6424048542976379, -0.0792677104473114, 0.3059365153312683, 0.28631889820098877, -0.0643293634057045, -0.5003244280815125, 0.15762044489383698, -0.35761967301368713, 0.10225559771060944, -0.3951946496963501, -0.07491597533226013, 0.05044851824641228, 0.17340585589408875, 0.3122509717941284, -1.1819255352020264, 0.30633166432380676, 0.42509880661964417, -0.07438705861568451, -0.03501478210091591, -0.25121328234672546, -0.5767176151275635, -0.3369129002094269, -0.14682883024215698, -0.735116183757782, -0.4947252869606018, -0.10130570083856583, -0.587433397769928, 0.15639951825141907, -0.4200039505958557, -0.5315623879432678, -0.26444756984710693, -0.16743019223213196, 0.14582186937332153, 0.7677597403526306, 0.0013250692281872034, -0.8103364706039429, 0.5777068734169006, 0.012440408580005169, -0.6378758549690247, 0.16028647124767303, -0.0386088564991951, 0.07317742705345154, 0.0757492184638977, 0.16357003152370453, -0.3405219316482544, 0.10188015550374985, 0.5589310526847839, -0.01920795813202858, 0.03669748082756996, 0.895480215549469, -0.34017398953437805, 0.7826760411262512, 0.5700454711914062, -0.5090300440788269, 0.470368355512619, -0.13452820479869843, 0.29791727662086487, 0.5688068866729736, -0.20183664560317993, -0.5097421407699585, -0.7633354067802429, -0.12285565584897995, -0.005397194530814886, -0.5609645247459412, 0.2610708177089691, -0.11080572754144669, 0.44393303990364075, 0.30848684906959534, 1.0124268531799316, -0.18498504161834717, 0.2606752812862396, 0.37929368019104004, 0.006462832912802696, 1.3043522834777832, -0.5215779542922974, 0.4586890637874603, 0.18594597280025482, 0.6553520560264587, 0.3712104558944702, -0.4488075077533722, 0.04572818800806999, 0.210615873336792, -0.214305117726326, 0.03318670764565468, -0.08109688013792038, -0.26936206221580505, -0.43548259139060974, 0.16407400369644165, 0.10643577575683594, 0.12458805739879608, 0.15986071527004242, -0.7684032917022705, 0.3653737008571625, -0.10122181475162506, 1.4972511529922485, -0.32400983572006226, 0.9995054602622986, -0.7916139960289001, -0.7589612603187561, -0.484268456697464, -0.08843553811311722, -0.3604923188686371, 0.025553369894623756, -1.0204118490219116, 0.7442488074302673, 0.15916690230369568, -0.250053733587265, -0.7851455807685852, 0.31659409403800964, 0.41579192876815796, 0.10879354178905487, -0.3997247815132141, -0.07626476883888245, 0.17138245701789856, 0.7545874118804932, -0.8586850166320801, 0.7382744550704956, -0.3921857476234436, 0.23300467431545258, 0.6289905309677124, -0.767227828502655, 0.6584888100624084, 0.16149280965328217, -0.12249226868152618, 0.003130042226985097, 0.39417144656181335, 0.8930163979530334, 1.4993538856506348, -0.1527373343706131, 0.4168463945388794, 0.4760977625846863, 0.10645198076963425, 0.43560007214546204, 0.09961439669132233, 0.5680557489395142, 0.6923024654388428, 0.025528335943818092, -0.1829378604888916, -0.23620222508907318, -0.5586346983909607, -0.5528622269630432, -0.9790868759155273, 0.3400231599807739, -0.5465217232704163, -0.014401545748114586, -0.23325861990451813, -1.1860569715499878, -0.6950948238372803, -0.033626291900873184, -0.16202005743980408, -0.5778074264526367, -0.7220740914344788, -0.03406514972448349, 0.007946294732391834, 0.9051523208618164, 0.09017200767993927, 0.6926386952400208, 0.3415641784667969, -0.127035453915596, -0.1137244701385498, 0.7807222604751587, 0.7269499897956848, -0.33691656589508057, 0.2143171727657318, -0.679182767868042, 0.6794217824935913, -0.8142861723899841, -0.33249324560165405, 0.43098026514053345, -0.7172847986221313, 0.47926199436187744, 0.4726924002170563, -0.08322267234325409, 0.2137608528137207, 0.36648479104042053, -0.17917579412460327, 0.16247868537902832, 0.9210540652275085, 0.11508426070213318, -0.3522588312625885, 0.12020761519670486, -0.5944083333015442, 0.5428475737571716, 0.24319598078727722, 0.8996825814247131, 0.8785103559494019, 0.351247102022171, 0.2591884434223175, 0.8684777617454529, 0.03423313796520233, 0.26436489820480347, 0.3986022472381592, 0.46238380670547485, 0.4942328631877899, -0.1733197122812271, -1.0273349285125732, 0.8178611993789673, -0.3046392500400543, -0.21268096566200256, -0.43042853474617004, -0.35109493136405945, 0.09502854943275452, 1.1155240535736084, 0.10880742967128754, 0.8660116195678711, -0.5840052366256714, -0.4006441831588745, 0.08994729816913605, -0.010851775296032429, -0.4647640287876129, -0.45730262994766235, -0.48795104026794434, -0.15294742584228516, -0.35515883564949036, -0.07028522342443466, 1.2471524477005005, 1.2589138746261597, 0.007125903852283955, 0.26187431812286377, 0.1860426366329193, -0.13732092082500458, -0.9618134498596191, -0.1282145082950592, -1.6393108367919922, -0.4592083990573883, -0.9481720924377441, 0.1393844485282898, 0.21543098986148834, -0.28121858835220337, 0.2914397120475769, -0.0910181924700737, -0.3218942880630493, -0.588693380355835, 1.089262843132019, 0.9109341502189636, 0.35570740699768066, -0.5829014778137207, -0.7298426628112793, -0.017926648259162903, -0.25137558579444885, 0.06276610493659973, -0.03382835537195206, -1.0402123928070068, -0.5807621479034424, -0.48247623443603516, 0.8462373614311218, -0.19465669989585876, -0.11197582632303238, 0.8833300471305847, -0.2820407748222351, 0.40617993474006653, -0.2472531497478485, -0.09247837960720062, -0.5787594318389893, 0.2183557003736496, -0.6215294599533081, 0.5937936305999756, 0.17602506279945374, 0.11483334004878998, 1.0687930583953857, 0.6063452959060669, -0.3376517593860626, 0.47554758191108704, 0.4940180480480194, 0.2966631054878235, -0.7838606238365173, -0.4279138445854187, 0.7646861672401428, -0.2855125665664673, 0.8124257922172546, -0.05627337843179703, -0.85654217004776, 0.3912373185157776, -0.5676119923591614, -0.48283883929252625, 0.19386082887649536, 0.5574405789375305, -0.011479916982352734, -1.2497508525848389, -0.2765728235244751, -0.7255045771598816, -1.3781312704086304, -0.20223264396190643, 0.2124490588903427, -0.31733351945877075, 0.3105482757091522, 0.5655903816223145, -0.42798125743865967, 0.06523660570383072, -0.42989015579223633, -0.6948765516281128, 0.24591664969921112, -1.1874644756317139, -0.0034761973656713963, 0.30678337812423706, 0.19272959232330322, 0.32515954971313477, 0.9547523260116577, -0.6668230295181274, 0.47053101658821106, 0.8687871694564819, -0.3526270389556885, -0.1587526500225067, 0.6954697370529175, -0.6151155829429626, -0.7042357325553894, 0.7091967463493347, -0.28540173172950745, -0.8536798357963562, -0.018710099160671234, 0.4188561737537384, 0.15090270340442657, -0.6974154114723206, -0.09527689218521118, -0.03408951312303543, -0.911967933177948, -0.47419074177742004, 0.1560068279504776, 0.5198851823806763, 0.9980965852737427, 0.3338414132595062, 0.20299240946769714, 0.022088944911956787, -0.3930506110191345, -0.16799701750278473, 0.16940386593341827, -0.6780011653900146, 0.7615978717803955, 0.8390523195266724, 0.7707546353340149, -0.7547175288200378, 0.12768815457820892, 0.9699744582176208, 0.8032769560813904, 0.7974275350570679, 0.23049217462539673, 0.3977094292640686, -1.1209936141967773, -0.03244706988334656, 0.2702440619468689, -0.4541361331939697, 0.18881955742835999, -0.3339487910270691, 0.8038762211799622, 0.6563997268676758, -0.8480362296104431, -0.11049676686525345, -0.21092289686203003, 0.5133313536643982, 0.46733301877975464, 0.10244323313236237, 0.5222167372703552, -0.20491266250610352, 0.4611041843891144, 0.519088625907898, 0.27422839403152466, 0.2070493996143341, -0.9420888423919678, 0.4891386926174164, 0.5455078482627869, -0.8438591361045837, -0.5540422201156616, -0.6015210747718811, -0.47661522030830383, -0.18145596981048584, 0.00027836079243570566, -0.2948867976665497, -0.23960301280021667, -0.5091293454170227, -0.4611864686012268, -0.4042690694332123, 0.8563568592071533, -0.47777649760246277, -1.084375262260437, -0.25234317779541016, -0.048327911645174026, 0.28483274579048157, 0.031078778207302094, -0.7503498196601868, 0.9367794990539551, 0.566480278968811, -0.5140769481658936, -0.2986113131046295, -0.31163927912712097, -0.16504812240600586, -0.5713430047035217, 0.3455471098423004, 0.4136964976787567, -0.31259480118751526, -0.12589170038700104, -0.29999640583992004, -0.21283087134361267, -0.6967375874519348, -0.7913867235183716, -0.6431081891059875, 0.23576368391513824, 0.4567505717277527, 0.721918523311615, 0.24220311641693115, 0.11261089891195297, 0.6168226599693298, 0.7629537582397461, -0.919646143913269, 0.6855378150939941, -0.7038624286651611, -0.30183932185173035, -0.4829033315181732, 0.10243286937475204, -0.0567723773419857, -0.25326868891716003, -0.1299389749765396, -0.157000333070755, -0.0674251988530159, 0.16401273012161255, 0.03486435487866402, -0.3689773380756378, 0.6591117978096008, 0.10447379946708679, 0.3504747152328491, 1.3765720129013062, -0.4575473368167877, -0.25772780179977417, 0.5448766946792603, -0.05261656641960144, -0.67708420753479, -0.017817268148064613, 0.25963664054870605, -0.1722276657819748, 0.33491793274879456, -0.4467546343803406, 0.19279597699642181, -0.6165444254875183, 0.3189486265182495, 0.6097686290740967, 0.6717221140861511, 0.061009734869003296, -0.7222319841384888, 0.02202489599585533, -0.2263934314250946, -0.847659707069397, 0.5117734670639038, 0.20708096027374268, -0.08370832353830338, -0.351322740316391, 0.7075487375259399, -0.5545212626457214, -0.7169594168663025, -0.4769565463066101, 0.0737510696053505, -0.5432108044624329, 0.08793135732412338, 0.867493748664856, -1.2341259717941284, -0.5003405809402466, -0.29247328639030457, 0.9165528416633606, -0.5652986764907837, -0.6835526823997498, 0.4863004982471466, -0.6276004910469055, -0.08264463394880295, -0.3098272383213043, 0.3740963637828827, -1.198305606842041, -0.8176079392433167, 0.1713375747203827, 0.3139464557170868, 0.40694141387939453, 0.41416630148887634, -0.44104698300361633, 0.318433940410614, -0.5325310230255127, -0.25634387135505676, 0.4537452161312103, 0.32281479239463806, 0.21291843056678772, 0.5355966687202454, -0.20054222643375397, -1.1018778085708618, 0.05355239287018776, -0.9191955327987671, 0.3932185173034668, -0.8006467819213867, 0.3438749313354492, 0.11077883094549179, -0.11025681346654892, 0.2840007245540619, 0.20647206902503967, -0.7618491649627686, 0.8994600772857666, 0.3392052948474884, -0.7594671249389648, 0.5277109742164612, -0.11663401871919632, -0.2487611025571823, 0.12504594027996063, -0.7765306234359741, -0.09875974804162979, 1.5126932859420776, 0.0809289813041687, 0.44389885663986206, 0.09821475297212601, 0.22606155276298523, 0.6317194700241089, -0.07171792536973953, -0.4273938834667206, -0.17230406403541565, 0.4895128309726715, 0.6931993365287781, 0.014874711632728577, -0.1308135688304901, -0.5342185497283936, 0.8206849694252014, 0.25561249256134033, 0.16992506384849548, 0.2787938714027405, 0.1804674118757248, 0.5030761361122131, -0.9238739609718323, 0.9972828030586243, -0.03535085916519165, 0.4465796649456024, 0.17337460815906525, 0.04052484780550003, 0.2334599792957306, -0.4052199721336365, -0.2935886085033417, -1.630345106124878, -0.35379114747047424, -1.568188190460205, 0.16615045070648193, 0.14892859756946564, 0.011297134682536125, 0.018927691504359245, -0.43084195256233215, -0.7170444130897522, -0.9961407780647278, 0.5125260353088379, 0.5327774286270142, -1.2179968357086182, -0.601116955280304, -0.15909461677074432, 0.644325315952301, 0.9767146110534668, 0.3914332091808319, -0.01490563340485096, -0.115831159055233, 0.05208152160048485, 0.29406216740608215, -0.9833340048789978, -0.9920498728752136, -0.33074384927749634, 0.3779214918613434, 0.9512194395065308, -0.027193529531359673, 0.1478947550058365, -0.14978784322738647, -0.25205740332603455, -1.0947606563568115, 0.7646855115890503, -0.24898555874824524, -0.1267196387052536, 0.7955794334411621, 0.11225752532482147, -0.2853030264377594, 0.14743594825267792, -0.011484033428132534, -0.11836046725511551, 0.500274121761322, 1.4448049068450928, 0.5677574872970581, -1.7135640382766724, 0.5504748821258545, 0.5766303539276123, -0.7720754146575928, -0.10961999744176865, -0.12753042578697205, -0.6637585163116455, -0.7865994572639465, -0.322354257106781, -0.27219653129577637, 0.6712580323219299, 0.07245692610740662, 0.6131777167320251, -0.021300001069903374, 0.19442220032215118, 0.5949068069458008, 0.1114373728632927, 0.5110246539115906, -0.5764718651771545, -0.2785573899745941, 0.2439441978931427, -0.4288623332977295, 0.13784030079841614, 0.4653848111629486, 0.25319036841392517, 0.16885167360305786, 0.2976611256599426, 0.6940832138061523, -0.6472060084342957, 0.3929952383041382, 0.175678089261055, 0.3317120671272278, 0.6679903864860535, 0.47851476073265076, -0.48033103346824646, 1.1173009872436523, 0.3147611618041992, -0.5593301653862, -0.629273533821106, 0.5468044281005859, -0.4086310863494873, 0.1074991300702095, -0.5875855684280396, -0.5187042951583862, 0.6294217705726624, 0.18923522531986237, 0.1348651498556137, -0.6699897050857544, -0.6621113419532776, 0.011210508644580841, -0.34177476167678833, -0.12589235603809357, -0.9936016201972961, 0.003939781337976456, 0.4416874051094055, -0.6453468203544617, -0.8541571497917175, -0.30647337436676025, 0.45309263467788696, -0.6317278146743774, -0.09059382230043411, -0.6398892402648926, 0.6383598446846008, -0.7193378806114197, -0.6493402123451233, -0.6128631830215454, 0.12832853198051453, -0.8515329957008362, 0.9245237708091736, -0.5081459283828735, -0.27829045057296753, -0.1269732564687729, 0.24853713810443878, 0.05999772623181343, 0.922402024269104, -0.22769103944301605, 0.006566524971276522, -0.2706773579120636, 0.8937146067619324, -0.27606895565986633, -0.18708421289920807, 1.2520110607147217, -0.406796932220459, 0.6858208179473877, 0.33467400074005127, 0.20593735575675964, 0.05524292588233948, 0.11794496327638626, -0.04743080958724022, -0.3797629177570343, -0.3335117697715759, -0.47451281547546387, -0.09852536022663116, -0.6200839877128601, -0.12009062618017197, -0.4893604516983032, -0.6183542609214783, -0.17185617983341217, -0.14115063846111298, -0.19324079155921936, 0.5332618951797485, 0.04169229790568352, -0.23436829447746277, 0.1592724323272705, 0.8192930817604065, 0.28448399901390076, 0.3268492817878723, 0.37346741557121277, 0.12610331177711487, 0.33718687295913696, -0.938015341758728, 0.6235148310661316, 0.5307388305664062, 0.20671935379505157, 0.25498315691947937, -0.006043930072337389, 0.4940871000289917, 0.20946432650089264, 0.02119101956486702, 0.4721285104751587, 0.6371691226959229, 0.14972202479839325, 0.10448192059993744, -0.08709750324487686, -0.25877392292022705, -0.17816339433193207, -1.3935019969940186, -1.0520613193511963, -0.5881149768829346, 0.558331310749054, -0.8339071273803711, -1.0005911588668823, -0.3850156366825104, -0.7610809803009033, 1.005330204963684, -0.18814240396022797, -0.2946682572364807, -0.14526893198490143, 0.786409854888916, 0.12267354875802994, 0.43782368302345276, -0.1966925412416458, 0.19350649416446686, -0.20550677180290222, 0.21513567864894867, -0.5070461630821228, -0.9283139109611511, 0.08203016966581345, 0.5591748952865601, 0.5841971635818481, -0.27530601620674133, -0.6096157431602478, 0.01230224035680294, -0.13472755253314972, -0.276163786649704, 0.02948790416121483, 0.4560246169567108, 0.07421430200338364, 0.42773881554603577, -0.11167211085557938, 0.2518100440502167, 0.0915088802576065, -0.13611255586147308, 0.4659726023674011, -1.1309164762496948, -0.11354056000709534, -0.05402122065424919, 1.3353750705718994, 0.43058058619499207, 0.018150590360164642, 0.11235400289297104, 0.7731937170028687, -0.3097399175167084, -0.04733145236968994, 0.45131683349609375, 0.605451762676239, -0.5774726867675781, 0.26494884490966797, 0.46605628728866577, 0.699920117855072, 0.17824262380599976, 0.08108790963888168, -0.8413857817649841, 0.44607090950012207, 0.38764694333076477, 0.3808172643184662, 0.13669425249099731, -0.6650903224945068, 0.3266723155975342, -0.0006324602290987968, -0.7108713984489441, 0.3984813690185547, 0.2753487825393677, 0.9576162695884705, 0.4891563653945923, 0.3080143928527832, 0.42982059717178345, -0.8940558433532715, 0.07901329547166824, -0.25646573305130005, 0.28074657917022705, 0.43912550806999207, 0.054017964750528336, 0.3159107267856598, 0.08688203990459442, 0.5335076451301575, 0.28746873140335083, 0.14749056100845337, 0.4879552125930786, -0.32038694620132446, 0.2859049439430237, -0.6145328283309937, 0.9129076600074768, 0.01707702875137329, -0.2182544469833374, 0.439566969871521, -0.20329071581363678, -0.16278837621212006, -0.056846313178539276, -0.039063386619091034, -0.2224789559841156, 1.3720431327819824, -0.42261433601379395, 0.20815277099609375, 0.4444494843482971, -0.11185472458600998, -0.36978840827941895, 0.07746976613998413, 0.7467103004455566, -0.9127926230430603, 0.035224977880716324, 0.3849234879016876, 0.13210448622703552, 0.5116143226623535, 0.293552041053772, 0.5365797281265259, -1.0134458541870117, -0.04003951698541641, -0.22804206609725952, -0.16177846491336823, -0.020387565717101097, -0.24298714101314545, -0.3563767969608307, -0.3691073954105377, -0.3878510594367981, -0.36457115411758423, 0.3226621747016907, -0.07732074707746506, -0.10971321165561676, 0.5459877252578735, -0.2048734873533249, -0.1703232377767563, -1.2212899923324585, -0.4133814573287964, -0.5219834446907043, -0.2951931059360504, -0.20941764116287231, 0.11988519132137299, 0.4934956431388855, -0.6230739951133728, -0.5637235045433044, -0.45486634969711304, -0.6139289736747742, 0.42275896668434143, -0.5156868100166321, 0.519791305065155, -0.0017749413382261992, 0.2199847251176834, -0.6653113961219788, -1.3136807680130005, 0.2769075632095337, -0.37391072511672974, 0.35512134432792664, -0.5839942693710327, -0.32487747073173523, -0.02653517760336399, 0.8959185481071472, 0.4095795452594757, 0.2956816852092743, 0.06711780279874802, 0.39194878935813904, 1.2618601322174072, -0.15438784658908844, 0.4302521347999573, -0.0448840893805027, -0.15258251130580902, -0.02754449099302292, 0.41822299361228943, -0.016910146921873093, -0.5246793031692505, -0.12973949313163757, -0.09475316107273102, 0.23825807869434357, 0.09027284383773804, -0.8852730989456177, 0.9130098223686218, 0.021431939676404, -0.6790193319320679, -0.1445361077785492, -0.23918446898460388, -0.43637436628341675, -0.6959336996078491, 0.39651480317115784, -0.5562081336975098, -0.5419840812683105, -0.38042306900024414, -0.0007768914219923317, 0.5122660994529724, -0.862521767616272, 4.012508869171143, 1.4162671566009521, 0.5859962105751038, -0.46881091594696045, 0.11778246611356735, 0.4836682379245758, 0.19762808084487915, 0.11563513427972794, -0.00846888404339552, -0.2042195200920105, 0.008089901879429817, 0.8394257426261902, 0.33557650446891785, 0.4028148055076599, 0.2772429287433624, 0.474370539188385, -0.5433435440063477, -0.04849221929907799, 0.24060915410518646, -0.582277238368988, -0.03521250560879707, 0.186767578125, -0.5386389493942261, 0.5994898676872253, 0.2802622318267822, 0.31986236572265625, 0.5214011669158936, -0.0867217481136322, 0.0612613782286644, -0.16681735217571259, 0.632438600063324, -0.4016297161579132, 0.3276628255844116, -0.7559123039245605, -0.33982527256011963, 0.18782849609851837, 0.861642062664032, -0.6588189005851746, -0.07044825702905655, 0.022521911188960075, 0.6591307520866394, -0.4712211489677429, -0.13349264860153198, -0.16376443207263947, -0.21204665303230286, 0.14513961970806122, -0.02049880661070347, -0.15849296748638153, 0.12213394790887833, -0.06484785676002502, 0.8645449280738831, -0.372765451669693, -0.3016025722026825, -0.12628258764743805, -1.2185879945755005, 0.3896421492099762, -0.212571918964386, -0.7480505704879761, 0.6442534923553467, 0.27714061737060547, 0.7001568078994751, -0.24902644753456116, -0.2645565867424011, -0.12147261947393417, -0.22425071895122528, 0.2660912275314331, 0.037888891994953156, 0.21445851027965546, -0.16210350394248962, -0.396163672208786, -0.062029849737882614, -0.9005934000015259, -0.7407253980636597, -0.42857006192207336, 1.003610372543335, 0.3324930667877197, -0.5661308765411377, 0.8998953104019165, -0.1861036717891693, -0.4852977991104126, 0.03481506183743477, 0.029695238918066025, 0.54732745885849, -0.5508086085319519, 0.3277379870414734, 0.9243918657302856, -0.29025739431381226, -0.2809804081916809, -1.05672287940979, 0.30114638805389404, 0.9691367745399475, -0.25129446387290955, -0.22633686661720276, 0.6075521111488342, -0.4201813042163849 ]
{"Title": "HIV-associated sensory neuropathy continues to be a problem in individuals starting tenofovir-based antiretroviral treatment", "Authors": "Pillay Prinisha, Wadley Antonia L, Cherry Catherine L, Karstaedt Alan S, Kamerman Peter R", "Abstract": "Abstract HIV-associated sensory neuropathy (HIV-SN) is a common and often painful neurological condition associated with HIV-infection and its treatment. However, data on the incidence of HIV-SN in neuropathy-free individuals initiating combination antiretroviral therapies (cART) that do not contain the neurotoxic agent stavudine are lacking. We investigated the six-month incidence of HIV-SN in ART na\u00efve individuals initiating tenofovir (TDF)-based cART, and the clinical factors associated with the development of HIV-SN. 120 neuropathy-free and ART na\u00efve individuals initiating cART at a single centre in Johannesburg, South Africa were enrolled. Participants were screened for HIV-SN at study enrolment and then approximately every two-months for a period of approximately six-months. Symptomatic HIV-SN was defined by the presence of at least one symptom (pain/burning, numbness, paraesthesias) and at least two clinical signs (reduced vibration sense, absent ankle reflexes or pin-prick hypoaesthesia). Asymptomatic HIV-SN required at least two clinical signs only. A total of 88% of the cohort completed three visits within the six-month period. Eleven individuals developed asymptomatic HIV-SN and nine developed symptomatic HIV-SN, giving a six-month cumulative incidence of neuropathy of 140 cases per 1000 patients (95% CI: 80 - 210) at an incidence rate of 0.37 (95% CI: 0.2 - 0.5) per person year. Increasing height and active tuberculosis (TB) disease were independently associated with the risk of developing HIV-SN (p < 0.05). We found that within the first six months of starting cART, incident SN persists in the post-stavudine era, but may be asymptomatic.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002220"}
10.1101/19014100
[ -0.13546022772789001, -0.10297061502933502, -0.3338834345340729, 0.3698907792568207, -0.8862037658691406, -0.7661170959472656, 0.41511499881744385, 0.3692532777786255, 0.23612555861473083, 0.9494408369064331, 0.5104358196258545, -0.39382848143577576, 0.32526344060897827, -0.24971133470535278, 0.3316621482372284, -0.0027816530782729387, -0.7555832862854004, 0.34971028566360474, 0.004453149624168873, 0.061215028166770935, 0.06564085185527802, 0.624186635017395, -0.7155675292015076, 0.09026675671339035, -0.22046969830989838, 0.3161396384239197, -0.22400367259979248, 0.24640381336212158, 0.9891753792762756, 0.7894302606582642, -0.46687743067741394, 0.1947377622127533, 0.136705219745636, 0.027470316737890244, -0.5397836565971375, 0.038857605308294296, 0.5638477206230164, -0.13398988544940948, 0.4106600284576416, -0.41761910915374756, 0.08505523949861526, 0.4043009579181671, 0.36128395795822144, -0.539592444896698, -1.0966181755065918, -0.5688135623931885, 0.025909187272191048, -0.8025499582290649, -0.12918226420879364, -1.1142014265060425, -0.23416195809841156, 0.029063835740089417, -0.06357244402170181, -0.37985989451408386, 0.15936397016048431, 0.03276024013757706, 0.6226832270622253, -0.042849477380514145, -0.5243578553199768, 1.208659052848816, 0.717671811580658, -0.2017342448234558, 1.1374986171722412, -0.8543552160263062, 0.5686312913894653, 0.7560260891914368, -0.43092015385627747, -0.0746883749961853, -0.5439091324806213, 0.0753725990653038, -0.521870493888855, -0.7999074459075928, -0.03043348528444767, -0.3676045835018158, -0.4893893301486969, -0.37246081233024597, 0.14050647616386414, 0.14736749231815338, -0.021604428067803383, -0.436994343996048, -0.2190745323896408, -0.0630762055516243, 0.20981746912002563, 0.5234255790710449, 0.10954862087965012, 0.130207821726799, 0.36160826683044434, 0.6627588868141174, -0.017715690657496452, 0.12947013974189758, -0.06672648340463638, 0.33157631754875183, -0.11989811062812805, 0.06638403981924057, 0.512924075126648, 0.9322790503501892, -0.24093452095985413, 0.09626180678606033, 0.09822695702314377, 0.7396252155303955, -0.009299064055085182, 1.1433418989181519, -0.30833131074905396, 0.9955573081970215, -0.3104364275932312, 0.03669770807027817, 0.6490136384963989, -0.3212188482284546, 0.1577848345041275, -1.3891974687576294, -0.09462378174066544, -0.06223619356751442, -0.1831447035074234, -0.44981327652931213, 0.24829594790935516, 0.731489896774292, 0.0014346453826874495, 0.4113102853298187, -0.030122149735689163, 0.6118117570877075, -0.16471941769123077, -0.2648388147354126, 0.2582390606403351, -0.38406768441200256, 0.667125940322876, -0.09625140577554703, 0.26213744282722473, 0.2793687582015991, -0.33843541145324707, -0.8294710516929626, 0.12929454445838928, -0.2847385108470917, 0.36812782287597656, 0.6936962008476257, -0.40213724970817566, 0.0558181032538414, -0.16227780282497406, 0.45299404859542847, 0.19592654705047607, -0.20339757204055786, -0.030684523284435272, 0.5571670532226562, -0.2120402455329895, 0.9017408490180969, -0.13954323530197144, 0.7800395488739014, -0.7563232779502869, -1.2545139789581299, -0.5158132910728455, -0.05872812122106552, 0.02734346129000187, 0.3755318522453308, -0.6199273467063904, -0.4616791307926178, 0.22979174554347992, -0.4215082824230194, -0.38821181654930115, 0.7282824516296387, -0.0488777682185173, 0.6259369850158691, 0.23220539093017578, 0.5911308526992798, -0.21320931613445282, 0.6626554727554321, -0.5998673439025879, 0.5196574926376343, 0.4088698625564575, -0.47572216391563416, 0.15425485372543335, -0.31428053975105286, 0.7855450510978699, -0.0034471487160772085, -0.4786544442176819, -0.6027378439903259, 0.5111081600189209, 0.7863892316818237, 0.7060021758079529, -0.24444983899593353, 0.2523130476474762, 0.45496293902397156, 0.39826491475105286, 0.1759723573923111, 0.14570185542106628, 1.224134087562561, 0.7123107314109802, 0.4367305040359497, -0.5818301439285278, -0.3835057318210602, -0.12220233678817749, -0.27169159054756165, 0.07381494343280792, 0.15178871154785156, -0.2252553254365921, 1.3969274759292603, -0.19850575923919678, 0.19311566650867462, -0.309393972158432, -0.3448185622692108, 0.8544290065765381, -0.1829744130373001, -0.22010110318660736, 0.7532839179039001, -0.3741459250450134, 1.1251592636108398, 0.5775690078735352, 0.1102290228009224, 0.2557094395160675, 0.3666115701198578, -0.47183293104171753, 0.7049009799957275, -0.33934709429740906, 0.11722046136856079, -0.6192335486412048, -0.1831381469964981, 1.220808982849121, -0.3936389684677124, -0.8431573510169983, 0.15173174440860748, -0.360477477312088, -0.6807295083999634, 0.05738825723528862, 0.28696078062057495, 0.20395676791667938, 0.03258424624800682, 0.09196385741233826, -0.33176389336586, 0.10328426212072372, 0.6012675762176514, -0.272331178188324, -0.06472137570381165, 0.37013787031173706, 0.8185101747512817, -0.08570076525211334, 0.8549875020980835, 1.246372938156128, 0.2736450135707855, 0.2409510761499405, 0.19492243230342865, 0.3512760102748871, 0.3436759412288666, 0.4092327356338501, 0.28846168518066406, 1.375791311264038, 0.8683622479438782, -0.793705403804779, 0.5279625058174133, -0.19230131804943085, 0.09359946846961975, 0.12304168939590454, 0.6950003504753113, 0.14867524802684784, 0.5701974034309387, 0.2741484045982361, 0.34182843565940857, -0.5393167734146118, 0.20271772146224976, 0.2812342047691345, 0.0951024666428566, -0.3614629805088043, -0.7056331038475037, -0.5355363488197327, 0.2533397376537323, 0.06977781653404236, -0.037882570177316666, 0.5948901772499084, -0.5207833647727966, -0.04828538000583649, -0.08096221089363098, 0.47134554386138916, -0.16719196736812592, -0.7278628349304199, 0.08061569184064865, -0.7694087624549866, -0.7431658506393433, -0.8588958978652954, -0.024717269465327263, 0.010056525468826294, -0.4542292356491089, -0.04953794926404953, -0.16472643613815308, 0.12089613825082779, -0.39817026257514954, -0.27003154158592224, 0.800765872001648, -0.057048652321100235, 0.7122786641120911, -0.6273297667503357, -0.11998286843299866, -0.5761935114860535, -0.2421473115682602, -0.38188600540161133, -0.558422327041626, -0.7159103751182556, -0.5753037929534912, 0.36240091919898987, -0.6420615911483765, -0.11613181233406067, -0.27514132857322693, -0.6370829939842224, -0.867655873298645, 0.2926758825778961, -0.13865001499652863, 0.5134298801422119, 0.2911492884159088, -0.5416423082351685, 0.8647116422653198, 0.18427743017673492, 0.4172045886516571, 0.6214520335197449, 0.39057958126068115, -0.6935458779335022, 0.6063655614852905, -0.053878311067819595, 0.14584970474243164, -0.6265130043029785, -0.3231673240661621, 0.5641998648643494, -0.503128707408905, 0.09572508186101913, -0.5037655234336853, -1.216681957244873, 0.03919489309191704, 0.4972095787525177, -0.13462570309638977, -0.2730656862258911, -0.27254894375801086, 0.3439033031463623, -1.1606260538101196, -0.30508068203926086, -0.27224108576774597, -0.4129484295845032, -0.1849411278963089, -0.3585267663002014, 0.9969469904899597, 0.01557934656739235, -0.4133111834526062, -0.3171771764755249, -0.46913576126098633, 0.6264148950576782, -0.28755131363868713, 0.5100146532058716, -0.8325318098068237, -0.3704359531402588, -0.13196980953216553, -0.42533156275749207, -0.013015217147767544, -0.490561306476593, -0.292280912399292, -0.325895756483078, -0.28493139147758484, -0.7033303380012512, 0.6901870965957642, 0.3571981191635132, -0.21708272397518158, 0.15873290598392487, 0.6697160005569458, -0.11396466195583344, -0.021166879683732986, -0.19172562658786774, -0.002286400180310011, -0.09488774836063385, 0.07460848242044449, -0.12076755613088608, 0.505692183971405, -0.35814207792282104, -0.2887670695781708, 0.9161278605461121, -0.2307528257369995, 0.6199228167533875, -0.25443118810653687, 0.46169164776802063, -0.23320388793945312, 0.4474579095840454, 0.04395994916558266, 0.33671095967292786, -0.24570250511169434, 1.0447909832000732, 0.14207503199577332, 1.1263580322265625, -0.7087317705154419, 0.20358486473560333, 0.28223252296447754, 1.4060752391815186, -0.016664082184433937, -0.00900715496391058, 0.18950875103473663, -0.6659671664237976, 0.7090108394622803, 0.20783355832099915, -0.6886756420135498, -0.05966531112790108, -0.7847383618354797, -0.13601717352867126, 0.2825492322444916, -0.9132649302482605, -0.5092219710350037, 0.21482808887958527, 0.02524837665259838, 0.1005561351776123, -0.5563490986824036, 0.37769392132759094, 0.14955012500286102, -0.2075437307357788, 0.05298848822712898, 0.23850007355213165, 0.07675494998693466, -0.29350927472114563, 0.07058335840702057, -0.4111669361591339, -0.7944338321685791, -0.3089980483055115, -0.08007428050041199, 0.3561822772026062, 0.12712761759757996, 0.01929708570241928, 0.32166433334350586, 0.06821682304143906, -0.27008017897605896, 0.4785999059677124, 0.20639288425445557, -0.25929298996925354, 0.2671390771865845, -0.542163610458374, -0.26952436566352844, -0.37428000569343567, -0.10202863812446594, -0.32064521312713623, -0.6967923045158386, 0.8391270637512207, 0.7863186001777649, -0.28205132484436035, -0.7863929867744446, -0.2465144544839859, 0.23551712930202484, -0.8123571276664734, -0.27531957626342773, 0.23379254341125488, -0.2413775771856308, 0.6835694909095764, -0.2551318407058716, -0.08864368498325348, -0.5143466591835022, -0.5247947573661804, 0.47949206829071045, 0.2691570222377777, 0.056965213268995285, 0.8604532480239868, 0.782402515411377, 0.25276896357536316, -0.21928562223911285, 0.5602580308914185, -0.8683342933654785, 0.8047279715538025, 0.23819494247436523, -0.5428041815757751, 0.055325865745544434, -0.1739339530467987, -0.1408109962940216, -0.09248317033052444, -0.19428057968616486, -0.6522578001022339, 0.1780892014503479, -0.3366175889968872, 0.2384619563817978, -0.2600348889827728, 0.34927797317504883, -0.8227260708808899, 0.15975038707256317, 0.7298868298530579, -0.7268251180648804, -0.3645159900188446, -0.32731181383132935, -0.18871358036994934, -0.8883164525032043, 0.38498616218566895, -0.1814952939748764, 0.34297046065330505, 0.3118394613265991, -0.6866500377655029, 0.3053366243839264, 0.14785759150981903, 0.693500280380249, -0.04572444409132004, -0.2899533808231354, -1.0100764036178589, -0.31649133563041687, -0.5976841449737549, -0.014007138088345528, -0.49211588501930237, 0.8606621623039246, -0.6663311123847961, -0.9705721735954285, -0.225092813372612, -0.3304043710231781, -0.08597515523433685, -0.34487804770469666, -0.09052897244691849, -0.05999179556965828, -0.340752512216568, -0.27081170678138733, 0.48543432354927063, -0.6856285929679871, -0.9969448447227478, 0.17981788516044617, 0.4517313539981842, -0.7906342148780823, -0.2087688446044922, -0.7100422978401184, 0.6014246344566345, -0.4314514696598053, -0.1446801871061325, -0.29522982239723206, -0.38153237104415894, 0.2015935182571411, -0.23771071434020996, -0.352173775434494, -0.157978355884552, -0.2911252975463867, -0.3792448341846466, 1.1151601076126099, -0.26513391733169556, -0.9450636506080627, -0.7044777274131775, 0.1666768342256546, -0.37169259786605835, 0.47045132517814636, -0.7156087756156921, -0.8853288292884827, -0.552483320236206, -1.4157274961471558, 0.19354407489299774, -0.4502614438533783, -0.17384982109069824, -0.2506398856639862, -0.44099366664886475, 0.3178445100784302, 0.1999744325876236, 0.15061113238334656, 0.7616407871246338, 0.08216799050569534, -0.4135967493057251, 0.09727220982313156, -0.5202060341835022, 0.22788767516613007, -0.2588655650615692, -0.3699023425579071, 0.1535770446062088, 0.9438826441764832, 0.7483236789703369, -0.01272036973387003, -0.3875267505645752, -0.4437916576862335, 0.36223161220550537, -0.02486777864396572, -0.07919339835643768, 0.004508679267019033, -0.10155122727155685, 0.8021073937416077, -0.1170254796743393, -0.9627636671066284, -1.2116390466690063, 1.1646727323532104, -0.8480657339096069, -0.017804881557822227, -1.0551543235778809, -0.15739265084266663, -0.18989139795303345, -0.3523384928703308, 0.7325137853622437, 0.04318563640117645, 0.4217838644981384, -0.03278689086437225, 0.0819733515381813, 0.43202871084213257, 0.2917386293411255, -1.3629674911499023, -0.599877655506134, -0.5070675015449524, -0.9590409398078918, 0.6464694738388062, 0.1374349445104599, -0.36515796184539795, 0.1338174045085907, -0.5245358347892761, 0.08212770521640778, -0.18917560577392578, 1.3452025651931763, 0.782436192035675, -1.392605185508728, 0.038856297731399536, 0.42815834283828735, 0.19637680053710938, 0.7662563323974609, 0.022349132224917412, 0.09579785913228989, -0.6249712109565735, 0.5087752938270569, -0.3577161133289337, -0.6733096241950989, -0.5167041420936584, -0.38763001561164856, -0.03900108486413956, 0.8157224059104919, -0.10141348093748093, 0.41017645597457886, 0.008008548989892006, 0.03137108311057091, -0.4767780900001526, 1.0729402303695679, 0.5311914086341858, -0.10980379581451416, 0.716637134552002, -0.2650209665298462, -1.0684971809387207, 0.1656133532524109, 0.05795459821820259, 0.06794470548629761, -0.08591002225875854, 0.16106155514717102, 0.401319682598114, -1.548083782196045, 0.5526607036590576, 0.22374099493026733, -0.7291049957275391, 0.11773839592933655, 0.1877024620771408, -0.35165882110595703, -0.08947098255157471, -0.34367573261260986, -0.561484694480896, 0.4966655969619751, 0.6700214147567749, 0.6942844986915588, -0.062015898525714874, 0.022892745211720467, -0.26816850900650024, -0.6831126809120178, 0.23243306577205658, -0.31533995270729065, 0.04519089311361313, 0.5778845548629761, 0.18570776283740997, 0.6002241373062134, -0.6584199666976929, 0.44771096110343933, -0.13508166372776031, 0.17936038970947266, 0.7784324288368225, -0.503180205821991, -0.5940049290657043, -0.009120346046984196, 0.19843044877052307, 0.17673900723457336, -0.23814253509044647, -0.4139425754547119, 0.5438831448554993, -0.520877480506897, -0.3385579288005829, -0.13588495552539825, 0.5590017437934875, 0.4517444968223572, 0.6353772282600403, -0.06096700578927994, -0.496929794549942, 0.8730344772338867, 0.603300154209137, 0.3893864154815674, -0.3350470960140228, -0.674064040184021, -0.7703145742416382, -0.36581951379776, -0.37905624508857727, -0.13927488029003143, -0.76753169298172, 0.4170849621295929, 0.02876283973455429, -0.8820255398750305, 0.44547179341316223, 1.4275023937225342, 0.02931397035717964, 0.4142666459083557, -0.34495487809181213, 0.45155069231987, -0.5821011662483215, -0.2796119451522827, -0.2859478294849396, -0.8469611406326294, -0.22276951372623444, 1.0870753526687622, -0.14977337419986725, -0.14363908767700195, 0.2973223030567169, 0.6432781219482422, -0.22916527092456818, -0.04219716787338257, -0.2931976318359375, -0.6576350331306458, 0.18601061403751373, 0.13001695275306702, 0.37493741512298584, -0.2589075267314911, 0.5578955411911011, -0.1028883084654808, 0.0964370146393776, 0.3747691810131073, -0.008884415961802006, 0.1601901650428772, 0.6945838332176208, 0.17039832472801208, -0.7780954241752625, -0.33938825130462646, -0.19215986132621765, -0.4055687487125397, -0.4672805070877075, -0.10334161669015884, -0.10328330099582672, 0.24577170610427856, 0.2242315262556076, 0.1269405335187912, 0.4186896085739136, 0.4069550037384033, 0.2720351219177246, 0.03859197720885277, 0.13279636204242706, 0.8388189077377319, 0.6277433633804321, -0.40702638030052185, 0.4084151089191437, 0.5204746723175049, 0.6090787053108215, -0.607123076915741, 0.16004560887813568, -0.14683493971824646, -0.013887560926377773, 0.059720948338508606, 0.17870107293128967, -0.2633986473083496, -0.17019912600517273, 0.000917681201826781, -0.39779457449913025, 0.47533202171325684, -0.29834792017936707, 0.3428123891353607, 0.4799647927284241, -0.2355772703886032, -0.5483276844024658, -0.0706811472773552, -1.205389380455017, -0.7195464372634888, 0.3876653015613556, -0.972549319267273, -0.7139183282852173, -0.698710560798645, -1.011743187904358, -0.14510515332221985, -0.20577429234981537, 0.6579469442367554, -0.2672697603702545, 0.6784422397613525, 0.2215345799922943, 0.6118037700653076, 0.6549624800682068, -0.3715376555919647, -0.08977148681879044, 0.25311538577079773, 0.08115299791097641, -0.4101603031158447, 0.2127511203289032, -0.48316332697868347, 0.8250091075897217, -0.2832142114639282, -0.5256713032722473, -0.2408321052789688, 0.577207624912262, -0.39895978569984436, -0.2819473445415497, 0.07516135275363922, -0.7262321710586548, -0.4728415310382843, 0.48609432578086853, 0.06988006830215454, -0.3061753809452057, 0.6307088136672974, 0.042077723890542984, -1.092478632926941, -1.1169120073318481, -0.031067417934536934, 0.8498417139053345, -0.08951965719461441, -0.030830109491944313, -0.008736580610275269, 0.16624198853969574, 0.15745873749256134, 0.06639768183231354, 0.8437793254852295, 0.1619737595319748, 0.40384146571159363, 0.39000454545021057, -0.37095046043395996, -0.2196888029575348, 0.8091888427734375, 0.4787534773349762, 0.4747786521911621, 0.43259820342063904, -0.08503769338130951, 0.0049368892796337605, 0.08482152223587036, -0.7201581001281738, 0.6946409344673157, 0.03414791077375412, -0.4516594111919403, 0.21513423323631287, 0.2155969887971878, 0.5077404975891113, 0.27892357110977173, -0.9803338050842285, -0.27468767762184143, -1.0676555633544922, -0.8515517711639404, -0.3589992821216583, -0.8988704085350037, 1.031105637550354, -0.11862469464540482, 0.6056926250457764, 0.15893955528736115, -0.05886845290660858, -0.49604332447052, -0.08755362778902054, 0.6602311730384827, 0.022691592574119568, -0.5827849507331848, -0.32221633195877075, 0.6158478260040283, -0.13873063027858734, 0.39030706882476807, -0.7378303408622742, -0.44330036640167236, 0.8144322633743286, 0.5740305185317993, 0.9171087145805359, 0.3631230890750885, 0.0946856141090393, -0.40522363781929016, -0.2124851644039154, -0.13602189719676971, -0.5708572268486023, -0.0020330622792243958, -1.027643084526062, 0.3806994557380676, 0.04753363877534866, -0.010224366560578346, -0.26524969935417175, 0.4923797845840454, 0.08399724960327148, 0.6732304096221924, 0.8207353949546814, -0.5833315253257751, 0.33818596601486206, 0.6233539581298828, -0.32662373781204224, -0.42334070801734924, -0.4189295470714569, 0.10514353960752487, 0.3436645269393921, -0.18803419172763824, -0.1941913515329361, -0.03351235389709473, 0.22787874937057495, -0.06057382747530937, 0.24234697222709656, -0.03699060529470444, -0.8308092355728149, -1.3242570161819458, -0.19846922159194946, -0.37126296758651733, 0.8688519597053528, 0.35209357738494873, -0.07362768054008484, -0.08672019839286804, 0.21891961991786957, 0.07489211857318878, 0.14091922342777252, -0.09412907063961029, -0.023775942623615265, -0.850631594657898, 0.17866989970207214, -0.1027006059885025, -0.7034898400306702, -0.7848361730575562, -0.9330227971076965, 0.23513339459896088, 0.4907616674900055, 0.4326881468296051, -1.4908360242843628, 0.08765463531017303, 0.33858364820480347, 0.7050498723983765, -0.0275300033390522, -0.5749638676643372, -0.121388740837574, 0.34200212359428406, 0.8235880136489868, 0.2038128674030304, 0.5062605738639832, 1.1548913717269897, -0.04204864054918289, 0.35402634739875793, 0.22653231024742126, 0.6521379351615906, 0.4531845152378082, 0.04469050467014313, 0.40972381830215454, 0.4619430899620056, 0.2066306471824646, -0.5389589667320251, 0.18771417438983917, 1.167108178138733, -0.715010941028595, -0.11440720409154892, -0.07395429909229279, -0.6588011384010315, -0.25250422954559326, 1.3724174499511719, -0.46110647916793823, 0.285099059343338, 0.4195236563682556, 0.12169676274061203, 0.37556660175323486, -1.2000678777694702, 4.194831848144531, 0.9131576418876648, 0.708096444606781, 0.16010332107543945, 0.31613194942474365, -0.04647945240139961, 0.8914415240287781, 0.17203743755817413, 0.32573074102401733, -0.2940366566181183, 0.24852986633777618, 0.7847229838371277, -0.2412206083536148, 0.10260143876075745, 0.24637442827224731, 0.5107088685035706, -1.3281404972076416, -0.1772417277097702, -0.47636210918426514, -0.5935467481613159, -0.7735151648521423, -0.01110786758363247, -0.2885270118713379, -0.051073912531137466, -0.5160911679267883, -0.019582243636250496, 0.24996037781238556, 0.19670379161834717, -0.105061374604702, -0.8076798319816589, -0.2109820544719696, -1.0552493333816528, 0.0984441339969635, -1.162482738494873, 0.1684698909521103, 0.31217777729034424, 0.564450204372406, 0.06849773973226547, 0.3812137544155121, 0.3456018567085266, 0.39951199293136597, 0.07228507846593857, -0.22334817051887512, -0.3543837070465088, -0.05933276191353798, 0.5612032413482666, -0.34939637780189514, -0.26063546538352966, 0.3505352735519409, -0.2626883089542389, 0.9380106329917908, -1.000270962715149, 0.8239087462425232, 0.3311576247215271, -0.7679399847984314, -0.08492176234722137, -0.49217653274536133, -0.17877618968486786, 0.5100650191307068, 0.5494897961616516, 0.529811680316925, 0.09705429524183273, 0.19541658461093903, -1.0328937768936157, -0.05487201735377312, 0.6430096626281738, -0.013820587657392025, 0.2520855665206909, 0.4400349259376526, 0.18866567313671112, 0.5868779420852661, -0.14942969381809235, -0.6173046231269836, 0.029422694817185402, 0.6305528283119202, 0.32773706316947937, -0.22049011290073395, 0.3286285996437073, -0.5147271752357483, -0.6280798316001892, 0.40874895453453064, 0.38868942856788635, -0.21336302161216736, -0.40749025344848633, -0.2082444578409195, 0.8949075937271118, -0.7908648252487183, -0.32840418815612793, -0.5429063439369202, 0.5805594325065613, 0.42067670822143555, -0.23583713173866272, 0.5031963586807251, -0.8011391162872314, -0.2235253006219864 ]
{"Title": "Knowledge about benefits and risks of undergoing cataract surgery among cataract patients in Southern China", "Authors": "Ye Guofang, Qu Bo, Shi Wen, Chen Xin, Ma Pengjuan, Zhong Yuxin, Chen Shida, Lamoureux Ecosse, Zheng Yingfeng", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To develop a theoretical framework for assessing knowledge about the possible outcomes of undergoing cataract surgery, and explore the association of knowledge level with psychological status and decision quality among patients with cataract in Southern China. Methods The details of the knowledge scale were based on the health education information booklet provided by National Eye Institute, NIH. We used a theory-based approach to assess gist knowledge, which comprises conceptual and numeric questions related to knowledge of the possible surgical outcomes. The scale was then used in a cross-sectional study to assess the association of knowledge score with psychological status and decision quality of cataract patients, including worry, anxiety, attitudes, intentions, decisional conflict, confidence in decision making, anticipated regret and temporal orientation. Results A total of 489 participants with age-related cataract were included in this study, and 10.2% (50/489) of them had adequate level of knowledge. The knowledge scale was significantly associated to the levels of worry (Odds Ratio (OR) = 0.36, 95%CI: 0.18, 0.70; P = 0.003), anxiety (beta coefficient = -5.36, 95%CI: -8.88,-1.84; P = 0.003), inaction regret (OR = 0.49, 95%CI : 0.28, 0.88; P = 0.016) and decision conflict (beta coefficient = -7.93, 95%CI: -12.81, -3.04; P = 0.002) in multivariate analyses adjusted for age, sex, education level and literacy level. Conclusion The level of knowledge adequacy with cataract surgery outcomes is high in China and was associated with psychological status and decision quality. These findings suggest that strategies targeting knowledge of possible surgical outcomes may reduce psychological stress and improve decision quality among patients with age-related cataract.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19014100"}
10.1101/19005181
[ 0.2501514256000519, 0.7785338163375854, -0.18347783386707306, 0.6034582257270813, -0.6166204810142517, -0.3294881284236908, -0.07167325913906097, -0.12481571733951569, 0.017748937010765076, 0.48855140805244446, 0.11427275091409683, -0.3664161264896393, 0.005049335304647684, -0.4732094705104828, -0.6956013441085815, 0.1407850831747055, -0.8053831458091736, -0.18531903624534607, -0.4030442535877228, 0.5622150301933289, -0.208131343126297, 0.2192772626876831, -0.5123341083526611, 0.07591467350721359, -0.6486824154853821, 0.47812023758888245, -0.2031174600124359, 0.12494062632322311, 0.8075443506240845, 0.6015026569366455, 0.2161344587802887, -0.3586772382259369, -0.07109422236680984, -0.8224024176597595, -0.2215634286403656, -0.05900386720895767, 0.9456587433815002, -0.6527219414710999, -0.28294074535369873, -0.7661718726158142, -0.22364388406276703, -0.06545916199684143, 0.3345814049243927, -0.49933555722236633, -0.873558759689331, -0.9657419323921204, -0.3714866638183594, -0.046878084540367126, -0.17327898740768433, -0.7308123111724854, 0.12604200839996338, 0.6177266240119934, -0.1976650059223175, -0.020765524357557297, -0.48508813977241516, 0.07671214640140533, -0.03487763553857803, -0.3163676857948303, -0.2768251299858093, 0.43925946950912476, 0.521730363368988, -0.36622074246406555, 0.20866712927818298, -1.4444743394851685, 0.36149874329566956, 0.8228307366371155, -0.4111686944961548, -0.3212669789791107, -0.29693230986595154, 0.06665754318237305, -0.2001083493232727, -0.4976551830768585, -0.0036784764379262924, -0.4362678527832031, 0.01319881621748209, 0.2382991760969162, 0.03899592161178589, -0.16709275543689728, -0.22147122025489807, -1.3369991779327393, -0.2446511685848236, -0.02211604081094265, -0.1661878079175949, 0.15428774058818817, -0.8142492771148682, -0.09862471371889114, 0.18749354779720306, -0.36405444145202637, 0.2657562792301178, 0.25554829835891724, 0.4172966778278351, 0.3671662211418152, -0.47342953085899353, 0.405181884765625, 0.1777251958847046, 0.5016269087791443, -0.2689967453479767, -0.07489846646785736, 0.5493298768997192, -0.33476144075393677, 0.08237991482019424, 0.7604629397392273, -0.502893328666687, 1.2402304410934448, -0.47084465622901917, 0.7161430716514587, 0.8100044131278992, -0.28019019961357117, -0.2635085880756378, -0.8371636867523193, 0.7094665169715881, 0.1725665181875229, -0.28897273540496826, 0.4607654809951782, 0.33353516459465027, 0.13599678874015808, 0.278224915266037, 0.8629004955291748, -0.29393312335014343, 0.6260112524032593, -0.348264217376709, -0.228530153632164, 0.05698565021157265, -0.7522104978561401, 0.607229471206665, 0.08066899329423904, 0.4611362814903259, 0.4487336575984955, -0.5455158948898315, -0.12797363102436066, -0.29153138399124146, -0.09814833104610443, 0.08030296862125397, 0.7645254135131836, -0.47659212350845337, -0.3110817074775696, 0.07635276019573212, 0.4872051775455475, 0.5236667990684509, -0.43295371532440186, -0.3662879765033722, 0.10880641639232635, 0.2386009693145752, 1.0848242044448853, -0.12604360282421112, 0.3270491659641266, -0.5498500466346741, -0.7627116441726685, -0.2916114926338196, 0.13748131692409515, -0.1541980803012848, 0.721792459487915, 0.17271147668361664, 0.07297883182764053, 0.630088746547699, -0.3069073259830475, -0.6886662840843201, 0.7350100874900818, -1.1207785606384277, 0.0716836079955101, -0.21294623613357544, -0.12690043449401855, -0.08330272883176804, 0.7064881920814514, -0.9697606563568115, 0.31671422719955444, 0.2840418517589569, -0.21636736392974854, 0.5031096935272217, -0.549771785736084, 0.5903112888336182, 0.6068193912506104, 0.3237779438495636, -0.4216494560241699, 0.1329958140850067, 0.9910622239112854, 0.3435879051685333, 0.4569929242134094, 0.3626088500022888, 0.9071119427680969, -0.5732967257499695, 0.20198893547058105, 1.131203055381775, 0.2135198712348938, 0.2394644021987915, -0.047122057527303696, -0.37707170844078064, -0.5086272358894348, -0.15541386604309082, 0.3309759795665741, -0.2931942641735077, 0.6074071526527405, -0.2523701786994934, 0.4761154055595398, 0.19465114176273346, -0.2695901393890381, -0.38634899258613586, -0.1277897208929062, 0.10143189132213593, -0.26041245460510254, -0.489674836397171, 0.6152486205101013, 0.24864202737808228, 0.23460274934768677, -1.2434022426605225, 0.6253235936164856, 0.5773177742958069, 0.7014172673225403, -0.05082699656486511, 0.5936427712440491, 0.47205302119255066, -0.01689605787396431, 0.023352324962615967, 0.24794691801071167, 0.4966657757759094, 0.0032070125453174114, 0.22713987529277802, -0.1202048808336258, -0.2204665094614029, 0.41169223189353943, -0.09514883160591125, -0.04950878769159317, 0.6861721873283386, 0.1705075353384018, -0.19166383147239685, 0.13743342459201813, 0.30890485644340515, -0.042163390666246414, 0.31905800104141235, -0.6380489468574524, 0.4959539473056793, 0.6082544326782227, -0.17128503322601318, 0.7560901045799255, 1.1634660959243774, 0.30932050943374634, 0.35404056310653687, 0.35751986503601074, 0.6914158463478088, 0.5818451046943665, 0.2663726210594177, 0.3588208556175232, 1.061141014099121, 0.36431941390037537, 0.002842462621629238, 0.22451744973659515, -0.1372990608215332, -0.25748544931411743, -0.23409506678581238, -0.29001209139823914, -1.1226989030838013, 0.2496449500322342, 0.5344167351722717, 0.4037827253341675, -0.704185426235199, -0.07062757760286331, 0.48124364018440247, 0.18117505311965942, -0.29740703105926514, -0.6031030416488647, 0.5621406435966492, 0.07184748351573944, -0.002820221008732915, 0.08528450131416321, 0.5869414210319519, 0.715196967124939, 0.2246113121509552, 0.5207096338272095, 0.7564441561698914, -0.06304057687520981, -0.3174976408481598, -0.5355372428894043, -1.0928285121917725, -0.7760604619979858, -0.30564501881599426, -0.769066333770752, -0.08487267792224884, -0.4709151089191437, 0.46074071526527405, -0.3666253983974457, 0.8289645314216614, -0.12065298110246658, -0.12354088574647903, 0.6762759685516357, -0.07184387743473053, 0.061848826706409454, -1.1183209419250488, 0.7342285513877869, -0.11068671196699142, 0.19926047325134277, 0.5765578746795654, -0.5509751439094543, -0.6814044713973999, -1.3062418699264526, 0.32252955436706543, -1.0469470024108887, 0.47968682646751404, -0.5113765597343445, -0.1369902342557907, -0.21738645434379578, 0.6820290684700012, 0.0890195220708847, -0.4762895703315735, -0.06080169975757599, -0.5301274657249451, 0.5762302279472351, -0.33710965514183044, 0.2483399510383606, -0.07427264004945755, 0.4254896938800812, -0.6017189621925354, 0.19803401827812195, 0.5605424642562866, 0.7086783647537231, -0.6914843320846558, 0.11284355074167252, 0.7232456803321838, -0.417724072933197, -0.005548272281885147, -0.011011413298547268, -0.6818303465843201, 0.17881840467453003, -0.5026298761367798, -0.7728429436683655, -0.49343714118003845, 0.48244374990463257, -0.13980849087238312, -1.0716475248336792, -0.14976975321769714, -0.6260257363319397, -1.2425576448440552, 0.3572509288787842, -0.6315449476242065, 0.6817256808280945, 0.042096368968486786, -0.43359091877937317, -0.30946406722068787, -0.13966050744056702, 0.2448093146085739, 0.7418301105499268, 0.39404425024986267, -0.25042960047721863, -0.006754142697900534, 0.051214925944805145, -0.4859486222267151, 0.892148494720459, 0.3978330194950104, 0.014596828259527683, -0.6156406402587891, -0.121446892619133, -0.27965691685676575, 0.16432900726795197, 0.5782492756843567, -0.7065368294715881, 0.24582158029079437, 0.059267256408929825, -0.36937764286994934, -0.3665517270565033, 0.5899187326431274, 0.3605194091796875, 0.2771713435649872, 0.20333519577980042, -0.15151286125183105, 0.48342177271842957, -0.5323594808578491, -0.4316559433937073, 0.1239493191242218, 0.20898616313934326, 0.3310734033584595, -0.5612651705741882, 0.7568544149398804, -0.04034801200032234, 0.09875059872865677, -0.043669022619724274, -0.20394118130207062, 0.6458607912063599, 0.8353638648986816, 1.102549433708191, 1.1777580976486206, -0.9639915227890015, 0.19805863499641418, 0.3095510005950928, 0.003121855203062296, 0.30579325556755066, 0.3003993630409241, 0.10026080906391144, -0.8597561120986938, 0.19953621923923492, 0.1090831458568573, 0.11893530935049057, 0.6834656000137329, 0.16754040122032166, -0.7506451606750488, -0.5508959293365479, -0.8803949952125549, -0.16965794563293457, 0.05013247951865196, 0.5332090854644775, -0.7088806629180908, -0.1299680471420288, 0.3803243637084961, -0.4373449385166168, 0.23276370763778687, 0.3365669250488281, 0.3661175072193146, 0.06095341220498085, -0.3907459080219269, -0.03360307216644287, -0.2942564785480499, 0.21576151251792908, -0.3972945511341095, -0.5949065089225769, -0.6644333600997925, -0.2337401807308197, 0.1315261274576187, 0.2911297678947449, -0.4571865200996399, -0.31027868390083313, -0.5313183665275574, -0.21949270367622375, 0.07676668465137482, 0.2687455713748932, -1.1208062171936035, 0.3367939591407776, 0.2209242284297943, -0.5598678588867188, -0.4333342909812927, -0.6087694764137268, 0.3695375621318817, 0.862152636051178, -0.2587505877017975, -0.5688578486442566, -0.38830316066741943, -0.24131891131401062, -0.6929852962493896, 0.4567723274230957, -0.07124975323677063, -0.12686768174171448, 0.671267569065094, 0.39873582124710083, 0.34045177698135376, -0.5522797107696533, -0.10147818177938461, -0.4501776397228241, 0.17897391319274902, 0.34066423773765564, 0.8396374583244324, 0.2512702941894531, 1.035290241241455, 0.4186387360095978, 0.8468210697174072, -0.8069000244140625, 0.3498121201992035, -0.5722808837890625, -0.8841555118560791, 0.051651306450366974, -0.2220538854598999, -0.2616351842880249, -0.4933944642543793, -0.810373842716217, -0.2358761876821518, -0.9231314659118652, -0.4849536418914795, -0.09496951848268509, 0.18107788264751434, 0.24983318150043488, -0.5500596165657043, -0.3815721273422241, 1.212048888206482, -0.6815118193626404, 0.9161610007286072, -0.5474328994750977, -0.19225595891475677, -0.4098219871520996, 0.0015280754305422306, 0.13929371535778046, 0.44099801778793335, -0.12796102464199066, -0.2117789089679718, -0.4752328097820282, -0.1904401034116745, 0.0488024465739727, -0.2743071913719177, 0.28817281126976013, -0.4774087071418762, -0.1572587937116623, -0.5910532474517822, -0.17463281750679016, -0.5434955954551697, 0.8656648397445679, 0.38716939091682434, -0.3967192471027374, -0.18538060784339905, -0.0061169820837676525, -0.5243664979934692, -0.1201048493385315, -0.9576464295387268, 0.462108314037323, 0.7829759120941162, -0.39790111780166626, 0.28744468092918396, -1.3280081748962402, -0.6029841303825378, 0.676678478717804, 0.574163556098938, -0.650982677936554, -0.17483621835708618, -0.841037929058075, -0.40163707733154297, -0.542303740978241, -0.004995251074433327, 0.28599947690963745, -0.6709983348846436, 0.6467676162719727, -0.0254660714417696, -0.21766768395900726, 0.2757619619369507, -0.312068372964859, -0.7086893916130066, 0.9338937401771545, 0.07013639062643051, -0.8343905210494995, -0.23031267523765564, 0.2422671616077423, -0.09683854877948761, 0.27948787808418274, -0.2538006603717804, -0.4693863093852997, -0.31734248995780945, -0.8492578268051147, 0.5249207615852356, -0.7513845562934875, -0.019981494173407555, -0.2505235970020294, -0.26830142736434937, 0.23375247418880463, -0.1294059455394745, -0.5777006149291992, -0.5387465953826904, -0.14894506335258484, -0.2112596035003662, 0.8227730393409729, -0.45023858547210693, -0.2613420784473419, -0.15807172656059265, -0.4011669158935547, 0.1097448393702507, 0.6875160336494446, -0.30355966091156006, -0.2878677248954773, 0.3309403955936432, 0.03313497453927994, 0.714086651802063, 0.9498505592346191, -0.6778894662857056, -0.6587671041488647, 0.5876960754394531, 0.37017032504081726, -0.7629892230033875, -0.27524107694625854, -0.40585216879844666, 0.8719532489776611, -0.3933345377445221, 0.4170062839984894, -0.03744758293032646, -0.07263018190860748, 0.044084709137678146, -1.0994219779968262, 0.6720026135444641, -1.1674140691757202, 0.21269343793392181, 0.2871286869049072, 0.026651062071323395, -0.3124045133590698, 0.2778058648109436, -0.8957450985908508, -1.1887996196746826, -0.652086079120636, -0.6523357033729553, 0.10301508754491806, 0.11591903120279312, 0.32873818278312683, 0.004149328917264938, 0.06187417358160019, -0.3982546627521515, -0.3278532326221466, 0.4547182023525238, 0.7398166656494141, -0.43580758571624756, -0.21817868947982788, 0.13102857768535614, 0.3682010769844055, 0.8773043155670166, -0.11010179668664932, 0.3988850712776184, 0.10533655434846878, 0.11140987277030945, -0.24256272614002228, -0.3986856937408447, -1.2640800476074219, 0.27691227197647095, 0.7915903329849243, 0.6147690415382385, 0.3465379476547241, 0.2185865044593811, 0.11386936902999878, -0.6136798858642578, 0.12240543216466904, 0.7479789853096008, -0.4342867136001587, 0.23321042954921722, 0.23549431562423706, -0.4115945100784302, -0.5593665838241577, -0.43929365277290344, -0.334066241979599, 0.060277581214904785, 0.4266156852245331, -0.14917443692684174, 0.29184573888778687, -0.6273469924926758, 0.49486249685287476, 0.06262986361980438, -0.2816145122051239, -0.8753445148468018, 0.31885337829589844, -0.07658293098211288, -0.6176447868347168, -0.7129911184310913, 0.16935141384601593, 0.25786954164505005, -0.007947196252644062, -0.10584719479084015, -0.05210307985544205, 0.6245738863945007, -0.1490677148103714, -0.38586315512657166, -0.28222090005874634, -0.10256585478782654, 0.1402049958705902, 0.412777304649353, -0.07958898693323135, 0.9827417731285095, -0.19776268303394318, -0.26490938663482666, -0.09227874875068665, 0.21643222868442535, 0.24193301796913147, -0.7055683732032776, 0.14798931777477264, -0.08414814621210098, 0.04029533267021179, 0.1903042048215866, 0.8225541114807129, 0.3792388141155243, 0.8745322227478027, 0.43089744448661804, -1.1571146249771118, 0.18598584830760956, 0.6972087025642395, -0.23361915349960327, 0.8609060645103455, -0.15104301273822784, -0.16716068983078003, 0.541037380695343, 0.6140803098678589, 0.16708245873451233, 0.2554866671562195, -1.0732393264770508, -0.5635128021240234, 0.22341659665107727, 0.15393321216106415, -0.38951101899147034, -0.010877271182835102, 1.2122082710266113, -0.5591234564781189, -0.9104838967323303, -0.2765708863735199, 1.288501501083374, -0.19989611208438873, -0.14789007604122162, -0.4617307186126709, 0.09322710335254669, -0.7970648407936096, -0.6357261538505554, -0.485899418592453, -0.8968562483787537, -0.3264648914337158, 0.8435104489326477, 0.2503212094306946, -1.2928932905197144, -0.08281627297401428, 0.5167905688285828, 0.48984721302986145, 0.7564389705657959, -0.07155326008796692, 0.05708509311079979, 0.5559967756271362, 0.2568092942237854, 0.1326848715543747, 0.21229031682014465, 0.8604284524917603, -0.3027094602584839, 0.3253568708896637, -0.08444475382566452, -0.15316854417324066, -0.15729710459709167, -0.0852949395775795, 0.47079068422317505, -0.33673667907714844, -1.3264659643173218, -0.02432672120630741, 0.40843990445137024, -1.2530229091644287, -0.1007586270570755, 0.02006564661860466, 0.18734459578990936, 0.0909847542643547, 0.047838177531957626, -0.3426190912723541, 0.8876361846923828, -0.008144478313624859, 0.1160716712474823, 0.09018650650978088, 0.01747136376798153, 0.16058944165706635, 0.301187664270401, 0.39161163568496704, -0.15863871574401855, 0.12604911625385284, -1.1944139003753662, -0.21778805553913116, -0.356259822845459, -1.0606063604354858, 0.3865739703178406, -0.7132638096809387, 0.37668779492378235, -0.21042616665363312, -0.4406254291534424, 0.14061744511127472, 0.6105074286460876, -0.2854633033275604, 0.3253886103630066, 0.45466822385787964, 0.48728349804878235, -0.7861374020576477, -0.8637697696685791, -1.0256140232086182, -0.5609001517295837, 0.42956554889678955, -0.4048469662666321, -0.15845659375190735, -0.2303924858570099, -0.7074527144432068, 0.7685750126838684, 0.31698310375213623, 0.129587322473526, -0.5454655885696411, 1.0282396078109741, 0.06201799958944321, 0.801831066608429, 0.00017703333287499845, 0.17398099601268768, 0.3087003529071808, -0.12778308987617493, -0.8902586698532104, -0.03578263521194458, 0.57840496301651, 0.20459173619747162, 0.16999946534633636, -0.2018401324748993, 0.0020879467483609915, 0.21820881962776184, 0.29652681946754456, 0.16540859639644623, -0.23082974553108215, 0.3274138569831848, -0.7036933898925781, 0.13141979277133942, -0.22323472797870636, -0.021315954625606537, 0.11267979443073273, 0.7091661095619202, -0.053869377821683884, -0.3681572675704956, 0.014482337981462479, 0.06752526015043259, 1.0198216438293457, -0.5127301216125488, 0.44105634093284607, 0.1576109230518341, 0.6602250337600708, -0.5130172371864319, 0.3008233308792114, 0.19805344939231873, 0.5108505487442017, 0.17134812474250793, 0.030482793226838112, -0.2138582170009613, 1.2455412149429321, 0.4302559196949005, 0.363545686006546, 0.4485401213169098, 0.5180947184562683, 0.26243478059768677, -0.6575003266334534, 0.10208220779895782, -0.3592246174812317, 0.6411125659942627, 0.33053821325302124, 0.3855396509170532, 0.06969057768583298, 0.6382016539573669, 0.3145138919353485, -0.47781628370285034, -0.6503652334213257, -0.01803828589618206, -0.49789342284202576, -0.2012518346309662, 0.13736611604690552, 0.1295085847377777, 1.3954482078552246, 0.035434313118457794, -0.10947246104478836, -0.21119195222854614, 0.5659015774726868, 0.6321495771408081, -0.046670980751514435, 0.5266830921173096, 0.02116517163813114, -0.45021340250968933, -0.17066092789173126, 0.6725871562957764, 0.32277166843414307, -0.13111719489097595, 0.17055758833885193, 0.11948739737272263, 0.5072812438011169, 0.48373743891716003, -0.3230510652065277, -0.579239010810852, 0.5411847233772278, -0.0017473025945946574, -0.03298700228333473, -0.6338247656822205, -0.170623317360878, -0.03993279114365578, -0.3738223910331726, 0.9599051475524902, -0.014960454776883125, -0.8797075748443604, 0.806512713432312, 0.5617696046829224, -0.021360641345381737, 0.7999343872070312, 0.37229230999946594, -0.6112738847732544, 0.6210368871688843, -0.3459170162677765, -0.40287894010543823, -0.25546905398368835, -0.024111570790410042, -0.14260005950927734, -0.3045051693916321, -0.10206469893455505, 0.07951001822948456, -0.0037361804861575365, 0.17694342136383057, -0.20516665279865265, 0.7996705770492554, -0.814386785030365, 0.04964381456375122, -0.7706735134124756, 0.05059337988495827, -0.4817712604999542, -0.08035416901111603, -0.08556042611598969, -0.061061881482601166, -0.23300699889659882, -0.5044708251953125, -0.44366976618766785, -0.5369225740432739, -0.3283781409263611, -0.01537378691136837, -0.628991961479187, 0.3286140561103821, -0.3273147642612457, -0.03626067563891411, -0.8777853846549988, -0.4364146590232849, -0.4189888834953308, 0.6826450824737549, -0.45740827918052673, -0.4430907666683197, 0.579247772693634, 0.35057806968688965, 0.6388715505599976, 0.5658382177352905, 0.4136669635772705, 0.2038637399673462, 0.46897345781326294, 0.7201017141342163, -0.14327643811702728, -0.01363962423056364, 0.4687182605266571, 0.7910448312759399, 0.004306357819586992, -0.17568223178386688, 0.14762139320373535, -0.21262359619140625, -0.1488269418478012, -0.13295230269432068, -0.2627060115337372, -0.390200138092041, -0.46002069115638733, 0.18178781867027283, 0.07816138863563538, -0.9259875416755676, 0.27394264936447144, -0.5367556214332581, -0.8258144855499268, 0.10245559364557266, 1.23951256275177, -0.287625789642334, -0.0667782723903656, 0.3045540750026703, -0.15602295100688934, -0.4122295379638672, -0.6957054138183594, 4.2557549476623535, 1.2586547136306763, 0.3264707028865814, -0.6833938956260681, 1.1551588773727417, 0.45595359802246094, 0.3821805715560913, -0.4103887677192688, 0.11054482311010361, -0.3120776116847992, 0.442796528339386, -0.154676616191864, -0.5292902588844299, -0.5087184309959412, 0.40244609117507935, 0.29521599411964417, -0.08809429407119751, -0.21640357375144958, 0.007084205746650696, -0.8518010973930359, -0.34691137075424194, 0.28011175990104675, -0.150093674659729, 0.05340610817074776, -0.2648269236087799, -0.07297791540622711, 0.6417214870452881, 0.511236310005188, -0.2466428577899933, -0.04001331329345703, 0.034649234265089035, -0.4760661721229553, 0.3247024714946747, -0.39249879121780396, -0.3646908700466156, 0.677644670009613, -0.570838212966919, -0.7050549387931824, -0.5947144031524658, -0.596724808216095, 0.2634398639202118, 0.2384594976902008, -0.43411800265312195, -0.18965458869934082, -0.6486349701881409, 0.36182892322540283, -0.13025014102458954, 0.8220755457878113, 1.1634652614593506, -0.3894428014755249, 1.096648097038269, -0.8792893290519714, 0.5006283521652222, 0.4917519688606262, -1.047800898551941, 0.2399493306875229, -0.3000573217868805, -0.36447325348854065, 0.7080917954444885, 0.475644588470459, 0.33651602268218994, -0.18783171474933624, -0.4769341051578522, -0.015461619943380356, 0.12599408626556396, 0.2554188668727875, 0.17383089661598206, -0.25147655606269836, -0.2730678915977478, -0.06651068478822708, 0.45971888303756714, -0.5979405641555786, -1.0803565979003906, 1.0639917850494385, 1.0649595260620117, 0.6859509944915771, -0.05707565322518349, 0.11288068443536758, -0.5516195297241211, -0.27445095777511597, 0.3034769594669342, -0.2481321394443512, 0.63789963722229, -0.23902350664138794, -0.0690813958644867, 0.8561214208602905, -0.06153425946831703, -0.03487423434853554, -0.8038711547851562, 0.9830852746963501, 0.07798538357019424, -0.208141028881073, 0.1315993070602417, -0.5957930684089661, -0.40758946537971497 ]
{"Title": "Characteristics of Cardiac Memory in Patients with Implanted Cardioverter Defibrillator: the CAMI study", "Authors": "Haq Kazi T., Cao Jian, Tereshchenko Larisa G.", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective The goal of this study was to determine factors associated with cardiac memory (CM) in patients with implantable cardioverter-defibrillators (ICD). Methods Patients with structural heart disease (n=20; mean age 72.6\u00b111.6 y; 80% male; mean left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) 31.7\u00b17.6%; history of myocardial infarction (MI) in 75%, ventricular tachycardia (VT) in 85%) and preserved atrioventricular (AV) conduction received primary (80%) or secondary (20%) prevention dual-chamber ICD. Standard 12-lead ECG was recorded in AAI and DDD mode, before and after 7 days of right ventricular (RV) pacing in DDD mode with short AV delay. Direction (azimuth and elevation) and magnitude of spatial QRS, T, and ventricular gradient (SVG) vectors were measured before and after 7 days of RV pacing. CM was quantified as the degree of alignment between QRS DDD-7 and T AAI-7 vectors (QRS DDD-7 -T AAI-7 angle). Circular statistics and mixed models with a random slope and intercept were adjusted for days 1-7 change in cardiac activation, LVEF, known risk factors, and use of medications known to affect CM. Results QRS DDD-7 -T AAI-7 angle strongly correlated (circular r = - 0.972; P<0.0001) with T AAI-7 -T DDD-7 angle. In the mixed models, history of MI (\u2212180\u00b0(95%CI \u2212320\u00b0 to \u221240\u00b0); P=0.011) and female sex (\u2212162\u00b0(95%CI \u2212268\u00b0 to \u221255\u00b0); P=0.003) counteracted CM-T azimuth changes (+132\u00b0(95%CI 80\u00b0-184\u00b0); P<0.0001). History of VT (+27(95%CI 4-46) mV*ms; P=0.007) amplified CM-T area increase (+15(95%CI 6\u201324) mV*ms; P<0.0001). Conclusions Existing cardiac remodeling affects CM in response to RV pacing. Women develop less CM than men. Activation memory is another manifestation of CM.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005181"}
10.1101/19004465
[ 0.3414430618286133, -0.271339476108551, -0.3716827630996704, 0.6393823623657227, -0.550338864326477, -0.8937739133834839, 0.4737401306629181, 0.25131720304489136, 0.6151389479637146, 0.8095079064369202, -0.14074084162712097, -0.17333534359931946, 0.7390843033790588, -0.12191203236579895, 0.055452268570661545, 0.17505501210689545, 0.5745774507522583, 0.47417116165161133, -0.696308434009552, 0.14385157823562622, -0.06598905473947525, 0.6851427555084229, -0.8209100365638733, -0.27509668469429016, -0.6139959096908569, 0.02143656462430954, -0.44560062885284424, 0.4043635129928589, 0.8867167830467224, 0.9272586703300476, -0.25458475947380066, 0.30537062883377075, 0.20756211876869202, -1.020012378692627, -0.10665315389633179, -0.13143186271190643, 0.7751408815383911, -1.2851507663726807, 0.46514880657196045, -0.2131512463092804, 0.2878144383430481, -0.05948711931705475, 1.147715449333191, -0.6915952563285828, 0.007843129336833954, -0.46275973320007324, -0.004468340426683426, 0.08339977264404297, -0.4459989070892334, 0.0318680964410305, -0.453986793756485, 0.35355207324028015, 0.3096858263015747, -0.16665151715278625, 0.2808666527271271, -0.3106156289577484, 0.8728388547897339, -0.10092592984437943, -0.33756983280181885, -0.17028996348381042, -0.1077776625752449, 0.04649638757109642, 0.46143555641174316, -0.8302699327468872, 0.45758581161499023, 0.4692589044570923, 0.05742673948407173, 0.363986998796463, -0.24503323435783386, -0.07689084112644196, -0.8924239873886108, -0.07432720065116882, 0.03331621736288071, 0.27816423773765564, -0.030003955587744713, -0.70297771692276, -0.08296675235033035, -0.6932381987571716, 0.028062967583537102, -0.07949349284172058, 0.518925666809082, 0.1649569869041443, 0.028782382607460022, 0.11093977093696594, -0.17444513738155365, -0.30360147356987, 0.02897038497030735, 0.4425347149372101, 0.7653896808624268, 0.6419929265975952, 0.4073992967605591, 0.18848928809165955, 0.3324526250362396, 0.05437293276190758, 0.12740227580070496, 0.9770643711090088, -0.18346911668777466, -0.020370079204440117, 0.16327856481075287, 0.011259864084422588, 0.8655177354812622, 0.8336909413337708, -0.6086083650588989, 0.46794378757476807, -0.9505536556243896, 0.31724876165390015, 0.9653688669204712, -0.13085825741291046, -0.1853281706571579, -1.0426867008209229, -0.463957816362381, 0.6369819045066833, -0.7505794763565063, -0.6079094409942627, 0.7072855234146118, 0.28342097997665405, 0.12627242505550385, 0.48207753896713257, -0.5603024363517761, 0.45925554633140564, -0.01198333315551281, -0.05654897913336754, 0.1664712131023407, -0.11535663902759552, 0.38175520300865173, -0.1549149453639984, 0.3569236397743225, 0.9584400653839111, -0.6334146857261658, 0.46798908710479736, 0.09119738638401031, -0.9928411245346069, -0.04180464893579483, 0.121592678129673, -0.5166265964508057, -0.4617052972316742, 0.3261851668357849, 0.6297432780265808, 0.40702375769615173, -0.47947025299072266, -0.5572093725204468, 0.6230928897857666, -0.03517499566078186, 0.9100809693336487, -0.4578785300254822, 0.9723991751670837, -0.5819442272186279, -0.582247257232666, -0.39844557642936707, -0.07186747342348099, -0.16103839874267578, 0.6590920090675354, 0.10862047225236893, -0.1606747955083847, 0.468302845954895, -0.19276148080825806, -0.07730814069509506, -0.14869223535060883, 0.3411481976509094, 0.44990473985671997, -0.6258295774459839, 0.1660655438899994, 0.3570350706577301, 0.9525940418243408, -0.25116851925849915, 0.8922867178916931, -0.5715405941009521, -0.4946635961532593, -0.152290478348732, -0.5673865675926208, 0.18409228324890137, 0.8454881906509399, -0.6045056581497192, 0.46571457386016846, 0.7613131999969482, 0.1686631441116333, 0.8954886198043823, 0.3430543839931488, 0.30069226026535034, 0.10846328735351562, 0.08165236562490463, -0.23824550211429596, 0.551421046257019, 0.888012707233429, -0.21142292022705078, 0.5382281541824341, -0.18255986273288727, -0.9881371259689331, 0.06855972111225128, -0.6838958859443665, -0.5066935420036316, 0.3900930881500244, -0.4277200996875763, 0.2666614353656769, 1.035913109779358, -0.4194501042366028, -0.7781902551651001, 0.01620396599173546, 1.3299216032028198, -0.633936882019043, -0.15743125975131989, 0.17336498200893402, -0.0804813951253891, 0.3118676245212555, -0.2643749713897705, 0.3895875811576843, 0.07602205127477646, 0.5903305411338806, 0.14051403105258942, 0.14085404574871063, 1.3697006702423096, -0.18301509320735931, -0.6152899861335754, 0.118731290102005, 0.5874943137168884, -0.45605552196502686, -1.1907382011413574, 0.08667722344398499, -0.17530037462711334, -0.5809602737426758, -0.5957837104797363, -0.11580080538988113, 0.16581983864307404, -0.05068695917725563, 0.07333976030349731, 0.09391625225543976, 0.8575224280357361, 0.5401167869567871, -0.49010875821113586, -0.9949013590812683, 0.20587500929832458, -0.08499118685722351, 0.19612400233745575, 0.3798035681247711, 1.105886459350586, -0.18551626801490784, 0.30562788248062134, 0.7019209861755371, 0.7766262292861938, 0.11645030230283737, 0.7567809224128723, 0.4358843266963959, 1.0084878206253052, 0.42577385902404785, -0.14379504323005676, 0.8379195928573608, -0.31813690066337585, -0.4036378562450409, -0.41448232531547546, 0.20066531002521515, -0.3963741064071655, 1.0716077089309692, 0.8924891948699951, -0.015926280990242958, -1.2497670650482178, 0.5722995400428772, 0.30730879306793213, 0.8499085307121277, -0.4826349914073944, -0.48295310139656067, -0.1387617439031601, 0.39658406376838684, -0.277834415435791, 0.37290793657302856, 1.2781503200531006, 0.03676804527640343, 0.12930919229984283, 0.2309407889842987, 0.6133843064308167, -0.04477822780609131, -0.8782041072845459, -0.6293749213218689, -0.5135958194732666, -0.2512674927711487, -1.271923542022705, 0.6403168439865112, 0.03218522295355797, -0.7065761685371399, 0.47649216651916504, 0.5148140788078308, 0.3772648870944977, 0.10297407954931259, -0.38751745223999023, -0.32332852482795715, -0.2887393832206726, 0.44924336671829224, -1.5053921937942505, -0.10089977085590363, -0.35943013429641724, 0.11406020075082779, -0.5248395204544067, -0.42603638768196106, -0.7073602676391602, -0.23990032076835632, 0.6685557961463928, -0.4655154049396515, 0.20712681114673615, -0.04222865030169487, -0.6240558624267578, -0.8450477123260498, 0.8620863556861877, 0.02913651056587696, 0.6018493175506592, -0.32772043347358704, -0.9037358164787292, 0.7467629313468933, -0.35123690962791443, 0.1993345320224762, 0.20232629776000977, -0.47180137038230896, -0.36739352345466614, 0.5871730446815491, -0.25215625762939453, 0.4345875680446625, -1.0755462646484375, 0.39764514565467834, 0.31913697719573975, 0.11722201853990555, 0.1677447259426117, -0.17237213253974915, -0.7873866558074951, -0.5854810476303101, 0.13874875009059906, -0.73436039686203, -0.43345803022384644, 0.068203404545784, 0.5275436639785767, -0.9739638566970825, 0.5369555950164795, -0.6408286690711975, -0.7399396896362305, -0.15976491570472717, -0.28938981890678406, 0.35253486037254333, -0.3359505832195282, -0.16948294639587402, -0.4588858485221863, -0.1408175379037857, -0.582842230796814, -0.10721498727798462, -0.233321413397789, -0.9540665149688721, -0.7213318943977356, 0.2943703532218933, -1.153306484222412, 0.7852189540863037, 0.2479739785194397, 0.33630213141441345, -0.7302590608596802, -0.46687591075897217, 0.012179385870695114, -0.6188163757324219, 0.8054280281066895, -0.3505323827266693, -0.47948622703552246, 0.49677929282188416, 0.16134096682071686, -0.06570469588041306, 0.2563740015029907, -0.3913756310939789, -0.8476975560188293, 0.8373764753341675, -0.7949671149253845, 0.5524243116378784, -0.9740742444992065, -1.0864207744598389, -0.3023078143596649, -0.03131294995546341, 0.1981230229139328, -0.595966100692749, 1.2588361501693726, 0.06164225935935974, 0.06000341475009918, 0.08973651379346848, -0.022466855123639107, -0.2424435317516327, 1.1794246435165405, 0.4370031952857971, 0.2519991993904114, -0.578677237033844, -0.4016481041908264, -0.011908767744898796, 1.1232527494430542, -0.6087213754653931, -0.3706980049610138, 0.5963934659957886, -0.5986105799674988, 0.23850765824317932, 0.45177051424980164, -0.5686968564987183, -0.21860700845718384, -0.17754414677619934, 0.4138938784599304, -0.3891329765319824, -0.80473792552948, -0.025535861030220985, -0.23360803723335266, 0.47342175245285034, 0.7450412511825562, 0.18984170258045197, 0.625836193561554, 0.08878764510154724, 0.501612663269043, 0.48057985305786133, 0.7041643261909485, 0.6361073851585388, -1.0112766027450562, 0.022777970880270004, -0.3471626043319702, 0.5327371954917908, -0.33316850662231445, 0.43627917766571045, 0.31654274463653564, 0.6020993590354919, 0.4128566384315491, -0.11161724478006363, 0.3030199408531189, -0.36527571082115173, -0.05787390470504761, -0.007387078832834959, -0.11328528076410294, -0.5405624508857727, -0.30378568172454834, 0.013292759656906128, -0.5714167356491089, 0.6856778264045715, -0.01265773270279169, -0.20744410157203674, 0.14978249371051788, 0.2941892147064209, -0.023391172289848328, -1.2599343061447144, 0.22785653173923492, -0.33623206615448, -0.4310504198074341, -0.21065381169319153, -0.6856352090835571, -0.2544873058795929, 0.7678858637809753, -0.5300214886665344, -0.07561879605054855, -0.604911208152771, 0.11814632266759872, -0.3444329500198364, 0.37832555174827576, 0.27290505170822144, 1.0057604312896729, 0.3306235373020172, 0.1440308541059494, -0.02483309805393219, 0.17735612392425537, -0.269418865442276, 0.6779980063438416, 0.15491580963134766, -0.7839107513427734, 0.024260586127638817, 0.16264067590236664, 0.15294532477855682, -0.2931608259677887, -0.4660576581954956, -0.41877564787864685, -0.4349624216556549, -0.03193875774741173, -0.5187910795211792, -0.92728191614151, 1.1715617179870605, -0.8931378126144409, 0.5434862375259399, 1.0683616399765015, -0.5832629203796387, -0.2196817696094513, -0.40705305337905884, -0.9624831080436707, -0.8846127986907959, 0.36417052149772644, -0.796140193939209, 0.26243793964385986, 0.5201315879821777, -0.5602209568023682, 0.18390622735023499, -0.14744828641414642, 0.18608173727989197, -0.4423450529575348, -0.6216275095939636, -1.083839774131775, -0.5778400897979736, -0.4465048015117645, -0.4288683831691742, -0.23919087648391724, -0.40556296706199646, -0.10609930753707886, -0.4203890860080719, -0.49943146109580994, -0.11408478766679764, -0.5912297964096069, 0.0958554819226265, -0.02398773841559887, -0.6629943251609802, -0.8441454172134399, -0.018118666484951973, 0.7963937520980835, -0.1932598352432251, -1.177686095237732, -0.005957737099379301, 0.6349005103111267, -1.2373430728912354, -0.5247703790664673, -0.3112938404083252, -0.2292943298816681, 0.02894395776093006, -0.5886300802230835, 0.09067845344543457, -0.908569872379303, 0.6271382570266724, 0.09612106531858444, 0.04240348935127258, 0.020498862490057945, -0.2526148557662964, 0.5119305849075317, 0.42061835527420044, 0.3426494598388672, -0.4481183588504791, -0.11932342499494553, 0.71370530128479, -0.46969980001449585, 0.026602111756801605, -0.8062741160392761, -0.7856137156486511, -0.9018750786781311, -0.7289301753044128, 0.04323437437415123, -0.5302616953849792, -0.034182995557785034, -0.4173876941204071, 0.11605115979909897, -0.35341495275497437, 0.42967045307159424, 0.1804041564464569, 0.165367990732193, -0.13727623224258423, -0.16266541182994843, -0.38614246249198914, 0.06349867582321167, 0.7083998322486877, 0.5065918564796448, -0.9916844964027405, 0.26355332136154175, 1.5085786581039429, 1.0021662712097168, 0.49689799547195435, -0.26242196559906006, -0.5152432322502136, 0.2872976064682007, 0.03967152163386345, -0.1259862780570984, -0.4005371630191803, 0.24972866475582123, 0.2091945856809616, 0.08932842314243317, -0.3197995722293854, -0.9015662670135498, 0.6947247982025146, -0.8650444149971008, 0.17321176826953888, -0.41609635949134827, 0.020339736714959145, -0.3642580509185791, 0.12832015752792358, 1.0525656938552856, -0.07748029381036758, 0.2846665680408478, 0.5284307599067688, 0.46488094329833984, 0.35597679018974304, 0.14410486817359924, -0.12107942998409271, -0.2637633979320526, -0.22488117218017578, -0.32966530323028564, 0.24362972378730774, 0.6056832671165466, -0.18290309607982635, 0.18249844014644623, -0.17412154376506805, -0.10623742640018463, -1.0910784006118774, 0.7752665877342224, 0.05860750749707222, -0.9033069610595703, -0.7029162645339966, 0.08241499960422516, 0.30243125557899475, 0.49129819869995117, 0.5218925476074219, 0.40098902583122253, -0.3608767092227936, 0.5811607837677002, 0.1811039000749588, -0.25965556502342224, 0.039462555199861526, -0.4530099034309387, 0.304736465215683, 0.734430730342865, -0.42942821979522705, -0.11024919152259827, 0.053739938884973526, 0.1926724761724472, -0.8010528087615967, 1.3809194564819336, -0.3456622064113617, -0.013324698433279991, 0.6483293771743774, -0.6992793083190918, -0.5968642830848694, -0.3182145953178406, 0.23204654455184937, -0.17754152417182922, -0.3526305556297302, 0.6566073894500732, 0.09853057563304901, -1.1675488948822021, 0.3088054656982422, 0.49868524074554443, -0.4673873484134674, 0.04265914112329483, -0.010201794095337391, 0.35548174381256104, 1.1248594522476196, -0.2508716583251953, -0.2924853265285492, 0.8614253997802734, -0.09508918225765228, 0.9242651462554932, -0.18773671984672546, -0.741621732711792, -0.12461580336093903, -0.5711171627044678, -0.3484613597393036, -0.43931904435157776, 0.3066411018371582, 0.7644009590148926, -0.5170791149139404, 0.37905237078666687, 0.4468706250190735, -0.5726729035377502, 0.7194687128067017, 0.09272017329931259, 0.8844318389892578, -0.2637287974357605, 0.07639648020267487, -0.018483100458979607, -0.3518271744251251, 0.15858817100524902, 0.06257926672697067, -0.863625705242157, 0.7551484704017639, 0.1129751056432724, -0.5077870488166809, -0.5826545357704163, 0.04647814854979515, 0.12783032655715942, 0.7169733047485352, -0.6058767437934875, -0.2595008313655853, 1.0659922361373901, 1.087151050567627, 0.571198046207428, -1.0051195621490479, -1.2240358591079712, -0.5890845656394958, 0.7150968313217163, 0.4559653103351593, -0.5129187703132629, -0.7104024887084961, 0.35637882351875305, -0.3480242192745209, -0.3044111132621765, 0.3988769054412842, 1.0078755617141724, -0.5461560487747192, -0.2146974354982376, -0.7760874032974243, 0.8227089047431946, -0.35085591673851013, -0.3928983509540558, -0.2748214304447174, -0.6911243200302124, -0.26757845282554626, 0.5840756297111511, -0.47355979681015015, -0.44680094718933105, 0.1272120177745819, 0.029959900304675102, 0.18488934636116028, 0.13437741994857788, -0.20825912058353424, -0.7427468299865723, 0.46632689237594604, 0.7361448407173157, -0.7288494110107422, -0.32923462986946106, 0.6496720314025879, -0.9283267259597778, 0.8740331530570984, 0.26733139157295227, -0.42771175503730774, 0.03847264125943184, -0.3996371328830719, -0.25470322370529175, -0.7856260538101196, -1.582095742225647, 0.09155186265707016, -0.010022674687206745, -0.3761741816997528, -0.5056683421134949, -0.40012064576148987, 0.28859442472457886, -0.14064736664295197, -0.24390800297260284, -0.43863531947135925, 0.2520367205142975, 0.205861434340477, 0.5109077095985413, 0.4128336012363434, 1.0834598541259766, 0.3349234461784363, 0.3155292570590973, 0.16408735513687134, 0.010022236034274101, -0.3331867754459381, -0.32450032234191895, -0.059006139636039734, 0.06453385949134827, 0.10120514035224915, 0.5228663682937622, -0.27254238724708557, 0.2709488868713379, -0.3475145399570465, -0.41415759921073914, -0.343485951423645, 1.4101290702819824, 0.22991450130939484, -0.06960668414831161, 0.23883341252803802, -0.33720168471336365, -0.2928793132305145, -0.8221147060394287, -0.8651270866394043, -0.15422210097312927, 0.3539580702781677, 0.027917534112930298, -0.01060660183429718, 0.20458664000034332, -0.39561840891838074, 0.9850400686264038, 0.025093313306570053, 1.088989496231079, -0.35290491580963135, 0.10153350979089737, 0.36942413449287415, 0.9954794645309448, 0.5421141386032104, 0.12342581152915955, 0.2432233989238739, -0.15713483095169067, -0.2590991258621216, -0.32357364892959595, 0.34732404351234436, 0.010728863999247551, 0.410237580537796, -0.10559145361185074, 0.16139085590839386, -0.37247034907341003, 0.46636369824409485, 0.3886350989341736, 0.5034579038619995, -0.3138406276702881, -1.11164128780365, -0.4606662094593048, 0.12840117514133453, 0.06779021769762039, -0.5467371940612793, -0.2983419895172119, 0.36183804273605347, -1.1524200439453125, -0.9156985282897949, -0.4365427792072296, 0.695339024066925, 0.39683353900909424, 0.3488662838935852, -0.06006713584065437, 0.33473658561706543, -0.6351147294044495, 0.1779337078332901, -0.012478210963308811, 0.28771331906318665, 0.25935330986976624, -0.17256726324558258, -0.0665329322218895, 0.6754263639450073, 0.7302581667900085, 0.07506728172302246, 0.4635162651538849, 0.32788920402526855, 0.3064545691013336, -0.49227187037467957, -0.2130545973777771, -0.4751242995262146, 0.8236566185951233, 0.27079206705093384, 0.28179287910461426, 0.9379745721817017, -0.1172255203127861, 1.0071440935134888, -0.6155555248260498, -0.44155406951904297, 0.7603172659873962, -0.7462852597236633, -1.1160094738006592, -0.2662089169025421, 0.06442908942699432, 0.6744593977928162, 0.515304446220398, 0.6054590344429016, 1.0982452630996704, -0.35847413539886475, 0.019516009837388992, -0.5380548238754272, 0.68147212266922, 0.20604604482650757, -0.2526112496852875, -0.710603654384613, -0.08357328921556473, -0.5731297135353088, 0.7305368781089783, -0.1294110119342804, -0.07925248891115189, 0.07565081119537354, 0.636800229549408, -0.08111228048801422, 0.09790021926164627, 0.6156438589096069, -0.4990791380405426, 0.05504626780748367, 0.3616468906402588, 0.284671425819397, -0.06592623144388199, -0.54420405626297, 0.5220731496810913, -0.3006923198699951, 0.07034209370613098, -0.3034159243106842, -0.0716453567147255, 0.5431549549102783, 0.23653168976306915, 0.8018338680267334, -0.5222049951553345, 0.49081963300704956, 1.0281630754470825, -0.17546235024929047, -0.16626590490341187, -0.272308349609375, -0.0008918537641875446, -0.5519751310348511, 0.1627347767353058, 0.2653839886188507, -0.119996577501297, -0.04652499407529831, -0.5796635746955872, 0.08835626393556595, -0.320575088262558, -0.5156562328338623, 0.0685509592294693, -0.13393262028694153, -0.5662739872932434, 0.6710638999938965, -0.1592131406068802, -0.5250692367553711, 0.20164814591407776, 0.3184070587158203, 0.07881144434213638, 0.17949074506759644, -0.2583691477775574, -0.13708533346652985, -0.742979109287262, 0.22819386422634125, -0.3252304494380951, -0.8797152638435364, -0.3275090456008911, -0.8789191842079163, 0.44441911578178406, 0.24033227562904358, -0.5417993068695068, -0.4503524601459503, 0.2904749810695648, 0.03464708477258682, 0.4425906240940094, 0.42235448956489563, -0.5625420212745667, 0.34032803773880005, 0.7273151278495789, 0.0037581634242087603, 0.5521929264068604, 0.4272094666957855, -0.016147863119840622, 0.36935514211654663, 0.48047563433647156, -0.17346230149269104, 0.17346152663230896, -0.02002706751227379, -0.14424586296081543, -0.23128153383731842, -0.19962216913700104, 0.3838919699192047, -0.7817124128341675, 0.20026062428951263, 0.6238996386528015, 0.6610707640647888, -0.7728028297424316, -0.6610575318336487, -1.3975085020065308, -0.6157536506652832, 0.9692782163619995, -0.10127930343151093, 0.03160427138209343, -0.0667857676744461, 0.5944513082504272, 0.042120177298784256, -1.153449296951294, 3.958648204803467, 1.1689646244049072, 0.35048195719718933, 0.13569483160972595, 0.08524370193481445, 0.5636801719665527, 0.46260252594947815, -0.3785894811153412, 0.9955160021781921, -0.5339583158493042, -1.1480449438095093, 0.5459315180778503, 0.30041447281837463, 0.7419834733009338, 0.48107728362083435, 0.9032829403877258, -1.0808355808258057, -0.16909730434417725, -0.5934349894523621, -1.2149871587753296, -0.29591479897499084, -0.02116071619093418, -0.4623730182647705, 0.7677081227302551, -0.04514303430914879, -0.22473186254501343, 0.47800421714782715, 0.7093162536621094, 0.20044812560081482, -0.3984014391899109, 0.22233371436595917, -0.5246921181678772, -0.18968269228935242, -0.7860926985740662, -0.031552571803331375, 0.017598755657672882, -0.32772767543792725, -0.5355873703956604, -0.1791967898607254, 0.824227511882782, 0.39314141869544983, 0.7532194256782532, -0.13419553637504578, -0.2880519926548004, 0.16565197706222534, 0.5249454975128174, -0.5757596492767334, -0.10511577874422073, 0.4764043390750885, -0.7127537131309509, 0.9075181484222412, -1.16279137134552, 0.4871554672718048, 0.6870265007019043, -0.927935004234314, -0.5134628415107727, 0.030160479247570038, -0.6013651490211487, 0.17431984841823578, 0.9288188815116882, 0.5925974249839783, -0.03499193489551544, -0.05829852074384689, -0.41452133655548096, 0.42335525155067444, 0.9831312894821167, 0.23789100348949432, -0.3595021963119507, -0.4429589509963989, 0.038808416575193405, -0.5744580030441284, 0.5784658193588257, -0.288867712020874, -0.8523037433624268, 0.5282188653945923, 0.6939167976379395, 0.6746382713317871, 0.358943372964859, -0.28933241963386536, -0.9284504652023315, 0.06132910028100014, 0.39562273025512695, -0.1794051229953766, 0.7321338057518005, -0.13641773164272308, 0.9156403541564941, -0.7201618552207947, -0.391597181558609, -0.24420088529586792, 0.1605643630027771, 0.3284366726875305, -0.8652734756469727, -0.21996180713176727, -0.6966050267219543, 0.416360080242157 ]
{"Title": "Physician Suicide: A Scoping Review to Highlight Opportunities for Prevention", "Authors": "Leung Tiffany I., Pendharkar Sima S., Chen Chwen-Yuen Angie, Snyder Rebecca", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective The aim of this scoping review is to map the current landscape of published research and perspectives on physician suicide. Findings could serve as a roadmap for further investigations and potentially inform efforts to prevent physician suicide. Methods Ovid MEDLINE, PsycInfo, and Scopus were searched for English-language publications from August 21, 2017 through April 28, 2018. Inclusion criteria were a primary outcome or thesis focused on suicide (including suicide completion, attempts, and thoughts or ideation) among medical students, postgraduate trainees, or attending physicians. Opinion articles were included. Studies that were non-English, or those that only mentioned physician burnout, mental health or substance use disorders were excluded. Data extraction was performed by two authors. Results The search yielded 1,596 articles, of which 347 articles passed to the full-text review round. The oldest article was an editorial from 1903; 210 (60.3%) articles were published from 2000 to present. Authors originated from 37 countries and 143 (41.2%) were opinion articles. Most discussed were suicide risk factors and culture of practice issues, while least discussed themes included public health and postvention. Conclusions Consistency and reliability of data and information about physician suicides could be improved. Data limitations partly contribute to these issues. Also, various suicide risk factors for physicians have been explored, and several remain poorly understood. Based on this scoping review, a public health approach, including surveillance and early warning systems, investigations of sentinel cases, and postvention may be impactful next steps in preventing physician deaths by suicide.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004465"}
10.1101/19010298
[ -0.4165874123573303, 0.10935711115598679, -0.08543791621923447, 0.1934291571378708, -0.6428897380828857, 0.508134126663208, -0.016001906245946884, 0.25161513686180115, 0.5809895992279053, 0.6343674659729004, 0.479036808013916, -0.6268216371536255, 0.9159495234489441, -0.2476380467414856, -0.6265772581100464, -0.0652909129858017, -0.0636558085680008, 0.09331478923559189, 0.11931563913822174, 0.1524936407804489, -0.41891005635261536, 0.0593365877866745, -0.684109091758728, 0.09299305081367493, 0.26527711749076843, 0.05121737718582153, 0.3754088282585144, -0.41713348031044006, 1.272542119026184, 0.6496016383171082, -0.8452719449996948, -0.2379174828529358, 0.5446372628211975, -0.14077895879745483, -0.13480070233345032, -0.04776114225387573, 0.6241707801818848, -0.03259551152586937, -0.1561153680086136, -1.0215569734573364, 0.1858813464641571, 0.3627542555332184, 0.5871743559837341, -0.983905017375946, 0.026777496561408043, -0.29557469487190247, 0.07189203053712845, -0.05184689909219742, -0.2059423327445984, -0.0183353740721941, -0.5020686984062195, -0.4231334626674652, -0.007559503428637981, -0.2572859227657318, -0.0597224086523056, -0.09362532198429108, 0.05668482184410095, -0.22827394306659698, -1.3545920848846436, 0.5500144362449646, 0.4440159499645233, -0.6035037636756897, 0.5862730145454407, -0.9807991981506348, 1.311803936958313, 0.6890633702278137, -0.5069238543510437, 0.282303124666214, -0.4274698495864868, -0.32394126057624817, 0.30268093943595886, 0.1175774484872818, -0.7040348649024963, -0.15361590683460236, -0.44584253430366516, -0.5753117799758911, 0.8456806540489197, -0.04105938598513603, -0.3591860234737396, 0.3250110149383545, -0.552547037601471, -0.20356181263923645, -0.11744426190853119, 0.007579941302537918, -0.6880108714103699, -0.31342533230781555, 0.03192926570773125, 0.6264054775238037, -0.4818570017814636, 0.6916195154190063, 0.4359126091003418, 0.6584425568580627, -0.1563701629638672, -0.18748889863491058, -0.12617968022823334, 1.3075300455093384, -0.5698368549346924, -0.23326438665390015, -0.2762518525123596, -0.3400832712650299, 0.20141653716564178, 0.0822548121213913, -0.46598300337791443, 0.8434628248214722, -0.43545642495155334, 0.35723209381103516, -0.19953960180282593, -0.09058854728937149, -0.6959731578826904, -0.16145232319831848, 0.2936033308506012, 0.49965032935142517, -0.21820443868637085, -0.15366874635219574, 1.10627281665802, 0.28161099553108215, -0.830402135848999, 1.269852876663208, -0.9029303789138794, -0.06374834477901459, 0.02470029890537262, 0.1641339212656021, 0.8521090149879456, 0.20312415063381195, 0.6564623713493347, 0.31100669503211975, -0.12184034287929535, 0.9183365702629089, -0.4993712604045868, 0.2308916598558426, -0.4038360118865967, -0.4397144019603729, 0.031352076679468155, 0.5632534027099609, -0.28148722648620605, 0.18329739570617676, 0.13846802711486816, 0.5028002262115479, 0.24517999589443207, -0.34722599387168884, 0.221937358379364, 1.1008273363113403, -0.3990812301635742, 1.0654579401016235, -0.4131779074668884, 1.1930102109909058, -0.9611307382583618, -0.4963543713092804, -0.8752277493476868, -0.11196918040513992, -0.10929499566555023, 0.7222002148628235, 0.04715646430850029, 0.17825418710708618, 0.3421335518360138, 0.2982619106769562, -0.1630571037530899, -0.2632569372653961, -0.49968042969703674, 0.0932481586933136, 0.014521556906402111, 0.8805292844772339, 0.08908016979694366, 0.5174484252929688, -1.2290008068084717, 0.1443665474653244, 0.48376867175102234, 0.15483418107032776, 0.05211622640490532, -1.1973103284835815, 0.42384248971939087, 0.4994485080242157, -0.26874619722366333, -0.1726876199245453, 0.22044634819030762, 0.39760681986808777, 0.5110322833061218, -0.12464437633752823, 0.32020941376686096, 0.6411575078964233, 0.2708095610141754, 0.8279827833175659, 0.3491109013557434, 0.34064731001853943, -0.2935273051261902, 0.3546890914440155, -0.1767813116312027, -0.25255686044692993, 0.05885760858654976, 0.1704261749982834, 0.06348732113838196, -0.01868305541574955, -0.7679885029792786, 1.2012944221496582, -0.5577237606048584, -0.0021698076743632555, -0.8262611031532288, 0.1579795479774475, -0.040663942694664, -0.2437206655740738, -0.5684018731117249, 0.9364120364189148, 0.24725906550884247, 0.5028396248817444, -0.2718152105808258, 0.6913823485374451, -0.6460479497909546, 0.24737699329853058, -0.48970696330070496, -0.3172595798969269, 0.9671119451522827, 0.6045079827308655, 0.1605369746685028, 0.10361563414335251, 0.13356296718120575, -0.0055033136159181595, 0.15931513905525208, 0.25568661093711853, -0.9419361352920532, 0.20483645796775818, -0.3012872338294983, 0.30796870589256287, 0.5527879595756531, 0.8052332401275635, -0.29115891456604004, 0.24874438345432281, 0.3350655138492584, 0.6585965156555176, 0.11297255754470825, -0.2942189872264862, 0.6459123492240906, 0.7022300958633423, 0.25963202118873596, 0.20346663892269135, 0.2938185930252075, 0.6490925550460815, 0.07647296786308289, 0.11880211532115936, 0.159219428896904, 0.6830831170082092, 0.5418058037757874, 0.5007038116455078, 1.0130531787872314, 0.24710798263549805, -0.23723646998405457, 0.79706209897995, -0.013209513388574123, 0.2920389473438263, -0.35997310280799866, 1.0696295499801636, -0.608760416507721, 0.6131325960159302, 0.7940757274627686, 1.121415615081787, 0.009655768051743507, -0.2187817543745041, 0.983609676361084, -0.03566564619541168, -0.1398446261882782, -0.1485365629196167, -0.5357212424278259, 0.024047372862696648, -0.043246399611234665, -0.0770336240530014, 1.0631005764007568, 1.1577844619750977, 0.3329943120479584, 0.8737916350364685, 0.4624199867248535, -0.3883620500564575, -0.011284200474619865, -1.0672684907913208, -0.8813716173171997, -0.771278977394104, -0.6594474911689758, -0.19497373700141907, -0.6704335808753967, -0.0561896376311779, 0.2280178666114807, 0.5968441367149353, 0.36106783151626587, -0.3551507890224457, -0.6918540596961975, 0.5658332705497742, 0.5439879298210144, 0.11778312921524048, -0.5093152523040771, 0.43596285581588745, -0.23740482330322266, 0.31037479639053345, -0.22007691860198975, 0.38232293725013733, -0.9493960738182068, -1.2321751117706299, 0.6352671384811401, -0.37042129039764404, 0.059785205870866776, -0.837846040725708, 0.41695746779441833, 0.11156637221574783, -0.08772812783718109, 0.17920920252799988, -0.1616327315568924, 0.10731004178524017, -0.5810540914535522, -0.12736350297927856, 0.2845134437084198, 0.20314176380634308, -0.06320255994796753, 0.5840831398963928, 0.5497462153434753, 0.2790559232234955, -0.0911480262875557, 0.3827804625034332, -0.9170886278152466, 0.15661291778087616, 0.4433125853538513, -0.16952839493751526, 0.15332798659801483, -0.7863651514053345, -1.18002188205719, -0.42820948362350464, -0.5498630404472351, 0.16327907145023346, 0.17192769050598145, 0.6879544258117676, 0.2277175337076187, -1.0190235376358032, 0.12089334428310394, 0.09018965810537338, -1.284461498260498, 0.454664409160614, -0.4764899015426636, 0.23819191753864288, -0.26514700055122375, 0.04968857765197754, -0.2169710397720337, 0.2864895164966583, -0.17950540781021118, -0.10369226336479187, 0.11771953850984573, 0.05122039467096329, 0.06201524659991264, 0.060632962733507156, 0.29979726672172546, -0.05672493204474449, 0.8499599099159241, -0.27322718501091003, -0.5040239691734314, -0.36666586995124817, -0.30749842524528503, 0.8785938024520874, 0.6446306109428406, 0.27811694145202637, -0.6738654971122742, 0.29215511679649353, 0.4458339512348175, -0.18095003068447113, -0.0034321837592869997, 0.39251336455345154, -0.7813959717750549, 0.4752345681190491, -0.34442955255508423, 0.17210441827774048, -0.516557514667511, -1.074925422668457, 0.41402432322502136, -0.7985973954200745, 0.8064082264900208, -0.5463101267814636, 0.3695778250694275, -0.1242913082242012, 0.12360657751560211, -0.13110245764255524, -0.10471469163894653, 0.24514330923557281, 1.0350399017333984, 0.09332004189491272, 0.8966644406318665, -0.61178058385849, 0.2581333816051483, -0.1133359894156456, 0.3862597346305847, 0.5683091282844543, 0.35845455527305603, 0.2993949055671692, -0.4502931535243988, 0.716356098651886, -0.2750951945781708, -0.05839625746011734, 0.10049877315759659, -0.3436543643474579, 0.7162834405899048, 0.005462797824293375, -1.1650238037109375, -0.7259323596954346, 0.30512988567352295, 0.5126635432243347, -0.43971577286720276, -0.09790130704641342, 0.5914115905761719, -0.17750005424022675, 0.5797644257545471, 0.07200850546360016, 0.4421117603778839, 0.523228645324707, -0.6409788131713867, 0.4158296585083008, 0.05701851844787598, -0.5774661302566528, 0.005236275028437376, -0.24888105690479279, -0.2397155612707138, -0.5175305008888245, 0.3426927924156189, -0.37064939737319946, -1.040531039237976, -0.33984294533729553, -0.29270613193511963, 0.7383469939231873, 0.45305439829826355, -0.10354676097631454, -0.7831544280052185, 0.2791215181350708, -0.03108903393149376, -0.7991563677787781, 0.17972949147224426, -0.4191015958786011, -0.3808721899986267, 0.6281318068504333, 0.21759779751300812, -0.7509055137634277, -0.34928804636001587, -0.2329220473766327, -0.5629871487617493, -0.02338329330086708, 0.41989654302597046, 0.35065871477127075, 0.20528057217597961, -0.09218249469995499, -0.19306129217147827, -0.6282488107681274, 0.053851913660764694, -0.3457462787628174, 0.524641752243042, 0.3968788683414459, 0.5724166631698608, 0.5560070872306824, -0.20731815695762634, -0.26861637830734253, 0.7138369679450989, -0.16683577001094818, 0.9123308062553406, -0.03339128941297531, -1.0513198375701904, 0.11164320260286331, -0.8222135305404663, 0.16939805448055267, -0.3646000325679779, -0.652109682559967, -0.40871188044548035, 0.10937374085187912, -0.018493350595235825, -0.6132432818412781, -0.7681041359901428, 0.34831106662750244, -0.532882034778595, -0.008753271773457527, 1.3425374031066895, -0.44350242614746094, 0.17697280645370483, -0.31618690490722656, 0.20177945494651794, -1.010910987854004, 0.5715791583061218, 0.6393736004829407, 0.1832003891468048, -0.12148444354534149, -0.8359101414680481, -0.07577872276306152, -0.34213966131210327, 0.5975075364112854, -0.6628553867340088, 0.01740022748708725, -0.46809783577919006, 0.06580275297164917, -0.4396025538444519, -0.21834765374660492, -0.9446750283241272, 0.7617589831352234, -0.42389753460884094, -0.4892669916152954, -0.49765047430992126, -0.535032331943512, -0.497252881526947, -0.3763101398944855, -0.7195044159889221, 0.3743184804916382, -0.05514739826321602, -0.37185174226760864, 1.3580292463302612, -0.5971691608428955, -0.49557772278785706, -0.004151749424636364, 0.6414690017700195, -0.6755167841911316, -0.3598746657371521, -0.1977631002664566, -0.2610730826854706, -0.7552506923675537, -0.08948124200105667, -0.211332306265831, -0.3493727147579193, -0.4552929401397705, -0.5793267488479614, 0.50832200050354, 1.1451666355133057, -0.2133786976337433, -0.663638710975647, 0.5024005174636841, 0.24782268702983856, -1.0605860948562622, -0.47445085644721985, 0.2781584858894348, 0.4495478868484497, 0.31327834725379944, -0.11442116647958755, -0.6458978056907654, -0.41729554533958435, -0.568672239780426, -0.14362256228923798, -0.7443650960922241, -0.425950288772583, -0.5473095178604126, -0.5772823691368103, -0.04270247742533684, 0.838067889213562, 0.3295595049858093, 0.08467096835374832, 0.1816321760416031, -0.739103376865387, 0.3631499111652374, -0.3656277656555176, -0.4907252788543701, -0.0006372232455760241, -0.6209244132041931, 0.1341821551322937, 0.9446849822998047, 0.06239767372608185, -0.26157012581825256, 0.2474524825811386, 0.09412748366594315, 0.9290400743484497, 0.6383538842201233, -0.5031062960624695, -0.8285790085792542, -0.16362297534942627, 0.9415974617004395, -1.0171090364456177, -0.3989303410053253, -1.3372948169708252, 1.0017285346984863, -0.5886959433555603, 0.5720644593238831, -0.3164680600166321, -0.5205047726631165, -0.40700414776802063, -0.1413583904504776, 0.6232449412345886, -0.8275406956672668, 0.15044385194778442, 0.11682857573032379, -0.503355860710144, 0.2604607939720154, 0.1635693460702896, -0.47145524621009827, -0.5983673930168152, -0.9587254524230957, -0.379131019115448, 0.9308083653450012, 0.31120753288269043, 0.20033636689186096, 0.09289649873971939, 0.09167739748954773, 0.09917372465133667, -0.08131126314401627, 0.8749813437461853, 0.7751047611236572, -0.8068817853927612, -0.2774805724620819, -0.10040149837732315, 0.06677659600973129, 0.4650574028491974, -0.43219640851020813, 0.11001496016979218, -0.19593068957328796, 0.5789265632629395, -0.1409052610397339, -0.5145223736763, -0.7505679726600647, -0.0009300094097852707, 0.5810000896453857, 0.27906182408332825, 0.5062574148178101, 0.23321862518787384, -0.10674375295639038, -0.5151313543319702, 0.26625534892082214, 0.7135094404220581, -0.1083938479423523, 0.8153705596923828, 0.7076854109764099, -0.46778061985969543, 0.022111250087618828, 0.7953646183013916, -0.42404577136039734, -0.030435267835855484, -0.5339756011962891, 0.36392706632614136, 0.3553454875946045, -0.9127554297447205, 0.5560986995697021, -0.08970338851213455, -0.7737549543380737, -1.0477240085601807, 0.05312736704945564, -0.5046629309654236, -0.5560914278030396, 0.4725262522697449, -0.4179573059082031, 0.92159503698349, -0.3541997969150543, 0.4651908874511719, -0.3236145079135895, 0.22453773021697998, -0.015898048877716064, -0.674022912979126, 0.24382667243480682, -0.6478142738342285, -0.05845975875854492, 1.4370975494384766, 0.3035610616207123, 0.06317232549190521, 0.18066193163394928, 0.33381831645965576, -0.41423946619033813, 0.5877560973167419, -0.2354874312877655, -0.20964708924293518, 0.2534361183643341, 0.445485919713974, -0.06977950036525726, 0.3229779601097107, 0.41063207387924194, -0.2986947000026703, 0.9158443212509155, 0.4722752869129181, -1.1925158500671387, -0.535591721534729, 0.42679572105407715, 1.131333589553833, 0.7820318341255188, 0.4532904624938965, -0.18425454199314117, 0.7018122673034668, -0.2796725630760193, 0.5379695296287537, 0.38993287086486816, 0.6129307746887207, -0.25658467411994934, -0.49785253405570984, 0.24347548186779022, -0.8599963188171387, 0.116239994764328, 0.9056930541992188, -1.14582359790802, -0.2260175496339798, 0.5102006196975708, 0.7050442099571228, -0.24806948006153107, -0.4681302309036255, -0.5617419481277466, -0.13332565128803253, -0.8619489669799805, -0.5635462403297424, -0.19149424135684967, -0.7540690302848816, 0.2084628939628601, 1.2619253396987915, -0.04266053065657616, -0.6064470410346985, 0.3275241255760193, 0.031103067100048065, 0.22046218812465668, 0.4487275779247284, -0.5040034055709839, -1.0785189867019653, 0.0031785606406629086, 0.2567649483680725, 0.512452244758606, -0.06177714467048645, 0.4733240604400635, -0.16744308173656464, 0.2330256849527359, 0.700858473777771, -0.2799268960952759, -0.19643627107143402, 0.25178802013397217, 0.19696500897407532, -0.6641597151756287, -0.8317640423774719, -0.5016542673110962, 0.851290762424469, -1.1852843761444092, -0.5614774823188782, -0.7277182340621948, 0.2154371440410614, 0.2721082866191864, 1.026328682899475, -0.8818305730819702, 0.6161017417907715, 0.5503371357917786, -0.10428349673748016, 0.5257990956306458, 0.25702548027038574, 0.3880425989627838, -0.3124236464500427, 0.4364745020866394, 0.24596823751926422, 0.6482094526290894, -0.9474177360534668, -0.47042548656463623, 0.48043331503868103, -0.3423468768596649, 0.33144861459732056, -0.4266769587993622, 0.6638110280036926, -0.5051283240318298, -0.12674982845783234, -0.9366872906684875, -0.4374781548976898, 0.2580127716064453, 0.1549414098262787, -0.08127547055482864, -0.6925144791603088, -0.33932092785835266, 0.17766982316970825, -0.7589275240898132, -0.8944509029388428, 0.693693995475769, -0.7484630346298218, 0.1894003450870514, -0.203974187374115, -0.8830579519271851, 0.1329643726348877, -0.06993555277585983, -0.07198311388492584, -0.6168173551559448, 0.5618897676467896, 0.08835430443286896, 0.414983332157135, 0.11787869036197662, -0.04908294603228569, 0.21495771408081055, 0.07556764781475067, -0.9286292791366577, -0.8479456901550293, 0.0005989256897009909, 0.07359643280506134, 0.7630985379219055, -0.5209730863571167, 0.3331514596939087, 0.10170914232730865, -0.019779004156589508, -0.38933849334716797, 0.3002174198627472, -0.23724065721035004, -0.45094913244247437, 0.2933200001716614, -0.9393266439437866, -0.34617966413497925, -0.46860477328300476, 0.285878449678421, -0.09642588347196579, -0.05780930072069168, -0.13589394092559814, -0.09196329116821289, 1.3553478717803955, 0.23415809869766235, 0.37404778599739075, 0.5255850553512573, 0.25525426864624023, -0.8361527919769287, -0.19756034016609192, 0.9702480435371399, 0.770805299282074, -0.339394748210907, 0.23648394644260406, -0.2995024621486664, 0.3681052327156067, 0.5980608463287354, 0.5804493427276611, -0.4054223597049713, 0.5996204018592834, 0.9054645895957947, 0.42749258875846863, 0.4894157350063324, 0.12845978140830994, 0.33576399087905884, 0.66945481300354, -0.6947240829467773, 0.08556221425533295, 0.5924364924430847, 0.6643633842468262, 0.18421001732349396, -0.4390697181224823, 0.6649201512336731, -0.5777520537376404, -0.5157071948051453, -0.29824891686439514, 0.3743921220302582, 0.9755221605300903, 0.5768170952796936, 0.20521104335784912, -0.31489983201026917, 0.6050273776054382, 0.17980752885341644, 0.8344341516494751, 0.9855253100395203, -0.9248151779174805, -0.168157696723938, -0.5269554257392883, -0.20095239579677582, 0.20222604274749756, -0.21983970701694489, -0.1433168351650238, -0.23910896480083466, -0.0723428726196289, 0.8528571128845215, -0.08754174411296844, -0.25277841091156006, 0.5405083894729614, 0.258343368768692, -0.4278927445411682, -0.3704566955566406, 0.08026451617479324, 0.09555698931217194, -0.3920067846775055, 1.2099626064300537, -0.5252774357795715, -0.0007135370397008955, 0.2036951631307602, -0.04862973093986511, 0.4558194577693939, 0.013209940865635872, 0.30119019746780396, -0.6747297048568726, 0.08863677084445953, 0.19968999922275543, 0.24800287187099457, -0.00518591795116663, -0.6286126375198364, -0.5365001559257507, -0.5513582229614258, 0.0812780037522316, 0.058551397174596786, 0.007823009975254536, -0.3933456242084503, -0.7298744916915894, 0.5215470194816589, -0.5322006940841675, -0.7597861886024475, -0.7551721334457397, -0.8891445398330688, -0.11643194407224655, -0.022086165845394135, -0.489651083946228, 0.6516575217247009, 0.44341301918029785, -0.12587308883666992, 0.27218204736709595, -0.00498281279578805, -0.6957798600196838, 0.31371426582336426, -0.33994409441947937, 0.3232764005661011, -0.03356306627392769, -0.3387905955314636, -0.5411711931228638, -1.1055302619934082, -0.35314518213272095, -0.35058069229125977, -0.08100230991840363, -0.5401525497436523, 0.00417770491912961, 0.06194997578859329, 0.8202996850013733, -0.3372613787651062, 0.095335453748703, 0.35698452591896057, -0.15693604946136475, 0.6108190417289734, -0.1475909948348999, 0.27692052721977234, -0.27978241443634033, 0.4380565285682678, -0.8498058915138245, -0.2424742877483368, -0.3607787787914276, -0.1914173811674118, -0.3354172706604004, -1.2378796339035034, 0.3563340902328491, -0.2975386381149292, -0.8815350532531738, 0.4919658899307251, 0.36741313338279724, -0.5014793276786804, -0.6046304106712341, -0.7440550923347473, 0.029841650277376175, -0.5242573618888855, 0.5378214120864868, -0.1847412884235382, -0.2671756446361542, 0.5032696723937988, 0.10689309984445572, 0.679618775844574, -0.5046806335449219, 4.015386581420898, 0.7788362503051758, 0.31104934215545654, -0.23282895982265472, 0.44529271125793457, -0.18329550325870514, 0.23098015785217285, -0.45645397901535034, 0.6183487772941589, 0.06830500811338425, -0.5049690008163452, 0.24771998822689056, -0.4401915967464447, 0.24735687673091888, 0.6111273169517517, 0.7066441178321838, -0.7885047793388367, 0.07396664470434189, 0.029366711154580116, -1.4002090692520142, -0.7198793888092041, -0.18955034017562866, 0.16850508749485016, -0.26121416687965393, 0.4972202479839325, -0.1224885806441307, 0.7772740721702576, 0.18657143414020538, -0.14386242628097534, -0.8010900020599365, -0.06090221554040909, -0.36921852827072144, 0.49403712153434753, -0.37814003229141235, -0.22663308680057526, 0.5473686456680298, -0.8492802381515503, -0.10973250865936279, -0.29039451479911804, 0.2048959732055664, 0.2639177143573761, 0.05603760480880737, 0.07212161272764206, -0.3911314606666565, -0.24586614966392517, 0.4231553375720978, -1.0068023204803467, 0.3180898129940033, -0.18749591708183289, -0.32966771721839905, 0.7243256568908691, -0.8703316450119019, 0.32874584197998047, -0.3722153604030609, -1.0622612237930298, -0.5545883178710938, -0.19462400674819946, -1.599924087524414, -0.04410133883357048, 0.889857292175293, 0.28892382979393005, 0.26072078943252563, -0.4848483204841614, 0.14612559974193573, 0.24047069251537323, 0.5997443199157715, 0.13525652885437012, 0.5277232527732849, -0.5806565880775452, 0.23193033039569855, 0.2971647381782532, -0.8764960169792175, -0.6041696071624756, 0.014810094609856606, 0.37408924102783203, 0.7411785125732422, -0.31132128834724426, 1.1043421030044556, -0.40027573704719543, -0.8803887963294983, 1.0529848337173462, 0.33443886041641235, 0.7238506078720093, -0.8979486227035522, 0.97779780626297, 0.8920506834983826, -0.8516753315925598, -0.7900745272636414, -0.7840704917907715, 0.8930503726005554, 0.2087768316268921, 0.17716079950332642, 0.5182340145111084, -0.48330560326576233, -0.5126497149467468 ]
{"Title": "Maternal MTHFR A1298C polymorphism and risk of congenital heart disease in fetus", "Authors": "Rai Vandana", "Abstract": "Abstract Methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) is an important enzyme involved in folate metabolism, DNA synthesis and methylation. A number of studies have examined the association of maternal MTHFR A1298C polymorphism with congenital heart disease (CHD) susceptibility; however, the conclusions were contradictory. To clarify the influence of maternal MTHFR A1298C polymorphism on CHD, a meta-analysis of seventeen case- control studies was carried out. Four electronic databases - Pubmed, Google Scholars, Elsevier and Springer Link were searched upto June, 2018 for suitable articles. The pooled odds ratios (ORs) with 95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) were used to evaluate the association. Meta-analysis was performed by Mix and MetaAnalyst programs. The results of meta-analysis suggested that except co-dominant model, maternal A1298C polymorphism is risk for CHD in fetus using overall comparisons in four genetic models (C vs. A: OR= 1.19, 95% CI= 1.00-1.41, p= 0.04; CC+AC vs. AA: OR= 1.19, 95% CI= 0.97-1.4, p= 0.04; CC vs. AA: OR= 1.46, 95% CI= 1.00-2.13, p= 0.04; AC vs. AA OR= 1.13, 95% CI=0.93-1.36, p= 0.23; CC vs. AC+AA: OR=1.34, 95% CI=1.1-1.6, p=0.01). Publication bias was absent using four genetic models. In conclusion, results of present meta-analysis showed significant association between maternal MTHFR A1298C polymorphism and CHD risk.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010298"}
10.1101/19007989
[ -0.34967881441116333, 0.6289641857147217, -0.7372769117355347, 0.5764228105545044, -1.1462807655334473, 0.23644861578941345, 0.016545018181204796, 0.464739590883255, 0.6274439096450806, 0.3012481927871704, 0.12401342391967773, -0.7597302198410034, 0.3861907124519348, -0.04299363121390343, -0.2476428598165512, -0.14465831220149994, -0.95294189453125, 0.01964111067354679, -0.6473840475082397, 0.36562201380729675, 0.1549811214208603, 1.1697109937667847, -0.5020073652267456, 0.0855037048459053, -0.8031582236289978, 0.7201657891273499, -0.3054615259170532, -0.39935019612312317, 0.7159342765808105, 0.7856792211532593, -0.2301657497882843, 0.04086976498365402, 0.8485633134841919, -0.15290947258472443, -0.33508163690567017, -0.6661685109138489, 0.2523464560508728, 0.020450299605727196, -0.5890674591064453, -0.26317664980888367, -0.12858255207538605, -0.3004947602748871, 0.11624550074338913, 0.16969417035579681, -0.6489279866218567, -0.22031435370445251, 0.4064256548881531, -0.6147758364677429, -0.2703152894973755, -0.19794748723506927, 0.05318319797515869, 0.09391786903142929, 0.050412941724061966, -0.45017337799072266, -0.369783878326416, 0.4888392388820648, -0.3324851989746094, 0.2552618086338043, -0.4881947338581085, 0.5064610838890076, 0.04909674823284149, -0.42392274737358093, 0.6150063276290894, -1.1136912107467651, 0.9635934829711914, 0.6227180361747742, -0.10886777937412262, -0.040738679468631744, -0.0790707990527153, -0.28306326270103455, -0.548721969127655, -0.7192496061325073, -0.43556854128837585, -0.6356295943260193, 0.29909440875053406, 0.28590452671051025, 1.0934137105941772, -0.3648364245891571, -0.1628868728876114, -0.6404492259025574, 0.05146041512489319, 0.3112688362598419, 0.26107943058013916, -0.0949481651186943, -0.9807969927787781, 0.24036407470703125, 0.0372522734105587, 0.6348061561584473, 0.8176043629646301, -0.0013995850458741188, -0.31888720393180847, 0.3951583206653595, 0.11182811856269836, -0.629359245300293, 0.0020867742132395506, 0.22841839492321014, -0.7875099182128906, 0.7461016178131104, -0.14629073441028595, -0.7586938738822937, 0.1344246119260788, 0.41567447781562805, -0.0948561504483223, 0.3059641718864441, -0.29102522134780884, 0.5584983229637146, 0.6725378036499023, -0.33537814021110535, -0.4045531153678894, -0.5798799991607666, 0.6922302842140198, -0.2617701590061188, -0.585995614528656, 0.07222484052181244, 0.46854835748672485, 0.6428935527801514, -0.1820850521326065, 0.6534134745597839, -0.20267966389656067, 0.2774839997291565, 0.3832037150859833, 0.02668881230056286, 0.584231972694397, -0.5886014103889465, 0.5511775016784668, -0.3846001923084259, -0.1618719846010208, -0.03542404621839523, -0.38929426670074463, -0.4085559844970703, -0.14700821042060852, -0.481929212808609, -0.09186027944087982, 0.3903576731681824, -0.7945985198020935, 0.06693997979164124, 0.16818487644195557, 0.6880267262458801, 0.17109708487987518, -0.25526395440101624, -0.3935474157333374, 0.7131568789482117, -0.3246610462665558, 0.9268174767494202, -0.031070511788129807, 0.6402438879013062, -0.8224576711654663, -0.6411529779434204, -0.7682445049285889, 0.19303938746452332, 0.03529448062181473, 0.3360763490200043, -0.09887275844812393, 0.25806406140327454, 0.05046345293521881, 0.2329370677471161, -0.32676491141319275, 0.8289812207221985, 0.1257733851671219, 0.07227493822574615, -0.7962310910224915, -0.14722511172294617, -0.047330714762210846, 0.6360733509063721, -0.6483654975891113, 0.6370927691459656, -0.46050554513931274, -0.11157117038965225, 0.27871784567832947, -1.109316110610962, 0.7004193663597107, -0.26175180077552795, -0.09279264509677887, -0.3416230380535126, 0.3661715090274811, 0.7904117703437805, 1.0439603328704834, 0.7614262104034424, 0.5341094136238098, 0.813947856426239, 0.0968504548072815, -0.26689964532852173, 0.5641113519668579, 1.2225627899169922, -0.5106447339057922, 0.08294088393449783, -0.8269835114479065, -0.8602950572967529, -0.1770177185535431, -0.2548772692680359, -0.6045313477516174, 0.4363064765930176, -0.40593698620796204, 0.6538103818893433, 0.16936421394348145, -0.19874359667301178, -0.1462322622537613, 0.42910850048065186, 0.0925622507929802, -0.3162425458431244, -0.3525323271751404, 0.46820223331451416, -0.5319696664810181, 0.23759838938713074, 0.6875535249710083, 0.36065077781677246, -0.4212251603603363, 0.4462798237800598, -1.0734320878982544, 0.3748282790184021, 0.5962984561920166, 0.3977765440940857, -0.24553221464157104, -0.40093091130256653, 0.4128681421279907, -0.427083820104599, -0.0009700817172415555, -0.24119852483272552, -0.6876991987228394, -0.0958593338727951, 0.07639921456575394, -0.7250816822052002, 1.2638999223709106, -0.038527339696884155, -0.4858047664165497, 0.03540469706058502, 0.44820234179496765, 0.35219380259513855, -0.07343342900276184, -0.560409426689148, 0.7198643088340759, 0.13954977691173553, 0.1493472158908844, 0.8972253799438477, 0.9168447256088257, 1.2732048034667969, 0.6688511967658997, 0.08064091950654984, 0.4100128710269928, 0.5430254340171814, 0.6031162142753601, 0.15458735823631287, 0.9840713739395142, 0.013294016942381859, -0.5652226209640503, 0.2869754135608673, -0.42905139923095703, 0.09607582539319992, -0.05816860869526863, -0.3405801057815552, -0.34426984190940857, -0.21255138516426086, 0.716663658618927, 0.03315864875912666, -0.7879495024681091, 0.665855348110199, 0.653795063495636, -0.12922212481498718, -0.0708761066198349, 0.07874699681997299, 0.06876862794160843, 0.6246747374534607, 0.17143718898296356, 0.18161757290363312, 0.8457984924316406, -0.2240772694349289, -0.14477741718292236, 0.6216162443161011, 0.34415939450263977, -0.32757237553596497, -0.5630397796630859, -0.7659033536911011, -0.9040085077285767, -0.8832021951675415, -0.35621586441993713, -0.15936000645160675, -0.13874737918376923, -0.03924664109945297, 0.29920217394828796, -0.21093937754631042, 0.49517425894737244, -1.1042364835739136, -0.010760988108813763, 0.22518619894981384, 0.5670561790466309, 0.24259832501411438, -1.0244340896606445, -0.658359944820404, -0.4192887246608734, -0.46283450722694397, 0.3095790147781372, -0.45211535692214966, -0.3638206720352173, -0.6399253606796265, 0.008159080520272255, -0.45735764503479004, 0.15090696513652802, -0.4795021414756775, -0.8140271902084351, -0.34883806109428406, 0.8986517190933228, -0.1444721668958664, 0.24745358526706696, 0.13572993874549866, -0.5657362341880798, 0.794879138469696, 0.28287461400032043, 0.08164859563112259, 0.365802526473999, 0.1789911836385727, 0.38506394624710083, 0.5422139167785645, -0.29262474179267883, 0.7250510454177856, -0.7271315455436707, -0.34104207158088684, 0.7684322595596313, 0.21425046026706696, -0.23965366184711456, -0.5874291062355042, -0.8144603371620178, -0.20051926374435425, 0.4052840769290924, 0.1950170397758484, -0.7705835103988647, -0.36431512236595154, -0.3998159170150757, -1.3854377269744873, 0.05059337243437767, -0.11678465455770493, -1.4446865320205688, -0.11389947682619095, -0.5398246645927429, 0.06042753532528877, 0.17125947773456573, -0.4381810426712036, 0.454203337430954, -0.007484357338398695, -0.19770099222660065, 0.17597663402557373, 0.26255717873573303, -0.42102837562561035, -0.08531663566827774, 0.4472537040710449, -0.3788507580757141, 0.4686230421066284, 0.06265727430582047, 0.18629604578018188, -0.21605771780014038, -0.46031856536865234, -0.9104536771774292, 0.25081902742385864, 0.1281849443912506, -0.00018804435967467725, 0.19000007212162018, 0.4304417669773102, 0.39729511737823486, -0.0775083526968956, -0.29630303382873535, 0.3833024501800537, 0.06379879266023636, 0.12571752071380615, -0.15561868250370026, -0.26174822449684143, -0.6992012858390808, -0.11469248682260513, 0.7620847225189209, 0.4053669273853302, 0.2613011300563812, -0.212849423289299, 0.4048950672149658, 0.17116709053516388, -0.021161887794733047, -0.08291146904230118, 0.10614396631717682, -0.0645090639591217, 0.7177748680114746, 0.5146777033805847, 0.4978947341442108, -1.548982858657837, -0.022498438134789467, 0.22102834284305573, 0.9796558618545532, -0.12094980478286743, -0.04461083188652992, 0.2008824497461319, -0.7373901009559631, 0.21927186846733093, 0.25660908222198486, -0.34481438994407654, 0.42132803797721863, 0.2712363600730896, 0.17016912996768951, 0.03775690123438835, -0.4965125322341919, -0.0654391199350357, 0.4794229567050934, 0.23839320242404938, 0.3717029094696045, -0.3403216600418091, 0.4912106990814209, 0.5516620874404907, 0.1227317601442337, 0.12924228608608246, 0.40398988127708435, -0.027036529034376144, -0.7116608619689941, -0.2491413652896881, 0.697081983089447, -0.6250060200691223, -0.630071222782135, -0.6183329820632935, 0.03797324374318123, -0.07834626734256744, 0.2077847421169281, 0.1652783751487732, 0.07108357548713684, -0.3407354950904846, 0.061030492186546326, 0.055701661854982376, 0.10740379244089127, 0.24077178537845612, -0.8404314517974854, -0.140999898314476, 0.18878237903118134, -0.3751063048839569, 0.33437982201576233, -0.762530505657196, 0.660987377166748, 1.1417016983032227, -0.3453826904296875, -0.5181462168693542, -0.4038386940956116, -0.47434818744659424, -0.17743702232837677, 0.3876785933971405, 0.31736671924591064, -0.6462779641151428, 0.05106345936655998, -0.23850110173225403, 0.27204418182373047, -0.1238897368311882, -0.029578018933534622, -0.04386550560593605, -0.25576454401016235, 0.3942336440086365, 0.49999552965164185, 0.14632520079612732, 0.7052744626998901, -0.7022236585617065, 0.4236486256122589, -0.5325156450271606, -0.08941959589719772, -0.7392487525939941, -0.03112245351076126, -0.10391451418399811, 0.035710256546735764, -0.010680860839784145, 0.003946430049836636, -0.3058622181415558, -0.35265231132507324, 0.17507748305797577, 0.1276804804801941, -0.2275247722864151, 0.2148628532886505, 0.9186767339706421, -1.1951600313186646, -0.45740488171577454, 1.2324272394180298, -0.4359291195869446, -0.1900477409362793, -0.12094071507453918, 0.048136938363313675, -0.6178614497184753, 0.7750215530395508, -0.2657427489757538, -0.01286182552576065, 0.16386502981185913, -0.05886257439851761, -0.1052316352725029, -0.4255227744579315, 0.015049852430820465, -0.6938819885253906, -0.13408929109573364, -0.44309279322624207, -0.6300246119499207, -0.06620168685913086, -0.34061551094055176, -0.9324373006820679, 0.5841508507728577, -0.2804160714149475, -0.8175597190856934, -0.18748688697814941, 0.15140685439109802, -0.23735323548316956, -0.5294332504272461, -0.02087235078215599, 0.6826817393302917, -0.23076149821281433, -0.3292292356491089, 1.0121614933013916, -1.1032356023788452, -0.9584494233131409, 0.6614654064178467, 0.279792845249176, -0.5413232445716858, -0.040558360517024994, 0.21262814104557037, 0.2480524182319641, -0.009821278043091297, -0.3316948413848877, 0.3970487713813782, -0.433730810880661, 0.33115673065185547, 0.02358742244541645, 0.2854451537132263, 0.3237341344356537, -0.658420205116272, -0.006219277624040842, 0.1111302301287651, -0.3438037931919098, -0.47677069902420044, -0.745894193649292, 0.06851841509342194, 0.13649708032608032, -0.0035522975958883762, -0.3698081076145172, -0.21963642537593842, -0.09838293492794037, -0.8921579122543335, 0.6457696557044983, -0.20552994310855865, -0.37755560874938965, -0.4792174994945526, -0.8369033336639404, -0.31146955490112305, 0.5154891014099121, 0.048848073929548264, 0.09231693297624588, -0.38638877868652344, 0.011147246696054935, 0.9565930962562561, -0.5672804713249207, -0.23899443447589874, -0.2923276126384735, -0.08955484628677368, -0.266986608505249, 0.32261979579925537, 0.20871146023273468, 0.06825242191553116, -0.7068230509757996, -0.008947327733039856, 0.5018315315246582, 0.8129864931106567, 0.06883958727121353, -0.34833693504333496, 0.13801540434360504, -0.38371357321739197, -0.08014307916164398, -0.1076342985033989, -0.6836959719657898, 0.32665276527404785, -0.2232191264629364, 0.23978191614151, -0.6013484597206116, -0.15536542236804962, 0.3556784689426422, -0.5351584553718567, 0.6202928423881531, -0.41287755966186523, -0.4723629951477051, 0.07726220041513443, 0.12219526618719101, -0.4967010021209717, 0.2931830585002899, -0.41526979207992554, -0.3506914973258972, -1.077622413635254, -0.8081851601600647, 0.20952469110488892, 0.15856388211250305, -0.5437313318252563, -0.027471425011754036, -0.4045274257659912, -0.07945364713668823, 0.26331689953804016, 0.9272371530532837, 0.8285592198371887, -0.4622962772846222, -0.28095006942749023, 0.08047077059745789, 0.24186567962169647, 0.332580029964447, 0.42085617780685425, 0.3824854791164398, -0.376981258392334, 0.17866972088813782, -0.7470631003379822, -0.2811921536922455, -1.0176289081573486, -0.20282776653766632, 0.5430914759635925, 0.3461897373199463, 0.04359731823205948, 0.5156466960906982, 0.5181673765182495, -0.5707528591156006, -0.03470294550061226, -0.044380221515893936, -0.18049070239067078, 0.3659469187259674, 0.5093132257461548, 0.03177393227815628, -0.6077532768249512, 0.25090405344963074, 0.07516293972730637, 0.44862839579582214, -0.11453090608119965, 0.2037319540977478, 0.6660933494567871, -0.8717566728591919, 0.5038053393363953, 0.9027273654937744, -0.655114471912384, -0.3055139482021332, -0.23458042740821838, -0.3832824230194092, 0.34044352173805237, -0.8337531089782715, -0.39075449109077454, 0.7036378979682922, -0.04443441331386566, 0.8448266983032227, -0.6454540491104126, -0.20015114545822144, 0.39663946628570557, -0.6411749124526978, 0.4618150293827057, -0.7842118144035339, -0.264225035905838, 0.17116421461105347, 0.18537504971027374, 0.2360144704580307, 0.23458650708198547, 0.30306264758110046, 0.7525036334991455, 0.40781697630882263, 0.2716829478740692, -0.7461950778961182, -0.6818715333938599, 0.037248216569423676, 0.2549784779548645, 0.0627286359667778, 0.23650500178337097, 0.2218736857175827, 0.6289420127868652, 0.19654585421085358, -0.38512977957725525, -0.11616285145282745, 0.5860649347305298, -0.00010987046698573977, -0.03299257159233093, -0.06708724796772003, 0.19598466157913208, 0.8613008260726929, 0.9517366290092468, 0.6197448968887329, 0.18676693737506866, -1.26327383518219, -0.23497381806373596, -0.36764585971832275, 0.06581227481365204, -0.09702703356742859, 0.5126624703407288, 0.15383020043373108, -0.5882047414779663, -0.9517872333526611, -0.5428374409675598, 1.1206319332122803, 0.13245323300361633, -0.027366923168301582, -0.7188987731933594, 0.8664038181304932, -0.543580949306488, -0.7616406679153442, -0.35441532731056213, 0.07080322504043579, -0.4692264199256897, 0.9779015779495239, -0.6847267746925354, 0.025388924404978752, -0.2878822386264801, -0.014867148362100124, -0.7865843772888184, 0.7285189032554626, -0.31810006499290466, -0.14079126715660095, -0.0808904692530632, 0.02050652913749218, -0.11937635391950607, 0.3336107134819031, 1.2333375215530396, -0.9516078233718872, -0.09789077937602997, 0.032438669353723526, -0.3413582146167755, -0.8350832462310791, 0.16304568946361542, 0.2508733868598938, -0.5562007427215576, -1.4723645448684692, -0.164303258061409, 0.3974115550518036, -0.605305552482605, 0.00991416722536087, 0.09635889530181885, 0.47550126910209656, 0.2318699061870575, 0.2861814796924591, -0.05955001339316368, 0.5739638209342957, 0.05369209870696068, 0.2603761851787567, 0.06594819575548172, 0.7620086073875427, 0.3907288908958435, -0.431328147649765, 0.841387152671814, 0.17854714393615723, 0.41057756543159485, -1.486107587814331, 0.41336479783058167, 0.6239578723907471, -0.5489723682403564, 0.6261026859283447, 0.05111163854598999, 0.3045004904270172, 0.26186516880989075, -0.16072137653827667, -0.07188914716243744, 1.1060963869094849, 0.4556398391723633, 0.39823096990585327, 0.46182847023010254, 0.030937466770410538, -0.572441041469574, -0.9149152636528015, -0.6942934393882751, -0.7375067472457886, 0.6522095799446106, -0.3605554401874542, -0.38467761874198914, -0.4533732533454895, -0.6862589120864868, 0.3748966157436371, 0.12319539487361908, 0.6449183225631714, -0.7685328125953674, 0.8984024524688721, 0.10569266974925995, 0.06627361476421356, 0.5199753642082214, -0.3988482356071472, 0.3914659321308136, 0.015984956175088882, -0.832152783870697, -0.4723646938800812, 0.6973028182983398, 0.46885421872138977, 0.5298854112625122, -0.2932521402835846, -0.29461535811424255, 0.4539332389831543, 0.4565941393375397, -0.13717535138130188, -0.7157860994338989, 0.13110268115997314, -0.8240295052528381, 0.2936425805091858, -0.27463483810424805, -0.058779679238796234, -0.38839831948280334, 0.7603375315666199, -0.13483555614948273, -0.5671644806861877, -0.3515606224536896, 0.5566253066062927, 0.4521638751029968, -0.5549865365028381, 0.11615274101495743, -0.39338842034339905, 0.27330151200294495, -0.26323017477989197, -0.6194612979888916, 0.4278077781200409, 1.204188346862793, 0.8923144340515137, 0.44459205865859985, 0.13770247995853424, 0.29806411266326904, 0.6637007594108582, 0.9791793823242188, 0.5212715268135071, 0.3219272792339325, 0.7710574269294739, 0.33475354313850403, 0.08333073556423187, -0.9147709012031555, -0.1205131858587265, 0.2538111209869385, -0.28690505027770996, -0.015571637079119682, 0.6412470936775208, 0.6418691873550415, 0.40764591097831726, -0.2427976429462433, 0.22468602657318115, -0.30058592557907104, -0.2595186233520508, 0.4997195303440094, 0.3092465102672577, 0.3413988947868347, 0.14146165549755096, -0.12040375918149948, -0.20201778411865234, 0.3951919972896576, 0.018093010410666466, 0.41879788041114807, 0.8561022281646729, -0.534519612789154, -0.4437887370586395, -0.6074706315994263, 0.9726908802986145, 0.29469263553619385, 0.2386680692434311, 0.4956289827823639, -0.0867505595088005, 0.29602551460266113, 0.3471823036670685, -0.15045766532421112, -0.8976292014122009, 0.49316608905792236, -0.3462379574775696, -0.5591489672660828, -0.10574977844953537, 0.3945670425891876, -0.47250860929489136, -0.20866866409778595, 0.5135012865066528, -0.3135351836681366, 0.050643958151340485, -0.10168343782424927, 0.519075870513916, 0.46723848581314087, 0.9705683588981628, 0.8413001298904419, -0.37650543451309204, 0.31681889295578003, 0.9134716987609863, -0.055886734277009964, 0.11628097295761108, 0.16720914840698242, -0.13174737989902496, 0.02081991359591484, -0.23258814215660095, 0.36635780334472656, -0.2102561891078949, -0.008410871960222721, -0.5000948905944824, 0.21893396973609924, 0.1524045765399933, 0.17794641852378845, -1.0177268981933594, -0.06051792576909065, 0.1627238690853119, 0.33488407731056213, -0.07951922714710236, 0.40462249517440796, -0.0218290276825428, -0.445785254240036, -0.021008946001529694, -0.3374998867511749, -0.4570293724536896, 0.14934048056602478, -0.4313555061817169, 0.227113738656044, 0.07459115236997604, -0.10641013830900192, -0.7324718236923218, -0.6690054535865784, 0.13107424974441528, 0.5299503803253174, -0.0568460188806057, -0.8572030067443848, -0.19650734961032867, -0.4536604583263397, 0.4541066586971283, 0.014611657708883286, 0.03267649561166763, -0.5591990947723389, 0.45561888813972473, 0.36401864886283875, -0.2811906039714813, 0.20870578289031982, 0.0823332816362381, 0.023598944768309593, -0.13793444633483887, 0.08214223384857178, -0.08156879991292953, -0.8547811508178711, -0.3929116129875183, -0.23187023401260376, 0.0444101057946682, 0.44854745268821716, -0.7581132054328918, -0.23350881040096283, 0.6898452043533325, -0.49064546823501587, 0.21004220843315125, -0.25673985481262207, -1.0837459564208984, -0.31346601247787476, 0.24853740632534027, -0.06917387992143631, 0.09201603382825851, 0.4020550847053528, -0.051857758313417435, 0.67661052942276, -1.0045535564422607, 4.372745990753174, 1.0850809812545776, 0.3255961835384369, 0.007354420609772205, 0.3670307993888855, 0.3686319887638092, 0.8059423565864563, -0.0008525603916496038, -0.18584689497947693, -0.10858926922082901, -0.3370441794395447, -0.05989709496498108, -0.20025880634784698, -0.47373270988464355, 0.33136141300201416, 0.10477037727832794, -0.21306085586547852, -0.056744977831840515, -0.13533566892147064, -0.6028544306755066, -0.24146698415279388, -0.23622125387191772, -0.3893587291240692, 0.14023877680301666, -0.0862904042005539, 0.6340791583061218, -0.090020090341568, 0.35005322098731995, -0.05557510629296303, 0.018039889633655548, -0.054850634187459946, -0.509033203125, -0.12365725636482239, -0.975345253944397, -0.5560803413391113, 0.2267133742570877, 0.16889747977256775, -0.23927462100982666, -0.12195523083209991, -0.4733577072620392, 0.7003132104873657, 0.07457718253135681, -0.36944591999053955, -0.6350237727165222, -0.39421162009239197, 0.14663366973400116, -0.34344783425331116, 0.8604042530059814, 0.5689666867256165, -0.5779748558998108, 0.5535822510719299, -1.1265645027160645, 0.2549436390399933, -0.2289726585149765, -0.36545678973197937, -0.3820015490055084, 0.11283226311206818, -0.5907390713691711, 0.15131591260433197, 0.8328948616981506, 0.6907012462615967, -0.1936769336462021, 0.004301871173083782, 0.5903238654136658, 0.5683748126029968, 0.698529839515686, 0.506407618522644, 0.018749387934803963, -0.2617489993572235, -0.584354043006897, -0.5224311947822571, -0.6176372170448303, -0.004232758190482855, -0.025975262746214867, 1.3957054615020752, 0.44248276948928833, -0.25358545780181885, 0.435348778963089, -0.6796963214874268, -0.37636545300483704, 0.5031381249427795, 0.06724084168672562, 0.3977307975292206, -0.6665626764297485, -0.02320835553109646, 0.9711122512817383, -0.7123348116874695, 0.17904742062091827, -0.5924499034881592, 0.27233025431632996, 0.46222755312919617, -0.5773453712463379, -0.12179899960756302, -0.327883780002594, 0.18076464533805847 ]
{"Title": "A Personalized Multi-Component Lifestyle Intervention Program Leads to Improved Quality of Life in Persons with Chronic Kidney Disease", "Authors": "Headley Samuel A., Hutchinson Jasmin C., Thompson Brian A., Ostroff Marissa L., Doyle-Campbell Courtney J., Cornelius Allen E., Dempsey Kristen, Siddall Jennifer, Miele Emily M., Evans Elizabeth E., Wood Brianna, Sirois Cherilyn M., Winston Brett A., Whalen Stefanie K., Germain Michael. J.", "Abstract": "Abstract Introduction Lifestyle interventions have been shown to produce favorable changes in some health outcomes in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD). However, few such studies, employing \u201creal world\u201d methods have been completed in patients with CKD. Objective This study tested the effectiveness of a comprehensive, multicomponent, lifestyle intervention, delivered through individualized counseling on a variety of health outcomes in pre-dialysis CKD patients. Methods Eligible patients were assigned randomly to the intervention (TR) or usual care group (UC). A six-month home-based program involving personalized counseling to increase physical activity to recommended levels among stage G3a to G4 CKD patients while exchanging plant proteins for animal proteins was implemented. Physical function, cardiovascular function, dietary intake, medication use, and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) were assessed at baseline and after 1-month, 3-months (M3) and 6-months (M6). Results Forty-two, patients (age 60.2 \u00b1 9.2, BMI 34.5 \u00b1 7.8) participated in this study (TR=27 UC=15). The intervention reduced (p<0.05) brachial (bSBP) and central systolic blood pressures (cSBP) at month 3 (M3) but both were attenuated at month 6 (M6). Scores on the effect of kidney disease subscale of the HRQOL measure improved in the intervention group at M3 and M6. There was no change in the other measures of HRQOL or in any physical function scores. Conclusions This personalized multi-component lifestyle intervention enabled CKD patients to self-report fewer concerns with how CKD affected their daily lives independent of changes in physical function.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007989"}
10.1101/19005504
[ 0.13303904235363007, 0.23694102466106415, -0.0824139341711998, -0.29324018955230713, 0.15891237556934357, -0.4823553264141083, -0.43600767850875854, -0.4612780809402466, -0.005509655922651291, 0.7123249769210815, 0.18139447271823883, -0.23731708526611328, 0.9151881337165833, -0.7336525321006775, -0.1908562183380127, -0.4199247658252716, -0.6166521906852722, -0.5916843414306641, -0.7020906209945679, -0.4214470088481903, 0.1874849796295166, 0.5230968594551086, -0.692839503288269, 0.12203012406826019, -0.5470027923583984, 0.47855159640312195, 0.2554934024810791, 0.0969747006893158, 1.1404333114624023, 0.7547269463539124, 0.16247862577438354, -0.41717660427093506, 0.38358646631240845, -0.6225894093513489, 0.07255379855632782, -0.38826343417167664, 0.8447087407112122, -0.2526649832725525, -0.18701918423175812, -0.44406500458717346, 0.3081875443458557, 0.3149067163467407, 0.3155887722969055, -1.2826944589614868, -0.637579619884491, -0.908665657043457, 0.06476125866174698, 0.23567776381969452, 0.2862434387207031, -0.027173535898327827, -0.01746462471783161, -0.49495282769203186, 0.48747995495796204, -0.8933552503585815, -0.261392205953598, -0.21401728689670563, -0.21614708006381989, -0.27770906686782837, -0.4897885024547577, -0.2211427241563797, 0.7174534201622009, 0.1931699961423874, 0.3855421841144562, -0.25598156452178955, 0.30441814661026, 0.2965116500854492, 0.07909446209669113, -0.39118289947509766, -0.6371025443077087, -0.009514973498880863, -0.8619804978370667, 0.37282639741897583, -0.02858617529273033, -0.4113297462463379, -0.2945638597011566, -0.12433608621358871, -0.15554971992969513, -0.23560023307800293, -0.5639524459838867, 0.21954602003097534, 0.19402959942817688, 0.3347741365432739, 0.5085977911949158, -0.08856537938117981, -0.10347086191177368, -0.12510226666927338, 0.49990251660346985, -0.582680881023407, 0.27892035245895386, 0.24625146389007568, 0.5060156583786011, 0.5518811941146851, 0.09673914313316345, 0.20809116959571838, 0.4058244526386261, 0.6042642593383789, 0.5694873332977295, 0.46414217352867126, 0.4082154333591461, 0.022559212520718575, 0.8095883727073669, 1.4340083599090576, 0.06521167606115341, 0.6350709199905396, -0.3713548481464386, 0.4381813406944275, 0.14107677340507507, -0.14554625749588013, -0.08081627637147903, -0.8556089401245117, 0.1367902159690857, -0.11845207214355469, 0.04126537963747978, -0.3011780381202698, 0.20178724825382233, 0.4568973779678345, 0.5245295166969299, 1.0992176532745361, -0.13467971980571747, 0.4827130138874054, -0.290047824382782, 0.5977554321289062, 0.12900693714618683, -0.6211957931518555, -0.11276714503765106, 0.24560366570949554, 0.3033837378025055, 0.5302888751029968, -0.39582979679107666, -0.2014852613210678, -0.042840391397476196, 0.041293445974588394, -1.1532635688781738, 0.5647017359733582, -0.013729779049754143, -0.1361110955476761, 0.5781844854354858, -0.02455267868936062, -0.03101988695561886, -0.16683337092399597, -0.27316319942474365, 0.6349061727523804, -0.8175257444381714, 1.1284416913986206, -1.0476720333099365, 0.4337550103664398, -0.1212107315659523, -0.9068605899810791, -0.5214546322822571, -0.9154549241065979, -0.11735719442367554, 0.5066945552825928, 0.15531787276268005, -0.024207444861531258, -0.4027304947376251, -0.12164107710123062, -0.1208815947175026, -0.31733569502830505, -0.5524318814277649, 0.08762893080711365, 0.29914531111717224, 0.37127867341041565, -0.9666284918785095, 0.1981053203344345, -0.029406534507870674, 0.5141521096229553, 0.6855624318122864, -0.10582419484853745, 0.216899111866951, -0.8062272667884827, 0.2284199744462967, 0.23675818741321564, 0.09153547883033752, 0.2921706736087799, 0.17624026536941528, 0.6436540484428406, 0.9910514950752258, 0.13376206159591675, 0.3322809338569641, 0.37818774580955505, 0.2726893126964569, -0.7829689383506775, 0.7389726638793945, -0.07237786054611206, -0.08464612066745758, 0.7364738583564758, -0.5667018294334412, -0.24722473323345184, -0.3211399018764496, -0.5531224012374878, 0.3525855839252472, 1.5336424112319946, -0.6126976609230042, 0.24484597146511078, -0.4144022464752197, -0.2525368332862854, 0.26197418570518494, 0.7526206970214844, 0.831718385219574, -0.7544881701469421, -0.47746747732162476, 0.6939606070518494, -0.08031433075666428, 0.5759257674217224, -0.9316131472587585, 0.5958779454231262, 0.2947450280189514, 0.5546900629997253, -0.10523365437984467, 0.4695277512073517, -0.05591301992535591, -0.08484091609716415, -0.17231900990009308, 0.7155743837356567, 1.0051392316818237, -0.4478257894515991, 0.1583004891872406, -0.0897487923502922, 0.08165884763002396, -0.28021499514579773, -0.6022754311561584, 0.06456342339515686, 0.9709320068359375, -0.16256895661354065, 0.05805022642016411, -0.3802420198917389, 0.521841824054718, 0.5784283876419067, -0.06370876729488373, -0.03820822760462761, -0.24725604057312012, 0.49667254090309143, -0.21869996190071106, 0.4221487045288086, 0.6830077767372131, 0.5392538905143738, 0.7797015905380249, 0.6331473588943481, 0.8284180760383606, -0.3913362920284271, -0.35677850246429443, -0.34015506505966187, 0.5207090377807617, 0.49840834736824036, -0.18183860182762146, 0.47456809878349304, 0.10133200138807297, -0.11210054159164429, 0.34438350796699524, -0.45694786310195923, -0.5865684151649475, 1.4755992889404297, 0.9118452668190002, 0.33499589562416077, -0.7249456644058228, -0.20672538876533508, 0.6532191634178162, 0.8743526935577393, -0.20028379559516907, -0.7602869272232056, -0.00044330378295853734, 0.0936821848154068, -0.19680050015449524, -0.10011503845453262, 0.3647001385688782, 0.20147180557250977, -0.03857148066163063, 0.24081070721149445, -0.15018337965011597, -0.30086037516593933, -0.8228175640106201, -1.22151517868042, -1.251314640045166, -0.214821457862854, -0.7698663473129272, 0.10003535449504852, -0.7465499639511108, -1.21906316280365, 0.5240479707717896, 0.20749107003211975, -0.5715509057044983, -0.0726829543709755, -0.5966920852661133, 0.3135365843772888, 0.3564341366291046, 0.2619360387325287, -1.4850072860717773, 0.7060472369194031, 0.0003341268457006663, 0.254914790391922, -0.1448441445827484, -0.5118438601493835, -0.835360050201416, -0.2199411392211914, 0.6742099523544312, -0.3771779239177704, 0.1017821654677391, 0.6556293964385986, -0.008797703310847282, 0.03133351355791092, 0.5374305248260498, -0.3537697494029999, 0.03273720294237137, -0.2548511028289795, -0.383980393409729, 0.3579135239124298, -0.6670109033584595, -0.1997799128293991, 0.4663270115852356, 0.8102961778640747, -0.4837024509906769, 0.997492253780365, 0.3271505832672119, -0.12117856740951538, -0.5140638947486877, -0.17936907708644867, 0.31225892901420593, -0.6981191039085388, -0.30934974551200867, -0.27239513397216797, -0.8294962644577026, -0.5129790902137756, -0.49121806025505066, -0.33230462670326233, -0.06575831025838852, 0.9473603367805481, -0.16592134535312653, -0.9716690182685852, 0.5338462591171265, -1.325227975845337, -0.7528945803642273, 0.1718348264694214, 0.22309871017932892, 0.6378296613693237, 0.38145554065704346, 0.23902565240859985, -0.7025805711746216, 0.11809414625167847, 0.9149563312530518, 0.4553038477897644, 0.6287490725517273, -0.23077525198459625, -0.37742239236831665, 0.44039177894592285, -0.38648417592048645, 0.1261122226715088, -0.7244847416877747, -0.4676443338394165, -0.9919852018356323, -0.17396463453769684, -0.0692315325140953, -0.13670986890792847, 0.48730558156967163, 0.523600161075592, -0.018130658194422722, 0.7759830355644226, -0.7489182949066162, 0.11202264577150345, 0.5770641565322876, 0.632838249206543, 0.13313013315200806, 0.046139463782310486, 0.18891815841197968, 0.8163661360740662, -0.473481684923172, -0.21083983778953552, 0.012592630460858345, 0.229075089097023, -0.11698349565267563, -1.0065666437149048, 0.8466638922691345, -0.44755786657333374, -0.3971058130264282, 0.29364123940467834, 0.1306941658258438, -0.19016388058662415, 0.9892790913581848, -0.26059094071388245, 1.5256470441818237, -0.8149905204772949, 0.02333815209567547, 0.5351191163063049, 0.09176047891378403, -0.07307719439268112, 0.14872461557388306, 0.4481474757194519, -0.2416951209306717, -0.1819334179162979, -0.013716970570385456, -0.7502687573432922, -0.40955331921577454, -0.18024802207946777, -0.2910425066947937, -0.3408275544643402, -0.43305981159210205, 0.07039418816566467, 0.6618863940238953, 0.22438669204711914, 0.24754999577999115, 0.25085821747779846, 0.521264374256134, -0.4597891867160797, 0.6885899901390076, 0.49096211791038513, 0.5701107978820801, 0.1624843329191208, -0.364997535943985, -0.5717668533325195, -0.45369166135787964, 0.1513870805501938, -0.4134766459465027, 0.20037181675434113, -0.9212225675582886, -0.07198220491409302, 0.7128945589065552, 0.18403507769107819, -0.2982419729232788, 0.024761250242590904, 0.10623428970575333, 0.07870200276374817, 0.21871568262577057, -0.1283731907606125, -0.7578189969062805, 0.6299914121627808, -0.5254537463188171, -1.1002402305603027, 0.20276769995689392, -0.7093718647956848, 0.3000403940677643, 0.6189642548561096, -0.8662475347518921, -0.20616288483142853, 0.026588043197989464, -0.4211738407611847, 0.01247833576053381, -0.19697049260139465, -0.11126049607992172, 0.7365421652793884, 0.6149535179138184, -0.3817930221557617, -0.5556079149246216, -0.16633835434913635, -0.6413161754608154, -0.6616991758346558, 0.04404119402170181, -0.08696035295724869, 0.4360540509223938, 0.53425532579422, 0.3922784924507141, -0.41288548707962036, 0.3864917457103729, -0.62502121925354, 0.4714250862598419, -0.36622756719589233, 0.10216779261827469, 0.0794464647769928, -0.05207160860300064, -0.49069640040397644, 0.4634855091571808, 0.0496482253074646, -0.8108071088790894, -0.12230485677719116, 0.27775999903678894, -0.11382728070020676, -0.9203962683677673, 0.36927857995033264, 0.24154052138328552, -0.180274099111557, 1.2710026502609253, -0.416708379983902, -0.09823324531316757, -0.9023338556289673, -0.3543841540813446, -0.5392470359802246, 0.6095655560493469, -0.7015427947044373, 0.3576953709125519, -0.32486647367477417, -0.8146074414253235, 0.18799050152301788, -0.4013562500476837, 0.7103020548820496, -0.8646853566169739, -0.7795912027359009, -0.8625999689102173, -0.28853100538253784, -0.27439236640930176, -0.45514386892318726, -0.7857391834259033, 0.4930289387702942, -0.3280118405818939, -0.5330291986465454, -0.35382476449012756, -0.6514884829521179, -0.12054385244846344, -0.03202171251177788, -0.552372395992279, -0.30047011375427246, 0.12857341766357422, 0.21054969727993011, 0.21161960065364838, -0.4554172158241272, -0.6696827411651611, 0.38410449028015137, 0.5095228552818298, -0.1831303834915161, -0.4233703911304474, 0.0206882506608963, 0.08439125120639801, -0.5653064250946045, -0.5701894164085388, 0.6785678267478943, -0.6248260140419006, 0.33419328927993774, 0.12901325523853302, 0.2027314305305481, -0.13680137693881989, -0.4065427780151367, -0.6664721965789795, 0.5878608226776123, -0.39541780948638916, -0.6778572797775269, -0.5951047539710999, -0.08223405480384827, 0.38712120056152344, 0.4551684260368347, -0.5576723217964172, -0.533466100692749, -0.4457283616065979, -0.5275996327400208, 0.5899962782859802, -0.22044813632965088, 0.27209189534187317, -0.312630832195282, 0.03460797294974327, -0.4793146550655365, 0.3247038424015045, 0.141494482755661, -0.28597742319107056, -0.3776382505893707, -0.18143780529499054, -0.2954474687576294, -0.1690443605184555, -0.9404171705245972, 0.32359087467193604, 0.2790415585041046, -0.005966211203485727, 0.21250200271606445, 0.22021174430847168, 0.11739456653594971, 0.08654509484767914, 0.27529817819595337, 0.19032062590122223, 0.4528731405735016, -0.14746898412704468, -0.3873777687549591, 0.6103553771972656, 0.5674803853034973, 0.7604165077209473, -0.2798892855644226, -0.3908422589302063, 0.3327504098415375, -1.3193483352661133, 0.5194166302680969, -0.4649745225906372, -0.12682902812957764, 0.5732224583625793, -0.26706984639167786, 1.133410096168518, -0.3688059449195862, -0.2509470283985138, -0.2078995555639267, 0.443503737449646, 0.37536290287971497, -0.25143691897392273, -0.590996503829956, -0.9234821796417236, -0.7670698165893555, -0.439792662858963, -0.3888055980205536, -0.032867319881916046, -0.26033997535705566, 0.3419446349143982, 0.6868315935134888, 0.3001028895378113, -0.6085016131401062, 0.8154627084732056, 0.12526926398277283, 0.2084198147058487, -0.3427293300628662, 0.0037917648442089558, -0.40062808990478516, 0.2657089829444885, 0.3126414716243744, -0.20193970203399658, -0.342734694480896, 0.2643146216869354, -0.6143234372138977, 0.058134742081165314, -0.7179017066955566, -0.011816015467047691, -0.443149209022522, 0.5320668816566467, -0.6899001598358154, -0.38949790596961975, 0.8740531206130981, -0.18156790733337402, -0.41231849789619446, -0.01604444719851017, -0.33350980281829834, -0.07285148650407791, 0.9320883750915527, -0.1275838315486908, -0.46284765005111694, -0.33078479766845703, -0.2982397675514221, -0.20216019451618195, 0.3563000559806824, 0.6233659386634827, 0.10414738953113556, -0.424016535282135, 0.2708835005760193, 0.04899302124977112, -0.8119978904724121, -0.3428683876991272, 0.3389040231704712, -0.559472382068634, 0.5115916132926941, -0.44352489709854126, 0.1534910649061203, -0.2682027518749237, -0.10226725786924362, 0.39565226435661316, -0.19371746480464935, -0.06998959928750992, -0.032025884836912155, -0.07870377600193024, 0.11165399104356766, -0.4193185865879059, 0.7635083198547363, 0.5280786752700806, -0.5888494253158569, 0.42111948132514954, -0.3196958005428314, 0.20514361560344696, -0.2899358570575714, 0.6776978969573975, 0.37425363063812256, -0.24036528170108795, 0.3645913600921631, 0.4905049502849579, -0.023795371875166893, 0.11629999428987503, 0.26743507385253906, 0.029955541715025902, 0.3725855052471161, 0.13440115749835968, -1.374964952468872, -0.3683840334415436, 0.15873077511787415, -0.03324534371495247, 0.4398995041847229, -0.26143139600753784, 0.08033296465873718, 0.14674678444862366, 0.7516331076622009, 1.0554040670394897, -0.4274304509162903, -0.3777507543563843, -0.49166420102119446, 0.32561272382736206, 0.06174016743898392, -0.3386242687702179, -0.1904856115579605, 0.18685026466846466, 0.37755003571510315, -0.7395835518836975, 0.5549294948577881, 0.5579569935798645, -0.45314615964889526, 0.164402574300766, -0.7626948356628418, 0.43153247237205505, -0.18858987092971802, -0.9773731231689453, -0.28550028800964355, -0.42508944869041443, 0.07463574409484863, 0.3886808753013611, -0.35396015644073486, -0.12473606318235397, 0.29047152400016785, 0.38836655020713806, -0.12579382956027985, 0.5105966329574585, -0.7679249048233032, 0.2724914252758026, -0.2656583786010742, 0.5225458145141602, -0.10955016314983368, 0.5855430960655212, 0.2738599181175232, -0.4248110055923462, 0.4177473783493042, 0.2361704707145691, -0.09792943298816681, 0.3116030991077423, -0.05177685618400574, 0.3737715482711792, -0.25283220410346985, -0.6602463126182556, 0.03168288618326187, 0.6053596138954163, -0.421724796295166, 0.1965334415435791, 0.3451981246471405, 0.07687490433454514, 0.3320283889770508, 0.14960847795009613, -0.2735177278518677, 0.8904470801353455, 0.16056203842163086, 0.7124065160751343, -0.34173157811164856, 0.05253013223409653, -0.504767656326294, 0.4985353350639343, 0.6782342791557312, 0.5100363492965698, -0.029452679678797722, -1.3159385919570923, 0.2563340365886688, 0.23660945892333984, -0.18494075536727905, 0.23086343705654144, -0.6451159119606018, 0.4261745810508728, 0.32392755150794983, 0.10738343745470047, 0.5353208184242249, 0.37801942229270935, 0.09429711103439331, -0.13993139564990997, 0.022687600925564766, 0.27875277400016785, -0.6686245203018188, 0.45231789350509644, -1.1111003160476685, -0.4514143168926239, -0.02110961638391018, -0.33098819851875305, -0.10393323004245758, -0.7003144025802612, -0.8070870637893677, 0.10659296065568924, 0.21157094836235046, 0.23714253306388855, -0.672710657119751, 1.0145903825759888, 0.0634542778134346, 0.8071444034576416, 0.17078591883182526, -0.03435148298740387, -0.2824191749095917, 0.3487432897090912, -0.7195590138435364, -0.14389470219612122, 0.691728949546814, 0.4477290213108063, 0.37403735518455505, -0.6395928263664246, -0.6867643594741821, 0.46425068378448486, -0.048136111348867416, -0.41125789284706116, -0.15281373262405396, -0.2329031378030777, -1.131881833076477, -0.21155010163784027, -0.2922672629356384, 0.36602485179901123, -0.5413115620613098, 0.5213007926940918, -0.029058586806058884, -0.5948448777198792, -0.5917934775352478, 0.16773772239685059, 0.38970568776130676, -0.4900152385234833, 0.4054506719112396, 0.09970782697200775, 0.6349464654922485, 0.6577253341674805, -0.48402801156044006, 0.618311882019043, 0.17760562896728516, 0.03606069087982178, -0.23845301568508148, -0.8679606318473816, 0.5209989547729492, 0.7234049439430237, -0.08722217381000519, 0.7169139385223389, 1.151789665222168, 0.08211858570575714, 0.2507511377334595, 0.10812435299158096, -0.4062781035900116, 0.5560298562049866, 0.6131386756896973, 0.16385699808597565, 0.09547645598649979, 0.3574753701686859, -0.24712300300598145, 0.6691821813583374, -0.24958303570747375, 0.22529858350753784, 0.005076161585748196, -1.2873034477233887, -0.02741681970655918, 0.07470811903476715, 0.6252269148826599, 0.29456716775894165, 0.679339587688446, 0.09557002782821655, 0.5209444165229797, 0.7370916604995728, -0.31497621536254883, 0.40923038125038147, -0.23030373454093933, 0.08018511533737183, -0.19330891966819763, 0.6417528986930847, 0.09123676270246506, -0.07876656204462051, -0.689169704914093, -0.04120778664946556, -0.11950856447219849, 0.09736435115337372, 0.18720875680446625, -0.07737471908330917, 0.4862957000732422, -0.3161020576953888, 0.7698516249656677, -0.3189059793949127, 0.12901164591312408, -0.9261207580566406, -0.0955677330493927, 0.37934166193008423, 0.154258131980896, -0.560474693775177, 0.8567867875099182, 0.1461837887763977, -0.04107451066374779, 0.18999171257019043, 0.5402465462684631, -0.4523852467536926, 0.7141894698143005, 0.17698031663894653, 0.49831464886665344, 0.14175941050052643, 0.3040737807750702, -0.5843648314476013, 0.13639463484287262, -0.10786079615354538, 0.10380425304174423, 0.06529911607503891, -0.20530180633068085, -0.725498616695404, -0.3388431966304779, 0.00679496256634593, -0.4809648096561432, -0.27599915862083435, 0.10207149386405945, -0.8337733745574951, -0.5064626336097717, -0.2844184339046478, 0.33863767981529236, 0.16946710646152496, 0.30854061245918274, -0.3246649205684662, -0.8458555936813354, -0.3317486643791199, -0.2813741862773895, 0.039688944816589355, 0.916038453578949, -0.5165910124778748, -1.2678700685501099, 0.016528848558664322, -0.6201759576797485, -0.7536702156066895, 0.7524070143699646, 0.589708685874939, -0.22273918986320496, -0.01302719209343195, 0.1437188982963562, 1.1119616031646729, -0.13416048884391785, -0.1956719011068344, 0.0010467772372066975, 0.0573931448161602, 0.962866485118866, 0.49239951372146606, 0.7992916107177734, 0.30444619059562683, -0.01277394499629736, 0.2324516475200653, -0.6400405168533325, -0.40520650148391724, -0.2285042703151703, -0.4097278118133545, -0.5678447484970093, 0.42175135016441345, -0.15695573389530182, -0.7467551231384277, 0.15087012946605682, 0.8251323699951172, 0.04113524407148361, -0.13097958266735077, -1.041966199874878, 0.31621018052101135, -0.86575847864151, 1.0317288637161255, 0.12868548929691315, 0.8270552754402161, 0.04562653973698616, -0.6622567772865295, -0.3690730929374695, -0.6176019310951233, 4.3244309425354, 0.5904853343963623, 1.0651370286941528, 0.6297565698623657, 0.4515988528728485, 0.3106866776943207, 0.3849751651287079, -0.6048227548599243, 0.008742372505366802, 0.47796276211738586, -0.22678089141845703, 0.07462862879037857, -0.16951656341552734, 0.2578679621219635, 0.49101075530052185, 0.4136574864387512, -0.37402892112731934, -0.12692996859550476, 0.20225633680820465, -0.7064793705940247, -0.6062650084495544, 0.6253182291984558, 0.022236164659261703, 0.42488059401512146, -0.08188111335039139, -0.7781645059585571, 0.2643720507621765, 0.14195019006729126, -0.05517054349184036, -0.25997620820999146, -0.12283734977245331, -0.43063056468963623, 0.022624582052230835, -0.865020751953125, -0.13301053643226624, 0.21275873482227325, 0.07497836649417877, -0.6197800040245056, -0.21517255902290344, 0.02863348461687565, 0.5237845182418823, 0.38741636276245117, 0.23989078402519226, -0.06956999748945236, -0.6081186532974243, 0.07969404757022858, -0.26328763365745544, 0.3825686275959015, 1.0992231369018555, -0.8862505555152893, 1.1142594814300537, -0.7475222945213318, 0.6676661968231201, -0.005027916748076677, -0.7058216333389282, -0.44470763206481934, -0.9834993481636047, -0.7660661935806274, -0.46393629908561707, 0.9132397770881653, 0.11162073910236359, 0.43901580572128296, 0.34751787781715393, -0.32454580068588257, -0.45933443307876587, 0.27694171667099, 0.21163982152938843, 0.2454390823841095, -0.1382773369550705, 0.27918198704719543, 0.47026482224464417, -0.32714352011680603, 0.07076440006494522, -0.056120216846466064, 0.6077452301979065, 0.4650183320045471, -0.03643348067998886, 0.6317707300186157, -0.07347343116998672, -0.7087900638580322, -0.31517359614372253, 0.07662232965230942, 0.4921092689037323, -0.3079186677932739, -0.07547309249639511, 0.6118413805961609, -0.9039934277534485, -0.8138233423233032, -0.9481087923049927, 0.45407143235206604, 0.6574355363845825, 0.03619246557354927, 0.20356164872646332, -0.2555292248725891, -0.33100518584251404 ]
{"Title": "Impact of spectrograms on the classification of wheezes and crackles in an educational setting. An interrater study", "Authors": "Aviles-Solis JC., Storvoll I, Sophie Vanbelle, Melbye H.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Chest auscultation is a widely used method in the diagnosis of lung diseases. However, the interpretation of lung sounds is a subjective task and disagreements arise. New technological developments like the use of visual representation of sounds through spectrograms could improve the agreement when classifying lung sounds, but this is not yet known. Aims To test if the use of spectrograms improves the agreement when classifying wheezes and crackles. Methods We used 30 lung sounds recordings. The sample contained 15 normal recordings and 15 with wheezes or crackles. We produced spectrograms of the recordings. Twenty-three third to fifth-year medical students at UiT the Arctic University of Norway classified the recordings using an online questionnaire. We first showed the students examples of how wheezes and crackles looked in the spectrogram. Then, we played the recordings in a random order two times, first without the spectrogram, then with live spectrograms displayed. We asked them to classify the sounds for the presence of wheezes and crackles. We calculated kappa values for the agreement between each student and the expert classification with and without display of spectrograms and tested for significant improvement. We also calculated Fleiss kappa for the 23 observers with and without the spectrogram. Results When classifying wheezes 13/23 (1 with p<.05) students had a positive change in k, and 16/23 (2 with p<.05). All the statistically significant changes were in the direction of improved kappa values (.52 - .75). Fleiss kappa values were k=.51 and k=.56 (p=.63) for wheezes without and with spectrograms. For crackles, these values were k=.22 and k=.40 (p=<0.01) in the same order. Conclusions The use of spectrograms had a positive impact on the inter-rater agreement and the agreement with experts. We observed a higher improvement in the classification of crackles compared to wheezes.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005504"}
10.1101/19014118
[ -0.2415846884250641, 0.3135308623313904, -0.4899330139160156, 0.38943612575531006, -0.6556499004364014, -0.5528456568717957, 0.12284903228282928, 0.13495418429374695, 0.6452429294586182, 0.35288769006729126, -0.012936090119183064, -0.09499605000019073, -0.21435649693012238, -0.5227834582328796, -0.4945218861103058, 0.3073301315307617, -0.24347329139709473, 0.4944627285003662, -0.3654315769672394, 0.16309112310409546, 0.3667481541633606, 0.058610644191503525, -0.7010030150413513, -0.4335004985332489, -1.213944673538208, -0.09136035293340683, 0.0068292818032205105, -0.6688981652259827, 1.3567050695419312, 0.7407385110855103, -0.053579460829496384, -0.2266622930765152, 0.7925176620483398, -0.5829253196716309, 0.02501003071665764, 0.13598667085170746, 0.7188584804534912, -1.3597830533981323, -0.43172723054885864, -0.13871626555919647, -0.12814365327358246, -0.008943767286837101, 0.7713593244552612, -0.16242294013500214, -0.752350926399231, -0.5142444372177124, -0.022409431636333466, -0.19554591178894043, 0.16967523097991943, -0.3163997232913971, -0.8303385972976685, -0.0346507765352726, 0.020692622289061546, -0.22339452803134918, 0.1387944519519806, -0.28865575790405273, 0.6776973605155945, -0.1562270075082779, -0.07160763442516327, 0.4139246344566345, 0.3355567455291748, -0.19869445264339447, 0.8462357521057129, -0.6135029196739197, 0.07830369472503662, 1.4631613492965698, -0.5825967192649841, 0.2713402211666107, 0.24360007047653198, -0.6078420281410217, 0.18848058581352234, 0.14326444268226624, -0.13309137523174286, -0.41718196868896484, -0.4541313350200653, -0.21884562075138092, -0.2312106341123581, -0.5948584079742432, 0.30165544152259827, -0.3213671147823334, -0.31228524446487427, 0.869530200958252, 1.0163804292678833, -0.25933074951171875, -0.44348961114883423, -0.5139532685279846, 0.7977229952812195, 0.5063687562942505, 0.020320968702435493, 0.8223696947097778, 0.583207905292511, 0.5616281032562256, -0.6605592966079712, 0.40526309609413147, 0.1477377712726593, 1.1277244091033936, -0.17688165605068207, -0.34655144810676575, 0.040825873613357544, 0.15089979767799377, 0.3945086598396301, 0.3079468011856079, -0.28190878033638, 0.7811269760131836, -0.6510183215141296, 0.8579891920089722, 0.06111893430352211, -0.4558587968349457, 0.3084076941013336, -0.6999461054801941, -0.17580321431159973, 0.49726608395576477, -0.7983500957489014, -0.7062281966209412, 0.5701197981834412, 0.26258954405784607, 0.13108181953430176, 1.272007942199707, -0.545782744884491, 1.2827967405319214, -0.5322467684745789, 0.1711769551038742, 0.7910646200180054, 0.145189568400383, 0.26476824283599854, -0.8283373713493347, 1.2596006393432617, 0.5770074129104614, -0.3897407650947571, -0.5847992300987244, 0.2345680147409439, -0.409566193819046, -0.45292094349861145, 0.8145577311515808, 0.0468984954059124, -0.0651903748512268, 0.49386683106422424, 1.0028843879699707, 0.15423814952373505, -0.29000160098075867, -0.821992814540863, 1.4575986862182617, -0.28607720136642456, 0.8821544051170349, 0.09366301447153091, 0.5912691950798035, -0.013657690025866032, -0.6298201084136963, -1.1370822191238403, 0.3477919101715088, 0.3958818018436432, 0.8000918626785278, 0.22456489503383636, -0.14265477657318115, 0.28958019614219666, -0.058892056345939636, -0.5403090715408325, 0.3930487036705017, -0.9463949799537659, 0.8524563908576965, -0.9257692694664001, -0.36122235655784607, -0.13089913129806519, 0.93668133020401, -0.7276872396469116, 0.08986973017454147, 0.3430369794368744, -0.01745745539665222, 0.08031459897756577, -0.5876561403274536, 0.6086444854736328, 0.2749669849872589, -0.1387723684310913, -0.31684693694114685, 0.4056749939918518, 1.1454299688339233, 0.37433362007141113, 0.20278829336166382, 0.08863025903701782, 1.2626851797103882, 0.06752234697341919, 0.5096362233161926, 0.14237859845161438, 0.3054147958755493, -0.4155294597148895, 0.20527981221675873, -0.6042135953903198, -0.7954162359237671, -0.4053187668323517, -0.36039528250694275, 0.1619977355003357, 0.5295729637145996, -1.3985631465911865, 1.0460084676742554, -0.014313233084976673, 0.01988096721470356, -0.19235621392726898, 0.17874370515346527, 0.17163103818893433, 0.038371965289115906, -0.9013476371765137, 0.11367658525705338, 0.4844856858253479, 0.3889060318470001, -0.6878939270973206, 0.5710527896881104, 0.37949660420417786, -0.10601256042718887, 0.15642966330051422, 0.12281256914138794, 1.2436600923538208, 0.11985565721988678, -1.0012059211730957, 0.550876259803772, 0.36488640308380127, -0.5939778089523315, -0.7610758543014526, 0.02087266556918621, -0.11785709112882614, -0.29542845487594604, -0.4902302920818329, 0.48740801215171814, 0.2430488020181656, 0.4612463116645813, 0.08702249079942703, -0.2288789302110672, 1.1524672508239746, 0.45375242829322815, -1.0607093572616577, -0.4720856547355652, 0.13263192772865295, 0.25355497002601624, 0.09984871000051498, 0.18652813136577606, 1.4528396129608154, 0.2387443333864212, 0.3881070613861084, 0.33300432562828064, 0.8934457302093506, 0.0705319494009018, 0.7961037755012512, 0.3088998794555664, 0.7649881839752197, 0.39729103446006775, 0.15259024500846863, 0.7443597316741943, 0.19615082442760468, -1.000543475151062, -0.28359952569007874, -0.05666295811533928, -0.25713348388671875, 0.5645159482955933, 0.726926326751709, 0.5462309718132019, -0.5280910730361938, 0.22574584186077118, 1.0026100873947144, 0.10263446718454361, -0.579293966293335, -0.840691864490509, -0.01732989214360714, -0.06501908600330353, -0.3984188437461853, -0.09473565965890884, 0.2901541590690613, 0.41843733191490173, -0.7404785752296448, -0.1994418054819107, 0.14232012629508972, -0.5159687399864197, -0.8817561268806458, -0.4641140103340149, -1.3471232652664185, 0.04401182383298874, -0.43484577536582947, 0.6509214043617249, -0.1483077108860016, -0.19930872321128845, 0.6420890092849731, 0.022757980972528458, -0.03227750584483147, 0.08933261036872864, -0.4429541230201721, 0.600226104259491, 0.40734121203422546, -0.059331029653549194, -1.380811095237732, 0.4406319260597229, 0.23586252331733704, 0.38834571838378906, -0.05929913744330406, -0.1783425658941269, -0.8878601789474487, -0.718848705291748, 0.8515225648880005, -1.2622332572937012, 0.7236079573631287, 0.12914948165416718, -0.5705425143241882, -0.5668075680732727, 0.8213510513305664, 0.1695350855588913, 0.28927063941955566, -0.23231272399425507, -0.3976125419139862, 1.5983798503875732, 0.264586865901947, 0.38573282957077026, -0.16386312246322632, 0.5744723081588745, -0.09358660131692886, 0.6114294528961182, -0.005163264460861683, 0.847614586353302, -0.7248812317848206, 0.9749477505683899, 0.5249232053756714, -0.7921432852745056, -0.023154933005571365, -0.17914174497127533, -1.2507355213165283, -0.15185000002384186, -0.17403267323970795, -0.3000207543373108, -0.1346643567085266, 0.08386729657649994, 0.17821118235588074, -1.2922228574752808, 0.5066266059875488, -0.6664286255836487, -0.5948470234870911, 0.15708281099796295, -0.668406069278717, 0.30862584710121155, -0.7364621758460999, 0.06802324205636978, -0.4712832570075989, 0.33955079317092896, -0.02026952989399433, -0.018874524161219597, 0.010597570799291134, -0.43764784932136536, 0.5309850573539734, 0.22845688462257385, -0.7932994961738586, 0.35905903577804565, -0.48579004406929016, 0.18866591155529022, -1.2810975313186646, -0.2646913230419159, -0.565111517906189, 0.5591585636138916, 0.5439941883087158, -0.44200843572616577, -0.17646683752536774, 1.0659115314483643, 0.23459091782569885, 0.07665354758501053, 0.23136763274669647, 0.5735149383544922, -0.004676707088947296, -0.25132864713668823, -0.48624226450920105, 1.0968624353408813, -0.5995255708694458, -0.44212043285369873, 0.4383751153945923, 0.20779696106910706, 0.21565592288970947, -0.6058355569839478, 1.1204546689987183, -0.4754100441932678, -0.4082114100456238, 0.4378379285335541, -0.34471139311790466, -0.33200424909591675, 0.9880424737930298, 0.3294164538383484, 0.5186920762062073, -0.19816412031650543, 0.3740513324737549, 0.34566858410835266, 0.932039737701416, -0.09394326061010361, -0.35316431522369385, 0.10050075501203537, -0.4201827049255371, 0.2218913733959198, 0.06465505808591843, -0.9476121068000793, 0.09988917410373688, -0.3845573663711548, 0.10684323310852051, -0.7625401020050049, -1.0933077335357666, -0.13065844774246216, 0.12833961844444275, 0.21787190437316895, 0.4904438555240631, -0.26054662466049194, 1.0437511205673218, 0.48858585953712463, 0.6530331969261169, 0.2240026593208313, 0.15733687579631805, 0.42735111713409424, -0.5064759254455566, 0.031151067465543747, 0.004938434809446335, -0.7780411839485168, -0.6124438643455505, -0.8896538615226746, 0.3220021426677704, 0.12256928533315659, 0.14116385579109192, 0.39236536622047424, -0.320702463388443, -0.2893171012401581, -0.4919136166572571, 0.49058249592781067, -0.04215049743652344, -0.7773659229278564, -0.3259424865245819, 0.12796583771705627, -0.44294726848602295, -0.5716819167137146, -0.7168651223182678, -0.7250833511352539, 0.14767228066921234, 0.263210266828537, 0.2224300652742386, -0.8367011547088623, -0.6165568828582764, 0.13737308979034424, -1.0848437547683716, -0.7499102354049683, -0.5114366412162781, 0.31313151121139526, -0.02364744059741497, -0.5805786848068237, 0.025457970798015594, -0.49240782856941223, 0.3339816927909851, -0.38679543137550354, -0.3587276339530945, 0.13156157732009888, 0.7269720435142517, 0.8728211522102356, -0.09316092729568481, -0.04909886047244072, 0.7283342480659485, -0.6260392665863037, 0.9361916184425354, 0.19552144408226013, -0.4897294044494629, 0.6774176359176636, -0.6034366488456726, 0.4620133340358734, -0.18195345997810364, -0.1966191828250885, -0.6142510175704956, -0.467958927154541, 0.06378474086523056, -0.17536424100399017, -0.3215247690677643, 0.8180645108222961, -0.6977240443229675, -0.2670440375804901, 1.0799095630645752, -1.0964499711990356, -0.1147591769695282, -0.24745482206344604, -0.8856732249259949, -0.3659113049507141, -0.1079673245549202, -0.24109645187854767, 0.17683528363704681, 0.49587252736091614, -0.5896369814872742, 0.34906336665153503, -0.2598448395729065, 0.7777625918388367, -0.14661863446235657, -0.22310027480125427, -1.2756541967391968, -0.2770186960697174, 0.06504657864570618, 0.7744942903518677, -0.47127342224121094, 0.9577057361602783, 0.03838413208723068, -0.5574056506156921, -0.5112143754959106, -0.020706014707684517, -1.2578421831130981, 0.05621962994337082, -0.4878237843513489, 0.07129385322332382, 0.13771262764930725, -0.48119494318962097, 0.5627608895301819, -0.4637126922607422, -0.5880776047706604, -0.12495720386505127, 0.43220874667167664, -0.6415255665779114, -0.2925902307033539, 0.014916105195879936, -0.8961621522903442, -0.8088526725769043, -0.007043183781206608, 0.17342248558998108, -1.070298194885254, 0.10734439641237259, -0.734559178352356, -0.13329395651817322, 0.41156113147735596, -0.41619759798049927, 0.12856152653694153, 0.6562327742576599, -0.2871295213699341, -0.3358268737792969, -0.13156907260417938, 0.8598780035972595, 0.5436643362045288, 0.14778590202331543, -0.8211079239845276, -0.27907708287239075, -0.3349322974681854, -1.493386149406433, -0.20344138145446777, -1.11284601688385, -0.2067553997039795, 0.3522826135158539, -0.5119359493255615, -0.014875040389597416, 0.2745276391506195, 0.2881646752357483, 0.30111071467399597, -0.402066707611084, -0.3735833466053009, -0.18512338399887085, -0.5243654251098633, -0.39771968126296997, 0.5062901973724365, -0.6496052742004395, -0.05415870249271393, 0.6059175729751587, 0.07899346202611923, 0.18821795284748077, -0.18135692179203033, 0.3070409893989563, -0.08266662806272507, -0.44086840748786926, 0.2788005471229553, -0.9158812165260315, -0.20828497409820557, 0.8663981556892395, -0.2018425613641739, -0.6052396297454834, -0.36886096000671387, 0.37669363617897034, -0.7472933530807495, 0.5673684477806091, -0.3759637176990509, -0.5245742201805115, -0.10129294544458389, -0.27492448687553406, 1.167830228805542, 0.11381796002388, 0.20962725579738617, 1.0362880229949951, -0.1372046023607254, -0.05404692143201828, 0.1548512876033783, -0.8158982396125793, -0.20681263506412506, -0.40431907773017883, -0.7158439755439758, 0.05971095710992813, 0.9273087978363037, -0.2463197410106659, 0.6062270998954773, 0.41007447242736816, -0.6313377022743225, -0.3308296501636505, 0.5606066584587097, 0.6132321953773499, -1.187106728553772, -0.39470216631889343, -0.3278491497039795, 1.088922142982483, 0.15988025069236755, -0.1728617548942566, 0.2796667516231537, 0.5922175049781799, 0.3181838095188141, -0.36412742733955383, -0.553564190864563, -0.35737112164497375, -0.3581623435020447, -0.16642896831035614, 0.34337425231933594, 0.06382082402706146, 1.0243303775787354, 0.1336117684841156, -0.5186433792114258, -0.40300384163856506, 0.6621959209442139, -0.19722142815589905, -0.013302179984748363, 1.1201756000518799, 0.07522828876972198, -0.34988489747047424, -0.6130011677742004, -0.2687184512615204, 0.19567064940929413, 0.5762096047401428, 0.38475945591926575, -0.0628313273191452, -0.8918842673301697, 0.6729285717010498, 0.3042983114719391, 0.058331772685050964, -0.5293473601341248, 0.16153155267238617, 0.15567147731781006, -0.03868621215224266, -0.3066490888595581, -0.36635255813598633, 0.5392211675643921, 0.7529144883155823, 0.2029610425233841, -0.11736813932657242, 0.07574895769357681, 0.6344889402389526, -0.3999817669391632, 0.555535614490509, 0.04872128739953041, -0.2534053325653076, 1.0842097997665405, -0.51235032081604, 0.3461015522480011, 0.013604960404336452, -0.2178114354610443, -0.24401378631591797, 0.21201449632644653, -0.14207053184509277, -0.23636271059513092, -0.0699789822101593, -0.2454584240913391, -0.3858121633529663, 0.16718997061252594, 0.1650460660457611, -0.034294914454221725, 0.6411327719688416, 0.14106115698814392, -1.0118699073791504, -0.24448245763778687, 0.4713711142539978, 0.03884584456682205, 0.729017436504364, -0.39146432280540466, -0.260468065738678, 0.7148999571800232, 0.17030541598796844, 0.3763820230960846, -0.27933940291404724, -0.19417594373226166, -0.5864180326461792, 0.11713731288909912, -0.028057068586349487, -0.24607394635677338, -0.69892817735672, 0.18427839875221252, 0.4838974177837372, -0.3671119809150696, 0.6319975256919861, 0.245432510972023, -0.28497615456581116, 0.1915477067232132, -0.2680269479751587, 0.12971146404743195, -0.930105984210968, -0.6178985238075256, -0.23629261553287506, -0.5153427720069885, 0.3003809154033661, 0.8650997281074524, -0.6807423233985901, -0.7211733460426331, 0.19682751595973969, 0.625135064125061, 0.002202187664806843, 0.6996346116065979, -0.4851938784122467, 0.1800115406513214, 0.00930341612547636, 0.37833914160728455, 0.2713475227355957, -0.1941542774438858, 0.22158707678318024, -0.4751076102256775, 0.2055596262216568, 0.058150243014097214, -0.2654089629650116, 0.037884365767240524, -0.5424466133117676, 0.179738387465477, -0.27471718192100525, -1.5606096982955933, 0.1986801028251648, 0.7021340131759644, -0.6026144027709961, 0.27769479155540466, -0.0362715870141983, 0.14962732791900635, -0.2558211088180542, -0.2108457237482071, -0.279661625623703, 0.21844744682312012, -0.5467660427093506, 0.2463451474905014, 0.34399697184562683, 0.786226749420166, 0.12197866290807724, 0.26567286252975464, 0.45925650000572205, -0.44749435782432556, 0.13484008610248566, -1.2510029077529907, -0.19850459694862366, 0.2158144861459732, -0.16704021394252777, 0.2633874714374542, -1.1575261354446411, -0.36024102568626404, -0.46043556928634644, -0.42306748032569885, 0.15673872828483582, 0.46851587295532227, 0.5420309901237488, 0.16964375972747803, -0.07465860247612, -0.0248215701431036, -0.6233765482902527, -0.3610306680202484, -1.502713918685913, 0.10125353932380676, 0.265807181596756, -0.6459034085273743, -0.023699171841144562, 0.07675673812627792, -0.5772398114204407, 0.6201568841934204, -0.612958550453186, 0.31114473938941956, -0.08612339198589325, 0.8096767067909241, 0.07903217524290085, 1.171756386756897, 0.2266135960817337, 0.7963082194328308, 0.0395813062787056, -0.07190205156803131, -0.11649788916110992, -0.33115527033805847, 0.1996312290430069, 0.7914988398551941, 0.6095717549324036, 0.7194733619689941, -0.18212099373340607, 0.04308199882507324, -0.30027082562446594, -0.2567206025123596, 0.1511538326740265, 0.10354095697402954, -1.1535707712173462, -0.4221627414226532, 0.015409303829073906, 0.528267502784729, -0.4096907079219818, 0.4942339062690735, 0.2776549756526947, -0.9442135691642761, -0.52896648645401, -0.22180989384651184, 0.7013459205627441, -0.2514008581638336, -0.04482671245932579, -0.30227476358413696, 0.6855849027633667, 0.09784085303544998, -0.02905384823679924, 0.06275871396064758, 0.577836811542511, -0.020758936181664467, 0.21497420966625214, -0.38656532764434814, 0.6536828875541687, 0.5190091133117676, 0.2390165477991104, 0.06714634597301483, 0.8666357398033142, 0.7178035974502563, -0.431348592042923, 0.37378501892089844, -0.0060122329741716385, 0.3349806070327759, 0.34453925490379333, -0.3431673049926758, 0.39772358536720276, -0.18124252557754517, 0.3251359462738037, 0.029745832085609436, -0.6196162700653076, 0.6794674396514893, -0.7111256718635559, -0.4667656719684601, -0.2350127398967743, -0.34565016627311707, 0.5340003371238708, 0.47437629103660583, 0.3222893476486206, 0.2878662347793579, 0.48253437876701355, 0.4519471526145935, 0.36635762453079224, 0.406124085187912, -0.3228400945663452, -0.6114731431007385, -0.5818569660186768, 0.1805400252342224, -0.255391389131546, 0.3853757083415985, -0.373469740152359, -0.0789676159620285, 0.00523440632969141, 0.6950723528862, -1.312989354133606, 0.3011782765388489, 0.4361901581287384, -0.314834862947464, -0.09019786864519119, -0.21799087524414062, 0.07277105748653412, -0.863644003868103, -0.8005250692367554, 0.14542993903160095, 0.3711276650428772, -0.1902962476015091, 0.6719695329666138, 0.5251716375350952, 0.5805485248565674, 0.6755092144012451, 0.2544402480125427, -0.9460196495056152, 0.2746189534664154, -0.07154333591461182, -0.4097529351711273, 0.48569875955581665, -0.40462785959243774, -0.2728768587112427, -0.2945348918437958, -0.5363497734069824, 0.03990679979324341, -0.03534698858857155, 0.37383943796157837, -0.9447239637374878, 0.24645155668258667, 0.3546141982078552, -0.37863677740097046, -0.9834848046302795, 0.2817487418651581, -0.4883352518081665, 0.3597154915332794, -0.11609301716089249, -0.12708240747451782, -0.26611438393592834, -0.09449215978384018, 0.31282442808151245, -0.7070041298866272, 0.061333999037742615, 0.4844319224357605, -0.5388354063034058, 0.44879913330078125, -0.2513348460197449, -0.5142980813980103, -0.14386121928691864, -1.0749887228012085, -0.0267958864569664, 0.28530868887901306, -0.3571561574935913, -0.5702141523361206, 0.05504933372139931, 0.43225306272506714, 0.968834400177002, 0.09380451589822769, -0.27558034658432007, 0.39013707637786865, 0.49301236867904663, 0.8267757892608643, -0.22586217522621155, 0.4283059239387512, 0.1313048154115677, 0.4752962291240692, 0.38749104738235474, -0.7538039088249207, 0.1696675568819046, 0.4963509738445282, -0.6187257170677185, 0.26015612483024597, 0.027898890897631645, -0.21694722771644592, -0.40603992342948914, 0.3026701509952545, -0.060600508004426956, -0.8020203709602356, -0.8691588044166565, -0.45738929510116577, -0.518137514591217, -0.39980578422546387, 0.7232556939125061, -0.06780125200748444, 0.00023589568445459008, 0.4665369391441345, -0.11198089271783829, 0.8120806217193604, -0.4921686053276062, 4.003111362457275, 0.30599743127822876, 0.23619399964809418, -0.4302162230014801, 0.5469282269477844, 0.801662802696228, 0.4708959758281708, -0.18780606985092163, 0.3050292730331421, -0.5820544958114624, 0.08419133722782135, -0.3996720612049103, 0.1438894271850586, -0.20306110382080078, 0.08802592754364014, 0.9400529861450195, -0.7998728156089783, 0.4606132209300995, -0.13182567059993744, -1.1863881349563599, -0.5834364891052246, 0.4399172067642212, -0.6006478667259216, 0.5106679201126099, 0.18488386273384094, -0.10450362414121628, 0.5722514390945435, 0.26482832431793213, 0.9522040486335754, -0.37940531969070435, -0.10195579379796982, -1.1938385963439941, 0.36763277649879456, -0.5128222107887268, -0.17534001171588898, 1.0096461772918701, 0.2889125645160675, -0.5771423578262329, -0.5026650428771973, -0.34069061279296875, 0.47846102714538574, 0.13049428164958954, 0.3460341691970825, -0.11769796907901764, -0.8479143381118774, 0.6842936277389526, -0.7240577340126038, 0.24870875477790833, 0.5131467580795288, -0.5828940868377686, 0.6608704924583435, -1.2609834671020508, 0.6112666726112366, -0.22874101996421814, -0.6238590478897095, -0.30932268500328064, -0.26541876792907715, -0.6050101518630981, -0.20677369832992554, -0.5037358999252319, 1.4139715433120728, -0.009174845181405544, -0.038501277565956116, -0.12824273109436035, 0.345399409532547, 0.5553092956542969, 0.6803258061408997, 0.04340699315071106, 0.07251351326704025, -0.27316468954086304, 0.3033900558948517, -0.4989028573036194, -0.6075614094734192, 0.48254120349884033, 1.1633942127227783, 0.902657151222229, 0.48091408610343933, 0.1778876781463623, -0.25012585520744324, -0.5231049060821533, 0.848666250705719, -0.02285626344382763, 0.6175148487091064, 0.4477856159210205, -0.028824947774410248, 0.7475017309188843, -0.5130598545074463, -0.9636180996894836, -0.5393872857093811, 0.49369755387306213, 0.6302897930145264, 0.11592733860015869, -0.27908259630203247, -0.04374414309859276, 0.18254372477531433 ]
{"Title": "Out of hospital cardiac arrests in the Gulf Region: a scoping review", "Authors": "Batt Alan M., Lanos Chelsea, Delport Shannon, Al-Hasan Dalal, Knox Shane, Alhmoudi Assim, Anderson Megan, Fares Saleh, Cummins Fergal H.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) is a major cause of mortality worldwide. Recent studies demonstrated low survival rates in Middle Eastern countries. Anecdotally there are unique demographic, cultural and logistical challenges in this region. However, there remains a paucity of data published on OHCA in the Middle East. In order to address OHCA in a meaningful manner in the region, we first need to quantify the issue. Methods We conducted a scoping review of published and grey literature on OHCA in the Gulf Cooperative Council region that utilised Arksey and O\u2019Malley\u2019s framework. Electronic databases and grey literature sources were identified and searched. Subject matter experts in the region were consulted. All types of studies in English and Arabic were included. Results A total of 24 studies were included from Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Oman, Kuwait, and Qatar. No literature was identified from the state of Bahrain. OHCA victims in the region are younger, predominantly male, and more co-morbid than other international studies. We observed low Emergency Medical Service utilisation, low bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation, return of spontaneous circulation, and survival to discharge rates across the region. There are differences in characteristics of OHCA among ethnic groups. Discussion and conclusions We identified unique characteristics associated with OHCA in the region, variances in processes and outcomes, and a lack of coordinated effort to research and address OHCA. We recommend creating lead agencies responsible for coordinating and developing strategies such as community response, public education, and reporting databases.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19014118"}
10.1101/19001156
[ -0.03378811478614807, 0.3646203577518463, -0.9036381244659424, 0.6558220386505127, -0.3975989818572998, 0.21755725145339966, 0.15583772957324982, 0.625950813293457, 0.11547546088695526, 0.6171286702156067, -0.506761372089386, -0.7056133151054382, 0.516451358795166, -0.2619837820529938, -0.6531944274902344, 0.026104366406798363, -0.16292008757591248, -0.8369763493537903, -0.4273643493652344, -0.1979728490114212, -0.14867810904979706, 0.9632991552352905, -0.7372813820838928, 0.20102094113826752, -0.9388448596000671, 0.8561626672744751, -0.4791414141654968, -0.398610383272171, 1.676133632659912, 0.5606092214584351, 0.2758362591266632, -0.2723079025745392, 0.6331927180290222, -0.9685988426208496, -0.014446288347244263, 0.14245519042015076, 0.3523905277252197, 0.7726390957832336, -0.5915538668632507, -0.5979278683662415, 0.6979415416717529, -0.09654687345027924, 0.14129696786403656, -0.11683820933103561, -0.3781490623950958, 0.0024765091948211193, 0.053646404296159744, 0.34296929836273193, -0.17456871271133423, 0.2779349088668823, 0.6445627212524414, -0.30470946431159973, 0.080826535820961, -0.28966987133026123, -0.41765129566192627, -0.7525241374969482, 0.006436534691601992, -0.3069484829902649, -0.5224733352661133, -0.3255006670951843, 0.22206149995326996, 0.36631789803504944, 0.44767117500305176, -0.6378304958343506, 0.7436193227767944, 1.1061108112335205, -0.22774800658226013, -0.20737451314926147, -0.20223261415958405, -0.21470028162002563, 0.4553506374359131, -0.03257070854306221, -0.48036783933639526, -0.9611178636550903, -0.6936535239219666, -0.6309782862663269, 0.1853732168674469, -0.3236423134803772, 0.22472670674324036, -0.16568835079669952, -0.3331536650657654, 0.17835572361946106, 0.7711437344551086, 0.05381793528795242, -0.8949735164642334, 0.023076917976140976, -0.3186236023902893, 0.4050540626049042, 0.696853518486023, 0.5766608119010925, 0.2008344680070877, -0.15276502072811127, -0.16621114313602448, -0.15883944928646088, 0.16696599125862122, 0.9732058048248291, -1.0256251096725464, 0.10230139642953873, 0.10726281255483627, -0.1999710351228714, 0.38618358969688416, 0.38358229398727417, -0.22541247308254242, 1.0507539510726929, -0.7934624552726746, 0.5847924947738647, 0.6667960286140442, -0.1200670674443245, -0.2742587625980377, -0.5666621327400208, 0.36181437969207764, 0.2598792016506195, -0.5396385192871094, -0.32358017563819885, 0.9966936111450195, 0.6366594433784485, -0.07603322714567184, 0.6418761610984802, -0.5659639835357666, -0.4101777970790863, 0.7793177962303162, 0.10095980763435364, 0.3280295133590698, -0.389642596244812, 0.05169996991753578, -0.23760735988616943, -0.26830601692199707, 0.9440850615501404, -0.5639265775680542, 0.17950841784477234, -0.24250251054763794, -0.5458539128303528, 0.1871674805879593, 0.2575817108154297, 0.788084089756012, -0.2671682834625244, 0.0013524583773687482, 0.6139830350875854, 0.9357686042785645, -0.0747024416923523, 0.30071043968200684, 0.3489156663417816, -0.5917079448699951, 1.7989633083343506, -0.011652225628495216, 1.1765507459640503, -0.3229687511920929, -0.6640938520431519, 0.09041131287813187, 0.70438152551651, -0.20720447599887848, 0.31377601623535156, -0.36086171865463257, 0.1667235940694809, 0.41165345907211304, -0.06705468147993088, -0.3967025578022003, -0.16532473266124725, 0.0835832729935646, -0.17945192754268646, -0.8498561978340149, 0.3823542892932892, -0.016711369156837463, 0.3714367747306824, -1.258028268814087, 0.08937318623065948, -0.07732120901346207, 0.46186286211013794, 0.48926424980163574, -0.5949345231056213, 1.3729044198989868, -0.028508951887488365, -0.1899268627166748, 0.39768627285957336, 0.36994314193725586, 1.010130524635315, 0.2958911955356598, -0.27001336216926575, 0.2232319563627243, 0.42798903584480286, 0.20313769578933716, 0.4540509879589081, -0.11309944838285446, 1.0555109977722168, 0.2929895520210266, 0.21902047097682953, 0.09856601804494858, -0.7620887756347656, -0.36281076073646545, -0.572641134262085, 0.1385403722524643, 0.7209376096725464, -0.4762077331542969, 0.41395315527915955, -0.08410944044589996, 0.734329104423523, -0.45686331391334534, 1.4671976566314697, 0.4449830651283264, -0.613207221031189, 0.045659713447093964, 0.9076739549636841, -0.34540924429893494, 0.6019682288169861, 0.3164634108543396, 0.4625251293182373, 0.37497368454933167, -0.12413781881332397, 0.14289788901805878, 0.25756412744522095, 0.9415128827095032, -0.32802295684814453, -0.9810250997543335, -0.5854434370994568, 0.8518754839897156, -0.72032630443573, -0.02655990608036518, 0.6724010109901428, -1.0398318767547607, 0.048164911568164825, 0.11853773146867752, -0.9301691651344299, 0.12036946415901184, 0.2132173329591751, -0.3262065351009369, 0.38266095519065857, -0.42089492082595825, 0.6703229546546936, -0.28327417373657227, 0.3443610370159149, -0.016951700672507286, 0.9248313307762146, -0.1458914428949356, 0.8422235250473022, 0.785483717918396, 0.25179624557495117, 0.3038339912891388, 0.2193993628025055, -0.006422503851354122, 0.2653447687625885, 0.2867763936519623, 0.7874965071678162, 0.337567001581192, 0.03615128621459007, -0.9157311320304871, 0.8096898198127747, -0.60499107837677, 0.22411735355854034, -0.778737485408783, 0.4237018823623657, -0.9531353116035461, 0.4741136133670807, -0.010225949808955193, 1.220512866973877, -0.9840911626815796, 0.02125529758632183, 0.2803032398223877, 0.1779158115386963, -1.1609622240066528, 0.2630380690097809, -0.5579923391342163, 0.5187246203422546, -0.8851034045219421, 0.0384969636797905, 0.4203806519508362, 0.8489269614219666, -0.24174067378044128, 0.7167330384254456, 0.13177116215229034, 0.05935762822628021, -0.5401450395584106, 0.2541649639606476, -0.44295477867126465, -1.033285140991211, -0.5921781659126282, -0.1488056182861328, -0.2716110348701477, -0.237380251288414, -0.18526722490787506, 0.052322354167699814, -0.02237703837454319, -0.7582495808601379, -0.03629617393016815, 1.0105483531951904, 0.028650466352701187, 0.16021734476089478, -0.9730042219161987, 0.17479033768177032, 0.21989020705223083, -0.2180481255054474, -0.7467525005340576, 0.13198456168174744, -0.9435730576515198, -1.0683537721633911, 0.7971863150596619, 0.6457923650741577, -0.48607364296913147, 0.15878747403621674, -0.141824871301651, -0.4387444257736206, 0.2530032694339752, -0.11409321427345276, 0.7198541164398193, 0.3375753164291382, -0.30286723375320435, 0.22104522585868835, 0.00883963517844677, 0.8612310886383057, 0.6184723377227783, -0.3808627426624298, -0.814412534236908, 0.13059347867965698, 0.20331840217113495, 0.3533749282360077, -1.2410579919815063, -0.9359070062637329, 0.5857406258583069, 0.5654999017715454, -0.112762451171875, -0.07195001095533371, -1.106641173362732, -0.16312545537948608, 0.06856679916381836, -1.0378614664077759, -0.42185068130493164, 0.08390383422374725, -0.03795468807220459, -1.4425170421600342, 0.6082974672317505, -0.656454861164093, -0.6338481903076172, -0.098329558968544, -0.2536705434322357, 1.1042169332504272, 0.7827494740486145, 0.4445602297782898, -0.24075379967689514, -0.3184845447540283, -0.8993031978607178, 0.2726607918739319, 0.3902857005596161, 0.08020636439323425, -0.08413746953010559, 0.12801383435726166, -0.2695826590061188, 0.5419850945472717, 0.683785617351532, -0.30603042244911194, 0.16395127773284912, 0.011588058434426785, 0.1018187403678894, 0.2388206124305725, 0.7694447636604309, -0.15417851507663727, -0.8936858177185059, 0.6956987977027893, -0.2790508568286896, -0.2444966584444046, 0.3393980860710144, -0.1856231391429901, -0.4121660590171814, 0.14716757833957672, -0.5213950872421265, -0.27072837948799133, -0.651481032371521, -0.5426190495491028, 0.27911099791526794, 0.34965553879737854, 0.5887789726257324, -0.03294966369867325, 0.4226131737232208, -0.644252359867096, -0.4117198884487152, -0.04404072090983391, -0.12909819185733795, -0.018645938485860825, 0.6188650727272034, 0.9423186779022217, 1.025320291519165, -0.5372350811958313, -0.05782390758395195, 0.30647438764572144, 0.5707377195358276, -0.01734873838722706, -0.6886699795722961, 0.4771673083305359, -0.886723518371582, -0.40148887038230896, 0.1288110762834549, -0.40676242113113403, -0.11753502488136292, -0.3963626027107239, 0.8314389586448669, 0.5209838151931763, -0.8091728687286377, -0.7641182541847229, 0.14687009155750275, 0.764570951461792, 0.2452358603477478, 0.7791690230369568, 0.5321921110153198, -0.4008011221885681, 0.7187396883964539, 0.2066527009010315, 0.27420076727867126, 0.6128926873207092, -0.6743136644363403, 0.06399331986904144, -0.12589602172374725, -0.5705032348632812, -0.5450758934020996, -0.49356892704963684, 0.04770756885409355, -0.11315487325191498, -0.013782271184027195, -0.04532039910554886, -0.6432748436927795, 0.12291229516267776, -0.6047163605690002, 0.017760055139660835, -0.3291759192943573, -0.36238187551498413, -0.5841051936149597, 0.4002688229084015, -0.4086741507053375, -0.23790065944194794, 0.6520095467567444, -1.065352439880371, 1.1432219743728638, 0.8303166031837463, -0.4981350600719452, -0.3722916841506958, -0.5460509657859802, -0.4394089877605438, -0.2507685124874115, 0.1973717361688614, 0.6271060109138489, -0.07590815424919128, 0.32357436418533325, -0.6103992462158203, -0.07373812794685364, 0.13407164812088013, -0.6707652807235718, -0.32148900628089905, -0.22736524045467377, 0.17682872712612152, 1.2868479490280151, 0.2871406078338623, 0.5983247756958008, -0.09088907390832901, 1.112296462059021, -0.1635313481092453, 0.3052905201911926, -0.7411779761314392, -0.11795315146446228, 0.1551111787557602, -0.26920822262763977, 0.3164214789867401, -0.3504631817340851, 0.10405640304088593, -0.1656276136636734, -0.23392589390277863, 0.3422524034976959, -0.17143294215202332, 0.4030579626560211, 0.8106276392936707, 0.11419129371643066, -0.06257922947406769, 0.46937957406044006, -0.3486747741699219, -0.0010154786286875606, 0.3179042935371399, 0.3146894872188568, -0.6219156384468079, 0.10941507667303085, 0.360277384519577, -0.513619601726532, 1.0962116718292236, -0.54742431640625, 0.30337706208229065, 0.14868272840976715, -0.07847911864519119, 0.5212939977645874, 0.20923054218292236, 0.5963614583015442, -0.4105675220489502, -0.5402898788452148, -0.168057382106781, -1.2606492042541504, 0.13682852685451508, -0.1476767361164093, -0.18408630788326263, -0.16553181409835815, 0.6141546964645386, -0.5563417673110962, -0.5983177423477173, -0.27119919657707214, 0.1377863883972168, 0.47794127464294434, 0.13748832046985626, 0.930107057094574, -0.8083910942077637, -0.833725094795227, 0.17010116577148438, 0.42448973655700684, -0.6022708415985107, -0.5264565348625183, 0.21552006900310516, -0.7502135634422302, -0.4630180299282074, -0.5129208564758301, 0.09144144505262375, -0.6881116032600403, -0.2838061451911926, 0.12801244854927063, -0.18901243805885315, 0.6383056044578552, 0.19800728559494019, 0.036354780197143555, 0.3213135898113251, -0.4969237446784973, -0.056185659021139145, -0.05841128155589104, 0.3988839089870453, -0.3577045798301697, 0.5251309871673584, 0.11305935680866241, -0.5625566244125366, 0.011337663047015667, -0.8415979743003845, 0.24400554597377777, -0.20952188968658447, -0.37572935223579407, -0.09449759870767593, -0.8624281287193298, -0.3116840124130249, 0.6824958920478821, -0.7572438716888428, -0.3214307129383087, -0.12922145426273346, -0.5857630968093872, 0.10083648562431335, -0.42823097109794617, -0.10802832990884781, -0.270567387342453, -1.1931712627410889, -0.08308075368404388, 1.0447959899902344, -0.4842946529388428, -0.03643426299095154, -0.06780526041984558, -0.056394271552562714, 0.45424115657806396, 0.27197596430778503, -0.16789160668849945, 0.18436400592327118, 0.10999611020088196, -0.24202783405780792, -0.9436684250831604, -0.11555198580026627, -0.6712554693222046, 0.9847092032432556, -0.32215753197669983, 0.4808655381202698, 0.19607877731323242, 0.1810261607170105, -0.07073396444320679, -1.0293097496032715, 0.8892167210578918, -0.2046218067407608, 0.03067169524729252, -0.09646599739789963, -0.27510321140289307, 0.13851848244667053, 0.29391002655029297, -0.25268179178237915, -0.4294610917568207, -1.4456532001495361, -1.2668055295944214, 0.5006762146949768, -0.11214562505483627, -0.32931703329086304, -0.033238913863897324, -0.09463745355606079, 0.22011607885360718, 0.0317823626101017, 0.9602540731430054, 0.7477155327796936, -1.279172658920288, -0.43092939257621765, -0.3491978049278259, 0.9273321628570557, 0.06636670976877213, 0.1723995804786682, 0.15170957148075104, -0.28069835901260376, -0.13575513660907745, 0.08496371656656265, -0.7882534861564636, -0.5448852181434631, 0.25598087906837463, 0.7931071519851685, 0.9524075388908386, -0.473175972700119, -0.05390402302145958, 0.16985313594341278, -1.012992262840271, -0.5825443267822266, 0.5519219636917114, 0.32083001732826233, 0.8698939681053162, 0.767861008644104, -0.05293833836913109, 0.07645347714424133, 0.5739341974258423, 0.16214562952518463, 0.5396150350570679, 0.15455837547779083, 0.5095297694206238, 0.3904965817928314, -1.2138186693191528, 0.904778003692627, -0.13082392513751984, -0.8782459497451782, -0.5900290012359619, 0.16213937103748322, -0.4984293282032013, -0.46471211314201355, 0.2720690369606018, -0.3284260928630829, 0.6666741967201233, 0.24511684477329254, 0.404936820268631, 0.3890630304813385, 0.3269917070865631, 0.531962513923645, -0.4162476658821106, 0.0781618133187294, 0.1932329386472702, -0.4413515329360962, 0.9604683518409729, -0.520246684551239, -0.22155505418777466, 0.7786231637001038, 0.2790553867816925, 0.21433207392692566, 0.19204869866371155, 0.4790832996368408, -0.8395628929138184, -0.18691737949848175, 0.1870870441198349, 0.09493248164653778, 0.7426880598068237, 0.32784631848335266, 0.002988251857459545, 0.08618976920843124, -0.5336817502975464, -0.7594277858734131, -0.5329535007476807, 0.37260228395462036, 0.429814875125885, -0.24425512552261353, -0.12739013135433197, -0.20906701683998108, 0.5847727656364441, -0.1819716989994049, 0.3824073374271393, -0.5760132670402527, -0.845912754535675, -0.7246105670928955, -0.31829410791397095, -0.029929790645837784, -0.3815377950668335, 0.8101258277893066, 0.42065688967704773, -0.8513081073760986, -0.39836257696151733, -0.12696002423763275, 0.20992346107959747, -0.07026264816522598, -0.8162091374397278, -0.5836191773414612, -0.07545647025108337, -0.9970046281814575, -0.8082718253135681, -0.21674177050590515, -0.32068121433258057, 0.1964607834815979, 0.8914152979850769, -1.0511118173599243, -0.32835543155670166, -0.2124144583940506, 0.8344990611076355, 0.013735899701714516, 0.3661741614341736, -0.3483646512031555, -0.5806429982185364, -0.017407279461622238, 0.5550183057785034, 0.20113658905029297, -0.5412887334823608, 0.9866507649421692, -0.7311826348304749, 0.29089319705963135, 0.2122238576412201, 0.06446851789951324, -0.19461539387702942, -0.025141866877675056, 0.8030011057853699, -0.7960173487663269, -0.4186837673187256, 0.41888999938964844, 0.4561702311038971, -1.174379825592041, -0.4583267867565155, -0.6148604154586792, -0.10804011672735214, 0.34906408190727234, 0.1933380514383316, -0.7787153720855713, 0.40440312027931213, -0.3006521463394165, -0.4733522832393646, 0.11176000535488129, 1.0039565563201904, 0.44095706939697266, 0.15657120943069458, 0.9509465098381042, 0.01851009950041771, -0.11421380192041397, -1.0933582782745361, 0.8448407053947449, 1.1557457447052002, 0.3128398358821869, 0.3199184238910675, 0.3384229838848114, 0.7914739847183228, 0.29686492681503296, -0.5600969195365906, -0.5981549024581909, 0.8410428166389465, 0.2830958664417267, 0.3659185469150543, -0.16658085584640503, 0.24083702266216278, -0.43203040957450867, -0.4983118772506714, -0.9974372982978821, -0.112544946372509, 0.5732489824295044, -1.454635739326477, -0.6397082805633545, -1.1358468532562256, -0.9443906545639038, 0.1989142894744873, 0.3014321029186249, 0.4031263589859009, -0.7856464385986328, 0.07851223647594452, 0.2770336866378784, 0.6303120851516724, -0.22835280001163483, -0.31062930822372437, -0.138010635972023, 0.29404276609420776, 0.012842088006436825, -0.09399332106113434, -0.04985230788588524, 0.4435258209705353, 0.3315979838371277, -0.46641775965690613, -0.2921583950519562, -0.06598581373691559, -0.21148048341274261, -0.39627471566200256, -0.22586917877197266, -0.11427295953035355, -0.42844656109809875, 0.447794646024704, -0.30365127325057983, -0.4699675738811493, -0.2523013651371002, -0.23106680810451508, -0.44075289368629456, -0.699779748916626, -0.9402416348457336, 0.26004838943481445, 0.4757644534111023, 0.5427151322364807, 0.8733808398246765, 0.6618826389312744, 0.5201573371887207, -0.19552390277385712, -0.2922503650188446, 0.615023136138916, 1.0615434646606445, -0.14779910445213318, 0.17470596730709076, -0.33126771450042725, 0.6067937612533569, 0.6865811347961426, -0.3814750611782074, -0.5310584306716919, -0.030117742717266083, -0.1717587113380432, -0.030540721490979195, -0.5545095205307007, -0.7344095706939697, 0.3316382169723511, -0.0945608839392662, -0.10757862031459808, 0.4525541067123413, 0.8468703031539917, 0.6537553668022156, 0.6852651238441467, -0.4295803904533386, -0.20996689796447754, -0.35350993275642395, -0.17691081762313843, -0.7001745700836182, -0.2121259719133377, 1.1722712516784668, -0.15460094809532166, 0.5343161225318909, -0.00025429221568629146, 0.9069957137107849, -0.011102842167019844, -0.46132785081863403, 0.43981441855430603, -0.8800292611122131, -0.014926397241652012, -0.677064836025238, 0.2208155393600464, 0.25153282284736633, -0.1863236278295517, 0.08583134412765503, -0.07679156213998795, -0.052856240421533585, 0.2727505564689636, -0.46855348348617554, -0.44584107398986816, 1.276432991027832, -0.2338530421257019, -0.5862517356872559, 0.18341676890850067, -0.22714318335056305, -0.8520369529724121, -0.13401927053928375, 0.8614445328712463, -0.05900641530752182, 0.5286491513252258, -0.40156981348991394, 1.0186353921890259, 0.9339221715927124, 0.5794838666915894, 0.9356569051742554, -0.5509119033813477, 0.48075130581855774, 0.30437371134757996, -0.13388791680335999, -0.6694052815437317, -0.1359940618276596, -0.21342268586158752, -0.19820161163806915, -0.06737224012613297, 0.4316975176334381, 0.09103453159332275, -0.3357516825199127, -0.20715001225471497, 0.3936111032962799, 0.07579690963029861, -0.25412869453430176, -0.5865164995193481, -0.25157079100608826, -0.10639519989490509, 0.3307565748691559, -0.0043103802017867565, 0.31676071882247925, -0.3567005693912506, 0.12893874943256378, -0.44145506620407104, -0.40011224150657654, -0.5918915867805481, 0.10878179967403412, -0.6697844862937927, 0.15642781555652618, 0.14847244322299957, 0.4758937358856201, -0.9830576777458191, -1.3470699787139893, 0.02015892043709755, 0.0076135024428367615, -0.5968841910362244, -0.7775663733482361, -0.45010173320770264, 0.724166989326477, 0.02435593120753765, 0.20541127026081085, -0.1591411978006363, -0.8348214030265808, -0.10904404520988464, 0.7415958642959595, 0.16816619038581848, 0.33006754517555237, -0.6398797631263733, 0.0015787238953635097, 0.35357987880706787, -0.31755515933036804, 0.3298087418079376, -0.3401518166065216, -0.3646630048751831, 0.1139713004231453, 0.3784013092517853, 0.19900090992450714, -0.3463367223739624, 0.09666596353054047, 0.5399485230445862, 0.05647490173578262, -0.2944674491882324, -0.5199995636940002, -0.6484156250953674, -0.9498130083084106, 0.6588029265403748, -0.11413267254829407, -0.14137110114097595, 0.45699089765548706, -0.7697879672050476, 0.47738105058670044, -1.282420039176941, 3.971313714981079, 1.5131638050079346, 1.1850612163543701, 0.11360721290111542, 0.5090725421905518, 0.2377382069826126, 0.7817736864089966, 0.23580020666122437, 0.7182164192199707, -0.21634945273399353, -0.24724841117858887, 0.18462826311588287, 0.07895266264677048, 0.34332627058029175, 0.2757227122783661, 0.5522450804710388, -0.336321085691452, -0.22503650188446045, -0.2199385166168213, -0.6803053021430969, -0.5859912633895874, 0.21450155973434448, 0.41829779744148254, 0.8386309146881104, -0.10216797143220901, 0.027499187737703323, 0.6157448291778564, 0.12954464554786682, 0.21741586923599243, -0.8456065654754639, 0.39522480964660645, 0.3177121579647064, 0.36378708481788635, -1.0470689535140991, -0.5955654382705688, 0.23327399790287018, -0.22384291887283325, -0.445961594581604, 0.22898414731025696, -0.575259268283844, 0.3271668255329132, 0.07098275423049927, -0.08737635612487793, -0.5734859108924866, -0.09303850680589676, -0.23970502614974976, -0.48187729716300964, 0.09834091365337372, 0.8539894819259644, -0.05190397799015045, 0.4457245469093323, -0.5379281640052795, 0.16123463213443756, -0.5381097793579102, -0.9077938795089722, -0.2576991617679596, 0.22901637852191925, -0.8269172310829163, 0.32593318819999695, 0.3025018274784088, 0.4048095643520355, 0.11457820981740952, -0.29740217328071594, -0.3561251163482666, 0.18557938933372498, 0.26974138617515564, -0.034522250294685364, 1.4184579849243164, -0.5778703093528748, -0.8577665090560913, -0.04917338863015175, -0.3830764591693878, -0.08919299393892288, -0.3649660348892212, 0.29314401745796204, 0.4337007403373718, -0.13836537301540375, 0.37625977396965027, -0.4302566647529602, -0.08748544752597809, 0.18790075182914734, 0.019908534362912178, 0.24009859561920166, 0.526709794998169, 0.42694321274757385, 0.6211488246917725, -0.4306621253490448, -0.5382353067398071, -1.0200190544128418, 1.0365941524505615, 0.27732187509536743, -0.9971407055854797, -0.013969329185783863, 0.31928056478500366, -0.2668352723121643 ]
{"Title": "Intermittent Lactobacilli-containing Vaginal Probiotic or Metronidazole Use to Prevent Bacterial Vaginosis Recurrence: Safety and Preliminary Efficacy by Microscopy and Sequencing", "Authors": "van de Wijgert Janneke H.H.M., Verwijs Marijn C., Agaba Stephen K., Bronowski Christina, Mwambarangwe Lambert, Uwineza Mireille, Lievens Elke, Nivoliez Adrien, Ravel Jacques, Darby Alistair C.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Bacterial vaginosis (BV) is associated with HIV acquisition and adverse pregnancy outcomes. Recurrence after metronidazole treatment is high. HIV-negative, non-pregnant Rwandan BV patients were randomized to four groups (n=17/group) after seven-day oral metronidazole treatment: behavioral counseling only (control), or counseling plus intermittent use of oral metronidazole, Ecologic Femi+ vaginal capsule (containing multiple Lactobacillus and one Bifidobacterium species), or Gynophilus LP vaginal tablet ( L. rhamnosus 35) for two months. Vaginal microbiota assessments at all visits included Gram stain Nugent scoring and 16S rRNA gene qPCR and HiSeq sequencing. All interventions were safe. BV (Nugent 7-10) incidence was 10.18 per person-year at risk in the control group, and lower in the metronidazole (1.41/person-year; p=0.004), Ecologic Femi+ (3.58/person-year; p=0.043), and Gynophilus LP groups (5.36/person-year; p=0.220). In mixed effects models adjusted for hormonal contraception/pregnancy, sexual risk-taking, and age, metronidazole and Ecologic Femi+ users, each compared to controls, had higher Lactobacillus and lower BV-anaerobes concentrations and/or relative abundances, and were less likely to have a dysbiotic vaginal microbiota type by sequencing. Inter-individual variability was high and effects disappeared soon after intervention cessation. Lactobacilli-based vaginal probiotics warrant further evaluation because, in contrast to antibiotics, they are not expected to negatively affect microbiota or cause antimicrobial resistance.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19001156"}
10.1101/19007450
[ -0.6568917036056519, 0.10525179654359818, 0.06884174793958664, 0.8325177431106567, 0.2046865075826645, -0.3389228880405426, -0.24705632030963898, 0.11096948385238647, -0.6569225788116455, 1.0624914169311523, -0.3833085000514984, -0.5283772945404053, 0.34782838821411133, -0.25044283270835876, -0.5991812348365784, -0.6213163733482361, -0.6998163461685181, -0.4601333439350128, -0.21857142448425293, 0.03897632658481598, 0.4539638161659241, 0.4608164131641388, -1.1552774906158447, 0.2214469462633133, -0.3103903830051422, 0.24757564067840576, 0.1613144725561142, 0.18274623155593872, 1.460249662399292, 1.0381704568862915, 0.2897779047489166, -0.1794034242630005, 0.4398946762084961, -0.4689347445964813, -0.31226545572280884, -0.2069983035326004, 0.43847328424453735, -0.6097293496131897, 0.299283891916275, -0.9062658548355103, 0.7157890796661377, -0.195913627743721, 0.14813293516635895, -0.36789649724960327, -0.9965264797210693, 0.4424508512020111, -0.16597779095172882, 0.354265034198761, -0.1889168918132782, -0.21508292853832245, 0.4756394922733307, -0.07898809015750885, 0.24817365407943726, -0.39697548747062683, 0.09994233399629593, 0.4138203263282776, -0.43773314356803894, -0.01611224375665188, -0.44733795523643494, -0.21147404611110687, -0.11432192474603653, -0.30128592252731323, 0.9371771216392517, -0.9153764247894287, 0.8272897601127625, 0.8305513262748718, 0.002965096617117524, -0.22256430983543396, -0.47975045442581177, 0.1922730952501297, -0.12081180512905121, -0.3241561949253082, -0.07690425217151642, -0.24011266231536865, -0.3215748965740204, -0.03258250653743744, -0.35659268498420715, -0.1832071989774704, -0.4567328691482544, 0.410504013299942, -0.20245462656021118, 0.43334701657295227, 0.6097211241722107, 0.7332034111022949, -0.8667678236961365, 0.3393747806549072, -0.14841371774673462, -0.12252962589263916, 0.21393069624900818, 0.6257734298706055, -0.11792383342981339, 0.47524410486221313, 0.7341144680976868, 0.12256690114736557, 0.1777425855398178, 0.8584304451942444, -0.4450574219226837, -0.21340611577033997, 0.5123682618141174, -0.25311416387557983, 0.09058196097612381, -0.25386151671409607, -0.6575928330421448, 0.5786391496658325, -0.38432809710502625, 1.1021076440811157, 0.3676025867462158, 0.08906202763319016, -0.21348682045936584, -0.8052179217338562, 0.16231432557106018, -0.45284053683280945, -0.22954829037189484, 0.32493504881858826, 0.5972828269004822, 0.010844213888049126, 0.27918463945388794, 1.1227763891220093, -0.9074653387069702, 0.8878528475761414, -0.27371665835380554, 0.03956875205039978, 0.40437349677085876, -0.542088508605957, 0.2156439870595932, 1.2232279777526855, 0.32565492391586304, 0.576063334941864, -0.409701943397522, 0.20787693560123444, 0.1370745450258255, -0.7066622376441956, 0.04526820778846741, 0.7127621173858643, -0.47329190373420715, -0.27862828969955444, -0.18491218984127045, 1.2953815460205078, 0.5549557209014893, -0.35085776448249817, 0.006192314904183149, 0.6885070204734802, -0.7622626423835754, 1.2846498489379883, -0.35265836119651794, 0.7177196145057678, -0.7532762289047241, -0.4534483253955841, -1.1068164110183716, -0.49940481781959534, -0.26027750968933105, 0.41623610258102417, -0.4725535213947296, 0.30353251099586487, 0.6374502182006836, 0.022782713174819946, 0.09591386467218399, -0.28089502453804016, -0.058459121733903885, 0.255767285823822, -0.8304394483566284, 0.6567125916481018, 0.30705052614212036, 0.9830846786499023, -0.19015726447105408, 0.4304329752922058, -0.3027994930744171, 0.33629417419433594, 0.12294783443212509, -1.0942931175231934, 0.8462542295455933, 0.038048308342695236, -0.5106346011161804, 0.20409657061100006, 0.34675800800323486, 0.1533920019865036, 0.2953355610370636, -0.2832893133163452, 0.16446875035762787, 0.3543654680252075, 0.14460425078868866, 0.9238227009773254, 0.6202750205993652, 0.49265655875205994, 0.46710315346717834, -0.23056085407733917, -0.4025425910949707, -0.48090171813964844, -0.03772595897316933, -0.30254849791526794, 0.2957836091518402, -0.08850333839654922, 0.29521578550338745, 0.42093878984451294, -0.008836042135953903, 0.15903978049755096, -1.1912610530853271, 0.34982892870903015, -0.06687600910663605, -0.4107000231742859, -0.30949875712394714, -0.12131724506616592, -0.33341047167778015, 0.6644881367683411, 0.37189605832099915, 0.6030966639518738, 0.5238231420516968, -0.13627685606479645, -0.5825432538986206, 0.620808482170105, 0.8175864815711975, 0.03037361055612564, -0.0689467340707779, -0.3555639386177063, 0.8298729658126831, -0.5699994564056396, -0.3654806911945343, -0.09905700385570526, -0.9768698215484619, 0.35897818207740784, 0.1469060182571411, -0.4078920781612396, 1.0064010620117188, 0.623741626739502, -0.07403204590082169, 0.44896969199180603, 0.18875010311603546, -0.15109112858772278, 0.0008543272269889712, -0.43415459990501404, -0.5150900483131409, 0.31312018632888794, -0.5295572876930237, 0.8805952072143555, 0.863891065120697, 0.05881141498684883, 0.06720094382762909, -0.031226707622408867, 0.615460991859436, 0.411685049533844, 0.8132331371307373, 0.7857383489608765, 0.34144917130470276, 1.135130524635315, -0.31325477361679077, 0.7395989298820496, -0.5088739395141602, 0.696828305721283, -0.3538656532764435, -0.1970217227935791, -0.15732228755950928, 0.058070648461580276, 0.4883612096309662, 0.5169494152069092, -0.5921570658683777, -0.5142449736595154, -0.14992830157279968, 0.26800739765167236, -1.0343762636184692, -0.15053798258304596, -0.7592283487319946, 0.25514715909957886, -1.1712592840194702, 0.041469328105449677, 0.5076413750648499, 0.7807517647743225, -0.3439306616783142, -0.1314263790845871, 0.808639407157898, -0.24717643857002258, -0.9364606738090515, -0.09508326649665833, -0.9686439037322998, -0.8131214380264282, -0.863750159740448, -0.18873581290245056, -0.17211854457855225, -0.5504193305969238, 0.10568499565124512, -0.49748507142066956, 0.33090105652809143, -0.3320600688457489, -0.2556155025959015, 0.10565652698278427, 0.24555115401744843, -0.17073111236095428, -0.8837870359420776, 0.5814774036407471, -0.46742624044418335, 0.36382248997688293, -0.32025325298309326, -0.20274749398231506, -0.8940151333808899, -0.6936667561531067, 0.5354170203208923, -0.4741097390651703, 0.14470027387142181, 0.5051531791687012, 0.000699605094268918, -0.36432182788848877, 0.1231997013092041, -0.36760038137435913, 0.5367220640182495, -0.021774886175990105, -0.9862549901008606, 0.01562517136335373, -0.17161166667938232, 0.5002136826515198, 0.4316338896751404, 0.4656805396080017, -0.8706380724906921, 0.2581203877925873, -0.3278328478336334, 0.2344539314508438, -0.6892703771591187, -0.19204209744930267, -0.013667021878063679, 0.18147431313991547, 0.7801830172538757, -0.6888147592544556, -0.4384611248970032, 0.7142459750175476, -0.6033433079719543, -0.10764455050230026, -0.150687575340271, 0.725936770439148, -0.40491804480552673, -0.831005871295929, 0.27889376878738403, -0.4320184886455536, -1.5419740676879883, 0.11945942789316177, -0.45868515968322754, 0.8825457096099854, 0.8694478273391724, -0.0023436283227056265, -0.08166904002428055, 0.292800635099411, 0.043123215436935425, 0.36220335960388184, 0.1200581043958664, -0.38786691427230835, 0.42487600445747375, 0.13447360694408417, 0.0036148757208138704, -0.40009045600891113, 0.20762041211128235, -0.5771893858909607, -0.13938294351100922, 0.03227432817220688, 0.07283037900924683, -0.3269689977169037, 0.2835652828216553, 0.11329802125692368, -0.6542147397994995, 0.08483827859163284, -0.07372821867465973, 0.6791542172431946, -0.023828968405723572, 0.4349900484085083, -0.09485936909914017, 0.0007659335387870669, 0.15154513716697693, 0.8443607091903687, -0.376579225063324, -1.3624863624572754, 1.3309810161590576, -0.36056259274482727, 0.3751932382583618, -0.8632172346115112, 0.3354642391204834, 0.11743955314159393, -0.3173302114009857, 0.17902132868766785, -0.17510338127613068, 0.33512353897094727, 0.6230248212814331, -0.4021000564098358, 1.5777339935302734, -1.1139671802520752, 0.5217680931091309, 0.8354741334915161, 1.5223878622055054, 0.4014725387096405, 0.2660311460494995, 0.001526404288597405, -0.5624259114265442, 1.061234474182129, -0.04480919614434242, -0.4232642650604248, -0.6286054849624634, -0.24715296924114227, -0.04228617250919342, 0.5976229906082153, -0.8126803040504456, -0.2176850140094757, -0.7557668089866638, 0.064433254301548, 0.06404166668653488, -0.3105444014072418, 0.8541836142539978, -0.4087725281715393, 0.3311922252178192, 0.563848614692688, 0.22403554618358612, 0.19528892636299133, -0.7463458776473999, 0.393505334854126, 0.1631486564874649, -0.42653414607048035, 0.013572106137871742, 0.48148664832115173, -0.7434708476066589, -0.1383860856294632, 0.11621732264757156, -0.03786022588610649, -1.3487228155136108, -0.8954498767852783, -0.7635919451713562, 0.09535207599401474, 0.12600775063037872, 0.29028409719467163, -0.7425111532211304, 0.036191023886203766, 0.8616306185722351, -1.0564953088760376, -0.32109513878822327, -0.9003399610519409, 1.165257215499878, 0.9552956819534302, -0.6822160482406616, -0.3227372169494629, -0.5741844773292542, -0.30090567469596863, 0.15527307987213135, -0.0554019995033741, 0.43832507729530334, -0.08407372981309891, -0.47763192653656006, -0.13996124267578125, -0.1666584014892578, -0.7602737545967102, -0.145157590508461, -0.41487354040145874, 0.2102816253900528, 0.3291874825954437, 1.1498464345932007, 0.034816987812519073, 0.6615493893623352, -0.12626473605632782, 0.24697372317314148, -0.8038293719291687, 0.2914069592952728, -0.7421339154243469, -0.2586694359779358, 0.20322304964065552, -0.27185240387916565, -0.3983559310436249, 0.5772372484207153, -0.45006152987480164, -0.14222753047943115, -0.36125582456588745, -0.013356504030525684, 0.10549721866846085, 0.21993063390254974, 0.8124914765357971, -0.22775523364543915, 0.44685089588165283, 0.7514351606369019, 0.05946578457951546, 0.07247355580329895, 0.5786542296409607, 0.004575827624648809, -0.6553047299385071, 0.24160946905612946, 0.15161144733428955, -0.2599969506263733, 0.42547449469566345, -1.02251398563385, -0.6740137934684753, -0.6811769008636475, 0.18995434045791626, -0.5140708088874817, 0.536835253238678, -0.9316478967666626, -0.1666007786989212, -0.29488685727119446, 0.03869150951504707, -0.8346952199935913, 0.2287745475769043, -0.330240935087204, 0.14672741293907166, 0.03201181814074516, 0.34767547249794006, -1.1446642875671387, -0.09236177057027817, -0.5203557014465332, 0.21676726639270782, -0.8394712209701538, -0.3214901387691498, 1.3161274194717407, -0.47150635719299316, -0.7780272960662842, 0.3067173957824707, 0.934634268283844, -0.23089775443077087, -0.19853664934635162, 0.12971556186676025, -0.5238608121871948, -0.6419556736946106, 0.10670284926891327, 0.500921368598938, -0.6711406707763672, 0.1467239260673523, 0.15457366406917572, 0.03807641938328743, 0.31072887778282166, -0.24475708603858948, 0.21141977608203888, 0.2700865864753723, 0.59760582447052, -0.4786554276943207, -0.04087667912244797, -0.12050580978393555, -0.15456464886665344, 0.17140033841133118, -0.14661574363708496, -1.089747428894043, -0.1834675520658493, -0.7849978804588318, 0.14322619140148163, -0.2685268521308899, 0.15399408340454102, -0.3718344569206238, 0.37373581528663635, -0.1952468901872635, 0.7838337421417236, 0.6573584079742432, 0.7027328610420227, -0.07181604951620102, -0.20686651766300201, -0.3348054885864258, -0.907058596611023, 0.16910910606384277, -0.3611356317996979, -1.1348438262939453, 0.42248934507369995, 0.6778439283370972, 0.0896768793463707, -0.022143207490444183, 0.04325474426150322, 0.02048124559223652, 0.9126296043395996, -0.398982435464859, -0.33134377002716064, -0.5063766837120056, 0.2831551730632782, 0.8451299667358398, -0.7190830111503601, -0.5773630738258362, -1.4956541061401367, 1.122763752937317, -0.5293264389038086, 0.9958023428916931, -0.0679096132516861, 0.11596615612506866, -0.06543802469968796, 0.1198333203792572, 0.9798637628555298, -0.4420141875743866, 0.5427513718605042, 0.18403396010398865, 0.3709527850151062, 0.005600190721452236, 0.11004839092493057, -1.420622706413269, -0.9257342219352722, -0.5134404301643372, -0.6046977639198303, 0.4055280387401581, -0.13979217410087585, 0.05506227910518646, 0.2369319349527359, -0.0003201907966285944, -0.6340997815132141, -0.8987473249435425, 1.6011923551559448, 0.763918936252594, -1.0468559265136719, 0.3683258593082428, 0.4168153405189514, 0.27185437083244324, -0.30291202664375305, 0.6355624794960022, 0.28169065713882446, -0.26824283599853516, -0.2815120220184326, -0.33118101954460144, -0.2056557685136795, -0.5963528752326965, -0.5041747689247131, 0.1933184713125229, 0.7950182557106018, -0.6030396819114685, 0.5204237103462219, -0.41419658064842224, 0.20790161192417145, 0.0030552188400179148, 1.1955729722976685, 0.038825493305921555, 0.28487828373908997, 0.7192767262458801, -0.6221624612808228, -0.07044509798288345, -0.2087247669696808, -0.48126861453056335, -0.1684047132730484, 0.07294102013111115, 0.19147023558616638, 0.5431293845176697, -0.8314931988716125, 0.5658349394798279, 0.7561914324760437, -0.575512170791626, -0.2187196910381317, 0.08074112981557846, -0.3476349413394928, 0.15454143285751343, 0.36499929428100586, -0.22213047742843628, 0.06832502037286758, -0.27344122529029846, -0.011883541941642761, 0.17540661990642548, 0.49549224972724915, 0.2400365173816681, -1.1252787113189697, 0.4339662492275238, -0.7784491181373596, 0.1365843117237091, 0.3780554533004761, 0.7000971436500549, 0.42753952741622925, 0.1937354952096939, 0.6689919233322144, 0.22755533456802368, 0.6215789318084717, 0.6761602163314819, -0.7451936602592468, 0.32639768719673157, 0.4351806044578552, 0.2798094153404236, 0.5419009923934937, -0.14046241343021393, -0.6431509852409363, 0.9528260231018066, 0.6755414605140686, -0.4496772289276123, -0.548442542552948, 0.21226467192173004, 0.835189938545227, 0.17868463695049286, -0.14210724830627441, 0.012318423949182034, 0.5548385977745056, 0.5350024104118347, 0.5988069772720337, 0.3819446265697479, -0.8297807574272156, -0.20605699717998505, 0.013825326226651669, 0.08919065445661545, 0.003457025857642293, 0.624014675617218, 0.9600368738174438, -0.7816622853279114, -0.9381651282310486, -0.587120771408081, 1.0148648023605347, -0.12594780325889587, -0.28617480397224426, -0.24771074950695038, 0.21908435225486755, -0.9840777516365051, -0.8055911064147949, -0.13919872045516968, -0.16281060874462128, -0.2774576246738434, 0.2894890308380127, -0.2129030078649521, -0.13582439720630646, -0.024693237617611885, -0.20150843262672424, 0.26942014694213867, 0.4212503135204315, -0.15773847699165344, -0.5487542152404785, -0.21500006318092346, 0.5093835592269897, 0.514857828617096, 0.11663047224283218, 1.3185617923736572, -0.2794727385044098, 0.7300266027450562, 0.2117493748664856, 0.7841445803642273, -0.9412463903427124, -0.39553797245025635, 1.121140480041504, -0.05929427966475487, -0.9586496949195862, 0.1786573827266693, 0.28352272510528564, -0.7552383542060852, -0.6780831813812256, 0.004471336957067251, -0.177879199385643, 0.0002566564944572747, -0.2778538465499878, 0.5339875221252441, -0.11770403385162354, -0.07441236078739166, 0.023960817605257034, -0.230447456240654, 0.4674627184867859, -0.22774916887283325, 0.0742710754275322, 0.4133719503879547, 0.5078105926513672, 0.01847144216299057, -0.10004692524671555, 0.11210443824529648, 0.1828841120004654, -0.18594145774841309, -0.2134917974472046, -0.5299520492553711, 0.41288262605667114, -0.058307018131017685, -0.10633071511983871, 0.7303948998451233, 1.030601978302002, 0.5143542885780334, 0.7032952904701233, -0.28785744309425354, -0.4059235155582428, -0.37654250860214233, -0.43078097701072693, -0.9654647707939148, -0.3691911995410919, 0.03216087073087692, -0.3268897831439972, -0.46276167035102844, -1.0152705907821655, -0.49920809268951416, 0.39455145597457886, 0.8843461871147156, 0.16244104504585266, -0.3716428875923157, 0.1554730236530304, 0.7165708541870117, 1.250559687614441, 0.0024204710498452187, -0.21655453741550446, -0.3747134804725647, -0.1958617866039276, -0.7917529344558716, -0.4192357063293457, -0.011845329776406288, -0.4209602177143097, 0.19382134079933167, -0.778367817401886, -0.6221718192100525, 0.31853240728378296, 0.20883876085281372, -1.1370683908462524, -0.49479350447654724, -0.3851357400417328, -0.630375862121582, -0.25551894307136536, -0.5645817518234253, 0.08992910385131836, -0.22499646246433258, 0.12954606115818024, -0.3122237026691437, -0.8028078675270081, -0.5903360843658447, 0.03546762838959694, 1.5722399950027466, -0.1388276070356369, 0.09597133845090866, 0.15692123770713806, 0.6707066297531128, 0.7625946998596191, -0.663341224193573, 0.7880920767784119, 0.4026915431022644, 0.2267676591873169, 0.41328176856040955, 0.3910369575023651, 0.669609010219574, 0.5692384839057922, 0.37736085057258606, -0.027916207909584045, 0.3837920129299164, -0.2848886549472809, -0.45106497406959534, 0.5756927132606506, -0.503791332244873, 1.229981780052185, 0.4432082176208496, -0.5995852947235107, -0.4047752916812897, 0.31205514073371887, 0.527076005935669, -0.588433027267456, -0.4091886878013611, 0.23604720830917358, -1.4013235569000244, -0.4136351943016052, -0.09385167062282562, 0.400012731552124, 0.4374975860118866, 0.09260094165802002, 0.16464641690254211, 0.11421920359134674, 0.7752351760864258, -0.5321377515792847, 0.14500899612903595, -0.041232720017433167, -0.555237352848053, -0.13685299456119537, -0.43448179960250854, 0.18542666733264923, -0.7371384501457214, -0.1547519862651825, 0.17883364856243134, 0.2642711102962494, -0.13502298295497894, 0.29958271980285645, -0.8631893396377563, 0.19832034409046173, 1.2849842309951782, -0.3060600757598877, -0.09067392349243164, 0.19478392601013184, 0.14360596239566803, -0.6218844056129456, -0.9583132863044739, 0.9836519956588745, -1.215593934059143, 0.22847430408000946, 0.22657328844070435, 0.28068915009498596, 1.152253270149231, -0.24957063794136047, -0.28034767508506775, 0.42045822739601135, 0.30278879404067993, 0.3229169249534607, -0.18074052035808563, -0.7900918126106262, 0.04332317039370537, -0.4833516776561737, -0.2189880907535553, 0.1347387284040451, -0.3938056230545044, 0.31072917580604553, -0.25514182448387146, -0.1900145262479782, 0.28020626306533813, 0.2581482529640198, -0.07970274984836578, -0.6333386301994324, -0.027047760784626007, -0.12585172057151794, -0.31842875480651855, -0.24446026980876923, 0.09737612307071686, 0.21967437863349915, -0.701171338558197, -0.3813585340976715, -0.06401770561933517, -0.47484254837036133, 0.3048587441444397, -1.1563193798065186, 0.4087573289871216, 0.4649774432182312, 0.2811448872089386, -0.7480646371841431, -0.34716421365737915, -0.8760313987731934, -0.2575335204601288, 0.20539984107017517, -1.033511757850647, 0.019705425947904587, 0.05556090548634529, 0.12746962904930115, 0.40690696239471436, 0.0989975556731224, 0.3171912431716919, -0.12521067261695862, 0.16649924218654633, -0.45572513341903687, 0.42149433493614197, -0.4346519708633423, -0.3515213429927826, -0.00972252432256937, 0.3140352964401245, 0.2655671238899231, -0.295777291059494, -0.8562825322151184, -1.0458879470825195, 0.5590013861656189, 0.1807500571012497, -0.4712996780872345, 0.5305382013320923, 0.49411851167678833, -0.2915079891681671, -0.475530743598938, -0.6338279247283936, -0.3152192533016205, -0.5011065006256104, 0.8912668824195862, -0.5964909791946411, 0.17955423891544342, 0.6420547962188721, 0.24683712422847748, 0.9557862877845764, -1.239337682723999, 3.997511625289917, 1.0991910696029663, 0.9996070861816406, -0.3415413200855255, 0.7499796152114868, 0.7037611603736877, -0.07188048958778381, 0.12891077995300293, -0.05028654262423515, -0.19718007743358612, -0.006281071808189154, 0.17898184061050415, -0.058626752346754074, 0.5504851341247559, 0.5774447321891785, 0.26937198638916016, -1.035263180732727, 0.06127554178237915, -0.23353588581085205, -1.438307523727417, -0.4907965362071991, 0.32899168133735657, -0.366586297750473, 0.07419034093618393, 0.4756898581981659, 0.0017927148146554828, 0.11463931202888489, -0.13307949900627136, 0.006129623856395483, -0.13521459698677063, 0.09552803635597229, -0.2730104923248291, -0.28727710247039795, -0.5494523644447327, -0.4106004238128662, 0.09302879124879837, -0.1889023780822754, -0.24890266358852386, 0.37525802850723267, -0.39524027705192566, -0.20284110307693481, -0.49577465653419495, 0.2363939732313156, -0.47879573702812195, -0.45524847507476807, 0.5370997786521912, -0.4425256550312042, 0.41107046604156494, -0.3274637460708618, -0.31303349137306213, 0.8146606087684631, -0.3417947292327881, 0.4266812801361084, -0.49829381704330444, -0.5994060039520264, 0.03286314755678177, -0.5520952343940735, -0.5720217823982239, 0.8241974115371704, 0.1935347616672516, 0.7402821183204651, 0.0004488870908971876, -0.8472853302955627, 0.34890130162239075, 0.15194012224674225, 0.13509601354599, 0.1778092384338379, 0.6863678097724915, -0.5828472971916199, 0.007465495262295008, -0.00990279670804739, -0.3183561861515045, -0.265976220369339, -0.34124696254730225, 0.6811157464981079, 0.30825042724609375, -0.4242154061794281, 0.11821561306715012, 0.25845810770988464, -0.40263208746910095, 0.008168699219822884, 0.5380793213844299, 0.6221250891685486, -0.6191768050193787, 0.29826951026916504, 1.0542703866958618, -0.12237666547298431, 0.2767466604709625, -1.2149217128753662, 0.7723284363746643, 0.48143070936203003, -0.39462339878082275, 0.09057709574699402, -0.1534697264432907, 0.014381593093276024 ]
{"Title": "Systematic review and meta-analysis of the association between Epstein-Barr virus, Multiple Sclerosis, and other risk factors", "Authors": "Jacobs Benjamin M, Giovannoni Gavin, Cuzick Jack, Dobson Ruth", "Abstract": "Abstract Background EBV infection is thought to play a central role in the development of Multiple Sclerosis (MS). If causal, it represents a target for interventions to reduce MS risk. Objective To examine the evidence for interaction between EBV and other risk factors, and explore mechanisms via which EBV infection may influence MS risk. Methods Pubmed was searched using the terms \u201cmultiple sclerosis\u201d AND \u201cEpstein Barr virus\u201d, \u201cmultiple sclerosis\u201d AND EBV, \u201cclinically isolated syndrome\u201d AND \u201cEpstein Barr virus\u201d and \u201cclinically isolated syndrome\u201d AND EBV. All abstracts were reviewed for possible inclusion. Results 262 full-text papers were reviewed. There was evidence of interaction on the additive scale between anti-EBV antibody titre and HLA genotype (AP 0.48, p<1\u00d710 \u22124 ; RERI 3.84, p<5\u00d710 \u22123 ; S 1.68, p=0.06). Previous IM was associated with increased OR of MS in HLA-DRB1*1501 positive but not HLA-DRB1*1501 negative persons. Smoking was associated with a greater risk of MS in those with high anti-EBV antibodies (OR 2.76) but not low anti-EBV antibodies (OR 1.16). No interaction between EBV and risk factors was found on a multiplicative scale. Conclusions EBV appears to interact with at least some established MS risk factors. The mechanism via which EBV influences MS risk remains unknown.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007450"}
10.1101/19004473
[ 0.2877541184425354, 0.7500763535499573, 0.39293304085731506, 0.6723342537879944, -0.35916852951049805, 0.5746636986732483, 0.5107995867729187, 0.20747587084770203, 0.9139397144317627, 0.6315104365348816, -0.4681854844093323, -0.2564917504787445, 0.8571546673774719, -0.15216293931007385, -0.580143392086029, -0.026327956467866898, 0.046696607023477554, -0.19162818789482117, -0.3120271563529968, -0.31786057353019714, -0.42772483825683594, 0.595040500164032, -1.0298267602920532, 0.07764790952205658, -1.183207392692566, 0.5910897254943848, 0.02402576245367527, -0.1359338015317917, 1.2348178625106812, 0.5795502662658691, -0.6368442177772522, -0.47094962000846863, 0.6953004002571106, -0.12509647011756897, -0.5352331399917603, -0.15469308197498322, 1.4866114854812622, -0.16814668476581573, -0.16598081588745117, -0.15746331214904785, 1.0966143608093262, 0.3546190857887268, 0.2728729844093323, -0.5662492513656616, -0.08321385085582733, -0.11251440644264221, -0.6499133706092834, -0.2036328762769699, -0.24485871195793152, -0.8149635791778564, -0.2153736650943756, 0.006860645953565836, -0.07858023047447205, -0.899412214756012, 0.09443230926990509, 0.11646798253059387, -0.3398563265800476, -0.33851122856140137, -0.7699423432350159, -0.2806471586227417, 0.5204952359199524, -0.13343222439289093, 0.07738881558179855, -0.8840758800506592, 0.48444071412086487, 0.7271113395690918, -0.11550596356391907, 0.020287415012717247, -0.04963622987270355, -0.5915136933326721, 0.0979231595993042, 0.807856559753418, -0.12123555690050125, -0.8882250785827637, -0.8378462791442871, 0.5813533067703247, 0.09649951010942459, 0.25425782799720764, -0.34435898065567017, -0.48269549012184143, 0.2232874184846878, 0.6185518503189087, 0.26045921444892883, -0.4985787868499756, -0.7307529449462891, 0.2714141607284546, -0.7018680572509766, 0.5900401473045349, -0.21400345861911774, -0.9337935447692871, 0.007590173743665218, 1.3541662693023682, 0.5019780993461609, -0.011366788297891617, -0.09865696728229523, 0.09359413385391235, -0.36502575874328613, -0.4603158235549927, 1.031575322151184, 0.3777114152908325, 0.5650532841682434, 0.4025132656097412, 0.10607131570577621, 0.5696723461151123, -0.5069727301597595, 1.3606919050216675, 0.25536975264549255, -0.9804742932319641, -0.7482550740242004, -0.5581830143928528, -0.20765523612499237, -0.47210872173309326, -0.3121805489063263, -0.03341978043317795, 0.7973523139953613, -0.6023650169372559, 0.7212124466896057, 0.48499226570129395, -0.11650726199150085, 0.0644628033041954, 0.27915188670158386, -0.13243433833122253, 0.6702542901039124, -0.26727116107940674, -0.353207528591156, -0.3947684168815613, 0.7206297516822815, 0.2107517570257187, -0.27909570932388306, 0.3549700975418091, 0.19989344477653503, -0.6698043346405029, -0.6841697096824646, 0.9365972876548767, 0.018564928323030472, 0.20527760684490204, 0.5555118918418884, 0.34706440567970276, 0.8792270421981812, -0.07644272595643997, 0.573826253414154, 0.6316966414451599, -0.39953625202178955, 0.6494948267936707, 0.10495193302631378, 0.5189918279647827, -0.4796273708343506, -0.9357306361198425, -0.3957931101322174, 0.28642094135284424, -0.796811580657959, 0.29500433802604675, 0.13941943645477295, 0.06888847798109055, 0.13983528316020966, 0.6917365789413452, -0.8903213143348694, 0.3648095428943634, -0.37690719962120056, 0.7927193641662598, -0.2538466453552246, -0.41990962624549866, -0.38485458493232727, 0.3884391188621521, -0.7142924070358276, 0.41403070092201233, 0.22637709975242615, 0.12535254657268524, 0.5445932745933533, -0.2089461386203766, 0.898837685585022, 0.12614664435386658, -0.10399244725704193, -0.32093966007232666, -0.09486028552055359, 0.2661135196685791, 1.2578504085540771, -0.09568660706281662, 0.37519019842147827, 1.2874152660369873, -0.11728186160326004, -0.4096514880657196, 0.32892584800720215, 0.6598296761512756, 0.26785755157470703, 0.7604783177375793, 0.33871161937713623, -0.6399771571159363, 0.47408345341682434, -0.17217685282230377, 0.4880807399749756, 0.6810742020606995, -0.8857167363166809, 0.9551036953926086, -0.4690921902656555, 0.03283517807722092, -0.39791813492774963, -0.25649428367614746, -0.03732173144817352, -0.8316069841384888, -0.2596702575683594, 0.15367789566516876, -0.20164862275123596, -0.285686194896698, -0.23584577441215515, 0.37366074323654175, 0.8738685250282288, 0.6107628345489502, -0.0415356419980526, -0.2000388652086258, 0.7852749824523926, -0.12134900689125061, -0.746282160282135, -0.4409814178943634, 0.18506650626659393, -0.4260503649711609, 0.4772621691226959, 0.6252495050430298, -0.19045042991638184, 0.020919421687722206, 0.6999381184577942, -0.06911546736955643, 0.7233484387397766, 0.6455575227737427, 0.2541360855102539, 0.3710894286632538, -0.7432901263237, 0.7378412485122681, -0.4234767556190491, -0.707318127155304, 0.10403724014759064, 0.610397458076477, -0.08373058587312698, 0.917999804019928, 1.7470417022705078, -0.09196572750806808, -0.027352921664714813, 0.40048903226852417, -0.16994501650333405, -0.14260606467723846, 0.13471464812755585, 0.2742805480957031, 0.2467646300792694, 0.4206458032131195, -0.5797278881072998, -0.27419620752334595, -0.5675981044769287, -0.3079688251018524, 0.13817085325717926, -0.12418632209300995, 0.27638164162635803, -0.024302009493112564, 0.7331135869026184, -0.5231802463531494, -0.8895547986030579, -0.026234090328216553, 0.4198761582374573, 0.5428689122200012, -0.4873337149620056, 0.7798839211463928, 0.49115484952926636, 0.793418288230896, -0.8229091763496399, 0.19906938076019287, 0.4156286120414734, 0.29594874382019043, 0.21090945601463318, 0.13649263978004456, -0.37559816241264343, 0.006232470273971558, -0.8952023983001709, -0.48098286986351013, -1.1132773160934448, -0.567430317401886, -0.28716176748275757, -0.3243083953857422, -0.20401206612586975, -0.3410622179508209, 0.35978782176971436, 0.30503177642822266, -0.06567161530256271, -0.6086417436599731, -0.59126877784729, 0.6313555836677551, -0.18195408582687378, 0.3411750793457031, -0.7386999130249023, -0.19522999227046967, 0.15644283592700958, 0.3396732807159424, -0.49399876594543457, -0.30347320437431335, -0.7540273666381836, -0.6835851669311523, 0.36663728952407837, -0.552884578704834, 0.210648313164711, -0.5768193006515503, -0.5121729969978333, -0.1155371144413948, 0.5225208401679993, -0.16605502367019653, 0.790100634098053, 0.3377372920513153, -0.8292909860610962, 0.6431559920310974, -0.30855119228363037, 0.8911676406860352, 0.2520115077495575, -0.13092564046382904, -0.5030218958854675, 0.17428119480609894, 0.7192556858062744, 0.39595136046409607, -0.6638027429580688, -0.08627454191446304, -0.2662522494792938, -0.6620521545410156, 0.08849336206912994, -0.6412980556488037, -0.7630259990692139, 0.4298306405544281, -0.26629823446273804, -0.2228146493434906, -0.04996506869792938, 0.6664681434631348, -0.2862119972705841, -1.1810803413391113, 0.17456331849098206, -0.7556887269020081, -0.5078972578048706, 0.1537265032529831, -0.48514822125434875, 0.8284140825271606, -0.372410386800766, -0.1807268112897873, -0.4841814339160919, -0.06671611219644547, 0.28990229964256287, 0.07971521466970444, 0.6560036540031433, -0.37457525730133057, 0.6885702610015869, -0.05616307631134987, -0.25339794158935547, 0.36501726508140564, 0.10284136235713959, -0.5795922875404358, 0.16972316801548004, -0.6752791404724121, -0.08657583594322205, -0.016675978899002075, 0.3025711476802826, 0.008028696291148663, -0.11109457165002823, 0.7810335755348206, 0.46339330077171326, -0.6852491497993469, 0.4214395582675934, 0.4769611060619354, 0.30402669310569763, -0.09924090653657913, 0.05170329287648201, 0.5179630517959595, -0.6545106172561646, -1.0511810779571533, -0.31768473982810974, 0.13929066061973572, 0.6977624893188477, -0.488537460565567, 0.14245189726352692, 0.0011566814500838518, -0.22029109299182892, -0.019980192184448242, -0.3274729251861572, -0.28840193152427673, 0.4091506600379944, -0.29937848448753357, 1.275207757949829, -0.8791064023971558, 0.7403395771980286, -0.08352803438901901, 0.5769528150558472, 0.017065180465579033, -0.3741147518157959, -0.1260255128145218, -0.40774956345558167, 0.2996649444103241, -0.6330286264419556, -1.0892375707626343, -0.14912469685077667, -0.2760499119758606, 0.5638739466667175, 0.1883736401796341, -0.9087907671928406, -0.15027432143688202, 0.39876288175582886, 0.32332322001457214, -0.04631921276450157, 0.534537672996521, 0.8453187346458435, -0.36058929562568665, 0.5814284682273865, 0.5914875864982605, 0.12046252191066742, 0.5877617597579956, -0.31027352809906006, -0.01783984713256359, -0.3838532567024231, -0.43031319975852966, 0.2628864049911499, -0.07953609526157379, -0.2978864908218384, -0.3863104581832886, 0.0014053359627723694, 0.2656269073486328, 0.5619657039642334, 0.34810692071914673, -0.23515066504478455, -0.6245085597038269, -0.4951836168766022, -0.43682029843330383, -0.6381806135177612, -0.22348681092262268, 1.031705617904663, -0.07189083099365234, 0.0531039759516716, -0.9523424506187439, 0.13088147342205048, 0.7424213886260986, -0.46667274832725525, -0.25100159645080566, 0.2742343246936798, -0.20974615216255188, -0.1455104947090149, 0.47627389430999756, 0.5774288177490234, 0.39771854877471924, -0.04467559978365898, -0.6366745829582214, -0.23065002262592316, 0.19513040781021118, -0.4535357654094696, -0.6509448885917664, -0.3372085690498352, 0.40379801392555237, 0.7242916822433472, 0.39402464032173157, 0.2610091269016266, 0.034532107412815094, 0.34731507301330566, -0.7491478323936462, 0.6175222992897034, -0.5922089219093323, -0.8572611808776855, 0.549119770526886, -0.0886974036693573, 0.29191169142723083, 0.7394620776176453, 0.06791874021291733, -0.4004096984863281, -0.7003553509712219, 0.2259202003479004, -0.42957794666290283, -0.5655585527420044, 0.5700878500938416, 0.9592350721359253, 0.44062289595603943, 1.0921010971069336, -0.870743989944458, 0.22430844604969025, 0.03115580417215824, 0.008935343474149704, -0.6493993401527405, 0.6015526652336121, 0.23406395316123962, -0.3205273747444153, 0.6595384478569031, -0.7637264132499695, 0.020700272172689438, -0.39831289649009705, 0.7173529267311096, 0.14027811586856842, 0.06251794844865799, -0.24715211987495422, -0.6154428720474243, -0.20664732158184052, 0.0706389844417572, -0.6461438536643982, 1.150207281112671, -0.43706008791923523, -0.49871230125427246, 0.24516001343727112, -0.006080412771552801, -0.3053598999977112, -0.3720942437648773, -0.5499353408813477, -0.4443051517009735, 0.3306661546230316, 1.0346434116363525, 0.4726678133010864, -0.5774248838424683, -0.5961718559265137, 0.4842556416988373, -0.7320818901062012, -0.797743558883667, 0.2719901204109192, 0.20162001252174377, -0.5674973726272583, -0.30320146679878235, -0.8495193719863892, 0.6958759427070618, -0.30954551696777344, -0.4273882508277893, -0.38417690992355347, -0.2981005907058716, 0.5700039267539978, 0.4744943082332611, -0.4738011062145233, 0.4026303291320801, 0.24610283970832825, -0.7487184405326843, -0.6478959321975708, 0.6187260746955872, -0.04647668078541756, 0.799265444278717, 0.007288328837603331, 0.02562643028795719, -0.19722656905651093, -0.7733095288276672, 0.4232954978942871, -0.21935853362083435, 0.3956080675125122, 0.09287767112255096, -0.17633803188800812, -0.4223521649837494, 1.1324187517166138, -0.029146777465939522, -0.04291164129972458, -0.3842453360557556, -0.664445698261261, -0.10726853460073471, -0.15841762721538544, -0.13242745399475098, -0.49448490142822266, -0.9889078736305237, -0.11119049787521362, -0.014141350984573364, 0.14375808835029602, 0.248257577419281, -0.08217927813529968, -0.3736448287963867, 0.7769495844841003, 0.38710135221481323, -0.329866886138916, -1.0450721979141235, 0.34583666920661926, 0.9575716257095337, -0.3961317241191864, -0.4404219388961792, -1.0449879169464111, 0.3468621075153351, -0.6955015659332275, 0.8912465572357178, 0.20789891481399536, -0.1987125128507614, 0.46817848086357117, -0.8687635660171509, 0.54349684715271, -0.6454121470451355, -0.3778530955314636, 0.8368963003158569, 0.5215189456939697, -0.2582274377346039, 0.4096717834472656, -1.15603768825531, 0.40182265639305115, -0.4009295105934143, -1.2997151613235474, -0.25265973806381226, -0.4247606098651886, -0.18769247829914093, -0.17251385748386383, -0.34672126173973083, 0.08727865666151047, -0.6360092163085938, 1.1752527952194214, 0.20248453319072723, -0.6244008541107178, -0.6547725200653076, -0.9711199402809143, 0.06032755598425865, -0.1577681452035904, -0.02836478315293789, -0.19672144949436188, -0.8137288689613342, 0.15561755001544952, -0.2776873707771301, 0.09546379745006561, -1.6366794109344482, -0.42851707339286804, 0.02730158530175686, -0.056177541613578796, -0.013101105578243732, 0.14125265181064606, -0.52205491065979, -0.22394725680351257, 0.09890152513980865, 0.8897129893302917, -0.3045333921909332, 0.6070519685745239, 0.8807284235954285, -0.06228461489081383, -1.0163288116455078, -0.1286526471376419, -0.06096638739109039, -0.432718425989151, 0.074287049472332, 0.4983925223350525, 0.9322404265403748, -1.0268785953521729, 0.49397581815719604, 0.8201049566268921, -0.1986238956451416, -0.6388623118400574, 0.9413889050483704, -0.5758315324783325, 0.4219393730163574, -0.13802464306354523, -0.2196040153503418, 0.04146084934473038, -0.21462008357048035, -0.5416378378868103, -0.027699101716279984, -0.18194438517093658, 0.9640417098999023, -0.8689635396003723, -0.38269996643066406, -0.7718259692192078, -0.41636553406715393, 0.6136277914047241, -0.6282151341438293, 0.4785752594470978, 0.6384425759315491, -0.622242271900177, -0.007170149590820074, 0.05967655032873154, -0.346174955368042, -0.20247212052345276, -0.007632333319634199, 0.7544845938682556, 0.007014336530119181, 1.0314072370529175, 0.5775817632675171, -0.04968036711215973, 0.48572221398353577, 0.6596016883850098, -0.5833948254585266, -0.16377243399620056, 0.40641656517982483, 0.34121307730674744, -0.20760232210159302, -0.28400081396102905, 0.06727660447359085, 0.44018909335136414, 0.8197358250617981, 0.6134012341499329, -0.5108843445777893, -1.1793975830078125, -0.9646867513656616, 0.10108936578035355, -0.13001972436904907, 0.18165424466133118, -0.4178043305873871, 0.8986832499504089, -0.19176959991455078, 0.28399112820625305, -0.17607446014881134, 0.1623607873916626, 0.6345555186271667, -0.39479100704193115, -0.8446054458618164, 0.09135960787534714, -0.09975576400756836, -1.3045380115509033, -0.7409034967422485, -0.5361275672912598, -0.16763031482696533, 0.8581428527832031, -1.1414430141448975, -0.6369761824607849, 0.8525454998016357, -0.34884917736053467, -0.5073039531707764, 0.22470402717590332, -0.12832878530025482, 0.26728397607803345, -0.15005306899547577, 1.0720109939575195, -0.3065442740917206, -0.18484050035476685, -0.11996524035930634, -0.33868134021759033, 0.6389545202255249, 0.3639557361602783, 0.2637491524219513, -0.04395679756999016, -0.2914431095123291, 0.03375624492764473, -0.596670925617218, 0.16703148186206818, -0.6060960292816162, 0.21826514601707458, -0.5585930347442627, 0.3570728003978729, 0.3998663127422333, 0.15515907108783722, 0.7352785468101501, 0.37506794929504395, -0.02945343405008316, -0.006813560612499714, 0.11727447062730789, -0.056090325117111206, -0.015588429756462574, 1.1786364316940308, 0.6376013159751892, 0.026344982907176018, 1.073708176612854, 0.2408086657524109, -0.09853001683950424, -0.8147463202476501, 0.6801687479019165, 0.8804536461830139, 0.11886986345052719, 0.6563659906387329, -0.31186142563819885, 0.699320912361145, -0.7935420274734497, -0.4127962589263916, -0.11316588521003723, 0.5914174318313599, 0.4494847357273102, 0.35544243454933167, 0.10452830791473389, 0.46761995553970337, -0.9115975499153137, -0.5050690174102783, -0.6379517912864685, -0.6378969550132751, 0.47290968894958496, -0.6095626354217529, -0.37590500712394714, -0.49875158071517944, -0.50834059715271, 0.41359561681747437, 0.24984702467918396, 0.06184186041355133, -0.6054005026817322, 0.9730759263038635, 0.5453776717185974, 0.3561001420021057, -0.3194926381111145, 0.24647994339466095, 0.19604331254959106, 0.4369916021823883, -0.46976378560066223, -0.5129984021186829, 0.17202669382095337, 0.0963352844119072, 0.2891327142715454, 0.27218377590179443, -0.7211544513702393, 0.5567002296447754, 0.12787283957004547, -0.23794715106487274, 0.15809907019138336, -0.04167896509170532, -1.8236461877822876, 0.240920752286911, -0.6089044809341431, 0.09604041278362274, -0.37392616271972656, 0.47703009843826294, -0.06901074200868607, -0.2951273024082184, -0.8106662034988403, -0.3060971796512604, 0.7421609163284302, -0.8713772892951965, 0.4444434940814972, -0.12940391898155212, 0.26890501379966736, -0.6841270923614502, -0.23287327587604523, 0.15708497166633606, 0.5643499493598938, -0.3373851776123047, 0.19903573393821716, -0.1760963499546051, 0.28762713074684143, 0.43799301981925964, -0.27064573764801025, 0.3696899712085724, -0.24121874570846558, -0.38638007640838623, -0.4006013572216034, 0.13945633172988892, -0.5093775391578674, 0.8857988119125366, -0.07386224716901779, -0.16746236383914948, -0.6286489963531494, 0.28153595328330994, -0.3689705729484558, -0.2511154115200043, -0.2586704194545746, 0.4632813632488251, -0.24646584689617157, -0.48365163803100586, -0.16982021927833557, -0.22338354587554932, 1.0386298894882202, 0.2676483690738678, -0.14742493629455566, 0.15996265411376953, 0.7039616703987122, 0.3003934919834137, -0.16811291873455048, 1.0182769298553467, -0.2960209846496582, 0.06889976561069489, -0.6243283748626709, 0.2821647822856903, -0.05568480119109154, 0.24450136721134186, -0.04216384515166283, -0.2617633640766144, -0.6122561097145081, 0.24851550161838531, 0.29113101959228516, -0.04170485585927963, 0.7452802658081055, 0.30123013257980347, 0.4310927093029022, -0.19420881569385529, 0.20564880967140198, -0.9224331378936768, 0.13724125921726227, 0.2443496584892273, -0.5675685405731201, -0.033423397690057755, 0.18724611401557922, 0.7185738682746887, 0.605705738067627, 1.126563549041748, 0.4133470058441162, 0.2006128430366516, 0.23505546152591705, -0.29929548501968384, -0.3076365292072296, 0.5315980911254883, -0.3378671109676361, -0.04577622190117836, -0.09257032722234726, -0.2546636164188385, 0.30570724606513977, 0.24099598824977875, 0.5266836881637573, -0.7185267210006714, 0.37161752581596375, -0.007081695832312107, -0.09362763166427612, -1.139676570892334, 0.34528374671936035, 0.19609478116035461, -0.06731101125478745, 0.09001839905977249, 0.14650461077690125, 0.7673051357269287, 0.484293133020401, -0.49421781301498413, -0.45757460594177246, -1.2391904592514038, -0.6376937031745911, -0.012628725729882717, -0.002799858106300235, -0.20296332240104675, -0.13298733532428741, 0.06036750599741936, -0.5660728216171265, 0.12679889798164368, 0.12950550019741058, -0.580629825592041, -1.0818032026290894, 0.11985177546739578, 0.11960814148187637, 0.7697581648826599, 0.2952621281147003, 0.17028678953647614, 0.07218979299068451, 0.19070053100585938, 0.1819934993982315, -0.3474879562854767, 0.7945499420166016, 0.6671128273010254, -0.43625423312187195, 0.36189043521881104, 0.20142531394958496, 0.40405789017677307, -0.3727812170982361, -1.0115491151809692, -0.26273950934410095, -0.2194489985704422, -0.42538589239120483, -0.26953884959220886, 0.5916003584861755, 1.4190888404846191, -0.1705981194972992, -0.1541336327791214, -0.5688489079475403, -0.6078501343727112, -0.5809630155563354, 0.3272348940372467, -0.3916841149330139, -0.19417621195316315, 0.4242161512374878, -0.05989530310034752, 0.6775291562080383, -1.1407209634780884, 4.04318904876709, 1.1194478273391724, 0.6669533848762512, 0.11636509746313095, 0.25751936435699463, 0.6361861228942871, 0.35403043031692505, -0.9161444902420044, -0.28038015961647034, 0.3433993458747864, 0.07396648824214935, -0.03550649434328079, 0.6215054988861084, -0.32508182525634766, 0.7975272536277771, 1.0017298460006714, -0.4619678556919098, -0.23571249842643738, -0.036147210747003555, -1.0994701385498047, -0.07399217039346695, 0.3614954650402069, -0.7597116827964783, -0.28677451610565186, -0.47318896651268005, 0.5312719345092773, 0.3667510151863098, 0.8160717487335205, -0.2891472578048706, 0.0037563859950751066, 0.3309433162212372, -0.1389756202697754, 0.5251285433769226, -1.1634553670883179, -0.5442925095558167, 0.20438367128372192, 0.26507893204689026, -0.6242979764938354, -0.7176820635795593, 0.5065578818321228, 0.07440358400344849, 0.08131956309080124, -0.27358460426330566, -0.21264725923538208, -1.2055598497390747, 0.2939976155757904, -0.5434175729751587, 0.6794499754905701, 0.9411808848381042, -0.402721107006073, 0.23654314875602722, -0.257874995470047, 0.20591290295124054, -0.2871108651161194, -0.5383091568946838, -0.10862774401903152, -0.28473901748657227, -0.3017418086528778, -0.13478802144527435, 0.08391942083835602, 0.2714029550552368, 0.1873602569103241, -0.40113088488578796, -0.7112683057785034, -0.18723247945308685, 0.0102850878611207, 0.35875678062438965, 0.43515336513519287, -0.2563280463218689, -0.6754794120788574, 0.4652974605560303, -0.07076231390237808, 0.3274594843387604, 0.2186610847711563, 0.9334235787391663, 0.4691670536994934, -0.4081990420818329, 0.4142722487449646, -0.8542672991752625, -0.7553154826164246, 0.6077628135681152, 0.790688157081604, 0.4887043237686157, -0.22980555891990662, -0.052230555564165115, 0.4925999343395233, -0.24108456075191498, -0.6595774292945862, -1.4497880935668945, 0.7857522964477539, 0.49247121810913086, 0.1990940421819687, -0.6581815481185913, -0.23371417820453644, 0.3787686228752136 ]
{"Title": "Evaluation of a rapid lateral flow calprotectin test for the diagnosis of prosthetic joint infection", "Authors": "Trotter Alexander J., Dean Rachael, Whitehouse Celia E., Mikalsen Jarle, Hill Claire, Brunton-Sim Roxanne, Kay Gemma L., Shakokhani Majeed, Durst Alexander, Wain John, McNamara Iain, O\u2019Grady Justin", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Microbiological diagnosis of prosthetic joint infection (PJI) relies on culture techniques that are slow and insensitive. Rapid tests are urgently required to improve patient management. Calprotectin is a neutrophil biomarker of inflammation that has been demonstrated to be effective for the diagnosis of PJI. A calprotectin based lateral flow test has been developed for the rapid detection of PJI using synovial fluid samples. Methods A convenience series of 69 synovial fluid samples from patients at the Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals (NNUH) were collected intraoperatively from 52 hip and 17 knee revision operations. Calprotectin levels were measured using a new commercially available lateral flow assay for PJI diagnosis (Lyfstone). For all samples, synovial fluid was pipetted onto the lateral flow device and the signal was read using a mobile phone app after 15 minutes incubation at room temperature. Results According to the Musculoskeletal Infection Society (MSIS) criteria, 24 patients were defined as PJI positive and the remaining 45 were negative. The overall accuracy of the lateral flow test against the MSIS criteria was 75%. The test had a sensitivity and specificity of 75% and 76% respectively with a positive predictive value (PPV) of 62% and a negative predictive value (NPV) of 85%. Discordant results were then reviewed by the clinical team using available patient data to develop an alternative gold standard for defining presence/absence of infection (MSIS+). Compared to MSIS+, the test showed an overall accuracy of 83%, sensitivity and specificity of 95% and 78% respectively, a PPV of 62% and an NPV of 98%. Test accuracy for hip revisions was 77% and for knee revisions was 100%. Conclusions This study demonstrates that the calprotectin lateral flow assay is an effective diagnostic test for PJI. Our data suggests that the test is likely to generate false positive results in patients with metallosis and gross osteolysis.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004473"}
10.1101/19002238
[ 0.13881312310695648, 0.16342693567276, -0.513292670249939, 0.3002592623233795, -0.14604485034942627, -0.45838961005210876, -0.1170746386051178, -0.10688689351081848, 0.5982033610343933, 0.9235497713088989, 0.0319535918533802, -0.32487010955810547, 1.064773678779602, -0.0974607914686203, 0.04146696254611015, 0.25896093249320984, -0.1816360354423523, 0.08714332431554794, -0.3081105649471283, -0.12587575614452362, -0.4452570080757141, 0.40153735876083374, -0.9614205360412598, 0.15356291830539703, -0.49271735548973083, 0.43025505542755127, -0.08434216678142548, 0.11610227823257446, 1.425673484802246, 0.6135398745536804, 0.5041057467460632, -0.035072579979896545, 0.09799914807081223, -0.7233326435089111, -0.06314992159605026, -0.7471042275428772, 1.0841370820999146, -0.24930721521377563, 0.24163679778575897, -0.3534661829471588, 0.5076757073402405, -0.1323876827955246, 0.5147301554679871, -0.8489419221878052, -0.7579514980316162, -0.3234074115753174, 0.2499750554561615, 0.7059341073036194, 0.3636995255947113, -0.3591650426387787, -0.2589072585105896, -0.06070931255817413, -0.23387230932712555, -0.3684905767440796, 0.3468658924102783, -0.13877615332603455, 0.6256130337715149, -0.3501838445663452, -0.41434985399246216, -0.18281804025173187, 0.328894704580307, -0.028788305819034576, 0.9384636282920837, -0.5362816452980042, 0.8280876278877258, 0.6197595000267029, -0.13361388444900513, -0.3065448999404907, -0.4876238703727722, -0.059115152806043625, -0.22828996181488037, -0.24263690412044525, -0.30253735184669495, -0.5755646824836731, -0.7208685278892517, -1.1503323316574097, 0.3816703259944916, -0.49663442373275757, 0.2708056569099426, 0.1525750607252121, 0.1966761350631714, 0.43613171577453613, 0.6569594740867615, -0.3031890392303467, 0.004327652510255575, -0.2850075960159302, 0.8424736261367798, -0.2577193081378937, 0.49470990896224976, 0.37056222558021545, 0.20659245550632477, 0.24323417246341705, -0.4901185929775238, 0.7553214430809021, -0.010166396386921406, 0.8320731520652771, -0.39021944999694824, 0.134725421667099, 0.41650235652923584, -0.12281905859708786, 1.0064343214035034, 1.2238668203353882, 0.2563002407550812, 0.7640979886054993, -0.3179107904434204, 0.4468865394592285, 0.8094148635864258, -0.5869803428649902, 0.07410284131765366, -0.6756223440170288, -0.14939895272254944, 0.1479952186346054, -0.5497534275054932, -0.16685684025287628, 0.6174123883247375, -0.037356387823820114, 0.45907214283943176, 1.193954348564148, -0.1734597533941269, -0.40932193398475647, 0.10241686552762985, -0.049867480993270874, -0.15597356855869293, -0.23968343436717987, 0.172915980219841, -0.07093772292137146, 0.09086977690458298, 0.8185496926307678, -0.33960121870040894, -0.421044260263443, 0.06648585200309753, -0.9086490273475647, -0.6417189836502075, 0.780144214630127, 0.15762031078338623, -0.11229323595762253, 0.855126142501831, 0.2496533989906311, 0.297585129737854, -0.06297586858272552, -0.4197319447994232, 0.6073923707008362, 0.08015850186347961, 0.9600411057472229, 0.03131772577762604, 1.2313076257705688, -0.5758817195892334, -0.7210718393325806, -0.6147127747535706, -0.16113685071468353, 0.44752973318099976, 0.4662090241909027, 0.455231636762619, 0.2938178777694702, 0.009657611139118671, 0.5913398265838623, -0.678743302822113, -0.24748103320598602, -0.38278597593307495, -0.0812651589512825, 0.04041413217782974, 0.9822617173194885, -0.6114190220832825, 0.2576919496059418, -0.1178194135427475, 0.7794738411903381, 0.3001437783241272, -0.11017348617315292, 0.5525972843170166, -0.5173225402832031, 0.18046879768371582, 0.3631763458251953, -0.11912574619054794, -0.15767188370227814, 0.2385781854391098, 0.3435708284378052, 0.6083428263664246, 0.16779394447803497, 0.2719292938709259, 0.5303353071212769, 0.40086692571640015, 0.16562983393669128, 0.7042240500450134, 0.6918323040008545, -0.34253281354904175, 0.5541088581085205, -0.3709773123264313, -0.6400594711303711, -0.5029551982879639, -0.8122981786727905, -0.32377567887306213, 0.5491962432861328, -0.7081193923950195, 0.5598331689834595, -0.420431524515152, 0.0072374059818685055, -0.10881691426038742, 0.45626893639564514, 0.7569634318351746, -0.30110347270965576, -0.46059659123420715, 0.32049354910850525, -0.09705889225006104, 0.06164062023162842, -0.29256483912467957, 0.48875492811203003, 0.23657551407814026, 0.13346615433692932, -0.6983351707458496, 0.8999188542366028, 0.5890244245529175, -0.07273272424936295, -0.5052788257598877, 0.023986568674445152, 1.1464263200759888, -0.7413028478622437, -0.3578990399837494, 0.1767166703939438, -0.08837064355611801, -0.12746915221214294, -0.66376793384552, 0.03660048544406891, 0.6501796245574951, 0.1007634848356247, -0.14895318448543549, 0.4197676479816437, 0.8894338011741638, 0.5131837725639343, -0.4461672902107239, -0.31853407621383667, 0.20915737748146057, 0.7200051546096802, 0.32993584871292114, 0.28703346848487854, 0.8686755895614624, -0.17996633052825928, 0.6566739082336426, 0.7838409543037415, 0.29134637117385864, 0.09275919944047928, 0.6294057369232178, 0.427786648273468, 0.3684885501861572, 0.09838232398033142, -0.4757919907569885, 0.8588410019874573, -0.1382145881652832, 0.18791437149047852, -0.27928948402404785, 0.3128608763217926, -0.22400909662246704, 1.36688232421875, 0.32475075125694275, 0.3500564694404602, -1.04862380027771, -0.926558256149292, 0.7243586182594299, 0.12393144518136978, -0.4625825881958008, -0.3069065511226654, -0.045779962092638016, 0.46548783779144287, 0.05731073394417763, 0.15987887978553772, 0.4477454423904419, -0.5395951867103577, -0.07880913466215134, -0.06125005707144737, 0.581751823425293, -0.19383743405342102, -1.1446186304092407, -0.6660568118095398, -1.4637928009033203, -0.8606293201446533, -0.750452995300293, 0.3123668134212494, 0.3090560734272003, -0.9835336804389954, 0.23131205141544342, 0.2788623571395874, 0.46960800886154175, 0.44934335350990295, -0.45341938734054565, 0.24215379357337952, 0.2688084542751312, 0.3416708707809448, -0.870924711227417, 0.6126270890235901, -0.16231964528560638, 0.6503643989562988, -0.07578884810209274, -0.2977534830570221, -1.1613713502883911, 0.15121929347515106, 0.3375251293182373, 0.00301507581025362, 0.5135027170181274, 0.5949024558067322, -0.47549235820770264, -0.44847920536994934, 0.689808189868927, -0.5871905088424683, 0.23830029368400574, -0.54678875207901, -0.7966856360435486, 0.45597320795059204, -0.8778297305107117, 0.044350504875183105, 0.37311261892318726, 0.3089190721511841, -0.3873938322067261, 0.7720541954040527, 0.615675151348114, 0.064179927110672, -0.9181354641914368, 0.17449334263801575, 0.3589966297149658, -0.5228231549263, 0.24459348618984222, -0.6260897517204285, -1.0980656147003174, -0.315922349691391, 0.2847054898738861, -1.109846591949463, -0.000696896284352988, 0.38725924491882324, 0.3011545240879059, -1.8710869550704956, -0.04892455413937569, -0.9628262519836426, -1.101086974143982, 0.33750635385513306, 0.342963308095932, 0.5003235936164856, 0.7690901756286621, 0.0793367400765419, -0.572596549987793, -0.11698803305625916, 0.12722419202327728, -0.009523213841021061, 0.7545998096466064, -0.523525059223175, -0.281971275806427, 0.23263511061668396, -0.6781768798828125, 0.21436992287635803, -0.20050416886806488, -0.37349724769592285, -0.5959641933441162, -0.037730149924755096, -0.2806357443332672, 0.5532590746879578, 0.6609858870506287, -0.07850370556116104, -0.2058851420879364, 0.3694632649421692, -0.1847601979970932, -0.16375106573104858, 0.09642841666936874, 0.42315050959587097, -0.3811631500720978, 0.6566057205200195, -0.37159463763237, 0.01708589494228363, -1.1785424947738647, -0.5025894045829773, -0.004443500656634569, 0.28391361236572266, 0.1514221876859665, -0.9634888172149658, 0.25261518359184265, -0.6456760764122009, 0.08819488435983658, 0.6385225057601929, -0.2693912982940674, -0.30538925528526306, 1.1766011714935303, -0.1950264722108841, 1.1932541131973267, -0.6790980696678162, -0.2966866195201874, 0.6996005177497864, 0.663702666759491, 0.07253988087177277, -0.4986013174057007, 0.689478874206543, -0.35788050293922424, 0.32372429966926575, -0.48998892307281494, -0.5335937738418579, -0.18059270083904266, -0.6069499850273132, -0.3660617768764496, 0.07248605787754059, -0.6086090207099915, -0.25595659017562866, 0.43172749876976013, 0.43841251730918884, 0.1330714076757431, -0.034486398100852966, 0.918687641620636, -0.4197434186935425, 0.35013270378112793, 0.9891353249549866, 0.5516055822372437, 0.6467292308807373, -0.6549118757247925, 0.64237380027771, -0.08084102720022202, 0.35355234146118164, 0.18628112971782684, 0.15106697380542755, -0.48235926032066345, -0.18380855023860931, 0.03207053616642952, 0.23566138744354248, -0.484421044588089, -0.422238826751709, -0.24563947319984436, 0.2292880415916443, -0.38947293162345886, 0.30723437666893005, -1.5062655210494995, 0.4066499173641205, -0.26075705885887146, -0.5876404047012329, 0.5448893904685974, 0.04459661617875099, 0.5157325267791748, 0.9265905022621155, -0.501686155796051, -0.791523277759552, -0.16898475587368011, -0.3497926890850067, -0.5103419423103333, 0.11895453184843063, -0.32443687319755554, -0.027445871382951736, 0.4561915695667267, -0.5500742793083191, -0.0843350887298584, -0.5886821150779724, -0.8249765634536743, 0.21320293843746185, -0.20768645405769348, 0.24597762525081635, 1.576422095298767, 0.7279432415962219, 0.7283630967140198, 0.7434549927711487, 0.2724760174751282, -0.03680708259344101, 0.46478959918022156, 0.2645168602466583, -0.4367852807044983, -0.04535580798983574, -0.11841755360364914, -0.24784094095230103, -0.3492783010005951, 0.025661304593086243, -0.07933370769023895, 0.006883090361952782, 0.2544066905975342, -0.11594060808420181, -1.147624135017395, 0.7627477049827576, -0.1521364450454712, 0.13608510792255402, 0.6608306765556335, -0.04929288104176521, -0.02731226570904255, -0.3864591419696808, -0.40886008739471436, -0.08873715251684189, -0.03449811041355133, -0.15470357239246368, -0.1225617304444313, -0.07855258882045746, -0.8132932782173157, 0.48867881298065186, -0.09802821278572083, 0.5467361807823181, -0.30638453364372253, -0.3887071907520294, -0.6162547469139099, -0.14050641655921936, -0.44304588437080383, 0.2666923999786377, -0.6838908791542053, 0.7106078863143921, -0.8488354086875916, -0.06599634140729904, -0.18523399531841278, -0.3455231487751007, -1.0966308116912842, -0.14192789793014526, 0.024608859792351723, -0.7054937481880188, 0.099888376891613, 0.4799688160419464, 0.6183055639266968, -0.16447797417640686, -1.0686979293823242, -0.2619708478450775, 0.9668943881988525, -0.169134721159935, -0.3868294656276703, 0.052290476858615875, 0.03159567341208458, -0.15787963569164276, -0.5206697583198547, 0.07186733931303024, -0.47664523124694824, 0.4297090172767639, -0.6831681132316589, 0.14855065941810608, 0.50992751121521, -0.09380786120891571, -0.6531034111976624, 0.05893173813819885, -0.25156301259994507, -0.9635022878646851, -0.8505907654762268, -0.2346385270357132, -0.06837432831525803, 0.719249427318573, -0.3429476320743561, -0.318918913602829, -0.3189265727996826, -0.7630333304405212, -0.04212154448032379, -0.13968293368816376, -0.44519859552383423, 0.04116182401776314, -0.7020457983016968, -0.049199219793081284, 0.7027994394302368, 0.2963779866695404, -0.015584577806293964, 0.10314681380987167, -0.6518217325210571, -0.20614151656627655, -0.14650379121303558, -0.2931382954120636, 0.4207843244075775, -0.6334090232849121, 0.07583645731210709, 1.7709739208221436, 0.6577250957489014, -0.5681993961334229, -0.2303013801574707, 0.09207235276699066, 0.2744629681110382, 0.12483319640159607, -0.39305010437965393, -0.4572102725505829, 0.2563364505767822, 0.4800473153591156, -0.17506778240203857, -0.18839898705482483, -1.2227487564086914, 0.7735219597816467, -1.0083067417144775, 0.3268740773200989, -0.2741324007511139, -0.374055415391922, -0.17556539177894592, -0.33571699261665344, 0.4702865183353424, -0.6936797499656677, 0.5600659251213074, -0.0025817309506237507, 0.21823081374168396, -0.35558438301086426, 0.14326703548431396, -0.45431220531463623, -0.5834736227989197, -0.4803300201892853, 0.10362129658460617, -0.2867856025695801, 0.05159533768892288, 0.3277356028556824, 0.31181254982948303, -0.2971726357936859, 0.0714830830693245, -1.095978021621704, 0.7036179900169373, 0.4006511867046356, -0.7815268635749817, -0.05251476913690567, -0.23726563155651093, 0.09219727665185928, 0.41669800877571106, 0.2660103440284729, 0.31698521971702576, -0.4660218060016632, -0.01884562522172928, -0.4591708481311798, 0.2568875551223755, -0.21189166605472565, -0.3581518530845642, 0.11818195879459381, 0.6236938834190369, -0.40318912267684937, -0.29910069704055786, 0.2896173596382141, -0.04167540743947029, 0.15916389226913452, 0.9763402342796326, 0.07563230395317078, 0.030279656872153282, 0.32314828038215637, -0.8125725388526917, -0.4919346570968628, 0.25272712111473083, -0.5071795582771301, 0.2602815330028534, 0.07010463625192642, 0.7543590664863586, 0.19975626468658447, -0.912606954574585, 0.3324539363384247, 0.036978431046009064, -1.027935266494751, 0.21231214702129364, -0.08006329834461212, -0.329273521900177, 0.5036441683769226, -0.14159002900123596, -0.5962352156639099, 0.7506516575813293, -0.19605545699596405, 0.45930153131484985, -0.2529127299785614, -0.16715265810489655, -0.2691437304019928, -1.0160378217697144, 0.05764925479888916, -0.05467192828655243, 0.7528130412101746, 0.8113481402397156, -0.3390975296497345, 0.513198971748352, 0.28140661120414734, 0.34711480140686035, 0.14123181998729706, 0.1428004652261734, 0.29982587695121765, -0.6651387214660645, 0.4765191972255707, 0.8245342969894409, 0.07836148142814636, 0.13746173679828644, 0.27492761611938477, -0.833829402923584, 0.8021491765975952, 0.46620848774909973, -1.2935764789581299, -0.6261810064315796, 0.08515508472919464, 0.5730852484703064, 0.1300753355026245, -0.6410744786262512, -0.10872917622327805, 1.0555921792984009, 0.5574729442596436, 0.8147047758102417, -0.8190295100212097, -0.4537878930568695, -0.3782542943954468, 0.06870745122432709, -0.0881439670920372, -0.36521655321121216, 0.13062426447868347, 0.4220587909221649, -0.04197379946708679, -0.7300301790237427, -0.4470205008983612, 0.6324911713600159, -0.4319309592247009, -0.26879778504371643, -0.3969491720199585, 0.6363781690597534, -0.9040828347206116, -0.7740316390991211, -0.2689257562160492, -0.1223161444067955, 0.19914212822914124, 0.5095371007919312, -0.6825562119483948, -0.39228376746177673, 0.20976948738098145, -0.03673725575208664, 0.28078049421310425, 0.3808034360408783, -0.6632918119430542, -0.17329822480678558, -0.27802741527557373, 0.29177913069725037, 0.2106054276227951, 0.13966314494609833, 0.3136334717273712, -1.0340694189071655, 0.570851743221283, 0.4520263969898224, -0.5666396021842957, -0.1377764195203781, 0.1571403294801712, 0.07433097064495087, -0.6769209504127502, -1.0156365633010864, -0.5056118369102478, 0.49227720499038696, -0.8809955716133118, 0.3202345371246338, 0.1005791649222374, 0.23345260322093964, 0.30162397027015686, -0.5561997294425964, -0.9269007444381714, 0.7871067523956299, 0.16889454424381256, 0.25847041606903076, 0.06706929206848145, 0.05128831788897514, 0.18654662370681763, 0.34516966342926025, 0.775745153427124, 0.15699805319309235, 0.13935118913650513, -1.028786301612854, 0.41082534193992615, 0.06688225269317627, 0.19437195360660553, 0.47294676303863525, -0.3577755391597748, 0.7586534023284912, -0.29011133313179016, -0.1320444941520691, 0.2869813144207001, 1.0212830305099487, 0.7480161190032959, 0.12677668035030365, 0.14435456693172455, -0.4218807816505432, -0.5494998693466187, -0.31454697251319885, -0.7509595155715942, -1.045735239982605, 0.6060714721679688, -0.6733448505401611, 0.35336625576019287, -0.6517101526260376, -0.3713832497596741, 0.37360525131225586, -0.02768035978078842, 0.004691095557063818, 0.0182036105543375, 0.7440482378005981, 0.2508695125579834, 1.1280086040496826, 0.1828920841217041, -0.20132815837860107, -0.35539019107818604, 0.1919926404953003, -0.5219119787216187, 0.10272996872663498, -0.09548468887805939, 0.20544439554214478, 0.99245285987854, -0.29893290996551514, -0.5032284259796143, 0.44657957553863525, 0.1294037103652954, -0.33457374572753906, 0.04526859521865845, 0.27340468764305115, -0.7466913461685181, -0.3898337185382843, 0.04940890893340111, 0.47336843609809875, -0.47389066219329834, -0.12942031025886536, 0.26988011598587036, -0.3976999521255493, -0.885508120059967, -0.0416937880218029, 0.45598530769348145, -0.11804842948913574, -0.20247222483158112, -0.146562859416008, 0.13190804421901703, 0.5691359639167786, -0.40485888719558716, 0.6220555901527405, 0.03613338991999626, 0.3369331657886505, 0.015668297186493874, -0.5480629801750183, 0.5236741304397583, 0.7191928625106812, 0.2966727912425995, -0.11269780248403549, 0.6155347228050232, 0.17851658165454865, -0.6946014761924744, 0.15625710785388947, -0.8176602721214294, 0.8060484528541565, 0.2313060760498047, -0.3272131681442261, -0.07430505752563477, 0.8363795876502991, 0.4302902817726135, 0.2547338902950287, -0.7760555148124695, 0.5892882347106934, -0.6569769978523254, -1.1701533794403076, -0.06439650803804398, 0.17945311963558197, 0.38493216037750244, 0.5949170589447021, 0.8377578258514404, 0.5715765953063965, 0.4105592668056488, 0.25326189398765564, -0.09241407364606857, 0.628163754940033, 0.34485527873039246, 0.13413450121879578, -0.5483450293540955, 0.17993038892745972, -0.37735193967819214, 0.02157822623848915, -0.16971087455749512, -0.24312101304531097, 0.12914447486400604, -0.02913377806544304, 0.10027442127466202, -0.22731442749500275, 0.70836341381073, -0.43922385573387146, -0.43917229771614075, -0.896678626537323, -0.26029348373413086, -0.7738147974014282, -0.3824511170387268, 0.9292604327201843, -0.37786993384361267, -0.10318342596292496, 0.5708281993865967, 0.6353006958961487, -0.021285617724061012, 0.4665140211582184, 0.6664544343948364, -0.015804192051291466, 0.19085384905338287, 0.5210044980049133, 0.7708404064178467, -0.3559670150279999, 0.5137795805931091, -0.126100093126297, -0.5511244535446167, 0.18976396322250366, 0.1319502741098404, 0.23389802873134613, 0.35073554515838623, -0.2923923432826996, -0.21709206700325012, -0.2256828099489212, -0.3076249063014984, -0.7014968991279602, -0.7292609214782715, -0.2416398674249649, 0.09361691772937775, 0.12644080817699432, 0.8361141085624695, 0.20872139930725098, 0.2979055345058441, -0.15879465639591217, -0.09000639617443085, -1.040482521057129, -0.05856986716389656, -0.0300225131213665, -0.05956229940056801, 0.19317367672920227, -0.3104267716407776, -0.18213491141796112, -1.5576488971710205, -0.04016723483800888, -0.18406876921653748, 0.09270558506250381, -0.2888184189796448, 0.24523158371448517, -0.009433398023247719, 1.133898138999939, -0.3156265914440155, -0.4234353303909302, 0.495357483625412, -0.0425688736140728, 0.6078112721443176, 0.26151174306869507, 0.7863278388977051, 0.2353593409061432, 0.5259073376655579, 0.026957547292113304, -0.3911959230899811, 0.04836312308907509, -0.1520056128501892, -0.9270429015159607, -0.7294505834579468, 0.005229072645306587, -0.5791541337966919, -1.0108213424682617, -0.3499112129211426, 0.5934150815010071, 0.39533868432044983, 0.06833088397979736, -0.8286464810371399, -0.12286859005689621, -0.7312065362930298, 0.31963402032852173, -0.79697585105896, -0.13796813786029816, 0.5975475907325745, -0.20811590552330017, 0.6956691741943359, -0.45803314447402954, 4.155466079711914, 0.9846327304840088, 0.43571439385414124, -0.2917134761810303, 0.2753373980522156, 0.6043490171432495, 0.6781937479972839, -0.287202388048172, 0.27721863985061646, 0.174723282456398, 0.06943149119615555, -0.2713811695575714, -0.10985585302114487, 0.5357292294502258, 0.13284075260162354, 0.15915526449680328, -1.037408709526062, -0.5322436690330505, -0.20223110914230347, -1.1268174648284912, -0.2657688856124878, -0.1467074155807495, 0.12797415256500244, 0.1320868730545044, -0.011575027368962765, -0.9708868265151978, 0.31638863682746887, 0.6319156885147095, -0.28503096103668213, -0.21194350719451904, -0.42663753032684326, -0.3695008456707001, 0.8059940934181213, -1.0141218900680542, -0.7408716678619385, -0.1372165083885193, 0.29103145003318787, -0.06788981705904007, 0.06266473978757858, -0.056041087955236435, 0.7199597358703613, 0.1452794224023819, 0.021740898489952087, -0.43050163984298706, -0.048844967037439346, -0.0014629503712058067, -0.06205226108431816, -0.28877097368240356, 0.00011580922728171572, -0.1889743208885193, 0.9163888096809387, -1.0493038892745972, 0.40598633885383606, -0.7476390600204468, -0.8333863615989685, -0.4162326455116272, -0.30487194657325745, -0.945942759513855, -0.02725915051996708, 0.28304341435432434, 0.8016495108604431, 0.7697543501853943, -0.020525623112916946, 0.003986853174865246, -0.26268914341926575, 0.25978103280067444, -0.5029703378677368, -0.19774408638477325, 0.08520127087831497, -0.37281522154808044, -0.2266010344028473, -0.29469040036201477, -0.5627234578132629, -0.48121482133865356, 0.6059617400169373, 0.8314030766487122, -0.3813021779060364, 0.8770959973335266, -0.6005136370658875, -0.6786615252494812, 0.2349344938993454, 0.3632736802101135, 0.09303240478038788, 0.07696263492107391, 0.29226887226104736, 0.8326125144958496, -1.1056584119796753, -0.3954712748527527, -0.9447833895683289, 0.5298725962638855, 0.49245041608810425, -0.5628509521484375, -0.07842980325222015, 0.10389877110719681, 0.2749452590942383 ]
{"Title": "An Assessment of Transparency and Reproducibility-related Research Practices in Otolaryngology", "Authors": "Johnson Austin L., Torgerson Trevor, Skinner Mason, Hamilton Tom, Tritz Daniel, Vassar Matt", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Introduction Clinical research serves as the foundation for evidence-based patient care, and reproducibility of results is consequently critical. We sought to assess the transparency and reproducibility of research studies in otolaryngology by evaluating a random sample of publications in otolaryngology journals between 2014 and 2018. Methods We used the National Library of Medicine catalog to identify otolaryngology journals that met the inclusion criteria (available in the English language and indexed in MEDLINE). From these journals, we extracted a random sample of 300 publications using a PubMed search for records published between January 1, 2014, and December 31, 2018. Specific indicators of reproducible and transparent research practices were evaluated in a blinded, independent, and duplicate manner using a pilot-tested Google form. Results Our initial search returned 26,498 records, from which 300 were randomly selected for analysis. Of these 300 records, 286 met inclusion criteria and 14 did not. Among the empirical studies, 2% (95% CI, 0.4%-3.5%) of publications indicated that raw data were available, 0.6% (95% CI, 0.3%-1.6%) reported an analysis script, 5.3% (95% CI, 2.7%-7.8%) were linked to an accessible research protocol, and 3.9% (95% CI, 1.7%-6.1%) were preregistered. None of the publications had a clear statement claiming to replicate, or to be a replication of, another study. Conclusions Inadequate reproducibility practices exist in otolaryngology. Nearly all studies in our analysis lacked a data or material availability statement, did not link to an accessible protocol, and were not preregistered. Most studies were not available as open access. Taking steps to improve reproducibility would likely also improve patient care.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002238"}
10.1101/19010348
[ -0.15038847923278809, -0.23566174507141113, -0.5838816165924072, 1.0609444379806519, -0.6751596331596375, 0.032258979976177216, 0.005482994951307774, -0.11533991992473602, 0.8806230425834656, 0.5088672041893005, -0.4319700300693512, -0.38270553946495056, 0.7828774452209473, -0.263110488653183, -0.4105205535888672, 0.18430158495903015, -1.1962900161743164, 0.2874174416065216, -0.18846216797828674, 0.02222372405230999, -0.07401075214147568, 0.181468203663826, -1.2528167963027954, 0.1978914588689804, -0.518103301525116, 0.6345068216323853, 0.1499655842781067, -0.010740761645138264, 1.2652021646499634, 0.9858436584472656, -0.24373820424079895, -0.1702827513217926, 0.29033923149108887, -0.8094301223754883, 0.06719706207513809, 0.07255733013153076, 0.625647246837616, -0.4959367513656616, -1.0247762203216553, -0.33552369475364685, -0.21302399039268494, 0.19706030189990997, 0.08261001110076904, -1.2173019647598267, -0.8646851181983948, 0.07758386433124542, 0.47054749727249146, -0.1414194107055664, 0.5230470895767212, -1.0788880586624146, -0.380195677280426, 0.37765973806381226, -0.4210595488548279, -0.264524906873703, 0.1944965273141861, -0.16287557780742645, -0.27472206950187683, -0.12823514640331268, -0.3585604727268219, 0.2487909346818924, -0.07047634571790695, -0.5087127685546875, 1.1281611919403076, -1.26142418384552, 0.6741939783096313, 0.931179404258728, -0.4058268070220947, -0.3162609934806824, -0.30450132489204407, -0.5711020231246948, -0.2033039629459381, 0.12356934696435928, -0.5294311046600342, -1.28125, -0.0616648904979229, 0.18158535659313202, 0.15440800786018372, -0.2982291281223297, 0.5357941389083862, -0.45617029070854187, 0.27176663279533386, 0.5178225636482239, -0.21250398457050323, 0.22890977561473846, -0.45050889253616333, -0.18650268018245697, 0.5785250663757324, -0.37461939454078674, 0.36415401101112366, -0.036969251930713654, 0.33882707357406616, -0.06820513308048248, 0.07476744055747986, 0.4865456819534302, 0.12384787946939468, 0.5852422714233398, -0.6746724247932434, -0.12470981478691101, 0.44858038425445557, 0.5550323724746704, 0.3350522220134735, 1.545163869857788, -0.36733436584472656, 1.3112132549285889, -0.32240167260169983, 0.7909784317016602, 0.5484410524368286, -0.5484343767166138, 0.019429173320531845, -0.8911347985267639, -0.28478389978408813, 0.16728700697422028, -0.15102873742580414, -0.6230544447898865, 0.8616541624069214, -0.009937328286468983, 0.13973106443881989, 1.3752034902572632, 0.01579144038259983, 0.19418597221374512, -0.7053582072257996, -0.12795530259609222, 0.5221174359321594, -0.7518659830093384, -0.0022093283478170633, -0.20214368402957916, 0.3898788392543793, 0.30472826957702637, -0.14654572308063507, -0.5174843668937683, 0.2872565686702728, -0.4554532766342163, -0.0824182778596878, 0.27952703833580017, -0.018162677064538002, 0.12147609889507294, 0.6713494062423706, 0.8463464975357056, 0.7561400532722473, 0.5884917974472046, -0.45207083225250244, -0.11977473646402359, -0.18778234720230103, 1.4731698036193848, 0.11344288289546967, 0.9383828043937683, -0.7437456846237183, -1.0974979400634766, -0.4999776780605316, 0.2824860215187073, 0.2515092194080353, 0.9493576884269714, 0.20278848707675934, 0.00010434165596961975, -0.2638401687145233, 0.4385570287704468, -0.22648508846759796, 0.667097270488739, -0.4846448600292206, 0.4627760350704193, -0.7713054418563843, 0.5034700036048889, -0.03898284211754799, 0.12174145132303238, -0.5437030792236328, 0.5921452045440674, 0.019753513857722282, 0.24904146790504456, 0.34689342975616455, -0.16546757519245148, 0.42275941371917725, 0.9683965444564819, -0.012285677716135979, -0.4081566035747528, 0.15298031270503998, 0.5246561765670776, 0.8953129649162292, 0.4004353880882263, 0.18609626591205597, 0.665109395980835, -0.12972858548164368, -0.1251644641160965, 0.11152574419975281, 0.5216465592384338, -0.12447147816419601, 0.12014322727918625, -0.029970617964863777, -0.34586668014526367, -0.38356879353523254, 0.0020302990451455116, 0.06286390870809555, 0.6541620492935181, -1.060868501663208, 0.654144823551178, -0.4118977189064026, -0.011322077363729477, -0.14253322780132294, 0.058596741408109665, 0.7928734421730042, -0.17413029074668884, -0.3998793065547943, 0.09447357058525085, -0.004730914253741503, -0.17847903072834015, -0.20797044038772583, 0.5963664650917053, 0.3186019957065582, 0.026772892102599144, -0.7071996331214905, 0.6590322256088257, 0.2666989266872406, 0.04514087736606598, -0.7283763289451599, -0.5125821828842163, 0.560822606086731, -0.20260536670684814, 0.3641456961631775, 0.280240923166275, -0.5468167662620544, -0.00875924527645111, -1.020098328590393, 0.32545205950737, 0.436710387468338, -0.3592141270637512, -0.2975771427154541, 0.7621938586235046, 0.5547473430633545, 0.8848047256469727, -0.45896437764167786, -1.002699851989746, 0.15702250599861145, 0.694100022315979, 0.11704840511083603, 0.4933338463306427, 0.823323130607605, 0.7267099618911743, 0.38098767399787903, -0.19289055466651917, 0.6662732362747192, 0.4557077884674072, 0.4384951889514923, 0.07786747068166733, 0.6571415662765503, -0.5797814726829529, 0.2512993812561035, -0.19892776012420654, 0.5027623772621155, -0.3918992578983307, -0.5115979313850403, -0.24652798473834991, -0.9665660858154297, 0.34816956520080566, 0.6968099474906921, 0.23161126673221588, -1.3015283346176147, 0.01988592930138111, 0.4226876199245453, 0.2635289430618286, -0.3054162263870239, -0.21736620366573334, 0.11064350605010986, 0.9546949863433838, -0.018263699486851692, 1.0169073343276978, 0.5934657454490662, 0.10896512866020203, 0.22613310813903809, 0.050305865705013275, 0.05371604114770889, -0.027781883254647255, -0.9573311805725098, -0.3772575855255127, -1.3049328327178955, -1.1137633323669434, -0.7308828830718994, -0.09710253775119781, -0.2072104662656784, -0.11535334587097168, 0.8130668997764587, -0.4194577634334564, 0.5578200221061707, -0.18280057609081268, 0.31422159075737, -0.17021912336349487, -0.05587506294250488, -0.04556339606642723, -1.035017967224121, 0.6052444577217102, 0.22581587731838226, 0.6547291874885559, 0.3091127872467041, -0.4754161834716797, -0.25936105847358704, -1.1640019416809082, -0.24911092221736908, -0.8830502033233643, 0.45674169063568115, 0.2520086169242859, -0.9064010977745056, -0.5665977597236633, 0.22025646269321442, -0.21265165507793427, 0.49133697152137756, -0.4336051344871521, -0.5023061037063599, 0.8818675875663757, 0.27256840467453003, 0.16629330813884735, 0.7625280022621155, 0.4321708083152771, -0.07541055977344513, 0.35278376936912537, 0.11858689785003662, -0.051859501749277115, -0.9826078414916992, 0.004531954415142536, 0.5797606110572815, -0.45304182171821594, -0.36047598719596863, 0.1474713385105133, -1.0680227279663086, -0.3693040907382965, -0.48502957820892334, -0.2124405801296234, -0.8525629043579102, -0.3054201900959015, -1.017106533050537, -1.743821620941162, -0.010343210771679878, -0.670695960521698, -0.5613449215888977, 0.32694876194000244, -0.1295122653245926, -0.037840794771909714, 0.08642466366291046, -0.7466397285461426, 0.05109849572181702, 0.37117037177085876, 0.2598300576210022, 0.4649982154369354, 0.7286149263381958, -0.5325816869735718, -0.32248327136039734, -0.15668591856956482, -0.5045238733291626, 0.4943999946117401, -0.16798889636993408, -0.4502057135105133, 0.23780477046966553, -0.5354514718055725, -0.3354332447052002, 0.052068956196308136, 0.10908734053373337, 0.07322011888027191, -0.07334531098604202, 0.5053277611732483, -0.6639866828918457, -0.1621677577495575, -0.10064589232206345, 0.1262749433517456, 0.5026969909667969, 0.6831777691841125, -0.7779974937438965, 0.11606445908546448, -0.8374250531196594, -0.2288101315498352, -0.21739588677883148, -0.18894217908382416, 0.5203083753585815, -0.28520768880844116, 0.5146485567092896, -0.34457671642303467, -0.26738157868385315, 0.5145661234855652, -0.46347036957740784, -0.7669015526771545, 0.8077594041824341, 0.29599982500076294, 0.6469222903251648, -0.6872351765632629, -0.17402616143226624, 0.4190447926521301, 0.8513432145118713, 0.138889342546463, 0.034733157604932785, 0.5465462803840637, -0.7376340627670288, 1.1158504486083984, 0.6047124862670898, -0.21093933284282684, 0.5013440847396851, 0.5121498107910156, 0.19993160665035248, 0.3274078965187073, -0.15217213332653046, -0.29964879155158997, 0.07092560827732086, 0.018629219383001328, 0.5947785973548889, -0.3543754816055298, 0.6774199604988098, 0.17362697422504425, 0.4165550768375397, 0.6188194155693054, 0.24656209349632263, 0.37020382285118103, -0.7620893716812134, 0.10236777365207672, 0.12012841552495956, -0.291584849357605, -0.11926782876253128, -0.9152666330337524, 0.1317327469587326, -0.03825449198484421, -0.29171955585479736, 0.6637442708015442, -0.4911439120769501, -0.4308925271034241, -0.20290209352970123, 0.535624086856842, 0.14633464813232422, 0.1299002319574356, -2.146207332611084, 0.43402495980262756, -0.11869855970144272, -0.3396889567375183, 0.29927533864974976, -0.4540826678276062, 0.4681794345378876, 0.7009180784225464, -0.8519942760467529, -0.4453580677509308, -0.34250926971435547, -0.20866243541240692, -0.37305888533592224, 0.6361508369445801, 0.2730445861816406, -0.2542133331298828, 0.21209344267845154, -0.6234872937202454, -0.16937848925590515, -0.4090847074985504, -0.03269015625119209, -0.296278715133667, 0.4026470482349396, 0.21054893732070923, 0.8699318766593933, 0.6523498296737671, 0.8099837303161621, 0.5092857480049133, 0.04115933179855347, -0.5930290818214417, 0.9025324583053589, -0.2722929120063782, -0.7546817660331726, 0.030564388260245323, 0.1823570281267166, -0.8601431250572205, -0.34605589509010315, -0.5032004714012146, 0.05104818940162659, -0.00032767350785434246, 0.03709212690591812, -0.014843626879155636, -0.37531039118766785, 1.2676007747650146, -0.48913896083831787, -0.6947345733642578, 1.1078312397003174, -0.014725453220307827, -0.2547891438007355, -0.5878574848175049, -0.5570549368858337, -0.33465898036956787, 0.5854924321174622, -0.19873131811618805, 0.09206165373325348, -0.030395787209272385, -0.2864777743816376, -0.24103252589702606, 0.17264801263809204, 0.5153473615646362, -0.1744052618741989, 0.03995989263057709, -1.0222547054290771, -0.5369579195976257, -0.187740758061409, 0.06977277994155884, -0.11588162928819656, 0.5931923985481262, -0.06405608355998993, -0.6922452449798584, -0.6624174118041992, -0.45207101106643677, -0.2395327240228653, -0.4232420325279236, -0.02664964646100998, -0.46293193101882935, 0.4655919671058655, -0.03327520191669464, 0.516047477722168, -0.5839617252349854, -1.5044670104980469, 0.14511117339134216, 0.911258339881897, -0.32703083753585815, -0.5624836087226868, -0.3813859522342682, 0.5733003616333008, -0.4610138237476349, -0.2362729161977768, 0.01288699358701706, -0.6532524228096008, 0.8162961602210999, -0.3825604319572449, -0.04315297678112984, 0.15118077397346497, 0.10654718428850174, -0.9216578006744385, 0.2641473412513733, 0.22052228450775146, -0.6455127596855164, -0.5331363081932068, 0.0881090760231018, -0.19395890831947327, -0.06447307020425797, 0.21258068084716797, -0.46296966075897217, -0.07664547115564346, -0.8973355293273926, 0.30850619077682495, -0.29344800114631653, -0.022127395495772362, -0.003779415739700198, -0.8344264030456543, 0.10955528169870377, 0.3124377429485321, 0.24937990307807922, 0.4085405468940735, -0.5189183950424194, -0.3233567178249359, -0.08776214718818665, 0.0684409961104393, -0.30095162987709045, 0.04603229835629463, 0.11820516735315323, 0.37901753187179565, 0.7473078966140747, -0.013047123327851295, -0.5629353523254395, -0.08039936423301697, 0.1968439668416977, 0.9566702246665955, 1.260284185409546, -0.3738846182823181, -0.5718423128128052, 0.5955668091773987, -0.40944409370422363, -0.22629384696483612, 0.01626492477953434, -0.6760881543159485, 0.30171993374824524, -0.7147625088691711, -0.3207760751247406, -0.7666038274765015, 0.1030113622546196, -0.15769119560718536, -0.612006664276123, 0.5211495757102966, -0.8084583878517151, 0.1838279366493225, -0.16236428916454315, -0.09472469240427017, -0.2913435101509094, 0.12932762503623962, -1.4854474067687988, -0.6546055674552917, -0.49847611784935, -0.2731342017650604, -0.45928889513015747, 0.20760630071163177, -0.21534845232963562, 0.16228428483009338, -0.7371652722358704, -0.3780474364757538, -1.0757172107696533, 0.8580141663551331, 0.31942176818847656, -0.3267150819301605, -0.2576894164085388, 0.3816909193992615, -0.015634844079613686, 0.5444201231002808, 0.2838861346244812, 0.04437405243515968, -0.4980508089065552, 0.16679741442203522, -0.8529326915740967, -0.6015070080757141, -0.23918704688549042, 0.04754894971847534, 0.08471203595399857, 0.44722333550453186, -0.5220398902893066, 0.07333038747310638, 0.1502363681793213, -0.5411723852157593, 0.2910967469215393, 0.9120416045188904, -0.2000810205936432, 0.41954895853996277, 0.7210505604743958, -0.023390771821141243, -0.6419988870620728, 0.18264567852020264, 0.0679595023393631, 0.34874996542930603, 0.06546294689178467, -0.2859664559364319, 0.1400560587644577, -0.3549148142337799, 1.2037410736083984, 0.5232036113739014, -0.916764497756958, 0.05567063391208649, 0.13720504939556122, -0.6360228657722473, -0.04487086832523346, -0.7010666131973267, -0.6932399272918701, 0.5560212731361389, 0.052615027874708176, 0.09345300495624542, -0.499372661113739, -0.15119284391403198, -0.22393786907196045, -0.46112337708473206, 0.5882065296173096, 0.09771262854337692, 0.011552270501852036, 0.8204113841056824, -0.45321372151374817, 0.12128649652004242, -0.018538743257522583, -0.10163132846355438, 0.14218255877494812, 0.47723227739334106, -0.2168339192867279, -1.071408748626709, -0.28013336658477783, 0.1488429754972458, 0.39975470304489136, 0.44505444169044495, 0.5614676475524902, 0.21749861538410187, 0.7807249426841736, -0.12113253027200699, -0.7558289170265198, -0.4964940845966339, 0.48931384086608887, -0.4686843156814575, 0.007162540219724178, -0.18288803100585938, 0.33203306794166565, 0.9617330431938171, 0.6039381623268127, 0.6010936498641968, -0.8859278559684753, -0.3204456567764282, -1.1439858675003052, -0.07623179256916046, 0.16313205659389496, -0.13380153477191925, -0.2887740135192871, 0.5704934000968933, -0.22258497774600983, -0.06800273805856705, -0.48016440868377686, 0.7757302522659302, -0.06696032732725143, -0.22955943644046783, -0.39092040061950684, 0.4455896019935608, -0.3277222514152527, -0.5258715152740479, -0.27710822224617004, -0.1329255849123001, 0.10393035411834717, 0.758114755153656, -0.9014488458633423, -0.9257554411888123, -0.004043282940983772, 0.0989018902182579, 0.25863581895828247, 0.7005969285964966, -0.5071372985839844, -0.4102472960948944, -0.18747113645076752, 0.5805256962776184, 0.2623538076877594, -0.12253917008638382, 0.6810721755027771, -0.42901358008384705, 0.626849353313446, -0.10777746140956879, -0.14925670623779297, -0.7816630601882935, 0.37949618697166443, 0.18134935200214386, -0.7439893484115601, -0.6279837489128113, -1.0567591190338135, 0.019549202173948288, -0.8252118229866028, 0.16366127133369446, 0.4754910171031952, 0.412587970495224, 0.04370231553912163, 0.22528697550296783, -0.4512355923652649, 0.22463329136371613, -0.21715064346790314, 0.7548539638519287, -0.3506772518157959, 0.4372691810131073, 0.6384493708610535, 0.03297444060444832, 0.14114497601985931, 0.5220837593078613, -0.4747195839881897, -1.1823230981826782, -0.061428140848875046, 0.4888570010662079, 0.16915228962898254, 0.18650978803634644, -0.36824217438697815, -0.22296278178691864, -0.14388056099414825, -0.1377711147069931, 0.3958260416984558, 1.220383882522583, 0.4410492777824402, 1.0279515981674194, 0.788912296295166, 0.13557901978492737, -0.2784918248653412, -0.925622284412384, -0.803420901298523, -0.5901678800582886, 0.6236613392829895, 0.1650976836681366, 0.4142860472202301, -0.0698334202170372, -0.37429365515708923, 0.03533199429512024, 0.07088764756917953, 0.22738833725452423, -0.6320204734802246, 0.8124383687973022, -0.05784403905272484, 0.44444242119789124, 0.051209043711423874, -0.4926520586013794, -0.5144631266593933, 0.44383564591407776, -0.3658748269081116, -0.09354820102453232, 0.07039693742990494, 0.3510340750217438, 0.45302677154541016, -0.21172037720680237, 0.024777550250291824, 0.1098923608660698, 0.5409964919090271, 0.12167024612426758, -0.22749380767345428, -0.12504753470420837, -1.2258858680725098, -0.31522002816200256, 0.31842100620269775, 0.7998713254928589, -0.6687377095222473, -0.03017011098563671, 0.10189161449670792, -0.769916832447052, -0.4163016378879547, 0.640642523765564, 1.099273443222046, -0.687646210193634, -0.010566692799329758, -0.10382581502199173, 0.1996939480304718, 0.4626480042934418, -1.246658205986023, 0.1828732043504715, 0.752432644367218, 0.32208317518234253, -0.24921366572380066, -0.8241884112358093, 0.5169980525970459, 0.8772043585777283, 0.9979475736618042, 0.26252666115760803, 0.20331889390945435, 0.722089946269989, -0.5966207385063171, 0.2604455053806305, -0.6103982925415039, 0.36781811714172363, -0.003243956947699189, -0.26375606656074524, 0.2724594175815582, 0.6045616269111633, 0.07677964121103287, 0.39381176233291626, -0.6852871179580688, -0.1583288013935089, -0.9335926175117493, -1.092272400856018, 0.07130064070224762, 0.2675299644470215, 0.4773428440093994, -0.25550487637519836, 0.5148283243179321, 0.3403117060661316, 0.5475497245788574, 0.3018456995487213, 0.7684698700904846, 0.33400610089302063, -0.05166750028729439, -0.48867878317832947, 0.1406535804271698, -0.24884285032749176, -0.7736831307411194, 0.465283066034317, 0.2799105942249298, 0.12244582176208496, 0.5888358354568481, 0.27809852361679077, 0.13566634058952332, -0.08839092403650284, 0.6715776324272156, 0.06512410938739777, -0.4381474256515503, -0.38060462474823, -0.20580068230628967, -0.7584683895111084, -0.38812538981437683, 0.4287126958370209, -0.07429882884025574, 0.06909924745559692, 0.2534569799900055, 0.3255336582660675, 0.5652199983596802, 0.38270923495292664, -0.2612992823123932, -0.19788388907909393, 1.0071845054626465, 0.640523374080658, 0.1720350831747055, -0.05167300999164581, 0.5476471185684204, -0.24829916656017303, 0.02334677428007126, -0.37521329522132874, 0.49108967185020447, -0.12257321923971176, 0.6736913919448853, -0.5879510045051575, 0.17156727612018585, -0.4823129177093506, 0.40018513798713684, -0.820412278175354, 0.0036230783443897963, 0.02963586524128914, 0.2349366843700409, -0.3711645305156708, 0.22900208830833435, -0.29522424936294556, -0.5699429512023926, -0.8334559202194214, -0.3308863043785095, -0.9682154059410095, 0.5583937764167786, -0.2700251638889313, 0.7287119030952454, 0.3490264415740967, -0.3727121353149414, -0.4496312439441681, -1.0944463014602661, -0.271749347448349, -0.31989625096321106, -0.029220523312687874, 0.006216084584593773, 0.003575637238100171, 0.4419690668582916, 0.9384662508964539, 0.32996073365211487, -0.14003263413906097, 0.025995388627052307, 0.8612411022186279, 0.8564710021018982, 0.18212798237800598, 0.9788824319839478, 0.396308958530426, 0.8533423542976379, -0.38759949803352356, -0.3681691586971283, -0.0007236375822685659, 0.16967694461345673, -0.28907305002212524, -0.7269291877746582, -0.21075546741485596, -0.44434621930122375, -0.7991301417350769, -0.1984591782093048, 0.6537982225418091, 0.30566591024398804, -0.07370464503765106, 0.12238196283578873, -0.23935872316360474, -0.2642541825771332, 1.0572715997695923, -0.6152454614639282, 0.1665867269039154, 0.835852324962616, 0.03383037820458412, 0.7206107378005981, -0.44764429330825806, 4.08412504196167, 0.6547169089317322, 0.299875944852829, -0.2948034107685089, 0.3826533854007721, 0.4987877309322357, 0.6986709833145142, 0.48060208559036255, 0.7742868661880493, -0.5828419923782349, -0.10243996977806091, 0.3828413486480713, -0.5125744342803955, 0.94004887342453, -0.05892423167824745, -0.06383193284273148, -0.7428178787231445, 0.09445220977067947, -0.087847501039505, -1.083825945854187, -0.3645956516265869, 0.08893235772848129, 0.018412770703434944, 0.387561172246933, -0.17270231246948242, -0.5731252431869507, -0.3317543566226959, 0.9940375089645386, -0.1118018850684166, -0.16990973055362701, -0.21923480927944183, -0.2709062695503235, 0.13349270820617676, -0.8944307565689087, -0.43632104992866516, 0.32487714290618896, 0.46073082089424133, -0.11532087624073029, -0.22070381045341492, -0.07507157325744629, 0.44442319869995117, 0.1821945309638977, -0.39423882961273193, -0.658728837966919, -0.4221780002117157, -0.26010453701019287, -0.1526498943567276, -0.14095255732536316, 0.18337148427963257, -0.9015188217163086, 0.9281617999076843, -0.8855173587799072, 0.5734583735466003, 0.0447758287191391, -0.5276271104812622, -0.42311450839042664, -0.4280771315097809, -0.6867392063140869, 0.2724860906600952, 0.5464192628860474, 1.260216474533081, 0.5593339800834656, -0.13230060040950775, -0.22947518527507782, -0.09709475189447403, 0.5572229623794556, 0.06080726161599159, 0.38576561212539673, 0.03566058725118637, -0.1481466442346573, 0.12577499449253082, -0.01641899347305298, -0.7748668789863586, -0.4564018249511719, 0.6456307768821716, 0.20973268151283264, -0.6995701789855957, 1.3720725774765015, -0.3488764762878418, -0.10973448306322098, 0.658811628818512, 0.37680479884147644, 0.9481858015060425, 0.18352369964122772, 0.40955716371536255, 0.8263368010520935, -0.9467558860778809, -0.12209822237491608, -0.3753606975078583, 0.14321382343769073, 0.17522673308849335, -0.060829658061265945, -0.30107206106185913, 0.3770507276058197, 0.1919626146554947 ]
{"Title": "Aggregating Multiple Real-World Data Sources using a Patient-Centered Health Data Sharing Platform: an 8-week Cohort Study among Patients Undergoing Bariatric Surgery or Catheter Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation", "Authors": "Dhruva Sanket S., Ross Joseph S., Akar Joseph G., Caldwell Brittany, Childers Karla, Chow Wing, Ciaccio Laura, Coplan Paul, Dong Jun, Dykhoff Hayley J., Johnston Stephen, Kellogg Todd, Long Cynthia, Noseworthy Peter A., Roberts Kurt, Saha Anindita, Yoo Andrew, Shah Nilay D.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Real-world data sources, including electronic health records (EHR) and personal digital device data, are increasingly available, but are often siloed and cannot be easily integrated for clinical, research, or regulatory purposes. We conducted a prospective cohort study of 60 patients undergoing bariatric surgery or catheter-based atrial fibrillation ablation at two U.S. tertiary care hospitals, testing the feasibility of using a patient-centered health data sharing platform to obtain and aggregate health data from multiple sources. We successfully obtained EHR data for all patients at both hospitals, as well as from 10 additional health systems, which were successfully aggregated with pharmacy data obtained for patients using CVS or Walgreens pharmacies, personal digital device data from activity monitors, digital weight scales, and single-lead ECGs, and patient-reported outcome measure data obtained through surveys to assess post-procedure recovery and disease-specific symptoms. A patient-centered health data sharing platform successfully aggregated data from multiple sources.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010348"}
10.1101/19007997
[ -0.29992079734802246, 0.14798559248447418, -0.6828756332397461, 0.4133453369140625, -1.147453784942627, 0.11024561524391174, 0.00902703870087862, 0.6242870092391968, 0.3265465497970581, 1.0416903495788574, -0.027705900371074677, -0.3361991047859192, 0.6746699213981628, -0.35854753851890564, -0.5994148850440979, 0.45122766494750977, -0.1782178282737732, -0.2008250653743744, -0.07821135222911835, 0.3107333779335022, 0.19940102100372314, 0.7056162357330322, -0.9415116310119629, 0.26987704634666443, -0.7382543683052063, 1.2214436531066895, -0.19770663976669312, -0.20138800144195557, 1.0994410514831543, 0.8672072887420654, -0.4502934217453003, -0.11129645258188248, -0.07466287165880203, 0.5114389061927795, 0.022421102970838547, -0.021198663860559464, 0.73576819896698, 0.25696226954460144, -0.18397091329097748, -1.1690587997436523, -0.172385111451149, 0.3107703626155853, 0.26402372121810913, -0.1726299524307251, -0.3438945412635803, -0.7525904178619385, 0.5449567437171936, -0.05510624125599861, 0.2000018209218979, -0.0655037984251976, 0.3334466218948364, 0.42694950103759766, -0.28574833273887634, -0.20417334139347076, -0.34985703229904175, 0.017466364428400993, 0.5198466777801514, -0.504214346408844, -0.5005188584327698, -0.5530461668968201, 0.11547762900590897, 0.05790896713733673, 0.04702996835112572, -0.6675243973731995, 1.133560061454773, 1.1890493631362915, -0.3942725658416748, -0.28260451555252075, -0.038177452981472015, -0.018042242154479027, 0.11860049515962601, -0.22179262340068817, -0.34015125036239624, -1.0983972549438477, -0.7615953683853149, -0.10826949775218964, 0.17375154793262482, 0.30674630403518677, -0.020181316882371902, -0.3845363259315491, 0.09763910621404648, 0.21627964079380035, 0.300508052110672, -0.6899030804634094, -0.27687811851501465, 0.8378723859786987, -0.04307115450501442, 0.6593980193138123, 0.1437217891216278, 0.07616960257291794, -0.046936407685279846, 0.05030255392193794, -0.19735130667686462, -0.375118225812912, -0.21650122106075287, 0.6864003539085388, -0.5827535390853882, -0.2603081166744232, 0.21439312398433685, 0.1813490390777588, -0.213507279753685, 0.5707937479019165, -0.35889512300491333, 0.80743807554245, -0.7473011016845703, 0.9164617657661438, 0.33560165762901306, -0.1820572018623352, -0.17169851064682007, -0.7508573532104492, -0.12398496270179749, -0.12709984183311462, -0.6212471127510071, -0.3182833790779114, 0.5866681933403015, 0.7719141840934753, -0.04212513566017151, 1.4055705070495605, -0.754728376865387, -0.08310985565185547, -0.16743646562099457, -0.12396394461393356, 0.5945883393287659, -0.5693365335464478, 0.12747326493263245, 0.2643882930278778, 0.16047976911067963, 0.08191888779401779, 0.03574743494391441, -0.6728425621986389, -0.34523874521255493, -0.40679317712783813, 0.1993483006954193, 0.350295752286911, 0.13518725335597992, 0.1184924766421318, 0.08819350600242615, 0.660564124584198, 0.03436524420976639, -0.03966619819402695, -0.2878449559211731, 0.18278437852859497, -0.7234764099121094, 1.1273688077926636, -0.1530950963497162, 0.5527732968330383, -0.115778848528862, -1.124727725982666, -0.3552640378475189, -0.15988728404045105, 0.016589784994721413, 0.46570736169815063, -0.06740868091583252, 0.041483666747808456, -0.014415041543543339, -0.20435884594917297, -0.11795049905776978, 0.2505629360675812, 0.08902440965175629, 0.6279236674308777, -0.6476271152496338, 0.7977825999259949, 0.019362112507224083, 0.43549031019210815, -0.643000602722168, 0.32607075572013855, 0.26736316084861755, -0.4143366515636444, 0.4991510808467865, -0.7195397019386292, 1.0141730308532715, 0.22075946629047394, -0.19464729726314545, 0.12351377308368683, 0.2818787395954132, 0.4556039571762085, 1.0216598510742188, -0.4285130500793457, 0.18595989048480988, 0.37409910559654236, -0.5159807801246643, -0.08884911984205246, -0.17944401502609253, 0.25297874212265015, 0.296953409910202, 0.4133009612560272, -0.27068349719047546, -0.4824593961238861, 0.1910790503025055, -0.5059167742729187, 0.11459193378686905, -0.5306909680366516, -0.12748965620994568, 0.6908462643623352, -0.05316853150725365, 0.597012460231781, -1.1788134574890137, 0.8050985336303711, 0.126013845205307, -0.6435813903808594, 0.3368615508079529, 0.286191463470459, -0.09486052393913269, 0.013396674767136574, 0.22246375679969788, 0.4625743329524994, 0.2675321102142334, 0.3812912702560425, -0.12899932265281677, 0.1434648185968399, -0.02275136485695839, 0.48198503255844116, -1.2773008346557617, -0.24349451065063477, 0.9476186037063599, -0.7279160618782043, -0.4756605327129364, 0.07030635327100754, -0.7350000143051147, 0.3204365670681, -0.31566715240478516, -0.4194205105304718, 1.235298752784729, -0.08678340166807175, -0.2925749719142914, 0.679607629776001, 0.8491531610488892, 0.4166071116924286, -0.10688687860965729, 0.0785013809800148, 0.0616333894431591, 0.5287657976150513, -0.17976997792720795, 0.47019514441490173, 0.6970734596252441, 0.1622391939163208, 0.08775313198566437, -0.06281562149524689, -0.36308759450912476, 0.5031326413154602, 0.009158164262771606, 0.8205148577690125, 0.9713698029518127, 0.41877004504203796, -0.7752074599266052, 1.065944790840149, 0.007390971761196852, -0.1250886768102646, -0.6989248991012573, 0.16403646767139435, -0.30190110206604004, 0.9068149328231812, -0.15126730501651764, 0.334614098072052, -0.14026978611946106, 0.06350036710500717, -0.027283215895295143, 0.6112616658210754, -0.7450721263885498, -0.2837827801704407, -0.17969585955142975, 0.47701331973075867, -0.573378324508667, -0.3305075764656067, 1.0245602130889893, 0.5733378529548645, -0.13115137815475464, 0.2655647397041321, 0.12496389448642731, -0.6831559538841248, -0.25207215547561646, -0.0413045808672905, -0.3941872715950012, -0.534993052482605, -0.964815616607666, -0.8030295968055725, 0.11574407666921616, -0.28899919986724854, 0.5799639821052551, 0.03164727985858917, 0.4257180392742157, -0.4742465317249298, -0.9933590292930603, 0.5630860328674316, -0.23260252177715302, 0.07280387729406357, -0.5474881529808044, 0.5526084899902344, 0.16150084137916565, 0.07195410877466202, -1.004042625427246, -0.21960261464118958, -1.4453386068344116, -0.44916948676109314, 0.5710412263870239, -0.4554738998413086, 0.030680770054459572, 0.6075248122215271, -0.5953150987625122, -0.288252055644989, 0.6531384587287903, 0.18753981590270996, 0.5914940237998962, 0.5077747702598572, -0.8974783420562744, 0.5002248287200928, -0.3378748297691345, 0.5110061764717102, 0.5738391280174255, -0.5784273147583008, -0.05985118821263313, 0.49362537264823914, 0.2795255482196808, -0.39511409401893616, -0.8347663879394531, -0.04758630320429802, -0.16406239569187164, -0.40479835867881775, -0.14973653852939606, 0.279804527759552, -0.7825344800949097, 0.18307074904441833, 0.1772492527961731, -0.22311221063137054, 0.15933112800121307, 0.09146718680858612, 0.2027748078107834, -1.652122974395752, 0.6267247796058655, -0.8334576487541199, -0.4970005750656128, 0.362713485956192, -0.2986272871494293, 0.5690078139305115, 0.7474972605705261, 0.39877569675445557, -0.9958760738372803, -0.1488657295703888, -0.14655014872550964, 0.2942643165588379, 0.5814157128334045, -0.2541794776916504, -0.7774251699447632, -0.13016974925994873, -0.6437868475914001, 0.4929371178150177, 0.12845036387443542, -0.48177069425582886, 0.162331685423851, -0.496615469455719, -0.47907885909080505, 0.4133278727531433, 0.19091875851154327, 0.329826295375824, 0.31615009903907776, 0.3195359408855438, -0.17062543332576752, 0.24213767051696777, 0.49027571082115173, 0.2727777659893036, 0.048151109367609024, -0.06143543869256973, 0.06586407870054245, 0.025524266064167023, -0.7985737323760986, -0.7110711932182312, 0.2710983157157898, -0.01690744236111641, 0.8621506690979004, -0.3035096824169159, 0.4531997740268707, -0.5043883919715881, -0.0149686885997653, -0.4490344524383545, -0.18095561861991882, -0.20254254341125488, 0.6215243339538574, -0.07061748206615448, 1.7116053104400635, 0.10567256063222885, 0.2637149393558502, 0.45285993814468384, 0.08444605022668839, -0.11813502758741379, -0.9433284997940063, -0.03035164624452591, -0.6863958835601807, 0.47899770736694336, 0.0019382159225642681, -0.7521392703056335, 0.09959538280963898, -0.5789312720298767, 0.5570260882377625, 0.42850157618522644, -0.05031280964612961, -0.5996351838111877, -0.4095197319984436, 1.035102128982544, -0.14973227679729462, 0.8569098114967346, 0.8548135757446289, -0.8821097016334534, -0.15265098214149475, -0.1682814061641693, 0.951312243938446, 0.5083279013633728, -0.6124093532562256, 0.38165566325187683, -0.22813233733177185, -0.633567214012146, 0.579594075679779, -0.3926129937171936, 0.38989877700805664, -0.304399311542511, 0.22610267996788025, -0.24944725632667542, -0.6103147268295288, 0.1432751715183258, -0.4326520562171936, 0.2726409137248993, -0.3509540259838104, -0.43608319759368896, -0.3875053822994232, 0.06894285976886749, -1.012540578842163, -0.30627575516700745, 0.11601226031780243, -0.7289004921913147, 0.9056901335716248, 0.8038771152496338, -0.6670154333114624, -0.2663470208644867, -0.2799466848373413, -0.5504578351974487, 0.2895219326019287, 0.27356597781181335, 0.47072333097457886, 0.10235827416181564, -0.08876899629831314, 0.3221823275089264, 0.14669832587242126, 0.047237545251846313, -0.42942479252815247, -0.267286479473114, -0.2825223207473755, 0.5489126443862915, 0.6876793503761292, 0.21388250589370728, 0.3928205370903015, -0.062130406498909, 0.5587561130523682, -0.6212543249130249, 1.6605892181396484, 0.052037276327610016, -0.5693559646606445, -0.6314462423324585, 0.0013093373272567987, 0.25457820296287537, -0.7149866819381714, -0.4502449631690979, -0.7313753962516785, 0.12013842165470123, 0.22721682488918304, -0.20858505368232727, -0.4161634147167206, 0.639178991317749, -0.695196270942688, 0.032149411737918854, 1.150866150856018, 0.2117672860622406, 0.4037080407142639, 0.21099638938903809, 0.6506904363632202, -0.8650406002998352, 0.23711253702640533, 0.3683088719844818, -0.4046412408351898, 0.7736608982086182, -0.6719761490821838, -0.0038832477293908596, -0.05872177332639694, -0.11227463185787201, -0.8483701944351196, -0.01067306101322174, -0.33476683497428894, -0.6432613730430603, -0.6241123080253601, -0.20369559526443481, -0.13450650870800018, 0.4863065779209137, -0.6872701048851013, -0.6013920307159424, -0.6146843433380127, 0.34055545926094055, -0.95530104637146, -0.8492850065231323, -0.4672871530056, 0.0242798812687397, 0.14147420227527618, 0.41655638813972473, 0.2039949595928192, 0.12117234617471695, -0.7953487038612366, 0.609535276889801, 0.4496290385723114, -1.1072018146514893, -0.38490691781044006, -0.5828138589859009, 0.3690774440765381, -0.5170447826385498, -0.588616669178009, -0.14133603870868683, -0.1881452053785324, -0.15590079128742218, 0.07052042335271835, -0.30906644463539124, 0.6250097751617432, 0.27672079205513, 0.11872904002666473, 0.5861931443214417, 0.022055020555853844, -0.6730979681015015, -1.055589199066162, 0.46466192603111267, -0.37598758935928345, -0.046249158680438995, -0.02542210929095745, -0.42750728130340576, -0.4973186254501343, -0.8662199378013611, 0.03842291980981827, 0.18594291806221008, -0.5525458455085754, 0.047938019037246704, -0.1467570811510086, -0.1368773728609085, -0.31714677810668945, -0.25001204013824463, 0.27529922127723694, -0.3346215486526489, -0.9714733958244324, 0.22848784923553467, -0.5482838153839111, 0.1180824264883995, 0.030169328674674034, -0.8231330513954163, 0.39500245451927185, 0.735785186290741, 0.12971550226211548, 0.12455809861421585, 0.405913770198822, 0.09137707948684692, 0.35563376545906067, -0.2664005160331726, -0.1356543004512787, -0.9886667728424072, 0.006088960915803909, 0.7857577204704285, -0.10213116556406021, -0.800586998462677, -0.5968341827392578, 0.9826685786247253, -0.7385480403900146, 0.11671753227710724, 0.14864960312843323, 0.032566603273153305, 0.7520928978919983, -1.791860818862915, 0.5895003080368042, -0.4716298580169678, 0.25658583641052246, 0.8967288136482239, -0.20522890985012054, 0.16691182553768158, 0.16624592244625092, -0.35047709941864014, -0.043256375938653946, -0.21407827734947205, -0.415740966796875, 0.2938735783100128, -0.5144851207733154, -0.2025092989206314, -0.060358546674251556, -0.6775530576705933, -0.06605399399995804, -0.1065274327993393, 0.9503362774848938, 0.8162960410118103, -0.1488538533449173, -0.5817696452140808, -0.22483588755130768, -0.0708792582154274, 0.7316506505012512, 0.5758885145187378, 0.7405670881271362, -0.07100491225719452, 0.19135290384292603, -0.5823050141334534, -0.34236249327659607, -0.3330296277999878, -0.1423100084066391, 0.05568055808544159, 0.2764487862586975, 0.08991029858589172, 0.12349097430706024, 0.31619009375572205, -0.29728683829307556, -0.28678151965141296, 1.2700445652008057, -0.04133905470371246, 0.5876011848449707, 0.7220442295074463, -0.7487688660621643, -0.7601288557052612, 0.6836089491844177, -0.3959009349346161, -0.32440921664237976, -0.1272127330303192, 0.1653541624546051, -0.1697406768798828, -0.8938053846359253, 0.5135940313339233, 0.26745927333831787, -0.1937296837568283, -0.3998126983642578, 0.5034849047660828, 0.07356856018304825, 0.6309905052185059, -0.08813773095607758, -0.9046943187713623, 0.8437759876251221, 0.5221053957939148, 0.6640253663063049, -0.26071667671203613, 0.11389129608869553, 0.4851752817630768, -0.6413180232048035, -0.1042071059346199, -0.36473774909973145, -0.46335890889167786, 0.7863357067108154, 0.2422083169221878, -0.07385975122451782, 0.6546188592910767, 0.4216325581073761, -0.014585536904633045, 0.3520365357398987, -0.20446255803108215, -0.506991982460022, -0.2898305654525757, 0.35583609342575073, 0.18574465811252594, 0.8908345103263855, -0.4015454947948456, -0.8495638370513916, 0.7954171299934387, -0.29087910056114197, -0.8516229391098022, -0.1529293805360794, 0.20918278396129608, -0.0051855663768947124, 0.0755375400185585, 0.048126570880413055, -0.3440346121788025, 0.9322818517684937, 0.07704225927591324, 0.13793326914310455, -0.17499572038650513, -0.2565399706363678, -0.645216166973114, 0.5155119895935059, 0.35224103927612305, 0.4376159608364105, -0.3391581177711487, 0.5442211031913757, 0.21685609221458435, 0.08351622521877289, 0.3050786852836609, 0.31302985548973083, -0.39203256368637085, -0.09018728137016296, -0.32375937700271606, 0.09115834534168243, -0.635250449180603, -0.5941553115844727, 0.0006618660409003496, -0.5347318649291992, -0.14906027913093567, 0.4797252118587494, -0.7131516337394714, -0.6060085296630859, -0.43892180919647217, 0.43924441933631897, 0.21751637756824493, 0.17393988370895386, -0.37838098406791687, -0.20492801070213318, 0.23588842153549194, 0.5477355122566223, 0.37347790598869324, -0.20012521743774414, 0.5962088704109192, -0.7956857085227966, 0.20030057430267334, 0.2861301898956299, 0.475847452878952, 0.06030827760696411, -0.1296660602092743, 0.6891753077507019, -0.2522203326225281, -0.6791463494300842, 0.2464391440153122, 0.195880725979805, -0.6216117143630981, 0.5284308195114136, -0.7624894380569458, 0.4370678663253784, -0.09786634892225266, 0.6781216859817505, -0.15600939095020294, 0.47428378462791443, 0.664661169052124, 0.44300293922424316, -0.10719797760248184, 0.4830576479434967, 0.44939225912094116, 0.002431696280837059, 0.6526134610176086, 0.7163650393486023, 0.06691746413707733, -0.27840688824653625, 0.306233674287796, 1.2701153755187988, -0.05419259890913963, 0.6063428521156311, 0.14275187253952026, 0.674826443195343, 0.02942112274467945, -0.42189615964889526, -0.2614031136035919, 1.0444819927215576, 0.3326898217201233, 0.5608868598937988, -0.3341887295246124, 0.12094352394342422, -0.7235832810401917, -0.3061109483242035, -0.35330930352211, -0.8880816102027893, 0.027384452521800995, -0.3273645341396332, -0.7040526866912842, -1.0071535110473633, -0.9112073183059692, 0.07754537463188171, -0.1341247707605362, 0.885377049446106, -0.29709210991859436, 0.2335509955883026, 0.10399915277957916, 1.361342191696167, -0.020054947584867477, 0.3883380889892578, -0.3035421669483185, -0.11649593710899353, -0.1989704966545105, -0.16986139118671417, 0.85733562707901, 0.2994506359100342, -0.19265906512737274, -0.6587940454483032, -0.32017016410827637, 0.651246964931488, 0.23040258884429932, -0.4157782196998596, -0.43588632345199585, 0.21046939492225647, -1.0536623001098633, -0.22280360758304596, -0.5321499705314636, 0.2612731158733368, -0.6763843297958374, 0.8292086720466614, -0.5634824633598328, -0.3529808521270752, -1.3420227766036987, 0.4168951213359833, 0.9930857419967651, -0.028950879350304604, 0.22570739686489105, 0.5991304516792297, 0.2876988649368286, -0.6557384133338928, -0.6967096924781799, 0.5901623368263245, 0.39055395126342773, -0.3480320870876312, -0.4489935040473938, -0.24567453563213348, 0.5772878527641296, 0.6552447080612183, -0.44256076216697693, -0.22741243243217468, 0.49320194125175476, -0.0745621919631958, 0.5447967648506165, -0.23545397818088531, -0.5757741928100586, 0.33969926834106445, -0.3055513799190521, -0.639615535736084, -0.17677411437034607, 0.33996838331222534, 0.3581717908382416, 0.2183637171983719, -1.1540520191192627, -0.2381192445755005, -0.8700155019760132, -0.3816159665584564, -0.41065385937690735, -0.3062902092933655, 1.3189146518707275, 0.3646043539047241, 0.48879098892211914, 0.22948779165744781, 0.5764862895011902, -0.15054896473884583, 0.2641386091709137, 0.4275321364402771, -0.5910637378692627, -0.1251218020915985, -0.43700262904167175, 0.2692573070526123, 0.03843367099761963, 0.44049856066703796, 0.14973725378513336, 0.21926581859588623, 0.5037450790405273, 0.4602791965007782, 0.004725311417132616, 0.24147829413414001, 0.5895752310752869, -0.32988062500953674, -0.3651368021965027, 0.17933781445026398, -0.11534925550222397, -0.48971113562583923, -0.31702613830566406, 0.4730268716812134, -0.03741246834397316, 0.06284265220165253, -0.37800830602645874, 1.3402292728424072, -0.183951273560524, 0.1890285611152649, 0.08509676158428192, -0.6909375786781311, 0.6798608899116516, 0.5021228790283203, -0.2690182626247406, -0.2427344173192978, 0.068156898021698, -0.5433850884437561, -0.4948596656322479, -0.25137221813201904, 0.09353940188884735, -0.28401294350624084, 0.20866604149341583, 0.12928465008735657, 0.5067958235740662, -0.20456700026988983, -0.5027745962142944, -0.9322677254676819, -0.443830281496048, 0.16953878104686737, 0.37373241782188416, 0.0893518477678299, -0.018326329067349434, 0.4397248923778534, -0.30786386132240295, -0.08260593563318253, -0.07029561698436737, -1.3260613679885864, 0.38170066475868225, -0.8092852234840393, -0.2645244598388672, -0.8987219333648682, -0.2030191272497177, -0.8409470319747925, -0.4906708896160126, -0.3157050609588623, 0.268357515335083, 0.18264953792095184, -0.35072916746139526, 0.2244541049003601, 0.3392984867095947, -0.12207433581352234, 0.19540609419345856, -0.7649120688438416, -0.11057022213935852, -0.4166869521141052, 0.709308385848999, 0.6620476841926575, 0.07886633276939392, -0.18425635993480682, 0.14860455691814423, -0.014700159430503845, -0.530418872833252, -0.10606277734041214, -0.04006478935480118, -0.4582658112049103, -0.23298045992851257, 0.337965726852417, -0.10742856562137604, -0.12869201600551605, 0.16512537002563477, 0.3983634412288666, -0.38575753569602966, -0.20851707458496094, -0.7588298916816711, -0.0029013424646109343, -0.9888306856155396, 0.5902124643325806, -0.4330003559589386, -0.25916871428489685, 0.09056813269853592, -0.3434350788593292, 0.3644903004169464, -0.5567240715026855, 4.241115093231201, 1.2597225904464722, 1.0479971170425415, -0.7688230276107788, 0.3682965934276581, 0.5045425891876221, 0.30462712049484253, 0.34174615144729614, 0.2418213188648224, -0.47811421751976013, 0.33368998765945435, 0.17448244988918304, 0.08966580033302307, 0.964667558670044, 0.5874524712562561, 0.05785512551665306, -0.4070044159889221, -0.13625456392765045, 0.31216758489608765, -0.7282787561416626, -0.4708472788333893, -0.165558859705925, -0.11701474338769913, 0.2805598974227905, 0.023545578122138977, 0.1876809298992157, 0.16411451995372772, 0.04713642597198486, 0.021616246551275253, -0.21846072375774384, -0.13691067695617676, -0.23689515888690948, 0.2825075089931488, -0.6119946837425232, -0.3003394901752472, 0.13013076782226562, -0.2847430408000946, -0.6689701080322266, -0.27843496203422546, 0.014339721761643887, 0.22197631001472473, 0.7789274454116821, -0.08136863261461258, -0.9833471775054932, 0.7640162706375122, 0.24442058801651, -0.27797287702560425, 0.1481766700744629, 0.8527354598045349, -0.39219364523887634, 0.524280846118927, -0.6014204621315002, 0.42626282572746277, -0.4475212097167969, -0.8615180850028992, 0.11236497759819031, -0.4333140254020691, -0.5406497716903687, -0.034513380378484726, 1.0154054164886475, 0.3538201153278351, -0.20520636439323425, -0.4148736298084259, 0.004710473585873842, 0.6463380455970764, 0.9568396210670471, 0.1725456714630127, 0.17325808107852936, -0.6097385883331299, -0.17601345479488373, -0.0035824875812977552, -0.3066423535346985, 0.08873818814754486, 0.09494751691818237, 1.1295472383499146, 0.13534581661224365, -0.70009446144104, 0.2934524416923523, -0.09299954771995544, 0.0788174495100975, 0.4167638421058655, 0.37602272629737854, 0.31668728590011597, -0.04942796751856804, -0.0018959520384669304, 0.9145219922065735, -0.821295976638794, -0.651870608329773, -0.7409720420837402, 0.6715542078018188, -0.197870135307312, -0.6544544100761414, 0.13781724870204926, 0.04901526868343353, -0.3361853063106537 ]
{"Title": "Safety of Flexible Sigmoidoscopy in Pregnant Patients with known or suspected Inflammatory Bowel Disease", "Authors": "Ko Myung S., Rudrapatna Vivek A., Avila Patrick, Mahadevan Uma", "Abstract": "Abstract I. Background and Aims Lower gastrointestinal endoscopy is the gold standard for the diagnosis and staging of Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD). However, there is limited safety data in pregnant populations, resulting in conservative society guidelines and practice patterns favoring diagnostic delay. The aim of this study is to investigate if the performance of flexible sigmoidoscopy is associated with adverse events in pregnant patients with known or suspected IBD. II. Methods A retrospective cohort study was conducted at the University of California San Francisco (UCSF) between April 2008 and April 2019. Female patients aged between 18 and 48 years who were pregnant at the time of endoscopy were identified. All patient records were reviewed to determine disease, pregnancy course, and lifestyle factors. Two independent reviewers performed the data abstraction. Adverse events were assessed for temporal relation (defined as within 4 weeks) with endoscopy. Any discrepancies in the two reviewers\u2019 data were reviewed by a third independent investigator. Descriptive statistics of data were calculated, and comparison of continuous and categorical data were made using a one-sided Wilcoxon rank-sum test and Fisher\u2019s exact test, respectively. III. Results We report the outcomes of 48 pregnant patients across all trimesters who underwent lower endoscopy for suspected or established IBD. There were no hospitalizations or adverse obstetric events temporally associated with sigmoidoscopy. 78% of patients experienced a change in treatment following sigmoidoscopy. 12% of the patients with known IBD were found to have no endoscopic evidence of disease activity despite symptoms. IV. Conclusions Lower endoscopy in the pregnant patient with known or suspected IBD is low risk and affects therapeutic decision making. It should not be delayed in patients with appropriate indications.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007997"}
10.1101/19013540
[ -0.5883876085281372, 0.08042515069246292, -0.17161986231803894, 0.49190250039100647, -0.12598872184753418, -0.19229568541049957, -0.1342710554599762, 0.3546351492404938, 0.18144626915454865, 1.059694766998291, -0.00047295534750446677, -0.2893739938735962, 0.3889102041721344, -0.2717723846435547, 0.0697777196764946, -0.3935370147228241, 0.2908226251602173, -0.07271664589643478, 0.050362031906843185, -0.48886990547180176, 0.3323146104812622, 0.318634957075119, -0.6552889347076416, 0.22148993611335754, -1.0690993070602417, 0.5361080765724182, -0.2462901622056961, -0.4917967915534973, 0.9429313540458679, 0.7193616032600403, -0.43713223934173584, -0.23637141287326813, 0.8098143339157104, -1.465170979499817, -0.22024279832839966, -0.4995296001434326, 0.38023748993873596, -0.21470129489898682, -0.33479079604148865, -0.19147616624832153, 0.6293948292732239, 0.15646976232528687, 0.4656244218349457, 0.5302729606628418, -0.18049506843090057, -0.8078115582466125, -0.7929216027259827, -0.31999775767326355, -0.8237826228141785, 0.300988107919693, -0.11476067453622818, -0.03468862175941467, 0.5250160098075867, -0.6275246143341064, -0.1877310574054718, 0.1924978345632553, 0.027747128158807755, 0.3818633556365967, -0.3180173635482788, 0.2002105563879013, -0.2619591951370239, -0.23459911346435547, 0.16146019101142883, -1.2739291191101074, 1.215012550354004, 0.6903708577156067, -0.07345565408468246, -0.5995771884918213, -0.2071676403284073, -0.09426256269216537, -0.4228234887123108, -0.4190708100795746, -0.512702465057373, -0.920141875743866, -0.31283438205718994, -0.2659841477870941, 0.46558648347854614, -0.4865542948246002, 0.09804455190896988, -0.06419423967599869, 0.17613105475902557, 0.06281353533267975, 0.03625425696372986, 0.5856355428695679, 0.029070354998111725, 0.3058738708496094, 0.2397550493478775, 0.9442224502563477, -0.12951409816741943, 0.7334305644035339, 0.43926385045051575, 0.343622624874115, -0.0380721390247345, -0.2695130705833435, -0.6711931228637695, 1.1216341257095337, -0.9807127118110657, 0.10471975803375244, 0.17838969826698303, -0.5938834547996521, 0.23513880372047424, -0.30449458956718445, -0.6702877879142761, 0.47355788946151733, -0.026164500042796135, 0.6450563073158264, 0.6930996179580688, -0.23881115019321442, -0.08429533988237381, -0.9914191961288452, 0.1392158716917038, 0.12210068851709366, -0.6491371393203735, 0.3217264711856842, 0.8816661238670349, 0.631832480430603, 0.06277849525213242, 0.7388865947723389, -0.6484163403511047, -0.3788744807243347, 0.4676048755645752, -0.07462779432535172, 0.5794980525970459, -0.06845224648714066, 0.3891519606113434, 0.19247408211231232, 0.24536584317684174, 1.0782109498977661, -0.4212872087955475, -0.42457231879234314, 0.05446872115135193, -1.0628118515014648, 0.21118482947349548, 0.28617942333221436, -0.3887576162815094, -0.001873089699074626, -0.2552420198917389, 0.6017018556594849, 0.40737125277519226, -0.7796539068222046, -0.3099807798862457, 0.41668760776519775, -0.19697575271129608, 1.2114375829696655, 0.2861971855163574, 0.6621577739715576, -0.660481333732605, -0.9950616359710693, -0.6240382790565491, -0.20791347324848175, -0.09631187468767166, 0.21895775198936462, -0.7995697259902954, -0.5354325771331787, -0.2851223647594452, 0.2646096646785736, 0.07507601380348206, -0.019233999773859978, 0.035810936242341995, 0.059708308428525925, -1.2559127807617188, 0.16970214247703552, 0.13697874546051025, 1.0606342554092407, -0.1528812199831009, 0.5454224348068237, -0.3064650893211365, 0.14271341264247894, 0.2901224195957184, -0.7783479690551758, 0.17131541669368744, -0.5696647763252258, -0.6663841009140015, 0.2565908432006836, -0.006630411371588707, 0.13724029064178467, 0.8143283724784851, -0.02641306445002556, -0.5263589024543762, 0.44398441910743713, -0.18262916803359985, 0.13378043472766876, -0.13961893320083618, 1.0215790271759033, -0.04993057623505592, -0.2695787250995636, -0.4653629660606384, -0.0770987942814827, 0.0990808829665184, -0.70607990026474, -0.3978332579135895, 0.41534316539764404, 0.001800890197046101, 0.26746267080307007, -0.05196854844689369, 0.5904410481452942, -1.1689298152923584, 0.24845436215400696, 0.41864633560180664, 0.45598793029785156, -0.37097397446632385, -0.054586607962846756, -0.9856651425361633, 0.2363756150007248, -0.042897868901491165, 0.5398613214492798, -0.03168029338121414, 0.22151833772659302, 0.18585023283958435, 0.3774273693561554, 0.40699970722198486, 0.23250171542167664, -0.5529630184173584, -0.7670937180519104, 0.24083277583122253, -0.5179920792579651, -0.4642268121242523, 0.4149560034275055, -0.46405673027038574, 0.7397938370704651, -0.4626706838607788, -0.8150470852851868, 1.169636845588684, 0.40613487362861633, -0.22429272532463074, 0.5121135115623474, 0.5864704251289368, 0.7047908306121826, -0.3018767535686493, 0.18009644746780396, 0.26879796385765076, 0.7600125074386597, -0.5877821445465088, 0.6484683752059937, 0.39861825108528137, 0.12269420176744461, 0.7669743895530701, 0.7582054138183594, 0.5324183106422424, 0.661414384841919, 0.9685269594192505, 1.1113933324813843, 0.35414496064186096, 0.30800893902778625, 0.048355311155319214, 0.19846399128437042, -0.5201323628425598, 0.39389702677726746, -0.5455403923988342, 0.5279421806335449, -0.7722623348236084, 0.8279905319213867, 0.7732225656509399, 0.43825632333755493, -1.2356916666030884, -0.2108476758003235, 0.1019604355096817, 0.262421578168869, -0.453416109085083, -0.47686314582824707, -0.031645845621824265, 0.6623142957687378, 0.03939187154173851, -0.3738846778869629, 0.33299049735069275, 0.5997923612594604, -0.17275434732437134, -0.0058999331668019295, -0.03924153000116348, 0.13271024823188782, -0.6069927215576172, -0.5087307691574097, -0.562481701374054, -0.6735342144966125, -0.5607272982597351, 0.052260398864746094, 0.24136514961719513, -0.20945261418819427, 0.6065784692764282, 0.38703855872154236, 0.2800813317298889, -0.2813541293144226, -0.2984391450881958, 0.23673826456069946, 0.256994366645813, 0.12154041230678558, -0.9720333218574524, -0.46268823742866516, -0.4569581151008606, 0.20212477445602417, -0.4274020493030548, -0.38779976963996887, -0.4251994788646698, -0.6673973798751831, 0.31168875098228455, -0.3062977194786072, -0.11726804822683334, -0.18942216038703918, 0.11768843978643417, 0.421578586101532, 0.12860305607318878, 0.3304295539855957, -0.028638597577810287, -0.4410042464733124, -0.6499083042144775, 0.7499813437461853, 0.10167792439460754, 0.13802745938301086, 0.6925905346870422, 0.5488032698631287, -0.06725601106882095, 0.5804902911186218, 0.03569754958152771, -0.035027503967285156, -0.813026487827301, 0.6370558738708496, 0.655013918876648, -0.08688108623027802, 0.5454088449478149, -1.24177086353302, -0.7381229400634766, -0.14010381698608398, 0.44235002994537354, -0.42292359471321106, 0.4390137195587158, 0.12493868917226791, 0.3145960867404938, -0.9302741289138794, 0.5397160053253174, 0.2627725601196289, -0.9209875464439392, 0.45552000403404236, 0.1885051429271698, 0.47291621565818787, 0.531092643737793, 0.1110914945602417, -0.07379703968763351, 0.6380975246429443, 0.3119357228279114, 0.7189972400665283, -0.1724235862493515, 0.30627211928367615, -0.18562577664852142, 0.3152587115764618, -0.29254552721977234, -0.3412524163722992, 0.09076693654060364, 0.22224032878875732, -0.4691089689731598, -0.058968354016542435, -0.27834585309028625, 0.2148435264825821, 0.1606803685426712, 0.19282668828964233, -0.06736298650503159, 0.5005936026573181, 0.33708900213241577, 0.04617023095488548, 0.3205191493034363, 0.6866987943649292, -0.49290579557418823, 0.3773009181022644, -0.12110625952482224, 0.9246167540550232, -0.5683355927467346, -0.763255774974823, 0.7287581562995911, 0.12041344493627548, 0.6002988219261169, -0.9140996336936951, 0.5479598045349121, -0.15521731972694397, -0.28429684042930603, -0.11850841343402863, -0.3732203543186188, -0.24069328606128693, 0.8081218600273132, 0.13968192040920258, 0.6222133636474609, -0.8275303840637207, 0.3241579234600067, 0.33918920159339905, 1.1816341876983643, 1.036216378211975, -0.10534610599279404, 1.0404973030090332, -0.7254908680915833, 0.3923018276691437, -0.2936621308326721, -0.32389143109321594, -0.035849831998348236, -0.393911212682724, 0.04821178689599037, 0.14265312254428864, -0.1257021278142929, -0.3224106729030609, -0.2333535999059677, 0.8233212828636169, -0.36388280987739563, 0.41354483366012573, 0.35693827271461487, -0.3425089716911316, -0.1511281430721283, -0.2566642165184021, -0.20828238129615784, 0.12429187446832657, -0.6831839680671692, 0.3055030405521393, -0.3612813651561737, 0.5475278496742249, -0.4020276665687561, 0.13892164826393127, 0.14088357985019684, -0.1066860780119896, -0.3053692579269409, -0.3747086822986603, -0.6050101518630981, -0.4437282383441925, -0.41042056679725647, 0.0883578434586525, -0.14059726893901825, -0.2678702771663666, -0.06915858387947083, 0.13885663449764252, -0.38942399621009827, -0.6018808484077454, 0.013093735091388226, -0.618628740310669, 0.1905878633260727, 0.6746382117271423, -1.219322919845581, -0.7278696298599243, -1.492887020111084, 0.040692903101444244, -0.9052068591117859, 0.2926904857158661, 0.24374549090862274, -0.6347514390945435, 0.576420783996582, 0.1607682853937149, -0.5056715607643127, -0.5530374646186829, 0.12339958548545837, -0.38019901514053345, -0.14758285880088806, 0.33952102065086365, 1.3443678617477417, 0.007945623248815536, 0.4816504120826721, -0.3445621728897095, 0.3215723931789398, -0.5787134170532227, 0.6004311442375183, -0.6069967746734619, 0.17776431143283844, 0.2111397087574005, -0.8617085814476013, -0.10823890566825867, 0.3818892538547516, 0.2320874184370041, -0.2506413459777832, -0.036256495863199234, 0.27591174840927124, -0.167165607213974, -0.20401141047477722, 1.223727822303772, -0.5181958675384521, 0.7671442031860352, 0.9398722648620605, 0.1262083351612091, 0.4222031533718109, 0.3849612772464752, 0.50835782289505, -0.7651418447494507, 0.7123904824256897, 0.06524722278118134, -0.1696193367242813, 0.5756731033325195, -0.5068472027778625, -0.07293872535228729, -0.14758044481277466, 0.49828067421913147, -0.6998772621154785, -0.2308509796857834, -0.27354490756988525, -0.17767345905303955, -0.2319820523262024, -0.09880703687667847, -0.2484603077173233, -0.1528151035308838, 0.46408018469810486, -0.2922697067260742, 0.5832532048225403, 0.2523319721221924, -0.41559547185897827, -1.097044825553894, -0.4854709208011627, -0.37787675857543945, -0.5191057324409485, -0.20284581184387207, 0.6765922904014587, -1.1248383522033691, -0.46678510308265686, 0.5506471395492554, 0.29421818256378174, -0.601486086845398, -0.589740514755249, -0.6068935990333557, -0.18147829174995422, -0.7612050771713257, -0.04609842225909233, -0.2283390611410141, -0.7314987778663635, -1.165054440498352, 0.20364025235176086, 0.3144204318523407, 0.43163827061653137, 0.3531053960323334, -0.12689493596553802, 1.231917381286621, 0.37715214490890503, -0.2611798942089081, 0.04101736471056938, 0.7918955683708191, -0.3036094903945923, -0.1145944744348526, -0.219338521361351, -0.9967479109764099, -0.09765414148569107, -0.2179149091243744, 0.253437340259552, -0.6504871249198914, -0.3372146487236023, -0.011554274708032608, -0.024127883836627007, -0.06841273605823517, 0.4967002272605896, 1.101923942565918, 0.1752978265285492, 0.47390973567962646, -0.6621202230453491, 0.15724830329418182, -0.7161831855773926, 0.05415245518088341, -0.25147801637649536, -0.4626874625682831, -0.15003643929958344, 0.8215369582176208, -0.059451814740896225, -0.3234039545059204, 0.0051984949968755245, 0.16373862326145172, 0.4487282335758209, 0.5809722542762756, 0.26341378688812256, -0.9173508882522583, -0.17973290383815765, 0.7586627006530762, 0.3087614178657532, -0.18536412715911865, -1.0602116584777832, 0.2796102464199066, -0.017859624698758125, 0.19284161925315857, 0.5579323172569275, 0.12411960959434509, 0.06125809624791145, -0.903042197227478, 1.103058934211731, -0.3342295289039612, 0.15857353806495667, 0.2849362790584564, -0.298967182636261, -0.407965749502182, 0.5788442492485046, -0.8741412162780762, 0.045108452439308167, -0.6015163064002991, -0.8855434060096741, 0.8404297232627869, -0.14556951820850372, -0.15445293486118317, 0.39657673239707947, -0.27320602536201477, 0.30711597204208374, -1.411161184310913, 1.3002444505691528, 0.5639855265617371, -0.8000670671463013, -0.48943230509757996, 0.015135224908590317, -0.028265075758099556, 0.5512852072715759, -0.13023079931735992, 0.24588577449321747, 0.02651292271912098, -0.3804825246334076, -0.8194051384925842, -0.5563666820526123, -0.9292858839035034, -0.8010450005531311, 0.297389417886734, 0.5605506300926208, 0.48291584849357605, 0.09477563202381134, 0.061934322118759155, 0.2386363446712494, -0.10668586939573288, 0.8151849508285522, -0.12659868597984314, 0.642177164554596, 0.656700849533081, 0.6488792896270752, 0.1383046954870224, 0.3335963487625122, -0.6546621322631836, -0.05927663296461105, -0.3367083668708801, 0.29515576362609863, 0.947443962097168, -0.9216763973236084, 0.6828555464744568, 0.01906244456768036, -0.645321786403656, -0.5774314999580383, 0.3456101715564728, -0.3894869387149811, -0.25752484798431396, -0.21857216954231262, -0.33454281091690063, 0.4234812557697296, -0.43413132429122925, 0.6889030337333679, -0.04363390803337097, 0.24204564094543457, -0.3974202573299408, -0.8615697622299194, -0.004361607134342194, -0.6642472743988037, -0.3226408064365387, 1.4331493377685547, -0.725651741027832, 0.05672460049390793, -0.10298368334770203, 0.018801596015691757, 0.13446450233459473, -0.2554303705692291, 0.4101411998271942, -0.2344568818807602, 0.1717127114534378, -0.37141409516334534, -0.15243196487426758, 0.2252189964056015, 0.21500635147094727, -0.6286085844039917, 0.7896144986152649, 0.08904489129781723, -0.31315234303474426, -0.45614081621170044, 0.4083718955516815, 1.6645182371139526, 0.19866125285625458, 0.5113237500190735, -0.38734087347984314, 0.8624729514122009, -0.7117018103599548, -0.30812394618988037, -0.37843000888824463, -0.480845183134079, -0.9850745797157288, -0.8535582423210144, -1.1103018522262573, -0.4978858232498169, 0.22702522575855255, 0.7286516427993774, -0.3747565746307373, 0.07634563744068146, -0.2633684575557709, 0.6621677875518799, -0.0009558031451888382, -0.12072207033634186, 0.029724465683102608, 0.40858298540115356, -1.2749946117401123, -0.538277268409729, 0.42459139227867126, -0.8921753168106079, -0.2007313072681427, 0.4903324842453003, -0.655347466468811, -0.24864810705184937, -0.5521887540817261, 0.5098986625671387, -0.6057160496711731, 0.4601600766181946, -0.4294915497303009, -0.2907366454601288, -0.2812715768814087, 0.6105467677116394, 0.01296696811914444, 0.5486971735954285, 1.3002227544784546, -0.5911120772361755, 0.622579038143158, 0.5219091176986694, -0.01645982451736927, -0.9353328347206116, -0.06784757226705551, 1.205967903137207, -0.8896514177322388, -0.729158878326416, -0.47064638137817383, 0.16274377703666687, -1.547835350036621, -0.28790658712387085, -1.0144927501678467, 0.3410966396331787, 0.5074230432510376, 0.3187159299850464, -0.13921329379081726, 0.5988383889198303, 0.7178942561149597, 0.21106672286987305, 0.24340277910232544, 0.675291895866394, 0.30613529682159424, 0.6394656896591187, 0.9472977519035339, 0.2753055691719055, -0.12016094475984573, -0.8435462117195129, 1.1245617866516113, 0.8131032586097717, -0.39825764298439026, 0.11548548191785812, 0.1682025045156479, 0.3289722502231598, 0.014178918674588203, -0.6498712301254272, -0.33212602138519287, 0.6163102388381958, 0.7724370360374451, 0.41512438654899597, -0.14541801810264587, -1.5127813816070557, -0.7059783339500427, -0.5077880620956421, -1.0318622589111328, -0.07478251308202744, 0.42581304907798767, -0.20282959938049316, -0.6168798804283142, -0.2648335099220276, -0.4283636510372162, 0.6078106760978699, -0.1822243481874466, 0.6003035306930542, -0.4161982238292694, -0.43026411533355713, 0.2713841199874878, 0.5123238563537598, -0.271518349647522, 0.4688534736633301, -0.23663470149040222, 0.16538822650909424, -0.09812790900468826, -0.5265199542045593, 0.2694433629512787, -0.15701982378959656, 0.018267836421728134, -0.4421147406101227, -0.551237165927887, 0.09110158681869507, 0.3790432810783386, -0.022932248190045357, -0.7851871252059937, -0.0209756288677454, -1.0610904693603516, -0.0971747487783432, 0.43005993962287903, 0.30816444754600525, -0.6003735661506653, 0.1736156940460205, 0.059611350297927856, -0.6588953733444214, -0.5264991521835327, -0.2718329131603241, 1.2664580345153809, -0.5636293292045593, 0.5398287773132324, 0.27915680408477783, 0.3736083507537842, 0.08212519437074661, -0.4163478910923004, 0.9812088012695312, 1.065961241722107, 0.39031514525413513, 0.5245936512947083, 0.160200834274292, 0.733921229839325, 0.5561757683753967, 0.42006054520606995, 0.13503144681453705, 0.6467623710632324, 1.1569942235946655, 0.34561049938201904, -0.2068832516670227, 0.01576552540063858, 0.6396373510360718, 0.32637399435043335, 0.003948559518903494, -0.24509082734584808, 0.6469912528991699, 0.856082022190094, 0.5749589204788208, -0.5964376926422119, -0.2434832751750946, -1.3375272750854492, -0.22573384642601013, 0.29700034856796265, 0.14271217584609985, 1.1565797328948975, 0.028881661593914032, 0.18326057493686676, -0.06553341448307037, 0.7084295749664307, -0.7070572972297668, -0.10019595175981522, 0.15546616911888123, -0.8854761719703674, -0.9597305655479431, -0.8868474960327148, 0.7807724475860596, 0.08109726011753082, -0.3101010024547577, 0.08725052326917648, -0.30768507719039917, 0.22573617100715637, 1.1578105688095093, -1.0916857719421387, -0.27697858214378357, 1.0115940570831299, -0.4237774908542633, -0.2499905228614807, -0.7855068445205688, -0.015698470175266266, -0.5764345526695251, -0.35051798820495605, 0.35897284746170044, -0.5741504430770874, 0.6625855565071106, 0.27761274576187134, 0.4559399485588074, 0.5641590356826782, -0.09019630402326584, 0.2669394612312317, -0.57020503282547, -0.15002548694610596, 0.5126461386680603, 0.5879943370819092, -0.24083617329597473, 0.13504666090011597, -0.3438190221786499, -0.8353784084320068, -0.48358455300331116, 0.5415587425231934, 0.4340544044971466, -0.15188953280448914, 0.431686669588089, 0.3066907227039337, 0.3701205849647522, 0.08557318896055222, -0.423758864402771, -0.3017042279243469, 0.9584522843360901, 0.06971604377031326, -0.08911304175853729, -0.24691690504550934, 0.26631608605384827, 0.1756480485200882, -0.30696919560432434, -0.637755811214447, -0.763389527797699, 0.19859902560710907, -0.9266353249549866, 0.6219127178192139, -0.36101800203323364, 0.18040335178375244, 0.3804759979248047, -0.5252419114112854, 0.3126165270805359, 0.32013463973999023, -0.20570489764213562, -0.7032806277275085, 0.6068165302276611, -0.04313483089208603, 0.8778414130210876, -0.14411959052085876, -0.6842035055160522, 0.43212684988975525, 0.18673792481422424, 0.3464775085449219, -0.2735188603401184, 0.5040545463562012, -0.12641467154026031, 0.08288702368736267, 0.0799470990896225, 0.5133165717124939, 0.5817067623138428, -0.43470749258995056, -0.39831382036209106, -0.5718011856079102, 0.1430119127035141, -0.5651742815971375, -0.33063867688179016, 1.4078835248947144, 0.08711948990821838, -0.3373624384403229, -0.4835318624973297, -0.4845205247402191, -0.3690573573112488, -0.9167323112487793, 0.3095637857913971, 0.06298086792230606, 0.25281044840812683, 0.6432856917381287, -0.1264304518699646, 0.6460050940513611, -0.7899615168571472, 3.966510057449341, 1.6170238256454468, 0.36425483226776123, -0.13890255987644196, 0.6833128929138184, 0.5240171551704407, 0.9309433698654175, -0.9239806532859802, -0.04139542579650879, -0.08195322006940842, -0.5832780599594116, -0.44524258375167847, 0.09747813642024994, -0.2230006903409958, -0.015222619287669659, 0.6113206744194031, -1.50052011013031, -0.21112440526485443, 0.3405610918998718, -1.2115696668624878, -0.5033984780311584, 0.09693116694688797, -0.4034236669540405, -0.2689475119113922, 0.6211209893226624, -0.03401359170675278, -0.22685718536376953, 0.06812005490064621, -0.1472884714603424, 0.16223366558551788, -0.940504252910614, -0.9706356525421143, 0.11283346265554428, -0.16593655943870544, -0.4808211922645569, 0.1703331023454666, -0.21996623277664185, 0.1768835484981537, 0.5328822731971741, 0.24808967113494873, -0.26091793179512024, -0.2267404943704605, -0.1726912260055542, 0.12611615657806396, -0.16346170008182526, -0.030490851029753685, -0.8328059315681458, 0.5219965577125549, -0.3255210816860199, -0.8379653692245483, 0.6845601201057434, -0.40615805983543396, 0.6821046471595764, -0.5104401707649231, -1.372762680053711, -0.04843549057841301, 0.10074174404144287, -0.49380794167518616, -0.12765809893608093, 0.5126242637634277, 0.9925920367240906, 0.1805228441953659, -0.7013899683952332, 0.5457934737205505, 0.7926851511001587, 1.1237928867340088, -0.15027345716953278, 0.36647552251815796, -0.19631971418857574, -0.7330152988433838, -0.4103855490684509, -0.9493930339813232, -0.21814915537834167, 0.11944852024316788, -0.238507941365242, 0.1352526992559433, -0.1538105458021164, 0.7951631546020508, -0.39443638920783997, -0.39072132110595703, 0.45603829622268677, 0.4030967950820923, -0.47319650650024414, -0.5756816864013672, 0.38204848766326904, 0.151498943567276, -0.7736204862594604, 0.11585389077663422, -1.1080070734024048, 0.5409348011016846, 0.2800508141517639, 0.21072164177894592, 0.2400979995727539, 0.3786826431751251, -0.3128293454647064 ]
{"Title": "Null effect of circulating sphingomyelins on risk for breast cancer: a Mendelian randomization report using Breast Cancer Association Consortium (BCAC) data", "Authors": "Adams Charleen D.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Changes in cellular metabolism are a hallmark of cancer and are linked with sphingolipid synthesis. Due to immense interest in how sphingolipids influence chemoresistance, more is known about the impact of sphingolipids during cancer treatment and progression than about the potential role of sphingolipids in the induction of tumors in humans. Methods Because estrogen triggers sphingolipid signaling cascades, the causal role of circulating levels of sphingomyelin (a type of sphingolipid) on breast cancer was investigated with a well-powered Mendelian randomization design. Results The results reveal a null effect (OR = 0.94; 95% CI = 0.85, 1.05; P = 0.30). Conclusion Despite the role sphingomyelins play during chemoresistance and cancer progression, circulating sphingomyelins do not appear to initiate or protect from breast cancer. Impact This finding comprises the first causal report in humans that sphingomyelins on breast cancer initiation is null. Future investigations of risk in other cancer types are needed to further explore the potential role of sphingolipid biology in cancer etiology.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013540"}
10.1101/19005512
[ 0.06598903238773346, 0.025528358295559883, -0.26214760541915894, 0.5474972128868103, -0.9179632663726807, -0.21105879545211792, 0.26902341842651367, -0.14062027633190155, 0.513120174407959, 0.9385831356048584, -0.09874961525201797, 0.040166113525629044, 1.0507705211639404, -0.3872424066066742, -0.2945422828197479, 0.16681478917598724, -0.7229405045509338, 0.2596442699432373, -0.7496390342712402, -0.2905411422252655, 0.6701444983482361, 0.5712589621543884, -0.5338938236236572, -0.09686834365129471, -0.9913035035133362, 0.8486344218254089, -0.025607334449887276, 0.036965060979127884, 0.7714082598686218, 0.6152673959732056, 0.29156312346458435, -0.4850706160068512, 0.11665275692939758, -0.9595147967338562, -0.22888268530368805, -0.3043861985206604, 0.6013546586036682, -1.121489405632019, 0.1207328587770462, -0.03041013702750206, 0.28665706515312195, 0.008662160485982895, 0.3514866530895233, -0.769441545009613, 0.10155612230300903, 0.07866331934928894, 0.09377595782279968, -0.11935140937566757, -0.3579714596271515, -0.22161424160003662, -0.33622896671295166, 0.19084568321704865, -0.09417558461427689, -0.09626409411430359, 0.356300950050354, -0.16941288113594055, 0.10020516812801361, 0.1531670242547989, -0.26748359203338623, 0.015935756266117096, 0.2610921263694763, -0.44527724385261536, 0.5014522075653076, -1.095238208770752, 0.5387835502624512, 0.6040319204330444, 0.10563673824071884, -0.28004544973373413, -0.8401864767074585, 0.21471168100833893, -1.2183618545532227, -0.16300469636917114, -0.35754039883613586, -0.3630414307117462, -0.3098704218864441, -0.8365738391876221, 0.3383617699146271, 0.20731067657470703, -0.2962632477283478, -0.6004363894462585, 0.4456585943698883, -0.4513266384601593, -0.2945723235607147, 0.6699740290641785, -0.5410917401313782, 0.5542194247245789, -0.27996742725372314, 0.6655805110931396, 0.5443891286849976, -0.2794211208820343, -0.1923365592956543, 0.24252793192863464, 0.5455811619758606, 0.5784595608711243, -0.17117394506931305, 0.8855557441711426, -0.3423377573490143, 0.6397284865379333, 0.34110525250434875, -0.38701507449150085, 0.4414607882499695, 0.9378710389137268, -0.22138158977031708, 1.0265933275222778, -1.0024081468582153, 0.7483195662498474, 0.2004702389240265, -0.22254301607608795, -0.4082893133163452, -0.8420035243034363, 0.21230003237724304, 0.1049467921257019, 0.13163995742797852, 0.12153124064207077, 0.38323694467544556, 0.769063413143158, 0.5524372458457947, 0.6236410140991211, -0.34820249676704407, 0.9186307787895203, -0.07912462204694748, -0.6144947409629822, 0.519477367401123, -0.7455185055732727, 0.5185122489929199, -0.4944407045841217, -0.00158727599773556, 1.1211955547332764, -0.4496833384037018, 0.631260871887207, 0.6628168225288391, -0.23333655297756195, -0.2469165027141571, 0.5022273659706116, -0.1787954568862915, 0.09544677287340164, 0.3672565519809723, 0.8346957564353943, -1.0185497999191284, -0.2419351190328598, -0.36263203620910645, 0.5104939937591553, -0.601078450679779, 0.8710700869560242, -0.20569689571857452, 0.6986100673675537, -1.04219651222229, -0.6472742557525635, -0.7030891180038452, -0.33125412464141846, -0.19516193866729736, 0.41477668285369873, 0.28296732902526855, -0.7143325209617615, -0.4959375262260437, 0.07654432207345963, -0.01865430921316147, 0.7159479260444641, -0.05963737517595291, 0.5320284962654114, -0.7555903196334839, -0.17836028337478638, 0.4669841527938843, 0.525722861289978, -0.7141448855400085, 0.9401716589927673, 0.17903098464012146, 0.04489997401833534, 0.388723224401474, -0.7408838868141174, 0.17741748690605164, 0.8953567743301392, -0.744053065776825, -0.7516822814941406, 0.3630360960960388, 0.5458159446716309, 1.3153778314590454, 0.3345194160938263, 0.04148828238248825, 0.42195382714271545, -0.28186944127082825, -0.9616898894309998, -0.28992781043052673, 0.5860300660133362, -0.03774445131421089, -0.20023669302463531, -0.48768720030784607, -0.7446454167366028, 0.0977109745144844, -0.09720205515623093, 0.17256046831607819, 0.8150582313537598, -0.38378244638442993, 1.019057273864746, 0.09594901651144028, -0.16546717286109924, -0.6459916830062866, 0.5298575162887573, 0.06319180876016617, -0.29269590973854065, -0.6240233182907104, 0.7342097163200378, -0.4555944800376892, 0.04996470361948013, -0.3824459910392761, 1.0665088891983032, 0.07721240073442459, 0.5972924828529358, -0.7148208618164062, 0.06439855694770813, 0.7172976136207581, 0.15226899087429047, -0.12465719878673553, -0.037357740104198456, 0.865679144859314, -0.5100913643836975, -0.11282335221767426, -0.28706055879592896, -0.5190045833587646, -0.4866144061088562, 0.5548558831214905, -0.35531413555145264, 0.41988644003868103, -0.20734348893165588, 0.23920047283172607, 0.6747048497200012, 0.014667117968201637, -0.2969910502433777, 0.2935166656970978, -0.4697212278842926, 0.3350985050201416, 0.7572698593139648, 0.4434092342853546, 0.5699946880340576, 0.5564736127853394, 0.08044277876615524, 0.8085638880729675, 0.0059222872368991375, 1.0265878438949585, 0.8340837359428406, 0.303786963224411, 0.9133132100105286, 0.6967098712921143, 0.35737550258636475, -0.7545716166496277, 0.039505526423454285, -0.5004109144210815, 0.11501790583133698, -0.3505195379257202, 0.9327014684677124, -0.9684256911277771, 0.4315299093723297, -0.0506431870162487, 0.5757967233657837, -0.526988685131073, -0.4297218918800354, 0.0896531343460083, 0.4036313593387604, 0.17999663949012756, -0.7425101399421692, -0.013909785076975822, 0.07472139596939087, 0.13152815401554108, 0.39898616075515747, 0.9178232550621033, 0.2954097092151642, 0.24219006299972534, 0.5379064679145813, 0.04744395241141319, -0.13152624666690826, -0.8547592759132385, -0.7009710669517517, -0.7266084551811218, -0.47926804423332214, -1.0789755582809448, 0.3086763918399811, 0.22718746960163116, -0.3706532418727875, 0.31150421500205994, -0.27269941568374634, -0.013454717583954334, -0.18933501839637756, 0.10842270404100418, 0.6037061810493469, 0.6887494325637817, 0.12257108837366104, -1.2956136465072632, 0.14700864255428314, -0.6201109886169434, 0.3794226348400116, -0.05649218708276749, -0.8826507329940796, -1.0406962633132935, -0.5491599440574646, 0.4107142686843872, -0.6093915700912476, 0.14439469575881958, 0.09764969348907471, -0.44175928831100464, -0.5417051315307617, -0.6284521818161011, 0.028676362708210945, -0.40845346450805664, -0.3452189266681671, -0.37248530983924866, 0.8946976065635681, -0.3938707411289215, 0.02179120108485222, 0.30455198884010315, 0.6203811764717102, -0.4912702143192291, 0.08709261566400528, 0.215541809797287, 0.4463983476161957, -0.7932514548301697, 0.6070724129676819, 0.7018360495567322, -0.3116387724876404, -0.37072768807411194, -0.4923597276210785, -1.383956789970398, -0.4474378824234009, -0.3667337894439697, 0.15710456669330597, -0.02610022760927677, 0.015564031898975372, -0.5402912497520447, -1.0313907861709595, 0.6186766028404236, -0.42561888694763184, -0.4273478388786316, -0.47665536403656006, -0.538680911064148, 0.5222471356391907, -0.47024235129356384, -0.30306148529052734, -0.5270839929580688, -0.06337840855121613, 0.24889539182186127, 0.1383480578660965, -0.045358747243881226, -0.12049166113138199, -0.07132717221975327, -0.29775312542915344, -0.0599680170416832, 0.6338363885879517, 0.762463390827179, -0.8038002848625183, 0.15340784192085266, -0.4181669354438782, 0.43953728675842285, 0.18119022250175476, 0.9372798800468445, -0.27945366501808167, 0.6064555048942566, 0.37803158164024353, -0.03423994407057762, -0.12767627835273743, -0.28028950095176697, 0.465960830450058, -0.29607537388801575, 0.5113576054573059, -0.3522554039955139, 0.563762903213501, -0.8116077780723572, -0.5078219771385193, 0.20166493952274323, -0.42650091648101807, 0.9776655435562134, -0.9909976124763489, 0.6815056204795837, 0.33596423268318176, -0.22331152856349945, 0.3382329046726227, -0.3820977807044983, -0.7309332489967346, 1.0902607440948486, 0.18491093814373016, 0.9583340883255005, -1.5003536939620972, 0.6698530912399292, 0.25613874197006226, 1.0916491746902466, 0.04673406854271889, -0.31540241837501526, 0.4510800540447235, -0.4424574077129364, 0.6290499567985535, -0.1499260663986206, -0.009923825971782207, 0.5684192776679993, 0.07610872387886047, -0.20888517796993256, 0.32902103662490845, -0.778170645236969, -0.056497346609830856, 0.4000067412853241, 0.5896052718162537, -0.4379887282848358, -0.15920674800872803, 0.8105331063270569, -0.04996371269226074, -0.24721425771713257, 0.3677399158477783, 0.761795699596405, -0.394822895526886, -0.4437549412250519, -0.0887085497379303, -0.20679093897342682, -0.5712390542030334, -0.26122966408729553, -0.12147027254104614, -0.2611919939517975, 0.33614009618759155, 0.6415897011756897, -0.09243147075176239, -0.27207475900650024, -0.14122475683689117, -0.01011393778026104, 0.4302615523338318, 0.24688228964805603, 0.2862812876701355, -0.8317649960517883, 0.05518050491809845, 0.7739832401275635, -0.2691923677921295, -0.2769828140735626, -0.7122914791107178, 0.7914937734603882, 0.46037358045578003, -0.10281582921743393, -1.0603939294815063, -0.1318420171737671, 0.3568803369998932, -0.3347700238227844, -0.7646952271461487, 0.04526955261826515, -0.08673299103975296, 0.023466646671295166, 0.08205372095108032, -0.1661759912967682, -0.8732937574386597, 0.184919536113739, -0.16435156762599945, 0.23775702714920044, 0.1396225541830063, 0.20733638107776642, 0.41806742548942566, 0.5654601454734802, -0.3077857196331024, 0.23567616939544678, -0.3578636944293976, 0.19702096283435822, -0.1819349229335785, -0.24561943113803864, -0.4662904143333435, -0.25412458181381226, 0.1803535372018814, 0.3999016284942627, -0.40239784121513367, -0.32216182351112366, 0.320103257894516, 0.5952237248420715, -0.10468224436044693, -0.05498907342553139, 1.5499640703201294, 0.1263619065284729, -0.19164390861988068, 1.0544276237487793, 0.3329777121543884, -0.2748788297176361, -0.38593801856040955, -0.2827851176261902, -1.0205671787261963, 0.10953915119171143, -0.4387756884098053, -0.2183312326669693, -0.05849897861480713, -0.09462128579616547, 0.0645265132188797, -0.21040858328342438, 0.5528078675270081, -0.14929665625095367, 0.25190088152885437, -0.3261117935180664, -1.0534991025924683, -0.2724301218986511, -0.09821514785289764, -0.8638702630996704, 0.5772396326065063, 0.2793625295162201, -0.5738862752914429, -0.6222995519638062, 0.3996579945087433, -0.21332915127277374, -0.2559024393558502, -1.0975850820541382, 0.159820556640625, -0.3701733648777008, -0.09002701938152313, 0.5697491765022278, -0.4376673102378845, -0.4594869315624237, 0.05932791531085968, 0.6940233111381531, -0.6736043691635132, -0.38456040620803833, -0.22860471904277802, 0.2950649559497833, -0.22486500442028046, -0.2286503165960312, 0.027857951819896698, -0.32835039496421814, 0.6586771607398987, -0.2953295111656189, -0.1614835411310196, 0.35865288972854614, -0.3283000886440277, -0.507361114025116, 1.0741552114486694, 0.09138472378253937, -0.7566754221916199, 0.019933918491005898, 0.523413896560669, 0.11838003993034363, 0.3046995997428894, -0.5493138432502747, -0.3009450435638428, -0.39646849036216736, -1.0961805582046509, -0.17762182652950287, -1.354734182357788, 0.43076092004776, -0.1998130977153778, 0.433539479970932, 0.19073563814163208, 0.35914376378059387, 0.19251124560832977, 0.28079235553741455, 0.06827031075954437, -0.20541465282440186, 0.13160116970539093, -0.4157571494579315, -0.3671807050704956, -0.07306747138500214, -0.31418871879577637, 0.03204045817255974, 0.9873398542404175, 0.7252838015556335, -0.20709773898124695, 0.17964774370193481, 0.01621825061738491, 0.3069450259208679, -0.08336959034204483, -0.105116106569767, -0.34489911794662476, 0.28317588567733765, 1.056320071220398, 0.04269210621714592, -0.4142621159553528, -1.069349765777588, -0.10255586355924606, -0.7584871053695679, 0.02345498837530613, -0.10871775448322296, -0.35085329413414, -0.25152647495269775, -0.1860520988702774, 1.1242047548294067, -0.755365252494812, -0.3722395598888397, -0.30342361330986023, 0.1563134342432022, 0.4474621117115021, 0.21411541104316711, -0.5749809145927429, -1.1250067949295044, -0.7353414297103882, -0.5727765560150146, 0.4427744150161743, 0.03525472432374954, 0.441772997379303, 0.6799646019935608, 0.29899129271507263, 0.19705191254615784, -0.5925180912017822, 0.5600028038024902, -0.05413662642240524, -1.1033934354782104, -0.47401002049446106, 0.2996766269207001, 0.43433618545532227, -0.39698904752731323, -0.029115913435816765, 0.061661940068006516, -0.5674720406532288, -0.281496524810791, 0.128792867064476, -0.5581358671188354, -0.5014684796333313, -0.23878520727157593, 0.02617870457470417, 0.6886240839958191, -0.053024809807538986, 0.004223525524139404, -0.15705694258213043, -0.2715229392051697, -0.8446669578552246, 0.540107786655426, -0.7694142460823059, -0.34500011801719666, 0.6412392258644104, -0.5273321866989136, -0.5370872020721436, 0.09937317669391632, -0.2878582179546356, -0.6578517556190491, -0.35989975929260254, 0.6543709635734558, 0.6009224057197571, -1.071890115737915, 0.3665914535522461, 0.12595225870609283, -0.2952719032764435, -0.40869638323783875, 0.2984038293361664, 0.11514788866043091, 0.20618069171905518, -0.33665692806243896, 0.4676511287689209, 0.45509809255599976, 0.19540898501873016, 0.5346536040306091, 0.15699972212314606, 0.3947847783565521, -0.4667239189147949, -0.13784784078598022, 0.24579447507858276, -0.26897937059402466, -0.4291267395019531, 0.3618946075439453, -0.36373499035835266, 0.9142313599586487, 0.31491535902023315, -0.3615764379501343, 0.14621742069721222, 0.5911586284637451, 0.47171229124069214, -1.0762778520584106, -0.3969525694847107, 0.07468581944704056, 0.39091598987579346, -0.3414633572101593, 0.08832448720932007, -0.16297130286693573, 0.609043538570404, -0.027463877573609352, -0.2341894954442978, -0.7529610395431519, 0.07094468921422958, 0.866736114025116, 0.8269184827804565, -0.3070346713066101, -0.11510904878377914, 0.9483561515808105, 0.6760959029197693, -0.000896536628715694, -0.11793945729732513, -1.216886281967163, -1.032773494720459, 0.0904839038848877, 0.4515281319618225, -1.1065706014633179, 0.5354122519493103, 0.31946149468421936, -0.5554031729698181, -1.0926296710968018, -0.6027129888534546, 0.9777941703796387, -0.2701323330402374, 0.005848135333508253, -0.3811896741390228, 0.6926695704460144, -0.5818378329277039, 0.2111022025346756, -0.5962136387825012, -0.2288104146718979, 0.16982126235961914, 0.4865280091762543, -1.1937302350997925, -0.7915981411933899, 0.36236926913261414, -0.09805743396282196, 0.07748955488204956, 0.7158658504486084, -0.11798431724309921, -0.3890013098716736, -0.05305713415145874, 0.6638545393943787, -0.03395792096853256, -0.028652044013142586, 1.0366047620773315, -0.09015412628650665, 0.7127203941345215, 0.26971161365509033, -0.20744284987449646, -0.16986031830310822, -0.08761655539274216, 0.2888309061527252, -0.8173083066940308, -0.8850767612457275, -0.9231352210044861, 0.7484055161476135, -0.6244978904724121, -0.6380810737609863, -0.4343441426753998, -0.042205892503261566, -0.08174248039722443, -0.07033336162567139, -0.13437508046627045, 0.5786026120185852, 0.06534918397665024, 0.1545315682888031, 0.26192060112953186, 0.2502032518386841, 0.4588313400745392, 0.07217194139957428, -0.010481985285878181, -0.3688737452030182, 0.2058192789554596, -0.07644985616207123, 0.6355328559875488, 0.2674412131309509, -0.6238960027694702, 0.2033725529909134, -1.0177966356277466, -0.17122703790664673, 0.22711259126663208, 0.03708833456039429, 0.29778939485549927, 1.200197696685791, 0.44876986742019653, -0.19469092786312103, 0.40743488073349, -0.11803338676691055, -0.24337637424468994, -0.3741318881511688, -1.0069811344146729, -0.7500906586647034, 0.6457594633102417, -0.8520932793617249, 0.31672510504722595, -0.45098963379859924, -1.055544137954712, 0.6802136898040771, 0.2003578394651413, 0.4889126420021057, -0.028822608292102814, 1.1204756498336792, 0.18361428380012512, 0.16783472895622253, 0.0022920912597328424, 0.09305304288864136, 0.6689141988754272, 0.1951526254415512, -0.4726354479789734, -0.681799054145813, 0.3012123703956604, -0.08832164853811264, 0.522179365158081, -0.13667646050453186, 0.3857306241989136, 0.19916854798793793, 0.07636363804340363, -0.017205839976668358, 0.11461061239242554, 0.32125410437583923, -0.3692872226238251, -0.19961987435817719, 0.07218880951404572, -0.25159093737602234, -0.6198781728744507, 0.7941456437110901, 0.5032132267951965, -0.953657865524292, -0.5917350649833679, -0.22859494388103485, 0.7058423757553101, -0.0288719329982996, 0.15195484459400177, -0.5399461388587952, 0.11595290154218674, -0.47783276438713074, -0.17542532086372375, 0.2158544659614563, 0.25688984990119934, 0.2178836166858673, 0.020081013441085815, 0.10810747742652893, 0.31426742672920227, 0.9893812537193298, 0.549768328666687, 0.22030572593212128, 1.1966001987457275, 0.37669527530670166, -0.38211652636528015, 0.12800560891628265, -0.4429852068424225, 0.6405196189880371, 0.29273149371147156, -0.11927665024995804, 0.15751370787620544, 0.1983923316001892, -0.09406143426895142, -0.2380182296037674, -0.39546963572502136, 0.7386752367019653, -0.22905321419239044, -0.48852598667144775, -0.13510844111442566, 0.4138779044151306, 0.4557228982448578, 0.4407939910888672, 0.3138960897922516, -0.18229329586029053, 0.4463878273963928, 0.10392432659864426, -0.5612753033638, 0.5232136249542236, -0.10399505496025085, -0.3419652581214905, -0.07940411567687988, 0.07690674066543579, 0.027081463485956192, -0.07316529750823975, 0.6872676014900208, -0.28253382444381714, 0.1925196498632431, 0.9952417612075806, 0.07645493745803833, -0.1797829121351242, 0.5357255339622498, -0.6860309839248657, -0.04904194921255112, -0.09799974411725998, -0.16422398388385773, -0.6325303316116333, -0.3466223478317261, 0.6155000329017639, -0.432009756565094, 0.03452733904123306, -0.07199586927890778, -0.10522715747356415, 0.419913113117218, 0.9194999933242798, 0.3323826193809509, -0.34008222818374634, 0.9166012406349182, 0.6008784174919128, -0.11451300978660583, -0.13511374592781067, -0.050618015229701996, -0.45914605259895325, 0.5992876291275024, -0.3076114356517792, 0.35491758584976196, -0.8461595177650452, -0.883912980556488, -0.2123381495475769, -0.1364390105009079, 0.16523335874080658, -0.03387082368135452, -0.15076009929180145, -0.3132328987121582, 0.5307816863059998, -0.13463085889816284, -0.39666199684143066, 0.29785144329071045, 0.16073904931545258, 0.5472554564476013, -0.11910691857337952, -0.21466539800167084, 0.0328386127948761, 0.585973858833313, -0.2857276499271393, 0.8723644614219666, 0.459717720746994, -0.26788660883903503, -0.2877378463745117, -0.8634552955627441, -0.17768453061580658, 0.015167445875704288, -0.34783291816711426, -1.0696847438812256, -0.006533647887408733, 0.007533605210483074, 0.4516957998275757, -0.04624691233038902, -0.7335056066513062, -0.33053380250930786, 0.3366228938102722, 1.069830298423767, -0.2213820219039917, 0.04273775964975357, 0.01714950241148472, 0.2563840448856354, 0.18354734778404236, 0.40659403800964355, -0.0368499830365181, -0.10448944568634033, -0.5101699233055115, -0.07810148596763611, -0.21034640073776245, -0.19653908908367157, -0.4743303060531616, 0.6268423795700073, 0.12781663239002228, 0.2240099012851715, -0.2475779950618744, -0.642579972743988, -1.0962828397750854, -0.6457222700119019, 1.795947551727295, -0.32165852189064026, 0.28104260563850403, -0.05616236850619316, -0.06451526284217834, 0.7315369248390198, -0.7978413105010986, 4.204116344451904, 1.1163122653961182, 0.486549437046051, 0.11556918174028397, -0.056710634380578995, 0.853348970413208, 0.7030901908874512, -0.7400045990943909, 0.4729557931423187, 0.0669846311211586, -0.5818523168563843, 0.2582333981990814, -0.18865308165550232, -0.6304195523262024, 0.7000226378440857, 0.40309515595436096, -1.0019844770431519, -0.002856703707948327, -0.2571485638618469, -0.5297852754592896, -0.2824133336544037, 0.662143886089325, 0.36052560806274414, 0.2888043224811554, -0.3265208899974823, -0.086785227060318, 0.14114482700824738, 0.22281277179718018, -0.5115129351615906, 0.4740959107875824, -0.2799564599990845, -0.926868200302124, -0.04631203040480614, -0.1322014331817627, 0.3618481457233429, 0.5074464678764343, -0.4786911904811859, -0.2814624011516571, -0.46217814087867737, -0.00584526639431715, -0.3619380593299866, -0.03594328090548515, -0.3298174738883972, -0.34539294242858887, -0.4189358055591583, 0.15996772050857544, -0.47182998061180115, 0.20626722276210785, 0.509496808052063, -0.10166514664888382, 1.2942098379135132, -0.9478878974914551, 0.12429971247911453, 0.30065444111824036, -0.371226966381073, -0.12493401020765305, -0.22373388707637787, -0.8312169909477234, 0.018165720626711845, 0.333858460187912, 0.31667882204055786, -0.04887867718935013, -0.07229888439178467, -0.1535177379846573, 0.8093129992485046, 0.1997981071472168, 0.5365580320358276, -0.7137139439582825, 0.15996123850345612, -0.08267596364021301, 0.04452838748693466, 0.3071777820587158, -0.8560340404510498, 0.2424308955669403, 0.7574635744094849, 0.9253072738647461, -0.1057358831167221, 0.4675927758216858, -0.5477024912834167, -0.7833171486854553, -0.00719721894711256, 0.022325823083519936, 0.16790862381458282, -0.13353902101516724, -0.09021969884634018, 1.2552247047424316, -0.6249285936355591, -0.22733436524868011, -1.15451979637146, 0.29502835869789124, 0.24124951660633087, -0.1050872653722763, -0.06964430958032608, -0.6888415217399597, 0.24539434909820557 ]
{"Title": "High occurrence of transportation and logistics occupations among vascular dementia patients: an observational study", "Authors": "van Loenhoud A.C., de Boer C., Wols K., Pijnenburg Y.A., Lemstra A.W., Bouwman F.H., Prins N.D., Scheltens P., Ossenkoppele R., van der Flier W.M.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Growing evidence suggests a role of occupation in the emergence and manifestation of dementia. Occupations are often defined by complexity level, although working environments and activities differ in several other important ways. We aimed to capture the multi-faceted nature of occupation through its measurement as a qualitative (instead of a quantitative) variable and explored its relationship with different types of dementia. Methods We collected occupational information of 2,121 dementia patients with various suspected etiologies from the Amsterdam Dementia Cohort (age: 67\u00b18, 57% male, MMSE: 21\u00b15). Our final sample included individuals with Alzheimer\u2019s disease (AD) dementia (n=1,467), frontotemporal dementia (n=281), vascular dementia (n=98), Lewy Body disease (n=174) and progressive supranuclear palsy/corticobasal degeneration (n=101). Within the AD group, we used neuropsychological data to further characterize patients by clinical phenotypes. All participants were categorized into one of 11 occupational classes, across which we evaluated the distribution of dementia (sub)types with Chi 2 analyses. We gained further insight into occupation-dementia relationships through post-hoc logistic regressions that included various demographic and health characteristics as explanatory variables. Results There were significant differences in the distribution of dementia types across occupation groups (Chi 2 =85.87, p<.001). Vascular dementia was relatively common in the Transportation/Logistics sector, and higher vascular risk factors partly explained this relationship. Alzheimer\u2019s disease occurred less in Transportation/Logistics and more in Health Care/Welfare occupations, which related to a higher/lower percentage of males. We found no relationships between occupational classes and clinical phenotypes of AD (Chi 2 =53.65, n.s.). Conclusions Relationships between occupation and dementia seem to exist beyond complexity level, which offers new opportunities for disease prevention and improvement of occupational health policy.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005512"}
10.1101/19014134
[ -0.18793855607509613, -0.11259648948907852, -0.5989094972610474, 0.5690004229545593, -0.6942049264907837, -0.5591424107551575, 0.5143183469772339, 0.20118573307991028, 0.3914838433265686, 0.7399953603744507, -0.1346004456281662, -0.8230172991752625, 0.0053247688338160515, 0.568028450012207, 0.15026941895484924, -0.3110767900943756, -0.08060546219348907, -0.49923422932624817, -0.45020633935928345, 0.13152731955051422, 0.433308482170105, 0.5335530042648315, -0.6264154314994812, -0.1578146517276764, -1.0265679359436035, 0.505342423915863, 0.17316856980323792, -0.0071824584156274796, 1.6417887210845947, 0.8299305438995361, 0.6265988349914551, -0.6994403004646301, 0.9775137305259705, -0.18902729451656342, -0.5283551216125488, -0.6076189279556274, 0.316799134016037, -0.1694159209728241, 0.03381301462650299, -0.13107998669147491, 0.22577305138111115, -0.6654232740402222, 0.315422922372818, -0.7109981179237366, -0.7101741433143616, -0.5473117232322693, 0.04361509159207344, 0.055955421179533005, 0.23348519206047058, -0.14470967650413513, -0.10363658517599106, 0.674692690372467, 0.2343190312385559, -1.0150295495986938, 0.15381860733032227, 0.32517850399017334, -0.305592805147171, -0.11361508816480637, -0.48030880093574524, 0.02301536127924919, 0.02711641602218151, 0.031106101348996162, 0.9367291331291199, 0.1677631437778473, 0.7509515285491943, 0.5372954607009888, 0.08098853379487991, -0.08190762251615524, -0.2024422436952591, -0.7138077616691589, -0.9938178658485413, -0.27893853187561035, -0.048310160636901855, -0.37436407804489136, -0.40127992630004883, -0.15933243930339813, 0.894755482673645, -0.03217310085892677, -0.4311596751213074, 0.1667891889810562, 0.3645974397659302, 0.22186577320098877, 0.6812161207199097, -0.020695289596915245, -0.3464839458465576, -0.047982051968574524, 0.1609858274459839, 0.0008157885749824345, -0.006026206538081169, 1.184269905090332, 0.36241310834884644, -0.20889660716056824, 0.2574383020401001, -0.0009421108989045024, -0.3790273368358612, 0.9874551892280579, -0.2857232093811035, -0.45134788751602173, 0.6140803098678589, -0.13921265304088593, 0.8621837496757507, 0.588240385055542, 0.1880778968334198, 0.7590304613113403, -0.5923190116882324, 0.37506961822509766, 0.43603718280792236, -1.181708812713623, -0.17378878593444824, -0.7122491598129272, -0.20234359800815582, 0.11618025600910187, -0.30409547686576843, -0.8029319047927856, 0.8839038014411926, 0.24679253995418549, 0.3718954622745514, 1.202520489692688, -0.6095942854881287, 0.4534587562084198, 0.08845560252666473, -0.1706298440694809, -0.27473995089530945, -0.114442840218544, 0.18591493368148804, -0.14237836003303528, 0.4886772632598877, 0.6734387278556824, 0.20062115788459778, 0.06901533156633377, -1.0605539083480835, -0.602153480052948, 0.12810443341732025, 0.646493136882782, -0.16337813436985016, 0.08003291487693787, 0.22039794921875, 0.4988640546798706, 0.28464335203170776, -0.6941501498222351, -0.4343428611755371, 0.6646518707275391, -0.7643440961837769, 0.7410801649093628, -0.3249421715736389, 1.123788833618164, -0.9184362888336182, -1.2608786821365356, -0.635944664478302, 0.07006759941577911, -0.24878756701946259, 0.5207182765007019, 0.4560354948043823, 0.4022946059703827, -0.019948668777942657, 0.5841323733329773, -1.0175069570541382, 0.3135230839252472, -0.1539222002029419, -0.07192164659500122, -0.4326452314853668, 0.1404760628938675, -0.4175962209701538, 0.5093702673912048, -0.9078094959259033, 0.7957888841629028, -0.07515182346105576, -0.5878011584281921, 0.5547884702682495, -0.8483834862709045, 0.2290652096271515, 0.4754481315612793, -0.8243926763534546, -0.014607669785618782, 0.8265672922134399, 0.8772937655448914, 0.37994033098220825, -0.04402485862374306, 0.2718687653541565, 0.6904186606407166, -0.028441987931728363, 0.023393206298351288, 0.6875861287117004, 1.0065240859985352, 0.1070527508854866, 0.3756707012653351, -0.16782920062541962, -0.8148979544639587, -0.2151295691728592, -0.688723087310791, -0.37430545687675476, 0.6664247512817383, -0.42871764302253723, 0.7853072285652161, -0.03870626538991928, -0.24318471550941467, -0.05766572058200836, 1.09253990650177, 1.1168365478515625, -0.0067929597571492195, -0.7816084623336792, 0.42474207282066345, -0.5791816711425781, -0.030333030968904495, -0.00489412248134613, 0.35741177201271057, 0.2270708829164505, 0.05351465195417404, 0.1067422553896904, 0.05753321200609207, 0.5987765789031982, 0.5840440988540649, -0.18328319489955902, 0.030556365847587585, 0.48222389817237854, -0.6035069227218628, -0.6221497654914856, 0.6327170729637146, -0.46298789978027344, 0.12831613421440125, 0.2315014749765396, -0.013747604563832283, 0.6127623319625854, 0.10595934092998505, -0.3596811294555664, 0.8810405731201172, 0.6103777289390564, 0.790679395198822, -0.4097979962825775, 0.013388694263994694, -0.4073403477668762, 1.6020318269729614, 0.4045194387435913, 0.2317739725112915, 0.946066677570343, 0.4137097895145416, 0.86788409948349, 0.9891166687011719, 0.15529370307922363, 0.17058798670768738, 0.5073292255401611, 0.17004863917827606, 0.5951578617095947, 0.4335649609565735, -0.2869488000869751, 0.538162112236023, 0.2678910195827484, -0.4322679936885834, 0.259967565536499, 0.376306414604187, -0.7400041818618774, 0.8079233765602112, -0.19481870532035828, -0.14349301159381866, -0.8235260248184204, -0.5883143544197083, 0.9387555718421936, -0.18941159546375275, -0.30613693594932556, -0.5556449890136719, -0.48423388600349426, 0.9596275091171265, -0.6824655532836914, -0.14104604721069336, 1.121474266052246, 0.45685532689094543, -0.2693027853965759, 1.108551263809204, 0.5599700212478638, -0.15168967843055725, -0.5846788287162781, -0.38518866896629333, -1.4648712873458862, -0.7900314927101135, -1.1255013942718506, 0.358271986246109, -0.8277407288551331, -0.24351361393928528, 0.584391176700592, -0.12584301829338074, 0.3154812455177307, 0.06784804165363312, -0.1225329339504242, -0.28123918175697327, 0.12567876279354095, 0.03303707763552666, -1.1119515895843506, 0.42017728090286255, 0.247670978307724, 0.060474734753370285, 0.07261501997709274, -0.4309004545211792, -1.2739245891571045, -0.18047203123569489, -0.22701771557331085, -0.44839581847190857, 0.3494478464126587, 0.25713983178138733, -0.16914397478103638, -0.27744272351264954, 0.12691833078861237, -0.677793025970459, 0.08056992292404175, -0.09038224071264267, -0.4621809720993042, 0.9287326335906982, -0.7917137145996094, 0.7216870188713074, 1.2386870384216309, 0.039267346262931824, -0.8569499254226685, 0.6396980285644531, 0.6431421041488647, 0.2354283183813095, -1.1036971807479858, -0.2897881269454956, -0.09954889118671417, -0.13805803656578064, 0.31186291575431824, -0.9546091556549072, -0.943185567855835, -0.1464463472366333, 0.3015590310096741, -0.36762702465057373, -0.28386345505714417, 0.12721747159957886, 0.6021273136138916, -1.2538700103759766, 0.23780566453933716, -0.45187708735466003, -1.3771532773971558, -0.20272038877010345, -0.0305100679397583, 0.023472575470805168, 0.396283358335495, -0.04345393553376198, 0.1477459818124771, -0.2564448118209839, 0.4768516421318054, 0.09370125830173492, 0.16673502326011658, -0.30439066886901855, -0.2635994255542755, -0.011274300515651703, -0.3351893424987793, 0.1594187319278717, 0.054109860211610794, -0.4136984348297119, -0.24232341349124908, -0.12568308413028717, -0.2448781132698059, 0.36334291100502014, 0.908967137336731, -0.3555385172367096, -0.3812938928604126, 0.5739768147468567, -0.025371244177222252, -0.3748222887516022, 0.24114103615283966, 0.7971109747886658, 0.5188354849815369, 0.21191243827342987, -0.39379024505615234, 0.18841217458248138, -1.1262356042861938, -0.30209243297576904, 0.33514511585235596, 0.009646706283092499, 0.16929472982883453, 0.13041743636131287, 0.9138540625572205, -0.5293343663215637, 0.3635513186454773, 0.13296999037265778, -0.13583870232105255, -0.0022067436948418617, 0.950898289680481, 0.22287744283676147, 0.9149823784828186, -1.0769585371017456, 0.04221607372164726, -0.048320844769477844, 0.7999053597450256, -0.22559642791748047, -0.3262554109096527, 0.6837533116340637, -0.5415968894958496, 0.4728366732597351, 0.1545674204826355, -0.8182590007781982, 0.18707531690597534, -0.3004143536090851, 0.34742408990859985, -0.5587188005447388, -0.6155630350112915, -0.39650794863700867, 0.15320323407649994, 1.0173338651657104, 0.2304140031337738, -0.018766533583402634, 0.7707758545875549, -0.25121942162513733, 0.5512174963951111, 0.15905776619911194, 1.1034700870513916, 0.4151464104652405, -0.8161064982414246, 0.5983645915985107, 0.16717857122421265, 0.155183345079422, -0.09536083042621613, 0.30351513624191284, -0.5505343079566956, 0.10017866641283035, -0.14096787571907043, -0.35933464765548706, -0.08622065931558609, -0.643980085849762, -0.5142282843589783, -0.19249041378498077, -0.11119960248470306, -0.29813310503959656, -0.4983255863189697, 0.14268502593040466, -0.4343283772468567, -0.4062190353870392, -0.23842184245586395, -0.9242429733276367, -0.1987633854150772, 0.6327704787254333, -0.2089579850435257, -0.7759681940078735, -0.051021791994571686, -0.3159677982330322, -0.1129971593618393, -0.0024588515516370535, -0.5159599184989929, 0.15744978189468384, -0.13025660812854767, -0.5671247839927673, -0.1699148714542389, -0.6613012552261353, -0.1793404072523117, 0.10022349655628204, 0.17570994794368744, 0.5356211066246033, 0.9167815446853638, 0.2645217180252075, 0.9024457931518555, -0.13019615411758423, 0.5584073066711426, -0.18009719252586365, 0.6385062336921692, -0.3706737458705902, -0.28840896487236023, -0.24462850391864777, 0.06889048218727112, -0.4680287837982178, -0.033151574432849884, 0.5004782676696777, -0.31991422176361084, 0.20547223091125488, 0.000174959801370278, 0.2844942510128021, -0.34689202904701233, 0.613181471824646, -0.44433727860450745, 0.37514084577560425, 1.0017962455749512, -0.5205746293067932, -0.31497135758399963, 0.03325860947370529, -0.1726411134004593, -0.7827251553535461, 0.07472272217273712, -0.27160608768463135, 0.49815845489501953, 0.819550096988678, -0.5792850852012634, 0.5631555914878845, 0.27518290281295776, 0.3712587058544159, -0.3359624445438385, 0.6605627536773682, -0.5414578318595886, -0.3412603437900543, -0.2137169986963272, -0.23962284624576569, -0.7372795939445496, 0.7215976715087891, -0.23183386027812958, -0.813071608543396, -0.47259801626205444, 0.617310106754303, -0.6646578907966614, -0.04979964345693588, 0.1466134488582611, -0.40105706453323364, -0.5109314918518066, -0.3613288402557373, 0.020175056532025337, -0.49447908997535706, -0.2309289425611496, -0.3542011082172394, 0.5970277190208435, -0.6281599402427673, -0.027394520118832588, -0.25894781947135925, -0.3613358736038208, -0.02893061749637127, -0.18538811802864075, 0.3974464535713196, -0.8008301854133606, -0.17782607674598694, -0.3262508511543274, -0.20227570831775665, 0.6303001642227173, -0.43119147419929504, -0.46847397089004517, 0.496700644493103, 0.2423344850540161, -0.6955015063285828, -0.3110850155353546, 0.21065349876880646, 0.10390609502792358, 0.6698560118675232, -0.15167605876922607, -0.3265392482280731, -0.4527716636657715, -0.931235134601593, 0.06604120135307312, -0.9385329484939575, -0.5395764112472534, 0.3176911473274231, -0.5058397650718689, 0.2392425686120987, 0.32976222038269043, 0.44287487864494324, 0.1485256552696228, 0.42414289712905884, -0.695868968963623, 0.684157133102417, -0.5460875630378723, -0.05966317281126976, 0.5021410584449768, -1.3143675327301025, 0.3548297584056854, 0.5627946853637695, 0.3504487872123718, 0.2639998495578766, 0.2964060306549072, 0.2773890495300293, 0.26474621891975403, 0.2584420144557953, -0.1469431072473526, -0.5553092360496521, 0.5953144431114197, 0.35830560326576233, 0.22926783561706543, -0.6532701253890991, -0.5200498700141907, 0.738266110420227, -1.0220597982406616, 0.6857271194458008, 0.20065465569496155, -0.2782103717327118, -0.4330892264842987, -0.6593261361122131, 0.9037812948226929, -0.6268103718757629, 0.4267798662185669, 0.1957307606935501, 0.17532333731651306, 0.3802964389324188, 0.6846650242805481, -0.5061951875686646, -0.2907068133354187, -0.6512442827224731, -1.361272931098938, -0.1374921202659607, 0.03240421041846275, 0.41976720094680786, 0.17797359824180603, 0.1939811110496521, 0.690779447555542, -0.6273486614227295, 1.3683665990829468, 0.5467799305915833, -0.7093837261199951, -0.27854013442993164, -0.03768949210643768, 0.16784554719924927, 0.9091002345085144, -0.2772558331489563, 0.5338025689125061, -0.2915373146533966, 0.49543529748916626, -0.48797422647476196, 0.25155308842658997, -0.39939379692077637, -0.12316599488258362, -0.06016784906387329, 0.7157906293869019, -0.4133906364440918, 0.0544314980506897, 0.22571322321891785, -0.36745381355285645, -0.9345724582672119, 0.5525570511817932, 0.022283397614955902, 0.3321404755115509, 0.6435226202011108, -0.7912126183509827, -0.5730828642845154, 0.5522757172584534, 0.2137477844953537, 0.5366736650466919, -0.026391763240098953, 0.5421614646911621, 0.3193518817424774, -1.650766134262085, 0.5257003903388977, 0.6932101845741272, -0.6251350045204163, -0.4800311028957367, -0.006611243821680546, -0.07141967117786407, 0.06747940927743912, -0.3500984311103821, -0.7882301807403564, 0.6893661618232727, 0.30778083205223083, 0.6253910660743713, 0.23074166476726532, -0.7142412066459656, 0.24621044099330902, -0.03456436097621918, 0.5150303840637207, -0.24347010254859924, 0.22343085706233978, 0.5090401768684387, 0.025527972728013992, -0.11716221272945404, 0.03254387155175209, -0.15691494941711426, 0.06263218820095062, -0.0923096239566803, 0.237664595246315, -0.660344660282135, 0.09869878739118576, 0.09328563511371613, 0.7185550332069397, -0.28348103165626526, -0.34508222341537476, -0.9354696273803711, 1.073788046836853, 0.7110975384712219, -1.172736644744873, -0.7080456018447876, 0.26573386788368225, 0.05465763807296753, 0.4019712805747986, -0.5530553460121155, -0.4222716987133026, 0.2703922390937805, 0.4066365957260132, -0.269033819437027, -0.4004265367984772, -1.1664581298828125, -0.24730506539344788, -0.25793296098709106, 0.04436163976788521, -0.5952741503715515, 0.1902415007352829, -0.010823443531990051, -0.768180251121521, -0.5436500906944275, -0.4332435429096222, 1.1660150289535522, -0.45545846223831177, -0.26042214035987854, 0.0606166236102581, 0.6890479326248169, -1.3375306129455566, -1.1991567611694336, -0.20892342925071716, -0.3646450340747833, -0.6037831902503967, 0.8013933300971985, -0.8673768639564514, -0.4381876289844513, 0.1563711166381836, 0.11031965166330338, 0.2618694305419922, 0.5308136343955994, -0.3520379066467285, -0.23422513902187347, -0.06677276641130447, 0.5156387090682983, -0.06025650352239609, -0.21618670225143433, 0.17386382818222046, -0.27737271785736084, 0.7482035160064697, 0.17519637942314148, -0.2748672664165497, -0.1523226648569107, 0.21607646346092224, 0.8004586696624756, -0.3130178451538086, -1.4167687892913818, -0.18360275030136108, 0.06615017354488373, -0.9090437889099121, 0.01568174920976162, -0.6597628593444824, -0.00039461394771933556, -0.38451653718948364, -0.012744116596877575, -0.4036845266819, 0.4769114851951599, 0.38276857137680054, -0.49954918026924133, 0.6727567315101624, 0.4351622462272644, -0.289620578289032, -0.04514691233634949, 0.49900177121162415, 0.400650292634964, 0.3804052770137787, -1.1340652704238892, 0.5977509021759033, 0.2714744508266449, -0.3495820164680481, 0.4600055515766144, -0.37408027052879333, 0.5637850165367126, 0.056514423340559006, -0.4868758022785187, -0.7381384968757629, 1.1930804252624512, 0.2877383530139923, 0.8287376165390015, 0.16896575689315796, 0.04521123692393303, -0.7300179600715637, -0.45098865032196045, -0.589443564414978, -0.08691176027059555, 0.34208106994628906, -0.18617413938045502, -0.6537266969680786, -0.17320632934570312, -0.5525219440460205, 0.9946868419647217, -0.16303275525569916, 0.3364192545413971, 0.1276065856218338, -0.26603996753692627, -0.3444129228591919, 0.6752164959907532, 0.01611206866800785, -0.020275074988603592, 0.5145503878593445, 0.3022032678127289, -0.8315476179122925, -0.002645710716024041, 0.18048083782196045, 0.2091790735721588, 0.727442741394043, -0.12631674110889435, 0.12206487357616425, 0.2947308421134949, 0.2938636839389801, 0.18951968848705292, -0.3292121887207031, 0.7903103828430176, -0.28674718737602234, 0.3326587975025177, -0.13489842414855957, 0.123445525765419, -0.4772988557815552, 0.2732199430465698, 0.23231413960456848, -0.3881054222583771, -0.6042999625205994, 0.4064275920391083, 0.011581466533243656, -0.30695071816444397, 0.4789724051952362, -0.31457042694091797, 0.1517726182937622, -0.3719864785671234, -0.20150600373744965, 0.8386766314506531, 0.3767753839492798, -0.12893663346767426, -0.05316364765167236, -0.501294732093811, 0.18580034375190735, 0.6445567607879639, 0.22842445969581604, 0.5724084973335266, 0.37101176381111145, -0.47874903678894043, -0.11063938587903976, -0.07225579023361206, -1.132610559463501, 0.5848409533500671, -0.1917380392551422, -0.053197115659713745, 0.5148624777793884, 0.48555994033813477, 0.5181437134742737, 0.06614353507757187, -0.5111016035079956, 0.7507212162017822, -0.5533339977264404, -0.32328730821609497, -0.23608337342739105, -0.47782883048057556, 0.324261337518692, 0.17864325642585754, 0.48001208901405334, -0.3649114668369293, 0.4391094446182251, -0.011681532487273216, -0.28609830141067505, 0.40917152166366577, 0.36448222398757935, -0.4509611129760742, -0.3315233886241913, 0.030695749446749687, -0.1853780448436737, 0.21457454562187195, 0.18947364389896393, -0.4375584125518799, 0.047401055693626404, 0.3622707426548004, 0.06460810452699661, -0.7171835899353027, 0.41202616691589355, -0.43384885787963867, -0.4597354531288147, 0.38829076290130615, -0.039622727781534195, -0.5392053723335266, -0.1814149171113968, 0.47964170575141907, -0.4871232509613037, 0.3430582582950592, 0.04609169065952301, 0.1247587725520134, 0.4745942950248718, 0.5569348931312561, 0.966434121131897, -1.032441258430481, -0.7249791622161865, 0.35054609179496765, -0.604711651802063, -0.15122297406196594, 0.4169470965862274, 0.25244906544685364, -0.37736964225769043, -0.3618758022785187, -0.1069846823811531, -0.13914182782173157, -0.018291495740413666, -0.5546275973320007, 0.6475552320480347, -0.43062400817871094, -0.4385570287704468, -0.5076373219490051, -0.45144444704055786, -0.6672684550285339, 0.3189423978328705, -0.42073333263397217, 0.3194819986820221, 0.024399427697062492, -0.3601206839084625, -0.20412272214889526, -0.14124837517738342, -1.329140067100525, 0.37278416752815247, -0.5878946781158447, 0.049731459468603134, -0.16626964509487152, 0.40495622158050537, -0.21725541353225708, -0.9274199604988098, 0.16367436945438385, -0.06404745578765869, 0.23330514132976532, -0.8475285172462463, 0.10268185287714005, 0.2282964289188385, 0.7966101765632629, 0.4099845886230469, -0.10858763754367828, 0.4462839663028717, 0.38391366600990295, 0.7745993733406067, 0.5701797008514404, 0.6167232990264893, 0.10211020708084106, 0.2841896116733551, 0.2859613299369812, 0.3982797861099243, 0.04585735499858856, -0.1581982672214508, -1.2509983777999878, -0.347896009683609, 0.4859241545200348, -0.1285180300474167, -0.3668796420097351, 0.042168475687503815, 0.7275332808494568, -0.29370060563087463, -0.23014312982559204, -0.6410353183746338, -0.3552473187446594, -0.724835991859436, 1.2527586221694946, -0.6630939841270447, -0.4770181477069855, -0.07398757338523865, -0.7219192981719971, 0.6848835945129395, -0.5666684508323669, 4.096414566040039, 1.1391830444335938, 0.5969258546829224, -0.3183385133743286, 0.2310130000114441, -0.07165490835905075, 0.7761192917823792, -0.026312677189707756, 0.2764338552951813, 0.005213422235101461, -0.40141844749450684, -0.10214535146951675, -0.09703892469406128, -0.15427476167678833, 0.5055349469184875, 0.15656891465187073, -1.142531156539917, 0.3383706510066986, 0.0851474329829216, -1.2110456228256226, -0.651498019695282, 0.09747970104217529, -0.9847267866134644, -0.06261298060417175, -0.004555362276732922, -0.45287975668907166, 0.3465789556503296, 0.1875361204147339, 0.0930885523557663, 0.0424131341278553, -0.019250784069299698, -0.5127328038215637, 0.35495561361312866, -0.7324143648147583, -0.555594265460968, 0.09788490831851959, -0.4470122754573822, -0.6642362475395203, 0.1610194593667984, 0.33420929312705994, 1.32903254032135, 0.1772954910993576, -0.18361563980579376, 0.1238669604063034, -0.06081108748912811, 0.6876076459884644, -0.3491574227809906, 0.10633928328752518, 0.4896021783351898, -0.3080783486366272, 0.8726563453674316, -0.4946587085723877, -0.008430257439613342, -0.40888169407844543, -1.1205168962478638, -0.9171643853187561, 0.21705463528633118, -0.8650169372558594, 0.5037400722503662, 0.1448628306388855, 0.9704462885856628, 0.16321395337581635, 0.2854228615760803, 0.5775482058525085, -0.3055499196052551, 0.2559888958930969, -0.07502429187297821, -0.027904657647013664, -0.1272226721048355, -0.1832878738641739, 0.23820076882839203, -0.5540504455566406, -0.21556785702705383, -0.01931736245751381, 0.874920666217804, -0.2238718420267105, -0.25071272253990173, 0.46423056721687317, 0.018872173503041267, -0.917305588722229, 0.3697311282157898, 0.0730806291103363, 0.3424978256225586, -0.2811151146888733, 0.3150985836982727, 1.2155497074127197, -0.4761909246444702, -0.053214047104120255, -0.549764096736908, 0.509990394115448, 0.48691239953041077, -0.05399122089147568, -0.41281911730766296, 0.33029985427856445, -0.0061260717920959 ]
{"Title": "The epidemiology of systematic review updates: a longitudinal study of updating of Cochrane reviews, 2003 to 2018", "Authors": "Bastian Hilda, Doust Jenny, Clarke Mike, Glasziou Paul", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background The Cochrane Collaboration has been publishing systematic reviews in the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews ( CDSR ) since 1995, with the intention that these be updated periodically. Objectives To chart the long-term updating history of a cohort of Cochrane reviews and the impact on the number of included studies. Methods The status of a cohort of Cochrane reviews updated in 2003 was assessed at three time points: 2003, 2011, and 2018. We assessed their subject scope, compiled their publication history using PubMed and CDSR , and compared them to all Cochrane reviews available in 2002 and 2017/18. Results Of the 1,532 Cochrane reviews available in 2002, 11.3% were updated in 2003, with 16.6% not updated between 2003 and 2011. The reviews updated in 2003 were not markedly different to other reviews available in 2002, but more were retracted or declared stable by 2011 (13.3% versus 6.3%). The 2003 update led to a major change of the conclusions of 2.8% of updated reviews (n = 177). The cohort had a median time since publication of the first full version of the review of 18 years and a median of three updates by 2018 (range 1\u201311). The median time to update was three years (range 0\u201314 years). By the end of 2018, the median time since the last update was seven years (range 0\u201315). The median number of included studies rose from eight in the version of the review before the 2003 update, to 10 in that update and 14 in 2018 (range 0\u2013347). Conclusions Most Cochrane reviews get updated, however they are becoming more out-of-date over time. Updates have resulted in an overall rise in the number of included studies, although they only rarely lead to major changes in conclusion.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19014134"}
10.1101/19007500
[ -0.2859369218349457, 1.1048884391784668, -0.4046102464199066, 0.005410393700003624, 0.8386698961257935, -0.23036159574985504, -0.3160862624645233, 0.5359827876091003, 0.00457502668723464, 0.5741875767707825, -0.6715709567070007, -0.22852179408073425, -0.002718362957239151, -0.11959242075681686, -0.8572366237640381, 0.29835525155067444, -0.9130046963691711, -0.315963476896286, -0.03124876692891121, 0.057733599096536636, -0.04554181918501854, 1.1949585676193237, -0.6808636784553528, -0.2790783941745758, -0.06697828322649002, 0.8457310795783997, -0.23572368919849396, 0.1357477903366089, 0.8601748943328857, 0.7631062269210815, 0.08015642315149307, -0.6566884517669678, 0.6640812158584595, -0.40005260705947876, -0.5943137407302856, 0.1347743272781372, 0.5244655013084412, -0.3298729360103607, 0.021881455555558205, -0.5767533779144287, -0.09739187359809875, 0.2482268065214157, 0.6969070434570312, -0.44089072942733765, -0.37726733088493347, -0.3970623016357422, -0.4686875641345978, 0.8067753911018372, 0.6897075772285461, 0.2744755744934082, -0.3039952516555786, -0.361369252204895, 0.7745038866996765, -0.6221651434898376, -0.2968197762966156, -0.704109251499176, 0.2342063933610916, -0.14371098577976227, -0.47295770049095154, 0.20897841453552246, 0.1799919158220291, -0.10521071404218674, 0.2773996889591217, -0.7502596378326416, -0.20284993946552277, 0.7307165861129761, 0.35675111413002014, -0.4355432391166687, 0.060880281031131744, 0.6631922721862793, -0.4088333547115326, 0.2665371298789978, -0.4047189950942993, 0.02406817488372326, -0.13445068895816803, -0.6347649693489075, -0.735724925994873, -0.14487700164318085, 0.11012662947177887, 0.8487111926078796, -0.1589299738407135, -0.012245947495102882, 0.8785375356674194, 0.025280995294451714, -0.5656482577323914, -0.0010582933900877833, 0.16250446438789368, 0.34997862577438354, 0.5355396270751953, 1.0889557600021362, 0.06746180355548859, 0.1027057021856308, 0.3897525370121002, -0.19429749250411987, 0.5897735357284546, 0.7626484036445618, -0.12354523688554764, 0.4041849970817566, 0.09537185728549957, -0.4866217076778412, 1.0510118007659912, 0.4827820062637329, 0.15176039934158325, 0.17534543573856354, -0.3498062193393707, 0.6999660134315491, 0.48447495698928833, 0.05103110149502754, -0.5044746398925781, -0.42029479146003723, -0.11532684415578842, -0.16851021349430084, -0.5072425007820129, -0.48344194889068604, 0.7614704370498657, 0.7460962533950806, 0.20979945361614227, 1.1185359954833984, -1.0729951858520508, 0.46076855063438416, -0.5891727805137634, 0.46084925532341003, 0.22119548916816711, -0.47424980998039246, 0.19145043194293976, 0.29221591353416443, -0.5306239724159241, 0.6836079955101013, -0.5932065844535828, -0.15480099618434906, 0.4245549440383911, 0.008006875403225422, -0.41243302822113037, 0.6443026661872864, 0.25315308570861816, -0.4265754222869873, 0.6086731553077698, 0.6055149435997009, -0.18932700157165527, -0.499994695186615, -0.5219452381134033, 0.2880626618862152, -0.7252219319343567, 0.878555417060852, -0.2450777292251587, 0.8796143531799316, -0.5566433072090149, -1.2999018430709839, -0.44447264075279236, -1.1247097253799438, -0.437532514333725, 0.3096545338630676, -0.2894687354564667, -0.26284509897232056, -0.08491300791501999, 0.6650989055633545, -0.5878962278366089, -0.5789709091186523, -0.2057778239250183, -0.6373096704483032, -0.38884034752845764, 0.09279263019561768, -0.2331174612045288, 0.30550938844680786, -0.6408969759941101, 0.29200565814971924, -0.14632807672023773, 0.2001621127128601, 0.6519558429718018, -0.6276959180831909, 0.6075230240821838, -0.03715399652719498, -0.21285054087638855, 0.5498991012573242, 0.4356984794139862, 0.8079206347465515, 0.2910551130771637, -0.3693050146102905, 0.2106209248304367, 0.7271783351898193, 0.07181766629219055, -0.26524171233177185, 0.009412233717739582, -0.02543557807803154, 0.3633825182914734, 0.4329061806201935, -0.7177767157554626, -0.6687771081924438, 0.1285836547613144, -0.632858157157898, -0.0211758092045784, 0.6024110317230225, -0.10235752165317535, 0.6872491240501404, -0.7326866388320923, -0.678904116153717, -0.03515070676803589, 0.4659026563167572, 0.5551808476448059, -0.028351081535220146, -0.516812264919281, 0.8592798709869385, -0.18952031433582306, 0.7546418309211731, -0.2487523853778839, 0.5236696600914001, 0.4356708824634552, 0.26576435565948486, -0.12432549148797989, 0.19352446496486664, 0.29118475317955017, -0.5939988493919373, 0.009240158833563328, -0.09383807331323624, 0.8737693428993225, -0.4043846130371094, -0.48313406109809875, 0.09298187494277954, -0.6269760727882385, -0.039460644125938416, 0.32166680693626404, -0.4236779510974884, 0.6364112496376038, 0.4825722277164459, -0.1550150066614151, 0.3675922751426697, 0.8288456797599792, -0.11814151704311371, -0.01250716857612133, 0.27275845408439636, 0.21346977353096008, 0.7052003741264343, -0.5227534174919128, 0.2138521522283554, 0.5660772323608398, 0.209428608417511, 0.32376331090927124, 0.39925330877304077, 0.13868464529514313, 0.4436003863811493, 0.05262532830238342, 0.017615824937820435, 0.43505164980888367, 0.4048483073711395, -0.5705825686454773, 0.9425609707832336, -0.8727903366088867, 0.23235855996608734, -0.24322742223739624, 0.7440080642700195, -0.4477437138557434, 0.7850517630577087, 0.6895669102668762, 0.6424736976623535, 0.003350289538502693, -0.1753387153148651, -0.40160441398620605, -0.20693586766719818, 0.25301486253738403, -0.5498940348625183, -0.23324963450431824, 0.519258975982666, -0.41620001196861267, -0.43846654891967773, 0.6521391272544861, 0.45223861932754517, -0.11741393059492111, 0.2867783308029175, 0.3437564969062805, -0.3679782450199127, -0.556360125541687, -0.5504166483879089, -1.0097705125808716, -0.3711168169975281, -1.200261116027832, 0.3345460593700409, -0.09446720033884048, -0.8036768436431885, 0.6589571833610535, -0.3269478976726532, -0.6687009930610657, 0.2494570016860962, -0.2125086933374405, 0.741813600063324, 0.041471242904663086, 0.27929651737213135, -0.8271564841270447, -0.059291765093803406, -0.02008531615138054, -0.19705256819725037, 0.12471707165241241, -0.1820962280035019, -0.18950316309928894, -0.5595553517341614, 0.6336923241615295, -0.47273749113082886, 0.24971486628055573, 0.9355654120445251, -0.4989013075828552, -0.10355978459119797, 0.49398237466812134, 0.003017685143277049, 0.15216657519340515, 0.13603374361991882, -0.4263676404953003, 0.6477718353271484, -0.3462446630001068, 0.07364910840988159, 0.7839040756225586, 0.8053425550460815, -0.8509354591369629, 0.3142799437046051, 0.36895453929901123, 0.09697729349136353, -0.7783592343330383, 0.14102141559123993, -0.2623831331729889, -0.23051999509334564, 0.3256412446498871, -0.29860058426856995, -1.0384355783462524, -0.6958449482917786, -0.42625340819358826, 0.10631401836872101, 0.0202668234705925, 0.684592068195343, -0.6042959094047546, -1.0321033000946045, 0.3231024146080017, -0.8283472657203674, -0.48951488733291626, -0.15505795180797577, 0.11817751824855804, 0.2711213231086731, -0.2347334623336792, 0.12201472371816635, 0.08876336365938187, -0.18054437637329102, 0.4697800576686859, 0.7455682754516602, -0.18586380779743195, 0.6327004432678223, -0.21167178452014923, 0.0988624095916748, 0.24160990118980408, 0.5083177089691162, -0.3152601420879364, -0.575314998626709, -0.5332304239273071, 0.30592867732048035, 0.318748414516449, -0.12614157795906067, 1.1819056272506714, -0.24227090179920197, -0.3049713969230652, 0.3303196132183075, -0.40281254053115845, 0.3833160400390625, 0.1317552775144577, 0.05055301636457443, -0.16648931801319122, 0.3380356729030609, -0.6924610733985901, 0.4640207290649414, -0.49101051688194275, -0.6377401351928711, 0.868493914604187, 0.5220683217048645, 0.27163758873939514, -0.7784850597381592, 0.7243543267250061, -0.06870149821043015, -0.7016431093215942, 0.0653543546795845, 0.5518636703491211, -0.04012670740485191, 0.7046021223068237, 0.19704246520996094, 1.3603417873382568, -0.6326780915260315, 0.6616051197052002, 0.6966157555580139, 0.767467200756073, -0.28923988342285156, -0.030705906450748444, 0.532926082611084, -0.46077433228492737, 0.2202053815126419, 0.4835985004901886, -0.4704781472682953, 0.23841272294521332, -0.5463082790374756, 0.039768680930137634, -0.39275988936424255, -0.03244487941265106, -0.5383629202842712, 0.13227753341197968, 0.30563685297966003, 0.6482950448989868, -0.05768056958913803, 0.7823185324668884, -1.054581642150879, 0.4604635536670685, 0.6371088027954102, 0.6825555562973022, 0.4187987446784973, -0.9252344965934753, 1.158360481262207, -0.262445867061615, -0.11694326251745224, 0.025840699672698975, -0.12464167177677155, -0.029132628813385963, -0.586633026599884, 0.9115688800811768, -0.3604373335838318, -0.9448367357254028, 0.35660067200660706, 0.03873360529541969, 0.42835620045661926, 0.2846934199333191, 0.45625361800193787, -0.4243306517601013, 0.22261276841163635, -0.3366323709487915, -1.1421711444854736, -0.045192766934633255, -0.902645468711853, 0.6610933542251587, 0.6045945286750793, -0.29029878973960876, -0.39686357975006104, -0.86311274766922, -0.40976476669311523, -0.0679791197180748, -0.34456783533096313, 0.62491375207901, 0.2417108118534088, 0.34095320105552673, 0.036875706166028976, -0.17411965131759644, -0.2700684666633606, -0.16356328129768372, -0.08223438262939453, 0.21195665001869202, 0.21727561950683594, 0.6489067077636719, 0.18102984130382538, 1.1701056957244873, -0.2785198986530304, 0.37636372447013855, -0.6798425912857056, 0.6149286031723022, -0.9076910018920898, 0.021193183958530426, -1.0111192464828491, 0.09951391816139221, 0.12796013057231903, 0.32122716307640076, -0.06564943492412567, -0.8401853442192078, 0.04980785772204399, 0.18164490163326263, -0.34279659390449524, -0.38938531279563904, 0.6182191371917725, -0.3475242555141449, -0.15186409652233124, 1.0929068326950073, -0.5755226016044617, -0.09225405007600784, -0.502758800983429, -0.40874138474464417, -0.8197581171989441, 0.31917184591293335, 0.11550863087177277, 0.42851555347442627, 0.6392561793327332, -0.31747743487358093, 0.42091313004493713, -0.23052753508090973, -0.031166456639766693, -1.3010735511779785, 0.016852635890245438, -0.8695037364959717, -0.33872029185295105, -0.09583448618650436, -0.6348211765289307, -0.29249307513237, 0.7270331382751465, -0.038041021674871445, -0.5959039926528931, -0.46206721663475037, -0.3677543103694916, 0.11868878453969955, -0.21053947508335114, -0.08961549401283264, -0.6055781841278076, -0.14205598831176758, 0.37179896235466003, 0.5817661285400391, -0.6280701160430908, -0.6079351902008057, -0.0035918785724788904, 0.6424098014831543, 0.23576082289218903, -0.3311266601085663, 0.24556425213813782, -0.18801680207252502, -1.2093820571899414, -0.14136429131031036, 0.8907068371772766, -0.9143438339233398, -0.41719716787338257, -0.4149293303489685, -0.4659915566444397, 0.4399564266204834, 0.12848035991191864, 0.25285401940345764, 0.08662845194339752, -0.9004237055778503, -0.9693171381950378, -0.42972517013549805, 0.4211377203464508, 0.1709282547235489, 0.7225797176361084, 0.09919632226228714, -1.193076491355896, -0.9344290494918823, -1.0249193906784058, 0.20114485919475555, -1.1032347679138184, 0.3104078769683838, 0.16502808034420013, 0.1570834368467331, 0.06671846657991409, 0.4116898775100708, 0.16738608479499817, 0.2460150271654129, -0.04497619718313217, -0.058084893971681595, 0.048365164548158646, -0.5577465295791626, -0.6185621619224548, 0.5160839557647705, -0.9070831537246704, 0.19867157936096191, 0.7037285566329956, 0.0314028225839138, -0.16225549578666687, -0.07245145738124847, 0.6458564400672913, -0.13505615293979645, 0.5331276059150696, -0.730197012424469, 0.1516726166009903, 0.34250685572624207, 0.7866015434265137, 0.11450206488370895, -0.8315653800964355, -0.9831271767616272, 0.6783542633056641, -0.611297070980072, 0.19429327547550201, 0.04001471400260925, -0.331053763628006, 0.7392261624336243, -0.0422765277326107, 0.9599944353103638, 0.02167379856109619, -0.2794126272201538, 0.07037268579006195, -0.004641316365450621, -0.1345108151435852, -0.1363302320241928, -0.5343073606491089, -0.5925957560539246, -0.7949414849281311, -0.5375198721885681, -0.07542294263839722, 0.1359843760728836, -0.034333206713199615, 0.3114469349384308, 0.37479209899902344, 0.48383840918540955, -0.3264586925506592, 0.8958724141120911, 0.26543352007865906, -0.7409709692001343, -0.14993850886821747, 0.1100604385137558, 0.13561038672924042, -0.1280868798494339, 1.221389651298523, 0.5053673982620239, -0.5859979391098022, 0.10508907586336136, -0.05824153125286102, 0.10376469045877457, -0.4842820167541504, -0.31760796904563904, 0.2714691162109375, 0.463437020778656, -0.36641979217529297, -0.2070205956697464, 0.8622087240219116, -0.28918781876564026, -0.0739627480506897, 0.5550543665885925, 0.27884358167648315, 0.36352667212486267, 0.8552834391593933, -0.7054290175437927, -1.0999162197113037, 0.19903971254825592, -0.36755502223968506, 0.2720474898815155, 0.20777562260627747, 0.7422218918800354, 0.1975012719631195, -0.46829262375831604, 0.2021501511335373, 0.0510944165289402, -0.6275738477706909, 0.07996484637260437, -0.004614500794559717, -0.4431132674217224, 0.015038891695439816, -0.0981658548116684, -0.1262923628091812, 0.01799905300140381, -0.1462395191192627, 0.5511197447776794, -0.2940305471420288, 0.03024430386722088, -0.04363920912146568, 0.10330253839492798, 0.5780748128890991, -0.30671221017837524, 0.12719294428825378, 0.4835994243621826, -1.0480471849441528, 0.3122563362121582, 0.4444020986557007, 0.42971011996269226, -0.57912278175354, 0.6302242875099182, 0.15167498588562012, -0.2644377648830414, 0.18023690581321716, 0.08788404613733292, -0.43208879232406616, 0.2558963894844055, -0.28840669989585876, -0.25926750898361206, 0.4744481146335602, -0.07391594350337982, -0.8071319460868835, -0.22814252972602844, -0.10447057336568832, 0.5065486431121826, -0.2327514886856079, 0.7218683958053589, -0.08242812752723694, 0.004616859368979931, 0.8030569553375244, 0.7274620532989502, -0.07737359404563904, -0.9311859607696533, -0.3018822968006134, -0.5084729194641113, -0.1706635057926178, -0.9088318943977356, 0.6753140091896057, 0.9377199411392212, -0.13677409291267395, -0.7172887921333313, 0.8988906145095825, 0.634994626045227, -0.07359815388917923, 0.2706860899925232, -0.14112046360969543, 0.06296074390411377, -0.306759238243103, -1.037869930267334, -0.2526357173919678, -0.43194717168807983, -0.6658585071563721, 0.5695584416389465, -0.8757163286209106, 0.24691615998744965, 0.07824243605136871, 0.3328695595264435, 0.3087466359138489, -0.25818461179733276, 0.09419412165880203, -0.5635419487953186, -0.04197467118501663, 0.9930554032325745, 0.22136642038822174, -0.035744138062000275, 1.0828443765640259, -0.15599970519542694, 0.409047394990921, -0.2019583135843277, -0.3471825420856476, 0.6105116009712219, 0.2625991404056549, 0.5007202625274658, -0.2310112714767456, -0.902337908744812, -0.1443326622247696, 0.7748802304267883, -0.6928460597991943, -0.4564480185508728, -0.33763405680656433, -0.039523571729660034, 0.27850404381752014, 0.384929358959198, -0.3426241874694824, 0.8896522521972656, -0.02957654371857643, 0.23233124613761902, -0.11153286695480347, -0.0583021305501461, -0.19315403699874878, 0.25667184591293335, 0.11245675384998322, 0.30014559626579285, 0.6730809211730957, -0.686349093914032, 0.08791226893663406, 0.4985146224498749, -0.0737912580370903, 0.24208511412143707, 0.015679767355322838, 0.8156613111495972, 0.13570472598075867, 0.4316413998603821, 0.944662868976593, 0.5453643798828125, 0.21665802597999573, -0.20349253714084625, -0.50966876745224, -0.1626446396112442, -0.3479086458683014, 0.4615636467933655, -0.819930374622345, -0.6306744813919067, 0.5637308955192566, -0.35186758637428284, -0.18964487314224243, -0.5399017930030823, -0.6031902432441711, 0.7608749270439148, 0.3088560998439789, 0.2072466015815735, 0.028609992936253548, 0.5178928375244141, -0.12362056970596313, 0.6129106283187866, 1.0330363512039185, 0.25782784819602966, 0.08223209530115128, 0.3959653377532959, -0.5270630121231079, -0.7690335512161255, -0.08038835972547531, 0.16060347855091095, -0.09138500690460205, -0.5747576355934143, -0.5601385831832886, 0.41519615054130554, -0.3819749057292938, 0.025874467566609383, -0.45490261912345886, -0.7236925959587097, -1.0449258089065552, -0.013995770364999771, -0.4799005091190338, -0.1527850329875946, -0.5259166359901428, 0.1746445894241333, 0.3488749861717224, -1.2694307565689087, -0.595165491104126, 0.2032843828201294, 0.4270051121711731, 0.15898455679416656, 0.09641480445861816, 0.12903980910778046, 0.5650835633277893, 0.4486684501171112, -0.48765474557876587, 0.1786303073167801, 0.3020106554031372, -0.24030278623104095, -0.6120030283927917, 0.06661791354417801, 0.2632583975791931, 0.7780068516731262, 0.1368998885154724, 0.2813318967819214, 0.6534729599952698, 0.22370865941047668, -0.25212112069129944, -0.3629997968673706, -0.4905258119106293, 0.6050631403923035, 0.2434822916984558, -0.5907294154167175, -0.12456478923559189, 0.26544681191444397, 0.4324204921722412, -0.0494314581155777, -0.6108033657073975, 0.1089097186923027, -0.09917886555194855, -0.5349045395851135, -0.20526598393917084, 0.29396194219589233, 0.2632431387901306, 0.36650651693344116, -0.013986704871058464, -0.04623251035809517, 1.1234397888183594, -0.16725240647792816, 0.08243385702371597, 0.6830024123191833, -0.9992315173149109, 0.3609296977519989, 0.03912597894668579, 0.04577530547976494, 0.022076275199651718, -0.668976366519928, -0.5837923884391785, -0.17678771913051605, -0.30654382705688477, 0.25546956062316895, -0.20356997847557068, 0.042105529457330704, 1.1737185716629028, -0.6132920980453491, -0.46281325817108154, -0.08393686264753342, -0.13450153172016144, -0.8194998502731323, 0.18330954015254974, 0.9049654603004456, -0.49591320753097534, -0.1527375429868698, 0.4381828010082245, 0.5655602216720581, -0.2756751775741577, 0.1291835457086563, 0.5699793100357056, -0.2831825017929077, 0.4396118223667145, 0.6761859059333801, 0.12973235547542572, -0.028313184157013893, -0.2939058542251587, -0.518646776676178, -0.5177808403968811, -0.022384781390428543, -0.18703952431678772, 0.6052142977714539, -0.5401451587677002, -0.6037796139717102, 0.10357417911291122, 0.18843141198158264, -0.91527259349823, -0.3760506808757782, -0.06618671864271164, -0.38926398754119873, -0.35233891010284424, -0.25277525186538696, 0.513932466506958, 0.4357742369174957, 0.06419195234775543, 0.3792293071746826, 0.11623235791921616, -0.01904073916375637, 0.038854096084833145, -0.18934591114521027, 0.6965956091880798, -0.5286544561386108, -0.5164181590080261, 0.06519514322280884, -1.1219342947006226, -0.2672065794467926, 0.14742232859134674, 0.24780985713005066, -0.8350937962532043, 0.009463797323405743, 0.15514340996742249, 0.904167890548706, -0.12186155468225479, -0.2077694535255432, 0.21633362770080566, -0.01717497408390045, 0.7849026322364807, 0.02593754045665264, -0.013539392501115799, -0.23978646099567413, -0.2778376340866089, 0.1272193044424057, -0.3953414261341095, -0.30361735820770264, -0.3399408459663391, -0.6849616765975952, -0.9011083245277405, 0.728912889957428, 0.37976834177970886, -0.9509560465812683, -0.22010208666324615, 0.7264012098312378, -0.03640669584274292, -0.6019579768180847, -0.8762706518173218, 0.37287119030952454, -1.0478243827819824, 1.2384589910507202, -0.19850146770477295, -0.34945613145828247, 0.2038782685995102, -0.7404707670211792, 0.0887455940246582, -0.9538317322731018, 4.236557483673096, 0.9691062569618225, 0.5866555571556091, -0.7907831072807312, 0.5116580128669739, 0.2672923505306244, 0.5756077170372009, 0.2504797577857971, -0.27870070934295654, 0.4405214190483093, -0.7646680474281311, 0.5740823149681091, 0.587478756904602, 0.5287960767745972, 0.4299345314502716, -0.002448923420161009, -0.8741539120674133, -0.10591252893209457, -0.4136892259120941, -0.2008468061685562, -1.0568768978118896, 0.5888742208480835, -0.0822504460811615, 0.7778741717338562, -0.17265646159648895, -0.6074402928352356, -0.4148930013179779, -0.07023549824953079, 0.06285266578197479, 0.28782063722610474, 0.06640967726707458, -0.5597835779190063, 0.2621057629585266, -0.9034944176673889, -0.5657814145088196, -0.04093237221240997, -0.4171272814273834, 0.09860989451408386, 0.1939176768064499, -0.28139376640319824, 0.20786277949810028, -0.030221624299883842, 0.03361504524946213, 0.06866242736577988, 0.3590073585510254, -0.13927288353443146, -0.9701756238937378, 0.09741264581680298, 0.8094069361686707, -0.6237800121307373, 0.8831493854522705, -0.7328192591667175, 0.6393433213233948, 0.4299527406692505, -1.1068761348724365, -0.4866020083427429, -0.6815070509910583, -0.8569477796554565, 0.3592747747898102, 0.6934864521026611, -0.08233781903982162, -0.0689401924610138, -0.41321489214897156, 0.8827794194221497, -0.006038912106305361, 0.437259703874588, -0.3264099359512329, 0.07392559200525284, -0.13170777261257172, 0.23687483370304108, 0.3663012683391571, -0.9044936895370483, -0.430716872215271, -0.14080829918384552, 0.6414952278137207, -0.5502015948295593, -0.20677071809768677, 0.6605236530303955, -0.5454190969467163, -0.23996922373771667, 0.5108471512794495, 0.08898363262414932, 0.18951532244682312, -0.4481864273548126, -0.022925404831767082, 1.2047375440597534, -0.7851371169090271, -0.657662034034729, -0.8025806546211243, 0.32036393880844116, 0.4329533874988556, 0.12176307290792465, 0.20251859724521637, -0.26216986775398254, -0.686923623085022 ]
{"Title": "Isolated night cough in children: how does it differ from wheeze?", "Authors": "Jurca Maja, Goutaki Myrofora, Latzin Philipp, Gaillard Erol A., Spycher Ben D., Kuehni Claudia E.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Children with night cough but no wheeze might have a mild form of asthma (cough variant asthma), sharing risk factors with children who wheeze, and possibly developing wheeze later. Methods We compared risk factors of children with isolated night cough and children with wheeze in the Leicester Respiratory Cohort study at ages 1, 4, 6, and 9 years. We also compared prognoses of children with isolated night cough, children with wheeze, and asymptomatic children. Results Among 4,101 children at age 1 year, 2,854 at 4, 2,369 at 6, and 1,688 at 9 years, the prevalence of isolated night cough was 10% at age 1 and 18% in older children, while prevalence of wheeze decreased from 35% at 1 year to 13% at age 9. Although many risk factors were the same for cough and wheeze, day care, reflux, and family history of bronchitis were more strongly associated with cough, and male sex and family history of asthma with wheeze. Over one-third of pre-schoolers with cough continued to cough at school age, but their risk of developing wheeze was similar to that of children asymptomatic at earlier surveys. Wheeze tracked more strongly throughout childhood than cough. Conclusions Some risk factors for cough and wheeze were shared and some were not; there was little evidence that children with isolated night cough have an increased risk of future wheeze. This suggests that only a fraction of children with isolated night cough might have a variant of asthma, if at all.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007500"}
10.1101/19004499
[ -0.06550971418619156, 0.5181052088737488, -0.28745460510253906, 0.46744978427886963, -1.130936622619629, -0.8425601124763489, 0.10360097140073776, -0.20967218279838562, -0.13239048421382904, 0.24020642042160034, -0.27953311800956726, 0.10431386530399323, 0.7080502510070801, -0.28397178649902344, -0.286685049533844, 0.2588624656200409, -0.9179717898368835, 0.27964890003204346, 0.04176046699285507, -0.5075068473815918, 0.3920534551143646, 0.8814243674278259, -0.5981835126876831, 0.42932161688804626, -0.46550166606903076, 0.32630497217178345, -0.09017898887395859, -0.3590383231639862, 1.3943277597427368, 0.5275339484214783, -0.4244779348373413, -0.5727794766426086, 0.8824413418769836, 0.04431191459298134, -0.358354777097702, -0.2515895962715149, 0.8033396601676941, -0.8271476030349731, -0.4585660994052887, 0.07899604737758636, 0.43476706743240356, 0.644402801990509, -0.05983109027147293, -0.5135780572891235, -0.48825502395629883, -0.5583289861679077, 0.31953564286231995, -0.7049984335899353, 0.25622716546058655, -0.9227243065834045, -1.0401347875595093, 0.14725138247013092, -0.03537693992257118, -0.8720097541809082, 0.22601598501205444, -0.22178487479686737, 0.7732326984405518, -0.09212939441204071, -0.30601879954338074, -0.5058726072311401, 0.9714956879615784, 0.66851806640625, 0.19448380172252655, -0.3940806984901428, 0.6034712791442871, 0.30562490224838257, 0.10237594693899155, -0.2805835008621216, -0.21057777106761932, -0.5979433655738831, -0.8560286164283752, 0.724345862865448, -0.3673972189426422, -0.6856153011322021, -0.3357926309108734, -0.01641218550503254, 0.1500627100467682, 0.03879619389772415, -0.21183770895004272, -0.42092880606651306, 0.17913034558296204, 0.24069644510746002, 0.5522916316986084, 0.46749135851860046, -0.04489262402057648, -0.25485682487487793, 0.9884181618690491, 0.5348906517028809, 0.40534651279449463, -0.11857397109270096, 0.032978374511003494, -0.2834576368331909, 0.3815927803516388, 0.5131166577339172, -0.33320361375808716, 0.2260631024837494, -0.45920461416244507, -0.47666770219802856, 0.836506187915802, -0.11629242449998856, -0.21954669058322906, 1.30263090133667, 0.15516869723796844, 0.4791974127292633, -0.9070647954940796, 0.5804082751274109, 0.2425161898136139, -0.7394033670425415, 0.16680261492729187, -0.5892903804779053, 0.30565640330314636, 0.4827527403831482, -0.0739479511976242, -0.6742803454399109, -0.1405487358570099, 0.25452345609664917, 0.3429565727710724, 0.6090404987335205, -0.47821512818336487, 1.1108732223510742, 0.014144555665552616, 0.5945037007331848, 0.7744084000587463, -0.8719348311424255, 0.5884453654289246, -0.179241344332695, 1.23549222946167, 0.023328471928834915, -0.29539918899536133, -0.4972843825817108, 0.36559614539146423, -0.7118313908576965, -0.6019750833511353, 0.8133256435394287, -0.29145529866218567, -0.0645548477768898, 0.09489504247903824, 0.541012167930603, -0.11688251793384552, 0.06941025704145432, -0.4980485439300537, 0.19640570878982544, -0.03152448683977127, 1.2283440828323364, -0.3294092118740082, 0.8208100199699402, -0.5530133843421936, -1.0834451913833618, -0.03690410405397415, 0.3549869954586029, 0.47481608390808105, -0.0030234537553042173, 0.4356665015220642, 0.5854912400245667, 0.23394794762134552, -0.5286100506782532, -0.7166394591331482, 0.6424824595451355, -0.6909571290016174, 0.01420754287391901, 0.0785655677318573, 0.3623955249786377, -0.39850926399230957, 1.0227112770080566, 0.22595727443695068, 0.267361581325531, 0.1354789435863495, 0.047878362238407135, -0.3946283757686615, -0.5730454325675964, 0.5890027284622192, 0.5725982189178467, 0.2880057394504547, 0.06866110861301422, 0.2662738263607025, 0.4910632371902466, 0.8576211333274841, 0.11799811571836472, 0.05363120883703232, 0.7485357522964478, -0.3331475555896759, -0.5236219167709351, 0.8585453629493713, 0.5540359020233154, -0.5448235273361206, 0.6414466500282288, 0.053791943937540054, -0.4766768515110016, 0.05230100825428963, -0.017090365290641785, 0.5153017044067383, 0.5532868504524231, -1.2472862005233765, 0.5768252015113831, -0.056134507060050964, -0.5806553959846497, -0.02924780175089836, 0.38679295778274536, 0.5116075277328491, -0.37016069889068604, -0.15323406457901, 0.008886565454304218, 0.12254619598388672, 0.05315404757857323, -0.6947399377822876, 0.6828870177268982, 0.6224736571311951, 0.25331562757492065, 0.0283780749887228, -0.31451061367988586, 0.3777461051940918, -0.3696434795856476, -0.12844543159008026, 0.8064032196998596, 1.5062886476516724, -0.19634124636650085, 0.390136182308197, -0.1880389004945755, -0.050315599888563156, -0.5059323310852051, -0.2013222873210907, 0.32681721448898315, 0.6796146035194397, 0.5213248133659363, 0.3661484718322754, 0.3984973430633545, -0.5829167366027832, -0.017096128314733505, -0.1845790147781372, -0.34805771708488464, -0.044241003692150116, 0.39924752712249756, -0.03437716141343117, 0.1385626345872879, 0.5390433073043823, -0.037550318986177444, 0.07073312997817993, 0.5918453335762024, 0.49962764978408813, -0.08523150533437729, 0.3765771687030792, 0.39529767632484436, 0.3909851908683777, 0.1565183699131012, -0.027591129764914513, 0.23739054799079895, -0.24334648251533508, 0.037879545241594315, -0.2305675745010376, -0.1380973905324936, -0.003995824605226517, 0.7420046925544739, -0.0270156841725111, 0.21117304265499115, -0.6604276895523071, -0.4570203423500061, -0.18602950870990753, 0.7499738335609436, -0.5510249137878418, -0.3165755271911621, -0.2532365918159485, 0.16072440147399902, 0.7357637882232666, 0.216963991522789, 0.32324448227882385, 0.22171013057231903, -0.18846552073955536, 0.035587940365076065, -0.38585734367370605, -0.5020806789398193, -1.125138521194458, -0.5366026163101196, -0.9034706950187683, -0.2730534076690674, -0.6849823594093323, -0.5684526562690735, -0.24481450021266937, -0.7648940086364746, 0.8468677401542664, -0.6505699753761292, -0.132044717669487, -0.6637150645256042, 0.1213262677192688, 0.3213403522968292, -0.411105215549469, 0.10573951154947281, -1.4288750886917114, -0.12388110160827637, -0.3513215482234955, 0.6458489298820496, -0.4769250452518463, -0.7001998424530029, -0.6341438293457031, -0.7717009782791138, 0.4382498860359192, -0.7897030711174011, 0.15527620911598206, 0.04670370742678642, -0.3470815420150757, -0.6705224514007568, 0.6307308673858643, -0.15774637460708618, 1.072956919670105, 0.015981459990143776, 0.07759062200784683, 0.07263109087944031, -0.12542149424552917, 0.27205848693847656, 0.5874406695365906, 0.45420804619789124, -0.8622264266014099, 0.04437100887298584, 0.28862521052360535, -0.5342059135437012, -0.3040074408054352, 0.6751899123191833, 0.1418246030807495, -0.42095619440078735, -0.2922409474849701, -0.4794537425041199, -0.6570873856544495, 0.15883608162403107, -0.2179882675409317, -0.6142184138298035, 0.20998717844486237, 0.3601994216442108, 0.3808434009552002, -1.229485034942627, -0.00584804592654109, -0.8483689427375793, -0.8840255737304688, 0.2952161431312561, 0.009832306765019894, 0.4008004069328308, -0.22061020135879517, 0.10159818828105927, 0.02036881633102894, -0.4526785612106323, 0.7606451511383057, 0.27047404646873474, 0.24040253460407257, -1.4365239143371582, -0.03740348294377327, 0.18292568624019623, 0.04737025871872902, 0.7578343749046326, -0.14590954780578613, -1.0765846967697144, -0.141258105635643, -0.17268699407577515, -0.6229392290115356, 0.4159022271633148, 0.9162639379501343, -0.11405866593122482, 0.4338136315345764, 0.6627676486968994, -0.5039417147636414, 0.13768041133880615, 0.3226047456264496, 0.48366299271583557, 0.531342089176178, -0.027205681428313255, -0.4210190773010254, -0.372824490070343, -0.4110806882381439, -1.0822153091430664, 0.422762930393219, -0.21625027060508728, 0.09230551868677139, -0.5953414440155029, 0.8527926802635193, -0.3594362139701843, 0.5426977872848511, 0.048496030271053314, -0.13643710315227509, -0.7412611842155457, 0.9858114719390869, -0.35515928268432617, 0.7090886235237122, -0.9330831170082092, 1.0381871461868286, 1.1234393119812012, 0.20282495021820068, -0.6263207197189331, -0.4271319806575775, -0.22775909304618835, -0.19391509890556335, 0.2764767110347748, 0.6379382014274597, -0.0027108085341751575, -0.1037851944565773, -0.6285127401351929, 0.3458065092563629, -0.40995994210243225, -0.7696714997291565, -0.33578017354011536, -0.24113255739212036, 0.5772239565849304, 0.31278151273727417, -0.6565955877304077, 0.8318322896957397, -0.34497445821762085, -0.17331978678703308, 0.27722352743148804, 0.1775386780500412, -0.35628700256347656, -1.1752904653549194, 0.2957152724266052, -0.06709889322519302, -0.5884031057357788, -0.588681697845459, 0.39823099970817566, 0.32485663890838623, 0.20330850780010223, 0.5445288419723511, 0.3126160502433777, -0.33035388588905334, -0.7417951226234436, -0.606346845626831, -0.25423842668533325, 0.14618700742721558, -0.17157991230487823, -0.5884353518486023, -0.0935659408569336, 0.3423178493976593, -0.4636324942111969, -0.24112986028194427, -0.4728565216064453, -0.013120515272021294, 0.5938099026679993, -0.2637491524219513, -0.1245555430650711, 0.014673196710646152, -0.7579245567321777, 0.33419838547706604, -0.21089842915534973, -0.20573291182518005, 0.7899751663208008, 0.0533602312207222, -0.7555217146873474, -0.4394105076789856, -0.5160711407661438, -0.14436236023902893, -0.20549362897872925, -0.10358047485351562, 0.6181275844573975, 1.020721197128296, 0.37091803550720215, 0.07135613262653351, 0.5154713988304138, 0.741759181022644, -0.884163498878479, 0.847496509552002, -0.3253595232963562, -0.2230093628168106, 0.07555457204580307, -0.10739890486001968, -0.2989555597305298, 0.848887026309967, -0.7068998217582703, -0.35246890783309937, -0.6970948576927185, -0.17079098522663116, -0.5253749489784241, -0.16831418871879578, 0.7796521186828613, -0.07896756380796432, 0.23506373167037964, 0.708467960357666, -0.7815380096435547, -0.34041503071784973, 0.30119216442108154, 0.3224252164363861, -0.2875126898288727, 1.171920895576477, -0.2955933213233948, 0.49062129855155945, -0.09395234286785126, -0.3511974811553955, -0.7119961977005005, -0.10271552950143814, 0.37865790724754333, -0.4835759997367859, 0.27405601739883423, -0.7886455655097961, 0.07969839870929718, -0.3706221580505371, -0.2622382640838623, -0.9951847195625305, -0.047749925404787064, -0.770056962966919, -0.11143080145120621, 0.22184054553508759, -0.10416001081466675, -0.5806457996368408, 0.8120850920677185, -0.6265630722045898, 0.6590547561645508, -0.2823375165462494, 0.06153663620352745, 0.026777517050504684, -0.400105357170105, -1.143023133277893, -0.39325350522994995, 0.14566852152347565, -0.17953471839427948, -0.36884623765945435, -0.3367050588130951, -0.13156799972057343, 0.2110540121793747, -0.8397066593170166, 0.5795714855194092, -0.30230438709259033, 0.09333599358797073, -0.23800979554653168, -0.12118469923734665, 0.19914454221725464, -0.24825209379196167, -0.7708483934402466, 0.6790047883987427, -0.5168325304985046, -1.1458498239517212, -0.28118208050727844, 0.3677207827568054, 0.015131531283259392, 0.3365522027015686, -0.2352307140827179, -0.2769607603549957, -0.04190743342041969, -1.2462900876998901, 0.33117327094078064, -0.9351069331169128, 0.001062124385498464, 0.32942429184913635, -0.46102458238601685, -0.06694779545068741, -0.016756683588027954, 0.33523038029670715, -0.0981416180729866, -0.5716233253479004, 0.03659670054912567, -0.15645095705986023, -0.12432842701673508, -0.9137951135635376, -0.001287355669774115, -0.7111858129501343, 0.07310552150011063, 0.7112780809402466, 0.2239847630262375, -0.008396021090447903, 0.5567606091499329, 0.34274205565452576, 0.7436966300010681, -0.08773176372051239, 0.0073732417076826096, -0.8277475237846375, 0.040184348821640015, 0.5484136343002319, 0.505330502986908, 0.3790939748287201, -0.374801367521286, 0.4759964048862457, -0.4978235363960266, 0.7747758030891418, -0.8642703294754028, -0.5580417513847351, -0.35787642002105713, -1.287594199180603, 0.5204758048057556, -0.05836481228470802, 0.10192941129207611, 0.9029236435890198, -0.3573923110961914, -0.21791794896125793, -0.31545063853263855, -0.22880540788173676, -0.36144423484802246, -0.6454406380653381, -0.854335367679596, -0.005543481092900038, -0.15186361968517303, 0.11739502847194672, -0.00009749293531058356, 0.32300835847854614, 0.3253723680973053, -1.0311315059661865, 0.590107262134552, 0.3889090120792389, -0.2253478616476059, -0.3462115526199341, -0.6965237259864807, -0.3660653233528137, 0.1838741898536682, 0.6347424983978271, -0.12200118601322174, -0.43740156292915344, 0.11516548693180084, -0.21062129735946655, -0.5950055122375488, -0.7400931715965271, -0.30045923590660095, 0.34044384956359863, 0.1098775714635849, -1.1134073734283447, 0.49800220131874084, -0.41141271591186523, 0.48725810647010803, -0.5591636300086975, 0.9619485139846802, -0.22904375195503235, -0.5640257596969604, 0.748324990272522, 0.1370931714773178, -0.581692099571228, -0.4726082980632782, -0.17039288580417633, -0.17065651714801788, -0.038070857524871826, 0.38520359992980957, 0.2331012487411499, -0.6895136833190918, 0.5481976270675659, 0.687192976474762, -0.1506505012512207, -0.27458640933036804, -0.23719394207000732, -0.08083969354629517, 0.11433529853820801, -0.3136387765407562, -0.5628138780593872, 0.29383715987205505, -0.020277131348848343, 0.3755807876586914, 0.06710962951183319, -0.21816523373126984, 0.500870406627655, -0.39988768100738525, 0.4862543046474457, -0.814842939376831, -0.08639156073331833, 0.5112113952636719, -0.4132484793663025, 0.4455413818359375, 0.2904127836227417, 0.05699748545885086, 0.6743702292442322, 0.16951408982276917, 0.579384982585907, -0.20830276608467102, -0.20856668055057526, -0.0650215670466423, 0.3199842870235443, -0.041223734617233276, -0.4520522356033325, -0.013062319718301296, 0.5955836772918701, -0.07330474257469177, -0.04450871795415878, -0.8771353960037231, 0.6670193076133728, -0.09545232355594635, 0.7657036781311035, -0.4786895513534546, -0.09639277309179306, 0.3134815990924835, 1.2142432928085327, 0.012051033787429333, -0.3258679509162903, -0.46435531973838806, -0.44791457056999207, -0.32340380549430847, 0.27366116642951965, -0.4455869495868683, -0.5197128653526306, 0.1879936158657074, -0.4750276803970337, -0.5634878873825073, 0.283086895942688, 0.9431371688842773, -0.6467708945274353, -0.6130018830299377, -0.5810417532920837, -0.12133327126502991, -0.2777614891529083, -0.3044169247150421, -0.137932687997818, -0.9027965068817139, 0.16215567290782928, 1.069171667098999, -0.8343709707260132, -0.594546914100647, 0.146494522690773, -0.2165660858154297, -0.23516082763671875, 0.684718906879425, -0.3061297535896301, -0.16511553525924683, 0.1897035390138626, 0.3334929049015045, 0.17922088503837585, -0.3465804159641266, -0.21097466349601746, -0.21989309787750244, 0.8543994426727295, 0.7877916693687439, -0.028879253193736076, 0.4753269851207733, -0.09808139503002167, 0.2259586751461029, -0.2815670073032379, -0.3268601894378662, 0.45985016226768494, 0.055669158697128296, -0.4661194384098053, 0.2830143868923187, 0.2238920032978058, -0.22549448907375336, -0.16126640141010284, -0.45709550380706787, -0.07475288212299347, 0.5131077170372009, -0.16331183910369873, -0.7099787592887878, 0.06094623729586601, 0.5119809508323669, 0.7651172280311584, 0.21630990505218506, 0.477023184299469, 0.45056411623954773, 0.1457722783088684, -0.22665482759475708, -0.061070218682289124, 0.6349638104438782, 0.022813161835074425, 0.006483337376266718, -0.5842953324317932, 0.6513826251029968, 0.4644339978694916, -0.09049271792173386, 0.3248986601829529, 0.6719575524330139, -0.0660291537642479, -0.19439631700515747, 0.8363816142082214, -0.06061771139502525, -0.644069254398346, -0.518546462059021, -0.4122124910354614, -0.7064070105552673, 0.7986222505569458, -0.2879060208797455, 0.4334825575351715, 0.0022184483241289854, -0.7642890214920044, 0.19546891748905182, 0.4046286940574646, 0.4711192548274994, -0.26197516918182373, 0.47861117124557495, 0.08096405118703842, 0.5966730713844299, 0.009311692789196968, 0.3546316623687744, 0.5445248484611511, 0.4842968285083771, -0.8779296278953552, -0.451066792011261, 0.35782891511917114, 0.7355098128318787, 0.2623289227485657, -0.04853436350822449, -0.5057954788208008, 0.3734559714794159, -0.07995788007974625, -0.7668752670288086, -0.07519005984067917, -0.06716035306453705, -1.0076589584350586, -0.5006676316261292, -0.6259329915046692, 0.03361523896455765, -0.3416614532470703, 1.0492310523986816, 0.5865052938461304, -0.40737491846084595, -1.0193121433258057, -0.6717425584793091, 0.5148877501487732, -0.09155479073524475, 0.010010238736867905, -0.0827762633562088, 0.9009186029434204, -0.4655596613883972, -0.5097336769104004, 0.4817184507846832, -0.024761712178587914, 0.42550912499427795, 0.23438800871372223, -0.05391897261142731, 0.06447158753871918, 0.3477807939052582, 0.6416565775871277, 0.4743291139602661, -0.03283906355500221, -0.1206500306725502, -0.6464765071868896, 0.6243187189102173, -0.14061839878559113, 0.17679935693740845, -0.31467190384864807, -0.4857028126716614, 0.5408239364624023, -0.12887157499790192, 0.45067453384399414, -0.11294639855623245, -0.011475007981061935, 0.35063061118125916, -0.3051130771636963, -0.4939784109592438, -0.06653451919555664, 0.34000638127326965, 0.548071026802063, 0.17572392523288727, -0.15399393439292908, 0.12020501494407654, 0.011826182715594769, 0.4463678300380707, -0.08307018876075745, 0.5367159843444824, 0.2588035464286804, -0.2003360092639923, 0.17227987945079803, 0.2795165777206421, -0.08174177259206772, 0.6370874047279358, 0.11335952579975128, 0.257874459028244, -0.2556675970554352, 0.9018462300300598, 0.527350902557373, 0.3212662935256958, 0.9060434699058533, -0.44640740752220154, -0.33273136615753174, -0.004092280752956867, -0.4362553358078003, -1.3858153820037842, -0.13622328639030457, 0.4525989592075348, -0.5191583633422852, -0.1536119282245636, 0.11112623661756516, 0.47679945826530457, 0.21687383949756622, 0.47925472259521484, 0.5298236012458801, 0.14196239411830902, 0.42771095037460327, 0.2795466184616089, -0.4122970402240753, 0.017717840149998665, 0.03556831553578377, -0.46731117367744446, 0.3396727740764618, -1.051767110824585, 0.6136310696601868, 0.9294422268867493, 0.2442808449268341, -0.3538779616355896, 0.05487113818526268, -0.024519363418221474, 0.4125734865665436, -1.1856635808944702, 0.4758026599884033, -0.47127535939216614, 0.179317906498909, -0.5948357582092285, 0.5872864127159119, 0.4527036249637604, -0.23318438231945038, 0.009744526818394661, -0.11251034587621689, -0.7433229684829712, -0.18166188895702362, 0.11205834895372391, 0.08890794217586517, -0.5260576009750366, -0.34963253140449524, -0.14581476151943207, -0.6976878046989441, 0.8846361041069031, 0.8362178802490234, -0.24024836719036102, -0.617094099521637, 0.4142257571220398, 0.6321547627449036, 0.3951428234577179, 0.25686079263687134, -0.4779702425003052, 0.17052417993545532, 0.46314606070518494, 0.22666077315807343, -0.427120566368103, 0.5034231543540955, -0.02700943499803543, 0.0739172175526619, 0.5544780492782593, 0.07966334372758865, 0.06559817492961884, 0.2652238607406616, -0.9602217078208923, 0.06598129123449326, 0.03363931179046631, -0.029856963083148003, -0.44014254212379456, 0.6282053589820862, 0.6281183362007141, -0.24572846293449402, -0.24634389579296112, 0.08813745528459549, 0.24823489785194397, -0.5639028549194336, 0.9410338997840881, 0.043264955282211304, 0.8392155170440674, -0.3179301917552948, -0.3781760632991791, 0.22897621989250183, -0.5963039994239807, 4.292347431182861, 0.6718336939811707, 0.19947399199008942, 0.21834956109523773, 0.10711537301540375, -0.1127735897898674, 0.6592965126037598, -0.369310200214386, 0.10468298196792603, -0.17510554194450378, -0.40713104605674744, 0.24125374853610992, 0.476313054561615, 0.11989401280879974, 0.6538956165313721, -0.07012920081615448, -0.8238222002983093, -0.04652758315205574, 0.428830087184906, -1.430836796760559, -0.22138845920562744, 0.517493724822998, -0.5450320243835449, 0.05490405485033989, -0.08572352677583694, 0.005742209497839212, 0.3578585982322693, -0.12156415730714798, 0.3848968744277954, -0.5186827778816223, 0.5081623792648315, -0.5716489553451538, 0.9475368857383728, -1.134928584098816, -0.5444586873054504, 0.2983868420124054, 0.7244790196418762, -0.6495673656463623, -0.5175095796585083, -0.22347962856292725, 0.2139115035533905, 0.29663658142089844, -0.22599217295646667, -0.40257394313812256, -0.16824068129062653, 0.6236233711242676, -0.3180265724658966, 0.35570988059043884, 0.588861346244812, -0.6417722105979919, 1.162845253944397, -0.2640995681285858, 0.06894296407699585, 0.13243822753429413, -0.8049830198287964, -0.7026815414428711, -0.4158674478530884, -0.1483323723077774, -0.1441805511713028, 0.030139097943902016, 0.8329640626907349, 0.15725718438625336, -0.639409065246582, -0.26114699244499207, 0.1387912929058075, 0.5568439960479736, 0.11811314523220062, 0.37400713562965393, 0.38715043663978577, 0.5037487745285034, -0.06701432168483734, 0.21418888866901398, -0.1861909031867981, 0.4137962758541107, 0.5594289302825928, 0.3824019730091095, -0.43335384130477905, 0.2878970801830292, 0.5307285189628601, -0.04645972698926926, -0.28801342844963074, 0.7712951302528381, 0.5447799563407898, -0.0626416727900505, 0.29644593596458435, 0.5431127548217773, -1.0159504413604736, -0.9539421200752258, -0.848472535610199, 0.3277111053466797, 0.25264450907707214, 0.06485143303871155, -0.17762644588947296, 0.36364665627479553, -0.06015711650252342 ]
{"Title": "Rationalising neurosurgical head injury referrals: The development and implementation of the Liverpool Head Injury Tomography Score (Liverpool HITS) for mild traumatic brain injury", "Authors": "Gillespie Conor SN, Mcleavy Christopher M, Islim Abdurrahman I, Prescott Sarah, McMahon Catherine J", "Abstract": "Abstract Objectives To develop and implement a radiological scoring system to define a \u2018surgically significant\u2019 mild Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), stratify neurosurgical referrals and improve communication between referral centres and neurosurgical units. Design Retrospective single centre case-control analysis of ten continuous months of mild TBI referrals. Setting A major tertiary neurosurgery centre in England, UK. Participants All neurosurgical referrals with a mild TBI (GCS 13-15) during the period of 1 st January to 30 th October 2017 were eligible for the study. 1248 patients were identified during the study period, with 1144 being included in the final analysis. Interventions All patients\u2019 CT head results from the referring centres were scored retrospectively using the scoring system and stratified according to their mean score, and if they were accepted for transfer to the neurosurgical centre or managed locally. Main outcome measure Determine the discriminatory and diagnostic power, sensitivity and specificity of the scoring system for predicting a \u2018surgically significant\u2019 mild TBI. Results Most patients referred were male (59.4%, N=681), with a mean age of 69 years (SD=21.1). Of the referrals to the neurosurgical centre, 17% (n=195) were accepted for transfer and 83% (n=946) were not accepted. The scoring system was 99% sensitive and 51.9% specific for determining a surgically significant TBI. Diagnostic power of the model was fair with an area under the curve of 0.79 (95% CI 0.76 to 0.82). The score identified 495 (52.2%) patients in ten months of referrals that could have been successfully managed locally without neurosurgical referral if the scoring system was correctly used at the time of injury. Conclusion The Liverpool Head Injury Tomography Score (HITS) score is a CT based scoring system that can be used to define a surgically significant mild TBI. The scoring system can be easily used by multiple healthcare professionals, has high sensitivity, will reduce neurosurgical referrals, and could be incorporated into local, regional and national head injury guidance.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004499"}
10.1101/19000166
[ -0.1366824507713318, 0.428954154253006, -0.18139015138149261, 0.8256087899208069, -0.37887710332870483, 0.003016727976500988, -0.06708037853240967, 0.35445088148117065, -0.15515461564064026, 0.85826176404953, -0.948890745639801, -0.057531747967004776, 0.046620119363069534, -0.8248445391654968, -0.4073667526245117, 0.39822059869766235, -0.970888078212738, -0.7498522996902466, -0.8210848569869995, -0.08784846216440201, 0.5062739253044128, 0.2525339722633362, -0.9453755021095276, -0.15764473378658295, -0.33227232098579407, 0.5557005405426025, -0.1464751660823822, -0.1747753620147705, 1.1312572956085205, 0.5897310972213745, 0.8979349732398987, -0.2881135940551758, 0.29164958000183105, -0.5981823205947876, -0.49443015456199646, -0.4743026793003082, 0.97883540391922, -0.43050429224967957, 0.3783140778541565, -0.21673551201820374, 0.3883926570415497, -0.2629159092903137, 0.0996486023068428, -0.41005781292915344, -0.6217079758644104, -0.734666645526886, -0.11089532822370529, -0.2654346525669098, 0.3208451569080353, -0.46860459446907043, -0.11080171167850494, -0.0190188717097044, -0.08193598687648773, -0.46991434693336487, -0.23303167521953583, 0.43474841117858887, 0.052181340754032135, 0.3369315266609192, -0.37391120195388794, -0.11180189251899719, -0.05513647943735123, 0.4727371037006378, 0.6404018402099609, -1.7013733386993408, 0.7991117835044861, 0.10151628404855728, 0.29577741026878357, -0.5934609174728394, -0.7078449726104736, -0.932643473148346, -0.6633670926094055, -0.15335462987422943, 0.29691529273986816, -0.8280961513519287, -0.7573510408401489, 0.58792644739151, -0.2472541779279709, -0.187131866812706, 0.09041764587163925, -0.5811556577682495, 0.5223149657249451, -0.13258987665176392, -0.35202571749687195, 0.3797796964645386, -0.6183655261993408, 0.4577432870864868, -0.36164042353630066, -0.4315294623374939, 0.6738235950469971, -0.18733230233192444, -0.008665773086249828, 0.5282636880874634, 0.3662489950656891, 0.4734530448913574, -0.007099220994859934, 0.5367394685745239, -0.29355940222740173, -0.030841508880257607, 0.85242760181427, -0.22243976593017578, 0.03569507226347923, 0.6068238019943237, -0.12173465639352798, 1.2149819135665894, -0.5768131613731384, 0.8699101805686951, 0.28867828845977783, -0.3477357029914856, -0.7741908431053162, -0.6170186400413513, -0.15997214615345, 0.13504061102867126, -0.0675635039806366, 0.8578988909721375, -0.20382556319236755, 0.437545508146286, 0.403430312871933, 0.7342133522033691, -0.4931453466415405, 1.0753180980682373, 0.256178617477417, -0.468345582485199, 0.33163732290267944, -0.30320772528648376, 0.30396297574043274, -0.11872667074203491, 0.14752982556819916, 0.06599375605583191, -0.40105128288269043, 0.14935779571533203, 0.39633238315582275, -0.30190739035606384, 0.06057169288396835, 0.482176810503006, -0.30733662843704224, 0.14874112606048584, -0.4278930127620697, 0.6516414880752563, 0.2126442790031433, -0.19353310763835907, -0.5410529375076294, 0.36681053042411804, -0.24202960729599, 0.8214088082313538, -0.3590489625930786, 0.6343357563018799, -0.4725690484046936, -0.9088079333305359, -0.3495429456233978, -0.6296298503875732, -0.0974755585193634, 0.5133213996887207, -0.5346192717552185, 0.20835797488689423, 0.38265135884284973, -0.21881335973739624, -0.22675791382789612, 0.45191919803619385, -0.0037035010755062103, 0.3994113802909851, -0.04847266152501106, 0.15739259123802185, -0.2409931868314743, 0.4110170304775238, -0.26984184980392456, 0.829369068145752, -0.20826838910579681, 0.4755859971046448, 0.47814151644706726, -0.6133610606193542, 0.8023968935012817, 0.06497684866189957, 0.09290844947099686, -0.642715334892273, -0.3536573052406311, 1.0446382761001587, 0.6052544116973877, 0.5904137492179871, 0.6085535883903503, -0.14144237339496613, -0.05811451002955437, -0.24916425347328186, 0.2392628937959671, 0.2770187258720398, 0.15755745768547058, -0.5085296630859375, -0.797692060470581, -0.6669565439224243, -0.3945465683937073, -0.11520104110240936, -0.36859655380249023, 1.04454505443573, -0.12393496930599213, 0.14448443055152893, -0.17585456371307373, 0.010037897154688835, 0.10334029048681259, 0.31036341190338135, -0.5061635971069336, -0.5196486115455627, -0.32218852639198303, 0.15677165985107422, -0.6625344753265381, 0.02973063476383686, -0.9050599336624146, 0.6416131854057312, 0.35811111330986023, 0.7827669978141785, -0.28199976682662964, 0.3166382610797882, 0.7643916606903076, -0.3179752230644226, 0.35123294591903687, -0.3515562117099762, 0.8775981068611145, -0.34083473682403564, 0.13591121137142181, 0.30459341406822205, -0.7897015810012817, 0.2329462170600891, 0.2647443115711212, 0.07257069647312164, 1.0915745496749878, -0.08122719079256058, 0.665400505065918, 0.13263246417045593, 0.6900663375854492, 0.12923455238342285, -0.337814599275589, -0.04678750038146973, 0.12498753517866135, 0.8721919059753418, -0.1200995221734047, 0.48325952887535095, 0.7882435917854309, 0.7093640565872192, 0.3124360740184784, 0.1876402497291565, 0.079270139336586, 0.3202938735485077, 0.6712009310722351, 0.6017760634422302, 0.42398959398269653, 0.47299128770828247, -0.18368826806545258, 0.7900298833847046, -0.6010628342628479, 0.1768045574426651, -0.12871184945106506, -0.1166485995054245, -0.3683568835258484, 0.5785896182060242, 0.055312059819698334, 0.13059936463832855, -0.6852818131446838, -0.3222365975379944, 0.5543413758277893, 0.17083141207695007, -0.37071484327316284, -0.977659285068512, -0.12201358377933502, 0.27034857869148254, -0.05944529175758362, -0.30538687109947205, 0.22739022970199585, 0.8262743949890137, 0.10365380346775055, 0.3593725562095642, 0.7237963676452637, 0.04216166213154793, -0.465572714805603, -0.3470205068588257, -1.5202367305755615, -0.49866607785224915, -0.16123466193675995, -0.594243586063385, 0.01029345951974392, -0.14310859143733978, 0.6199833750724792, -0.4198017120361328, 0.24820812046527863, -0.7293670773506165, 0.21736159920692444, 0.4826033413410187, 0.3738517761230469, 0.23266442120075226, -0.96902996301651, 0.5792494416236877, -0.6169208884239197, 0.33120197057724, -0.1980854868888855, -0.6669237017631531, -0.19498643279075623, -0.05224204808473587, -0.1543780267238617, -0.8275651931762695, 0.0686391070485115, 0.7737056612968445, -0.5798152089118958, -0.34317493438720703, 0.2959132790565491, -0.1915968805551529, -0.5897805094718933, 0.055905070155858994, -1.1201257705688477, 0.8921938538551331, 0.42908763885498047, -0.193431094288826, 0.7053759694099426, 0.50948566198349, -0.44929590821266174, 1.062452793121338, 0.3062073886394501, -0.35736560821533203, -0.706518292427063, 0.20939688384532928, 0.7974137663841248, -0.524526834487915, 0.39129599928855896, -0.6506155729293823, -0.3053531050682068, 0.1992095708847046, 0.07912809401750565, 0.013180125504732132, 0.2544310390949249, -0.05855187773704529, -0.005659662652760744, -1.0146855115890503, 0.10229292511940002, -0.7014734745025635, -0.7795696258544922, -0.0019335263641551137, -0.047157756984233856, 0.028865745291113853, 0.6156384944915771, 0.01673796959221363, 0.054294321686029434, -0.5630021691322327, 0.08434069156646729, -0.009016922675073147, 0.14612360298633575, 0.20657573640346527, -0.6339199542999268, 0.5086346864700317, -0.10238395631313324, 0.347289115190506, -0.10848606377840042, -0.11013650894165039, -0.05598434805870056, 0.08304118365049362, -0.38913673162460327, 0.26063546538352966, 0.523177444934845, -0.11882629245519638, 0.12154297530651093, 0.04242447391152382, -0.16072329878807068, 0.003862290643155575, -0.18056261539459229, 0.2554825246334076, 0.01612749509513378, -0.29229408502578735, -0.06310053914785385, 0.33627066016197205, -0.34743180871009827, -0.09152761101722717, 0.6008637547492981, 0.7112385034561157, 0.06058868393301964, -0.7764779329299927, 0.10584109276533127, -0.4697944223880768, 0.33848410844802856, -0.06049235910177231, 0.14649294316768646, -0.3826344907283783, 0.9020471572875977, 0.09685641527175903, 1.5347977876663208, -1.3735920190811157, -0.02215506136417389, 0.5502481460571289, 0.8875947594642639, 0.28473949432373047, 0.6232803463935852, -0.10988175868988037, -1.126080870628357, 0.2969283163547516, 0.07865075021982193, -0.2911979854106903, -0.6821644306182861, 0.23863692581653595, -0.2868681848049164, -0.1378745436668396, -0.16927368938922882, -0.25643500685691833, -0.06496123969554901, 0.7138360142707825, 0.16060246527194977, 0.09082288295030594, 0.6809931993484497, 0.13024680316448212, -0.274599552154541, 0.7469544410705566, -0.17527686059474945, 0.07910412549972534, -0.6799671649932861, -0.020722605288028717, 0.12678027153015137, 0.08613213896751404, -0.03349649906158447, -0.15838681161403656, -0.6049215793609619, -0.12340172380208969, 0.5245490074157715, -0.036465030163526535, -0.20905275642871857, -0.19312363862991333, -0.5734661817550659, 0.5164642930030823, 0.6106123328208923, 0.3084140419960022, -0.7185630202293396, -0.018359044566750526, 0.5100728869438171, -0.2746913433074951, -0.8550695180892944, -0.8884175419807434, 1.0478487014770508, 0.9174181818962097, -0.6752924919128418, -0.34414491057395935, -0.0924496129155159, -0.18123184144496918, 0.31863072514533997, 0.010409475304186344, 0.13548414409160614, -0.12262649834156036, -0.13235878944396973, 0.2510679066181183, -0.3972226083278656, -1.0369467735290527, -0.6352883577346802, -0.4351046085357666, 0.49509191513061523, -0.10282484441995621, 0.9059661030769348, 0.42055565118789673, 0.3625265955924988, -0.09607347100973129, 1.1450798511505127, -0.9003008008003235, 0.5520537495613098, -0.3829575777053833, -0.0036477537360042334, -0.510245144367218, -0.35934507846832275, -0.2758735120296478, -0.1501535177230835, -0.5050500631332397, -0.1731647551059723, -0.2770376205444336, 0.1468912661075592, -0.04066205769777298, 0.7509708404541016, 1.3963146209716797, -0.4596831500530243, 0.21104484796524048, 0.8839905858039856, -0.10466241091489792, -0.18522122502326965, 0.20959210395812988, 0.09794855117797852, -0.5809984803199768, 0.2549712061882019, -0.1631190925836563, -0.4745340645313263, -0.12592972815036774, -0.21741700172424316, 0.14912734925746918, -0.8675158619880676, -0.13363544642925262, -0.17230628430843353, 0.2752693295478821, -0.21103547513484955, -0.5433253645896912, -0.3456118404865265, 0.06099143624305725, -0.2108743041753769, 0.45175859332084656, 0.3429982662200928, -0.6531168222427368, 0.24682191014289856, 0.009120704606175423, -0.36750805377960205, -0.10204152762889862, -0.7876178026199341, 0.5236948132514954, -0.6882803440093994, -0.16548030078411102, 0.2959578335285187, -0.7980157136917114, -0.6048579216003418, 0.3767780661582947, 1.0293710231781006, -0.890268862247467, -0.03157409653067589, 0.03099191002547741, -0.28823134303092957, -0.30675220489501953, -0.3629821836948395, 0.35497942566871643, -0.4440813958644867, 0.5843503475189209, -0.03039935790002346, -0.13794662058353424, 0.715438961982727, -0.25952404737472534, -0.2599227726459503, 0.14046548306941986, 0.03776469826698303, -0.8462325930595398, -0.4411350190639496, 0.1723041832447052, 0.3122205138206482, 0.048740167170763016, -0.07810032367706299, -0.16250111162662506, 0.026272691786289215, -0.8873785734176636, 0.0130503224208951, -0.19546034932136536, -0.19045309722423553, -0.3705958127975464, -0.6177194118499756, 0.11071265488862991, -0.09371951222419739, 0.6146923899650574, -0.05126122012734413, -0.4147150218486786, -0.5899952054023743, 0.9038936495780945, -0.6314259767532349, -0.3097499907016754, 0.4416244626045227, -0.3844461739063263, 0.13531158864498138, 0.9982706308364868, 0.0681314691901207, -0.0640353113412857, 0.8934840559959412, -0.003147045150399208, 0.6435447931289673, 0.22626212239265442, -0.4378483295440674, -1.0883800983428955, 0.42240414023399353, 0.26460620760917664, 0.5452332496643066, -0.7527729272842407, -0.14091798663139343, 0.7501319050788879, -0.6452159285545349, 0.15992766618728638, -0.3875228464603424, -0.12496697157621384, 0.43982836604118347, -0.7540415525436401, 0.8631799221038818, -0.7180917859077454, 0.30797818303108215, 0.4342220723628998, 0.1271035224199295, -0.4508489668369293, -0.2771282196044922, -0.9784392714500427, -0.4206498861312866, -0.3742934763431549, -0.9156033992767334, 0.4191429316997528, 0.430447518825531, -0.09635802358388901, 0.7078053951263428, -0.41883790493011475, -0.0416090302169323, -0.5382202863693237, 0.5065493583679199, 1.2318695783615112, -0.18581941723823547, 0.19692106544971466, 0.14710812270641327, 0.04317738860845566, 0.05223486199975014, 0.3271171748638153, -0.2152930051088333, -0.39534687995910645, -0.6587042212486267, -0.39647573232650757, -0.23110130429267883, -0.7154453992843628, 0.09467361122369766, 0.49405425786972046, 0.5855996608734131, -0.02901470847427845, 0.46951523423194885, -0.1467229425907135, 0.005681798793375492, -0.6830111145973206, 0.7551960945129395, -0.6272839307785034, 0.07272301614284515, 0.3157956302165985, -0.3513251543045044, -0.5405705571174622, -0.2686118185520172, 0.0015369696775451303, -0.5573041439056396, 0.12121670693159103, 0.43239742517471313, 0.7364364266395569, -0.9901636838912964, 0.15203508734703064, 0.6607049107551575, -0.3476044833660126, -0.49786296486854553, 0.18900296092033386, -0.03165823221206665, 0.5698726773262024, -0.3718142807483673, -0.2719137966632843, 0.8781183958053589, 0.1359058916568756, 0.16204892098903656, 0.038320813328027725, 0.09702921658754349, 0.5434362292289734, -0.7813044190406799, -0.04759986326098442, -0.6930846571922302, 0.16006915271282196, 0.4220345616340637, -0.1859613060951233, 0.4475509226322174, -0.19375164806842804, 0.35092777013778687, -0.29675233364105225, -0.029924549162387848, 0.27178293466567993, -1.1884024143218994, 0.01646437682211399, 0.20044465363025665, 1.054659366607666, -0.6343520283699036, -0.28784748911857605, 0.5259098410606384, 1.0310297012329102, 0.5465767979621887, -0.2756817042827606, -1.1448352336883545, 0.8600349426269531, 0.13907946646213531, 0.5921191573143005, -0.3144034147262573, 0.031094226986169815, 1.0347687005996704, 0.48522502183914185, -0.2879292964935303, -0.09039244800806046, -0.9593772292137146, -0.5404378771781921, -0.4221126437187195, 0.46672964096069336, -0.36632639169692993, 0.32796403765678406, 0.8272584676742554, -0.275656133890152, -0.9399830102920532, -0.5420336723327637, 0.5994024276733398, 0.05848773196339607, -0.4186495840549469, -0.12236405164003372, 0.8309605121612549, -0.5157612562179565, -0.25648415088653564, -0.7297989130020142, -0.028150301426649094, 0.10888894647359848, 0.3068526089191437, -0.6459934115409851, -0.3985377550125122, 0.4306640028953552, 0.017610596492886543, 0.37763726711273193, 0.844567060470581, -0.21989069879055023, -0.136204332113266, -0.19831451773643494, 0.42853590846061707, 0.45551297068595886, -0.020166579633951187, 1.7003260850906372, -0.18895871937274933, 0.39846673607826233, 0.37597861886024475, 0.30758196115493774, -0.890299916267395, 0.22434337437152863, 0.7785482406616211, -0.08730603009462357, -1.1812037229537964, 0.06027315557003021, 0.6401811838150024, -0.522717297077179, 0.04288019239902496, 0.19425638020038605, -0.3209073841571808, 0.22381483018398285, -0.20391975343227386, -0.039590414613485336, 0.451850950717926, 0.7194972634315491, 0.5144683122634888, -0.15408490598201752, 0.5199124217033386, -0.21940942108631134, 0.49135926365852356, 0.27853354811668396, 0.6739822626113892, -0.4958937168121338, -1.2698811292648315, 1.1749471426010132, 0.004234869498759508, -0.7238731384277344, 0.19948939979076385, -0.04510175809264183, -0.11405084282159805, 0.21325436234474182, -0.34563636779785156, -0.03371218219399452, 1.0109559297561646, 0.09411852806806564, 0.6106175184249878, 0.11422527581453323, -0.6449087858200073, -1.0210193395614624, -0.6182249188423157, -1.1002389192581177, 0.03660177066922188, 0.2202960103750229, -0.4521612524986267, -0.40422362089157104, -0.3962801396846771, -0.85942143201828, 0.5033763647079468, -0.20261892676353455, 0.5683536529541016, -0.20444802939891815, 0.41811391711235046, 0.6786803007125854, 0.5962744951248169, -0.7014320492744446, -0.4154643714427948, -0.23050852119922638, -0.06241239979863167, -1.0169516801834106, -0.23207029700279236, 0.008229631930589676, 0.14627999067306519, 0.23757226765155792, -0.3685952425003052, 0.29418373107910156, 0.08111119270324707, 0.2043280005455017, -1.2564136981964111, -0.9032564759254456, 0.2032560408115387, -0.35186371207237244, -0.3167921006679535, -0.31454095244407654, -0.05460530146956444, -0.06587731838226318, 0.7273893356323242, -0.0475960299372673, -0.3135799169540405, -0.6589478850364685, 0.19052644073963165, 0.8167368769645691, -0.6697301864624023, 0.05883854627609253, 0.053857509046792984, 0.42285263538360596, 0.31836217641830444, -0.06808728724718094, 0.7282377481460571, 0.714917778968811, 0.8622327446937561, 0.12713108956813812, -0.2549276351928711, 0.6100903749465942, 0.45251792669296265, 0.35392284393310547, 0.05323227122426033, 0.5366864800453186, 0.21111737191677094, -0.3871586322784424, 0.059427421540021896, -0.6501782536506653, 0.7271535992622375, 0.016195053234696388, -0.11018086969852448, -0.734591007232666, 0.4116726517677307, 0.12166093289852142, 0.43393346667289734, -0.6535422205924988, 0.27524760365486145, -0.6744672060012817, -0.553926944732666, 0.031209276989102364, 0.5296304821968079, 0.3417779803276062, 0.147792786359787, 0.15852895379066467, 0.03327040746808052, 0.09898966550827026, -0.052175309509038925, 0.5082641839981079, -0.21861258149147034, -0.6638908982276917, -0.2442767173051834, 0.04915915057063103, 0.6739775538444519, 0.02927117422223091, -0.12339963763952255, 0.19436883926391602, 0.12275756895542145, 0.07020165771245956, 0.7432553768157959, -0.7090527415275574, -0.38626745343208313, 0.7008806467056274, -0.4116688370704651, -0.2697734236717224, 0.27620771527290344, 0.34940052032470703, -0.8038140535354614, -0.9836830496788025, 0.3679679334163666, -0.6188441514968872, 0.31119656562805176, 0.8100038766860962, 0.47246143221855164, 0.46066948771476746, 0.2780909836292267, 0.6837420463562012, -0.04464523866772652, 0.7795346975326538, 0.09184442460536957, 0.346176415681839, 0.38313737511634827, 0.05180605873465538, -0.7927224636077881, -0.05736328661441803, 0.19925405085086823, 0.3558441698551178, -0.09928679466247559, -0.6670524477958679, 0.36408793926239014, 0.5595505237579346, -0.15030692517757416, 0.06493182480335236, -0.5874643921852112, -0.06606462597846985, 0.34457623958587646, -0.1124909371137619, -0.21258074045181274, -0.12940393388271332, 0.40720710158348083, -0.052660804241895676, 0.03756750002503395, -0.718913197517395, -0.8587123155593872, 0.45314860343933105, -0.7420119643211365, 0.5374557375907898, 0.9947050213813782, -0.3061184287071228, -0.045088768005371094, -0.8508637547492981, -0.5627293586730957, 0.004204263910651207, -0.1925308108329773, -0.8520360589027405, -0.44447097182273865, -0.005875507369637489, 0.9120886325836182, 0.0032034136820584536, 0.16591261327266693, -0.3010328710079193, -0.2828958332538605, 1.116538405418396, -0.0337250754237175, 0.18491242825984955, 0.11436419188976288, -0.2266559600830078, 0.3725477159023285, -0.19188162684440613, -0.2146318554878235, -0.5608980655670166, -0.6390636563301086, 0.13375644385814667, 0.46977391839027405, -0.012984161265194416, -0.7046905755996704, 0.22258511185646057, -0.1287207305431366, -0.049682676792144775, 0.3353576362133026, -0.5847565531730652, -0.8478350043296814, -0.216599240899086, 0.9340110421180725, -0.9532707929611206, 0.13326773047447205, 0.5393516421318054, -0.4576929211616516, 0.8412949442863464, -0.17560075223445892, 4.244142532348633, 0.9811344146728516, 0.5447051525115967, 0.2013172060251236, 0.25743308663368225, 0.8547282218933105, 0.8583782911300659, -0.2511095106601715, -0.2879081070423126, -0.33501169085502625, -0.21698997914791107, 0.5129589438438416, 0.3212837278842926, -0.43532899022102356, 0.5885096788406372, 0.23336629569530487, -0.8023427724838257, -0.4467298686504364, 0.2986498773097992, -1.189541220664978, -0.43271154165267944, 0.2223202884197235, -0.5090077519416809, -0.08435115218162537, 0.17936982214450836, 0.2867450714111328, 0.007572276052087545, -0.4359492063522339, -0.29561084508895874, -0.04541274532675743, -0.04975811392068863, -0.28478938341140747, -0.30493852496147156, -0.5301305651664734, -0.13779306411743164, 0.378522127866745, 0.3190535306930542, -0.09344503283500671, -0.9297139644622803, -0.654880166053772, 0.20568594336509705, -0.3131648600101471, -0.45758602023124695, -0.679863452911377, -0.7575167417526245, 0.9698241949081421, 0.3459412455558777, 0.2549709379673004, -0.048747215420007706, -0.5820969939231873, 1.2711739540100098, -0.31298989057540894, 0.3894708454608917, -0.3204457461833954, -1.3146883249282837, 0.11814182251691818, -0.5091497898101807, -0.6499427556991577, 0.33053675293922424, 0.41419273614883423, 0.40864136815071106, 0.09232395887374878, -0.34292858839035034, 0.8141762018203735, -0.08321120589971542, 0.22257712483406067, 0.31963247060775757, -0.007241185288876295, -0.10578301548957825, -0.30233708024024963, 0.07086551189422607, -0.698860228061676, -1.1713370084762573, -0.12497980892658234, 1.2102128267288208, 0.12522625923156738, -0.8719758987426758, 0.24455329775810242, -0.23631468415260315, -0.46883624792099, 0.03563443943858147, -0.05517572909593582, 0.2587507367134094, -0.2524545192718506, 0.02050941251218319, 0.9057588577270508, -0.20729726552963257, -0.27372410893440247, -0.9903804659843445, 0.15682609379291534, -0.15057919919490814, 0.10197895765304565, -0.5267077088356018, 0.08948800712823868, -0.47187912464141846 ]
{"Title": "Gait differences in patients with multiple sclerosis who have low and high levels of disability", "Authors": "Fraser John J., Stephenson Jeannie B.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Multiple Sclerosis (MS) often results in gait impairment and disability. Objective To investigate differences in spatiotemporal gait characteristics of people with MS who have low versus high levels of disability. Between trial and inter-limb consistency and the association of gait variables with level of disability were also investigated. Methods Participants with MS who had either low-disability [n=7; 3 females; EDSS mean: 2.7\u00b10.5, range 2.0-4.5; BMI=26.9\u00b16.6] or high-disability [n=11; 6 females; EDSS mean: 2.7\u00b10.5, range 6.0-6.5; BMI=27.8\u00b11.5) performed 2 trials of self-selected walking on an instrumented walkway. Differences in group, limb, and group by limb interactions were assessed using analysis of variance, independent-measures t-tests, and Cohen\u2019s d effect sizes (ES). Between-trial consistency of gait were assessed with intra-class correlation coefficients (2, k). Results Participants in the high disability group had increased step time (ES=0.8), cycle time (ES=0.8), and ambulation time (ES=1.2) while taking shorter strides (ES=0.9) and more steps at a slower rate (ES=1.1). The high disability group demonstrated less between-trial consistency for 69% of gait variables when compared to the low disability group. Conclusion People with MS who have high levels of disability walk differently and with less consistency than those with lower levels of disability.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000166"}
10.1101/19008011
[ -0.010965034365653992, 0.15131883323192596, 0.12192067503929138, -0.29308515787124634, -0.3454109728336334, -0.020471861585974693, 0.3879803717136383, 0.1617734283208847, 0.3116866648197174, 0.5474176406860352, 0.26482245326042175, -0.9935574531555176, 0.35726356506347656, -0.34963881969451904, 0.2895822823047638, 0.2979845106601715, -0.5110675692558289, -0.1884528398513794, -0.42127883434295654, 0.3280634582042694, 0.3947162330150604, 0.22190843522548676, -0.8333311676979065, 0.2762795090675354, -0.4966736137866974, -0.028437746688723564, -0.09471642971038818, -0.1452321857213974, 1.123044729232788, 0.6861921548843384, -0.3064342141151428, -0.7273836731910706, 0.9424135684967041, -0.8360896110534668, -0.4010641872882843, -0.004315414000302553, 0.7259217500686646, -0.2471563071012497, 0.04447439685463905, -0.12077926844358444, 0.6525619029998779, -0.5105813145637512, 0.6905218362808228, -0.040689677000045776, -0.1755795180797577, -0.12896238267421722, -0.3519136607646942, -0.5554888248443604, -0.0022941024508327246, -0.17365606129169464, -0.05199030041694641, -0.049961771816015244, -0.050079818814992905, -0.40732264518737793, -0.07473459094762802, 0.3582713007926941, 0.45468905568122864, 0.4543658196926117, -0.7137807011604309, 0.11740849167108536, -0.5056490302085876, 0.1739697903394699, 0.5748266577720642, -1.2865687608718872, 0.9406404495239258, 0.8628323674201965, 0.21437868475914001, -0.639102578163147, -0.3706809878349304, 0.1091480627655983, -0.1714038997888565, -0.9037014842033386, -0.2824843227863312, -0.2627616226673126, -0.157770574092865, -0.35093438625335693, -0.1139722466468811, 0.0940588116645813, 0.0825183093547821, 0.046912867575883865, 0.24555358290672302, 0.11685661971569061, -0.11640973389148712, 0.3674587309360504, -0.5082592964172363, -0.005011985078454018, 0.4674457311630249, 0.6855159997940063, 0.030314305797219276, 0.8779013752937317, 0.4231070876121521, 0.21546600759029388, -0.008836105465888977, 0.21199007332324982, 0.1523689180612564, 1.2381051778793335, -0.5170509815216064, 0.024897119030356407, -0.0979050025343895, -0.6044289469718933, 0.8385698199272156, 0.6460841298103333, -0.43002715706825256, 0.45091065764427185, -0.7926413416862488, 1.0502114295959473, 0.41115885972976685, -0.601076602935791, -0.43235278129577637, -0.7182960510253906, 0.42669451236724854, 0.19354356825351715, -0.29978105425834656, 0.3352434039115906, 0.8683087825775146, 1.0667345523834229, -0.11597424745559692, 0.9234429597854614, -0.4172808825969696, 0.11310327798128128, -0.0023181606084108353, 0.4434470236301422, 0.24474748969078064, -0.19414307177066803, 0.46288126707077026, 0.3294101357460022, -0.0955028086900711, 0.6553633809089661, -0.9027410745620728, -0.24554820358753204, -0.2205125391483307, -0.6605138182640076, -0.12664678692817688, 0.1597113013267517, -0.323284387588501, -0.25640714168548584, 0.005024312995374203, 1.2740763425827026, -0.2994878888130188, -0.6951272487640381, -0.055872842669487, 0.07333006709814072, -0.7847309708595276, 0.5240245461463928, -0.34385812282562256, 0.7008687853813171, -1.0467222929000854, -1.4459234476089478, -0.6195839643478394, -0.41512373089790344, 0.2109248787164688, 0.61106276512146, 0.05138280615210533, -0.6315124034881592, -0.34672197699546814, 0.4967314302921295, -0.597217321395874, 0.2785109877586365, 0.31227657198905945, -0.37813323736190796, -0.941352128982544, 0.06638161092996597, -0.6652199029922485, 1.1003533601760864, -0.4281378984451294, 0.4678434133529663, -0.18053656816482544, 0.22230054438114166, 0.8007296919822693, -0.7766636610031128, 0.12179169803857803, 0.21954210102558136, -0.1050894483923912, -0.2239391803741455, 0.6581994295120239, 1.356166958808899, 0.7336142063140869, -0.587047278881073, 0.4559260308742523, 0.2091345340013504, -0.05836179479956627, -0.022310351952910423, 0.3081863522529602, 0.9139471650123596, -0.47434306144714355, 0.04932272434234619, -0.37670913338661194, -0.5205069184303284, -0.17592699825763702, -0.47256991267204285, -0.1607493758201599, 0.014402720145881176, -0.29747501015663147, 0.9752840399742126, 0.254372775554657, 0.26054009795188904, -0.4307161867618561, 0.6519986391067505, -0.06121967360377312, -0.18484632670879364, -0.0504743717610836, 0.4800548553466797, -0.3322458267211914, 0.25328299403190613, -0.29740819334983826, 0.989308774471283, 0.4349278509616852, 0.3542766869068146, -0.638457715511322, 0.26738569140434265, 1.0758835077285767, -0.08307401835918427, -0.27607178688049316, 0.3284677267074585, 0.3122633397579193, 0.05699137970805168, -0.5059738159179688, 0.2348291277885437, -0.2911183834075928, 0.39608117938041687, -0.3751298785209656, -0.5452466607093811, 0.6039180755615234, 0.24736467003822327, 0.0297487061470747, 0.6188275218009949, 0.6191113591194153, 0.3455352485179901, -0.2611883878707886, -0.002060719532892108, 0.16150040924549103, 0.8890765309333801, 0.10218177735805511, 0.5083833932876587, 0.788443922996521, 0.6066811084747314, 0.14075973629951477, 0.5015104413032532, 0.32934683561325073, 0.6541543006896973, 1.0631636381149292, 0.8341490030288696, 0.6165284514427185, 0.1845400631427765, 0.025294853374361992, 0.3938254714012146, -0.6409745812416077, 0.4231513738632202, -0.0512850396335125, 0.6944029331207275, -0.6765327453613281, 0.406800776720047, 0.3782742917537689, 0.3820509612560272, -0.8655034303665161, -0.2437179982662201, -0.14051449298858643, 0.07322616875171661, -0.19834893941879272, -1.031112551689148, -0.26486900448799133, 0.6163216233253479, -0.2148231863975525, 0.2663757801055908, 1.330949068069458, 0.9081524610519409, 0.002189157996326685, 0.5259171724319458, 0.31704968214035034, -0.36736810207366943, -0.8612585067749023, -0.3010965883731842, -1.1053533554077148, -0.9966967701911926, -0.9226880073547363, -0.039890043437480927, 0.1156272366642952, -0.4413895308971405, 0.13004423677921295, -0.38870906829833984, -0.015831176191568375, -0.15639179944992065, -0.18177831172943115, 0.24258501827716827, 0.3771454691886902, 0.2662140130996704, -0.8792087435722351, 0.034876804798841476, -0.8031017184257507, 0.07933204621076584, 0.09038396179676056, -0.4505552351474762, -0.4818362295627594, -0.4161137342453003, 0.5764609575271606, -0.7677132487297058, -0.22774247825145721, -0.4652201533317566, 0.06896968185901642, -0.5851888656616211, 0.6128247380256653, 0.15965399146080017, 0.13432994484901428, 0.3493422567844391, -0.3014979958534241, 0.6006061434745789, 0.21024295687675476, 0.16870705783367157, 0.9082052707672119, 0.321938693523407, -0.47097235918045044, 0.1649848073720932, -0.015663860365748405, 0.06486117839813232, -0.63498854637146, -0.13802479207515717, 0.8662983775138855, -0.16384479403495789, 0.27266615629196167, -0.8790249228477478, -0.8784303665161133, -0.5567951798439026, 0.4252379536628723, -0.2484624832868576, -0.21882271766662598, 0.03852658346295357, 0.22267340123653412, -0.7730428576469421, -0.4035550653934479, 0.0720919743180275, -1.5864113569259644, 0.313738614320755, -0.5277694463729858, 0.5175651907920837, 0.23633243143558502, -0.26950332522392273, -0.007161308079957962, 0.243482306599617, 0.5615065097808838, 0.7136366367340088, 0.23732036352157593, -0.22163422405719757, 0.2950260639190674, 0.28341519832611084, -0.5579460263252258, 0.19098903238773346, -0.2442944347858429, -0.3343741297721863, -0.04297260567545891, 0.07776247709989548, -0.11258118599653244, 0.2708950638771057, 0.6914809942245483, 0.13023124635219574, -0.38519781827926636, 0.6970553994178772, 0.11390320211648941, 0.16915851831436157, 0.1221441775560379, 0.4112495481967926, 0.12313567847013474, 0.2701244652271271, -0.37235382199287415, 0.010781990364193916, -0.4966157078742981, 0.02160513587296009, 0.5544899106025696, -0.29611238837242126, 0.21207056939601898, -0.2253248393535614, 0.3641112148761749, 0.42881011962890625, -0.22912441194057465, -0.12285267561674118, 0.18050330877304077, 0.10377450287342072, 1.2213242053985596, 0.5719631910324097, 1.4154831171035767, -1.232264518737793, 0.47447872161865234, 0.37112581729888916, 0.6996305584907532, 0.5414806008338928, -0.1586541086435318, 0.9731497168540955, -0.5108789205551147, 0.22466474771499634, -0.19616149365901947, -0.051788199692964554, -0.48704254627227783, 0.49731001257896423, 0.4827202260494232, 0.0792219489812851, -0.1795685887336731, -0.4150296151638031, 0.01623602770268917, 0.32857391238212585, -0.3784373700618744, -0.2657593786716461, 0.43049177527427673, -0.7338172793388367, -0.010359544306993484, -0.009172443300485611, -0.05283210799098015, -0.0675533339381218, -0.5098975896835327, 0.24210146069526672, -0.28393515944480896, -0.3650157153606415, 0.12198573350906372, -0.18661026656627655, -0.38662973046302795, -0.6543986201286316, 0.3123857080936432, -0.2715838551521301, -0.3923337757587433, -0.45473289489746094, -0.5539048314094543, 0.5670778751373291, 0.2675917446613312, 0.5997003316879272, -0.6078466773033142, 0.2752014100551605, -0.21903523802757263, -0.6553743481636047, 0.18807978928089142, -0.7885947823524475, 0.19295600056648254, 0.6383805871009827, -0.17562516033649445, -0.7575443983078003, -0.730139970779419, -0.19407331943511963, 0.0059338402934372425, -0.007037459407001734, -0.1477455049753189, -0.34399932622909546, 0.05882549658417702, 0.2565084397792816, -0.26549196243286133, -0.588839590549469, 0.1500498652458191, -0.5130071640014648, 0.008727796375751495, -0.24782583117485046, 0.9857097268104553, 0.46182674169540405, 1.0132756233215332, 0.05433117598295212, 1.6295026540756226, -0.670843243598938, 0.314797580242157, -0.7165842652320862, -0.3853444755077362, -0.13781431317329407, -0.6061151027679443, -0.5165978670120239, 0.08829648047685623, -0.7447319030761719, -0.46729516983032227, -0.16546280682086945, -0.016572019085288048, -0.013527694158256054, -0.49128857254981995, 0.6986638903617859, -1.2555369138717651, 0.2446715533733368, 1.2961136102676392, -0.47252073884010315, -0.0918702483177185, 0.08731752634048462, -0.19317886233329773, -0.5148276090621948, 1.0738505125045776, 0.12201207131147385, -0.07636214792728424, -0.25777921080589294, -0.29674193263053894, -0.19578830897808075, 0.3918522596359253, 0.43167129158973694, -0.9366819262504578, -0.12101409584283829, -0.621317446231842, -0.4911634624004364, -0.44939351081848145, -0.15389978885650635, -0.7777820825576782, 0.48940032720565796, 0.2050987184047699, -0.277763694524765, -0.311537504196167, -0.6483142375946045, -0.02005092054605484, -0.31151479482650757, -0.7619149088859558, -0.33708950877189636, -0.11237940192222595, -0.004272324498742819, 0.8376584053039551, -0.3126293420791626, -0.5704437494277954, 0.27409765124320984, 0.7230110168457031, -0.6768894791603088, -0.6011543273925781, 0.05574870854616165, 0.08088336884975433, -0.7946832776069641, -0.13435910642147064, 0.37128210067749023, -0.4171751141548157, -0.9277464747428894, -0.48308810591697693, 0.4100913107395172, 0.6356640458106995, 0.012845740653574467, 0.009962867945432663, 0.5197799205780029, 0.16256608068943024, -0.8910796642303467, -0.31481099128723145, 0.7325112819671631, -0.09786999970674515, -0.31861501932144165, 0.0686207115650177, -1.1779195070266724, -0.37291014194488525, -0.8503484129905701, 0.3061087429523468, -0.45690786838531494, 0.028385769575834274, -0.6335407495498657, -0.26736143231391907, 0.08356999605894089, 0.8275314569473267, 0.19045859575271606, 0.32031330466270447, 0.14219920337200165, -0.24229082465171814, 0.19316622614860535, -0.34393996000289917, 0.25241637229919434, -0.8602212071418762, -0.4755367636680603, 0.19734548032283783, 0.9492592811584473, 0.20304204523563385, -0.4004442095756531, 0.3810882568359375, -0.14820384979248047, 0.41324537992477417, 0.7198449373245239, -0.456849068403244, -0.6776979565620422, 0.311359703540802, 0.43737101554870605, 0.11563818156719208, 0.0516362302005291, -0.8894760012626648, 0.9007585644721985, -0.24071629345417023, 0.291247695684433, -0.19914712011814117, -0.6719897985458374, 0.33696413040161133, -0.9556923508644104, 1.1132646799087524, -0.568022608757019, 0.40350157022476196, 0.2127411812543869, -0.3915225565433502, -0.5572877526283264, 0.3139602541923523, -0.9477159380912781, 0.1981666535139084, -0.46688413619995117, -0.7964907884597778, 0.5072478652000427, 0.052557867020368576, -0.019634388387203217, -0.13531999289989471, -0.34237244725227356, 0.3986089825630188, -0.42701247334480286, 1.0059597492218018, 0.49247339367866516, -0.2490922510623932, -0.81886887550354, 0.11618482321500778, 0.5125057101249695, -0.4198662340641022, 0.6526748538017273, 0.6583993434906006, -0.39094141125679016, -0.3457227051258087, -0.8143680691719055, -0.47346246242523193, -0.7064871191978455, -0.33082878589630127, 0.3457464277744293, 0.41310837864875793, -0.1589318960905075, 0.6056105494499207, -0.2178487926721573, -0.016829874366521835, 0.26996421813964844, 0.6860513091087341, -0.22675877809524536, 0.6653814911842346, 0.6283942461013794, 0.2885485887527466, -0.04210498556494713, 0.7461250424385071, -0.5492408871650696, -0.10692095011472702, -0.4028511643409729, -0.22413106262683868, 0.23780757188796997, -0.7846828103065491, 0.7785043120384216, 0.06085837259888649, -0.9027831554412842, -0.04478750005364418, 0.06608673185110092, -0.27147427201271057, -0.335645854473114, -0.22310765087604523, -0.17678798735141754, 0.8457009196281433, -0.24202443659305573, 0.5797290802001953, -0.31164512038230896, 0.22250881791114807, -0.04936177656054497, -0.7945184707641602, 0.31355592608451843, -0.5516472458839417, -0.5566534996032715, 0.9814581274986267, -0.810623049736023, -0.03480926901102066, 0.7048667669296265, 0.7764520645141602, 0.2411639541387558, 0.05388003960251808, 0.4522759020328522, -1.0040581226348877, -0.15794086456298828, -0.41626110672950745, -0.001630879007279873, -0.05923696607351303, 0.02289588935673237, -0.37893179059028625, 0.4310217797756195, -0.02411803789436817, -0.692111074924469, -0.8252241015434265, 0.38091549277305603, 1.0010957717895508, 0.3450276255607605, 0.45089393854141235, 0.06229499354958534, 0.3406364619731903, 0.0059382254257798195, 0.011574169620871544, -0.04879981279373169, -0.10866901278495789, -0.6129950881004333, -0.5928539633750916, -0.14614930748939514, -0.51072758436203, 0.17308861017227173, 1.0938729047775269, -0.14043857157230377, -0.8341727256774902, -0.17608077824115753, 0.7785536050796509, 0.35646769404411316, -0.10297632962465286, -0.2647162079811096, 0.22954674065113068, -0.7142263054847717, -0.5669410228729248, -0.020748432725667953, -0.698663592338562, -0.24455514550209045, 0.6395452618598938, -0.2233002632856369, -0.19671356678009033, -0.3644229471683502, 0.6575722098350525, -0.256405770778656, 0.4327239990234375, -0.6130886673927307, -0.3825845718383789, -0.43902990221977234, 0.5865134596824646, 0.24681071937084198, 0.0024634208530187607, 1.0475151538848877, -0.0861906036734581, 0.061778586357831955, 0.4025982618331909, -0.32697761058807373, -0.17986616492271423, 0.757233738899231, 0.8702129125595093, -0.45685574412345886, -0.6650269627571106, -0.07655324041843414, 0.6168263554573059, -1.2056365013122559, -0.2562207877635956, -0.5980653762817383, -0.13910852372646332, 0.1391768753528595, 0.42881301045417786, -0.3791126608848572, 1.03003990650177, 0.37952443957328796, 0.4099147617816925, -0.27141258120536804, 0.5660876035690308, 0.339932918548584, 0.1537938416004181, 0.9719793796539307, 0.2074279487133026, 0.3892488181591034, -0.7979607582092285, 0.10581857711076736, 0.32581695914268494, -1.0818966627120972, 0.45501747727394104, 0.26960259675979614, 0.4218825399875641, 0.2328287661075592, 0.17373010516166687, -0.07607564330101013, 0.2019432634115219, 0.23017831146717072, 1.0595693588256836, -0.2766590714454651, -0.8350692391395569, -0.9826837778091431, -0.07145956158638, -1.0742851495742798, -0.6309473514556885, 0.8993874788284302, -0.5038305521011353, 0.1321805715560913, -0.5788492560386658, -0.6070871353149414, 0.5302590727806091, 0.0005693287821486592, 0.09595479816198349, 0.2507356107234955, 0.08664029091596603, 0.0006245807162486017, 0.02893660217523575, 0.24251219630241394, -0.182967409491539, 0.37318897247314453, -0.2810141146183014, -0.9075949788093567, -0.5088664293289185, -0.11328202486038208, 0.2905844449996948, 0.15276461839675903, -0.2965472936630249, -0.46477726101875305, 0.023932240903377533, 0.4688260555267334, -0.041550882160663605, -0.27359703183174133, 0.11490755528211594, -0.7282399535179138, -0.08086077868938446, -0.1865423172712326, 0.08874329924583435, -0.5627381205558777, -0.1038813591003418, -0.07724924385547638, -0.723578691482544, -0.14820246398448944, 0.24697564542293549, 0.4138428270816803, -0.5460413098335266, 0.6740626096725464, -0.37357160449028015, 0.7753693461418152, -0.07775424420833588, -0.6403894424438477, 0.38196736574172974, 0.9569286108016968, 0.021209893748164177, -0.44316378235816956, -0.09567433595657349, 0.1577654331922531, 1.034657597541809, 0.848852276802063, -0.04540901258587837, 0.25056299567222595, 0.6267193555831909, 0.001259594107978046, 0.19120250642299652, -0.29090219736099243, 0.7055606842041016, 0.3283287584781647, -0.37040746212005615, 0.05026555433869362, 0.21141791343688965, 0.7926466464996338, -0.10605242103338242, -1.1253914833068848, 0.12024909257888794, -0.951519787311554, -0.05637214332818985, -0.05246390402317047, 0.39498698711395264, 1.168835163116455, -0.3430783748626709, 0.3698565363883972, 0.5028001070022583, 0.4259073734283447, 0.020234817638993263, -0.15972530841827393, 0.8585178852081299, -0.8280347585678101, -0.571209728717804, -0.07950051873922348, 0.22857224941253662, 0.162565678358078, -0.4756869971752167, 0.3927927613258362, -1.0145752429962158, 0.1671205312013626, 0.6150203943252563, -0.46978023648262024, 0.24396947026252747, 0.9984634518623352, -0.24285493791103363, -0.47752493619918823, -0.051301684230566025, -0.18760031461715698, -0.8137499690055847, -0.43086832761764526, 0.8554025888442993, -1.027972936630249, 0.341973215341568, 0.24269479513168335, 0.42590904235839844, 0.6509426832199097, 0.14965857565402985, 0.41096827387809753, -0.13787610828876495, 0.2947678565979004, 0.3701448142528534, 0.028382617980241776, -0.25463709235191345, 0.11474934220314026, -0.5236988663673401, 0.20890723168849945, -0.20249202847480774, -0.2271818220615387, 0.07264398038387299, -0.3248100280761719, -0.2765028476715088, 0.12536612153053284, -0.609097957611084, -0.032175756990909576, -0.1540648639202118, -0.8795706629753113, 0.18521705269813538, 0.2825774848461151, -0.7092308402061462, -0.3146106004714966, -0.0026123521383851767, -0.3247907757759094, -0.08570566773414612, -0.19254355132579803, -0.2093081921339035, -0.36961230635643005, -0.9818950891494751, 0.7975011467933655, -0.11288096755743027, 0.12629622220993042, -0.33303895592689514, -1.1475476026535034, 0.022219263017177582, 0.3250110447406769, 0.40277835726737976, -0.4648410975933075, 0.001990211196243763, 0.14404094219207764, 0.2855760157108307, -0.08043909072875977, -0.11410661786794662, -0.0372297540307045, 0.4527128338813782, 0.9227070808410645, -0.08479197323322296, 0.551734209060669, -0.39612624049186707, 0.544581949710846, -0.24554996192455292, 0.06820866465568542, 0.07246237248182297, 0.13426654040813446, -0.18507932126522064, -1.134319543838501, 0.0966566950082779, -0.29253098368644714, -0.5537652969360352, 0.7824717164039612, 0.8878476023674011, -0.34632745385169983, -0.22603648900985718, -0.5818589329719543, 0.13026899099349976, -0.7272433042526245, 0.7875892519950867, -0.06380915641784668, 0.07337753474712372, 0.9817361235618591, -0.30621016025543213, 0.9423846006393433, -0.8297021389007568, 4.182325839996338, 1.288963794708252, 0.7434378862380981, -0.5962709188461304, 0.9966536164283752, 0.0005158476997166872, 0.5585920214653015, -0.11172518134117126, 0.017374474555253983, -0.16722224652767181, -0.70412278175354, 0.4817683696746826, 0.2525789439678192, -0.4946836233139038, 0.13787318766117096, 0.30896905064582825, -1.0391768217086792, -0.45477625727653503, 0.19396701455116272, -0.7132565975189209, -0.8270382881164551, 0.17543476819992065, 0.13142263889312744, -0.026141177862882614, 0.29900994896888733, -0.06579947471618652, -0.3361763656139374, -0.6495530605316162, -0.30342504382133484, -0.7115554809570312, -0.14499735832214355, -0.6743746399879456, 0.024836169555783272, -0.36369088292121887, -0.49464723467826843, 0.9526581168174744, -0.37477362155914307, -0.46554073691368103, 0.06514929234981537, -0.36533913016319275, -0.4578232765197754, -0.12546668946743011, -0.3419100046157837, -0.26534271240234375, -0.2899664640426636, 0.32665857672691345, -0.5889327526092529, 0.7715267539024353, 0.5471557974815369, -0.9169936776161194, 0.7871403098106384, -0.9136723279953003, 0.646195650100708, -0.48734986782073975, -0.6526128053665161, -0.13076166808605194, -0.027263276278972626, -0.8969600796699524, -0.09464136511087418, 0.40746209025382996, 0.8875996470451355, -0.3241076171398163, 0.017057960852980614, 0.9988196492195129, 0.6284574866294861, 0.7154293656349182, -0.11671345680952072, 0.09948141127824783, 0.022972526028752327, -0.2846585512161255, -0.8698278665542603, -0.3485349416732788, -0.09586282819509506, -0.08711430430412292, 0.6618220210075378, 0.08637656271457672, -0.3430764079093933, 0.8547297716140747, -0.7457549571990967, -0.6748049259185791, 0.38346925377845764, 0.07227266579866409, 0.7150371670722961, -0.6172323226928711, 0.4071408808231354, 0.8433895707130432, -0.2065054476261139, -0.17000865936279297, -0.9495417475700378, 0.8175975680351257, 0.23881493508815765, -0.09443377703428268, -0.07030047476291656, 0.17129279673099518, -0.3473837375640869 ]
{"Title": "Can the impact of childhood adiposity on disease risk be reversed? A Mendelian randomization study", "Authors": "Richardson Tom G., Sanderson Eleanor, Elsworth Benjamin, Tilling Kate, Davey Smith George", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To evaluate whether early life adiposity has an independent effect on later life disease risk or whether its influence is mediated by adulthood body mass index (BMI). Design Two-sample univariable and multivariable Mendelian randomization. Setting The UK Biobank (UKB) prospective cohort study and four large-scale genome-wide association study (GWAS) consortia. Participants 453,169 participants enrolled in the UKB and a combined total of over 700,000 individuals from different GWAS consortia. Exposures Measured BMI during adulthood (mean age: 56.5) and self-reported adiposity at age 10. Main outcome measures Coronary artery disease (CAD), type 2 diabetes (T2D), breast cancer and prostate cancer. Results Individuals with genetically predicted higher BMI in early life had increased odds of CAD (OR:1.49, 95% CI:1.33-1.68) and T2D (OR:2.32, 95% CI:1.76-3.05) based on univariable MR (UVMR) analyses. However, there was little evidence of a direct effect (i.e. not via adult BMI) based on multivariable MR (MVMR) estimates (CAD OR:1.02, 95% CI:0.86-1.22, T2D OR:1.16, 95% CI:0.74-1.82). In the MVMR analysis of breast cancer risk, there was strong evidence of a protective direct effect for early BMI (OR:0.59, 95% CI:0.50-0.71), although adult BMI did not appear to have a direct effect on this outcome (OR:1.08, 95% CI:0.93-1.27). Adding age of menarche as an additional exposure provided weak evidence of a total causal effect (UVMR OR:0.98, 95% CI:0.91-1.06) but strong evidence of a direct causal effect, independent of early and adult BMI (MVMR OR:0.90, 95% CI:0.85-0.95). Weak evidence of a causal effect was observed in the MVMR analysis of prostate cancer (early life BMI OR:1.06, 95% CI:0.81-1.40, adult BMI OR:0.87, 95% CI:0.70-1.08). Conclusions Our findings suggest that increased CAD and T2D risk attributed to early life adiposity can be mitigated if individuals reduce their weight in later life. However, having a low BMI during childhood may increase risk of breast cancer regardless of changes to weight in later life, with timing of puberty also putatively playing an important role.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008011"}
10.1101/19005199
[ -0.058305129408836365, -0.5755736231803894, -0.6380404233932495, 0.7191580533981323, -0.31922319531440735, -0.4226016104221344, -0.09502820670604706, -0.12015251070261002, 0.0002115580573445186, 0.46397361159324646, -0.12333578616380692, -0.10886427015066147, 0.7205959558486938, 0.2995094656944275, -0.6816259026527405, -0.3401320278644562, -0.4774686098098755, 0.7926574945449829, 0.5907472372055054, 0.42447519302368164, -0.4140501618385315, 0.9237086176872253, -0.5451093912124634, -0.06670482456684113, -0.15973016619682312, 0.4895079731941223, -0.31482356786727905, -0.17732034623622894, 1.042197823524475, 0.9866728186607361, -0.21036848425865173, -0.37451839447021484, 0.06330937892198563, -0.06325803697109222, -0.542082667350769, -0.09844458103179932, 0.023867646232247353, -0.7637773156166077, -0.5854971408843994, -0.18645167350769043, 0.2679833173751831, -0.5384753942489624, 0.4914225935935974, -0.9371410012245178, -1.157055139541626, -0.4806693196296692, 0.18793049454689026, 0.07281254976987839, 0.20110222697257996, -0.3362935781478882, -0.5950849056243896, -0.10337962210178375, -0.46077707409858704, -0.23482990264892578, -0.14360761642456055, -0.1550717055797577, -0.44111406803131104, -0.28280535340309143, -0.29019325971603394, 0.10824272781610489, 0.2821797728538513, -0.5394259095191956, -0.05893511697649956, -0.4833119511604309, 0.6582092642784119, 0.5373538732528687, -0.3596946895122528, -0.1439671814441681, -0.1284252107143402, -0.41443008184432983, -0.7262669205665588, 0.1337018758058548, -0.4780194163322449, -1.0031784772872925, -0.1481233388185501, -0.5385993719100952, 0.7468196749687195, -0.4714655876159668, -0.44278085231781006, 0.6973928809165955, 0.6407244801521301, 0.15368473529815674, 0.6745561361312866, 0.17972727119922638, -0.21848994493484497, 0.5321377515792847, 0.29987436532974243, 0.3458661437034607, -0.08820521831512451, 0.5928203463554382, -0.049785688519477844, 0.4545111358165741, 0.01598270796239376, 0.20390506088733673, 0.4968298375606537, 0.38335222005844116, -0.14837120473384857, -0.2268901765346527, 0.7788898348808289, 0.3014051914215088, 0.19433850049972534, 1.1656523942947388, -0.4830544888973236, 0.6393428444862366, -0.37049204111099243, 1.1654565334320068, -0.07372120022773743, -0.404233455657959, -0.40479224920272827, -0.9176619052886963, -0.41960039734840393, -0.26853907108306885, -0.6589165925979614, -0.8747578263282776, -0.0620819553732872, 1.1454957723617554, -0.2252872735261917, 0.39087510108947754, -0.03783479705452919, 0.722895085811615, 0.14969703555107117, 0.08093627542257309, 1.0603874921798706, -0.45363327860832214, 0.42923131585121155, 0.031197069212794304, 0.552459716796875, 0.3650977909564972, -0.22752411663532257, -0.6274843215942383, -0.09545237571001053, -0.48847705125808716, -0.8433294296264648, 0.12809330224990845, -0.3244922459125519, -0.44309988617897034, 0.7590206265449524, -0.24213510751724243, 0.47518256306648254, 0.38993874192237854, -0.09835956245660782, 0.6352423429489136, -0.1830921471118927, 1.064563512802124, -0.08771073073148727, 0.7881287336349487, -0.43643441796302795, -0.5486477613449097, -0.6210715174674988, 0.13645921647548676, 0.3393562138080597, 0.4037624001502991, -0.17748215794563293, 0.6449417471885681, 0.22493790090084076, 0.13235443830490112, -0.295626699924469, -0.2077440321445465, -0.24300256371498108, 0.43626195192337036, -0.4793439507484436, 0.3594062924385071, -0.4224725067615509, 0.24727414548397064, -0.03609514236450195, 0.5416061878204346, 0.5693706274032593, -0.07429426908493042, 0.8149499893188477, -0.8741347193717957, 0.7406147718429565, 0.19353742897510529, -0.08885391801595688, 0.4024094343185425, 0.04770796746015549, 0.8257318139076233, 1.0837435722351074, -0.8339345455169678, 0.1962418556213379, 0.7850098609924316, 0.054831601679325104, -0.09651368111371994, 0.5138531923294067, 0.4831140637397766, 0.6044058799743652, 0.8178431391716003, -0.2678217887878418, -0.19807744026184082, -0.309440553188324, -0.39566221833229065, -0.09320766478776932, 0.5608826875686646, -0.7691605687141418, 0.7743415832519531, 0.10948465019464493, -0.6931062936782837, -0.48633047938346863, -0.13264934718608856, 0.5485802292823792, -0.6302286386489868, -0.3649452328681946, 0.40692758560180664, -0.5786650776863098, 0.43765968084335327, -0.5794663429260254, 0.9298407435417175, 0.4506347179412842, 0.5739717483520508, -0.3402389585971832, -0.03549005463719368, 0.6184924840927124, 0.3623982071876526, -0.350469172000885, -0.5360738039016724, 0.7159684300422668, -0.3812093734741211, -0.159279003739357, 0.20210492610931396, 0.09150725603103638, -0.14660705626010895, -0.9552558660507202, -0.07215368002653122, 0.23938094079494476, -0.07518337666988373, 0.0272096898406744, 0.14690878987312317, 0.5025891065597534, 0.7524340748786926, -0.815832793712616, -0.45819565653800964, 0.11194857954978943, 0.23212209343910217, -0.3633270859718323, 1.0056378841400146, 0.8235287666320801, 0.033941980451345444, -0.2590108811855316, -0.22128084301948547, 1.105039358139038, 0.3730735778808594, 0.6967087388038635, 0.37622159719467163, 0.46044284105300903, 0.08339796215295792, -0.6739006042480469, 0.4806228578090668, -0.12048202008008957, -0.4435863494873047, -0.9227426648139954, 0.19264879822731018, -0.01359814964234829, 0.5002216100692749, 0.7349281311035156, 0.48632141947746277, -0.7551487684249878, -0.6978338360786438, 0.9767346978187561, 0.44328826665878296, -0.5356609225273132, -0.11296316236257553, 0.12227130681276321, 0.6548773646354675, 0.4222826659679413, -0.11524102836847305, 1.28001868724823, 0.3151623010635376, -0.11708089709281921, 0.5889554619789124, 0.1811077892780304, -0.2616473138332367, -0.6244120001792908, -0.2831939458847046, -0.9569860696792603, -0.8549355268478394, -1.0505026578903198, 0.39769354462623596, 0.15486031770706177, -0.2852885127067566, 0.5462716221809387, 0.13093122839927673, -0.3226991891860962, 0.2285948246717453, -0.07384172081947327, 0.5866153836250305, 0.7551240921020508, 0.39678090810775757, -0.7814146876335144, 0.3700558841228485, 0.39068982005119324, 0.0812980905175209, -0.015266463160514832, -0.5354804992675781, -0.2808184027671814, -0.8995872735977173, 0.4647916555404663, -0.21970240771770477, 0.39810025691986084, 0.44226574897766113, -1.0528301000595093, 0.19011835753917694, 0.09478345513343811, 0.5769252181053162, 0.0027505147736519575, -0.4741416573524475, -0.8443867564201355, 0.28452691435813904, -0.31660476326942444, 0.3960759937763214, 0.43352898955345154, -0.12254419177770615, -0.10051310062408447, 0.9197716116905212, -0.03974347561597824, 0.030221452936530113, -0.6012868881225586, -0.062238115817308426, 0.6571220755577087, -0.9097064733505249, 0.10736260563135147, -0.013276137411594391, -0.9235739707946777, 0.20652076601982117, -0.48987770080566406, -0.1098354235291481, 0.47411251068115234, 0.11334671825170517, -0.034696340560913086, -1.4684737920761108, 0.4833070635795593, -1.2052581310272217, -1.0516571998596191, -0.16591088473796844, 0.4681324064731598, 0.11321493238210678, 0.24288195371627808, 0.14054828882217407, -0.7224962115287781, 0.05822774022817612, 0.3039194941520691, -0.19527429342269897, 0.45102405548095703, 0.04360039904713631, 0.1563616544008255, -0.11887113004922867, -0.05335661768913269, 0.2918062210083008, -0.2701807916164398, -0.1930927336215973, -0.5488853454589844, -0.2179412543773651, -0.006703921128064394, 0.3537400960922241, 0.6467634439468384, 0.5363162755966187, -0.40760618448257446, 0.7969653606414795, -0.8592996001243591, -0.2540854215621948, -0.2167036235332489, 0.6143518686294556, -0.19527924060821533, 0.6554522514343262, -0.04984768480062485, 0.5327403545379639, -0.3590639531612396, -0.5655677914619446, -0.16823358833789825, 0.2053700089454651, 0.4800558388233185, -0.2543871998786926, 0.20541545748710632, -0.9285513162612915, 0.7932263016700745, -0.15701758861541748, -0.4986054003238678, -0.7603136897087097, 0.6960905194282532, 0.4835372269153595, 1.0384082794189453, -1.3934892416000366, 0.5910407900810242, 0.5543810129165649, 0.46731093525886536, 0.9092046022415161, -0.3554072678089142, -0.05243124067783356, -0.38464319705963135, 0.6499344706535339, 0.5538238286972046, -0.7341970205307007, 0.44157251715660095, -0.18347181379795074, 0.6048215627670288, 0.37243232131004333, -0.7502700686454773, -0.11545716971158981, 0.3948504626750946, 0.3591930866241455, 0.817505955696106, 0.14744089543819427, 0.5262846946716309, 0.001276832539588213, 0.7917768359184265, 1.2140263319015503, 0.5449739694595337, 0.2080562263727188, -0.5992865562438965, -0.14946450293064117, -0.8088051676750183, -0.6201850771903992, -0.2823789119720459, -0.360061377286911, -0.16123303771018982, -0.23949530720710754, 0.17318037152290344, -0.19399720430374146, -0.17748233675956726, -0.0709489956498146, 0.13611075282096863, -0.17170345783233643, 0.3085416555404663, -0.5149444341659546, -0.4979788362979889, -0.10967111587524414, -0.007999793626368046, -0.5363659262657166, 0.49632975459098816, -0.8458273410797119, 0.7255033254623413, 0.32095766067504883, -0.16449448466300964, -0.7018823027610779, -0.3386738896369934, -0.055513303726911545, -0.4490596354007721, 0.399048775434494, -0.08895006030797958, -0.1647672802209854, -0.17511779069900513, -0.7684910297393799, -0.2371794879436493, -0.23892632126808167, -0.32074201107025146, -0.8209628462791443, -0.3562772274017334, 0.2967764735221863, 1.0104799270629883, 0.39339783787727356, -0.6691803932189941, 0.09212823957204819, 0.03627121075987816, -0.6251031756401062, 0.4396601915359497, -0.3637848198413849, -0.4872722327709198, -0.5494456887245178, 0.21389605104923248, 0.1477806270122528, 0.034230608493089676, -0.13548968732357025, -0.5092790722846985, 0.20296160876750946, 0.11706043779850006, 0.18295714259147644, -0.025602176785469055, 0.7973706722259521, -0.17244157195091248, 0.002442779717966914, 0.4887850284576416, -0.1938106268644333, -0.27186816930770874, -0.239298015832901, -0.06251620501279831, -0.9682554006576538, 0.13139809668064117, 0.593468427658081, -0.15340258181095123, 0.551604151725769, -0.24735848605632782, 0.3959183394908905, 0.5541098713874817, 0.367926687002182, -0.24582014977931976, -0.39440879225730896, 0.143507182598114, -0.5177029967308044, -0.6006272435188293, 0.029807014390826225, -0.5125209093093872, 1.2364124059677124, -0.3802245259284973, -0.2787006199359894, -0.4873964786529541, 0.4837380647659302, -0.46161460876464844, 0.11713667213916779, -0.5141662955284119, 0.055609844624996185, 0.07007481157779694, 0.20686349272727966, 0.5259336233139038, -0.33940181136131287, -0.26816442608833313, 0.02417190559208393, 0.07236165553331375, -0.3604799509048462, -0.1984625905752182, 0.22533389925956726, -0.39527449011802673, 0.007965009659528732, -0.7771467566490173, -0.023384539410471916, -0.9458377361297607, -0.40680989623069763, -0.1850024312734604, 0.41308316588401794, 0.7581930756568909, 0.1335395872592926, -0.41984009742736816, 0.07125548273324966, -0.525424599647522, -0.1492302119731903, -0.6173915863037109, 0.27002978324890137, 0.3353912830352783, 0.3339751064777374, 0.400003045797348, -0.6164296269416809, -0.1837168186903, -0.7804383635520935, 0.4302121102809906, -0.7449227571487427, 0.39130404591560364, 0.24148407578468323, -0.7353309392929077, 0.6442580223083496, -0.07887527346611023, 1.1009827852249146, 0.7574359774589539, -0.3774068355560303, -0.3431243598461151, 0.4924883544445038, 0.18380746245384216, -0.4264674782752991, -0.3732191026210785, -1.0465670824050903, -0.1708621233701706, 0.7364777326583862, 0.035605721175670624, -0.7686786651611328, -0.035141944885253906, 0.4165181815624237, 0.6588567495346069, -0.01730121299624443, -0.4029386639595032, -0.8000710606575012, 0.0251249298453331, 0.3629319667816162, 0.10935863107442856, 0.11012960225343704, -1.2066943645477295, 0.18147021532058716, 0.13929282128810883, 0.49883055686950684, -0.2113414704799652, -0.9967659115791321, 0.33332619071006775, -0.5162521600723267, 0.8769840598106384, 0.03739090636372566, 0.8807767033576965, 0.3892914354801178, 0.045687235891819, -0.5886027216911316, 0.0486525297164917, -0.5748968124389648, -1.0005996227264404, -0.04674816131591797, -0.5748695731163025, -0.1342245489358902, -0.1313696950674057, -0.4072680175304413, 0.46632131934165955, -0.17041167616844177, 0.02101670764386654, -0.08597896993160248, 0.6591829061508179, 0.2276477962732315, -0.7362580299377441, -0.4392698407173157, 0.2082618921995163, 0.7358132004737854, 0.029795600101351738, 0.7335720658302307, -0.7730556130409241, -0.5719667077064514, 0.35449889302253723, -0.03784015402197838, 0.053592242300510406, -0.5342624187469482, 0.2579045295715332, 0.3168785870075226, 0.20500138401985168, -0.2868037819862366, 0.14097978174686432, 0.05879916623234749, -0.5932793617248535, -0.7370554804801941, -0.14706943929195404, 0.25551190972328186, -0.28177976608276367, 0.5696892738342285, -0.07839132100343704, -0.8061237931251526, 0.8310794234275818, -0.13981150090694427, 0.24472510814666748, -0.40676042437553406, 0.9390028119087219, 0.17889390885829926, -1.7436527013778687, 0.7091923952102661, 0.16932496428489685, -0.16709905862808228, -0.8903209567070007, -0.7050315141677856, -0.9224037528038025, 0.6922202706336975, 0.1890912503004074, -0.5478179454803467, 0.4855908453464508, -0.391825407743454, 0.731059730052948, -0.05496318265795708, -0.25476959347724915, 0.2993907630443573, -0.17176415026187897, 0.5709571838378906, -1.1302692890167236, 0.10053005069494247, 0.3491368591785431, 0.17737142741680145, 0.5760880708694458, 0.22951337695121765, -0.4423169493675232, -0.3127591013908386, 0.5440858006477356, 0.6772454977035522, -0.4588767886161804, 0.12839369475841522, 0.14334440231323242, 1.0283571481704712, 0.13489025831222534, 0.22095821797847748, -0.09157972782850266, 1.2567933797836304, -0.32637473940849304, -0.527703583240509, -0.1763625144958496, 0.5211273431777954, 0.36119797825813293, 0.4442598223686218, -0.38664448261260986, 0.019332099705934525, 0.6625819206237793, 0.7743703722953796, 0.7872700095176697, -0.5574543476104736, -0.3148144781589508, -0.47433146834373474, -0.27272024750709534, -0.22496269643306732, -0.6350483298301697, -0.09057202935218811, -0.05117511749267578, -0.7757635712623596, -0.6748259663581848, -0.14051611721515656, 0.7051023840904236, -0.3698219358921051, -0.03544292971491814, -0.33977147936820984, 0.23927952349185944, 0.006393889430910349, -0.7655954957008362, -0.22911196947097778, -0.14929652214050293, 0.34384408593177795, 1.131973385810852, -0.9445945620536804, 0.5013279318809509, 0.3000149726867676, 0.011899784207344055, 0.04435199499130249, 0.2633635699748993, -1.1813663244247437, -0.42449238896369934, -0.14490483701229095, 1.2016993761062622, 0.10439927130937576, -0.49439579248428345, 0.9321959018707275, -1.1954541206359863, 0.26642605662345886, 0.37617143988609314, 0.1809447705745697, -0.41628825664520264, 0.016224000602960587, -0.09298217296600342, -0.5896359086036682, -0.5493370890617371, -0.17477773129940033, 0.26417458057403564, -0.3875274956226349, -0.258038729429245, -0.24657592177391052, -0.7100169062614441, -0.057298511266708374, 0.321630597114563, 0.2498539835214615, 0.15575124323368073, -0.13651055097579956, -0.001577327260747552, -0.06622591614723206, 0.5260236859321594, 0.05583241954445839, 0.7234205007553101, 0.3751227855682373, 0.0504252053797245, -0.10342517495155334, -0.5134823322296143, 0.6345199346542358, 0.3928031921386719, 0.013542934320867062, 0.0871344730257988, -0.4521537125110626, -0.05423763021826744, 0.9183651208877563, -0.03764401748776436, 0.5329053401947021, 0.7060415744781494, -0.09250480681657791, 0.8547996282577515, 0.6294941902160645, -0.30880439281463623, 0.3129461705684662, -0.4286278188228607, -1.1209028959274292, -0.403114378452301, 0.45160582661628723, -0.6635602116584778, -0.2973150908946991, -0.23367193341255188, -0.3579632341861725, 0.16648174822330475, 0.21780714392662048, 0.06255922466516495, 0.12939652800559998, 0.9280271530151367, 0.05096278712153435, 0.7347097992897034, 0.046185001730918884, 0.6593636870384216, -0.25365665555000305, 0.40576454997062683, -0.28175675868988037, -0.8665404915809631, 0.11242084950208664, 0.6914852857589722, 0.12223073095083237, 0.015731995925307274, -0.718692421913147, 0.04179111868143082, -0.6542842388153076, -0.49225902557373047, 0.32245519757270813, 0.4637055993080139, -0.9841157793998718, 0.09578372538089752, -0.12276071310043335, 0.447026789188385, -0.5049138069152832, 0.6761636137962341, 0.2501305341720581, -1.0286016464233398, -0.8037489056587219, -0.21085628867149353, 0.27036094665527344, -0.37386399507522583, 0.28067800402641296, -0.3260631561279297, -0.22081735730171204, 0.017141716554760933, -0.43849536776542664, 0.9826213717460632, 0.620608389377594, -0.11903481185436249, 0.18374797701835632, -0.414407879114151, 0.2238536775112152, 0.8721334934234619, -0.0771489292383194, -0.4781678020954132, 0.04435405135154724, -0.22888606786727905, 0.43401017785072327, -0.16744008660316467, 0.16363245248794556, 0.07590445131063461, -0.41440993547439575, -0.6140487790107727, 0.3284136652946472, -0.12378302216529846, 0.7205788493156433, 0.7941720485687256, -0.007427970413118601, 0.4492209255695343, 0.40273839235305786, -0.6800549626350403, -0.06932158768177032, -0.828072190284729, 0.47021013498306274, 0.12569119036197662, -0.04857204481959343, -0.32608452439308167, 0.4409945607185364, 0.4313024878501892, -0.20418418943881989, 0.3081374168395996, -0.39522600173950195, -0.09837663173675537, -0.5677048563957214, 0.3979552686214447, -0.06714336574077606, -0.17950643599033356, 0.4339351952075958, 0.22936958074569702, 0.47170862555503845, 0.0230745617300272, -0.18969912827014923, 0.4642418324947357, 0.7097260355949402, -0.21638336777687073, -0.44589537382125854, -0.06908775120973587, 0.27867838740348816, -0.6110702753067017, -0.2756093144416809, 0.42721351981163025, -0.03411659598350525, 0.058522678911685944, 0.13132071495056152, 0.8643633127212524, 0.18689708411693573, 0.1415276676416397, 0.20996485650539398, -0.5165835022926331, 0.3387101888656616, 0.7621042728424072, 0.14326870441436768, -0.6238735914230347, -0.19193392992019653, -0.08099892735481262, 0.23468713462352753, -0.034567248076200485, 0.08519675582647324, -0.09854152798652649, -0.499289870262146, -0.03045186959207058, 0.31812381744384766, 0.520298957824707, -0.02203400246798992, -1.2307745218276978, -0.08329299092292786, -0.019389525055885315, -0.04149675741791725, -0.29194214940071106, 0.1392243206501007, -0.054944127798080444, -0.49179723858833313, -0.08783210068941116, -0.00918659009039402, -0.10747570544481277, 0.1781802624464035, -0.9235326647758484, 0.2943050265312195, -0.3280216157436371, -0.6941301822662354, -0.46436604857444763, -0.7623920440673828, -0.018202468752861023, -0.33297038078308105, -0.40679770708084106, -0.5999768376350403, -0.1661093384027481, -0.023695344105362892, -0.02502703107893467, -0.44866347312927246, -0.5513159036636353, 0.10743889957666397, 0.3110889792442322, 0.7808270454406738, -0.49751603603363037, 0.3971221148967743, 0.27981919050216675, 0.10846566408872604, -0.26777514815330505, -0.2519119083881378, -0.06725765764713287, 0.679842472076416, -0.6574103832244873, -0.25594472885131836, -0.14925065636634827, -0.7684544920921326, -0.5377331972122192, -0.01179193053394556, 0.808458685874939, -0.2589726448059082, -0.17107003927230835, -0.01573416031897068, -0.8802449703216553, -0.8871896266937256, 0.6576554775238037, -0.06344642490148544, -0.14956986904144287, -0.2448430359363556, 0.033189188688993454, 0.4550026059150696, -0.5326692461967468, 4.277307033538818, 0.533338189125061, 0.4550713300704956, 0.10936659574508667, 0.17889422178268433, -0.021226558834314346, 0.24312804639339447, -0.06849657744169235, 0.39165911078453064, -0.5836008191108704, -0.4595934748649597, 0.2095513939857483, 0.04806360974907875, 0.029763508588075638, 0.17299668490886688, 0.17890292406082153, -0.7966474294662476, 0.349549263715744, 0.05558399483561516, -1.0637335777282715, -0.4193112552165985, 0.8142749667167664, -0.43782103061676025, 0.8689080476760864, -0.22638608515262604, 0.4563743472099304, 0.04771380126476288, 0.3278227150440216, 0.2337990254163742, 0.01361859031021595, 0.059337519109249115, -0.7956423759460449, 0.3454281687736511, -0.6930074691772461, -0.35293135046958923, 0.3530576527118683, 0.08467447012662888, -0.6906959414482117, 0.432745099067688, -0.5488636493682861, 0.4575965702533722, 0.6243856549263, 0.019315756857395172, 0.02397467941045761, -0.5524078011512756, 0.21944068372249603, -0.4601524770259857, -0.34927013516426086, 0.40073758363723755, -0.01182379201054573, 0.6727891564369202, -0.15795470774173737, -0.29040831327438354, 0.11856740713119507, -0.7112165093421936, -0.5781249403953552, -0.2251952588558197, -1.0628747940063477, -0.1360919326543808, -0.4256054162979126, 0.8754441142082214, -0.12484416365623474, 0.18687152862548828, -0.3450503945350647, 0.2738541066646576, 0.2994425296783447, -0.09270762652158737, -0.15480990707874298, -0.29631927609443665, -0.09246140718460083, 1.0434833765029907, -0.1917508989572525, -0.5794129967689514, -0.027076154947280884, 0.22681841254234314, 0.48240652680397034, -0.38740575313568115, 0.8183515071868896, -0.47811630368232727, -0.9114440083503723, 0.4888105094432831, 0.8094307780265808, 0.4938237965106964, -0.00858059898018837, 0.176131471991539, 0.7538325190544128, -0.7968241572380066, -0.420110285282135, -1.13350248336792, -0.3608968257904053, 0.9440076947212219, -0.044727325439453125, -0.3792992830276489, 0.8514432311058044, 0.16496917605400085 ]
{"Title": "Pre-diagnostic loss to follow-up in an active case-finding TB program: a mixed-methods study from rural Bihar, India", "Authors": "Garg Tushar, Gupta Vivek, Sen Dyuti, Verma Madhur, Brouwer Miranda, Mishra Rajeshwar, Bhardwaj Manish", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT background Despite active case-finding (ACF) identifying more presumptive and confirmed TB cases, high pre-diagnostic loss to follow-up (PDLFU) among presumptive TB cases referred for diagnostic test remains a concern. We aimed to quantify the PDLFU, and identify the barriers and enablers in undergoing a diagnostic evaluation in an ACF program implemented in 1.02 million rural population in the Samastipur district of Bihar, India. methods During their routine work, Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHA, a community health worker or CHW), informal providers, and community laypersons identified people at risk of TB, and referred them to the program. A field coordinator (FC) screened them for TB symptoms at the patient\u2019s home. The identified presumptive TB cases were accompanied by the CHW to a designated government facility for diagnostics. Those with a confirmed TB diagnosis were put on treatment by the CHW and followed-up till treatment completion. All services were provided free of cost and patients were supported throughout the care pathway, including a transport allowance. We analyzed programmatically collected data, conducted in-depth interviews with patients, and focus group discussions with the CHWs and FCs in an explanatory mixed-methods design. results A total of 11146 presumptive TB cases were identified from January 2018 to December 2018, out of which 4912 (44.1%) underwent a diagnostic evaluation. The key enablers were CHW accompaniment and support in addition to the free TB services in the public sector. The major barriers identified were transport challenges, deficient family and health provider support, and poor services in the public system. conclusion If we are to find missing cases, the health system needs urgent reform, and diagnostic services need to be patient-centric. A strong patient support system engaging all stakeholders and involvement of CHWs in routine TB care is an effective solution. STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY First such study to explore the reasons for pre-diagnostic loss to follow-up A mixed-method design including the views of both patients and community health workers Uses operational data from a routine programmatic setting at an NGO site No record of the actual number of people screened intuitively before being referred to the program. No record of patients accessing diagnostics in private sector and those completing the diagnostic process.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005199"}
10.1101/19013557
[ 0.17008237540721893, 0.7549660801887512, -0.31760063767433167, 0.8981282114982605, -0.7133963704109192, 0.35466068983078003, 0.30582553148269653, 0.26112887263298035, 0.4811846911907196, 0.7211145162582397, 0.2647465765476227, -0.8144868016242981, 0.4465174078941345, -0.8131067156791687, -0.05775638297200203, 0.48397862911224365, -0.2618076205253601, 0.059175096452236176, -0.4061247408390045, 0.2450188249349594, 0.27696895599365234, 0.3798529803752899, -0.061909936368465424, -0.11487016081809998, -0.7710614800453186, 0.6981654167175293, -0.4268490970134735, 0.06503673642873764, 0.7674005031585693, 0.041221026331186295, -0.014171688817441463, -0.8595144152641296, 0.6555884480476379, -0.3882393538951874, -0.017833128571510315, -0.291889488697052, 0.9474800229072571, -0.44057348370552063, -0.2733634114265442, -0.43352165818214417, 0.18680214881896973, 0.20682913064956665, -0.18803608417510986, -0.09569571912288666, -0.467444509267807, -0.10080424696207047, 0.5381558537483215, -0.8293555974960327, -0.41189339756965637, -0.46833547949790955, -0.3283263146877289, 0.16216780245304108, -0.17252632975578308, -0.4361428916454315, -0.12571626901626587, 0.23563465476036072, -0.0428924560546875, -0.3743927776813507, -0.4954965114593506, 0.22258508205413818, 0.6603105664253235, -0.4977837800979614, 0.2817460000514984, -1.2239882946014404, 0.2821747660636902, 0.5422083139419556, -0.06176050007343292, 0.40195417404174805, 0.2339615821838379, -0.13700614869594574, -0.5632917284965515, -0.1817004680633545, -0.4494449198246002, -0.46722307801246643, -0.10774236917495728, 0.5450785756111145, 0.2804730534553528, 0.5730960965156555, -0.0700354129076004, -0.09899696707725525, 0.4086800515651703, 0.13985958695411682, 0.3914853036403656, 0.23523744940757751, -0.5546644926071167, -0.12504591047763824, -0.1440286487340927, 0.2926316559314728, 0.1434333771467209, -0.5573912858963013, 0.44302111864089966, 0.2352493554353714, -0.40636271238327026, -0.06885971873998642, -0.057167407125234604, 0.42111077904701233, -0.4201277494430542, -0.5055744647979736, 0.19000934064388275, -0.6151233911514282, 0.4043274521827698, 0.7404493689537048, -0.15472595393657684, 0.3387032449245453, -0.845490574836731, 0.7944182753562927, 0.5576506853103638, -0.4179666340351105, -0.3702463209629059, -0.7287446856498718, 0.8657707571983337, -0.12439388036727905, -0.3094416856765747, 0.29100045561790466, 0.1611756980419159, 0.05974222719669342, 0.1551419347524643, 0.34903278946876526, -0.4094633460044861, 0.5294474959373474, 0.12643863260746002, 0.3424338102340698, 0.24832186102867126, -0.5396463871002197, 0.2305455505847931, -0.08140602707862854, 0.36809125542640686, 0.07430063933134079, 0.036141298711299896, 0.30227479338645935, 0.3687227964401245, -0.381168395280838, -0.2773762345314026, 0.28390994668006897, -0.8861023783683777, 0.34589189291000366, -0.1251755654811859, 0.8599755764007568, 0.3321629464626312, -0.34682220220565796, -0.5136184692382812, 1.0033992528915405, -0.59285968542099, 0.5572106242179871, -0.32854193449020386, 0.6490839719772339, -0.9055539965629578, -0.4746829569339752, -0.39940986037254333, 0.1207505315542221, -0.6103836894035339, 0.6664429903030396, -0.2693427503108978, 0.06877150386571884, -0.10533861070871353, 0.6107606291770935, -0.2291322648525238, 0.44781294465065, 0.11343400925397873, 0.6326136589050293, -0.026182595640420914, -0.17649056017398834, 0.06308874487876892, 0.31732821464538574, -0.7898529767990112, 0.9293374419212341, -0.1750049740076065, -0.3713502883911133, 0.6897405385971069, -0.2791585326194763, 0.39315664768218994, 0.32146549224853516, 0.15000082552433014, -0.4364970326423645, 0.25548484921455383, 0.8943566083908081, 0.9262591004371643, 0.6011859178543091, 0.26048189401626587, 0.4773232936859131, 0.6084824204444885, -0.37397345900535583, 0.5026596784591675, 1.067122220993042, -0.3499434292316437, 0.4295575022697449, -0.5636624693870544, -0.6055701971054077, -0.14036138355731964, -0.1976606398820877, -0.4770195782184601, 0.4283680021762848, -0.19734731316566467, 0.8075608611106873, -0.43595224618911743, -0.1654612123966217, -0.35762354731559753, 0.4290477931499481, -0.5669707655906677, -0.5280981659889221, -0.6831397414207458, 0.2524394094944, -0.5228517651557922, -0.14137203991413116, -0.44817203283309937, 0.055460553616285324, 0.39057737588882446, 0.4392731487751007, -0.6844086647033691, 0.7910722494125366, 1.0580543279647827, 0.16675816476345062, 0.21380077302455902, 0.03710756450891495, 0.4094257056713104, -0.3784363567829132, 0.0003318251110613346, 0.20427244901657104, -0.6443731784820557, 0.30179816484451294, -0.28468215465545654, -0.4587137997150421, 0.9396825432777405, 0.16563402116298676, 0.5079927444458008, -0.2955424189567566, 0.48266565799713135, 0.15338456630706787, -0.3059270679950714, -0.6230271458625793, 0.542194664478302, 0.5410491228103638, -0.03647948428988457, 0.8680666089057922, 0.9495176672935486, 0.3564207851886749, 0.6090968251228333, 0.3960126042366028, 0.8265445828437805, 0.631584882736206, 0.18283317983150482, 0.2820087969303131, 0.465962678194046, 0.1702897697687149, -0.6153842210769653, 0.18595565855503082, -0.7849186062812805, -0.10349289327859879, -0.21110448241233826, 0.09869691729545593, -0.4478755295276642, 0.13228881359100342, 1.0895551443099976, 0.47287216782569885, -1.271472454071045, 0.47102808952331543, 0.2080056518316269, -0.14195041358470917, -0.22646492719650269, 0.25033143162727356, 0.26566046476364136, 0.55697101354599, -0.14634419977664948, -0.027790026739239693, 0.40448319911956787, 0.2081938534975052, -0.6641294956207275, 0.8399701714515686, 0.5494415163993835, 0.006327836308628321, -0.3766999840736389, -0.5095846652984619, -1.5041617155075073, -1.0204744338989258, -0.2743207812309265, -0.015384330414235592, -0.4257943332195282, -0.3078416585922241, 0.3013840615749359, 0.2718736231327057, 0.09976579248905182, -1.114707112312317, -0.07520511001348495, 0.3730953633785248, 0.46299034357070923, 0.4600353240966797, -0.5274345874786377, -0.30889615416526794, -0.8247909545898438, -0.11786817014217377, -0.034978318959474564, -0.43106722831726074, -0.48310670256614685, 0.1771608293056488, -0.05076435208320618, -0.5737520456314087, 0.0911891832947731, -0.06604323536157608, -0.41991788148880005, -0.31498241424560547, 0.45780351758003235, -0.3402647078037262, -0.003492956515401602, 0.16714975237846375, -0.9106239676475525, 0.8726915121078491, 0.18561507761478424, 0.23786261677742004, 0.5513729453086853, 0.5164546966552734, 0.01962805539369583, 0.5100652575492859, 0.13049696385860443, 0.37536558508872986, -1.0449435710906982, 0.24004532396793365, 0.7850939631462097, -0.1753840446472168, -0.08796211332082748, -0.5607908964157104, -0.6626189351081848, -0.2698427736759186, 0.18703460693359375, -0.1791549175977707, -0.2413065880537033, 0.15097001194953918, -0.4485138952732086, -0.6876487731933594, 0.026517353951931, -0.2275206595659256, -1.1434537172317505, -0.006416351068764925, -0.3305816948413849, -0.2596946358680725, -0.237787663936615, -0.6493410468101501, 0.29535216093063354, -0.33125850558280945, -0.3181271553039551, 0.08699195086956024, 0.5145695805549622, -0.019526135176420212, -0.2733686566352844, 0.3564569354057312, -0.4137202799320221, 0.133065328001976, -0.5057672262191772, 0.17467555403709412, 0.2605814039707184, -0.2937745749950409, -0.7395834922790527, 0.5591772794723511, 0.45062923431396484, 0.08372398465871811, 0.06312724947929382, 0.4612065553665161, 0.32735803723335266, -0.052977826446294785, 0.1026848629117012, 0.7629293203353882, 0.4256238043308258, 0.01823548600077629, -0.015256659127771854, -0.04817964509129524, -0.8214026093482971, -0.30386921763420105, 0.08473913371562958, -0.12246149778366089, 0.11784210056066513, -0.6701757907867432, 0.6495459675788879, 0.22307759523391724, 0.30639079213142395, 0.30488213896751404, 0.4107013940811157, -0.030964616686105728, 1.0445537567138672, 0.5600090026855469, 1.1942707300186157, -1.4030978679656982, 0.4056771993637085, 0.6889099478721619, 0.7181857228279114, 0.3424367606639862, 0.004526030272245407, 0.5718152523040771, -0.3441907465457916, 0.20073716342449188, -0.34894534945487976, -0.6144720315933228, -0.24797111749649048, 0.3938050866127014, -0.26711779832839966, 0.039721738547086716, -0.42703673243522644, 0.209977388381958, 0.16766749322414398, 0.5856314301490784, 0.054516103118658066, -0.2508748471736908, 0.3443671464920044, -0.06186791881918907, -0.06051325425505638, 0.601809024810791, 0.7940844297409058, -0.33190277218818665, -0.5077406167984009, -0.16802465915679932, 0.08091401308774948, -0.38174381852149963, 0.04952745512127876, -0.5002291202545166, 0.038401588797569275, -0.2807385325431824, 0.33491185307502747, -0.1853591650724411, 0.1777372509241104, 0.006419910117983818, -0.5840190649032593, 0.31747928261756897, 0.39895099401474, -0.1418885588645935, -0.9551898837089539, -0.08417867124080658, 0.42191803455352783, -0.4480942487716675, -0.337134450674057, -0.7665995955467224, 0.3586442470550537, 0.8337342143058777, -0.19127985835075378, -0.698849618434906, -0.11586922407150269, -0.33135396242141724, -0.4459865987300873, 0.06441625952720642, 0.5211499333381653, -0.4478932321071625, 0.2732078433036804, -0.2931228280067444, -0.18706394731998444, -0.6252946853637695, 0.06348206102848053, -0.3328425884246826, -0.0016984358662739396, 0.6800996661186218, 0.8802664875984192, 0.08401510864496231, 0.4174109697341919, -0.23131093382835388, 0.4743974208831787, -0.41955065727233887, 0.425507128238678, -0.5277866721153259, -0.04811561107635498, -0.31895941495895386, -0.24041157960891724, 0.031320858746767044, 0.683905839920044, 0.007520325947552919, -0.5843884348869324, 0.27310049533843994, 0.1103009507060051, -0.27684542536735535, 0.3548704981803894, 0.8535651564598083, -1.288529396057129, -0.2354089617729187, 1.1714297533035278, -0.6481483578681946, -0.3787813186645508, -0.17074470221996307, 0.01731797680258751, -1.0467901229858398, 0.3390497863292694, -0.0756349265575409, -0.06416729092597961, 0.032285746186971664, -0.06649871915578842, 0.05561445280909538, -0.033203400671482086, 0.15266303718090057, -0.2492450475692749, 0.13982529938220978, -0.3674945831298828, -0.45782357454299927, -0.15498825907707214, -0.27928590774536133, -0.7514388561248779, 0.2201930582523346, -0.1660299301147461, -0.705790102481842, 0.06948528438806534, -0.36858052015304565, 0.10245608538389206, -0.1245700865983963, -0.8428298234939575, 0.4658433198928833, -0.3116748631000519, -0.27946412563323975, 1.13590407371521, -0.6342889070510864, -0.543388307094574, 0.6928077340126038, 0.20545794069766998, -0.5767244696617126, 0.16308364272117615, 0.02969454601407051, -0.01384287141263485, -0.016072632744908333, -0.4311710000038147, 0.9448002576828003, -0.678013026714325, 0.28606244921684265, -0.42394885420799255, -0.2204686403274536, 0.6395101547241211, 0.010148787871003151, -0.33171913027763367, 0.5799190402030945, -0.5050774812698364, -0.2717840075492859, -0.6006619334220886, 0.7147996425628662, 0.4339471757411957, 0.22473549842834473, -0.482739120721817, -0.6520698070526123, -0.7524202466011047, -0.8746386766433716, 0.587588369846344, -0.9663470387458801, -0.7236857414245605, -0.4441353678703308, -0.49292653799057007, -0.42002439498901367, 0.2798539698123932, 0.06452315300703049, 0.04870714247226715, -0.07654044777154922, -0.07016851752996445, 0.6988447904586792, -0.40584471821784973, -0.6916152834892273, -0.07042165845632553, 0.15502791106700897, -0.5026682615280151, 1.1344752311706543, 0.4652956426143646, 0.22074219584465027, -0.29677873849868774, 0.1858850121498108, 0.7287023067474365, 0.7447481751441956, -0.20450015366077423, -0.5888892412185669, 0.6222620010375977, 0.3209965229034424, 0.08309505879878998, -0.6225187182426453, -0.3854947090148926, -0.06519008427858353, 0.19438810646533966, 0.8199006915092468, -0.41383227705955505, -0.23217721283435822, 0.07674454152584076, -0.9726545810699463, 1.1218005418777466, -0.4754295349121094, -0.3048403263092041, 0.7387081384658813, 0.1115366518497467, -0.5242800712585449, 0.5724117755889893, -0.6079629063606262, -0.010232432745397091, -0.856299638748169, -0.6373641490936279, -0.12022700160741806, 0.5061107277870178, -0.5019674301147461, 0.3894737958908081, 0.17889828979969025, -0.24928560853004456, -0.1437799632549286, 1.3919717073440552, 0.366159588098526, -0.6001189351081848, -0.14121666550636292, 0.3065350651741028, -0.007719020824879408, 0.3391149342060089, -0.01850908435881138, 0.15386709570884705, -0.21695373952388763, 0.21285516023635864, 0.048880886286497116, -0.5870847105979919, -1.1091079711914062, -0.18426834046840668, 0.4794239103794098, 0.30044111609458923, 0.5637303590774536, 1.130857229232788, 0.5508403182029724, -0.2618370056152344, -0.23480258882045746, 0.2562413811683655, -0.36657819151878357, 0.7748435139656067, 0.9771761894226074, 0.07558213919401169, -0.29807060956954956, 0.16059046983718872, -0.47255852818489075, 0.2212214320898056, 0.07618361711502075, 0.47364968061447144, 0.4059988260269165, -1.0619999170303345, 0.3873370885848999, 0.41927096247673035, -0.7254133224487305, 0.08991089463233948, 0.005395891610532999, -0.11707761883735657, 0.3164929449558258, -0.45583516359329224, -0.477529376745224, 0.1330816149711609, -0.516273558139801, 0.022434581071138382, -0.3331684470176697, 0.09346934407949448, -0.04630165547132492, -1.125467300415039, 0.2540959119796753, -0.9016739726066589, -0.16135020554065704, 0.1115315854549408, -0.14022088050842285, 0.02079717628657818, 0.6227949857711792, 0.6403241157531738, 0.31353825330734253, 0.4255705773830414, 0.9357981085777283, -0.2386082261800766, -0.35576215386390686, 0.03339265659451485, 0.7496518492698669, -0.4179030954837799, 0.3670331835746765, 0.37454286217689514, 0.6252355575561523, 0.553888738155365, -0.6415279507637024, -0.4593561887741089, 0.28648969531059265, 0.43429553508758545, 0.2181868851184845, 0.09152117371559143, -0.10779417306184769, 0.7735629677772522, 0.9163941144943237, 0.42984768748283386, 0.31702569127082825, -1.108306884765625, -0.3150918781757355, 0.2757285535335541, 0.21228080987930298, -0.23497198522090912, 0.13927210867404938, 1.2851771116256714, -0.57181316614151, -1.066131591796875, -0.5854546427726746, 1.2055275440216064, 0.18431872129440308, 0.2200237661600113, -0.9320368766784668, 0.4958074688911438, -0.28800535202026367, -0.49862149357795715, -0.8392117023468018, 0.3169553875923157, -0.35427048802375793, 0.7061023712158203, -0.502432107925415, -0.006775188259780407, 0.836235761642456, 0.03833071514964104, -0.00949944369494915, 0.4941793382167816, 0.025882916525006294, -0.03307388350367546, -0.2615947127342224, -0.01461293175816536, 0.7988390326499939, 0.3793533146381378, 1.1190171241760254, -0.7764474749565125, 0.028351178392767906, 0.08681043982505798, -0.5288284420967102, -0.7142770290374756, 0.011368706822395325, 0.40139225125312805, -0.3740609586238861, -1.2906904220581055, -0.5227940678596497, 0.43055689334869385, -0.7880550622940063, 0.3185923993587494, -0.08376328647136688, 0.018291110172867775, -0.4799712002277374, 0.27762505412101746, -0.11266294866800308, 0.36921486258506775, -0.28656163811683655, -0.4470358192920685, -0.17419648170471191, 0.4849138557910919, -0.18048663437366486, -0.19907701015472412, 0.6146531105041504, 0.02602762170135975, 0.17935995757579803, -1.585661768913269, 0.8147852420806885, 0.4744901657104492, -0.9239467978477478, 0.8098829388618469, -0.07831516116857529, 0.04116729274392128, 0.11049511283636093, -0.6204646825790405, -0.11174476891756058, 1.2908544540405273, 0.08957228064537048, 0.6174665093421936, 0.2456228882074356, -0.0447879359126091, -1.1551986932754517, -0.3765268623828888, -1.023655891418457, -0.6666234731674194, 0.5871403217315674, -0.760507345199585, -0.5984508395195007, -0.6425836086273193, -0.83050936460495, 0.44411981105804443, 0.2458537518978119, 0.20163187384605408, 0.02053450047969818, 0.3896186351776123, 0.34936094284057617, 0.45218411087989807, 0.5880774855613708, -0.18277613818645477, 0.33082759380340576, -0.13503657281398773, -1.1439636945724487, -0.8768551349639893, 0.4691547155380249, 0.6088601350784302, 0.46369075775146484, -0.4041796624660492, 0.035022612661123276, 0.22479042410850525, 0.35279035568237305, -0.1396624892950058, -0.9320130348205566, 0.10444937646389008, -1.159731149673462, 0.2853119969367981, -0.14079508185386658, -0.2368791550397873, -0.7047863006591797, 0.466450572013855, 0.28632616996765137, -0.8309794068336487, -0.7784508466720581, -0.30792301893234253, 0.47780928015708923, -0.7796216607093811, 0.02125154249370098, 0.05308879166841507, 0.2645023763179779, -0.3316357433795929, -1.1257686614990234, 0.8210298418998718, 0.5720058083534241, 0.790892481803894, -0.11690482497215271, -0.2086503952741623, 0.3797323405742645, 0.6298869252204895, 0.28613898158073425, -0.06070910766720772, 0.33946743607521057, 0.31435585021972656, 0.19789214432239532, 0.27802225947380066, -0.40005868673324585, 0.38137781620025635, 0.2294744998216629, -0.20701903104782104, -0.05383570119738579, 0.47909170389175415, 0.4424578845500946, 0.01491847075521946, -0.5331478118896484, 0.943902313709259, -0.33005109429359436, -0.5095230937004089, 0.5061608552932739, 0.1837957799434662, 0.8146778345108032, 0.35559403896331787, -0.25567540526390076, -0.10722507536411285, 0.6462972164154053, 0.037875644862651825, 0.3625054955482483, 0.6258969306945801, -0.3702795207500458, -0.5874330401420593, -0.9239819645881653, 0.8075926303863525, -0.26683080196380615, 0.0700380802154541, 0.03732439875602722, -0.1371740847826004, 0.7451164126396179, 0.6277447938919067, 0.2766551971435547, -0.7511550784111023, 0.7429667115211487, -0.07238978892564774, -0.5037685632705688, -0.454585999250412, -0.07971170544624329, -0.34362420439720154, -0.8352811336517334, 0.7162107825279236, -0.28527575731277466, 0.8569470643997192, 0.6430732607841492, 0.24559088051319122, 0.16559691727161407, 0.7962450385093689, 0.6927382349967957, -0.366668164730072, 0.5784127116203308, 0.5157073736190796, -0.1235668882727623, 0.0829080268740654, 0.2577888071537018, -0.39347460865974426, -0.06176125258207321, -0.7782386541366577, 0.012986820191144943, -0.31721925735473633, -0.26382118463516235, -0.33945178985595703, 0.2657606601715088, 0.1427856683731079, 0.12885822355747223, -1.09598970413208, -0.21384601294994354, -0.0753600150346756, -0.34348613023757935, -0.16236095130443573, 0.20515666902065277, 0.32148507237434387, -0.2914278507232666, -0.05393676832318306, -0.10392475128173828, -0.3665676712989807, -0.37193232774734497, -0.468291312456131, 0.08839905261993408, -0.16831713914871216, -0.25624310970306396, -0.5991182327270508, -0.7878896594047546, -0.1257469207048416, 0.566625714302063, 0.03865347057580948, -0.9368610978126526, 0.015425513498485088, -0.23628196120262146, 0.7709653377532959, 0.09006563574075699, 0.13975873589515686, 0.12601633369922638, 0.02617041952908039, 1.0429883003234863, -0.23339815437793732, -0.03555344045162201, 0.27356991171836853, -0.15227662026882172, 0.5857918858528137, -0.20045499503612518, 0.3537382185459137, -0.9581596255302429, -0.389638751745224, -0.5990376472473145, 0.2927872836589813, -0.16331006586551666, -0.6764588952064514, -0.28161710500717163, 0.2512248158454895, -0.6480904817581177, 0.5207242369651794, -0.6201015710830688, -0.7895148396492004, -0.2999592125415802, 0.6469768285751343, 0.10380178689956665, 0.15807482600212097, -0.0031223243568092585, -0.26861685514450073, 0.10194268822669983, -1.1055655479431152, 4.26045036315918, 0.6818744540214539, 0.39301714301109314, -0.2533257305622101, 0.22860312461853027, 0.5115323066711426, 0.4998762905597687, -0.196654811501503, -0.21700744330883026, 0.3829635977745056, -0.17632699012756348, 0.4871637225151062, -0.2802276313304901, -0.3196486830711365, 0.6042143702507019, -0.02259232848882675, -0.5868504643440247, -0.8221588730812073, 0.12179446220397949, -1.3496589660644531, -0.21107657253742218, -0.18910333514213562, -0.5306052565574646, -0.026052340865135193, 0.1745142936706543, 0.5917022824287415, 0.3770551383495331, 0.4077935218811035, -0.2247871309518814, 0.09954480081796646, 0.2694322168827057, -0.24390539526939392, -0.537871778011322, -0.6297447681427002, 0.18558451533317566, 0.1755959689617157, 0.10784050822257996, -0.3552393615245819, -0.9063907265663147, -0.6581910252571106, 0.45721742510795593, -0.11626377701759338, -0.20002783834934235, -1.0886341333389282, -0.3458751440048218, 0.3842552900314331, -0.4413338899612427, 0.16909608244895935, 0.33932241797447205, -0.8272992372512817, 1.0036864280700684, -0.6458784937858582, -0.08851298689842224, 0.05596255883574486, -0.8773308396339417, 0.09676627069711685, -0.29991671442985535, -0.3259279429912567, 0.3280405104160309, 0.4852501153945923, 0.7183586359024048, -0.36911800503730774, 0.5053508281707764, 0.6209587454795837, 0.568435549736023, 0.3179956078529358, 0.24435284733772278, -0.1795756220817566, -0.6449733972549438, 0.031022626906633377, -0.1357048898935318, -0.5075965523719788, -1.1521118879318237, 0.1695287972688675, 0.9933825135231018, 0.5854093432426453, -0.2503224015235901, 0.669070839881897, -0.8155977129936218, -0.9029973149299622, 0.1720096915960312, 0.6541571021080017, 0.5100445747375488, -0.7702674269676208, 0.27623283863067627, 1.3152134418487549, -0.6418069005012512, 0.10724668204784393, -0.7049824595451355, -0.02056249789893627, 0.13219524919986725, -0.02978510595858097, -0.7612218856811523, -0.5704209208488464, -0.13524281978607178 ]
{"Title": "Rate of Force Development is Related to Maximal Force, Muscle Quality and Physical Function in Patients With Chronic Kidney Disease Predialysis", "Authors": "Gollie Jared M., Harris-Love Michael O., Patel Samir S., Blackman Marc R.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Physical function is severely compromised in people with chronic kidney disease (CKD) and worsens with continued decreases in kidney function. Neuromuscular force capacity is a key determinant of physical function in healthy older adults, though its importance in persons with CKD is less understood. Methods This study aimed to determine the relationships among rate of force development (RFD), muscle quality and physical function in a group of community-dwelling, middle-aged and older men (n=14; age=71.2\u00b16.2 years) with CKD stages 3 and 4 (eGFR=37.5\u00b110.4 ml/min per 1.73 m 2 ). Force characteristics were determined from maximal knee extensor isometric contractions and muscle quality was estimated using ultrasound grayscale analysis. Physical function was assessed by the Short Physical Performance Battery (SPPB) and 5-repetition sit-to-stand (STS) test. Results eGFR was directly related to SPPB (r=0.54, p=0.044) and inversely related to STS (r=-0.62, p=0.029). RFD was positively related to SPPB at time points 0-50 ms, 50-100 ms, and 0-300 ms (RFD 0-50 , r=0.73, p=0.010; RFD 50-100 , r=0.67, p=0.022 and RFD 0-300 r=0.61, p=0.045); and inversely related to STS at time points 0-50 ms, 50-100 ms, and 0-300 ms (RFD 0-50 , r=-0.78, p=0.007; RFD 50-100 , r=-0.78, p=0.006 and RFD 0-300 r=-0.76, p=0.009), respectively. RFD was positively associated with maximal voluntary force (MVF) at times 50-100 ms, 100-200 ms, and 0-300 ms (RFD 50-100 , r=0.72, p=0.011; RFD 100-200 , r=0.66, p=0.025; and RFD 0-300 r=0.70, p=0.016), respectively. Neither MVF nor muscle quality was significantly associated with functional measures. Conclusions RFD is an important determinant of physical function in middle-aged and older men with CKD stages 3 and 4.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013557"}
10.1101/19007526
[ -0.2136448472738266, 0.506623387336731, 0.04274153709411621, 0.31035760045051575, -0.5149842500686646, 0.2231328934431076, -0.14278069138526917, -0.0836193785071373, 0.2622127830982208, 0.7236214280128479, -0.5054742097854614, -0.3362307548522949, 0.3069482743740082, 0.5209208726882935, -0.5702112317085266, -0.19963201880455017, -0.3216368556022644, -0.42258214950561523, -0.10236691683530807, 0.8070703148841858, -0.14052177965641022, 0.5876175761222839, -0.8265212774276733, -0.34884053468704224, -0.8779050707817078, 0.466194748878479, 0.17693617939949036, -0.23450633883476257, 1.367323637008667, 0.7056441307067871, 0.5143198370933533, -0.09225766360759735, 0.7520860433578491, -0.34345921874046326, 0.010092983022332191, -0.32238543033599854, 0.65595543384552, -0.5554614663124084, 0.8722095489501953, -0.3187209963798523, 1.0146149396896362, 0.11510724574327469, 0.7227277159690857, -0.45528358221054077, -0.2793513536453247, -0.4504421651363373, 0.14105749130249023, 0.40313026309013367, -0.47520121932029724, -0.1313188672065735, -0.1599067896604538, 0.242218017578125, 0.40323466062545776, -0.41419488191604614, -0.607283890247345, 0.12748871743679047, -0.0017458477523177862, -0.014246578328311443, -0.3000684678554535, 0.6110663414001465, 0.14779672026634216, -0.06840194016695023, 0.22820284962654114, -0.8550881743431091, 0.7894315123558044, 0.4134553074836731, 0.02496699057519436, -0.13708582520484924, -0.12748940289020538, -0.49204882979393005, 0.08660672605037689, -0.44832780957221985, -0.41965675354003906, -0.3665691614151001, -0.5703252553939819, 0.33375656604766846, 0.5463405847549438, -0.38137948513031006, -0.48672640323638916, 0.1358429491519928, -0.590398907661438, -0.10554256290197372, 0.5429072976112366, 0.3435083031654358, -0.7739217877388, -0.45047274231910706, -0.043488241732120514, 0.2681175172328949, 0.4124673008918762, 0.43314477801322937, 0.11376062035560608, -0.32227808237075806, -0.5578412413597107, 0.1892654299736023, -0.16065847873687744, 0.8262519836425781, -0.4608795642852783, -0.13837075233459473, 0.14970000088214874, -0.6441198587417603, 0.8677147030830383, 0.9404042959213257, 0.17528700828552246, 1.0910184383392334, -0.7043065428733826, 0.699787437915802, 0.7175338864326477, -0.16956065595149994, 0.34435299038887024, -0.6748639941215515, -0.5482417941093445, -0.06400461494922638, -0.6994505524635315, -0.7310829758644104, 0.596479594707489, 0.7356116771697998, 0.3269113004207611, 0.7819120287895203, -0.10996098816394806, 0.470700204372406, -0.44628822803497314, 0.5720841884613037, 0.28796058893203735, 0.1438099443912506, -0.14071795344352722, -1.0753159523010254, 0.6195119619369507, 0.8188321590423584, -0.4749648869037628, -0.27591055631637573, 0.022890660911798477, -0.8535932302474976, -0.641603946685791, 0.053405094891786575, -0.047241613268852234, 0.24680739641189575, 0.594627320766449, 1.1243664026260376, 0.4160125255584717, 0.14956572651863098, 0.22332452237606049, 0.8397874236106873, -0.15015102922916412, 0.9468876123428345, -0.15674588084220886, 0.8306611776351929, -1.0358803272247314, -0.850519597530365, -0.44371870160102844, 0.5726794600486755, -0.0011379469651728868, 0.03886503726243973, 0.22715866565704346, 0.30997800827026367, 0.13911744952201843, 0.048736754804849625, -0.7153341174125671, -0.12079615890979767, -0.3719192147254944, 0.2709193527698517, -1.3160500526428223, -0.1814648061990738, -0.22095584869384766, 0.550681471824646, -0.5418344736099243, 0.9751240015029907, -0.1261204183101654, 0.4659164249897003, 0.6674962043762207, -0.8047725558280945, 0.6329294443130493, -0.3032882511615753, -0.6302483081817627, 0.14981861412525177, 0.44017261266708374, 0.28424933552742004, 0.4093589782714844, -0.5101664662361145, 0.2335902750492096, 0.8060822486877441, 0.38314178586006165, 0.38943785429000854, 0.9423583745956421, 1.4391924142837524, -0.5396288633346558, 0.11571682244539261, -0.7432106137275696, -0.8575760722160339, -0.11409035325050354, -0.4116198420524597, 0.05201823264360428, 0.7254144549369812, -0.4721308946609497, 0.5127188563346863, -0.006312130019068718, -0.3841063678264618, -0.7973654270172119, 0.5742915868759155, 0.8455471992492676, -0.6939937472343445, -0.3208432197570801, 0.5171482563018799, -0.19222228229045868, 0.38582727313041687, -0.22387491166591644, 1.1055352687835693, -0.295236736536026, 0.19084198772907257, -0.13041336834430695, -0.07418599724769592, 1.1057417392730713, -0.053732164204120636, -0.3711359202861786, 0.5549923181533813, 0.06426086276769638, -0.1605142056941986, 0.10681943595409393, 0.34882852435112, -0.3980666995048523, 0.34642311930656433, -0.48654067516326904, -0.14028730988502502, 0.3537835478782654, -0.09375955164432526, 0.510888934135437, 0.4205830991268158, 0.3078972399234772, -0.012315711937844753, -0.5591689348220825, -0.08058997243642807, 0.24365319311618805, 0.3859919011592865, 0.5409305691719055, 0.30824074149131775, 1.0285922288894653, 0.14159487187862396, 0.1707095503807068, 0.5800251364707947, 0.11376259475946426, 0.383706271648407, 1.4656203985214233, 0.6829695105552673, 0.4252355694770813, -0.3263234794139862, -0.16656962037086487, 0.879976749420166, 0.3430575728416443, 0.20480838418006897, 0.025327537208795547, 0.8410710692405701, -0.23481515049934387, 0.31197887659072876, -0.1565156877040863, -0.1503661572933197, -0.9036027789115906, 0.03965112194418907, 0.5925400257110596, 0.2441929280757904, -0.47765856981277466, -0.3558873236179352, 0.03211844339966774, 0.8257924914360046, 0.38677385449409485, 0.019791413098573685, 0.7929458618164062, 0.3074958026409149, 0.052187230437994, 0.729236364364624, 0.1935795396566391, 0.18506602942943573, -1.3931663036346436, -0.5170355439186096, -1.577393651008606, -0.22383427619934082, -1.3884625434875488, 0.4325575828552246, 0.48128336668014526, -0.28150349855422974, 0.2763552665710449, 0.4337311387062073, -0.05213235318660736, 0.02326587773859501, 0.09760355949401855, 0.14058826863765717, 0.24395428597927094, -0.1673101931810379, -1.2328633069992065, 0.21862046420574188, 0.29554256796836853, -0.10530654340982437, -0.27801576256752014, 0.11990393698215485, -1.0797749757766724, -0.8247802257537842, 0.8550662398338318, -0.03838353604078293, 0.35885459184646606, 0.1618025004863739, -0.4237091541290283, -0.6251476407051086, 0.7259961366653442, 0.13709436357021332, 0.16405706107616425, -0.17657117545604706, -0.7456498146057129, 0.9764105081558228, -0.08615365624427795, 0.7271854877471924, 0.3580252230167389, -0.292555570602417, -0.37757277488708496, 0.5586090683937073, 0.2460993081331253, 0.4159272611141205, -1.150119662284851, 0.1889743208885193, 0.4567045271396637, -0.34062057733535767, -0.09824226051568985, 0.1060219258069992, -0.5787162184715271, -0.38350892066955566, 0.9001767039299011, -0.3987228274345398, -0.7266007661819458, 0.17617465555667877, 0.5728151202201843, -1.0729864835739136, 0.590925395488739, -0.2976449429988861, -0.9880490303039551, 0.271420419216156, -0.2366456836462021, 0.008781136944890022, -0.44610556960105896, -0.1789647489786148, -0.795407235622406, 0.03467949107289314, -0.26658105850219727, -0.6645284295082092, 0.7714575529098511, -0.3014126420021057, -0.34870511293411255, -0.07904322445392609, -0.7921295166015625, 0.5679224133491516, -0.4323641359806061, 0.28243210911750793, -0.4543755352497101, 0.3870851993560791, -0.37051427364349365, 0.43825578689575195, 1.0306556224822998, -0.25497663021087646, 0.002096678363159299, 0.6067118644714355, 0.5971223711967468, 0.08637174963951111, 0.2676842510700226, 0.9621047377586365, 0.1820211261510849, 0.9138015508651733, -0.4790354073047638, -0.26243340969085693, -0.7599101662635803, -0.2279607355594635, 0.09349630773067474, 0.23964586853981018, 0.3523356318473816, -0.1053510382771492, -0.000248209573328495, -0.3383530080318451, -0.41548407077789307, 0.5256549119949341, -0.25686153769493103, -0.5543859601020813, 1.335756778717041, 0.39869627356529236, 1.1325476169586182, -0.7147142291069031, 0.17725928127765656, -0.11999757587909698, 0.8962336182594299, -0.141641303896904, -0.06568310409784317, 0.6746413111686707, -0.13328485190868378, 1.2101686000823975, -0.1552613228559494, -0.8714087009429932, -0.27212637662887573, -0.4953364133834839, 0.33811500668525696, 0.033782195299863815, -1.0544252395629883, -0.2720543444156647, 0.24519695341587067, 0.6402055621147156, 0.5872983932495117, -0.11189330369234085, 0.709243893623352, 0.3399950861930847, 0.7614623308181763, 0.5604857802391052, 0.5668657422065735, 0.4443265497684479, -0.36118069291114807, 0.32582566142082214, -0.3426285982131958, -0.2530013620853424, 0.3016003668308258, -0.6523428559303284, -0.5729715824127197, -0.1872940957546234, 0.37053564190864563, 0.029743922874331474, -0.6574866771697998, -0.7430503368377686, -0.39934539794921875, 0.5307124853134155, -0.20800115168094635, 0.3523043394088745, -0.841056227684021, 0.17924544215202332, -0.4622729420661926, 0.2156977355480194, -0.2509494721889496, -0.3016020655632019, 0.439517080783844, 0.5705588459968567, -0.5750676393508911, -0.9535832405090332, 0.15581287443637848, -0.7149918675422668, -1.1546646356582642, 0.035737086087465286, -0.3749855160713196, -0.542323648929596, -0.09569822996854782, -1.2300302982330322, -0.19079972803592682, -0.33843106031417847, -0.3391039967536926, -0.5750226378440857, -0.0978897288441658, 0.22990280389785767, 0.9797815084457397, 0.5353382229804993, 0.5342200398445129, -0.17097987234592438, 0.013403469696640968, -0.3673784136772156, 0.4898253083229065, -0.1085275337100029, -0.23561815917491913, -0.31498315930366516, -0.148821160197258, 0.26174700260162354, 0.22686365246772766, -0.44778603315353394, -0.8868932723999023, -0.28365635871887207, -0.01968999207019806, 0.0237679872661829, -0.5616655349731445, 1.1234874725341797, 0.05595766752958298, -0.3870371878147125, 0.39581307768821716, -0.46935194730758667, -0.041936516761779785, 0.09063065052032471, -0.44836336374282837, -1.1478923559188843, 0.1627226322889328, 0.09192842990159988, -0.03933488205075264, 0.3864918351173401, -0.8272212147712708, 0.41453972458839417, 0.076596200466156, 0.5753331780433655, -0.03663526847958565, -0.4047100841999054, -0.2229878157377243, -0.18523789942264557, -0.1775682419538498, -0.03150050714612007, -1.3550076484680176, 0.02868165634572506, -0.13356445729732513, -0.2607124447822571, -0.09366089850664139, 0.18259048461914062, -0.5692455768585205, -0.707211434841156, -0.3129512071609497, 0.0817064493894577, -0.06279950588941574, 0.6890507340431213, 1.0520330667495728, -0.42538806796073914, -0.8577844500541687, -0.1184755191206932, 0.5909683108329773, -0.2996714413166046, -0.3247582018375397, 0.5218051671981812, -0.30864113569259644, -0.12490915507078171, -0.20635177195072174, 0.1417984515428543, -0.9588683843612671, -0.5526905059814453, -0.45578914880752563, 0.13877646625041962, 0.562446653842926, -0.23900935053825378, -0.3474666178226471, 0.3466359078884125, -0.2163119614124298, -0.1424936056137085, -0.6483694314956665, 0.8931807279586792, -0.09199519455432892, 0.4416792392730713, -0.3953130543231964, -0.8184927105903625, -0.13478738069534302, -1.2692101001739502, -0.5450032949447632, -1.1501230001449585, 0.17295074462890625, -0.23229505121707916, -0.44827213883399963, 0.024206412956118584, 0.5924458503723145, 0.46752771735191345, 0.21008794009685516, 0.6417112350463867, -0.8759497404098511, 0.13442550599575043, 0.1391851305961609, 0.02129405178129673, -0.1527625471353531, -0.6854747533798218, 0.012707964517176151, 1.0331186056137085, 0.6270154118537903, -0.5133423209190369, -0.12752920389175415, 0.39364078640937805, 0.3566475808620453, 0.4216099679470062, -0.15113338828086853, -0.6479182243347168, 0.5595659613609314, 0.9122467637062073, -0.2607334852218628, -0.6785001754760742, -0.9941706657409668, 1.2104449272155762, -0.7117447853088379, 0.4992457330226898, 0.2337813824415207, -0.21324199438095093, -0.010729968547821045, -0.48250842094421387, 1.2625792026519775, -0.5791988372802734, -0.27276408672332764, -0.27751532196998596, 0.10774842649698257, -0.33083489537239075, 0.12437845021486282, -1.1399378776550293, -0.5833158493041992, -0.7155924439430237, -0.8243719935417175, 0.16897998750209808, 0.0009918007999658585, -0.1757686883211136, -0.321887731552124, -0.4301508963108063, -0.0137765659019351, -0.44493618607521057, 0.8583551645278931, 1.0916786193847656, -0.4437839686870575, -0.15696705877780914, 0.21690517663955688, 1.0585870742797852, 0.06188812106847763, 0.17051218450069427, 0.6414393186569214, 0.027262425050139427, 0.42531538009643555, 0.30095887184143066, -0.8639899492263794, -1.3845561742782593, -0.8456395268440247, 0.21747398376464844, 0.6812489032745361, -0.6133583188056946, 0.13779398798942566, 0.09483207762241364, -0.2375257909297943, -0.16118477284908295, 0.884357213973999, -0.19034896790981293, 0.47630953788757324, 1.3135993480682373, -0.2703893184661865, -0.34535107016563416, 0.47789862751960754, -0.04850010573863983, 0.543263852596283, 0.2017751932144165, 0.6389603018760681, -0.03502098470926285, -1.0748310089111328, 0.009062213823199272, 0.3928743302822113, -0.7158305048942566, -0.0245234202593565, 0.05920649319887161, -0.47359174489974976, 0.8057544827461243, 0.0266477782279253, 0.0641491487622261, 0.7694411873817444, -0.20033355057239532, 0.2122035026550293, 0.04818250611424446, -0.21184909343719482, 0.12631550431251526, -0.3679805397987366, 0.5773409605026245, -0.5951008796691895, 0.3241167366504669, 0.5803678035736084, -0.2154153287410736, 0.2133033573627472, 0.6818575859069824, -0.11670282483100891, 0.40568163990974426, 0.29073038697242737, 0.347462922334671, -0.8843451142311096, -0.0016732108779251575, 0.4008781611919403, -0.4577074646949768, -0.21268895268440247, -0.4663797914981842, -0.642429769039154, 0.5104437470436096, -0.167198047041893, -0.6294533610343933, -0.5687987208366394, 0.32911229133605957, 0.15286307036876678, 0.5715178847312927, 0.1421058177947998, -0.3319712281227112, 0.4214445650577545, 0.40120404958724976, 0.2975980341434479, -0.6028232574462891, -0.4929381310939789, -0.3751412034034729, -0.1708482950925827, -0.5686887502670288, -0.57731032371521, 0.12465222179889679, 0.1284392923116684, -0.43118035793304443, -0.3163871467113495, 0.3984540104866028, 0.7123510241508484, -0.7223557829856873, 0.7872931957244873, -0.5612536668777466, 0.8318793177604675, -0.7190631031990051, -0.9362441897392273, -0.40343931317329407, -0.41168665885925293, 0.3009051978588104, 1.341552972793579, -0.1932937651872635, -0.2940855920314789, 0.12231960892677307, 0.06407217681407928, 0.17179426550865173, 0.5848925113677979, -0.850507378578186, -1.008374571800232, -0.3120049834251404, 0.4935968518257141, 0.28765565156936646, -0.5083284378051758, 0.24596761167049408, 0.23687438666820526, -0.14183424413204193, 0.2730633616447449, -0.6180698275566101, -0.8011250495910645, -0.31522879004478455, 0.24563001096248627, -0.7402827739715576, -0.9803990125656128, -0.4245186448097229, 0.4608531594276428, -0.8340269327163696, 0.29949474334716797, -0.42504745721817017, 0.19217923283576965, -0.43713828921318054, 0.0021494636312127113, -0.44343215227127075, 0.34314101934432983, 0.06900712847709656, 0.7451387047767639, 0.40261945128440857, 0.9898465871810913, -0.0325840562582016, 0.03832126781344414, 0.1806769073009491, -0.038790348917245865, 0.49336695671081543, -0.5944565534591675, -0.11007608473300934, 0.5840513706207275, 0.08410926908254623, 0.3574683666229248, -0.38024190068244934, 0.22424814105033875, 0.1995825171470642, -0.10451635718345642, 0.0814497321844101, 1.0485519170761108, -0.4663393497467041, -0.06401972472667694, 0.03562376648187637, -0.22911839187145233, -0.6931552886962891, -0.8839012384414673, -0.5199254751205444, -0.29000377655029297, 0.6680909395217896, -0.8945142030715942, -0.29573097825050354, -0.030606752261519432, -1.0423375368118286, 0.6784048676490784, -0.2211429327726364, 0.31674134731292725, 0.22320964932441711, 0.8320874571800232, -0.12566585838794708, 0.8046274781227112, 0.007438556756824255, -0.2615344524383545, -0.0004128600412514061, -0.25905609130859375, -0.705009937286377, -0.25097426772117615, 0.49575304985046387, 0.9517216682434082, 0.32789257168769836, -0.05287986248731613, -0.3088856339454651, -0.08121255040168762, -0.3477442264556885, 0.10507512837648392, 0.6846293210983276, 0.6224991083145142, -1.7191970348358154, -0.0826295018196106, 0.008899599313735962, 0.3297935426235199, -0.68255215883255, 0.14245283603668213, -0.002171252854168415, -0.3509191572666168, -0.48547929525375366, 0.25864171981811523, 0.4514499008655548, 0.3102077543735504, 0.11769118160009384, -0.46169593930244446, 0.7898796796798706, 0.07624416053295135, -0.2983718812465668, 0.7840525507926941, 0.42405903339385986, -0.2661389112472534, -0.21052968502044678, -0.19702984392642975, -0.3510192632675171, 0.09689975529909134, -0.20196838676929474, -0.31983402371406555, -0.12603187561035156, 0.2072853446006775, 0.012363842688500881, 0.09268364310264587, -0.06054018437862396, 0.1217983067035675, 0.16714239120483398, -0.3258664011955261, 0.2918650209903717, -0.3375115692615509, 0.5938317179679871, 0.005631238222122192, -0.08407802879810333, 0.6207741498947144, -0.3161950707435608, -0.31639257073402405, 0.03850792720913887, 0.25562137365341187, 0.7033876776695251, 0.12588658928871155, 0.1848982572555542, 0.3815167248249054, 0.4396292269229889, 0.4595873951911926, -0.6599369049072266, 0.27602630853652954, -0.3059009909629822, 0.007914825342595577, -0.3399859368801117, 0.06327618658542633, -0.16263800859451294, 0.5188809037208557, -0.00019464229990262538, -0.4087885618209839, 0.020029008388519287, 0.7474537491798401, -0.026049647480249405, 0.6059373617172241, 0.9321457743644714, 0.4957105815410614, -0.6646977066993713, 0.23540720343589783, 0.07401404529809952, -0.22132542729377747, 0.24027882516384125, 0.9195912480354309, -0.15131273865699768, 0.03339877724647522, -0.10995907336473465, 0.659713089466095, 0.023326296359300613, 0.7795066237449646, 1.10311758518219, -0.40786248445510864, -0.11681120097637177, 0.42812326550483704, -0.23022738099098206, -0.11110579967498779, -0.6198590993881226, -0.12169439345598221, -0.36994925141334534, -0.717729926109314, 0.07184455543756485, 0.2799971103668213, 0.3874545097351074, -0.6081557273864746, 0.5012462735176086, -0.13488826155662537, -0.12201740592718124, -0.4322904646396637, -0.40052592754364014, -0.10683044791221619, 0.4994674623012543, -0.6165249943733215, 0.22059424221515656, -0.0299995057284832, 0.12695574760437012, -0.12328600138425827, -0.22070646286010742, -0.78042072057724, 0.036500535905361176, -0.965046226978302, 0.591974139213562, 0.11474237591028214, -0.3036308288574219, -0.46502405405044556, -1.8664004802703857, 0.2702261209487915, -0.05150853097438812, -0.009857912547886372, -1.0732611417770386, -0.156834214925766, -0.6341105103492737, 0.5341580510139465, 0.13757933676242828, -0.2064913958311081, -0.13755574822425842, 0.38687723875045776, 0.7922734022140503, -0.003559847828000784, 0.4335141181945801, -0.19687491655349731, 0.6629204750061035, 0.4002958834171295, -0.09314882010221481, 0.40254080295562744, -0.6355346441268921, -1.0277364253997803, -0.5380218029022217, 0.6720026135444641, 0.1848812848329544, -1.1015465259552002, -0.236833855509758, 0.522055447101593, -0.20218899846076965, -0.3734082281589508, -0.5231265425682068, -0.4549405872821808, -0.5165505409240723, 1.171155333518982, 0.14671725034713745, -0.17625291645526886, 0.10405731946229935, -0.4181970953941345, 0.5537161231040955, -0.8325375914573669, 4.069307327270508, 1.218187928199768, 0.19835272431373596, -0.8381820917129517, 0.43368658423423767, -0.0030277282930910587, 0.2912335693836212, 0.14973850548267365, 0.8578706383705139, -0.0315672904253006, -0.2955395579338074, -0.09334613382816315, 0.1321142464876175, 0.10126034915447235, 0.4918556213378906, 0.21774081885814667, -0.9186996221542358, 0.26657670736312866, -0.33645015954971313, -0.8394344449043274, -0.6652994751930237, 0.2188476175069809, -0.07114600390195847, 0.09985233098268509, -0.4140823483467102, 0.16250461339950562, 0.12021221220493317, 0.868964672088623, 0.1653524786233902, 0.13865555822849274, -0.17983323335647583, 0.0953812301158905, 0.2052098959684372, -0.8932944536209106, -0.6571313142776489, -0.4049617350101471, -0.4117072820663452, -0.37129130959510803, -0.40577203035354614, 0.08123209327459335, 0.554161787033081, 0.8700140714645386, -0.01699468307197094, -0.6036478281021118, 0.18537501990795135, 0.2791405916213989, -0.4452419579029083, -0.021506786346435547, 0.5572808384895325, -0.6783611178398132, 0.9387636184692383, -0.9235509634017944, 0.4787362813949585, -0.3324708938598633, -1.4240061044692993, -0.6978471875190735, 0.21543309092521667, -0.9131616950035095, 0.34493982791900635, 0.4729599952697754, 0.32740217447280884, -0.46694353222846985, 0.26504138112068176, -0.5210695862770081, 0.12636904418468475, -0.19810475409030914, -0.22573816776275635, -0.39940062165260315, 0.032437968999147415, -0.223477303981781, 0.275373637676239, -0.11200335621833801, 0.1387464553117752, -0.2908763885498047, 0.36433082818984985, 0.7951339483261108, -0.3020416498184204, 0.16854842007160187, -0.8424782156944275, -0.979136049747467, 0.14914511144161224, -0.1569308340549469, 0.15156465768814087, -0.2775540053844452, 0.25815847516059875, 1.0894484519958496, -0.24219150841236115, -0.4392119348049164, -0.6193375587463379, 0.5206610560417175, 0.2918663024902344, -0.6617062091827393, -0.0639934092760086, 0.2989614009857178, 0.4629746973514557 ]
{"Title": "Quaternary Prevention: Is this Concept Relevant to Public Health? A Bibliometric and Descriptive Content Analysis", "Authors": "Depallens Miguel Andino, Guimar\u00e3es Jane Mary de Medeiros, Filho Naomar Almeida", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective To measure and map research output on Quaternary Prevention (P4) and outline research trends; to assess the papers content, mainly regarding methods and subjects approached in order to contribute to the improvement of global knowledge about P4 and to evaluate its relevance for public health. Design Bibliometric and descriptive content analysis. Articles reviewed Scientific articles about P4 recorded in Pubmed, LILACS, Scielo or CINAHL published until August 2018, with correspondent full articles available in Portuguese, English, Spanish, German or French. Main outcome measures Year of publication, first authors\u2019 name and nationality, journals\u2019 name, country and ranking, publication language, used methods and main reported subjects. Results 65 articles were included, published in 33 journals of 16 countries between 2003 and 2018 with a peak of publications in 2015. The first authors came from 17 different countries, 23% of them were Brazilian and Uruguay was the leading nation according to the scientific production per capita. 40% of all the selected articles were in English, 32% in Portuguese, 26% in Spanish. 28% of the papers were published in Q1 or Q2 journals. The research outputs on P4 begun first in the South of Europe, went to South America and then expanded worldwide. 88% of the articles were bibliographic research and 38% of all focused on specific examples of medical overuse (including several screening tests). Conclusions Quaternary prevention represents an ethical and valid approach to prevent occurence of iatrogenic events and to achieve equal and fair access to health services. Conceptual, geographical and linguistic elements, as well as WONCA conferences and type of healthcare systems in the authors\u2019 country were fundamental factors that affected research output. The quality and quantity of available studies is still limited, therefore further investigations are recommended to assess the effective impact of P4 on public health.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007526"}
10.1101/19010389
[ 0.14156249165534973, 0.336357057094574, 0.3079962730407715, 0.5525016188621521, -0.443820983171463, 0.5829704403877258, -0.29119443893432617, -0.2686152458190918, 0.183623269200325, 0.2719901502132416, 0.36510053277015686, -0.6071770191192627, 0.1854150891304016, -0.678810715675354, 0.11895211786031723, 0.4031071662902832, -0.004299225751310587, -0.503335177898407, -1.0850564241409302, -0.42508381605148315, 0.2482515275478363, -0.3954910933971405, -0.5755223631858826, 0.12578539550304413, 0.24236124753952026, 0.37763068079948425, -0.018866965547204018, -0.23521415889263153, 0.8694806694984436, 0.1481231153011322, -0.30821484327316284, -0.35087278485298157, 1.1415860652923584, -0.8972775340080261, -0.32399648427963257, 0.2258697748184204, 0.9490945339202881, -0.3351862132549286, -0.16695430874824524, -0.8245067000389099, 0.2125788927078247, 0.42034563422203064, -0.10412269085645676, -0.4410001039505005, -0.4611630141735077, -0.10336091369390488, -0.1850859820842743, -0.5179394483566284, 0.1002577394247055, -0.9995401501655579, 0.1747577041387558, -0.2764453589916229, -0.6120526194572449, -0.9842417240142822, -0.3889336585998535, -0.09976166486740112, -0.023071344941854477, -0.5744748711585999, 0.2966592609882355, -0.3034639358520508, 0.8020358085632324, -0.30374670028686523, 0.29184654355049133, -1.328961968421936, 0.1799127757549286, 0.3654831349849701, 0.21067021787166595, 0.5949598550796509, 0.056492194533348083, -0.6030654311180115, -0.09458920359611511, 0.4382462799549103, -0.3219497799873352, -0.37570759654045105, -0.31013262271881104, 0.01612798310816288, 0.09671441465616226, 0.08227595686912537, 0.004940854385495186, -0.2190791815519333, 0.5764751434326172, 0.5151938796043396, 0.3210386633872986, 0.3492770493030548, 0.12753234803676605, 0.08751355111598969, -0.02416190318763256, 0.7208946347236633, -0.31830742955207825, -0.7078289985656738, 0.24841901659965515, 0.4611530005931854, -0.5789061188697815, -0.11243253946304321, 0.07616054266691208, 0.25058650970458984, -0.13918612897396088, 0.23805870115756989, 0.04449531435966492, -0.1831485629081726, 0.14692911505699158, 0.6181201934814453, -0.5720954537391663, 0.8109610676765442, 0.17782655358314514, 0.18348199129104614, -0.31775569915771484, -0.16871631145477295, 0.5346141457557678, -0.4898821711540222, 0.47759532928466797, -0.10142237693071365, -0.028464987874031067, -0.007790570147335529, 0.11274651437997818, -0.34666693210601807, -0.2786352336406708, 0.1493205726146698, -0.5617664456367493, 0.22500889003276825, -0.21445302665233612, 0.18522214889526367, 0.30484509468078613, -0.2943095862865448, -0.1236945241689682, -0.31492626667022705, 0.45585522055625916, 0.08093813061714172, 0.44576919078826904, -0.06962162256240845, 0.007664564065635204, -0.29212287068367004, -0.08507069200277328, 0.01128733903169632, -0.03362250700592995, 0.05697820335626602, -0.2309606671333313, 0.21671746671199799, -0.047950565814971924, -0.2449234575033188, -0.20210543274879456, 0.7256038784980774, -0.5551751255989075, 1.1543656587600708, 0.27043870091438293, 0.6360279321670532, -0.03955391049385071, -0.6013593673706055, -0.27729934453964233, -0.0467938557267189, 0.359712153673172, 0.5560464859008789, -0.3648982644081116, -0.050963420420885086, -0.4704578220844269, 0.19650758802890778, -0.5318857431411743, 0.129881352186203, -0.394621878862381, 1.1147122383117676, 0.07785583287477493, -0.10212903469800949, 0.32199984788894653, 0.6380342245101929, -0.0761333703994751, 0.938650906085968, 0.12681493163108826, 0.03402179107069969, 0.3245680034160614, -0.3929910361766815, 0.07702958583831787, 0.2840214967727661, -0.07578634470701218, -0.3486071228981018, -0.4244896471500397, 0.19792592525482178, 0.4731144905090332, 0.09834210574626923, 0.014749850146472454, 0.6958630084991455, 0.5935744643211365, -0.24582432210445404, 0.8940076231956482, 0.21646572649478912, -0.21231646835803986, 0.4231787621974945, -0.5852822661399841, -0.7920026183128357, 0.3898107409477234, -0.3166835308074951, -0.6965158581733704, 1.3978294134140015, -0.06260699033737183, 0.4313834607601166, -0.4997026026248932, -0.2718774974346161, 0.03010919876396656, -0.3347717523574829, 0.5258451104164124, -0.16266317665576935, -1.2225617170333862, 0.8321815133094788, -0.7522359490394592, -0.031519677489995956, -0.5349474549293518, 0.21998341381549835, 0.7787346243858337, 1.0180988311767578, -0.10157561302185059, 0.0899314433336258, 0.809846818447113, -0.08718311041593552, -0.26123350858688354, 0.1003892794251442, 0.19024552404880524, -1.1022114753723145, 0.6500723958015442, 0.6554346680641174, -0.7072190046310425, 0.06177959963679314, -0.42111754417419434, 0.2546030879020691, 0.4269970953464508, 0.6934844255447388, 0.2923857867717743, 0.5325134992599487, -0.11330429464578629, 0.7180027365684509, -0.4581741690635681, -0.4067833125591278, 0.5340791344642639, 0.5207343101501465, 0.5490370392799377, 0.11225888133049011, 0.7637643814086914, -0.2122890055179596, -0.07078230381011963, 0.5919650197029114, 0.3764166235923767, 0.9839869141578674, 0.4593662619590759, -0.1591734141111374, 0.6795448660850525, 0.19241684675216675, -0.4255189001560211, 0.16407449543476105, -0.07066935300827026, -0.5366230607032776, -0.35708293318748474, -0.5813578963279724, -0.7846707701683044, 0.756109356880188, -0.08767139911651611, -0.18694926798343658, -0.6816093921661377, 0.21542294323444366, 0.28970232605934143, -0.055546604096889496, -0.6466053128242493, 0.3988383412361145, -0.24457666277885437, -0.04291417449712753, 0.2453385293483734, 0.3907693326473236, 0.5284634232521057, -0.07250753790140152, 0.2545314431190491, 0.1113431453704834, -0.07849133014678955, -0.4915894865989685, -0.6553082466125488, -1.0966242551803589, -0.9365424513816833, -0.49804821610450745, 0.4427626132965088, -0.30686429142951965, -0.5373969078063965, -0.1879993975162506, 0.7830018401145935, 0.012251782231032848, -0.9634947180747986, -0.522858738899231, -0.48994606733322144, 0.12000630795955658, -0.7827815413475037, 0.21214523911476135, -1.177855372428894, 0.12947678565979004, -0.6096331477165222, 0.5968378186225891, -0.6160357594490051, -0.7849078178405762, -0.20977061986923218, -0.06227157637476921, 0.5493130683898926, -0.20039288699626923, -0.14408977329730988, -0.8204746246337891, -0.44451743364334106, -0.4083700180053711, 0.7020606994628906, -0.9952965378761292, 0.635442316532135, 0.32653942704200745, -1.185718297958374, 0.5316787362098694, -0.1668374091386795, -0.1303311288356781, 0.25725847482681274, 0.525020182132721, -0.42128509283065796, 0.7757097482681274, 0.5596485137939453, -0.2577696442604065, -0.504719078540802, 0.9467271566390991, 0.5969840884208679, -0.3280692994594574, 0.06581145524978638, -0.70250403881073, -0.5486270189285278, 0.34711623191833496, 0.1990128457546234, -0.21082960069179535, 0.6097309589385986, 0.01196285616606474, 0.19850684702396393, -0.486812949180603, -0.4406850039958954, -0.8046081066131592, -0.694878876209259, -0.1447547972202301, -0.3956611156463623, 0.12347237020730972, -0.24508675932884216, 0.048140011727809906, -0.09120354056358337, -0.6847983002662659, -0.3822440803050995, 0.7201892137527466, 0.2692543864250183, 0.4952766001224518, 0.13963501155376434, 0.4116193354129791, -0.46071457862854004, -0.17594605684280396, -0.5592513084411621, -0.48509374260902405, -0.22017264366149902, -0.6860119700431824, 0.3340476155281067, 0.762894332408905, 0.6052297353744507, -0.04674172028899193, -0.37688571214675903, 0.7890428304672241, -0.27814313769340515, -0.18401288986206055, 0.29661110043525696, 0.8561943173408508, 0.39860546588897705, 0.08098625391721725, 0.0826788917183876, -0.29420968890190125, -0.911759614944458, -0.20881275832653046, -0.6539887189865112, 0.4503385126590729, 0.29936695098876953, 0.14857470989227295, 0.2846626043319702, 0.07012467086315155, -0.2966510057449341, -0.29160284996032715, -0.23444268107414246, -0.35110539197921753, 0.5585907697677612, 0.23018813133239746, 0.8680251240730286, -0.06222685053944588, -0.38457292318344116, 0.8676325678825378, 0.28544506430625916, 0.11229070276021957, 0.16979461908340454, -0.3760892450809479, -0.004265995230525732, -0.086290143430233, 0.028672270476818085, 0.07647247612476349, -0.544849693775177, 0.2834893763065338, 0.7520089745521545, 0.14662319421768188, -0.8188260793685913, -0.0809575617313385, 0.5193772912025452, 1.2669402360916138, -0.13396596908569336, 0.32494035363197327, -0.17219708859920502, 0.030205102637410164, 0.1848846673965454, 0.59858638048172, 0.0804138258099556, -0.3204123377799988, -0.5848800539970398, 0.22410529851913452, 0.7072422504425049, -0.421015202999115, 0.6999855041503906, -0.5652529001235962, 0.3471919298171997, -0.1442522406578064, 0.07433461397886276, 0.09521260857582092, -0.20872828364372253, -0.5872412323951721, 0.0660170167684555, 0.5608569383621216, 0.6976392865180969, -0.046003106981515884, -0.8608711957931519, -0.03022124245762825, 0.24525661766529083, -0.12599220871925354, -0.28477105498313904, -1.3321870565414429, -0.3875011205673218, -0.1587221324443817, 0.027356408536434174, -0.16473357379436493, 0.05743425711989403, -0.3173450231552124, 0.19275616109371185, 0.9009810090065002, 0.08170263469219208, 0.40089306235313416, 0.40855783224105835, -0.3880962133407593, 0.0033780978992581367, 0.030796680599451065, -0.7863465547561646, -1.040647268295288, -0.1792083978652954, 0.25142475962638855, 0.5772838592529297, 1.1389838457107544, 0.5241703987121582, -0.11057758331298828, 0.7257197499275208, -0.3539179265499115, 0.6259996294975281, -0.5455346703529358, -0.5682210922241211, -0.24996472895145416, -0.2157461792230606, -0.3617507815361023, 0.8423885107040405, 0.07763245701789856, -0.20306424796581268, -0.524333655834198, 0.2453407347202301, -0.45332586765289307, -0.09714967757463455, 0.7925037741661072, -0.5236549377441406, 0.32160279154777527, 0.8447551727294922, -0.2355303317308426, -0.2375694215297699, -0.7153796553611755, 0.45120906829833984, -0.8879832625389099, 0.9482609629631042, -0.6779566407203674, -0.15773601830005646, -0.0014918537344783545, -0.8106579184532166, 0.17329175770282745, -0.25204965472221375, 0.5439605116844177, -0.5282822847366333, -0.11121659725904465, -0.5338851809501648, 0.41608375310897827, -0.3467797338962555, 0.006606888025999069, -0.3486408293247223, -0.09811228513717651, 0.07830105721950531, -0.5381501913070679, -0.13761599361896515, -0.47989755868911743, -0.4160102307796478, -0.330969899892807, -0.9582822322845459, -0.07717131823301315, 0.5967540144920349, -0.13308487832546234, 0.17384061217308044, -0.5691367387771606, -0.11436774581670761, 0.388125479221344, 0.3044555187225342, -0.45313018560409546, -0.14064179360866547, -0.4080992639064789, 0.018580446019768715, 0.10963280498981476, -1.1875033378601074, 0.712022066116333, -0.17044928669929504, 0.2694568932056427, -0.5331439971923828, 0.5543677806854248, 0.9961858987808228, -0.11914738267660141, -0.1353154182434082, -0.024725180119276047, -0.5044122338294983, -1.115472674369812, -0.13124701380729675, 0.32765674591064453, 0.36457958817481995, -0.12200802564620972, 0.15050385892391205, -0.17130936682224274, -0.44136059284210205, -0.982536256313324, 0.40023449063301086, -0.5966630578041077, -0.040856488049030304, -0.13278837502002716, 0.2236393243074417, 0.37424513697624207, -0.050815872848033905, -0.09704747796058655, -0.19798193871974945, -0.44138896465301514, -0.8434484004974365, -0.23694507777690887, 0.019585739821195602, -0.9486272931098938, -0.19649292528629303, -1.144213080406189, -0.4826236069202423, 1.1782540082931519, 0.14534986019134521, 0.30404314398765564, 0.20865924656391144, 0.35198765993118286, 0.444441556930542, 0.41456785798072815, -0.2680349051952362, -0.6423116326332092, 0.8637074828147888, 0.09223159402608871, 0.38195866346359253, -0.6291409134864807, -0.39682987332344055, 0.27595725655555725, -0.8831261992454529, 0.45836925506591797, 0.3750419318675995, -0.8369143009185791, 0.24219243228435516, -0.9146685004234314, 0.04095972701907158, -0.9433044195175171, 0.09574833512306213, 0.7110792994499207, 0.18923713266849518, -0.4574624001979828, -0.0860230028629303, -0.5690337419509888, 0.06741378456354141, -0.008042020723223686, -1.4482227563858032, 0.18808387219905853, -0.15228047966957092, -0.15681619942188263, 0.4975878596305847, -0.2109043002128601, 0.7221508026123047, -1.1591471433639526, 0.7415329217910767, 0.6406339406967163, -0.1609334498643875, -0.3763936460018158, 0.2187482863664627, 0.11491597443819046, 0.47141915559768677, 0.39267978072166443, 0.1128409206867218, 0.07722246646881104, -0.2598952353000641, 0.8041454553604126, -0.2796146869659424, -0.6744660139083862, -0.01039074081927538, 0.7000738382339478, -0.04615961015224457, -0.033682048320770264, 0.31940528750419617, -0.013126936741173267, 0.027867358177900314, -0.13270986080169678, 0.5999420881271362, -0.004566664807498455, -0.18477515876293182, 0.17824134230613708, -0.22587154805660248, -0.777704119682312, -0.083408422768116, -0.37955132126808167, -0.1617097705602646, 0.10047197341918945, 0.5546789169311523, 1.0181143283843994, -1.0785685777664185, 0.6578376293182373, 0.7750338912010193, -0.598789632320404, -0.260177880525589, -0.16591067612171173, -0.3186243772506714, 0.1215628981590271, -0.1795356571674347, -0.2286617010831833, 0.6759461760520935, -0.8307737708091736, 0.22088590264320374, 0.2429615706205368, 0.1999455988407135, 0.5518895983695984, -0.32608649134635925, 0.8521382808685303, -0.6846821904182434, 0.3531739115715027, 0.44923490285873413, -0.37017083168029785, -0.2948504686355591, -0.21169482171535492, 0.7602129578590393, -0.7597126960754395, 0.21506980061531067, 0.3856680393218994, 0.184533953666687, -0.030312515795230865, 0.17633695900440216, 0.5819954872131348, -0.1331547051668167, -0.062492482364177704, -0.11068840324878693, 0.3921164870262146, -0.2129359394311905, -0.3744676411151886, -0.24273617565631866, 0.4391566812992096, -0.7502043843269348, 0.5322549939155579, -0.40315327048301697, -0.41006264090538025, 1.178019642829895, 0.461694598197937, 0.07187464088201523, -0.5515249967575073, -0.9381260275840759, -0.8080055117607117, 0.11895520985126495, 0.45889973640441895, 0.3141382932662964, -0.5638810992240906, 1.4183754920959473, -0.5537185072898865, -0.25861215591430664, 0.3054846525192261, 0.5122427344322205, 0.0673125609755516, 0.8088505864143372, -0.5863287448883057, 0.1391303986310959, -0.32750195264816284, -0.3868800401687622, -0.18475621938705444, -0.38373562693595886, 0.1982494592666626, 0.5924853682518005, -0.013428698293864727, 0.3106769621372223, 0.5283447504043579, 0.47242531180381775, 0.3739050328731537, 0.8431236147880554, -0.5720129013061523, 0.22011344134807587, -0.49929219484329224, 0.3986174166202545, 0.33853277564048767, 0.05191506817936897, 0.7043947577476501, -0.5499902367591858, 0.5499754548072815, 1.2116429805755615, -0.7935473322868347, 0.3880224823951721, 0.4039228856563568, 0.637164294719696, -0.18306615948677063, -0.555273175239563, -0.12013142555952072, 0.423713743686676, -0.6009150147438049, 0.5537635087966919, -0.15721555054187775, 0.22335030138492584, 0.0495731495320797, 0.12985827028751373, -0.9235425591468811, 0.483153373003006, 0.2022298127412796, -0.7186272144317627, -0.06600597500801086, 0.573786199092865, 0.46379703283309937, -0.02771759033203125, -0.2526440918445587, 0.523752748966217, 0.18110841512680054, -1.0446640253067017, 0.7918038368225098, 0.7281250357627869, -0.12640713155269623, 0.3821171820163727, 1.0168423652648926, 0.08804279565811157, -0.4607916474342346, -0.15904033184051514, 0.006933578755706549, 0.3925236761569977, 0.23041123151779175, -0.1370527148246765, 0.37353283166885376, -0.15788871049880981, -1.0294698476791382, 0.3606138527393341, -0.8758913278579712, -0.6172853708267212, 0.6717109680175781, -0.38496342301368713, 0.500413715839386, -0.38666293025016785, -0.3704776465892792, 0.8327276110649109, -0.10400345921516418, 0.6251210570335388, -0.011402776464819908, 0.25248345732688904, 0.14726245403289795, 0.2911149263381958, 0.06835705786943436, -0.136527881026268, 0.13995404541492462, -0.17593851685523987, -0.6783360242843628, -1.4197288751602173, 0.35493430495262146, 0.3545302450656891, 0.5343016982078552, 0.038147661834955215, -0.060229916125535965, 0.11933048069477081, -0.06089763715863228, -0.4519701302051544, 0.014446266926825047, -0.24920016527175903, -1.226900577545166, -0.13158389925956726, -0.3499879837036133, 0.18398840725421906, -0.5325310826301575, 0.7712058424949646, 0.47692421078681946, -0.7181733250617981, -1.075982928276062, -0.3360355794429779, -0.0025311734061688185, -0.28987452387809753, 0.3382827639579773, 0.07347077876329422, -0.15049034357070923, -0.513397753238678, -0.6417431235313416, 1.0934077501296997, 0.2654799818992615, 0.22030051052570343, 0.5979498624801636, -0.5139339566230774, 0.14754530787467957, 0.4568658173084259, 0.39843207597732544, 0.31513625383377075, 0.5121910572052002, 0.4715115427970886, -0.21645000576972961, 0.5671703815460205, -0.3199443817138672, -0.30547773838043213, 0.0771186575293541, -0.05253823474049568, -0.04697706177830696, 0.08123574405908585, 0.41786110401153564, -0.06633143872022629, -0.5947951674461365, 0.5222153663635254, -0.43306031823158264, -0.3771456778049469, -0.4845380187034607, 0.2995356619358063, 0.8231309056282043, 0.33058834075927734, -0.12339647859334946, 0.14974309504032135, 0.3244604170322418, -0.06925737112760544, 0.06784811615943909, 0.755795419216156, -0.4085628390312195, 0.008191175758838654, -0.23168721795082092, 0.3188406229019165, -0.332165390253067, 0.5050797462463379, 0.12443434447050095, -0.432892382144928, -0.08812955021858215, -0.10900676995515823, 0.01335547398775816, 0.2610214054584503, 1.1414310932159424, -0.028110314160585403, -0.11361337453126907, 0.49891161918640137, 0.004857813939452171, -0.41707634925842285, 0.3365252912044525, 0.12405237555503845, -1.2773340940475464, 0.00518744857981801, 0.32645827531814575, 0.07757306843996048, 0.6661908626556396, 0.92972731590271, 0.3603633940219879, -0.08502203226089478, 0.7104042768478394, -0.029167404398322105, 0.1198718398809433, 0.22839736938476562, 0.3583317995071411, 0.11308257281780243, -0.14750003814697266, -0.5293188691139221, -0.17389893531799316, -0.03241749480366707, -0.20720762014389038, 0.3014436960220337, 0.5638725161552429, 0.2233998030424118, -0.21825914084911346, -0.48414573073387146, -0.4455678164958954, 0.013415711931884289, -0.2734709680080414, 0.3134683072566986, 0.6911472082138062, 0.10931362956762314, -0.6322826147079468, 0.058400318026542664, -0.20625364780426025, -1.040462613105774, -0.6605795621871948, -0.6669620275497437, -0.04621414095163345, 0.19943156838417053, -0.2467920184135437, 0.14451003074645996, -1.4356184005737305, 0.15203025937080383, 0.4835772216320038, -0.39509859681129456, -0.9450995922088623, 0.12319861352443695, -0.06875818222761154, 0.3431195914745331, 0.08121148496866226, 0.40886473655700684, 0.4890052080154419, 0.333731472492218, 0.8295102715492249, -0.3393651247024536, 0.7644446492195129, 0.6624067425727844, -0.36369383335113525, 0.36062589287757874, -0.2564318776130676, -0.5603801608085632, -0.07356584817171097, -0.3351849317550659, -0.4013972580432892, 0.3318006098270416, -0.07801409065723419, -0.25911641120910645, 0.2376527488231659, 0.6875755190849304, 0.323689728975296, -0.04550914466381073, -0.6160557270050049, -0.07748164981603622, -0.27608683705329895, 0.6354430913925171, -0.22256118059158325, 0.0578506700694561, 0.15397366881370544, 0.1884470134973526, 0.3984609544277191, -0.6444877982139587, 4.329119682312012, 0.8481239676475525, 0.6090027093887329, 0.39026132225990295, -0.5141424536705017, 0.4344710111618042, 0.20685414969921112, 0.31200167536735535, -0.21172501146793365, 0.07965394854545593, -0.14058323204517365, -0.14468301832675934, 0.566977858543396, -0.18424203991889954, 1.0204277038574219, 0.3060450553894043, -0.5305138230323792, -0.8447386622428894, 0.20139969885349274, -0.5635232329368591, -0.4383877217769623, 0.08698112517595291, -0.6275269389152527, -0.044917140156030655, 0.21631912887096405, 0.5352513194084167, 0.1940954327583313, 0.15958213806152344, -0.07012739032506943, -0.9918508529663086, 0.0655575543642044, -0.27997949719429016, -0.5863365530967712, -0.8687294125556946, 0.41014739871025085, 0.07846781611442566, 0.3908432126045227, -0.4414099156856537, -0.46798163652420044, -0.05903751403093338, -0.164464071393013, -0.16144929826259613, 0.08801213651895523, -0.9054887890815735, -0.685865044593811, 0.30990520119667053, -0.2786766588687897, -0.7875368595123291, 0.3531799912452698, -0.7944788932800293, 0.8164113759994507, -0.4061376452445984, 0.10944728553295135, -0.30954286456108093, -0.6068688035011292, 0.12107325345277786, -0.5988202095031738, -0.7150799036026001, 0.500756561756134, -0.40185078978538513, 0.5180344581604004, -0.08678736537694931, -0.8209286332130432, 0.43992120027542114, -0.8544343113899231, 0.1999044418334961, 0.07797455787658691, -0.00964834913611412, -0.3547179698944092, -0.6370330452919006, 0.45586085319519043, -0.5787973999977112, -0.5207798480987549, 0.5125002264976501, 1.3475172519683838, -0.35520994663238525, -0.21226973831653595, 0.6717767715454102, -0.2054305076599121, -0.7407180666923523, 0.392666220664978, 0.33217620849609375, -0.23549214005470276, -0.6742216944694519, 0.40545299649238586, 0.6562568545341492, -0.2593308985233307, -0.8576147556304932, -0.9935992360115051, 0.8309447169303894, 0.3723039925098419, 1.3372920751571655, -0.045258112251758575, 0.3493666350841522, -0.5739560723304749 ]
{"Title": "Tensor Fasciae Suralis \u2013 Prevalence Study and Literature Review", "Authors": "Bale Logan S., Herrin Sean O.", "Abstract": "SUMMARY Tensor fasciae suralis (TFS) is an accessory muscle of the posterior lower extremity. Although TFS has been documented in cadaveric and radiological reports, its prevalence remains unknown. The TFS variant is noteworthy to anatomists, as it may be encountered in the dissection laboratory, and clinicians, as the muscle could potentially cause confusion during physical examination or diagnostic imaging. Multiple variations of TFS have been reported in the literature, suggesting the need for a classification system. We dissected 236 formalin-fixed cadaveric lower limbs to determine the prevalence of TFS. The PubMed and MEDLINE databases were searched to compare the anatomical features of independent TFS case reports. In our prevalence study, the TFS muscle was identified in three lower limbs (1.3%). In total, 35 cases of TFS (31 cadaveric and four radiological) were identified in the literature. Our literature review revealed that the accessory muscle most often arises as a single head from the long head of the biceps femoris, yet many other presentations have been documented. The need for a classification system to distinguish between the subtypes of TFS became apparent during the literature review. Tensor fasciae suralis is a rare muscle, present in only 3 of 236 (1.3%) cadaveric lower limbs dissected in this study. We propose the use of a classification system, based on muscle origin and number of heads, to better organize the subtypes of TFS.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010389"}
10.1101/2019.12.10.19014159
[ -0.32605165243148804, 0.38933706283569336, 0.030134404078125954, 0.6798521280288696, -0.061275381594896317, -0.9834164977073669, 0.007953505963087082, 0.11599662154912949, -0.5685957074165344, 0.16826121509075165, 0.0645303800702095, -0.053329888731241226, 0.2827680706977844, -0.4488447308540344, 0.10553175210952759, 0.03293529897928238, -0.6930409073829651, -0.39174315333366394, -0.6537386775016785, -0.07027684152126312, -0.36989596486091614, 0.448579877614975, -0.6791264414787292, 0.1692184954881668, 0.13181698322296143, 0.49536827206611633, -0.0924469456076622, 0.15783074498176575, 1.34274423122406, 0.2937345504760742, 0.6386247277259827, -0.29194706678390503, 0.5266727209091187, -0.5514272451400757, -0.5674899220466614, -0.3563638925552368, 0.3397912085056305, -0.3146304786205292, 0.11153137683868408, -0.20725247263908386, 0.7842811942100525, -0.26413267850875854, 0.23966366052627563, -1.045648217201233, -0.8659911155700684, -0.6847208142280579, -0.0684685930609703, -0.7836329936981201, -0.5081899762153625, 0.0026492546312510967, -0.433293879032135, -0.16651208698749542, 0.6314800977706909, -0.1541929692029953, -0.0026281008031219244, -0.6560593843460083, 0.36639609932899475, -0.45134156942367554, -0.7902849912643433, 0.4942868649959564, 0.32023242115974426, 0.454725980758667, 0.279949814081192, -1.219900131225586, 0.13679395616054535, 0.2559179663658142, 0.09575312584638596, -0.08815357834100723, -0.6083055734634399, -0.19990330934524536, -1.2502694129943848, 0.2111562341451645, -0.11310804635286331, -0.16613836586475372, 0.23367254436016083, -0.7653295993804932, 0.20418229699134827, -0.7298954725265503, 0.2529985308647156, -0.07209527492523193, 0.12075427174568176, 0.2108820229768753, 0.06826386600732803, 0.6932218074798584, -0.3641470670700073, -0.19354628026485443, -0.08115977048873901, 0.14374478161334991, 0.3977098762989044, -0.2755626440048218, 0.2652354836463928, 0.15479469299316406, -0.35012707114219666, 0.641323447227478, 0.04657455533742905, 0.8146556615829468, 0.08446747064590454, 0.21487627923488617, 0.3155508041381836, -0.4272673428058624, 0.6892417669296265, 0.38135045766830444, -0.11322510242462158, 0.9699492454528809, -0.8003512620925903, -0.35724782943725586, 0.23070983588695526, -0.05729801952838898, 0.16524219512939453, -0.4983566105365753, 0.2690989673137665, 0.3308890461921692, 0.12880787253379822, 0.12945953011512756, 0.020663565024733543, 0.15107524394989014, -0.10372950881719589, 0.30891650915145874, -0.5477334260940552, 0.4070735573768616, -0.42403271794319153, -0.011132828891277313, 0.14843854308128357, -0.19582857191562653, 0.6820593476295471, -0.3691650629043579, 0.04161163792014122, 0.21342960000038147, 0.35857442021369934, -0.11313722282648087, 0.3767280876636505, 0.24612286686897278, 0.22943700850009918, 1.262804388999939, -0.30568623542785645, 0.2204807698726654, -0.640937864780426, 0.5479655265808105, -0.4503716826438904, -0.567907452583313, -0.34111037850379944, -0.04351631924510002, -0.17405831813812256, 1.1756131649017334, 0.10607725381851196, 0.37395960092544556, -0.2599374055862427, -0.5570312142372131, -0.30325832962989807, -0.5378523468971252, -0.33831238746643066, 0.04654334485530853, 0.08673226833343506, 0.23087571561336517, -0.5049223303794861, -0.25859418511390686, -0.552028238773346, 0.07266084104776382, -0.4031461179256439, -0.17196786403656006, 0.15933458507061005, 0.18462102115154266, -0.7412963509559631, 1.0610666275024414, -0.27549153566360474, 0.24007616937160492, -0.16654671728610992, 0.07469166815280914, 0.360920250415802, -0.9278004169464111, 0.27095556259155273, 0.06697055697441101, -0.21987038850784302, -0.1817181557416916, -0.16513365507125854, 1.1644960641860962, 0.6661949157714844, 0.6355618238449097, -0.0773155465722084, 0.08181356638669968, -0.1534131020307541, -0.34695833921432495, 0.7613649964332581, 0.6911464929580688, 0.21731142699718475, -0.5919758677482605, -0.8012846112251282, -0.39908596873283386, 0.186570942401886, -0.1565735936164856, -0.21190178394317627, 0.8878914713859558, -1.0788201093673706, 0.478273868560791, 0.08578556030988693, 1.170967936515808, -0.3057599365711212, 0.4727434813976288, 0.2911190092563629, -0.40126869082450867, -0.4096372425556183, 1.0982078313827515, 0.11718875169754028, -0.007892102003097534, -0.16909465193748474, -0.04974456876516342, 0.20176087319850922, 0.27396151423454285, -0.1634783148765564, 0.04233825206756592, 0.21316911280155182, -0.0074264719150960445, -0.4432600736618042, 0.3601498305797577, 0.8567214012145996, -1.0186986923217773, -0.04543451592326164, 0.28895103931427, 0.2984725534915924, 0.3127407431602478, 0.28024065494537354, -0.26498034596443176, 0.5586633682250977, 0.23805908858776093, -0.11348703503608704, -0.04212695360183716, 0.8044794797897339, 0.45789071917533875, -0.18132993578910828, 0.4602588415145874, 0.05083991587162018, 0.3071484863758087, -0.0008201541495509446, 0.04157838225364685, 0.16649295389652252, 0.4685385525226593, 0.08915544301271439, 0.31236037611961365, 0.7348024249076843, -0.5347529053688049, 0.13533104956150055, -0.22623226046562195, 1.4954562187194824, -0.05155453458428383, -0.20187506079673767, 0.9259279370307922, -0.20103222131729126, -0.051784925162792206, -0.6899017691612244, -0.1348869502544403, -1.6414079666137695, 0.8203586339950562, 0.17356140911579132, -0.0352814681828022, -0.5457034707069397, 0.21735833585262299, 0.5357624292373657, 0.6816105246543884, -0.2574980854988098, -0.6396663188934326, 0.05131816118955612, -0.32096192240715027, 0.4841831922531128, -0.37714922428131104, 0.7811341285705566, 0.9826090931892395, -0.043879877775907516, 0.4312894642353058, -0.18009713292121887, -0.3650628328323364, -0.5666297674179077, -1.0285168886184692, -1.4614685773849487, -0.18575231730937958, -0.553636372089386, -0.34350383281707764, -0.19956344366073608, -0.8188050985336304, 0.44886520504951477, 0.043752189725637436, 0.015587604604661465, -0.27171340584754944, 0.004709477070719004, 0.4151538610458374, 0.7573635578155518, -0.016082771122455597, -0.27858859300613403, 0.11428765207529068, -0.0978124737739563, 0.43823951482772827, 0.16601161658763885, -0.4634101390838623, -0.5024369359016418, -0.9584969282150269, 0.8650617599487305, -0.18570257723331451, 0.5014768838882446, 0.2542988657951355, -0.25344398617744446, -0.07308962196111679, 0.33584684133529663, -0.2883652448654175, 0.2623806595802307, 0.2525486946105957, -1.213912010192871, 0.6058604717254639, 0.5319815278053284, 0.08255820721387863, 0.4133233428001404, 0.4652533233165741, -0.4291289746761322, 1.2291673421859741, 0.16249823570251465, 0.1641995906829834, -0.6196379661560059, -0.09320789575576782, 0.29480770230293274, 0.05408792197704315, 0.17640145123004913, -0.7440454959869385, -0.8050486445426941, 0.18538667261600494, 0.17098699510097504, -0.5925540924072266, 0.08013593405485153, 0.1629452407360077, -0.15046823024749756, -0.6350094676017761, -0.3388518989086151, -0.6986388564109802, -0.7031481266021729, 0.5496016144752502, 0.11805722117424011, 0.4589114487171173, 0.19530397653579712, 0.36927586793899536, -0.263455331325531, -0.4300439953804016, 0.6291515231132507, 0.3500044047832489, 0.5362717509269714, -0.10407005250453949, -0.06390956789255142, 0.2865634560585022, 0.37777888774871826, 0.780778169631958, 0.46905723214149475, -0.13448566198349, -0.5115324258804321, -0.46688657999038696, 0.0891466960310936, 0.06262070685625076, 0.43297290802001953, -0.7706361413002014, 0.09317201375961304, 0.17140530049800873, -0.5278986692428589, -0.23844100534915924, 0.347602516412735, 0.7545122504234314, -0.5467450618743896, -0.013485152274370193, 0.4844975173473358, 0.10427885502576828, -0.8752104640007019, 0.15510758757591248, 0.5403096675872803, 0.4081256091594696, 0.04876663163304329, -0.8451842665672302, 0.18678352236747742, 0.06727729737758636, 0.011928454972803593, 0.14245815575122833, 0.40764230489730835, -0.5235982537269592, 1.0942256450653076, -0.1073489636182785, 0.8828486204147339, -0.7141571044921875, -0.17227666079998016, 0.6902410984039307, 0.9473705887794495, 0.01770201325416565, 0.14249064028263092, -0.00937944557517767, -0.31862181425094604, 0.5644226670265198, 0.5006056427955627, 0.023940902203321457, -0.05778304859995842, -0.17280758917331696, 0.47543570399284363, -0.39279884099960327, -0.8332786560058594, -0.4989093542098999, 0.685435950756073, 0.7155334949493408, 0.15782839059829712, -0.24315577745437622, 0.8906214237213135, -0.8691760897636414, 0.32350727915763855, 0.4721132218837738, 0.02802230231463909, -0.22998100519180298, -0.869156539440155, 0.5129063725471497, -0.33808934688568115, -0.1379331350326538, 0.3569338023662567, 0.1273062527179718, -0.4602122902870178, 0.247017040848732, 0.20705483853816986, 0.2521243691444397, -0.4018360674381256, -0.32638487219810486, -0.09553104639053345, 0.4248031973838806, -0.5059559941291809, 0.2342948317527771, -0.20668505132198334, 0.01453604456037283, 0.44352614879608154, -0.8065261840820312, -0.4391160309314728, -0.7473968267440796, 0.49549829959869385, 0.421864777803421, -0.3273408114910126, -0.4421561360359192, 0.2580317556858063, -0.12277694046497345, -0.6254898309707642, 0.5061957240104675, 0.43551355600357056, -0.06967223435640335, 0.15116660296916962, -0.2848922312259674, -0.3951931595802307, 0.07215095311403275, -0.40565264225006104, -0.4912349283695221, 0.16009625792503357, -0.04698988422751427, 0.2157588005065918, 0.5080704092979431, 0.8316973447799683, -0.47034379839897156, 0.4046449065208435, -0.9619802236557007, 0.43644383549690247, -0.21209244430065155, -0.4317837655544281, -0.8585918545722961, 0.2889389991760254, 0.15266509354114532, 0.01955384947359562, -0.5206025242805481, -0.8467985391616821, 0.08904052525758743, 0.6998469829559326, -0.6578927636146545, -0.0015037464909255505, 0.3471231758594513, -1.0613611936569214, 0.2454293817281723, 0.11764483153820038, -0.02020280808210373, -0.6258808374404907, -0.3759765923023224, -0.2954481542110443, -1.0731953382492065, 0.38337990641593933, -0.21742761135101318, 0.21136362850666046, -0.662372350692749, -0.5287725925445557, -0.4458526372909546, -0.11864101141691208, 0.2116679549217224, -0.7572269439697266, -0.3946942985057831, -0.48900648951530457, 0.22421130537986755, 0.21749812364578247, -0.30162057280540466, -0.6859064698219299, -0.09297371655702591, 0.41379106044769287, -0.3577158749103546, 0.28329208493232727, -0.12153801321983337, -0.22732065618038177, -0.74369215965271, -0.8517482876777649, 0.7973266243934631, -0.20562081038951874, 0.09411023557186127, 1.3185019493103027, -0.46918168663978577, -0.02344927377998829, -0.023470161482691765, 0.14670050144195557, 0.007165835238993168, -0.26126644015312195, -0.26727181673049927, -0.9953057169914246, 0.05452689528465271, -0.051243431866168976, 0.8256149888038635, -0.5325774550437927, 0.4995606243610382, 0.2809771001338959, -0.24395184218883514, 0.42735210061073303, -0.5759388208389282, -0.2852016091346741, 0.686538815498352, -0.88462895154953, -0.5521564483642578, -0.37915775179862976, 0.4480256736278534, -0.6026859283447266, 0.2338283509016037, -0.4508900046348572, 0.00513527262955904, -1.1124483346939087, -1.0474802255630493, 0.461458683013916, -0.8560922741889954, -0.06019335985183716, -0.5321869254112244, -0.6381276249885559, 0.34476983547210693, -0.3061447739601135, 0.6153348684310913, -0.44233110547065735, 0.19740808010101318, -0.5481419563293457, -0.4903731346130371, -0.44420096278190613, -0.4602511525154114, 0.34211137890815735, -0.6368933916091919, 0.42571258544921875, 1.0634608268737793, 0.6878830790519714, -0.21204550564289093, 0.17368526756763458, 0.2750861644744873, 0.7608054280281067, 1.2045109272003174, -0.6834122538566589, -0.18940217792987823, 0.3512779772281647, 0.28240302205085754, 0.37678262591362, -0.15056860446929932, -0.344127893447876, -0.14680863916873932, -0.541928231716156, 0.8731177449226379, -0.7776520252227783, -0.5073065757751465, -0.4754798114299774, -0.08776268362998962, 0.8327404260635376, -0.6958337426185608, 0.16611947119235992, -0.3604907989501953, 0.7495922446250916, 0.36912891268730164, 0.5776810646057129, -0.6511799097061157, -0.20370204746723175, -0.8626861572265625, -1.0208330154418945, 0.024954602122306824, -0.31098976731300354, 0.6259351372718811, 0.3914521336555481, 0.21331200003623962, 0.22271618247032166, -0.754662811756134, 1.5650675296783447, 0.8501074910163879, -0.028770694509148598, -0.4384349286556244, -0.5027078986167908, -0.08576996624469757, 0.2314893752336502, 0.3336729109287262, -0.6354541778564453, -0.09402206540107727, 0.3109239935874939, -0.2783645689487457, -0.9759354591369629, -0.6520688533782959, -0.17946825921535492, 0.07687675952911377, 0.8023360371589661, -0.5784891247749329, 0.3008718192577362, 0.06289296597242355, 0.2499609738588333, -0.8840019106864929, 0.5982041358947754, -0.43004369735717773, 0.405828058719635, 0.39776626229286194, 0.026459887623786926, -1.1652429103851318, -0.17822876572608948, 0.09815198928117752, -0.2581838071346283, 0.13614508509635925, 0.49347245693206787, 0.41706788539886475, -0.484763503074646, 0.006827486213296652, 0.6864570379257202, 0.035520877689123154, -0.8783624172210693, 0.29584237933158875, -0.1558643877506256, 0.1471204310655594, -0.3067268133163452, -0.2701307237148285, 0.403506875038147, -0.2793245315551758, -0.367936909198761, 0.6455058455467224, 0.07877296954393387, 0.1893741339445114, 0.41202083230018616, -0.062030285596847534, -0.13308411836624146, 0.10413536429405212, 0.16194511950016022, -0.09438381344079971, -0.2834801971912384, -0.08819416910409927, 0.35594019293785095, -0.1982225775718689, -0.03524940833449364, 0.552958607673645, -0.025418423116207123, 0.607252836227417, -0.03031185269355774, 0.21124573051929474, 0.13148599863052368, -0.4654734432697296, -0.23365645110607147, 0.5236294269561768, -0.9817875623703003, -0.7197554707527161, -0.06818503141403198, 0.7546310424804688, 0.058562982827425, 0.5495824813842773, -0.3636355698108673, -0.7458111047744751, 0.5444878935813904, 0.7809685468673706, 0.34408387541770935, -0.7930653691291809, -0.569942831993103, -0.7609286308288574, -0.5940055251121521, 0.16195987164974213, -0.8061365485191345, 0.16107341647148132, 0.6003420352935791, -0.6143146753311157, -0.7653833627700806, 0.06842415779829025, 0.45101532340049744, -0.8499401807785034, -0.38695791363716125, -0.29353106021881104, 0.028635576367378235, -0.6215483546257019, 0.04481087252497673, 0.7340932488441467, -0.6732463836669922, 0.09514561295509338, 0.2760210931301117, -0.5559422969818115, 0.47387412190437317, -0.16605301201343536, 0.5553690791130066, -0.4058941602706909, 0.31492021679878235, -1.2158933877944946, -0.6164155602455139, -0.2106853425502777, 0.24344120919704437, 0.3215641677379608, -0.4174846112728119, 0.9772432446479797, -0.21993306279182434, 0.2353118509054184, 0.0740000531077385, 0.221413254737854, -0.9062768816947937, 0.5942463278770447, 0.2299460768699646, -0.14765892922878265, -0.27388256788253784, 0.15232908725738525, 0.7904049754142761, -0.2921960949897766, -0.43551960587501526, -0.09427347034215927, 0.7108660340309143, -0.25114259123802185, -0.15649408102035522, 0.26573967933654785, 1.049943447113037, 0.5390334725379944, -0.573732852935791, 0.7228504419326782, 0.12831565737724304, 0.17093022167682648, 0.4754623472690582, -0.3924824595451355, -0.0700247660279274, 0.38477712869644165, -1.1356110572814941, 0.6862963438034058, 0.14360971748828888, -0.19102375209331512, 0.6380230188369751, 0.1658380925655365, 0.4086785912513733, 0.0026058144867420197, 0.8651081323623657, 0.5532041788101196, 0.7604321837425232, -0.11030521988868713, -0.4975276291370392, 0.4010935425758362, -0.6274738311767578, -0.5141369104385376, 0.147769033908844, -0.7416461706161499, -0.6311324238777161, 0.4641176462173462, -0.782349169254303, -0.4625241160392761, 0.05117334797978401, -0.4135816693305969, 0.010699021629989147, 0.14883533120155334, 0.040809933096170425, -0.08213933557271957, 0.8622316122055054, 0.6003583669662476, 0.2773946225643158, 0.001203632215037942, -0.6317587494850159, -0.1652005910873413, -0.18153245747089386, -0.7096641659736633, -0.7777314186096191, 0.4444274604320526, 0.305521160364151, 0.43036505579948425, -0.681011974811554, -0.5447060465812683, 0.047664470970630646, -0.2784053385257721, -0.06951283663511276, -0.21832185983657837, 0.419939249753952, -0.3424040377140045, -0.27023035287857056, -0.3341333568096161, 0.29186558723449707, 0.34224995970726013, 0.3524338901042938, 0.6455134749412537, -0.4902764856815338, -0.584911584854126, 1.0260182619094849, 0.14050713181495667, -0.3644987940788269, -0.10062272846698761, -0.3805731534957886, 0.5261954665184021, -0.10669749230146408, 0.22755342721939087, 0.6617037653923035, 0.6846767067909241, 1.0181339979171753, 0.5929856300354004, 0.12089411914348602, 0.7893566489219666, 0.26473942399024963, 0.5305517315864563, 0.4834093451499939, 0.34281834959983826, 0.04047062247991562, -0.2743411958217621, -0.19797244668006897, -0.45461505651474, 0.24633000791072845, -0.23223204910755157, -0.29531750082969666, 0.10863906890153885, 0.12603868544101715, 0.2215198278427124, -0.21747234463691711, -0.9073689579963684, 0.5071755647659302, 0.22353631258010864, -0.937374472618103, 0.1370425969362259, 0.9727607369422913, 0.0961780920624733, 0.1687575876712799, 0.04247724264860153, 0.0023921565152704716, 0.4517219364643097, 0.40546849370002747, 0.0585184246301651, 0.2979056239128113, -0.6383032202720642, -0.27248021960258484, 0.3618406355381012, 0.6016874313354492, 0.25564664602279663, -0.23274590075016022, 0.3338112533092499, -0.04203746095299721, -0.861472487449646, 0.7930932641029358, 0.3322697579860687, -0.9353926777839661, 0.7223801016807556, -0.6432924866676331, -0.5935834646224976, 0.11009878665208817, 0.26638463139533997, -0.9545465707778931, -0.44069764018058777, 0.6811807751655579, -0.7634235620498657, 0.03524330258369446, 0.7566474080085754, 0.4430069625377655, 0.3181326389312744, 0.04046797379851341, 0.47439709305763245, 0.11819716542959213, 1.417021632194519, 0.8039318323135376, 0.2717094123363495, 0.28296929597854614, 0.3112805187702179, -0.2402149885892868, -0.38322675228118896, -0.2239985316991806, -0.2484213262796402, -0.3687146306037903, -0.854197084903717, -0.22787317633628845, -0.4749581813812256, 0.10803836584091187, -0.5035133361816406, -0.3661966919898987, 0.0620257668197155, -0.026079637929797173, 0.009455014020204544, -0.11180886626243591, 0.7634594440460205, -0.3466533422470093, 0.4158410131931305, 0.5636187791824341, 0.26945358514785767, -0.8549600839614868, 0.08645211160182953, 0.0868658795952797, 0.21883796155452728, 0.20044134557247162, -0.5393548011779785, 0.33898282051086426, -0.7691765427589417, -0.32818496227264404, -0.35479578375816345, -0.05861418694257736, -1.3060472011566162, 0.27978676557540894, 0.3547825813293457, 0.0663716271519661, 0.7687978148460388, -0.22577176988124847, -0.48514071106910706, 0.3346785008907318, 0.9429215788841248, -0.4607732892036438, 0.5750349760055542, 1.0355350971221924, -0.5830628871917725, 0.22709773480892181, 0.07916729897260666, 0.5806764364242554, -0.34285876154899597, -0.13679681718349457, -0.5564981698989868, 0.4681270122528076, -0.03946254402399063, -0.4924810826778412, 0.32816940546035767, 0.707144558429718, -0.17734810709953308, -0.11195647716522217, -1.1014108657836914, -0.18912512063980103, -0.6404909491539001, 0.8428711295127869, -0.5315576791763306, -0.1268758773803711, 0.2191009819507599, -0.544228196144104, 0.5799054503440857, -0.44309312105178833, 4.3040008544921875, 1.132152795791626, 0.11052694171667099, 0.36011502146720886, -0.1788478046655655, 1.080926775932312, 1.0001933574676514, -0.14097487926483154, 0.06997521966695786, -0.07335583120584488, -0.22782813012599945, 0.3528379499912262, 0.2859082818031311, 0.058659300208091736, 0.6666993498802185, 0.56939297914505, -0.9947388172149658, -0.45973581075668335, -0.5815057158470154, -0.9769065976142883, -0.36320579051971436, 0.3579055070877075, 0.15908564627170563, 0.2144237905740738, 0.24445784091949463, -0.3992472290992737, -0.08130315691232681, -0.05117076635360718, -0.6588126420974731, -0.04203224182128906, -0.33636054396629333, -0.43807461857795715, 0.5166983008384705, -0.9638440608978271, -0.26549652218818665, 0.3980036675930023, -0.12277428805828094, -0.1240960955619812, -0.031410932540893555, 0.10097455233335495, 0.20779038965702057, -0.20423758029937744, 0.3155086934566498, -0.5293191075325012, -0.3762163519859314, 0.27823054790496826, -0.5589068531990051, 0.41621142625808716, 0.05469999462366104, -1.0177948474884033, 0.6596096158027649, -1.1497139930725098, 0.23284661769866943, 0.1308165192604065, -0.5525255799293518, -0.693557620048523, -0.5931510925292969, -0.8022263050079346, 0.0584026537835598, 0.8969922065734863, 0.5186956524848938, 0.704466700553894, 0.07877570390701294, 0.10785505175590515, -0.05664307251572609, 0.43039175868034363, 0.0046990420669317245, 0.7359963059425354, -0.56058269739151, 0.07655583322048187, 0.217111274600029, -0.7024773955345154, -0.06834566593170166, -0.007830259390175343, 0.6639822125434875, 0.3960789144039154, -0.07588871568441391, 0.43933966755867004, 0.16834333539009094, -0.9383682608604431, 0.23991428315639496, -0.14196212589740753, -0.1294155716896057, -0.10337276756763458, 0.30889976024627686, 0.975499153137207, -0.24067498743534088, -0.43408986926078796, -1.043236255645752, 1.1124601364135742, 0.26444870233535767, 0.2721785306930542, -0.05670379847288132, 0.07846471667289734, -0.47025325894355774 ]
{"Title": "Novel prefrontal synthesis intervention improves language in children with autism", "Authors": "Vyshedskiy Andrey, Khokhlovich Edward, Dunn Rita, Faisman Alexander, Elgart Jonah, Lokshina Lisa, Gankin Yuriy, Ostrovsky Simone, deTorres Lauren, Edelson Stephen M, Ilyinskii Petr O", "Abstract": "Abstract Prefrontal synthesis (PFS) is defined as the ability to juxtapose mental objects at will. Paralysis of PFS may be responsible for the lack of comprehension of spatial prepositions, semantically-reversible sentences, and recursive sentences observed in 30 to 40% of individuals with ASD. In this report we present data from a three-year-long clinical trial of 6,454 ASD children aged 2-12 years, which were administered a PFS-targeting intervention. Tablet-based verbal and nonverbal exercises emphasizing mental-juxtaposition-of-objects were organized into an application called Mental Imagery Therapy for Autism (MITA). The test group included participants who completed more than one thousand exercises and made no more than one error per exercise. The control group included the rest of participants. The test group participants were matched to the control group by age, gender, expressive language, receptive language, sociability, cognitive awareness, and health at the 1 st evaluation. The test group showed 1.7-fold improvement in receptive language score vs. control group (p=0.0002) and 1.4-fold improvement in expressive language (p=0.0144). No statistically significant change was detected in other subscales not targeted by the exercises. These findings show that language acquisition improves by training PFS and warrants further investigation of the PFS-targeting intervention in a randomized controlled study.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.10.19014159"}
10.1101/19005520
[ -0.48296254873275757, -0.20654810965061188, -0.47643953561782837, 0.06528950482606888, -0.42889076471328735, -0.5961431860923767, 0.019966432824730873, 0.4859463572502136, -0.04456108435988426, 0.6800119280815125, -0.06500209122896194, -0.3194584250450134, 0.005404661875218153, 0.138703852891922, 0.08400745689868927, -0.008991104550659657, -0.5193045139312744, -0.47193044424057007, 0.14842210710048676, 0.2965092062950134, 0.16888941824436188, 0.2265501469373703, -1.0659255981445312, 0.32777538895606995, -0.8056357502937317, 0.6193814873695374, 0.14429384469985962, -0.5094520449638367, 0.9057966470718384, 0.454549640417099, -0.36818617582321167, 0.3120887875556946, 0.748971700668335, -0.8336836099624634, 0.2809108793735504, -0.25321710109710693, 0.02148234285414219, -0.5620625615119934, -0.6006886959075928, -0.39151135087013245, -0.04320966824889183, 0.41931992769241333, 0.3576846420764923, -0.9871323108673096, -0.4178299605846405, 0.20606639981269836, 0.3228561580181122, -0.28281378746032715, -0.7136667966842651, 0.016785878688097, -0.42718786001205444, -0.6584277749061584, -0.3993086814880371, -0.4022737145423889, -0.14240379631519318, -0.7081822752952576, 1.0938780307769775, -0.25010281801223755, -0.5813256502151489, 0.6620842814445496, 0.6892411112785339, -0.19198031723499298, 0.5383657813072205, -0.8786827325820923, 0.4722457230091095, 0.483043372631073, -0.37193769216537476, 0.1376517415046692, -0.23737464845180511, -0.304056853055954, -0.3996923565864563, -0.920499324798584, -0.9138296842575073, -0.3459125757217407, -0.29264429211616516, 0.17874586582183838, 0.09826233983039856, -0.4302247166633606, 0.23213908076286316, -0.33774760365486145, 0.46896296739578247, 0.2276003360748291, -0.23375771939754486, 0.08767582476139069, -0.7731000781059265, 0.36176636815071106, -0.33377835154533386, 0.5799633264541626, -0.03470398113131523, 0.7101528644561768, 0.2961975336074829, 0.25396066904067993, -0.17588017880916595, 0.07692625373601913, 0.8336805701255798, 1.3250244855880737, -0.5239003896713257, -0.33312323689460754, -0.09926770627498627, -0.4598478376865387, 0.617931604385376, 0.761338472366333, -0.28742095828056335, 0.56451815366745, -0.785496711730957, 0.3980749249458313, 0.691598117351532, -0.9169026017189026, 0.6502524018287659, -0.9971654415130615, 0.19680383801460266, -0.21889391541481018, -0.5943194031715393, -0.41116252541542053, 0.1812220811843872, 0.09178705513477325, -0.5197632908821106, 0.20347578823566437, -0.2360982447862625, 0.23965123295783997, -0.4630282521247864, 0.6454549431800842, -0.0663076639175415, -0.36001700162887573, 0.5929506421089172, -0.34861502051353455, 0.5502976179122925, -0.18174980580806732, -0.39847812056541443, -0.7544665932655334, -0.20596559345722198, -1.3382996320724487, 0.5159004330635071, -0.2394556999206543, 0.3905165195465088, 0.14326423406600952, -0.35410356521606445, 1.0353970527648926, 0.06014767661690712, -0.21006891131401062, -0.5618410706520081, 0.6025978922843933, -0.08330836147069931, 1.676709532737732, 0.6456515789031982, 0.7224897742271423, -0.38164588809013367, -0.023874202743172646, -0.12351926416158676, -0.009846319444477558, 0.6009584069252014, -0.12529979646205902, 0.14550918340682983, 0.342426598072052, 0.7612027525901794, -0.3996131718158722, -0.28250792622566223, -0.024169793352484703, -0.24817492067813873, 0.2760545611381531, -0.5946433544158936, 0.558652400970459, -0.5487795472145081, 0.8915765285491943, -0.6189635992050171, 0.4409911036491394, -0.011372731067240238, -0.1530444622039795, 0.5069534778594971, -0.028484022244811058, 0.9558565020561218, 0.41247281432151794, -0.3841039538383484, -0.4738467335700989, 0.5944143533706665, 0.14643464982509613, 0.0998808890581131, -0.2166246473789215, 0.5157531499862671, 0.3610166609287262, -0.2653006315231323, -0.023072754964232445, 0.07552897930145264, 1.1532118320465088, 0.28604456782341003, 0.7269759774208069, -0.4316193461418152, -0.6190599799156189, -0.3378029465675354, 0.19185298681259155, -0.4735020399093628, 0.7380384802818298, -0.5118030905723572, 0.2129068821668625, 0.8117543458938599, 0.4806482493877411, -0.16478589177131653, -0.053496357053518295, 0.7069467306137085, -0.5947141647338867, 0.2627916932106018, 0.2498277872800827, -0.6410542130470276, 0.8730264902114868, -0.30901163816452026, -0.05866504833102226, 0.2577296793460846, 0.3162967562675476, -1.112352728843689, -0.1632116734981537, 0.8816369771957397, 0.6696224808692932, -0.6635464429855347, -0.2736872434616089, 0.47452667355537415, -0.5021473169326782, -0.0323551744222641, 0.46339744329452515, -1.4271031618118286, 0.4610099196434021, -0.37367480993270874, -0.4718828797340393, 0.04423123225569725, -0.2690422236919403, -0.43751829862594604, -0.6061117649078369, 0.5519481897354126, 0.8196749687194824, -0.2360592782497406, 0.13042551279067993, 0.588615357875824, 0.7619547247886658, 0.4672393798828125, -0.05352890118956566, 1.1809055805206299, 0.2017342746257782, 0.0665627270936966, 0.6824883818626404, -0.04473176598548889, 1.002464771270752, 0.5570804476737976, 0.47128671407699585, 1.2678048610687256, 0.44208821654319763, -0.5490734577178955, 0.373627632856369, 0.11195392161607742, -0.3961373269557953, 0.07198769599199295, -0.15788035094738007, -0.4454398453235626, 0.8691046237945557, 0.8822973966598511, 1.247097373008728, -1.1966793537139893, 0.28046998381614685, 0.23474426567554474, 0.2916359007358551, -0.4522407650947571, -0.27132904529571533, -0.3638021647930145, 0.505825400352478, 0.6626189351081848, 0.009846845641732216, 0.5947385430335999, 0.7404621839523315, -0.14414361119270325, 0.8425289988517761, -0.37240850925445557, -0.5984038710594177, -0.4574759900569916, -0.39459314942359924, -0.8899520635604858, -0.588741660118103, -0.5733332633972168, 0.5331431031227112, 0.6126103401184082, 0.06696287542581558, -0.15140773355960846, -0.23902207612991333, -0.11259401589632034, 0.18139900267124176, -0.1890222281217575, 0.16108590364456177, 0.25646305084228516, -0.5348644256591797, -1.0073314905166626, 0.47946056723594666, 0.2318260818719864, 0.40892279148101807, -0.04185193404555321, -0.010265163145959377, -0.2634626030921936, -0.7805573344230652, 0.7250049710273743, -0.010405631735920906, -0.43834924697875977, -0.5712542533874512, -0.34754931926727295, -0.9511415362358093, 0.0851626917719841, -0.6167314052581787, 0.4176707863807678, -0.13481304049491882, -0.6693407893180847, 0.7760350108146667, 0.28133639693260193, 0.015158340334892273, 0.7726666927337646, 0.7809619903564453, -0.09721005707979202, 0.13128700852394104, -0.42988502979278564, 0.1711573302745819, -0.592034637928009, 0.3420991599559784, 0.3655630946159363, -0.6765273809432983, 0.4515587389469147, 0.06378724426031113, -1.1337240934371948, -0.41611796617507935, 0.20781485736370087, -0.3342665433883667, -0.36416947841644287, 0.27543121576309204, 0.3436625599861145, -1.470210075378418, 0.2950308918952942, -0.5032371878623962, -0.8097582459449768, 0.15587863326072693, -0.19075973331928253, 0.16072113811969757, 0.6055203080177307, -0.6243438124656677, -0.9509608149528503, 0.008429529145359993, -0.15907983481884003, -0.2711125612258911, 0.7829465270042419, -0.9502114653587341, 0.690387487411499, -0.6986991763114929, -0.3285839557647705, 0.19342942535877228, -0.011115164496004581, -0.03203853964805603, -0.24905921518802643, 0.066958487033844, 0.6615898013114929, 0.974259614944458, 0.5964601635932922, 0.02105693146586418, -0.9025391936302185, 0.43500885367393494, -0.06587151437997818, 0.2819792330265045, 0.0011295131407678127, 0.12753459811210632, -0.4390864968299866, 0.5344201326370239, -0.9426626563072205, 0.023928577080368996, -0.4679746627807617, -0.21991066634655, 0.3199509382247925, 0.2632790207862854, 0.8487867116928101, -0.5164970755577087, 0.489363431930542, -0.5075008273124695, -0.23302114009857178, 0.5520959496498108, 0.15128663182258606, -0.47472870349884033, 0.9746686816215515, -0.4138254225254059, 1.367383360862732, -1.0951533317565918, 0.199418306350708, 0.10287982225418091, 1.6059359312057495, 0.7465348243713379, 0.6629387736320496, 0.8017592430114746, -0.8975606560707092, 0.2885323762893677, 0.12774144113063812, -1.275848388671875, -0.023784825578331947, -0.8383322358131409, -0.024772917851805687, 0.463310182094574, -0.4340210556983948, -0.4852937161922455, -0.45526745915412903, 0.5273403525352478, 0.40600425004959106, 0.1214255690574646, 0.28930601477622986, 0.21851472556591034, 0.6572496891021729, 0.1616288721561432, 0.3228256404399872, 0.6105890870094299, -0.69769287109375, 0.6209419965744019, -0.35719001293182373, -0.7215029001235962, 0.697403609752655, -0.913119912147522, 0.12024587392807007, 0.1275671273469925, 0.2560526430606842, 0.3483456075191498, -0.7227138876914978, -1.1776422262191772, 0.33672115206718445, 0.548354983329773, 0.24386487901210785, 0.19928447902202606, -0.0015496623236685991, 0.7355840802192688, -0.29947784543037415, -0.3148983418941498, 0.4828357994556427, -1.3751513957977295, 1.279712200164795, 0.8006361126899719, -0.41592440009117126, -0.6430617570877075, -0.2608170509338379, -0.2367502897977829, -0.37635135650634766, -0.21250811219215393, -0.5459920167922974, 0.25402796268463135, -0.25582975149154663, -0.9187566041946411, -0.18479619920253754, 0.04738301783800125, 0.17402465641498566, -0.23620830476284027, 0.13475975394248962, 0.09664686769247055, 0.4128323495388031, 0.6370751857757568, 0.022934840992093086, -0.5380899310112, 1.317378282546997, -1.011610746383667, 0.19778068363666534, -0.023491553962230682, 0.2628522217273712, -0.20687246322631836, -0.4441760778427124, 0.24822071194648743, -0.1438339650630951, -0.9533606171607971, -0.8643484711647034, 0.3579161763191223, 0.13948765397071838, -0.44044288992881775, 0.14859023690223694, 0.9026188254356384, -0.026203136891126633, -0.9477786421775818, 0.8065921664237976, -0.21515525877475739, 0.2550455331802368, 0.19571757316589355, -0.24991658329963684, -1.1735385656356812, 1.00894033908844, -0.0631614401936531, 0.2642310559749603, 0.2728762626647949, -0.4818001985549927, 0.4882458746433258, 0.6468964219093323, 0.8085128664970398, -0.17126862704753876, -0.06800387799739838, -0.10365675389766693, -0.3358612656593323, -0.4082975685596466, -0.2808026969432831, -0.004957650788128376, 0.6760454177856445, -0.14029264450073242, -0.6663232445716858, -0.009997334331274033, -0.19322100281715393, -0.16003106534481049, 0.7230657935142517, -0.3035007119178772, -0.40199974179267883, 0.2783478796482086, 0.5224985480308533, 0.6027920246124268, -1.0300029516220093, -0.5572211742401123, -0.22856394946575165, 0.46222949028015137, -0.5147998332977295, -0.5609241127967834, -0.301423043012619, -0.33911845088005066, -0.3420286774635315, -0.15892626345157623, -0.19165872037410736, -0.22622334957122803, 0.06573119014501572, -0.24991992115974426, 0.03965803608298302, 0.3823808431625366, -0.10893386602401733, 0.4018753170967102, 0.589270830154419, -0.6438976526260376, -0.7947568893432617, 0.22984518110752106, 0.5672836303710938, 0.3271908462047577, 0.2107929289340973, -0.4207810163497925, -0.7293232679367065, -1.0944736003875732, -1.1894383430480957, -0.039676349610090256, -0.4990652799606323, -0.19651319086551666, 0.6082088351249695, 0.32582977414131165, 0.04541018605232239, 0.16829931735992432, -0.1863267570734024, 0.6901960968971252, -0.3631269335746765, -0.8811467289924622, 0.28372472524642944, 0.2936503291130066, -0.30414140224456787, -0.09182940423488617, -1.586197018623352, 0.6922248601913452, 0.9355780482292175, 1.00800359249115, -0.06279871612787247, -0.14118726551532745, -0.313981294631958, -0.15674562752246857, -0.402066171169281, 0.6227601170539856, -0.11465335637331009, -0.31230223178863525, 0.19053715467453003, -0.4739377200603485, -0.5589183568954468, -1.245985984802246, 1.460848331451416, -0.46089741587638855, -0.06232484430074692, 0.07020930200815201, -0.4638127386569977, 0.23669466376304626, -0.6533361673355103, 0.8600996732711792, -0.3856995105743408, 0.6286442875862122, -0.38985273241996765, -0.33023136854171753, 0.2507065534591675, 0.2035750150680542, -0.4599112868309021, 0.08981195092201233, -0.4182136654853821, -0.9582613110542297, 0.6958633661270142, -0.20544297993183136, -0.48857975006103516, -0.3942928910255432, 0.17766842246055603, 0.44875776767730713, -0.9192835688591003, 0.6411331295967102, 1.0926616191864014, -0.4086146056652069, -0.0720309168100357, -0.46295931935310364, 0.7215648889541626, -0.15403896570205688, 0.024075457826256752, 0.10658345371484756, -0.12662650644779205, -0.22564342617988586, -0.7304378151893616, -0.6074206829071045, -0.5910937786102295, -0.1950296312570572, 0.17057234048843384, 0.7775830626487732, -0.2008422315120697, 0.6958085894584656, -0.16604724526405334, -0.5650206208229065, -0.4274667203426361, 0.4574754536151886, -0.1705160140991211, 0.37808161973953247, 1.1924766302108765, -0.4940997064113617, -0.040272306650877, 1.0315027236938477, 0.274522602558136, 0.11187899112701416, -0.1965164691209793, 0.02594985067844391, -0.04481308534741402, -0.767099916934967, -0.10428617894649506, -0.2927727699279785, -0.7605900764465332, 0.10158530622720718, -0.42899420857429504, -0.5888984799385071, 0.0794125646352768, -0.04474608972668648, -0.3286135196685791, 0.10839585214853287, 0.3627668619155884, 1.400139331817627, 0.4891324043273926, 0.0052015166729688644, 0.004471656400710344, 0.24945102632045746, 0.020378243178129196, -0.7338694334030151, -0.10906627029180527, 0.3133716881275177, -0.4741867482662201, -0.11097411066293716, 0.440169095993042, 0.37023043632507324, 0.20698456466197968, -0.42303478717803955, 0.3776245713233948, -0.8063963651657104, 0.012480569072067738, -0.20139138400554657, -0.24815033376216888, 0.4909629821777344, -0.539459764957428, -0.2436627894639969, -0.006682708393782377, -0.3678569793701172, -0.4028514325618744, -0.3799949586391449, 0.5537412762641907, 0.5016105771064758, 0.7178242206573486, -0.10858427733182907, -0.3152390718460083, 0.6067802906036377, 0.22807347774505615, 0.38911551237106323, -0.37432441115379333, -0.3741304576396942, -0.7474203705787659, -0.8895851373672485, 0.07990438491106033, -0.09591817110776901, -0.4582757353782654, -0.10242853313684464, -0.06349685043096542, -0.8654480576515198, -0.09655570238828659, 1.2589006423950195, -0.08050894737243652, 0.2211354672908783, -0.2807808816432953, 0.22137285768985748, -0.41881316900253296, -0.4771818220615387, -0.32723620533943176, 0.4405406415462494, 0.35718071460723877, 0.3929528295993805, -0.8196220993995667, 0.9989956617355347, -0.5488311052322388, 0.5359681248664856, 0.3781464695930481, 0.7551436424255371, -0.5257487893104553, -0.6193244457244873, 0.27469709515571594, 0.18400265276432037, 0.4620842933654785, -0.321657657623291, 1.2005971670150757, -0.14180444180965424, 0.09822772443294525, 0.8291532397270203, -0.3803490102291107, -0.1324087232351303, 0.5092402696609497, 0.6733171939849854, -0.6401784420013428, -0.3975912928581238, -0.3825297951698303, -0.010081138461828232, -0.5855191946029663, -0.3958590626716614, -1.0437484979629517, 0.4381616711616516, -0.3874833583831787, 0.151791512966156, 0.09676194936037064, 0.07454010099172592, 0.8480039238929749, 0.29112666845321655, -0.09105618298053741, 0.9513967037200928, 0.12251759320497513, -0.06562834978103638, 0.33665138483047485, 0.47629019618034363, 0.5199946761131287, -0.438024640083313, 0.1146925836801529, 0.7170276045799255, -0.1749316304922104, 0.41236549615859985, -0.7015140056610107, -0.5571954846382141, 0.2980530858039856, 0.3904532790184021, 0.2852727174758911, 0.6622788906097412, -0.0641806349158287, 0.1934751570224762, -0.3397983908653259, -0.559657633304596, -0.5493156313896179, -0.7887877821922302, -1.9545105695724487, -0.13140235841274261, 0.7882012724876404, -0.35386034846305847, 0.07291611284017563, -0.3373013734817505, -0.3396431505680084, 0.3930383622646332, -0.5970068573951721, 0.38044828176498413, -0.28711816668510437, 0.33521661162376404, -0.6601415872573853, 0.8604587316513062, 0.3119715750217438, 0.8882642984390259, -0.17328321933746338, 0.37381190061569214, -0.5989275574684143, -0.9472026824951172, 0.07668846845626831, 1.0888502597808838, -0.1785094439983368, -0.24334432184696198, -0.5042290091514587, -0.5066347122192383, 0.34835392236709595, 0.2265496551990509, -0.20890015363693237, 0.11827468127012253, 0.17543482780456543, -0.17696742713451385, 0.27363502979278564, 0.4972470700740814, -0.7153909802436829, -0.3310379385948181, -0.12539538741111755, -1.2588469982147217, -0.7826616764068604, 0.8007595539093018, 0.7662390470504761, 0.3058430254459381, 0.14453092217445374, 0.17553670704364777, 0.6395143866539001, -0.22763225436210632, 0.09811879694461823, 0.5166943073272705, 0.9671135544776917, -0.5301019549369812, -0.3647279143333435, -0.500700056552887, 0.31242305040359497, 0.675092875957489, 0.7329550981521606, -0.06406228244304657, -0.23945461213588715, 0.3494764566421509, 0.14351139962673187, -0.5161411166191101, -0.4951287508010864, 0.2362881302833557, 0.3688642382621765, -0.8380340337753296, 0.35881978273391724, -0.5296247601509094, 0.47565311193466187, 0.3140265643596649, 0.0184067003428936, 0.7213107943534851, -0.2471519410610199, -0.5126834511756897, -0.08599477261304855, 0.026629585772752762, 0.6515074372291565, -0.20924220979213715, 0.4388206899166107, 0.9739121794700623, 0.20730949938297272, -0.09516536444425583, -0.5625658631324768, 0.1803792417049408, -0.3086985647678375, -0.5544492602348328, -0.315862238407135, 0.23101073503494263, 0.42302247881889343, 0.2895067632198334, 0.2707008421421051, -0.37630102038383484, -0.09826270490884781, 0.9762752056121826, -0.9779573678970337, 0.29253724217414856, 0.9439943432807922, -0.7798214554786682, -1.1034899950027466, 0.21874912083148956, 0.4947858452796936, 0.09645705670118332, -0.4229830205440521, 0.8352939486503601, 0.32058632373809814, 0.028281744569540024, -0.044016480445861816, 0.3838467299938202, 0.790860116481781, 0.6601236462593079, -0.1860009729862213, -0.9598709940910339, 0.3607420325279236, 0.17928306758403778, -0.12578865885734558, 0.4475470781326294, -0.3891046345233917, -0.3783172369003296, 0.0019979123026132584, -0.39431342482566833, 0.46989327669143677, 0.023941753432154655, -0.36905089020729065, 0.05590580403804779, 0.15845513343811035, -0.07139980047941208, -0.3225424289703369, -1.1872506141662598, -0.45347627997398376, -0.5075990557670593, 0.003434595186263323, 0.11956685781478882, 0.13495446741580963, -0.6835500001907349, 0.18525362014770508, 0.7033367156982422, -0.32238686084747314, -0.11218918114900589, 0.288251668214798, -1.0252790451049805, 0.3961219787597656, 0.39938849210739136, -0.26324689388275146, -0.4550878405570984, -1.358697772026062, 0.03824585676193237, -0.4341357946395874, 0.0511493906378746, -0.7969366908073425, -0.4058927297592163, 0.369800865650177, 0.3613784611225128, -0.7284175753593445, -0.37580522894859314, -0.449460506439209, -0.004594933707267046, 1.0147202014923096, -0.3942757844924927, 1.145961880683899, 0.24395734071731567, -0.3408104479312897, -0.15079009532928467, -0.0039659179747104645, 0.20276415348052979, -0.14281974732875824, -0.4385378956794739, -0.3755321204662323, 0.0335942767560482, 0.3916671574115753, -0.20588116347789764, 0.4534553587436676, 0.11115417629480362, -0.06326904892921448, -0.09276566654443741, -0.6150933504104614, -0.4964633882045746, -0.6550610065460205, 1.4861223697662354, -0.8544769287109375, -0.11158742010593414, 0.6062906384468079, -0.2522945702075958, 0.38613975048065186, -0.6603732705116272, 3.9612810611724854, 0.7985367178916931, 0.08554664254188538, -0.47656580805778503, 0.2302962839603424, 0.901477575302124, 0.8043439984321594, 0.11496986448764801, 0.9393512606620789, 0.4237881898880005, -0.08825460821390152, 0.3293495178222656, 0.0711539015173912, 0.029281675815582275, -0.010161221027374268, 0.6633545756340027, -0.8415317535400391, -0.672114372253418, -0.26704883575439453, -0.5521273612976074, 0.0713294968008995, 0.7210407853126526, 0.27083897590637207, 0.4200834333896637, -0.4676721394062042, 0.28389614820480347, 0.27639445662498474, -0.1651204377412796, 0.2734839916229248, -0.34140321612358093, 0.22972123324871063, -0.5607420802116394, 0.6034377813339233, -0.4328525960445404, 0.08084765076637268, 0.5434314012527466, 0.09029876440763474, -0.8116869330406189, 0.22333425283432007, 0.46252670884132385, -0.1815112978219986, 0.39327025413513184, 0.11693564802408218, -0.4646115303039551, -0.4388464391231537, 0.425796777009964, -0.44509896636009216, 0.10095382481813431, 0.34995928406715393, -0.3644964098930359, 0.347676157951355, -0.8355866074562073, 0.43327057361602783, -0.06967290490865707, -0.6807007789611816, 0.1746726632118225, -0.4450743794441223, -0.7620958685874939, 0.6416367888450623, -0.16558203101158142, 0.23140539228916168, -0.0878395289182663, -0.16975776851177216, -0.3413434326648712, 0.6872983574867249, 1.0194144248962402, 0.9548795819282532, -0.7407515645027161, 0.1466750204563141, -0.775945782661438, -0.16999059915542603, -0.8334845900535583, 0.32355958223342896, -0.23120388388633728, 0.32698842883110046, -0.1823791116476059, -0.23329727351665497, 0.8560357093811035, -1.4860825538635254, -0.627355694770813, 0.12531548738479614, -0.596927285194397, -0.24577811360359192, -0.4446169137954712, 0.3228033781051636, 1.0806149244308472, -0.8022240400314331, -0.6296887993812561, -0.5708704590797424, 0.4161219298839569, 0.5580974221229553, -0.07463686913251877, -0.14512988924980164, 0.30408528447151184, 0.5598272681236267 ]
{"Title": "Community gender systems and daughter\u2019s risk of female genital mutilation/cutting: New theory and application to Egypt", "Authors": "Yount Kathryn M., Cheong Yuk Fai, James-Hawkins Laurie, Grose Rose Grace, Hayford Sarah R.", "Abstract": "Abstract We proposed and tested a feminist social-ecological theory about daughters\u2019 experience of female genital mutilation/cutting (FGMC) in Egypt, where over 90% of women ages 15\u201349 are cut. FGMC has potential adverse effects on demographic and health outcomes and has been defined as a human-rights violation. Contextual factors are important determinants of FGMC, but an integrated theory is lacking, and quantitative multilevel research is limited. We theorized that more favorable community-level gender systems, including gender norms opposing FGMC and expanded opportunities for women outside of the family, would be associated with a daughter\u2019s lower risk of FGMC and would strengthen the negative association of a mother\u2019s opposition to FGMC with her daughter\u2019s risk of cutting. Using a national sample of 14,171 mother-daughter dyads from the 2014 Egypt Demographic and Health Survey, we estimated multilevel discrete-time hazard models to test these relationships. Community gender norms opposing FGMC had significant direct, negative associations with the hazard that a daughter was cut, but women\u2019s opportunities outside the family did not. Maternal opposition to FGMC was negatively associated with cutting a daughter, and these associations were stronger where community opposition to FGMC and opportunities for women were greater. Results provided good support for a gender-systems theory of the multilevel influences on FGMC. Integrated, multilevel interventions that address gender norms about FGMC and opportunities for women in the community, as well as beliefs about the practice among the mothers of at-risk daughters may be needed for sustainable declines in the practice.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005520"}
10.1101/19002352
[ 0.034316595643758774, 0.46829384565353394, -0.17199651896953583, 0.4831806719303131, -0.4974989593029022, -0.05529851093888283, -0.1981598436832428, -0.17488189041614532, -0.06387114524841309, 0.46572452783584595, 0.12398503720760345, -0.4980606436729431, -0.3420509696006775, -0.8906651735305786, 0.03109692595899105, 0.695751965045929, -0.7247199416160583, -0.049604617059230804, -0.6713921427726746, -0.2782822847366333, 0.5477504730224609, -0.24988088011741638, -0.5091657638549805, 0.4030352234840393, 0.05320928245782852, 0.9343613386154175, -0.27727892994880676, 0.3063444197177887, 0.9530928134918213, 0.3286036550998688, 0.2596835792064667, -0.5466977953910828, 0.8635315299034119, -1.0792940855026245, -0.16149887442588806, 0.04497041553258896, 0.6210371255874634, -0.8403279185295105, -0.06941103935241699, -1.0995160341262817, 0.5524808764457703, 0.35843831300735474, 0.006925123278051615, -0.586477518081665, -0.6377910375595093, -0.4223606586456299, -0.6162594556808472, -0.4355258643627167, -0.4976230263710022, -0.7460895776748657, -0.785763144493103, -0.178046315908432, 0.33806005120277405, -0.2437230348587036, -0.051982779055833817, -0.4666430354118347, 0.08459627628326416, -0.6477175951004028, -0.4782670736312866, 0.3025311529636383, 0.5588394999504089, -0.3175613284111023, 0.2028854787349701, -1.433253288269043, -0.09859846532344818, 1.2521284818649292, -0.26091501116752625, -0.17074285447597504, -0.4198858439922333, -0.7037804126739502, -0.9834915995597839, 0.08800122141838074, -0.7035971879959106, -0.08933280408382416, 0.08030489832162857, 0.044619981199502945, 0.5603996515274048, -0.04759647324681282, 0.5832349061965942, -0.2564431130886078, 0.5445476770401001, -0.15983110666275024, -0.3826676905155182, 0.986859142780304, -0.2240748107433319, -0.2993756830692291, 0.07209889590740204, 0.18826907873153687, 0.8764098286628723, 0.10022526979446411, 0.4932790994644165, 0.13854382932186127, 0.4940217435359955, 0.3143557012081146, 0.2910795509815216, 0.30031317472457886, -0.46668195724487305, 0.3458864092826843, 0.5541064739227295, -0.07412461936473846, -0.17416325211524963, 0.500227689743042, -0.28075239062309265, 0.9519336223602295, -0.8935419321060181, -1.0019739866256714, 0.5829954147338867, -0.05772026255726814, 0.44897374510765076, -0.6809413433074951, 0.163566455245018, 0.22798477113246918, -0.48628830909729004, 0.23643985390663147, -0.16696703433990479, 0.03905479237437248, -0.32570716738700867, 0.06160978600382805, -0.39087432622909546, -0.04220961034297943, -0.44196948409080505, -0.4760512709617615, 0.5777760744094849, -0.05200810357928276, 0.20816494524478912, -0.019175350666046143, 0.03128984197974205, 0.6858388781547546, -0.27424779534339905, -0.15926705300807953, 0.3738713264465332, -0.41198304295539856, -0.4253799021244049, 0.6551542282104492, -0.13535533845424652, -0.021048905327916145, 0.0034548575058579445, 0.5853176116943359, -0.12931665778160095, -0.3096112608909607, -0.6829299926757812, 0.06813862919807434, 0.3815464973449707, 1.0573453903198242, -0.47266432642936707, 0.5121710300445557, -0.6308777928352356, -0.5220961570739746, 0.45499303936958313, -0.1722152978181839, 0.23368427157402039, 0.0725613385438919, 0.47842198610305786, 0.22026486694812775, -0.12534284591674805, -0.3664725720882416, -0.5999451875686646, 0.7207608222961426, -0.14609295129776, 0.37836676836013794, -0.031193885952234268, 0.18563058972358704, -0.2838297188282013, 1.1074196100234985, -0.6110423803329468, 0.5745264291763306, 0.6451555490493774, -0.8434781432151794, 0.6195828318595886, -0.24366985261440277, -0.13905483484268188, 1.0077306032180786, 0.048135414719581604, -0.24204860627651215, -0.2642166018486023, 0.24329999089241028, 0.7124442458152771, 0.4694916903972626, 0.1861838400363922, 0.018682559952139854, 0.38098135590553284, -0.2888927757740021, 1.0336138010025024, 0.3584047853946686, 0.4149087965488434, -0.027177516371011734, -0.3768262565135956, -0.6560435891151428, 0.16565528512001038, -0.1662088930606842, -0.2992215156555176, 1.0005580186843872, -0.21801850199699402, 0.9104462265968323, -0.43701767921447754, 0.2678234279155731, -0.2952338457107544, -0.4645547568798065, 0.2177158147096634, -0.16923250257968903, 0.19742560386657715, 0.6501258611679077, -0.14123131334781647, 0.9668139219284058, -0.4151196777820587, 0.4273811876773834, 0.16917656362056732, 0.34600162506103516, -0.271064430475235, 0.10142025351524353, -0.05551600456237793, -0.17754463851451874, -0.20340077579021454, 0.08045485615730286, 0.8926352858543396, -1.0789954662322998, 0.5014729499816895, 0.08440542966127396, 0.07938678562641144, -0.15530046820640564, 0.6617490649223328, 0.2936910092830658, 0.4173363149166107, 0.022853165864944458, -0.3169167935848236, 0.038523055613040924, 0.36752596497535706, 0.05958276242017746, 0.16102349758148193, -0.5591940879821777, -0.10776149481534958, 0.6333242654800415, 0.5899501442909241, 0.1078135147690773, 0.6695507764816284, -0.3449062407016754, -0.15983355045318604, 0.7210763096809387, 0.2872130274772644, -0.013746850192546844, 0.6041595935821533, 0.5801540613174438, 0.8800475597381592, 0.44274768233299255, 0.6114842295646667, -0.2135980874300003, -0.014139045961201191, 0.021009087562561035, -1.1573785543441772, -0.47681525349617004, -1.6120517253875732, 0.809208869934082, -0.8210421204566956, 0.42342671751976013, -0.001300124917179346, -0.23758091032505035, 0.06713231652975082, 0.2121736854314804, 0.05608566850423813, -1.306067943572998, -0.3916473984718323, -0.4597002863883972, 0.14304018020629883, 0.12838463485240936, 0.6105329990386963, 0.44358521699905396, 0.24016176164150238, -0.17773719131946564, 0.11187983304262161, -0.12332428991794586, -0.5527303218841553, -0.15629902482032776, -0.8026073575019836, -0.15097898244857788, -0.4180486500263214, -1.2664098739624023, -0.1238272488117218, -0.23171068727970123, 0.5682605504989624, 0.31091398000717163, 0.5267672538757324, -0.7859082221984863, 0.2624586224555969, -0.21446026861667633, 0.11773939430713654, 0.41280850768089294, -1.0990512371063232, 0.4557572305202484, -0.38087940216064453, 0.15410158038139343, -0.11379595845937729, -0.9115111827850342, -1.0750850439071655, -0.3618132472038269, 0.9102071523666382, -0.041143812239170074, -0.5372751355171204, -0.24537304043769836, 0.08227226138114929, -0.18188415467739105, -0.32936665415763855, -0.30731213092803955, 0.2754736840724945, 0.39666885137557983, -0.8654281497001648, 0.6771140694618225, -0.37011387944221497, 0.3699047863483429, 0.5456637144088745, 0.18149493634700775, 0.0076295542530715466, 0.045597974210977554, 0.40193453431129456, 0.08003795146942139, -0.2096552550792694, 0.7401009798049927, 0.31471964716911316, 0.07916099578142166, 0.406200647354126, -0.9543519616127014, -0.5910825133323669, -0.33184516429901123, 0.013547925278544426, -1.1399084329605103, 0.8311655521392822, 0.06852612644433975, 0.13625457882881165, -0.7132396101951599, 0.11142157763242722, -0.367185115814209, -0.46291226148605347, 0.3050443232059479, -0.6785157322883606, 0.9460802674293518, 0.18240287899971008, 0.3807607889175415, -1.1111297607421875, -0.1722460240125656, -0.18891070783138275, 0.258685439825058, 0.4146987497806549, -0.6784413456916809, -0.31014686822891235, 0.5034782290458679, -0.05069750174880028, 0.0940006822347641, 0.6005792021751404, -0.19911861419677734, -0.5421258211135864, -0.30648311972618103, -0.895052433013916, 0.015193546190857887, -0.28877636790275574, -0.5828684568405151, 0.759450376033783, 0.15399402379989624, -0.18046727776527405, -0.09495140612125397, 0.0671766996383667, 0.8014043569564819, -0.06382903456687927, 0.26278364658355713, 0.4694385826587677, 0.03647301718592644, -0.5563499927520752, -0.47055014967918396, 0.31262755393981934, -0.04420732334256172, 0.49839282035827637, -0.645918071269989, 0.3566407859325409, -0.12338171154260635, 0.3133585751056671, -0.49576887488365173, -0.23990032076835632, -0.03330158814787865, 0.08408878743648529, 0.3202418386936188, 1.371389627456665, -0.75491863489151, 0.20920716226100922, 0.7170962691307068, 0.5728148818016052, 0.18439510464668274, 0.4298636317253113, 0.045836836099624634, -0.6393380761146545, 0.031158220022916794, 0.5617841482162476, 0.21736927330493927, 0.37590375542640686, 0.2848951816558838, 0.14019805192947388, 0.6249002814292908, -0.4338582754135132, -0.20015007257461548, 0.9652963280677795, 0.9117789268493652, -0.7205601334571838, -0.25846126675605774, 0.14096668362617493, 0.22040165960788727, 0.4353352189064026, 0.9997440576553345, 0.36641421914100647, -0.5432698130607605, -0.43849417567253113, 0.48441025614738464, -0.010394880548119545, 0.010076692327857018, 0.4519105553627014, -0.2475176751613617, 0.05111517757177353, -0.22057202458381653, -0.21845094859600067, 0.2856343686580658, -0.9274846315383911, -0.7793787717819214, -0.3074338138103485, -0.10791510343551636, -0.01662236824631691, 0.2636796236038208, -1.1691930294036865, 0.3432677388191223, 0.4687329828739166, -0.883817732334137, 0.19658425450325012, -1.005144476890564, 0.6815118789672852, 0.7408808469772339, -0.426307737827301, -0.34162774682044983, 0.6835850477218628, -0.06611540913581848, -0.13004060089588165, 0.9967313408851624, 0.1217333972454071, -0.30443936586380005, 0.4552006125450134, 0.04133426770567894, 0.2868153154850006, 0.060313671827316284, -0.6923120617866516, -0.4143839180469513, 0.09428876638412476, 0.675407350063324, 0.2639447748661041, 0.7914421558380127, 0.06757555902004242, 0.13030967116355896, 0.9878684878349304, -0.6951293349266052, 0.4262891113758087, -0.3086587190628052, -0.8603711128234863, 0.07386714965105057, -0.4061204195022583, -0.38495513796806335, -0.05056513473391533, -0.30154532194137573, -0.2836047112941742, -0.7594870924949646, -0.08926036953926086, -0.3155255913734436, -0.6108752489089966, -0.05592738464474678, -0.48669761419296265, 0.62740558385849, 0.3455400764942169, -0.1367390751838684, -0.1853533387184143, -0.4257361590862274, 0.5066236853599548, -0.6173233389854431, 0.6862508058547974, -0.8418947458267212, 0.03280883654952049, 0.04525088891386986, -0.5604711174964905, -0.30950650572776794, -0.21939872205257416, 0.3605409264564514, -0.4510495662689209, 0.17766936123371124, -0.023151710629463196, -0.07001077383756638, -0.5189446806907654, -0.09763812273740768, -0.8099738359451294, -0.19342614710330963, 0.7966805696487427, -0.5933108925819397, 0.1328638643026352, 0.5619737505912781, 0.34187212586402893, -0.7200784683227539, -1.1262787580490112, 0.38409554958343506, 0.565362274646759, -0.010899176821112633, 1.5380558967590332, 0.05618744716048241, -0.49387437105178833, 0.9206235408782959, -0.021611711010336876, -0.5895291566848755, -0.42922496795654297, -0.10457277297973633, -0.3297540545463562, 0.1589922308921814, 0.32614389061927795, -0.19024984538555145, 0.16080904006958008, -0.01563146710395813, -0.7319418787956238, 0.40994757413864136, 0.29860246181488037, -0.5523697137832642, -0.8493916988372803, 0.6630986928939819, 0.08943897485733032, -0.9597032070159912, 0.19662079215049744, 0.03811491280794144, -0.14739865064620972, -0.6252533197402954, -0.2982138395309448, -0.43785208463668823, -0.23468700051307678, -0.6592392325401306, 0.6617133021354675, -1.5181548595428467, 0.3302134573459625, -0.36212295293807983, -0.2977454662322998, 0.07128751277923584, -0.3045889735221863, 0.26914992928504944, -0.005753411911427975, -0.17547868192195892, -1.030260682106018, -0.11207155883312225, -0.5738024711608887, -0.635880708694458, -0.9099829196929932, -0.44530048966407776, 0.31965866684913635, 1.0788787603378296, 0.6454411149024963, -0.6172446012496948, 0.6025599837303162, -0.5950421094894409, 0.459905207157135, 0.12380875647068024, -0.1541864573955536, -0.2714983820915222, 0.7097755670547485, 0.6070669889450073, -0.059257134795188904, 0.24121925234794617, -0.9452390670776367, 0.21734382212162018, -0.1683444082736969, 0.09479357302188873, -0.5362502336502075, 0.7014555335044861, -0.17624066770076752, -0.6963574886322021, 0.5615004301071167, -0.4503318667411804, 0.25478485226631165, 0.3038237392902374, 0.10566067695617676, -0.2393047958612442, -0.002389811212196946, -0.3710618019104004, -0.6542178988456726, -0.49171382188796997, -1.2263902425765991, 0.4916906952857971, -0.2938031554222107, -0.23445750772953033, 0.0864504799246788, -0.08243260532617569, -0.03322286158800125, -0.7817959785461426, 0.6016545295715332, 0.5588146448135376, 0.15788938105106354, -0.2697528302669525, -0.6520780920982361, 0.20293574035167694, 1.107340693473816, -0.10369191318750381, 0.020426547154784203, -0.4145180583000183, -0.6420223712921143, -0.23334363102912903, -0.3799852132797241, -0.4313577711582184, -0.2738562226295471, 1.1550824642181396, 0.5707051753997803, -0.35004761815071106, 0.3650207817554474, -0.31630679965019226, -0.20858195424079895, 0.11013790965080261, 0.8690071702003479, -0.0381929911673069, -0.3580087125301361, 0.4676479995250702, -0.5039839744567871, -0.8681259155273438, 0.2427218109369278, 0.5771992802619934, -0.6562779545783997, -0.06091872602701187, 0.5260972380638123, 0.3347908854484558, -0.6378964781761169, 0.3793683350086212, 0.1303020566701889, -0.7918223738670349, -0.6311842203140259, -0.004178423434495926, -0.032457999885082245, 0.30743005871772766, 0.30682387948036194, 0.02998797595500946, -0.1450595259666443, -0.2231214940547943, 0.3339710235595703, 0.5337516665458679, 0.5946258306503296, 0.032193444669246674, -0.05606524273753166, -0.42668676376342773, -0.7822295427322388, 0.896402895450592, 0.7136799693107605, -0.11495987325906754, 0.024926312267780304, -0.4768384099006653, -0.030049458146095276, 0.2806360721588135, -0.504298985004425, 0.3515574634075165, -0.24785907566547394, 0.17510467767715454, 0.07991281896829605, 0.921646773815155, 0.3452247381210327, 0.038230929523706436, 0.20344078540802002, 1.0412578582763672, -0.39705318212509155, -0.07174991816282272, 0.22237145900726318, 0.658754289150238, 0.09728004038333893, 1.0636392831802368, -1.0111123323440552, 0.028097204864025116, 1.0421544313430786, 0.8021860122680664, -0.019267214462161064, -0.44187164306640625, -1.5739505290985107, -0.7965304851531982, 0.17526762187480927, 0.248386949300766, -0.6758768558502197, -0.7260841727256775, 1.3352806568145752, -1.01723051071167, -0.14825063943862915, 0.08642293512821198, 0.864786684513092, -0.8747730851173401, 0.00862647034227848, -0.41432586312294006, -0.5547441840171814, -0.6122428178787231, 0.18472613394260406, 0.2916358411312103, -1.5671619176864624, -0.14449846744537354, 0.2850506901741028, 0.062022071331739426, 0.23166702687740326, -0.055720001459121704, 0.9100257158279419, 0.4606781303882599, 0.9361693263053894, -0.24834327399730682, -0.23799139261245728, -0.5500310063362122, 0.7676510214805603, -0.24658797681331635, 0.5257961750030518, 0.302215576171875, -0.20677399635314941, 0.6782849431037903, 0.7643083333969116, -0.4186936914920807, 0.06794373691082001, 0.3649522066116333, -0.024819673970341682, -0.5018570423126221, -0.44997090101242065, 0.657000720500946, 0.5289342999458313, -0.28780397772789, -0.841289222240448, -0.3985920250415802, 0.2713358402252197, 0.1396843045949936, -0.4110972285270691, -0.5345566868782043, 1.150148630142212, -0.17929968237876892, -0.6264693737030029, -0.08625661581754684, 0.7509063482284546, 0.00678780023008585, 0.6539601683616638, 0.6671286225318909, 0.03523083031177521, 0.07345869392156601, -0.6876093149185181, -0.25124236941337585, 0.5923280715942383, -0.4114629924297333, -0.11507941037416458, 0.6054132580757141, 0.20620015263557434, -0.0461743101477623, -0.162650465965271, -0.1801363229751587, 0.13616861402988434, -0.33529382944107056, -0.4158920347690582, 0.3762844204902649, -0.15682485699653625, -0.8846732378005981, -0.8065415024757385, -0.7349867820739746, -0.6778920888900757, 0.4526668190956116, -0.3869829773902893, -0.029793575406074524, 0.1315847486257553, -0.5640423893928528, 0.6430798768997192, 0.15551435947418213, 1.0360573530197144, 0.026156364008784294, 0.030389074236154556, 0.40918925404548645, 0.07353097200393677, -0.3398992419242859, -0.04824448376893997, 0.11317329853773117, 0.16767197847366333, -0.3302777409553528, -0.5680348873138428, 0.7909212708473206, 0.299966961145401, -0.11765029281377792, -0.7475859522819519, 0.1943792998790741, -0.002136662369593978, -0.4736158549785614, -0.6079224348068237, -0.3217838704586029, -0.15460413694381714, -0.5757879614830017, -0.46306341886520386, -0.7567397952079773, -0.178303062915802, -0.3949678838253021, 0.17455410957336426, 0.4390115439891815, 0.00794390682131052, -0.29824694991111755, -0.2597631514072418, 0.5642775297164917, -0.15576815605163574, 0.4521283507347107, -0.17214351892471313, 0.1314953863620758, -0.486719012260437, -0.2832458019256592, 0.8523728847503662, 0.2250613570213318, 0.7816234827041626, 0.564714252948761, 0.522644579410553, 1.1131525039672852, 0.6107332706451416, 0.5413464307785034, 0.34375813603401184, 0.11648869514465332, 0.22234401106834412, -0.15721823275089264, 0.08136745542287827, -0.5389231443405151, 0.8173667788505554, 0.38793060183525085, 0.0517379455268383, 0.6480770111083984, 0.7973500490188599, 0.45635807514190674, -0.10530894994735718, -0.6130796670913696, -0.1652231514453888, -0.692192554473877, -0.6431389451026917, -0.6541679501533508, 0.5821218490600586, 1.0316053628921509, -0.258233904838562, 0.5454708933830261, 0.15786640346050262, 0.14073309302330017, 0.04015260934829712, -0.09093796461820602, 0.3643072247505188, -0.16663676500320435, -0.13105596601963043, -0.2222837656736374, 0.3247653543949127, -0.020547745749354362, 0.0403980016708374, 0.36983203887939453, -0.6751663684844971, -0.5120072364807129, 0.2057621330022812, -0.14056327939033508, -0.5112969279289246, 0.1826857030391693, -0.4709147810935974, -0.45896491408348083, -0.1390266716480255, -0.0764213278889656, -0.5288106203079224, -0.08788810670375824, 0.40117010474205017, -0.9250590801239014, -0.07761895656585693, 0.06407906115055084, -0.45647886395454407, 0.391236275434494, 0.7519072890281677, 0.6001393795013428, -0.7127266526222229, 1.3160887956619263, 0.18831877410411835, 0.2354506403207779, 1.0207468271255493, -0.26615557074546814, -0.3311075270175934, 0.29499903321266174, -0.32259783148765564, 0.09150633215904236, 0.2939996123313904, 0.2342369705438614, -0.018965015187859535, 0.39716389775276184, -0.010493210516870022, -0.42264848947525024, -0.48931884765625, 0.2742295563220978, 0.45591461658477783, -0.49250438809394836, -0.2677951157093048, 0.6243252754211426, -0.4113997519016266, -0.31503826379776, -0.15566085278987885, -0.42555296421051025, -0.412017285823822, -0.19105742871761322, -0.1917598694562912, 0.02996005490422249, 0.3362439274787903, -0.5760787129402161, -0.0060996077954769135, -0.9239529967308044, -0.21024689078330994, -0.02256094105541706, -0.7143642902374268, -0.2621470093727112, 0.32436972856521606, 0.2833082973957062, -0.18754445016384125, 1.0741772651672363, 0.09683015197515488, 0.2612900733947754, 0.5548662543296814, 0.9394751191139221, -0.07212907820940018, 0.2613876461982727, 0.5025153756141663, 0.407271146774292, -0.022255195304751396, 0.7845350503921509, 0.6616466641426086, 0.026911234483122826, -0.360271155834198, -0.4202827215194702, 0.12220019102096558, -0.07924949377775192, -0.3914491534233093, 0.11395758390426636, 0.13126125931739807, -0.3794124722480774, -0.15284833312034607, -0.7041006088256836, -0.20208725333213806, -0.48794302344322205, 0.6389886140823364, 0.08580639213323593, 0.4992217719554901, 0.2567252218723297, -0.8564633727073669, -0.23664814233779907, -0.6176913976669312, 4.2550859451293945, 1.2663583755493164, 0.10023287683725357, 0.03499249368906021, -0.2334137111902237, 0.3087964653968811, 0.27602458000183105, -0.11295488476753235, 0.400558203458786, -0.16945695877075195, -0.33030372858047485, 0.29572969675064087, -0.34321045875549316, -0.4534337520599365, 0.41498517990112305, 0.9788452386856079, 0.13696794211864471, 0.026617126539349556, 0.4155813455581665, -0.7406287789344788, 0.16408663988113403, 0.12965112924575806, 0.16335192322731018, -0.3276740312576294, -0.034044235944747925, 0.02462616376578808, -0.2681981921195984, 0.16190940141677856, -0.37299200892448425, 0.2952548563480377, -0.5170770883560181, -0.47960346937179565, 0.4734216034412384, -0.198574960231781, -0.10277573764324188, 0.045898083597421646, -0.07561096549034119, -0.5156654119491577, 0.09756898134946823, -0.03710183501243591, 0.006364240311086178, 0.015370145440101624, 0.08807436376810074, -0.4109974205493927, -0.7504569888114929, 0.03482048958539963, 0.21245311200618744, 0.41147878766059875, 0.929214596748352, -0.9335753917694092, 0.7146731615066528, -0.7386760711669922, -0.47235172986984253, 0.09942500293254852, -1.0411051511764526, 0.2998305857181549, 0.31048986315727234, -0.34100455045700073, 0.36874768137931824, -0.3555085361003876, 0.8165526986122131, 0.27879294753074646, -0.5461723208427429, -0.7501710653305054, -0.49309614300727844, 0.23327171802520752, 0.5020222067832947, 0.7403976917266846, -0.4201594293117523, 0.0558692030608654, -0.31404343247413635, 0.03237325698137283, -0.4362581968307495, 0.35976940393447876, 0.49460065364837646, 0.48820507526397705, -0.31102001667022705, -0.07813135534524918, -0.826749324798584, 0.1600496619939804, -0.21063339710235596, 0.10004894435405731, -0.24700810015201569, 0.5640395879745483, 0.5348309278488159, 0.8040437698364258, -0.047334134578704834, -0.9823548793792725, -0.8472517132759094, 0.5597841143608093, 0.6009309887886047, -0.3262443244457245, -0.06933871656656265, -0.6156487464904785, 0.1393282115459442 ]
{"Title": "The ansa subthalamica: a neglected fiber tract", "Authors": "Lopes Alho Eduardo Joaquim, Di Lorenzo Alho Ana Tereza, Horn Andreas, M. Martin Maria da Graca, Edlow Brian L, Fischl Bruce, Nagy J\u00f3zsef, Fonoff Erich T, Hamani Clement, Heinsen Helmut", "Abstract": "Abstract Background The pallidofugal pathways are classically subdivided into ansa lenticularis, lenticular fasciculus, and subthalamic fasciculus. In addition to these three subsystems, we characterize an anatomical structure that connects the antero-medial pole of the subthalamic nucleus to the ventral portions of the pallidum, both related to limbic processing of information. This bundle has been previously considered to form a part of the ansa lenticularis, however, it shows striking differences on histology and MRI features compared to the ansa lenticularis, and therefore we suggest to denominate it ansa subthalamica . Objectives To describe the ansa subthalamica as a different structure than the ansa lenticularis, that can be recognized by different methods (histology, high-field MRI and connectome tractography), including current 3T clinical imaging. Methods A complete human brain was histologically processed and submitted to registration procedures to correct for tissue deformations and normalization to MNI space. Coordinates of histological structures were then comparable to high-field (7T) post-mortem and in vivo MRIs, 13 pre-operative 3T imaging of parkinsonian patients and normative connectome tractography. Mean intensity gray values for different structures were measured in Susceptibility-Weighted Images. Results It was possible to characterize this structure with different methods and there was significant difference in signal intensity in the ansa subthalamica (hypointense), compared to the ansa lenticularis (hyperintense). Conclusions The ansa subhtalamica may represent the anatomical pathway that connects limbic regions of the STN and pallidum, and should be investigated as a possible substrate for limbic effects of stereotactic surgery of the subthalamic region.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002352"}
10.1101/19000257
[ -0.09580262005329132, 0.5105527639389038, 0.08933668583631516, 0.07060613483190536, -0.04566755145788193, 0.062033552676439285, 0.5923892855644226, -0.11463173478841782, -0.031712159514427185, 0.5430611968040466, -0.4727744460105896, -0.37857720255851746, 0.3049148917198181, 0.4211306869983673, -0.11575134098529816, -0.37795186042785645, -0.430789053440094, -0.252331018447876, 0.0388018861413002, 0.03875293210148811, 0.06336288154125214, 0.8708800673484802, -1.0652661323547363, -0.18632492423057556, -0.39362356066703796, 0.8114115595817566, -0.01276183407753706, -0.43757930397987366, 1.021628737449646, 1.0767691135406494, -0.32882970571517944, -0.23511001467704773, 0.6386258602142334, -0.5773906111717224, -0.4087488055229187, -0.024924499914050102, 0.5700316429138184, -0.663817822933197, 0.010208786465227604, -0.6210505962371826, 0.5422386527061462, -0.4089685082435608, 0.9194803833961487, -0.4072306156158447, 0.19242806732654572, 0.08506818115711212, -0.37407878041267395, 0.512336790561676, 0.04725877195596695, 0.9385623931884766, -0.04816855490207672, 0.2810090482234955, -0.11217659711837769, -0.21453671157360077, -0.6105489730834961, 0.35013753175735474, -0.40451300144195557, -0.560440719127655, -1.0573348999023438, -0.1293911635875702, 0.043357834219932556, 0.08374964445829391, 0.5863258242607117, -0.9341480731964111, 0.3818190097808838, 0.9620237946510315, -0.4188936948776245, -0.3851791024208069, -0.04266657680273056, 0.028778517618775368, -0.09334731101989746, -0.3016732931137085, -0.332965612411499, -1.1445553302764893, -0.5936639904975891, -0.7944006323814392, -0.4102993607521057, -0.4633304476737976, 0.32631710171699524, 0.3864000737667084, 0.4587361812591553, 0.446109414100647, 0.5405228137969971, 0.4079173803329468, -0.38083067536354065, 0.6727378964424133, 0.21945525705814362, 0.2799484133720398, 0.045843079686164856, 0.72768634557724, -0.15572403371334076, 0.6246429681777954, -0.3405330777168274, 0.22379091382026672, 0.8894290328025818, 1.026511788368225, -0.43872007727622986, 0.19122041761875153, -0.45207592844963074, 0.2014884352684021, 1.0711123943328857, 0.6330913305282593, 0.09477019309997559, 1.125619649887085, 0.1088332012295723, 0.3542454242706299, 0.13145287334918976, -0.39616554975509644, -0.15247847139835358, 0.047104574739933014, 0.14295481145381927, -0.09207212924957275, -0.8654268383979797, -0.32422909140586853, 0.6345556378364563, 0.6332163214683533, 0.11006506532430649, 0.8026555180549622, 0.15584999322891235, 0.21058662235736847, -0.827987551689148, 0.18730716407299042, 0.5747296810150146, -0.47852998971939087, -0.3899981379508972, -0.27802854776382446, 0.09157437086105347, 0.7248010635375977, -0.4253460466861725, -0.12092019617557526, 0.06433969736099243, -0.7991766333580017, -0.02525307424366474, 0.6956325173377991, 0.09081076085567474, -0.16720473766326904, 0.1603870689868927, 0.02640240080654621, 0.2731839418411255, -0.06987351924180984, -0.32342544198036194, 0.3134706914424896, -0.4825857877731323, 1.0215184688568115, -0.07795173674821854, 1.1089627742767334, -0.4206988513469696, -1.408819317817688, -0.46739909052848816, -0.3763856887817383, 0.36238670349121094, -0.31253889203071594, -0.0711754560470581, -0.02839699015021324, 0.48396867513656616, 0.4611300528049469, -0.4085024297237396, -0.062452949583530426, -0.3318405747413635, -0.5348585247993469, -0.062082380056381226, -0.04389490932226181, 0.11745373904705048, -0.09545072913169861, -0.50007164478302, 0.44979771971702576, 0.2917730510234833, -0.01519159134477377, 0.6003955006599426, -0.22980134189128876, 1.2622661590576172, -0.30460524559020996, -0.3200434446334839, -0.10325102508068085, 0.12446106970310211, 0.5720211863517761, 0.48059168457984924, -0.27082931995391846, 0.3689737319946289, 0.8031331300735474, -0.08705615252256393, -0.41039904952049255, 0.06723114848136902, 0.6429492831230164, 0.14638873934745789, 0.5219014286994934, -0.408480703830719, -0.8551685214042664, -0.1456362009048462, -1.0207241773605347, -0.028418036177754402, 0.44823989272117615, -0.4744829833507538, -0.3617188632488251, 0.11933465301990509, -0.6385902762413025, -0.13537529110908508, 0.5116532444953918, 0.39208123087882996, -0.7816305160522461, -0.9062526822090149, 0.5842640995979309, -0.19046969711780548, 0.32693570852279663, -0.2492070496082306, 0.23076333105564117, 0.004004507791250944, 0.18323326110839844, -0.5849959254264832, -0.09462246298789978, 1.2152636051177979, -0.2357746958732605, -0.17833691835403442, -0.5448899865150452, 0.5317984819412231, -0.18861041963100433, 0.21000762283802032, 0.4609069228172302, -1.1341418027877808, 0.26273858547210693, -0.13980717957019806, 0.49871963262557983, 0.6272285580635071, 0.043663281947374344, 0.16654016077518463, 0.02467663772404194, 0.12967020273208618, 0.11271006613969803, -0.2574458718299866, 0.4932010769844055, -0.2143593728542328, 0.7794285416603088, 0.2748543620109558, 0.8911698460578918, 1.0571777820587158, -0.1405113935470581, 0.3727051317691803, 0.3323419392108917, -0.3319949507713318, 0.07850281894207001, 0.3186682164669037, 0.40001893043518066, 0.2836143970489502, 0.1362658143043518, -0.3939566910266876, 1.4645280838012695, -0.3938716650009155, -0.07567691057920456, -0.48516637086868286, 0.5595235824584961, -0.4604644775390625, 1.0617941617965698, 0.5155957937240601, 0.6293467879295349, -1.1117734909057617, -0.3543044924736023, 0.3835841119289398, 0.17852210998535156, -0.5748519897460938, -0.10101688653230667, -0.892491340637207, 0.4772545397281647, 0.03816290944814682, 0.1978965699672699, 1.07356595993042, 0.6030961871147156, -0.3870420753955841, 0.918797492980957, 0.3150342106819153, -0.70734703540802, -1.1887729167938232, -0.1707160621881485, -1.4319329261779785, -0.7634521722793579, -1.0350371599197388, 0.37011420726776123, -0.04831799864768982, -0.38322770595550537, 0.47910499572753906, 0.22125177085399628, -0.6117693781852722, -0.15233929455280304, 0.6818898916244507, 0.44120749831199646, 0.5975493788719177, 0.050137292593717575, -0.6450315713882446, -0.47593870759010315, 0.5025848150253296, 0.5162990093231201, -0.20303136110305786, -0.25306951999664307, -0.1001206710934639, -0.34792056679725647, 1.0214444398880005, -0.33429041504859924, -0.11812921613454819, 0.6696405410766602, 0.0264262817800045, 0.14335402846336365, -0.22929182648658752, 0.08681652694940567, -0.1669393628835678, -0.344126433134079, -0.4079156517982483, 0.9058035016059875, -0.5410006046295166, 0.19035907089710236, 0.7890182137489319, 0.03137793019413948, -0.06637643277645111, 0.4590955376625061, 0.1605452448129654, -0.1956869512796402, -0.7621309757232666, 0.21054208278656006, 0.9907511472702026, -0.051858581602573395, 0.018628930673003197, -0.31278476119041443, -0.8483728170394897, -0.11118584871292114, 0.1483522653579712, -0.39922407269477844, -0.18325266242027283, 0.14070041477680206, 0.39869600534439087, -1.4895185232162476, 0.1348932981491089, -0.474616676568985, -1.1598929166793823, -0.5200485587120056, 0.1272738128900528, -0.1294337660074234, 0.7100266218185425, 0.005727485287934542, -0.5138090252876282, 0.488934189081192, -0.13591016829013824, -0.20168866217136383, 0.4839787483215332, -0.2527290880680084, 0.3921697735786438, 0.07439000904560089, 0.2459511160850525, 0.49703484773635864, -0.1616518199443817, -0.6312548518180847, -0.34636738896369934, 0.37101227045059204, 0.3090556859970093, -0.019274501129984856, 1.2200580835342407, 0.24584434926509857, -0.3770577013492584, 1.0093134641647339, -0.3798670172691345, 0.13276314735412598, 0.5132203698158264, 0.5063300728797913, 0.13105440139770508, 0.2324785441160202, 0.06627289205789566, -0.12060588598251343, -0.5775540471076965, -0.01321428269147873, 0.25302380323410034, 0.6011390089988708, 0.888324499130249, -0.3594343960285187, 0.2852289080619812, -0.5895679593086243, 0.14656803011894226, 0.5550230741500854, -0.2514576017856598, -0.6051018834114075, 1.178105354309082, 0.8610004782676697, 1.313072681427002, -1.3375147581100464, 0.7173899412155151, 0.040635671466588974, 0.4728163182735443, 0.2835300862789154, -0.07908744364976883, 0.1807815134525299, -0.4468425214290619, 0.3106713891029358, 0.25267136096954346, -0.9230297207832336, 0.04696717858314514, -0.39893433451652527, -0.6004796028137207, 0.36405619978904724, -0.5346651673316956, 0.005618477240204811, -0.5692108273506165, -0.03261590376496315, 0.7144760489463806, 0.22467629611492157, 0.2564418911933899, -0.42577606439590454, 0.6728506684303284, 0.680909276008606, 0.6774390339851379, 0.10525607317686081, -0.12195155769586563, 0.17978790402412415, -0.26366814970970154, -0.931962788105011, 0.3509332537651062, -0.8554862141609192, -0.2866775393486023, -0.14301064610481262, 0.798281729221344, -0.29037773609161377, -0.2874690890312195, -0.2961857318878174, -0.12825874984264374, -0.04862615466117859, 0.0335281677544117, -0.09189839661121368, -0.6936073303222656, 0.07680471241474152, -0.0991210788488388, -0.20559097826480865, 0.252384752035141, -0.4768325686454773, -0.0868176743388176, 0.4727015197277069, 0.13950009644031525, -0.512948215007782, -0.3005150556564331, 0.21100877225399017, -0.16217269003391266, -0.14154106378555298, 0.293680340051651, -0.1808539181947708, -0.1385352611541748, -0.7947204113006592, -0.515071451663971, 0.28002533316612244, -0.240962952375412, -0.14193923771381378, 0.06036379188299179, -0.10588689148426056, 1.3373520374298096, 0.6722617149353027, 0.612216591835022, -0.029461076483130455, 0.14994031190872192, -1.0733551979064941, 0.5533810257911682, -0.0002538998960517347, -0.20084115862846375, -0.4470727741718292, -0.10816089808940887, 0.6411611437797546, 0.13475511968135834, -0.47333192825317383, -0.7708568572998047, 0.40817055106163025, 0.6757751703262329, 0.08101022988557816, -0.9634180665016174, 0.8008193969726562, 0.08070766925811768, -0.22522933781147003, 0.917428195476532, -0.3905562460422516, -0.46193018555641174, 0.010988069698214531, 0.029512327164411545, -0.5789644122123718, 0.48256710171699524, 0.0453413762152195, 0.14769665896892548, 0.3234501779079437, -0.519666850566864, 0.08934980630874634, 0.13142885267734528, 0.1949235200881958, -0.3181956708431244, -0.17135334014892578, -0.02010340616106987, -0.23032447695732117, -0.22238396108150482, 0.5518585443496704, -0.6084339618682861, 1.0959672927856445, -0.03828946873545647, -1.0011733770370483, -0.3474564552307129, 0.11916874349117279, -0.05385826155543327, -0.3420393764972687, -0.3097841143608093, -0.35917800664901733, -0.055322203785181046, -0.27480074763298035, 0.8901838660240173, -0.44824764132499695, -0.18689794838428497, 0.054664187133312225, 0.42502889037132263, -0.8158015012741089, -0.1664513200521469, 0.9967676997184753, -0.8318729400634766, -0.6859437227249146, -0.536478579044342, -0.24285553395748138, -0.584891140460968, -0.3533477485179901, 0.013547689653933048, 0.40587562322616577, 0.6103435754776001, 0.3888113796710968, -0.47999700903892517, 0.37864449620246887, -0.4131335914134979, -0.5190430879592896, -0.19850057363510132, 0.6581438779830933, 0.7409658432006836, 0.3606865704059601, 0.14901812374591827, -0.13480699062347412, -0.4392065107822418, -0.8213033080101013, -0.05593682453036308, -0.42869967222213745, 0.2825661599636078, -0.18433816730976105, -0.004329888615757227, 0.1991967409849167, 0.6603125333786011, 0.11608899384737015, 0.4829941391944885, 0.29700884222984314, -0.8407947421073914, -0.10870974510908127, -0.22947995364665985, -0.7545032501220703, -0.07543378323316574, -1.6536891460418701, -0.05140909552574158, 0.9260719418525696, 0.23955683410167694, -0.32752010226249695, -0.046269889920949936, 0.5595239996910095, 0.20389065146446228, 0.3718154728412628, -0.11434833705425262, -0.13057556748390198, 0.18976666033267975, 0.45139849185943604, 0.13986732065677643, 0.010252251289784908, -1.0045175552368164, 1.1759331226348877, -0.7917852401733398, -0.10086587816476822, -0.030056467279791832, -0.42153042554855347, 0.3168953061103821, -0.22542376816272736, 1.0802693367004395, 0.004923736676573753, 0.2990383207798004, -0.39037349820137024, 0.4037890136241913, 0.28908541798591614, 0.012600055895745754, -0.8170673847198486, -1.2818118333816528, -0.7467721700668335, -0.808519721031189, 0.3341187834739685, -0.27656984329223633, -0.06689424067735672, 0.10868086665868759, 0.22038491070270538, -0.058682408183813095, 0.01225650031119585, 0.9522085785865784, 0.3642100691795349, -0.4085082709789276, -0.29595237970352173, 0.014638497494161129, 0.7559265494346619, -0.29857346415519714, 0.4479973316192627, 0.11171573400497437, -0.1100381463766098, 0.27476727962493896, 0.012063965201377869, -0.016238702461123466, -0.832394003868103, -0.43592369556427, -0.024619504809379578, 0.9421459436416626, -0.7437600493431091, 0.006956830155104399, 0.23609992861747742, -0.4354608952999115, -0.581113874912262, 0.35529911518096924, -0.12457432597875595, 0.06339321285486221, 0.9748539328575134, -0.07187774032354355, -0.6674748063087463, 0.664074182510376, 0.043159861117601395, -0.030859241262078285, -0.13312119245529175, 0.909731388092041, 0.5439674258232117, -1.398600697517395, 0.455708384513855, 0.4137689173221588, -0.9599820971488953, -0.2945716679096222, -0.1624867022037506, -0.9691146016120911, -0.2332557737827301, 0.14327751100063324, 0.06956982612609863, 0.016563814133405685, -0.3988337218761444, 0.42352113127708435, -0.11632753908634186, 0.1717882752418518, -0.3544161915779114, -0.053270913660526276, 1.1314902305603027, -0.29513856768608093, -0.36580705642700195, 0.07704934477806091, -1.028123140335083, 0.18809033930301666, 0.18113504350185394, -0.30137962102890015, -0.09870821237564087, 0.13927337527275085, 0.41823428869247437, -0.1658499836921692, -0.0860716700553894, 0.45339956879615784, 0.32961875200271606, -0.3840498626232147, -0.12041154503822327, -0.3347078859806061, 0.8221386075019836, 0.11127859354019165, -0.10304636508226395, -0.8390645384788513, 0.7343429327011108, 0.6793874502182007, -0.12491941452026367, -0.5085132122039795, -0.4801314175128937, 0.2215152531862259, 0.36013004183769226, 0.1367928683757782, -0.3119279444217682, -0.5726065039634705, -0.48669859766960144, -0.5561832785606384, -0.42929312586784363, -0.8104250431060791, -0.009434433653950691, -0.06649073213338852, -0.34965577721595764, -0.6096605658531189, 0.10978621244430542, 0.6281367540359497, -0.15941289067268372, 0.4105322062969208, 0.20686069130897522, 0.7618725299835205, -0.6600278615951538, -0.8887423276901245, -0.44524192810058594, 0.6553110480308533, 0.08694788813591003, 0.7312647104263306, -1.2036709785461426, -0.18296824395656586, -0.2846800684928894, -0.05469505116343498, 0.4472900629043579, 0.7195899486541748, -0.725099503993988, -0.42868050932884216, -0.7081103324890137, 0.6981421709060669, 0.30117759108543396, -0.3566085398197174, 0.8683832287788391, -0.16713637113571167, 0.16240695118904114, 0.7900951504707336, 0.25516068935394287, -0.2770569622516632, 1.018227458000183, 0.2355891466140747, -0.27852514386177063, -0.27991095185279846, -0.03195099160075188, 0.26470714807510376, -0.7588211894035339, 0.31653526425361633, -1.0123833417892456, -0.7740194797515869, -0.17081204056739807, -0.11626604944467545, -0.026434265077114105, -0.025555038824677467, -0.06556032598018646, 0.4292716681957245, 0.10019601881504059, 0.3788594901561737, 0.17996816337108612, 0.34295618534088135, 0.2549482583999634, 0.10595228523015976, 0.3731999695301056, -1.3974841833114624, 0.9296938180923462, 0.6473786234855652, -0.19866600632667542, 0.5498554706573486, -0.10375674813985825, 0.02077672630548477, 0.3714611530303955, 0.1875920593738556, 0.4658486843109131, 0.5350514054298401, 0.12738461792469025, 0.6241537928581238, -0.02836981788277626, -0.8284933567047119, -0.06375640630722046, 0.2799604535102844, -1.2747986316680908, -0.16959701478481293, 0.5186397433280945, -0.6797687411308289, -0.7945588231086731, -0.9815164804458618, -0.9813097715377808, 0.9729787707328796, -0.5452446937561035, -0.5660648941993713, 0.7118951678276062, 1.0675883293151855, 0.17634572088718414, 1.0898213386535645, 0.37839290499687195, 0.13275063037872314, -0.28797024488449097, 0.20653876662254333, -0.3535257577896118, -0.7625673413276672, -0.4302610158920288, 0.09465689212083817, 0.7730420231819153, 0.2396780550479889, -0.020024064928293228, -0.04114728420972824, -0.4998841881752014, 0.04352179914712906, 0.10795073211193085, -0.20083053410053253, -1.011174201965332, -0.15501081943511963, 0.2366979569196701, 0.4665411710739136, -0.43524450063705444, 0.3753626048564911, 0.14887981116771698, -1.1147738695144653, -0.7673760652542114, 0.42419806122779846, 0.26598283648490906, 0.007362016011029482, 0.30322518944740295, 0.41731569170951843, 0.22960823774337769, -0.2592146098613739, -0.4581924080848694, 0.417925626039505, 0.37047719955444336, -0.4631066620349884, 0.2374327927827835, -0.04695391282439232, -0.11018954962491989, 0.8627845644950867, 0.3747885823249817, -0.23674030601978302, 0.02784884162247181, -0.284765362739563, 0.05905346944928169, -0.15978164970874786, -0.690976083278656, 0.16367118060588837, 0.2875879406929016, -0.9438003897666931, -0.11187621206045151, 0.11290962249040604, 1.1103512048721313, 0.843837559223175, -0.3319478929042816, 0.5018977522850037, -0.31479331851005554, -0.3621782958507538, 0.020431382581591606, 0.30894002318382263, 0.3840380609035492, 0.6137434840202332, 0.33017319440841675, 0.37729141116142273, 1.436882734298706, 0.09556573629379272, -0.31900253891944885, 0.25358858704566956, -0.6864526867866516, -0.42792826890945435, -0.7564272284507751, 0.3366982638835907, -0.25994107127189636, 0.06532271206378937, 0.12585137784481049, -0.4649127721786499, -0.4571439027786255, 0.07124713063240051, -0.08738458156585693, 0.12966954708099365, 1.2273863554000854, 0.21202535927295685, -0.8304596543312073, 0.07449235767126083, -0.06366688758134842, -1.0083969831466675, -0.1435728371143341, 0.004889338277280331, -0.2726236581802368, -0.05795919522643089, -0.22014807164669037, 0.3686239719390869, 0.49306848645210266, 0.24336813390254974, 0.24412566423416138, -0.2841435372829437, 0.32610058784484863, 0.49674880504608154, -0.033565595746040344, -0.3651621341705322, -0.4883119761943817, -0.1758655160665512, 0.35098111629486084, -0.786336362361908, -0.22148078680038452, 0.47740450501441956, -0.811443030834198, 0.07610148191452026, 0.2267705500125885, 0.32238879799842834, -0.5306119918823242, -0.9778160452842712, -0.40901634097099304, 0.01946946606040001, 0.1030304878950119, -0.3039001226425171, 0.2464160919189453, 0.11385197937488556, 0.005766912363469601, 0.26516756415367126, -0.8571734428405762, -0.3683953583240509, 0.2511709928512573, -0.6707124710083008, 0.8811237215995789, -0.12857936322689056, -0.2807244658470154, -0.501851499080658, -1.4508781433105469, -0.35158538818359375, 0.09008627384901047, -0.22680479288101196, -1.039995551109314, -0.022848203778266907, 0.28947579860687256, 0.328268826007843, -0.08891086280345917, 0.12207002937793732, -0.2508499026298523, -0.05553777515888214, 1.557966947555542, -0.5698038339614868, 0.35171568393707275, -0.5359649658203125, -0.6226420402526855, 0.31443119049072266, -0.17281728982925415, -0.016898106783628464, 0.058961011469364166, -0.6115155816078186, -0.28393569588661194, 0.48114386200904846, -0.263605535030365, -0.5005980730056763, 0.335618793964386, 0.7705187797546387, 0.09310106188058853, -0.10288093239068985, -0.38462674617767334, 0.12464822828769684, -0.761786162853241, 1.0375548601150513, -0.3132244944572449, -0.2527385950088501, -0.29364505410194397, -0.131434366106987, 0.3110092878341675, -0.7978150248527527, 4.141655921936035, 0.5187526345252991, 0.6754909157752991, -0.2956404387950897, 0.5058846473693848, -0.11724505573511124, 0.6667497754096985, 0.132610484957695, 0.38785654306411743, 0.061162594705820084, -0.48483535647392273, 0.6091533899307251, 0.4926547706127167, 0.0140636395663023, 0.48736846446990967, -0.18820437788963318, -1.1904422044754028, 0.017521901056170464, 0.17377980053424835, -0.8086236119270325, -0.1627286672592163, 0.32634028792381287, -0.24192266166210175, 0.023897819221019745, 0.0071871583350002766, -0.05416014418005943, 0.02071920409798622, -0.054630909115076065, 0.15263375639915466, -0.27018654346466064, 0.7802633047103882, -0.6078510284423828, 0.1374078392982483, -0.8184167146682739, -0.3492952287197113, -0.010925051756203175, -0.09087900817394257, -0.4307062327861786, -0.183557391166687, -0.7370678186416626, 0.2245170623064041, 0.5630862712860107, 0.4400177597999573, -0.2200135886669159, 0.2503809630870819, 0.3642948269844055, -0.6641550064086914, -0.8460379242897034, 0.5867846012115479, 0.13080798089504242, 0.7965291142463684, -1.2781169414520264, 0.06254996359348297, 0.07824598997831345, -1.0585203170776367, -0.750516951084137, -0.46458184719085693, -1.5698981285095215, 0.22244837880134583, -0.08002631366252899, 0.05932977423071861, -0.10021772235631943, 0.6081828474998474, 0.270964652299881, -0.5513007640838623, -0.027214979752898216, 0.7187039852142334, -0.08948274701833725, 0.39598017930984497, -0.5002408027648926, 0.2736162543296814, -0.6910540461540222, 0.20969219505786896, -0.8077670335769653, 0.1626039296388626, -0.0393359437584877, -0.5871325135231018, 0.8301023244857788, -1.1137468814849854, -0.742146909236908, 0.3325965404510498, 0.16231274604797363, 0.15786431729793549, -0.5566495656967163, 0.29091373085975647, 0.4632839858531952, -0.5480769276618958, -0.2044830322265625, -0.5643340945243835, 0.5402390360832214, 0.6601207256317139, 0.2730555236339569, 0.06920108199119568, 0.04219796508550644, 0.3031243681907654 ]
{"Title": "The prevalence of scabies, pyoderma and other communicable dermatoses in the Bijagos Archipelago, Guinea-Bissau", "Authors": "Marks Michael, Sammut Thomas, Cabral Marito Gomes, da Silva Eunice Teixeira, Goncalves Adriana, Rodrigues Amabelia, Mandjuba Crist\u00f3v\u00e3o, Nakutum Jose, Ca Janete, D\u2019Alessandro Umberto, Achan Jane, Logan James, Bailey Robin, Mabey David, Last Anna, Walker Stephen L.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Skin diseases represent a significant public health problem in most low and middle income settings. Nevertheless, there is a relative paucity of high-quality epidemiological data on the prevalence of these conditions. Materials/methods We conducted two cross-sectional population-based skin-surveys of children (6 months to 9 years old) in the Bijag\u00f3s Archipelago of Guinea-Bissau during the dry season (February-March 2018) and the wet season (June-July 2018). Following a period of training, a nurse performed a standardised examination for communicable dermatoses for each participant. We calculated the prevalence of each skin condition and investigated demographic associations. Results 1062 children were enrolled in the dry season survey of whom 318 (29.9%) had at least one skin diseases. The most common diagnosis was tinea capitis (154/1062, 14.5% - 95% CI 12.5-16.8%) followed by tinea corporis (84/1062, 7.9% - 95% CI 6.4-9.7%), pyoderma (82/1062, 7.7% - 95% CI 6.2-9.5%) and scabies (56/1062. 5.2% - 95%CI 4.0 \u2013 6.8%). 320 children were enrolled in the wet season survey of whom 121 (37.8%) had at least one skin problem. Tinea capitis remained the most common diagnosis (79/320, 24.7% - 95% CI 20.1 \u2013 29.9%), followed by pyoderma (38/320, 11.9% - 95% CI 8.6-16.1%), tinea corporis (23/320, 7.2% - 95% 4.7 \u2013 10.7%) and scabies (6/320, 1.9% - 95% CI 0.8-4.2%). Conclusions Our study, which utilised robust population-based cluster random sampling methodology, demonstrates the substantial disease burden caused by common communicable dermatoses in this setting. Given these findings, there is a need to consider common dermatoses as part of Universal Health Coverage to deliver \u2018skin-health for all\u2019. Author Summary Skin conditions are very common in many low and middle income settings but there have been relatively few surveys of skin disease conducted using the best epidemiological approaches. We performed two cross-sectional population-based skin-surveys of children in the Bijag\u00f3s Archipelago, Guinea-Bissau, using gold-standard sampling methodologies. Skin conditions were extremely common and almost 30% of children had at least one common, infectious skin condition in both surveys. Fungal skin and scalp infections were the most common conditions followed by bacterial skin infections. Our survey demonstrates that common, easily treatable skin conditions are responsible for a high burden of disease in this population. Skin-health should be considered a key component of the Universal Health Coverage agenda.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19000257"}
10.1101/19008029
[ 0.2735121548175812, 0.5638096928596497, -0.21254238486289978, 0.7135196924209595, -0.40044838190078735, 0.2502000629901886, -0.2884443402290344, 0.12372030317783356, -0.05173782631754875, 0.8861472010612488, -0.20767229795455933, -0.8005411028862, 0.060994237661361694, 0.36884212493896484, -0.6076538562774658, 0.03432415425777435, -0.27804696559906006, -0.06975852698087692, -0.24276871979236603, -0.2526361048221588, -0.0027974704280495644, 1.0770916938781738, -1.276304841041565, -0.22021545469760895, -0.7830034494400024, 0.9049955606460571, 0.16538797318935394, 0.08096461743116379, 1.8177244663238525, 0.9967820644378662, 0.7521381378173828, -0.06801392883062363, -0.011609517969191074, -0.38004088401794434, -0.6873276233673096, -0.41561439633369446, 0.40091246366500854, -0.19631671905517578, 0.1672181338071823, -0.23476871848106384, 0.4589645564556122, -0.5808185935020447, 0.7087140083312988, -0.7315830588340759, -0.8638819456100464, 0.09183671325445175, -0.02961367927491665, 0.4082680344581604, -0.17328529059886932, 0.17152847349643707, -0.213052436709404, 0.3527250587940216, -0.11750563234090805, -0.8850401043891907, 0.0842738151550293, -0.18636712431907654, -0.2542732357978821, 0.009524587541818619, -0.44118306040763855, -0.1733884960412979, 0.22622042894363403, -0.7105586528778076, 0.46026450395584106, -0.6577152609825134, 0.7971181869506836, 1.456885576248169, 0.08728804439306259, -0.23762953281402588, 0.34541258215904236, -0.007309860549867153, -0.25196462869644165, -0.4438188076019287, -0.8040016293525696, -0.5779863595962524, -0.40198010206222534, -0.433908075094223, 0.4866950511932373, -0.3238888382911682, -0.5044385194778442, 0.04058331623673439, 0.09339233487844467, 0.4204610288143158, 0.6448625326156616, -0.1563531756401062, -0.7859214544296265, 0.5219129920005798, 0.26410460472106934, 0.533382773399353, 0.5929836630821228, 0.5242361426353455, -0.29986053705215454, 0.5877256989479065, 0.0859900712966919, -0.2589420676231384, -0.20746879279613495, 0.9718774557113647, -0.7522263526916504, -0.24628522992134094, 0.45965537428855896, -0.3592837452888489, 0.9050352573394775, 0.8062456846237183, -0.3554611802101135, 1.0495845079421997, -0.6249389052391052, 0.2860323190689087, 0.4474713206291199, -0.28107959032058716, -1.1731168031692505, -0.8922203183174133, 0.21308663487434387, -0.16994720697402954, -0.8069471716880798, -0.8821964263916016, 1.4190024137496948, 0.49502748250961304, 0.22499755024909973, 0.8839420080184937, -0.5352174639701843, 0.5162758827209473, 0.23254375159740448, -0.5558736324310303, 0.658044695854187, -0.3731914758682251, -0.006680136546492577, -0.05569516494870186, -0.22064821422100067, 0.4923245310783386, -0.5675062537193298, 0.25812944769859314, -0.13865278661251068, -0.31950145959854126, 0.1402963250875473, 0.4678829312324524, -0.1944054514169693, 0.06060778349637985, 0.6339216232299805, 0.5124269127845764, 0.014723983593285084, -0.5008185505867004, -0.022340543568134308, 0.6231690645217896, -0.7630757689476013, 1.2131569385528564, -0.3928607404232025, 0.998528003692627, -0.9685339331626892, -0.22847971320152283, -0.12169841676950455, 0.08061590790748596, -0.14003980159759521, 0.8262156844139099, -0.6060068607330322, -0.06334973126649857, -0.09488004446029663, 0.39654624462127686, -0.9879923462867737, 0.35206201672554016, -0.5989439487457275, -0.16523586213588715, -0.8627704977989197, 0.10199576616287231, 0.1836809366941452, 0.2473483681678772, -1.3235080242156982, 0.9276291131973267, -0.8058342337608337, 0.08263189345598221, 0.3116324841976166, -0.26733532547950745, 1.5574569702148438, 0.42055317759513855, -0.5870088338851929, 0.21702860295772552, 0.40146604180336, 0.7351282238960266, 0.9659557938575745, 0.13493339717388153, 0.7406405806541443, 0.8480482697486877, 0.19005389511585236, -0.03559189289808273, -0.1102793961763382, 0.3115081787109375, -0.2678537964820862, 0.446117103099823, -0.15549808740615845, -0.6428865194320679, -1.1544344425201416, -0.5325954556465149, 0.3399629592895508, 1.0059908628463745, -0.39457088708877563, -0.10558115690946579, 0.3497638404369354, -0.22709402441978455, -0.40907004475593567, 0.5356765985488892, 0.9682396650314331, -0.7820504903793335, -0.3857932984828949, 0.5652329921722412, -0.5712482929229736, -0.02559981495141983, -0.4248831272125244, 1.2039220333099365, 0.3746710419654846, 0.12968870997428894, -0.6026129722595215, 0.07185385376214981, 0.7578882575035095, -0.4385374188423157, -0.4013034701347351, -0.43728119134902954, 0.4740448594093323, -0.29274100065231323, 0.5533964037895203, 0.5118577480316162, -0.3714333772659302, -0.7265058755874634, -0.47157925367355347, -0.6721704006195068, 0.5716620683670044, 0.08817820996046066, 0.47294941544532776, 0.45002883672714233, 0.8824301958084106, 0.7277100682258606, -0.9919790625572205, 0.22637894749641418, -0.19935327768325806, 0.3678613603115082, -0.07900216430425644, 0.8801989555358887, 0.6421946883201599, 0.23760846257209778, 0.3117501139640808, 0.9681956768035889, -0.2186356484889984, -0.012115458957850933, 0.4234997630119324, 0.605250358581543, 0.4379847049713135, -0.40172937512397766, -0.9641351103782654, 0.39179959893226624, -0.1623651385307312, 0.7147716283798218, -0.41144728660583496, 0.5425873398780823, -0.4754929542541504, 0.3327019214630127, 1.0571720600128174, 0.45244479179382324, -1.0967644453048706, -0.06865151971578598, 0.13802948594093323, 0.09099400788545609, -0.7451807260513306, 0.02151630073785782, 0.1448533535003662, 1.0409191846847534, -0.27082374691963196, -0.28783538937568665, 0.7778218984603882, 0.5497043132781982, -0.15251505374908447, 0.5569057464599609, 0.5257827639579773, 0.4078015983104706, -1.4380947351455688, 0.08070877939462662, -0.42060041427612305, -0.38993027806282043, -0.7896658182144165, 0.18398261070251465, -0.6139724254608154, -0.17763425409793854, -0.03579608350992203, -0.08366917818784714, 0.2508489191532135, -0.8837839961051941, 0.42381516098976135, 0.7031394243240356, 0.1401330679655075, -0.0523613877594471, -1.0528607368469238, 0.4478045403957367, -0.18096286058425903, -0.20348475873470306, -0.2321244180202484, -0.06793332099914551, -0.7446461319923401, -1.1206953525543213, 0.5254825949668884, 0.2506462037563324, -0.08195760846138, 0.026765648275613785, -0.2872098684310913, -0.21829262375831604, 0.10738088190555573, -0.005480924155563116, 0.26674744486808777, -0.2622586786746979, -0.721287190914154, 0.5842155814170837, -0.4076504111289978, 0.17856401205062866, 0.6925331354141235, -0.2666420638561249, -0.5713709592819214, 0.44086384773254395, -0.20361535251140594, 0.6959838271141052, -1.3507189750671387, -0.2521287202835083, 0.48640891909599304, -0.19868974387645721, -0.034322865307331085, 0.11173674464225769, -0.6980582475662231, -0.35554376244544983, -0.3468254804611206, -0.7730687856674194, -0.2374221384525299, 0.6476777195930481, 0.10811429470777512, -1.430186152458191, 0.7305854558944702, -0.4968557357788086, -0.434839129447937, -0.22338178753852844, -0.14458897709846497, 0.2740442752838135, -0.07179928570985794, -0.40388309955596924, -0.3451705873012543, -0.5546427369117737, -0.41861313581466675, 0.298127681016922, 0.42529213428497314, -0.19133077561855316, -0.028845764696598053, 0.21100997924804688, -0.061856940388679504, 0.46139246225357056, 0.20702208578586578, -0.3416251540184021, 0.09303244203329086, -0.25887346267700195, 0.4053637683391571, 0.6018553376197815, 0.39345136284828186, 0.31531110405921936, 0.06619936227798462, 0.2780371904373169, 0.051313843578100204, 0.5214391350746155, 0.33499616384506226, 0.2107294797897339, 0.01699003577232361, 0.21024276316165924, -0.5093414783477783, 0.05419766530394554, -0.5640901327133179, -0.6528477072715759, 0.2967076599597931, 0.1419040560722351, 0.5051745176315308, -0.026452871039509773, 0.6625835299491882, -0.06802335381507874, -0.20944389700889587, -0.10221149772405624, -0.4003295302391052, -0.19332656264305115, 0.637900710105896, 0.4402388632297516, 0.48885342478752136, -1.3446009159088135, -0.08866455405950546, -0.09955023229122162, 1.1573823690414429, 0.5749483704566956, 0.17841672897338867, 0.8003904819488525, -0.570511519908905, 0.8884158730506897, -0.11015678197145462, -0.3760906457901001, -0.06160758435726166, -0.7486157417297363, -0.048955243080854416, -0.06820660829544067, -0.685044527053833, -0.15811403095722198, 0.24747997522354126, 0.2647337019443512, -0.433173805475235, -0.10325884819030762, 0.5552638173103333, -0.7961618304252625, 0.2989618480205536, 0.6789608001708984, 0.8080087304115295, 0.6678667664527893, -1.054244041442871, 0.29711151123046875, -0.14771005511283875, -0.16491162776947021, -0.12304666638374329, -0.622078001499176, 0.2903175950050354, -0.06568840146064758, 0.9375755786895752, 0.23810431361198425, -0.038487374782562256, -0.28246164321899414, 0.07296346873044968, -0.6122121214866638, 0.09622015058994293, 0.10512633621692657, -1.1181228160858154, 0.5440258979797363, 0.2981371283531189, -0.7177661657333374, 0.24146467447280884, -0.9392246603965759, 0.8267814517021179, 0.9017685651779175, -0.5936471223831177, -1.0858486890792847, -0.5195305347442627, 0.16695603728294373, -0.35096079111099243, 0.10398437082767487, 0.47211384773254395, -0.7567915320396423, 0.19692017138004303, -0.6808815002441406, 0.024424629285931587, -0.005902661941945553, -0.3008824288845062, -0.6070712208747864, -0.31901392340660095, -0.11216127872467041, 1.1078455448150635, 0.9140127897262573, 1.1739263534545898, -0.1320239007472992, 0.6868129968643188, -0.07346829771995544, 0.23571591079235077, -0.7907811999320984, -0.5608317255973816, -0.060303300619125366, 0.12078774720430374, 0.0254674069583416, -0.17119692265987396, -0.24218352138996124, 0.11530150473117828, -0.3010290265083313, 0.01015741191804409, -0.729826807975769, -0.7364393472671509, 1.4906184673309326, -0.06599505990743637, 0.12627708911895752, 1.023937463760376, -0.3575510084629059, 0.12798084318637848, 0.4427397847175598, -0.008784896694123745, -0.4962230920791626, 0.5615171194076538, 0.2919864356517792, -0.0936359167098999, 1.1850301027297974, -0.5555998086929321, 0.4762362837791443, -0.1790027916431427, -0.21087150275707245, 0.24648168683052063, 0.017455406486988068, -0.3886297345161438, -0.4602019786834717, -0.6476144194602966, -0.2735685706138611, -1.1703890562057495, 0.18836131691932678, -0.14148084819316864, -0.0945403203368187, -0.3154067397117615, 0.6152575612068176, -0.16041706502437592, -0.10535726696252823, -0.08440960198640823, -0.2527213990688324, 0.29195064306259155, 0.8726947903633118, 0.7763712406158447, -0.37209922075271606, -0.8154394626617432, -0.05301458388566971, 0.001571877277456224, -0.7954296469688416, -0.3156753480434418, -0.28776445984840393, 0.3867751955986023, -0.48433879017829895, -0.6997525095939636, -0.29547566175460815, 0.30004191398620605, 0.26133933663368225, 0.335482656955719, -0.27490922808647156, 0.1844906359910965, 0.01875924877822399, 0.3591540455818176, -0.04854806885123253, -0.29069921374320984, -0.6182869672775269, 0.10739047825336456, 0.3082837462425232, -0.4635685682296753, 0.4256211817264557, 0.10574354231357574, -0.5880656838417053, 0.2330612987279892, -1.21687650680542, -0.3312924802303314, -0.6664867997169495, -0.19617873430252075, 0.2636265456676483, -0.5648123621940613, -0.08155208826065063, 0.5610470175743103, 0.2938538193702698, 0.2667006552219391, 0.0037431472446769476, -0.055173762142658234, -0.2291388213634491, 0.142477348446846, 0.3562111258506775, -0.07863452285528183, -1.5577261447906494, 0.43057069182395935, 1.4140980243682861, -0.046595748513936996, -1.1927763223648071, -0.19644246995449066, 0.5519682765007019, 0.1416751742362976, 0.5604395866394043, -0.02910311333835125, 0.08602368086576462, -0.25160104036331177, 0.3678235113620758, -0.31233876943588257, 0.43853330612182617, -0.78669273853302, 0.26095297932624817, -0.35753217339515686, -0.039314188063144684, -0.26316818594932556, 0.258709192276001, 0.5460183620452881, -0.17717546224594116, 0.655485212802887, -0.2749326527118683, 0.17543721199035645, -0.41984254121780396, 0.014390668831765652, 0.09013106673955917, 0.7139428853988647, -0.6442579627037048, -0.5538028478622437, -1.4269769191741943, -0.4998934268951416, 0.21981967985630035, -0.3184433877468109, -0.3558197319507599, 0.5580211877822876, -0.6980352997779846, 0.6870209574699402, -0.5623313784599304, 0.9434574246406555, 0.7887995839118958, -0.6603373289108276, -0.9638678431510925, 0.16558459401130676, 0.274613618850708, -0.704316258430481, -0.17742791771888733, -0.21286945044994354, -0.3425643742084503, -0.08446765691041946, -0.002651872579008341, -0.2463623434305191, -0.09980668127536774, 0.043456871062517166, 0.20626594126224518, 0.6167212724685669, -0.1876911073923111, -0.07890943437814713, 0.5693277716636658, -0.39727169275283813, -0.616202175617218, 0.5220329761505127, 0.3981991708278656, 0.6992746591567993, 1.0130724906921387, -0.11606685072183609, -0.5678847432136536, 0.25466659665107727, 0.12522727251052856, 0.16897951066493988, -0.7397249937057495, 0.8482571244239807, 0.19450689852237701, -1.0169389247894287, 0.6845273971557617, 0.36554521322250366, -0.611729085445404, -0.04297236353158951, -0.21727333962917328, -0.46517813205718994, 0.3716922700405121, -0.11694393306970596, 0.01414589025080204, 0.8210859894752502, -0.009140672162175179, 0.7493563890457153, 0.045272499322891235, -0.3389703929424286, 0.23292116820812225, -0.5191609263420105, 0.9206812381744385, -0.41348129510879517, -0.14195798337459564, 0.521003246307373, 0.08519773930311203, -0.2303270846605301, 0.12707915902137756, -0.33248016238212585, 0.6522123217582703, 0.07630009204149246, 0.5326882004737854, -0.6764745116233826, -0.22897998988628387, 0.2802572548389435, 0.29514697194099426, 0.18536391854286194, 0.29085370898246765, 0.23083078861236572, 0.34575188159942627, -0.171259343624115, -0.42714494466781616, -0.4244290888309479, -0.21528230607509613, 0.680732011795044, -0.004417956806719303, -0.32450994849205017, 0.1936034858226776, 0.9480252861976624, -0.06738870590925217, 0.34848442673683167, -0.5509036183357239, -0.7655660510063171, -1.011945128440857, -0.592753529548645, -0.3595694899559021, -0.6589530110359192, 1.0932979583740234, 0.6265916228294373, -0.297385036945343, 0.16692961752414703, 0.02740638516843319, 0.1727745085954666, -0.34712645411491394, -0.8545353412628174, -0.3720499277114868, 0.6828623414039612, -0.6946911215782166, -0.744870662689209, -0.7069434523582458, -0.03447242081165314, -0.21632058918476105, 0.6693235635757446, -1.402174949645996, 0.1755123734474182, -0.05793077498674393, 0.524153470993042, 0.2672416865825653, 0.23368553817272186, -0.7532750368118286, -0.25658369064331055, -0.01754121296107769, 0.6737774610519409, -0.08456972241401672, 0.2857022285461426, 0.39350688457489014, -0.4308725893497467, 0.8433882594108582, 0.4860911965370178, -0.4487808048725128, -0.2635312080383301, -0.052030112594366074, 0.5385403037071228, -0.9808831810951233, -0.4586133062839508, -0.5197687745094299, 0.2881072461605072, -1.0034734010696411, -0.6547578573226929, -0.5461606383323669, 0.21839940547943115, 0.36699357628822327, 0.0017684957711026073, -0.21455161273479462, 0.7542800307273865, 0.07895112037658691, 0.27259746193885803, -0.14319173991680145, 1.0713484287261963, 0.5724478960037231, -0.2733630836009979, 0.30138853192329407, 0.08243957161903381, -0.6558709740638733, -1.0412931442260742, 0.309587299823761, 1.0682413578033447, 0.004268074873834848, -0.024669231846928596, -0.18038219213485718, 0.9613065123558044, 0.027469037100672722, -0.468558669090271, -0.7493740916252136, 1.2528706789016724, 0.6133317351341248, 0.23665688931941986, -0.10722264647483826, -0.2766868472099304, 0.0031616382766515017, -0.0796332135796547, -0.9208595156669617, -0.19477131962776184, 0.562757670879364, -0.2273339033126831, -0.5273448824882507, -0.7079426050186157, -0.5059732794761658, -0.0888889878988266, 0.05900786072015762, -0.1244526356458664, 0.15834885835647583, 0.3526194393634796, 0.2991471588611603, 0.9730249643325806, 0.45190995931625366, -0.2736601233482361, 0.37265026569366455, 0.1365262120962143, -0.4432213306427002, -0.1740577667951584, 0.05441005527973175, 0.23760339617729187, 0.39424237608909607, 0.06289468705654144, -0.40744704008102417, 0.4683794677257538, 0.004222838673740625, -0.19028860330581665, -0.5082862973213196, 0.003888395382091403, -1.3399821519851685, 0.21141859889030457, 0.3836899995803833, -0.17750521004199982, -0.5711687803268433, 0.10894541442394257, -0.40233731269836426, -0.6942994594573975, -0.5339521765708923, 0.7268859148025513, 0.37780800461769104, 0.003841905388981104, 0.4256640672683716, 0.09895512461662292, 0.554017961025238, 0.25105610489845276, -0.20544524490833282, 0.8983551859855652, 0.45987173914909363, 0.15387532114982605, 0.3402117192745209, 0.44859129190444946, 0.029381657019257545, 0.8318749666213989, -0.24780958890914917, 0.2606772780418396, 0.3001902103424072, -0.4062386751174927, -0.0008091285708360374, -0.6621471643447876, -1.1132783889770508, 0.4372027814388275, -0.8070384860038757, -0.5456784963607788, 0.056074175983667374, 0.05654704570770264, 0.07317440211772919, 0.32804960012435913, -0.8120723366737366, 0.6907656192779541, -0.5306673645973206, -0.9031811952590942, 0.2426084578037262, -0.23724378645420074, 0.9248571395874023, 0.4007505774497986, 0.3781919479370117, 0.28233787417411804, 1.3420298099517822, -0.05036190524697304, -0.5409126877784729, 0.6708338260650635, -0.3872421681880951, -0.05121308192610741, -0.34760940074920654, 0.09755397588014603, -0.12407751381397247, -0.054282285273075104, 0.27233409881591797, -0.1276526004076004, 0.07025055587291718, -0.28611329197883606, -0.7707136273384094, -0.2375834882259369, 0.783035159111023, -0.2922587990760803, -0.5447320938110352, -0.03243635594844818, 0.3742161989212036, -0.9679726362228394, -0.7013294100761414, 0.5803316831588745, 0.08513112366199493, -0.07045021653175354, -0.08964274823665619, 0.7623239159584045, 0.46751514077186584, 0.877745509147644, 0.3766903877258301, -0.2913096249103546, 0.5505943298339844, 1.1826201677322388, 0.019959988072514534, -0.18894369900226593, -0.42887255549430847, -0.04533039405941963, 0.1569015383720398, 0.1737929880619049, 0.18097585439682007, 0.5394999384880066, 0.50787752866745, -0.8688706755638123, 0.22793681919574738, -0.07901180535554886, -0.2180461436510086, -0.28221315145492554, -0.5882250070571899, 0.3304366171360016, 0.6259650588035583, -0.249312162399292, 0.501892626285553, -0.0971815213561058, 0.16353604197502136, -0.41013675928115845, 0.23301154375076294, -1.358019471168518, 0.3914578855037689, -0.9616363048553467, 0.5239006280899048, 0.004316412843763828, 0.36408284306526184, -0.3317801356315613, -1.2187659740447998, 0.05814093351364136, 0.05581033229827881, -0.23315571248531342, -0.41000938415527344, -0.3716481626033783, 0.20277522504329681, 0.12781935930252075, -0.09698605537414551, 0.1253957450389862, 0.019910123199224472, 0.6733124256134033, 0.14108040928840637, -0.22329466044902802, 0.05295998603105545, -0.10025747120380402, 0.18347519636154175, -0.0930904746055603, 0.019920986145734787, 0.14881716668605804, -0.5495314598083496, -0.8814231157302856, -0.010363785549998283, 0.2705085575580597, 0.08231637626886368, -0.34400901198387146, 0.35009339451789856, 0.7548474669456482, 0.41730251908302307, -0.4050123393535614, -0.7895300984382629, -0.6793500185012817, -0.7705685496330261, 1.2328771352767944, -0.20151184499263763, -0.21780724823474884, 0.3198094069957733, 0.29268941283226013, 0.2324884533882141, -0.8328531384468079, 4.002985000610352, 1.64765202999115, 0.8173346519470215, -0.5350289940834045, 0.7622920870780945, 0.05340169742703438, 0.34374532103538513, -0.036969758570194244, 0.35743948817253113, -0.1193220466375351, -0.10566771775484085, -0.12553155422210693, 0.16530455648899078, 0.13010117411613464, 0.08685585856437683, -0.0736815556883812, -0.6035471558570862, 0.06621629744768143, -0.3256534934043884, -0.6803185939788818, -0.3161243200302124, 0.2996087670326233, -0.02754962630569935, -0.3693158030509949, -0.3261473774909973, -0.4264206290245056, 0.9016703367233276, 0.23220574855804443, 0.27059048414230347, -0.3953765332698822, 0.7106460928916931, -0.3192584216594696, 0.2246772050857544, -1.5423723459243774, -0.5635582208633423, 0.20002342760562897, -0.3154948055744171, -0.21143122017383575, -0.06803125143051147, 0.26716965436935425, 0.20007668435573578, 0.6591349244117737, -0.7617152333259583, -0.12384921312332153, -0.44499310851097107, -0.06801383197307587, -0.6496076583862305, -0.31392109394073486, 0.6925417184829712, 0.31294938921928406, 0.9383854866027832, -0.9253889322280884, 0.15084882080554962, -0.5807636380195618, -0.17073652148246765, -0.3792324364185333, 0.05977720394730568, -1.0540688037872314, 0.14979110658168793, 0.3320169448852539, 0.7578749060630798, -0.23239517211914062, 0.22816330194473267, -0.23160754144191742, 0.20509740710258484, 0.2688407301902771, 0.24705730378627777, -0.09328354150056839, -0.18211063742637634, -0.774356484413147, -0.2887342870235443, -0.5345584750175476, -0.4091569781303406, -0.8846952319145203, 0.43736928701400757, 0.1156056597828865, -0.1618553102016449, 0.8295429348945618, -0.19165286421775818, -1.1262097358703613, -0.08292432874441147, -0.01858001947402954, -0.06363170593976974, 0.08841514587402344, 0.21398977935314178, 0.8417043685913086, -0.8723833560943604, -0.05325184762477875, -0.8190158009529114, 0.025680331513285637, 0.30873826146125793, -0.2472059279680252, 0.5495479106903076, -0.6837698221206665, 0.18498510122299194 ]
{"Title": "Potential impact of outpatient stewardship interventions on antibiotic exposures of bacterial pathogens", "Authors": "Tedijanto Christine, Grad Yonatan H, Lipsitch Marc", "Abstract": "Abstract The relationship between antibiotic stewardship and population levels of antibiotic resistance remains unclear. In order to better understand shifts in selective pressure due to stewardship, we use publicly available data to estimate the effect of changes in prescribing on exposures to frequently used antibiotics experienced by potentially pathogenic bacteria that are asymptomatically colonizing the microbiome. We quantify this impact under four hypothetical stewardship strategies. In one scenario, we estimate that elimination of all unnecessary outpatient antibiotic use could avert 6 to 48% (IQR: 17 to 31%) of exposures across pairwise combinations of sixteen common antibiotics and nine bacterial pathogens. All scenarios demonstrate that stewardship interventions, facilitated by changes in clinician behavior and improved diagnostics, have the opportunity to broadly reduce antibiotic exposures across a range of potential pathogens. Concurrent approaches, such as vaccines aiming to reduce infection incidence, are needed to further decrease exposures occurring in \u201cnecessary\u201d contexts.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008029"}
10.1101/19005207
[ 0.3011802136898041, 0.10260942578315735, 0.19199654459953308, 0.16374504566192627, -0.6152405738830566, 0.26822590827941895, -0.39356309175491333, 0.35966166853904724, -0.02988872490823269, 0.6851881742477417, 0.09439954906702042, -0.7315770983695984, 0.411705881357193, 0.9116989970207214, -0.2140389233827591, 0.09895440936088562, -0.6177798509597778, -0.5884007811546326, 0.09080056846141815, -0.29347217082977295, 0.27599018812179565, 1.147802710533142, -0.4523980915546417, -0.12628841400146484, -0.6711291074752808, 0.7617238759994507, 0.2084781676530838, -0.14199404418468475, 1.386779546737671, 0.3975726366043091, 0.36372998356819153, -0.288682222366333, 0.5012742280960083, -0.6285356879234314, -0.26876842975616455, -0.6725037693977356, 0.2065388709306717, -0.049945831298828125, -0.6555271744728088, -0.34544602036476135, 0.7558695077896118, -0.4153851568698883, 0.5668132901191711, -0.38426366448402405, -0.6863166689872742, -0.19613628089427948, -0.03516785800457001, 0.1295243501663208, -0.3502334952354431, 0.4205489158630371, 0.18515823781490326, 0.06997799128293991, 0.5316290259361267, -0.5931851863861084, -0.4379638433456421, -0.6227535605430603, -0.07050185650587082, -0.3582378327846527, -0.22766806185245514, 0.18049529194831848, -0.14290253818035126, 0.07107025384902954, 0.010132620111107826, -0.6164451241493225, 0.48616331815719604, 0.4789752960205078, 0.02930586412549019, -0.055343180894851685, 0.09938431531190872, -0.3765017092227936, -0.20362511277198792, -0.628612756729126, -0.9092779755592346, -0.47887593507766724, -0.014459674246609211, -0.47547832131385803, 0.22415781021118164, -0.47591230273246765, -0.4323474168777466, -0.3970668315887451, 0.6808920502662659, 0.02442479133605957, 0.6778603196144104, 0.45657697319984436, -0.6409358978271484, 0.5164215564727783, 0.02798764780163765, 0.5435123443603516, 0.21782821416854858, 0.49377796053886414, -0.049688100814819336, 0.1747197061777115, 0.1282014548778534, -0.38667911291122437, -0.10093510150909424, 0.7793844938278198, -0.1607450544834137, 0.03919749706983566, 0.3281724154949188, -0.37817755341529846, 0.6098210215568542, 1.0071003437042236, -0.5334530472755432, 0.5991267561912537, -0.43631473183631897, 1.0253760814666748, 0.4500208795070648, -0.2610742151737213, -0.3222053647041321, -0.7697001099586487, 0.41146954894065857, -0.4197588562965393, -0.8043981790542603, -0.46128806471824646, 0.5579478740692139, -0.26558515429496765, -0.31042203307151794, 0.9010425806045532, -0.17571695148944855, 0.2835690677165985, -0.08576125651597977, 0.4169991910457611, 0.5798109769821167, -0.4812813997268677, 0.03272742033004761, 0.005578168202191591, 0.40300247073173523, 0.022735852748155594, -1.138583779335022, -0.14051276445388794, -0.00656925467774272, -0.25702187418937683, 0.03519286960363388, 0.29679498076438904, 0.20373117923736572, 0.01868623122572899, 0.504583477973938, 0.7031447887420654, 0.9578098654747009, -0.42265933752059937, -0.15226519107818604, 0.45373016595840454, -0.5891647934913635, 1.6666589975357056, -0.2907240688800812, 0.5281854271888733, -0.3099187910556793, -0.8218719363212585, 0.6837084293365479, 0.6265358328819275, -0.2688765525817871, -0.0903390571475029, -0.6477784514427185, 0.08587321639060974, 0.2731609344482422, -0.5273646116256714, -1.0195108652114868, -0.19639399647712708, 0.025385932996869087, -0.15646246075630188, -1.5538489818572998, 0.13854604959487915, -0.3572175204753876, 0.6918361186981201, -0.7235077023506165, 0.4727817475795746, -0.8807587027549744, 0.15768739581108093, 0.14200294017791748, -0.11440760642290115, 1.0504467487335205, 0.22611136734485626, -0.05479517951607704, 0.29277169704437256, 0.1777181178331375, 1.0767544507980347, 0.6635153293609619, -0.5038813948631287, 0.44792506098747253, 0.30526646971702576, 0.09598352015018463, -0.03334374725818634, 0.9573096632957458, 0.8913623690605164, -0.08193173259496689, 1.0737063884735107, -0.42670750617980957, -0.23719897866249084, -0.29633739590644836, 0.13461004197597504, 0.06088382750749588, 0.6901351809501648, -0.16401799023151398, 0.15427380800247192, 0.6054821014404297, -0.10319538414478302, 0.3565528094768524, 0.24391679465770721, 0.0933675691485405, -0.8232988119125366, 0.14955344796180725, 0.18785297870635986, -0.10033535212278366, 0.7086769938468933, -0.5077350735664368, 0.5986906886100769, 0.24205860495567322, 0.17679886519908905, -0.7231117486953735, 0.5609099864959717, 1.1865886449813843, -0.030276762321591377, -0.6887708902359009, -0.33860883116722107, 0.5778529047966003, -0.25642257928848267, -0.3723006844520569, 0.2797716557979584, -0.4583306908607483, -0.44492027163505554, -0.2772739827632904, -0.9363089203834534, 0.4293757379055023, -0.5506634712219238, -0.031307995319366455, 0.6864271759986877, 0.44648364186286926, 1.145512342453003, -0.6560297012329102, 0.5785300731658936, -0.18553562462329865, 0.30436283349990845, 0.0075514730997383595, 0.764120876789093, 0.6143962144851685, 0.17902547121047974, 0.24928590655326843, 0.9738436937332153, 0.17263120412826538, 1.0415308475494385, 1.1415928602218628, 0.573872983455658, 0.26685214042663574, 0.16606558859348297, -0.601979672908783, 0.12469222396612167, -0.21226339042186737, -0.03794475272297859, -0.321027547121048, -0.26075899600982666, -0.7277779579162598, 0.5801323056221008, 0.05751153081655502, 0.5073584914207458, -0.8960236310958862, -0.17946217954158783, 0.3224121928215027, 0.09386595338582993, -0.9039188623428345, -0.03764741122722626, -0.26661351323127747, 0.8743019104003906, -0.5420217514038086, -0.7092468738555908, 0.8424412608146667, 0.8062062859535217, 0.44577401876449585, 0.16014601290225983, -0.02284330502152443, 0.04155035689473152, -0.6800366640090942, -0.2748229503631592, -0.8178560137748718, -0.4838203191757202, -0.31323960423469543, 0.7494204640388489, 0.04970472678542137, -0.5859391093254089, -0.7325998544692993, -0.202213853597641, -0.21305489540100098, -0.23552262783050537, -0.09747272729873657, 0.7440481781959534, 0.13925933837890625, -1.029080867767334, -0.6300379633903503, -0.9083542227745056, 0.48535090684890747, 0.17841604351997375, -0.4066295623779297, -0.0921703577041626, -0.32965967059135437, -0.835624098777771, 0.21028205752372742, 0.14430777728557587, 0.08479736745357513, 0.6738802194595337, -0.20759698748588562, -0.43182724714279175, 0.6479183435440063, -0.0685570165514946, 0.43274661898612976, -0.21545323729515076, -0.788000226020813, 0.4635469317436218, -0.1651950478553772, 0.13055886328220367, 0.484047532081604, 0.12712258100509644, -0.6999894976615906, -0.07831351459026337, -0.022457381710410118, 0.4179084897041321, -1.0583056211471558, 0.38733652234077454, 0.47130927443504333, -0.46047070622444153, 0.12507952749729156, -0.08874766528606415, -0.8698307871818542, -0.801862359046936, 0.27273011207580566, -0.658092200756073, -0.14307405054569244, 0.7217984795570374, 0.5397658944129944, -1.1697518825531006, 0.5994989275932312, -0.4633769690990448, -0.748098611831665, -0.6160217523574829, -0.1952940672636032, 0.4980340301990509, 0.6370024085044861, -0.4192146956920624, -0.465271532535553, -0.1631295531988144, -0.3443070948123932, 0.3309120535850525, 0.04784346744418144, -0.7094630599021912, 0.32750403881073, 0.4951263666152954, -0.13863155245780945, 0.1850624680519104, 0.5280393362045288, -0.5376471281051636, -0.11030995100736618, 0.03729281947016716, 0.04739696532487869, 0.6184564232826233, 0.30766215920448303, 0.022350458428263664, -0.9052075743675232, 0.660645067691803, -0.33588215708732605, 0.3278604745864868, 0.352281391620636, 0.25122132897377014, 0.3265138268470764, 0.515496015548706, -0.8643252849578857, 0.5309221148490906, -0.7301537394523621, -0.007891695946455002, -0.11494201421737671, 0.4831484854221344, 0.7586092352867126, -0.022045286372303963, 0.20669087767601013, -0.8904149532318115, -0.14663992822170258, -0.31300172209739685, -0.2861045002937317, -0.02116483822464943, 0.6162211298942566, 0.6351584792137146, 0.6518195271492004, -1.2757234573364258, -0.380029559135437, 0.21790654957294464, 0.5557991862297058, 0.4627940356731415, -0.23072512447834015, 0.7455480098724365, -0.47475379705429077, 0.5850269794464111, 0.06659114360809326, -0.4958514869213104, 0.1818411499261856, -0.08751990646123886, 0.3458489775657654, -0.11351381987333298, -0.29148218035697937, -0.4163464605808258, 0.21410369873046875, 0.5808742642402649, 0.32197847962379456, 0.34989118576049805, 0.585381805896759, -0.7975431680679321, 0.5777803063392639, 0.3211139142513275, 0.3490881621837616, 0.6150103807449341, -0.9173606038093567, -0.1066221073269844, -0.27307581901550293, -1.2937597036361694, -0.3070884346961975, -0.7135080695152283, -0.41884660720825195, -0.057728543877601624, 0.42288362979888916, 0.01960659958422184, -0.2464647889137268, -0.3346693813800812, -0.48469454050064087, -0.22974447906017303, 0.09790972620248795, -0.15299798548221588, -0.5735425353050232, 0.571559488773346, 0.42563068866729736, 0.12753640115261078, 0.1251121461391449, -1.5588887929916382, 0.8227784633636475, 1.3590511083602905, -0.3522447943687439, -1.1622204780578613, -0.1561744213104248, -0.26917529106140137, -0.6300791501998901, 0.22950433194637299, 0.3100796639919281, 0.08823990076780319, -0.26537981629371643, -0.6496598124504089, -0.5010649561882019, -0.08340050280094147, -0.31575170159339905, -0.11760540306568146, 0.18458017706871033, 0.07946735620498657, 0.8423723578453064, 0.6160814762115479, 0.1165120005607605, -0.23939286172389984, 0.8914305567741394, -0.6541345715522766, 0.17983759939670563, -0.9015936851501465, -0.13728299736976624, -0.13846497237682343, -0.001952151651494205, 0.2992839515209198, -0.1782417744398117, -0.09239661693572998, -0.23186473548412323, -0.22986680269241333, 0.33631882071495056, -0.8958589434623718, -0.3578587472438812, 0.9168312549591064, -0.5407022833824158, -0.4099397361278534, 0.5237581133842468, -0.6354392170906067, -0.20771579444408417, 0.3072704076766968, 0.0068002380430698395, 0.00355716235935688, 0.10560805350542068, 0.20633742213249207, 0.39457133412361145, 0.9117088913917542, -0.43816614151000977, -0.16647253930568695, -0.5654594302177429, -0.045380011200904846, -0.11720234900712967, -0.440889835357666, -0.3275034725666046, -0.6530891060829163, -0.4801524579524994, -0.30366504192352295, -0.5920472145080566, 0.9484226703643799, 0.13605627417564392, 0.4391617774963379, -0.4821714162826538, 0.24262705445289612, -0.19288264214992523, -0.28605329990386963, 0.14186914265155792, 0.34435319900512695, 0.2857261896133423, 0.8998566269874573, 0.5393177270889282, -0.7239620089530945, -0.8424026370048523, 0.047605711966753006, 0.8559415340423584, -0.49674704670906067, -0.17704671621322632, 0.5288509726524353, -1.091652512550354, -0.43058788776397705, -0.5422696471214294, 0.8709198236465454, -0.6412832140922546, 0.28253790736198425, 0.32009005546569824, -0.2622486352920532, 0.39198043942451477, -0.5194730162620544, -0.24615712463855743, 0.011285418644547462, -0.2256305068731308, -0.6824546456336975, 0.49510127305984497, 0.27128341794013977, -0.2120601385831833, 0.6048871278762817, -0.17354841530323029, -1.2217003107070923, -0.7445309162139893, -1.3821009397506714, 0.5646199584007263, -0.3889259397983551, 0.356284499168396, 0.003541687736287713, -0.054157327860593796, 0.009821033105254173, 0.41418975591659546, -0.05362565815448761, 0.6776580810546875, 0.15713906288146973, -0.5936046242713928, 0.9212644696235657, -0.027907392010092735, 0.4886544346809387, 0.1631312072277069, -1.16860830783844, 0.18569007515907288, 0.42599332332611084, -0.2539106011390686, -0.6562990546226501, -0.3832390606403351, 0.5741108655929565, 0.7159508466720581, -0.027792219072580338, -0.1978774070739746, 0.1513306200504303, 0.21270756423473358, 0.22251634299755096, -0.8299678564071655, -0.776343047618866, -1.0948001146316528, 0.5740364789962769, 0.01674940250813961, 0.6780384182929993, -0.14080284535884857, 0.040909506380558014, -0.09172865748405457, -0.6524929404258728, 0.8760548830032349, -0.3636036217212677, 0.3383665382862091, -0.2853635847568512, 0.14615419507026672, 0.379043847322464, 0.5203841328620911, -0.6093297600746155, -0.18940240144729614, -0.5033032298088074, -0.9681936502456665, 0.881264328956604, -0.10750259459018707, -0.036655619740486145, -0.4754873216152191, -0.3568796217441559, -0.33173856139183044, -0.12044961750507355, 0.03400133550167084, 0.9952784180641174, -1.0430690050125122, -0.3099518120288849, 0.3693346679210663, 1.2874592542648315, -0.47528207302093506, 0.4780992865562439, 0.1512632519006729, 0.08277997374534607, -0.30676475167274475, 0.5035568475723267, -1.252993106842041, -0.7460015416145325, 0.4134191870689392, 0.33569908142089844, 0.7168925404548645, 0.20469437539577484, 0.14430756866931915, 0.08731719851493835, -0.5527264475822449, 0.3031519949436188, 0.2666701674461365, 0.5286378264427185, 0.08661266416311264, 0.5547078251838684, 0.9363976120948792, -0.6006738543510437, 0.13799162209033966, -0.10347899049520493, -0.5003660917282104, 0.13972215354442596, 0.7640637755393982, 0.600872278213501, -1.2440946102142334, 0.5321463346481323, 0.10279908031225204, -0.622861385345459, -0.19151656329631805, -0.03420000895857811, -0.6230042576789856, 0.7020081877708435, 0.39313244819641113, -0.10198132693767548, 0.27787870168685913, -0.3950466215610504, 0.7331463098526001, 0.30997294187545776, 0.4698014259338379, 0.22888681292533875, -0.4323022961616516, 0.22285740077495575, 0.040556758642196655, 0.06322603672742844, 0.5594766736030579, -0.3622899651527405, 0.41570359468460083, 0.7621701955795288, 0.0671052411198616, 0.3257262408733368, -0.15741896629333496, 0.5825508832931519, -0.7014049291610718, -0.5755680203437805, 0.17218497395515442, -0.11124000698328018, 0.5224571824073792, 0.7071055769920349, -0.09910168498754501, 0.2642035186290741, -0.7546181082725525, -0.6431447267532349, -0.027712229639291763, 0.44818684458732605, -0.1635858714580536, -0.0613926500082016, -0.17298711836338043, 0.4889301061630249, 0.5227878093719482, -0.4078967869281769, 0.3325321674346924, -0.990573525428772, -0.3417103588581085, -0.9526594877243042, -1.1162323951721191, -0.7402644157409668, -0.46031105518341064, 0.6681100726127625, 0.9552850127220154, -0.6569148302078247, -0.4727141261100769, -0.2644294798374176, 0.754148542881012, -0.04351860284805298, -0.16704069077968597, -0.03793003410100937, 0.029667969793081284, -0.853618323802948, -0.0728595182299614, -0.311801552772522, -0.47203224897384644, -0.24582217633724213, 1.2646219730377197, -0.6538876891136169, 0.35744237899780273, -0.419178307056427, -0.16942442953586578, -0.01586565561592579, 0.9070672988891602, -0.35721948742866516, -1.0468264818191528, -0.33876773715019226, 0.4435630440711975, 0.019779393449425697, -0.6409779191017151, 0.7440803050994873, -0.42435479164123535, -0.014734289608895779, 0.6997681856155396, 0.018145408481359482, -0.2509288191795349, -0.24386273324489594, 0.6448574662208557, -0.23083439469337463, 0.08736302703619003, -0.18732495605945587, 0.28378239274024963, -0.8439882397651672, -0.19977998733520508, -0.8299983143806458, -0.7163969278335571, 0.104361392557621, -0.4427434802055359, -0.3681890070438385, 0.35812512040138245, 0.36563947796821594, 0.27038338780403137, 0.7364955544471741, 1.3645401000976562, 0.7093610167503357, -0.1432277113199234, 0.9522206783294678, -0.20296193659305573, -0.0968705341219902, -0.9870489835739136, 0.2602127194404602, 0.3840337097644806, -0.12257176637649536, 0.4798324704170227, 0.2933238446712494, 0.22836938500404358, 0.4261366128921509, -0.6834828853607178, -0.393420547246933, 0.26086434721946716, -0.10499231517314911, 0.5101022124290466, -0.020810194313526154, -0.27555593848228455, 0.09420107305049896, -0.6357239484786987, -1.086665391921997, -0.3936067521572113, 0.0837344154715538, -0.8473827838897705, -0.676682710647583, 0.030303508043289185, -0.6808546185493469, 0.14618970453739166, 0.18845973908901215, 0.07189873605966568, 0.03209105506539345, 0.6089789867401123, -0.022682074457406998, 0.8333364129066467, 0.061650022864341736, 0.23364898562431335, -0.575299084186554, 0.2673644721508026, -0.5597974061965942, -0.17039190232753754, -0.12877927720546722, 0.548150360584259, -0.059552714228630066, 0.22380731999874115, -1.3070833683013916, 0.33206191658973694, -0.06397168338298798, -0.8214786648750305, -0.3076923191547394, 0.35015416145324707, -1.0464166402816772, 0.2386201024055481, 0.03797788545489311, -0.006705255713313818, -0.05223790556192398, 0.2627257704734802, 0.44855666160583496, -1.0452001094818115, -0.6384426951408386, 0.5976918339729309, -0.02052704617381096, 0.0315743088722229, 0.09338658303022385, 0.3668587803840637, 0.3021816611289978, -0.1715618222951889, -0.077647864818573, 0.6644461750984192, 0.619459331035614, -0.16622771322727203, 0.00799577683210373, 0.6522550582885742, -0.3472196161746979, 0.5210111141204834, 0.295045405626297, -0.3370930850505829, -0.19312351942062378, -0.1439521610736847, -0.32816824316978455, -0.13028304278850555, -0.6352033019065857, 0.8349013924598694, -0.6187035441398621, -0.878284215927124, 0.3712993562221527, -0.041529588401317596, 0.7688438892364502, 0.3222059905529022, -0.42628002166748047, 0.3786032795906067, -0.6360713243484497, 0.12681056559085846, -0.03689271956682205, 0.40832364559173584, 0.7618270516395569, 0.09017008543014526, -0.10502173006534576, 0.07341504842042923, 1.0562553405761719, 0.24219220876693726, -0.48547232151031494, 0.2176266610622406, -0.6129915714263916, 0.347039133310318, 0.19478349387645721, 0.8752952218055725, -0.1152210682630539, -0.10309743881225586, -0.04559286683797836, -0.3232540488243103, -0.2549566924571991, 0.12702517211437225, -0.4091923236846924, 0.3270042836666107, 1.0846205949783325, -0.6832259297370911, -0.5875976085662842, 0.41304054856300354, 0.4580310881137848, -0.7541525363922119, -0.020787982270121574, 1.3394343852996826, -0.47062698006629944, 0.04144850745797157, 0.18658824265003204, 0.3682238757610321, 0.5408447980880737, 0.13379505276679993, 1.061107873916626, -0.14717552065849304, -0.20464009046554565, 0.7911352515220642, -0.07338756322860718, -0.277787446975708, -0.4866906702518463, -0.10527493059635162, 0.010000287555158138, -0.289950430393219, -0.1274707317352295, 0.29693603515625, -0.3693137466907501, -0.6134154796600342, -0.2257348895072937, 0.08633062243461609, -0.23333577811717987, -0.4015364348888397, -0.6295053362846375, -0.10476245731115341, -0.19279946386814117, -0.043422043323516846, 0.6206022500991821, 0.09802018851041794, 0.1525956243276596, -0.4636889398097992, -0.39088207483291626, -0.6655307412147522, -0.35963478684425354, -1.2164112329483032, -0.3592785596847534, -0.05376429110765457, -0.07811227440834045, -0.28219249844551086, -1.3471922874450684, -0.4805275797843933, -0.060795482248067856, -0.20825091004371643, -0.8104822039604187, 0.25107133388519287, 0.21076257526874542, 0.4395354390144348, 0.25280728936195374, 0.2192283570766449, -0.51715487241745, 0.041633836925029755, 0.5054163336753845, -0.7083629369735718, 0.6751430034637451, -0.3187870681285858, -0.18045274913311005, -0.35869109630584717, 0.11263931542634964, 0.5421585440635681, 0.12914524972438812, -0.6976737976074219, -0.3119881749153137, 0.24729786813259125, -0.32283535599708557, -0.5865421891212463, -0.3582513928413391, 0.7172455787658691, -0.4301503002643585, -0.35204973816871643, -0.1580338031053543, -0.5052080750465393, -0.9835612177848816, 0.6518529653549194, -0.053048741072416306, -0.18189118802547455, 0.30684393644332886, -0.3966982662677765, 0.056521620601415634, -0.6387573480606079, 4.058506011962891, 0.9284863471984863, 0.9098283052444458, -0.2929771840572357, 1.0680320262908936, 0.7814733982086182, 0.6171145439147949, 0.18839173018932343, 0.812330961227417, -0.38285931944847107, 0.09329625964164734, 0.03970427066087723, 0.041213348507881165, -0.4843500256538391, 0.6990737915039062, 0.14564022421836853, -0.6693989038467407, -0.2631828784942627, 0.08202556520700455, -0.4437033534049988, -0.4776665270328522, 0.0036430279724299908, -0.105996273458004, 0.2258521020412445, 0.2186369001865387, 0.28305336833000183, 0.6168137192726135, -0.18581344187259674, 0.13430871069431305, -0.5305265188217163, 0.24733476340770721, -0.22561581432819366, 0.5639032125473022, -0.8979343175888062, -0.8054319620132446, 0.19357675313949585, -0.051166776567697525, -0.12792550027370453, 0.35673028230667114, -0.6877108216285706, 0.08488240092992783, 0.5227600932121277, -0.05627503618597984, -0.5695398449897766, 0.03891859948635101, 0.48014262318611145, -0.033307913690805435, 0.4533744156360626, 1.1200315952301025, -0.3880118131637573, 0.6238470673561096, -0.9018759727478027, 0.37889987230300903, 0.40147125720977783, -1.0982954502105713, 0.23217494785785675, 0.5599233508110046, -1.2987080812454224, 0.9020630121231079, 0.6389646530151367, 0.8127771019935608, -0.1016131266951561, 0.09559116512537003, -0.2956511378288269, 0.7365476489067078, -0.13852070271968842, -0.11220467835664749, -0.16933201253414154, -0.1146567314863205, -0.9087664484977722, -0.07749363780021667, -0.3021591603755951, 0.972416341304779, -1.119744896888733, 0.29862117767333984, 0.32341164350509644, -0.09207740426063538, 0.5537241101264954, -0.6211503148078918, -0.9176283478736877, -0.26124316453933716, -0.49036088585853577, 0.8901728987693787, -0.12988778948783875, 0.8248549699783325, 1.4277323484420776, -0.22394154965877533, -0.6055297255516052, -0.2888214588165283, 0.5733723640441895, 0.2338630110025406, -0.291774719953537, -0.023509284481406212, 0.200574591755867, 0.4455636739730835 ]
{"Title": "The Impact of Pre-exposure Prophylaxis for Human Immunodeficiency Virus on Gonorrhea Prevalence", "Authors": "Pharaon Joe, Bauch Chris T.", "Abstract": "Abstract Pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) has been shown to be highly effective in reducing the risk of HIV infection in gay and bisexual men who have sex with men (GbMSM). However, PrEP does not protect against other sexually transmitted infections (STIs). In some populations, PrEP has also led to riskier behaviour such as reduced condom usage, with the result that the prevalence of bacterial STIs like gonorrhea has increased. Here we develop a compartmental model of the transmission of HIV and gonorrhea, and the impacts of PrEP, condom usage, STI testing frequency and potential changes in sexual risk behaviour stemming from the introduction of PrEP in a population of GbMSM. We find that introducing PrEP causes an increase in gonorrhea prevalence for a wide range of parameter values, including at the current recommended frequency of STI testing once every 3 months for individuals on PrEP. Moreover, the model predicts that a higher STI testing frequency alone is not enough to prevent a rise in gonorrhea prevalence, unless the testing frequency is increased to impractical levels. However, testing every 2 months in combination with sufficiently high condom usage by individuals on PrEP would be successful in maintaining gonorrhea prevalence at pre-PrEP levels. The results emphasize that programs making PrEP more available should be accompanied by efforts to support condom usage and frequent STI testing, in order to avoid an increase in the prevalence of gonorrhea and other bacterial STIs.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005207"}
10.1101/19004523
[ -0.11372041702270508, -0.011190583929419518, -0.25987428426742554, 0.21510906517505646, -0.7054329514503479, -0.6416749358177185, 0.5512300729751587, 0.4823239743709564, -0.04235992580652237, 0.34759944677352905, -0.2091936469078064, -1.0313156843185425, 0.6698341965675354, -0.13315773010253906, 0.10565976798534393, -0.7314028739929199, -0.35509786009788513, -0.23601046204566956, 0.21300345659255981, 0.029258567839860916, 0.5209949016571045, 0.6837032437324524, -0.5563710927963257, 0.2890569567680359, -0.5976794362068176, 0.3250799775123596, -0.3330809772014618, -0.3803475797176361, 0.961649477481842, 0.633646547794342, -0.46118971705436707, -0.23536548018455505, 0.6640360355377197, -0.7158535718917847, -0.09374431520700455, -0.23790553212165833, 0.2215559333562851, -0.5911010503768921, 0.035301703959703445, -0.6731075644493103, 0.8139836192131042, -0.4447060823440552, -0.16959966719150543, -0.3407854735851288, -0.22071997821331024, -0.30334872007369995, -0.41569164395332336, -0.4207524061203003, -0.30272260308265686, 0.7325703501701355, 0.131496399641037, 0.22331039607524872, -0.32182151079177856, 0.3767131268978119, -0.4030304551124573, 0.4055427014827728, -0.28014275431632996, 0.19560657441616058, -0.7099140286445618, 0.6784485578536987, 0.1566946804523468, 0.7224730253219604, 0.4084450602531433, -1.3431730270385742, 0.7121279835700989, 1.0278666019439697, -0.3091089427471161, -0.46458515524864197, -1.0066356658935547, 0.003923704847693443, -0.20376944541931152, -0.7402576208114624, -0.4649618864059448, -1.0459399223327637, -0.24578966200351715, -0.2256356179714203, -0.2862936854362488, -0.4556257724761963, 0.09827174246311188, -0.5239079594612122, 0.18900975584983826, 0.2934134304523468, 0.018319709226489067, 0.6997488737106323, -0.5548110008239746, 0.6102696061134338, 0.4566440284252167, 0.6567806601524353, 0.2170509248971939, 0.15487666428089142, 0.04754484444856644, 0.4956889748573303, -0.7765101194381714, 0.04315738379955292, 0.27729150652885437, 1.061381459236145, -0.8503314256668091, 0.24405188858509064, 0.08025708049535751, -0.4593977630138397, 0.919952929019928, -0.02970436029136181, -0.20867705345153809, 0.7496167421340942, -0.6904857754707336, 0.9367870092391968, 0.17133453488349915, -0.48417118191719055, -0.1674877554178238, -0.5158233046531677, 0.6320456862449646, -0.6018899083137512, 0.0605081208050251, -0.26081401109695435, 0.1654990315437317, 0.8924804329872131, -0.2310875654220581, 0.5540260672569275, -0.38225775957107544, 0.2007373571395874, -0.36375564336776733, -0.08796016871929169, -0.022394195199012756, -0.24110530316829681, 0.16552439332008362, -0.13484321534633636, 0.5532781481742859, 0.23021924495697021, -0.7981529831886292, -0.3604539632797241, -0.05787450447678566, -0.6737615466117859, 0.36905020475387573, 0.05026686191558838, -0.8601646423339844, 0.03785672411322594, -0.19320452213287354, 1.1317272186279297, -0.1222483217716217, -0.23311282694339752, -0.06509730964899063, 0.7825148105621338, -0.4571223258972168, 1.1236780881881714, 0.18386897444725037, 0.7938265800476074, -0.7482799291610718, -1.1215063333511353, -0.8002811074256897, 0.03178631514310837, 0.5002649426460266, 0.8956795334815979, -0.38696664571762085, 0.07168139517307281, -0.32713639736175537, 0.19534270465373993, 0.3382941782474518, 0.19875755906105042, 0.07105469703674316, -0.014276660978794098, -0.3114687204360962, 0.6025972962379456, -0.6445140838623047, 1.1559981107711792, -0.7201792001724243, 0.553550124168396, -0.8506251573562622, -0.1410532295703888, 0.8330137729644775, -1.0645122528076172, -0.1144365593791008, 0.3081915080547333, 0.18029503524303436, -0.5295832753181458, 0.30278152227401733, 1.1007204055786133, 1.1013411283493042, -0.5691529512405396, 0.34718236327171326, 0.22725549340248108, -0.3376477062702179, 0.0717553049325943, 0.34182223677635193, 1.3563990592956543, -0.6452518701553345, -0.12287090718746185, -0.8531668186187744, -0.6931760907173157, -0.3655254542827606, -0.273772656917572, -0.17230507731437683, 0.15869376063346863, -0.21234962344169617, 0.7605275511741638, 0.7107135057449341, 0.3470551073551178, 0.08847938477993011, 0.9398966431617737, 0.34920191764831543, -0.719012975692749, -0.4446527361869812, 0.8311359882354736, 0.22461771965026855, 0.22133520245552063, 0.5592532753944397, 0.3476479947566986, -0.02966897189617157, 0.29559263586997986, -0.6397503614425659, 0.5724373459815979, 0.4673779308795929, -0.36359187960624695, 0.4393768310546875, -0.6200113296508789, 0.6372116208076477, -0.34629884362220764, -0.16411449015140533, 0.19535574316978455, -0.47091591358184814, 0.24131479859352112, -0.3608335554599762, -0.4408489167690277, 0.25140100717544556, 0.031014585867524147, 0.17550858855247498, 0.0567607507109642, -0.08805263787508011, 0.08161567151546478, -0.13345219194889069, -0.05360924452543259, -0.3324235677719116, 1.158585548400879, 0.9536544680595398, 0.6782738566398621, 0.431851327419281, 1.0240747928619385, 0.09507162868976593, -0.1212838739156723, 0.5534127354621887, 0.31247642636299133, 0.5198164582252502, 0.4147759974002838, 0.7124702334403992, -0.17463721334934235, 0.13694405555725098, 1.2634000778198242, -0.3482080399990082, 0.5361900329589844, 0.10685540735721588, 0.4775182902812958, -0.0732211098074913, 0.7550287842750549, 0.05329093337059021, 0.5498533844947815, -1.348711609840393, 0.5381044149398804, 0.643841028213501, 0.02098628133535385, 0.4090080261230469, -0.4444270730018616, -0.3579238951206207, 0.5560187101364136, 0.523958146572113, 0.1879446804523468, 0.8845797181129456, 0.6484687924385071, -0.2532481551170349, 0.954744279384613, 0.6894538402557373, 0.13011913001537323, -1.1772183179855347, -0.4545479714870453, -1.6819756031036377, -0.8912888169288635, -1.0209167003631592, 0.29666808247566223, -0.13789837062358856, -0.40560489892959595, -0.28866928815841675, -0.2629449665546417, 0.46715787053108215, -0.4320598840713501, 0.364867627620697, 0.002460378222167492, 0.7065075039863586, 0.08585508912801743, -0.3565649092197418, -0.1370205283164978, -0.8303929567337036, 0.4883047342300415, -0.2523616850376129, -0.48588207364082336, -0.5810001492500305, -0.3165622651576996, 0.41746875643730164, -0.5415948033332825, -0.40836766362190247, 0.13605032861232758, -0.005787407048046589, -0.42687344551086426, 0.6614007949829102, -0.28502705693244934, 0.6183387637138367, 0.29968544840812683, -0.9143591523170471, 0.41015154123306274, 0.3618309199810028, 0.12688131630420685, 0.6351824402809143, 0.006923046428710222, -0.027234897017478943, 0.11376847326755524, 0.07906768471002579, 0.007255677133798599, -0.43265724182128906, -0.046644601970911026, 1.0542476177215576, -0.14297355711460114, -0.10444428771734238, -0.4084274172782898, -0.9316213726997375, -0.4320935904979706, 0.309365838766098, -0.022477904334664345, -0.051506828516721725, -0.13219769299030304, -0.3983718752861023, -1.3841568231582642, -0.07929380238056183, -0.6077030897140503, -1.671603798866272, -0.17317093908786774, 0.030210964381694794, 0.7714284062385559, 0.687017023563385, 0.2432829588651657, 0.09274966269731522, 0.5816977024078369, 0.5223850607872009, 0.02672111801803112, 0.5756351947784424, -0.15212948620319366, -0.31194519996643066, 0.8262708187103271, -0.19585838913917542, 0.7296772599220276, -0.5098916292190552, -0.36561664938926697, -0.10452694445848465, -0.5627920031547546, 0.22941158711910248, 0.6735779643058777, 0.9214300513267517, -0.19183675944805145, 0.541297972202301, 1.0443228483200073, -0.10244612395763397, 0.30510973930358887, 0.03158674016594887, 0.3101365268230438, -0.2703027129173279, -0.012400418519973755, 0.07952450960874557, 0.12352067232131958, -1.151727318763733, -0.14333900809288025, 0.0782165601849556, -0.37880367040634155, 0.6207826137542725, -0.7696619033813477, 0.7780340909957886, -0.18829643726348877, -0.5835453867912292, 0.35525259375572205, -0.13652236759662628, 0.0005065560108050704, 1.3712444305419922, 0.5767821669578552, 1.58500337600708, -1.2551108598709106, 0.5334774851799011, -0.4489365518093109, 0.201590895652771, -0.11094523966312408, -0.5078980922698975, 0.5383227467536926, -0.323397696018219, 0.2715919017791748, 0.39157843589782715, -0.4086676836013794, -0.25097253918647766, 0.006046508438885212, 0.01981367915868759, 0.19471938908100128, -0.9329940676689148, -0.08403471112251282, -0.41068440675735474, -0.14593040943145752, 0.7138898372650146, 0.1733393371105194, 0.04710700735449791, 0.16653212904930115, -0.16100913286209106, -0.41302490234375, 0.1297176480293274, 0.37303856015205383, -0.40173155069351196, -0.04962708055973053, 0.18868675827980042, -0.8146330118179321, -0.017909707501530647, -0.005242779850959778, -0.19921766221523285, -0.309049516916275, 0.6552139520645142, -0.2899714708328247, -0.23725029826164246, -0.7245246767997742, 0.0687573179602623, 0.5231618285179138, -0.04752860963344574, 0.0271624606102705, -0.754442572593689, 0.6840442419052124, 0.412363201379776, -0.0475696437060833, 0.14407120645046234, -0.5836085081100464, 0.21020828187465668, 0.9566453695297241, -0.3627457618713379, -1.3753594160079956, -0.330791711807251, 0.19244392216205597, -0.6824939846992493, 0.4119369089603424, 0.2737245261669159, -0.6623444557189941, -0.17615939676761627, -0.19258025288581848, -0.2729259431362152, 0.33086302876472473, -0.31072890758514404, 0.42164912819862366, -0.3467184007167816, 0.34334760904312134, 0.44268080592155457, 0.6091645359992981, 0.44430530071258545, 0.13569414615631104, 0.20848599076271057, -1.132190465927124, 0.6807128190994263, -0.8621156811714172, -0.14917756617069244, 0.2845109701156616, 0.4009529948234558, 0.1873307079076767, -0.03923165053129196, -0.5968862771987915, -0.33023130893707275, 0.37661316990852356, -0.3393198847770691, -0.1612827330827713, -0.4958264231681824, 0.9545769095420837, -0.7724329233169556, -0.37734249234199524, 0.9031049609184265, -0.38419514894485474, -0.08513084053993225, 0.28871843218803406, 0.1889556646347046, -1.2146100997924805, 0.5512304306030273, -0.3554982542991638, -0.17458020150661469, -0.09785395860671997, -0.27739158272743225, 0.029835831373929977, 0.4484194815158844, 0.1824004203081131, -0.5289507508277893, -0.7356284260749817, -1.2445448637008667, -0.40799087285995483, -0.23807880282402039, 0.13207699358463287, -0.6900086402893066, 0.5534154772758484, -0.21631671488285065, -0.751941978931427, -0.2736000418663025, -0.02886076457798481, -0.39642611145973206, -0.512130856513977, -0.4042046368122101, 0.441484659910202, 0.1691652536392212, -0.6434726119041443, 0.6161831021308899, -0.4617444574832916, -0.47193947434425354, 0.3023786246776581, 0.5385732650756836, -0.41866162419319153, -0.2313510626554489, 0.31835606694221497, 0.3972190320491791, -0.30559372901916504, -0.039473921060562134, -0.03398317098617554, -0.6820975542068481, -0.35350552201271057, 0.22997848689556122, -0.34238332509994507, 0.15985026955604553, 0.3530140519142151, -0.459574818611145, 0.9386476874351501, -0.2378082424402237, -0.5313343405723572, -0.41905903816223145, 0.4031030535697937, 0.004428589716553688, 0.7878025770187378, -0.3188348114490509, -0.8379240036010742, -0.42057347297668457, -1.19427490234375, -0.1780671626329422, -0.718047559261322, 0.15591119229793549, -0.6532638669013977, 0.04162285849452019, -0.5559068918228149, 1.2948448657989502, -0.14593251049518585, 0.30601826310157776, -0.12763534486293793, -0.5867295265197754, 0.2221067249774933, -0.42370736598968506, -0.18878285586833954, -0.48525309562683105, -0.5856050252914429, 0.48714473843574524, 0.8339770436286926, 0.06671059876680374, -0.3941870927810669, 0.7029751539230347, 0.6310995817184448, -0.016999587416648865, 0.36674633622169495, -0.2407107651233673, -0.04031313210725784, 0.03290494903922081, 0.5177546739578247, -0.37413015961647034, 0.12269813567399979, -0.7821469902992249, 0.5876017808914185, -0.38985475897789, 0.6812607049942017, 0.04515758529305458, 0.07006023079156876, 0.33499306440353394, 0.18324343860149384, 1.3957771062850952, -0.47620683908462524, -0.15712293982505798, -0.4162973165512085, 0.037845611572265625, 0.15159733593463898, 0.5276240110397339, -0.5270816087722778, -0.04104544222354889, -1.3174071311950684, -0.7740685939788818, 0.3758591413497925, 0.05900527536869049, -0.2231365591287613, -0.4232241213321686, -0.8042075634002686, -0.12497372925281525, -0.26264241337776184, 1.1881904602050781, 0.8866195678710938, -0.13729706406593323, -0.705263078212738, 0.19066083431243896, 0.41521093249320984, 0.9144369959831238, 0.21710124611854553, 0.6988115310668945, -0.5214236378669739, -0.4010583162307739, -0.5313597917556763, -0.668865978717804, -0.7644165754318237, -0.3706199526786804, 0.29559531807899475, 0.3159558176994324, -0.9997859597206116, 0.2966564893722534, 0.009586733765900135, -0.19779182970523834, -0.6430419087409973, 0.4879591464996338, -0.24267418682575226, 0.875098705291748, 1.1742841005325317, -0.1044403687119484, -0.5507388114929199, 0.4702352285385132, 0.4828905761241913, -0.3840991258621216, -0.3305419683456421, 0.2580094039440155, 0.6941798329353333, -0.6769354939460754, 0.3501027524471283, 0.1234397366642952, -1.4579079151153564, 0.05772482976317406, 0.07195073366165161, -0.2797572612762451, 0.46536538004875183, -0.1496700495481491, -0.125957652926445, 0.7326058149337769, -0.07651892304420471, 0.46720293164253235, 0.04460710659623146, -0.5007284283638, 0.01823793165385723, -0.2799266576766968, 0.6860742568969727, -0.7103483080863953, -0.44628167152404785, 0.4458601772785187, -0.4938296377658844, -0.15701234340667725, 1.070641279220581, 0.6772950291633606, 0.4479845464229584, 0.3065488934516907, 0.756102979183197, -0.798974335193634, -0.6713414788246155, -0.2584238648414612, 0.25367429852485657, 0.09744585305452347, -0.35318002104759216, -0.5219314098358154, 0.5573626160621643, 0.21763522922992706, 0.03969501331448555, -1.2012461423873901, 0.06386703997850418, 0.5499527454376221, 0.49358856678009033, -0.27277082204818726, -0.42780086398124695, 0.4445922374725342, 0.23977147042751312, -0.4672180712223053, 0.11943712830543518, -0.738351583480835, -1.2174198627471924, -0.6196325421333313, -0.26198437809944153, -0.6116043329238892, -0.14839361608028412, 0.5636526346206665, -0.2748847007751465, -0.5185027122497559, -0.3702952265739441, 0.5881114602088928, -0.6102524995803833, 0.33930012583732605, -0.7449231147766113, 0.8565900325775146, -0.7643553614616394, -0.928116500377655, -0.278669148683548, -0.4867912232875824, -0.375398188829422, 0.8140286207199097, -1.0045111179351807, -0.31415361166000366, -0.32494068145751953, 0.27512454986572266, -0.24482381343841553, 0.9331537485122681, -0.7757988572120667, -0.27491793036460876, -0.668624758720398, 1.0323991775512695, 0.44871118664741516, 0.15078015625476837, 0.8342674374580383, 0.3882695734500885, -0.1689523607492447, 0.4660065174102783, -0.03753328695893288, -0.5316581726074219, 0.649909257888794, 0.6463783383369446, -0.6336494088172913, -0.48198646306991577, 0.3770160973072052, 0.2375069409608841, -1.1481727361679077, 0.2392120212316513, -0.6112598180770874, -0.15674233436584473, 0.10651465505361557, 0.3201885223388672, 0.15879923105239868, 0.6914900541305542, 0.34077319502830505, 0.2201678603887558, 0.16639575362205505, 0.7211806774139404, 0.33018866181373596, -0.7542857527732849, 0.23376671969890594, 0.46408358216285706, 0.8349263072013855, -1.0258913040161133, 0.22644568979740143, 0.6407746076583862, -0.6309080123901367, 0.42457032203674316, -0.18238139152526855, -0.08844362944364548, 0.14427383244037628, -0.22962376475334167, 0.049776531755924225, 1.1209851503372192, 0.23760420083999634, 0.42739585041999817, 0.47371870279312134, -0.5185682773590088, -0.6526588797569275, -0.6188473701477051, -1.583785057067871, -0.5164485573768616, 0.6494840979576111, -0.6581940650939941, -0.48314040899276733, -0.6529826521873474, -0.2715968191623688, 0.45492807030677795, -0.30967941880226135, 0.613041341304779, 0.3048141300678253, 0.3192996084690094, -0.3402446508407593, 1.0827667713165283, -0.18671636283397675, -0.2909146249294281, 0.03760526329278946, -0.3695143461227417, -0.6551312804222107, -0.5922685265541077, 0.26446616649627686, 0.4874248206615448, 0.40414923429489136, -1.0095747709274292, -0.24928204715251923, 0.29081618785858154, 0.4342128336429596, -0.039485055953264236, 0.20009829103946686, 0.7131097912788391, -0.6707675457000732, 0.0826859325170517, 0.021293889731168747, 0.3020549416542053, -0.6136508584022522, -0.024564754217863083, 0.14948320388793945, -1.1948158740997314, -0.11297107487916946, 0.5934752821922302, 1.074027419090271, 0.2069268524646759, 0.8526248335838318, -0.8100423216819763, 0.6637774705886841, -0.3678933382034302, -0.3428416848182678, 0.2061140388250351, 0.8460816740989685, 0.13564957678318024, -0.49010545015335083, 0.041891586035490036, -0.23714841902256012, 1.3547033071517944, 0.6305623054504395, 0.6894505023956299, 0.22056341171264648, 0.11956428736448288, 0.4898117184638977, 0.3372595012187958, -0.816260039806366, 0.5178859233856201, 0.4847954213619232, -0.061981137841939926, 0.1671019047498703, -0.1574110984802246, 0.9990581274032593, 0.01890472322702408, -0.752044677734375, -0.1352291703224182, -0.7959662079811096, -0.0211076308041811, 0.14708420634269714, 0.25546953082084656, 0.8927541375160217, 0.4806140661239624, 0.7226964831352234, 0.4866466224193573, 0.8041929602622986, -0.18111562728881836, 0.05403284728527069, 0.7174062728881836, -0.5858327746391296, -0.8885980248451233, -0.48627516627311707, 0.6033798456192017, 0.1226859986782074, -0.4032672643661499, 0.6503891944885254, -0.3191676139831543, 0.21871350705623627, 0.48385244607925415, -0.3962736129760742, -0.30430370569229126, 1.2441962957382202, 0.03990869224071503, -0.43791043758392334, -0.23881833255290985, 0.059318892657756805, -0.5251514315605164, -0.3992491066455841, 0.4572111964225769, -0.5860060453414917, 0.01079681795090437, -0.3285151720046997, -0.13215912878513336, 0.7611910700798035, 0.4691042900085449, 0.8217480182647705, -0.5787985920906067, 0.3588200509548187, 0.9793931245803833, 0.010576466098427773, 0.01227540522813797, -0.4706149697303772, -0.09545789659023285, 0.6989541053771973, 0.030147815123200417, 0.06614050269126892, -0.11195896565914154, -0.31242242455482483, -0.21091388165950775, 0.26013660430908203, 0.13489827513694763, 0.0006252496968954802, -1.1636375188827515, -0.17518764734268188, 0.11280471831560135, 0.399129182100296, -0.43116649985313416, -0.48458656668663025, -0.45463788509368896, 0.37270644307136536, 0.19054639339447021, -0.8052518367767334, -0.07945325970649719, 0.027209045365452766, -0.25049853324890137, 0.5279121994972229, -0.3714789152145386, -0.09810315817594528, 0.0862777903676033, -1.431377649307251, -0.24085158109664917, 0.5787808895111084, 0.35940176248550415, -0.9918122887611389, -0.035928916186094284, 0.10537506639957428, -0.24589838087558746, 0.2833949029445648, 0.13020123541355133, -0.17525199055671692, 0.5358566641807556, 0.95423823595047, -0.37434884905815125, 0.6039547324180603, -0.35102608799934387, -0.23778584599494934, 0.8863154649734497, -0.2627445459365845, 0.36770087480545044, -0.36307859420776367, -0.5545347929000854, -0.6683045029640198, 0.435824453830719, -0.30928075313568115, -0.49482232332229614, 0.8435660600662231, 0.8791214823722839, -0.753686249256134, -0.10645778477191925, -0.9474842548370361, 0.027628015726804733, -0.37877723574638367, 0.4702819883823395, -0.6210794448852539, 0.09514883160591125, 0.4652121663093567, -0.19442473351955414, 0.0006160380435176194, -1.1187307834625244, 3.913651466369629, 0.8921997547149658, 0.4090215563774109, -0.010235888883471489, 0.6749611496925354, 0.296608030796051, 1.2977879047393799, 0.09153374284505844, -0.11165669560432434, 0.6450381875038147, 0.01278011966496706, 0.325897216796875, -0.15801487863063812, -0.42660823464393616, 0.7235068678855896, 0.3067275285720825, -1.1841552257537842, -0.8387547731399536, 0.712867796421051, -0.4713803231716156, -0.8559197783470154, 0.0009802468121051788, 0.5829158425331116, -0.8292988538742065, -0.1718093454837799, 0.295623779296875, -0.20843762159347534, -0.22399908304214478, -0.354290634393692, -0.001513252267614007, 0.22418005764484406, -0.6200644969940186, 0.4102380573749542, -0.9893115162849426, -0.99327152967453, 0.7301176190376282, 0.17737439274787903, -0.16038239002227783, 0.05250595137476921, -0.07727218419313431, 0.2583973705768585, 0.1265811324119568, -0.15821941196918488, -0.38082435727119446, -0.36387044191360474, 0.9122597575187683, -0.9085352420806885, -0.08589525520801544, 0.21208149194717407, -0.4207151234149933, 1.071679711341858, -1.3933262825012207, 0.5371127724647522, -0.5367587804794312, -0.3499143421649933, -0.47215959429740906, 0.12454093247652054, -0.7472302913665771, -0.09100500494241714, 0.04692820832133293, 0.27882036566734314, -0.36908406019210815, 0.008155873976647854, -0.10362440347671509, 0.11220446228981018, 0.5141362547874451, 0.45250123739242554, 0.1386564075946808, 0.08660105615854263, -0.2952723205089569, -0.6363117098808289, -0.7297961711883545, 0.32602038979530334, 0.25184166431427, 0.8887622356414795, 0.4810338020324707, -0.53092360496521, 0.792130172252655, 0.06592950969934464, -0.47052764892578125, -0.025245290249586105, -0.1284627616405487, -0.3321673572063446, -0.38421422243118286, 0.6627644896507263, 0.2308589667081833, -1.3588274717330933, 0.006324253045022488, -1.041116714477539, 1.058979868888855, 0.573929488658905, -0.21563197672367096, 0.19489242136478424, -0.07153649628162384, -0.48581641912460327 ]
{"Title": "Reactions to an Online Demonstration of the Effect of Increased Fruit and Vegetable Consumption on Appearance: Survey", "Authors": "Cairns Patrick, Ozakinci Gozde, Perrett David Ian", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Inadequate fruit and vegetable consumption causes a considerable disease burden and premature mortality. Despite considerable public health promotion of a healthy diet the average consumption is still below recommended levels. Fruit and vegetable consumption influences human skin colour, increasing red/yellow/orange pigment in the skin. Given that this colour is deemed attractive and healthy-looking, the appearance benefit may provide motivation to eat more fruit and vegetables. Such appearance motivation could be particularly effective in young individuals who currently eat least fruit and vegetables. Objectives To assess how widely the impact of diet on skin colour is known within the UK. To compare the strength of motivation to eat fruit and vegetables based on health and appearance benefits and to compare the effect of different UK demographics on motivation. Methods Four groups of UK residents (N = 200 each group) were recruited through the Prolific online platform. Groups comprised younger (aged 18-24) and older adults (aged 40-60) of low and high self-reported socioeconomic status (1-5 and 6-10 on a 10-point rating scale). Facial images simulating the skin colour associated with low and high fruit and vegetable diets were shown to participants. Questionnaires were used to assess (1) background knowledge of the health and skin colour effects of dietary fruit and vegetables; (2) the specific motivational impact of the skin colour illustration and (3) the relative importance of motivation to consume fruit and vegetables arising from health and skin colour appearance benefits. Results (1) 61% of all participants were unaware of the dietary\u2013skin colour association. (2) 57% of participants found the simple demonstration of the dietary impact on skin colour positively motivating to eat more fruit and vegetables. The visual demonstration was equally motivating for participants of high and low self-reported socioeconomic status ( P = .63) and different ethnic backgrounds (White N = 453, Black N = 182, Asian N = 87, P = .22). Health benefits from a diet high in fruit and vegetables were regarded as more motivating than skin colour appearance benefits. The appearance benefits of a high fruit and vegetable diet (compared to the health benefits) were relatively more important for the younger participants (Mann-Whitney U = 96,263, P < .001) and for women (N = 489) than for men (N = 310, U = 83,763, P = .01). Conclusions These findings indicate that promotion of the skin colour effects of diets high in fruit and vegetables could provide additional motivation for a healthier diet. Our study indicates the wide appeal of appearance benefits from dietary fruit and vegetable (across ethnicity and socioeconomic status) and particularly amongst young adults where inadequate diet is most prevalent.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004523"}
10.1101/19008037
[ 0.015463153831660748, 0.16098155081272125, -0.24104063212871552, 0.6664999723434448, -0.14125695824623108, -0.42700138688087463, -0.5542407631874084, -0.08624616265296936, -0.28200238943099976, 0.3799567222595215, -0.48528122901916504, -0.3274131417274475, 0.023900801315903664, -1.0506762266159058, 0.3218829929828644, 0.062209371477365494, -0.7478237152099609, -0.21185073256492615, 0.0674576610326767, -0.8043634295463562, 0.6241512298583984, 0.3725106716156006, -0.3460471034049988, 0.09383300691843033, -1.0939116477966309, 0.6190357208251953, 0.34842467308044434, -0.22016741335391998, 0.7033111453056335, 0.3242531418800354, -0.14509062469005585, -1.0648266077041626, 0.45291346311569214, -1.4455270767211914, 0.05830737575888634, -0.08234038203954697, 0.8492578268051147, -0.6582003831863403, -0.45556360483169556, -0.4296717643737793, 0.10686635971069336, 0.048367828130722046, 0.4744543731212616, -0.7992560267448425, -0.342568963766098, 0.18115420639514923, 0.007506342139095068, -0.4182320833206177, 0.0497150756418705, -0.4101817309856415, -0.08641480654478073, -0.25039249658584595, 0.09546449780464172, -0.2718741297721863, 0.11472156643867493, -0.2807372212409973, 0.5211130976676941, 0.10051626712083817, -0.1365654170513153, -0.3621978461742401, 0.49309831857681274, -0.18889613449573517, 0.0640723928809166, -1.2428151369094849, 0.11828768253326416, 0.670352578163147, -0.11679493635892868, -0.017002426087856293, -0.2869078814983368, -0.7596608996391296, -0.9408472180366516, -0.41578227281570435, -0.2809390425682068, -0.7058645486831665, -0.47571492195129395, 0.02089289389550686, 0.014727103523910046, 0.1377585381269455, -0.013362749479711056, -1.071796178817749, 0.04581434652209282, -0.08671141415834427, 0.09799621999263763, 0.7358283996582031, 0.050167717039585114, -0.36092713475227356, 0.5757483243942261, -0.06351114064455032, 0.03513050079345703, -0.07694710791110992, 0.6295711398124695, 0.3709278106689453, 0.3404071629047394, 0.4106840193271637, 0.31481844186782837, 0.631790280342102, -0.008232994005084038, -0.3997898995876312, 0.12984496355056763, 0.3189780116081238, 0.5246111154556274, 0.7539808750152588, 0.27639850974082947, 1.6006377935409546, -0.763393759727478, 1.0449885129928589, 0.30775725841522217, -0.30072322487831116, -0.14817839860916138, -1.457247018814087, 0.12697626650333405, 0.4493861794471741, -0.4034062325954437, 0.02690257877111435, 0.10862580686807632, 0.39519402384757996, -0.29967746138572693, 0.2331821322441101, -0.0955732986330986, 0.6276308298110962, -0.41275158524513245, 0.47121113538742065, 0.4322737753391266, -0.7076147794723511, 0.382061630487442, -0.16076068580150604, 0.5685673356056213, 0.15553197264671326, -0.322148859500885, -0.4483654797077179, -0.22619332373142242, -0.7904256582260132, 0.19684627652168274, 0.7048975825309753, 0.500328540802002, -0.7375755310058594, -0.18473000824451447, 0.23754268884658813, -0.011333373375236988, -0.5777085423469543, -0.884353756904602, 0.1006133183836937, -0.09170360118150711, 1.0668026208877563, -0.28576046228408813, 0.4832577407360077, 0.3597622811794281, -1.5011937618255615, 0.17985865473747253, -0.19044622778892517, -0.16436667740345, 0.017595555633306503, -0.22661322355270386, -0.3825473189353943, -0.2786872982978821, -0.7020200490951538, -0.31428441405296326, 1.205374836921692, -0.6267903447151184, 0.34967660903930664, 0.439179927110672, 0.39424312114715576, -0.3353332281112671, 0.7423155307769775, -0.2838507890701294, 0.520240068435669, 0.5417478680610657, -0.36054572463035583, -0.3928375244140625, -0.6940109729766846, 0.746223509311676, 0.474033385515213, -0.20503577589988708, 0.2389829158782959, 0.2162533551454544, 0.8878473043441772, 1.1511716842651367, 0.4548301100730896, 0.555705189704895, -0.09105537831783295, -0.38482093811035156, -0.6473197937011719, 1.0257123708724976, 1.150417685508728, -0.18558122217655182, 0.2125878632068634, -0.7143214344978333, -0.6602184772491455, -0.036581408232450485, 0.3393251299858093, 0.642270565032959, 0.5799252986907959, -0.5881415605545044, 0.04060713201761246, -0.3188896179199219, 0.09050754457712173, -0.3350068926811218, 0.2784363925457001, 0.5684718489646912, -0.6245447993278503, -0.19821879267692566, 0.759131669998169, -0.9707915782928467, 0.2586009204387665, -0.5875176191329956, 0.6443086862564087, 1.3077348470687866, 0.4054888188838959, -0.3815290033817291, 0.18452270328998566, 0.7447589039802551, -0.07730469107627869, 0.13137781620025635, 0.18220902979373932, 0.17000529170036316, -0.5132131576538086, -0.6332748532295227, 0.21784695982933044, -0.3780437409877777, -0.5153335332870483, 0.13864688575267792, -0.5564423203468323, -0.0019088196568191051, -0.016089966520667076, 0.4839019477367401, -0.18336129188537598, 0.17264555394649506, -0.023231854662299156, 0.46753162145614624, -0.003468048060312867, 0.2383883148431778, 0.640453040599823, -0.29111629724502563, 0.9084663987159729, 0.7015431523323059, -0.13395504653453827, 0.4622761011123657, 0.5335899591445923, 0.8244444131851196, -0.37450623512268066, 0.7188068628311157, -0.12315182387828827, 0.8823491930961609, 1.0948529243469238, 0.06834592670202255, -0.2492666393518448, -0.6281319260597229, 0.03712976351380348, 0.07519038021564484, 0.02850252389907837, -0.7506037354469299, 0.728096604347229, -0.1539410799741745, 0.638009250164032, -0.8404444456100464, -0.20723176002502441, 0.03094153106212616, 1.1514406204223633, 0.2311430424451828, -0.47379645705223083, -0.2745095193386078, 0.25404852628707886, 0.4139804542064667, 0.490310400724411, 0.36016175150871277, 0.9155568480491638, 0.05461058393120766, 0.2780081629753113, 0.004941737744957209, -0.7781545519828796, -1.1152129173278809, -1.030737042427063, -1.0417940616607666, -0.7719077467918396, -0.260369211435318, -0.1662464290857315, 0.09472157806158066, -0.13505819439888, 0.639460563659668, 0.6125364303588867, 0.09177793562412262, 0.052531808614730835, 0.49412012100219727, 0.6255080699920654, 0.2848230004310608, -0.051281508058309555, -1.5372118949890137, 0.7905269861221313, -0.30016347765922546, 0.847306489944458, -0.0406867079436779, -0.8299639821052551, -0.36649414896965027, -1.4153233766555786, 0.5696486830711365, -0.5409217476844788, -0.32144400477409363, -0.18381068110466003, 0.1986955851316452, 0.22433771193027496, 0.20167285203933716, -0.26827073097229004, -0.16375543177127838, 0.185438334941864, -0.9225687384605408, 0.5605104565620422, 0.4779798984527588, 0.23169536888599396, 0.728044867515564, 0.5210487246513367, -0.6605059504508972, 1.218414545059204, 0.1005794033408165, -0.3484751880168915, -0.708124041557312, 0.7550281882286072, 1.1174179315567017, -0.29909026622772217, 0.17115704715251923, -0.933958888053894, -0.5078544616699219, -0.20001429319381714, -0.2871270477771759, -1.0629733800888062, 0.06000002846121788, 0.9323167204856873, 0.15457400679588318, -0.38813886046409607, 0.10536879301071167, -1.3122377395629883, -1.3472388982772827, 0.30482494831085205, -0.38457128405570984, 1.5332807302474976, 0.28661835193634033, -0.5200933218002319, -0.8432105779647827, -0.26255446672439575, 0.59628826379776, 1.3034976720809937, 0.5777055025100708, -0.809084951877594, 0.10304035246372223, 0.7699263095855713, -0.13208477199077606, 0.381582111120224, 0.7586394548416138, -0.40114107728004456, -0.6588886380195618, 0.1728598177433014, -0.1656075268983841, -0.08542317152023315, 0.4097556471824646, 0.09166576713323593, -0.08783626556396484, 0.2794976532459259, -0.9325604438781738, 0.24645696580410004, 0.6103169918060303, -0.002602222142741084, -0.25658532977104187, 0.17901133000850677, -0.6818925142288208, 0.7119568586349487, -1.0835825204849243, -0.6311696171760559, 0.24559149146080017, -0.21969863772392273, 0.5358893275260925, -0.770002007484436, 0.539929211139679, -0.3575708568096161, -0.6798826456069946, 0.15913860499858856, -0.25162458419799805, -0.4726593792438507, 1.407570719718933, -0.08530787378549576, 1.484896183013916, -1.1134033203125, 0.3146776258945465, 1.1683241128921509, 0.9639767408370972, 0.5685489773750305, 0.29652881622314453, 0.17145860195159912, -0.706571102142334, -0.19022589921951294, -0.07116492092609406, -0.45812487602233887, 0.18110758066177368, -0.13069599866867065, -0.6787896156311035, -0.25923916697502136, -1.4875248670578003, -0.43861594796180725, -0.26730117201805115, -0.03874674439430237, 0.3993379473686218, -0.30545711517333984, 0.9034445285797119, -0.8812018632888794, 0.2126777470111847, 0.6460955739021301, 0.3243170380592346, -0.11075493693351746, -0.5615538954734802, 0.1605657935142517, -0.144585981965065, -0.713481605052948, -0.4282529950141907, -0.23531687259674072, -0.4242801368236542, 0.350167453289032, 0.23867547512054443, 0.18596084415912628, -0.2767185866832733, 0.059583816677331924, 0.5033439993858337, 0.137754425406456, 0.3770703673362732, 0.22532151639461517, -0.7393231391906738, 0.7314901351928711, 0.2082517445087433, -0.6376078724861145, -0.26653409004211426, -1.424506664276123, 0.6636180281639099, 1.216277837753296, -0.14306049048900604, -0.8944870233535767, 0.5893417000770569, -0.2644800543785095, -0.36807864904403687, -0.3275745213031769, -0.23910054564476013, -0.4225693643093109, 0.44582486152648926, 0.08788631856441498, -0.3130511939525604, -0.33755168318748474, -0.5712640881538391, -0.5518035292625427, -0.25556761026382446, 0.3011854290962219, -0.04243611544370651, 0.6502140760421753, 0.43386006355285645, -0.37191247940063477, 0.29906752705574036, -1.4035472869873047, 0.3275965750217438, -0.33989280462265015, -0.6637192964553833, 0.797121524810791, 0.4544075131416321, -0.35852953791618347, 0.07722942531108856, -0.4423346221446991, -0.2452014982700348, 0.09534342586994171, 0.89377760887146, 0.06660794466733932, -0.5979124903678894, 0.7467554211616516, -0.3168708086013794, 0.19191639125347137, 0.48510444164276123, -0.34912246465682983, 0.234987273812294, -0.16357797384262085, -0.4299366772174835, -0.24624010920524597, 0.1261252462863922, -0.38216230273246765, 0.3549504280090332, -0.37025192379951477, -0.5639467239379883, 0.0028456326108425856, -0.23359555006027222, 0.5527228116989136, -0.7725201845169067, -0.20298704504966736, -0.6097612977027893, 0.20127390325069427, -0.6998195648193359, -0.4030534327030182, -0.22139491140842438, 0.2736437916755676, -0.01981140300631523, -0.3479088842868805, 0.04315444454550743, 0.18894697725772858, -0.17880816757678986, 0.26900532841682434, -0.8937501907348633, 0.011611299589276314, -0.17787964642047882, 0.42101916670799255, 0.6849720478057861, -0.57186359167099, -0.35761913657188416, 0.5294297933578491, 0.507340133190155, -0.12786421179771423, -0.3357977271080017, -0.3845480680465698, -0.7453058958053589, -0.21314072608947754, 0.20672297477722168, 0.5099717974662781, -0.6370776891708374, 0.2599770426750183, -0.08273077756166458, -0.2178473174571991, -0.9482358694076538, -0.0749320238828659, -0.29308897256851196, 0.9369569420814514, -0.14787733554840088, -1.076045274734497, -0.08228781819343567, 0.6030161380767822, -0.03437751904129982, 0.18592442572116852, -0.4645358920097351, -1.151045799255371, -0.38615742325782776, -0.36825305223464966, 0.655027449131012, -1.2673927545547485, 0.16696876287460327, -0.7842029333114624, -0.028327735140919685, -0.1289575695991516, 0.5073570609092712, 0.18225188553333282, -0.22113096714019775, -0.4244539141654968, -0.5460482835769653, -0.19164100289344788, -0.5506049394607544, -0.9327503442764282, 0.18667003512382507, -0.19090478122234344, 0.008921011351048946, 1.2248709201812744, 0.03088226169347763, -0.13413381576538086, 0.18449246883392334, -0.11705673485994339, 0.5123694539070129, 0.7819639444351196, -0.896121621131897, -0.7193782925605774, 0.35616451501846313, 0.2704245448112488, 0.08261045068502426, -0.22190509736537933, -0.45742836594581604, 0.1770431101322174, -0.8096256256103516, 0.08783465623855591, -1.1019439697265625, 0.048783719539642334, 0.05826755240559578, -0.1975404918193817, 0.2495959848165512, -0.30163371562957764, 0.1264113187789917, 0.3945143222808838, -0.20285360515117645, -0.3078104555606842, 0.3478238880634308, -0.9754201173782349, -0.49775055050849915, -0.6095067262649536, -1.1785005331039429, 0.4774476885795593, -0.4429134726524353, -0.10537025332450867, 0.15257640182971954, 0.7239059209823608, 0.2428402304649353, -1.0216432809829712, 1.1789413690567017, 0.7439513206481934, -0.1747359037399292, -0.6178735494613647, 0.07843771576881409, -0.4919658303260803, 0.20605425536632538, 0.050200410187244415, -0.07664605230093002, -1.084463357925415, -0.21186959743499756, -0.029692500829696655, -0.698217511177063, -0.9429604411125183, -0.2893102467060089, -0.40014591813087463, 0.452249675989151, -0.814513623714447, 0.5083920955657959, 0.1702229082584381, 0.42234688997268677, -0.27863502502441406, 0.3976130485534668, -0.39450594782829285, -0.22278346121311188, 0.8119178414344788, -0.05090197175741196, -0.01086107175797224, -0.6860706210136414, -0.05294724926352501, 0.4457022249698639, -0.01838703453540802, 0.29172244668006897, 0.20815862715244293, -0.6883720755577087, -0.21836262941360474, 0.05887552350759506, 0.26337307691574097, -1.3186886310577393, -0.35773590207099915, -0.07667789608240128, 0.3640406131744385, -0.5219229459762573, -0.3100889325141907, 0.08175060153007507, -0.37685897946357727, 0.40759748220443726, 0.3728039264678955, 0.30593809485435486, -0.059128522872924805, 0.2595948576927185, -0.26948627829551697, -1.2253875732421875, 0.5753601789474487, 0.8595086932182312, -0.26312255859375, 0.30731871724128723, -0.24193792045116425, -0.38698768615722656, -0.15707401931285858, -0.3081609606742859, 0.2664112448692322, -0.7042068839073181, 0.0032232028897851706, 0.8657554984092712, 0.3080858886241913, 0.4677472412586212, 0.6336008906364441, 0.10292702168226242, 0.7514187693595886, 0.7957697510719299, -1.1290019750595093, 0.11776087433099747, 0.4434354901313782, 0.5859465599060059, 0.4197935163974762, -0.8417584300041199, 0.05804755538702011, 0.46784546971321106, 0.3584546148777008, -0.1999327838420868, -0.42403876781463623, -0.7478923797607422, -1.2251182794570923, -0.7590951323509216, 0.33316466212272644, 0.02200702205300331, -1.1475783586502075, 0.19200634956359863, -0.16680456697940826, -0.7789196968078613, -0.11085338890552521, 0.37164515256881714, -0.32678961753845215, -0.18362393975257874, -0.8912579417228699, -0.17879372835159302, -0.4607265889644623, 0.07216337323188782, -0.0072154090739786625, -0.9997463226318359, 0.17432208359241486, 0.5708471536636353, 0.18936143815517426, -0.13252003490924835, 0.3136097490787506, -0.06330224871635437, -0.4027913510799408, 0.4849500358104706, -0.6610942482948303, -0.4247641861438751, 0.5554454326629639, 0.5925774574279785, 0.17145341634750366, -0.10939961671829224, 0.20385149121284485, -0.41624537110328674, 0.6733436584472656, 0.954508900642395, 0.7601001858711243, -0.46469539403915405, -0.035127878189086914, 0.542850911617279, 0.11457821726799011, 0.02892294153571129, 0.14593608677387238, 0.9285460114479065, -0.9837976098060608, -0.09836814552545547, -0.6775968670845032, 0.25860458612442017, 0.10678431391716003, -0.20541052520275116, 1.1863830089569092, 0.4188937544822693, -0.0372137650847435, -0.05848317965865135, -0.470462441444397, 0.7690243124961853, 0.08430849760770798, 0.04141385480761528, 0.47730255126953125, -0.4678593873977661, 0.09371917694807053, -0.8943535089492798, 0.3133958876132965, -0.02060660533607006, -0.35795482993125916, -0.5874316692352295, -1.0810086727142334, 0.039835475385189056, 0.28367525339126587, -0.095846027135849, 0.6773039102554321, 0.42705655097961426, -0.7646077275276184, -0.01996278576552868, 0.38340243697166443, -0.14638729393482208, -0.7070464491844177, -0.16383442282676697, -0.8800287246704102, -0.33570700883865356, 0.92287677526474, -0.10627208650112152, -0.14374728500843048, -0.663292646408081, -0.9449916481971741, 0.5587647557258606, 0.1262059211730957, 0.7003225088119507, 0.3511141240596771, 0.7134445309638977, 0.4384639859199524, 0.4763651192188263, 0.16045774519443512, 0.14380595088005066, 0.10754498094320297, -0.14640414714813232, -0.3809949457645416, -0.16904933750629425, 0.13744699954986572, 0.6479941010475159, 0.21243663132190704, -0.07580619305372238, -0.46232688426971436, -0.0762273296713829, 0.16080622375011444, -0.3172726035118103, 0.4661731421947479, 0.43570268154144287, -0.032843563705682755, 0.2588115930557251, -0.17436084151268005, -0.2415541112422943, -0.22344575822353363, 0.13271525502204895, 0.027865568175911903, -1.2370893955230713, -0.6833850145339966, -0.2139461189508438, 0.3311103284358978, -0.5574974417686462, 0.8992253541946411, 0.10303279757499695, 0.4476281702518463, -0.49909982085227966, 0.5881170630455017, 0.3851030766963959, 0.7038416862487793, 0.26746177673339844, -0.244896799325943, -0.8583247065544128, 1.164074420928955, 0.46597516536712646, 0.6700658798217773, -0.02951178513467312, 1.0227727890014648, 0.06168634817004204, -0.20360949635505676, 0.29890599846839905, -0.30599498748779297, 0.2474873960018158, 0.4873195290565491, 0.26572370529174805, 0.36690524220466614, 0.35914894938468933, 0.044246260076761246, -0.41164350509643555, -0.0828089565038681, 0.6827462315559387, -0.04160698130726814, -0.5840080380439758, -0.1670590490102768, 0.28355872631073, 1.0520074367523193, 0.054656337946653366, 0.38996461033821106, 0.10502858459949493, 0.29812929034233093, 0.5288043022155762, 0.10406957566738129, 0.675980806350708, 0.094044990837574, -0.6351659893989563, -0.3851446509361267, 0.7854907512664795, 0.28408193588256836, 0.48100370168685913, 0.001564232399687171, -0.2541423738002777, -0.7115511298179626, 0.6714866757392883, -0.15299668908119202, -0.2931998074054718, 0.9499236941337585, 0.17029114067554474, 0.30798834562301636, -0.05055541545152664, 0.18561704456806183, -0.7860100865364075, -0.27671024203300476, 0.40398308634757996, 0.05283132940530777, -0.28902679681777954, 0.1463814228773117, 0.18127372860908508, 0.7154173254966736, 0.29292356967926025, 0.6740170121192932, -0.6192029714584351, 1.5230478048324585, 0.39422348141670227, -0.8301500082015991, 0.23198622465133667, 0.25419944524765015, -0.46826425194740295, -0.18543478846549988, -0.08547113090753555, 0.9737709164619446, 0.1884007453918457, -0.4846929907798767, 0.5088202357292175, 0.809148371219635, -0.17010612785816193, -0.10161776095628738, -0.5143430233001709, 0.8585023880004883, -0.054492540657520294, -0.16785216331481934, 0.08652116358280182, 0.21673767268657684, -0.20831042528152466, 0.14465521275997162, -0.020444858819246292, -0.660491943359375, -0.4742352068424225, -0.348030149936676, -0.8645257353782654, 1.2378607988357544, -0.2901305556297302, -0.22840215265750885, -0.8774022459983826, -0.8846665024757385, -0.39741891622543335, 0.12362727522850037, -0.020606566220521927, -0.305409699678421, 0.6426482200622559, 0.6217649579048157, 0.3443065583705902, 0.05290060117840767, -0.16007868945598602, -0.06476175040006638, 1.1021747589111328, 0.531863808631897, -0.022266296669840813, 1.1657465696334839, -0.28793832659721375, 0.3420354127883911, 0.054965123534202576, -0.21104760468006134, 0.30168119072914124, 0.1061839908361435, -0.5986683964729309, -0.35956907272338867, -0.4697672724723816, -0.6765022277832031, -0.4723246693611145, 1.1899231672286987, 0.7692751884460449, -0.5421667098999023, -0.44201940298080444, -0.5718585252761841, -0.07236532866954803, -0.6287177801132202, 1.2705360651016235, -0.20509566366672516, 0.44428524374961853, 0.10823031514883041, -0.7126448154449463, -0.5098521113395691, -1.0389190912246704, 3.9160315990448, 1.340099573135376, 0.883219301700592, -0.11646717041730881, 0.595827043056488, 0.49330687522888184, 0.8176709413528442, -0.08453834056854248, -0.17538319528102875, 0.32701921463012695, -0.1519346684217453, 0.5872135162353516, -0.16226385533809662, -0.15503236651420593, 0.73302161693573, 0.6935662031173706, -0.7957678437232971, 0.023316534236073494, 0.18821202218532562, -0.9287939667701721, -0.5183383822441101, 0.37138229608535767, 0.06095977872610092, 0.24344459176063538, -0.16505524516105652, -0.16023334860801697, 0.07713691145181656, 0.3374272882938385, -0.15905480086803436, -0.003835695330053568, -0.49251386523246765, -0.5427682995796204, 0.9025527834892273, -0.3383827209472656, -0.2502557337284088, 0.3394906520843506, 0.2141725718975067, -0.37223225831985474, -0.20562653243541718, -0.008247900754213333, -0.50990891456604, 0.12911337614059448, 0.3226608633995056, 0.03750241920351982, -0.8027236461639404, 0.259443461894989, -0.42420491576194763, -0.11259886622428894, 1.3142482042312622, -0.46875232458114624, 0.9515389204025269, -0.908536970615387, 0.06109031289815903, 0.1775839477777481, -0.5902407169342041, 0.00993516854941845, -0.6137228012084961, -0.8999229073524475, 0.10089574754238129, 0.09151562303304672, 0.7575469613075256, 0.30377495288848877, -0.3408806025981903, -0.42160624265670776, 0.8548702597618103, 0.5798251628875732, 0.34860724210739136, 0.34953054785728455, 0.5422183871269226, -0.018933167681097984, -0.3540630340576172, -0.1952323168516159, -0.47252917289733887, 0.15603910386562347, 0.7113721370697021, 0.6185297966003418, -0.3774549961090088, -0.014870728366076946, -0.6896088719367981, -0.5805396437644958, -0.33394089341163635, -0.043227262794971466, 0.5656344294548035, 0.05276954546570778, 0.014769874513149261, 0.6219845414161682, 0.3768528401851654, -0.17557212710380554, -1.2209230661392212, 0.9117441177368164, 0.6798722147941589, 0.17548823356628418, 0.7082265019416809, 0.1459844410419464, 0.03623931109905243 ]
{"Title": "Classifying post-traumatic stress disorder using the magnetoencephalographic connectome and machine learning", "Authors": "Zhang Jing, Richardson J. Don, Dunkley Benjamin T.", "Abstract": "Abstract Given the subjective nature of conventional diagnostic methods for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), an objectively measurable biomarker is highly desirable. Macroscopic neural circuits measured using magnetoencephalography (MEG) has previously been shown to be indicative of the PTSD phenotype and severity. In the present study, we employed a machine learning-based classification framework using MEG neural synchrony to distinguish combat-related PTSD from trauma-exposed controls. Support vector machine (SVM) was used as the core classification algorithm. A recursive random forest feature selection step was directly incorporated in the nested SVM cross validation process (CV-SVM-rRF-FS) for identifying the most important features for PTSD classification. For the five frequency bands tested, the nested CV-SVM-rRF-FS analysis selected the minimum numbers of edges per frequency that could serve as a PTSD signature and be used as the basis for SVM modelling. Many of the selected edges have been reported previously to be core in PTSD pathophysiology, with frequency-specific patterns also observed. Furthermore, the independent partial least squares discriminant analysis suggested low bias in the nested CV-SVM-rRF-FS process. The final SVM models built with selected features showed excellent PTSD classification performance (area-under-curve value up to 0.9). Testament to its robustness when distinguishing individuals from a heavily-traumatised control group, these developments for a classification model for PTSD also provide a comprehensive machine learning-based computational framework for classifying other mental health challenges using MEG connectome profiles.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008037"}
10.1101/19005538
[ -0.36622169613838196, -0.5915583372116089, -0.4076203405857086, 0.8615072965621948, 0.21754752099514008, -0.7413669228553772, 0.3234999477863312, -0.3454219698905945, -0.10479876399040222, 0.5135712027549744, -1.2975696325302124, 0.15124952793121338, 0.25633132457733154, 0.6069426536560059, -0.8241425156593323, 0.22806254029273987, -0.35961705446243286, -0.2888433635234833, -0.7110428810119629, 0.2849711775779724, -0.20214992761611938, 1.3274580240249634, -0.6882747411727905, 0.0927455872297287, -0.08041157573461533, 0.7652269005775452, 0.12205668538808823, 0.29311102628707886, 1.4118058681488037, 0.6634095311164856, -0.07821349054574966, -0.2914106845855713, -0.019735001027584076, -0.5190333127975464, -0.06927724182605743, -0.4965169429779053, 0.1665714681148529, -0.0019031842239201069, -0.2674585282802582, -0.8315644264221191, 0.42340853810310364, -0.329956591129303, 0.24306294322013855, -0.10368700325489044, -1.0209399461746216, -0.2325989007949829, 0.1407299041748047, -0.1888883411884308, 0.1754220873117447, 0.9474655985832214, -0.09023690223693848, 0.07333448529243469, -0.1335129290819168, -0.4428976774215698, -0.5742234587669373, -0.10650372505187988, 0.6433040499687195, 0.03010469488799572, -0.787373960018158, 0.49872711300849915, 0.3050297200679779, 0.20038175582885742, 0.28463467955589294, -0.9086493849754333, 0.1844327598810196, 0.7751068472862244, -0.631139874458313, 0.11257873475551605, -0.23771913349628448, -0.17227964103221893, -0.5500216484069824, 0.3601369857788086, -0.5071741342544556, -0.32476961612701416, -0.4468620717525482, -0.19936184585094452, -0.3598792850971222, -0.42447414994239807, 0.23615892231464386, 0.10929982364177704, -0.04750707000494003, 0.9558631181716919, 0.9399797916412354, 0.028559181839227676, -0.40875986218452454, 0.1696842759847641, 0.11782325059175491, 0.29644620418548584, 0.14536775648593903, 0.6895025968551636, -0.24543848633766174, 0.2404775768518448, -0.3272130489349365, 0.20114390552043915, -0.18809102475643158, 1.1619902849197388, -0.5104032754898071, -0.6352959871292114, 0.34298425912857056, -0.8635150790214539, 0.9325655102729797, 0.7917839884757996, -0.4382873475551605, 0.7152125835418701, -0.47822386026382446, 0.7677819132804871, 0.7656023502349854, -0.6409770846366882, -0.7021692991256714, -0.624609649181366, 0.1305553913116455, -0.43120917677879333, -0.9038068652153015, -0.4118417203426361, 0.4706021249294281, 0.6619929075241089, -0.10500150918960571, 0.5947180390357971, -0.10515380650758743, 0.1694866269826889, 0.042486436665058136, 0.4778954088687897, 0.8830412030220032, -0.1493375301361084, 0.8588230609893799, 0.25163722038269043, 0.498395711183548, 0.2798286974430084, -0.12622188031673431, -0.20710818469524384, 0.14459820091724396, -0.3755947947502136, 0.1311764419078827, 0.5551623106002808, -0.33759063482284546, -0.4680638313293457, 0.7649213671684265, 0.20486579835414886, 0.6361189484596252, -0.16875489056110382, -0.31171730160713196, 0.6133595705032349, -0.32934871315956116, 1.259255051612854, -0.5249207019805908, 0.6998167634010315, -0.30465275049209595, -0.936604917049408, -0.8370491862297058, -0.6546082496643066, -0.15851648151874542, 0.01607387699186802, -0.6091753244400024, 0.8076172471046448, 0.46507948637008667, 0.3270328640937805, -0.5011904239654541, -0.5732578635215759, -0.24008893966674805, 0.028753679245710373, -0.2915259897708893, -0.012590392492711544, -0.24313807487487793, 0.47813794016838074, -0.44684815406799316, 0.16418054699897766, -0.0069778175093233585, -0.20072053372859955, 0.4451150894165039, 0.08644859492778778, 1.1808549165725708, -0.25291547179222107, -0.15222570300102234, 0.025006400421261787, 0.2572963535785675, 0.7803266644477844, 0.4742112159729004, -0.17198045551776886, -0.10932665318250656, 0.8695772886276245, 0.018190691247582436, 0.4373493492603302, 0.13339067995548248, 0.6086615920066833, -0.1198892593383789, 0.27684107422828674, 0.0501163974404335, -0.025275815278291702, -0.37183085083961487, -0.8892507553100586, -0.513359785079956, 0.5479898452758789, -0.788302481174469, 0.6520037055015564, 0.20458149909973145, -0.48558399081230164, -0.609101414680481, -0.22873933613300323, 0.2608163058757782, -0.36513325572013855, -1.253566861152649, 0.541943371295929, 0.21189917623996735, 0.5335010886192322, 0.042245011776685715, 0.8413216471672058, 0.13420593738555908, -0.4416886866092682, -0.12240813672542572, 0.0671563372015953, 0.8915305137634277, -0.40370598435401917, -0.44377827644348145, 0.3222130835056305, 0.8688792586326599, -0.3289560079574585, -0.11548706889152527, 0.5212231278419495, -0.7722923159599304, 0.9554965496063232, -0.07827377319335938, -0.40142160654067993, -0.013910572975873947, -0.14743024110794067, 0.17298583686351776, -0.14397943019866943, 0.1143680289387703, 0.6210018396377563, -0.687984824180603, 0.05597435683012009, -0.0848892331123352, 0.8737867474555969, -0.4408494532108307, 1.3043030500411987, 1.0691547393798828, 0.12101969867944717, -0.5992173552513123, 0.5474661588668823, 0.5131165981292725, 0.49952417612075806, 0.5487843751907349, 0.009242556989192963, 0.0008276065345853567, -0.4499852955341339, -0.8261619806289673, 0.8054266571998596, -0.5683801174163818, -0.39707091450691223, 0.0773371234536171, -0.25473645329475403, 0.0018842773279175162, 1.190061092376709, 0.9667691588401794, 0.7782071828842163, -1.6171343326568604, -0.2969128489494324, 0.01602254994213581, 0.17297910153865814, -0.6901482939720154, -0.2785014808177948, -0.04907669126987457, 0.22001533210277557, -0.33598077297210693, -0.7017476558685303, 1.3039180040359497, 0.7642982006072998, -0.553339958190918, 0.673537015914917, -0.01260313019156456, -0.31497281789779663, -0.8878726959228516, -0.5221703052520752, -1.0963464975357056, -0.5628498792648315, -0.45522215962409973, 0.36193063855171204, 0.35418936610221863, 0.012420102022588253, -0.013278930447995663, 0.019719531759619713, -0.09171945601701736, 0.28552767634391785, 0.8105679154396057, 0.4772647023200989, 0.6480807662010193, -0.031956225633621216, -0.3002452552318573, 0.13212351500988007, 0.4685668349266052, -0.2602262794971466, -0.3399605453014374, -0.3424622118473053, -0.5245746970176697, -0.8813806176185608, 0.2964170575141907, -0.5429826378822327, -0.09695085883140564, 0.5438402891159058, -0.6028047204017639, -0.21241934597492218, 0.025439539924263954, -0.6850301027297974, -0.5747647285461426, -0.11048449575901031, -0.7784265279769897, 0.4659271836280823, -0.6164682507514954, 0.13200059533119202, 0.5634278655052185, 0.21772503852844238, -0.782271683216095, 0.7046692967414856, 0.21165572106838226, -0.07180566340684891, -1.262437105178833, -0.17243239283561707, 0.45971009135246277, -0.6399251818656921, 0.35441499948501587, 0.04096629098057747, -0.4364813268184662, 0.37001657485961914, 0.21739360690116882, -0.6242387294769287, -0.45717957615852356, 0.43680331110954285, 0.04668201878666878, -1.4115644693374634, -0.12285278737545013, -0.7448157072067261, -0.6891619563102722, -0.04830095171928406, 0.32852861285209656, -0.13933338224887848, 0.14232903718948364, 0.04792280122637749, -0.45256125926971436, -0.05683362856507301, -0.7493715882301331, -0.1947639137506485, 0.0487494021654129, -0.2815399467945099, 0.11167702078819275, 0.25707167387008667, -0.017226770520210266, 0.2711568772792816, 1.0659024715423584, -0.6000760197639465, -0.17298336327075958, 0.7759562134742737, 0.29952317476272583, -0.13669900596141815, 0.8890988826751709, -0.6514744758605957, -0.8047374486923218, 0.6175689697265625, -0.22939403355121613, -0.21482443809509277, -0.31330248713493347, 0.3412942886352539, -0.30022957921028137, -0.2125856727361679, -0.5215916037559509, -0.10964880138635635, -0.6410621404647827, -0.9337859153747559, 0.6953468322753906, 0.8437071442604065, 0.7902503609657288, -0.16901008784770966, 0.03609186410903931, -0.4689934551715851, -0.31331634521484375, 0.3087444305419922, 0.450778067111969, -0.3975118100643158, 0.8832219839096069, 0.8093046545982361, 1.3598712682724, -1.1273192167282104, 0.1201639249920845, 0.9765645861625671, 0.8532619476318359, 0.5834531784057617, 0.4445791244506836, 0.020524954423308372, -0.2232157289981842, 0.9497992396354675, 0.5097984075546265, -0.5306847095489502, 0.4131947159767151, 0.29043683409690857, 0.046001285314559937, -0.4334370791912079, -0.377974271774292, -0.5486865043640137, 0.7037786245346069, 0.8428916931152344, 0.7911164164543152, 0.01751120574772358, 0.8150014281272888, -0.748934805393219, 0.8184906840324402, 0.39728468656539917, 0.5771207213401794, 0.904708981513977, -1.0260754823684692, 0.22258585691452026, 0.04290768876671791, -1.0991888046264648, -0.5072091221809387, -0.8352035284042358, -0.15819428861141205, -0.4014839231967926, -0.1683531254529953, 0.36427581310272217, 0.08776983618736267, -0.5781781673431396, -0.2506271302700043, -0.028095321729779243, 0.06472939252853394, -0.2475597858428955, -0.4421162009239197, 0.09550948441028595, 0.2594437599182129, -0.09067295491695404, -0.18707793951034546, -0.6965851783752441, 0.7125149965286255, 1.045973539352417, -0.8269051313400269, -0.30036839842796326, -0.6991059184074402, -0.05235573649406433, -0.37073028087615967, 0.028251752257347107, 0.49310949444770813, -0.20774808526039124, 0.09647931158542633, -0.4624257981777191, -0.2622651755809784, -0.4221266508102417, -0.3374492824077606, -0.3030465543270111, 0.5404080748558044, -0.2392423152923584, 0.9306455850601196, 0.4297824800014496, -0.2938799560070038, 0.2871874272823334, 0.4004531800746918, -1.0209808349609375, 0.5706040859222412, -0.2819431722164154, 0.3472234904766083, -0.10559645295143127, -0.3674551248550415, -0.020140094682574272, 0.04836658015847206, 0.25279849767684937, -0.8247539401054382, -0.202589750289917, -0.2707509696483612, 0.09861215204000473, 0.04960218444466591, 0.7834368348121643, 0.5310361385345459, 0.514201819896698, 0.8279150128364563, -0.7218226194381714, -0.5128951668739319, 0.5812610983848572, -0.5158342123031616, -0.9173089265823364, 0.5629056096076965, 0.9426263570785522, 0.17641456425189972, 0.33623433113098145, -0.6790761351585388, 0.3121086359024048, -0.08151699602603912, 0.2763766944408417, 0.05942428857088089, -0.11430660635232925, 0.5410117506980896, -0.3579370379447937, 0.3152081072330475, 0.02490413933992386, -1.185947299003601, 0.44782349467277527, -0.3409883379936218, -0.14670901000499725, -0.1813286691904068, 0.43323594331741333, -0.5144273042678833, -0.30036649107933044, -0.2772843837738037, 0.323313444852829, 0.423663854598999, -0.09816548228263855, 0.508557915687561, -0.5962199568748474, -0.5374465584754944, -0.4399571120738983, 0.5629046559333801, -0.45177167654037476, -0.7023770213127136, 0.128682479262352, -1.253785252571106, -0.22139203548431396, -0.04737720265984535, 0.7408064007759094, -0.9229859709739685, -0.5136051177978516, -0.619207501411438, 0.07157707214355469, 0.5082610845565796, -0.12954556941986084, 0.7011496424674988, 0.07306181639432907, -0.20149743556976318, -0.0620858371257782, -0.11829940974712372, 0.3208312690258026, 0.5671066045761108, 0.5356258749961853, -1.0589739084243774, -0.9915761947631836, -0.37789276242256165, -0.8792538046836853, 0.3842303156852722, -0.45096781849861145, -0.5102511644363403, 0.45064064860343933, -0.42862075567245483, 0.07631339877843857, -0.2007901519536972, 0.13181814551353455, 0.42406126856803894, 0.4306325912475586, -0.2613561749458313, 0.47195741534233093, -0.11308257281780243, -0.05719979852437973, 0.39203399419784546, -0.6634411811828613, 0.20470307767391205, 1.1578893661499023, 0.09794770926237106, -0.44073206186294556, -0.1552302986383438, 0.42141959071159363, 0.7837802767753601, 0.6138505339622498, -0.6741666793823242, -0.716194212436676, 0.02540232613682747, 0.4239988625049591, -0.22750262916088104, -0.6637874841690063, -1.3098886013031006, 0.43815377354621887, 0.021886425092816353, 0.3056555986404419, 0.0075766113586723804, -0.5766230225563049, 0.3063204884529114, -0.5876830816268921, 1.2489653825759888, 0.06368124485015869, 1.0169864892959595, 0.2577313482761383, -0.3956143260002136, 0.2188323587179184, 0.4312930703163147, -0.2859552204608917, -1.2990459203720093, -0.7775806188583374, -0.7869468927383423, -0.17788031697273254, 0.05540284886956215, -0.005785203538835049, 0.35982421040534973, -0.3471398651599884, -0.24697507917881012, 0.1029457226395607, 0.6924992203712463, 1.028987169265747, -1.1103941202163696, -0.27131175994873047, 0.5356208682060242, 0.7698802351951599, 0.20658951997756958, -0.15505902469158173, -0.41875433921813965, -0.3644455075263977, -0.0928027406334877, 0.14277443289756775, -0.25272947549819946, -0.7693180441856384, -0.14217963814735413, 0.45286598801612854, 0.919532060623169, 0.14499728381633759, 0.3403227627277374, -0.5555207133293152, -0.4467065632343292, -0.3801340162754059, 0.14766521751880646, -0.29535987973213196, 0.20376943051815033, 0.4674687683582306, 0.059265319257974625, -0.38189497590065, 1.057377815246582, -0.007665094453841448, 0.7104462385177612, 0.2217446267604828, 1.1831669807434082, 0.3560185432434082, -1.7526963949203491, 1.0589921474456787, 0.10458007454872131, -0.35063302516937256, -0.5541556477546692, -0.5622854232788086, -0.8823180794715881, -0.44683659076690674, 0.01796274073421955, -0.39420685172080994, 0.8763641715049744, -0.009134122170507908, 0.5422864556312561, -0.04593397304415703, -0.05759838968515396, 0.15922263264656067, -0.009348335675895214, 0.15518653392791748, -0.2185262143611908, -0.14357146620750427, 0.6080307364463806, -0.3635554909706116, 0.5249186158180237, 0.3582155704498291, 0.013456776738166809, -0.24466097354888916, 0.2449435144662857, 0.2554628849029541, -0.17838536202907562, -0.12413093447685242, -0.314457505941391, -0.15311048924922943, 0.481100469827652, 0.005636545829474926, 0.08485464006662369, 0.6695073246955872, 0.13877758383750916, -1.2476105690002441, -0.22624145448207855, 0.8750857710838318, 0.270008385181427, -0.16840840876102448, 0.019383441656827927, 0.28526365756988525, -0.2442617416381836, -0.03974214568734169, 1.2642927169799805, -0.20404480397701263, -0.5409104228019714, -0.22508247196674347, -0.8737627267837524, 0.06891299039125443, -0.41560298204421997, -0.2100176215171814, 0.27229225635528564, -0.6704379320144653, -0.5909054279327393, 0.24980613589286804, 0.9846204519271851, -0.024539176374673843, -0.5977514982223511, -0.4753223657608032, 0.3174791932106018, -0.9381787776947021, -1.4389307498931885, -0.5936874151229858, -0.40634459257125854, 0.13401667773723602, 0.9886184930801392, -0.29685884714126587, -0.12518948316574097, 0.28508320450782776, 0.3438277840614319, -0.014381054788827896, 0.6993690729141235, -0.20239798724651337, -0.4705996811389923, 0.37211424112319946, 0.3569188117980957, -0.0035330341197550297, -0.557562530040741, 1.4486732482910156, -0.7879985570907593, 0.27507346868515015, -0.0313541442155838, -0.08629127591848373, -0.03743189200758934, 0.4585316777229309, -0.24979689717292786, -0.43917861580848694, -0.45856451988220215, -0.11170368641614914, 0.8022708892822266, -0.8179715871810913, -0.8551604747772217, -0.05380229651927948, -0.7837820649147034, -0.10361301153898239, 0.0053756325505673885, -0.5589333772659302, 0.22737838327884674, -0.10974480956792831, -0.006438218057155609, 0.06996561586856842, 0.5912790894508362, 0.4634610116481781, 0.43233489990234375, 0.02703654207289219, 0.3480873107910156, 0.13775266706943512, -0.8224636316299438, 0.5804762840270996, 0.5361984372138977, -0.03678438812494278, 0.31667560338974, -0.301015168428421, 0.27231916785240173, 0.5671155452728271, -0.43655380606651306, 0.06695233285427094, 1.0840134620666504, -0.24012446403503418, 0.4838153123855591, -0.22240164875984192, -0.6595181226730347, -0.025988386943936348, -1.313744306564331, -1.1120777130126953, -0.9697368741035461, 0.1758531779050827, -0.7965192794799805, -0.0006842389702796936, -0.6171904802322388, -0.4171279966831207, 0.2517589032649994, 0.26418545842170715, -0.1924760937690735, -0.0651506632566452, 0.7714544534683228, 0.5123506784439087, 0.21268270909786224, 0.48587566614151, -0.12383381277322769, 0.09650973975658417, 0.6870111227035522, -0.5215131640434265, -0.9116411209106445, -0.3101848065853119, 0.48510393500328064, 0.46246859431266785, -0.06489717215299606, -0.967734694480896, 0.02117418684065342, -0.6075111627578735, -0.603294849395752, -0.47833219170570374, 0.5126520991325378, -0.04678318277001381, -0.3154487609863281, -0.5263222455978394, 0.11028826981782913, 0.744489312171936, 0.1826072782278061, 0.2557941973209381, -1.2756154537200928, -0.4088228642940521, 0.32465624809265137, 0.41358670592308044, -0.1381988674402237, 0.3485592007637024, 0.3073314428329468, 0.3832046389579773, -0.15123970806598663, 0.3345925211906433, 0.5675263404846191, 0.5555274486541748, -0.5951240658760071, 0.37701472640037537, 0.021652888506650925, 0.0985962301492691, 0.6803525686264038, 0.1142924502491951, -0.1731901466846466, 0.2833399474620819, 0.094892218708992, -0.04938827455043793, -0.20932935178279877, -0.3752177655696869, -0.024163175374269485, 0.26754599809646606, -0.6465023159980774, 0.5754398107528687, 0.4989619851112366, 0.6957586407661438, 0.9466859102249146, -0.09688166528940201, 0.4087371826171875, -1.0236570835113525, -0.5855329036712646, 0.47383761405944824, 0.281745970249176, 0.9456455707550049, -0.36334431171417236, 0.3179008662700653, -0.1405346542596817, 0.44438794255256653, 0.3290634751319885, -0.1776852011680603, 0.852078914642334, -0.5046742558479309, -0.060671065002679825, -0.6362237334251404, 0.8118022680282593, 0.11081883311271667, -0.26196202635765076, 0.17089176177978516, -0.2650805115699768, -0.37271443009376526, 0.33326035737991333, 0.27181926369667053, -0.5439947247505188, 1.4622704982757568, -0.37882399559020996, -0.2521897256374359, 0.128413125872612, -0.5507087707519531, -0.1730419248342514, 0.1675988733768463, 0.8466466665267944, -0.7121835350990295, 0.6123359203338623, -0.08801139891147614, 0.9058239459991455, 0.15261243283748627, 0.7022719383239746, 0.739435076713562, -0.47717389464378357, 0.3447452783584595, 0.2666771709918976, 0.2935613691806793, -0.036574169993400574, -0.2486213594675064, -0.47545433044433594, -0.503466784954071, -0.09484147280454636, 0.09221552312374115, 0.3380812406539917, -0.6065234541893005, -0.5216768383979797, 0.32324469089508057, -0.0502748005092144, -0.6425682306289673, -1.1982331275939941, -0.2975742220878601, -0.3105754852294922, -0.4768543541431427, 0.051811035722494125, -0.0909445509314537, 0.08808077126741409, -0.41205811500549316, 0.07070868462324142, -0.6593800187110901, -0.5274189710617065, 0.025815127417445183, -0.40954136848449707, 0.17582114040851593, 0.428993284702301, -0.6182039976119995, -0.43711987137794495, -1.3843259811401367, 0.01418526004999876, 0.005943105090409517, 0.010377779603004456, -0.8323740363121033, -0.013306735083460808, 0.3351256549358368, 0.41122162342071533, -0.003369530662894249, -0.001567379105836153, 0.1930919885635376, 0.22180140018463135, 0.9532905220985413, -0.6413679122924805, 0.47119706869125366, -0.2651568055152893, -0.5991520285606384, 0.2130495309829712, 0.08887386322021484, 0.4625127911567688, 0.02010292373597622, -0.48856446146965027, 0.2579687833786011, 0.7781611084938049, 0.25819534063339233, -1.0512433052062988, 0.3299981951713562, 0.74761563539505, -0.7353650331497192, -0.7142384052276611, -0.8375318050384521, -0.48994889855384827, -0.7471482753753662, 1.3148972988128662, 0.1111660972237587, 0.19466254115104675, -0.10063803195953369, -0.31536129117012024, 0.5373662710189819, -0.9516599774360657, 3.863129138946533, 1.021266222000122, 0.2604433298110962, -0.05531524121761322, 0.6424083709716797, 0.6968833208084106, 0.6573824286460876, -0.3190687298774719, 0.19033585488796234, -0.8975599408149719, 0.260485976934433, 0.8093258142471313, -0.13969556987285614, -0.3048526346683502, -0.1501501053571701, 0.1896834522485733, -1.0051449537277222, -0.07466461509466171, -0.27436742186546326, -1.3203850984573364, -0.8854213356971741, 0.35532358288764954, 0.032412149012088776, 0.15370269119739532, -0.24585431814193726, -0.15967686474323273, 0.7831777930259705, -0.19510290026664734, 0.5381968021392822, 0.14154094457626343, 0.03797069191932678, -0.41296637058258057, 0.4833138883113861, -1.2786074876785278, -0.2960549592971802, -0.05211682990193367, 0.4600221812725067, -0.8131200075149536, 0.4941522777080536, -0.3527257740497589, -0.00874052569270134, -0.16014830768108368, 1.027445673942566, -0.40248292684555054, -0.16036038100719452, -0.15507382154464722, -0.7839717268943787, 0.06523287296295166, -0.26570236682891846, -0.20268648862838745, 0.794227659702301, -0.7992998957633972, 0.05945804342627525, 0.3294445276260376, -0.7410901784896851, -0.9194273948669434, -0.7151637077331543, -1.0378096103668213, 1.5038731098175049, 0.44041502475738525, 1.1116026639938354, -0.030264226719737053, -0.34821245074272156, -0.1797996163368225, 0.37177690863609314, 0.4995305836200714, 0.22885961830615997, 0.2133920043706894, -0.19001692533493042, -0.6873605847358704, 0.5167514085769653, -0.3892311155796051, -0.5381723642349243, 0.001381393987685442, 0.6300829648971558, 0.17339327931404114, 0.10304520279169083, 0.9963053464889526, -0.4058176577091217, -0.7722169160842896, 0.5312053561210632, 0.928409218788147, 0.6710593700408936, -0.4435795247554779, 0.471067875623703, 1.1461513042449951, -0.4791436493396759, -0.5222217440605164, -0.666157066822052, 0.42345935106277466, 1.264864206314087, 0.3149859607219696, -0.3980349004268646, 0.5249316692352295, -0.21827378869056702 ]
{"Title": "Rate and predictors of Treatment Failure among pediatric population taking Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy in Ethiopia", "Authors": "Getaneh Yimam, Yizengaw Ajanaw, Likie Agajie, Getahun Mulusew, Feleke Altaye, Kidane Eleni, Yilma Amelework, Mulugeta Achamyeleh, Moshago Tezera, Assefa Yibeltal", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Though the unprecedented global effort at scaling up universal access to antiretroviral therapy (ART) has decreased the progression of HIV, treatment failure (TF) among pediatric patients receiving ART against human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is becoming a global public health concern which may impact on treatment outcome. Thus, the aim of this study was to determine the rate and predictors of treatment failure (TF) among HIV-infected pediatric patients taking ART in Ethiopia. Methods A prospective and retrospective follow-up study was conducted from March 2016 to 2017. Retrospective clinical and laboratory data were captured from patients\u2019 medical record. Socio-demographics and explanatory variables of participants were collected using pre-tested structured questionnaire and study participants were followed for three to six month after baseline viral load has been done to classify virologic failure (VF). TF was ascertained from population who virally failed with the denominator of population taking ART. Chi-square test and multiple logistic regressions were conducted to assess predictors TF. Statistical significance was set at P-value less than 0.05. Results A total of 554 pediatrics patients taking ART from 40 selected health facilities were included in the study. Viral load suppression (VLS) (VL<1000 copies/ml) among pediatric population taking ART in Ethiopia were found to be 344 (62.1%). From those who was not virally suppressed at baseline of the study 210 (37.9%), 99 (51.6%) were re-suppressed after three to six month of enhanced adherence and counseling, leading the overall virologic failure (VF) among pediatric population taking ART in Ethiopia to be 93 (17.3%). The mean CD4 count was improved from 490 cells/ml at ART initiation to 921 cells/ml after 80 months of ART exposure. Moreover, the clinical outcome was improved from 42% to 89% at ART initiation and after 80 month of ART experience. CD4 count, clinical stage, Hemoglobin and weight were found to be predictors of VF. Moreover; family HIV and disclosure status, duration on ART, age, being orphan, stigma and medication adherence have significant association with VF. Conclusions The low level of VLS (62.1%) and the high level of VF (18.3%) could explain the challenge on the national ART program among pediatric population. The significant improvement on immunologic and clinical outcome could indicate the success of ART on treatment outcome among pediatric population. CD4 count, clinical stage, Hemoglobin and weight could be good predictors of TF among pediatric population. Improving disclosure status, stigma and medication adherence could improve the treatment outcome of pediatric population taking ART in Ethiopia.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005538"}
10.1101/19004812
[ 0.19669492542743683, -0.18050622940063477, -0.04167688637971878, 0.7908098697662354, -0.33140432834625244, -0.1559157520532608, 0.14366415143013, -0.06356212496757507, 0.14625297486782074, 0.3356706500053406, -0.39824676513671875, -0.5638600587844849, 0.299663782119751, 0.17962881922721863, -0.32069888710975647, 0.11526960879564285, -0.3468115031719208, -0.14372944831848145, -0.5969252586364746, 0.526465117931366, 0.38694602251052856, 0.13855482637882233, -0.7805742621421814, 0.37661850452423096, -0.22450679540634155, 0.6878868937492371, 0.028427334502339363, -0.02514207549393177, 1.501534104347229, 0.4684486985206604, -0.4862062633037567, -0.16206462681293488, 0.2163226455450058, -1.2551960945129395, 0.07167986780405045, -0.061199724674224854, 0.45465871691703796, -0.06542959064245224, -0.6215484142303467, -0.4255827069282532, 0.4375750422477722, 0.0500364750623703, 0.2633149027824402, 0.293439656496048, -0.7817299365997314, -0.0830351933836937, -0.45501723885536194, -0.3377644717693329, -0.04571455344557762, 0.621872067451477, 0.032389577478170395, -0.07462368160486221, 0.757878303527832, -0.09908710420131683, -0.3466026782989502, 0.14593715965747833, 0.25238892436027527, 0.23144254088401794, -0.8321273922920227, 0.05867656692862511, -0.1316751390695572, 0.1103443056344986, 0.5865442156791687, -1.5325597524642944, 0.7792647480964661, 0.489258348941803, -0.4429382085800171, -0.04313004016876221, -0.8403566479682922, -0.31768620014190674, -0.5602501034736633, 0.10401052236557007, -0.35541319847106934, -0.21083052456378937, -0.3324531018733978, -1.0075775384902954, 0.44191691279411316, -0.29987096786499023, -0.459367960691452, -0.14939160645008087, 0.3130950927734375, 0.29644495248794556, 0.5873560309410095, 0.17801697552204132, -0.4150192141532898, 0.05299345403909683, 0.5113949179649353, 0.27304965257644653, 0.5375632047653198, 0.8619090914726257, -0.18321748077869415, 0.01780046708881855, -0.12009789794683456, -0.11247646808624268, -0.27711328864097595, 0.776972234249115, -0.7142802476882935, -0.31103622913360596, 0.218173548579216, -0.05032644048333168, 1.273067593574524, 0.27605587244033813, -0.6984619498252869, 0.9204901456832886, -0.3722645342350006, 0.7010641098022461, 0.5286048650741577, -0.273151695728302, -0.8599961996078491, -0.2557446360588074, 0.964338481426239, -0.14499247074127197, -0.5385892987251282, 0.6529322862625122, 0.9866440892219543, 0.5782209038734436, -0.23322728276252747, 0.9035685658454895, -0.08418861031532288, -0.3399760127067566, -0.13194960355758667, 0.34937143325805664, 1.166879415512085, -0.026838164776563644, 0.8191404938697815, 0.06231551989912987, 0.058324288576841354, 0.4579043686389923, -0.7354273200035095, -0.1373124122619629, 0.31569167971611023, -0.5197390913963318, 0.0973249152302742, 0.2069840133190155, -0.5402202606201172, -0.05627619847655296, 0.3685288727283478, 1.0295482873916626, 0.7786164879798889, -0.4071727693080902, 0.22852662205696106, 0.7717480659484863, -1.232069969177246, 1.058293342590332, -0.02929939515888691, 0.6832222938537598, -0.6536925435066223, -1.3390288352966309, -1.1139743328094482, 0.12465454638004303, -0.4902368485927582, 0.6131917834281921, -0.25383302569389343, -0.14124304056167603, 0.4268370568752289, 0.2666100263595581, -0.9064463973045349, -0.15708136558532715, -0.037966419011354446, -0.017160717397928238, -1.0399705171585083, -0.5641013979911804, 0.15894053876399994, 0.7813122868537903, -0.10826731473207474, 0.7785279750823975, -0.5947854518890381, 0.4318135976791382, 0.6860477924346924, -0.40973272919654846, 1.3805245161056519, -0.20315809547901154, -0.8390044569969177, 0.5567240715026855, -0.1508689969778061, 0.7844428420066833, 0.4591432809829712, -0.10472846031188965, 0.5375405550003052, 0.8151943683624268, -0.1413872092962265, 1.0513705015182495, -0.06282109022140503, 0.15067510306835175, -0.05464407056570053, 0.08559710532426834, -0.008393479511141777, -0.44992929697036743, -0.3249659836292267, -0.5286300182342529, -0.32599392533302307, 0.25537240505218506, -0.5681709051132202, 0.8412604331970215, -0.09468769282102585, -0.8199611306190491, -0.8540079593658447, 0.23197053372859955, 0.16042454540729523, -0.4669314920902252, -0.5062245726585388, 0.2044200301170349, 0.17857442796230316, 0.31083327531814575, -0.09512931108474731, 0.6422153115272522, -0.4193333387374878, -0.13715603947639465, -0.5118943452835083, 0.5808877944946289, 1.1287981271743774, -0.029534846544265747, -0.35471177101135254, -0.5499712824821472, 0.3390744626522064, -0.03234008699655533, 0.030400725081562996, 0.34863391518592834, -1.0540380477905273, 0.30773887038230896, 0.19170570373535156, -0.3681636154651642, 0.4944227337837219, 0.2718014121055603, -0.06346507370471954, -0.2903265058994293, 0.2605394124984741, 0.7405708432197571, -0.4857805371284485, -0.3047931492328644, -0.14222389459609985, 0.8812414407730103, -0.0749787911772728, 0.9382392168045044, 0.8992084264755249, 0.6515260338783264, -0.006132034584879875, 0.7452900409698486, 0.43049126863479614, 0.5269636511802673, 0.7742854952812195, 0.7311563491821289, 0.18848764896392822, 0.22593766450881958, -0.16459113359451294, 0.7124394774436951, -0.2199583649635315, -0.4770042896270752, 0.23836930096149445, 0.2687571346759796, -0.05085214599967003, 0.6927236914634705, 0.4515435993671417, 0.8516853451728821, -0.8119369149208069, -0.33073046803474426, 0.3639364242553711, -0.3087227940559387, -0.2385469675064087, -0.3020855188369751, -0.32277610898017883, -0.00979413092136383, -0.6740919351577759, -0.3729667365550995, 1.3410464525222778, 1.0723588466644287, -0.0660826563835144, -0.11304043233394623, 0.33710241317749023, -0.46067431569099426, -0.9388695359230042, -0.5402805805206299, -1.6252260208129883, -0.4748948812484741, -0.582186758518219, 0.24693626165390015, 0.004916610661894083, -0.20488464832305908, 0.3162042796611786, 0.4824284017086029, -0.0025400358717888594, 0.0428462028503418, 0.23306718468666077, 0.7038871049880981, 0.9461588263511658, -0.301264226436615, -0.28463757038116455, 0.015694312751293182, 0.41789373755455017, 0.24904552102088928, -0.07937967032194138, -0.5554540753364563, -0.48302409052848816, -1.0629045963287354, 0.4404084086418152, -0.36563605070114136, 0.06434851139783859, 0.19728019833564758, -0.4198782444000244, -0.02549588307738304, 0.17735497653484344, 0.15983600914478302, -0.8748698234558105, -0.5687499642372131, -1.0084903240203857, 0.10804983973503113, 0.28144940733909607, 0.35149085521698, 0.5553224086761475, 0.36851435899734497, -0.30393821001052856, 0.4881400167942047, 0.5109705924987793, 0.33473634719848633, -1.1291120052337646, -0.32457125186920166, 0.8125501871109009, -0.07721686363220215, 0.05015508458018303, -0.5050275325775146, -1.5233429670333862, 0.2320738285779953, 0.016366293653845787, -0.42339813709259033, 0.3390633761882782, 0.49011605978012085, 0.6637737154960632, -0.9830178618431091, 0.4135013520717621, -0.21415826678276062, -1.2003955841064453, -0.02557789534330368, -0.040932122617959976, -0.3098016679286957, 0.5275944471359253, 0.21078671514987946, -0.3202943205833435, 0.17711780965328217, -0.24850288033485413, 0.3792627453804016, -0.2639048397541046, -0.528364896774292, 0.31505900621414185, 0.47218841314315796, 0.01756899617612362, 0.15845656394958496, 0.9310088753700256, -0.4724584221839905, -0.05341527238488197, 0.43048515915870667, -0.08610576391220093, -0.09378177672624588, 0.7930111885070801, 0.3702230751514435, -0.6235186457633972, 1.2222654819488525, -0.07218120247125626, 0.02109442465007305, 0.017522133886814117, 0.7774124145507812, 0.11207534372806549, 0.21973145008087158, 0.06214505806565285, -0.11262273788452148, -0.40344321727752686, -0.6416060328483582, 0.6054402589797974, 0.12494786083698273, 0.7567964792251587, 0.2748451828956604, 0.7341062426567078, 0.2762722373008728, -0.6438522934913635, 0.228009894490242, -0.048967454582452774, 0.04803600162267685, 0.8164030313491821, 0.5437922477722168, 1.1606541872024536, -1.4308074712753296, 0.04536556825041771, 1.195364236831665, 1.0545381307601929, 0.12005309015512466, -0.23142163455486298, 0.3076442778110504, -0.7680612802505493, -0.05111001431941986, 0.10994916409254074, -0.2844727039337158, 0.18247781693935394, 0.4660187363624573, 0.3067331910133362, 0.2222166359424591, -0.5648978352546692, -0.7900181412696838, 0.4354890286922455, 0.34387898445129395, 0.532309353351593, -0.0215263944119215, 1.2720274925231934, 0.01462475210428238, 0.390365332365036, 0.12854696810245514, 0.2334137260913849, 0.46037110686302185, -0.23064982891082764, -0.2213948667049408, 0.15171895921230316, -0.8752158880233765, -0.17028704285621643, -0.754795253276825, -0.40431734919548035, -0.30686432123184204, 0.13955730199813843, -0.03281509131193161, -0.4299650192260742, -0.22825118899345398, -0.42552727460861206, -0.47494301199913025, 0.13143454492092133, 0.28425315022468567, -0.9260261058807373, 0.06211958825588226, 0.5662205815315247, 0.1902654767036438, -0.23610654473304749, -0.4296568036079407, -0.1354742795228958, 0.47561588883399963, -0.7477143406867981, -0.9363465905189514, -0.5936154127120972, 0.08395681530237198, -0.43681541085243225, -0.3110857903957367, -0.01813010312616825, -0.5352732539176941, 0.2436881959438324, -0.5109548568725586, -0.3963847756385803, -0.712765097618103, -0.15998110175132751, -0.3915650546550751, 0.48637333512306213, -0.23041395843029022, 1.0224311351776123, 0.17240221798419952, 0.0039676483720541, -0.12572380900382996, 0.12032201886177063, -0.6979888081550598, 0.5751137733459473, -0.6189799904823303, -0.6706291437149048, -0.002168097300454974, -0.47536301612854004, -0.15420715510845184, -0.43923279643058777, -0.3997756838798523, -0.45313921570777893, 0.1833799034357071, -0.12564319372177124, -0.05182048678398132, -0.5461809635162354, 0.977392315864563, -0.14867419004440308, 0.6171916723251343, 1.2528972625732422, -0.4716648757457733, -0.19903364777565002, 0.5307959318161011, 0.1509823352098465, -0.7423020005226135, 0.2214517444372177, 0.07979235053062439, -0.1780310869216919, 0.34585079550743103, -0.35408779978752136, -0.06947121024131775, -0.580050528049469, 0.6801481246948242, -0.13233128190040588, -0.35272765159606934, -0.13863474130630493, -0.3370777368545532, -0.40297797322273254, 0.03688835725188255, -1.18824303150177, 0.033487431704998016, -0.19504010677337646, -0.539012610912323, -0.0936620831489563, 0.08369819074869156, -0.6211339235305786, -0.6007330417633057, -0.2584724724292755, 0.2012697458267212, -0.18194599449634552, 0.10733407735824585, 0.6636448502540588, -0.5831454396247864, -0.7494005560874939, 0.1835007220506668, 0.5636397004127502, -0.8088110685348511, -0.5897927284240723, 0.3961701989173889, -0.1540253609418869, -0.43843692541122437, -0.32624900341033936, 0.34729334712028503, -0.8383165597915649, -0.6175041198730469, -0.25298261642456055, 0.5350126028060913, 0.45627328753471375, -0.08261574804782867, -0.15340062975883484, 0.630513608455658, 0.03256504237651825, -0.42201438546180725, -0.4135819673538208, 0.695263683795929, 0.6764832735061646, 0.4077863395214081, -0.19598256051540375, -0.6716968417167664, -0.06189613416790962, -0.5246829390525818, 0.3536857068538666, -0.7227195501327515, 0.009540070779621601, -0.19998545944690704, -0.4369158446788788, 0.3473547101020813, 0.38428542017936707, -0.1485615074634552, 0.5490063428878784, 0.3871268928050995, -0.47045889496803284, 0.9533328413963318, -0.3190940320491791, 0.08466098457574844, -0.1518540382385254, -0.1572388857603073, 0.3508978486061096, 0.8450170159339905, 0.15736950933933258, -0.40161725878715515, -0.05276557430624962, 0.08382222801446915, 1.4044021368026733, 0.0223151296377182, -0.8931231498718262, -0.651164710521698, 0.17031869292259216, 0.5025633573532104, -0.5657702684402466, -0.0719289630651474, -1.329688310623169, 0.4440080523490906, -0.06263556331396103, 0.3345926105976105, 0.8285562992095947, -0.2487737238407135, 0.20449452102184296, -0.7343657612800598, 1.2813456058502197, -0.7566017508506775, -0.19778059422969818, -0.0031717652454972267, -0.061149273067712784, 0.38304606080055237, -0.5035920143127441, -0.042672980576753616, -1.0580401420593262, -1.1033228635787964, -1.2546977996826172, 0.29709112644195557, 0.008194373920559883, 0.13849519193172455, 0.8690680861473083, 0.24684356153011322, -0.38615691661834717, -0.30799105763435364, 1.0120010375976562, 0.8678143620491028, -0.666678786277771, -0.448566734790802, 0.03251948580145836, -0.06990911066532135, 0.4497371315956116, -0.8015576601028442, -0.41431158781051636, -0.7332379817962646, -0.2798239588737488, 0.29256466031074524, -0.21942147612571716, -0.9076377749443054, -0.01697542704641819, 0.27676525712013245, 1.06137216091156, 0.19435368478298187, -0.041854359209537506, -0.057612042874097824, -0.2497943937778473, -0.6386685967445374, 0.6830872893333435, -0.5118910670280457, 0.2395792454481125, 0.7138034105300903, -0.10859113186597824, 0.22854973375797272, 0.6392610669136047, -0.19175562262535095, 0.18404515087604523, 0.29284989833831787, 1.133023977279663, 0.6072622537612915, -1.3608051538467407, 0.7562187910079956, 0.541172206401825, -0.8772568106651306, -0.8221848011016846, -0.06491470336914062, -0.740667462348938, -0.853223979473114, 0.0499517060816288, -0.5082253217697144, 0.5641299486160278, -0.5369860529899597, 0.834340512752533, -0.13588817417621613, -0.07113194465637207, -0.157876655459404, -0.30414697527885437, 0.09657615423202515, -0.8310126066207886, 0.15840187668800354, 0.8597862720489502, -0.8895596265792847, 0.509173572063446, 0.33873841166496277, 0.146815225481987, 0.21795669198036194, 0.28647392988204956, 0.13937708735466003, -0.24138380587100983, -0.38724157214164734, -0.8241310119628906, 0.008661902509629726, -0.11397791653871536, 0.5290601253509521, -0.06931550055742264, 0.15187226235866547, 0.93548583984375, -0.5027796626091003, -0.693393349647522, 1.2274585962295532, 0.4637533724308014, 0.09380081295967102, 0.1535799503326416, 0.403988778591156, 0.6481780409812927, -0.31396356225013733, 0.4374998211860657, -0.4046420454978943, -0.13193729519844055, -0.37703993916511536, -0.3170397877693176, -0.1523311585187912, -1.1357303857803345, -0.1953350454568863, 0.28870269656181335, -0.33978164196014404, -0.6692796349525452, -0.44658294320106506, 0.36829400062561035, 0.14656689763069153, -0.8873175382614136, -0.46644121408462524, 0.09361088275909424, -0.9700981378555298, -1.0962872505187988, -0.00876636989414692, -0.5792461633682251, -0.2438538670539856, 1.6459252834320068, -0.263491690158844, -0.6658733487129211, 0.08069641143083572, 0.47135481238365173, -0.24300922453403473, 0.8868820667266846, -0.6156117916107178, -0.9499545693397522, -0.521302342414856, 0.2617168724536896, 0.09364469349384308, -0.028030697256326675, 0.9385291934013367, -0.42010748386383057, 0.8521752953529358, 0.385532945394516, -0.31087756156921387, -0.5145055055618286, -0.07953745871782303, -0.21143659949302673, -0.2632157504558563, -0.5566446781158447, 0.06182291731238365, 0.677859365940094, -1.269687294960022, -0.680700421333313, -0.8634840250015259, -1.3389898538589478, -0.29385995864868164, 0.8322713971138, -0.3756825625896454, 0.5368947386741638, -0.20443372428417206, -0.01207786612212658, 0.015073523856699467, 0.13225114345550537, 0.42169180512428284, -0.40618667006492615, 0.17090116441249847, -0.7230364084243774, 0.1419132500886917, -0.9040865898132324, 0.25600099563598633, 0.5656585097312927, -0.2709527611732483, 0.05702462047338486, -0.048939526081085205, 0.4705706834793091, 0.46859675645828247, -0.3460378348827362, -0.17508816719055176, 0.5720348954200745, 0.01471881102770567, 0.45904678106307983, -0.12125489115715027, -0.5301080346107483, -0.536588728427887, -1.1168429851531982, -0.5589561462402344, -0.26768216490745544, 0.6491373777389526, -0.9395027756690979, 0.19056522846221924, -0.5372039079666138, -0.5977720618247986, 0.03132869675755501, 0.4077518582344055, 0.038634564727544785, -0.12601162493228912, 0.7238368988037109, 0.0937468558549881, -0.05751536041498184, 0.2839849293231964, -0.03521227464079857, 0.3207068145275116, 0.37851443886756897, -0.8282776474952698, -0.7086886167526245, 0.10722695291042328, 0.6890240907669067, 0.15104727447032928, 0.0757003054022789, -0.6679031848907471, -0.07765712589025497, -0.2533096671104431, -0.6329367756843567, 0.1655212640762329, 0.38445791602134705, -0.08009298890829086, -0.14989212155342102, -0.5713056921958923, 0.2865087687969208, -0.07617990672588348, 0.03758975863456726, -0.0013280218699947, -1.0409517288208008, 0.24418190121650696, -0.32422304153442383, 0.3967059254646301, -0.24123767018318176, 0.6446216106414795, 0.35480427742004395, 0.4412008821964264, -0.2863669693470001, 0.036256782710552216, 0.163609579205513, 0.647743284702301, -0.24117781221866608, 0.26334425806999207, 0.2507341504096985, 0.5709271430969238, 0.6241050958633423, 0.981505274772644, -0.217624232172966, 0.09867388755083084, 0.6948338150978088, 0.4960053563117981, -0.11210675537586212, -0.24940195679664612, -0.024928977712988853, 0.8228240013122559, -0.7575244903564453, 0.38211384415626526, 0.6702303886413574, 0.9218451380729675, -0.04450375586748123, -0.07066336274147034, 0.5090929269790649, -1.007827639579773, -0.044958483427762985, 0.46306106448173523, 0.3495538830757141, 0.8097131252288818, 0.06848553568124771, 0.4706660509109497, 0.23570875823497772, 0.530475378036499, 0.009719890542328358, 0.659064531326294, 0.5207840800285339, -0.6325198411941528, -0.4339495301246643, -0.9588682055473328, 0.4148994982242584, -0.13984686136245728, -0.09217260777950287, 0.14200249314308167, -0.7393484115600586, -0.06832794845104218, 0.614878237247467, -0.5612569451332092, -0.4441646933555603, 1.2526143789291382, -0.2057150900363922, -0.12276291847229004, 0.0002116606046911329, -0.08754440397024155, -0.05415525287389755, -0.0624338798224926, 0.5067209601402283, -0.857523500919342, 0.29047080874443054, 0.5584574937820435, 0.8686113953590393, 1.071983814239502, 0.23668187856674194, 0.6664170026779175, -0.47302788496017456, -0.10450930148363113, 0.4705718755722046, 0.46762070059776306, -0.08454930037260056, -0.5131173133850098, 0.1750698685646057, -0.6411110758781433, -0.45244765281677246, -0.27817580103874207, 0.3111601769924164, -0.4779300093650818, -0.5088114142417908, 0.788817286491394, 0.06428327411413193, -0.22523824870586395, -0.5714846253395081, -0.18042145669460297, 0.017539070919156075, 0.018180357292294502, -0.45691317319869995, -0.23311516642570496, 0.6224546432495117, -0.14232878386974335, -0.2498575896024704, -0.7033611536026001, -0.6123005747795105, 0.17807693779468536, -1.1250495910644531, 0.2644483745098114, 0.30256178975105286, 0.14089490473270416, -0.906376838684082, -1.785965085029602, -0.06404737383127213, -0.35045838356018066, -0.3187388479709625, -0.8603078722953796, 0.20194029808044434, 0.24309933185577393, 0.5980690121650696, 0.49928295612335205, 0.48512616753578186, 0.25587543845176697, 0.18132281303405762, 0.983860969543457, -0.7576315402984619, 0.4412359893321991, -0.3883483111858368, 0.10793216526508331, 0.25670498609542847, 0.06358008086681366, -0.47643375396728516, -0.0915268063545227, -0.23612388968467712, -0.31599438190460205, 0.28837811946868896, -0.47315511107444763, -1.1305571794509888, 0.9828230738639832, 0.5768186450004578, -0.4048153758049011, -1.0302135944366455, 0.014281907118856907, 0.07379704713821411, -0.5804347395896912, 0.2376088798046112, -0.3679564893245697, 0.0034617192577570677, -0.06069387122988701, -0.06992023438215256, 0.6032631993293762, -0.8471320867538452, 3.9421842098236084, 1.2746831178665161, 0.7387495040893555, 0.46132567524909973, 0.3724963963031769, 0.402632474899292, 0.45662009716033936, -0.00714742299169302, 0.011047077365219593, -0.4936196208000183, 0.109468974173069, 1.0457110404968262, 0.20737431943416595, 0.03626903519034386, 0.19144771993160248, 0.24597138166427612, -0.9839397668838501, 0.05147671326994896, 0.5431832671165466, -1.1988857984542847, -0.5282096266746521, 0.5233153104782104, -0.591153085231781, 0.02079596184194088, 0.6807694435119629, 0.1854969710111618, 0.5211738348007202, -0.21146215498447418, -0.18897587060928345, -0.537135124206543, 0.11719372868537903, -0.6831300854682922, 0.45106759667396545, -0.5837050676345825, -0.3919293284416199, 0.14171119034290314, 0.030191855505108833, -0.7467204928398132, 0.17326907813549042, 0.10426249355077744, -0.03500157594680786, -0.4923774302005768, -0.2697848379611969, -0.25216418504714966, -0.5726920962333679, -0.07095354050397873, -0.8708641529083252, 0.042822763323783875, 0.11505681276321411, -0.039516132324934006, 0.5614596009254456, -1.0049748420715332, 0.23280037939548492, -0.1568593531847, -0.6237381100654602, -0.3513316810131073, -0.13160142302513123, -0.8633779883384705, 0.7487499713897705, 0.5785913467407227, 1.2289994955062866, -0.15086622536182404, -0.29148849844932556, -0.3616945743560791, 0.8565042614936829, 0.2561824917793274, 0.7050037384033203, 0.4943434000015259, -0.1838829070329666, -0.58659827709198, 0.2990301847457886, -0.2757011353969574, -0.4585438370704651, 0.04776008799672127, 0.6209766268730164, 0.42362308502197266, -0.3444972336292267, 1.010285496711731, -0.20828990638256073, -0.5927498936653137, 0.3559657037258148, 0.1627810299396515, 0.10651908814907074, -0.9161903262138367, 0.7047306299209595, 0.7536089420318604, -0.23848988115787506, -0.2008604258298874, -1.1526832580566406, 0.7480409145355225, 0.7916319966316223, -0.2511128783226013, -0.009662467986345291, 0.4816327691078186, -0.01324272621423006 ]
{"Title": "Association of Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms with Dyslipidemia in Antiretroviral Exposed HIV Patients: A Case-Control Study in a Ghanaian population", "Authors": "Obirikorang Christian, Acheampong Emmanuel, Quaye Lawrence, Yorke Joseph, Amos-Abanyie Ernestine Kubi, Akyaw Priscilla Abena, Anto Enoch Odame, Bani Simon Bannison, Asamoah Evans Adu, Batu Emmanuella Nsenbah", "Abstract": "Abstract Dyslipidemia is a potential complication of long-term usage of antiretroviral therapy (ART) and also known to be associated with genetic factors. The host genetic variants associated with dyslipidemia HIV patients on ART in Ghana have not been fully explored. A total of 289 HIV-infected patients on stable ART for at least a year and 104 age-matched controls with no history of HIV and dyslipidemia were recruited for the study. Fasting blood was collected into EDTA for lipids measurements. Lipid profiles were determined as a measure of dyslipidemia. There was a significant difference in case-control prevalence for dyslipidemia (31.4% vs. 18.3%, p=0.013). Four candidate Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) from four genes (ABCA1-rs2066714, LDLR-rs6511720, APOA5-rs662799 and DSCAML1-rs10892151) were determined. Genotyping was performed on isolated genomic DNA of study participants using PCR followed by a multiplex Ligation Detection Reaction (LDR). Significantly increased levels of total cholesterol (TC) low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) and triglycerides [TG] were observed in protease inhibitor-based (PI) treated case subjects compared to non-PI-based case subjects. The population frequency of homozygotes for the rare alleles rs6511720 (T/T), rs2066714 (G/G), rs10892151 (T/T) and rs662799 (G/G) were 3.6%, 9.6%, 6.4% and 6.0%, respectively. Adjusted analysis controlling for age, gender and duration of treatment revealed that rare homozygous genotypes for APOA5 (G/G) [aOR=18.74(5.65-54.73), p<0.0001], ABCA1 (G/G) [aOR=3.94(0.86 \u221217.38), p=0.033] and DSCAML1 (T/T) [aOR=11.46(3.651-43.56), p<0.0001) were significant factors for high TC. Subjects with the T/T genotype for DSCAML1 (rs10892151) were associated with a high likelihood of raised levels of LDL-C [aOR=3.76(1.43-8.46), p=0.033]. Furthermore, the rare homozygous genotype for ABCA1 (G/G) [aOR=5.67(3.43-13.54), p<0.0001] and LDLR (T/T) [aOR=4.46(1.86-10.56), p<0.0001) was significantly associated with hypertriglyceridemia. The study has demonstrated the presence of SNPs in four candidate genes among HIV patients exposed to ART in the Ghanaian population. SNPs were found to associate with dyslipidemia. These findings provide baseline information that necessitates a pre-symptomatic strategy for monitoring dyslipidemia in ART-treated HIV patients. There is a need for longitudinal studies to validate a comprehensive number of SNPs and its association with dyslipidemia.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19004812"}
10.1101/19005223
[ -0.3021741807460785, 0.08450596779584885, 0.0444907546043396, 0.07548089325428009, -0.6057812571525574, -0.48256686329841614, -0.015432083979249, -0.2949899435043335, -0.011184812523424625, 0.3028661608695984, -0.44386470317840576, -0.622470498085022, 0.591450035572052, -0.498727023601532, -0.42543837428092957, -0.65800940990448, -0.2694022059440613, 0.21986934542655945, -0.19378486275672913, -0.4215112030506134, 0.9143043756484985, -0.1144203320145607, -0.5881762504577637, 0.961175262928009, -0.2002326250076294, 0.5036251544952393, -0.12726257741451263, -0.2828896939754486, 1.1419754028320312, 0.41397765278816223, -0.09740113466978073, -0.44310858845710754, 0.2322341501712799, -1.603842854499817, 0.045210100710392, -0.28479135036468506, 0.7604977488517761, -0.15283063054084778, -0.4066951274871826, 0.014869257807731628, 0.4531445801258087, 0.12401214241981506, 0.11651412397623062, -0.25949937105178833, -0.5499056577682495, -0.07036738842725754, -1.1177812814712524, 0.5542289018630981, 0.03692955523729324, -0.17859771847724915, -0.19920657575130463, -0.44561299681663513, 0.14516912400722504, 0.04826970025897026, 0.11293063312768936, -0.42552629113197327, -0.20776423811912537, 0.7653200626373291, -0.5262881517410278, 0.35913488268852234, 0.48050957918167114, 0.29745030403137207, 0.3483102321624756, -0.6020148396492004, 0.9036825895309448, 0.9526153206825256, 0.3156064748764038, -0.09754708409309387, -0.656337320804596, 0.019008874893188477, -0.0493745431303978, -0.19464026391506195, -0.11562596261501312, -0.8364176750183105, -0.37875133752822876, -0.15964335203170776, 0.3917142450809479, -0.48128777742385864, 0.3683925271034241, 0.08725322782993317, 0.05691434070467949, 0.3134091794490814, 0.5424038171768188, 0.8887615203857422, -0.49944135546684265, 0.28514108061790466, 0.03737988695502281, 0.5664087533950806, 0.19791452586650848, 0.3319390118122101, 0.29543522000312805, 0.4808211028575897, -0.13356228172779083, 0.08707787841558456, 0.2079298049211502, 0.13311146199703217, -0.4691840410232544, 0.4520869553089142, 0.6000308990478516, -0.6194614768028259, 0.32794827222824097, 0.8192601203918457, 0.10288158804178238, 0.8342026472091675, -0.6372346878051758, 0.7585874199867249, 0.2492988109588623, 0.12457837909460068, -1.0164874792099, -0.5311222076416016, -0.4005852937698364, -0.5016928911209106, -0.28768107295036316, -0.14227500557899475, 0.07421353459358215, 0.5965548157691956, -0.4271198809146881, 0.8532655239105225, -0.37581929564476013, -0.17037154734134674, 0.31168195605278015, -0.3631040155887604, 0.6638195514678955, -1.2329789400100708, -0.17341582477092743, -0.3348448574542999, -0.08320346474647522, 0.4324270486831665, -0.23167946934700012, 0.26778683066368103, -0.2984153926372528, -0.5818459987640381, -0.11087194830179214, 0.06884858757257462, -0.1423140913248062, -0.6680353879928589, 0.2569611072540283, 0.6657140254974365, 0.01741005852818489, 0.03329012170433998, -0.3161930739879608, 0.8211486339569092, -0.47189247608184814, 1.0888525247573853, 0.16287733614444733, 0.8979746103286743, -0.12256509810686111, -1.2087262868881226, 0.11007808148860931, 0.038317207247018814, -0.1499721258878708, 0.5491613149642944, 0.013153650797903538, -0.35644611716270447, -0.11468449980020523, 0.29352065920829773, -0.04664982482790947, -0.09946902841329575, 0.001419939799234271, -0.2941712439060211, -0.3550294041633606, 0.4693015515804291, -0.29758724570274353, 0.45266658067703247, -0.028962261974811554, 0.23086810111999512, -0.1980457603931427, 0.621202290058136, 0.10752610117197037, -0.951511561870575, 0.18043024837970734, -0.04458574205636978, -1.096739411354065, 0.23163041472434998, -0.16373804211616516, 0.38474851846694946, 1.3003844022750854, -0.0031430756207555532, 0.005843167193233967, 0.06702705472707748, -0.06977149844169617, -0.5691037774085999, 0.08470839262008667, 1.1443411111831665, 0.27360403537750244, 0.28090426325798035, -0.7848772406578064, -0.7586371898651123, -0.5966390371322632, -0.3994987905025482, 0.1465437263250351, 0.5238642692565918, -0.8357579708099365, 0.22391143441200256, -0.33592531085014343, 0.06283886730670929, 0.25586608052253723, 1.0171314477920532, 0.7477139830589294, -0.5712081789970398, -0.881135880947113, 0.7608675360679626, -0.9644322395324707, 0.3170328140258789, 0.6680428385734558, -0.10583339631557465, -0.16630102694034576, 0.402248740196228, -0.9052748680114746, -0.17582830786705017, 0.5195357203483582, -0.21928265690803528, -0.11966273188591003, 0.27841219305992126, 0.09336118400096893, -1.1045492887496948, 0.14160491526126862, 0.28802552819252014, -0.7930746078491211, -0.0657748207449913, -0.7344793677330017, -0.6256325840950012, 0.037739284336566925, -0.05347103625535965, 0.43489953875541687, 0.5900498032569885, 0.59627765417099, 0.7469326257705688, 0.05796171352267265, -0.008523658849298954, 0.1849726438522339, 0.9039406180381775, 0.27290400862693787, 0.10206378996372223, 0.3704066872596741, 0.35104724764823914, 1.0718518495559692, 0.6111002564430237, 0.41074734926223755, 0.5441451072692871, 0.7542852759361267, 0.5641866326332092, 0.3524646759033203, -0.09673207998275757, -0.334724485874176, 0.810878574848175, -0.3968035578727722, 0.01337136048823595, -0.4680362343788147, 0.9444942474365234, -0.16212227940559387, 0.661953330039978, 0.7548293471336365, 0.537909746170044, -0.8858413696289062, -0.43125635385513306, 0.4029625654220581, 0.34303802251815796, 0.19957326352596283, -0.0997735857963562, -0.25812628865242004, -0.21964378654956818, 0.33202657103538513, 0.13831979036331177, 0.519266664981842, 0.5827111601829529, 0.539943277835846, -0.05978384241461754, 0.536274254322052, 0.02164514735341072, -1.3242734670639038, -0.8682516813278198, -0.8146498203277588, -0.8194931149482727, -0.48880627751350403, 0.5934733152389526, -0.014243547804653645, -0.44521164894104004, 0.3109391927719116, 0.48125776648521423, -0.06870714575052261, -0.5265489816665649, 0.8435648679733276, 0.5760995149612427, 0.5767925381660461, 0.48024997115135193, -0.3372001051902771, 0.08828722685575485, -0.9784469604492188, -0.03386633098125458, 0.10949215292930603, 0.023652590811252594, -0.6134489178657532, -0.6116133332252502, 0.37881341576576233, 0.13604839146137238, -0.3705868124961853, 0.6299814581871033, -0.1481490135192871, -0.031112387776374817, 0.294243723154068, -0.009372607804834843, 0.0591096356511116, -0.29303833842277527, -0.9289336204528809, 0.25234222412109375, 0.39870184659957886, 0.09194359183311462, 0.3572547733783722, -0.02444208785891533, 0.19831019639968872, 0.16691124439239502, -0.2565481960773468, 0.4591001272201538, -0.5170398354530334, 0.17999769747257233, 0.5904927849769592, -0.2480478733778, 0.2965763211250305, -0.678436815738678, -1.5470753908157349, -0.698686957359314, -0.3945280909538269, -0.7542273998260498, -0.1246085986495018, 0.4181114733219147, -0.20717599987983704, -1.2244250774383545, 0.37449049949645996, -0.7932556867599487, -0.9382981061935425, -0.11185212433338165, -0.0069197192788124084, 0.3981464207172394, 0.411803275346756, 0.4589838981628418, 0.21740476787090302, 0.32247164845466614, 0.4163311719894409, 0.018943792209029198, 0.6361004710197449, 0.0892680436372757, -1.2294714450836182, 0.5516582727432251, 0.15968450903892517, 1.038675308227539, 0.3526475429534912, -0.1950966864824295, -0.2964644730091095, -0.43543416261672974, -0.11411004513502121, -0.06517581641674042, 0.47658273577690125, 0.12419981509447098, 0.006649209186434746, 0.8713130354881287, 0.07918060570955276, -0.10012540966272354, 0.29015642404556274, -0.042177069932222366, -0.5187020301818848, -0.39108261466026306, -0.49605536460876465, 0.37164944410324097, -0.22173479199409485, -0.5916609168052673, 0.05006669834256172, -0.291959673166275, 0.23117545247077942, -0.8538944721221924, 0.5756428837776184, -0.41632282733917236, -0.377666711807251, -0.03909270465373993, 0.3179020285606384, -0.37358951568603516, 0.4882853329181671, 0.3857056498527527, 1.4080911874771118, -1.2687077522277832, 0.39215394854545593, 0.27115803956985474, 1.2147995233535767, 0.37201955914497375, -0.08025015890598297, 0.5422462224960327, -1.2719752788543701, -0.09136120975017548, -0.46134811639785767, -0.12386336922645569, -0.09629561007022858, 0.46416839957237244, 0.7632331848144531, 0.3822244107723236, -0.46685296297073364, -0.4690607488155365, -0.20686005055904388, 0.4237936735153198, 0.44718119502067566, 0.054147228598594666, 0.5964020490646362, -0.4786704480648041, 0.008857638575136662, 0.6200915575027466, 0.6469619870185852, 0.24428924918174744, -0.5519732236862183, 0.39979973435401917, 0.18554092943668365, -0.7593166828155518, -0.4728761911392212, 0.32900768518447876, -0.4165056049823761, -0.34524276852607727, 0.6773338913917542, -0.05314506217837334, -0.35903120040893555, -0.24819396436214447, 0.19850297272205353, 0.024704188108444214, 0.2357221394777298, 0.2936418652534485, -0.4861394762992859, -0.18808124959468842, 0.4910790026187897, -0.4579527676105499, 0.454851895570755, -0.4824851155281067, 0.8871285915374756, 1.2225620746612549, -0.12934616208076477, -0.9484098553657532, -0.126163050532341, 0.2592371702194214, -0.6216949224472046, 0.5133641958236694, -0.12377119064331055, -0.4669550657272339, 0.44604405760765076, 0.252000093460083, 0.1288258135318756, -0.24511849880218506, -0.5170207023620605, -0.04918212071061134, 0.17250901460647583, 0.15912361443042755, 0.9374313354492188, 0.6008418798446655, 0.8738833069801331, 0.19214004278182983, -0.09983716905117035, -0.7629364728927612, 0.41600823402404785, -0.5549476146697998, -0.44446229934692383, 0.4155701696872711, 0.3664501905441284, 0.4194950461387634, 0.5357385277748108, 0.15517248213291168, -0.14356990158557892, -0.18308565020561218, 0.07120630890130997, -0.5462981462478638, -0.2972313463687897, 1.024491548538208, -0.3380078971385956, 0.3024231493473053, 0.30839410424232483, -0.25330454111099243, -0.43310993909835815, -0.3003139793872833, 0.17146065831184387, -0.684130847454071, 0.51823890209198, -0.1582731157541275, -0.08411359041929245, 0.45348674058914185, -0.6246890425682068, -0.3124038875102997, -0.12289829552173615, 0.49927228689193726, -0.4571566879749298, -0.7243945002555847, -0.5971934199333191, -0.46829184889793396, -0.6093618869781494, -0.6413871645927429, -0.7025406360626221, 0.3357917070388794, 0.2234022319316864, -0.4750230014324188, -0.5427424311637878, 0.43915820121765137, -0.5710298418998718, -0.9275164604187012, -0.49592357873916626, -0.07281176745891571, 0.02529558353126049, 0.05291556194424629, 1.0586587190628052, -0.8016063570976257, -0.7218654155731201, -0.0445229709148407, 0.3871203362941742, -0.038866713643074036, -0.9134283661842346, 0.2799719274044037, -0.12310397624969482, -0.9771835207939148, -0.3174360394477844, 0.4511789083480835, -0.35403451323509216, -0.1170995831489563, 0.06251539289951324, 0.05954594537615776, 0.39435282349586487, 0.10184590518474579, -0.555614709854126, -0.126640185713768, -0.8016936182975769, -0.5613414645195007, -0.4829712510108948, -0.18801145255565643, 0.07678156346082687, 0.4795677661895752, 0.21367891132831573, -1.3073158264160156, -0.1251443773508072, -1.0866268873214722, 0.13836881518363953, -0.7042770981788635, 0.09092444181442261, -0.6071668863296509, 0.13005200028419495, -0.31062328815460205, 0.8923309445381165, 0.24456475675106049, 0.10465193539857864, -0.15855316817760468, -0.35305601358413696, 0.4173418879508972, 0.0900077074766159, -0.8529781699180603, 0.3258943557739258, -0.6327034831047058, -0.02591046877205372, 0.9566055536270142, -0.5032305121421814, 0.13094200193881989, -0.026597460731863976, 0.4919711947441101, 0.016990847885608673, 0.4952758848667145, -0.052555907517671585, -0.2201187014579773, 0.783757746219635, 0.7824513912200928, 0.07067488133907318, 0.6513860821723938, -0.6186731457710266, 0.35839295387268066, -0.18155570328235626, 0.10856831818819046, -0.18577982485294342, -0.3224541246891022, 0.10216385126113892, -0.25101447105407715, 1.3718065023422241, 0.056908831000328064, -0.48136696219444275, 0.023783104494214058, 0.08348193764686584, -0.18849658966064453, 0.6038417220115662, -0.6968135833740234, -0.4947323203086853, -0.9600403904914856, -1.0650492906570435, 0.6625863909721375, -0.13218924403190613, -0.2980530858039856, 0.7132793664932251, 0.07583633065223694, 0.3255637288093567, -0.8815511465072632, 0.5250763297080994, 0.23036077618598938, -0.7653099298477173, -0.7604449987411499, 0.16144846379756927, 0.33590167760849, -0.019042814150452614, 0.41257137060165405, 0.28813567757606506, -0.08990529179573059, -0.47198033332824707, -0.548427164554596, -0.2480299323797226, -0.9184988737106323, -0.07271675765514374, 0.3106813430786133, 0.7808550596237183, -0.0301715936511755, 0.3441195785999298, 0.40967535972595215, -0.38525092601776123, -0.5068042874336243, 0.2811581790447235, -0.33054032921791077, 0.4704722464084625, 0.8121070861816406, -0.07262960076332092, -0.800604522228241, -0.19791829586029053, 0.1708688884973526, 0.43456196784973145, -0.5188317894935608, 0.5305274128913879, 0.8811130523681641, -0.9965358376502991, 0.41064608097076416, 0.4536776542663574, -0.43298837542533875, -0.16096468269824982, 0.005504604894667864, -0.39435797929763794, -0.1999383121728897, 0.12235330045223236, -0.16443708539009094, 0.1617935299873352, -0.0261536817997694, 0.3647086024284363, -0.21374104917049408, -0.069640152156353, 0.4384686350822449, -0.3189604878425598, 0.6173833012580872, -0.6911670565605164, 0.03913188353180885, 0.5876795053482056, -0.8259141445159912, 0.22348415851593018, 0.27669408917427063, 0.4965105652809143, 0.24925410747528076, 0.31304827332496643, 0.45090949535369873, -0.5350885391235352, -0.27325719594955444, 0.6506848931312561, 0.3180790841579437, 0.24447467923164368, 0.027617087587714195, 0.052301257848739624, 0.48564642667770386, -0.18111151456832886, -0.7669367790222168, -0.31833451986312866, 0.3027368485927582, 0.42624977231025696, 0.5600826144218445, -0.19948309659957886, 0.5206937193870544, 0.6378470063209534, 0.34552448987960815, 0.4250229597091675, -0.5395357608795166, -0.9518468976020813, -1.024504542350769, -0.7300511598587036, -0.19882023334503174, -1.0075734853744507, 0.46874019503593445, 0.5800147652626038, -0.33172139525413513, -0.8583053350448608, -0.9877198934555054, 0.1974654197692871, -0.094366155564785, -0.7952890992164612, -0.5108199715614319, 0.6230522394180298, -0.4291122555732727, -0.4810577929019928, -0.03964104875922203, -0.7477909922599792, -0.1240440383553505, 0.8831156492233276, -1.115648865699768, -0.48992231488227844, -0.4317323565483093, 0.10535314679145813, -0.06284940242767334, 0.7728992104530334, -0.30072224140167236, -0.6362012624740601, -0.5575408339500427, 0.9755297899246216, 0.18892784416675568, -0.2791483700275421, 0.7629005312919617, 0.014714859426021576, 0.4345373213291168, 0.9197288751602173, 0.19431203603744507, -0.6043040752410889, 0.07551784068346024, 0.28898897767066956, -0.372517466545105, -0.42147114872932434, -0.12076101452112198, 0.6979394555091858, -0.9140921235084534, 0.18958500027656555, -0.46420562267303467, -0.009929967112839222, 0.6708502769470215, 0.026724956929683685, -0.29810798168182373, 0.6078188419342041, 0.22948293387889862, 0.2927532494068146, -0.046494703739881516, 0.5411593914031982, 0.17891958355903625, -0.15193048119544983, 0.7363726496696472, -0.2195678949356079, -0.1642773300409317, -0.9302344918251038, 0.6864407062530518, 0.6453831195831299, -0.30743926763534546, 0.3776630461215973, -0.2705366611480713, 0.1852247416973114, -0.08507834374904633, 0.03491733595728874, 0.7111759781837463, 0.6547299027442932, 0.2652735114097595, -0.014535506255924702, -0.36628231406211853, -0.596362292766571, -1.029540777206421, -0.46915534138679504, -0.9062621593475342, -0.743134081363678, 0.9533284306526184, -0.6332802772521973, 0.06193089485168457, -0.5908451676368713, -0.03920318931341171, 0.46972906589508057, -0.17992930114269257, 0.5686255097389221, -0.1883753538131714, 0.232948437333107, -0.42090940475463867, 0.6510037779808044, 0.24422214925289154, 0.21355625987052917, -0.289737343788147, -0.25557658076286316, -0.701155424118042, -0.09533612430095673, 0.2937845289707184, 0.6181746125221252, 0.3509005904197693, -0.22049309313297272, -0.3181692957878113, 0.21793261170387268, -0.32615894079208374, -0.6258488297462463, -0.13462646305561066, -0.0940772145986557, -0.7766819000244141, 0.2224082201719284, -0.17993572354316711, 0.0036184226628392935, -0.354111909866333, 0.14974242448806763, -0.247799813747406, -0.6512905359268188, 0.01079649105668068, 0.09364081174135208, 0.551816999912262, -0.20710253715515137, 0.6829538345336914, 0.14860031008720398, -0.07644940912723541, 0.40677475929260254, -0.011166133917868137, 0.4606441259384155, 0.6370683908462524, 0.1780708134174347, 0.06915314495563507, -0.22159947454929352, 0.5015852451324463, 0.8556144833564758, 0.7347418665885925, 0.0687139481306076, 0.1812601089477539, 0.4096629321575165, 0.35583654046058655, 0.08762534707784653, -0.552480161190033, 0.6568880081176758, 0.588756799697876, -0.10847638547420502, 0.03467601537704468, 0.4065927565097809, 0.22659018635749817, 0.6643344163894653, -0.29108744859695435, 0.017564332112669945, -0.3976578116416931, -0.7125192284584045, 0.3880862593650818, 0.4657667577266693, 1.0314327478408813, 0.33409371972084045, 0.2803436517715454, -0.1641547679901123, 0.6622017621994019, -0.2968447208404541, 0.14647753536701202, 1.0337103605270386, -0.817698061466217, -0.8254399299621582, -0.5285309553146362, 0.13753634691238403, 0.5854068398475647, -0.45380720496177673, 0.10176907479763031, -0.01052107010036707, 0.002449569059535861, 0.7380056977272034, -0.7333102822303772, -0.12366890162229538, 0.5778018236160278, -0.3562091588973999, -0.003923729527741671, -0.09243174642324448, 0.3798134922981262, -1.056457757949829, -0.13839681446552277, 0.8282403349876404, -0.8090234398841858, 0.48121756315231323, 0.09814119338989258, -0.3401767313480377, 0.7900757789611816, 0.41082751750946045, 0.5821546912193298, -0.6694725751876831, 0.5756900906562805, 0.8935097455978394, 0.4358944296836853, 0.09413816779851913, -0.41609010100364685, -0.4161798655986786, 0.038491107523441315, -0.6492916345596313, 0.10379544645547867, 0.3971194624900818, -0.6623150110244751, -0.03760972619056702, 0.08608885854482651, 0.2531454265117645, -0.4504055380821228, -1.1772550344467163, 0.29082661867141724, 0.1573641300201416, -0.06817546486854553, 0.19695763289928436, 0.20793208479881287, 0.24073980748653412, 0.3288262188434601, 0.22288160026073456, -0.7859840393066406, -0.36565518379211426, -0.4828101098537445, -0.15944790840148926, 0.6723532676696777, 0.1965155005455017, -0.4523642063140869, -0.27364978194236755, -0.9338693618774414, -0.5625378489494324, 0.257919043302536, -0.3516589105129242, -0.7459107041358948, -0.4433373808860779, 0.2839350998401642, 0.563692569732666, 0.022145794704556465, -0.513246476650238, -0.15154920518398285, -0.12318547815084457, 0.48223447799682617, 0.1273808777332306, 0.7083562612533569, -0.000331537943566218, -0.23142850399017334, -0.09088838845491409, 0.07417792826890945, -0.04117978364229202, -0.2837202250957489, -0.7069036364555359, -1.2875245809555054, 0.3976442217826843, 0.4497072994709015, -0.4828839898109436, 0.8322224020957947, 0.8297300934791565, 0.14839187264442444, -0.40009987354278564, -1.2179639339447021, -0.34144940972328186, -0.5781185626983643, 0.49253472685813904, -0.2353900521993637, -0.11413794010877609, -0.13624896109104156, -0.2302560806274414, 0.6618567109107971, -0.934371829032898, 4.229619026184082, 1.0352603197097778, 0.6418806910514832, -0.08652374893426895, 0.36432525515556335, 0.19829332828521729, 1.066218376159668, -0.6881989240646362, -0.2860914170742035, 0.7755670547485352, -0.55727219581604, 0.3696309030056, 0.4808090925216675, 0.028704175725579262, 0.7949956655502319, 0.6301841139793396, -0.7939885854721069, 0.05430515483021736, -0.008856733329594135, -0.27372464537620544, 0.013951249420642853, -0.009987488389015198, 0.2349724918603897, 0.08631237596273422, 0.6053901314735413, -0.3685687184333801, 0.04503994435071945, -0.04833460971713066, -0.37924185395240784, -0.6361021995544434, -0.14570309221744537, -0.08251851052045822, 0.4552227854728699, -0.9537863731384277, -0.5159828066825867, 0.16953732073307037, -0.15417484939098358, -0.40509191155433655, 0.42953962087631226, -0.16077493131160736, -0.1753266304731369, 0.304427832365036, 0.08085125684738159, 0.13996337354183197, -0.13695436716079712, -0.3706369400024414, -0.40820619463920593, -0.2593989074230194, 0.19256751239299774, -0.06600449979305267, 1.2077735662460327, -1.30225670337677, 0.4291515648365021, -0.18268346786499023, -0.9741151332855225, -0.19060029089450836, -0.4662077724933624, -1.1146234273910522, -0.17724724113941193, 0.2596285045146942, 0.6635742783546448, 0.36329594254493713, -0.24412228167057037, 0.14129748940467834, 0.4999680519104004, 0.0427892692387104, 0.3331998884677887, 0.2898912727832794, 0.14436466991901398, -0.5361369252204895, -0.16285406053066254, -0.34621381759643555, 0.02718261443078518, -1.3552947044372559, 0.5990129113197327, 0.1527758538722992, -0.48221275210380554, 0.4360014498233795, -0.20966273546218872, -0.5821506381034851, 0.16693326830863953, 0.1092820093035698, -0.33302557468414307, -0.30303606390953064, 0.6747751235961914, 0.6408032178878784, -0.7684900164604187, 0.29100215435028076, -1.4715975522994995, 0.5540728569030762, 0.6510688066482544, 0.029484637081623077, -0.019633520394563675, -0.08770641684532166, -0.1688874214887619 ]
{"Title": "Identifying subtypes of a stigmatized medical condition", "Authors": "Gabashvili Irene S.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Some conditions - such as obesity, depression and functional odor disorders - come with a social stigma. Understanding the etiology of these conditions helps to avoid stereotypes and find remedies. One of the major obstacles facing researchers, especially for those studying socially distressing metabolic malodor, is the difficulty in assembling biologically homogenous study cohorts. Objective The aim of this study was to examine phenotypic variance, self-reported data and laboratory tests for the purpose of identifying clinically relevant and etiologically meaningful subtypes of idiopathic body odor and the \u201cPeople are Allergic To Me\u201d (PATM) syndrome. Methods Participants with undiagnosed body odor conditions enrolled to participate in this research study initiated by a healthcare charity MEBO Research and sponsored by Wishart Research group at the Metabolomics Innovation Centre, University of Alberta, Canada. Primary outcomes were differences in metabolite concentrations measured in urine, blood and breath of test and control groups. Principal component analyses and other statistical tests were carried out for these measurements. Results While neither of existing laboratory tests could reliably predict chronic malodor symptoms, several measurements distinguished phenotypes at a significance level less than 5%. Types of malodor can be differentiated by self-reported consumption of (or sensitivity to) added sugars (p<0.01), blood alcohols after glucose challenge (especially ethanol: p<0.0005), urinary excretion of phenylalanine, putrescine, and combinations of blood or urine metabolites. Conclusions Our preliminary results suggest that malodor heterogeneity can be addressed by analyses of phenotypes based on patients\u2019 dietary and olfactory observations. Our studies highlight the need for more trials. Future research focused on comprehensive metabolomics and microbiome sequencing will play an important role in the diagnosis and treatment of malodor. Trial Registration The study discussed in the manuscript was registered as NCT02692495 at clinicaltrials.gov. The results were compared with our earlier study registered as NCT02683876.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005223"}
10.1101/19002378
[ 0.22935928404331207, 0.2312675267457962, 0.3257869482040405, 0.7138746976852417, -1.1356191635131836, -0.3602897822856903, -0.007646620273590088, 0.08591579645872116, -0.034902580082416534, 0.7769479155540466, 0.002295771613717079, -0.14348888397216797, -0.022826602682471275, -0.6668825745582581, -0.1261010318994522, 0.09341078996658325, -0.7878069877624512, -0.04443275183439255, -0.22197332978248596, -0.18131598830223083, 0.9247385263442993, 0.5021225214004517, -1.1453561782836914, 0.24705670773983002, -0.7830803394317627, 0.6356664896011353, 0.5103614926338196, 0.28836023807525635, 1.4768450260162354, 0.2483927458524704, -0.0548594705760479, -0.6727883815765381, 0.40806540846824646, -1.265296459197998, 0.1806350201368332, -0.4058234989643097, 0.5189300775527954, -0.15939654409885406, 0.04862760752439499, -0.3287324607372284, 0.3638407588005066, -0.14687232673168182, 0.2614845335483551, -0.16055624186992645, -1.2996550798416138, 0.18081510066986084, -0.3109554946422577, -0.47816282510757446, -0.17517715692520142, -0.5406166911125183, -0.649580180644989, 0.13120132684707642, -0.06307797878980637, -0.2133483737707138, 0.033686891198158264, 0.03156859800219536, -0.029276249930262566, -0.0024257092736661434, -0.2589760720729828, 0.2962605357170105, 0.1826293021440506, -0.04276573285460472, 0.46590644121170044, -1.479386329650879, 0.7267211079597473, 0.8940314650535583, 0.2313821166753769, -0.5637281537055969, -0.09465843439102173, -0.24905823171138763, -0.7195912599563599, -0.6855155229568481, 0.34391289949417114, -0.7065560221672058, -0.0008939614635892212, 0.042949605733156204, 0.2070293128490448, 0.3097967207431793, -0.25300511717796326, -0.4777872860431671, 0.5496218204498291, 0.3884807825088501, -0.46875590085983276, 1.1634135246276855, -0.4929337501525879, -0.5077905058860779, 0.20177949965000153, 0.2709691524505615, 0.5567910075187683, -0.5881062150001526, -0.6053107976913452, 0.2746737003326416, 0.5574755072593689, 0.23922720551490784, -0.2160400152206421, 0.6775015592575073, -0.49807271361351013, -0.04380113258957863, 0.6816307902336121, 0.12903262674808502, 0.8347648978233337, 0.8556506633758545, -0.2888336479663849, 0.787898063659668, -0.5960642695426941, 0.6127704977989197, 0.5651900768280029, -0.0387248694896698, -0.8945973515510559, -0.5908258557319641, 0.03085576370358467, -0.01637859269976616, 0.1135418638586998, 0.5126160383224487, 0.22511829435825348, 0.5143482089042664, -0.17708371579647064, 0.6378331780433655, -0.35035231709480286, 0.3237348794937134, -0.9134305715560913, -0.10470233857631683, 0.397940456867218, -0.047044962644577026, 0.3908364176750183, -0.05123824253678322, 0.09812832623720169, 0.6039950251579285, -0.33498385548591614, 0.29941508173942566, -0.1077156662940979, -0.5738815665245056, -0.15301629900932312, 0.9339945316314697, -0.4911697804927826, -0.26638495922088623, 0.11229387670755386, 0.4666944742202759, -0.6035797595977783, -0.4875229299068451, -0.023089107125997543, 0.1376858800649643, -1.047066569328308, 1.1831096410751343, -0.08235064893960953, 0.7665613889694214, -0.5936393141746521, -1.8778005838394165, 0.14691443741321564, -0.14509543776512146, -0.724912166595459, 0.6525574326515198, 0.5327674150466919, -0.5341668128967285, -0.30563637614250183, 0.23231816291809082, 0.1736658662557602, 0.5395790934562683, -0.5771633386611938, -0.41079404950141907, -0.015126628801226616, 0.04208490997552872, -0.31592217087745667, 0.7573871612548828, -0.21516510844230652, 0.8979603052139282, -0.1899884045124054, -0.07567773759365082, -0.05080737546086311, -0.9141021370887756, 0.16983452439308167, 0.63158118724823, -0.5987675189971924, -0.09739449620246887, 0.09693732112646103, 0.7710281610488892, 1.0084995031356812, 0.06080681085586548, 0.5477760434150696, 0.29403403401374817, -0.23625975847244263, -0.7604590058326721, 0.12191497534513474, 0.23359930515289307, -0.3355156183242798, 0.10001896321773529, -0.4275112450122833, -0.3084576427936554, 0.1119387224316597, 0.07397553324699402, -0.04032876342535019, 0.5947235822677612, -0.4386664032936096, 0.6265159845352173, -0.4483602046966553, -0.031642407178878784, -0.5154426097869873, 0.33612802624702454, -0.15577375888824463, -0.17583349347114563, -0.6505162119865417, 0.7313410639762878, -0.8913218379020691, 0.09385424852371216, -0.6658810377120972, 1.0738333463668823, -0.0129622220993042, 0.032284513115882874, -1.269606113433838, 0.6136462092399597, -0.013191656209528446, -0.0686093345284462, -0.2926881015300751, 0.24159488081932068, 0.41901102662086487, -0.2538076937198639, 0.2797998785972595, 0.04844838008284569, -0.2727757394313812, -0.09983794391155243, 0.6177140474319458, -0.5580165982246399, 0.8220623135566711, 0.2299775630235672, 0.4993917644023895, -0.06445637345314026, 0.3319191336631775, -0.05328291282057762, 0.12320928275585175, -0.6526047587394714, 0.1541890949010849, 0.6869967579841614, -0.5044992566108704, 1.2454218864440918, 0.3594680726528168, 0.19119486212730408, 0.5812461972236633, 0.4822433888912201, 0.45832258462905884, 0.1843436062335968, 0.536264181137085, 0.43994107842445374, 1.04486083984375, 0.9996817708015442, -0.030524270609021187, 0.08732687681913376, -0.13390740752220154, 0.05359160900115967, -0.45164304971694946, 0.5228443741798401, -0.6610167622566223, 0.7349922060966492, 0.4297563135623932, 0.31830719113349915, -0.7084439396858215, 0.00028991588624194264, 0.2434949427843094, 0.33977827429771423, 0.2028152346611023, -0.9272770881652832, -0.05826740711927414, -0.08663993328809738, -0.2525309920310974, 0.16685858368873596, 0.6244808435440063, 0.8279574513435364, 0.15891095995903015, -0.16705654561519623, 0.0271214097738266, -0.48674124479293823, -0.6759859919548035, -0.7682210206985474, -1.1370458602905273, -0.7495110034942627, -0.9082655310630798, -0.20490367710590363, 0.3573467433452606, -0.16124819219112396, -0.10232456773519516, 0.24489597976207733, -0.201007679104805, -0.04372579976916313, 0.0608033686876297, 0.697763204574585, 1.1197330951690674, 0.32717373967170715, -1.416014552116394, 0.8408817052841187, -0.7547115683555603, 0.8291439414024353, 0.6378974914550781, -0.19194909930229187, -0.7822504639625549, -0.8438379168510437, 0.3752811849117279, -0.48579350113868713, 0.3610016405582428, -0.29313182830810547, -0.19776412844657898, -0.07491002976894379, 0.09937689453363419, 0.5170858502388, 0.06925099343061447, -0.05424579232931137, -0.9532120227813721, 0.6301661729812622, 0.31117886304855347, -0.127944678068161, 0.6624590754508972, 0.2286171168088913, -0.9145865440368652, 0.8667055368423462, -0.351929247379303, -0.01025467924773693, -0.785287618637085, 0.937086284160614, 0.5094584226608276, 0.06454553455114365, 0.24125897884368896, -1.1908540725708008, -1.1372390985488892, 0.055705476552248, -0.039803773164749146, -0.22273710370063782, 0.03838400915265083, 0.6988568305969238, -0.2636110782623291, -0.7822323441505432, 0.21269184350967407, -0.13855913281440735, -0.8310086131095886, 0.32366567850112915, -0.07618558406829834, 0.8837201595306396, 0.2110975831747055, -0.5547855496406555, -0.9958198070526123, -0.04019264876842499, -0.10507155954837799, 1.0023164749145508, 0.25837254524230957, -0.5112379193305969, -0.09689833223819733, 0.6085286736488342, 0.3464026153087616, 0.3457869589328766, 1.2645907402038574, -0.31344735622406006, -0.1201293095946312, 0.06366816908121109, 0.2509365975856781, -0.2124888151884079, 0.37933775782585144, -0.0034026068169623613, 0.4076162576675415, 0.07787859439849854, -0.2671051621437073, -0.10207604616880417, 0.5403028130531311, -0.011618205346167088, -0.2935436964035034, 0.9036632180213928, 0.0017515080980956554, 1.044742465019226, -0.6333722472190857, -0.6262640357017517, 0.15734116733074188, -0.47596126794815063, 0.5896166563034058, -0.8426878452301025, 0.2951847314834595, 0.36040958762168884, -0.17165501415729523, 0.2980360984802246, -0.13064761459827423, -0.7118523716926575, 1.0785539150238037, 0.35362645983695984, 1.5323606729507446, -1.1377710103988647, 0.6378686428070068, 0.5114039182662964, 0.9234527945518494, 0.2811872959136963, 0.5436157584190369, 0.3801450729370117, -0.9738656282424927, 0.8070369958877563, -0.08095955848693848, 0.14243099093437195, -0.11413483321666718, 0.06699799001216888, -0.7484335899353027, 0.17952707409858704, -0.5779989957809448, -0.4809439778327942, 0.17734402418136597, 0.14160841703414917, -0.6027993559837341, -0.3406194746494293, 1.0753843784332275, -0.25574561953544617, 0.07834478467702866, 0.7776047587394714, 0.4621550738811493, -0.40699946880340576, -0.6561272144317627, -0.12332036346197128, -0.6661170125007629, -0.5315855741500854, 0.40245363116264343, -0.13239161670207977, -0.666588306427002, -0.057773489505052567, 0.7344403862953186, -0.02857312373816967, -0.6354796886444092, -0.07534319162368774, -0.7457457184791565, 0.19307009875774384, 0.22143051028251648, 0.7197992205619812, -0.45945248007774353, -0.529672384262085, 0.3773086965084076, -0.34054288268089294, 0.040717963129282, -0.8567363619804382, 0.6918990015983582, 0.9238753318786621, -0.49617519974708557, -0.5429604649543762, -0.19262541830539703, -0.13615961372852325, 0.16107788681983948, 0.19168168306350708, 0.18673336505889893, -0.3343113660812378, 0.3953761160373688, -0.4214131236076355, -0.4650620222091675, -0.5587222576141357, 0.1327057033777237, -0.541849672794342, 0.49356186389923096, 0.2450917512178421, 0.7962772846221924, 0.3622274398803711, 0.7096648216247559, 0.2075432389974594, 0.4579058289527893, -0.8090446591377258, 0.17582282423973083, -1.2202482223510742, -0.3493718206882477, 0.28522998094558716, -0.5597167015075684, -0.3629714846611023, 0.889559805393219, -0.35810762643814087, -0.027800025418400764, 0.03732850402593613, 0.31502765417099, -0.3790440559387207, 0.10988085716962814, 0.9894088506698608, 0.18762658536434174, 0.41795337200164795, 1.6889758110046387, 0.08595086634159088, -0.2382412999868393, 0.2811696529388428, 0.3128957748413086, -0.904763400554657, 0.3246028423309326, 0.14618989825248718, 0.17827384173870087, -0.0157708078622818, -0.3509342074394226, -0.4218827486038208, -0.5089619159698486, 0.07579314708709717, -0.6905144453048706, 0.14425694942474365, -0.5903956294059753, -0.38704293966293335, -0.5553593635559082, -0.3417319059371948, -0.802273690700531, 0.19066618382930756, 0.26560458540916443, -0.9688321948051453, 0.07402253150939941, -0.007005348335951567, -0.26582974195480347, -0.11575737595558167, -0.8409092426300049, 0.4722634255886078, -0.37620264291763306, -0.1029834896326065, 0.713918924331665, -0.22332096099853516, -0.7816279530525208, 0.6095693707466125, 0.057145342230796814, -0.48643672466278076, -0.49259623885154724, -0.5506032109260559, -0.4222066402435303, -0.9955713152885437, 0.11955609917640686, -0.12168142199516296, -0.2709070146083832, -0.4894629716873169, 0.04704555869102478, -0.9277388453483582, 0.23933470249176025, -0.8239775896072388, -0.7180119752883911, 1.626466155052185, -0.6382080316543579, -0.9581743478775024, -0.12472960352897644, 0.4885393977165222, 0.6070204973220825, 0.17551949620246887, 0.03792806714773178, -0.6763232946395874, -0.042684029787778854, -0.8835201263427734, 0.2604038417339325, -1.2235816717147827, 0.4452349543571472, -0.668921947479248, 0.4222668409347534, 0.0356796532869339, 0.0959937646985054, 0.6897934079170227, -0.07923812419176102, 0.0609072670340538, 0.20705893635749817, 0.20836706459522247, -0.6910796165466309, -0.8590733408927917, -0.36155790090560913, 0.19360728561878204, 0.39145126938819885, 0.6848809719085693, 0.19595275819301605, -1.108931303024292, 0.12763354182243347, 0.1441604495048523, 0.17502133548259735, 0.29278790950775146, -0.24125619232654572, -0.6674041748046875, 0.05535174161195755, 0.25984910130500793, 0.2682887315750122, 0.030200637876987457, -0.6809460520744324, -0.09757401049137115, -0.6869007349014282, 0.47605353593826294, -0.8126909732818604, -0.3120306134223938, -0.2548978328704834, -0.5165352821350098, 1.1695635318756104, -0.5527132153511047, 0.06327824294567108, 0.10732666403055191, -0.11378343403339386, -0.05787752568721771, 0.4849125146865845, -1.094189167022705, -0.9527246356010437, -1.1940419673919678, -0.7939097881317139, 0.6736644506454468, -0.24613995850086212, 0.5350626111030579, -0.1562543511390686, 0.4521823525428772, -0.5893316268920898, -0.5861589908599854, 0.6405467391014099, 0.40545758605003357, -0.5621468424797058, -0.5831772685050964, 0.21088670194149017, 0.1329784393310547, -0.12381461262702942, 0.029940107837319374, -0.32440516352653503, -0.517228364944458, 0.1604304164648056, -0.36710795760154724, -0.9642977714538574, -1.2565093040466309, -0.6206610202789307, 0.06618203222751617, 0.3875473439693451, 0.31515979766845703, 0.18270353972911835, -0.12074460834264755, 0.15574225783348083, -0.5640973448753357, 0.8826180100440979, -0.3200533390045166, -0.11361697316169739, 0.9151638150215149, -0.8120396733283997, -0.023578990250825882, 0.19369035959243774, -0.014998877421021461, -0.5881422758102417, -0.3049079179763794, -0.08090245723724365, 0.22359150648117065, -0.7769116759300232, 0.6711356043815613, 0.46696069836616516, -0.36106276512145996, -0.2546655833721161, 0.19483473896980286, 0.13746948540210724, -0.2871350944042206, -0.6701413989067078, -0.05748436227440834, 0.3909624516963959, -0.6871430277824402, 0.459076851606369, 0.011269590817391872, -0.11257703602313995, -0.20222900807857513, -0.05531558394432068, -0.2519129812717438, -1.1199074983596802, 0.07470662146806717, 0.5177654027938843, -0.15641899406909943, 0.39353108406066895, 0.05149576812982559, 0.4007733166217804, 0.0312659814953804, 0.05648486316204071, 0.5806481838226318, -0.4090336561203003, -0.3945833742618561, 0.3169819116592407, 0.4095759987831116, -0.3444775640964508, 0.008424544706940651, 0.41667813062667847, 0.657200038433075, 0.817146360874176, -0.3854221701622009, -0.9488457441329956, 0.5554023385047913, 1.4030544757843018, 0.9751380085945129, 0.0230008065700531, -0.20821748673915863, 0.5154422521591187, 0.9252500534057617, -0.45183417201042175, -0.257197767496109, -0.5752512216567993, -1.1241346597671509, -0.3771950304508209, 0.2897832989692688, -0.6771917939186096, -0.23093824088573456, 0.8872456550598145, 0.0885377898812294, -0.6848481297492981, -0.12217270582914352, 1.4956507682800293, 0.02636103704571724, -0.2209853082895279, -0.6920216679573059, 0.14781233668327332, -1.2451733350753784, -0.5023515224456787, -0.36713775992393494, -0.7970031499862671, 0.3457629978656769, 1.187950849533081, -0.058909736573696136, 0.25090256333351135, 0.23977935314178467, -0.18281449377536774, -0.22248698770999908, 0.4951234459877014, -0.44849780201911926, -0.7009057998657227, -0.331868976354599, 0.5390695929527283, -0.16589854657649994, 0.51374751329422, 0.5303840637207031, -0.5429984331130981, 0.45273712277412415, 0.24763691425323486, 0.01860874891281128, -1.052830457687378, -0.384235143661499, 0.30176788568496704, -0.7645055055618286, -0.37764960527420044, -0.29868078231811523, 0.6793745160102844, -0.8820135593414307, -0.8659588098526001, -0.39694148302078247, -0.3354780972003937, -0.42076870799064636, 0.7509836554527283, 0.012670985423028469, 0.9366629123687744, 0.37496712803840637, 0.020635543391108513, -0.46935349702835083, 0.38762298226356506, 0.43582025170326233, 0.11047884076833725, 0.7829269170761108, 0.07051835209131241, -0.03386528417468071, -0.9099830389022827, 0.8838303089141846, 0.2671624422073364, -0.5633591413497925, 0.11491508036851883, -0.5777646899223328, 0.21208378672599792, 0.5947158932685852, 0.17715637385845184, 1.0761587619781494, 1.1228384971618652, 0.1700260192155838, -0.4579061269760132, 0.18313628435134888, -0.09188085794448853, -0.8290678858757019, -0.3703500032424927, -1.220201849937439, -0.834013044834137, 0.527143657207489, -0.20378297567367554, 0.32374876737594604, -0.2996709942817688, -0.31284165382385254, 0.7219804525375366, 0.8065011501312256, 0.38926148414611816, 0.0369575172662735, 0.6822959780693054, 0.1882021129131317, 0.18531468510627747, -0.2829400300979614, -0.7462036609649658, 0.13037118315696716, 0.06935916095972061, -0.7211169600486755, -0.47909867763519287, 0.342283695936203, -0.23192308843135834, 0.41700834035873413, -0.49992313981056213, -0.08026926219463348, 0.5117174386978149, 0.49109524488449097, -0.5702936053276062, -0.6117342114448547, 0.3862755000591278, -0.3472726345062256, 0.06780048459768295, -0.4381002187728882, -0.5185462832450867, -0.2943483293056488, 0.16922947764396667, 0.09384024143218994, -0.5360039472579956, -0.16572198271751404, -0.008165156468749046, 0.9064015746116638, -0.7645378708839417, 0.30064740777015686, -0.33502396941185, 0.65632563829422, -0.21273885667324066, -0.12876473367214203, 0.4232744872570038, 0.24849605560302734, 0.45466291904449463, -0.037777967751026154, 0.21026727557182312, 0.9284964799880981, 0.8765817880630493, 0.2865619957447052, 0.8550063371658325, 0.25305426120758057, -0.5976134538650513, -0.21667547523975372, 0.29665419459342957, -0.35422492027282715, 0.6917715072631836, 0.740107536315918, -0.21911348402500153, -0.08582291752099991, 0.5881680846214294, -0.12206446379423141, -0.3455875515937805, -0.39963316917419434, -0.19865724444389343, -0.5860416293144226, -0.9330167174339294, 0.28848302364349365, 0.9238477349281311, 0.3666543960571289, -0.2401013821363449, 0.7770363688468933, 0.2896857261657715, 0.4133836328983307, 0.6556177735328674, -0.10525178164243698, 0.4467518925666809, -0.2614923417568207, -0.5998707413673401, -0.4158615171909332, 0.15466418862342834, -0.3545551598072052, 0.37036386132240295, 0.9791712760925293, -0.4823280870914459, 0.004690172616392374, 0.7115249037742615, -0.08785361796617508, -0.03437257930636406, 0.6345938444137573, -0.13478168845176697, -0.21237614750862122, -0.4579385221004486, 0.5473041534423828, -0.17179378867149353, -0.027607247233390808, 0.1898248940706253, -0.7113671898841858, 0.3905070126056671, -0.05436653271317482, 0.21009708940982819, 0.39975786209106445, 0.7270618677139282, 0.5878193378448486, -0.22616270184516907, 1.3342067003250122, 1.2417058944702148, 0.34328752756118774, 0.09934186190366745, -0.004763741046190262, -0.3581644296646118, -0.008490413427352905, -0.11135698109865189, 0.3142142593860626, 1.0320498943328857, -0.326134592294693, -0.6090390086174011, 0.056864894926548004, -0.8743582367897034, -0.17110475897789001, -0.7065927982330322, 0.22922074794769287, 0.42173895239830017, 0.08466801047325134, -0.443073034286499, 0.7876279354095459, 0.0984577015042305, 0.07719440013170242, -0.32516708970069885, -0.2550128400325775, -0.651539146900177, 0.5198682546615601, -0.5496075749397278, 0.3386962413787842, 0.09227826446294785, -0.024568362161517143, -0.24688668549060822, -1.0243918895721436, -0.021133093163371086, -0.4345700740814209, -0.2765202224254608, -0.7933674454689026, 0.09472890943288803, 0.5144626498222351, 0.7381125092506409, 0.02061433717608452, -0.24997678399085999, -0.06862294673919678, 0.042822834104299545, 0.6484007835388184, -0.23297405242919922, 0.9115935564041138, 0.46881332993507385, 0.01838558167219162, 0.06027719005942345, 0.9836635589599609, 0.7433161735534668, -0.4603351652622223, -0.13714049756526947, -0.17713631689548492, 0.41949698328971863, 0.13824336230754852, -0.8652943968772888, 0.3842433989048004, 0.4173296391963959, -0.1729518622159958, -0.36529800295829773, -0.5417003631591797, 0.11737032234668732, -0.6809861660003662, 1.4554188251495361, 0.30582818388938904, 0.6047224402427673, 0.3324504494667053, -0.4279654324054718, 0.7494134902954102, -1.382541537284851, 3.9183573722839355, 1.7327584028244019, 0.24822063744068146, -0.36123889684677124, 0.4263652563095093, 0.21881705522537231, 0.7319290637969971, -0.221575528383255, 0.5015982985496521, 0.964748740196228, -0.2924793064594269, 0.20220640301704407, 0.09670903533697128, -0.2989421486854553, 0.30086299777030945, -0.001816893694922328, -1.1511175632476807, 0.22677946090698242, -0.05350545421242714, -1.2987797260284424, -0.6001932621002197, 0.7756981253623962, 0.10657224804162979, -0.581309974193573, 0.18939055502414703, -0.117367684841156, -0.07134022563695908, 0.19474926590919495, -0.24104154109954834, 0.08921920508146286, -0.8603381514549255, -0.4723997414112091, 0.09335461258888245, -0.22788892686367035, -0.17020222544670105, 0.8110137581825256, -0.02825089544057846, -0.5747105479240417, -0.032085128128528595, -0.1130882278084755, 0.09557458758354187, -0.42227983474731445, -0.7503530383110046, 0.18289649486541748, -0.11426229774951935, 0.12397782504558563, -0.6210570335388184, 0.8472819924354553, 0.43129223585128784, -0.8533775210380554, 1.0403196811676025, -1.0481576919555664, 0.05496152862906456, -0.29175540804862976, -0.7604004740715027, -0.47614583373069763, -0.7918218970298767, -0.9906843304634094, 0.3626810610294342, 0.6285876631736755, 0.7570556402206421, 0.2344941794872284, -0.5819495320320129, -0.1068570613861084, 0.5121668577194214, 0.45019519329071045, 0.6047836542129517, -0.13791069388389587, -0.11369557678699493, -0.02961892820894718, 0.07895564287900925, 0.028400108218193054, -0.8179028630256653, 0.32385390996932983, 0.45722705125808716, 0.125199556350708, -0.6295825242996216, 0.3982931673526764, -0.3601992726325989, -0.4548393487930298, -0.10607422888278961, 0.13819268345832825, 0.3536853790283203, -0.13180647790431976, -0.06654497236013412, 0.8789733648300171, -0.23060289025306702, 0.21607232093811035, -0.8753277659416199, 0.30454176664352417, 0.4346121847629547, -0.78266841173172, 0.033741727471351624, -0.6842111945152283, 0.03488106653094292 ]
{"Title": "Nonlinear biomarker interactions in conversion from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer\u2019s disease", "Authors": "Popescu Sebastian G., Whittington Alex, Gunn Roger N., Matthews Paul M., Glocker Ben, Sharp David J, Cole James H", "Abstract": "Abstract The multi-faceted nature of Alzheimer\u2019s disease means that multiple biomarkers (e.g., amyloid-\u03b2, tau, brain atrophy) can contribute to the prediction of clinical outcomes. Machine learning methods are a powerful way to identify the best approach to this prediction. However, it has been difficult previously to model nonlinear interactions between biomarkers in the context of predictive models. This is important as the mechanisms relating these biomarkers to the disease are inter-related and nonlinear interactions occur. Here, we used Gaussian Processes to model nonlinear interactions when combining biomarkers to predict Alzheimer\u2019s disease conversion in 48 mild cognitive impairment participants who progressed to Alzheimer\u2019s disease and 158 stable (over three years) people with mild cognitive impairment. Measures included: demographics, APOE4 genotype, CSF (amyloid-\u03b242, total tau, phosphorylated tau), neuroimaging markers of amyloid-\u03b2 deposition ([18 F ]florbetapir) or neurodegeneration (hippocampal volume, brain-age). We examined: (i) the independent value each biomarker has in predicting conversion; and (ii) whether modelling nonlinear interactions between biomarkers improved prediction performance. Despite relatively high correlations between different biomarkers, our results showed that each measured added complementary information when predicting conversion to Alzheimer\u2019s disease. A linear model predicting MCI group (stable versus progressive) explained over half the variance (R 2 = 0.51, P < 0.001); the strongest independently-contributing biomarker was hippocampal volume (R 2 = 0.13). Next, we compared the sensitivity of different models to progressive MCI: independent biomarker models, additive models (with no interaction terms), nonlinear interaction models. We observed a significant improvement ( P < 0.001) for various two-way interaction models, with the best performing model including an interaction between amyloid-\u03b2-PET and P-tau, while accounting for hippocampal volume (sensitivity = 0.77). Our results showed that closely-related biomarkers still contribute uniquely to the prediction of conversion, supporting the continued use of comprehensive biological assessments. A number of interactions between biomarkers were implicated in the prediction of Alzheimer\u2019s disease conversion. For example, the interaction between hippocampal atrophy and amyloid-deposition influences progression to Alzheimer\u2019s disease over and above their independent contributions. Importantly, nonlinear interaction modelling shows that although for some patients adding additional biomarkers may add little value (i.e., when hippocampal volume is high), but for others (i.e., with low hippocampal volume) further invasive and expensive testing is warranted. Our Gaussian Processes framework enables visual examination of these nonlinear interactions, allowing projection of individual patients into biomarker \u2018space\u2019, providing a way to make personalised healthcare decisions or stratify subsets of patients for recruitment into trials of neuroprotective interventions.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002378"}
10.1101/19008045
[ -0.070937380194664, -0.1425791084766388, 0.01856650598347187, -0.03573552146553993, -0.8004343509674072, -0.4821956157684326, 0.3094019889831543, 0.132110133767128, 0.5412966012954712, 1.123082160949707, 0.4359515607357025, -0.9108390808105469, 0.736370861530304, 0.04010874032974243, 0.1269906759262085, -0.07984906435012817, -0.8987405896186829, -0.033009663224220276, 0.12823976576328278, -0.18748365342617035, -0.008484774269163609, -0.09692186862230301, -0.6482616066932678, -0.10486750304698944, -0.5423173308372498, 0.5208613872528076, -0.033182766288518906, 0.42740991711616516, 1.8967211246490479, 0.42577922344207764, 0.06768340617418289, 0.13026872277259827, 0.8007395267486572, -0.32880914211273193, 0.041426900774240494, 0.9238377809524536, 0.5186429023742676, 0.19324782490730286, -0.3271424174308777, -0.48966529965400696, 0.5562204718589783, 0.532384991645813, 0.8406257033348083, -1.18731689453125, -0.7830389142036438, 0.2361527681350708, 0.5017679333686829, 0.1696590781211853, -0.1823987513780594, -1.1789623498916626, -0.429822713136673, -0.149723082780838, 0.2478172481060028, -0.6725397706031799, -0.06886450946331024, -0.1004481241106987, 0.17193910479545593, -0.1374257653951645, -0.19415755569934845, 1.0411330461502075, 0.6643704175949097, -0.5136741995811462, 0.9494723081588745, -0.822258472442627, 0.6078693270683289, 0.15041515231132507, 0.010599496774375439, 0.6367696523666382, -0.35895293951034546, -0.09545610845088959, -0.3381199538707733, 0.2612729072570801, -0.7313192486763, -0.59758460521698, -0.21420377492904663, 0.14799772202968597, 0.47714322805404663, -0.30810561776161194, -0.13031260669231415, 0.10822445154190063, -0.2792529761791229, 0.6097537279129028, 0.399696946144104, 0.15576137602329254, -0.10325002670288086, -0.22711677849292755, 0.04598957300186157, 0.3698369860649109, -0.24321044981479645, -0.2143416404724121, -0.1275089979171753, 0.5159108638763428, 0.12641680240631104, 0.21780627965927124, 0.16560889780521393, 0.8983325958251953, -0.26521119475364685, 0.08795903623104095, 0.17095191776752472, -0.24591724574565887, 0.8178344964981079, 1.310046672821045, -0.032395485788583755, 1.2146021127700806, -0.6490716934204102, 0.8655251860618591, 0.6063448786735535, -0.3551672101020813, -0.005228364374488592, -0.7724614143371582, 0.1802217960357666, 0.15897387266159058, -0.43512168526649475, -0.47903016209602356, 0.7324769496917725, -0.08691748231649399, -0.10819625854492188, 0.118140809237957, -0.2636259198188782, 0.6667736768722534, 0.1750066727399826, -0.08127255737781525, 0.9467954039573669, -0.9173007011413574, 0.25326040387153625, -0.06681200116872787, 0.981922447681427, -0.047484494745731354, -0.32019442319869995, -0.36138370633125305, 0.5340390205383301, -0.5250037312507629, -0.66391921043396, -0.02689451351761818, -0.34104207158088684, -0.3169434666633606, -0.17292000353336334, 0.41791433095932007, 0.10600833594799042, 0.170998215675354, 0.1387658566236496, 0.630702555179596, -0.824015200138092, 1.319266676902771, 0.12195894867181778, 0.13679729402065277, -0.10241381824016571, -0.9570677280426025, 0.18853351473808289, 0.5556780099868774, 0.010663077235221863, 0.5893955826759338, -0.5201451778411865, 0.30545446276664734, -0.04752400517463684, 0.36070531606674194, -0.28899258375167847, 0.4008898138999939, -1.0380542278289795, 0.2757534682750702, 0.22301965951919556, -0.1798265278339386, -0.22214727103710175, 0.15511412918567657, -0.07884213328361511, 0.7387259602546692, -0.07472189515829086, -0.313502699136734, -0.1277458816766739, -0.6625549793243408, 0.7326081991195679, 0.31289350986480713, -0.32780489325523376, -0.2597920000553131, 0.4821760654449463, 0.9715802669525146, 0.6976097822189331, -0.35542571544647217, -0.4726240634918213, 0.0718730092048645, 0.16854225099086761, -0.8343942165374756, -0.13931655883789062, 0.5543060302734375, 0.15550291538238525, 0.9632733464241028, -0.5229024887084961, 0.3660125136375427, 0.16646578907966614, -0.1374330371618271, -0.06667463481426239, 0.19878824055194855, -0.3140178322792053, 0.7434130311012268, -0.6815357208251953, -0.0073470668867230415, -0.2573809027671814, 0.31768113374710083, 0.6035983562469482, -0.013907921500504017, -0.06449031829833984, 0.15357905626296997, -0.36002984642982483, 0.5436368584632874, -0.40827974677085876, 0.738733172416687, 0.15977945923805237, 0.5059369206428528, -0.5791050791740417, 0.16819323599338531, 0.09560343623161316, 0.403211385011673, -0.43012210726737976, -0.05289379134774208, 0.2778395116329193, -0.6296325325965881, -0.7903388738632202, 0.046653904020786285, -0.1468304842710495, -0.6273398995399475, -0.6522210836410522, -0.35593101382255554, 1.064354658126831, -0.014825047925114632, 0.7759947180747986, 0.3470517694950104, 0.4341183304786682, 0.8075171113014221, 0.5271630883216858, -0.3988403081893921, 0.08569484204053879, 1.0630736351013184, -0.6426769495010376, 1.0519946813583374, 0.8920607566833496, -0.06219992786645889, 0.17986464500427246, -0.3171652853488922, 0.33157914876937866, 0.19030964374542236, 0.42667511105537415, -0.46475571393966675, 0.29505881667137146, 0.8352035880088806, -0.46285802125930786, 0.22757792472839355, -0.4643942415714264, 0.09598583728075027, -0.30429670214653015, -0.04968234896659851, -0.1301714926958084, 0.4003051519393921, 0.27237945795059204, 0.7109586000442505, -1.5535508394241333, 0.09510717540979385, 0.10627772659063339, 0.5175796747207642, -0.18709851801395416, 0.010984586551785469, -0.7204626798629761, 0.5034219622612, -0.6973857283592224, 0.8199886679649353, 0.5970628261566162, 0.02814519591629505, 0.0727590024471283, -0.2585209012031555, 0.00017198942077811807, -0.2008359432220459, -0.9933169484138489, -0.5474632978439331, -0.8937512636184692, -0.9420411586761475, -0.26648247241973877, 0.47007638216018677, -0.16054947674274445, -0.5078445672988892, 0.0557415634393692, -0.36609357595443726, -0.45838624238967896, -0.17599982023239136, 0.1540759950876236, 0.09170540422201157, 0.21959856152534485, -0.48176294565200806, -0.5565415620803833, 0.5631749629974365, -0.13229018449783325, 0.4301729202270508, -0.13385866582393646, -0.5455081462860107, -0.6001908779144287, -0.5768100023269653, 0.6852002143859863, -0.6967709064483643, 0.2062418907880783, 0.19051140546798706, -0.42919448018074036, -0.5828486680984497, 0.07301299273967743, 0.23932191729545593, 0.7337677478790283, -0.26688122749328613, -0.5714313387870789, 0.7658924460411072, 0.32534825801849365, 0.3365548849105835, -0.006185426842421293, 0.09619344025850296, -1.2193684577941895, 0.435238242149353, -0.31452828645706177, 0.09085732698440552, -0.6880063414573669, -0.5747372508049011, 0.42706671357154846, -0.4520495533943176, 0.01759188249707222, -0.9258518218994141, -0.8094741702079773, -0.02111438289284706, -0.13978880643844604, -0.007200772408396006, -0.0560552217066288, 0.7065393924713135, -0.4342879354953766, -0.8367735147476196, 0.22512027621269226, -0.9236937165260315, -0.7326729893684387, -0.3228529095649719, -0.17488418519496918, 0.4542391896247864, 0.48388710618019104, -0.9331519603729248, -1.3408572673797607, 0.14245370030403137, 0.5319952964782715, 0.2844216227531433, 0.03371666371822357, -0.299466073513031, -0.14245043694972992, 0.7164555191993713, -0.06495031714439392, -0.17337577044963837, 0.564647912979126, -0.29427769780158997, -0.7976846098899841, -0.19361436367034912, 0.48728567361831665, 0.12055297195911407, 0.1892501413822174, 0.30623334646224976, -0.6940063238143921, 0.433826208114624, -0.3744222819805145, 0.3395214080810547, 0.2772655785083771, 0.44578567147254944, 0.09708143770694733, 0.28931036591529846, -0.189000204205513, 0.028074229136109352, -1.016537070274353, -1.530811071395874, 0.11352086067199707, 0.15885896980762482, 0.1255865842103958, 0.05388956516981125, 0.8422838449478149, 0.037389468401670456, -0.4891427457332611, -0.0026089672464877367, 0.07265648990869522, 0.20555338263511658, 0.4173624515533447, 0.20483963191509247, 0.890169084072113, -0.9866213202476501, 0.42231664061546326, 0.0017984434962272644, 0.7381982207298279, 0.4193011522293091, 0.043545205146074295, 0.4188794493675232, -0.5542851686477661, 0.24741791188716888, 0.26770883798599243, -0.23564006388187408, -0.33702588081359863, 0.20987731218338013, 0.1310044229030609, 0.09821517020463943, -0.5765858292579651, -0.8017821907997131, -0.6541568040847778, -0.10880274325609207, 0.24970708787441254, -0.44184064865112305, 0.7546883225440979, -0.40317994356155396, 0.25859636068344116, 0.22515681385993958, 0.6150516271591187, 0.2608806788921356, -0.8881028890609741, 0.17093786597251892, 0.0940610021352768, -0.14684614539146423, -0.06464386731386185, -0.4124109745025635, 0.1437620371580124, -0.05020894110202789, 0.12966537475585938, -0.1837533563375473, -0.5204310417175293, -0.5746355056762695, -0.5162546038627625, 0.07522545009851456, 0.8852065801620483, 0.02407449297606945, -0.9441605806350708, -0.07850202918052673, 0.36377570033073425, -0.2753109633922577, -0.2779638171195984, -0.5692175626754761, 0.5380812883377075, 0.9150002598762512, -0.5936390161514282, -1.28158438205719, 0.39338481426239014, 0.3352670669555664, -0.5158665776252747, 0.5356605052947998, 0.1398414969444275, -0.7297035455703735, 0.7583183646202087, -1.103605031967163, -0.7838018536567688, -0.400919646024704, -0.018335608765482903, 0.12501293420791626, 0.3083086609840393, 0.48470547795295715, 1.4791384935379028, 0.8252806067466736, 0.23743748664855957, 0.07792897522449493, 0.22900822758674622, -0.9200140833854675, 0.6315633058547974, -0.644409716129303, 0.036048129200935364, 0.7106304168701172, -0.4702092409133911, -0.26109564304351807, 0.03845634683966637, 0.5216187834739685, -0.1489739567041397, 0.38041064143180847, -0.044941771775484085, 0.21590133011341095, -0.3752670884132385, 0.5730551481246948, 0.2741532325744629, -0.4216811954975128, 0.942041277885437, -0.47202497720718384, -0.27031031250953674, 0.23316138982772827, 0.1652870774269104, -0.8498611450195312, 0.33484914898872375, -0.19776807725429535, 0.4402838945388794, -0.14336653053760529, -0.31655409932136536, -0.1888859122991562, -0.22884590923786163, 0.17056217789649963, -0.05967119708657265, -0.17184050381183624, -0.07348672300577164, -0.6990335583686829, -0.5287282466888428, -0.037774961441755295, -1.1172267198562622, 0.7074731588363647, -0.5474305748939514, -0.12777769565582275, 0.06920210272073746, -0.46206170320510864, -0.23815229535102844, 0.31393808126449585, -0.5798546671867371, -0.540221631526947, -0.035641737282276154, -0.11916322261095047, 0.20278820395469666, -0.6805461049079895, -0.885059654712677, 0.6413182616233826, 0.1776891052722931, -0.4667188227176666, -0.25075891613960266, -0.7605791687965393, 0.09370818734169006, -0.40378662943840027, -0.5327450633049011, 0.31659358739852905, -0.7400091886520386, -0.6041237115859985, -0.5301756262779236, -0.6318116188049316, 0.38786911964416504, -0.3062537610530853, -0.8599386215209961, 0.5764358639717102, -0.42297428846359253, -0.42903098464012146, -0.9135937094688416, 0.8545483350753784, -0.07066988199949265, 0.3870674669742584, -0.13944794237613678, -0.830411970615387, -0.2306297868490219, -0.5661939382553101, 0.10283312946557999, -1.1205759048461914, -0.22813522815704346, -0.07658722251653671, -0.7286603450775146, -0.3960730731487274, -0.14303061366081238, 0.04453996941447258, 0.5334169268608093, -0.5034530162811279, -0.09651224315166473, 0.7835258841514587, -0.3052237927913666, -0.4800123870372772, 0.19452865421772003, -0.40817347168922424, 0.022132720798254013, 0.40213707089424133, 0.11917489022016525, -0.6089346408843994, -0.6740267276763916, 0.21385900676250458, 0.8509316444396973, 0.5980764627456665, -0.39345383644104004, -0.4694652557373047, -0.29697108268737793, 0.3117021322250366, 0.2941690683364868, -0.786283552646637, -0.8800644874572754, 1.2887276411056519, -0.6132511496543884, 0.2166433483362198, -0.4158172905445099, -0.0046597435139119625, -0.5892094969749451, -0.6200369000434875, 0.8127630949020386, -0.05752826854586601, 0.5455203056335449, 0.42065370082855225, -0.3655352294445038, 0.46040308475494385, 0.4130553603172302, -0.918633222579956, -0.6978679299354553, -0.5666484236717224, -0.9659528136253357, 0.3424612283706665, -0.23723188042640686, -0.03456646576523781, -0.05831312760710716, -0.2767004370689392, -0.11175613105297089, -0.1961350291967392, 1.3431940078735352, 0.8372094035148621, -0.5735087990760803, -0.46228331327438354, 0.2825637459754944, -0.39691704511642456, 0.3729035556316376, 0.5229589343070984, -0.08962840586900711, -0.5674297213554382, 0.32214081287384033, 0.14958107471466064, -0.11400213092565536, -1.0983269214630127, -0.518534243106842, -0.06770823895931244, 0.06759702414274216, -0.2803979218006134, 0.694901704788208, -0.6485313773155212, -0.17068034410476685, -0.13920952379703522, 0.6256163120269775, 0.3681985139846802, -0.16848668456077576, 0.4555148184299469, 0.5987558960914612, 0.03742416575551033, 0.4805038869380951, -0.2831067144870758, 0.018396764993667603, -0.3437890112400055, 0.006751277018338442, 0.23557233810424805, -1.3096109628677368, -0.2616836130619049, 0.3167184591293335, -0.18487262725830078, 0.058985620737075806, 0.6429415941238403, -0.3942444324493408, -0.26122912764549255, -0.6730770468711853, -0.8424465656280518, 0.5409315228462219, -0.19078496098518372, 0.47863516211509705, -0.036495450884103775, 0.028706099838018417, 0.262597918510437, -0.14412619173526764, 0.7252654433250427, -0.434330016374588, 0.01790899969637394, 0.8734374046325684, -0.38603606820106506, 0.3996618092060089, -0.37786346673965454, -0.42246559262275696, 0.07503147423267365, 0.47595730423927307, 0.7088067531585693, -0.19624130427837372, -0.29900047183036804, 0.5311100482940674, -0.09268728643655777, 0.012657110579311848, 0.5891203284263611, -0.3835313022136688, 0.6115434765815735, 0.028568552806973457, -0.6431359648704529, 0.001787878922186792, 0.364683598279953, 0.6425713300704956, 0.2960071861743927, -0.07221151143312454, -0.3511295020580292, 0.1792200654745102, 0.4188724160194397, 0.012246347032487392, -0.841022253036499, 0.21860109269618988, -0.7921392321586609, -0.15073195099830627, -0.29343098402023315, -0.21451035141944885, -0.2745610475540161, 0.25121980905532837, -0.38896599411964417, -0.3796919882297516, 0.35434234142303467, 1.4273600578308105, -0.3223746418952942, -0.008780431002378464, -0.5247615575790405, -0.04596700146794319, -0.4073235094547272, -0.45093345642089844, 0.09916622936725616, -0.16335651278495789, -0.40799030661582947, 1.671594262123108, -0.3986220359802246, -0.04413380101323128, 0.8245734572410583, -0.38620078563690186, -0.09915174543857574, 0.5721257328987122, -0.023929761722683907, -0.3522254228591919, -0.1967129111289978, 0.5379583835601807, 0.31965604424476624, -0.22971318662166595, 0.12622486054897308, -0.9689258933067322, 0.06748077273368835, 0.25961655378341675, 0.2658253610134125, -1.0991510152816772, 0.22745341062545776, 0.007087232079356909, -1.0873024463653564, -0.10102411359548569, -0.5598043203353882, -0.2607966661453247, -0.761332094669342, -0.026747990399599075, -0.27634814381599426, -0.3150494694709778, 0.7546361088752747, 0.5643492341041565, 0.741249680519104, 0.38646483421325684, -0.2856948673725128, -0.018190374597907066, 0.5792039632797241, 0.6122655868530273, 0.5896504521369934, -0.577239990234375, 1.031301498413086, 0.2472439706325531, 0.6550332903862, -0.9407491087913513, 0.7049863934516907, 0.6533182859420776, -0.09225605428218842, 0.11612837016582489, -0.7521025538444519, -0.05254161357879639, -0.14708341658115387, -0.5797935724258423, 0.5752788782119751, 0.8421727418899536, 0.24252936244010925, 0.27470192313194275, -0.27921995520591736, -0.0934605821967125, -0.7239460349082947, -0.6235367655754089, -0.9698420763015747, -0.9150018095970154, 0.9848464131355286, -0.49025067687034607, 0.10620922595262527, -0.8772458434104919, -0.32413196563720703, -0.2754135727882385, 0.5434574484825134, 0.080250084400177, -0.34052902460098267, 0.7655051946640015, -0.31959229707717896, 0.26347652077674866, -0.09993261098861694, -0.43602994084358215, 0.2867436110973358, 0.4663620591163635, -0.29539912939071655, -0.5845224857330322, 0.5096024870872498, -0.23058485984802246, 0.8996034264564514, -0.30134937167167664, -0.6914128661155701, 0.21634671092033386, 0.6601894497871399, -0.023188862949609756, -0.19950176775455475, -0.005090005230158567, -0.586406946182251, -0.2427133321762085, 0.027671603485941887, 0.293902188539505, -0.37027475237846375, 0.27786850929260254, -0.10059312731027603, -0.7103362679481506, -0.5018897652626038, -0.5884595513343811, 1.0848079919815063, -0.6951289772987366, -0.24015925824642181, 0.26501011848449707, 0.03368999809026718, -0.30500712990760803, -0.4244144856929779, 0.8185805082321167, 0.06348098069429398, 0.05164800211787224, 0.3468759059906006, -0.4365042448043823, -0.015668679028749466, 0.7990270256996155, 0.7633048892021179, 0.4994836449623108, 0.3591027557849884, 0.17550215125083923, -0.12800338864326477, 0.4758870601654053, 0.24244384467601776, 0.6257830858230591, -0.40143710374832153, -0.451510488986969, -0.3060891032218933, 0.6801844835281372, 0.2771763503551483, 0.6076180934906006, -0.6051284074783325, 0.05321443825960159, -0.588060736656189, -1.1798648834228516, 0.2058405578136444, -0.5487176179885864, 0.8163179159164429, 0.2134656459093094, 0.24996495246887207, 0.3322421610355377, 0.7866044640541077, -0.3095949590206146, 0.5165631175041199, 0.6214457750320435, 0.2489672154188156, -0.2992461919784546, -0.24177342653274536, -0.07125354558229446, -1.1464977264404297, 0.37977635860443115, 0.15673206746578217, -0.14262112975120544, 0.1514221578836441, 0.11780501157045364, 0.11659740656614304, -0.15538853406906128, 0.9629173874855042, -0.020443549379706383, 0.3591993451118469, -0.5866667628288269, -0.26639702916145325, -0.20064914226531982, -0.05219537764787674, 0.5134604573249817, 0.15845054388046265, 0.21904568374156952, -0.017425263300538063, 0.32003024220466614, 0.29299795627593994, 0.7806888222694397, 0.7038608193397522, 0.17784975469112396, 0.8760818839073181, 0.6601775288581848, -0.09978161007165909, -0.2101573795080185, -0.41713687777519226, 0.037024322897195816, -0.17733991146087646, -0.22255344688892365, 0.15639366209506989, 0.17326736450195312, 0.2872878313064575, -0.7063909769058228, 0.4363406002521515, 0.4561045169830322, 0.06753089278936386, -0.6192478537559509, -0.43884751200675964, -0.4664223790168762, -0.0012598176253959537, -0.249284565448761, 0.46963515877723694, 0.24581092596054077, -0.4032813310623169, -0.13152606785297394, 0.44928184151649475, -0.628162682056427, 0.08658476173877716, -0.4009092450141907, 0.2763617932796478, -0.3962222635746002, -0.7107023596763611, -0.6146314144134521, -0.9347033500671387, 0.30011263489723206, 0.545549213886261, -0.012583532370626926, -0.4979691207408905, 0.8379814028739929, 0.366767555475235, 0.7801235318183899, -0.18579669296741486, -0.7623655796051025, 0.05207114666700363, 0.532024621963501, 0.18541677296161652, -0.5440667867660522, 0.6804340481758118, 0.07713693380355835, 0.14684905111789703, 0.8499252200126648, 0.2219374030828476, -0.43636202812194824, 0.30010703206062317, -0.696541428565979, -0.41416800022125244, -0.15207026898860931, -0.5427733063697815, -0.6386216282844543, 0.40043535828590393, 2.0260732173919678, -0.5271596312522888, -0.3922872841358185, -0.2505878508090973, -0.15474417805671692, -1.0997116565704346, 0.8417801856994629, -0.1513725072145462, 0.2537921369075775, 0.15124724805355072, 0.4700798988342285, -0.2427636981010437, -1.0257649421691895, 4.117731094360352, 0.9561886787414551, 0.3693470358848572, -0.132297545671463, 0.39380282163619995, 0.4655533730983734, 0.26476162672042847, -0.1507691740989685, -0.18145932257175446, -0.18567654490470886, -0.4240776002407074, 0.18097920715808868, 0.38474345207214355, 0.263658344745636, 0.1273447722196579, -0.1346586048603058, -1.1656975746154785, 0.2580285668373108, 0.25721222162246704, -1.0418370962142944, -1.249259352684021, 0.6824309229850769, -0.02307577058672905, 0.43455439805984497, -0.06960808485746384, -0.13865651190280914, -0.40228980779647827, 0.5281488299369812, 0.3538669943809509, -0.1157805323600769, -0.19268684089183807, -0.5574172139167786, 0.20603953301906586, -0.41808199882507324, 0.2610566318035126, 0.14973510801792145, 1.217475175857544, -0.4851782023906708, -0.015740713104605675, 0.28947532176971436, 0.7863039970397949, 0.26196032762527466, -0.09201502054929733, -0.11338134109973907, -0.6651868224143982, 0.775790274143219, -0.33242905139923096, -0.47823670506477356, 0.3310079574584961, -0.8655049204826355, 0.9448001384735107, -0.6381664276123047, -0.06490729004144669, -0.2863011956214905, -0.8349804282188416, -0.03660035505890846, -1.2540408372879028, -0.40430131554603577, 0.2533974051475525, 0.6601313352584839, 0.5594416260719299, 0.25859713554382324, -0.7431268095970154, -0.28589195013046265, 0.22160154581069946, 0.30230793356895447, 0.05810735747218132, 0.2937610447406769, 0.08946530520915985, 0.15855447947978973, 0.590294599533081, -0.3593263626098633, -0.2871982455253601, -0.22167539596557617, 0.9377439022064209, 0.2992217242717743, -0.7312731146812439, 0.47703075408935547, 0.007676650770008564, -0.5305466055870056, 0.808128297328949, 0.42082592844963074, 1.1255414485931396, -0.5752314925193787, 0.4644279479980469, 0.2639419734477997, -0.39257749915122986, 0.12473084777593613, -0.34619343280792236, 0.756437361240387, 0.44644272327423096, 0.5502132773399353, -0.04502634331583977, 0.37554994225502014, -0.2221662849187851 ]
{"Title": "Predicting the required pre-surgery blood volume in surgical patients based on machine learning", "Authors": "Li Ruilin, Han Xinyin, Sun Liping, Feng Yannan, Sun Xiaolin, He Xiaoyu, Zhang Yu, Zhu Haidong, Zhao Dan, Dai Chuangchuang, He Zhipeng, Chen Shanyu, Wang Xin, Li Weizhong, Chi Xuebin, Yu Yang, Niu Beifang, Wang Deqing", "Abstract": "Abstract Precisely predicting the required pre-surgery blood volume (PBV) in surgical patients is a formidable challenge in China. Inaccurate estimation is associate with excessive costs, postponed surgeries and adverse outcome after surgery due to in sufficient supply or inventory. This study aimed to predict required PBV based on machine learning techniques. 181,027 medical documents over 6 years were cleaned and finally obtained 92,057 blood transfusion records. The blood transfusion and surgery related factors of perioperative patients, surgeons experience volumes and the actual volumes of transfused RBCs were extracted. 6 machine learning algorithms were used to build prediction models. The surgery patients received allogenic RBCs or without transfusion, had total volume less than 10 units, or had the latest laboratory examinations of pre-surgery within 7 days were included, providing 118,823 data points. 39 predictive factors related to the RBCs transfusion were identified. Random forest model was selected to predict the required PBV of RBCs with 72.9% accuracy and strikingly improved the accuracy by 30.4% compared with surgeons experience, where 90% of data was used for training. We tested and demonstrated that both the data-driven models and the random forest model achieved higher accuracy than surgeons experience. Furthermore, we developed a computational tool, PTRBC, to precisely estimate the required PBV in surgical patients and we believe this tool will find more applications in assisting clinician decisions, not only confined to making accurate pre-surgery blood requirement predicting.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008045"}
10.1101/19005124
[ 0.4529435336589813, 0.33608341217041016, -0.9123372435569763, 0.78084397315979, -0.3675985336303711, 0.04609863832592964, 0.5598173141479492, -0.029283270239830017, 0.5249629616737366, 0.8281612396240234, -0.10046933591365814, 0.2195497751235962, 0.380076140165329, -0.2831260859966278, -0.07803482562303543, -0.28118839859962463, -0.8376889228820801, -0.18494895100593567, -0.24824538826942444, 0.09597527980804443, 0.2247282862663269, 0.9201990365982056, -0.34836262464523315, -0.02641190215945244, -1.103774905204773, 0.35466107726097107, -0.30978628993034363, 0.5807011127471924, 1.136804223060608, 0.461922287940979, 0.3643547594547272, -0.46497175097465515, 0.3997149169445038, -0.43082502484321594, -0.2088192105293274, -0.7030869722366333, 0.5871591567993164, -0.639858067035675, -0.15983979403972626, -0.043365415185689926, 0.37737029790878296, -0.17366145551204681, 0.5433592796325684, -0.5687353014945984, -0.539206862449646, -0.7234124541282654, -0.30674248933792114, -0.9967265725135803, -0.28862327337265015, 0.12658138573169708, -0.13351856172084808, 0.37642350792884827, 0.031129049137234688, -0.22030703723430634, 0.3440795838832855, -0.23985981941223145, 0.00042364586261101067, -0.30599528551101685, -0.7497240900993347, 0.34732067584991455, 0.2467590868473053, -0.2029748260974884, 0.676845908164978, -1.1814846992492676, 0.2926637530326843, 0.5818120241165161, -0.3505476713180542, -0.7780717015266418, -0.5932974219322205, -0.555755078792572, -0.8763951063156128, 0.005923309829086065, -0.06699129194021225, -1.0113589763641357, 0.04192660003900528, -0.21740812063217163, 0.37872612476348877, -0.22569695115089417, 0.25392085313796997, -0.1853795200586319, 0.6587495803833008, 0.23555535078048706, -0.1935243308544159, 0.07539746165275574, -0.5615864396095276, -0.08243614435195923, 0.7966154217720032, -0.11840736120939255, 0.08904337882995605, -0.1967679113149643, -0.07203028351068497, 0.44367775321006775, 0.1879202276468277, 0.054420340806245804, 0.11639627069234848, 0.9883331060409546, -0.35060936212539673, 0.08204837143421173, 0.5017829537391663, -0.0775456354022026, 0.8957833647727966, 0.4616318643093109, -0.36746659874916077, 1.0625654458999634, -0.8941434621810913, 0.6741864681243896, 0.14000104367733002, -0.7262061238288879, -0.6623454093933105, -1.409021019935608, 0.345836341381073, 0.178086057305336, -0.1031055822968483, -0.08927170932292938, -0.7461487650871277, 0.6274275779724121, -0.333139568567276, 0.922487735748291, -0.2908494770526886, 0.3692585825920105, -0.3912949562072754, 0.11810080707073212, 0.24538622796535492, -0.48786675930023193, 0.23667758703231812, -0.011241006664931774, 0.3895295262336731, 0.5007521510124207, -0.3074324429035187, -0.4632525146007538, 0.13122330605983734, -0.47167786955833435, 0.3933217227458954, 0.7569519281387329, -0.5874263644218445, -0.013018106110394001, 0.3432861268520355, 0.38518017530441284, -0.12504911422729492, -0.28274649381637573, -0.23076416552066803, 0.07334595173597336, -0.2137966752052307, 1.2027372121810913, 0.28258949518203735, 0.42479515075683594, -0.8420418500900269, -0.6885848641395569, -0.311811625957489, 0.14480984210968018, 0.49641481041908264, 0.50689697265625, 0.4188189208507538, 0.28012561798095703, -0.01220812276005745, -0.5664821267127991, -0.1144368052482605, 0.7407426238059998, 0.009604007937014103, -0.03583424910902977, -0.11480757594108582, 1.050414800643921, -0.4112551510334015, 0.4799019396305084, -0.459757000207901, 0.3062894344329834, 0.06958883255720139, -0.3484673798084259, 0.9876090884208679, -0.38715991377830505, 0.535062849521637, 0.49015894532203674, 0.23214472830295563, -0.4781504273414612, 0.4064268171787262, 0.7017856240272522, 0.646475613117218, 0.5087972283363342, 0.6860328912734985, 0.361540287733078, -0.5863851308822632, -0.6455787420272827, 0.5152689814567566, 0.6403090357780457, -0.2831932008266449, 0.0969790369272232, -0.8130443692207336, -0.09940537810325623, 0.0401226207613945, 0.112277552485466, -0.5504591464996338, 0.2753411829471588, -0.8105173110961914, 0.6531637907028198, 0.32210952043533325, 0.18800301849842072, -0.12621060013771057, 0.3949829936027527, 0.3409959673881531, -0.5991334915161133, -0.7580205798149109, 0.5879454612731934, -0.18056394159793854, 0.4750072658061981, -0.20281091332435608, 0.9926735758781433, 0.10611945390701294, 0.47652241587638855, -0.6965042352676392, 0.12250957638025284, 0.22509053349494934, 0.12713982164859772, -0.8596429228782654, 0.17512552440166473, 0.9968576431274414, -1.0092459917068481, -0.07004878669977188, -0.2303280085325241, 0.31383028626441956, 0.08502699434757233, 0.08433239907026291, -0.45367535948753357, 0.5599462389945984, -0.20210540294647217, -0.15475153923034668, 0.7029719948768616, 0.001324717071838677, -0.014056653715670109, -0.1366485357284546, -0.20045940577983856, 0.44526299834251404, 0.6461687684059143, 0.12817682325839996, 0.862221360206604, 0.3377944827079773, 0.5353196859359741, 0.5636289715766907, 0.19774383306503296, 0.7283703684806824, -0.1950426697731018, 0.1692434847354889, 0.35006284713745117, 1.0791453123092651, 0.2247382253408432, -0.41374272108078003, 0.4423184394836426, -0.1453113704919815, 0.32736971974372864, -0.19764959812164307, 0.37433815002441406, -1.1313369274139404, 0.583219051361084, 0.15857908129692078, 0.3825407028198242, -1.203608751296997, -0.11495649814605713, 0.4577297270298004, 0.6454390287399292, 0.372796893119812, -0.9314686059951782, 0.00792910996824503, 0.019719481468200684, 0.3514401316642761, 0.3383784890174866, 0.8123874068260193, -0.09539032727479935, 0.19043172895908356, 0.9071183800697327, 0.35197344422340393, -0.17714066803455353, -0.7386465072631836, -0.7345003485679626, -1.5811314582824707, -0.7871312499046326, -0.9306136965751648, 0.14826421439647675, 0.08678333461284637, -0.8580822348594666, 0.21192532777786255, -0.655551552772522, 0.5828477740287781, -0.681912362575531, 0.39161014556884766, 0.8572674989700317, -0.06865470856428146, 0.559376060962677, -1.1268908977508545, 0.3580556809902191, -0.14680708944797516, -0.0030937506817281246, 0.4607303738594055, -0.0033835647627711296, -0.30607929825782776, -0.7348453998565674, 0.6585459113121033, -0.8511242270469666, 0.14463971555233002, 0.7048292756080627, -0.702337384223938, 0.028142670169472694, 0.8023626804351807, -0.005147681105881929, 0.2744797170162201, -0.27494627237319946, -0.4717012047767639, 0.756851077079773, -0.04077649489045143, 0.13945670425891876, 0.9661798477172852, -0.022837603464722633, -0.7150301337242126, 0.6072675585746765, -0.11877907812595367, 0.20106258988380432, -0.798927366733551, -0.1025768369436264, 0.45649856328964233, -0.7651739716529846, 0.24122188985347748, -0.20045243203639984, -0.7190485000610352, -0.7562915682792664, 0.03841416537761688, -0.33708807826042175, -0.1697835624217987, -0.17446333169937134, -0.4285593330860138, -1.466940999031067, -0.26441341638565063, -0.5684981346130371, -0.5903072953224182, -0.333443820476532, -0.24128399789333344, 0.7932639122009277, -0.2830908000469208, 0.05261051282286644, -0.6374112963676453, 0.08397041261196136, -0.12055101990699768, 0.2700285017490387, 0.6180899739265442, -0.2516617774963379, -0.6671539545059204, 0.2757788598537445, 0.21590420603752136, 0.8219935894012451, 0.10336971282958984, -0.9606747031211853, -0.22758105397224426, 0.13543999195098877, -0.6236477494239807, 0.35990118980407715, 0.36219269037246704, -0.048520781099796295, 0.9244256615638733, 0.47496500611305237, -0.493462473154068, -0.2563506066799164, 0.13991670310497284, 0.4554336369037628, -0.2820192277431488, 0.29898688197135925, 0.16543051600456238, 0.7477800846099854, -0.41720470786094666, -0.46791213750839233, 0.4025418162345886, 0.10996820777654648, 0.4558156430721283, -1.116966724395752, 0.5701905488967896, -0.21103541553020477, -0.1020788848400116, 0.08564707636833191, -0.19511021673679352, -0.5019578337669373, 1.2928844690322876, -0.08578262478113174, 1.232646107673645, -1.0371959209442139, -0.15774482488632202, 0.6251420974731445, 0.30907338857650757, 0.3729749023914337, -0.08782929182052612, -0.3676466941833496, -0.35607999563217163, 0.5285126566886902, 0.31730419397354126, -0.07882367074489594, 0.22372621297836304, 0.4871320128440857, -0.7425804138183594, 0.33611413836479187, -0.6784798502922058, -0.32846546173095703, 0.46339869499206543, 0.3203582465648651, 0.33265331387519836, -0.9309455752372742, 0.6784544587135315, -0.3581649363040924, 0.35233333706855774, 0.02638735994696617, 0.2491457462310791, -0.3796263039112091, -0.6997867822647095, 0.3779214322566986, -0.5192490816116333, -0.21663972735404968, -0.3872756361961365, -0.1087685227394104, -0.5212578773498535, -0.29091623425483704, 0.4483342468738556, 0.15682585537433624, -0.3786795735359192, 0.12215754389762878, -0.10072509199380875, 0.32785624265670776, 0.09765421599149704, 0.5480456352233887, -0.7661427855491638, 0.2447776049375534, 0.5088825225830078, -0.11897604167461395, -0.32185447216033936, -0.6907525062561035, 0.4475003182888031, 0.9106737375259399, -0.3899831473827362, -1.0315022468566895, -0.08239011466503143, -0.23959992825984955, -0.09926016628742218, 0.3629136383533478, 0.03701504319906235, -0.25991496443748474, 0.140620157122612, 0.4088086485862732, -0.20562756061553955, -0.058930493891239166, 0.018241435289382935, -0.6091766357421875, -0.004222603514790535, 0.028136830776929855, 0.7939638495445251, 0.2716868221759796, 0.9436099529266357, 0.13581854104995728, 0.21302931010723114, -0.5556634664535522, 0.5128190517425537, -0.6132376790046692, -0.7697652578353882, -0.19579172134399414, 0.41831690073013306, 0.38270431756973267, 0.00704432837665081, -0.26109763979911804, 0.030771298334002495, -0.0019170882878825068, 0.5462419390678406, 0.41057711839675903, -0.04060356691479683, 0.9412274956703186, -0.36431509256362915, -0.27552980184555054, 0.4695684015750885, 0.2873389720916748, -0.53348708152771, 0.08519840240478516, 0.06631488353013992, -0.5378027558326721, 0.27473264932632446, -0.5170586109161377, 0.14917626976966858, -0.2356441169977188, -0.4745207130908966, 0.5813916921615601, -0.2851032316684723, 0.07944487780332565, -0.36736536026000977, 0.0799960047006607, -0.8626055121421814, -0.14744672179222107, -0.2987649738788605, -0.830942690372467, -0.9422289133071899, 1.258178949356079, 0.012176159769296646, -0.7849653959274292, -0.46138033270835876, 0.5382790565490723, -1.3169234991073608, -0.1482481062412262, -0.6534444093704224, 0.5650200247764587, -0.4762917459011078, 0.23362019658088684, 0.4386664032936096, -0.030283674597740173, -0.17073127627372742, 0.32172998785972595, 0.5246421694755554, -0.9443464875221252, -0.5828344225883484, -0.665189266204834, 0.030436288565397263, -0.7584332823753357, -0.01111060194671154, 0.1829366534948349, -0.3506506383419037, 0.674161434173584, 0.04581573233008385, -0.1772499680519104, 0.5817881226539612, -0.43591123819351196, -0.37535175681114197, 0.48564913868904114, -0.19979648292064667, -0.6443773508071899, -0.5264747142791748, 0.23763622343540192, -0.2954550087451935, -0.013100292533636093, -0.5352062582969666, -0.28045251965522766, -0.7126733660697937, -1.1263941526412964, 0.09420250356197357, -0.41346094012260437, 0.3630773723125458, -0.5690832734107971, -0.39118102192878723, -0.2460387498140335, -0.10874596983194351, 0.37894976139068604, 0.07039237767457962, 0.12308914959430695, -0.4371347427368164, 0.8616762757301331, 0.2370958924293518, 0.17741058766841888, 0.15604113042354584, -0.2181311398744583, 0.20880332589149475, 0.9170352816581726, 0.6309335827827454, -0.33964166045188904, 0.6349973678588867, 0.12015770375728607, 0.2568114995956421, 0.6481531858444214, -0.32016298174858093, -0.6586355566978455, 0.05469447746872902, 0.2562026381492615, -0.2441539317369461, 0.06451479345560074, -0.6754027009010315, -0.197292760014534, -0.7275641560554504, 0.03306274116039276, 0.0718206986784935, -0.6220865249633789, -0.45834243297576904, 0.09776436537504196, 0.8258975744247437, -0.43808597326278687, 0.25303131341934204, 0.02697027288377285, 0.3113596439361572, 0.4674588441848755, 0.33042269945144653, -1.1288952827453613, 0.03570963069796562, -0.7043854594230652, -0.5517007112503052, -0.08404184877872467, 0.10890692472457886, 0.5161731839179993, 0.15609772503376007, 0.02909674495458603, -0.3919033408164978, -0.3064895272254944, -0.025638263672590256, 0.5308345556259155, -0.7499369382858276, -0.44185709953308105, -0.07597391307353973, 0.9410251379013062, -0.24664321541786194, 0.13999459147453308, -0.3556414842605591, -0.7240846157073975, 0.6888898611068726, -0.5280428528785706, -0.7508435845375061, -0.7655092477798462, -0.5679215788841248, 0.12539295852184296, 0.5336918830871582, -0.10081177204847336, 0.03591609373688698, 0.492480993270874, -0.9232723712921143, -0.5270454287528992, 0.5642022490501404, -0.3093269169330597, 0.1629563570022583, 0.24775545299053192, -0.06336190551519394, -0.8225051760673523, -0.3233082592487335, -0.28932270407676697, -0.2718585133552551, 0.1305418759584427, 0.2227235734462738, 0.9143628478050232, -0.35240045189857483, 0.5924295783042908, 0.5840618014335632, -0.2838975787162781, -0.7448005080223083, 0.5622186660766602, 0.16380374133586884, 0.12092708051204681, -0.7138525247573853, -0.13796071708202362, 0.07468957453966141, 0.05698109790682793, 0.34347495436668396, 0.1984385997056961, -0.351904958486557, -0.5016434788703918, -0.06765352189540863, 0.08688009530305862, -0.24306920170783997, -0.2893452048301697, 0.2615307569503784, -0.5390682220458984, 0.5607209205627441, 0.08120403438806534, -0.02546517364680767, 0.14966164529323578, 0.08079064637422562, 0.11426317691802979, -1.2271027565002441, -0.5415720343589783, 0.18533557653427124, 0.37755244970321655, -0.05028803274035454, -0.10743234306573868, -0.24593573808670044, 0.8010644912719727, -0.511560320854187, -0.7621582746505737, -0.5112388730049133, 0.7650265097618103, 0.562850296497345, 0.5085919499397278, -0.682328999042511, -0.217131108045578, 0.3255279064178467, 0.8957541584968567, 0.3408406376838684, 0.1379137486219406, -0.9957169890403748, -0.5560685396194458, -0.11829766631126404, 0.20426994562149048, -0.8620350956916809, -0.3850429356098175, 0.6059824824333191, -0.21291637420654297, -0.38977593183517456, -0.899302065372467, 1.5195629596710205, -0.4568640887737274, -0.6502148509025574, -0.6460814476013184, 0.8352690935134888, -0.45286670327186584, -0.23173652589321136, -0.30831634998321533, -0.4354669451713562, -0.03547956421971321, 0.37287306785583496, -0.7204869389533997, -0.08632829040288925, -0.30593442916870117, 0.39869681000709534, -0.18918365240097046, 0.5215981006622314, -0.7524253726005554, -0.2297358363866806, -0.11020264029502869, 0.8347537517547607, -0.07363800704479218, -0.17811983823776245, 0.6167225241661072, -0.25003355741500854, 0.5089187622070312, -0.3398451805114746, 0.07444026321172714, -0.6738462448120117, 0.5938048362731934, 0.11684971302747726, -0.5482804775238037, -0.6338014006614685, -0.35688817501068115, 0.5824413895606995, -0.8873588442802429, -0.4850603938102722, -0.7091147303581238, -0.00956799741834402, -0.2685806453227997, -0.14710205793380737, 0.10997751355171204, 0.8870955109596252, 0.585654616355896, 0.30910345911979675, 0.38284048438072205, 0.41537415981292725, 0.509502649307251, 0.2137203961610794, 0.4040961265563965, 0.07151000201702118, -0.07117326557636261, -0.9210910797119141, 0.4180617928504944, -0.469556987285614, -0.7555040717124939, 0.7043624520301819, -1.13121497631073, 0.42106860876083374, 0.48758000135421753, -0.015013803727924824, 0.34163662791252136, 0.40222102403640747, 0.13064898550510406, 0.813884973526001, 0.37116739153862, 0.09923740476369858, -0.43636447191238403, -0.4682430922985077, -1.0035021305084229, -1.4322386980056763, 0.6033217310905457, -0.5442538857460022, 0.25123533606529236, -0.25677216053009033, -0.4769658148288727, 0.6803362965583801, 0.322378009557724, 0.20493000745773315, 0.06760276108980179, 1.0119657516479492, 0.05413557216525078, 0.851314127445221, 0.22392220795154572, -0.013858259655535221, 0.29642415046691895, 0.3889091908931732, -0.5978310704231262, -0.7311506867408752, -0.02731669880449772, 0.7164879441261292, 0.38905230164527893, -0.11040224134922028, -0.6008620262145996, 0.3679051399230957, 0.3037039339542389, 0.08380261063575745, 0.05168961361050606, 0.40125831961631775, -0.5219270586967468, 0.4177820682525635, 0.18410803377628326, 0.6233626008033752, 0.031335439532995224, 0.4943525195121765, 0.577038049697876, -0.3958725929260254, -0.6591545343399048, -0.09557024389505386, 0.2760497033596039, -0.33647421002388, 0.7246453166007996, -0.841096043586731, 0.2810573875904083, -0.15541505813598633, 0.15773655474185944, 0.31957095861434937, 0.7947078347206116, 0.4297940731048584, -0.11059104651212692, -0.0945853590965271, 0.9464066028594971, 0.7506837844848633, 0.008932435885071754, 0.8466688394546509, 0.7798569798469543, 0.09022894501686096, -0.37292760610580444, 0.11824802309274673, -1.0172706842422485, 0.2740003168582916, 0.248103529214859, 0.14251631498336792, -0.18708784878253937, 0.10628432780504227, 0.43094131350517273, -0.1702035367488861, -0.9828372597694397, 0.2920435965061188, -0.13821114599704742, -0.369257390499115, 0.16352257132530212, 0.9192877411842346, -0.009954666718840599, 0.2949120104312897, 0.5124457478523254, -0.2445344775915146, 0.43409180641174316, 0.46920686960220337, -0.3793811798095703, 0.6991847157478333, -0.2552659511566162, -0.3534167408943176, -0.13053248822689056, 0.2554365396499634, -0.5765953063964844, -0.08506198227405548, 0.337580144405365, -0.5774532556533813, 0.061469100415706635, 0.679142415523529, 0.20173469185829163, -0.652682900428772, 0.2510400712490082, -0.6242997050285339, -0.7485477328300476, -0.49101006984710693, -0.5450567603111267, -1.0039266347885132, -0.5385242700576782, 0.2757289707660675, -0.07758672535419464, -0.14705944061279297, 0.2808777987957001, 0.11139044165611267, 0.3169582784175873, 0.5204086303710938, 0.639792799949646, -0.412447065114975, 1.0456199645996094, 1.075804352760315, 0.195884570479393, -0.6458098292350769, 0.1894671767950058, -0.08659106492996216, 0.6613455414772034, 0.04257727786898613, 0.16368648409843445, 0.42299214005470276, -0.13960248231887817, -0.2712657153606415, 0.2945983111858368, 0.03240964189171791, -0.45848771929740906, -0.5026323795318604, 0.0223622377961874, -0.09972982108592987, 0.22048911452293396, -0.2927432656288147, 0.2793188691139221, -0.24636606872081757, 0.7672675848007202, -0.46573948860168457, 0.09194247424602509, -0.5182608366012573, 0.2447383999824524, -0.5610425472259521, 0.08271998912096024, 0.011992407031357288, -0.8336516618728638, -0.22510167956352234, -0.7263092398643494, -0.18034934997558594, -0.1135689914226532, -0.23819959163665771, -0.7176544070243835, 0.04848957434296608, 0.1585206389427185, 0.4831988513469696, -0.07750630378723145, -0.2167246788740158, -0.15440769493579865, 0.6296720504760742, 1.1963602304458618, -0.09569345414638519, 0.0957079529762268, 0.20888455212116241, 0.5316284894943237, 0.12072180956602097, 0.20274090766906738, 0.411124050617218, 0.02770324982702732, -0.15560221672058105, 0.08171781897544861, -0.290975421667099, -0.2320215255022049, -0.2691650688648224, -0.20275788009166718, 0.07367075234651566, -0.36174309253692627, -0.1186450719833374, -0.9385830163955688, -0.7569860219955444, -0.6466864943504333, 1.052260398864746, -0.1964872181415558, 0.2452736496925354, 0.38431623578071594, -0.20768295228481293, 0.4250929057598114, -1.235390305519104, 4.2165632247924805, 1.3428864479064941, 0.05775054916739464, -0.37876129150390625, -0.03755249083042145, 0.3158055245876312, 1.2797150611877441, -0.4436958432197571, 0.4628373384475708, 0.36892685294151306, -0.2472652941942215, 0.05910976603627205, 0.042896125465631485, -0.392545610666275, 0.9415430426597595, 0.11632199585437775, 0.007872466929256916, -0.2203727513551712, -0.008542084135115147, -0.7295640110969543, -0.22589556872844696, 0.44496652483940125, 0.3276023268699646, -0.2629595994949341, 0.47229450941085815, -0.11194736510515213, 0.12706302106380463, 0.32317230105400085, -0.6074514389038086, 0.041986703872680664, 0.29046034812927246, -0.38833969831466675, 0.15224212408065796, -0.13955318927764893, -0.6813551187515259, 0.9086976647377014, 0.3212193250656128, -0.8101078867912292, -0.4262197017669678, -0.3134062588214874, -0.11123485863208771, 0.003588710445910692, -0.1418672502040863, -0.02121632918715477, -0.29607129096984863, 0.47013628482818604, -0.29055556654930115, 0.513327956199646, 0.7954549789428711, -0.637119710445404, 0.8838286399841309, -1.0927413702011108, 0.24167107045650482, 0.16022053360939026, -0.8681806921958923, -0.2768198549747467, -0.13691024482250214, -0.7499629855155945, -0.21994806826114655, 0.25457170605659485, 0.34276965260505676, -0.2056952565908432, -0.29198428988456726, -0.4316288232803345, -0.23411138355731964, 0.6302902102470398, 0.7815659642219543, -0.06847608089447021, -0.08842543512582779, -0.2631395161151886, 0.022861920297145844, 0.23274892568588257, -1.113071084022522, -0.2110719382762909, 0.8050878047943115, 1.2322754859924316, -0.36676454544067383, 0.8641298413276672, -0.30883556604385376, -0.4285206198692322, -0.029924340546131134, 0.14166945219039917, 0.046005912125110626, -0.0606515109539032, 0.048300810158252716, 1.2911657094955444, -0.6774895787239075, 0.1545548141002655, -1.4362746477127075, 0.8838437795639038, 0.6588517427444458, -0.5734307765960693, -0.39291247725486755, -0.1553405076265335, 0.43723541498184204 ]
{"Title": "The Mezurio smartphone application: Evaluating the feasibility of frequent digital cognitive assessment in the PREVENT dementia study", "Authors": "Lancaster Claire Dr, Blane Jasmine, Chinner Amy, Wolters Leona, Koychev Ivan Dr, Hinds Chris Dr", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Smartphones may significantly contribute to the detection of early cognitive decline at scale by enabling remote, frequent, sensitive, economic assessment. Several prior studies have sustained engagement with participants remotely over a period of a week; extending this to a period of a month would clearly give greater opportunity for measurement. However, as such study durations are increased, so too is the need to understand how participant burden and scientific value might be optimally balanced. Objectives We explore the \u2018little but often\u2019 approach to assessment employed by the Mezurio app, interacting with participants every day for over a month. We aim to understand whether this extended remote study duration is feasible, and which factors might promote sustained participant engagement over such study durations. Methods Thirty-five adults (aged 40-59 years) with no diagnosis of cognitive impairment were prompted to interact with the Mezurio smartphone app platform for up to 36 days, completing short, daily episodic memory tasks in addition to optional executive function and language tests. A subset ( n =20) completed semi-structured interviews focused on their experience using the app. Results Average compliance with the schedule of learning for subsequent memory test was 80%, with 88% of participants still actively engaged by the final task. Thematic analysis of participants\u2019 experiences highlighted schedule flexibility, a clear user-interface, and performance feedback as important considerations for engagement with remote digital assessment. Conclusions Despite the extended study duration, participants demonstrated high compliance with the tasks scheduled and were extremely positive about their experiences. Long durations of remote digital interaction are therefore definitely feasible, but only when careful attention is paid to the design of the users\u2019 experience.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005124"}
10.1101/19005546
[ 0.34603413939476013, 0.40055403113365173, -0.35435616970062256, 0.5000184774398804, -0.651441752910614, -0.15334884822368622, -0.4023682475090027, -0.24524761736392975, 0.719316840171814, 0.5808197259902954, -0.0484619103372097, -0.5358461141586304, 0.9101358652114868, 0.13197793066501617, -0.34311503171920776, 0.29555240273475647, -0.27414989471435547, -0.41048088669776917, 0.051667582243680954, -0.013913475908339024, -0.059718772768974304, 0.33756721019744873, -0.4412878453731537, -0.10158652812242508, -0.33419254422187805, 0.4056580662727356, -0.5897819399833679, 0.03456679731607437, 1.1479040384292603, 0.11670345067977905, -0.8902431130409241, -0.24103976786136627, 1.327467441558838, -0.413455605506897, -0.12306225299835205, -0.293722927570343, 0.22660864889621735, 0.1282380372285843, -0.6594354510307312, -1.142224669456482, 0.31025567650794983, 0.26553237438201904, 0.5473691821098328, 0.19653813540935516, -0.21738013625144958, 0.613328218460083, 0.07877117395401001, 0.33379867672920227, 0.46399644017219543, -0.5312466025352478, -0.3387596011161804, 0.11222504079341888, -0.3579280972480774, -0.8166909217834473, -0.1053524762392044, -0.0783308669924736, 0.03290532901883125, -0.26943346858024597, -0.32484421133995056, 1.094131588935852, 0.6777637600898743, -0.2670685350894928, 0.7583172917366028, -0.8021284937858582, 1.0638759136199951, 0.9647558331489563, -0.7261627912521362, -0.04704711586236954, -0.2768830955028534, -0.20858867466449738, -0.43190836906433105, 0.06098340079188347, -0.47897350788116455, -0.7780574560165405, 0.2897237539291382, 0.3269740045070648, 0.19775961339473724, -0.07978992164134979, 0.13806061446666718, -0.8560113906860352, 0.6882928609848022, 0.6171207427978516, 0.6024565100669861, -0.761418342590332, -0.40659862756729126, 0.16448599100112915, -0.7391048669815063, 0.527282178401947, -0.025230228900909424, -0.33509159088134766, 0.3394021987915039, 0.7011495232582092, 0.585929274559021, -0.15612511336803436, -0.09198351204395294, 0.631941020488739, -0.6221118569374084, 0.15852804481983185, 0.8415006399154663, -0.9631830453872681, 0.2572193443775177, 0.6940125226974487, -0.0026234176475554705, 0.7205485701560974, -0.6365986466407776, -0.29836031794548035, 0.06798940151929855, -0.34011369943618774, -0.4192505478858948, -0.5970480442047119, 0.19026806950569153, 0.1680629402399063, -0.49001646041870117, -0.7763703465461731, 0.28462356328964233, 0.45671263337135315, -0.058461714535951614, -0.011085686273872852, -0.728744626045227, 0.5003839731216431, 0.4317916929721832, -0.023071549832820892, 0.4436032176017761, -0.869843602180481, 0.7069252729415894, -0.09101668000221252, 0.15728706121444702, 0.33358532190322876, -0.5728439092636108, -0.12530682981014252, 0.11616558581590652, -0.7952280044555664, -0.8361656069755554, 1.1974995136260986, -0.6898232698440552, 0.3694654107093811, 0.20572654902935028, 0.6739776134490967, 0.08708318322896957, 0.03132793679833412, -0.4838322699069977, 0.5675348043441772, -0.2620270848274231, 1.006337285041809, -0.06712222099304199, 0.8589841723442078, -0.364080011844635, -0.9491574168205261, -0.24552476406097412, 0.16484330594539642, -0.5111584067344666, 0.5084929466247559, -0.24635817110538483, 0.53101646900177, 0.04014405608177185, 0.28770509362220764, -0.400882750749588, 0.9075095057487488, -0.2033046931028366, -0.08412931114435196, -0.23383772373199463, 0.0015318648656830192, -0.4282771944999695, 0.5662834644317627, -0.26025745272636414, 0.762912929058075, -0.17526327073574066, -0.3012886345386505, -0.17122787237167358, -0.3884256184101105, 1.0607261657714844, -0.0001833884889492765, 0.07901682704687119, 0.059603847563266754, 0.34382909536361694, 0.26782095432281494, 0.9371423125267029, 0.8959369659423828, -0.42941755056381226, 0.43866443634033203, 0.8712303638458252, 0.13922645151615143, 0.7729272246360779, 1.1634541749954224, -0.2385888695716858, 0.6411119103431702, -0.42661771178245544, -0.6955773234367371, 0.20838351547718048, 0.3660498559474945, -0.5382700562477112, 0.707094132900238, -0.38768333196640015, 0.5642790198326111, -0.3985338807106018, 0.09451150894165039, 0.09086459875106812, 0.3359108567237854, 0.36430877447128296, -0.7875672578811646, -0.3151591718196869, 0.3398239314556122, -0.8460752367973328, 0.33821991086006165, -0.41410496830940247, 0.5428985357284546, 0.48018911480903625, 0.26138225197792053, -0.0636770948767662, 0.608113706111908, 0.6837176084518433, 0.007316509261727333, -0.03711356595158577, 0.21065929532051086, 0.4296283721923828, -0.7172502875328064, -0.3323551118373871, -0.4851311147212982, -0.6597241759300232, 0.5818597674369812, 0.1052527129650116, -0.4721517562866211, 1.3688404560089111, -0.22660419344902039, 0.1518888920545578, 0.22730816900730133, 0.16249333322048187, 0.08137284219264984, -0.029604770243167877, -1.2124738693237305, -0.36355623602867126, 0.3728911280632019, -0.5084689259529114, 1.1292685270309448, 1.2578171491622925, -0.07446140050888062, 0.2754402160644531, 0.5605292320251465, -0.09258802980184555, 0.09845393896102905, 0.34286144375801086, -0.13270282745361328, 0.5386139750480652, 0.0713624507188797, -0.8088633418083191, 0.26248496770858765, -0.8865755200386047, 0.09678226709365845, -0.28108930587768555, 0.14782334864139557, -0.08719059824943542, -0.2704910337924957, 0.17120929062366486, 0.37975138425827026, -0.7805651426315308, 0.05140140652656555, 0.19396142661571503, 0.11153752356767654, -0.21574214100837708, 0.3692590892314911, 0.1911107748746872, 0.3355216085910797, -0.5011623501777649, 0.5147994756698608, 0.29660937190055847, 0.7761067748069763, -0.1008775606751442, -0.041141144931316376, -0.36586859822273254, -0.0689581036567688, -0.7200198769569397, -0.4413232207298279, -0.8538207411766052, -0.57039475440979, -0.7229915857315063, -0.83694988489151, 0.5025619864463806, 0.23465774953365326, 0.5661031007766724, -0.03751472383737564, 0.2524316608905792, -0.9503081440925598, -0.3976250886917114, 0.3268623352050781, 0.7910037040710449, 0.16196653246879578, -1.246797800064087, 0.42470934987068176, -0.581139087677002, -0.1251840740442276, 0.1876593381166458, 0.046719640493392944, -0.41869255900382996, -0.4395900368690491, 0.030700115486979485, -0.07709815353155136, 0.25845572352409363, -0.6979436874389648, -1.074571967124939, 0.32432103157043457, 0.3747510015964508, -0.016969112679362297, 0.4084795415401459, -0.07801342755556107, -0.49920907616615295, 0.6452436447143555, -0.03669702261686325, 0.30692747235298157, 0.4718076288700104, 0.16588807106018066, 0.16463997960090637, 0.5348469614982605, -0.51687091588974, 0.4324515461921692, -0.48681801557540894, 0.4851806163787842, 0.055138811469078064, 0.5491235256195068, 0.37213388085365295, -0.061133090406656265, -0.3111864924430847, 0.368981271982193, 0.6057599782943726, -0.8154221773147583, -0.44804996252059937, 0.2765445113182068, 0.2546040713787079, -1.2567921876907349, -0.0072253369726240635, -0.5052209496498108, -1.1415199041366577, 0.15940871834754944, 0.1873237043619156, 0.25717082619667053, 0.05405888333916664, 0.10337604582309723, 0.0804668590426445, 0.29218778014183044, -0.3195507526397705, -0.2842017114162445, 0.22836001217365265, -0.5227969288825989, 0.19558972120285034, 0.004216395318508148, -0.6002100110054016, -0.4741073250770569, 0.02182728424668312, -0.22946391999721527, -0.16400013864040375, -0.4130828082561493, -0.05820593610405922, 0.31898024678230286, -0.18577082455158234, -0.5391138195991516, 0.44931161403656006, 0.7932367324829102, 0.4837284982204437, 0.440693199634552, -0.10960511863231659, 0.5476459264755249, 0.051825184375047684, 0.2493598312139511, 0.017086530104279518, -0.5363536477088928, -0.7290288805961609, -0.7860285043716431, 0.35942453145980835, 0.9829359650611877, 0.046288762241601944, -0.5403890609741211, 0.663516640663147, 1.2995363473892212, -0.2446097582578659, 0.36118149757385254, 0.392347514629364, 0.5809879899024963, 0.020324135199189186, 0.36164775490760803, 1.137614130973816, -0.8840883374214172, -0.3301127254962921, 0.4093113839626312, 0.5654159188270569, -0.5128660798072815, -0.11824345588684082, 0.11849399656057358, -1.0171985626220703, 0.5835556387901306, -0.07284317165613174, -0.25788816809654236, 0.7743337750434875, -0.3383169174194336, -0.29703089594841003, -0.32989805936813354, -0.8603382110595703, -0.08563604205846786, 0.14494846761226654, 0.3123306930065155, -0.277896910905838, -0.05292690917849541, 0.4502946436405182, 0.8892784118652344, 0.6183325052261353, 0.18256013095378876, 0.33732250332832336, -0.7874109745025635, -0.34268897771835327, 0.19749847054481506, 0.33877918124198914, -0.27172937989234924, -0.5492625832557678, 0.08951784670352936, 0.005917218513786793, 0.5796083211898804, -0.09188595414161682, 0.24523736536502838, 0.24330708384513855, 0.13183140754699707, -0.12873543798923492, 0.005913431290537119, 0.07324795424938202, -0.32763779163360596, -0.22072984278202057, -0.40617427229881287, 0.09392839670181274, -0.6369844079017639, -0.0463053323328495, 0.015120736323297024, -0.2840331196784973, 0.4730815887451172, -0.4521637558937073, -0.37756621837615967, 0.2787232995033264, 0.21836590766906738, -0.5316454768180847, 0.6975222229957581, 0.10015187412500381, -0.4781409204006195, 0.6274788975715637, -0.1602814644575119, -0.37368836998939514, -0.1876174956560135, -0.42917993664741516, -0.38095542788505554, -0.2997322380542755, 0.5082610845565796, 1.3044573068618774, -0.26754117012023926, 0.4591676592826843, 0.5031877756118774, 1.3261831998825073, -0.2842892110347748, 0.8903520703315735, -0.4095481336116791, 0.05084972083568573, 0.45087864995002747, -0.8371111750602722, 0.3657515347003937, 0.9844448566436768, -0.19874374568462372, -1.6593692302703857, -0.1989716738462448, 0.4274165630340576, -0.7562685608863831, -0.13600069284439087, 0.2565673291683197, -0.28837689757347107, 0.28244009613990784, 1.0067404508590698, -0.4916307032108307, -0.14360368251800537, 0.6075237393379211, -0.20443406701087952, -0.7654711604118347, 0.15372532606124878, -0.3688790202140808, 0.3481384813785553, 0.38685116171836853, -0.27713504433631897, 0.29381492733955383, -0.24272623658180237, -0.28417420387268066, -0.7861112356185913, 0.01343857403844595, -0.23138892650604248, -0.7276190519332886, -0.2790135443210602, 0.5432716012001038, -0.8923224806785583, -0.2000865787267685, 0.18108788132667542, -0.3415663242340088, 0.22600114345550537, 0.23152939975261688, -0.024464484304189682, -0.43199974298477173, -0.40467238426208496, 0.04463007301092148, -0.0036020867992192507, -0.62528395652771, 0.8715684413909912, -0.8143552541732788, -1.283434271812439, 0.6515659093856812, -0.5158886313438416, -0.26638415455818176, -0.2468482404947281, -0.5417405366897583, -0.8806067109107971, -0.017131874337792397, -0.5701166987419128, 0.549051821231842, -0.3853966295719147, -0.3421107828617096, 0.2155127376317978, 0.43437376618385315, 0.13236355781555176, -0.8215656876564026, -0.0023251932580024004, 0.5537240505218506, -0.7460431456565857, -0.5960950255393982, -1.0730524063110352, 0.42454594373703003, -0.05391232296824455, 0.28875088691711426, -0.06221117079257965, -0.7620634436607361, -0.7343297600746155, -0.421622633934021, 0.7534217834472656, -1.2489571571350098, -0.4616639316082001, -0.4208211600780487, -0.49397456645965576, -0.7275362014770508, 0.1675865799188614, -0.10199709981679916, -0.4551737904548645, -0.43237587809562683, -0.6250520944595337, 0.1353408545255661, -0.017412999644875526, -0.2581305205821991, -0.6239858865737915, -0.3765057325363159, -0.5786325931549072, 0.09711726754903793, -0.32653963565826416, -0.3334929645061493, -0.6230267882347107, 0.5819591879844666, 0.6482734084129333, 0.17086265981197357, 0.785772442817688, -0.9659976959228516, -0.6118083000183105, 0.19647790491580963, -0.5365270376205444, 0.2496880739927292, -0.7980174422264099, 0.18886947631835938, 0.05084352567791939, 0.4082099199295044, -0.7596158385276794, 0.21556589007377625, 0.08131402730941772, -1.1645309925079346, 0.593439519405365, -0.5310749411582947, 0.3821578919887543, 0.38636744022369385, 0.2145894318819046, -0.04938856512308121, 0.39918434619903564, -0.16539466381072998, 0.0517081692814827, -0.8302789330482483, -1.4934892654418945, 1.0932748317718506, -0.29882556200027466, -0.332553505897522, 0.3164496123790741, -0.17646072804927826, -0.13276280462741852, -0.4193893074989319, 0.5546092391014099, 0.7178133726119995, -0.3432445526123047, -0.4422895014286041, -0.5534932613372803, 0.17363664507865906, 0.6204469203948975, -0.05631439760327339, -0.6657475829124451, -0.2152959108352661, 0.006599991582334042, -0.6560875177383423, -0.3064022660255432, -1.0521711111068726, -0.6469242572784424, 0.08527227491140366, 0.4275558292865753, -0.04431915655732155, 0.48478832840919495, -0.5613109469413757, -0.6977480053901672, -0.44001275300979614, -0.036586858332157135, -0.21709983050823212, 0.5168223977088928, 0.6077219843864441, -0.03436015546321869, -0.1085820347070694, -0.7696930170059204, -0.7724612951278687, -0.3276676535606384, 0.5925471186637878, 0.10117115825414658, 0.3377048671245575, -0.9343283772468567, -0.050474632531404495, 0.5844239592552185, -0.354261189699173, -0.8676882386207581, 0.13783933222293854, -0.6718277335166931, -0.5977286696434021, -0.4132198691368103, -0.8645749688148499, 0.17541396617889404, -0.24070356786251068, -0.25206440687179565, -0.27517545223236084, 0.67137211561203, 0.2596791088581085, -0.8140991926193237, -0.3078039884567261, -0.8655745983123779, -0.4125348925590515, 0.37691473960876465, 0.007012321148067713, -0.4076108932495117, -0.19056129455566406, 0.5475797653198242, 0.3761307895183563, 0.2190162092447281, 0.2631419897079468, 0.36397498846054077, 0.2974257469177246, -0.5270292162895203, 0.03798534721136093, 0.5246542096138, 0.42122843861579895, -0.12433520704507828, 0.19343474507331848, 0.2104589343070984, -0.4691525995731354, 0.2632485330104828, 0.5444666147232056, 0.3027231991291046, 0.15056660771369934, -0.015396780334413052, 0.1659003496170044, 0.9349798560142517, 0.30797553062438965, 0.3757353723049164, -0.4544878602027893, -0.8950092792510986, -0.616614580154419, 0.2587624788284302, -0.24765783548355103, -0.15706591308116913, 0.007928630337119102, 0.7875159382820129, -0.9194172024726868, -0.4500586688518524, -0.22214359045028687, 0.10653478652238846, 0.07077892124652863, 0.024057680740952492, -0.48651233315467834, 0.1813746839761734, -1.16208815574646, -0.9233257174491882, -0.2387290596961975, -0.4084733724594116, -0.46864384412765503, 1.0849676132202148, -0.35057532787323, 0.09530144184827805, 0.04017403721809387, 0.019030507653951645, -0.3794192671775818, 0.2810210883617401, -0.11576035618782043, -0.3008542060852051, 0.3466340899467468, 0.6503987312316895, 0.18427971005439758, 0.2968491017818451, 0.6129001975059509, -0.8161149621009827, 0.46967121958732605, 0.9018906950950623, -0.5990442633628845, -0.3210911750793457, 0.4130942225456238, 0.24248006939888, -0.302651584148407, -0.3421702980995178, -0.05204695090651512, 0.4733685255050659, -0.28736403584480286, 0.47124311327934265, -0.08825431019067764, -0.07809179276227951, 0.4568878412246704, 0.6542494893074036, -0.10755112022161484, 1.003193974494934, 0.37231919169425964, 0.3531113862991333, -0.2618708312511444, 1.0539772510528564, 0.6625710725784302, -0.13739757239818573, 0.605648934841156, -0.15721414983272552, -0.17642788589000702, -1.7014572620391846, 0.33389487862586975, 0.9685224294662476, -0.877403199672699, 0.5418234467506409, 0.15037944912910461, 0.24317888915538788, -0.6864116787910461, 0.4224407970905304, -0.03273169696331024, 0.6016188859939575, 0.6503158211708069, 0.027261603623628616, 0.5103075504302979, -0.09953813999891281, -0.7196803689002991, -1.082350254058838, -0.35352468490600586, -0.3181435465812683, 0.5019237995147705, -0.6851781606674194, -0.6383906006813049, -0.7254505157470703, -0.45178136229515076, 0.3095800280570984, 0.7330672144889832, 0.5850406289100647, -0.7182443141937256, -0.3353874683380127, 0.00839279405772686, -0.054170720279216766, -0.42809808254241943, 0.22277027368545532, 0.4775456488132477, 0.45758315920829773, -0.46678921580314636, -0.2957081198692322, 0.14142413437366486, 0.41736680269241333, 0.2566830515861511, -0.3044317066669464, -0.655298113822937, 0.3414609432220459, 0.532743513584137, -0.0864691436290741, -0.8324330449104309, -0.08746612071990967, -0.7047404050827026, -0.02474868670105934, 0.08939705789089203, -0.18303856253623962, -0.4058256149291992, 0.20760571956634521, 0.043107472360134125, -0.5313308238983154, -0.9285460710525513, -0.03383941575884819, 0.5616294741630554, -0.9014348387718201, 0.5690021514892578, 0.31278249621391296, 0.6635766625404358, -0.3164500594139099, -0.4139954149723053, 0.03488321229815483, 0.5377904772758484, 0.5417718291282654, 0.5130676627159119, -0.13316629827022552, 0.04321521893143654, 0.5902470946311951, -0.033122655004262924, -0.2704664468765259, 0.6495845317840576, 0.2715756297111511, -0.9618713855743408, 0.22108368575572968, -0.14602352678775787, 0.20345650613307953, -0.04754631221294403, 0.23619353771209717, 0.4898151755332947, 0.7219976782798767, 0.135975643992424, 0.4986865222454071, 0.119581438601017, 0.24455980956554413, -0.7025799751281738, -0.24759669601917267, 0.4285080134868622, 0.5783012509346008, 0.25210970640182495, -0.12595579028129578, -0.4431193172931671, 0.027589373290538788, 0.5445112586021423, -0.30737510323524475, 0.6733027100563049, 0.6781240105628967, -0.5821444988250732, -0.5093597173690796, -0.7233303785324097, 1.1483840942382812, 0.28901347517967224, 0.26906704902648926, 0.5705425143241882, -0.3536379635334015, 0.4423147141933441, 0.9655084013938904, -0.3300478458404541, -0.9525393843650818, -0.39515915513038635, 0.5479589700698853, 0.22273236513137817, -1.2122629880905151, 0.3492225408554077, -0.40695953369140625, -0.0001723758177831769, 0.35410550236701965, -0.31778544187545776, -0.4147975444793701, 0.1259910762310028, 0.6055857539176941, 0.9944213032722473, 0.49967560172080994, 0.7572159171104431, -0.43103259801864624, 0.46327415108680725, 0.5397560596466064, -0.24270188808441162, 0.01762518100440502, 0.39691752195358276, -0.04861248657107353, -0.2005675733089447, -0.24645788967609406, 0.4217740297317505, -0.2566741704940796, 0.13777221739292145, -0.6284182071685791, 0.24778759479522705, -0.1580212265253067, 0.34402891993522644, -1.3455952405929565, -0.28016483783721924, -0.030429325997829437, 0.22597098350524902, 0.1367211788892746, 0.4559010863304138, 0.6098490357398987, 0.09615583717823029, 0.4867171347141266, -0.2784762382507324, -0.22235214710235596, 0.26094850897789, -0.4458932876586914, 0.07916585355997086, 0.19222266972064972, -0.46760210394859314, -0.37656012177467346, -0.984908938407898, 0.15965011715888977, 0.5376355051994324, -0.3905884921550751, -0.6999900937080383, 0.6584799885749817, 0.46208250522613525, 1.4909838438034058, 0.506180465221405, -0.3154893219470978, -0.32655805349349976, 0.1794085055589676, -0.21897752583026886, -0.15724602341651917, 0.8809632062911987, 0.31385377049446106, -0.11312750726938248, 0.7816429138183594, -0.023236071690917015, 0.9622056484222412, -0.5604504346847534, 0.3279280364513397, -0.3085156977176666, -0.5766867399215698, -0.10600331425666809, -0.12410832196474075, -0.3691006004810333, 1.2383785247802734, -0.12951214611530304, 0.07623241096735, -0.33500880002975464, -0.38806667923927307, -0.5960122346878052, -0.225973442196846, 0.7092178463935852, 0.4364781081676483, -0.1868315488100052, 0.1908842921257019, 0.3610599637031555, -0.35734111070632935, 4.147391319274902, 1.1204286813735962, 0.48839837312698364, -0.8584415316581726, 0.6295743584632874, 1.022920846939087, 0.671059787273407, -0.5704596042633057, -0.407144695520401, 0.16883738338947296, -0.23100845515727997, 0.005643103271722794, 0.4091690480709076, -0.012471292167901993, 0.48987215757369995, -0.06855044513940811, -0.42344769835472107, 0.11314408481121063, -0.5320627093315125, -1.095862627029419, -0.25782403349876404, 0.38239213824272156, -0.8684983849525452, 0.4811588525772095, 0.055970534682273865, 0.4537413418292999, 0.3821136951446533, 0.7049556970596313, 0.33616387844085693, -0.02041521482169628, -0.13207732141017914, -0.35388651490211487, 0.4180947542190552, -0.8398488163948059, -0.32512977719306946, 0.1622343212366104, 0.2659025192260742, -1.0697053670883179, 0.047001004219055176, -0.09451206773519516, 0.22388960421085358, 0.36148035526275635, 0.16726094484329224, -0.570859432220459, -0.06601904332637787, 0.2045922726392746, -0.24620051681995392, -0.06042170524597168, 0.4905681014060974, -0.9873714447021484, 1.1499552726745605, -1.0400553941726685, 0.1658586710691452, -0.2977304458618164, -0.3681145906448364, -0.8245026469230652, -0.05458169803023338, -0.4420410394668579, 0.2808672785758972, 0.43115392327308655, 0.8146592974662781, 0.1473199725151062, 0.37159067392349243, 0.27852362394332886, 0.3400971293449402, 1.1340075731277466, 0.25123101472854614, 0.06959744542837143, 0.08199650794267654, -0.2571841776371002, -0.6973050236701965, -0.3708072006702423, -0.27345800399780273, -0.11626969277858734, 0.07010442018508911, 0.40841883420944214, -0.14428433775901794, 0.020756559446454048, -0.27753132581710815, -0.6345328688621521, -0.15336360037326813, 0.8270995020866394, 0.22765877842903137, -0.06228441372513771, -0.048745814710855484, -0.028688697144389153, -0.20221708714962006, -0.23749925196170807, -0.1395137757062912, 0.383060097694397, 0.9469062685966492, 0.08227969706058502, -0.8137413859367371, 0.30270686745643616, -0.08401986211538315 ]
{"Title": "Novel delivery of cellular therapy to reduce ischaemia reperfusion injury in kidney transplantation", "Authors": "Thompson Emily R, Bates Lucy, Ibrahim Ibrahim K, Sewpaul Avinash, Stenberg Ben, McNeill Andrew, Figueiredo Rodrigo, Girdlestone Tom, Wilkins Georgina C, Irwin Ellen A, Tingle Samuel J, Scott William E III, Lamos Henrique, Mellor Andrew L., Roobrouck Valerie D., Ting Anthony E., Hosgood Sarah A, Nicholson Michael L, Fisher Andrew J, Ali Simi, Sheerin Neil S, Wilson Colin H", "Abstract": "Abstract Ex-vivo normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) of donor kidneys prior to transplantation provides a platform for direct delivery of cellular therapeutics to optimise organ quality prior to transplantation. Multipotent Adult Progenitor Cells (MAPC \u00ae ) possess potent immunomodulatory properties which could prove beneficial in minimising subsequent ischaemia reperfusion injury. We investigated the potential reconditioning capability of MAPC cells in kidney NMP. Methods Pairs (5) of human kidneys from the same donor were simultaneously perfused for 7 hours. The right or left kidney was randomly allocated to receive MAPC treatment. Serial samples of perfusate, urine and tissue biopsies were taken for comparison with the control paired kidney. Results MAPC-treated kidneys demonstrated improved urine output (p<0.01), decreased expression of the kidney injury biomarker NGAL (p<0.01), improved microvascular perfusion on contrast enhanced ultrasound (cortex p<0.05, medulla p<0.01), downregulation of IL-1\u03b2 (p<0.05) and upregulation of IL-10 (p<0.05) and Indolamine-2, 3-dioxygenase (p<0.05). A mouse model of intraperitoneal chemotaxis demonstrated decreased neutrophil recruitment when stimulated with perfusate from MAPC-treated kidneys (p<0.01). Immunofluorescence revealed pre-labelled MAPC cells home to the perivascular space in the kidneys during NMP. MAPC therapy was not associated with detrimental physiological or embolic events. Conclusion We report the first successful delivery of cellular therapy to a kidney during NMP. Kidneys treated with MAPC cells demonstrate improvement in clinically relevant functional parameters and injury biomarkers. This novel method of cell therapy delivery provides an exciting opportunity to recondition organs prior to clinical transplantation. One Sentence Summary Ex-vivo reconditioning of human kidneys using Multipotent Adult Progenitor Cell therapy delivered during normothermic machine perfusion.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005546"}
10.1101/19005231
[ -0.13689681887626648, -0.0019907038658857346, -0.202233225107193, 0.21530602872371674, -0.3632555902004242, -1.0701422691345215, 0.10822802037000656, 0.26365816593170166, -0.260823130607605, 0.40688765048980713, -0.771674633026123, -0.07826786488294601, 0.4999293386936188, -0.7066490054130554, 0.07076884061098099, -0.7685052752494812, 0.5733135938644409, 0.20845305919647217, -0.7885569334030151, 0.1968468427658081, 0.0023129801265895367, 0.3419363796710968, -0.5205250382423401, 0.20188848674297333, -0.29983216524124146, 0.998357355594635, 0.42660751938819885, -0.06991954147815704, 0.4021441638469696, 0.6717086434364319, -0.6624629497528076, 0.17709098756313324, 0.11741747707128525, -1.313889503479004, 0.024394284933805466, -0.8044739365577698, 0.21241824328899384, -0.9246484041213989, 0.24504420161247253, -0.36629509925842285, 0.6289316415786743, -0.12380866706371307, 0.33946311473846436, -1.183821678161621, -0.5284000039100647, 0.7700417041778564, -0.2654510736465454, -0.3028385639190674, -0.06843704730272293, -0.9250400066375732, -0.08767084032297134, 0.18157830834388733, -0.30173829197883606, 0.17112022638320923, 0.6339467167854309, -0.24348022043704987, 0.9072801470756531, -0.4731293320655823, -0.5556808710098267, 0.0992499589920044, 0.6488228440284729, -0.003057357156649232, 0.3875637352466583, -0.7429476380348206, 0.30603155493736267, 0.45372074842453003, -0.16547280550003052, -0.10207298398017883, -0.390521764755249, 0.06507521122694016, -0.9353851079940796, -0.3365010619163513, -0.23639017343521118, -0.47786152362823486, 0.17010623216629028, -0.07382792979478836, 0.39800041913986206, -0.5492019057273865, -0.029341628775000572, -0.6781585216522217, 0.7622684836387634, 0.3074498772621155, -0.1492445170879364, 0.3013797700405121, -0.010220037773251534, 0.22559499740600586, -0.2976437211036682, 0.15565639734268188, 0.8028325438499451, -0.194178968667984, 0.21307626366615295, 0.5406315922737122, 0.45311081409454346, 0.5980777144432068, 0.3813020884990692, 0.878533661365509, -0.06109524145722389, -0.05646715313196182, 0.19524411857128143, 0.4731104373931885, 0.2640349864959717, 0.6798287034034729, -0.3275531232357025, 0.6486735939979553, -1.624605417251587, 0.7192796468734741, 1.1066579818725586, -0.2338363230228424, -0.0297688040882349, -1.2466017007827759, -0.2012207806110382, 0.5159397721290588, -0.7485095262527466, -0.27227938175201416, 0.13189086318016052, 0.44251197576522827, -0.09389913082122803, 0.697878360748291, -1.05609929561615, 0.5332589745521545, -0.2938925325870514, -0.10685017704963684, 0.2455684095621109, -0.4474744498729706, 0.5083997249603271, 0.08593736588954926, -0.07717300951480865, 0.6244470477104187, -0.29269540309906006, 0.1584758311510086, -0.2827022075653076, -0.3240582048892975, 0.38670971989631653, 0.4376838505268097, -0.32089653611183167, -0.4422737956047058, 0.2071467787027359, 0.4579460024833679, 0.5181142091751099, -0.5480395555496216, -0.9895458817481995, 0.8303037285804749, -0.24769069254398346, 0.9627162218093872, -0.41468602418899536, 0.5945479869842529, -0.42300307750701904, -0.8530913591384888, -0.2947586178779602, -0.4864121675491333, 0.10888905823230743, 0.5099695324897766, -0.3585818409919739, -0.3362260162830353, 0.04385676980018616, -0.1112493947148323, 0.08548801392316818, 0.17045310139656067, 0.358635276556015, -0.005725436843931675, -0.13732217252254486, 0.4786597192287445, -0.14074856042861938, 1.2762974500656128, -0.053160324692726135, 0.7750136256217957, -0.003298379248008132, -0.5162985324859619, 0.5528264045715332, -0.8928990960121155, 0.4025615155696869, 0.396148145198822, -0.3632432818412781, 0.33271652460098267, 0.5811851024627686, -0.11437422037124634, 0.5816158652305603, -0.13897602260112762, 0.2137635052204132, -0.36034244298934937, -0.3015700876712799, -0.4709378182888031, 0.7634530067443848, 0.9506914019584656, 0.16572213172912598, 0.09232690930366516, 0.4532215893268585, -1.3776836395263672, 0.05932595580816269, -0.48063620924949646, -0.4135077893733978, 0.20704080164432526, -0.1658371388912201, -0.21740077435970306, 0.7653467059135437, -0.3946446478366852, -0.5224949717521667, -0.21935303509235382, 0.1928214430809021, -0.6647078394889832, -0.1576898694038391, 0.722001314163208, -0.7167882919311523, 0.8456706404685974, -0.4306270480155945, 0.1709219217300415, 0.49805593490600586, 0.4983687400817871, 0.19405297935009003, -0.39756929874420166, 0.8412298560142517, 0.3094799220561981, -0.3391140401363373, -0.5758635997772217, 0.5024222135543823, -0.5496660470962524, -0.5753862857818604, 0.2981528639793396, -0.9700403809547424, -0.7546707391738892, -0.4331168234348297, -0.3185756206512451, 0.2507390081882477, -0.263560026884079, -0.2674691677093506, 0.21055148541927338, -0.002403226215392351, 0.2703520953655243, -0.21279704570770264, -0.5468704700469971, -0.04467146098613739, 0.23951084911823273, -0.2969914972782135, 0.24700860679149628, 1.262021541595459, 0.4623299241065979, 0.6386347413063049, 0.41644054651260376, 0.9940913319587708, 0.05086866766214371, -0.015914645045995712, 0.5479146838188171, 1.337971806526184, 0.23593203723430634, -0.7736851572990417, 0.438223659992218, -0.6277796626091003, 0.027082709595561028, -0.017274850979447365, 0.7099825143814087, -0.5376394391059875, 0.8468081951141357, 1.3053669929504395, 0.7791112065315247, -1.622910976409912, 0.4713714122772217, 0.3985845446586609, 1.0298786163330078, -0.2146453559398651, -0.3082185387611389, -0.6676061749458313, 0.126747727394104, 0.3114311099052429, 0.29919636249542236, 1.188637614250183, -0.14014911651611328, -0.1959415227174759, 0.48991858959198, 1.0704659223556519, -0.8933594822883606, -0.8269405961036682, -0.6986123323440552, -0.7262133359909058, -0.6410843729972839, -0.6426954865455627, 0.2023637592792511, 0.26981082558631897, -0.39592570066452026, 0.19666029512882233, 0.7145220637321472, -0.24542918801307678, -0.18778488039970398, -0.12780267000198364, -0.07686490565538406, 0.23479753732681274, 0.5572887659072876, -1.2667585611343384, -0.08117903769016266, -0.4176032245159149, 0.29868626594543457, -0.4776676297187805, -0.6721287965774536, -0.04763924330472946, -0.7171568274497986, 0.5080274939537048, -0.2626379132270813, 0.06576397269964218, 0.20508289337158203, -0.7655252814292908, -0.5437173843383789, 0.4826623499393463, -0.33345091342926025, -0.18872876465320587, -0.24300190806388855, -1.214317798614502, 0.8346463441848755, -0.2400847226381302, 0.3142542541027069, 0.5578296184539795, 0.08983072638511658, -0.30422595143318176, 0.34955185651779175, -0.6876187920570374, 0.10704375803470612, -0.7099687457084656, 0.019412102177739143, 0.29629603028297424, -0.2111406773328781, 0.021080484613776207, -0.017695501446723938, -0.6395097970962524, -0.2622816860675812, -0.2378411889076233, -0.03764889016747475, -0.3088686168193817, -0.06556089967489243, 0.14991694688796997, -0.6583878993988037, 0.270536869764328, -0.8681111335754395, -0.5980450510978699, 0.07119230926036835, -0.7042309641838074, 0.8059049248695374, -0.006694328039884567, -0.0801892802119255, -0.4968579113483429, 0.454807311296463, 0.8791694641113281, -0.3593161106109619, 0.29271000623703003, -0.403931587934494, -0.5858622789382935, 0.006140204146504402, -0.8336264491081238, 0.5515970587730408, 0.13618311285972595, -0.22787967324256897, -0.5062856078147888, 0.12792085111141205, 0.15573209524154663, -0.2956511676311493, 0.5845102667808533, -0.24948729574680328, -0.2561745345592499, 0.6067932844161987, -0.2491680234670639, 0.16382987797260284, 0.44787248969078064, -0.5899837017059326, -0.6818142533302307, -0.07546481490135193, -0.26240894198417664, 0.29086825251579285, -1.0175538063049316, -0.6231038570404053, 0.9734007120132446, -0.6468921303749084, 0.1873006373643875, -0.5993586778640747, 0.5795977115631104, 0.3250104486942291, 0.14091140031814575, 0.264766663312912, 0.01537475734949112, -0.05396512523293495, 0.6809632778167725, -0.07867110520601273, 0.1278759092092514, -1.2628594636917114, -0.019543355330824852, -0.20773746073246002, 1.5101721286773682, -0.11653010547161102, -0.10414984077215195, 0.034584593027830124, -0.7813158631324768, 0.8125004172325134, 0.09717117249965668, -0.47424373030662537, 0.4248514175415039, 0.09097599238157272, 0.27081164717674255, -0.16752555966377258, -0.5722779631614685, 0.07689781486988068, 0.21237711608409882, -0.022733060643076897, -0.051368970423936844, 0.19249221682548523, 0.6779686808586121, -0.187888041138649, -0.2755197286605835, 0.4828829765319824, 0.7093292474746704, -0.46851322054862976, -0.19476519525051117, -0.1126125380396843, -0.4287818670272827, -0.4092061221599579, -0.21920554339885712, -0.028283940628170967, -0.04851572960615158, 0.6138884425163269, 0.4785277545452118, -0.14472822844982147, 0.10080692917108536, -0.030194079503417015, 0.009190669283270836, -0.2681067883968353, 0.594245195388794, -0.5653433203697205, -0.6284540295600891, 0.31962689757347107, 0.06012553721666336, -0.20182813704013824, 0.1942620575428009, -0.36509886384010315, 0.23080451786518097, 0.8134575486183167, -0.5552914142608643, -1.1366111040115356, 0.0013528068084269762, -0.16690438985824585, 0.11612524837255478, -0.5280736684799194, 0.22120864689350128, -0.33596381545066833, -0.017724893987178802, -0.22681154310703278, 0.5054426193237305, -0.2498897761106491, -0.4072408080101013, -0.6069778203964233, 0.4475218653678894, 0.7314305901527405, 0.6410197019577026, 0.489474892616272, 0.11773276329040527, -0.445007860660553, 0.6067517399787903, -1.105470895767212, 0.33495232462882996, 0.25545579195022583, -0.4621351957321167, 0.26792749762535095, -0.32238200306892395, -0.01301821693778038, 0.3262105882167816, -0.1850510537624359, -0.690078854560852, 0.17459096014499664, 0.8336461782455444, 0.08928294479846954, -0.4242105782032013, 0.831697940826416, -0.3082505464553833, 0.8713865876197815, 0.9373298287391663, 0.002978940960019827, -0.3619568645954132, -0.777097225189209, -0.4040863811969757, -0.5436272621154785, 0.9975637793540955, -0.6594089865684509, -0.34680062532424927, 0.293605774641037, -0.17397142946720123, 0.351200670003891, -0.15455010533332825, -0.3077397644519806, -0.5588769912719727, -0.8771371245384216, -0.9266158938407898, 0.10134351253509521, -0.3426191806793213, -0.18580922484397888, -0.5708189606666565, -0.2983245849609375, -0.14569585025310516, -0.47557172179222107, -1.0128226280212402, 0.38554731011390686, -0.11050392687320709, -0.1789213865995407, -0.572788417339325, -0.4396904706954956, -0.26438480615615845, -0.42545878887176514, 0.9532505869865417, -0.6293609738349915, -0.789004385471344, -0.34138768911361694, 0.976966917514801, -1.4055951833724976, -0.8087581396102905, -0.19476331770420074, -0.005517594050616026, -0.43676459789276123, 0.1041930690407753, 0.5940902829170227, -0.40160679817199707, 0.66243577003479, 0.16862067580223083, 0.302769273519516, -0.09572801738977432, -0.20344862341880798, 0.27844199538230896, 0.4160371720790863, -0.39275267720222473, -0.2485707849264145, 0.2282756268978119, 0.1683485358953476, -0.16161927580833435, 0.1432887464761734, -0.7782445549964905, -0.6829954981803894, -0.700484037399292, -0.5948268175125122, -0.3504681885242462, -0.5639430284500122, 0.2514059245586395, -0.6373790502548218, 0.11522749811410904, -0.06596745550632477, 0.8292571306228638, 0.23908314108848572, 0.8027423024177551, -0.05478425323963165, -0.24107132852077484, 0.24030327796936035, 0.22107748687267303, -0.05172455683350563, 0.6223544478416443, -0.27482128143310547, 0.2132890224456787, 0.8881391882896423, 0.8461574912071228, 0.7058113813400269, -0.16324280202388763, -0.40591296553611755, 0.5046249032020569, 0.3948942720890045, -0.33742576837539673, -0.07043959945440292, 0.08771289885044098, -0.22329063713550568, 0.5873091816902161, -0.17046423256397247, -0.915283203125, 1.2203119993209839, 0.04583152383565903, 0.19373905658721924, -0.6028061509132385, 0.05018309876322746, -0.18511910736560822, 0.062183577567338943, 1.074336051940918, 0.20005758106708527, 0.10378231853246689, 0.07281568646430969, -0.19977967441082, 0.38354453444480896, 0.15722714364528656, -0.5587161183357239, -0.8591965436935425, -0.6632898449897766, -0.45420703291893005, -0.1062299832701683, 0.3131939768791199, -0.5046124458312988, 0.2920112609863281, 0.15039530396461487, 0.49014702439308167, -0.8212379217147827, 1.0247583389282227, -0.26148682832717896, -0.5770402550697327, -0.4800274074077606, 0.21330107748508453, 0.141013041138649, 0.43093597888946533, 0.7676883339881897, 0.6242150664329529, -0.7063539624214172, 0.13996297121047974, -0.2921358048915863, -0.03340237960219383, -0.5084116458892822, -0.11127236485481262, 0.3598823845386505, 0.6970973610877991, 0.11340520530939102, 0.13971710205078125, 0.3310333490371704, 0.0774012878537178, -0.5538052320480347, 1.1273363828659058, -0.32010018825531006, -0.6353821158409119, 0.6070337295532227, -0.4268070161342621, -0.43902722001075745, -0.11444137990474701, 0.3175622820854187, 0.11656725406646729, -0.33646419644355774, 0.8301024436950684, 0.5071707963943481, -1.1379097700119019, -0.040798064321279526, 0.2964075207710266, -0.7087001800537109, -0.7853454351425171, -0.35202914476394653, 0.568808376789093, 0.6899915933609009, -0.370991051197052, -0.5504552721977234, 0.9747354388237, -0.29111582040786743, 0.43334072828292847, -0.05492118373513222, -0.24597479403018951, -0.3485149145126343, -0.43502938747406006, -0.23307888209819794, -0.5762907266616821, 0.4329301416873932, 0.2971835136413574, 0.1082862839102745, 0.17764395475387573, 0.42754557728767395, 0.017357023432850838, 0.40051519870758057, 0.34602633118629456, 1.1643022298812866, -0.7039418816566467, -0.5825376510620117, 0.20090484619140625, 0.04904244840145111, 0.12882891297340393, 0.21231675148010254, -0.5625550150871277, 0.8165153861045837, -0.16141967475414276, -0.4688754975795746, -0.21796981990337372, 0.07067222893238068, 0.25835710763931274, 0.7559606432914734, -0.42029762268066406, -0.3456360399723053, 0.7981635928153992, 0.43011072278022766, 0.8257988095283508, -0.04138864204287529, -1.210966944694519, -0.6084145903587341, -0.16605965793132782, 0.06178103759884834, -0.41278454661369324, -0.6945996284484863, 0.48259881138801575, 0.4449077546596527, -0.7521724700927734, 0.2481340616941452, 1.0231828689575195, -0.16255372762680054, -0.5667824745178223, -0.806369423866272, 1.0544581413269043, 0.4556686282157898, -0.3491672873497009, 0.147724911570549, -0.5244764685630798, -0.000940613797865808, 0.352133184671402, -0.28561335802078247, -0.12105274945497513, -0.40609854459762573, 0.606101930141449, 0.14569488167762756, 0.7624498009681702, -0.218760684132576, -0.21417264640331268, 0.4214124381542206, 0.5659560561180115, -0.41209128499031067, -0.2592655122280121, 0.8784164786338806, -0.7954561114311218, 0.12590044736862183, 0.8418444395065308, -0.17599613964557648, -0.12642711400985718, -0.2080206722021103, 0.2918834090232849, -0.43472030758857727, -0.5968047976493835, -0.1511639952659607, 0.7965303659439087, -0.7592253684997559, -0.6190771460533142, -0.287462055683136, -0.21853254735469818, 0.24831722676753998, -0.1344742476940155, 0.008691549301147461, 0.22025233507156372, 0.4829550087451935, 0.6559464335441589, -0.1442737877368927, 0.971123993396759, -0.5213696360588074, 0.04035676643252373, -0.2542854845523834, 0.23249544203281403, 0.426830530166626, -0.9217994809150696, -0.062440425157547, 0.46166732907295227, -0.6441066265106201, 0.24891482293605804, -0.2998719811439514, -0.3918845057487488, -0.1863795965909958, -0.10291019827127457, 0.07317612320184708, 1.2020553350448608, 0.7786625027656555, -0.4087628722190857, -0.1693895310163498, 0.06596861034631729, -0.4054621458053589, -0.174400195479393, -0.6367782354354858, -0.31082478165626526, -0.00943563599139452, -0.433253675699234, -0.21270063519477844, -0.9026204347610474, -0.6647446155548096, 0.6533998250961304, -0.10495925694704056, 0.240313321352005, -0.3716224133968353, 0.6389042139053345, 0.21477611362934113, 0.20487426221370697, 0.5181228518486023, 0.12896119058132172, 0.15003491938114166, 0.3959450423717499, -0.34080570936203003, -0.7985305786132812, 0.7421274781227112, 0.03674648702144623, -0.11208729445934296, 0.35783371329307556, 0.002241820562630892, 0.6464006900787354, 0.4521547555923462, 0.29483675956726074, 0.06435491144657135, -0.32243892550468445, -0.38982370495796204, -0.6185004115104675, -0.23792323470115662, 0.5360901951789856, -0.5237716436386108, 0.277605265378952, -0.20466016232967377, -1.202949047088623, -1.1699812412261963, 0.09930632263422012, 0.9805251359939575, -0.09150481224060059, 0.5225794315338135, -0.25091201066970825, 0.6655948758125305, -0.15599298477172852, 0.1274612694978714, 0.12507829070091248, 0.21631929278373718, -0.3334546387195587, -0.017632821574807167, 0.11520516127347946, 0.369721919298172, 0.8435986638069153, 0.3751368224620819, -0.2213248312473297, 0.607903778553009, 0.3414154648780823, -0.24946606159210205, -0.21703007817268372, -0.44805005192756653, 0.9635803699493408, 0.5467215180397034, -0.28156915307044983, 0.08260856568813324, 0.024313388392329216, 0.012303556315600872, 0.08406534045934677, -0.778607189655304, 0.6411474943161011, -0.18667754530906677, -0.5603819489479065, -0.37159010767936707, -0.14552120864391327, 0.6686408519744873, -0.3617469370365143, 1.213972806930542, 0.9288848638534546, 0.4863182306289673, -0.35941657423973083, -0.11792060732841492, 0.8179039359092712, -0.4448884129524231, -0.5153437852859497, -0.2440781444311142, 0.17948676645755768, 0.1701188087463379, -0.31852757930755615, 0.13958726823329926, -0.6463399529457092, 0.123494952917099, 0.5271521806716919, -0.004615449346601963, 0.19996124505996704, 0.7823947072029114, -1.0132830142974854, 0.07318857312202454, -0.2630590498447418, 0.4650295078754425, -0.3779699504375458, -0.42218607664108276, 0.5926715731620789, -0.14241237938404083, -0.11985505372285843, -0.1927938014268875, 0.28227826952934265, 0.6229398846626282, 0.3352194130420685, -0.11506135016679764, -0.6055412292480469, 0.45645496249198914, 0.6456214785575867, -0.04553789645433426, -0.08358661085367203, -0.26000115275382996, -0.1988251656293869, 0.016266735270619392, -0.12093168497085571, 0.6843917965888977, 0.3006654977798462, -0.44291090965270996, -0.24783068895339966, 0.005701286718249321, -0.13002696633338928, -0.47519129514694214, -0.22586499154567719, -0.5630525350570679, -0.2913738191127777, -0.1419234424829483, -0.34012797474861145, -0.35668283700942993, -0.1994069665670395, -0.14343351125717163, -0.009145624004304409, -0.09963134676218033, -0.10935956984758377, 0.15823163092136383, -0.4186685085296631, 0.7293016314506531, 0.32669252157211304, -1.061437726020813, -0.7783421874046326, -0.31295445561408997, -0.13977886736392975, 0.47472384572029114, -0.16452117264270782, -0.3634558916091919, 0.017711400985717773, -0.20437303185462952, 0.2426787167787552, 0.35188040137290955, -0.7927230000495911, -0.1467888206243515, 0.19946318864822388, 0.4518893361091614, 0.01344386488199234, 0.8939149379730225, 0.13854166865348816, -0.25004032254219055, 0.22228668630123138, -0.4805462062358856, 0.5399365425109863, -0.0041487859562039375, 0.20460136234760284, -0.0063133854418993, 0.2604386806488037, 0.36508968472480774, -0.46651870012283325, 0.71216881275177, 0.7823660373687744, 0.4340350031852722, -0.018205124884843826, -0.8318747282028198, -1.5195434093475342, -0.4411572813987732, 1.1539546251296997, -0.2684158384799957, 0.535983681678772, -0.23557579517364502, 0.48322737216949463, 0.33338233828544617, -1.1258641481399536, 4.173249244689941, 0.9209418892860413, 0.654947817325592, -0.1446489542722702, 0.21604718267917633, 0.9740509390830994, 0.09720982611179352, -0.026290616020560265, 0.958868682384491, -0.1853944957256317, -0.1419486105442047, 0.4960848391056061, 0.36894986033439636, 0.40374940633773804, 1.1234667301177979, 1.0721160173416138, -0.3083086907863617, -0.6540794968605042, -0.15596885979175568, -0.6826357245445251, -0.00675125140696764, 0.1293882429599762, -0.13854727149009705, 0.6725838780403137, -0.1670456975698471, -0.2636430859565735, 0.13073737919330597, 0.8156871795654297, -0.10804077237844467, -0.10423656553030014, 0.20361416041851044, -0.3620189428329468, -0.05815443769097328, -1.418163776397705, 0.5681526064872742, 0.061812616884708405, -0.09908769279718399, -0.35202401876449585, -0.21280059218406677, 0.3740670382976532, -0.09921766817569733, 0.2844614088535309, -0.1180766373872757, -0.6123247742652893, -0.2316155582666397, 0.0010623532580211759, -0.7173547148704529, 0.16831520199775696, -0.3406861126422882, -0.5422319173812866, 1.1551713943481445, -1.1574589014053345, 0.329517126083374, 0.46208369731903076, -0.51115882396698, 0.1170119196176529, -0.04490562900900841, -0.1881103664636612, -0.03253525123000145, 0.8322012424468994, 0.3402263820171356, 0.18337702751159668, 0.2682422399520874, -0.16942298412322998, 0.4536094665527344, 1.0550720691680908, 0.17831574380397797, 0.3547966182231903, -0.7774946689605713, 0.09828674048185349, -0.23120160400867462, 0.39163053035736084, -0.23790359497070312, -1.117008090019226, 0.6004282832145691, 0.12676751613616943, -0.0839916467666626, 0.43818163871765137, -0.2852165102958679, -0.24667100608348846, -0.43051663041114807, 0.4350320100784302, -0.3370957672595978, -0.12533187866210938, -0.6350164413452148, 1.1013147830963135, 0.06189320981502533, -0.48049280047416687, -1.1067696809768677, 0.21520733833312988, -0.042090754956007004, -0.1417769491672516, -0.04147437587380409, -0.3640313744544983, 0.09960440546274185 ]
{"Title": "Against Empathy: distinct correlates of empathy and compassion with burnout and affective symptoms in health professionals and students", "Authors": "Romani-Sponchiado Aline, Jordan Matthew R., Stringaris Argyris, Salum Giovanni Abrah\u00e3o", "Abstract": "Concern for the well-being of medical professionals has increased considering the high rates of depression and suicidal ideation observed among medical students and residents. However, the causes of such psychological distress among health professionals are still unknown.\nOne possibility is that such negative outcomes arise from individual differences in how clinicians respond to the emotional states of their patients: while some tend respond with empathy (feeling what others feel), others tend respond with compassion (caring about what others feel). The aim of this study is to investigate the hypothesis that empathy is related to higher levels of burnout and affective symptoms, while compassion is related to lower levels of these outcomes.\nWe surveyed 464 undergraduate students and professionals in medicine (34.3%), psychology (47%) and nursing (18.8%), 79.7% female, with a median age of 23.3. The survey included the concern and perspective taking subscales from the Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI); empathy and behavioral contagion from the Empathy Index (EI); the depression, anxiety, and anger subscales from PROMIS; and the Medical Student Well-Being Index (MSWBI).\nEmpathy was associated with higher symptoms of burnout, depression, anxiety and anger; while higher levels of compassion were associated with lower levels of these outcomes.\nOur findings provide new evidence that the well-being of medical professionals might be affected differently depending on socio-emotional traits relevant to emotional connection.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005231"}
10.1101/19010397
[ 0.36455240845680237, -0.2534601390361786, -0.47526541352272034, 1.2176635265350342, -0.5475163459777832, 0.005257731303572655, 0.41019168496131897, 0.05646996572613716, 0.4718277156352997, -0.017595749348402023, -0.8599395751953125, -0.4677700996398926, 0.2015402913093567, -0.2422030121088028, -0.34316685795783997, -0.17627687752246857, -0.5612716674804688, -0.44993332028388977, -1.086884617805481, 0.5811354517936707, -0.03048231266438961, 0.6724543571472168, -0.32799774408340454, 0.45478203892707825, -0.5295723676681519, 0.3712652623653412, -0.42058175802230835, 0.1357213407754898, 1.058498740196228, 0.5725690722465515, -0.008762236684560776, -0.21727783977985382, 0.23530688881874084, -0.25083398818969727, -0.7375098466873169, -0.32276761531829834, 0.2982567846775055, -0.11950091272592545, -0.2626652121543884, -0.26912638545036316, 0.1975935995578766, 0.046500254422426224, 0.03692750260233879, -0.24610716104507446, -1.1859179735183716, 0.3958112597465515, 0.04708721488714218, -0.9805780649185181, 0.08261055499315262, -0.15856528282165527, -0.2638169527053833, -0.15125396847724915, 0.20280738174915314, -0.14407996833324432, -0.27964717149734497, -0.006576776038855314, -0.3130142092704773, 0.10928339511156082, -0.6515448689460754, 0.5067700743675232, 0.3718331456184387, 0.155877023935318, 0.40939369797706604, -1.2952700853347778, 0.6718265414237976, 0.597983181476593, 0.19186508655548096, -0.15357331931591034, -0.4354758858680725, -0.37440332770347595, -0.4777710735797882, -0.15603989362716675, -1.1363872289657593, -0.8123201727867126, 0.19847047328948975, 0.08709827065467834, 0.543645977973938, -0.10200059413909912, 0.04323172569274902, -0.6228966116905212, 0.7497028112411499, 0.4444551169872284, 0.872366189956665, 0.2877551019191742, -0.417761892080307, 0.21199554204940796, 0.646319568157196, -0.1835692971944809, 0.11966673284769058, -0.4185313284397125, -0.09588862210512161, 0.5105675458908081, -0.03836735710501671, -0.1499374508857727, 0.2321682572364807, 0.7649832963943481, -0.2627401053905487, -0.010037916712462902, 0.3246680200099945, -0.2342754453420639, 0.4070909917354584, 0.7518315315246582, -0.5611412525177002, 0.8688740730285645, -0.5131716132164001, 0.5973691940307617, 1.0604861974716187, -0.7515530586242676, -0.5385118126869202, -0.9118947982788086, 0.006404217332601547, -0.417070209980011, -0.5289939641952515, 0.9152529239654541, 0.5183159112930298, 0.6584940552711487, -0.09936969727277756, -0.1757412552833557, -0.7052217125892639, 0.888274073600769, 0.20926836133003235, 0.09068320691585541, 0.15163402259349823, -0.7482388615608215, 1.1555700302124023, 0.2502376437187195, 0.41736462712287903, -0.013927722349762917, -0.4366407096385956, -0.1450735330581665, 0.6790071129798889, -0.13423356413841248, 0.3119873106479645, 0.5205370783805847, -0.928065836429596, -0.46728143095970154, 0.15966694056987762, 0.20807994902133942, 0.5383532643318176, -0.2105664163827896, -0.5629445910453796, 0.21713998913764954, -0.0328916497528553, 0.5333260297775269, -0.2380065619945526, 0.7674075365066528, -0.9904370307922363, -1.1417466402053833, -0.6350367069244385, -0.24362963438034058, -0.35300251841545105, 0.24448975920677185, -0.9572916030883789, 0.29159557819366455, -0.14560861885547638, 0.4967164099216461, -0.48210662603378296, 0.6327235698699951, -0.25700142979621887, 0.07958433032035828, -0.2569938004016876, 0.4289853274822235, -0.10418324172496796, 0.1875135451555252, -0.12079998850822449, 0.6563263535499573, -0.515619695186615, -0.18977588415145874, 0.6006701588630676, -0.2975379228591919, 0.08885520696640015, -0.17681953310966492, -0.6023755073547363, -0.2309151440858841, -0.02028004825115204, 0.703421413898468, 0.969479501247406, 0.3319607377052307, -0.39422550797462463, 0.06546191871166229, -0.0615035742521286, 0.1263195276260376, 0.42054030299186707, 0.9789150357246399, -0.4555060863494873, -0.16847874224185944, -0.20316211879253387, -0.48296812176704407, -0.5927226543426514, -0.22703170776367188, 0.05915674567222595, 0.8585411906242371, -0.3075551688671112, 1.1425769329071045, 0.11610497534275055, 0.17157775163650513, -0.20210148394107819, 0.1669957935810089, 0.023885352537035942, -0.4649284780025482, -1.1674820184707642, 0.8632673025131226, -0.08809029310941696, 0.2517003118991852, -0.30284518003463745, 0.8551675081253052, 0.560975193977356, 0.07265299558639526, -0.6498002409934998, -0.1782330870628357, 0.9299978613853455, 0.11426606774330139, 0.14845798909664154, 0.41463276743888855, 0.5365709066390991, -0.2691880166530609, -0.14874286949634552, 0.27438658475875854, -0.34059542417526245, 0.2612161338329315, -0.6323227882385254, -0.28449007868766785, 0.5421751737594604, 0.3268057703971863, 0.7523433566093445, 0.08691518008708954, 0.8444634675979614, 0.15664851665496826, -0.43859338760375977, -0.5665740966796875, 0.4456801116466522, 0.24532410502433777, -0.22638891637325287, 0.9700634479522705, 0.574963390827179, 0.263163685798645, -0.10472812503576279, 0.3388765752315521, 0.6670012474060059, 0.26485076546669006, 0.7940118908882141, 0.020812055096030235, 1.0095829963684082, 0.0721319392323494, -0.7737752795219421, 0.4848213195800781, -1.0066938400268555, -0.018146716058254242, -0.2709333598613739, -0.07136453688144684, -0.49430540204048157, 0.22566315531730652, 0.26885882019996643, 0.6504881978034973, -1.264359474182129, -0.344590961933136, 0.2563585638999939, 0.2359742373228073, -0.16137059032917023, -0.31888237595558167, 0.31862303614616394, -0.17601187527179718, -0.28588807582855225, -0.08597520738840103, 1.017394781112671, 0.855343759059906, 0.023505358025431633, 0.48900845646858215, 0.2783282697200775, -0.5260416865348816, -0.23291122913360596, -0.850396990776062, -1.4321585893630981, -0.8264901638031006, -0.23841190338134766, 0.5368360280990601, -0.013305244036018848, -0.2968403697013855, 0.5432494282722473, -0.13895803689956665, 0.1357448697090149, -0.20239849388599396, 0.5942871570587158, 0.4359009265899658, 0.3201429545879364, 0.351267546415329, -0.7015831470489502, 0.056220684200525284, -0.6622245907783508, -0.037478748708963394, -0.04347052052617073, -0.2653209865093231, 0.5104118585586548, -0.6823517680168152, 1.0506068468093872, -0.983130693435669, -0.5946943163871765, 0.24004215002059937, -0.8065691590309143, -0.33087849617004395, 0.5313523411750793, -0.49240076541900635, 0.6001635193824768, 0.6075695157051086, -1.4087198972702026, 0.664763867855072, 0.22735366225242615, -0.22375117242336273, 1.0362809896469116, 0.10945983976125717, 0.26106587052345276, 0.6488475203514099, -0.1286206692457199, -0.5358666777610779, -0.7737957239151001, 0.2583667039871216, 0.35169482231140137, -0.9536159634590149, 0.23414729535579681, -0.49797964096069336, -0.16701927781105042, -0.08501196652650833, -0.20878919959068298, -0.47638189792633057, 0.07827930152416229, 0.1768614649772644, -0.16326989233493805, -0.9446508884429932, -0.1353856772184372, -0.6825921535491943, -1.1344724893569946, -0.0981806144118309, 0.014133214950561523, 0.2887134850025177, 0.06052947789430618, 0.2023400217294693, -0.3803067207336426, 0.2193799912929535, 0.05516361817717552, -0.16578446328639984, 0.00414647301658988, 0.09045256674289703, 0.15876024961471558, 0.08622737228870392, 0.1745789647102356, -0.0705726146697998, -0.060985077172517776, -0.31401509046554565, -0.2509496808052063, 0.041614215821027756, 0.00151218066457659, 0.29383325576782227, 0.44038328528404236, -0.5764435529708862, -0.19841477274894714, 0.4865889251232147, 0.3472130596637726, -0.41596323251724243, 0.7339945435523987, 1.1104356050491333, 0.33584094047546387, -0.03753930330276489, 0.18451741337776184, -0.019819272682070732, -0.6595023274421692, -0.4004845917224884, 0.58807772397995, 0.3907737135887146, 0.5903667211532593, 0.0663420557975769, 0.7474609613418579, 0.1421303004026413, -0.7534334659576416, -0.11705035716295242, 0.3379974067211151, 0.19291415810585022, 0.40249350666999817, 0.3598511815071106, 1.3035287857055664, -0.8478337526321411, 0.27669182419776917, 0.9856908321380615, 1.0680873394012451, 0.13382969796657562, 0.5223731398582458, 0.2946247458457947, -0.7815955877304077, -0.14800423383712769, 0.34395983815193176, -0.35075220465660095, -0.43739524483680725, 0.256997287273407, 0.5545526742935181, 0.0768786296248436, 0.026725387200713158, 0.14387762546539307, 0.08146634697914124, 0.3035348653793335, 0.4348994493484497, -0.4802415668964386, 0.9097434282302856, -0.1745348870754242, -0.2290053516626358, 0.2118840366601944, 0.6254972815513611, -0.4573068618774414, -0.41280364990234375, -0.13065572082996368, 0.4394071102142334, -0.36293649673461914, -1.1585009098052979, -0.15042681992053986, -0.228277787566185, -0.19355028867721558, 0.14788256585597992, 0.058088887482881546, -0.4190378487110138, 0.17902515828609467, -0.10448776930570602, 0.6884033679962158, 0.5949671268463135, 0.21232853829860687, -0.3191259503364563, -0.07297725975513458, 0.3558143675327301, -0.24176500737667084, 0.05160660669207573, -1.0141894817352295, -0.2356070727109909, 0.5921761989593506, -0.622708261013031, -0.3895139992237091, -0.3042309880256653, -0.11364070326089859, -0.3228108584880829, 0.707547664642334, 0.458577036857605, -0.3556579053401947, 0.19820357859134674, -0.4821373224258423, 0.27548882365226746, -0.4236834943294525, -0.08189598470926285, -0.5487258434295654, 0.08703358471393585, 0.167430579662323, 0.9249205589294434, 0.07678929716348648, 0.8754223585128784, -0.2548351585865021, 0.2972038984298706, -0.4207687973976135, 0.5188239216804504, -0.4175739586353302, 0.0077380831353366375, -0.18986761569976807, 0.26669377088546753, -0.03487107902765274, 0.136286199092865, -0.14281919598579407, -0.6815484762191772, -0.36765995621681213, 0.07085783779621124, 0.04871943220496178, 0.8262553215026855, 1.2845841646194458, -1.0072661638259888, -0.37197446823120117, 0.9952666759490967, -0.5244598388671875, -0.3903297185897827, 0.009866414591670036, 0.03634166717529297, -0.2479144185781479, 0.5462260842323303, 0.20246495306491852, -0.45315486192703247, -0.1011243686079979, -0.4310776889324188, 0.6983644366264343, -0.7287506461143494, 0.08139929920434952, -0.861415445804596, -0.15372000634670258, -0.4813753068447113, -0.46424198150634766, -0.5313690304756165, 0.0015596554148942232, -1.2682521343231201, 0.4788150489330292, -0.0642046332359314, -0.251392126083374, 0.45795151591300964, 0.5506669282913208, -0.6316090226173401, -0.45414119958877563, -0.4998791515827179, 0.2651093006134033, -0.08760466426610947, -0.2333557903766632, 0.41665375232696533, -1.4591658115386963, -0.3435695171356201, 0.1569657325744629, 0.12546947598457336, -0.6850537061691284, -0.2115921527147293, -0.4846417307853699, -0.4867027997970581, -0.06459759920835495, -0.21430809795856476, -0.1617792695760727, -0.584186315536499, 0.31093457341194153, -0.2952482998371124, 0.28810182213783264, 0.654401957988739, -0.1906934678554535, 0.13359346985816956, 0.503007709980011, -0.555229902267456, -0.4545995891094208, -0.1819603443145752, 0.10593092441558838, 0.4204823970794678, 0.3631725609302521, 0.12493322044610977, -0.6422070264816284, -0.446725457906723, -0.5078069567680359, 0.2968659996986389, -1.0209625959396362, -0.7301129102706909, -0.10541500151157379, -0.05073105916380882, -0.45477989315986633, 0.13402225077152252, 0.15183134377002716, -0.1751420944929123, -0.31656351685523987, -0.48040011525154114, 0.5459085702896118, 0.010058198124170303, 0.3472384512424469, 0.2379530817270279, -0.42868340015411377, -0.13409171998500824, 1.0070635080337524, -0.014667235314846039, 0.3883426785469055, -0.5318661332130432, 0.056101635098457336, 0.626960813999176, 1.263541579246521, 0.1269807070493698, -0.8488967418670654, 1.0063661336898804, 0.19572505354881287, 0.25731325149536133, -0.04644390568137169, -0.33506399393081665, 0.19737829267978668, 0.08764050900936127, 0.4796714782714844, -0.2372717708349228, -0.45379334688186646, 0.05257890000939369, -0.26901793479919434, 0.5651611685752869, -0.17794860899448395, 0.5737196207046509, 0.17340876162052155, -0.30359944701194763, 0.1138908863067627, 0.5715634226799011, -0.5195005536079407, 0.5968472361564636, -0.42618653178215027, -0.47418543696403503, -0.48090070486068726, 0.510927140712738, -0.07466033846139908, 0.5850188732147217, -0.383481502532959, -0.09910666942596436, -0.1608305126428604, 0.7832474112510681, 1.2523471117019653, -0.6158566474914551, -0.2708274722099304, -0.2373478263616562, 0.28806784749031067, 0.09287384897470474, 0.5728696584701538, 0.09302917122840881, -0.2652856409549713, 0.2820615768432617, 0.010053766891360283, -0.5288854241371155, -0.6743167638778687, -0.4696337580680847, 0.2708023190498352, 0.36519548296928406, 0.2647421658039093, 0.3368987441062927, 0.08366909623146057, 0.14895936846733093, -1.1317360401153564, 0.3270937204360962, -0.20740634202957153, 0.24659360945224762, -0.2166404277086258, 0.12370701879262924, -0.5367549061775208, -0.14200380444526672, -0.44281521439552307, 0.4690280854701996, 0.38860949873924255, 0.18275371193885803, 0.661710262298584, -0.8575600385665894, 0.606731653213501, 0.8260827660560608, -0.4430464804172516, -0.9061183333396912, -0.38900768756866455, 0.22486701607704163, 0.018367694690823555, -0.21538151800632477, -0.7295101881027222, 0.9618926644325256, -0.07600200921297073, 0.5991960167884827, 0.077438123524189, -0.08714917302131653, -0.06950361281633377, -0.6349729299545288, 0.45079493522644043, -0.4751955568790436, -0.7121250629425049, 0.17184707522392273, 0.10803920775651932, -0.14941035211086273, 0.3612631559371948, 0.781932532787323, -0.54572993516922, 0.5608566403388977, 0.5629960298538208, -0.6887556910514832, -0.24910053610801697, -0.48668810725212097, 0.7732223868370056, -0.10645036399364471, 0.5158410668373108, 0.30432355403900146, 0.8169357776641846, 0.36879777908325195, -0.6925895810127258, -0.3408816456794739, 0.6008866429328918, -0.01568000577390194, 0.6237910985946655, 0.007882778532803059, -0.22379526495933533, 1.0781691074371338, -0.12741416692733765, 0.6321973204612732, -0.5720601677894592, -0.8845525979995728, -0.5563576221466064, -0.5212833881378174, 0.41966408491134644, -0.10508137196302414, -0.12560823559761047, 0.805927574634552, -0.6834500432014465, -0.636971652507782, -0.7166144847869873, 1.2363923788070679, -0.24493056535720825, -0.6393100619316101, -0.8810268640518188, 0.5293147563934326, -0.6448933482170105, -1.2470855712890625, -1.1719021797180176, -0.44860130548477173, 0.13286294043064117, 0.9604576230049133, -0.03787295147776604, 0.11598701775074005, 0.1649332046508789, 0.04579031839966774, -0.0231830682605505, 0.16335485875606537, -0.4082418978214264, 0.06079525500535965, -0.28943711519241333, 0.8554168939590454, 0.8766465187072754, -0.2784249782562256, 1.7768876552581787, -0.9319963455200195, 0.1718517690896988, 0.161876380443573, -0.18969471752643585, -0.5942654609680176, 0.22527460753917694, 0.13162775337696075, -0.579365074634552, -0.8601579070091248, -0.5159924030303955, 0.19297409057617188, -1.0428364276885986, -0.04277845472097397, 0.22345863282680511, -0.16020876169204712, 0.09292518347501755, 1.014392614364624, -0.26519545912742615, 0.581662118434906, 0.6235000491142273, 0.2387417107820511, -0.4726068079471588, 1.2345619201660156, 0.15075816214084625, 0.4041465222835541, 0.4994811415672302, 0.7066164612770081, -0.37777334451675415, -1.0162497758865356, 1.0137784481048584, 0.3892238438129425, -0.43170666694641113, 0.48518240451812744, 0.2061859667301178, 0.39513877034187317, -0.07143030315637589, -0.2068340927362442, 0.289192259311676, 1.0263265371322632, 0.42909982800483704, 0.6047695279121399, 0.1146794781088829, -0.17959514260292053, -0.7101507186889648, -0.3754312992095947, -1.4486114978790283, -0.9775632619857788, 0.3231642246246338, -0.24526460468769073, -0.4821987748146057, -0.7678744196891785, -0.5747518539428711, 0.411408394575119, -0.45703423023223877, 0.3304100036621094, -0.24757446348667145, 0.2426849603652954, -0.0905948057770729, 0.37592920660972595, 0.25033918023109436, -0.1679377257823944, -0.32170382142066956, -0.14179149270057678, -0.4930957853794098, -0.6452348828315735, -0.10174335539340973, 0.6939381957054138, 0.7152150273323059, -0.4398617744445801, -0.10692895203828812, -0.27648401260375977, 0.19793619215488434, 0.15517650544643402, -1.143723726272583, 0.15903274714946747, -0.025123294442892075, -0.14978866279125214, -0.2640012502670288, -0.43991202116012573, -0.012693961150944233, 0.943751335144043, 0.13020318746566772, -0.9666708707809448, -0.2714412212371826, 0.49829867482185364, -0.008904563263058662, 0.09813432395458221, 0.5389611124992371, -0.690867006778717, 0.2995956540107727, -0.06128387525677681, -0.019750596955418587, 0.7811902165412903, 1.0666877031326294, 0.44348859786987305, 0.34178686141967773, 0.11611700057983398, 0.34279802441596985, 0.4644164741039276, 0.8599562048912048, -0.4237578511238098, 0.8958637714385986, -0.32677125930786133, 0.4855949878692627, -0.14549873769283295, -0.6065182089805603, -0.1600533276796341, 0.1448647677898407, -0.038811154663562775, 0.5101905465126038, -0.26104798913002014, 0.44527506828308105, -0.07197305560112, -0.7181826233863831, 0.71891850233078, -0.6618817448616028, -0.2876979112625122, 0.5921807885169983, 0.17163687944412231, 0.5125336050987244, -0.03262060508131981, -0.20149412751197815, 0.3177880346775055, 0.30979615449905396, -0.24156875908374786, 0.22002573311328888, 0.4717797040939331, -0.5222540497779846, -0.47159627079963684, -0.9916819930076599, 0.9229772090911865, -0.15899397432804108, 0.1760486215353012, -0.04417705908417702, -0.18310874700546265, 0.48134148120880127, 0.47626087069511414, -0.11868677288293839, -0.504153311252594, 0.7504789233207703, -0.22997930645942688, 0.03722791746258736, -0.14945852756500244, -0.21785107254981995, -0.7440484166145325, -1.1719406843185425, 0.17578239738941193, 0.23565760254859924, 0.2188567966222763, 0.09329112619161606, 0.593370258808136, 0.78178870677948, 0.4457860291004181, 0.49220335483551025, 0.19462314248085022, 0.3122826814651489, 0.4796363115310669, -0.5227167010307312, -0.5713928937911987, -0.2696899175643921, -0.33573609590530396, -0.5435142517089844, 0.36472460627555847, -0.02637455053627491, -0.21584047377109528, -0.6271287798881531, -0.10947518795728683, 0.20133325457572937, -0.04249724745750427, -0.36655154824256897, -1.1012768745422363, -0.05011367425322533, -0.4568822383880615, -0.17214958369731903, -0.24143604934215546, 0.6437196135520935, 0.5845984220504761, -0.43382444977760315, -0.19478745758533478, -0.1495979130268097, -0.7909692525863647, 0.4179960787296295, -0.4605780839920044, 0.21803514659404755, 0.5234953165054321, -0.21086281538009644, -0.38811805844306946, -0.9515191912651062, 0.31282171607017517, 0.4689944386482239, -0.14619101583957672, -0.3947448134422302, -0.49662137031555176, 0.05688514932990074, 0.8269850015640259, 0.43245816230773926, -0.3486684560775757, 0.20387090742588043, 0.45238956809043884, 0.6610524654388428, -0.29999420046806335, 0.5527470111846924, 0.37567830085754395, -0.5120115876197815, 0.14609447121620178, -0.32898178696632385, -0.16753169894218445, -0.8062205910682678, -0.0871424674987793, -0.6984481811523438, 0.3227938413619995, -0.09141714870929718, -0.3186403214931488, 0.49665096402168274, 1.0563310384750366, -0.5786505341529846, -0.4024658799171448, -0.8110371232032776, -0.5237258076667786, -0.22050480544567108, 0.5304345488548279, -0.910973310470581, 0.1450943946838379, 0.05692711099982262, -0.21723900735378265, 0.048446137458086014, -0.8291252255439758, 4.14074182510376, 1.1377298831939697, 1.0064164400100708, -0.4278727173805237, 0.4787140488624573, 0.8747870326042175, 0.6617898941040039, -0.2868802547454834, -0.24582193791866302, -0.06701398640871048, 0.3777138888835907, 0.11764073371887207, 0.1345554143190384, -0.359905868768692, 0.354792982339859, 0.04565124213695526, -0.8605953454971313, -0.11347180604934692, -0.44293472170829773, -1.3894706964492798, -0.6035449504852295, -0.2646106481552124, -0.11385726928710938, 0.5559939742088318, 0.48954126238822937, 0.09335310012102127, 0.31644704937934875, -0.33327287435531616, -0.3597376346588135, -0.21608363091945648, -0.23525623977184296, 0.06572452187538147, 0.17316500842571259, -0.977027416229248, -0.35320571064949036, 0.635831356048584, 0.22436566650867462, -0.7490271329879761, -0.9144346117973328, -0.3950076103210449, 0.04312653839588165, -0.10849859565496445, 0.2445010244846344, -0.6145418882369995, -0.4263565242290497, 0.5791298747062683, -0.6369282603263855, 0.2687198221683502, 0.2394247055053711, -0.8753945827484131, 1.0341777801513672, -0.5180521607398987, 0.14156277477741241, -0.46875840425491333, -0.31584033370018005, -0.49638375639915466, -0.3092696964740753, -0.7863138318061829, 0.24135500192642212, -0.5460193157196045, 0.5104082822799683, 0.1848490834236145, -0.2313452810049057, 0.8481673002243042, 0.26794445514678955, 0.4705440104007721, 0.4570218026638031, 0.6162790656089783, -0.43959999084472656, -0.43121445178985596, -0.18488551676273346, -0.6889849901199341, -1.0960501432418823, 0.29350733757019043, 0.7367863059043884, 0.037221264094114304, 0.23432570695877075, 0.3634865880012512, -0.040753867477178574, -0.7901087403297424, 0.3557705581188202, 0.6889622807502747, 0.12567585706710815, -0.6288111209869385, 0.19937480986118317, 1.0112472772598267, -0.4628737270832062, -0.3963010907173157, -1.0782197713851929, 0.3940933048725128, 0.6759093999862671, -0.08739737421274185, -0.5187845230102539, 1.309652328491211, -0.877859354019165 ]
{"Title": "From frail to fit after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation: Scope of the problem and a strength-based solution", "Authors": "Sweetnam Jason, Twohey Eric, Skendzel Sasha, Stingle John, Arora Mukta, Baraki Austin, Cao Qing, Grillo Sonya, Holtan Shernan G.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Frailty is a common but underdiagnosed syndrome among long-term survivors of allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). Conditions such as malnutrition, fatigue, and weakness may suggest frailty despite patients not receiving a formal diagnosis. Furthermore, the optimal interventions to overcome frailty in long-term survivors of allogeneic HCT is not yet established. Patients and Methods This study consists of a retrospective and prospective component. First, we completed a retrospective review using diagnosis data from the electronic medical record to estimate the prevalence of components of frailty in 1077 recipients of allogeneic HCT through 5 years post-transplant. Second, we developed a community-based pilot study of strength training for long-term survivors of allogeneic HCT that addressed several common barriers exercise engagement and adherence. Four allogeneic HCT recipients (2 males, 2 females) and 4 controls (2 males, 2 females) completed the strength training pilot study, consisting of a baseline assessment, 10 weeks of personalized and supervised strength programming at least once weekly as a group, and an end-of-study assessment to measure progress in strength, body composition, and a standardized measure of self-efficacy. Results Despite a lack of a formal diagnosis, approximately 80% of HCT recipients in this series received a diagnosis of a component of frailty (weakness, fatigue, or malnutrition), and over 1/3 of HCT recipients had symptoms extending beyond 1 year. Over the course of the strength training pilot study, both pre-frail/frail allogeneic HCT recipients and healthy controls doubled their total strength, lost body fat, and gained muscle mass. Self-efficacy improved from baseline in allogeneic HCT recipients after the strength training pilot program. Discussion Based upon the prevalence of frailty-related diagnoses among long-term survivors of HCT, a comprehensive mitigation strategy needs to be developed for this population. A community-based strength training program that includes a personalized component, a group setting, and caregiver/partner involvement appears feasible and overcomes several established barriers to exercise engagement and adherence.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010397"}
10.1101/19013573
[ 0.016604389995336533, 0.2701267898082733, -0.07928714156150818, 0.40083640813827515, 0.5529015064239502, -0.29132241010665894, -0.3100756108760834, 0.09118679910898209, -0.11598266661167145, 0.7978709936141968, -0.4345880150794983, -0.7321813702583313, 0.33040812611579895, -0.3714168965816498, -0.1037178561091423, -0.6239055395126343, -0.010710217989981174, -0.1278369128704071, 0.33710771799087524, -0.4610947370529175, 0.04133350029587746, 0.2894558310508728, -1.1221270561218262, 0.6654481291770935, -0.13553893566131592, 0.9107227921485901, -0.36108729243278503, 0.217452272772789, 1.1566015481948853, 0.34011560678482056, -0.17354470491409302, -0.2278248816728592, 0.11331009119749069, -1.336869478225708, -0.038356054574251175, -0.16233500838279724, 0.24996384978294373, -0.3651958405971527, -0.7484169006347656, 0.049042709171772, 0.4129130244255066, 0.6313204169273376, 0.4000851809978485, -0.38331419229507446, -0.22167876362800598, 0.030827060341835022, -0.24742217361927032, -0.1837695986032486, 0.26646387577056885, 0.30393752455711365, -0.2511049807071686, 0.3630378544330597, 0.6224021911621094, -0.1432771235704422, 0.021942364051938057, -0.3944154381752014, 0.21046417951583862, -0.6029897332191467, -0.6275584697723389, -0.5021575689315796, 0.33532992005348206, 0.4242817759513855, 0.7188441157341003, -0.7433191537857056, 0.40011918544769287, 1.2358214855194092, 0.021944668143987656, -0.060317736119031906, -0.28869080543518066, -0.09850355982780457, -0.13023324310779572, -0.40517348051071167, -0.8559759259223938, -0.9211950898170471, -0.3399604260921478, 0.27920466661453247, 0.14958253502845764, 0.14086632430553436, -0.14356502890586853, 0.612586259841919, 1.0275802612304688, 0.6321817636489868, 0.559834361076355, -0.5031262636184692, -1.1723732948303223, 0.6299258470535278, 0.5844327807426453, 1.3916345834732056, -0.09617825597524643, 0.6846717596054077, -0.5244591236114502, 0.003223083447664976, -0.1455531120300293, 0.12471458315849304, -0.03554009273648262, 1.238956093788147, -0.9295001029968262, 0.12460806965827942, -0.6419075131416321, -0.6197013258934021, 0.5515680909156799, 0.40917128324508667, -0.19917303323745728, 0.960945188999176, -0.15818201005458832, 0.7198539972305298, 0.5975670218467712, -0.7700983881950378, -0.5668643712997437, -0.6697428226470947, 0.5772613286972046, 0.0888424813747406, -0.5076143145561218, -0.2495010942220688, 0.8771388530731201, 0.35646429657936096, -0.5320814251899719, 0.2970700263977051, -0.6589324474334717, 0.04241868853569031, 0.49574506282806396, -0.03728197515010834, 0.7952445149421692, -0.17221204936504364, 0.15883859992027283, 0.10119744390249252, 0.11904784291982651, 0.07796457409858704, -0.16739805042743683, -0.18935243785381317, 0.22728464007377625, -0.4179760217666626, 0.07131125777959824, 0.17415151000022888, 0.30854332447052, 0.08644533902406693, -0.3478013873100281, 0.6306902766227722, 0.6783277988433838, -0.8669013977050781, 0.33989667892456055, 0.8237845301628113, -0.7153752446174622, 1.2588741779327393, -0.06264953315258026, 0.6378301382064819, -0.7716788053512573, -0.8896164894104004, -0.8090114593505859, -0.12899191677570343, -0.09927447140216827, 0.23397472500801086, -0.12678077816963196, -0.4595198631286621, -0.23100735247135162, 0.9768787026405334, 0.5031725764274597, -0.19025632739067078, -0.09901996701955795, 0.26095089316368103, -0.5252372622489929, -0.2153104990720749, 0.26859575510025024, 1.0549229383468628, -0.2181374728679657, 0.7057268619537354, 0.09623590111732483, -0.40284615755081177, 0.08551277965307236, -0.9113678932189941, 0.8339276313781738, -0.5603242516517639, -0.06408797949552536, 0.6704525947570801, 0.0769568532705307, 0.5789196491241455, 0.6633947491645813, -0.31130850315093994, 0.22612395882606506, -0.2768937647342682, -0.0855400338768959, 0.24440781772136688, -0.30137550830841064, 0.42646798491477966, 0.214849591255188, 0.2205744832754135, -0.13930580019950867, -0.28542423248291016, -0.08408663421869278, -0.5091593265533447, 0.3818422555923462, -0.4346807301044464, -0.22066989541053772, 0.5404154658317566, -0.2873132526874542, 0.3130529522895813, -0.8895477652549744, 0.49761536717414856, -0.45939207077026367, -0.4449877440929413, 0.026619764044880867, 0.5228343605995178, 0.4269546866416931, 0.7388693690299988, 0.5658778548240662, 0.43264830112457275, 0.2862706482410431, 0.041154105216264725, -0.661369800567627, 0.5098134875297546, 0.8607648015022278, -0.04598101228475571, -0.7666687369346619, -0.5142285823822021, 0.5283018350601196, -0.5996902585029602, 0.1598799079656601, 0.35791873931884766, -0.9133772850036621, 0.23267744481563568, -0.20270933210849762, -0.24032539129257202, 0.464674174785614, 0.3781885802745819, 0.15555785596370697, 0.36266085505485535, 0.09076488763093948, 0.3212103843688965, 0.0637063980102539, 0.1969631314277649, 0.3638477921485901, 0.7963207364082336, -0.36616840958595276, 0.980108916759491, 1.108025074005127, 0.4441169202327728, -0.020594879984855652, 0.3326253890991211, -0.07416785508394241, 0.830377459526062, 0.7133308053016663, 0.24487030506134033, 0.322797566652298, 0.7318262457847595, -0.30486729741096497, 0.5021438002586365, -0.3740622103214264, 0.02742980793118477, -0.3637249767780304, 0.7178226709365845, -0.19423265755176544, 0.2028260976076126, 0.3474986255168915, 0.547694206237793, -0.6431275606155396, -0.5857178568840027, 0.6243212819099426, 0.20201601088047028, -0.03220570459961891, -0.03405886888504028, -0.4555511772632599, 0.520479142665863, -0.3881979286670685, 0.7800688147544861, 0.8396230340003967, 0.5217113494873047, -0.39041653275489807, 0.14706164598464966, 0.7120875120162964, -0.5971097350120544, -1.0422614812850952, -0.11223389953374863, -1.1473402976989746, -1.0936733484268188, -1.2118629217147827, -0.14947810769081116, 0.9845055341720581, -0.3313964307308197, -0.11911016702651978, 0.23486337065696716, -0.0636916384100914, -0.04921142756938934, -0.24828100204467773, 0.5435062050819397, 0.3460673987865448, 0.2648271918296814, -0.7174583673477173, 0.36917644739151, -0.24842846393585205, -0.1804182529449463, -0.5860334634780884, -0.39429575204849243, -0.6940179467201233, -0.7428928017616272, 0.5096051692962646, -0.11529947817325592, 0.4327927827835083, 0.2533313035964966, 0.47556033730506897, 0.11033046245574951, -0.0479479655623436, -0.5063512921333313, 0.487886905670166, -0.10847409069538116, -1.0244613885879517, 0.08417634665966034, 0.0144215552136302, 0.050197530537843704, 0.7161834239959717, 0.533073902130127, -0.7870055437088013, -0.10254321247339249, 0.08822918683290482, 0.8833390474319458, -0.9679461717605591, 0.31828656792640686, 0.2626361846923828, 0.7308652997016907, 0.21860073506832123, -0.7432323098182678, -1.2077559232711792, 0.5367443561553955, -0.13745124638080597, 0.19898399710655212, 0.6998516917228699, 0.43839922547340393, -0.16113610565662384, -1.3504537343978882, 0.8019808530807495, -0.3292415142059326, -0.7417067289352417, -0.1984662562608719, 0.16791638731956482, 0.5413988828659058, 0.6435142755508423, -0.29880577325820923, -0.48895782232284546, 0.27543535828590393, -0.4151351749897003, 0.6557809710502625, 0.4435548782348633, -0.5477474927902222, 0.2392149120569229, 0.30702725052833557, 0.5737547874450684, 0.21632415056228638, 0.2783334255218506, -0.01765448786318302, -0.39140188694000244, -0.2379269301891327, 0.9058456420898438, 0.434039443731308, 0.7479755878448486, 0.14803893864154816, -0.4085678458213806, 0.032238926738500595, -0.10170909762382507, 0.36072370409965515, 0.7917470335960388, 0.06757909804582596, 0.5425199866294861, 0.2885839641094208, -0.5013314485549927, -0.07953061908483505, -0.8614804744720459, -0.7742229104042053, 0.3025016188621521, 0.06681709736585617, 0.7157660722732544, -0.6440410017967224, 0.7311303019523621, 0.30251118540763855, -0.6682212948799133, 0.34373095631599426, -0.2818807363510132, 0.16178861260414124, 0.7558613419532776, -0.1429518610239029, 0.9695091843605042, -1.247939109802246, 0.1866844743490219, 0.4336366355419159, 0.2290695756673813, 0.37532487511634827, 0.19126135110855103, 0.944407045841217, -0.38555705547332764, 0.40374991297721863, 0.3816761374473572, -0.43987733125686646, 0.282266765832901, -0.2893756330013275, 0.420494943857193, 0.4020579159259796, -0.4551358222961426, 0.01931743137538433, -0.6163308620452881, 0.23372942209243774, 0.3352103531360626, 0.4515591859817505, 0.5227705836296082, -0.6375800967216492, 0.16821560263633728, 0.19311052560806274, 0.23473995923995972, 0.5788630843162537, -0.03228180110454559, 0.4431726038455963, -0.18274754285812378, -0.8718360066413879, 0.7945073246955872, -0.5351598262786865, -0.5298386216163635, -0.16377899050712585, -0.4161919057369232, -0.39702725410461426, -0.39451339840888977, 0.03306898847222328, -0.07691659778356552, -0.3810160756111145, 0.5056763887405396, -0.44310539960861206, -0.8686223030090332, 0.6322416067123413, 0.34162357449531555, -0.7498838901519775, 0.248465433716774, -0.3791271448135376, 0.3505135476589203, 0.7040244340896606, -0.9499346613883972, -1.001578450202942, -0.12627841532230377, -0.6738021373748779, -0.35774239897727966, -0.26476699113845825, 0.1598978042602539, -0.16148267686367035, 0.25685474276542664, -0.4465915858745575, -0.5345033407211304, 0.08907342702150345, -0.3552122116088867, -0.19940005242824554, -0.24355444312095642, 0.11346156150102615, 0.8126587271690369, 0.6623197793960571, 0.14103950560092926, -0.22313852608203888, 0.13611361384391785, -0.5322002172470093, 0.4160248935222626, -0.9369992613792419, -0.5393728613853455, 0.44018808007240295, -0.5047138929367065, 0.4291359782218933, 0.1782298982143402, -0.05989724397659302, -0.5024843811988831, 0.19091080129146576, 0.17698633670806885, -0.7341379523277283, -0.9927526116371155, 0.10750970989465714, -0.2737680673599243, -0.25480106472969055, 1.1759573221206665, -0.47877418994903564, -0.1785697489976883, -0.3513258397579193, 0.4134005308151245, -0.610730767250061, 0.154460608959198, 0.4346439838409424, 0.125790536403656, 0.3029136061668396, 0.05702069774270058, -0.3181905746459961, -0.044038571417331696, 0.3872988820075989, -0.6876644492149353, -0.39792221784591675, -0.3292551636695862, -0.5098245739936829, -0.32944005727767944, 0.6545290946960449, -0.7277305722236633, 0.04283252730965614, -0.4840347170829773, -0.5337191820144653, -0.1811256855726242, 0.1815260648727417, -0.6715696454048157, -0.014331796206533909, -0.3726698160171509, -0.16200220584869385, 0.15991337597370148, 0.6460381150245667, 0.39357027411460876, -0.17694057524204254, -0.6713448762893677, 0.19050978124141693, -0.11609867215156555, -0.5451926589012146, -0.15192095935344696, -0.07051320374011993, 0.16618987917900085, -0.7634109854698181, 0.22117573022842407, 0.1923103928565979, -0.7132328748703003, -0.18795868754386902, -0.15748265385627747, 0.5749198794364929, 0.5416845679283142, 0.3127160668373108, -0.2517417073249817, 0.38852494955062866, -0.07364412397146225, -1.163320779800415, -0.06195080280303955, 0.5000790953636169, 0.3444008231163025, 0.800100564956665, -0.2541907727718353, -0.6638593673706055, -0.4133770167827606, -0.8508327603340149, 0.12107430398464203, -0.7323794364929199, 0.3761095702648163, -0.29238247871398926, -0.6108445525169373, 0.1092090830206871, 0.5704556703567505, 0.12483731657266617, 0.016839193180203438, -0.4185151755809784, -1.0936863422393799, 0.7192398905754089, -0.25703150033950806, -0.5252398252487183, 0.2790820896625519, -1.0069196224212646, 0.04149980843067169, 0.8912754058837891, 0.14180411398410797, -0.1820986270904541, 0.813228189945221, -0.1275668889284134, -0.07109446078538895, 0.18447929620742798, -0.7201426029205322, -0.2752329409122467, 0.08369112014770508, 0.580528199672699, -0.8818877339363098, -0.212904691696167, -0.7787205576896667, 0.6957088708877563, -0.12284096330404282, 0.2109096497297287, -0.014533018693327904, -0.39370211958885193, 0.34987369179725647, -0.35366931557655334, 0.8684911131858826, -0.30094873905181885, 0.34725475311279297, -0.02984079346060753, 0.12762807309627533, -0.24043434858322144, 0.410564124584198, -0.22162789106369019, -0.7625871896743774, -1.1089259386062622, -0.6502219438552856, 0.6448050737380981, -0.4392508864402771, -0.11998186260461807, 0.6573871374130249, 0.28687742352485657, 0.29834669828414917, -0.6932957172393799, 1.136677622795105, 0.582561194896698, -0.7016823291778564, -0.17290844023227692, -0.3240514099597931, 0.35352838039398193, 0.09315915405750275, -0.4909457564353943, 0.7850574851036072, -0.3798295855522156, -0.5628476142883301, 0.5195110440254211, 0.07841919362545013, -1.0687092542648315, -0.0638386532664299, -0.3390877842903137, 0.23223045468330383, 0.4846380054950714, 0.25409141182899475, 0.7477304935455322, -0.4418661296367645, -0.6615453362464905, 0.6409333348274231, 0.3593856394290924, -0.014156620018184185, 0.37931764125823975, -0.1319161206483841, 0.38304492831230164, 0.8292369842529297, -0.2628006935119629, 0.3472975194454193, -0.2987920641899109, 0.5001957416534424, 0.42591363191604614, -1.1317445039749146, 0.39213913679122925, 0.43611252307891846, -0.8309402465820312, -0.2870514690876007, 0.18087923526763916, -0.4225997030735016, -0.5657966732978821, 0.17202365398406982, -0.39622583985328674, 0.30292171239852905, 0.16396979987621307, 0.2126946747303009, -0.2959095537662506, 0.17788760364055634, 0.03529392555356026, -0.6584594249725342, 0.29922354221343994, -0.7883792519569397, 0.33457058668136597, 0.9031279683113098, -0.6336094737052917, 0.6044110059738159, 0.04842266067862511, 0.35680949687957764, 0.05402974784374237, -0.20261964201927185, -0.0018908418715000153, -0.21036741137504578, 0.26675403118133545, -0.23512248694896698, -0.03666830435395241, 0.1966133415699005, 0.5206594467163086, -0.804764449596405, 1.034173846244812, 0.34431082010269165, -0.28954920172691345, 0.4158645272254944, 0.2503787875175476, 0.8756046891212463, 0.32648947834968567, 0.5171496272087097, -0.3627983629703522, -0.056117549538612366, -0.1259012520313263, 1.2733356952667236, -0.5817029476165771, -0.13069824874401093, -0.6248925924301147, -0.17360414564609528, -0.01908576302230358, -0.2104508876800537, 0.07156344503164291, 0.50543612241745, -0.04936748370528221, -0.9352201819419861, -0.7038937211036682, 0.548562228679657, 0.3913452625274658, 0.3890421390533447, -0.19541560113430023, 0.41997164487838745, -0.7142359614372253, -0.9562514424324036, -0.4794418513774872, -0.23743411898612976, 0.036372896283864975, 0.9588680267333984, -0.3389493227005005, -0.25432807207107544, 0.20434029400348663, 0.035778749734163284, 0.057907700538635254, 0.4086492657661438, -0.5257826447486877, -0.5960554480552673, -0.8558263182640076, 0.7540428042411804, 0.8456943035125732, -0.3488268554210663, 0.8198508620262146, -0.747998058795929, 0.44574812054634094, 0.22062139213085175, 0.17570455372333527, -0.1008431538939476, 0.08453096449375153, 0.757814347743988, -0.9019395709037781, -0.44613608717918396, -0.4501340687274933, 0.713768482208252, -1.5149561166763306, -0.3285953402519226, -0.8697874546051025, 0.02927304618060589, -0.02332986891269684, -0.08306146413087845, 0.4738371968269348, 0.37193089723587036, -0.1455812156200409, 0.27584442496299744, 0.14015211164951324, 0.9849145412445068, 0.6151832342147827, -0.49645259976387024, 0.5370093584060669, 0.4231116473674774, 0.204976424574852, -0.5228485465049744, 0.3008340299129486, 0.4248049557209015, -0.2818872928619385, 0.3909705579280853, 0.1383558064699173, 0.5567752718925476, -0.04035581275820732, 0.11286492645740509, -0.3830038011074066, 0.44838353991508484, 0.4009247422218323, 0.5289796590805054, 0.0060522896237671375, -0.27994808554649353, -0.8738927245140076, -0.6219653487205505, -0.7301228642463684, -0.6590831875801086, 0.5606622099876404, -1.147038221359253, 0.6065786480903625, -1.2619270086288452, -0.3287435472011566, 0.990050196647644, 0.4439936578273773, 0.10742442309856415, -0.06454742699861526, -0.06633885949850082, 0.37130361795425415, 1.3065847158432007, -0.02115046977996826, 0.5485764145851135, -0.19611229002475739, 0.2692510485649109, -0.8577565550804138, -0.10835966467857361, -0.15541616082191467, 0.306361585855484, -0.10308787226676941, -0.24651595950126648, -0.5157678127288818, -0.10392051935195923, 0.01077346783131361, -0.5659269690513611, -0.4218031167984009, 0.1256440132856369, -0.2642119824886322, 0.24406316876411438, -0.5379689335823059, 0.1370212584733963, -0.7717977166175842, -0.09164853394031525, 0.1866147518157959, -0.7348508238792419, -0.15405958890914917, -0.10077052563428879, 0.6953353881835938, -0.47884243726730347, 0.6196798086166382, 0.4233015477657318, 0.24330759048461914, -0.12454135715961456, -0.873443603515625, 0.6064612865447998, 0.851854681968689, -0.4527897238731384, 0.059653110802173615, 0.11412204056978226, 0.4892931580543518, 0.9559144973754883, 0.002819696208462119, -0.9598240256309509, 0.6727095246315002, 0.6232759356498718, -0.016744745895266533, 0.48995816707611084, -0.49218079447746277, -0.32809317111968994, 0.7239171266555786, 0.02441950887441635, 0.17437994480133057, 0.35901254415512085, 0.559517502784729, 0.3043862581253052, -0.11316398531198502, 0.5285672545433044, -0.3465513288974762, -0.3909399211406708, -0.22248828411102295, -0.46537908911705017, 0.8871142864227295, 0.3246915936470032, 0.59634929895401, -0.4355602562427521, 0.7752188444137573, -0.28221336007118225, 0.2772861123085022, 0.5037672519683838, -0.7635506987571716, 0.05068659409880638, -1.1126219034194946, -0.1274939477443695, -0.35643571615219116, -0.16432376205921173, 0.4688708186149597, -0.013031748123466969, -0.05438394844532013, 0.3478879928588867, -0.8761993050575256, 0.13916581869125366, 1.0489521026611328, -0.15869873762130737, -0.03770563378930092, -0.7531776428222656, -0.27789878845214844, -0.9477542638778687, 0.061306606978178024, -0.26257362961769104, -0.5822679996490479, -0.41128239035606384, 0.41224247217178345, 0.4981262981891632, 0.7131314873695374, 0.16560783982276917, 0.7006347179412842, 0.009196057915687561, 0.3767099380493164, 0.6282148361206055, 0.46661123633384705, -0.21332667768001556, -0.7069991827011108, -0.20966880023479462, -0.03343094512820244, -0.4358551502227783, -0.4756328761577606, 0.38002675771713257, -0.8006669878959656, -0.37610751390457153, 0.3856552541255951, 0.5823051333427429, -0.6485024690628052, -0.9551292657852173, -0.24106311798095703, -0.030169401317834854, -0.35215428471565247, -0.4760291874408722, 0.42345499992370605, 0.0721258670091629, -0.18089869618415833, -0.12473651766777039, -0.6206303238868713, -0.3190450668334961, 0.32411906123161316, -0.7167611718177795, 0.6060411930084229, -0.5442362427711487, 0.279295414686203, -0.939529299736023, -1.1245073080062866, 0.21435247361660004, 0.07543163746595383, -0.5197018384933472, -0.13509829342365265, -0.3218913972377777, 0.3333219587802887, 0.2391350120306015, 0.1001913845539093, -0.5424206852912903, 0.20838138461112976, -0.12629719078540802, 0.40391796827316284, -0.09606516361236572, 0.5157528519630432, -0.6022266745567322, 0.29028937220573425, -0.006287723314017057, -0.28072887659072876, -0.26721811294555664, -0.11851374804973602, -1.0681278705596924, -0.9637688994407654, 0.7207016348838806, -0.1821984350681305, -0.8654296398162842, 0.1633499413728714, 0.9701446294784546, -0.2878935933113098, -0.08437343686819077, -1.110598087310791, -0.3102726638317108, -0.3299320340156555, 0.2762189209461212, -0.4495190680027008, 0.05240562930703163, -0.22707879543304443, -0.18853476643562317, 0.35867398977279663, -0.7199554443359375, 4.119703769683838, 1.049883484840393, 0.7109131813049316, -0.016741929575800896, 0.31689560413360596, 0.5237196683883667, 0.171491339802742, 0.43059083819389343, 0.014727779664099216, 0.43954703211784363, 0.2225523591041565, 0.2271290272474289, 0.32720234990119934, -0.2350175678730011, 0.9912984371185303, 0.23519577085971832, -1.0787546634674072, 0.0502210333943367, 0.3676077127456665, -1.1813794374465942, -0.7671180963516235, 0.12400336563587189, 0.20508965849876404, -0.4207432270050049, 0.3950014114379883, 0.6311976313591003, 0.07852127403020859, 0.21404694020748138, -0.7808388471603394, -0.4909660518169403, -0.7288868427276611, -0.33464303612709045, 0.8185312151908875, -0.445892870426178, -0.5956369638442993, 0.15254192054271698, -0.528120219707489, -0.7334790825843811, 0.5470463633537292, -0.20819969475269318, 0.5588139295578003, -1.0193970203399658, 0.13077227771282196, -0.4964776933193207, 0.4123343527317047, 0.3145340085029602, -0.8662354350090027, 0.568261444568634, 0.44005638360977173, -0.3918968737125397, 0.45452460646629333, -0.8375863432884216, 0.3289216160774231, -0.7695257663726807, -0.2902663052082062, -0.14663450419902802, -0.7528467178344727, -0.7984062433242798, -0.6153119206428528, 0.2918514907360077, 0.4035429060459137, -0.14860713481903076, -0.20332154631614685, -0.39718037843704224, 0.029973788186907768, 0.450158029794693, 0.35996657609939575, 0.46584829688072205, -0.3284186124801636, -0.036889709532260895, 0.18962465226650238, -0.7924603223800659, -0.3618507981300354, -0.3839690387248993, 0.16981039941310883, 0.4093080163002014, -0.47079330682754517, 0.8059827089309692, -0.678005576133728, -0.04726161062717438, 0.5064219832420349, 0.3544495701789856, 0.310162216424942, -0.20493580400943756, -0.14839833974838257, 0.20030100643634796, -1.1506327390670776, -0.2038508951663971, -1.3387820720672607, 0.5818987488746643, 0.8364178538322449, 0.11721412092447281, 0.27826619148254395, -0.09970687329769135, -0.5774092674255371 ]
{"Title": "Independently Carriage of IL-1RN*2 Allele Associated with Increased Risk of Gastric Cancer in The Sudanese Population", "Authors": "Idris Abeer Babiker, Ataelmanan Amany Eltayib, Eltaher Sulafa Mohamed, Idris Einas Babiker, Osman Arbab Bashir M., Idris Ahmed Ibn, Mansour Mohamed, Ibrahim El-Amin Mohamed, Hassan Mohamed A.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Helicobacter pylori is responsible for gastric cancer in approximately tens of millions of patients. Gastric cancer in Sudan represents one of the top causing death among cancers with about 686 cases per year and a 2.7 % mortality rate. IL-1RN VNTR polymorphism has been reported to increase the risk of gastric cancer. Objective The purpose of this study was to assess the association of the 86 bp VNTR polymorphism of IL- 1RN gene and the susceptibility to H. pylori infection and gastric cancer in the Sudanese population. Materials and methods Genomic DNA was extracted from 114 subjects. Of whom 60 had gastritis and duodenitis, 26 had a peptic ulcer, 16 had gastric cancer and 12 had normal gastroscopy findings. H. pylori infection was investigated by specific 16S rRNA . And IL-1RN VNTR polymorphism at intron 2 was genotyped using the PCR method and direct sequencing for random samples. Results The positive H. pylori infection rate among participants was 47.37%. There is a lack of a significant difference in IL- 1RN genotype with H. pylori infection (p-value=1.0000). The IL-1 RN L/L genotype was significantly more frequent in a patient with benign disorders (gastritis or duodenitis or peptic ulcer), Odd=6.000 (95% CI =1.750-20.57, P=0.0056). While the heterozygote genotype 2/L was associated with an increased risk of gastric cancer with OR = 12.83 (95% CI = 1.261-130.6, P=0.0302). Conclusion Independently carriage of IL-1RN *2 allele was associated with increased risk of gastric cancer in the Sudanese population. Notwithstanding the relatively small sample size of the study population, our findings show that the host genetic can be a useful tool for identifying high-risk individuals among dyspeptic patients; and also underscore the role played by host genetics in gastric carcinogenesis. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study in Sudan concerning this issue.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013573"}
10.1101/19007542
[ -0.09009543806314468, 0.70686936378479, -0.36989033222198486, 0.5083765983581543, -0.3682786822319031, -0.29111990332603455, -0.004247501492500305, 0.4795561134815216, -0.12714165449142456, 0.7163956761360168, 0.2520886957645416, -0.46311503648757935, -0.25519412755966187, -0.36549994349479675, -0.2199360877275467, 0.0679122656583786, -0.7331401109695435, 0.16155318915843964, 0.35974276065826416, 0.10116381198167801, 0.6083382964134216, 0.2654912769794464, -0.44477635622024536, 0.3144054114818573, -0.55436110496521, 0.8042731285095215, -0.29010462760925293, -0.4020434319972992, 1.07571542263031, 0.3401966691017151, 0.5067132711410522, -0.3952476978302002, 0.7150577902793884, -1.0621412992477417, 0.09585195034742355, 0.4334087669849396, 0.8840020895004272, -0.6911748647689819, -0.47137314081192017, -0.3663807511329651, 0.321327269077301, 0.5932345390319824, -0.33845722675323486, -1.0699028968811035, -0.7523583173751831, 0.2135988473892212, -0.1992967426776886, -0.7855886816978455, 0.10078396648168564, -0.447547048330307, -0.1720511019229889, 0.23367218673229218, 0.11483108252286911, 0.11133474111557007, 0.008487971499562263, -0.7019925713539124, 0.40925344824790955, -0.23502090573310852, -0.18882232904434204, 0.8592077493667603, 0.7881553769111633, 0.17401017248630524, 0.0888010710477829, -1.2819727659225464, 0.18146727979183197, 0.7723337411880493, -0.42714253067970276, -0.03592781350016594, -0.5118003487586975, -0.4200707972049713, -1.019152045249939, 0.2389417439699173, -0.8964503407478333, -0.1338745355606079, -0.10007435083389282, 0.24543480575084686, 0.03452776372432709, -0.1863720566034317, -0.05426493287086487, -0.7508119940757751, -0.4049568772315979, -0.14785724878311157, -0.12757371366024017, 0.7112350463867188, -0.34002262353897095, -0.13609091937541962, -0.16579847037792206, -0.17782807350158691, 0.8006100058555603, 0.03378574550151825, 0.5117828249931335, -0.15252946317195892, -0.0684816986322403, -0.17502880096435547, 0.09612348675727844, 0.6551064848899841, -0.21098361909389496, 0.09528360515832901, 0.35011518001556396, 0.030472880229353905, 0.8732861280441284, 0.3222619891166687, 0.19104546308517456, 0.9463430047035217, -1.4840571880340576, -0.1541237086057663, 0.33348602056503296, -0.06468106806278229, 0.1100216805934906, -1.3856827020645142, 0.13073855638504028, -0.16019420325756073, -0.5033764839172363, 0.23390626907348633, -0.40082094073295593, 0.40917909145355225, -0.2563931345939636, -0.15473729372024536, -0.7246782183647156, -0.39687591791152954, -0.20605941116809845, -0.3530136048793793, -0.21925856173038483, -0.6643312573432922, 0.2861579656600952, -0.7597468495368958, 0.18543826043605804, 0.7618950605392456, -0.24941304326057434, -0.5711283683776855, -0.2900177240371704, -0.2683642506599426, 0.009671790525317192, 0.8618597388267517, -0.632584273815155, -0.16178323328495026, -0.7273959517478943, 0.15309560298919678, 0.06642256677150726, -0.6164450645446777, -0.3443600833415985, 0.3700433671474457, 0.36781108379364014, 1.1648043394088745, -0.2167041003704071, 0.9368272423744202, -0.33124613761901855, -0.707934558391571, 0.08294947445392609, 0.12109899520874023, 0.41902104020118713, 0.10523475706577301, -0.13307365775108337, 0.35119494795799255, -0.6838699579238892, -0.6391549110412598, -1.0379931926727295, 0.8655832409858704, -0.29470980167388916, 0.2504004240036011, 0.1921493411064148, 1.1368484497070312, -0.9319912791252136, 0.6129597425460815, -0.6124980449676514, 0.3346889317035675, -0.44902923703193665, -0.14788798987865448, 0.30552682280540466, -1.0945788621902466, 0.544159471988678, 0.45098477602005005, -0.05486656725406647, 0.26872336864471436, 0.39201420545578003, 0.2362101972103119, 0.8207147121429443, 0.6973208785057068, -0.14512890577316284, 0.10281208902597427, -0.6434570550918579, -0.17391672730445862, 0.8749719262123108, 1.1503227949142456, 0.4535033106803894, -0.6361215710639954, -0.6696828603744507, -1.0420613288879395, -0.2914901077747345, 0.4493953287601471, -0.32098230719566345, 0.6786887645721436, -1.1553747653961182, 0.5970837473869324, -0.10064548254013062, -0.0004981557140126824, -0.5272009372711182, 0.17503204941749573, 0.4677506685256958, -1.0378086566925049, 0.1671299934387207, 0.7944183349609375, -0.9499963521957397, 1.281629204750061, -0.4139200448989868, 0.6398226022720337, 0.589477002620697, 0.9896873235702515, 0.014157081954181194, -0.0919826328754425, 0.40197357535362244, -0.2639177739620209, 0.4620968699455261, -0.7278292775154114, 0.49252042174339294, -0.9075645804405212, -0.015283687971532345, 0.48662126064300537, -0.23633301258087158, -0.54657381772995, 0.4073372781276703, -0.2347579300403595, 0.46792399883270264, 0.08834489434957504, -0.41260769963264465, -0.4364253282546997, 0.2998005151748657, 0.22983163595199585, -0.06708038598299026, 0.13748608529567719, -0.15619313716888428, 0.6214804649353027, 0.20035964250564575, 0.2541670799255371, 0.3473576009273529, 0.4575846791267395, 0.658323347568512, 0.3853221833705902, 0.8301684260368347, -0.423649400472641, 0.29539069533348083, 0.5347902178764343, 0.6936891078948975, -0.1934913545846939, -0.04395832493901253, 0.13629050552845, 0.08012058585882187, 0.37896084785461426, -0.5190571546554565, 0.18369229137897491, -0.8532504439353943, 0.620913565158844, 0.3791109621524811, 0.47806787490844727, -0.7579407691955566, 0.10474124550819397, 0.10277028381824493, 0.8886025547981262, 0.17715226113796234, -1.021623969078064, -0.5823523998260498, 0.026304231956601143, 0.9433900117874146, 0.0919543206691742, 0.05106143653392792, 0.2778465151786804, -0.3934624195098877, 0.9200062155723572, 0.02189948968589306, -0.024770714342594147, -1.2653722763061523, -0.279834508895874, -0.8122044205665588, -0.7038849592208862, -0.2558188736438751, -0.005385146476328373, 0.2303384244441986, 0.010495114140212536, 0.4592495262622833, 0.7233576774597168, 0.48996883630752563, -0.7010414004325867, 1.0354727506637573, 0.43638598918914795, 0.29174843430519104, 0.2102406919002533, -0.9824330806732178, 0.479349285364151, -0.39502599835395813, 0.4855518639087677, -0.20355674624443054, -0.5873920917510986, -0.5995863080024719, -0.8250415921211243, 0.4640738070011139, 0.2476707100868225, -0.33007416129112244, -0.14936473965644836, 0.09379745274782181, -0.42076942324638367, 0.7217300534248352, -0.2547149360179901, -0.3291374444961548, 0.2760084569454193, -1.4149359464645386, 0.8596052527427673, 0.4597206711769104, 0.7390170693397522, 0.8518079519271851, -0.40802913904190063, 0.31361234188079834, 0.6514831781387329, -0.4511767625808716, 0.21009483933448792, -0.5615594387054443, 0.8230224847793579, 0.8214796781539917, -0.2030041664838791, 0.21823246777057648, -0.6376444101333618, -1.0114657878875732, -0.4991489052772522, 0.06379328668117523, -0.9776791930198669, -0.021017801016569138, 0.4465843439102173, 0.4335869252681732, -0.936467707157135, 0.0026142289862036705, -0.6293528079986572, -1.148760437965393, 0.5210729837417603, -0.7998272180557251, 0.25808390974998474, 0.07160822302103043, 0.3358098566532135, -1.2384910583496094, 0.09587139636278152, -0.305434912443161, 0.5277236104011536, 0.6663893461227417, -0.8352085947990417, 0.06645558029413223, 0.36725255846977234, -0.037755031138658524, 0.6173900961875916, 0.625572144985199, -0.39130899310112, 0.12205680459737778, 0.06983918696641922, -0.6428831815719604, 0.14422306418418884, -0.06497731059789658, -0.7037203907966614, 0.1814296692609787, 0.3532315194606781, -0.38552364706993103, -0.057079631835222244, 0.10191218554973602, 0.4109591543674469, -0.30672702193260193, -0.11398430168628693, 0.17939162254333496, 0.02306094951927662, -0.19731324911117554, -0.10178855061531067, 0.3996039628982544, 0.09337640553712845, 0.7508673071861267, -1.124075174331665, 0.1513102948665619, 0.2515835762023926, 0.2523753046989441, -0.5265069007873535, -0.11060433834791183, -0.3741227984428406, 0.3416365087032318, 0.02517707832157612, 0.7282812595367432, -0.9416555762290955, -0.186298668384552, 0.5992125868797302, 1.8378252983093262, 0.3826025724411011, -0.043887630105018616, -0.07220917195081711, -1.099241018295288, 0.34520384669303894, -0.05167855694890022, -0.4503227174282074, 0.4136890769004822, -0.2117830216884613, 0.21636393666267395, 0.19490180909633636, -0.9701632857322693, 0.04374641552567482, 0.9879766702651978, 0.40646305680274963, -0.2113751471042633, -0.7521995902061462, 0.47269535064697266, 0.11918225884437561, 1.0619163513183594, 0.2361340969800949, 0.27442264556884766, -0.6795283555984497, -0.41680893301963806, 0.7486037015914917, -0.06972088664770126, -0.2508441209793091, 0.30054521560668945, 0.2645914852619171, -0.42284804582595825, -0.5073373913764954, 0.6878834962844849, -0.10933950543403625, -0.6953165531158447, -0.019089022651314735, 0.1512075960636139, -0.05367552489042282, 0.11452304571866989, 0.5689235925674438, -0.820039689540863, 0.41462045907974243, 0.39604514837265015, -0.823240339756012, -0.04368771240115166, -0.4903401732444763, 1.0215250253677368, 1.0634783506393433, -0.7320269346237183, -0.8153466582298279, 0.4492020905017853, -0.12400054186582565, -1.2776107788085938, 0.2174987643957138, 0.9233947992324829, -0.7454571723937988, -0.1401677131652832, 0.6581781506538391, -0.17831698060035706, -0.845943808555603, -0.8530023097991943, -0.0781397894024849, 0.3708983063697815, 0.10963733494281769, 0.36501213908195496, -0.12746483087539673, 0.36165785789489746, 0.04123292118310928, 0.3873758018016815, -1.0530223846435547, 0.6606280207633972, -0.05485013872385025, -0.7612462043762207, 0.318936824798584, 0.3080537021160126, -0.19213733077049255, -0.2587984502315521, -0.24357153475284576, -0.1479896456003189, -0.055189475417137146, 0.38778382539749146, 0.5268073081970215, -0.20267744362354279, 0.43787050247192383, -0.20413845777511597, 0.3721047341823578, 0.07093125581741333, -0.44752344489097595, 0.1831102818250656, 0.3261720538139343, 0.06806827336549759, -0.7815465927124023, 0.15296855568885803, -0.6073704957962036, 0.1853877753019333, 0.6070559620857239, -0.12950992584228516, -0.08438806235790253, 0.5239828824996948, -0.06004263460636139, -0.13223838806152344, 0.2536790072917938, 0.13321906328201294, 0.22582204639911652, -0.04535423591732979, -0.2196703851222992, -0.703078031539917, 0.2042728215456009, 0.36346235871315, -0.38511282205581665, -0.022934986278414726, 0.559258222579956, -0.35468605160713196, -0.4367086589336395, -1.3168429136276245, -0.008626124821603298, 0.2507987916469574, 0.4777439534664154, 1.2867528200149536, -0.6064644455909729, -0.49693939089775085, 0.06944924592971802, 0.2869870364665985, -0.14623427391052246, -0.8193157315254211, 0.2977009117603302, -0.6385711431503296, -0.12064646184444427, -0.12715406715869904, -0.3378039598464966, 0.20778068900108337, -0.19438602030277252, -0.26380807161331177, -0.3239730894565582, 0.014569402672350407, -0.43587401509284973, -0.7216727137565613, 0.5620607137680054, -0.2519521713256836, -0.4706310033798218, 0.10260780900716782, 0.4546491205692291, -0.46842676401138306, 0.3578720688819885, 0.029883038252592087, -1.4086655378341675, -0.14311933517456055, -1.571969985961914, 0.422439306974411, -1.5893138647079468, 0.3234080374240875, -0.5034523606300354, -0.4170132875442505, -0.04514504596590996, -0.12777483463287354, 0.22367210686206818, 0.20319941639900208, 0.27079126238822937, -0.6120708584785461, -0.21505631506443024, -0.49618327617645264, -0.9001231789588928, -0.3528989851474762, -0.39377278089523315, -0.04037531837821007, 1.0810388326644897, 0.6678147315979004, -0.1513236165046692, 0.3413383960723877, 0.2722235918045044, 0.31750303506851196, -0.15202125906944275, -0.21905064582824707, -0.18767163157463074, 0.49743327498435974, 0.6437111496925354, 0.37614908814430237, 0.5832904577255249, -0.959591805934906, -0.11554311960935593, -0.24056550860404968, 0.3038029968738556, -0.2033531665802002, 0.20162001252174377, -0.009555378928780556, -0.03853467479348183, 1.0304465293884277, -0.2430269569158554, 0.12800489366054535, 0.40700414776802063, 0.057095274329185486, -0.05627982318401337, 0.197565495967865, -0.542544424533844, -0.627688467502594, -0.6486448645591736, -1.4842067956924438, 0.15316472947597504, -0.22743982076644897, -0.20237676799297333, -0.15130218863487244, 0.557330846786499, 0.06428632885217667, -0.6602721810340881, 0.84978848695755, 0.9634807705879211, -0.4803089201450348, -0.599418044090271, 0.2592083811759949, 0.5328985452651978, 0.48162609338760376, 0.24935945868492126, -0.24241924285888672, -0.487885981798172, 0.019866380840539932, -0.8289228677749634, -0.9579558372497559, -0.3574264347553253, -0.10871613025665283, 0.340359091758728, 0.9041739702224731, -0.2529408931732178, 0.5368486046791077, 0.1742202192544937, -0.18990470468997955, -0.8356298804283142, 0.6367115378379822, 0.1322328895330429, 0.2753573954105377, 0.36052677035331726, -0.5078557729721069, -0.4321260452270508, -0.07268232107162476, 0.2468114048242569, -0.26943883299827576, 0.03735421225428581, 0.6687430143356323, 0.9426644444465637, -0.5910270810127258, 0.0868573784828186, 0.08156826347112656, -0.2835589647293091, -0.8089553713798523, -0.5018728375434875, -0.9564913511276245, 0.6332061290740967, -0.6509327292442322, -0.28564468026161194, -0.35918763279914856, -0.21455815434455872, 0.11200752854347229, 0.2841328978538513, -0.04587088152766228, -0.06594332307577133, 0.4885019063949585, -0.45451003313064575, -1.271706223487854, 0.13606519997119904, 0.855367124080658, -0.09054707735776901, -0.5145352482795715, 0.20035111904144287, -0.45498228073120117, 0.6376091241836548, 0.018254844471812248, 0.7035313844680786, -0.6551038026809692, 0.00785297341644764, -0.11871116608381271, 0.609167754650116, 0.0835827887058258, -0.1534278392791748, 0.3939555883407593, 0.5454652905464172, -0.48084262013435364, -0.28388330340385437, -0.12355633080005646, 0.5697343349456787, 0.2674378752708435, 1.0181703567504883, -0.7378984689712524, -0.3071419894695282, 0.2876884341239929, 0.43093743920326233, -0.3591386377811432, -0.3630431592464447, -0.8148991465568542, -1.0239882469177246, -0.6887041330337524, -0.009147013537585735, -0.8452603816986084, -0.6500981450080872, 0.37851205468177795, -1.0436049699783325, -0.42354676127433777, -0.38010162115097046, 0.45667964220046997, -1.0890309810638428, -0.3298410177230835, -0.15178386867046356, 0.08224526047706604, -1.114124059677124, 0.4500545263290405, 0.7904742360115051, -1.5021162033081055, -0.23354943096637726, 0.5837616920471191, -0.0705263689160347, 0.46327343583106995, 0.24331480264663696, 0.47501498460769653, -0.054079219698905945, 0.5185713768005371, -0.7378513813018799, -0.9775079488754272, -0.20171311497688293, 0.7161650657653809, -0.2887163460254669, 0.2523476481437683, 0.8307222723960876, 0.08375482261180878, 0.7091017365455627, 0.25241759419441223, -0.03819141536951065, -0.47177737951278687, 0.30830979347229004, 0.33589667081832886, 0.19147296249866486, -0.1288987696170807, -0.061722975224256516, 0.07714040577411652, -0.9228113293647766, -0.4967363476753235, -0.764649510383606, 0.318062961101532, 0.17025938630104065, -0.9298350214958191, 0.07949352264404297, 1.1191567182540894, 0.14884239435195923, -0.16291654109954834, 0.2184416651725769, 0.3460608124732971, 0.23294663429260254, 0.11580172181129456, 0.21549375355243683, 0.1477016806602478, -0.392390638589859, -0.7338326573371887, 0.15747715532779694, 0.31543776392936707, -0.5300760269165039, 0.2911825180053711, -0.7285005450248718, 0.19831205904483795, 0.6855903267860413, 0.12048852443695068, 0.14182741940021515, 0.8371551036834717, -0.47593727707862854, -0.28936222195625305, 0.15040211379528046, 0.09456534683704376, -0.17486172914505005, -0.49305179715156555, -0.37479540705680847, -0.23363535106182098, 0.5077669024467468, -0.6458010673522949, -0.6413173079490662, -0.09434080123901367, 0.10915952175855637, 0.30429473519325256, -0.01566644385457039, 0.08128665387630463, 0.13633324205875397, 0.2229793816804886, -0.3259754180908203, 0.30734017491340637, 0.27192530035972595, -0.1930161714553833, 0.11686856299638748, 0.1604979932308197, -0.41416212916374207, -0.630426287651062, 0.937915027141571, 0.3822309970855713, 0.2523500621318817, 0.04089754819869995, -0.1459735631942749, 0.1431744545698166, -0.37692633271217346, -0.883960485458374, 0.02309258095920086, 0.3890513479709625, -0.12114060670137405, 0.010404055006802082, 0.10171778500080109, -0.18403762578964233, -0.4631939232349396, -0.3990161418914795, 0.5403841733932495, -0.49703747034072876, -0.6724467277526855, 0.06806488335132599, 0.4534313380718231, -0.08800254762172699, 0.4668665826320648, -0.4675961434841156, 0.026796506717801094, 0.06569235771894455, 0.35529300570487976, 0.3739873766899109, 0.1435689926147461, 0.0758030042052269, 0.24054571986198425, 0.4956216812133789, 1.1191635131835938, 0.3976753056049347, 0.0965966060757637, 0.5342512130737305, 0.2098790854215622, 0.25335919857025146, 0.10391687601804733, -0.025311820209026337, -0.7741231322288513, 0.7587765455245972, 0.18386432528495789, 0.07742377370595932, 0.3411412239074707, 0.8369827270507812, 0.15261037647724152, -0.1487155556678772, -0.22985407710075378, 0.2607823312282562, -0.7764549255371094, -0.5846741795539856, -0.39448902010917664, 0.784072756767273, 0.5588753819465637, -0.06861754506826401, 0.6247718334197998, 0.18133772909641266, 0.7642378807067871, 0.7388325929641724, -0.5031329393386841, 0.4523417055606842, -0.40402573347091675, -0.6095779538154602, 0.06317009776830673, 0.3675107955932617, 0.423857718706131, 0.1874430775642395, 0.6760260462760925, -0.2733248174190521, -0.6452560424804688, 0.641944408416748, -0.19675172865390778, -0.15251436829566956, 0.7856467366218567, -0.07882822304964066, -0.594206690788269, -0.09257539361715317, -0.37077596783638, -0.1763390302658081, -0.1924174576997757, 0.8962936997413635, -0.6275644302368164, -0.13583797216415405, -0.038326725363731384, 0.06046897545456886, 0.2761813700199127, -0.31654229760169983, 0.2587648034095764, -0.6734403371810913, 0.6726366877555847, 0.8244056701660156, 0.7071905732154846, 0.3721390664577484, -0.410020649433136, -0.4474225640296936, -0.26431575417518616, -0.7141698002815247, 0.3288421928882599, 1.2756520509719849, 0.07262062281370163, 0.2022567093372345, 0.7993059158325195, 0.003399971639737487, -0.04697269946336746, -0.7896713018417358, 0.7014418840408325, -0.2793872356414795, 0.03945702314376831, -0.1090894266963005, 0.1650005728006363, -0.03779546171426773, -0.29911404848098755, -0.2660420536994934, -0.4747163653373718, -0.3655663728713989, -0.09518175572156906, 0.044310878962278366, 0.3875401020050049, 0.3950222432613373, -0.13018715381622314, 0.18259885907173157, -0.6835895776748657, -0.16976290941238403, -0.33603808283805847, -0.5933767557144165, -0.7092540264129639, -0.09897695481777191, 0.21262696385383606, -0.044094111770391464, 0.37023064494132996, -0.5606580376625061, -0.13293704390525818, 0.3126307725906372, 1.055980920791626, -0.20293787121772766, 0.9859314560890198, 0.7712451219558716, -0.05336553603410721, 0.18495777249336243, 0.3408810794353485, 0.35984307527542114, -0.03896362707018852, -0.4758603870868683, -0.3099745213985443, -0.02273366041481495, -0.3135907053947449, -0.15618090331554413, 1.1329530477523804, 0.28083059191703796, -0.10915566980838776, -0.17600856721401215, -0.047161392867565155, -0.4011852741241455, -0.43933624029159546, 0.7218736410140991, -0.6946120858192444, 0.38720428943634033, 0.6219569444656372, -0.6820803880691528, 0.43582883477211, -0.49622371792793274, 4.16471004486084, 0.6889740824699402, 0.4760759770870209, -0.17794305086135864, 0.2049635797739029, 0.46076205372810364, 1.0406614542007446, 0.4221622049808502, 0.7922579050064087, 0.011429358273744583, -0.551467776298523, 0.6829930543899536, -0.11827757954597473, -0.21658681333065033, 1.1360632181167603, 0.8729109764099121, -0.1720874160528183, -0.44931986927986145, 0.266135573387146, -0.437063604593277, 0.5859408974647522, -0.16054247319698334, 0.05729011446237564, 0.2777291238307953, 0.2941770553588867, -0.2856167256832123, -0.28813430666923523, 0.2550033628940582, -0.15524455904960632, -0.5815821886062622, 0.01631372608244419, -0.17584747076034546, 0.5645560026168823, -0.6105116009712219, 0.013654847629368305, 0.23247599601745605, -0.344350129365921, -0.31928008794784546, 0.21718807518482208, 0.22783586382865906, -0.3203100562095642, 0.35459470748901367, -0.00872162263840437, -0.5213140845298767, -0.6018098592758179, 0.2687811851501465, 0.0701662003993988, 0.11718209087848663, 0.42656105756759644, -0.3914704918861389, 0.44381633400917053, -0.8198001384735107, -0.09636276215314865, -0.1414441615343094, -1.3433737754821777, 0.5201800465583801, 0.5338147878646851, -0.5307486653327942, 0.5075196623802185, 0.0018094673287123442, 0.3321613669395447, 0.14888393878936768, -0.055832114070653915, -0.3676700294017792, 0.5837764143943787, 0.3895800709724426, 0.5937798619270325, 0.1445292979478836, -0.4303392767906189, -0.19139450788497925, -0.29425036907196045, -0.03179120272397995, -0.5411877036094666, -1.0260158777236938, 0.2394251972436905, 0.7515340447425842, -0.20268301665782928, 0.11696965992450714, -0.2029094696044922, -0.35889506340026855, -0.39838090538978577, -0.2224525511264801, -0.19080308079719543, 0.42481812834739685, 0.0452679879963398, 0.5223838686943054, 0.3342059850692749, -0.20947463810443878, -1.1632832288742065, 0.1953725516796112, 0.8002191185951233, -0.17933987081050873, 0.10612493753433228, 0.2701389491558075, -0.016262508928775787 ]
{"Title": "Subacute effects of the psychedelic ayahuasca on the salience and default mode networks", "Authors": "Pasquini Lorenzo, Palhano-Fontes Fernanda, Araujo Draulio B.", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Neuroimaging studies have just begun to explore the acute effects of psychedelics on large-scale brain networks\u2019 functional organization. Even less is known on the neural correlates of subacute effects taking place days after the psychedelic experience. This study explores the subacute changes of primary sensory brain networks and networks supporting higher-order affective and self-referential functions 24h after a single session with the psychedelic ayahuasca. Methods We leveraged task-free functional magnetic resonance imaging data one day before and one day after a randomized placebo-controlled trial exploring the effects of ayahuasca in na\u00efve healthy participants (21 placebo/22 ayahuasca). We derived intra- and inter-network functional connectivity of the salience, default mode, visual, and sensorimotor networks, and assessed post-session connectivity changes between the ayahuasca and placebo groups. Connectivity changes were associated with Hallucinogen Rating Scale scores assessed during the acute effects. Results Our findings revealed increased anterior cingulate cortex connectivity within the salience network, decreased posterior cingulate cortex connectivity within the default mode network, and increased connectivity between the salience and default mode networks one day after the session in the ayahuasca group compared to placebo. Connectivity of primary sensory networks did not differ between-groups. Salience network connectivity increases correlated with altered somesthesia scores, decreased default mode network connectivity correlated with altered volition scores, and increased salience-default mode network connectivity correlated with altered affect scores. Conclusion These findings provide preliminary evidence for subacute functional changes induced by the psychedelic ayahuasca on higher-order cognitive brain networks that support interoceptive, affective, and self-referential functions.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007542"}
10.1101/19002436
[ -0.18386785686016083, -0.30945584177970886, 0.19090396165847778, 0.36721962690353394, -0.6679137349128723, -0.7799472212791443, -0.028886964544653893, 0.3902582824230194, -0.1689601093530655, 0.988041877746582, -1.346560001373291, -0.765872061252594, -0.05456293001770973, -0.05322219058871269, 0.4739510416984558, 0.10212315618991852, -1.194644570350647, -0.04455699771642685, -0.6206969022750854, 0.9186475872993469, 0.4823457896709442, 0.3448368012905121, -0.26114118099212646, 0.2735784649848938, -0.2792980670928955, 0.9498589038848877, -0.01840067468583584, 0.05990978330373764, 1.2071384191513062, 0.035688403993844986, -0.13546784222126007, -0.7643712162971497, 0.17004308104515076, -0.5567745566368103, -0.12185889482498169, -0.3759954571723938, 0.37153568863868713, -0.7101115584373474, -0.07931286096572876, 0.1957467645406723, 0.6225966811180115, -0.18013237416744232, 0.795484721660614, -1.0591886043548584, -0.2602537274360657, -0.19825614988803864, -0.010968024842441082, -0.09387817233800888, -0.09956639260053635, -0.8717976808547974, -0.995794951915741, -0.07459498941898346, -0.00261661852709949, 0.2308085560798645, -0.48468896746635437, 0.01666606031358242, 0.33077841997146606, 0.2162715047597885, -0.6525464653968811, 0.01659686304628849, 0.3835721015930176, 0.024245809763669968, 0.38820359110832214, -0.6294131875038147, 0.04289121925830841, 0.5214890837669373, -0.36258676648139954, 0.23870661854743958, -0.6023792028427124, 0.358359158039093, -0.6553537249565125, 0.10935259610414505, -0.056721244007349014, -0.7400797605514526, -0.6933806538581848, -0.1836516261100769, 0.28662148118019104, -0.569929838180542, 0.7377489805221558, 0.3624415695667267, 0.5962390303611755, 0.37010130286216736, -0.5701777338981628, 0.5618641376495361, -0.2045108526945114, 0.3885614573955536, 0.6049197316169739, 0.49533209204673767, 0.14523561298847198, -0.13757704198360443, 0.22175118327140808, 0.4835887551307678, 0.16085819900035858, 0.917108952999115, 0.3432829976081848, 0.839049220085144, 0.27703505754470825, 0.16807624697685242, 0.17799337208271027, 0.36506354808807373, 0.7256311178207397, 0.5075669884681702, -0.12549002468585968, 0.2824392020702362, -0.7659335136413574, 0.5015404224395752, 0.8272722363471985, -0.10366292297840118, -0.1391117125749588, -0.8483765125274658, 0.3764774799346924, 0.466072142124176, -0.3598950505256653, -0.09189237654209137, 0.05888541042804718, 0.7399859428405762, 0.05737708508968353, 0.7771231532096863, -0.49507421255111694, 0.21427495777606964, 0.2637852132320404, 0.1952868551015854, -0.03880001977086067, -0.5429835319519043, 0.05294724181294441, -0.31550514698028564, -0.15173335373401642, 0.8793932199478149, -0.04381502792239189, -0.2899305522441864, -0.5020037889480591, -0.6212834715843201, -0.03785771131515503, 0.6511488556861877, 0.27835145592689514, -0.2275337278842926, 0.08780890703201294, 1.0774821043014526, 0.04481951892375946, -0.32556235790252686, -0.37540948390960693, 0.5591737031936646, -0.09342209994792938, 1.0178314447402954, 0.24938520789146423, 0.7361606955528259, -0.0037484634667634964, -0.8534752130508423, -0.3002271056175232, -0.27854716777801514, -0.36066317558288574, 0.4832374155521393, 0.06861566752195358, -0.2583406865596771, 0.3487703204154968, -0.43112820386886597, -0.08245515823364258, 0.19016633927822113, -0.14677245914936066, -0.7405239343643188, -0.10079895704984665, -0.07269157469272614, -0.5922329425811768, 0.8352263569831848, -0.47927337884902954, 0.3160799741744995, 0.0018263240344822407, -0.27212485671043396, 0.5765272378921509, -0.7215625047683716, 0.11632131785154343, 0.24667662382125854, -0.12007651478052139, -0.048309702426195145, 0.2182791531085968, 0.48386940360069275, 1.2285524606704712, -0.1359495222568512, 0.7017049789428711, 0.2006046175956726, -0.12718583643436432, 0.20873211324214935, 0.3560427129268646, 0.5566628575325012, 0.2445325255393982, 0.6562258005142212, -0.4726038873195648, -1.0262364149093628, -0.25955963134765625, -0.15239693224430084, -0.17791897058486938, 0.04348883777856827, -1.059036135673523, 0.16676142811775208, 0.138982892036438, -0.18750505149364471, 0.42323899269104004, 0.5745742321014404, 0.020862076431512833, -0.7205082178115845, -0.17254437506198883, 0.9477086067199707, -0.49363166093826294, 0.48217883706092834, -0.19321174919605255, 0.26776430010795593, 0.4427241086959839, 0.305671751499176, -0.7112141251564026, 0.0761444941163063, 0.5847200155258179, 0.1688268929719925, -0.36899691820144653, 0.17562954127788544, 0.10085491091012955, -0.49877336621284485, 0.20149265229701996, 0.38491567969322205, -0.863589882850647, -0.07723090797662735, -0.5038483738899231, -0.16904017329216003, 0.3971668779850006, 0.18493624031543732, 0.1415221095085144, -0.5739988684654236, -0.1385209709405899, 0.5661330819129944, -0.009131042286753654, -0.057995788753032684, 0.14542481303215027, 0.5774741172790527, 0.3393796682357788, 0.6664705276489258, 1.0213738679885864, -0.24417810142040253, 0.3129649758338928, 0.2145489603281021, 0.3241865038871765, 0.02198798954486847, 0.33158424496650696, 0.4764471650123596, 0.9024808406829834, 0.03960175812244415, -0.013164164498448372, 0.7660166025161743, -0.6780998706817627, -0.386639803647995, 0.5839563012123108, 0.15402841567993164, -1.1249266862869263, 1.132075309753418, 0.6602909564971924, 0.10559163987636566, -0.7327703833580017, 0.1539592146873474, 0.09621133655309677, 0.4732326865196228, -0.12289746105670929, -0.0461292527616024, 0.17865781486034393, 0.3582358956336975, 0.645530641078949, 0.05195143446326256, 0.6535987257957458, 0.6629155278205872, -0.004169650841504335, 0.4266270101070404, 0.29964515566825867, -0.7176968455314636, 0.013979031704366207, -0.6972516775131226, -1.3456605672836304, -0.4676624834537506, -0.5463398098945618, 0.5025047063827515, 0.04543442279100418, -0.3671410381793976, 0.15708643198013306, 0.2870846390724182, 0.39572030305862427, -0.3210075795650482, 0.6583924889564514, 0.33566710352897644, 0.30950164794921875, -0.12029710412025452, -0.41743186116218567, 0.07344350218772888, -0.12320968508720398, 0.5686207413673401, -0.35252857208251953, -1.057409405708313, -0.34293222427368164, -0.908970832824707, 0.5083757638931274, -0.4458530843257904, -0.032525982707738876, -0.00855918601155281, -0.6422389149665833, -0.015160714276134968, 0.6821190118789673, -0.12196946889162064, 0.04299446567893028, -0.6333057880401611, -1.23722505569458, 0.5197921395301819, 0.3282730281352997, 0.6388422846794128, 0.2299799919128418, 0.6896872520446777, -0.4175204932689667, 0.47666797041893005, -0.13688412308692932, -0.12430655211210251, -0.7827848792076111, -0.40999606251716614, -0.10192584246397018, -0.8533480167388916, -0.5085097551345825, -0.30811864137649536, -0.870181679725647, -0.17751777172088623, -0.2184617668390274, -0.5810244679450989, -0.30366644263267517, 0.03646707162261009, 0.2998407483100891, -0.46753400564193726, 0.0030735875479876995, -1.2004377841949463, -0.3803396224975586, 0.7231783270835876, -0.545335054397583, 0.7034581899642944, 0.5280319452285767, 0.5858896374702454, -0.4596238136291504, -0.9369601011276245, 0.6768608093261719, 0.35340458154678345, 1.0241200923919678, -0.3149715065956116, -0.8946977257728577, 0.19108687341213226, -0.3055305778980255, 0.473287433385849, 0.18064677715301514, -0.1537155956029892, -0.1600114107131958, 0.05620938912034035, -0.5113916397094727, -0.29394981265068054, 0.8050593137741089, -0.298229843378067, 0.2749669849872589, 0.764362633228302, -0.8331891894340515, -0.36011382937431335, 0.48341259360313416, -0.4438948929309845, -0.5446290373802185, 0.3371163308620453, -0.6434962153434753, 0.24667339026927948, -0.8948796987533569, -0.7242838144302368, 0.5207927823066711, 0.30063125491142273, 0.2058093547821045, -0.4292218089103699, 0.7465006709098816, -0.027568070217967033, 0.5926713347434998, 0.6076592803001404, 0.4126264154911041, -0.6617913842201233, 1.1621774435043335, 0.26482632756233215, 1.7320168018341064, -1.1814491748809814, 0.5012007355690002, 0.6093284487724304, 0.8685765862464905, 0.13600173592567444, 0.23301257193088531, 0.0976194366812706, -1.1127222776412964, 0.12117887288331985, 0.27625104784965515, -0.41537949442863464, 0.5111128687858582, 0.6447739601135254, 0.014958783984184265, -0.12084991484880447, -0.9032373428344727, -0.7163609862327576, -0.4127448797225952, 0.07164429128170013, 0.3865109980106354, 0.059145983308553696, 0.48263439536094666, -0.7504522204399109, 0.13527919352054596, 0.4051595628261566, 1.3943068981170654, -0.19807761907577515, 0.00287845847196877, -0.05027144029736519, -0.5339229702949524, -0.6352419257164001, 0.5214982628822327, -0.41440048813819885, -0.14470107853412628, 0.2514045834541321, 0.2852410078048706, 0.014986138790845871, -0.3741986155509949, -0.1366948038339615, -0.2548632323741913, 0.15640856325626373, -0.37343499064445496, 0.4392813742160797, 0.21293237805366516, -0.15066583454608917, -0.6006131768226624, -0.5793038010597229, 0.13134676218032837, -0.7289623618125916, 0.526253342628479, 1.3985106945037842, 0.15556903183460236, -0.7573878169059753, -0.2466370165348053, 0.32129016518592834, -0.27669844031333923, 0.015021765604615211, -0.1466142237186432, -0.3051588237285614, 0.7598544955253601, -0.44331204891204834, -0.056465476751327515, 0.07194159924983978, -0.6802414655685425, 0.40264004468917847, 0.4557154178619385, 0.4662492275238037, 0.62576824426651, 0.27677586674690247, 0.6573801636695862, -0.5636885166168213, 0.22171539068222046, -0.8830174803733826, 0.40588822960853577, -0.3001573383808136, -0.3095357120037079, -0.5388086438179016, 0.06274205446243286, 1.0272494554519653, -0.49123772978782654, -0.2658401131629944, -0.43846219778060913, 0.06370969116687775, 0.8310399651527405, 0.3083513081073761, -0.8413089513778687, 0.588870644569397, -0.4896754026412964, -0.33966025710105896, 0.9192003607749939, 0.13417500257492065, -0.5331516861915588, -0.7251003980636597, -0.30867233872413635, -0.6339890360832214, 0.819715678691864, 0.23719753324985504, 0.2756698429584503, -0.3098028004169464, -0.6710271835327148, -0.1807089000940323, -0.025763213634490967, 0.34121373295783997, -0.29935190081596375, -0.5049169063568115, -0.1738329976797104, 0.025641364976763725, -0.09355732798576355, -0.6336896419525146, -0.6492140293121338, -0.004765613004565239, -0.32649192214012146, -1.0363901853561401, -0.7239827513694763, -0.15465404093265533, -0.11364923417568207, -0.5034570693969727, -0.8244520425796509, 0.21749109029769897, -0.45219677686691284, 0.2685995399951935, 1.1972944736480713, -0.615543007850647, -0.26921331882476807, 0.20021995902061462, 1.2242830991744995, -0.7652676701545715, -1.0905011892318726, 1.3560322523117065, 0.06176985055208206, 0.17254014313220978, -0.2877254784107208, 0.07468106597661972, -0.4840869605541229, 0.3685269355773926, -0.20516881346702576, -0.07224837690591812, 0.36236751079559326, -0.22226069867610931, -0.4664212763309479, 0.08799638599157333, -0.3882712721824646, -0.6871819496154785, -0.7731577157974243, 0.3325427770614624, 0.031208189204335213, -0.05595594644546509, -0.39213037490844727, -1.0501610040664673, -0.492426335811615, 0.15422555804252625, -0.09564689546823502, -0.8537892699241638, 0.5235099196434021, -0.21458692848682404, 0.5171982645988464, 0.19893769919872284, -0.292218416929245, 0.6334514021873474, 0.11573202908039093, 0.03579509258270264, -0.019841082394123077, 0.16927985846996307, -0.25448065996170044, -0.5612839460372925, 0.2333681732416153, -0.3005167245864868, 0.5291954874992371, 0.6275845170021057, 0.5349260568618774, -0.6003080010414124, 0.3193407654762268, -0.29761943221092224, 0.45898351073265076, -0.0469328910112381, -0.7007899880409241, -0.003097600070759654, -0.09112530946731567, 0.3099536597728729, 0.3358369767665863, -0.18925543129444122, -1.0876327753067017, 1.0744537115097046, -0.6473888754844666, 0.7192918658256531, -0.17008082568645477, -0.8332048654556274, -0.027137435972690582, -0.1037573292851448, 0.7796545028686523, -0.42175132036209106, 0.10582493990659714, 0.29833683371543884, -0.5581868290901184, -0.44260767102241516, -0.08833462744951248, -0.6411288976669312, -0.24324603378772736, -0.3729245662689209, -0.4686444103717804, 0.0634133592247963, 0.012545810081064701, 0.204662024974823, 0.8795631527900696, -0.1263597011566162, -0.20402008295059204, -0.48691537976264954, 1.0549548864364624, 0.18202200531959534, 0.06713885068893433, -0.27234622836112976, 0.1586219072341919, 0.11508966237306595, 0.4697118103504181, 0.45886823534965515, 0.4542052447795868, -0.8338524103164673, -0.32508471608161926, 0.44556647539138794, -0.3718651235103607, -0.470795601606369, -0.34544602036476135, 0.1747683584690094, 0.549485981464386, -0.4382251799106598, -0.13218197226524353, 0.8597734570503235, -0.1510157734155655, -0.6132060289382935, 0.305890828371048, -0.21145576238632202, 0.2941504418849945, 0.9526333808898926, -0.2858029901981354, -0.8505021333694458, 0.5595647096633911, 0.4980944097042084, 0.6487768888473511, -0.16801543533802032, 0.47309184074401855, 0.3498830497264862, -1.0628494024276733, -0.5178210735321045, 0.3100290298461914, -0.806498646736145, -1.0178442001342773, 0.10183987021446228, -0.12202052026987076, 0.19988033175468445, -0.6052640080451965, -0.6797122955322266, 0.13338702917099, -0.6547840237617493, 0.8263550996780396, -0.008951984345912933, 0.25714075565338135, -0.13786134123802185, -0.6856837272644043, -0.13055048882961273, -0.4752904176712036, 0.5765402913093567, 0.3696952164173126, 0.03936520591378212, 0.10926671326160431, -0.37501975893974304, 0.3703748881816864, 0.3364180028438568, 0.36142465472221375, 0.5457115173339844, -0.15539804100990295, -0.27400991320610046, -0.2932843267917633, 0.5268546938896179, 0.0890655517578125, 0.1667402684688568, -0.31207969784736633, 1.0477267503738403, -0.5276023149490356, -1.2039364576339722, -0.6983851790428162, 0.05586429685354233, 0.7724944353103638, 0.2146620899438858, -0.3817855417728424, -0.01868443749845028, 0.541876494884491, 0.9966010451316833, 0.10728725790977478, -0.5029598474502563, -1.1217138767242432, -0.41657182574272156, -0.015713825821876526, -0.1936175525188446, -0.566494345664978, -0.5033894777297974, 0.10239287465810776, 0.17632228136062622, -0.7158912420272827, -0.058188024908304214, 0.41025999188423157, -0.47755730152130127, -0.4390268623828888, -0.831389307975769, 0.13985277712345123, -0.42850393056869507, -0.09752827137708664, -0.5153387188911438, -0.5678995251655579, 0.2130604386329651, 0.7423064112663269, -0.8498924374580383, -0.144972562789917, -0.3551247715950012, 0.8047330379486084, -0.16984175145626068, 0.8315119743347168, -0.6171212196350098, -0.9382826685905457, 0.16671374440193176, 0.2881363034248352, -0.06842149049043655, -0.08704689890146255, 1.0667587518692017, -0.31240904331207275, 0.07697214931249619, 0.3005800247192383, 0.6740540862083435, -0.5047560334205627, 0.07796098291873932, 0.05080663785338402, -0.5939486026763916, -0.2792178988456726, -0.2618546187877655, 0.459245890378952, -0.48479023575782776, -0.03651709854602814, -1.2360469102859497, 0.37993597984313965, -0.37971925735473633, -1.0729864835739136, 0.050067875534296036, 1.0072027444839478, 0.14853592216968536, 0.15274019539356232, 0.41577669978141785, 0.14284224808216095, 0.2673483192920685, 0.6592988967895508, -0.1751001477241516, 0.03855665400624275, 0.2832345962524414, -0.6763182282447815, 0.46981191635131836, 0.307015597820282, -0.27341440320014954, 0.10923915356397629, -0.15644612908363342, -0.27814364433288574, 0.2142479568719864, -0.13566537201404572, 0.7950966358184814, 0.6696355938911438, -0.10539623349905014, 0.11807789653539658, -0.14257743954658508, -0.16860570013523102, -0.7618556022644043, -0.8477569818496704, -1.2455754280090332, -0.5536413192749023, 0.31413501501083374, -0.4118332862854004, -0.5101396441459656, -0.5548085570335388, -0.7438594102859497, 0.6399562358856201, -0.2585970461368561, 0.6431970596313477, -0.44344350695610046, 0.9399697780609131, 0.2743307650089264, 0.38812559843063354, 0.7378902435302734, -0.25386184453964233, 0.4957481622695923, 0.2759924829006195, -0.19654157757759094, -0.6203787922859192, 0.3365105092525482, 0.9379982352256775, 0.007177378516644239, -0.045806918293237686, -0.42301681637763977, 0.13259847462177277, -0.624354362487793, 0.02601024881005287, 0.04615502804517746, 0.1879516988992691, 0.010279867798089981, -0.26005759835243225, -0.5209709405899048, 0.7108142971992493, -0.19798049330711365, 0.19168946146965027, 0.25793465971946716, -1.0358741283416748, -0.7816824913024902, 0.2501735985279083, 0.36059683561325073, 0.04484057426452637, 0.4775574207305908, -0.21222856640815735, 0.668751060962677, -0.5930349826812744, -0.04812723398208618, 0.5259005427360535, 0.4619421660900116, 0.1743188053369522, -0.026892511174082756, -0.40735888481140137, 0.22935912013053894, 0.9299334287643433, 0.14657755196094513, 0.3811103105545044, 0.621487557888031, -0.3949832618236542, 0.5127294659614563, -0.3404023349285126, -0.7345341444015503, 1.0462461709976196, 0.06687923520803452, 0.20014601945877075, 0.2701411247253418, -0.3354645371437073, 0.7973890900611877, 0.018651826307177544, -0.5819876790046692, 0.37724149227142334, -0.15486522018909454, -0.5394263863563538, -0.21689021587371826, 0.4875929057598114, 0.8927134871482849, -0.007213297300040722, 0.5972374677658081, 0.5657071471214294, 0.21837152540683746, 0.4638734757900238, -0.08664417266845703, 0.823013961315155, 0.04997287690639496, -0.36452558636665344, -0.5473295450210571, 0.6626476645469666, 0.24577753245830536, -0.447582870721817, -0.1612440049648285, 0.33867406845092773, -0.4117455780506134, 0.9270113110542297, 0.14254048466682434, -0.30457186698913574, 0.6601330041885376, -0.661632239818573, 0.16996856033802032, -0.04702607914805412, 0.18005384504795074, -0.19765573740005493, -0.4512133002281189, 0.6536515951156616, -0.24262192845344543, 0.09506750106811523, 0.1492237001657486, -0.21798376739025116, 0.24768617749214172, 0.00840943492949009, 0.24552060663700104, -0.7025166153907776, 0.5500409007072449, 0.40780961513519287, -0.7566112279891968, 0.3375406861305237, -0.19468465447425842, -0.6046569347381592, 0.11855410784482956, -0.4796280264854431, 0.40671980381011963, -0.2217191457748413, -0.06715960800647736, 0.047741375863552094, 0.17070631682872772, -0.2567891478538513, -0.486976683139801, -0.3109967112541199, 0.8336701393127441, -0.3727729022502899, -0.2830508351325989, -0.696772038936615, -0.4078982472419739, 0.04304115101695061, 0.32911255955696106, 0.5706579685211182, -0.5680280327796936, 0.10771476477384567, 0.07352964580059052, -0.3070651888847351, 1.2072138786315918, 0.23349052667617798, -1.3457841873168945, -0.9170595407485962, -0.7237446904182434, -0.1314345896244049, -0.06705448031425476, -0.47251033782958984, -0.32258814573287964, 0.404837965965271, 0.04263784736394882, -0.0007918804185464978, -0.32044196128845215, -0.2616139054298401, -0.5020424127578735, 0.06764090061187744, 1.170983910560608, -0.3141568601131439, 0.7996399402618408, 0.2960527837276459, -0.18820028007030487, 0.12093675136566162, -0.16709375381469727, -0.12723682820796967, -0.15283766388893127, -0.09062027186155319, -0.02427074685692787, -0.08469568192958832, 0.15959696471691132, -0.02289724163711071, 0.2965560555458069, 0.8089718222618103, 0.26186928153038025, 0.09225951880216599, -0.9524629712104797, -0.767579197883606, -1.2145549058914185, 1.1698849201202393, -0.31058648228645325, 0.5287251472473145, -0.6799519062042236, -0.7830514311790466, 0.5855872631072998, -0.9213242530822754, 4.165772914886475, 0.4739896059036255, 0.288036972284317, -0.2761288583278656, -0.4463166296482086, 0.10885216295719147, 0.6423134207725525, -0.4451214373111725, 0.3893764317035675, 0.43123477697372437, -0.8930352330207825, 0.7698585391044617, -0.02423691377043724, 0.028181342408061028, 0.6220357418060303, 0.6981918811798096, -0.5973393321037292, -0.1582772582769394, 0.30755773186683655, -0.6466596126556396, -0.6734691262245178, 0.031631916761398315, 0.3024599850177765, 0.5370869040489197, -0.3420063555240631, -0.3105469346046448, 0.14987261593341827, 0.5134803652763367, -0.049671418964862823, -0.45395466685295105, -0.30371710658073425, -0.6181869506835938, 0.6155999302864075, -0.49416571855545044, -0.06195200979709625, 0.17288218438625336, 0.29119133949279785, 0.9696758985519409, 0.07520447671413422, 0.007591446861624718, 0.4959864914417267, 0.003179428167641163, 0.04973883926868439, -0.3898082375526428, 0.2942778766155243, -0.20953255891799927, -0.5919573903083801, -0.10779567807912827, 0.23235028982162476, -0.6624919772148132, 1.0844146013259888, -1.0811848640441895, 0.7502593398094177, 0.2710016667842865, -1.1556333303451538, -0.39187079668045044, -0.23895612359046936, -0.9952428936958313, 0.21778179705142975, 0.02790389209985733, 0.9042757153511047, -0.29038724303245544, -0.06187418848276138, -0.3973563015460968, 0.4751316010951996, 0.4556165337562561, 0.38848188519477844, 0.20109596848487854, -0.02350364811718464, -0.4094712436199188, 0.04686686769127846, -0.5937871932983398, -0.09020200371742249, -0.3487274646759033, 0.2319832295179367, 0.44289109110832214, -0.38568204641342163, 0.13499467074871063, -0.462893009185791, -0.4882795810699463, 0.24031226336956024, -0.15616607666015625, 0.464408814907074, -0.14205580949783325, 0.8034817576408386, 0.6460189819335938, -0.8078152537345886, 0.11622805893421173, -1.2019435167312622, 0.39006322622299194, 0.7215734124183655, 0.3759458065032959, 0.4269806444644928, -0.15022698044776917, 0.09192296862602234 ]
{"Title": "Disruptive Mood Dysregulation Disorder: symptomatic and syndromic thresholds and diagnostic operationalization", "Authors": "Laporte Paola Paganella, Matijasevich Alicia, Munhoz Tiago N., Santos In\u00e1 S., Barros Alu\u00edsio J. D., Pine Daniel Samuel, Rohde Luis Augusto, Leibenluft Ellen, Abrah\u00e3o Salum Giovanni", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective The aim of this study is to identify the most appropriate threshold for Disruptive Mood Dysregulation Disorder (DMDD) diagnosis and the impact of potential changes in diagnostic rules on prevalence levels in the community. Method Trained psychologists evaluated 3,562 pre-adolescents/early adolescents from the 2004 Pelotas Birth Cohort with the Development and Well-Being Behavior Assessment (DAWBA). The clinical threshold was assessed in three stages: symptomatic, syndromic and clinical operationalization. The symptomatic threshold identified the response category in each DAWBA item which separates normative misbehavior from a clinical indicator. The syndromic threshold identified the number of irritable mood and outbursts needed to capture pre-adolescents/early adolescents with high symptom levels. Clinical operationalization compared the impact of AND/OR rules for combining irritable mood and outbursts on impairment and levels of psychopathology. Results At the symptomatic threshold, most irritable mood items were normative in their lowest response categories and clinically significant in their highest response categories. For outbursts some indicated a symptom even when present at only a mild level, while others did not indicate symptoms at any level. At the syndromic level, a combination of 2 out of 7 irritable mood and 3 out of 8 outburst indicators accurately captured a cluster of individuals with high level of symptoms. Analysis combining irritable mood and outbursts delineated non-overlapping aspects of DMDD, providing support for the OR rule in clinical operationalization. The best DMDD criteria resulted in a prevalence of 3%. Conclusion Results provide information for initiatives aiming to provide data-driven and clinically oriented operationalized criteria for DMDD.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002436"}
10.1101/19008052
[ -0.2865190804004669, -0.29652878642082214, -0.0512402281165123, 0.31416577100753784, 0.14761057496070862, 0.35593339800834656, -0.2573128342628479, -0.3235081136226654, 0.2402976155281067, 0.7610137462615967, -0.2793883681297302, -0.3358927369117737, 0.035870205610990524, -0.36391037702560425, -0.8116742968559265, -0.37076491117477417, -0.12793515622615814, 0.6466864943504333, 0.15574079751968384, 0.07446552813053131, 0.03780294582247734, 0.29057684540748596, -0.792398989200592, 0.13556914031505585, -0.28994324803352356, 1.1087275743484497, -0.5597803592681885, 0.11399036645889282, 1.3000109195709229, 0.9825248718261719, 0.5298570990562439, -0.27985697984695435, 0.5764559507369995, -0.5686729550361633, -0.24713432788848877, -0.19318439066410065, 0.9028299450874329, 0.3439202904701233, -0.26293468475341797, -0.5468025207519531, 1.0317115783691406, -0.5221121311187744, 0.5202506184577942, 0.3581154942512512, -0.8326045274734497, -0.15848414599895477, -0.1724369078874588, 0.4325597882270813, -0.21904811263084412, 0.6105290651321411, -0.1536480337381363, -0.04156333953142166, 0.469368040561676, 0.08892247080802917, -0.6019370555877686, -0.01940709911286831, -0.09007896482944489, -0.3903665542602539, -0.6220274567604065, 0.11358966678380966, 0.5017899870872498, -0.31172463297843933, 0.6981897354125977, -0.8623418211936951, 0.4690973460674286, 0.3521609306335449, -0.2458314299583435, 0.415396511554718, -0.21678240597248077, -0.5730897188186646, -0.2968609929084778, -0.11120922118425369, -0.17217010259628296, -0.7762338519096375, -0.8716641068458557, -0.5662904977798462, 0.315726637840271, -0.2148410677909851, -0.5227574110031128, 1.0157631635665894, 0.2284564971923828, 0.33660373091697693, 1.2543920278549194, -0.39463335275650024, -0.306408554315567, 0.5028377771377563, -0.034795816987752914, 0.2951303720474243, -0.04598337411880493, 1.131298542022705, 0.05771972984075546, 0.005243857391178608, 0.06362821906805038, -0.18600691854953766, 0.5103789567947388, 0.9960477948188782, -0.7774840593338013, -0.0040096621960401535, 0.4429514706134796, -0.17911377549171448, 1.2389284372329712, 0.7525433301925659, -0.47631996870040894, 0.9815322756767273, -0.36588093638420105, 0.2202943116426468, -0.02036077342927456, -0.4875926375389099, -0.3910090923309326, -0.101130411028862, 0.2881910800933838, 0.12017796188592911, -1.1154273748397827, -0.7150957584381104, 0.6524722576141357, 0.6449178457260132, -0.2996256947517395, 0.694221019744873, 0.0377158597111702, 0.7201457023620605, -0.08444051444530487, 0.22523747384548187, 1.0181012153625488, -0.12118154019117355, 0.20190180838108063, -0.28983816504478455, 0.12370643764734268, 0.6409510374069214, -0.015719112008810043, -0.28832775354385376, 0.21980537474155426, -0.47383618354797363, -0.3719869554042816, 0.13628748059272766, -0.49779340624809265, -0.15178678929805756, 0.6627233624458313, 0.64381343126297, 0.3998654782772064, -0.20831571519374847, 0.4401440918445587, 0.4844464361667633, -0.22249864041805267, 1.0205631256103516, -0.5295310020446777, 0.8823754787445068, -0.5631792545318604, -1.020422101020813, -0.5636080503463745, 0.05285230651497841, 0.20600326359272003, -0.3080945312976837, -0.013965832069516182, 0.22958441078662872, -0.18467018008232117, 0.5792297720909119, -0.34633874893188477, 0.31676802039146423, -0.1389704942703247, -0.11580249667167664, -0.6505183577537537, -0.041798148304224014, 0.1355263888835907, 0.5409715175628662, -0.5294525623321533, 0.38259777426719666, 0.23239807784557343, -0.04230790585279465, 0.3437887132167816, -0.44099804759025574, 0.4695247411727905, -0.4832595884799957, 0.17261919379234314, 0.4446570873260498, 0.23084591329097748, 1.05381441116333, 0.1540134996175766, -0.2620071768760681, 0.5908633470535278, 0.7018387317657471, 0.605914831161499, 0.2478458434343338, 0.27102819085121155, 0.06350373476743698, 0.11643646657466888, 0.7977138757705688, 0.10521426796913147, -0.10439833253622055, -0.3290761709213257, -0.917335569858551, 0.4233667254447937, 0.6846567988395691, -0.305531769990921, 0.28865283727645874, -0.14705640077590942, -0.682353138923645, -1.2228820323944092, 0.14504052698612213, 0.42681077122688293, -0.6352351903915405, -0.6722680330276489, 0.2115018367767334, 0.10703151673078537, 0.6579316258430481, -0.3732541501522064, 0.331489235162735, -0.04807000607252121, 0.6246882081031799, -0.042624518275260925, 0.023409519344568253, 0.8795004487037659, -0.5991995334625244, -0.024447457864880562, -0.10213350504636765, 0.6539754271507263, 0.09988383948802948, -0.1622813642024994, 0.7641753554344177, -0.8419895768165588, -0.05526401102542877, -0.2184058576822281, -0.6097037196159363, 0.5092775225639343, 0.10092546045780182, 0.30248403549194336, 0.41605791449546814, 0.7140711545944214, 0.2709985375404358, -0.5710998773574829, 0.16415072977542877, 0.17048077285289764, 0.26161691546440125, -0.20504821836948395, 1.2029181718826294, 0.7862739562988281, -0.044276703149080276, 0.27422553300857544, 0.5158989429473877, 1.0772271156311035, 0.21980638802051544, 0.5485313534736633, 0.22488681972026825, -0.12506908178329468, 0.36429911851882935, -0.7263801693916321, 0.7522671818733215, -0.09524285048246384, -0.14079511165618896, -0.7471824884414673, 0.6349228024482727, -0.0576295405626297, 0.6075354218482971, 0.7816024422645569, 0.3535666763782501, -0.47264963388442993, -0.7236351370811462, 0.741205096244812, 0.15013229846954346, -0.6760018467903137, 0.10259271413087845, -0.36662134528160095, -0.11543679982423782, -0.010472974739968777, -0.36688467860221863, 1.507367491722107, 0.8017534613609314, -0.8241714239120483, 0.09028108417987823, 0.7062385082244873, -0.11710899323225021, -1.469265103340149, -0.5696582198143005, -1.0040210485458374, -0.5298596620559692, -0.9263939261436462, 0.20003333687782288, 0.2034032940864563, 0.10654199868440628, 0.8894435167312622, 0.2851792871952057, -0.1387777179479599, 0.20379160344600677, 0.6596502065658569, 0.3768949806690216, 0.635758101940155, 0.04693815857172012, -0.7420785427093506, 0.9481865167617798, 0.10264456272125244, -0.6218182444572449, -0.43717634677886963, -0.29680347442626953, -0.8316041827201843, -0.744356632232666, 0.10982285439968109, 0.2936776578426361, -0.0010752941016107798, 0.9238083958625793, -0.07029978185892105, 0.4522232115268707, -0.02099047601222992, 0.12535494565963745, -0.4552876055240631, -0.5726850628852844, -0.32092103362083435, 0.6913316249847412, -0.26887771487236023, 0.19472862780094147, 0.21166636049747467, 0.2197740525007248, -0.7137691974639893, 0.6940969228744507, 0.35465970635414124, -0.17934349179267883, -0.7705069184303284, -0.4360431432723999, 1.2358806133270264, -0.5274158716201782, 0.20838212966918945, -0.6596149206161499, -1.3286999464035034, -0.10746913403272629, 0.07791344821453094, -0.3279353678226471, 0.7862224578857422, 0.4800996482372284, 0.2684257924556732, -1.0015039443969727, 0.9160351157188416, -0.2587828040122986, -1.208654522895813, 0.11555410921573639, 0.36494308710098267, -0.2875783443450928, -0.06128115579485893, 0.02663758397102356, -0.7628005743026733, 0.21430276334285736, -0.44518738985061646, -0.83824622631073, 0.12128715962171555, -0.1345069408416748, 0.19907177984714508, 0.04027175530791283, 0.4212629497051239, 0.5075461864471436, 0.08275248855352402, -0.3434835374355316, -0.6721212863922119, 0.502315878868103, -0.24099016189575195, 0.16884830594062805, 0.8560927510261536, 0.9447620511054993, -1.0659679174423218, 0.5473858118057251, -0.2172207087278366, -0.7215832471847534, -0.2091132402420044, 0.8848899602890015, -0.059592925012111664, 0.5793768167495728, -0.31780749559402466, 0.22448961436748505, -0.5832648277282715, -0.9093968868255615, -0.04885825514793396, 0.39857062697410583, 0.5194522738456726, -0.6533353924751282, 0.7011501789093018, -0.22830359637737274, 0.22418038547039032, 0.1118263378739357, 0.153988778591156, -0.05363449081778526, 1.1796550750732422, -0.031143296509981155, 1.215265154838562, -1.4579216241836548, 0.28276392817497253, 0.701876163482666, 0.4674598276615143, 0.8161377310752869, 0.9408930540084839, 0.21674402058124542, -0.05024709179997444, 0.13052737712860107, 0.018880758434534073, -0.5093106031417847, -0.05617954954504967, -0.06264699995517731, 0.5120794177055359, -0.2947750389575958, -0.5766457319259644, -0.08499594032764435, 0.6392989158630371, 0.46087172627449036, 0.45707929134368896, 0.3877008855342865, 0.7162284255027771, -0.3949016034603119, 0.5787347555160522, 0.8383039236068726, 0.4955182671546936, 0.808199942111969, -0.6024707555770874, 0.28733840584754944, -0.9258508086204529, -0.569726288318634, -0.14908424019813538, -0.9662861824035645, -0.31984004378318787, -0.1521194875240326, -0.06331227719783783, 0.034277599304914474, -0.20748795568943024, -0.39013174176216125, 0.11938851326704025, 0.12913405895233154, 0.23155951499938965, -0.23288503289222717, -0.6298618316650391, 0.38384804129600525, 0.02759694494307041, -0.9082633256912231, 0.25730252265930176, -1.0343564748764038, -0.33216315507888794, 0.7604187726974487, -0.0033214499708265066, -0.7061755061149597, -0.31380704045295715, 0.09423533082008362, -0.9566891193389893, -0.16082045435905457, -0.43724432587623596, 0.047242216765880585, 0.07335051149129868, -0.1742824912071228, -0.5404499173164368, -0.2230849713087082, -0.4286440908908844, -0.2934557795524597, 0.17593108117580414, 0.18268059194087982, 0.7743045687675476, 0.40976619720458984, -0.22112734615802765, 0.5823375582695007, 0.1965791881084442, -0.4356343448162079, -0.24242375791072845, -0.22199863195419312, -0.1894335150718689, -0.34964218735694885, -1.0279282331466675, 0.6757607460021973, 0.0009526631329208612, -0.0071946498937904835, -0.4207214117050171, 0.011918524280190468, 0.028702128678560257, -0.2546365261077881, -0.6849042177200317, 0.5652840733528137, 0.47402119636535645, 0.13865724205970764, 0.9374355673789978, -0.9585925936698914, -0.04036559537053108, 0.34496009349823, 0.2376958429813385, -0.707025408744812, 0.24890512228012085, 0.6087868213653564, 0.5342398285865784, 0.6186332702636719, -0.32873860001564026, 0.35578277707099915, 0.09649976342916489, 0.37513378262519836, -0.34071990847587585, -0.052510105073451996, 0.33051779866218567, -0.7127993702888489, -0.4117475748062134, 0.25448378920555115, -0.8453181982040405, 0.6746204495429993, -0.7895504236221313, -0.21591252088546753, -0.24083535373210907, 0.554287314414978, -0.8653249740600586, -0.7662484049797058, -0.6159447431564331, -0.3246123790740967, 0.01912156119942665, 0.14263693988323212, 0.7107017040252686, -0.19804702699184418, -0.4245627224445343, 0.20309783518314362, 0.6785895228385925, -0.8408957719802856, -0.2919882833957672, 0.5395251512527466, -0.3506833016872406, -0.1915714591741562, 0.06924191862344742, 0.4636717736721039, -0.6060957312583923, -0.9180389046669006, 0.12526077032089233, 0.26968324184417725, 1.2287355661392212, 0.19222387671470642, -0.43732962012290955, 0.1358853280544281, -0.5855875015258789, -0.6274666786193848, 0.1165362149477005, 0.3371446132659912, 0.41093727946281433, 0.3246411383152008, -0.21485036611557007, -0.5572004914283752, -0.6484026312828064, -0.8108103275299072, -0.10771494358778, -1.0513972043991089, 0.15796761214733124, 0.2331143021583557, -0.7797548174858093, 0.14962135255336761, 0.3704403042793274, 0.6849564909934998, 0.8067864179611206, 0.18853507936000824, -0.9234181046485901, 0.2994464933872223, -0.08967006206512451, -0.512012779712677, -0.21428079903125763, -1.1048542261123657, -0.6877207159996033, 0.8510339856147766, -0.19531629979610443, -0.9742882251739502, 0.6698060035705566, 0.843741238117218, 0.5291123390197754, 0.05518475919961929, -0.13602934777736664, -0.7162773013114929, 0.12269849330186844, 0.7708335518836975, -0.8254224061965942, -0.18637937307357788, -1.191507339477539, 0.5460918545722961, -0.5135504603385925, 0.34689974784851074, -0.19127170741558075, -0.5286046862602234, 0.3383505940437317, -0.27797576785087585, 1.5215915441513062, 0.4159119427204132, 0.5344939231872559, 0.17403389513492584, -0.18209099769592285, -0.140508234500885, 0.3867436349391937, -0.5201869606971741, -1.0921112298965454, -0.9804903864860535, -1.1190011501312256, 0.6533063054084778, -0.25502800941467285, -0.20843079686164856, 0.7774538993835449, 0.20782537758350372, 0.2758933901786804, -0.1174645870923996, 1.0737518072128296, 0.05003076419234276, -0.9633551239967346, -0.36495399475097656, 0.11450659483671188, 0.7427102327346802, -0.0938812717795372, -0.4631642997264862, -0.4876122772693634, -0.40322595834732056, 0.06264201551675797, 0.41596534848213196, 0.36633554100990295, -0.5047428607940674, 0.5463606715202332, 0.07196932286024094, 0.4262206554412842, 0.010882127098739147, 0.4569135308265686, -0.015359420329332352, -0.6249867677688599, -0.8539498448371887, 0.19853100180625916, 0.35094308853149414, 0.12883710861206055, 0.7170135378837585, -0.8854936361312866, 0.2690895199775696, 0.25949594378471375, 0.2846476435661316, -0.033142268657684326, -0.23857685923576355, 0.9139251708984375, -0.09372884780168533, -1.536574125289917, 0.4037591814994812, -0.2956470549106598, -0.6398809552192688, -0.8756572008132935, -0.3909609317779541, -0.8992260694503784, -0.5015861988067627, 0.04312662407755852, -0.07361962646245956, 0.052082642912864685, 0.10214819014072418, 0.6814200282096863, -0.06890150159597397, -0.1592533439397812, 0.20835712552070618, -0.5614978075027466, 0.5638827681541443, -0.933712899684906, 0.35887962579727173, 0.8911935091018677, -0.10960561782121658, 0.41741394996643066, 0.5539610981941223, -0.016612306237220764, 0.21702687442302704, 0.22181037068367004, 0.3099270462989807, -0.014125578105449677, 0.5533314347267151, -0.13901175558567047, 0.4763948321342468, -0.29993709921836853, 0.10053404420614243, 0.06758784502744675, 0.35438886284828186, 0.9614084362983704, -1.1623376607894897, -1.0366544723510742, 0.34239739179611206, 0.6434748768806458, 0.6263281106948853, 0.04538245499134064, -0.41786420345306396, 0.841118574142456, -0.5153840184211731, 1.3484385013580322, -0.3651365637779236, 0.36153489351272583, -0.7573352456092834, -0.22783975303173065, -0.24008026719093323, -1.1064774990081787, 0.3948637545108795, 0.21289962530136108, -0.7306933999061584, -0.35450905561447144, 0.3287622630596161, 0.25571513175964355, 0.14538191258907318, -0.016475606709718704, 0.18255449831485748, -0.18434922397136688, -0.8093635439872742, -1.246130108833313, -0.07953701913356781, 0.015113712288439274, 0.4245476722717285, 0.8718740940093994, -0.9319275617599487, -0.0031510316766798496, 0.6155508160591125, 0.401960551738739, 0.6191484332084656, 0.4058762192726135, -0.4408203661441803, -0.6447633504867554, -0.7858206033706665, 0.20277221500873566, 0.2793107330799103, -0.23720945417881012, 0.7875221967697144, -0.23311175405979156, 0.21201278269290924, 0.31136178970336914, -0.1285989135503769, -0.21002790331840515, -0.23442070186138153, 0.5697777271270752, -0.5306981205940247, -0.7526078224182129, -0.16217570006847382, 0.6564342975616455, -0.887077271938324, 0.028634440153837204, -0.58245450258255, -0.5709667205810547, 0.12213871628046036, 0.36315178871154785, -0.5627245903015137, 0.23946130275726318, -0.42333337664604187, -0.36123624444007874, 0.1574852466583252, 0.24239671230316162, -0.038225773721933365, -0.3337523937225342, 0.10658706724643707, 0.10600575804710388, 0.4114953875541687, -0.990761399269104, 0.6882305145263672, 0.8046345710754395, -0.3644970953464508, 0.40765124559402466, -0.05254778265953064, -0.07454346120357513, 0.435261070728302, -0.37200093269348145, -0.23401203751564026, 0.25531405210494995, -0.4135983884334564, 0.8384805917739868, 0.24371391534805298, -0.7614004015922546, -0.44124045968055725, -0.38669201731681824, -1.4273607730865479, -0.2802828550338745, 0.17130480706691742, -0.5805801153182983, -0.0053395298309624195, -0.7608829140663147, -0.7826182246208191, 0.5595539212226868, -0.3599338233470917, -0.4150806963443756, 0.40146198868751526, 0.23740777373313904, 0.19549742341041565, 0.7609824538230896, -0.13700160384178162, -0.07530421763658524, 0.3141711354255676, 0.22294247150421143, -0.6616682410240173, -1.0578651428222656, -0.429505854845047, 0.5033069252967834, 0.2984321713447571, 0.462423175573349, -0.9256446957588196, -0.5322870016098022, -0.4039808511734009, -0.7275689244270325, -0.1795072704553604, 0.1876676082611084, -0.6706896424293518, 0.37553778290748596, -0.188420370221138, -0.057264551520347595, -0.4568014442920685, 0.02970907650887966, 0.3190888464450836, -0.4750438630580902, -0.8091581463813782, -0.3601748049259186, 0.3119060695171356, 0.37566959857940674, 0.5237674713134766, 0.23700730502605438, -0.03253597021102905, -0.1716429591178894, -0.31849437952041626, 0.7372184991836548, 0.33281034231185913, -0.7777358889579773, 0.608362078666687, 0.19669444859027863, 0.4141507148742676, 0.8528578877449036, -0.47746458649635315, -0.8460351228713989, 0.250533789396286, 0.29257068037986755, -0.0773402601480484, 0.25104820728302, -0.6051595211029053, 0.17213310301303864, 0.013873587362468243, -0.4753301441669464, 0.46497806906700134, 0.3170618712902069, 0.6668973565101624, 1.075926423072815, 0.2055848389863968, 1.154421091079712, -0.3341486155986786, -0.42562034726142883, 0.06201143190264702, -0.31714215874671936, 0.8878573179244995, -0.05174802243709564, 0.09642066061496735, -0.5042378902435303, 1.0345128774642944, 0.029275381937623024, -0.09550492465496063, 0.27859222888946533, -0.7075394988059998, -0.05166963115334511, -0.5015460252761841, 0.3639019727706909, -0.27270111441612244, 0.16964191198349, 0.6692409515380859, -0.11263149231672287, -0.37735435366630554, -0.03785224258899689, -0.13775907456874847, 0.057905878871679306, 1.068582534790039, 0.24778078496456146, -0.19498230516910553, -0.20263060927391052, -0.07251686602830887, -0.4973810613155365, -0.0046898480504751205, 0.5573912262916565, -0.4860576093196869, -0.10925092548131943, 0.17665310204029083, 0.49682286381721497, 0.18770836293697357, 0.37572023272514343, 0.7602065801620483, -0.396774023771286, -0.16506211459636688, -0.05207720398902893, 1.0291703939437866, 0.5779075026512146, -0.19864775240421295, -0.32035794854164124, -0.13222254812717438, -0.6369723677635193, -0.5272587537765503, 0.39565184712409973, -0.5912330746650696, -0.5405661463737488, 0.6240813136100769, 0.027097484096884727, -0.803214967250824, -0.6217297315597534, -0.31450381875038147, 0.2506243884563446, -0.1508733332157135, -0.404638409614563, 0.6191469430923462, 0.5854605436325073, -0.23879727721214294, -0.005414691753685474, -1.0751729011535645, -0.29336339235305786, 0.3120403289794922, -0.8345052003860474, 0.2731066644191742, -0.03301580622792244, 0.14829915761947632, -0.8072913289070129, -1.5712699890136719, -0.3828667104244232, -0.7020667195320129, -0.891986608505249, -1.0004959106445312, -0.3499557375907898, -0.10656756907701492, 0.577100932598114, -0.8110491037368774, -0.1760193407535553, 0.09993448853492737, 0.006023581605404615, 0.9937262535095215, -0.5838369727134705, 0.41221651434898376, -0.2328244000673294, 0.49456021189689636, -0.11785479635000229, -0.17041130363941193, -0.07943449169397354, 0.3024557828903198, -0.606732189655304, 0.1637454330921173, 0.10660108178853989, -0.19836224615573883, -1.0909351110458374, 0.5856627821922302, 0.1648523509502411, -0.25907185673713684, -0.2281833440065384, -0.3111416697502136, -0.5604990720748901, -0.287884384393692, 0.6027755737304688, 0.26216915249824524, 0.1232544407248497, -0.26477256417274475, 0.34695011377334595, 0.7768475413322449, -0.7192540168762207, 3.9186058044433594, 1.127720832824707, 0.380201518535614, 0.23601247370243073, -0.17997562885284424, -0.14633463323116302, 0.4510408043861389, -0.2059634029865265, 0.4923858344554901, -0.5469024777412415, -0.3027171492576599, 0.2192302942276001, 0.5399028062820435, 0.07599380612373352, -0.33442771434783936, 0.1787818819284439, -0.7892561554908752, 0.38108769059181213, 0.24965830147266388, -1.5650672912597656, -0.8443205952644348, 0.5641374588012695, -0.5304173231124878, -0.17580528557300568, 0.3414466679096222, 0.2639084756374359, 0.2956187427043915, 0.14194703102111816, 0.5441880226135254, 0.05716485157608986, -0.05538306012749672, -0.5173341631889343, 0.12458506971597672, -0.801487386226654, -0.0935460701584816, 0.01508696936070919, -0.08994735032320023, -1.232728362083435, 0.04631240293383598, -0.2764416038990021, 0.5265363454818726, -0.0943998396396637, 0.07488077133893967, -0.25102895498275757, -0.27171483635902405, 0.14371483027935028, -0.9788004755973816, -0.07487756758928299, 0.6078941226005554, 0.06104707345366478, 0.628261923789978, -0.7743467092514038, -0.005923266056925058, -0.34592610597610474, -0.7857269048690796, -0.2420460432767868, -0.6285963654518127, -1.5259751081466675, 0.6051096320152283, -0.18368221819400787, 0.9258396625518799, -0.07205815613269806, -0.17906974256038666, -0.6516676545143127, 0.3082193434238434, 0.7714123725891113, 0.8241426944732666, -0.05046096444129944, -0.04019464552402496, -0.5286313891410828, 0.7409918308258057, -0.5677157044410706, -0.44192469120025635, -0.06425975263118744, -0.08142850548028946, 0.5191003084182739, -0.2030697464942932, 1.3831416368484497, -0.760534942150116, -0.7235991358757019, 0.6204383373260498, 0.07315346598625183, 0.5991286039352417, -0.23628182709217072, 0.2614123821258545, 0.9400180578231812, -0.7133682370185852, -0.03281006962060928, -1.1180639266967773, 0.39849308133125305, 1.3608392477035522, -0.051319073885679245, -0.21041744947433472, -0.1557559072971344, 0.24257925152778625 ]
{"Title": "Molecular Epidemiology, Diagnostics and Mechanisms of Antibiotic Resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex in Africa: A Systematic Review of Current Reports", "Authors": "Sekyere John Osei, Reta Melese Abate, Maningi Nontuthuko Excellent, Fourie Petrus Bernard", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Tuberculosis (TB) remains a main global public health problem. However, a systematic review of TB resistance epidemiology in Africa is wanting. Methods A comprehensive systematic search of PubMed, Web of Science and ScienceDirect for English research articles reporting on the molecular epidemiology of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex resistance in Africa from January 2007 to December 2018 was undertaken. Results and conclusion Qualitative and quantitative synthesis were respectively undertaken with 232 and 186 included articles, representing 32 countries. TB monoresistance rate was highest for isoniazid (59%) and rifampicin (27%), particularly in Zimbabwe (100%), Swaziland (100%), and Sudan (67.9%) whilst multidrug resistance (MDR) rate was substantial in Zimbabwe (100%), Sudan (34.6%), Ivory Coast (24.5%) and Ethiopia (23.9%). Resistance-conferring mutations were commonly found in katG (n=3694), rpoB (n=3591), rrs (n=1272), inhA (n=1065), pncA (n=1063) and embB (n=705) in almost all included countries: S 315 G/I/N/R/T, V 473 D/F/G/I, Q 471 H/Q/R/Y, S 303 C/L etc. in katG; S 531 A/F/S/G, H 526 A/C/D/G, D 516 A/E/G etc. in rpoB; A 1401 G, A 513 C etc. in rrs; C 15 T, G 17 A/T, -A 16 G etc. in inhA; Ins 456 C, Ins 172 G, L 172 P, C 14 R, Ins 515 G etc in pncA . Commonest lineages and families such as T (n=8139), LAM (n=5243), Beijing (n=5471), Cameroon (n=3315), CAS (n=2021), H (n=1773) etc., with the exception of T, were not fairly distributed; Beijing, Cameroon and CAS were prevalent in South Africa (n=4964), Ghana (n=2306), and Ethiopia/Tanzania (n=799/635) respectively. Resistance mutations were not lineage-specific and sputum (96.2%) were mainly used for diagnosing TB resistance using the LPA (38.5%), GeneXpert (17.2%), whole-genome sequencing (12.3%) and PCR/amplicon sequencing (9%/23%). Intercountry spread of strains were limited while intra-country dissemination was common. TB resistance and its diagnosis remain a major threat in Africa, necessitating urgent action to contain this global menace.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008052"}
10.1101/19005421
[ 0.643003523349762, -0.5350401997566223, 0.17752449214458466, 0.5968871116638184, -0.37053191661834717, 0.1974477618932724, 0.20863720774650574, 0.8463629484176636, 0.0014550941996276379, 0.7707983255386353, 0.5723299384117126, -0.8432506322860718, 0.10675803571939468, 0.027325978502631187, 0.28706619143486023, 0.22721925377845764, -0.05802735313773155, -0.4995947778224945, 0.121946319937706, -0.25116047263145447, 0.14740243554115295, 0.19922666251659393, -0.2654929757118225, 0.41482576727867126, -0.34330564737319946, 0.5023664832115173, -0.3379071056842804, 0.23577751219272614, 0.5107912421226501, 0.8236242532730103, -0.013937118463218212, -0.42850545048713684, 1.0477594137191772, -0.9658240675926208, -0.3394060730934143, -0.2253367304801941, 0.35958972573280334, -0.3588218688964844, 0.04579109698534012, 0.006059400271624327, 0.09675730764865875, -0.4599541127681732, 0.6090462803840637, -0.18749968707561493, -0.6791179776191711, -0.040512923151254654, -0.4181710183620453, -0.45621636509895325, -0.23902006447315216, -0.16636140644550323, -0.04996979981660843, 0.06770043820142746, 0.32150670886039734, -0.5405251979827881, -0.22425520420074463, 0.2786325216293335, -0.11297804862260818, 0.345516175031662, -0.5228613018989563, 0.0880981907248497, -0.17401239275932312, 0.011295603588223457, 0.446317583322525, -0.8204519152641296, 1.0572179555892944, 1.0307835340499878, 0.5674479603767395, -0.1699749082326889, 0.36804625391960144, 0.03982151672244072, -0.16652847826480865, -0.49851420521736145, -0.15308254957199097, -0.36537861824035645, 0.05631938576698303, -0.445372611284256, 0.0606096051633358, 0.09858115762472153, -0.37743815779685974, -0.256744921207428, 0.24230076372623444, 0.2940281927585602, 0.16231302917003632, 0.40150851011276245, -0.3069877624511719, 0.214503675699234, 0.8209491968154907, 0.8586325645446777, 0.43559661507606506, 0.5726546049118042, 0.4617248773574829, 0.11533199995756149, 0.20510806143283844, 0.010902333073318005, -0.053062621504068375, 1.0080519914627075, -0.24874484539031982, -0.24293266236782074, 0.36325570940971375, -0.22125688195228577, 0.8458566069602966, 0.21229499578475952, -0.8574196100234985, 0.30426323413848877, -0.7102677226066589, 1.027762770652771, 0.8004969358444214, -0.44646355509757996, 0.02640487626194954, -0.7983810901641846, 0.7057673335075378, 0.22181060910224915, -0.3137059211730957, 0.6294212937355042, 0.8590514063835144, 0.24081066250801086, -0.15964320302009583, 0.3065043091773987, 0.10668317973613739, 0.17511454224586487, 0.22365835309028625, -0.07042325288057327, 0.3269555866718292, -0.20305676758289337, -0.104057677090168, 0.2499406635761261, 0.6153034567832947, 0.5161068439483643, -0.9890581369400024, 0.28199994564056396, -0.5441436171531677, 0.3162720203399658, 0.3031971752643585, -0.24777336418628693, -0.15742681920528412, -0.5445579290390015, 0.0388304740190506, 0.8669118285179138, -0.1534632444381714, -0.18779996037483215, 0.055692028254270554, 0.34248754382133484, -0.7607796788215637, 0.4977988302707672, -0.2651827037334442, 0.4004378318786621, -0.5258345603942871, -1.252975583076477, -0.3422366678714752, -0.20996397733688354, 0.17973394691944122, 1.0516302585601807, -0.08380790799856186, -0.7730214595794678, 0.1272805780172348, 0.6808189749717712, 0.18058699369430542, 0.26504772901535034, 0.4760451912879944, -0.5086745023727417, -0.9923609495162964, -0.007054954767227173, -0.5643052458763123, 0.8768525123596191, -0.2295142412185669, 1.3354839086532593, -0.3442775011062622, -0.35987764596939087, 0.0455867275595665, -0.4618145227432251, -0.21158114075660706, 0.15394636988639832, -0.8729591965675354, -0.0665515810251236, 0.01804514229297638, 1.5644625425338745, 0.9908783435821533, -0.14956143498420715, 0.37951216101646423, 0.005225128028541803, -0.5712803602218628, -0.5318728089332581, -0.2623277008533478, 0.6999409198760986, -0.24903474748134613, 0.3876483142375946, -0.08114181458950043, -0.28104156255722046, -0.05721013620495796, -0.9281425476074219, 0.2747344970703125, -0.41330376267433167, 0.042008571326732635, 0.8791515827178955, 0.14283865690231323, 0.0394398495554924, -0.4973161220550537, 0.21265815198421478, 0.296303927898407, -0.1878940463066101, -0.08736863732337952, 0.24729083478450775, -0.4605378806591034, 0.6777704358100891, -0.6263896226882935, 0.8360689878463745, 0.40522870421409607, 0.6152178645133972, -1.215459942817688, 0.40283724665641785, 1.1665637493133545, -0.12078200280666351, -0.0517810583114624, -0.4811997413635254, 0.08949895203113556, 0.2107037901878357, -0.21927422285079956, 0.4100657105445862, -0.0076306103728711605, 0.5872431993484497, -0.596583366394043, -0.13796661794185638, 0.4351396858692169, -0.1918698251247406, 0.3344610631465912, 0.8398095965385437, 0.8399171233177185, 0.43627095222473145, -0.7478967308998108, -0.261540025472641, -0.38349953293800354, 0.7296748757362366, -0.08658460527658463, 0.36070045828819275, 0.31866660714149475, 0.4041990041732788, 0.1582861989736557, 0.21486033499240875, 0.889336884021759, 0.5227914452552795, 0.8108809590339661, 0.9249230623245239, 0.19761066138744354, -0.30746370553970337, 0.25087597966194153, 0.35437947511672974, -0.4928765892982483, 0.18148744106292725, -0.034159861505031586, 0.1695566326379776, -0.46380263566970825, 0.7213724255561829, 0.3102093040943146, 0.6535734534263611, -1.3299013376235962, 0.26635754108428955, 0.2443336695432663, -0.0739065557718277, -0.6683462858200073, -0.20008714497089386, -0.423690527677536, 0.3360559046268463, -0.41484135389328003, 0.33991196751594543, 1.12620210647583, 0.6258498430252075, 0.18467186391353607, 0.11096528172492981, 0.5876167416572571, 0.3118409812450409, -0.9547228813171387, -0.24923017621040344, -0.9978979825973511, -1.1420608758926392, -0.9544903039932251, 0.19298139214515686, 0.10569508373737335, -0.39209049940109253, -0.35334858298301697, -0.1565811038017273, -0.138711079955101, -0.3208078444004059, -0.02897562086582184, -0.13562312722206116, 0.02429480478167534, 0.15676729381084442, -0.5548058152198792, -0.5263422727584839, -0.4792080223560333, 0.00048722338397055864, -0.3740880489349365, -0.2869110107421875, -0.5037971138954163, -0.3762837052345276, 0.39701351523399353, -0.8119546175003052, 0.14296099543571472, -0.6522459387779236, -0.1848566085100174, -1.031456470489502, 0.9126805067062378, -0.16383494436740875, 0.3726159632205963, 0.11979607492685318, -0.6856828331947327, 0.18580223619937897, -0.05694187432527542, 0.10325527936220169, 0.8942270278930664, 0.8255585432052612, -0.4439440071582794, 0.5770683288574219, 0.10381701588630676, 0.5261605381965637, -0.6802114844322205, 0.002090248977765441, 0.6134244203567505, -0.18722586333751678, -0.19566203653812408, -1.1364338397979736, -0.3263159990310669, -0.054833248257637024, 0.014803893864154816, -0.07948554307222366, 0.23510758578777313, 0.034342434257268906, 0.2987253665924072, -0.5346865057945251, 0.11420741677284241, -0.1205405592918396, -1.260280966758728, -0.5251821279525757, -0.7341682314872742, 0.3480278551578522, 0.0393960177898407, -0.25862428545951843, 0.25109878182411194, 0.2304401844739914, 0.32145294547080994, 0.7469887733459473, 0.05141899734735489, -0.32428842782974243, -0.28115856647491455, 0.30403298139572144, -0.5767201781272888, -0.25597280263900757, -0.06489075720310211, 0.16811731457710266, -0.5535300970077515, 0.103817880153656, -0.3550776541233063, 0.21280448138713837, 0.3962961435317993, 0.728134274482727, -0.2766033411026001, 0.8992278575897217, 0.21504852175712585, 0.25195226073265076, 0.5174757838249207, 0.6874998807907104, 0.553092896938324, 0.49214404821395874, -0.7748920917510986, 0.11141674220561981, -0.28079307079315186, -0.017931243404746056, 0.1880541443824768, 0.3694224953651428, 0.28893232345581055, -0.12512555718421936, 0.8511741161346436, -0.12866917252540588, -0.15416157245635986, -0.19471995532512665, 0.10504840314388275, -0.3622453510761261, 0.9309979677200317, 0.05015874654054642, 0.9243596196174622, -1.140236735343933, 0.14639998972415924, 0.746822714805603, 0.08088891208171844, 0.15929549932479858, -0.27017921209335327, 0.7744157910346985, -0.6263594627380371, 0.7037835121154785, 0.0734008252620697, -0.3308335840702057, -0.3325625956058502, 0.38121169805526733, 0.48274415731430054, 0.32602939009666443, -0.458001047372818, 0.011872392147779465, -0.26899510622024536, 0.28214964270591736, -0.13675639033317566, 0.04111037403345108, 0.16717812418937683, -0.29029369354248047, 0.3908102214336395, 0.28512632846832275, 0.6353274583816528, 0.13123098015785217, -0.374303936958313, 0.3443719744682312, -0.13269339501857758, -0.45753055810928345, -0.45580554008483887, 0.0378001444041729, -0.3266889154911041, -0.30076366662979126, 0.3040589690208435, -0.2923109233379364, -0.27410438656806946, -0.03263756260275841, -1.16228187084198, 0.7483945488929749, 0.36196014285087585, 0.21782433986663818, -0.505507230758667, -0.20390178263187408, 0.09258732944726944, -0.17289391160011292, -0.154231458902359, -0.41187745332717896, 0.1938907355070114, 0.9419134855270386, -0.5621642470359802, -0.4660114347934723, -0.4302380383014679, -0.7625322937965393, 0.1740483194589615, 0.28304100036621094, 0.04869628697633743, -0.06996852159500122, 0.17190200090408325, -0.07272044569253922, -0.27615034580230713, -0.5718002319335938, 0.26428794860839844, -0.6172031164169312, -0.05073178559541702, 0.3929094076156616, 1.0241289138793945, 0.7760368585586548, 0.5724198818206787, -0.2850876450538635, 0.589307963848114, -0.731367826461792, -0.21902596950531006, -0.19492477178573608, -0.4957134425640106, -0.2569483518600464, -0.21104563772678375, -0.6573430299758911, 0.33028846979141235, -0.2812510132789612, -0.4148706793785095, -0.14559756219387054, 0.14835213124752045, -0.7857180237770081, -0.3353692293167114, 0.7353059649467468, -1.0849403142929077, 0.5163971185684204, 1.4158352613449097, -0.8204423189163208, 0.1429155021905899, 0.25381171703338623, -0.1513703465461731, -0.6915363669395447, 0.3946920931339264, -0.017669685184955597, -0.17793132364749908, 0.39733487367630005, -0.07428994029760361, -0.22929058969020844, 0.5496480464935303, 0.8980612754821777, -0.647034227848053, -0.3599396049976349, -1.0329923629760742, -0.47329336404800415, -0.5927766561508179, -0.2643923759460449, -0.5826143026351929, 0.7147621512413025, 0.30392545461654663, -0.07288812100887299, -0.030134327709674835, -0.5279176831245422, 0.20024369657039642, -0.20838777720928192, -0.13033702969551086, -0.10451778769493103, 0.09251834452152252, 0.17442137002944946, 0.25673067569732666, -0.4455869197845459, -1.105193853378296, -0.30827170610427856, 1.0364876985549927, -0.470903605222702, 0.004911867901682854, -0.14247576892375946, 0.2522982358932495, -0.2764683663845062, -0.8575119376182556, 0.13269998133182526, -0.9303725957870483, -0.5924445390701294, -0.14935420453548431, -0.12638215720653534, 0.7916527986526489, 0.15613335371017456, -0.47332993149757385, 0.6609828472137451, 0.2529410421848297, -0.23207567632198334, -0.46869510412216187, 1.0091793537139893, 0.03139156475663185, -0.13086923956871033, -0.24977779388427734, -0.822417676448822, -0.9140928983688354, -1.1181448698043823, 0.43097931146621704, -0.12213853746652603, -0.1663120537996292, -0.9318296909332275, -0.31810298562049866, -0.2758924663066864, 0.28121545910835266, -0.21241797506809235, 0.6318745017051697, 0.3209362328052521, -0.3389570116996765, 0.4589400589466095, -0.2370695322751999, 0.12206332385540009, -0.2879723310470581, -0.31971481442451477, 0.3992246687412262, 0.5326074957847595, 0.5456613898277283, -0.620596170425415, 0.17155516147613525, -0.13737265765666962, 0.5452815890312195, 0.39202797412872314, -0.3936345875263214, -0.826095461845398, 0.38527941703796387, 0.04154422506690025, -0.31065332889556885, -0.5787243247032166, -0.6428965926170349, 0.2641240954399109, -0.20684906840324402, 0.8156487941741943, -0.1350768655538559, -0.3561496138572693, -0.16965343058109283, -0.8869866728782654, 1.0925570726394653, -0.37657880783081055, -0.048691313713788986, 0.6885538697242737, -0.26677754521369934, -0.80652916431427, 0.6607373952865601, -0.6634501218795776, -0.37637993693351746, -0.32976576685905457, -0.8226929903030396, 0.45333757996559143, 0.19393609464168549, -0.05189254879951477, -0.4305756986141205, -0.17636790871620178, -0.11507385224103928, -0.33260995149612427, 0.5674179792404175, 0.6856726408004761, -0.6717633008956909, -0.9187445044517517, 0.0638146698474884, 0.8806992173194885, -0.4317089915275574, 0.14809639751911163, 0.5305734276771545, 0.2262888103723526, -0.14989596605300903, -0.8786336779594421, -0.2661869525909424, -0.6644659042358398, -0.3941386044025421, 0.1346888393163681, 0.5283672213554382, -0.25802287459373474, -0.12170398980379105, 0.23376350104808807, -0.4552833139896393, 0.33399325609207153, 0.4503016471862793, -0.08798979222774506, 0.41549769043922424, 0.20188139379024506, 0.4079401195049286, -0.3212008774280548, 0.01126203965395689, -0.11732741445302963, -0.07577333599328995, -0.3878169655799866, -0.3154072165489197, 0.42308199405670166, -0.8787620663642883, 0.9010363221168518, 0.5370157957077026, -0.6634321212768555, 0.5430569648742676, -0.004129999317228794, -0.4678798019886017, -0.03598785027861595, 0.3585328459739685, -0.45630472898483276, 0.8926435708999634, 0.0011796620674431324, 0.9809321761131287, -0.7156870365142822, 0.35079923272132874, -0.4252687096595764, -0.5171582102775574, 0.6661926507949829, -0.6243342161178589, -0.33619314432144165, 0.5825896859169006, -0.620126485824585, -0.03786824271082878, 0.39358195662498474, 0.7232484817504883, -0.44743791222572327, -0.07299603521823883, 0.40550655126571655, -0.6278111338615417, -0.2056320756673813, -0.24561810493469238, 0.030042679980397224, -0.24290554225444794, 0.7758870720863342, -0.5085785984992981, 1.0601807832717896, -0.21323515474796295, -0.27209219336509705, -0.6355226635932922, 0.5766075849533081, 0.734213650226593, 0.5510579943656921, 0.00995540525764227, -0.29447856545448303, 0.3028262257575989, 0.14222055673599243, -0.15739120543003082, -0.02422943338751793, -0.21809270977973938, -0.684181272983551, -0.5095906257629395, -0.7328230738639832, -0.8060426712036133, -0.3462165296077728, 0.6506696939468384, -0.5379853844642639, -0.8180388808250427, -0.1697271168231964, 0.7672843933105469, 0.4223230481147766, 0.1759805828332901, -0.389180451631546, 0.40267646312713623, -0.5716226100921631, -0.7402527928352356, -0.23441891372203827, -0.6167351007461548, 0.16881226003170013, 0.6297554969787598, -0.5042389035224915, -0.26986902952194214, 0.3607417345046997, -0.22744518518447876, -0.3060375154018402, 0.6524340510368347, -0.4210842251777649, -0.42902666330337524, -0.5198788642883301, 0.6504325866699219, 0.08612600713968277, -0.1379338502883911, 1.2154762744903564, -0.10331718623638153, 0.08817987889051437, 0.48449066281318665, -0.11796636879444122, 0.1094539538025856, -0.018770543858408928, 0.248942568898201, -0.20309661328792572, -0.6424739956855774, -0.1006142869591713, 0.09503600746393204, -0.708625316619873, -0.05261247977614403, -0.7010242938995361, -0.19535823166370392, -0.15390314161777496, 0.0828121230006218, 0.10758057981729507, 0.4184514284133911, -0.005071794148534536, -0.020094791427254677, -0.21770809590816498, 1.394036889076233, 0.3259894549846649, -0.043725624680519104, 1.1058565378189087, 0.07934274524450302, -0.016071565449237823, -0.6501381993293762, 0.29106956720352173, 0.9113902449607849, -0.5104187726974487, 0.10877656936645508, 0.3395094871520996, 0.09756123274564743, 0.5608466863632202, -0.4310753345489502, 0.6102760434150696, 1.1228572130203247, -0.06475630402565002, 1.5354728698730469, -0.1868503987789154, -0.785469114780426, -0.862602710723877, -0.662080705165863, -1.1506074666976929, -0.43591028451919556, 0.7929812669754028, -0.09616930037736893, -0.18960092961788177, -0.10685460269451141, -0.3057151436805725, 0.869680643081665, 0.1919410526752472, 0.785138726234436, -0.3461824655532837, 0.31964385509490967, 0.4075625538825989, 0.13430283963680267, 0.19234369695186615, -0.14520922303199768, -0.39380761981010437, 0.24287329614162445, -0.7238174080848694, -0.37331733107566833, -0.021079713478684425, 0.09594479203224182, 0.5045605301856995, -0.48998793959617615, -0.32913538813591003, 0.45615312457084656, 0.5898107290267944, -0.12137357890605927, -0.6248798966407776, 0.12339255213737488, -1.210292935371399, 0.2881525456905365, 0.1854635775089264, -0.17969486117362976, -0.23506979644298553, -0.17115028202533722, -0.15596801042556763, -1.2860100269317627, -0.03239244222640991, 0.20146232843399048, 0.4939422905445099, -0.8958719372749329, 0.21094399690628052, -0.28024885058403015, -0.03142537549138069, 0.6540915369987488, -1.00675368309021, 0.943250298500061, 0.9566228985786438, 0.4013674557209015, -0.25140658020973206, -0.4038534462451935, -0.2610545754432678, 1.0258837938308716, 0.3591744005680084, 0.41589492559432983, 0.487621545791626, 0.0597621388733387, 0.19622942805290222, 0.49793872237205505, 0.32923004031181335, 0.5937379598617554, 0.2712570130825043, -0.3742300570011139, 0.5605319142341614, -0.2733405828475952, 0.5644596219062805, 0.40310344099998474, -0.8066635727882385, 0.4209091067314148, -0.8500338792800903, -0.42122796177864075, 0.020797135308384895, 0.18107309937477112, 0.8670432567596436, -0.2870808243751526, -0.24811992049217224, 0.25323426723480225, 0.2224828004837036, -0.2786588966846466, -0.22558696568012238, 0.31365132331848145, -0.7464854717254639, -0.5425614714622498, 0.019788295030593872, -0.1391822248697281, -0.10510824620723724, -0.1442853957414627, 0.20966464281082153, -0.22580009698867798, 0.2015044242143631, 0.42038193345069885, 0.09350889921188354, 0.08849729597568512, 0.9714716672897339, -0.5181713104248047, 0.21309800446033478, 0.2195575088262558, -0.43447184562683105, -0.7847891449928284, -0.8038728833198547, 0.5689104199409485, -0.8513690829277039, 0.6165861487388611, 0.2036236673593521, 0.4945344626903534, 0.6297357082366943, 0.1097361221909523, 0.7495903968811035, 0.16911405324935913, 0.36103615164756775, 0.7983701825141907, -0.8142391443252563, -0.32615146040916443, -0.28433024883270264, -0.34744396805763245, -0.22342097759246826, -0.3682016134262085, -0.0943196639418602, 0.015167036093771458, -0.3533702492713928, -0.5725647807121277, 0.14029531180858612, 0.14365971088409424, 0.42057883739471436, -0.7720884680747986, -0.3542962670326233, 0.15305185317993164, 0.4884938597679138, -0.8571557402610779, -0.17742599546909332, -0.007533325348049402, -0.49273738265037537, -0.06399316340684891, -0.6116245985031128, -0.29361042380332947, -0.2837311327457428, -0.8232114315032959, 0.5594639778137207, -0.9741103053092957, 0.32094547152519226, -0.5362221002578735, -0.9857505559921265, -0.16462522745132446, 0.41684427857398987, 0.5496810078620911, -0.7826489806175232, -0.2808407247066498, -0.07490070164203644, 0.19809620082378387, 0.12479235231876373, -0.11692868918180466, -0.1015644520521164, -0.07840690016746521, 0.8177343010902405, 0.18054643273353577, 0.6441851258277893, 0.026631062850356102, 0.5879740715026855, 0.13518588244915009, 0.09338196367025375, 0.2000744789838791, -0.056347332894802094, -0.5349549055099487, -0.9407641291618347, 0.31743717193603516, -0.13750465214252472, -0.6666843891143799, 0.4469602406024933, 0.8501837849617004, 0.07852470874786377, -0.23327994346618652, -0.7108351588249207, -0.39520135521888733, -0.3464818000793457, 0.6373240351676941, -0.2919663190841675, 0.10068311542272568, 0.098697230219841, -0.40993764996528625, 0.70503830909729, -1.1537874937057495, 4.207848072052002, 0.6937081217765808, 0.870592474937439, 0.26233571767807007, 0.6751922369003296, 0.23044024407863617, 0.8530102968215942, -0.2220136523246765, -0.11619545519351959, -0.026943638920783997, -0.1747501939535141, -0.007325258105993271, 0.08321326971054077, 0.0909072682261467, 0.5035384297370911, -0.0009452034719288349, -0.9154204726219177, -0.776337742805481, 0.12746810913085938, -1.3227499723434448, -0.30658647418022156, -0.28604236245155334, -0.10241033881902695, -0.19377200305461884, 0.4511510729789734, 0.1358131617307663, -0.4044765532016754, -0.6839905977249146, -0.31378382444381714, -0.662030041217804, -0.20033548772335052, -0.5706055164337158, -0.2701548635959625, -0.6869643330574036, -0.6836618185043335, 0.6616269946098328, -0.33708879351615906, -0.8503012657165527, 0.1459583044052124, -0.7345552444458008, -0.11795403808355331, 0.07566148042678833, -0.39351412653923035, -0.4545621871948242, 0.3338117301464081, -0.14086809754371643, -0.3325852155685425, 0.5305279493331909, 0.2916996479034424, -0.5546203255653381, 1.257295846939087, -0.3987034559249878, 0.3007853925228119, -0.05784454941749573, -0.8768834471702576, -0.16363371908664703, 0.2711086869239807, -0.6920580863952637, 0.21372172236442566, 1.3594753742218018, 0.9966691136360168, 0.0720767080783844, -0.30599263310432434, 0.15209157764911652, 0.31259825825691223, 0.5380010008811951, 0.1412503868341446, 0.4692935347557068, 0.37340569496154785, -0.6979997754096985, -0.5914658308029175, -0.34520775079727173, -0.2614594101905823, 0.040018387138843536, 0.6301534175872803, 0.2617129981517792, 0.21847155690193176, 1.035746455192566, -0.3954930901527405, -0.49556225538253784, 0.0870821475982666, 0.15384596586227417, 0.4247918426990509, -0.8115052580833435, 0.44089266657829285, 1.25434148311615, -0.5169447064399719, 0.08723428845405579, -1.2730971574783325, 0.6411638855934143, -0.1522679179906845, -0.7334995865821838, -0.5901268720626831, -0.6655901670455933, -0.34035030007362366 ]
{"Title": "Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Associations Between Body Mass Index, Prostate Cancer, Advanced Prostate Cancer and Prostate Specific Antigen", "Authors": "Harrison Sean, Tilling Kate, Turner Emma L., Martin Richard M., Lennon Rosie, Lane J. Athene, Donovan Jenny L., Hamdy Freddie C., Neal David E., Bosch J.L.H. Ruud, Jones Hayley E.", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose The relationship between body-mass index (BMI) and prostate cancer remains unclear. However, there is an inverse association between BMI and prostate-specific antigen (PSA), used for prostate cancer screening. We conducted this review to estimate the associations between BMI and (1) prostate cancer, (2) advanced prostate cancer, and (3) PSA. Methods We searched PubMed and Embase for studies until 02 October 2017 and obtained individual participant data from four studies. In total, 78 studies were identified for the association between BMI and prostate cancer, 21 for BMI and advanced prostate cancer, and 35 for BMI and PSA. We performed random-effects meta-analysis of linear associations of log PSA and prostate cancer with BMI and, to examine potential non-linearity, of associations between categories of BMI and each outcome. Results In the meta-analyses with continuous BMI, a 5 kg/m 2 increase in BMI was associated with a percentage change in PSA of \u22125.88% (95% CI \u22126.87% to \u22124.87%). Using BMI categories, compared to normal weight men the PSA levels of overweight men were 3.43% lower (95% CI \u22125.57% to \u22121.23%), and obese men were 12.9% lower (95% CI \u221215.2% to \u221210.7%). Prostate cancer and advanced prostate cancer analyses showed little or no evidence associations. Conclusion There is little or no evidence of an association between BMI and risk of prostate cancer or advanced prostate cancer, and strong evidence of an inverse and non-linear association between BMI and PSA. The association between BMI and prostate cancer is likely biased if missed diagnoses are not considered.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005421"}
10.1101/19005249
[ 0.01807861030101776, 0.3888300657272339, -0.299760639667511, 0.6635144352912903, -0.6865823864936829, 0.03214329481124878, 0.16832399368286133, 0.16263620555400848, 0.06203887239098549, 0.8148255944252014, -0.34635400772094727, -0.4466955065727234, 0.004044990986585617, -1.2954717874526978, -0.11930304765701294, 0.4974350333213806, -1.2979521751403809, -0.19226381182670593, -0.4940829277038574, -0.20908287167549133, 0.5771233439445496, 0.17056557536125183, -0.5641308426856995, 0.4298187494277954, -0.4990635812282562, 0.9882751703262329, -0.237540140748024, -0.2872934341430664, 1.3290201425552368, 0.12263227254152298, 0.8623332977294922, -0.843468427658081, -0.06162480637431145, -0.8067985773086548, -0.35696306824684143, -0.4948207139968872, 1.421944260597229, -0.2160513997077942, 0.05549359694123268, 0.10914216190576553, 0.4786713719367981, -0.6480437517166138, 0.25546661019325256, -0.5356497168540955, -0.6180813312530518, -0.7539616823196411, -0.8010317087173462, -0.5816993713378906, 0.13316915929317474, -0.6642645001411438, -0.29943713545799255, 0.2406964898109436, 0.08259417116641998, -0.23860196769237518, -0.24381336569786072, 0.04100911691784859, 0.3944609761238098, -0.21555864810943604, -0.45756760239601135, -0.14043106138706207, 0.5599005222320557, 0.09860780090093613, 0.5020551085472107, -1.8622181415557861, 0.22196422517299652, 0.5397869944572449, 0.07886827737092972, -0.5254859328269958, -0.9193331003189087, -0.23752956092357635, -0.6362305283546448, 0.3528808355331421, -0.008601297624409199, -0.588096559047699, -0.2597980499267578, 0.654620885848999, 0.052553560584783554, 0.12712252140045166, -0.14934442937374115, -0.7352817058563232, 0.8144185543060303, 0.17345252633094788, -0.1747099757194519, 0.5216012597084045, -0.4398818910121918, 0.0696556568145752, -0.2234812080860138, -0.07546377927064896, 0.5326723456382751, -0.6534543633460999, 0.007824917323887348, 0.07946696132421494, -0.05931148678064346, 0.5868940949440002, -0.04356323182582855, 0.8132101893424988, -0.5432322025299072, 0.007455524988472462, 0.36683017015457153, 0.06323956698179245, 0.5612364411354065, 0.8338567018508911, -0.0931384339928627, 1.245375156402588, -0.8691639304161072, 0.36251282691955566, 0.4807077944278717, -0.4666200876235962, -0.8892590403556824, -0.3836064040660858, 0.20130959153175354, 0.30246105790138245, 0.026558861136436462, 0.777301549911499, 0.09703512489795685, 0.07491733133792877, 0.6305403113365173, 0.3378455340862274, -0.43618044257164, 0.8575589656829834, 0.23941120505332947, -0.19328442215919495, 0.28389689326286316, -0.04673301801085472, 0.3719387352466583, -0.4215885102748871, -0.2349037081003189, 0.6530951857566833, -0.023028677329421043, -0.036793988198041916, -0.045885130763053894, 0.011116529814898968, 0.3633427619934082, 0.6147292256355286, -0.5135601162910461, 0.10094607621431351, 0.020589737221598625, 0.5997354388237, -0.35914984345436096, -0.2927914261817932, -0.3224267065525055, 0.23085716366767883, -0.5241900086402893, 0.9648416638374329, 0.12177266925573349, 0.8832947611808777, -0.9110804200172424, -1.048259973526001, 0.17979003489017487, -0.1581023931503296, -0.26498401165008545, 0.5214064121246338, -0.1007779911160469, -0.689185619354248, -0.39064979553222656, -0.10590878129005432, -0.34970882534980774, 1.1987448930740356, -0.026371484622359276, 0.2009590119123459, -0.10522126406431198, 0.3865455090999603, -0.22859500348567963, 0.5606439113616943, -0.4442010819911957, 0.6472407579421997, -0.376919150352478, -0.18043990433216095, 0.35612404346466064, -0.6091824173927307, 0.2697891891002655, 0.7617520689964294, -0.11701706796884537, -0.879694402217865, -0.19561220705509186, 0.7205938100814819, 1.2737717628479004, 0.7761427164077759, 0.5952489972114563, 0.10884793847799301, -0.4829652011394501, -0.7091625928878784, 0.6998394727706909, 0.6758821606636047, -0.5153789520263672, 0.08934382349252701, -0.5647789239883423, -0.8437953591346741, -0.11935249716043472, 0.616869330406189, -0.3579355776309967, 0.9128129482269287, -0.638353705406189, 0.47154438495635986, -0.09654582291841507, 0.31825748085975647, 0.10042890161275864, 0.9430413246154785, -0.358107328414917, -0.8787251710891724, -0.5083143711090088, 0.834189772605896, -0.5008902549743652, 0.1662728488445282, -0.8577232360839844, 0.8615302443504333, 0.6392457485198975, 0.6847801208496094, -0.5117458701133728, 0.1589294970035553, 0.29920727014541626, -0.2720572352409363, 0.07967109233140945, 0.11720991879701614, 1.0485213994979858, -0.25139063596725464, 0.367872416973114, -0.5595742464065552, -0.35916590690612793, -0.170990452170372, 0.2510758340358734, -0.339554101228714, 0.8071481585502625, 0.23043708503246307, 0.738605797290802, 0.49056559801101685, 0.20347456634044647, -0.15659672021865845, -0.00775866536423564, -0.3751717507839203, 0.61000657081604, 0.4682939946651459, -0.20451979339122772, 0.4356555938720703, 0.4766030013561249, 0.4552251398563385, 0.6356544494628906, 0.46640241146087646, 0.8685775399208069, 0.14700551331043243, 0.8256511688232422, 0.6844834685325623, 1.262077808380127, 0.6125860810279846, 0.1564311385154724, 0.018974609673023224, -0.7432448863983154, 0.03546818718314171, -0.2517800033092499, 0.05294070020318031, -0.8917949795722961, -0.08725951611995697, -0.5929858684539795, -0.24783144891262054, -0.5962116122245789, -0.24789828062057495, -0.04022029787302017, 0.48258259892463684, 0.3675294816493988, -1.023616075515747, -0.6153774857521057, 0.01755368337035179, 0.5619471073150635, 0.11940772086381912, 0.3505684733390808, 0.7362732887268066, 0.13370934128761292, 0.6489279270172119, 0.2769998610019684, -0.050524309277534485, -0.3439508378505707, -0.5063977837562561, -1.7478398084640503, -0.8634560704231262, -1.0056580305099487, -0.11708448827266693, 0.18040789663791656, -0.6605431437492371, 0.17378701269626617, 0.20070935785770416, 0.27922865748405457, -0.6488454341888428, 0.3974422812461853, 0.8159854412078857, 0.3305237591266632, 0.12431201338768005, -0.9345791935920715, 0.26380079984664917, -0.33381909132003784, 0.20231762528419495, 0.09637457877397537, -0.8056085705757141, -0.1810504049062729, -0.5748990774154663, 0.2478724718093872, -0.7522721886634827, 0.30824270844459534, 0.328689306974411, -1.0320392847061157, -0.2919188439846039, 0.2945963740348816, -0.09211888164281845, 0.07565518468618393, -0.12904848158359528, -1.0998311042785645, 1.2003161907196045, 0.3723964989185333, -0.24794596433639526, 0.7435685992240906, 0.30586227774620056, -0.6497889161109924, 0.9706138968467712, -0.03659958764910698, -0.2724904716014862, -0.9939807653427124, 0.6991125345230103, 0.7084779143333435, -0.6929979920387268, 0.45810338854789734, -0.5513187646865845, -0.6188721656799316, -0.23681803047657013, 0.3802237808704376, -0.38214606046676636, -0.0351330041885376, 0.08050919324159622, -0.05316398665308952, -0.6780527830123901, -0.13876031339168549, -0.7033076882362366, -0.54486483335495, 0.06154387444257736, -0.13931238651275635, 0.32368260622024536, -0.1617090106010437, -0.5575944781303406, -0.2536156475543976, -0.3471458852291107, 0.1643470674753189, 0.6653577089309692, 0.0015289717121049762, 0.2546917796134949, -0.5940828323364258, 0.17191153764724731, -0.0038984683342278004, 0.3131727874279022, 0.25128576159477234, -0.2539178431034088, 0.010966725647449493, -0.3126581013202667, -0.3116004168987274, 0.0556088387966156, 0.6685261726379395, -0.3606155216693878, 0.6236732006072998, 0.10448931157588959, -0.4415406286716461, -0.48875734210014343, 0.39754122495651245, 0.5073462724685669, -0.18351849913597107, 0.14830312132835388, 0.03176738694310188, 0.5338993668556213, -0.7374414205551147, -0.34281954169273376, 0.6510012149810791, 0.43501195311546326, 0.563083291053772, -0.861220121383667, 0.07262539863586426, -0.14995932579040527, -0.26721957325935364, -0.15254561603069305, -0.050741519778966904, -0.3433119058609009, 1.1211992502212524, 0.17509134113788605, 1.3375957012176514, -1.6721055507659912, 0.42146533727645874, 0.47990188002586365, 1.1308016777038574, 0.4039703607559204, 0.5328962802886963, -0.19298146665096283, -1.064344882965088, 0.41129422187805176, 0.30874860286712646, -0.0044480860233306885, -0.33857935667037964, 0.27968358993530273, -0.46878287196159363, -0.19178126752376556, -0.6668908596038818, -0.15373367071151733, 0.5412039756774902, 0.376651406288147, -0.46631571650505066, -0.4022359549999237, 0.8908227682113647, -0.3462885320186615, 0.027862004935741425, 0.38575124740600586, 0.5509151220321655, -0.6237217783927917, -0.43299785256385803, -0.10676764696836472, -0.30038583278656006, -0.03134432062506676, -0.31432044506073, -0.0860709622502327, -0.9497685432434082, 0.0620451346039772, 1.172944188117981, 0.3774973452091217, -0.3810727000236511, 0.017300955951213837, -0.2818910777568817, 0.12832361459732056, -0.069605752825737, 0.36729687452316284, -0.5068209767341614, -0.1364520639181137, 0.724151611328125, -0.29600438475608826, -0.3127491772174835, -0.9322547912597656, 0.6057213544845581, 0.5955032706260681, -0.3366226851940155, -0.6227380037307739, 0.0044893138110637665, -0.2101953625679016, -0.26210081577301025, -0.126738041639328, 0.01928124949336052, -0.632500946521759, 0.2546645700931549, 0.8040336966514587, -0.1940920203924179, -0.29803353548049927, -0.6988043189048767, -0.27299076318740845, 0.6282771229743958, 0.01683039963245392, 0.5157414674758911, 0.06036827713251114, 0.9641178250312805, 0.26564332842826843, 1.1047931909561157, -0.6747593283653259, 0.21434077620506287, -0.6807379722595215, -0.635664701461792, -0.5608809590339661, -0.33296898007392883, 0.16062746942043304, 0.21533022820949554, -0.3446604609489441, -0.37924903631210327, -0.2914283573627472, 0.49065160751342773, -0.27630624175071716, 0.30635198950767517, 0.6291100382804871, -0.35929784178733826, 0.07861031591892242, 0.8764793872833252, -0.039216529577970505, 0.07563468813896179, -0.3400065302848816, -0.10662154853343964, -0.5376328229904175, -0.057467103004455566, -0.06733977794647217, -0.2641249895095825, -0.5578370094299316, -0.13142512738704681, -0.2957664132118225, -0.5776406526565552, -0.1810895949602127, -0.07317038625478745, 0.4416927397251129, -0.3050217926502228, -0.26296472549438477, -0.48896586894989014, -0.10910366475582123, -0.7890372276306152, 0.3042847514152527, 0.4660418927669525, -0.47433367371559143, -0.0032433997839689255, 0.17932385206222534, -0.36745449900627136, -0.2935594916343689, -1.5678547620773315, 0.10834119468927383, -0.6041038632392883, 0.11620424687862396, 0.6096287965774536, -0.5483463406562805, -0.43323132395744324, 0.8934942483901978, 0.49843457341194153, -1.152347207069397, -0.19400818645954132, -0.6746817231178284, -0.04278610646724701, -0.25572630763053894, -0.129159078001976, 0.1566440314054489, -0.06840179860591888, 0.9530912637710571, 0.11457370966672897, -0.500333309173584, 0.7672313451766968, -0.4169362187385559, -0.6507291197776794, 0.47811800241470337, -0.38775742053985596, -0.853967010974884, -0.13439081609249115, 0.04837419465184212, 0.13579685986042023, 0.15512438118457794, 0.0023191962391138077, -0.729609489440918, -0.28020262718200684, -0.6854124665260315, 0.11587376147508621, -1.0021227598190308, 0.056647904217243195, -0.32272911071777344, 0.052689965814352036, 0.43342941999435425, -0.27570897340774536, 0.5887838006019592, -0.054682657122612, -0.008709047921001911, -0.09214834123849869, 0.7524001002311707, -0.17797546088695526, -0.5542566776275635, -0.08700167387723923, -0.04979998990893364, 0.3981328308582306, 0.7780230641365051, 0.39533206820487976, 0.09474068880081177, 1.0510587692260742, 0.11731525510549545, 0.5324872136116028, 0.8686293959617615, -0.6176009774208069, -0.33225560188293457, 0.5592523813247681, 0.7659191489219666, 0.40932199358940125, -0.413272500038147, -0.27997297048568726, 0.2884625196456909, -0.5845493078231812, 0.08545089513063431, -0.37466421723365784, 0.11405405402183533, -0.18998128175735474, -0.6454387903213501, 0.901006817817688, -0.4923810660839081, 0.1623922884464264, 0.10082900524139404, 0.2820693850517273, -0.33664149045944214, 0.2229090929031372, -0.6427862644195557, -0.2780596911907196, -0.5426051616668701, -1.2153245210647583, 0.21890954673290253, 0.1731104552745819, 0.4065420925617218, 0.538472592830658, 0.06559634953737259, -0.04997165873646736, -0.24379165470600128, 0.5776628851890564, 0.9434228539466858, -0.14515863358974457, -0.5363983511924744, 0.3136143386363983, -0.000951915979385376, -0.10761163383722305, -0.17164333164691925, -0.6077442765235901, -0.5310843586921692, -0.13707953691482544, -0.18294329941272736, -0.9615923166275024, -0.9065479040145874, -0.02562292478978634, 0.7642971277236938, 0.41025620698928833, 0.19925956428050995, 0.5294064283370972, -0.18394668400287628, 0.34534433484077454, -0.8699036836624146, 1.051842451095581, -1.0286669731140137, -0.0727299228310585, 0.32615041732788086, -0.7135158777236938, -0.19552095234394073, -0.13483484089374542, -0.06434087455272675, -0.4283280372619629, 0.01755950041115284, -0.017439527437090874, 0.744829535484314, -0.9700072407722473, 0.46583905816078186, 0.2849353551864624, -0.37366345524787903, -0.592348039150238, 0.44912126660346985, 0.28072279691696167, 0.39446213841438293, -0.865052342414856, -0.37833964824676514, 0.8377178311347961, -0.2859571576118469, 0.3457610607147217, 0.33444079756736755, -0.31925061345100403, -0.03178425505757332, -0.3828435242176056, -0.6959564685821533, -0.8500699400901794, -0.23422567546367645, -0.03663649410009384, -0.5340614318847656, 0.8018182516098022, 0.09914058446884155, 0.7877168655395508, 0.01763877645134926, 0.3383006155490875, 0.2591782808303833, -0.7699847221374512, -0.5561346411705017, 0.4071248471736908, 0.6772080063819885, -1.130497932434082, 0.0010427326196804643, 0.6376267671585083, 0.6110933423042297, -0.32028862833976746, -0.31115543842315674, -0.7532463073730469, 0.4952523112297058, 0.6964487433433533, 0.8268818259239197, -0.5340205430984497, -0.09958619624376297, 0.4405301511287689, 0.33576080203056335, -0.5407440662384033, -0.21623317897319794, -1.1321805715560913, -1.5703797340393066, -0.5108853578567505, 0.8877614140510559, -0.9664450883865356, 0.1947786957025528, 1.050660252571106, -0.1688845008611679, -0.5263457298278809, -0.8865315914154053, 0.5207213163375854, -0.5782753825187683, -0.4742448925971985, -0.20186279714107513, 0.1462441384792328, -0.9081010222434998, -0.21098682284355164, -0.46713966131210327, -0.6833428144454956, -0.15621355175971985, 0.5777401924133301, -0.45978274941444397, -0.0171413104981184, 0.4226217567920685, 0.24662049114704132, 0.015192356891930103, 0.5054666996002197, -0.18978644907474518, -0.30401718616485596, 0.04384412243962288, 0.6677917838096619, 0.3568853437900543, -0.3299102783203125, 0.9605740308761597, -0.13096946477890015, 0.45543110370635986, 0.5400817394256592, -0.1653652936220169, -0.7255398035049438, 0.13638773560523987, 0.34417539834976196, -0.5907188057899475, -0.8712496161460876, 0.060838256031274796, 0.5657967329025269, -0.4437507390975952, -0.16534246504306793, -0.06497278064489365, 0.11762667447328568, -0.07251444458961487, -0.041856877505779266, -0.3171107769012451, 1.116125226020813, 0.5241063833236694, 0.3717917203903198, -0.3912091851234436, -0.03206939995288849, -0.24510826170444489, 0.8380141258239746, -0.023675065487623215, 0.21608035266399384, 0.09216798841953278, -1.1020851135253906, 0.7880489826202393, -0.09424028545618057, -0.8670274019241333, 0.27539941668510437, -0.17107310891151428, 0.2701950669288635, 0.3491174280643463, -0.2803301215171814, 0.1208251416683197, 0.7818152904510498, 0.04637971147894859, 0.5494000315666199, 0.45580026507377625, 0.3757365643978119, -0.5589210987091064, -0.3453081250190735, -0.9953709840774536, -0.6747276186943054, 0.33353516459465027, -0.5340760350227356, 0.20293430984020233, 0.011641310527920723, -0.6006972193717957, 0.7373235821723938, -0.11811058968305588, 0.771252453327179, 0.03295092284679413, 0.6448748707771301, 0.5885142683982849, 0.21425947546958923, -0.3348053991794586, -0.360742449760437, 0.7411037087440491, -0.24579748511314392, -0.8565093874931335, -0.6797084212303162, 0.37617382407188416, 0.6244248151779175, 0.27164676785469055, -0.2752574384212494, 0.05881255120038986, 0.3524089753627777, 0.32179903984069824, -0.7761635780334473, -0.37257736921310425, 0.5835474729537964, -0.37421083450317383, -0.02469659596681595, 0.013187617063522339, -0.435308039188385, -0.2940979599952698, 0.6899013519287109, 0.31805020570755005, -0.5893564224243164, -0.798540472984314, -0.309428870677948, 0.1900646984577179, -0.7185183167457581, 0.36864209175109863, -0.6988332271575928, 0.5127544403076172, -0.07957495748996735, 0.23082740604877472, 0.07818958163261414, 0.6646462082862854, 0.6829100251197815, 0.3324708342552185, 0.11300864070653915, 0.8217384219169617, 1.092766523361206, 0.6929956078529358, 0.1576688438653946, 0.48350173234939575, -0.17516717314720154, -0.1870049685239792, -0.09494894742965698, -0.42347580194473267, 0.5013946890830994, 0.1785842776298523, 0.23664623498916626, -0.6052199006080627, 0.5005818605422974, 0.5106946229934692, -0.0013893777504563332, -0.31236815452575684, 0.5913210511207581, -0.15312373638153076, -0.2279237061738968, -0.20044220983982086, 1.0599476099014282, 0.020470814779400826, 0.12106464803218842, 0.21372006833553314, -0.3409975469112396, 0.11072848737239838, 0.6279590725898743, -0.18842874467372894, 0.17433926463127136, -0.30150488018989563, -0.7814072966575623, -0.14185667037963867, 0.5028108358383179, 0.3158975839614868, -0.18559972941875458, 0.4218519926071167, -0.08363772183656693, -0.2128961682319641, 0.9889445900917053, -0.11571340262889862, -0.4804524779319763, 0.5183207392692566, -0.03597897291183472, -0.22098924219608307, -0.27529680728912354, -0.14793899655342102, -0.7749522924423218, -0.7202091217041016, 0.2196621596813202, -0.7028058171272278, 0.06547624617815018, 0.3793897032737732, 0.1064487099647522, 0.743012547492981, 0.30916520953178406, 1.0562673807144165, -0.34078797698020935, 1.174759864807129, 0.5932758450508118, 0.11210647970438004, -0.3210330307483673, 0.11899888515472412, -0.5524833798408508, 0.15387286245822906, 0.12806785106658936, 0.48608508706092834, 0.04556981846690178, -0.5314134359359741, 0.007583837024867535, 0.46689552068710327, 0.05877526104450226, -0.0373668409883976, -0.4933241903781891, -0.03314908221364021, 0.13539056479930878, 0.056240055710077286, -0.09164518862962723, 0.3156234622001648, 0.14130710065364838, 0.2516152560710907, 0.013755581341683865, 0.03436111658811569, 0.05725942552089691, 0.5332993865013123, -0.35505783557891846, 0.5046125054359436, 0.29356035590171814, -0.36871811747550964, -0.19528861343860626, -1.074812889099121, -0.14149118959903717, 0.06121230497956276, -0.5495854020118713, -1.1051164865493774, -0.10329600423574448, -0.11196575313806534, 0.7729060053825378, 0.1803724616765976, -0.12019341439008713, -0.2726511061191559, -0.1443709284067154, 0.96128249168396, -0.40597546100616455, -0.13688308000564575, 0.39844784140586853, -0.03307417780160904, 0.20034483075141907, 0.10428205132484436, 0.7035630941390991, -0.049616437405347824, -0.3066469132900238, -0.011103243567049503, 0.18942031264305115, 0.14529281854629517, -0.09205759316682816, 0.16129998862743378, 0.148674875497818, 0.3048185408115387, 0.3684695065021515, -0.703548014163971, -0.7518959045410156, -0.4913354814052582, 1.2541927099227905, -0.1618977189064026, 0.18543240427970886, 0.5090711116790771, -0.5002247095108032, 0.2783907353878021, -0.3658897578716278, 4.0824432373046875, 1.3968302011489868, 0.5158016681671143, -0.3564174473285675, 0.0752585232257843, 0.5051693916320801, 0.7507880330085754, -0.7592092752456665, -0.03956439718604088, 0.3402279317378998, -0.6255764961242676, 0.8515352010726929, 0.260353147983551, -0.7785430550575256, 0.8736656904220581, -0.17580996453762054, -0.4049264192581177, -0.24146825075149536, -0.16339027881622314, -0.8174735307693481, -0.427541047334671, 0.8734482526779175, -0.0209733285009861, -0.41208693385124207, 0.09087048470973969, 0.2272292822599411, 0.05094879865646362, -0.1254584789276123, -0.6579675674438477, 0.04122767224907875, -0.3185858428478241, -0.8359668254852295, -0.2899235785007477, -0.5604457855224609, 0.07834529876708984, 1.0357844829559326, 0.07657086849212646, -0.26738935708999634, -1.0534451007843018, -0.3900657296180725, -0.000833565485663712, 0.11991281062364578, -0.7591572999954224, -0.5521144866943359, -0.40055784583091736, 0.9397444128990173, 0.43913447856903076, 0.041859738528728485, 0.7213313579559326, -1.2806459665298462, 1.3861593008041382, -0.7429776191711426, -0.07644852995872498, 0.13236075639724731, -1.0014907121658325, -0.20726804435253143, -0.437039852142334, -0.9327943921089172, 0.021518997848033905, 0.2711068391799927, 0.6072348356246948, 0.17800620198249817, 0.04658469557762146, 0.37296050786972046, 0.17971903085708618, 0.07744115591049194, 0.7126617431640625, -0.2142811268568039, -0.14815719425678253, -0.039231665432453156, -0.21514610946178436, -0.04569754749536514, -1.137195348739624, 0.10192829370498657, 0.8109564185142517, 0.5824316143989563, -0.14150474965572357, -0.04308752343058586, 0.2153596431016922, -0.4523172080516815, 0.1840783655643463, 0.0729740634560585, 0.5739127397537231, -0.4488953948020935, -0.1649945229291916, 1.18534517288208, -0.03641140088438988, 0.30586645007133484, -1.2114558219909668, 0.357573002576828, 0.1426832377910614, 0.28866663575172424, -0.5860152244567871, -0.6997183561325073, -0.2839224338531494 ]
{"Title": "Impairment of dual-task gait dynamics in older adults with mild cognitive impairment: Relationships to neuropsychological status, fitness and brain morphology", "Authors": "Hawkins Tess C, Samuel Rebecca, Fiatarone Singh Maria A, Gates Nicola, Wilson Guy C, Jain Nidhi, Meiklejohn Jacinda, Brodaty Henry, Wen Wei, Singh Nalin, Baune Bernhard T, Suo Chao, Baker Michael K, Foroughi Nasim, Wang Yi, Sachdev Perminder S, Valenzuela Michael J, Hausdorff Jeffrey M, Mavros Yorgi", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Background Individuals with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) have more gait variability under dual-task conditions than cognitively healthy adults. However, characteristics associated with this susceptibility of gait to dual-task stress are unknown. Methods Testing was performed at baseline in the Study of Mental And Resistance Training (SMART). Ninety-three adults with MCI (age 70\u00b16.8 years; 66.6% female) performed a single- and dual-task walk (cognitive distractor=letter fluency), in random order. Linear and non-linear gait variability were measured using force-sensitive insoles. Cognitive performance during dual-tasking was assessed by the number of correct words vocalized. Cognitive function, brain Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), muscle strength, aerobic capacity, body composition, physical and psychosocial function were also assessed as potential correlates of gait dynamics. Results Gait dynamics worsened during dual-tasking, with decrements in both stride time variability (p<0.001) and detrended fluctuation analysis (DFA) (p=0.001). Lower aerobic capacity and thinner posterior cingulate cortex were associated with greater decrements in DFA (p<0.05). Smaller hippocampal volume, worse psychological well-being and poorer static balance were associated with greater decrements in stride time variability (p<0.05). By contrast, cognitive performance did not change under dual-task conditions compared to seated testing (p=0.13). Conclusions Under dual-task conditions, participants with MCI preserved their cognitive performance at the expense of gait stability. Decrements in dual-tasking gait were associated with lower aerobic fitness, balance, psychological well-being, and brain volume in cognitively-relevant areas of the posterior cingulate and hippocampus, all potentially modifiable characteristics. Trials of targeted interventions are needed to determine the potential plasticity of gait variability in high-risk cohorts.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005249"}
10.1101/19005603
[ 0.3041605055332184, -0.06379040330648422, -0.6887571811676025, 0.8187938332557678, -0.27863532304763794, -0.4261936843395233, 0.1362038552761078, 0.05422525107860565, 0.2879498302936554, 0.36453568935394287, 0.05298755317926407, 0.006008768454194069, 0.435170978307724, 0.07283749431371689, -0.124100461602211, -0.1847657412290573, -0.8007418513298035, -0.52741938829422, 0.2306968867778778, -0.23872114717960358, -0.3824768364429474, 0.8340362310409546, -1.3540606498718262, 0.08377664536237717, -0.6793968677520752, 0.47158941626548767, 0.07235909253358841, -0.18257959187030792, 1.489247441291809, 0.22810550034046173, -0.028700770810246468, 0.05715470388531685, 0.6256433725357056, -0.6427879333496094, -0.24098245799541473, -0.4308965504169464, 1.0585386753082275, -0.6015903949737549, -0.5598331689834595, 0.14597086608409882, -0.3497494161128998, -0.25665178894996643, 0.0180987399071455, -1.1888870000839233, -1.2809351682662964, -0.7450529336929321, 0.6772000193595886, -0.09902927279472351, 0.12297624349594116, -0.44407206773757935, 0.009806455112993717, -0.041788894683122635, -0.3479801416397095, -0.4935797452926636, -0.25087055563926697, -0.11996705830097198, 0.5637409687042236, -0.03625543788075447, -0.9615330100059509, -0.2153710275888443, -0.26260626316070557, -0.13999252021312714, 0.7322753071784973, -0.9990984797477722, 0.538621723651886, 0.22947536408901215, -0.18584056198596954, -0.4239445626735687, 0.12419549375772476, -0.4608083963394165, -0.6744532585144043, 0.08468127995729446, -0.5610063076019287, -1.3380186557769775, -0.36613038182258606, -0.7559249401092529, 0.4971785247325897, -0.7143781781196594, 0.026055768132209778, 0.35952699184417725, 0.3696582615375519, 0.392371267080307, 0.6573310494422913, -0.22976164519786835, -0.12240514159202576, -0.0865689292550087, 1.4839357137680054, 0.16618430614471436, 0.7004582285881042, -0.20268464088439941, 0.09629187732934952, 0.10649488121271133, 0.6700246334075928, 0.24369163811206818, -0.2775234878063202, 1.1275603771209717, -0.5583250522613525, -0.02067556604743004, 0.8088624477386475, 0.1211387887597084, 0.7119632363319397, 1.5155715942382812, -0.2491045892238617, 0.9029097557067871, -0.19936631619930267, 0.32975274324417114, 0.15225063264369965, -1.1831945180892944, -0.36108890175819397, -0.3677695691585541, -0.3727598190307617, 0.09622930735349655, -0.933748722076416, -0.3066785931587219, -0.3136778771877289, 0.017784910276532173, -0.4682005047798157, 1.1683546304702759, -0.45315274596214294, 0.2816413342952728, -0.19516269862651825, 0.009323008358478546, 0.1517609804868698, -0.6265028119087219, 0.1841462105512619, -0.5171420574188232, 0.05979791283607483, 0.42447933554649353, -1.1252515316009521, 0.05915672704577446, 0.2758679687976837, -0.5202599763870239, 0.11360818892717361, 0.8281940817832947, -0.42698436975479126, -0.020770346745848656, 0.8194795846939087, 0.04255111888051033, 0.6288434863090515, -0.07430599629878998, -0.5204963088035583, -0.15430450439453125, -0.14921295642852783, 1.2305468320846558, 0.33724257349967957, 0.5422952771186829, -0.43166089057922363, -1.2707624435424805, -0.7733979821205139, 0.28603893518447876, -0.23387300968170166, 0.15043573081493378, 0.3180653750896454, 0.5236963033676147, -0.23793631792068481, 0.33673128485679626, 0.019985752180218697, 0.3657244145870209, -0.28291261196136475, 0.19365501403808594, -0.34508100152015686, 0.46763232350349426, -0.5313053727149963, 0.33443668484687805, -0.04840921610593796, 0.5865062475204468, -0.3104357421398163, 0.31685471534729004, 0.030845656991004944, -0.7693134546279907, 0.24624167382717133, 0.37592700123786926, 0.08540298789739609, 0.17989981174468994, 0.1482979953289032, 0.5423982739448547, 1.2301820516586304, 0.060790009796619415, 0.7703821659088135, 0.10721741616725922, -0.3277197480201721, 0.25498223304748535, -0.3073033392429352, 0.3392464518547058, -0.2729245722293854, 0.9952456951141357, -0.2804858386516571, -0.38287773728370667, -0.5579071640968323, -0.19018463790416718, 0.5516281127929688, 0.6393871307373047, -0.5105639100074768, 0.6021289229393005, 0.17572958767414093, 0.24424438178539276, -0.42918068170547485, 0.4429275691509247, 0.35002297163009644, 0.05057058483362198, -0.8253246545791626, 0.22119304537773132, -0.21446794271469116, -0.36868220567703247, -1.205425500869751, 1.0198169946670532, -0.6268734931945801, 0.14347030222415924, -0.2797003388404846, 0.14373861253261566, 0.6964432001113892, 0.6307396292686462, -0.5393275618553162, 0.20808081328868866, 0.9334803223609924, -0.1534896045923233, -0.3390938341617584, -0.2052002251148224, 0.18056952953338623, -0.3032754957675934, -1.483361840248108, -0.02689598686993122, 0.39562398195266724, -0.30663278698921204, 0.3179912567138672, 0.7101535797119141, 0.7396612763404846, 0.9343862533569336, -0.2958899736404419, -0.08431975543498993, 0.5363893508911133, 1.0251562595367432, -0.5727932453155518, 1.3341999053955078, 0.1378258317708969, 0.15049707889556885, 0.5494210124015808, 0.29993849992752075, 0.2486792802810669, 0.04101358726620674, 0.6123246550559998, 0.16184774041175842, 1.2043153047561646, 0.3004802465438843, -0.5627732276916504, 0.1763218492269516, 0.19445368647575378, 0.34089601039886475, 0.035512153059244156, 0.20883376896381378, 0.0710088238120079, 1.2112984657287598, -0.07753920555114746, 0.046544190496206284, -1.3022955656051636, -0.405911386013031, 0.714473307132721, 0.3900947868824005, -0.2987563908100128, -0.4122083783149719, -0.4147065281867981, 0.3926912546157837, -0.20791561901569366, 0.3560240864753723, 0.1245265081524849, -0.14440633356571198, 0.35040050745010376, 0.2500302195549011, -0.4940560460090637, -0.4410848021507263, -1.2041960954666138, -1.283364176750183, -1.1854312419891357, -0.38120898604393005, -0.36118388175964355, -0.020791834220290184, 0.05119462311267853, -0.5241819024085999, -0.25715556740760803, -0.5914439558982849, 0.6138814687728882, -0.09682741016149521, 0.0113223260268569, 0.3527517020702362, -0.41439250111579895, 0.021334540098905563, -1.2058309316635132, 0.04311306029558182, -0.18287165462970734, 1.0332021713256836, -0.21549025177955627, 0.09396447241306305, -0.35550814867019653, -1.0736851692199707, -0.11656040698289871, -0.9421994090080261, 0.3885190486907959, 0.19314420223236084, -0.8856903314590454, -0.45231837034225464, 0.750000536441803, -0.2198646515607834, 0.3186655640602112, -0.24658018350601196, -1.1049970388412476, 0.28672856092453003, 0.21638435125350952, 0.17905427515506744, 0.4972764849662781, 0.4875289797782898, -0.8328485488891602, 1.0070631504058838, 0.17871983349323273, -0.5234980583190918, -0.7516874670982361, -0.07133148610591888, 0.656223475933075, -0.39496463537216187, -0.0006308441516011953, -0.5880128145217896, -0.40321478247642517, -0.1800037920475006, -0.34302863478660583, -0.2644833028316498, 0.08591760694980621, 0.39923280477523804, 0.07490352541208267, -1.9271061420440674, 0.27263879776000977, -0.38569557666778564, -0.7723591327667236, 0.03447718545794487, -0.08553217351436615, 0.641877293586731, 0.3375880718231201, -0.26071619987487793, -0.4340115487575531, -0.05862695351243019, 0.6919488906860352, 0.2719466984272003, 0.4753914475440979, -0.7222199440002441, -0.5455727577209473, 0.5242817401885986, -0.47631633281707764, 0.41364437341690063, -0.487947553396225, -0.5865362286567688, -0.7852270007133484, 0.0740007534623146, -0.48185163736343384, 0.8820104002952576, 0.7189880609512329, -0.20733432471752167, 0.18292345106601715, 0.5812950134277344, -0.5978719592094421, -0.5625567436218262, 0.6678580045700073, 0.42170944809913635, 0.34426653385162354, 0.5873474478721619, -0.2987065017223358, 0.36847934126853943, -0.263643741607666, -1.0272046327590942, 0.2324773222208023, 0.48839619755744934, 0.23872938752174377, -0.7586079239845276, 0.5938624739646912, -0.5783211588859558, 0.3379685878753662, 0.002594494493678212, -0.5093455910682678, -1.3679139614105225, 0.7941660284996033, 0.08382146060466766, 1.406174898147583, -0.810469388961792, -0.4891260266304016, 0.4400850534439087, 0.9048081636428833, 0.3078554570674896, 0.051337823271751404, 0.7905855774879456, -0.17254683375358582, 0.5343506932258606, 0.28834623098373413, 0.3321132957935333, 0.03795172646641731, 0.530581533908844, -0.3118683099746704, 0.3534412682056427, -0.36592811346054077, -0.09863784909248352, -0.13794663548469543, 0.20644976198673248, 0.9763718843460083, -0.20809975266456604, 1.0220814943313599, -0.23418273031711578, 0.11797985434532166, 1.0103927850723267, 0.6179704070091248, 0.4486699402332306, -1.1538352966308594, 0.3177696168422699, 0.12900958955287933, 0.19220110774040222, -0.42925095558166504, 0.18003951013088226, 0.4975903332233429, -0.10230708867311478, 0.2589038610458374, -0.26995304226875305, -0.6916147470474243, -0.3905961215496063, -0.7533213496208191, 0.05497444048523903, 0.21635061502456665, -0.5630122423171997, -1.2703447341918945, 0.5506455302238464, 0.14774107933044434, 0.3692937195301056, 0.14598983526229858, 0.004556701518595219, 0.4942513108253479, 0.7930600643157959, -1.0278891324996948, -1.0915240049362183, -0.03395986184477806, -0.4262947142124176, -0.28493186831474304, 0.6643648147583008, -0.05180830508470535, -0.359611451625824, 0.6468287706375122, -0.6830977201461792, -0.36654722690582275, -1.0444917678833008, -0.011456198990345001, -0.3096770644187927, 0.5932188034057617, 0.0804564505815506, 1.4247597455978394, 0.5742791295051575, 0.3706258237361908, -0.08979424089193344, 0.4536515176296234, -0.32437649369239807, 1.010794758796692, -0.597537100315094, -0.0510682612657547, -0.2256472110748291, -0.09571150690317154, -0.16321846842765808, -0.7816933393478394, -0.24652263522148132, -0.2888551354408264, -0.03301101550459862, 0.3289929926395416, -0.13341982662677765, -0.6489886045455933, 0.9258628487586975, -0.10888855159282684, 0.03234400600194931, 0.6254819631576538, -0.2920339107513428, -0.6873228549957275, 0.18956983089447021, 0.26281604170799255, 0.21009798347949982, 0.4217527508735657, -0.4068855941295624, 0.3757098913192749, -0.019259080290794373, -0.44480210542678833, 0.31132766604423523, -0.46765047311782837, 0.16754263639450073, -0.5949668288230896, -0.30293500423431396, -0.6165933609008789, -0.8240005373954773, -0.5926393270492554, -0.32141271233558655, -0.5903652310371399, 0.5853480100631714, -0.3306938111782074, -0.1325523406267166, -0.1798281967639923, 0.1818477362394333, -0.8950921297073364, 0.17901729047298431, -0.28453749418258667, -0.40031126141548157, -0.20881345868110657, 0.47381648421287537, -0.0622246079146862, -0.752496063709259, -0.9043246507644653, 0.11205346137285233, 0.7711134552955627, -0.6385282874107361, -0.5004716515541077, -0.41451698541641235, -0.666455864906311, 0.02290843054652214, -0.6936639547348022, 0.6056027412414551, -0.5301185250282288, 0.040421534329652786, -0.4063167870044708, 0.01725083775818348, 0.2047845423221588, 0.20814834535121918, -0.2843559980392456, 0.577995240688324, -0.04350263997912407, -0.9058420658111572, -0.5162600874900818, 0.4817329943180084, -0.3403922915458679, 0.024262651801109314, 0.976716935634613, -0.25842010974884033, 0.11738275736570358, -0.8084111213684082, 0.785347580909729, -0.053034521639347076, -0.3268997371196747, 0.03314461559057236, -0.6769419312477112, -0.3778696358203888, -0.21406292915344238, 0.6674450039863586, -0.5357213020324707, -0.6942693591117859, -0.6307049989700317, 0.4397014379501343, -0.4944741725921631, 0.05449691042304039, 0.3336702287197113, -0.32399982213974, 0.579684317111969, 1.1924753189086914, 0.15250535309314728, -0.33075496554374695, -0.19465306401252747, 0.06172905117273331, 0.6020618081092834, 1.3485053777694702, -0.45769545435905457, -0.506429135799408, -0.03491909056901932, -0.5957846641540527, 0.14993341267108917, 0.19075614213943481, -0.3859550654888153, 0.37896934151649475, -0.7201446294784546, -0.1052740290760994, -0.21615849435329437, -0.6750769019126892, 0.1387164145708084, -0.5654593706130981, 1.0279617309570312, -0.6445804238319397, 0.5601407885551453, -0.03218143433332443, -0.03182237595319748, 0.36962056159973145, 0.2733236849308014, -1.1124790906906128, 0.04013504087924957, 0.028821423649787903, -0.0581698901951313, -0.21251261234283447, -0.11886145174503326, 0.17184780538082123, 0.6065556406974792, -0.4630732238292694, 0.38934051990509033, -1.3460309505462646, 0.3739723861217499, 0.6819217205047607, -0.796021580696106, -0.6822184324264526, -0.18349513411521912, -0.36749476194381714, 0.28027841448783875, 0.16874539852142334, 0.032635800540447235, -0.42522501945495605, -0.2832980751991272, -0.7332766056060791, -0.022623775526881218, -0.2354130893945694, 0.009008578024804592, 0.014914751052856445, 0.40173783898353577, -0.3100041449069977, -0.16527162492275238, 0.21242786943912506, -0.5840258598327637, -0.5580660104751587, 0.3678213357925415, -0.281263142824173, -0.33076712489128113, 0.2917931377887726, -0.09738032519817352, -0.2233416736125946, -0.021188240498304367, -0.45313501358032227, 0.15080499649047852, -0.23514819145202637, -0.1989273577928543, 0.12125635892152786, -0.5049844980239868, 0.5263047814369202, 0.5640116333961487, -0.37608468532562256, -0.31316593289375305, 0.33734554052352905, -0.5172144770622253, 0.1303296536207199, -0.17292439937591553, -0.6493207812309265, 0.7297592759132385, -0.26227983832359314, 0.5042206645011902, -0.5622630715370178, -0.44189906120300293, 0.09534802287817001, -0.4526042640209198, -0.07375424355268478, -0.01736067607998848, 0.763107419013977, 0.7520933747291565, -0.5624638199806213, 0.4423938989639282, -0.8178941011428833, -0.5217835903167725, 0.10450832545757294, -0.024125048890709877, -0.18363985419273376, -0.06448809057474136, -0.10301007330417633, 0.6168018579483032, 0.6019556522369385, 0.6243515014648438, -0.14281314611434937, -0.5564932227134705, 0.5456382632255554, 0.5316356420516968, -0.7981876730918884, -0.502423882484436, 0.556991696357727, -0.07260466367006302, 0.12317252904176712, -0.4446968734264374, 0.49950462579727173, 1.5039247274398804, 0.5516257286071777, 0.29778993129730225, -0.9155390858650208, -0.514687180519104, -0.4025014638900757, -0.2000020295381546, 0.080661341547966, -0.5459698438644409, -0.45446062088012695, 0.10801936686038971, -0.17892467975616455, -0.3933592736721039, -0.7432344555854797, 0.9550826549530029, -1.0570991039276123, -0.7316690683364868, -0.30308401584625244, 1.026100516319275, -0.6366189122200012, -0.5217491984367371, -0.2974143922328949, -0.2624577581882477, 0.16556110978126526, 0.6699037551879883, -0.5407038927078247, -0.4539858102798462, 0.437385618686676, 0.4248003363609314, 0.16887955367565155, 0.7700713872909546, -0.7410680651664734, -0.06384329497814178, 0.033139005303382874, 0.4215552806854248, 0.3246968686580658, 0.11756817251443863, 0.9169092178344727, -0.5535334944725037, 0.4710950255393982, 0.36962899565696716, 0.3360714316368103, -0.46965762972831726, 0.4377053380012512, 0.4162842035293579, -0.6834290623664856, -0.32096442580223083, -0.4944767653942108, 0.34647485613822937, -0.8910172581672668, 0.09474530071020126, 0.2454153299331665, -0.9014371633529663, 0.25262507796287537, 0.20050913095474243, -0.20965923368930817, 1.2640533447265625, -0.07649295777082443, 0.648544430732727, 0.22128941118717194, 0.5197413563728333, 0.21535055339336395, -0.28536492586135864, 0.03729424998164177, 0.13183070719242096, -0.364941269159317, -0.9883532524108887, 0.26897284388542175, 0.48072391748428345, -0.1004689633846283, -0.15442930161952972, -0.411319762468338, 0.057420626282691956, -0.24185487627983093, -0.44243764877319336, 0.24327650666236877, 1.4114245176315308, 0.6494861245155334, 0.4625566005706787, 0.5364158153533936, -0.1946733444929123, -0.5512495040893555, -0.4357609748840332, -1.1117029190063477, -0.9726548194885254, 0.7557222247123718, 0.19375598430633545, 0.5421465635299683, -0.4859468638896942, 0.09651229530572891, -0.41550034284591675, 0.8371344804763794, 0.26648879051208496, -0.122519351541996, 0.6588284969329834, 0.12873435020446777, 0.5178467631340027, 0.02806772291660309, -0.24189868569374084, -0.6112423539161682, 0.16224825382232666, -0.8633034825325012, -0.2145305722951889, 0.3427565395832062, 0.5956023931503296, 0.9227755069732666, 0.3144739270210266, -0.2945936322212219, 0.9375746846199036, -0.03341817855834961, -0.37233084440231323, -0.13129694759845734, -0.013397232629358768, -0.6596323251724243, 0.12472975999116898, 0.13381730020046234, 1.024285078048706, 0.24526052176952362, 0.500758171081543, 0.3665493130683899, -0.35212746262550354, -0.539996325969696, -0.029591988772153854, 0.4026089906692505, -0.8944507241249084, 0.06985205411911011, 0.25691911578178406, 0.17293678224086761, 0.01958274282515049, -0.2920890152454376, 0.7078540325164795, 0.2748442590236664, 0.6907585859298706, 0.019439533352851868, -0.3230799734592438, 0.838600754737854, 0.8778620958328247, 0.5538312196731567, -0.016475860029459, 0.6933286786079407, 0.3697296977043152, -0.32437190413475037, 0.4796379506587982, -0.45532333850860596, 0.5530877113342285, -0.425354927778244, -0.13851399719715118, 0.976686954498291, 0.09595393389463425, 0.3142717182636261, 0.2660040855407715, -1.2916725873947144, 0.3595350980758667, -0.4155600666999817, -0.5689128637313843, -0.21719203889369965, 0.5180229544639587, 0.48635637760162354, 0.21181049942970276, -0.02850847691297531, -0.15803059935569763, 0.9270853400230408, 0.2164464294910431, 0.3209806978702545, 1.033739686012268, 0.04922439157962799, -0.2801460027694702, -0.14069299399852753, 0.2446349412202835, -0.3722159266471863, 0.5664342641830444, -0.20295029878616333, -0.06335950642824173, -0.1587846726179123, 0.49848276376724243, 0.08871273696422577, -0.653240442276001, 0.6718066334724426, -0.3591708838939667, -0.21506130695343018, -0.46549540758132935, 0.04445517808198929, -0.9072346091270447, 0.11302847415208817, 1.004000186920166, -0.46145099401474, -0.30472517013549805, 0.527724027633667, 0.9260289669036865, 0.6691038012504578, 0.04020855948328972, 0.24047702550888062, -0.06984636932611465, 0.4714166224002838, 0.6770179867744446, -0.23065300285816193, 0.12354112416505814, 0.27525824308395386, 0.12275243550539017, -0.41642284393310547, -0.22194376587867737, 0.3793242573738098, -0.07877683639526367, -0.07057279348373413, -0.3403202295303345, -0.06452423334121704, -0.5024921894073486, -0.26920002698898315, -1.3115404844284058, 0.2695355713367462, -0.15560612082481384, 0.11998013406991959, -0.3633384108543396, 0.17913542687892914, 0.6167967319488525, 0.24065209925174713, -0.3859451413154602, -0.05695229396224022, -0.8043157458305359, 0.23800595104694366, -0.41821879148483276, 0.5988402366638184, -0.005294823087751865, -0.4894288182258606, -0.6125229597091675, -1.0335912704467773, -0.06996819376945496, -0.11097067594528198, 0.16442345082759857, -0.22069266438484192, 0.5638642907142639, 0.5623442530632019, 1.2022336721420288, 0.8543786406517029, 0.02554391883313656, 0.26644909381866455, 1.0155951976776123, 0.8663071990013123, 0.3371666371822357, 1.0731772184371948, 0.026566779240965843, 0.35597914457321167, 0.03294670954346657, -0.928428590297699, -0.04928063601255417, 0.18298737704753876, -0.2554434835910797, -0.5712389945983887, 0.05105921998620033, -0.5145341753959656, -1.000563621520996, -0.06976934522390366, 0.5542747974395752, 0.27018681168556213, -0.2906181514263153, -0.5959827899932861, -0.36280879378318787, -0.6704519391059875, 0.293606162071228, -1.1303168535232544, 0.6642665266990662, 0.344489187002182, 0.38761553168296814, 0.31749582290649414, -0.15938420593738556, 3.9359729290008545, 0.28724727034568787, 0.5875229239463806, 0.3361053168773651, 0.43734854459762573, 1.0389877557754517, 1.2186237573623657, 0.027441343292593956, 0.22401025891304016, -0.5956948399543762, 0.20956756174564362, -0.12326410412788391, 0.1950264722108841, -0.056520428508520126, -0.4821247160434723, -0.1842973381280899, -0.9987983703613281, -0.20776088535785675, 0.02927277609705925, -1.2868273258209229, -0.31414884328842163, -0.03162044286727905, -0.42594683170318604, 0.5048566460609436, 0.06559870392084122, 0.06410761922597885, 0.6550768613815308, 0.3104203939437866, -0.17154110968112946, -0.15517960488796234, -0.014252688735723495, -0.6790733933448792, 0.2126777172088623, -0.45338329672813416, -0.2706262767314911, 0.2856926918029785, 0.40304383635520935, -0.5155020356178284, -0.920859158039093, 0.33330750465393066, 0.15643906593322754, 0.7087103128433228, 0.32940274477005005, -0.11581414192914963, -0.3238741457462311, 0.5011622309684753, -0.3254271149635315, 0.5645533800125122, 0.5819754004478455, -0.30515629053115845, 0.7293198108673096, -0.6426482200622559, 0.4406973719596863, -0.2534709870815277, -0.8667558431625366, -0.5026060342788696, -0.2361559271812439, -1.064627766609192, -0.5076456069946289, 0.8546006679534912, 0.8808702230453491, 0.6398518681526184, 0.03265468031167984, 0.3932347297668457, -1.0233968496322632, 0.8030292391777039, 0.37582847476005554, -0.059438712894916534, -0.6647560596466064, 0.07246872037649155, -0.01989358849823475, 0.17319685220718384, -0.8224108219146729, -0.08387172967195511, 0.5377562642097473, 0.16525571048259735, -0.5354536175727844, 1.2228752374649048, -0.2818622291088104, -0.5536370873451233, -0.3534262180328369, 0.9198535084724426, 0.5520974397659302, 0.16184070706367493, 0.024840449914336205, 0.44111186265945435, -1.19051992893219, 0.041356161236763, -1.3180330991744995, -0.23504480719566345, 0.03803493082523346, -0.4539097845554352, 0.43463581800460815, 0.6088621616363525, -0.1070568785071373 ]
{"Title": "Natural Language Processing for Mimicking Clinical Trial Recruitment in Critical Care: A Semi-automated Simulation Based on the LeoPARDS Trial", "Authors": "Tissot Hegler, Shah Anoop, Agbakoba Ruth, Folarin Amos, Romao Luis, Brealey David, Harris Steve, Roguski Lukasz, Dobson Richard, Asselbergs Folkert", "Abstract": "Abstract Clinical trials often fail on recruiting an adequate number of appropriate patients. Identifying eligible trial participants is a resource-intensive task when relying on manual review of clinical notes, particularly in critical care settings where the time window is short. Automated review of electronic health records has been explored as a way of identifying trial participants, but much of the information is in unstructured free text rather than a computable form. We developed an electronic health record pipeline that combines structured electronic health record data with free text in order to simulate recruitment into the LeoPARDS trial. We applied an algorithm to identify eligible patients using a moving 1-hour time window, and compared the set of patients identified by our approach with those actually screened and recruited for the trial. We manually reviewed clinical records for a random sample of additional patients identified by the algorithm but not identified for screening in the original trial. Our approach identified 308 patients, of whom 208 were screened in the actual trial. We identified all 40 patients with CCHIC data available who were actually recruited to LeoPARDS in our centre. The algorithm identified 96 patients on the same day as manual screening and 62 patients one or two days earlier. Analysis of electronic health records incorporating natural language processing tools could effectively replicate recruitment in a critical care trial, and identify some eligible patients at an earlier stage. If implemented in real-time this could improve the efficiency of clinical trial recruitment.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005603"}
10.1101/19014175
[ -0.14216171205043793, 0.2109653204679489, -0.6226925253868103, 0.2404208928346634, -0.19460488855838776, -0.8034706711769104, 0.14109450578689575, 0.05025436356663704, 0.23748564720153809, 0.1887959986925125, 0.012457636184990406, -0.2555958926677704, 0.6832642555236816, -0.20911642909049988, -0.6099868416786194, -0.14178119599819183, -0.45165038108825684, -0.30666670203208923, -0.3910103738307953, -0.41176751255989075, -0.26930055022239685, 0.23326435685157776, -0.6727958917617798, -0.12317988276481628, -0.6738307476043701, 0.15306012332439423, 0.0849953144788742, -0.5493059754371643, 0.697396993637085, 0.7347862720489502, 0.014106173068284988, -0.28155404329299927, 0.7537766098976135, -0.10204048454761505, -0.20128686726093292, -0.00030439955298788846, 0.5287238359451294, -0.8994320631027222, 0.06831170618534088, -0.1608949899673462, 0.5251630544662476, 0.5584234595298767, 1.2432262897491455, -1.4688457250595093, -0.5395974516868591, -0.4425009489059448, 0.536131739616394, 0.6327759027481079, 0.1359463632106781, -0.1816047579050064, -0.20061402022838593, 0.38802775740623474, 0.7184741497039795, -0.9258993864059448, -0.3465946316719055, -0.7136201858520508, 0.5165334343910217, -0.561800479888916, -0.25972652435302734, 0.3579716980457306, 0.40806564688682556, -0.1738996058702469, 0.6819107532501221, -0.4068853557109833, 0.005606296006590128, 0.9776120185852051, -0.48343366384506226, -0.03473271429538727, -0.3734265863895416, -0.7908003926277161, 0.14899508655071259, 0.5387495160102844, -0.6778277158737183, -0.3903820514678955, 0.0665300190448761, 0.1832704246044159, -0.44446027278900146, -0.17313100397586823, -0.3551976978778839, 0.10887446999549866, -0.4606103003025055, 0.4954420328140259, 1.4555739164352417, -0.4942963123321533, -0.47780081629753113, -0.34574124217033386, 0.29756587743759155, 0.9394971132278442, 0.08322420716285706, 0.630020022392273, 0.01160353608429432, 0.6118103265762329, -0.9169314503669739, 0.1195855364203453, 0.22678464651107788, 0.4119940400123596, -0.4438649117946625, 0.1167168840765953, -0.20837929844856262, -0.17653484642505646, 0.6629185080528259, 0.42263415455818176, 0.4721727669239044, 0.74476557970047, -0.8930350542068481, 0.8288869857788086, -0.3076716661453247, -0.1987553983926773, 0.13790738582611084, -0.5379757285118103, -0.3264976441860199, 0.22452521324157715, -0.12207850813865662, -0.6315398216247559, 0.05566050857305527, 0.45013177394866943, 0.37389305233955383, 0.8436357975006104, -0.9513891339302063, 1.1554458141326904, -0.20430248975753784, 0.45322808623313904, 0.8201771378517151, -0.8083940744400024, 0.6192677617073059, -0.17331214249134064, 0.6973856687545776, 0.7513530254364014, 0.0004068128182552755, 0.2786253094673157, -0.4314272999763489, -0.27356797456741333, -0.3537791073322296, 0.5602612495422363, -0.03759055584669113, -0.08385217934846878, 0.2229136973619461, -0.12384223937988281, 0.2900269329547882, -0.16915112733840942, -0.8321641683578491, 1.0736501216888428, -0.22876660525798798, 1.0426474809646606, -0.30178114771842957, -0.06531459838151932, -0.6005657911300659, -0.11982619017362595, -0.40355536341667175, -0.1502806544303894, -0.16203878819942474, 0.5921818017959595, 0.5018901824951172, -0.09300943464040756, 0.24948982894420624, 0.0812905803322792, -0.26059490442276, 0.056576307862997055, -0.5832730531692505, 0.20543387532234192, -0.6172317266464233, 0.09119248390197754, -0.0992862805724144, 0.9266778230667114, -0.43813446164131165, -0.5731921195983887, 0.4997178614139557, -0.1927543431520462, 0.15941737592220306, -0.4841592013835907, 0.5013742446899414, 0.034108828753232956, -0.22551082074642181, 0.03632015734910965, 0.22658509016036987, 0.9871125817298889, 0.0031542314682155848, 0.16113726794719696, -0.3179677128791809, 0.8333155512809753, -0.15589094161987305, -0.4542831480503082, 0.5076445937156677, 0.3821459114551544, -0.1349141150712967, -0.2955384850502014, -0.14145733416080475, -0.7501936554908752, -0.5626411437988281, 0.09049254655838013, -0.02094184048473835, 0.2654837667942047, -0.7869311571121216, 1.1087566614151, -0.1308341920375824, -0.09635981172323227, -0.4902225434780121, 0.1853732168674469, 0.9806513786315918, -0.5581735968589783, -0.44927167892456055, 0.6145763397216797, 0.45531895756721497, 0.639910101890564, 0.13687290251255035, -0.05648225545883179, 0.6835589408874512, -0.09669138491153717, -0.28803321719169617, -0.36532822251319885, 0.6272691488265991, 0.19272923469543457, -0.5415076017379761, 0.31953737139701843, 0.5083502531051636, -0.5478418469429016, -0.9041795134544373, 0.1123398169875145, -0.37114620208740234, 0.14577463269233704, -0.23732487857341766, 0.10035988688468933, 0.5169438123703003, 0.6387737989425659, -0.4434106945991516, -0.566280722618103, 0.18949130177497864, 0.10661143809556961, -0.7083873748779297, 0.07618702203035355, 0.42721301317214966, 0.39591866731643677, 0.46816614270210266, 0.3320131003856659, 0.9989220499992371, 0.3435386121273041, 0.13845175504684448, 0.1644861251115799, 0.8206809163093567, 0.2871813476085663, 0.1772633194923401, 0.03459574282169342, 0.7452709674835205, 0.35207614302635193, -0.1646415740251541, 0.3004499673843384, 0.13142496347427368, -0.2826428711414337, -0.536672830581665, -0.27626097202301025, -0.8433982133865356, 1.1139247417449951, 0.17010603845119476, 1.4582957029342651, -0.5441529154777527, 0.09656072407960892, 0.5362150073051453, 0.09682907909154892, -0.5604084134101868, -0.5215681791305542, -0.20774804055690765, 0.04764557257294655, -0.4636245369911194, 0.2306128740310669, 1.0740156173706055, 0.27899742126464844, -0.5450069308280945, 0.6392693519592285, 0.24928906559944153, -0.40999895334243774, -0.38492879271507263, -0.3214680254459381, -0.7230058908462524, -0.23691387474536896, -0.6226302981376648, -0.07275991141796112, -0.05777869373559952, -0.2921527326107025, 0.3779374957084656, -0.4918622076511383, -0.5937501788139343, 0.3379068970680237, -0.8832540512084961, 0.5366855263710022, 0.32511118054389954, -0.7292307019233704, -0.9382046461105347, -0.11857065558433533, 0.26597854495048523, -0.09439776092767715, 0.015395776368677616, 0.3620806038379669, -0.3475362956523895, -1.1346714496612549, 0.8837282061576843, -0.26794031262397766, 0.295360803604126, 0.5969498753547668, -0.5233194231987, -0.7293090224266052, 0.13835936784744263, -0.18677660822868347, 0.16384759545326233, 0.2491547167301178, -0.6543812155723572, 0.927151620388031, -0.41651442646980286, -0.01056789979338646, 0.3749563694000244, 0.2406923472881317, -0.7743625640869141, 0.7084102630615234, -0.10955353081226349, 0.42005184292793274, -0.8199183940887451, 0.30397897958755493, -0.12789154052734375, -0.6900588274002075, 0.43200722336769104, -0.06313019245862961, -0.946256697177887, -0.2667352855205536, -0.23471572995185852, 0.1666305810213089, -0.34770137071609497, 0.4572763741016388, -0.15848104655742645, -0.9850155711174011, 0.5485478043556213, -0.7555049657821655, -0.026868024840950966, -0.33009591698646545, 0.34651297330856323, -0.12897400557994843, -0.1674836426973343, 0.4275384247303009, -0.4510771334171295, -0.223642036318779, 0.06823526322841644, -0.14489993453025818, 0.33665382862091064, 0.15121713280677795, 0.45702463388442993, -0.17907321453094482, -0.41332191228866577, -0.5137522220611572, -0.07792085409164429, 0.6141928434371948, -0.6746550798416138, -0.5812215209007263, -0.0008961810963228345, 0.3595923185348511, 0.7806488871574402, -0.11831282824277878, -0.1056395173072815, 0.8433704972267151, -0.0842791423201561, 0.19337785243988037, 0.7592936754226685, 0.6766884922981262, -0.5081491470336914, -0.42934393882751465, -0.2234484702348709, 0.10247741639614105, -1.1060028076171875, -0.512052059173584, 0.5366901755332947, 0.28451642394065857, 0.013492847792804241, -0.7582684755325317, 0.41339877247810364, -0.6467408537864685, -0.5995750427246094, -0.12544448673725128, -0.3741369843482971, -0.16758544743061066, 0.7993393540382385, 0.6154260635375977, 1.0863924026489258, -0.2615151107311249, 0.3308829069137573, 0.09537540376186371, 0.830973744392395, 0.19724269211292267, -0.46787554025650024, 0.03976701200008392, -0.08985527604818344, 0.5184138417243958, 0.4648193418979645, -0.7944782376289368, 0.10135038942098618, -1.1729912757873535, 0.4976446330547333, -0.21902650594711304, -0.3099827766418457, -0.324399471282959, 0.33475297689437866, 0.3075263202190399, 0.7374762892723083, 0.19829247891902924, 0.21260496973991394, -0.23148632049560547, 0.016693346202373505, 0.01734033226966858, 0.3722190856933594, 0.3970339894294739, -0.7637292146682739, 0.4331020712852478, -0.2870568037033081, -0.5804038643836975, -0.27985405921936035, -0.004109168890863657, -0.1938229203224182, 0.04181675612926483, -0.21130608022212982, 0.0393257737159729, -0.17577679455280304, -0.7938298583030701, -0.6119842529296875, 0.018318789079785347, -0.11397282034158707, -0.940395712852478, -0.1085285022854805, 0.40269163250923157, 0.08074479550123215, -0.518132209777832, -0.29860761761665344, -0.46353814005851746, 0.8260020017623901, 0.12261850386857986, -0.062363896518945694, -0.29593607783317566, -0.3389984369277954, -0.47038230299949646, -0.08343980461359024, -1.058792233467102, 0.46844616532325745, 0.1324092000722885, 0.5428619384765625, -0.26550015807151794, -0.21593713760375977, -0.6458784341812134, 0.44888633489608765, -0.4174470603466034, -0.02256656251847744, 0.129734069108963, 0.031526293605566025, 0.24867936968803406, -0.1550484448671341, -0.46281054615974426, 0.23290404677391052, -0.3258490562438965, 0.4047987759113312, -0.20154334604740143, 0.635749340057373, -0.02590516023337841, 0.13933368027210236, 0.6166930198669434, 0.07456880062818527, -0.12263435870409012, -0.6615917682647705, 0.3469240367412567, 0.5248458385467529, -0.18105706572532654, 0.029765643179416656, 0.35815927386283875, -0.10481888055801392, -0.35154837369918823, 0.5703964829444885, -0.5063700079917908, -0.37985336780548096, -0.699306070804596, -0.21773642301559448, -1.0626438856124878, 0.34900379180908203, 0.21651703119277954, -0.0992792546749115, 0.6593775153160095, -0.7396953105926514, 0.8077424168586731, -0.17942124605178833, 0.8357692956924438, -0.21987223625183105, 0.22623629868030548, -0.30118635296821594, 0.10040467977523804, -0.2959900200366974, 0.18244948983192444, -0.299855500459671, 0.5674284100532532, 0.18445277214050293, -0.4957827925682068, -0.2816108465194702, -0.047400232404470444, -0.44076642394065857, 0.16807124018669128, -0.2518024146556854, 0.003074956825003028, 0.3210843801498413, -0.3997764587402344, 0.9623020887374878, -0.27557215094566345, 0.13778290152549744, -0.31667041778564453, 0.045887887477874756, -0.4614720046520233, -0.31673189997673035, -0.20805151760578156, -1.0455601215362549, -0.2259376347064972, -0.22747772932052612, 0.688712477684021, -0.7533875703811646, 0.21693812310695648, 0.005743876099586487, 0.16686993837356567, 0.7922505140304565, 0.16578251123428345, 0.1650514155626297, 0.28093060851097107, -0.2541210353374481, -0.10983601957559586, -0.3257002532482147, 0.6701769232749939, -0.1973862648010254, 0.015689989551901817, -0.3668556213378906, -0.17916737496852875, -0.5143427848815918, -1.383848786354065, -0.0359894223511219, -0.8326144218444824, -0.44745105504989624, 0.17885169386863708, -0.11466233432292938, -0.06542955338954926, 0.35346534848213196, 0.24858319759368896, 0.27266067266464233, 0.21123573184013367, -0.28911831974983215, 0.30636680126190186, -0.038759347051382065, -0.4206596314907074, 0.7608826160430908, -1.0971883535385132, 0.003874422749504447, 0.8369812965393066, 0.6433473825454712, 0.2594221234321594, -0.22603371739387512, 0.24542807042598724, -0.06451860815286636, 0.12587125599384308, 0.2504134774208069, -0.7945189476013184, 0.37626034021377563, 1.082065463066101, -0.5419647693634033, -0.5848044157028198, -0.24595917761325836, 1.160179615020752, -0.4390813112258911, 0.4919724464416504, -0.019838467240333557, -0.3584885001182556, -0.01437670923769474, -0.3885849714279175, 1.1772170066833496, -0.000622337858658284, 0.24606779217720032, 0.08427686244249344, -0.05971025303006172, 0.15746605396270752, 0.09868116676807404, -0.4951164722442627, -0.5058338642120361, -0.45525285601615906, -0.7131821513175964, 0.10500573366880417, 0.8776782751083374, -0.14998182654380798, 0.6014516353607178, 0.18934938311576843, 0.2137761116027832, -0.2666488587856293, 0.904180645942688, 0.2990686595439911, -1.0038058757781982, -0.3082664906978607, -0.29217302799224854, 0.31056517362594604, -0.04288937523961067, 0.6308175921440125, 0.5216770768165588, -0.06068461760878563, 0.6356202363967896, -0.873467743396759, -0.5098616480827332, -0.48145824670791626, -0.7114102244377136, 0.38438647985458374, 0.4193793535232544, -0.3099679946899414, 0.8950966000556946, -0.06448803097009659, -0.571776270866394, -0.9216420650482178, 0.7062464356422424, -0.43794649839401245, -0.02587040700018406, 0.11270909756422043, -0.13135062158107758, -0.7159723043441772, -0.40698596835136414, -0.6206076741218567, 0.5851243138313293, -0.07717995345592499, 0.6663625240325928, -0.009893960319459438, -1.4041098356246948, 0.028670987114310265, 0.2613987326622009, -0.3048022985458374, 0.058773014694452286, -0.0998419001698494, -0.029025347903370857, 0.6106382012367249, 0.12453263998031616, -0.7791960835456848, 0.5377159118652344, 0.9263820648193359, 0.4473719298839569, -0.17115046083927155, -0.4638356566429138, 0.23833872377872467, -0.4320589005947113, 0.889724612236023, 0.6895390152931213, -0.8322373032569885, 0.5180217623710632, -0.24461491405963898, 0.1523849219083786, 0.2287985384464264, -0.18694359064102173, -0.67083740234375, 0.6326832175254822, 0.5529527068138123, 0.038729820400476456, 0.04112306982278824, 0.4782865047454834, -0.9871570467948914, 0.48273202776908875, 0.11800200492143631, -0.49546554684638977, 0.8110746741294861, -0.6775999665260315, -0.3591039776802063, -0.3594379723072052, 0.32754117250442505, 0.20836278796195984, 0.8186010122299194, -0.40117278695106506, -0.6732051372528076, -0.22031480073928833, 0.835330069065094, 0.7888900637626648, -0.058660849928855896, -0.4936006963253021, -0.4918496012687683, -0.2825464904308319, 0.2677741050720215, -0.33623892068862915, 0.10360457003116608, -0.14708489179611206, 0.5308012962341309, -1.0557364225387573, 0.504069983959198, 0.9707316756248474, -0.5449264645576477, 0.19879847764968872, -0.33023226261138916, 0.2509109079837799, -0.5153852105140686, -1.009528398513794, -0.09684660285711288, 0.2077857404947281, -0.32691487669944763, 0.6197521686553955, -0.6453677415847778, -0.01740463450551033, 0.048303063958883286, 1.0222673416137695, 0.08885366469621658, 0.08629375696182251, -0.5360210537910461, -0.1077767089009285, 0.5708386898040771, 0.672443151473999, 0.4251367747783661, -0.25905752182006836, -0.19781504571437836, -1.1467584371566772, -0.21099704504013062, -0.08371048420667648, -0.26988810300827026, 0.6116267442703247, 0.02482929825782776, 0.10363317281007767, -0.1937558352947235, -1.4453574419021606, 0.20460008084774017, 0.8706205487251282, -0.34955883026123047, -0.005979379639029503, -0.2421092540025711, 0.021098682656884193, -0.19901153445243835, 0.43633517622947693, 0.2137516885995865, 0.21568302810192108, 0.4347023367881775, 0.4455054700374603, 0.1030333936214447, 0.3907984495162964, -0.24952377378940582, 0.6137271523475647, 0.43180006742477417, -0.3172796666622162, 0.11135337501764297, -1.0819250345230103, -0.3049657642841339, 0.37704697251319885, -0.10669544339179993, 1.175345540046692, -0.6907000541687012, 0.2242087870836258, -0.4187343120574951, -0.05408793315291405, -0.210653617978096, 0.48281291127204895, -0.05312320217490196, -0.5906289219856262, -0.21343474090099335, 0.13237406313419342, -0.14290755987167358, 0.09929009526968002, -0.8879575133323669, -0.32360783219337463, 0.5305237174034119, -0.32155123353004456, -0.5389171838760376, -0.3970925807952881, -1.0702540874481201, 0.42791739106178284, -0.19166196882724762, 0.7995291948318481, -0.1821995973587036, 0.6634100675582886, 0.06145782768726349, 0.7531540393829346, 1.065610647201538, 0.23766455054283142, 0.12616780400276184, 0.0016917064785957336, -0.6589527130126953, -0.9890694618225098, 0.26927798986434937, 0.2146480530500412, -0.012393346056342125, -0.28735730051994324, 0.010503980331122875, -0.3307434916496277, -0.17401671409606934, 0.3041912913322449, -0.31733742356300354, 0.12047316879034042, -1.3278292417526245, -0.4460359513759613, -0.1535390317440033, 0.7316110730171204, -0.2648918628692627, 0.4926672875881195, 0.032004550099372864, -0.587520956993103, -0.6474955081939697, 0.1822224259376526, 0.7779148817062378, -0.3553332984447479, 0.371040016412735, 0.5417922735214233, 0.7184091806411743, -0.007527211215347052, 0.06784908473491669, 0.9428414106369019, 0.8777101039886475, -0.46840429306030273, 0.45217618346214294, -0.18826361000537872, 0.20409943163394928, 0.6001406311988831, -0.6217873692512512, -0.33680281043052673, 0.7870911955833435, 0.3575707674026489, -0.21651975810527802, -0.25702419877052307, -0.43660762906074524, -0.26644769310951233, -0.002699104370549321, -0.10261206328868866, 0.2796759009361267, 0.029100393876433372, 0.1968962550163269, 0.02142847701907158, -0.7121815085411072, 0.997378408908844, -0.14448648691177368, -0.4969114065170288, 0.14255763590335846, -0.29014644026756287, 0.8905762434005737, 0.764820396900177, 0.32805779576301575, -0.06397582590579987, 0.3048804998397827, 0.4404457211494446, -0.397431343793869, 0.033490944653749466, -0.2554415464401245, -0.01890891045331955, 0.0667785257101059, 0.46367451548576355, -0.6375795006752014, -0.10866979509592056, -0.678341805934906, -0.16848795115947723, -0.04459049552679062, 1.3903101682662964, -0.09613469243049622, 0.040044140070676804, 0.7502657175064087, 0.10775027424097061, -0.5967540740966797, -0.04976937547326088, -0.19810259342193604, -0.2385900765657425, -0.40049633383750916, 0.4776507318019867, 0.28610873222351074, -0.20948904752731323, 0.4331146776676178, 0.5955513119697571, 0.11420415341854095, 1.0194528102874756, 0.4340963363647461, -0.8774030804634094, 0.3427194058895111, 0.030347757041454315, -0.2683214843273163, -0.397599458694458, -0.6000864505767822, -0.1459215134382248, 0.23197101056575775, -0.7589493989944458, 0.25027358531951904, -0.44063252210617065, -0.28973671793937683, -1.1910552978515625, 0.39112719893455505, 0.4052601158618927, -0.4069845676422119, -0.6438738703727722, -0.06709535419940948, -0.20828400552272797, -0.39554208517074585, 0.02046327479183674, 0.38801631331443787, 0.07973507046699524, 0.48229217529296875, 0.28249219059944153, 0.039499856531620026, -0.01355998869985342, 0.42681798338890076, -0.6874372363090515, 0.6240634918212891, -0.27502429485321045, -0.9706922173500061, -0.1341346800327301, -0.7383818030357361, -0.054237108677625656, 0.7538987994194031, 0.13057710230350494, -1.1992181539535522, -0.20733775198459625, 0.30290883779525757, 0.45567384362220764, -0.0800800621509552, -1.166854739189148, -0.818520188331604, 0.25852149724960327, 0.8884310722351074, -0.14311790466308594, 0.14933297038078308, 0.2808184027671814, -0.2003713995218277, 0.20900040864944458, 0.08202389627695084, 0.36627548933029175, 0.467801570892334, -0.22543713450431824, 0.0057258689776062965, 0.3014116585254669, -0.3570170998573303, -0.9124427437782288, 0.5205583572387695, 0.5094157457351685, -0.24444662034511566, -0.3745229244232178, -0.8869351744651794, -0.5689920783042908, -1.331063151359558, 0.906624972820282, -0.4235976040363312, 0.4706724286079407, 0.08370936661958694, -0.8832550048828125, 0.4669579565525055, -0.7452054619789124, 4.261033058166504, 0.3987085819244385, 0.32880955934524536, -0.2784726321697235, 0.2920309901237488, 0.6296974420547485, 0.5575267672538757, -0.13855046033859253, 0.6524642705917358, -0.7627356052398682, -0.1602453887462616, -0.2099694311618805, 0.5850576162338257, 0.3105214536190033, 0.6104152798652649, 0.5288113951683044, -0.6203992366790771, 0.06499835848808289, -0.4845044016838074, -1.1797025203704834, -0.7844718098640442, 0.6535433530807495, -0.2509881854057312, 0.3921823799610138, -0.36709585785865784, -0.4062441289424896, -0.19951297342777252, -0.4688416123390198, 0.7825996279716492, -0.2902814745903015, 0.33444324135780334, -0.973727822303772, 0.07887152582406998, -0.09694855660200119, -0.24638110399246216, 0.8112154006958008, 0.09237918257713318, -0.5550839900970459, -0.19159531593322754, -0.13439272344112396, 0.03388714790344238, 0.5140912532806396, 0.22781647741794586, 0.19639351963996887, 0.23551948368549347, 0.6092728972434998, -0.6905913352966309, 0.049479104578495026, 0.6619581580162048, -0.5724827647209167, 0.8841466307640076, -1.0939648151397705, 0.571370005607605, -0.15194135904312134, -0.46258923411369324, -0.36743780970573425, -0.2634352147579193, -0.5983632206916809, -0.6013931632041931, 0.09774863719940186, 0.8077271580696106, 0.2465047389268875, -0.09404712915420532, 0.03959125652909279, 0.35941052436828613, -0.19702868163585663, 0.2902473211288452, -0.13731428980827332, -0.2525634169578552, 0.08371242135763168, 0.5231239795684814, -0.2892133295536041, -0.37129107117652893, 0.13187025487422943, 1.4449914693832397, -0.16354681551456451, 0.19112811982631683, -0.09360486268997192, -0.07722585648298264, -1.016536831855774, 0.6916894316673279, 0.07784049957990646, 0.46395358443260193, -0.08710659295320511, -0.0681198462843895, 0.9872041940689087, -0.36508047580718994, -1.08804452419281, -0.04901370406150818, 0.44741228222846985, 0.23075111210346222, -0.04469454288482666, 0.05247892066836357, 0.017363226041197777, 0.033227354288101196 ]
{"Title": "[Knowledge and attitudes regarding infant BLS among babysitters and nursemaids in north rural Jordan]", "Authors": "Raffee Liqaa, Hamadneh Shereen, Kassab Manal, Almomani Fidaa, Hamadneh Jehan, AlBashtawy Mohammed, Obeidat Rawan A., Almazloom Othman", "Abstract": "Abstract Background There is a lack of national data related to the public knowledge and attitudes concerning Basic Life Support (BLS) for an infant. This study is the first to assess the knowledge and attitude regarding infant BLS among babysitters and nursemaids who are working in registered nurseries in North Jordan. Methods A semi-structured questionnaire was conducted among a convenience sample of 77 child caretakers (babysitters and nursemaids) who were looking after infants in registered nurseries in north of Jordan. Results The findings show that the majority of participants were not aware of skills for managing foreign body aspiration (or CPR) among infants, while more than two-thirds of them never attended training and or education sessions regarding managing foreign body aspiration among infants. Conclusions This research strongly recommends training for babysitters and care center staff. The findings of this study indicated that caregivers in Jordanian kindergartens and nurseries lack awareness regarding safe infant care. As such, there is a lack of basic skills for resuscitation in urgent cases; which can increase the risk of sudden and unexpected child death. Accordingly, the infant life support course is highly recommended for babysitters and nursemaids. Health care professionals could help to implement infant basic life support training courses through local community basic service centers, non-governmental organizations, local associations, universities and health colleges through providing workshops that aim at enhancing knowledge and skills for infant BLS among caregivers and babysitters.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19014175"}
10.1101/19007559
[ -0.32112017273902893, 0.02394605427980423, -0.2348952442407608, 0.8917784690856934, -0.27980440855026245, 0.08097666501998901, 0.38801196217536926, -0.2662246823310852, 0.41329118609428406, 0.5142562985420227, -0.05718941241502762, -0.8183634877204895, 0.13847589492797852, -0.8713498115539551, 0.29211682081222534, 0.1315031349658966, -0.5728961229324341, -0.14689360558986664, -0.08910012245178223, 0.3991491496562958, 0.9406242966651917, -0.012459217570722103, -0.802973747253418, 0.6402711272239685, -0.024386193603277206, 0.4838602542877197, -0.10694379359483719, 0.23040875792503357, 1.6182456016540527, 0.1823836863040924, -0.02994784340262413, -0.690080463886261, 0.45511341094970703, -1.1464649438858032, -0.4939647614955902, -0.30166861414909363, 0.08862505853176117, -0.0754271000623703, 0.2544326186180115, -0.10510742664337158, 0.6224281191825867, -0.20471146702766418, 0.4649801552295685, -0.2882651090621948, -0.02487853914499283, -0.5134375095367432, -0.6524587869644165, -0.6270467042922974, -0.4218304455280304, 0.002990326378494501, -0.3580021560192108, 0.09170695394277573, 0.5655795335769653, -0.08601993322372437, 0.2816794216632843, 0.03838934376835823, -0.03516194224357605, 0.4525569975376129, -0.8809645175933838, 0.1125815138220787, -0.04032278060913086, -0.22439785301685333, 0.49228984117507935, -1.4222369194030762, 0.8263974785804749, 0.7975146770477295, 0.15024547278881073, -0.207625150680542, -0.44867783784866333, -0.3559328317642212, -0.38142064213752747, -0.26914381980895996, -0.6539645195007324, -0.28587961196899414, -0.20055899024009705, 0.12130250781774521, 0.5486050248146057, 0.25667527318000793, -0.1798604279756546, -0.015992283821105957, 0.6289838552474976, 0.38351503014564514, -0.20017264783382416, 0.7934193015098572, -0.4704778790473938, -0.06878796964883804, 0.08074679225683212, 0.809158444404602, -0.34058648347854614, -0.026958243921399117, 0.3965455889701843, 0.3303892910480499, 0.39243364334106445, 0.17203839123249054, 0.25715941190719604, 1.1074087619781494, -0.5648746490478516, 0.33335447311401367, -0.531420886516571, -0.24288396537303925, 0.5033628344535828, 0.4254492521286011, -1.0578960180282593, 0.993588387966156, -0.19989827275276184, 0.6173351407051086, 0.6904135346412659, -0.4030819833278656, -0.9921756982803345, -1.09440016746521, 0.2794663906097412, -0.06174692139029503, -0.47293370962142944, 0.7195417881011963, 0.6602423191070557, 0.6030962467193604, -0.43090400099754333, 0.8092707395553589, -0.9380213618278503, 0.5342108011245728, -0.6560739874839783, 0.4294503331184387, 0.22024968266487122, -0.25669872760772705, 0.35766133666038513, 0.05187293514609337, 0.3397842347621918, 0.2914849519729614, -0.2682383954524994, 0.6310964226722717, 0.13078613579273224, -0.20963771641254425, 0.018125198781490326, 0.7252155542373657, -0.25889888405799866, -0.44138115644454956, 0.09950288385152817, 1.3048864603042603, -0.25838547945022583, -0.8959279656410217, -0.24482080340385437, 0.17250549793243408, -1.1802284717559814, 0.7540885210037231, -0.4951852262020111, 1.4595438241958618, -1.141178011894226, -1.7384581565856934, -0.4486258625984192, 0.0881914496421814, 0.09419405460357666, 0.8819074630737305, -0.0480203814804554, -0.9311663508415222, -0.39513906836509705, 0.7621690034866333, -0.2702019512653351, 0.6566139459609985, 0.3903960585594177, 0.23141604661941528, -0.050393953919410706, 0.3091293275356293, 0.15115216374397278, 0.9183843731880188, -0.7808160185813904, 0.29631924629211426, -0.35227271914482117, 0.1970798224210739, 0.7052963376045227, -0.4016921818256378, 0.37711700797080994, 0.44355064630508423, -0.2996295094490051, -0.139133021235466, 0.49443885684013367, 0.7582594156265259, 0.6122829914093018, -0.8808670043945312, 0.7277685403823853, 0.022021660581231117, 0.10248497128486633, 0.26889482140541077, 0.1868799775838852, 0.7925350069999695, -0.4011162519454956, 0.24115705490112305, -0.19823609292507172, -0.2648090422153473, 0.0968683511018753, -0.11285009235143661, -0.1426457315683365, 0.39707282185554504, -0.15678709745407104, 1.5403106212615967, -0.2917070686817169, 0.14344869554042816, -0.4675549864768982, 0.6115065813064575, 0.44574958086013794, -0.5525418519973755, -0.6879308223724365, 0.786040723323822, 0.12693023681640625, 0.2011200189590454, 0.03653104603290558, 0.9030316472053528, 0.07026761025190353, 0.2709132730960846, -0.35103073716163635, -0.40969234704971313, 0.7471150159835815, -0.006575752981007099, -0.1554114669561386, -0.04764087498188019, 0.6366071701049805, -0.17071029543876648, -0.46957871317863464, -0.08588612079620361, -0.9373988509178162, -0.2317838966846466, -0.7840800881385803, -0.13173934817314148, 0.5842681527137756, -0.12018167972564697, 0.16132482886314392, 0.326295405626297, 1.0366970300674438, -0.07129699736833572, -0.20529837906360626, -0.8453389406204224, 0.40683841705322266, 0.8869202733039856, 0.10383979976177216, 1.01726233959198, 0.5984319448471069, 0.3550158441066742, 0.11013151705265045, 0.6187485456466675, 0.3823303282260895, 0.22412261366844177, 0.6790643334388733, 0.10987169295549393, 0.7995880246162415, 0.7729716897010803, -0.04048402979969978, -0.006904418580234051, -0.9709619283676147, 0.2010783553123474, -0.0642998144030571, 0.9497261047363281, -1.0163848400115967, 0.4283428192138672, 0.3527587354183197, 0.7665494084358215, -0.6426501274108887, -0.5952482223510742, -0.010874222964048386, 0.08958928287029266, -0.32032129168510437, -0.46313047409057617, -0.08126004040241241, 0.07495003193616867, -0.4130658209323883, -0.003140585031360388, 1.4732967615127563, 1.0450464487075806, -0.13310466706752777, 0.7867752909660339, 0.7079123258590698, -0.4424278140068054, 0.09775587916374207, -0.5745565295219421, -1.6066190004348755, -0.6764854788780212, -0.5305662751197815, -0.16338565945625305, 0.007146329153329134, -0.18506143987178802, 0.502546489238739, 0.275619775056839, 0.6191233992576599, -0.4566420614719391, -0.7555354237556458, 0.6021965146064758, 0.12062916159629822, 0.401825487613678, -0.7073166370391846, 0.3754381239414215, -0.8097471594810486, 0.24733710289001465, -0.08825462311506271, -0.1960020363330841, 0.14303290843963623, -0.20172710716724396, 0.8833857774734497, -1.1695013046264648, -0.36734747886657715, -0.2703286409378052, -0.19709090888500214, -0.2849085330963135, -0.05082013085484505, -0.578808069229126, 0.04068085551261902, -0.14594389498233795, -1.2002230882644653, 0.7569018602371216, 0.06303147226572037, 0.20070131123065948, 0.4455958604812622, 0.4449668526649475, -0.8660146594047546, 0.7162466049194336, 0.19169698655605316, -0.4448133707046509, -0.7688430547714233, 0.7403954863548279, 0.5715763568878174, -0.7086726427078247, 0.29130294919013977, -0.4447355568408966, -0.9894858598709106, -0.32060468196868896, -0.2219262421131134, -0.0636473149061203, 0.04163270816206932, 0.41253581643104553, 0.03253493830561638, -0.8866234421730042, -0.0024543520994484425, -0.05170615017414093, -1.208642840385437, 0.399374783039093, -0.23296332359313965, 0.39703190326690674, -0.2837061285972595, 0.0848482996225357, 0.0033683395013213158, -0.02168808877468109, -0.0949207991361618, 0.2258872240781784, -0.1643334925174713, -0.4175664186477661, 0.10119138658046722, 0.12711691856384277, -0.46814945340156555, 0.15108144283294678, 0.4864077866077423, -0.13721945881843567, 0.1557501256465912, 0.20202402770519257, 0.0919356718659401, 0.771457850933075, 0.7930988669395447, 0.15854333341121674, -0.39952266216278076, 0.7006747722625732, 0.21094760298728943, -0.10056944191455841, 0.5077581405639648, 0.8472952842712402, -0.04533572494983673, 0.2444877177476883, 0.3759958744049072, 0.7342691421508789, -0.5594867467880249, -0.6233141422271729, 0.8325870037078857, -1.0261321067810059, 0.18120551109313965, -0.5523823499679565, 0.7846457958221436, 0.7575863599777222, 0.05301239714026451, 0.042515095323324203, 0.1453879177570343, 0.3780507445335388, 0.9063516855239868, 0.4164351522922516, 1.381855845451355, -1.3855141401290894, 0.6792078614234924, 0.5292107462882996, 1.14557945728302, 0.3634132444858551, -0.03522922843694687, 0.5372173190116882, -1.0150020122528076, 0.31182146072387695, -0.2825895845890045, 0.06664479523897171, -0.12933678925037384, 0.14017876982688904, -0.44169706106185913, 0.10472726076841354, -0.419982373714447, -0.04129067808389664, -0.23751220107078552, 0.23853714764118195, -0.6418790221214294, -0.4471455514431, 0.5797167420387268, -0.302263081073761, 0.051277805119752884, -0.07106980681419373, 0.42388132214546204, -0.3277185559272766, -0.6197899580001831, 0.05359410494565964, -0.15071384608745575, -0.4207397997379303, 0.4348142445087433, -0.586953341960907, 0.15676423907279968, -0.42153555154800415, 0.5265809297561646, -0.7127536535263062, -0.5484081506729126, -0.5608826875686646, -0.3744381368160248, 0.24933001399040222, 0.565015435218811, -0.05255556106567383, -0.26419636607170105, 0.29576632380485535, 0.055842116475105286, -0.48289328813552856, -0.43101200461387634, -0.8398596048355103, -0.0903569683432579, 0.23948703706264496, -0.1935274302959442, -1.0095970630645752, -0.5525948405265808, 0.19416074454784393, -0.05038950964808464, 0.1526435911655426, 0.2937315106391907, -0.6735903024673462, -0.060608480125665665, 0.04010367766022682, -0.0071222479455173016, -0.8205962777137756, 0.31219589710235596, -0.3131861090660095, 0.5132337808609009, 0.1463596522808075, 0.5261719822883606, 0.3611975610256195, 1.0199519395828247, -0.6465876698493958, 0.6718078851699829, -0.8186227083206177, 0.4791955351829529, -0.9877954721450806, -0.49139881134033203, -0.3240295350551605, -0.18152466416358948, -0.023988286033272743, 0.05544638633728027, -0.2679758369922638, -0.3796539902687073, -0.4148426651954651, -0.05251869559288025, -0.0821571871638298, -0.5398007035255432, 1.085012435913086, -0.804987370967865, 0.418325811624527, 1.7669720649719238, 0.16039817035198212, -0.18932613730430603, -0.5154303908348083, -0.2077263742685318, -0.789217472076416, 0.7145013213157654, 0.19249455630779266, -0.3412628769874573, -0.5667912364006042, -0.7094959616661072, -0.09750110656023026, -0.34458664059638977, 0.6453672647476196, -0.6618831753730774, -0.3844810128211975, -0.5325816869735718, -0.5029047727584839, -0.29198476672172546, -0.4525035321712494, -1.3550108671188354, -0.29977017641067505, 0.27117109298706055, -0.46492263674736023, 0.13212789595127106, -0.25157278776168823, -0.7048748135566711, -0.5060766935348511, -0.9473883509635925, 0.07921979576349258, -0.12595988810062408, -0.015907857567071915, 1.3040387630462646, -0.15616001188755035, -0.7264816761016846, 0.24830231070518494, -0.007293702568858862, -0.8717131614685059, -0.2761555016040802, 0.15692850947380066, 0.1522613912820816, -1.1093682050704956, 0.5383626818656921, -0.3302885591983795, -0.3506290316581726, -0.0259590782225132, -0.36379867792129517, 0.03242367506027222, 0.7328885197639465, 0.0252210795879364, -0.034981925040483475, 0.6178202629089355, 0.16994813084602356, -1.0555068254470825, -0.21018508076667786, 0.8687447309494019, 0.13997088372707367, -0.12324126809835434, -0.25121670961380005, -0.8191924691200256, -0.7555206418037415, -1.0551717281341553, 0.16802872717380524, -1.2237820625305176, 0.3433745205402374, -0.5423843860626221, -0.315679669380188, -0.13929130136966705, 0.6951037645339966, 0.3053325116634369, 0.10071070492267609, -0.2744545042514801, -0.4226623475551605, 0.9629431366920471, -0.16481684148311615, -0.11740945279598236, -0.2794798016548157, -0.10852666199207306, 0.092274509370327, 1.3740575313568115, 0.280362069606781, -0.3715023100376129, 0.46781811118125916, -0.7107556462287903, 0.7651485204696655, 1.0282484292984009, -0.2417595088481903, -0.2402084916830063, 0.5531017184257507, 0.6434851288795471, -0.03668970614671707, -0.04203353822231293, -0.7444199323654175, -0.045402467250823975, -0.05892705172300339, 0.13251212239265442, -0.39843058586120605, -0.44700753688812256, 0.011613725684583187, 0.0029991110786795616, 1.0805344581604004, -0.5077146291732788, 0.16337263584136963, 0.3873392641544342, -0.6694404482841492, -0.28623515367507935, 0.39153119921684265, -0.49284178018569946, 0.19052214920520782, -0.8447486162185669, -0.954836905002594, 0.09299515932798386, 0.16708679497241974, 0.3186435103416443, 0.6434969305992126, 0.24247945845127106, 0.1333501636981964, -0.5563154816627502, 0.7062312364578247, 0.27561527490615845, -0.4442250728607178, -0.5389680862426758, 0.272628515958786, 0.6429453492164612, -0.2259512096643448, -0.2677462100982666, 0.41964277625083923, -0.2774439752101898, 0.3827895522117615, 0.003153574652969837, -0.6098799109458923, -0.8363285660743713, -0.30799078941345215, 0.37321117520332336, 0.6002637147903442, 0.7348629236221313, 0.23352055251598358, 0.19337183237075806, 0.2954810857772827, -0.3072470724582672, 1.2237311601638794, -0.37153491377830505, 0.2865731418132782, 0.6717493534088135, -0.32873281836509705, -0.17659176886081696, 0.1601049304008484, -0.3491218388080597, -0.4737228453159332, -0.3224668800830841, 0.3984321653842926, 0.7305045127868652, -0.8043099641799927, 0.5329822301864624, 0.7041308283805847, -0.7004625201225281, -0.7977287173271179, -0.2671738564968109, 0.39980822801589966, -0.06101400777697563, -0.5592526197433472, -0.32516443729400635, 0.5269470810890198, -0.4639197587966919, 0.18739478290081024, -0.23162752389907837, 0.013280932791531086, 0.13015282154083252, -0.6506918668746948, -0.24543701112270355, -0.7969154715538025, 0.33630090951919556, 0.640484631061554, -0.11905786395072937, 0.10254455357789993, 0.7099478840827942, 1.2160612344741821, -0.5303609371185303, 0.043546296656131744, 0.6030712127685547, -0.3314778506755829, -0.10521499812602997, -0.5009058713912964, 0.7836177349090576, -0.23951421678066254, 0.18191921710968018, 0.2477850317955017, 1.2613086700439453, 0.4468171298503876, -0.17174214124679565, -0.694083571434021, 0.32184284925460815, 0.45048362016677856, 0.9550200700759888, 0.133961483836174, 0.08443574607372284, 0.8040372729301453, 0.6547160148620605, 0.09014514833688736, -0.344808965921402, -0.34144777059555054, -0.35826918482780457, 0.249324232339859, 0.3994617164134979, -0.7618221044540405, -0.13988086581230164, 1.3967468738555908, -0.48947960138320923, -0.40026986598968506, -0.5786261558532715, 0.8696427941322327, 0.029127852991223335, -0.22136501967906952, -0.6557842493057251, 0.532306969165802, -0.582076907157898, -0.6435666084289551, -0.6881534457206726, -0.5346267223358154, -0.3904852867126465, 0.7363115549087524, -0.21552865207195282, -0.05882344767451286, 0.5314784049987793, 0.41426390409469604, 0.2840069830417633, -0.06080168858170509, -0.749281108379364, -0.31157204508781433, -0.8320648074150085, 0.9144330024719238, 0.5410758852958679, 0.2560146749019623, 1.240332007408142, 0.28036636114120483, 0.9189686179161072, 0.07386939227581024, -0.5416216850280762, -0.9270979762077332, 0.08542567491531372, 0.6046562194824219, -1.0133984088897705, -0.49387338757514954, -0.7229154109954834, 0.8570107221603394, -0.7449834942817688, -0.6396056413650513, -0.5597682595252991, -0.0751604214310646, -0.46532946825027466, 0.9245508909225464, -0.6691514849662781, 0.6216810345649719, 0.7124698162078857, -0.380687415599823, 0.3743707537651062, 0.6150228977203369, 0.23842158913612366, -0.01797790825366974, 0.2731097638607025, -0.16330620646476746, 0.20420785248279572, -0.9947107434272766, 0.2207881063222885, 0.0303563941270113, -0.9936271905899048, 0.48127391934394836, -0.15048924088478088, 0.44542551040649414, -0.05220618098974228, 0.3497442603111267, 0.1847178041934967, 0.09755704551935196, -0.02426433004438877, 0.3858424425125122, -0.2290828377008438, -0.6617262959480286, -1.0660688877105713, -0.5364298820495605, -1.521744728088379, -0.8922309279441833, 0.5376707315444946, -0.4953208565711975, 0.04047640040516853, -0.4862382113933563, -1.0498124361038208, 0.6530980467796326, 0.04774057865142822, 0.25669023394584656, 0.37914222478866577, 0.34301868081092834, 0.2067420333623886, 0.12383585423231125, 0.08983886986970901, 0.31242167949676514, 0.4948056936264038, -0.0123832356184721, -1.0522773265838623, -0.859976053237915, -0.014222587458789349, 0.22825485467910767, -0.07160256057977676, -0.29035425186157227, -0.21351957321166992, -0.09955514222383499, 0.5422458052635193, -0.030020667240023613, 0.10875021666288376, -0.03911910578608513, -0.5848997235298157, 0.07831189036369324, -0.36773958802223206, 0.014297653920948505, -0.6536308526992798, 0.8351393342018127, 0.5535848736763, -0.5778971910476685, -0.16769911348819733, 0.2868783473968506, 0.9500347971916199, -0.20690526068210602, 0.8530901670455933, -0.7441421151161194, 0.7992804646492004, -0.5662822127342224, -0.20962277054786682, 0.6030800342559814, 0.782792866230011, 0.01627538725733757, -0.28333568572998047, -0.23600611090660095, 0.5047667026519775, 0.628677487373352, 0.2644805312156677, -0.5237260460853577, 0.6499987840652466, 0.20870663225650787, 0.3996964395046234, 0.08578097075223923, -0.5007359981536865, -0.008363623172044754, 0.7365043759346008, -0.1985057145357132, 0.04038619250059128, -0.17559197545051575, 0.4168688654899597, -0.7743958234786987, -1.1612155437469482, 0.8406786918640137, -0.3371570110321045, -0.7395946979522705, 0.5397275686264038, 0.6807497143745422, 1.1853268146514893, 0.055620647966861725, 0.3397487699985504, 0.02011408843100071, 0.36397796869277954, -0.36381468176841736, 0.026823436841368675, 0.6002976894378662, -0.3093077540397644, -0.6826702952384949, -0.41912853717803955, 0.6022515892982483, -0.2141052633523941, 0.3010638654232025, 0.3264368772506714, -0.7238177061080933, 0.191900834441185, 0.9505810737609863, -0.19900958240032196, -0.36589810252189636, 0.5403708815574646, -0.441489040851593, -0.1798413097858429, -0.1627771109342575, 0.2656216621398926, -0.5915801525115967, -0.660887598991394, 0.5243819952011108, -0.33196553587913513, 0.4249713122844696, 0.2086225152015686, 0.04885833337903023, 0.9278064966201782, -0.11353165656328201, 0.712088942527771, -0.29408377408981323, 0.5762141942977905, 0.7317996621131897, 0.20109623670578003, -0.06546156108379364, -0.456403911113739, -0.0037463961634784937, -0.036973267793655396, -0.36620405316352844, -0.25020167231559753, 0.0959169790148735, -0.2473263442516327, -0.7484995126724243, 0.7096471190452576, -0.24114109575748444, -0.6917113065719604, -0.5136961340904236, -0.8215522170066833, 0.35778263211250305, 0.15910936892032623, -0.32773858308792114, 0.22218872606754303, 0.289909303188324, -0.2646140158176422, -0.15331847965717316, -0.09197608381509781, -0.9796088933944702, -0.09211809188127518, -0.5725963711738586, 0.8884323835372925, 0.0266873836517334, -0.3812001943588257, -0.7044997811317444, -0.6959505677223206, -0.2922554910182953, -0.24832206964492798, 0.11311618983745575, -0.6663500666618347, -0.17710670828819275, 0.07182827591896057, 0.5452703237533569, 0.2232678383588791, 0.06299154460430145, 0.662137508392334, 0.18047428131103516, 0.7889871597290039, -0.3659508228302002, 0.583914577960968, 0.06020963937044144, 0.449010968208313, -0.12457948923110962, -0.33691173791885376, -0.14969941973686218, -0.26367712020874023, 0.25364914536476135, -0.7546677589416504, 0.3413342237472534, 0.12509307265281677, -0.29999375343322754, 0.6192304491996765, 0.5145511627197266, -0.6892442107200623, -0.6203246712684631, -0.4612451493740082, -0.12407874315977097, -0.2531132996082306, 0.8629664778709412, -0.2765427827835083, -0.12627854943275452, 1.1417213678359985, -0.10493649542331696, 0.34612128138542175, -1.3301417827606201, 3.922273874282837, 1.3747297525405884, 0.6101353764533997, -0.5564291477203369, 0.3465573191642761, 0.6726686358451843, -0.012745914049446583, -0.10490957647562027, 0.14823535084724426, 0.23354372382164001, 0.021693753078579903, 0.9072480797767639, 0.3640294671058655, -0.3689158856868744, 0.6285616755485535, 0.383857786655426, -1.4089407920837402, 0.21450017392635345, 0.169026717543602, -0.8700879812240601, -0.5484052300453186, 0.1771477609872818, -0.052171461284160614, -0.2803075313568115, 0.3281130790710449, 0.2852374017238617, 0.25675272941589355, 0.33370813727378845, -0.4181045889854431, -0.09883522242307663, 0.26495975255966187, -0.6643897891044617, 0.05381873995065689, -0.3993951678276062, -0.5519422888755798, 0.6952795386314392, -0.1479969322681427, -0.46516120433807373, -0.7007067203521729, -0.0823737233877182, 0.31774359941482544, -0.6982576847076416, -0.6447651386260986, -0.22830884158611298, -0.4082707166671753, 0.3689466118812561, -0.27109676599502563, 0.40776053071022034, 0.4444982707500458, -0.7106572985649109, 0.6630929112434387, -0.7548048496246338, 0.2501468360424042, -0.47055482864379883, -0.9426866769790649, -0.1073024794459343, -0.34980738162994385, -0.9525384902954102, -0.10358671844005585, 0.10847736895084381, -0.17883145809173584, -0.2879665791988373, -0.38559070229530334, 0.24188514053821564, 0.15738098323345184, 0.45779046416282654, 0.26863807439804077, 0.3583154082298279, -0.4660186469554901, -0.16332270205020905, -0.03431803733110428, -0.4156382381916046, -0.9227173924446106, 0.27581799030303955, 0.5130702257156372, 0.3879723846912384, -0.08197978138923645, 0.370265394449234, -0.483095645904541, -1.0170642137527466, -0.01032344065606594, 0.059032175689935684, 0.16015560925006866, -0.8284196257591248, 0.24923953413963318, 1.1528422832489014, -0.5080284476280212, -0.5997515320777893, -1.4285969734191895, 0.3960763216018677, 0.20882202684879303, -0.08334099501371384, -0.1341334730386734, 0.3107686936855316, -0.02902604453265667 ]
{"Title": "A Genome-Wide Association Study of the Frailty Index Highlights Synaptic Pathways in Aging", "Authors": "Atkins Janice L, Jylh\u00e4v\u00e4 Juulia, Pedersen Nancy L, Magnusson Patrik K, Lu Yi, Wang Yunzhang, H\u00e4gg Sara, Melzer David, Williams Dylan M, Pilling Luke C", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Frailty is a common geriatric syndrome, strongly associated with disability, mortality and hospitalisation. The mechanisms underlying frailty are multifactorial and not well understood, but a genetic basis has been suggested with heritability estimates between 19 and 45%. Understanding the genetic determinants and biological mechanisms underpinning frailty may help to delay or even prevent frailty. We performed a genome-wide association study (GWAS) of a frailty index (FI) in European descent participants from UK Biobank ( n =164,610, aged 60-70 years). FI calculation was based on 49 self-reported items on symptoms, disabilities and diagnosed diseases. We identified 26 independent genetic signals at 24 loci associated with the FI ( p <5*10 \u22128 ). Many of these loci have previously been associated with traits such as body mass index, cardiovascular disease, smoking, HLA proteins, depression and neuroticism; however, three appear to be novel. The estimated single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) heritability of the FI was 14% (0.14, SE 0.006). A genetic risk score for the FI, derived solely from the UK Biobank data, was significantly associated with FI in the Swedish TwinGene study ( n =10,616, beta: 0.11, 95% CI: 0.02-0.20, p =0.015). In pathway analysis, genes associated with synapse function were significantly enriched ( p <3*10 \u22126 ). We also used Mendelian randomization to identify modifiable traits and exposures that may affect the risk of frailty, with a higher educational attainment genetic risk score being associated with a lower risk of frailty. Risk of frailty is influenced by many genetic factors, including well-known disease risk factors and mental health, with particular emphasis on synapse maintenance pathways.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007559"}
10.1101/19002485
[ 0.07451309263706207, 0.7814751267433167, -0.2782934904098511, -0.23508833348751068, -0.3345288038253784, -0.8743141293525696, -0.682820737361908, 0.40676331520080566, -0.383796364068985, 0.8032011985778809, -0.012295396067202091, -0.2066599726676941, 0.22730140388011932, 0.5742771625518799, -0.545093834400177, -0.22696343064308167, -0.7158352732658386, -0.8086854219436646, 0.4265430271625519, 0.4454127252101898, -0.28497907519340515, 0.8040701150894165, -1.249037742614746, -0.904388427734375, -0.516423761844635, 0.39203646779060364, 0.072154700756073, -0.7578071355819702, 1.660047173500061, 0.9321767687797546, 0.5300388336181641, -0.16013918817043304, 0.19752369821071625, -1.282594084739685, -0.2653023898601532, -0.20914699137210846, 0.35510438680648804, 0.04594602808356285, -0.16909515857696533, -0.630680501461029, 1.2796227931976318, -0.12539725005626678, 0.4336082935333252, -0.4233837425708771, -0.4788649082183838, -0.22781799733638763, -0.0102792177349329, 0.9003403186798096, -0.021579863503575325, 0.06033657118678093, 0.31658533215522766, 0.47550928592681885, 0.12835456430912018, -0.5341095924377441, -0.4374849200248718, 0.2844242751598358, -0.33061474561691284, 0.031013160943984985, -0.6029320955276489, 0.26658740639686584, -0.358205646276474, 0.22042842209339142, 0.553413987159729, -0.53497713804245, 0.20232148468494415, 0.7821832895278931, -0.06484880298376083, 0.09350692480802536, -0.41020530462265015, -0.05387665331363678, -0.43691113591194153, -0.7548327445983887, -0.8034372925758362, -0.8262852430343628, -0.7996808290481567, 0.22845874726772308, -0.16525596380233765, -0.7528291940689087, -0.943037748336792, -0.11758560687303543, -0.0705232322216034, 0.6205705404281616, 0.07918412983417511, -0.15854710340499878, -0.7202180027961731, 0.08747643232345581, 0.11869927495718002, -0.33484044671058655, 0.8205177783966064, 1.0643322467803955, -0.22060070931911469, 0.11750887334346771, 0.4122782349586487, -0.2469555139541626, -0.16429325938224792, 0.7736896276473999, 0.2129112333059311, 0.25264647603034973, -0.17940831184387207, 0.21825352311134338, 1.0705225467681885, 0.9049041867256165, 0.18031449615955353, 1.1598235368728638, -0.674562931060791, 0.832928478717804, 0.5672394037246704, -0.03285103663802147, -0.5416610240936279, -0.828148365020752, -0.33069175481796265, -0.05471479520201683, -0.9554466605186462, -0.2938709259033203, 0.9893296957015991, -0.12327761948108673, 0.02666359394788742, 0.6677256226539612, -0.39149925112724304, 0.7431768178939819, -0.5787526369094849, 0.17783896625041962, 0.6236754059791565, 0.14934100210666656, 0.02636202611029148, -0.474901020526886, 0.1217045858502388, 0.4786522686481476, -0.5023143887519836, 0.1677197366952896, -0.008753238245844841, -0.9119270443916321, -0.7697621583938599, 1.2589452266693115, -0.3887130320072174, 0.1411937177181244, 0.66765958070755, 1.1610498428344727, 1.3453731536865234, -0.043683700263500214, 0.06350734829902649, 0.23673509061336517, -0.5870932340621948, 1.0522441864013672, -0.2841084897518158, 0.6584868431091309, -0.2822279632091522, -0.8143231868743896, -0.5591424107551575, -0.040981926023960114, -0.1291063278913498, 0.44468003511428833, -0.43268269300460815, 0.0001282625598832965, 0.612092137336731, 0.09624908119440079, -0.4864928424358368, 0.3315560221672058, -0.1787354052066803, -0.31827908754348755, -0.6417441964149475, -0.06408179551362991, -0.2023913413286209, 0.7046935558319092, -1.0355271100997925, -0.018901122733950615, -0.774926483631134, 0.5151363015174866, -0.25882333517074585, -0.3922175467014313, 1.1296875476837158, -0.02708832174539566, -0.0013656294904649258, 0.45992857217788696, 0.6927481293678284, 0.7054854035377502, 0.3767869472503662, -0.4707695543766022, 1.222834587097168, 0.15575820207595825, 0.45057836174964905, 0.7580362558364868, 0.012829373590648174, 0.5250720977783203, 0.6531155109405518, 0.006507436744868755, -0.3879576325416565, -0.19064754247665405, 0.06760700047016144, -0.34799450635910034, -0.19423411786556244, 0.30965471267700195, -0.7208625674247742, 0.32505345344543457, 0.011291193775832653, 0.1458221673965454, 0.32276803255081177, 0.1894836127758026, -0.16029863059520721, -0.013445263728499413, 0.0005013126647099853, 0.467697411775589, -0.9470515251159668, 0.3281412124633789, -0.45729073882102966, 1.3232101202011108, 0.2640588581562042, 0.39081913232803345, -0.7988036274909973, 0.30582529306411743, 0.5391591191291809, -0.68300861120224, -0.4801074266433716, 0.12447025626897812, 0.7256900072097778, 0.16690006852149963, -0.4044193923473358, 0.2217261642217636, -0.5945402979850769, -0.5980923175811768, -0.3782254755496979, -0.8342254757881165, 0.6564056277275085, -0.1600499004125595, -0.15999285876750946, 0.12711898982524872, -0.1034407988190651, 0.41936275362968445, -0.8258727788925171, 0.15324826538562775, 0.10389970988035202, 0.014163502492010593, -0.1536114513874054, 1.1119004487991333, 0.30513304471969604, 0.04195982590317726, -0.014757981523871422, 0.43505093455314636, 0.06836478412151337, -0.11830387264490128, 1.1769415140151978, 0.1342371106147766, 0.5198239088058472, -0.32827988266944885, -0.8764054179191589, 0.571138858795166, -0.7064090371131897, -0.012398305349051952, -0.27750569581985474, 0.2356099933385849, 0.11933457851409912, 0.21798868477344513, 0.1832476705312729, 0.2901054620742798, -0.6262322664260864, 0.11267546564340591, 0.06269831955432892, -0.6819608807563782, -0.5396366715431213, -0.31296488642692566, -0.09566482156515121, 0.12192632257938385, 0.04995235800743103, -0.024846388027071953, 0.9516354203224182, 1.3586543798446655, 0.5198156833648682, -0.2317764163017273, 0.08478368818759918, -0.6037848591804504, -1.0914931297302246, 0.06988724321126938, -0.6907637715339661, -0.5469241142272949, -0.4307376444339752, -0.13975393772125244, 0.4451028108596802, -1.0536723136901855, 0.6270435452461243, -0.21439796686172485, 0.36572152376174927, 0.3427310287952423, -0.12629170715808868, 0.017726914957165718, 0.19153636693954468, -0.759425938129425, -0.48685410618782043, 0.5783601999282837, 0.19115470349788666, 0.11815501004457474, 0.042589545249938965, 0.2912633419036865, -0.5815514922142029, -0.6228944659233093, 0.8493427038192749, -0.03917833790183067, 0.6548421382904053, 0.5738281011581421, -0.7832366228103638, 0.24395348131656647, -0.023631654679775238, 0.5659617185592651, 0.749829888343811, -0.04114865884184837, -0.8725029826164246, 0.5522111058235168, -0.019192134961485863, 0.1171661838889122, 0.671661376953125, 0.229690819978714, -1.0372416973114014, 0.14585505425930023, -0.6097843647003174, 0.27626609802246094, -0.9256723523139954, 0.24138884246349335, 0.2768196165561676, -0.22915349900722504, 0.008126236498355865, -0.7388044595718384, -0.8182880878448486, 0.2238173484802246, 0.13410526514053345, -0.03256509453058243, 0.11280325055122375, 0.4335615634918213, -0.2764434814453125, -1.623703956604004, 0.06843309104442596, -0.31183061003685, -0.4835219085216522, -0.061993420124053955, -0.4665302336215973, 0.0012115961872041225, 0.17972508072853088, -0.5404751896858215, -0.47098201513290405, -0.01662118174135685, 0.25027644634246826, -0.31956908106803894, 0.32199209928512573, -0.04314080625772476, 0.11841893196105957, 0.5125568509101868, -0.43095988035202026, 0.3872111737728119, 0.6478215456008911, -0.4771807789802551, 0.20878705382347107, -0.14040623605251312, 0.15862444043159485, 0.3784772455692291, 0.7837409973144531, -0.5655985474586487, 0.014563402161002159, 1.0102468729019165, -0.3225296139717102, 0.26625388860702515, 0.05127408355474472, -0.4247492551803589, 0.5416437387466431, 0.012370712123811245, -0.45394018292427063, 0.1669078767299652, -0.7283198833465576, -0.5597189664840698, 0.8842316269874573, 0.30129534006118774, 0.19750352203845978, -0.07434040307998657, 0.3678276538848877, -0.13543708622455597, -0.51827073097229, 0.017819402739405632, 0.46724405884742737, 0.5861109495162964, 0.4819243848323822, 1.0570756196975708, 0.8186073303222656, -0.9995930194854736, -0.3600779175758362, 0.5853963494300842, 0.9938708543777466, 0.40231582522392273, -0.47635921835899353, 1.1843901872634888, -0.4593302607536316, 0.1498507708311081, 0.664381206035614, -0.3109051287174225, -0.5934496521949768, -0.545915961265564, -0.3163612484931946, -0.07670670747756958, -0.39378342032432556, -0.6305288076400757, 0.13936275243759155, 0.432834267616272, 0.5369042158126831, -0.25538769364356995, 0.9503292441368103, -0.7137860059738159, 0.07343892753124237, 0.21460118889808655, 0.38706204295158386, 0.42209818959236145, -0.5949954986572266, 0.1598784178495407, -0.6035700440406799, -0.48302915692329407, -0.06680050492286682, -0.49767231941223145, 0.029331862926483154, 0.15792283415794373, 0.14654575288295746, -0.19609390199184418, -0.6921417117118835, -0.08915510773658752, -0.2007385790348053, -0.30278125405311584, 0.4504341781139374, 0.2617601454257965, -0.1925330013036728, 0.10584376007318497, 0.4752025008201599, -0.6669135689735413, 0.10149132460355759, -1.403171181678772, 1.1603440046310425, 0.648764967918396, 0.07687236368656158, -0.5112916827201843, -0.4369683563709259, -0.17721450328826904, -0.5078982710838318, 0.16505104303359985, 0.6018708348274231, -0.8204219341278076, 0.5377342700958252, -1.153841257095337, -0.1767141968011856, -0.10221224278211594, -0.37899255752563477, -0.5371658802032471, -0.4324675500392914, -0.2960193455219269, 0.7456604838371277, 0.7723934054374695, -0.015964794903993607, -0.0534551702439785, 0.1231364756822586, -0.21327224373817444, 0.25328025221824646, -1.017293930053711, -0.4768052399158478, -0.6825180053710938, -0.41977089643478394, -0.13307060301303864, -0.026878243312239647, -0.2062259465456009, -0.9182664752006531, -0.5878841280937195, -0.0556228831410408, -1.3141087293624878, -0.31267011165618896, 0.7873967289924622, 0.1381460577249527, 0.3465832769870758, 0.6355704069137573, -0.634423017501831, 0.10852515697479248, -0.4728713035583496, 0.3899378478527069, -0.3409227430820465, 0.26779255270957947, -0.02390834502875805, -0.14899791777133942, 0.6112114191055298, -0.781417727470398, 0.6071415543556213, -0.5389467477798462, -0.5429867506027222, -0.47014912962913513, 0.049769673496484756, -1.019813895225525, -0.6397236585617065, 0.3091897964477539, 0.7234370112419128, -1.0923945903778076, 0.8400712013244629, -0.10272867977619171, -0.040498048067092896, 0.1893651932477951, 0.1197534054517746, -0.4176628291606903, -0.07027268409729004, 0.3260597586631775, -0.20193131268024445, 0.3906073570251465, -0.1339603215456009, 1.1442378759384155, -0.16795560717582703, -1.2317477464675903, -0.006941604893654585, 0.09934692084789276, -0.14770828187465668, -0.6070676445960999, -0.5119518041610718, -0.6697354316711426, -0.5441790819168091, -0.43323737382888794, 0.13228672742843628, -0.4548753499984741, 0.12854351103305817, -0.011781588196754456, -0.10593254119157791, 0.6558430790901184, -0.5721477270126343, 0.11103156208992004, -0.120995432138443, -0.22921304404735565, -0.5622849464416504, -0.37821948528289795, 0.5416460633277893, -0.27841976284980774, -0.002524596406146884, 0.20442719757556915, -1.1382434368133545, 0.010606199502944946, -0.9747546911239624, 0.1892830729484558, -1.0579663515090942, 0.6816666722297668, -0.15182335674762726, -0.04855350777506828, -0.402694433927536, 0.319172203540802, 0.049167439341545105, -0.03361999988555908, -0.38804274797439575, -0.7022547125816345, 0.33798232674598694, -0.09459131211042404, -0.07138680666685104, 0.11589348316192627, -0.926579475402832, -0.07156960666179657, 0.7724414467811584, -0.2930524945259094, -1.1704598665237427, -0.14504727721214294, 0.536536455154419, 0.023623988032341003, 0.6256405711174011, -0.6065154075622559, 0.16212821006774902, 0.3421823978424072, 0.5429962277412415, -0.31401681900024414, -0.12051862478256226, -0.7287845611572266, 0.7502124905586243, -0.23896579444408417, 0.26247310638427734, -0.14392520487308502, -0.14007364213466644, 0.5087305307388306, -0.46083441376686096, 1.099974274635315, -0.026491781696677208, 0.9558528661727905, -0.34977957606315613, -0.03658965229988098, 0.736112117767334, -0.17094315588474274, -0.8517940044403076, -0.05595078691840172, -0.7931905388832092, -0.6357370018959045, 0.5647813677787781, 0.03393799439072609, -0.040934376418590546, 0.24623386561870575, -0.6322482228279114, 0.03413859009742737, -0.12835417687892914, 0.6249024868011475, 1.1094378232955933, -0.6119897365570068, 0.31907594203948975, 0.22522957623004913, 0.32768377661705017, -0.4499334692955017, 0.891011655330658, 0.529951274394989, 0.299705445766449, 0.17468111217021942, 0.33397936820983887, -0.5991156697273254, -0.8896672129631042, -0.9353457689285278, 0.8689309358596802, 0.39149948954582214, -0.47627779841423035, 0.3592173457145691, -0.3594149053096771, -0.45138007402420044, 0.19635836780071259, 0.7495564818382263, 0.38820680975914, 0.14888644218444824, 0.9178997278213501, 0.6889124512672424, -0.6230593323707581, -0.38542723655700684, -0.2729080021381378, -0.015262404456734657, 0.2878226637840271, 0.6762214303016663, 0.06992293894290924, -0.5812548995018005, 0.2224586457014084, 0.662132740020752, -0.39029181003570557, -0.6367928385734558, -0.2814863622188568, -0.23489691317081451, 0.4032922387123108, -0.036131132394075394, -0.17325055599212646, 0.38042330741882324, -0.6505148410797119, 0.7568100094795227, -0.2831270098686218, 0.14903932809829712, 0.5311864614486694, -0.10287263989448547, 0.3987730145454407, -0.14125534892082214, 0.6209223866462708, 0.5305034518241882, -0.6304885745048523, -0.20800559222698212, -0.007094648201018572, -0.440146803855896, 0.7290604710578918, 0.28929147124290466, 0.4638596773147583, -0.2955796420574188, 0.3854522705078125, 0.6233688592910767, 0.0965971127152443, 0.35177361965179443, -0.27877718210220337, 0.3409839868545532, 0.44434964656829834, -0.4115520119667053, -0.740612268447876, -0.4181932210922241, 0.5709616541862488, -0.1378745436668396, 0.013121620751917362, 0.9702651500701904, 0.36059996485710144, 0.21619826555252075, 0.11327797919511795, -0.31738537549972534, -0.39659273624420166, -0.5389834046363831, -0.7752886414527893, -0.3643277883529663, -0.44616249203681946, 0.432304322719574, 0.6355732679367065, 0.11288098245859146, -0.4701550304889679, -0.17189006507396698, -0.14078257977962494, 0.5252618789672852, -0.5790664553642273, 0.5912385582923889, -0.054009631276130676, -0.2968682050704956, -0.8392593264579773, -1.0045441389083862, -0.5167644619941711, -1.15859055519104, -0.0017663710750639439, 0.6314407587051392, -0.70378178358078, 0.3975614309310913, -0.8166895508766174, 1.0393168926239014, 0.472242534160614, 0.07304646819829941, -0.4595967233181, -0.5501013994216919, -0.4307418167591095, 0.6849029660224915, -0.002933127572759986, 0.26522138714790344, 0.4613782465457916, -0.42581403255462646, 0.11575409770011902, 0.03617437556385994, 0.036769840866327286, 0.4863453507423401, 0.20547422766685486, 0.7605563402175903, -0.5382363796234131, 0.012690281495451927, -0.3425463140010834, 0.861253559589386, -1.0411674976348877, 0.06268366426229477, -0.39565613865852356, 0.5463699698448181, 0.589397668838501, 0.11220790445804596, -0.34296858310699463, 0.5629661083221436, 0.0028524554800242186, 1.2843819856643677, 0.09617207944393158, 0.6302345395088196, 0.6111984848976135, 0.0927804559469223, 0.16946306824684143, 0.3997938930988312, 0.21922074258327484, -1.1447815895080566, 0.13353091478347778, -0.15967699885368347, 0.1463889479637146, 0.35151082277297974, -0.18989284336566925, 0.6046597361564636, -0.29265356063842773, -0.1491006761789322, -0.19775447249412537, 0.5747584104537964, 0.559773325920105, 0.8848677277565002, 0.11640159785747528, -0.20534534752368927, -0.3339563012123108, -0.4063701033592224, -1.2706087827682495, 0.05601518228650093, 0.2467871755361557, -0.6967484354972839, -0.2519059181213379, -0.625965416431427, -0.6932929158210754, -0.2871927320957184, 0.4195038080215454, 0.3216877579689026, 0.31944143772125244, 0.2601373493671417, -0.2945549786090851, 0.9589224457740784, -0.4415404200553894, -0.1056443378329277, -0.2323131263256073, 0.26582100987434387, -0.8571444749832153, -0.6556634306907654, -0.3236752152442932, 0.33553776144981384, -0.30620118975639343, -0.32891711592674255, -0.46185019612312317, 0.5304625630378723, -0.4268358647823334, -0.2712266445159912, -0.8730839490890503, 0.3540057837963104, -1.1168899536132812, -0.5670848488807678, 0.4756583273410797, -0.5826217532157898, 0.16036145389080048, 0.1132354661822319, -0.07423243671655655, -0.4594423472881317, -0.8048035502433777, 0.11959279328584671, 0.4054867625236511, -0.17755645513534546, 0.14518563449382782, -0.2882102429866791, 1.1208146810531616, -0.24631263315677643, 0.0317484512925148, 0.06428106874227524, 0.33306223154067993, -0.2643457055091858, -0.04480833560228348, 0.5923362374305725, 0.6820136904716492, 0.3936910927295685, -0.27108415961265564, -0.7649495005607605, -0.06008711829781532, 0.12201454490423203, -0.6887900829315186, 0.4445662200450897, -0.7266998887062073, 0.8823720812797546, 0.01071003545075655, -0.0804343894124031, -0.06425339728593826, 0.24792303144931793, 0.8571367263793945, 0.3490116596221924, -1.0114938020706177, 0.3463252782821655, -0.7237853407859802, -0.40448325872421265, 0.21950839459896088, 0.20222336053848267, 1.2157313823699951, 0.035608477890491486, 0.0009207644034177065, 1.0006825923919678, 1.023432970046997, 0.44063398241996765, -0.37311726808547974, -0.02374323271214962, -0.4846227169036865, 0.21583658456802368, 0.34409451484680176, 0.39641237258911133, -0.7571617960929871, 0.07383941113948822, 0.12719935178756714, -0.9255002737045288, -0.12914256751537323, 0.1892968863248825, -0.9779070615768433, 0.1660880744457245, 0.35525238513946533, -0.27576032280921936, -0.15341725945472717, -0.3292371332645416, 0.4407638609409332, -0.2015095055103302, -0.03956206142902374, 0.23444652557373047, 0.03319532424211502, 0.2449323832988739, 0.46726253628730774, 0.8721883296966553, 0.4090800881385803, 0.7810564041137695, -0.060297396034002304, -0.12645398080348969, 0.24327519536018372, 0.7707110643386841, 0.10632944107055664, -0.15653479099273682, -0.27595406770706177, -0.13073456287384033, -0.17806921899318695, -0.3053225576877594, -0.34030717611312866, 0.46447306871414185, -0.15349948406219482, -1.0231549739837646, -0.2707633376121521, 0.07698392122983932, -0.5823142528533936, -0.5870054960250854, -0.15808402001857758, -0.23007914423942566, 0.6317814588546753, -1.1713366508483887, 0.8120867013931274, 0.18014411628246307, 0.1705823540687561, 0.21670834720134735, 0.3950938582420349, -0.6867608428001404, -0.07511694729328156, -1.044199824333191, -0.19395220279693604, 0.08697761595249176, -0.009325257502496243, 0.16613523662090302, -1.1154030561447144, 0.42918673157691956, -0.22897373139858246, -0.3070768415927887, -0.060103509575128555, 0.43232476711273193, 1.130756139755249, 1.2098804712295532, 0.8580962419509888, 0.2490469515323639, -0.00779498228803277, 0.42647507786750793, 0.8853687644004822, 0.24323798716068268, -0.08755147457122803, -0.3834937810897827, 0.4679080843925476, -0.09555438160896301, -0.4267856776714325, 0.8127989768981934, -0.08805317431688309, -0.39615505933761597, -0.6126784086227417, 0.3415363132953644, -0.15332767367362976, -0.5328086018562317, 0.37978067994117737, 0.5292938947677612, -0.015948548913002014, -0.5609477162361145, -0.33543479442596436, -0.45491862297058105, -0.737473726272583, 0.5792129039764404, -0.5220189094543457, -0.0810699388384819, 0.8756712675094604, -0.1763170212507248, -0.0969737246632576, -0.3601369559764862, 4.03099250793457, 0.9993457794189453, 0.4497084617614746, -0.2553815543651581, 1.6854653358459473, 0.5965872406959534, 0.1821756511926651, -0.0539240762591362, 0.16147765517234802, -0.11743399500846863, 0.25812071561813354, 0.37620943784713745, 0.41220951080322266, 0.0808580219745636, 0.7158713340759277, -0.010354445315897465, -0.5838828682899475, 0.6110444068908691, -0.43174979090690613, -0.4433049261569977, -1.5207369327545166, 0.3916095197200775, -0.21156802773475647, 0.4004550576210022, 0.5296481847763062, 0.1644437462091446, 0.3363262414932251, -0.1968633234500885, -0.14890596270561218, -0.30296608805656433, -0.11789121478796005, -0.18012963235378265, -0.3248254656791687, -0.3908638656139374, -0.9572762846946716, 0.636421263217926, 0.48007991909980774, -0.6461441516876221, -0.7650021314620972, -0.03128497302532196, 0.041859015822410583, 0.42203348875045776, -0.2268131524324417, -0.0951937586069107, -0.6117701530456543, -0.14669334888458252, -0.34176862239837646, -0.4764985144138336, 0.7218082547187805, -0.17548128962516785, 0.17361924052238464, -0.9744848608970642, 0.8167639970779419, -0.30782124400138855, -0.8745134472846985, 0.019233113154768944, 0.061323340982198715, -1.0999764204025269, 0.3082915246486664, 0.17513856291770935, 0.48113173246383667, -0.6253857016563416, 0.26285651326179504, 0.14077946543693542, 0.3476097881793976, 0.14936064183712006, -0.45930543541908264, -0.008448382839560509, -0.031108632683753967, 0.02759578637778759, -0.11717954277992249, -0.3950728178024292, -0.49450695514678955, -0.5164108276367188, 0.5663976073265076, 0.10879040509462357, 0.008780881762504578, 0.5513358116149902, -0.2066875845193863, -0.8341259360313416, 0.4178008437156677, -0.11033037304878235, 0.2968370318412781, -0.27819597721099854, -0.20838534832000732, 0.42206650972366333, 0.013177174143493176, -0.001989551819860935, -0.24323038756847382, 0.5444166660308838, 0.9121838808059692, 0.13501285016536713, -0.10824756324291229, 0.9481406807899475, 0.16555361449718475 ]
{"Title": "Considerations in the deployment of novel universal vaccines against epidemic and pandemic influenza", "Authors": "Arinaminpathy N, Riley S, Barclay W.S, Saad-Roy C, Grenfell B", "Abstract": "Abstract There is increasing interest in the development of new, \u2018universal\u2019 influenza vaccines (UIV) that - unlike current vaccines - are effective against a broad range of seasonal influenza strains, as well as against novel pandemic viruses. Even where these vaccines do not block infection, they can moderate clinical severity, reducing morbidity and mortality while potentially also reducing opportunities for transmission. Previous modelling studies have illustrated the potential epidemiological benefits of UIVs, including their potential to mitigate pandemic burden. However, these new vaccines could shape population immunity in complex ways. Here, using mathematical models of influenza transmission, we illustrate two types of unintended consequences that could arise from their future deployment. First, by reducing the amount of infection-induced immunity in a population without fully replacing it, a seasonal UIV programme may permit larger pandemics than in the absence of vaccination. Second, the more successful a future UIV programme is in reducing transmission of seasonal influenza, the more vulnerable the population could become to the emergence of a vaccine-escape variant. These risks could be mitigated by optimal deployment of any future UIV vaccine: namely, the use of a combined vaccine formulation (incorporating conventional as well as multiple universal antigenic targets), and by achieving sufficient population coverage to compensate for reductions in infection-induced immunity. As early candidates of UIVs approach advanced clinical trials, there is a need to monitor their characteristics in such a way that is focused on their potential impact. This work offers a first step in this direction.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002485"}
10.1101/19010413
[ 0.13758353888988495, -0.25800660252571106, -0.4131457805633545, -0.24187423288822174, -0.1748945415019989, -1.0897424221038818, 0.17077405750751495, 0.3338381350040436, 0.5547196269035339, 0.8073180317878723, 0.2533402740955353, -0.4752064347267151, 0.18986894190311432, -0.2684480845928192, -0.32328474521636963, 0.12063528597354889, -0.2021210640668869, 0.2657485604286194, -0.8712593913078308, 0.15046268701553345, 0.31509071588516235, 1.0029422044754028, -0.5886072516441345, -0.35706406831741333, -0.9788175821304321, 0.25699102878570557, 0.28975340723991394, 0.21963246166706085, 1.0973587036132812, 0.5756130218505859, 0.08124633878469467, -0.5401779413223267, 0.14926287531852722, -0.9357441067695618, -0.021226532757282257, -0.21124720573425293, 0.2029026448726654, -0.9132649898529053, -0.2985152304172516, -0.12887145578861237, 0.11403167992830276, 0.24411214888095856, 0.907911479473114, -0.8865475058555603, -0.3076319992542267, -0.432940274477005, -0.03292455896735191, -0.3842351734638214, -0.43348824977874756, 0.22591985762119293, -0.10202804207801819, 0.18955767154693604, 0.48587435483932495, -0.35060441493988037, 0.3776378929615021, -0.38872167468070984, 0.229440376162529, 0.07278350740671158, -0.5743340253829956, -0.3689728081226349, 0.3233175277709961, -0.3213208317756653, 0.20938611030578613, -0.8217304944992065, 0.48865631222724915, 0.6525281667709351, 0.18725930154323578, 0.13366015255451202, -0.13718976080417633, -0.5117573142051697, -0.6570284366607666, 0.0876360833644867, -0.31835654377937317, -0.49798572063446045, 0.3413773775100708, -0.38405516743659973, -0.07179642468690872, 0.25174686312675476, -0.15191571414470673, -0.0895162895321846, 0.2779480516910553, 0.5230614542961121, -0.44650688767433167, 0.453228622674942, -0.41743889451026917, -0.7935047149658203, 0.6980873346328735, 0.40819084644317627, 0.31544944643974304, -0.1974199116230011, -0.08718952536582947, 0.11660631000995636, 0.4595300257205963, 0.5339895486831665, 0.5699388980865479, 0.5087778568267822, -0.21005721390247345, -0.3219950199127197, 0.4223387837409973, -0.24532432854175568, 0.5893648862838745, 0.7999453544616699, -0.19982069730758667, 1.116443157196045, -0.8259637951850891, 0.41280901432037354, 1.123595952987671, -0.17875316739082336, -0.08996407687664032, -1.483704686164856, 0.09417497366666794, 0.30440783500671387, -0.35452038049697876, -0.10770203918218613, -0.21666587889194489, 0.4976101517677307, -0.4673806130886078, 0.5197949409484863, -0.4716568887233734, -0.04248815029859543, -0.5375379920005798, 0.1420009732246399, 0.36273834109306335, -0.6357631683349609, 0.7457097172737122, -0.1072603091597557, 0.456321120262146, 0.8064998388290405, -0.17373371124267578, -0.027862535789608955, 0.13187304139137268, -0.7860378623008728, -0.1437102109193802, 0.6622037291526794, -0.5675262808799744, -0.756247341632843, 0.29073089361190796, 0.585737407207489, 0.11231715232133865, -0.4234604239463806, -0.9412841200828552, 0.5547956824302673, -0.21024958789348602, 1.3128578662872314, -0.5946425199508667, 0.9214845299720764, -0.32765811681747437, -0.832778811454773, -0.0001404834329150617, 0.30788859724998474, -0.09631820768117905, 0.6567070484161377, -0.0029335462022572756, -0.14854851365089417, -0.23388680815696716, -0.10307048261165619, -0.47509047389030457, 0.006492996588349342, -0.07140614092350006, 0.04939334839582443, -0.15180692076683044, -0.17346341907978058, -0.2873331606388092, 1.1847038269042969, -0.23387275636196136, 1.0040464401245117, -1.0000238418579102, 0.03555871173739433, -0.09600255638360977, -0.41764113306999207, 0.7933823466300964, 0.13597723841667175, -0.3008599579334259, 0.6328611373901367, 0.2522103488445282, 1.2108097076416016, 1.0521092414855957, 0.2064937949180603, 0.7572527527809143, 0.29311230778694153, 0.16696512699127197, -0.5100185871124268, 0.41897428035736084, 0.7178558111190796, 0.026286717504262924, -0.17790737748146057, -0.267142653465271, -0.7583128809928894, -0.05970925837755203, 0.08788756281137466, 0.2067105770111084, 0.2195959985256195, -0.9636671543121338, 0.806466817855835, 0.12134388834238052, -0.08065573871135712, -0.3028494119644165, 0.33996090292930603, 0.7438122034072876, -0.4691562354564667, 0.19229798018932343, 0.9346915483474731, -0.4056011438369751, 0.29046714305877686, -0.24034535884857178, 0.49943915009498596, -0.08246979862451553, 0.43403592705726624, 0.020748233422636986, -0.013058525510132313, 0.3650936782360077, 0.3362216651439667, -0.9474525451660156, -0.1531316339969635, 0.7067035436630249, -0.5759994387626648, -0.4326351284980774, -0.23836708068847656, 0.12698279321193695, -0.5744125843048096, -0.25657784938812256, 0.12358852475881577, 0.046863067895174026, -0.12410850077867508, -0.15489338338375092, -0.44932639598846436, 0.6414790749549866, 0.1744987815618515, -0.7337334156036377, -0.19390755891799927, 0.5059715509414673, 0.6902826428413391, -0.4282350242137909, 0.3722701072692871, 0.6131037473678589, 0.7622571587562561, 0.34367015957832336, 0.5001200437545776, 0.16019704937934875, 0.6085940003395081, 0.22722728550434113, 0.3338780999183655, 1.161497950553894, 0.7958319783210754, -0.2368030846118927, 0.5832343697547913, -0.26040253043174744, -0.1304236203432083, -0.26883551478385925, 0.05551508814096451, -0.5456662774085999, 0.9650424122810364, 0.5118382573127747, 0.3632689118385315, -1.3759453296661377, 0.037835802882909775, 0.6437438130378723, 0.33195048570632935, -0.03131239861249924, -0.7506680488586426, -0.5533232688903809, 0.5303623080253601, 0.23490247130393982, -0.1630769520998001, 1.0776100158691406, 0.43837934732437134, 0.19737590849399567, 0.22988833487033844, -0.20646482706069946, -0.0019033352145925164, -0.5509546399116516, -1.2740168571472168, -1.4281010627746582, -0.6568500995635986, -0.7433978319168091, -0.15863007307052612, -0.15574660897254944, -0.46557730436325073, 0.18714208900928497, -0.14294838905334473, 0.5455837249755859, -0.47188329696655273, -0.04622016102075577, 0.36363908648490906, 0.4175397753715515, 0.170320525765419, -1.0385345220565796, 0.21069590747356415, -0.5693479776382446, 0.0631173625588417, 0.1303105354309082, -0.4789730906486511, 0.35245802998542786, -0.9957209825515747, 0.39628615975379944, -0.9445158243179321, 0.14473548531532288, -0.2512584924697876, -0.7946898341178894, -0.2811393439769745, 0.4820043444633484, 0.05628880858421326, -0.11441534012556076, -0.16785359382629395, -0.9118373394012451, 0.5889246463775635, 0.23327937722206116, -0.030204730108380318, 0.1225367859005928, 0.3035160303115845, -0.8867940902709961, 0.9151920676231384, -0.07815124094486237, 0.3154129981994629, -0.7550641298294067, 0.07853074371814728, 0.22339332103729248, -0.1761292666196823, 0.6366638541221619, -0.3574589490890503, -0.6131517887115479, -0.3472907245159149, -0.0478416308760643, -0.18633660674095154, -0.3411444127559662, 0.34414783120155334, 0.12777391076087952, -0.9101593494415283, -0.31722065806388855, -0.7169272899627686, -0.9744990468025208, 0.2542291283607483, -0.33001840114593506, 0.5874009132385254, 0.46203848719596863, 0.3383786380290985, -0.7319419980049133, -0.09627994149923325, -0.7786377668380737, 0.49848929047584534, 0.3047011196613312, -0.6743485927581787, -0.8654366135597229, 0.6673367023468018, -0.2849663496017456, 0.5898420810699463, 0.11145547032356262, -0.24009370803833008, -0.1528560221195221, -0.3697730004787445, 0.4431813061237335, 0.18821559846401215, 0.5885869860649109, -0.4117838740348816, 0.20623426139354706, 0.2889425754547119, -0.19054758548736572, 0.22612698376178741, 0.5472679734230042, -0.6084407567977905, 0.16844066977500916, 0.3032865524291992, -0.0524861142039299, 0.572224497795105, -0.00703243026509881, -0.7382702827453613, 0.005510446149855852, -0.5409306883811951, 0.8446646928787231, -0.23403561115264893, 0.2099996954202652, -0.03432466834783554, -0.3257550895214081, -0.00607283366844058, 0.379820853471756, -0.4727746844291687, 0.8110096454620361, -0.030458964407444, 0.34001120924949646, -1.0486853122711182, 0.15604552626609802, 1.051277756690979, 0.7039796113967896, 0.0982123613357544, 0.5544484257698059, 0.656182050704956, -1.1419799327850342, -0.22667086124420166, 0.05239938944578171, 0.11653535068035126, -0.15376490354537964, 0.04217706248164177, -0.32390284538269043, -0.2605709135532379, -0.5736350417137146, -0.17307305335998535, 0.011290142312645912, 0.0024133704137057066, 0.49204686284065247, -0.44282266497612, 1.380686640739441, -0.4768570363521576, 0.5309030413627625, 0.2746848464012146, 0.5316122770309448, 0.31564995646476746, -1.3059961795806885, -0.08840619027614594, -0.12488473206758499, -0.7986850142478943, 0.14605288207530975, 0.07329399883747101, 0.7007801532745361, 0.10016033053398132, 0.020273294299840927, -0.36766597628593445, 0.13017405569553375, -0.6373859643936157, -0.7928106784820557, 0.5296459794044495, -0.06995631009340286, -0.02907230332493782, -0.7187507748603821, 0.1751246452331543, -0.36450064182281494, -0.06738657504320145, -0.07866727560758591, -1.1353379487991333, 0.5157618522644043, 0.5874908566474915, -0.2421261966228485, -0.7902689576148987, -0.2356104999780655, -0.13560304045677185, -0.0730741024017334, 0.26867613196372986, 0.2975142300128937, -0.4457121193408966, 1.0562795400619507, -0.7331085801124573, -0.42275914549827576, -0.3639320135116577, 0.14009235799312592, -0.48844286799430847, 1.007650375366211, -0.0038456134498119354, 0.21872085332870483, 0.20253697037696838, 0.7965892553329468, -0.750237762928009, 0.1963910013437271, -0.6970037221908569, 0.6159642934799194, -0.7217718362808228, -0.4257071614265442, 0.4602939486503601, 0.37562957406044006, -0.19056981801986694, -0.36114466190338135, -0.23436720669269562, -0.3413061201572418, -0.3943482041358948, 0.1244410052895546, -0.1870039850473404, -1.1670275926589966, 0.5909262895584106, -0.5931549668312073, 0.3745374083518982, 1.1287189722061157, -0.5393235683441162, -0.35376301407814026, -0.3292055130004883, 0.027897590771317482, -1.0725396871566772, 0.7415273785591125, -0.021341901272535324, 0.17864757776260376, 0.20985029637813568, -1.042264461517334, 0.2787989377975464, -0.19469846785068512, 0.4193151593208313, -0.5252565145492554, -0.37798836827278137, -0.6200387477874756, -0.6974685788154602, -0.14499512314796448, -0.9361063838005066, -0.5699049234390259, 0.16374869644641876, 0.033517010509967804, -0.6444838643074036, -0.2886384129524231, -0.06297653913497925, -0.566942036151886, -0.0015360460383817554, -0.8463528156280518, -0.008593493141233921, -0.26783299446105957, -0.15199428796768188, 0.5752261877059937, -0.28830665349960327, -0.7329431176185608, 0.4658483862876892, 0.4850766956806183, -0.3488762378692627, -0.6021125912666321, 0.05088245868682861, 0.08914266526699066, -0.12743625044822693, -0.29751938581466675, 0.5774317383766174, -0.5926491618156433, -0.010107246227562428, -0.5224995017051697, -0.2137654423713684, -0.18877136707305908, -0.2468714416027069, 0.31148961186408997, 0.8800407648086548, -0.3131142258644104, -0.49307236075401306, 0.0515313558280468, 0.6266698241233826, -0.017241351306438446, 0.02034819684922695, 0.16564002633094788, -0.8441648483276367, -0.2706493139266968, -0.8597689867019653, 0.947792649269104, -1.323241114616394, 0.10078172385692596, -0.5289556384086609, 0.037497568875551224, 0.11331894248723984, 0.09364432096481323, 0.08818694949150085, 0.053686849772930145, -0.4700888395309448, 0.036778319627046585, 0.006908708717674017, -0.4664016366004944, -0.867018461227417, -0.2636224031448364, -0.2610853612422943, -0.2230609953403473, 1.0449837446212769, 0.48643937706947327, -0.006925535853952169, -0.4700407385826111, -0.42513567209243774, 0.5024769902229309, 0.550910472869873, -0.09863388538360596, -0.3489501476287842, 0.31273359060287476, -0.3757087290287018, 0.26082196831703186, -0.036842357367277145, -0.6897327303886414, 0.4881736934185028, -0.44555968046188354, -0.04325633868575096, -1.222920298576355, -0.1905183047056198, 0.3574121594429016, -0.12713126838207245, 1.180892825126648, -0.5691443085670471, 0.12554875016212463, 0.34974390268325806, -0.5305917859077454, 0.33211570978164673, -0.32390546798706055, -0.04527702182531357, -0.3916202783584595, -0.5162453055381775, -0.6216481924057007, 0.06275417655706406, -0.017890462651848793, 0.1701025366783142, 0.026365727186203003, 0.05505488067865372, -0.2254437357187271, -0.72543865442276, 0.7817307710647583, 0.013346554711461067, -0.44141265749931335, -0.5433176159858704, 0.6015731692314148, -0.07472922652959824, 0.7166773676872253, -0.015871185809373856, -0.3515225052833557, -0.871111273765564, 0.5885461568832397, 0.17102055251598358, -0.8207899928092957, -0.35628989338874817, -0.30449965596199036, 0.36789804697036743, 1.0634441375732422, -0.320426344871521, 0.11373770236968994, -0.03034047968685627, -0.2185397893190384, -1.1523058414459229, 0.7815696597099304, -0.5468335151672363, 0.16277439892292023, 0.46471115946769714, -0.011918139643967152, -0.2549026608467102, 0.48080071806907654, 0.05699923262000084, 0.3754841983318329, -0.34869927167892456, 0.453311949968338, 0.05926646664738655, -0.7309030294418335, 0.23181074857711792, 0.885340690612793, -0.1039000153541565, -0.8448640704154968, 0.03592447191476822, -0.14686915278434753, 0.9774717688560486, -0.5896258354187012, -0.41954725980758667, -0.05501241981983185, -0.06859543174505234, 0.860905647277832, -0.09794434159994125, -0.202285036444664, 0.009344232268631458, 0.3477669358253479, 0.20122002065181732, -0.9109750390052795, 0.5037515163421631, 0.3791169226169586, 0.428018718957901, 0.22345829010009766, -0.12420541793107986, -0.4657614529132843, 0.38682419061660767, -0.40601566433906555, 0.6456757187843323, -0.25396713614463806, -0.33624979853630066, 0.5094072818756104, -0.08518555760383606, 0.8708400726318359, 0.13078844547271729, -0.3819233179092407, 0.4718436598777771, 0.2686057686805725, -0.9457322955131531, 0.05413097143173218, 0.8675763010978699, 0.22657044231891632, 0.8143459558486938, -0.2131541520357132, 0.34117841720581055, 0.9779161810874939, 1.2556045055389404, 0.0692228451371193, -0.5775198936462402, -0.6799291968345642, -0.4266040325164795, -0.15654592216014862, 0.37006574869155884, -0.7680220007896423, -0.44671502709388733, 0.21310430765151978, -0.2853515148162842, -0.163252592086792, 0.012055578641593456, 0.7629634737968445, -0.5835382342338562, -0.7542582750320435, -0.6277620196342468, 0.017011718824505806, -0.3883601427078247, -0.08797445148229599, -0.10362933576107025, -0.4155796468257904, 0.1668892353773117, 1.0907624959945679, -0.24428103864192963, 0.13495150208473206, 0.4690421223640442, 0.17926079034805298, -0.12643608450889587, 0.18365919589996338, -0.3133434057235718, -0.28909191489219666, -0.3318442404270172, 0.3119123876094818, -0.2785017490386963, -0.2362741231918335, 0.9640556573867798, -0.8429586887359619, 0.4358256757259369, -0.10503964871168137, 0.5345612168312073, -0.3995027244091034, -0.09667165577411652, -0.6370656490325928, 0.05738277733325958, -0.09993227571249008, 0.012791024520993233, 0.6620075106620789, -0.7609753608703613, -0.7527898550033569, -0.4977576732635498, -0.3329373002052307, -0.29524216055870056, 0.05349613353610039, 0.29564204812049866, 0.05442342162132263, 0.0964103639125824, 0.5046002268791199, 0.6158549189567566, 1.0045465230941772, 0.1680690348148346, -0.20503801107406616, 0.611709713935852, -0.3315099775791168, 0.12360765784978867, -0.8454023003578186, 0.4224051237106323, 0.3178222179412842, -0.8698117733001709, 0.5903778672218323, -0.13712528347969055, -0.08587758988142014, 0.01995367743074894, 0.1831430345773697, -0.2085958868265152, 0.5951621532440186, 0.24475470185279846, 0.18898843228816986, 0.3295048177242279, -0.20840708911418915, -0.6729138493537903, -0.8667696118354797, -0.9720108509063721, -0.5645524263381958, 0.5146124958992004, -0.22979377210140228, -0.10555636882781982, 0.03157472983002663, -0.379614919424057, 0.8589531779289246, 0.25016099214553833, 0.8591340184211731, -0.1613457202911377, -0.036942627280950546, -0.07086198031902313, 0.34673526883125305, -0.05914785712957382, 0.25120189785957336, 0.23741242289543152, -0.0986657366156578, -0.4722072184085846, -0.09875748306512833, 0.5225069522857666, 1.0527901649475098, 0.577760636806488, -0.23987329006195068, -0.4837770164012909, -0.3847483992576599, 0.576983630657196, -0.6633067727088928, -0.07197440415620804, 0.5745669007301331, -0.8022462129592896, 0.32413026690483093, 0.27705904841423035, -0.06412007659673691, 0.4296269714832306, 0.5388755798339844, -0.05502677708864212, -0.8093248009681702, -0.7053806781768799, -0.5446736216545105, 0.5031744837760925, -0.44588732719421387, 0.4697519540786743, -0.31767362356185913, 0.9129725098609924, -0.36775675415992737, 0.23567701876163483, 0.2932030260562897, 1.1207027435302734, 0.058511994779109955, -0.5282783508300781, 0.07516425102949142, 0.8350948095321655, 1.0380630493164062, 0.06377970427274704, 0.2647947371006012, 0.9210063219070435, 0.033410683274269104, 0.34458574652671814, 0.05137154087424278, -0.8227362036705017, 0.9513336420059204, 0.15253211557865143, 0.2492346167564392, 0.05669315904378891, 0.21005785465240479, 0.4383305013179779, -0.03213110566139221, -0.815143346786499, 0.49636349081993103, 0.2039564996957779, -0.8131135702133179, -0.18681493401527405, 0.9352619051933289, 0.841178834438324, 0.011855408549308777, 0.7347832322120667, 0.23870810866355896, -0.22996538877487183, -0.05650155618786812, 0.4113468825817108, 0.8296036124229431, -0.34454259276390076, -0.26965391635894775, -0.24802860617637634, 1.1231732368469238, -0.4736645221710205, 0.012804782018065453, 0.07575476914644241, -0.13515467941761017, -0.017050346359610558, 1.0147557258605957, 0.39991846680641174, -0.5873703956604004, 0.5826023817062378, -0.23711563646793365, -0.07860080152750015, -0.1547997146844864, -0.02783309854567051, 0.20209848880767822, -0.30467045307159424, 1.0008951425552368, -0.4461197555065155, 0.019521931186318398, 0.02535206824541092, -0.5132113099098206, 0.33116674423217773, 0.33427104353904724, 0.4236605167388916, -0.3243095576763153, 1.4230393171310425, 1.1020643711090088, 0.10411006957292557, -0.31789150834083557, -0.3047752380371094, -0.00711480900645256, -0.01694679632782936, -0.17742028832435608, -0.005774363409727812, -0.20412084460258484, -0.6280966997146606, -1.027774691581726, 0.1449700891971588, -0.9267146587371826, -0.574733316898346, -0.49355462193489075, 0.07903231680393219, -0.3216858208179474, 0.37901225686073303, -0.5608752965927124, -0.2286500781774521, -0.0023368631955236197, 0.3702094554901123, -0.5388208031654358, -0.6868141889572144, -0.6943685412406921, 0.12584516406059265, -0.7741900682449341, 1.1212012767791748, -0.0835527628660202, -1.0128052234649658, -0.24894392490386963, -0.6400234699249268, -0.5734830498695374, 0.2422061562538147, 0.053037989884614944, -0.574329137802124, 0.327994167804718, 0.21073177456855774, 0.04023699089884758, 0.7768343091011047, -0.38408833742141724, -0.23237323760986328, 0.7121677398681641, 0.4393693506717682, -0.31460657715797424, 0.5320136547088623, 0.19474634528160095, 0.5439515113830566, 0.19414818286895752, 0.7352931499481201, 0.17268748581409454, -0.084391288459301, -0.31184473633766174, -0.030636243522167206, 0.31903350353240967, 0.2210111916065216, -0.6029376983642578, 0.37624073028564453, 0.48672762513160706, 0.4488584101200104, -0.5044061541557312, -0.7478611469268799, -0.8397671580314636, -1.0925763845443726, 1.562131643295288, -0.262806236743927, 0.7287394404411316, -0.2719384729862213, -0.10058096796274185, 0.2515218257904053, -0.9600245356559753, 4.160598278045654, 0.8956277966499329, 0.8144355416297913, 0.45289602875709534, 0.32451847195625305, -0.17996475100517273, 0.7707472443580627, 0.045312196016311646, -0.041811227798461914, 0.1193961352109909, -0.656639814376831, 0.343304306268692, 0.2958967387676239, -0.06345877796411514, 0.5220721364021301, 0.7206846475601196, -0.7589629888534546, 0.14740997552871704, -0.22892126441001892, -0.7112396359443665, -0.7071565389633179, 0.238973468542099, -0.3554545044898987, 0.6382061243057251, -0.16445578634738922, 0.1318967193365097, -0.09496279060840607, 0.013092129491269588, 0.19059619307518005, -0.4867051839828491, 0.15351498126983643, -1.0222502946853638, 0.0017095793737098575, -0.2955336570739746, -0.1437399834394455, 0.45613741874694824, 0.33449608087539673, -0.036830876022577286, -0.12357384711503983, 0.2779747545719147, -0.12782254815101624, -0.09207211434841156, -0.4773600995540619, -0.21008563041687012, -0.32913967967033386, 0.27216339111328125, -0.23328249156475067, 0.18909692764282227, 0.37912532687187195, -0.8208440542221069, 0.6568282246589661, -0.9451990723609924, 0.4329131841659546, 0.35645952820777893, -1.1161302328109741, -0.43693506717681885, -0.9356366991996765, -1.12116539478302, 0.592456579208374, 0.6664294600486755, 0.67903733253479, 0.10025489330291748, -0.2780013084411621, -0.443877637386322, 0.5653003454208374, 0.6602763533592224, -0.010058003477752209, 0.5308519601821899, -0.36615899205207825, -0.6978399753570557, 0.030363792553544044, 0.28245601058006287, -0.3841727674007416, -0.1999785453081131, 1.0608595609664917, 0.39966559410095215, -0.21552108228206635, 1.0314455032348633, -0.25558510422706604, -0.9260951280593872, -0.10236474126577377, 0.2878212630748749, 0.5657811164855957, 0.2931234836578369, 0.5598202347755432, 0.4513348937034607, -0.7511283755302429, 0.19057708978652954, -0.7653797268867493, 0.27414241433143616, 0.4468420743942261, 0.14969013631343842, 0.7859009504318237, -0.3719373643398285, -0.11678019165992737 ]
{"Title": "Prediction of Suicidal Ideation in the Canadian Community Health Survey - Mental Health Component Using Deep Learning", "Authors": "Desai Sneha, Tanguay-Sela Myriam, Benrimoh David, Fratila Robert, Brown Eleanor, Perlman Kelly, John Ann, DelPozo-Banos Marcos, Low Nancy, Israel Sonia, Palladini Lisa, Turecki Gustavo", "Abstract": "Abstract Introduction Suicidal ideation (SI) is prevalent in the general population, and is a prominent risk factor for suicide. However, predicting which patients are likely to have SI remains a challenge. Deep Learning (DL) may be a useful tool in this context, as it can be used to find patterns in complex, heterogeneous, and incomplete psychiatric datasets. An automated screening system for SI could help prompt clinicians to be more attentive to patients at risk for suicide. Methods Using the Canadian Community Health Survey - Mental Health Component, we trained a DL model based on 23,859 survey responses to predict lifetime SI on an individual patient basis. Models were created to predict both lifetime and last 12 month SI. We reduced 582 possible model parameters captured by the survey to 96 and 21 feature versions of the models. Models were trained using an undersampling procedure that balanced the training set between SI and non-SI respondents; validation was done on held-out data. Results AUC was used as the main model metric. For lifetime SI, the 96 feature model had an AUC of 0.79 and the 21 feature model had an AUC of 0.75. For SI in the last 12 months the 96 feature model had an AUC of 0.76 and the 21 feature model had an AUC of 0.69. DL outperformed random forest classifiers. Discussion Although requiring further study to ensure clinical relevance and sample generalizability, this study is a proof-of-concept for the use of DL to improve prediction of SI. This kind of model would help start conversations with patients which could lead to improved care and, it is hoped, a reduction in suicidal behavior.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010413"}
10.1101/19005579
[ -0.3669367730617523, 0.5476789474487305, 0.04161187633872032, 1.1751859188079834, -0.5366392731666565, 0.23668181896209717, 0.5311229825019836, 0.8800981044769287, -0.20286110043525696, 0.543143630027771, -0.5256986618041992, -0.27721479535102844, 0.574720025062561, -0.43273210525512695, -0.3437586724758148, -0.4364936053752899, -0.6848421096801758, -0.13691513240337372, -0.17294888198375702, 0.5288225412368774, 0.5093528628349304, 0.5847994685173035, -0.300353467464447, 0.27772802114486694, -0.6193673014640808, 0.31841233372688293, 0.5353717803955078, -0.40041181445121765, 0.8654484152793884, 0.6713305115699768, 0.006037619896233082, -0.4265037775039673, 0.5291606783866882, -0.7330564856529236, -0.053044237196445465, -0.1961439996957779, 1.0470293760299683, -0.06921440362930298, 0.6662957668304443, -0.10595906525850296, 0.13047929108142853, -0.6202026009559631, 0.4054926335811615, -0.3838299810886383, -0.39371606707572937, -0.33218392729759216, -0.10763707011938095, -0.2178962081670761, -0.12268882989883423, 0.23075595498085022, -0.579709529876709, 0.24874678254127502, 0.3719055950641632, -0.1329723596572876, 0.07826999574899673, 0.10711909085512161, -0.47996243834495544, -0.06060395389795303, -1.052531361579895, 0.8668070435523987, 0.2789658308029175, 0.4439333379268646, 0.9603392481803894, -0.6719978451728821, 0.6838576197624207, 0.6490902304649353, 0.005942201241850853, -0.008781582117080688, -0.18171332776546478, -0.7087535858154297, -0.3555983304977417, -0.05657268315553665, -1.2461928129196167, -0.3793414235115051, 0.09913665801286697, 0.011961622163653374, 0.3699243366718292, -0.489094614982605, -0.25782790780067444, 0.2678198218345642, -0.11494778841733932, 0.22701454162597656, 0.2719208598136902, 0.37600207328796387, -0.7284986972808838, 0.31109461188316345, 0.005470835138112307, 0.16402630507946014, 0.2671475410461426, 0.6767506003379822, -0.8129165172576904, 0.27132701873779297, -0.6745353937149048, -0.19284696877002716, 0.0264231376349926, 0.7677752375602722, -0.4279969334602356, 0.13696183264255524, 0.19215641915798187, -0.28686684370040894, 0.9633193016052246, 0.18827742338180542, -0.07992243021726608, 0.7531664371490479, -0.44385021924972534, 0.623757004737854, 0.2393195927143097, -0.22682920098304749, -0.5209740996360779, -0.6021575927734375, 0.046960316598415375, 0.12841889262199402, -0.3866811990737915, -0.6729540228843689, 0.4119712710380554, 0.8287512063980103, -0.19552487134933472, 1.149143099784851, -0.11146033555269241, 0.3327900469303131, -0.06870357692241669, 0.2757285535335541, -0.1539207547903061, 0.019621429964900017, 0.09363347291946411, -0.21540787816047668, -0.03286592662334442, 0.012671193107962608, -0.7474814653396606, 0.27859485149383545, -0.3146202564239502, -0.2734921872615814, -0.46009406447410583, -0.0015895419055595994, -0.28616511821746826, 0.4516342282295227, -0.17140187323093414, 1.0943111181259155, -0.02157634124159813, -0.6281175017356873, 0.18092168867588043, 0.12198815494775772, -0.39890503883361816, 0.9907127022743225, -0.12608356773853302, 0.23331284523010254, -1.066184639930725, -0.6007982492446899, -0.40734174847602844, -0.18242770433425903, 0.1767202764749527, 0.525688111782074, -0.4063320755958557, -0.5588366389274597, -0.06341160088777542, 0.7090973258018494, 0.008811681531369686, 0.3923616409301758, -0.16290467977523804, -0.6135115623474121, -0.9035815596580505, -0.5219290852546692, -0.8898118734359741, 0.6282095313072205, -0.6306715607643127, 0.8285082578659058, -0.2827708423137665, -0.17609815299510956, 0.02070697210729122, -0.5141196250915527, 0.21761146187782288, 0.08702966570854187, -0.5241251587867737, -0.19865472614765167, 0.04101775959134102, 0.7591825723648071, 0.9006233811378479, -0.6119584441184998, 0.1955644190311432, 0.2529468536376953, -1.0702043771743774, -0.5480656623840332, 0.6178308129310608, 0.4536747932434082, -0.9877705574035645, 0.7406631112098694, -1.1627881526947021, -0.6518464684486389, -0.359439879655838, -0.009263924323022366, -0.33587026596069336, -0.0326513797044754, -0.92192542552948, 0.21618570387363434, 0.03448908030986786, -0.052964624017477036, -0.28752386569976807, 0.8321976661682129, 0.6920258402824402, -0.6548869609832764, -0.5151326060295105, 0.819092333316803, 0.7854931354522705, 0.10727029293775558, 0.05624983832240105, 0.6520481109619141, 0.3450958728790283, 0.4436693489551544, -1.3360397815704346, 0.7557418346405029, 0.3477244973182678, 0.21261300146579742, -0.14926542341709137, 0.20214708149433136, -0.11380499601364136, -0.04993889108300209, 0.18122875690460205, 0.4414215385913849, -0.04358524829149246, 0.3682731091976166, 0.11938812583684921, -0.3509855270385742, 0.3425905406475067, 0.5339312553405762, 0.6606631278991699, 0.3153703808784485, 0.8296511173248291, 0.7487049102783203, -0.4877389669418335, -0.5827344059944153, 0.25327199697494507, 0.49428048729896545, 0.5042812824249268, 0.3389792740345001, 0.6934623718261719, 0.9339897036552429, -0.6024767756462097, 0.2801884412765503, 0.49694469571113586, -0.0937434732913971, 1.2283086776733398, 0.31802305579185486, 0.48537033796310425, 0.1092473566532135, 0.35069984197616577, 0.6007262468338013, -0.3061807155609131, 0.14909236133098602, 0.4982595443725586, 0.11205217987298965, -0.5690665245056152, 0.7131538391113281, 0.8287671804428101, 0.5582596063613892, -0.48480692505836487, -0.08053216338157654, -0.24308167397975922, 0.2788785398006439, -0.19286717474460602, -0.6044079065322876, 0.13969551026821136, 0.44513240456581116, 0.25952446460723877, -0.535393238067627, -0.0015641299542039633, 0.44568774104118347, -0.4946792721748352, 0.5911773443222046, 0.2416336089372635, 0.13349516689777374, -0.8396039009094238, -0.7839211225509644, -0.9232562184333801, -0.33930566906929016, -0.38152557611465454, 0.44799789786338806, 0.054778724908828735, -0.8496487140655518, -0.1633671224117279, -0.39226746559143066, -0.10122638195753098, -0.2195233702659607, 0.3463577926158905, 0.4066742956638336, 0.31593480706214905, 0.2724006474018097, -0.5600165724754333, -0.12368886917829514, -0.2552409768104553, 0.1321704238653183, -0.22917704284191132, -0.3754402995109558, 0.06832991540431976, -0.40758758783340454, 0.39860498905181885, -1.1641998291015625, -0.7119882106781006, 0.006793868727982044, 0.14457173645496368, -0.2874578535556793, 0.8093416690826416, -0.5904843211174011, 0.5512824058532715, -0.04751541092991829, -0.9493555426597595, 0.9183073043823242, 0.2274755835533142, 0.14857661724090576, 0.7246186137199402, 0.07806556671857834, -0.11655221879482269, 0.5655061602592468, -0.26394087076187134, 0.1894741654396057, -0.7246389985084534, -0.6919010281562805, 0.6772626638412476, -0.4992269277572632, -0.19174377620220184, -0.17264853417873383, -1.1371231079101562, -0.4107869863510132, 0.23046301305294037, -0.5559484958648682, -0.11422416567802429, -0.47769322991371155, -0.5285223126411438, -0.8751721382141113, 0.4609151780605316, -0.7283846735954285, -0.5512625575065613, -0.1384013593196869, 0.022318094968795776, 0.33214983344078064, 0.06869831681251526, -0.20172451436519623, 0.5866405963897705, 0.08361291140317917, 0.5088467597961426, 0.5970960855484009, 0.7217106223106384, -0.023488929495215416, 0.39146068692207336, 0.08863693475723267, -0.1701597422361374, 0.5471106767654419, 0.04256025329232216, 0.5064343810081482, -0.2311280071735382, -0.0607878603041172, 0.15626229345798492, 0.41797444224357605, 0.8628891110420227, -0.032289668917655945, -0.1624438315629959, 0.6916770935058594, 0.5063862800598145, 0.5062891244888306, 0.6776210069656372, 0.5149101614952087, -0.1513444036245346, -0.32614222168922424, -0.47915932536125183, -0.1042313501238823, -1.0996308326721191, -0.11887039989233017, 0.9383655190467834, 0.4607636630535126, 0.36822664737701416, -0.319484680891037, 0.29296284914016724, -0.5679312348365784, -0.009465662762522697, 0.5603379607200623, -0.0907994955778122, -0.45028576254844666, 1.008669376373291, 0.9451254606246948, 1.0469133853912354, -1.329201102256775, 0.4924907386302948, 0.20710401237010956, 0.7422844171524048, -0.01952636055648327, 0.19221612811088562, 0.32253438234329224, -0.2439669668674469, 0.6496326327323914, 0.32637038826942444, -0.3592919409275055, 0.5435147881507874, -0.17173796892166138, 0.20966246724128723, -0.3554050326347351, -0.7969041466712952, -0.5389497876167297, 0.3090967833995819, 0.2977284789085388, 0.505974292755127, 0.11007874459028244, 0.7467734217643738, -0.6112768650054932, 0.9831016659736633, -0.47092413902282715, 0.8470259308815002, 0.05163523554801941, -1.344872236251831, -0.14386926591396332, 0.07438644021749496, -0.7114574909210205, -0.06129642203450203, -0.4376845061779022, -0.0874127671122551, -0.6575380563735962, 0.3742786645889282, 0.017783142626285553, -0.26048743724823, -0.31523972749710083, 0.1997353583574295, 0.42175185680389404, 0.11537301540374756, 0.31564560532569885, -0.10518214106559753, 0.5372283458709717, 0.2567959129810333, -0.684697687625885, 0.3575250804424286, -0.7638134360313416, 0.6654390692710876, 1.2264776229858398, -0.7233802080154419, -0.92840975522995, -0.8406941294670105, -0.0660308450460434, -1.0932471752166748, 0.04075773432850838, 0.22231487929821014, -0.6746445298194885, 0.03911372274160385, -0.5506716370582581, -0.3527483344078064, 0.3161756098270416, -0.5289762020111084, -0.15578897297382355, -0.05662631243467331, 0.38703009486198425, 0.6483800411224365, 0.7684731483459473, 0.301494836807251, -0.15982496738433838, 0.4077363908290863, -0.661647617816925, 0.28435322642326355, -0.4618607759475708, -0.7202605605125427, -0.031052468344569206, 0.575614333152771, -0.5883998274803162, -0.2057706117630005, -0.642799437046051, -0.26870936155319214, 0.15341314673423767, 0.1460358202457428, 0.04469405487179756, -0.5493264198303223, 0.9347478747367859, -1.2113102674484253, -0.14638523757457733, 1.2422925233840942, -0.36657455563545227, -0.3656856417655945, -0.25468477606773376, -0.21237115561962128, -0.5640260577201843, 1.1139496564865112, -0.2893175482749939, 0.3092384934425354, 0.7725046277046204, -0.2308458536863327, -0.052398957312107086, 0.49355968832969666, -0.15955470502376556, -0.15841244161128998, -0.3743155598640442, -0.2626689076423645, -0.32582712173461914, -0.019706886261701584, 0.7155736684799194, -0.6945656538009644, 1.21645188331604, -0.29702430963516235, -0.28758642077445984, -1.0133055448532104, 0.20893330872058868, -0.7864066362380981, -0.15229977667331696, 0.2163025289773941, -0.879153311252594, 0.18202665448188782, -0.019841866567730904, 0.498360276222229, -1.1144773960113525, -0.7182518243789673, -0.3918895423412323, 0.5697131156921387, -0.5946229696273804, -0.4818420708179474, 0.1099184900522232, 0.08204471319913864, -0.6488133072853088, 0.06583064794540405, 0.3717176914215088, -0.46480610966682434, 0.2180040031671524, -0.09238768368959427, -0.11169617623090744, 0.5723153948783875, 0.06113594025373459, -0.6150100231170654, 0.54640793800354, 0.29644298553466797, -0.5878930687904358, -1.0038172006607056, 0.3901040554046631, -0.11809908598661423, 0.28072118759155273, -0.005457076709717512, -0.8957997560501099, -0.10950779914855957, -1.1495881080627441, -0.06090530753135681, 0.16902194917201996, -0.12428885698318481, -0.5731910467147827, -0.5727269649505615, -0.6211428642272949, 0.7146989107131958, 0.09626095741987228, 0.6407573819160461, -0.0683087408542633, 0.03176472708582878, -0.2402026653289795, 0.3467256426811218, 0.17309632897377014, -0.09097503125667572, -0.44104859232902527, 0.48103731870651245, 0.4043372869491577, 0.08201771974563599, -0.5619627237319946, 0.3587360084056854, -0.06769389659166336, -0.025804055854678154, 0.425222784280777, -0.6476449370384216, -0.012952925637364388, 0.028386499732732773, 0.6500559449195862, -0.23895536363124847, -0.1189599484205246, -0.7248395681381226, 0.7990322709083557, -0.7871159315109253, 0.30997830629348755, -0.08454789966344833, 0.08143072575330734, 0.4894196391105652, -0.26746219396591187, 0.3529243469238281, -0.2641342282295227, 0.070945143699646, -0.3211730420589447, -0.25320056080818176, -0.41831567883491516, 0.2357814460992813, -1.1109747886657715, -0.04299174249172211, -0.5369911789894104, -0.83897864818573, 0.19525741040706635, 0.06363975256681442, 0.18314705789089203, -0.04039052128791809, -0.901854932308197, 0.11974069476127625, -0.08776909857988358, 1.0520150661468506, 1.3101301193237305, -0.2525479793548584, -0.5341770052909851, -0.30661869049072266, 0.29682841897010803, 0.12059240788221359, -0.24411097168922424, 0.35393452644348145, -0.3121456205844879, 0.1773708462715149, -0.710541844367981, -0.10878558456897736, -0.05364695191383362, -0.3531176447868347, 0.35078659653663635, 0.38378074765205383, -0.03046068735420704, 0.187622532248497, -0.022048691287636757, -0.44671669602394104, 0.41140085458755493, 0.8392042517662048, -0.2358858436346054, 0.2861543893814087, 0.6185404062271118, 0.38814541697502136, -0.7776737809181213, 0.5858535170555115, -0.2187637984752655, 0.4949193000793457, 0.11009719222784042, -0.059997592121362686, 0.04536779224872589, -1.2757797241210938, 0.22266575694084167, 0.15330395102500916, -0.8127841353416443, 0.4498431384563446, 0.29413992166519165, -0.49223029613494873, 0.5834631323814392, -0.12223626673221588, -0.6497118473052979, 1.0543875694274902, -0.5219327211380005, 0.18414439260959625, -0.4189445972442627, -0.673782467842102, -0.5828639268875122, -0.39893844723701477, 0.896821141242981, 0.03746799752116203, -0.07139568030834198, 0.377123087644577, -0.8296470046043396, -0.2054547518491745, 0.2003532350063324, 0.34587562084198, 0.30616816878318787, -0.23120629787445068, 0.8425520062446594, -1.3107123374938965, -0.643649697303772, -0.34332796931266785, -0.3733420968055725, 0.4282282590866089, 0.016424894332885742, -0.374298095703125, 0.660717785358429, -0.25129234790802, -0.6842862963676453, -0.5846897959709167, -0.19191895425319672, 0.28062063455581665, -0.41882652044296265, 0.09243354946374893, 0.13333551585674286, 0.2420395016670227, 0.11865271627902985, 0.06673555821180344, -0.5344167947769165, -0.5255375504493713, -0.6543543338775635, -0.3814623951911926, -0.4236668348312378, -0.4356268346309662, 0.023919586092233658, 1.3304383754730225, 0.39314451813697815, -0.5190444588661194, -0.1344260573387146, 0.9004940390586853, -0.40606483817100525, -0.0444733165204525, -0.23165202140808105, 0.13634999096393585, 0.464314728975296, -0.6288115978240967, 0.21528999507427216, -0.0383005253970623, 0.1295759081840515, 0.7214150428771973, -0.65782231092453, 0.21243074536323547, -0.12189701199531555, 0.48215463757514954, -0.18293292820453644, 0.48104262351989746, -0.8975929021835327, -0.2864416837692261, 0.22947758436203003, 0.44787654280662537, 0.21998858451843262, -0.09167661517858505, 0.5608382821083069, -0.5317148566246033, 0.15335287153720856, -0.2521815598011017, -0.36313295364379883, -0.07851878553628922, 0.5627742409706116, 0.31600815057754517, 0.025763442739844322, -0.8833232522010803, -0.01980735920369625, 0.16512207686901093, -0.6229157447814941, -0.6444202065467834, -0.4684062898159027, 0.7741393446922302, 0.5767872929573059, -0.33097782731056213, 0.013983529061079025, 1.1256424188613892, 0.41761675477027893, 0.018489956855773926, -0.39483967423439026, 0.3983929753303528, 0.4248602092266083, -0.06533710658550262, 0.30725282430648804, 0.05400174483656883, 0.1809437870979309, -1.2763322591781616, 0.2201056331396103, 0.78477942943573, -0.18871435523033142, 0.3168221712112427, -0.01409958116710186, 0.2741704285144806, 0.35790881514549255, -0.10690654069185257, -0.5369364619255066, 1.2869110107421875, 0.07999521493911743, 0.13772855699062347, -0.14798012375831604, -0.4577414393424988, -0.3239034414291382, -0.40116068720817566, -0.9177249670028687, -0.28154006600379944, 0.6330597996711731, -0.22871501743793488, -0.70830237865448, -0.7769858241081238, -0.3722821772098541, -0.022684676572680473, -0.2319442331790924, 0.4008004069328308, 0.009791468270123005, 0.2275969535112381, 0.27056604623794556, 0.483228474855423, 0.044226642698049545, -0.24402876198291779, 0.5500075817108154, -0.031108926981687546, -0.8038544058799744, -0.3563648760318756, 0.5893546342849731, 0.8712177872657776, 0.3279871642589569, -0.2120591551065445, -0.5670695900917053, -0.3590593934059143, 0.7941591739654541, 0.3889862298965454, -0.2933277487754822, 0.4402843415737152, -0.5836936235427856, -0.2136964052915573, -1.24576735496521, -0.5726370215415955, -0.24928134679794312, -0.08640588074922562, -0.13868235051631927, -0.8074528574943542, 0.029860833659768105, 0.44391754269599915, 0.9974424839019775, 0.3061780333518982, 0.9628185629844666, -0.3816753923892975, 0.7564924955368042, 0.38664543628692627, -0.43126705288887024, 0.6336950659751892, 1.7784833908081055, 0.24380157887935638, -0.08910365402698517, 0.32642754912376404, -0.8552936911582947, 0.7379984855651855, 0.37369728088378906, 0.365377813577652, 0.792005181312561, 0.029238693416118622, -0.2980257570743561, -0.14883413910865784, -0.32676973938941956, 0.7248145341873169, 0.09490618109703064, -0.2723793387413025, 0.48142924904823303, -0.07071108371019363, 0.39557549357414246, 0.5083927512168884, -0.7531373500823975, 0.020458662882447243, -1.157295823097229, -0.6522404551506042, 0.484700471162796, 0.9437527060508728, 0.42931804060935974, 0.17758457362651825, 0.23153187334537506, 0.6012315154075623, 0.8524125814437866, -0.09606730937957764, 0.20750553905963898, 0.6396865248680115, -0.4886595904827118, -0.4620662331581116, -0.6954469680786133, 0.30082792043685913, 0.22009840607643127, -0.043355681002140045, -0.18283380568027496, -0.325240820646286, 0.3232252895832062, 0.7436490058898926, -0.2071223109960556, 0.25069376826286316, 1.4007612466812134, -0.06591814011335373, -0.7863568663597107, 0.060295309871435165, 0.29898232221603394, -0.46123427152633667, -0.5961905717849731, 1.0621236562728882, -0.2164357751607895, 0.08219270408153534, 0.1931213140487671, 0.3006076216697693, 0.3553086519241333, 1.0653918981552124, 0.4380016624927521, -0.3795097768306732, 0.24592448770999908, 0.5939822793006897, -0.1970866322517395, 0.3017357885837555, -0.5078580975532532, -0.7467751502990723, 0.2094629555940628, -0.6371438503265381, 0.2345992922782898, 0.08766118437051773, -0.12276989221572876, -0.12264280021190643, 0.49081918597221375, -0.27502894401550293, -0.5253490209579468, -0.8456442356109619, 0.4394659996032715, -0.19788041710853577, 0.09861329942941666, -0.7922034859657288, -0.4929770529270172, -0.6331863403320312, -0.16636799275875092, -0.12647642195224762, -0.42520463466644287, -0.2915365993976593, -0.37271687388420105, 0.04223107546567917, 0.8846343755722046, -0.9090796113014221, -0.3990475833415985, 0.009846877306699753, -1.1994816064834595, -0.25882506370544434, 0.2264658659696579, -0.4933558702468872, -0.6938878297805786, -0.3530321419239044, 0.3868955969810486, 0.229578897356987, -0.37476325035095215, 0.12816840410232544, -0.025848206132650375, 0.2328767031431198, 0.8318847417831421, -0.4582344889640808, 0.19295981526374817, -0.010095329955220222, -0.11611396819353104, 0.32558104395866394, -0.03245522454380989, -0.2423183023929596, -0.269746333360672, -0.4068702161312103, -0.41771358251571655, 0.10408265143632889, -0.08663687855005264, -0.7105947732925415, 0.4998485743999481, 0.6955170631408691, -0.7944571375846863, -0.21477839350700378, -0.9167101979255676, -0.41940176486968994, -0.9298213124275208, 0.7309892177581787, -0.6188154816627502, 0.40988975763320923, 0.5108153223991394, -0.16221089661121368, -0.0026531226467341185, -1.3655097484588623, 4.17075777053833, 0.5372452139854431, 0.37782415747642517, 0.058263685554265976, 0.7353096604347229, 0.4170791208744049, 1.5837819576263428, 0.407522588968277, -0.38642939925193787, 0.7866294384002686, 0.002055012620985508, 0.26828286051750183, 0.0608522929251194, -0.03555158153176308, 0.2011025995016098, 0.3107258379459381, -1.084052562713623, -0.08625616878271103, 0.27478212118148804, -0.3861401379108429, -0.7029016613960266, -0.10590685158967972, 0.34493374824523926, -0.18131226301193237, -0.12695036828517914, -0.2751574218273163, 0.008021650835871696, -0.36589545011520386, 0.186940997838974, -0.19278542697429657, 0.37667790055274963, -0.6931837797164917, 0.6000078320503235, -0.4829178750514984, -0.14915630221366882, 0.04034041613340378, 0.007153488229960203, -0.5268056988716125, -0.17029017210006714, -0.6479367017745972, -0.5172223448753357, 0.35406965017318726, -0.34877532720565796, -0.15520773828029633, 0.39568695425987244, 0.7197927236557007, -0.7145044207572937, 0.554479718208313, 0.4083459973335266, -0.7024639248847961, 1.0890885591506958, -0.564268171787262, 0.20711039006710052, 0.2397335320711136, -0.5010445713996887, -0.6938712000846863, 0.21513065695762634, -0.2873803675174713, -0.2582431435585022, -0.39969560503959656, 0.6822923421859741, -0.01867229864001274, -0.3820628523826599, 0.5884451866149902, -0.26133736968040466, 0.29100003838539124, 0.3475566506385803, -0.2057366669178009, 0.04340765252709389, 0.040787339210510254, -0.5180699229240417, -0.49451738595962524, 0.3338226079940796, -0.4938454329967499, 0.43038350343704224, -0.2249709814786911, -0.46443936228752136, 0.40581074357032776, -0.3901748061180115, -0.051147863268852234, 0.6432615518569946, -0.5421260595321655, -0.3828067183494568, -0.2787434756755829, 0.2728813886642456, 1.3243352174758911, -0.5975975394248962, -0.23920938372612, -0.6547231078147888, 0.415183961391449, 0.35812103748321533, -0.43432775139808655, 0.14874018728733063, 0.2598705589771271, 0.08046430349349976 ]
{"Title": "Changes in association between school foods and child and adolescent dietary quality during implementation of the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010", "Authors": "Berger Aaron T., Widome Rachel, Erickson Darin J., Laska Melissa N., Harnack Lisa J.", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose To estimate the effect of Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act of 2010 (HHFKA) implementation on dietary quality of all US school-aged children and adolescents, and examine whether those effects differed by demographic group. Methods We used survey regression on 2007-2016 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) data to estimate the proportion of energy intake from school foods and the association between school food intake and dietary quality, before and after HHFKA passage/implementation. To account for demographic changes in the US population over time, inverse probability weighting was employed. The product of the proportion of energy from school foods and the association between school food intake and dietary quality estimated the effect of HHFKA implementation on dietary quality. Results School food intake quantity remained stable during the study period. HHFKA implementation improved students\u2019 dietary quality by 4.3 Healthy Eating Index-2010 (HEI) points (95% CI: 2.5, 6.1) on days when school foods were eaten, and by 1.3 HEI points (95% CI: 0.73, 1.8) averaged over all days annually. Conclusions HHFKA implementation improved the total dietary quality of US school students. US students would benefit from eating school meals in the post-HHFKA era, and HHFKA regulations should not be relaxed.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005579"}
10.1101/19008078
[ 0.619779646396637, -0.6096962690353394, 0.1013910174369812, -0.25626876950263977, -0.2965712547302246, -0.43034085631370544, -0.34660375118255615, 0.2562499940395355, 0.09810484945774078, 0.994877278804779, 0.30302193760871887, -0.3379964232444763, 0.42316120862960815, -0.5168850421905518, -0.27280744910240173, -0.04442816600203514, 0.1168166846036911, 0.07789618521928787, -0.07376597821712494, -0.4483979642391205, 0.5156291723251343, 0.09122096002101898, -0.5615522861480713, 0.1580500453710556, -0.6632084846496582, 0.9746413826942444, 0.5260857343673706, 0.584834098815918, 0.8361742496490479, -0.2957274615764618, -0.7691740393638611, -0.10149835795164108, -0.12559159100055695, -0.1633865386247635, 0.08479058742523193, 0.10510849207639694, 1.1142849922180176, -0.34337514638900757, -0.829719066619873, -1.25227689743042, 0.09533501416444778, 0.31071290373802185, 0.07866781949996948, -1.1109532117843628, -0.5556260943412781, -0.07869761437177658, 0.5363582968711853, -0.2905479073524475, 0.17375051975250244, -0.18881584703922272, -0.4022137522697449, 0.48712649941444397, 0.1818065345287323, -0.0413445420563221, -0.5181252360343933, -0.2285478115081787, 0.3672289550304413, -0.040599629282951355, -0.510452389717102, -0.7664744853973389, 0.5518180131912231, -0.05479278415441513, 0.11963572353124619, -1.0090526342391968, 0.21668963134288788, 0.6821157336235046, -0.11249419301748276, -0.4443932771682739, 0.2865201532840729, -0.04304300621151924, -0.6959204077720642, -0.19718551635742188, 0.4061007797718048, -0.6470655202865601, -0.3281302750110626, -0.6637544631958008, 0.2564878463745117, -0.18689392507076263, -0.34745240211486816, 0.09486768394708633, 0.03668101131916046, 0.31278157234191895, 0.06838922947645187, -0.2757585346698761, -0.23792441189289093, 0.035949625074863434, 1.2039991617202759, 0.6988384127616882, 0.48375219106674194, -0.43277519941329956, -0.5853708982467651, 0.15716958045959473, -0.7128406763076782, 0.15946190059185028, -0.21481944620609283, 1.0060192346572876, -0.031122155487537384, 0.043196577578783035, 0.48190736770629883, 0.22013872861862183, 0.20091737806797028, 1.4380378723144531, -0.9605558514595032, 1.2070846557617188, -0.19362282752990723, 0.2315983921289444, 0.7247836589813232, -0.5987429618835449, -0.25939249992370605, -0.8053026795387268, 0.5152373909950256, -0.08951694518327713, -0.3860020339488983, 0.19212351739406586, 0.3376827836036682, 0.5570456981658936, 0.08031483739614487, 0.37002328038215637, -0.6474496126174927, 0.48037973046302795, -0.29953059554100037, -0.2480960637331009, 0.9052755832672119, -0.006113527808338404, 0.21518762409687042, 0.5665085315704346, 0.6884881854057312, 0.07053650170564651, -0.6289684772491455, -0.3667488396167755, 0.19515009224414825, -0.5774868130683899, 0.2204468846321106, 0.1727854162454605, -0.14837245643138885, -0.15025605261325836, -0.08172844350337982, 0.10311396420001984, 0.15353134274482727, 0.2050405591726303, -0.10852443426847458, 0.18603381514549255, -0.9015187621116638, 1.407644510269165, -0.2034861147403717, -0.01455725822597742, -0.33875590562820435, -0.496216356754303, -0.33963438868522644, -0.1469227373600006, -0.12705664336681366, 0.26090002059936523, -0.05250098183751106, -0.0516769215464592, -0.9608365893363953, 0.2662443220615387, -0.2541729509830475, 0.15145477652549744, -0.2655017375946045, 0.44618892669677734, -0.022415632382035255, 0.5587972402572632, -0.31729185581207275, 0.5826680660247803, 0.4936208724975586, 1.4497358798980713, -0.2572239339351654, -0.21988311409950256, -0.04623328894376755, -0.27039822936058044, 0.667735755443573, 0.054576121270656586, -0.19704380631446838, 0.41099610924720764, -0.20124919712543488, 0.8944469094276428, 1.2700974941253662, -0.07069281488656998, -0.09802597016096115, -0.02721152827143669, -0.5588891506195068, -0.7119162082672119, -0.32335734367370605, 0.3681332468986511, 0.3989016115665436, -0.010662227869033813, -0.26066842675209045, -0.25605088472366333, 0.3774968981742859, -0.28030192852020264, 0.4912106692790985, -0.10046744346618652, -0.2738370895385742, 0.467214435338974, -0.7046425342559814, 0.35802432894706726, -0.06176060810685158, 0.39136824011802673, 0.4464510977268219, -0.2471635341644287, -0.07882826775312424, 0.813113808631897, 0.3159860074520111, -0.527596116065979, -0.44465506076812744, 1.0172274112701416, 0.25336402654647827, 0.9564282894134521, -1.1511186361312866, 0.860028088092804, -0.3141193687915802, 0.15262408554553986, -0.1563277542591095, 0.1405455470085144, 0.7729936838150024, -0.4687228500843048, -0.2424679398536682, 0.008139890618622303, 0.7349180579185486, 0.22759713232517242, 0.068863146007061, 0.13741713762283325, 0.2950342893600464, -0.5350168943405151, -0.202730193734169, 0.5569795966148376, 0.21902084350585938, 0.2873501181602478, 0.6336036920547485, 0.3764060437679291, -0.348652184009552, 0.4650048017501831, -0.8622744083404541, 0.19400224089622498, 0.3237602710723877, 0.32200613617897034, -0.3796861171722412, -0.003914535511285067, -0.12407886981964111, 0.2856321930885315, -0.05456922575831413, 0.6679306626319885, 1.222965955734253, 0.8872930407524109, -0.07601204514503479, 0.665955662727356, 0.16935445368289948, 0.467166006565094, -0.5039976239204407, 0.2905833125114441, -0.973470151424408, 0.9952756762504578, 0.1676899790763855, 0.32687050104141235, -0.4126288890838623, -0.4481281042098999, 0.4781133830547333, 0.7177044153213501, -0.11570070683956146, -1.3381223678588867, -0.7003690004348755, 0.45993268489837646, -0.04717632010579109, -0.19279806315898895, 0.3653359115123749, 0.48989003896713257, -0.10199347138404846, -0.5316723585128784, 0.00470005813986063, -0.13651543855667114, -1.1199986934661865, -0.2033960521221161, -1.0704071521759033, -0.4360443353652954, -0.6432797908782959, -0.8314969539642334, -0.0280199833214283, -0.17564572393894196, 0.5181922912597656, -0.08364538103342056, -0.42445096373558044, -0.6093649864196777, -0.6993404626846313, 0.36245232820510864, 0.06762245297431946, 0.2479727864265442, -1.263008713722229, 0.39994290471076965, -0.11230233311653137, 0.4634675681591034, -0.3176926374435425, -0.304930180311203, -0.9474489688873291, -0.38629528880119324, -0.1278495341539383, -0.7476733922958374, 0.5411056280136108, 0.3693082630634308, -0.5933958888053894, -0.4751218259334564, 0.6418597102165222, -0.2922839820384979, 0.4252193868160248, -0.15982304513454437, -0.523627519607544, 0.37721142172813416, 0.3143487274646759, -0.004756984766572714, 1.134171724319458, 0.21009759604930878, -0.421575665473938, 0.8507668972015381, 0.029071316123008728, 0.6049865484237671, -0.25520724058151245, 0.6437435746192932, -0.029116611927747726, -0.38988256454467773, -0.10097543895244598, -0.6238097548484802, -0.7608078122138977, 0.45130372047424316, -0.4484579861164093, -0.8451847434043884, 0.3619373142719269, 0.34606069326400757, 0.6497727632522583, -1.4565327167510986, 0.48405763506889343, -0.8829430341720581, -0.911165714263916, -0.2433668076992035, 0.2225334346294403, 0.9545804858207703, 0.23327898979187012, -0.2998470366001129, -0.6758991479873657, -0.08094468712806702, -0.11412841081619263, 0.7892953157424927, 0.3038761615753174, -0.7245739102363586, -0.5469772219657898, 0.27792099118232727, -0.3186786472797394, 0.016220392659306526, 0.3615955114364624, 0.40628764033317566, 0.1408414989709854, -0.5170512199401855, 0.06918451935052872, 0.24277180433273315, 0.4583216905593872, -0.09500259906053543, 0.3549804985523224, -0.1048245057463646, -0.6421199440956116, 0.859046459197998, 0.2753514349460602, -0.034661609679460526, 0.642504870891571, 0.4137885570526123, 0.13696929812431335, -0.09377724677324295, -0.5775466561317444, -0.2691715955734253, -0.09904322028160095, 0.016863718628883362, 0.6761564612388611, -0.11549224704504013, 0.18418167531490326, -0.785335123538971, -0.6123780608177185, 0.05575094744563103, -0.22827200591564178, -0.5593557953834534, 0.5073950290679932, -0.21411627531051636, 1.7104811668395996, -0.8292876482009888, 0.07047828286886215, 0.543042778968811, -0.380270391702652, 0.06953859329223633, -0.35215824842453003, 0.404903382062912, -0.11090710014104843, 0.22503766417503357, -0.18464942276477814, -0.39982399344444275, -0.005496911238878965, -0.16497153043746948, -0.4063683748245239, 0.6405991315841675, -0.482087641954422, -0.242488294839859, -0.12764373421669006, 0.5155773758888245, 0.30561313033103943, 0.40486109256744385, 1.0172532796859741, -1.0106366872787476, 0.17649708688259125, 0.40265142917633057, 0.818423867225647, -0.011865919455885887, -0.6822803020477295, 0.14419858157634735, -0.17913976311683655, -0.9166765213012695, -0.06788041442632675, -0.35896387696266174, 0.23636475205421448, 0.017492065206170082, -0.2872183620929718, 0.5407543182373047, -0.09482386708259583, -0.38179290294647217, -0.11019545048475266, 0.3109110891819, 0.1096668541431427, 0.160905122756958, -1.0680971145629883, 0.30490580201148987, -0.2758656144142151, -0.9004067182540894, -0.6985638737678528, -0.25876176357269287, 0.6496055126190186, -0.04749022424221039, -1.238145112991333, -0.3478648364543915, -0.04469727724790573, -0.7058396935462952, 0.23306617140769958, 0.41744980216026306, 0.2116377055644989, -0.04008953645825386, 1.1637972593307495, 0.4582717716693878, -0.021102597936987877, 0.2528146207332611, -0.11732541024684906, -0.33117544651031494, -0.17789512872695923, 0.24601301550865173, 0.6308408975601196, 1.1541364192962646, -0.6514681577682495, -0.20407167077064514, 0.1963377743959427, -0.4970243573188782, 1.166436791419983, -0.3710009455680847, -0.14444981515407562, 0.07350509613752365, 0.11137982457876205, -0.6623086929321289, 0.21858814358711243, -0.04913873225450516, -0.8334562182426453, 0.10448698699474335, 0.13059945404529572, -0.49507248401641846, -1.0184341669082642, 0.091380275785923, -0.23954640328884125, 0.452580064535141, 1.2206435203552246, -0.01155068539083004, -0.11782994866371155, 0.018483009189367294, 0.6215402483940125, -1.5837222337722778, 0.21061190962791443, -0.5205863118171692, 0.028767947107553482, 0.2991099953651428, -0.8493700623512268, 0.3554812967777252, -0.000019838927983073518, 0.5352714657783508, -0.6246531009674072, -0.3425966501235962, -0.37441104650497437, -0.5393041968345642, -0.4409014880657196, 0.4212830662727356, -0.5947742462158203, -0.05060739070177078, -0.38101089000701904, -0.563423752784729, 0.1983926147222519, -0.2729738652706146, -0.5292390584945679, -0.48613259196281433, -0.1799532175064087, -0.2545928955078125, 0.4373084604740143, 0.032486747950315475, -0.0017007492715492845, -0.2553417980670929, -1.0638445615768433, 0.023598182946443558, -0.2651411294937134, -0.39529702067375183, -0.46171656250953674, -0.3987620174884796, 0.604658305644989, -0.16954128444194794, -0.7758619785308838, 0.2207697629928589, 0.11019445210695267, -0.2850463092327118, -0.03866729885339737, 0.1299276500940323, -0.04755600169301033, -0.10186580568552017, -0.19241327047348022, 1.0118238925933838, -0.039045851677656174, -1.434482455253601, -0.8238603472709656, 0.7748721837997437, 0.09428893029689789, -0.5309914350509644, -0.1205054447054863, -0.3745579719543457, 0.003861588891595602, -0.9955424070358276, 0.7150490880012512, -0.267555832862854, -0.37544184923171997, -0.2622007429599762, -0.46132174134254456, -0.12548401951789856, 0.22553198039531708, 0.12402351200580597, -0.4449708163738251, -0.09212733060121536, -1.2027101516723633, 0.113746777176857, -0.2988607883453369, -0.8991124629974365, -0.26001089811325073, -0.2610119581222534, -0.20043732225894928, 0.5246012210845947, -0.11476340889930725, -0.4572661817073822, 0.4977033734321594, 0.35625502467155457, 0.2533411681652069, 0.26520800590515137, -0.8387555480003357, -1.1646702289581299, -0.07955887913703918, -0.1831979900598526, 0.003358762012794614, 0.1848011165857315, -0.6728017330169678, 0.31577855348587036, -0.7076590061187744, -0.25709885358810425, -0.1741759181022644, -0.09660181403160095, 0.6004847288131714, -0.7057506442070007, 0.7326686978340149, -0.8247036337852478, 0.5807279348373413, 0.3506740629673004, 0.036662328988313675, -0.013574217446148396, 0.23258797824382782, -0.639220654964447, -0.4098263680934906, -0.4561211168766022, -0.5793509483337402, 0.49026185274124146, -0.4782121479511261, -0.08027613908052444, 0.2538290321826935, -0.5079752206802368, -0.22062215209007263, -0.3849048614501953, 0.589419424533844, 1.3561837673187256, 0.017157725989818573, -0.3989883363246918, -0.14310579001903534, -0.29853883385658264, 0.6127354502677917, -0.19717280566692352, -0.1314275562763214, -0.19952566921710968, 0.15264807641506195, -0.222437784075737, -0.6791543364524841, -0.5725529789924622, -0.3825463056564331, -0.31432753801345825, 0.14774520695209503, -0.4665529131889343, 0.23303699493408203, 0.4732634425163269, -0.05791254714131355, -0.17878618836402893, 0.6879162788391113, 0.2358303815126419, 0.05816643312573433, 0.28167563676834106, -0.011730274185538292, 0.21822768449783325, 0.6336855888366699, -0.01564628817141056, -0.33445411920547485, -0.37264004349708557, 0.7030001878738403, 0.05901976674795151, -0.7565125226974487, 0.2076788693666458, 1.0496878623962402, -0.8920812010765076, -0.5115350484848022, 0.7164497375488281, -0.016552776098251343, 0.9569845795631409, -0.27399587631225586, -0.3222760856151581, 0.3639563322067261, 0.398975133895874, 0.44870951771736145, 0.16399173438549042, 0.05610531568527222, 0.04385519400238991, 0.325259268283844, 0.23237770795822144, -0.5612796545028687, 0.18797734379768372, 1.255218505859375, -0.19601242244243622, 0.012838689610362053, -0.5651736259460449, -0.5678824782371521, -0.2822875380516052, -0.25766533613204956, 0.20322592556476593, 0.0909944623708725, -0.44532930850982666, 0.5360670685768127, -0.16686829924583435, 0.37979963421821594, 0.24248428642749786, -0.4241088926792145, 0.49013033509254456, 0.03034575656056404, -0.7916768789291382, -0.2956456243991852, 0.5458704233169556, -0.04626145586371422, 0.16325955092906952, 0.40150144696235657, -0.21318590641021729, 0.5852696299552917, 0.48263150453567505, 0.4312557578086853, -0.6045628190040588, -0.5440881848335266, -1.2893892526626587, -0.3055936098098755, -0.15834248065948486, -0.09229208528995514, -0.3514925539493561, -0.11974699050188065, 0.5016362071037292, -0.27557721734046936, 0.1643414944410324, 0.6442114114761353, -0.599672257900238, -0.5968828797340393, -0.6777652502059937, 0.027546044439077377, -0.3950004577636719, -0.8704625368118286, 0.434331476688385, -0.29827752709388733, 0.05535958334803581, 1.0714738368988037, -0.2672179043292999, -0.07926797866821289, 0.08779608458280563, 0.20400455594062805, -0.4038086533546448, 0.4196339547634125, -0.4094788432121277, 0.09063603729009628, -0.8240132331848145, 0.40571776032447815, 0.49916326999664307, -0.23955190181732178, 0.8028951287269592, -1.4340859651565552, -0.04126464203000069, 0.18371932208538055, 0.12062641978263855, -0.21193742752075195, -0.35548120737075806, 0.6202113628387451, -0.2681930959224701, -0.01632198505103588, 0.27715983986854553, 0.13208270072937012, -0.6643670797348022, -0.25578078627586365, 0.06550897657871246, -0.2733463644981384, 1.114917516708374, 0.5875509977340698, 0.5727275609970093, 0.9316401481628418, 0.1398439258337021, 0.3323192894458771, 0.01660056971013546, 0.7983514666557312, -0.31195446848869324, -0.4482758343219757, 0.45387813448905945, 0.10631835460662842, 0.12197640538215637, -0.6631950736045837, 0.04245110973715782, 1.1264071464538574, -0.5185632109642029, -0.2722466289997101, 0.45566418766975403, 0.03881020471453667, 0.13026279211044312, -0.494183212518692, -0.15665782988071442, 0.9975185394287109, 0.1315998136997223, 0.7168245315551758, 0.5352500081062317, 0.3253520727157593, -1.0716207027435303, -0.11436860263347626, -0.4564046859741211, -1.1295936107635498, 0.17810392379760742, -0.3794594407081604, 0.524569571018219, -0.6905084848403931, -0.6398497223854065, 0.3086916208267212, 0.32139167189598083, 1.487522006034851, 0.2480926811695099, 0.8474612832069397, 0.25082775950431824, 0.7775254845619202, -0.6024225950241089, -0.11230489611625671, -0.3499503433704376, -0.2360749989748001, -0.2241426259279251, -0.2832399904727936, 0.48621949553489685, -0.2611583471298218, 0.2724730372428894, -0.4317513704299927, -0.22419926524162292, 0.7510591149330139, 0.4269714057445526, 0.0772051215171814, -0.6243107318878174, 0.1569128930568695, -1.5859920978546143, 0.4329195022583008, -0.12943702936172485, 0.5100021362304688, -0.12746046483516693, 1.010351300239563, 0.2722976803779602, -0.740117073059082, -0.6224291920661926, -0.31655779480934143, 0.8466933965682983, -0.831176221370697, 0.13673418760299683, 0.14368855953216553, 0.48251140117645264, 0.2318720519542694, -0.41213637590408325, 0.19364359974861145, -0.09493591636419296, -0.034566450864076614, -0.37045204639434814, -0.3715916574001312, 0.7555617094039917, 1.3935376405715942, -0.3096555769443512, 0.3745494484901428, 0.8438150882720947, 0.21721334755420685, -0.12845146656036377, -0.06631620228290558, -0.4554775655269623, 0.26356661319732666, -0.5141189694404602, -0.6424647569656372, 0.0565209724009037, 0.4448825716972351, -0.11324695497751236, 0.46610212326049805, -1.3745287656784058, -0.340435266494751, -0.6118914484977722, -1.3685544729232788, -0.40262579917907715, 0.10951240360736847, 0.8034279346466064, 0.12997429072856903, 0.973970353603363, 0.10918892920017242, 0.42510491609573364, 0.0004451561253517866, -0.014351741410791874, 0.48272475600242615, -0.19934886693954468, -0.2839716076850891, -0.14372286200523376, 0.23438246548175812, -0.387297123670578, 0.08748168498277664, 0.44665631651878357, -0.38301753997802734, 0.372576504945755, 0.5844522714614868, 0.009728207252919674, -0.27904024720191956, 0.4790775179862976, -0.23035481572151184, 0.36477571725845337, -1.0145833492279053, -0.15056680142879486, -1.0330976247787476, 0.09469719231128693, 0.6867198348045349, -0.5456357002258301, -0.4191155433654785, 0.715012788772583, 0.22044260799884796, 0.0919530987739563, 1.3025410175323486, 0.6664820909500122, 0.6423879265785217, 1.1670200824737549, 1.1668435335159302, -0.11413148790597916, -0.2272055447101593, 0.2614605128765106, -0.07829644531011581, -0.06783650070428848, -0.09591767936944962, 0.011378091759979725, 0.4421411156654358, -0.5986155271530151, 0.06305450201034546, 0.22071745991706848, -0.34948840737342834, -0.3901800215244293, -0.3175013065338135, -0.2136160433292389, 0.30062925815582275, -0.2517618238925934, -0.1239129975438118, 0.33816295862197876, 0.6150545477867126, -0.05218929797410965, -0.16725774109363556, -0.4366190731525421, -0.6286500692367554, -0.07776495069265366, -0.376092791557312, 0.3113444745540619, -1.2243186235427856, -0.31680232286453247, -0.4607402980327606, -0.2762077748775482, -0.3841506838798523, 0.5903458595275879, 0.3871578872203827, -0.09104501456022263, 0.708770215511322, 0.7400479912757874, 0.16573412716388702, 0.23611439764499664, -0.33205321431159973, 0.24651287496089935, 0.23405738174915314, 0.45027363300323486, 0.7256610989570618, 0.4690888524055481, 0.8239132761955261, -0.26328808069229126, 0.5305970311164856, -0.062393609434366226, 0.15679451823234558, 0.2560606896877289, -0.3832663297653198, 0.3680465519428253, 0.04118305817246437, -0.6658841371536255, -0.6515325307846069, 0.256273478269577, 0.8722540140151978, 0.17562144994735718, -0.17886245250701904, -1.1079833507537842, 0.08701230585575104, -0.41325971484184265, 0.9354138374328613, -0.4410342276096344, 0.9127637147903442, -0.3083258271217346, -0.3256443738937378, -0.6323031187057495, -0.23789888620376587, 4.125239849090576, 1.6747552156448364, 0.7389329671859741, 0.40231049060821533, 0.8524186015129089, -0.03270580992102623, 0.7136825919151306, -0.0724201574921608, 0.10070066899061203, -0.05659742280840874, 0.8142229914665222, -0.2459009736776352, 0.6147378087043762, 0.23283493518829346, 0.020539646968245506, 0.08872939646244049, -0.44138097763061523, -0.20200110971927643, 0.392805278301239, -0.4628608226776123, -1.2781978845596313, -0.19437947869300842, -0.2193850576877594, -0.5620586276054382, -0.07594835758209229, -0.1563391089439392, -0.18211084604263306, 0.1336183249950409, -0.5258836150169373, -0.270734041929245, -0.19454531371593475, -0.15253645181655884, 0.47768616676330566, -0.8064234852790833, -0.029457084834575653, 0.06382641196250916, 0.276699960231781, -0.6159468293190002, -0.014357063919305801, 0.2683621644973755, -0.2348320633172989, -0.4301087558269501, 0.051933176815509796, -0.3854304552078247, 0.1947614550590515, 0.28263288736343384, -0.29002001881599426, -0.05783044919371605, 0.8757774233818054, -0.9651811718940735, 0.6204817891120911, -0.5321570634841919, -0.10657787322998047, -0.36895790696144104, -0.11659447103738785, -0.506314754486084, -1.1573243141174316, -0.17941585183143616, -0.16504043340682983, 1.0196532011032104, 0.8861029744148254, 0.10208258777856827, -0.057576436549425125, -0.6115692257881165, -0.22302007675170898, 0.39637380838394165, 0.48746076226234436, 0.39854753017425537, 0.016711268573999405, 0.020464716479182243, 0.31276583671569824, 0.37513676285743713, 0.05329582840204239, 1.1546357870101929, 0.7333555221557617, 0.39268195629119873, -0.25815966725349426, 1.0361238718032837, 0.22398541867733002, -0.12970507144927979, 0.010791938751935959, 0.35361528396606445, -0.35835936665534973, 0.34161895513534546, 0.3843572437763214, 0.32731160521507263, -0.9778954386711121, -0.28951162099838257, -1.1980911493301392, 0.4569132328033447, -0.24089950323104858, -0.027928587049245834, 0.1642407774925232, -0.25332126021385193, -0.64811772108078 ]
{"Title": "Setting Standards to Promote Artificial Intelligence in Colon Mass Endoscopic Sampling", "Authors": "Zheng Yueping, Su Ruizhang, Wang Wangyue, Meng Sijun, Xiao Hang, Zhang Wen, Xu Haineng, Bu Yemei, Zhong Yuhuan, Zhang Yi, Qiu Hesong, Qin Wenjuan, Zhang Yongxiu, Xu Wen, Chen Hong, Zhang Changhua, Wu Siqi, Han Zhaofang, Zheng Xiaofang, Zhu Huafen, Wu Shuisheng, Pan Wensheng, He Yulong, Hu Yiqun", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective Artificial intelligence (AI) has undeniable values in detection, characterization, and monitoring of tumors during cancer imaging. However, major AI explorations in digestive endoscopy have not been systematically planned, and more important, most AI productions are based on Single-center Studies (ScSs). ScSs result in data scarcity, redundancy as well as island effects, which leads to some limitations in applying it on endoscopy. We investigate the disadvantages of picture processing which may effect the AI detection, and make improvements in AI detection and image recognition accuracy. Design Current investigation aggregates a total of 2,500 gastroenteroscopy samples from various hospitals in multiple regions and carries out deep learning. Results It is found that factors inconducive to AI recognition are common such as: (a) the gastrointestinal tract is not cleaned up completely; (b) shooting angle (from left to right and the top of polyp are unexposed clearly), shooting distance (too close or too far to shoot causes the lump to be unclear), shooting light (insufficient light source or overexposed light source in mass) and unstable shooting lead to poor quality of pictures. Conclusion We set standards for a multicenter cooperation involving three-level medical institutions from the provincial, municipal and county to improve the recognition accuracy as well as the diagnosis and treatment efficiency meanwhile.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008078"}
10.1101/19005280
[ 0.5413067936897278, -0.19733668863773346, -0.18522241711616516, 0.5239187479019165, -0.406313955783844, 0.09933097660541534, -0.21012838184833527, -0.20267032086849213, 0.8244969248771667, 0.45797306299209595, -0.10257673263549805, -0.4400395154953003, -0.14102691411972046, 0.24195067584514618, -0.0903976783156395, 0.022200610488653183, -0.8487424850463867, -0.2307409942150116, -0.15040791034698486, -0.36749574542045593, 0.06266312301158905, 0.6827531456947327, -1.3882787227630615, 0.5109557509422302, -0.7006776332855225, 0.49120017886161804, 0.2652619183063507, 0.32803961634635925, 1.2204614877700806, 1.0821713209152222, 0.08044175803661346, -0.6453253626823425, 0.601062536239624, -0.8828573822975159, -0.19187122583389282, -0.4880809485912323, 0.7581136226654053, -0.6604040265083313, -0.22763986885547638, 0.2571869194507599, -0.1043471246957779, -0.26881784200668335, 0.19197356700897217, -0.9040483236312866, -1.3940285444259644, -0.49258479475975037, 0.11196655035018921, 0.004803569056093693, -0.250313401222229, -0.9327235221862793, -0.18696768581867218, 0.15693219006061554, -0.3791801631450653, -0.21201512217521667, 0.2300870716571808, 0.1062329038977623, 0.38687029480934143, -0.0487271249294281, -0.479148268699646, 0.11550291627645493, -0.16218410432338715, -0.49863892793655396, 0.5366701483726501, -0.5100189447402954, 0.43892741203308105, 0.5684231519699097, 0.11762892454862595, -0.1787886619567871, 0.14603102207183838, -0.7548977732658386, -0.4492822289466858, -0.08074255287647247, -0.36239442229270935, -0.6599562764167786, -0.6704695224761963, -0.10279897600412369, 0.3393767774105072, -0.06269405037164688, -0.03047815151512623, 0.10144626349210739, 0.030225342139601707, 0.47218057513237, 0.4186304807662964, 0.263613224029541, -0.213599294424057, -0.521874189376831, 1.0218311548233032, 0.11826015263795853, 0.2581247091293335, -0.01675117015838623, 0.053514592349529266, 0.19741562008857727, 0.4668242633342743, 0.19607093930244446, -0.012603350915014744, 0.7722915410995483, -0.22095966339111328, -0.16182273626327515, 0.8395081758499146, -0.06847167015075684, 0.8024899959564209, 1.246275544166565, -0.5818894505500793, 1.2665756940841675, -0.11715435981750488, 0.9144219756126404, 0.47385820746421814, -0.5829488039016724, -0.042843159288167953, -0.9117772579193115, -0.7007452845573425, 0.045410655438899994, -0.7704308032989502, -0.29663607478141785, -0.2057332694530487, 0.09808588773012161, 0.4724319577217102, 0.9224047064781189, 0.001987041672691703, -0.011609528213739395, -0.40285128355026245, -0.11805222183465958, 0.3246196508407593, -0.4698583483695984, 0.25595077872276306, -0.7461560964584351, 0.14078249037265778, 0.6989086866378784, -0.8192421197891235, -0.3977773189544678, -0.26902955770492554, -0.15181826055049896, -0.03297625854611397, 0.6157892942428589, 0.22994904220104218, -0.005131533369421959, 1.1545050144195557, 0.5196722745895386, 0.7498772740364075, -0.012886825948953629, 0.08596241474151611, -0.4046848714351654, -0.2875382602214813, 1.2173019647598267, 0.10380465537309647, 0.5998029112815857, 0.09189186245203018, -1.4337416887283325, -0.9788932204246521, 0.40124112367630005, -0.05280238762497902, 0.5998475551605225, 0.11128739267587662, 0.052516959607601166, -0.014187752269208431, 0.26997098326683044, 0.32980725169181824, 0.20453916490077972, -0.24247877299785614, -0.004833531565964222, -0.48978933691978455, 0.1821790486574173, -0.3666734993457794, 0.25735509395599365, -0.5328126549720764, 0.34092846512794495, -0.24411506950855255, 0.34693601727485657, 0.3081974685192108, -0.8772756457328796, 0.3852916955947876, 0.5045944452285767, 0.10853860527276993, 0.14644266664981842, 0.046757739037275314, 0.9746031165122986, 0.7663353681564331, 0.06796785444021225, 0.37357383966445923, 0.4611344635486603, 0.21117575466632843, -0.28487375378608704, 0.17489328980445862, 0.3552567660808563, -0.5640242695808411, 0.6295194029808044, 0.05593298748135567, -0.41056010127067566, -0.44799068570137024, -0.4853510558605194, 0.24064350128173828, 0.7139750123023987, -0.575339674949646, 0.716780960559845, -0.1191822960972786, 0.3375346064567566, -0.7005302906036377, 0.5751863718032837, 0.4004261791706085, -0.18241147696971893, -0.7141026854515076, 0.42619258165359497, -0.016169467940926552, -0.4665350019931793, -0.32572877407073975, 0.6201888918876648, 0.30793723464012146, 0.058430999517440796, -0.6741353273391724, 0.5890485048294067, 0.7203488349914551, 0.34324273467063904, -0.6101848483085632, 0.26893559098243713, 1.0856359004974365, -0.308122456073761, -0.35682499408721924, 0.10030165314674377, -0.20658856630325317, 0.09272772818803787, -1.2141882181167603, 0.29782944917678833, 0.4241327941417694, -0.32729971408843994, 0.5273481011390686, 0.4498005509376526, 0.5658321380615234, 0.8077621459960938, -0.601131796836853, 0.16502982378005981, 0.14328108727931976, 0.9927942752838135, -0.9923563003540039, 0.7411614656448364, 0.2021578550338745, 0.3917762041091919, 0.3858250081539154, 0.4157472252845764, 0.3869454562664032, 0.4887448251247406, 0.4409148693084717, 0.2684222459793091, 0.7807889580726624, 0.0695103332400322, -0.5640813708305359, 0.21707512438297272, 0.20067189633846283, 0.2176744043827057, -0.15336008369922638, 0.2763477861881256, -0.02100742608308792, 0.664553165435791, 0.012023866176605225, -0.04044654592871666, -1.5531858205795288, -0.5830649733543396, 0.2984454035758972, 0.5445591807365417, -0.3765868842601776, -0.3771367371082306, -0.4974941313266754, 0.4443287253379822, -0.3402910828590393, 0.154291570186615, 0.46083253622055054, -0.09553861618041992, 0.5538946986198425, 0.41980496048927307, 0.04465432092547417, -0.18242278695106506, -1.4494366645812988, -1.2330105304718018, -1.2827070951461792, -0.5855613946914673, -0.21947187185287476, -0.03079456463456154, -0.24049276113510132, -0.46662238240242004, -0.09353451430797577, -0.029847003519535065, 0.20995868742465973, -0.4141319692134857, 0.12818382680416107, 0.09371889382600784, -0.23283882439136505, 0.06760157644748688, -0.733691930770874, 0.26837217807769775, 0.06631401181221008, 0.9334093928337097, 0.2844471335411072, 0.48224493861198425, -0.8285427689552307, -1.1955468654632568, -0.33955079317092896, -0.37697333097457886, 0.3381923735141754, 0.25170838832855225, -0.5210893154144287, -0.6467226147651672, 0.5052608251571655, -0.22428028285503387, 0.2699914276599884, -0.5605894923210144, -0.8881381750106812, 0.5366233587265015, 0.28159335255622864, 0.3635075092315674, 0.6305161714553833, 0.7094884514808655, -0.7680503129959106, 0.8893442153930664, 0.11038942635059357, -0.06193389743566513, -0.9655097723007202, 0.3917160630226135, 0.48831459879875183, -0.48724454641342163, 0.3433191180229187, -0.28246068954467773, -0.6395263671875, -0.04546910524368286, -0.1868262141942978, -0.5400460958480835, -0.1195714920759201, 0.33610600233078003, -0.11193118989467621, -1.763777494430542, 0.020015209913253784, -0.8149587512016296, -1.4170461893081665, 0.36871033906936646, -0.1129792332649231, 0.3915656805038452, 0.0021545407362282276, -0.10926180332899094, -0.49070706963539124, 0.2840406596660614, 0.4028927981853485, 0.7581720352172852, 0.44538795948028564, -0.3828732967376709, -0.7362954020500183, 0.4148920476436615, -0.15623122453689575, -0.13113270699977875, -0.2908906638622284, -0.0916161760687828, 0.06357451528310776, -0.037707019597291946, -0.5513399243354797, 1.0881725549697876, 0.8734928965568542, -0.16539129614830017, -0.25843605399131775, 0.3445758819580078, -0.449057936668396, 0.2052709460258484, 0.6203315258026123, 0.11791849881410599, 0.14112502336502075, 0.6053350567817688, -0.49589118361473083, 0.1320105940103531, -0.2857026159763336, -0.8539923429489136, -0.08758528530597687, -0.07178483158349991, 0.48824650049209595, -0.7128627300262451, 0.5099220871925354, 0.017610518261790276, 0.651780903339386, 0.4269595146179199, -0.2254069745540619, -1.2696874141693115, 0.7556033730506897, 0.1148407906293869, 1.2113722562789917, -0.6142334342002869, 0.18421199917793274, 0.21839304268360138, 1.5014466047286987, 0.5169438719749451, 0.06692606210708618, 0.6008821725845337, -0.4400816261768341, 0.6582288146018982, 0.13135860860347748, 0.11270065605640411, -0.013899565674364567, 0.6210743188858032, 0.17760547995567322, 0.22497642040252686, -0.06059250980615616, -0.5319124460220337, 0.17377367615699768, 0.6293474435806274, 0.33951401710510254, -0.40081655979156494, 0.7682209610939026, -0.183105006814003, 0.2939002513885498, 0.8687219619750977, 0.982089638710022, -0.03179234638810158, -0.7064610123634338, 0.058637361973524094, -0.007956205867230892, 0.099610835313797, -0.6224854588508606, -0.008537061512470245, 0.38253888487815857, 0.19658829271793365, 0.2618114650249481, 0.3524778485298157, -0.8433680534362793, -0.9492378234863281, -0.2796773910522461, 0.5575715899467468, 0.5641279816627502, -0.5491271615028381, -1.2212960720062256, 0.13635863363742828, -0.38730403780937195, -0.07408923655748367, 0.013579938560724258, -0.2388300895690918, 0.19907251000404358, 0.4958949685096741, -0.9801855683326721, -0.959821879863739, -0.033791717141866684, -0.6259558200836182, -0.6286263465881348, 0.6005118489265442, -0.366970032453537, -0.03668741136789322, 0.2681540548801422, -0.7898074984550476, -0.4544064700603485, -0.6095914244651794, 0.2838013470172882, -0.080111064016819, 0.5820839405059814, 0.0878736823797226, 0.9563326835632324, 0.4626592695713043, 0.22652454674243927, -0.2950345575809479, 0.2313089817762375, -0.23263810575008392, 0.5938939452171326, -0.4087507426738739, -0.6540319919586182, 0.11178988963365555, 0.2862778902053833, -0.33996686339378357, -0.629793643951416, -0.008180366829037666, 0.027796177193522453, -0.44180700182914734, 0.3458530604839325, 0.06787899136543274, -0.8347243666648865, 1.4101450443267822, -0.2844354510307312, 0.29198670387268066, 0.47836318612098694, -0.2911834418773651, -0.3432033061981201, -0.029528100043535233, 0.04406730830669403, -0.7946523427963257, 0.5573901534080505, 0.22373244166374207, 0.16154035925865173, -0.26699134707450867, -0.5677699446678162, -0.029072536155581474, -0.45077407360076904, 0.27966779470443726, -0.2897621989250183, -0.3711738884449005, -0.9669975638389587, -0.6548534631729126, -0.3455175757408142, -0.0903780460357666, -0.28256136178970337, 0.3282238245010376, -0.5212623476982117, -0.5974557399749756, -0.2654916048049927, -0.39299434423446655, -0.8453514575958252, -0.3716978132724762, -0.27703842520713806, -0.36685243248939514, -0.2941560447216034, -0.03405912593007088, 0.14700043201446533, -0.8869234323501587, -1.1735550165176392, 0.07856970280408859, 1.0768167972564697, -0.6623735427856445, -0.2485731989145279, -0.32961350679397583, -0.13661812245845795, -0.3071804344654083, -0.5157832503318787, 0.07627195119857788, -0.8850058913230896, 0.09137802571058273, -0.2758968770503998, 0.10789863020181656, 0.5976300835609436, 0.1741141378879547, -0.18337924778461456, 0.25745970010757446, 0.3664532005786896, -0.80173259973526, -0.44278809428215027, 0.4495161175727844, -0.34448862075805664, 0.29554206132888794, 0.6270014047622681, -0.27415814995765686, -0.012314106337726116, -0.594828188419342, 0.3841134011745453, -0.060426048934459686, -0.29611000418663025, -0.4496775269508362, -0.37692970037460327, -0.014156735502183437, 0.1112217903137207, 0.9530153274536133, -0.4505968689918518, -0.36502352356910706, -0.6200740933418274, 0.2117222249507904, -0.03249216824769974, 0.029341189190745354, 0.02309419959783554, -0.29567068815231323, 0.555883526802063, 0.9032294154167175, -0.40582168102264404, -0.5142471790313721, -0.5980929136276245, -0.28159040212631226, 0.5406661629676819, 1.3625885248184204, -0.7542580366134644, -0.3760248124599457, 0.07664420455694199, -0.5835869312286377, 0.337705135345459, -0.06164606288075447, -1.2402898073196411, 0.15387612581253052, -0.8472734689712524, 0.039544280618429184, -0.6089723706245422, -0.17716513574123383, -0.28639864921569824, -0.6222960352897644, 0.7131567001342773, -0.6711909770965576, 0.016380399465560913, 0.37180566787719727, -0.12261784076690674, -0.43844789266586304, 0.4040033221244812, -1.0881178379058838, -0.3327677547931671, -0.05190213397145271, -0.22819973528385162, -0.29976484179496765, -0.23164914548397064, 0.30117708444595337, 0.5275354385375977, -0.5110534429550171, 0.10582321882247925, -0.9381426572799683, 0.6115177869796753, 0.6102378368377686, -0.03254971653223038, -0.4172172248363495, 0.03425911068916321, -0.06378855556249619, 0.4633541703224182, -0.09348927438259125, 0.6110537052154541, -0.17529591917991638, -0.7040024399757385, -0.4826805591583252, -0.11270444840192795, -0.5094277858734131, 0.2166907787322998, 0.07527968287467957, 0.9787251949310303, -0.3546268343925476, -0.0645373985171318, 0.45437851548194885, -0.07925394922494888, -0.1461634337902069, 0.3277619183063507, -0.4943169951438904, 0.18147359788417816, 0.8424972891807556, -0.09787001460790634, -0.545211136341095, 0.2414218932390213, -0.46318602561950684, 0.15618650615215302, -0.11570171266794205, 0.017403485253453255, 0.40936633944511414, -1.0049583911895752, 0.8345494866371155, 0.2254400998353958, -0.38296911120414734, -0.5227192044258118, 0.2639143466949463, -0.7350194454193115, 0.03261902928352356, -0.46535634994506836, -0.26669833064079285, 1.1392449140548706, -0.2278641164302826, 0.19723725318908691, -0.8793817162513733, -0.46565893292427063, -0.1899416595697403, -0.5148019194602966, 0.3158881962299347, -0.5429834723472595, 0.49354952573776245, 0.6519903540611267, 0.029368441551923752, 0.4351879954338074, 0.021613024175167084, 0.2418634295463562, 0.3943774402141571, 0.5746240615844727, 0.05942269042134285, -0.5689650177955627, -0.34585103392601013, -0.36939287185668945, 0.4825526773929596, 0.43292325735092163, -0.1861831545829773, -0.6250754594802856, 0.5669209957122803, 0.2418266087770462, -0.8460139632225037, -0.3775408864021301, 0.2884122133255005, -0.28954482078552246, 0.2798192501068115, 0.010327843017876148, 0.660068154335022, 1.5128661394119263, 0.47751957178115845, 0.25506654381752014, -0.8248592615127563, -0.12078528851270676, -0.5575345754623413, -0.10306044667959213, -0.0793679729104042, -0.5019282102584839, -0.4329753816127777, 0.34489282965660095, -0.1691085547208786, -0.43654000759124756, -0.577456533908844, 1.1087594032287598, -0.6369919776916504, -0.5951561331748962, -0.20181909203529358, 0.8890196681022644, -0.3553207814693451, -0.20895355939865112, -0.21581852436065674, -0.07939111441373825, 0.239665225148201, 0.7053139209747314, -0.6894650459289551, -0.4494988024234772, 0.0696849599480629, 0.026350297033786774, -0.03568672761321068, 0.5180002450942993, -1.0972825288772583, -0.15357184410095215, -0.04000905528664589, 0.29425597190856934, 0.10098797082901001, 0.10894565284252167, 0.5012823939323425, -0.20468682050704956, 0.16180367767810822, 0.5362444519996643, -0.13044865429401398, -0.8098518252372742, 0.3138441741466522, 0.20481730997562408, -0.410571426153183, -0.1534278839826584, -0.684880256652832, 0.6263904571533203, -0.9443528652191162, 0.03905776888132095, 0.744819700717926, -0.49581587314605713, -0.06557042896747589, 0.1736481934785843, 0.07850892096757889, 0.947257399559021, 0.016255391761660576, 0.6746053695678711, 0.2328670769929886, 0.3866359293460846, -0.14008522033691406, -0.3081901967525482, 0.4523211419582367, -0.021797645837068558, -0.7418474555015564, -0.7574602365493774, 0.2867905795574188, 0.9482965469360352, -0.25447702407836914, -0.04673544317483902, -0.1297869235277176, 0.15632511675357819, -0.3686867952346802, -0.31481316685676575, 0.4549458622932434, 1.167548418045044, 0.9451014399528503, 0.7699206471443176, 0.42628374695777893, -0.4044593572616577, -0.6465300917625427, -0.4595998525619507, -0.9644999504089355, -1.09357750415802, 0.6093858480453491, -0.16071030497550964, 0.13927960395812988, -0.5758466124534607, -0.4793408215045929, -0.14343200623989105, 0.5939834117889404, 0.10397644340991974, -0.13211756944656372, 0.8935023546218872, 0.23716755211353302, 0.09376485645771027, 0.31416022777557373, -0.041469503194093704, -0.24076862633228302, -0.1307484656572342, -0.8242751955986023, -0.5870463252067566, 0.37222719192504883, 0.6014477610588074, 0.3502153158187866, 0.13009397685527802, -0.6744247078895569, 0.36117851734161377, 0.05180063098669052, -0.7200459837913513, -0.4277659058570862, 0.0616069920361042, -0.6255897283554077, -0.13075599074363708, -0.21600346267223358, 0.3445645272731781, -0.15199261903762817, 0.5770626068115234, 0.6840241551399231, -0.3168381452560425, -0.6194431781768799, 0.30839666724205017, 0.6226539611816406, -0.3507785499095917, 0.09861600399017334, 0.23617908358573914, 0.2151060551404953, 0.21575789153575897, -0.976974606513977, 0.40444332361221313, 0.7703378200531006, 0.46004894375801086, -0.5563041567802429, -0.6624818444252014, 0.14546428620815277, 0.7870754599571228, 0.33862924575805664, -0.28069865703582764, 0.9241331815719604, 0.24495834112167358, -0.3141908645629883, 0.07489864528179169, -0.1596129834651947, 0.3492511808872223, -0.4459553062915802, 0.19403330981731415, 0.4523523151874542, 0.23080633580684662, -0.02684207446873188, 0.2315472811460495, -0.8388074636459351, 0.0773409828543663, -0.5053791999816895, -1.1220101118087769, -0.411609023809433, 0.30079254508018494, 0.016011424362659454, 0.07576540112495422, 0.6932816505432129, -0.5728148818016052, 0.6023749113082886, 0.44652652740478516, 0.4347705543041229, 0.9862840175628662, 0.0157097727060318, -0.2517596185207367, -0.21078777313232422, 0.4471311867237091, -0.813988447189331, 0.8166479468345642, -0.2950652837753296, 0.13120900094509125, 0.24125763773918152, 0.5685585141181946, -0.12870019674301147, -0.42703837156295776, 0.8915892839431763, -0.31064873933792114, -0.3761700689792633, -0.4537353515625, 0.2514835298061371, -0.6681643724441528, -0.5628887414932251, 1.2817987203598022, -0.4750881493091583, 0.013865376822650433, -0.11693444848060608, 0.4262937307357788, 0.2870732247829437, 0.2201061248779297, 0.4863213896751404, 0.2014809250831604, 0.55255126953125, 0.5953055620193481, -0.11514978110790253, -0.46642616391181946, 0.08548194915056229, 0.28562846779823303, -0.1654055118560791, -0.1709677129983902, 0.2747911214828491, -0.13361455500125885, -0.19949008524417877, -0.5430244207382202, 0.07278946787118912, -0.5130323767662048, 0.03533075004816055, -1.1180741786956787, -0.4874049723148346, 0.16456836462020874, -0.4216400682926178, 0.2958459258079529, 0.6916701793670654, 0.20458880066871643, -0.14395074546337128, -0.6110198497772217, 0.07894023507833481, -0.7036011815071106, -0.053634725511074066, -0.5516171455383301, 0.11772459000349045, -0.05174889415502548, -0.7466932535171509, -0.7790877819061279, -1.1444320678710938, 0.06235064938664436, 0.0805959403514862, -0.25485607981681824, -0.38878586888313293, -0.055897220969200134, 0.08119285851716995, 1.185288906097412, 0.19275319576263428, -0.20836955308914185, 0.29065436124801636, 0.9134448170661926, 0.9129859209060669, 0.3517873287200928, 1.3410067558288574, 0.1041211411356926, 0.7995522022247314, 0.41297972202301025, -0.05318353697657585, -0.005362566560506821, -0.17768137156963348, -0.32133427262306213, -0.6510127186775208, -0.18237905204296112, -0.10877809673547745, -1.0184202194213867, -0.08715804666280746, 0.9485046863555908, 0.5460308790206909, -0.3544859290122986, -0.5274367332458496, 0.25824257731437683, -0.357496052980423, 0.8311760425567627, -0.5167196393013, 0.46136870980262756, 0.25542595982551575, 0.4062676429748535, 0.2105175107717514, -0.49457627534866333, 4.107442378997803, 0.6149293780326843, 0.9062653183937073, 0.058422937989234924, 0.40455251932144165, 0.6526480317115784, 1.0564982891082764, 0.2846112549304962, 0.6331322193145752, -0.6665837168693542, 0.1419268250465393, -0.12315032631158829, -0.36519885063171387, 0.023145293816924095, 0.07610218226909637, -0.1340855062007904, -0.417289137840271, 0.13036859035491943, -0.07280103862285614, -1.0640687942504883, -0.3617713153362274, 0.28065741062164307, -0.8670907616615295, 0.5978713035583496, 0.026377743110060692, -0.5301285982131958, 0.7692063450813293, 0.5372152924537659, 0.19904664158821106, 0.09773526340723038, -0.08409103006124496, -0.18051990866661072, 0.4063585102558136, -0.665942370891571, 0.16536220908164978, 0.08036544919013977, 0.22591590881347656, -0.8771425485610962, -0.3060532808303833, 0.19256068766117096, 0.38776645064353943, -0.17617030441761017, -0.040153320878744125, 0.043582893908023834, -0.4792114198207855, 0.38525888323783875, -0.14440186321735382, 0.14364735782146454, 0.4482566714286804, -0.20276682078838348, 0.9952215552330017, -0.7760353088378906, 0.457275390625, -0.048080213367938995, -0.5648173093795776, -0.837231457233429, -0.5979495048522949, -1.0696345567703247, -0.2952658236026764, 1.213450312614441, 0.9342456459999084, 0.7808564305305481, -0.3384495675563812, 0.4739837944507599, -0.332452654838562, 0.8486984968185425, 0.34569963812828064, -0.3701002299785614, -0.027749327942728996, 0.14712058007717133, 0.916182816028595, 0.19089360535144806, -0.5335038900375366, 0.09245964884757996, 0.4372517764568329, -0.16858753561973572, -0.7887817025184631, 1.1359189748764038, -0.21839837729930878, -0.17823131382465363, -0.21076692640781403, 0.8426401615142822, -0.12087864428758621, -0.23174799978733063, -0.09088505059480667, 0.8899479508399963, -1.1466177701950073, -0.06414931267499924, -0.8817929625511169, 0.24988825619220734, -0.08898855000734329, -0.020334474742412567, 0.13868480920791626, 0.2273990362882614, 0.17322814464569092 ]
{"Title": "Evaluation of Patient-Level Retrieval from Electronic Health Record Data for a Cohort Discovery Task", "Authors": "Bedrick Steven D., Cohen Aaron M., Wang Yanshan, Wen Andrew, Liu Sijia, Liu Hongfang, Hersh William R.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Objective Growing numbers of academic medical centers offer patient cohort discovery tools to their researchers, yet the performance of systems for this use case is not well-understood. The objective of this research was to assess patient-level information retrieval (IR) methods using electronic health records (EHR) for different types of cohort definition retrieval. Materials and Methods We developed a test collection consisting of about 100,000 patient records and 56 test topics that characterized patient cohort requests for various clinical studies. Automated IR tasks using word-based approaches were performed, varying four different parameters for a total of 48 permutations, with performance measured using B-Pref. We subsequently created structured Boolean queries for the 56 topics for performance comparisons. In addition, we performed a more detailed analysis of 10 topics. Results The best-performing word-based automated query parameter settings achieved a mean B-Pref of 0.167 across all 56 topics. The way a topic was structured (topic representation) had the largest impact on performance. Performance not only varied widely across topics, but there was also a large variance in sensitivity to parameter settings across the topics. Structured queries generally performed better than automated queries on measures of recall and precision, but were still not able to recall all relevant patients found by the automated queries. Conclusion While word-based automated methods of cohort retrieval offer an attractive solution to the labor-intensive nature of this task currently used at many medical centers, we generally found suboptimal performance in those approaches, with better performance obtained from structured Boolean queries. Insights gained in this preliminary analysis will help guide future work to develop new methods for patient-level cohort discovery with EHR data.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005280"}
10.1101/2019.12.09.19014183
[ -0.3186151385307312, 0.6541527509689331, -0.1636953502893448, 0.61765056848526, -0.47152388095855713, 0.5531622171401978, 0.00409268494695425, -0.046212613582611084, 0.07095007598400116, 0.8423321843147278, -0.26177889108657837, -0.6102342009544373, 0.4404130280017853, -0.1546037197113037, -0.2203962653875351, 0.13869315385818481, -0.06665699928998947, 0.16115175187587738, -0.7937360405921936, 0.25762084126472473, 0.3247048258781433, 1.2672719955444336, -1.147368311882019, 0.2803471088409424, -0.41711705923080444, 0.8961654305458069, 0.2045823484659195, 0.6889318823814392, 1.4903589487075806, 0.9148504734039307, 0.14437395334243774, -0.3184143006801605, 0.8285332918167114, -0.40054041147232056, -0.5487045049667358, -0.33795806765556335, 0.42139261960983276, 0.7256382703781128, -0.5887925028800964, -0.9280176162719727, 1.0885387659072876, 0.3383086919784546, 0.24956832826137543, 0.5631741881370544, -0.3400481641292572, 0.3016194701194763, -0.09460348635911942, 0.3192899823188782, 0.3648172616958618, -0.19107754528522491, 0.2523389160633087, 0.3947145640850067, 0.7606903910636902, -0.19188442826271057, -0.2988710403442383, -0.08754277229309082, -0.2321104258298874, 0.01702667772769928, -0.6913333535194397, -0.3121023178100586, 0.1818830519914627, -0.16174878180027008, -0.23735928535461426, -1.2166545391082764, 1.1781336069107056, 1.3331031799316406, 0.4082431197166443, -0.6434021592140198, -0.5791933536529541, 0.07339469343423843, 0.3175082802772522, -0.03689935803413391, 0.17021501064300537, -1.1546622514724731, -0.9427436590194702, -0.692619800567627, 0.6068625450134277, -0.37216150760650635, 0.0655759796500206, -0.3617968261241913, 0.13969603180885315, 0.7672926187515259, 0.2655051350593567, 0.29710477590560913, -1.0468742847442627, 0.03070170059800148, 0.28972822427749634, 0.9681727886199951, 0.342276006937027, 0.5533232688903809, -0.009774254634976387, 0.9764100313186646, 0.22577549517154694, 0.1514705866575241, 0.4852225184440613, 0.7928813099861145, -0.717269778251648, 0.6392040252685547, 0.11130954325199127, -0.6261659264564514, 0.9064871668815613, 0.21844016015529633, -0.09861095994710922, 1.023900032043457, -0.2185765504837036, 0.785254955291748, 0.1204303428530693, -0.26941725611686707, -0.12721258401870728, -0.28291332721710205, 0.7599411606788635, -0.7190313339233398, -0.11779738962650299, -0.35605141520500183, 1.306937336921692, 0.8095195293426514, -0.4105498492717743, 0.783585250377655, -0.7282077074050903, -0.1348850578069687, 0.08772462606430054, -1.0039538145065308, 0.2799481153488159, -0.6221188306808472, -0.10517926514148712, 0.13569959998130798, -0.6644660234451294, 0.4533354640007019, 0.08941595256328583, 0.8196402192115784, 0.4564627707004547, -0.8300771713256836, -0.3981943726539612, 0.6164177060127258, -0.09032800793647766, -0.3934272229671478, -0.5158392786979675, 1.0650554895401, 0.22868219017982483, -0.5415162444114685, 0.2328486442565918, 0.7023855447769165, -0.7133338451385498, 1.451055884361267, -0.37185749411582947, 0.8265959620475769, -0.8675183653831482, -1.1722968816757202, -1.0151900053024292, 0.6673818826675415, -0.18083298206329346, 0.4820302724838257, -0.03488954156637192, -0.39383792877197266, 0.18883435428142548, 0.6086835861206055, 0.10410071909427643, 0.5646144151687622, -0.14049941301345825, 0.5874082446098328, -0.6993337273597717, 0.2547922134399414, -0.012300071306526661, 0.1753474324941635, -1.0238019227981567, 0.7655844688415527, 0.0007455620798282325, -0.041500408202409744, 0.16626569628715515, -0.8507252931594849, 1.1241161823272705, -0.3689814507961273, 0.02549714967608452, 0.06256379932165146, -0.3748059868812561, 0.4023435115814209, 0.4569770395755768, -0.3542906641960144, 0.48895907402038574, 0.8554604053497314, 0.23927493393421173, -0.040127791464328766, -0.4813925325870514, 0.33140993118286133, -0.30341213941574097, 0.05502164736390114, -0.36805260181427, -1.0836186408996582, -0.4546950161457062, -0.6226606965065002, -0.15550658106803894, 0.06114198639988899, 0.276711106300354, 0.8875723481178284, -0.01813345029950142, 0.2734852135181427, -0.5488671660423279, 0.4958869218826294, -0.26643499732017517, -0.1729310303926468, -0.12956103682518005, 0.6055831909179688, 0.049813851714134216, -0.06534934043884277, 0.0006346870213747025, 0.029542068019509315, 0.5065392851829529, 0.49066731333732605, -0.3397742807865143, 0.12565702199935913, 0.9105536937713623, -0.3800731897354126, -0.5034400224685669, -0.8477953672409058, 0.1391219198703766, -0.8002328872680664, 0.377983421087265, 0.887504518032074, -1.0106207132339478, 0.06871042400598526, -0.3560344874858856, -0.5930007696151733, 0.6584197878837585, -0.16220936179161072, -0.1276889443397522, 0.12110935151576996, 0.5822293758392334, 0.5152523517608643, -0.17631390690803528, -0.6513676643371582, 0.12143680453300476, 0.356770396232605, -0.5608680248260498, 1.0450550317764282, 0.9246277213096619, 0.48871293663978577, -0.007818296551704407, 0.4448526203632355, 0.0778547003865242, 0.5235003232955933, 0.30173081159591675, -0.06047863885760307, 0.31365767121315, 0.3770739734172821, -0.34144580364227295, 0.24765008687973022, -0.21963262557983398, -0.0867641493678093, -0.49067461490631104, 0.5704379081726074, -0.3377261161804199, -0.13535141944885254, 0.5789126753807068, 0.6690410375595093, -1.071998953819275, -0.7749708890914917, 0.31013450026512146, -0.05321770906448364, -0.4426124095916748, -0.32541102170944214, -0.8906512260437012, 0.5317105054855347, -0.6751819252967834, -0.37735071778297424, 1.4154340028762817, 0.84980708360672, -0.12301766872406006, 0.841772198677063, 0.29514986276626587, -0.30331918597221375, -1.210529088973999, -0.43133750557899475, -1.2307511568069458, -0.6167632341384888, -1.1692203283309937, -0.08023380488157272, 0.0922323539853096, -0.32950910925865173, 0.1863837093114853, -0.3386094570159912, 0.31216683983802795, -0.520591676235199, -0.3617119789123535, 0.25858914852142334, 0.7053532004356384, 0.18820150196552277, -0.7910967469215393, 0.17643900215625763, -0.7306904196739197, -0.14006786048412323, -0.31375929713249207, -0.5879287123680115, -0.5920652151107788, -0.3194429278373718, 0.4238339960575104, -0.2022293508052826, -0.15990504622459412, -0.3417513072490692, 0.1443413943052292, -0.177577406167984, 0.09363462030887604, 0.3423048257827759, 0.07196106016635895, -0.30461373925209045, -1.1323579549789429, 0.2349218875169754, 0.18161721527576447, -0.05684830993413925, 0.9158350825309753, -0.291922390460968, -0.5910128951072693, 0.44798192381858826, 0.5089801549911499, -0.15861153602600098, -0.912800133228302, -0.025254860520362854, 0.17085252702236176, 0.5775773525238037, 0.09024188667535782, -0.9275829195976257, -1.2963287830352783, -0.12485536932945251, -0.023641111329197884, -0.6212285161018372, -0.3923216164112091, 0.5706024765968323, -0.6072320938110352, -1.4972883462905884, 0.3071593642234802, -0.19899030029773712, -0.9699620008468628, -0.23724670708179474, 0.09930165857076645, 0.772843062877655, 0.7775378227233887, 0.5714272856712341, -0.3926967680454254, 0.587224543094635, -0.3205910623073578, 0.7108161449432373, -0.23232413828372955, -0.4555645287036896, 0.25624319911003113, 0.35148125886917114, 0.30564332008361816, 0.3397309184074402, 0.2665178179740906, -0.1592690646648407, 0.14680680632591248, 0.09774968773126602, -0.15720976889133453, 0.4487663209438324, 0.5543202757835388, 1.124651312828064, 0.004494532942771912, 0.38722360134124756, -0.1558959037065506, 0.27084264159202576, 0.499813973903656, -0.023327894508838654, 0.1374659389257431, 0.13967609405517578, -0.14583206176757812, 0.12324117124080658, -0.3916335999965668, -0.7201321721076965, 0.36195215582847595, -0.520127534866333, 0.6120965480804443, -0.16927769780158997, 1.1899738311767578, 0.7074625492095947, -0.0745265781879425, 0.3564412593841553, -0.28924185037612915, 0.11826632916927338, 1.123703956604004, -0.07994484901428223, 1.5605833530426025, -1.542832851409912, -0.4161530137062073, 0.05110776424407959, 0.993049144744873, 0.2006690949201584, -0.03991441801190376, 0.6593548059463501, -0.8029340505599976, 0.27443957328796387, -0.11536738276481628, 0.30928537249565125, -0.026768693700432777, -0.5655287504196167, 0.4784896671772003, 0.49975481629371643, -0.7274751663208008, -0.4140799343585968, -0.0065316092222929, 0.2847519516944885, 0.06253350526094437, 0.32604941725730896, 0.955389142036438, -0.8745973110198975, 0.8777748346328735, 0.3782554268836975, 0.8957078456878662, 0.3988180458545685, -1.1318225860595703, -0.019145626574754715, 0.34320029616355896, -0.35533222556114197, -0.043447788804769516, -0.27540117502212524, -0.9759390354156494, -0.44018760323524475, 0.42604130506515503, -0.06211518868803978, -0.8467836380004883, 0.3118375539779663, -0.21886585652828217, 0.2505649924278259, 0.20528022944927216, 0.17818956077098846, -0.07388109713792801, -0.1159382089972496, 0.2559044361114502, -0.7867375612258911, -0.1991444081068039, -1.1552786827087402, 0.47784894704818726, 0.8780277371406555, -0.427809476852417, -1.0583547353744507, -0.7260696887969971, 0.028719741851091385, 0.11150360852479935, 0.08800801634788513, 0.8578668832778931, -0.08467144519090652, 0.11863034963607788, 0.06677921116352081, 0.05088984966278076, -0.32994210720062256, -0.0860951691865921, -0.6378870606422424, -0.46369943022727966, 0.27282240986824036, 0.4580402374267578, 0.4183356463909149, 0.7743978500366211, -0.05478603392839432, 0.421663373708725, -0.3702084422111511, -0.3582884669303894, -0.879715621471405, -0.06253958493471146, 0.10644962638616562, 0.06360188126564026, 0.15602117776870728, 0.6104931831359863, -0.5143506526947021, -0.44652682542800903, -0.015833986923098564, 0.11488859355449677, -0.24268381297588348, -0.5382028818130493, 0.6927239298820496, -0.724873423576355, -0.04194371774792671, 0.9709847569465637, 0.06970461457967758, 0.12457920610904694, 0.29595428705215454, 0.46959584951400757, -0.6440048217773438, 0.3054667115211487, 0.24905329942703247, 0.13922134041786194, 0.9642983675003052, -0.39231443405151367, -0.16632622480392456, -0.27947863936424255, 0.4906892776489258, -0.6105166673660278, 0.2716600000858307, -0.32702571153640747, -0.5046567320823669, -0.47985929250717163, -0.19849030673503876, -0.9198624491691589, 0.45168986916542053, -0.5425305366516113, -1.058401346206665, 0.06377164274454117, 0.0095248743891716, -0.5342400074005127, -0.49272069334983826, -0.2739632725715637, 0.31024396419525146, -0.6936763525009155, 0.6929123401641846, 0.866062581539154, 0.23165683448314667, -0.9614303708076477, 0.5125714540481567, 0.08385410159826279, -1.0306212902069092, -0.691145122051239, -0.2256961315870285, 0.5215814709663391, -0.7238141298294067, -0.07382681220769882, -0.011629965156316757, -1.1688852310180664, -0.3166559338569641, -0.16998577117919922, -0.1812783032655716, 0.8812318444252014, 0.11325521767139435, 0.026534218341112137, 0.3104497790336609, 0.3986806273460388, -1.0136070251464844, -0.4990456998348236, 0.3148403465747833, -0.28072065114974976, 0.014902360737323761, 0.14196999371051788, -0.6157481670379639, -0.48918861150741577, -1.400286078453064, 0.3827477991580963, -0.17908936738967896, -0.024642573669552803, -0.631449282169342, -0.5047275424003601, -0.09375041723251343, 0.7377960681915283, 0.25361841917037964, 0.469117134809494, -0.21210038661956787, -0.439925879240036, 0.12813010811805725, -0.007830219343304634, -0.2114427536725998, -0.6764367818832397, -0.3393285274505615, -0.05744419991970062, 0.7520491480827332, -0.1450384259223938, -0.6705088019371033, 0.4966690242290497, 0.20836059749126434, 0.8558557033538818, 0.378811776638031, -0.4194747507572174, -0.5007380843162537, -0.5248426198959351, 0.2174040973186493, -1.0742310285568237, 0.6960965394973755, -1.4044514894485474, 0.27190250158309937, -0.28536972403526306, 0.024102434515953064, -0.28677019476890564, -0.17584308981895447, 0.3080750107765198, 0.08555231243371964, 0.8604715466499329, -0.3037479519844055, 0.04051189124584198, 0.7682732343673706, 0.5280764698982239, -0.4932379126548767, 0.17766733467578888, -0.27415868639945984, -0.4117225706577301, -1.0018130540847778, -1.2235139608383179, 0.21464374661445618, -0.4521152377128601, -0.38429680466651917, 0.10444260388612747, -0.058526661247015, 0.7512560486793518, -0.4847858250141144, 1.4478870630264282, 0.6094115972518921, -0.7090429663658142, 0.055461570620536804, -0.01930197887122631, 0.49742043018341064, -0.20601050555706024, -0.4002971947193146, -0.010747114196419716, -0.4685220718383789, 0.11768335103988647, 0.0881190225481987, -0.08623434603214264, -1.3047163486480713, -0.0084286043420434, 0.05391811951994896, 0.6255424618721008, -0.11089623719453812, -0.06709481030702591, -0.02807794138789177, -0.315152108669281, -0.5892891883850098, 0.8488634824752808, 0.1917431801557541, -0.029599346220493317, 1.0502784252166748, -0.6844469308853149, -0.18818680942058563, 0.9494752287864685, -0.08976736664772034, 0.04229127988219261, -0.4694425165653229, 1.116756796836853, 1.0666433572769165, -1.0940234661102295, 0.7900868058204651, 0.2527388036251068, -0.6796251535415649, -0.06492354720830917, -0.4261929988861084, -0.20433861017227173, -0.17443884909152985, 0.055012185126543045, -0.14068283140659332, 0.3207475543022156, -0.16734060645103455, 0.3615117073059082, -0.26187342405319214, 0.32763242721557617, 0.20657123625278473, -0.6453738808631897, -0.2183014452457428, -0.6756908297538757, -0.40977346897125244, 0.5857223868370056, 0.42341896891593933, 0.10624264925718307, 0.6634313464164734, 0.9912353157997131, 0.17487312853336334, 0.17299845814704895, 0.4415462911128998, -0.7977389097213745, 0.020127644762396812, -0.19565805792808533, 1.0662232637405396, -0.1801328957080841, -0.053575266152620316, 0.03257124498486519, 0.7014034986495972, 0.7335537672042847, -0.5708063840866089, -0.7098813056945801, -0.122859887778759, 0.4023468494415283, 0.2461574524641037, 0.00741278100758791, 0.21031923592090607, 0.8882441520690918, 0.3466012477874756, 0.5138128995895386, -0.5219374895095825, -0.5152839422225952, -0.6090651154518127, 0.13932009041309357, 0.35379138588905334, -0.33614581823349, 0.010822263546288013, 0.6626764535903931, -0.03436847776174545, -0.3214500844478607, -0.4740792512893677, 0.8588351607322693, 0.5499165654182434, -0.05962565168738365, -0.8255441784858704, -0.15904030203819275, -0.8680388331413269, -0.6018149852752686, -0.5808574557304382, -0.3398345410823822, -0.04211830347776413, 0.8852214217185974, -0.6111704707145691, -0.2208196222782135, 0.2471989095211029, 0.5561961531639099, 0.13607029616832733, 0.19101843237876892, -0.9985649585723877, -0.06392255425453186, -0.6187361478805542, 0.3146117925643921, 0.4639955163002014, -0.5013306736946106, 0.589830756187439, -0.4448566436767578, 0.7235867977142334, 0.8701369166374207, 0.11845305562019348, -0.680367648601532, -0.15332764387130737, 0.9346767663955688, -1.0986757278442383, -0.5248562097549438, -0.5297351479530334, 0.760635256767273, -1.1881134510040283, -0.5422820448875427, 0.06863387674093246, -0.7817684412002563, 0.031347859650850296, 0.2993330955505371, 0.21138454973697662, 0.3907823860645294, -0.022063875570893288, -0.4013822674751282, -0.27333924174308777, 1.0120795965194702, 0.13456542789936066, -0.4902976155281067, 0.8649994730949402, -0.3617071509361267, -0.46734970808029175, -1.0610650777816772, 0.6190448999404907, 0.6197039484977722, -0.5556426644325256, 0.5655284523963928, 0.13189657032489777, 0.7811393737792969, -0.2227480262517929, -0.6813768148422241, 0.267082154750824, 0.4758129119873047, 0.32926878333091736, 1.0274057388305664, -0.24975217878818512, -0.2475535124540329, -0.8681557178497314, -0.4759751260280609, -1.0987663269042969, -0.6049563884735107, 0.7177968621253967, -1.1170713901519775, -0.33370086550712585, -1.3713793754577637, -0.5984070897102356, 0.5627386569976807, 0.7855233550071716, -0.1219249740242958, -0.7798102498054504, 0.47847744822502136, 1.2291282415390015, 0.9087310433387756, 0.7416359782218933, -0.39922910928726196, 0.027174782007932663, 0.22429697215557098, -0.7119022011756897, 0.2556333839893341, -0.0495576336979866, 0.1154002770781517, 0.2819742262363434, -0.37649598717689514, -0.3386404514312744, 0.03687145933508873, -0.18446487188339233, 0.0591958649456501, -0.31910914182662964, -0.43726757168769836, -0.4249769449234009, 0.4299628436565399, -0.4564855992794037, -0.41467708349227905, -0.9149469137191772, 0.6708078384399414, -0.09902743250131607, -1.1196035146713257, -0.625323474407196, 0.48471811413764954, 0.6819994449615479, -0.11544179171323776, 0.6320041418075562, 0.16307543218135834, 0.2881968319416046, -0.0915590226650238, -0.3110228478908539, 0.7955456972122192, 0.2312621921300888, 0.03844586759805679, 0.20815345644950867, -0.21460650861263275, 0.8346495628356934, 0.5381658673286438, 0.326688677072525, -0.28282850980758667, 0.2624848186969757, 0.37980708479881287, 0.04678044840693474, 0.07160480320453644, -0.42255088686943054, -0.15259622037410736, 0.21667511761188507, -0.7203030586242676, -0.18508118391036987, 0.7262604832649231, 0.3246540427207947, -0.4253298044204712, -0.24018871784210205, 0.11615045368671417, -0.37170085310935974, -0.3770866096019745, -0.22364626824855804, 0.27995312213897705, 0.963870644569397, -0.06911462545394897, 0.09840602427721024, 0.13014711439609528, 1.0658434629440308, -0.04804195836186409, -0.008131418377161026, 0.6604427099227905, -0.5771292448043823, -0.18176355957984924, -0.6654740571975708, 0.23908019065856934, 0.4940335750579834, 0.28752294182777405, 0.38014084100723267, -0.7335944175720215, 0.48742738366127014, 0.7442110776901245, -0.23673014342784882, -0.16002511978149414, 0.9710260629653931, 0.3024126887321472, -0.4120504856109619, -0.12392468750476837, 0.09056608378887177, -1.129589557647705, 0.08024115115404129, -0.22148104012012482, -0.3934086859226227, 0.4788191318511963, 0.16188278794288635, 0.6953408718109131, 1.0242348909378052, -0.14817550778388977, 0.30901771783828735, -0.19209757447242737, 0.23850058019161224, 1.0662884712219238, 0.5858582258224487, -0.45016175508499146, -0.31578102707862854, 0.05055147781968117, -0.7648046016693115, -0.131498321890831, -0.04526100307703018, 0.14372655749320984, -0.2864035367965698, 0.06950969994068146, -0.30721187591552734, 0.20764289796352386, -0.13721811771392822, -0.42466220259666443, -0.026644814759492874, 0.4590245485305786, -0.30765748023986816, -0.38015609979629517, 0.5735573768615723, 0.15513867139816284, -0.30587971210479736, -0.49711528420448303, -0.012969177216291428, -0.9674974679946899, 0.7764310836791992, -0.38141930103302, 0.5978091359138489, -0.2067253738641739, -0.12541337311267853, -0.7246400117874146, -0.7065781354904175, -0.7101811766624451, -0.38011690974235535, 0.17720749974250793, -1.1556423902511597, -0.5047393441200256, 0.15114353597164154, 0.15718144178390503, 0.34764137864112854, 0.14383503794670105, 0.05384921655058861, -0.3937983512878418, 0.6831381916999817, -0.028225043788552284, 0.664150059223175, -0.029753578826785088, 0.1732931286096573, -0.06461381912231445, 0.32294946908950806, -0.0707297995686531, -0.5112870931625366, -0.6727816462516785, -0.2562643587589264, 0.3396154046058655, 0.5477750897407532, -1.0462212562561035, 0.28967976570129395, 0.5972711443901062, 0.09391079097986221, -0.46198105812072754, -0.6059160828590393, -0.7059410810470581, 0.004634270444512367, 0.41050848364830017, -0.4104043245315552, -0.2850390076637268, 0.3484170436859131, 0.0460074357688427, 1.3161261081695557, -1.5168664455413818, 3.824798107147217, 1.3712999820709229, 0.8861681222915649, -0.14045344293117523, -0.30500102043151855, 0.67003333568573, 0.629898726940155, 0.09180216491222382, -0.28017541766166687, -0.3602343201637268, -0.07390225678682327, 0.0707162469625473, 0.1536390781402588, 0.24077413976192474, 0.13024431467056274, 0.795442521572113, -1.226199984550476, 0.4276551604270935, -0.24923227727413177, -1.1592649221420288, -0.45827606320381165, 0.24784384667873383, -0.5016983151435852, 0.17533689737319946, 0.36832308769226074, 0.23268632590770721, 0.35189196467399597, 0.5992271900177002, -0.13559980690479279, -0.12104794383049011, 0.4646778106689453, -0.4169304072856903, 0.3528539538383484, -0.682343602180481, -0.4220110774040222, 0.18557967245578766, -0.24504221975803375, -0.7226453423500061, 0.4140387177467346, -0.11117233335971832, 0.32272177934646606, -0.6584610342979431, -0.6429241299629211, -0.661401629447937, -0.5187109708786011, -0.1883310228586197, -0.4982353746891022, 0.1451127976179123, 0.40772756934165955, -0.3291260004043579, 0.8269601464271545, -0.733720064163208, 0.5892180800437927, -0.5521910786628723, -0.3024844527244568, -0.2758561968803406, -0.16959354281425476, -0.7681502103805542, 0.2821875810623169, 0.43355709314346313, 0.4869025647640228, -0.013128715567290783, -0.5696069002151489, -0.46909722685813904, 0.6855139136314392, 0.1102389320731163, 0.3329773545265198, -0.14615380764007568, -0.28635749220848083, -0.871944010257721, -0.10541321337223053, -0.5706896781921387, -0.12445434927940369, -0.5994477272033691, 0.45661595463752747, 0.7834640145301819, -0.011247284710407257, 0.43224504590034485, 0.278828501701355, -0.351846843957901, 0.22416819632053375, 0.1404755860567093, -0.009693127125501633, -0.10353130102157593, 0.13369014859199524, 0.4993952214717865, -0.6204781532287598, -0.29196181893348694, -1.2138087749481201, 0.6777368783950806, 0.7613914012908936, 0.18819376826286316, 0.14705504477024078, 0.24518683552742004, -0.6099438667297363 ]
{"Title": "A polygenic risk score for rheumatoid arthritis sheds light on the Prevotella association", "Authors": "Wells Philippa M, Adebayo Adewale S, Freidin Maxim B, Finckh Axel, Strowig Till, Lesker Till Robin, Alpizar-Rodriguez Deshire, Gilbert Benoit, Kirkham Bruce, Cope Andrew P, Steves Claire J, Williams Frances M K", "Abstract": "Abstract Background Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic inflammatory autoimmune disease associated with reduced life expectancy. It is heritable and an extensive repertoire of genetic variants have been identified. The gut microbiota may represent an environmental risk factor for RA. Indeed, Prevotella copri is a candidate keystone species, but whether it lies on the causal pathway for disease or is simply a bystander reflecting host-genetic predisposition to RA, remains to be determined. The study of disease-microbiota associations may be confounded by the presence of the disease of interest or by its treatment. To circumvent this issue, we assessed whether known RA risk alleles were associated with the gut microbiota, in a large who do not have RA. Methods Blood and stool acquired from volunteers from TwinsUK were used for genotyping and assessment of the gut microbiota, respectively. A weighted polygenic risk score (PRS) for RA was calculated in 1650 unaffected twins from the TwinsUK cohort, based on 233 published GWAS-identified published RA associated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Amplicon sequence variants (ASVs) were generated from 16S rRNA sequencing of stool samples and assessed for association with RA PRS. Confirmation of findings was performed using an independent sample comprised of first-degree relatives of RA patients from the SCREEN-RA cohort (n=133). Findings We found that Prevotella spp was positively associated with RA PRS in TwinsUK participants (p.adj<1e-7). This finding was validated in SCREEN-RA participants carrying the shared epitope risk alleles (p.adj=1.12e-3). An association of Prevotella spp . with pre-clinical RA phases was also demonstrated (p.adj=0.021). Interpretation Prevotella in the gut microbiota is associated with RA genotype in the absence of RA, as well as in subjects at high risk of developing RA. This work suggests that host genotype is associated with microbiota profile prior to disease onset. Research in context Evidence before this study? Prevotella copri is increased within the gut microbiota in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients, predominantly those with early disease, before treatment is initiated. Prevotellaceae (family) has been demonstrated to be increased in pre-clinical RA cases compared to controls. Prevotella copri is posited to be an inflammatory driver, contributing to RA pathology by promoting a pro-inflammatory cytokine milieu. What does this study add? This study is the first to demonstrate that, in a large human cohort, carrying genetic risk factors for RA is associated with a higher abundance of Prevotella spp . in the absence of RA. How might this impact on clinical practice or future developments This work suggests that any potential causal role of Prevotella spp . occurs very early in disease development. Strategies to intervene should target early or asymptomatic at-risk groups", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.09.19014183"}
10.1101/19013599
[ 0.058074042201042175, -0.18157583475112915, 0.05334100499749184, 0.48073500394821167, -0.49118003249168396, 0.033255334943532944, 0.0897931233048439, -0.5801607966423035, 0.4259498119354248, 0.8681607842445374, 0.5239519476890564, -0.677434504032135, 0.25571203231811523, -0.19895151257514954, -0.362482488155365, 0.5706506967544556, 0.3777972459793091, -0.09893427044153214, -0.47266626358032227, 0.11023423075675964, 0.20053216814994812, -0.0034691926557570696, -0.8379604816436768, -0.3797505497932434, 0.051077041774988174, 0.5869334936141968, 0.15054848790168762, -0.30144065618515015, 0.8398438096046448, 0.2722664475440979, -0.9594169855117798, -0.1540406048297882, 0.45558661222457886, -0.4759984612464905, -0.6737902164459229, 0.49058035016059875, 0.4966857135295868, 0.19063399732112885, 0.004714375827461481, -0.6718478798866272, 0.7956035733222961, -0.03931239992380142, 0.37372180819511414, -0.18967333436012268, -0.02649639919400215, -0.23463578522205353, -0.015948649495840073, -0.11860916018486023, 0.17201778292655945, 0.358256459236145, -0.579506516456604, 0.04262125492095947, 0.2350654900074005, -0.11636096984148026, 0.0049922592006623745, 0.6859107613563538, 0.5025557279586792, -0.012499518692493439, -0.6724105477333069, -0.25393620133399963, 0.13840441405773163, 0.3487386703491211, 0.41449135541915894, -1.3376474380493164, 0.452338308095932, 1.0134369134902954, -0.23272378742694855, -0.11571983993053436, 0.3402036726474762, -0.29148828983306885, 0.5281461477279663, 0.15055431425571442, -0.013839755207300186, -0.24046845734119415, -0.2902565002441406, -0.8764791488647461, 0.4767919182777405, -0.22035618126392365, 0.3553503155708313, 0.6181105971336365, 0.025575505569577217, -0.022196384146809578, 0.2917061746120453, 0.10492014139890671, -0.1260078102350235, 0.25857269763946533, 0.09895316511392593, 0.8370715975761414, -0.7618056535720825, 0.4465436339378357, 0.29703113436698914, 0.5630592107772827, 0.17988723516464233, 0.3056817650794983, 0.42022204399108887, 0.25306379795074463, -0.28966692090034485, 0.505894124507904, -0.39167100191116333, 0.14532925188541412, -0.20580561459064484, 1.1081959009170532, -0.011689520440995693, 0.7132290601730347, -0.024640148505568504, 0.034380462020635605, 0.16704997420310974, 0.16605938971042633, -0.47359177470207214, -0.39419233798980713, 0.09847012907266617, -0.08226165175437927, -0.40367400646209717, 0.47601351141929626, 0.6869584918022156, 0.5123458504676819, -0.9822913408279419, 0.4200100004673004, -1.0560591220855713, -0.5076397657394409, -0.37880754470825195, 0.20481544733047485, 0.5536054968833923, 0.46650299429893494, 0.3997848927974701, 0.09799366444349289, -0.5989013314247131, 0.358900249004364, -0.16969692707061768, -0.08192004263401031, 0.2862112522125244, -0.6913268566131592, -0.0834810733795166, 0.8579607009887695, -0.02946847304701805, -0.1405017077922821, -0.13021869957447052, 0.619055986404419, 0.25418341159820557, -0.6645127534866333, -0.3759468197822571, -0.32579901814460754, -0.7482091188430786, 1.344681978225708, -0.5800347924232483, 1.213346004486084, -0.16395846009254456, -0.9656186699867249, -0.6427292227745056, -0.3993317186832428, 0.2150048166513443, 0.5230992436408997, -0.3228980004787445, -0.49503475427627563, 0.04992605000734329, 0.4181336760520935, -0.6299335956573486, 0.42294058203697205, 0.18547368049621582, 0.1743297576904297, 0.36622312664985657, 0.3447429835796356, -0.05172986537218094, 0.0652739629149437, -0.6746807098388672, 0.594836950302124, -0.12850268185138702, 0.03459266945719719, 0.5159305930137634, 0.30231773853302, 0.36833128333091736, -0.5630932450294495, 0.07900919765233994, -0.11281182616949081, -0.05567234009504318, 0.31872454285621643, 0.7330994009971619, -0.45867180824279785, -0.1714681088924408, -0.30241724848747253, 0.5987347364425659, 0.13816383481025696, 0.49649855494499207, 0.18975615501403809, -0.1750195324420929, 0.20304492115974426, -0.7200544476509094, -0.1452203392982483, -0.1887737512588501, -1.0726567506790161, -0.10265720635652542, 0.48274683952331543, -0.8163425326347351, 0.644965648651123, -0.38141006231307983, -0.21533168852329254, -0.9878735542297363, -0.3408317565917969, 0.5972080826759338, -0.3093065023422241, -0.37281596660614014, 0.6430787444114685, -0.42347946763038635, 0.33492913842201233, 0.17823952436447144, 0.1579439789056778, 0.16074056923389435, 0.6741323471069336, -0.7619575262069702, 0.4940555691719055, 0.8363503217697144, -0.39364802837371826, -0.30044546723365784, 0.4668866693973541, 0.7412554621696472, -0.14163431525230408, -0.28811970353126526, -0.043766386806964874, -1.0887439250946045, -0.21191951632499695, -0.18194551765918732, -0.09687738865613937, 0.4322611689567566, -0.03010055236518383, -0.09478975832462311, 0.24582669138908386, 0.6823731660842896, 0.165045827627182, -0.19973737001419067, -0.0752003937959671, -0.059997089207172394, 0.1600659191608429, 0.5480995774269104, 0.6232329607009888, 0.6581910252571106, 0.024741297587752342, 0.40308552980422974, 0.34698593616485596, -0.5032956600189209, 0.44136059284210205, 0.16609491407871246, -0.12076451629400253, 0.3381996750831604, 0.4282185435295105, 0.13924115896224976, 0.8406656384468079, -0.16200225055217743, -0.07864703983068466, -0.6942482590675354, 1.223383903503418, -0.7250754237174988, 1.1380959749221802, 0.19669170677661896, -0.5064926743507385, -0.6275055408477783, -0.740950882434845, 0.17604778707027435, 0.17715336382389069, -0.0440947562456131, 0.1322266012430191, -0.03843181952834129, -0.24123196303844452, -0.3236711919307709, -0.5338961482048035, 0.7519034147262573, 0.7120763063430786, 0.4645114243030548, 0.3920547664165497, 0.5385769009590149, -0.2802092432975769, -0.7095176577568054, -0.31062501668930054, -0.8193828463554382, -0.652575671672821, -0.8318836092948914, -0.6973068714141846, 0.3756310045719147, -0.49292993545532227, 1.4160994291305542, 0.3253916800022125, 0.42196202278137207, -0.8932002782821655, -0.4076424837112427, 0.5572257041931152, 0.1348215937614441, 0.49312394857406616, -0.39671066403388977, 0.5425286293029785, -0.44563522934913635, 0.6998035311698914, -0.22279837727546692, -0.08995897322893143, -0.49222129583358765, -0.6184819936752319, 0.5627829432487488, -0.3948078751564026, -0.1967223435640335, -0.0033297690097242594, -0.3398827910423279, -0.15492777526378632, -0.163741797208786, -0.16326354444026947, -0.06738323718309402, 0.010991408489644527, -0.38837704062461853, 0.22991126775741577, 0.22664397954940796, 0.3765201270580292, -0.06901277601718903, 0.5684769749641418, -0.9417809844017029, 0.019572990015149117, 0.13318011164665222, 0.08104830980300903, -0.815994381904602, 0.22462259232997894, 0.0963791012763977, -0.15282580256462097, -0.01287771761417389, -0.7692254185676575, -1.0064035654067993, -0.2649823725223541, 0.04947822168469429, -0.2260020226240158, -0.1586282104253769, 0.5551421642303467, 0.23709583282470703, -0.7234339118003845, 0.23152406513690948, 0.07052473723888397, -1.2540711164474487, 0.2618268132209778, 0.05639796704053879, 0.08947868645191193, 0.20839184522628784, 0.8362132906913757, 0.2615998089313507, 0.028809648007154465, -0.12614719569683075, -0.08938472718000412, 0.4137897789478302, 0.13025206327438354, -0.12263112515211105, 0.3812260627746582, 0.5756201148033142, 0.26859477162361145, 0.26705050468444824, -0.133242666721344, 0.5261245965957642, 0.2544541358947754, -0.30984020233154297, 0.40621429681777954, 0.4410724937915802, 0.3294829726219177, -0.0363604761660099, 0.24672967195510864, 0.0157807394862175, -0.7447402477264404, -0.5629096627235413, -0.13598360121250153, -0.0003530383692122996, 0.7418444156646729, -0.12527219951152802, -0.14116515219211578, -0.24649307131767273, -0.0007848703535273671, 0.3354719877243042, 0.0001089815195882693, 0.10536108911037445, -0.7275462746620178, 0.1899382770061493, 0.33248668909072876, -0.1399817317724228, -0.004543386399745941, 0.5531129837036133, 0.576018214225769, 0.8840819597244263, 0.06458815932273865, 1.3638087511062622, -0.7101156711578369, 0.21658430993556976, 0.79038405418396, 0.47019803524017334, -0.5031198263168335, -0.2378595620393753, -0.032498881220817566, -0.9055593013763428, 0.05936283618211746, -0.05666609853506088, -0.5863393545150757, -0.3806104362010956, 0.2640867829322815, -0.05876952409744263, 0.03653264790773392, -0.6889813542366028, -0.33070313930511475, -0.7225252985954285, 0.7369491457939148, -0.49811655282974243, 0.12130536884069443, 0.8439441323280334, -0.3215033710002899, 0.38054534792900085, 0.03777481988072395, 0.5859262347221375, 0.5303685665130615, -0.6336054801940918, 0.29955410957336426, 0.13266780972480774, -0.4501679241657257, 0.0034678322263062, 0.41112494468688965, -0.05621536076068878, 0.025403283536434174, 0.12398392707109451, -0.37139683961868286, -0.8662488460540771, -0.1990145742893219, 0.1389051377773285, 0.9497785568237305, 0.06911247968673706, 0.6496332287788391, -0.9566525220870972, -0.14485786855220795, 0.26612260937690735, -0.2716411054134369, -0.49024245142936707, -0.6177641153335571, 0.11907339841127396, 0.611213743686676, 0.1760365515947342, -0.5316640138626099, -0.04224710911512375, 0.15494117140769958, -0.2281648963689804, -0.20657791197299957, 0.27212589979171753, 0.6153199076652527, 0.6511121988296509, -0.1433935910463333, -0.16524913907051086, 0.000976642593741417, -0.712348461151123, -0.17754249274730682, 0.18581481277942657, 0.20529082417488098, 1.3673924207687378, 0.46243253350257874, 0.30287057161331177, -0.3532234728336334, 0.28424814343452454, -0.6785205006599426, 1.1502127647399902, -0.42179128527641296, -0.6868735551834106, -0.38412559032440186, 0.15800000727176666, 0.10188610851764679, 0.0522010363638401, -0.05968892201781273, -0.3449917435646057, -0.47797250747680664, -0.2742934226989746, -1.1070266962051392, -1.0855790376663208, 0.3598793148994446, -0.2867199778556824, 0.09714394807815552, 1.335340976715088, -0.11676260828971863, -0.154814213514328, -0.12796509265899658, -0.06000347062945366, -1.2437689304351807, 0.51343834400177, 0.16682642698287964, 0.37128686904907227, 0.13578449189662933, -0.761586606502533, -0.3111377954483032, -0.12191515415906906, 0.21285255253314972, -0.5980024933815002, -1.2092183828353882, 0.079407699406147, -0.2885963022708893, -0.7574362754821777, 0.3395814001560211, -0.31756410002708435, 0.5059588551521301, 0.11692222207784653, 0.17479611933231354, 0.5497037768363953, -0.7888374924659729, -0.35185107588768005, -1.1088862419128418, -0.12547513842582703, 0.2623097896575928, -0.1367589682340622, 0.07280628383159637, 0.48447155952453613, 0.06651550531387329, -0.7983353734016418, 0.944142758846283, 0.8931059837341309, -0.7267869114875793, -0.11095047742128372, 0.020946890115737915, 0.24859128892421722, -0.6027593612670898, -0.2765386700630188, -0.02994164638221264, -0.057494062930345535, -0.3563254177570343, -0.5090776085853577, 0.4836331605911255, 0.8737173080444336, 0.06269240379333496, -0.274100661277771, 0.45946642756462097, 0.3785499334335327, -1.2753902673721313, -0.3160673677921295, 0.6032831072807312, 0.16079944372177124, 0.1846649944782257, -0.4511917233467102, -0.13011212646961212, -0.5280978679656982, -0.644081175327301, 0.14503204822540283, -0.7343958616256714, -0.2943512201309204, -0.517111599445343, -0.046853430569171906, 0.030616752803325653, 0.8364927172660828, 0.23960557579994202, 0.007612357381731272, 0.3148046135902405, -1.0925781726837158, 0.02429928258061409, -0.42487573623657227, -0.0006649729912169278, -0.06609223783016205, -0.5723181366920471, -0.15726810693740845, 1.0273702144622803, -0.06961658596992493, -0.6911187171936035, 0.2165915071964264, 0.3151218295097351, 0.48100441694259644, 0.45701539516448975, -0.5738928914070129, -0.12014729529619217, 0.05632500350475311, 0.35837069153785706, -0.30095309019088745, -0.18097855150699615, -0.43851882219314575, 0.3451813757419586, -0.6709145903587341, 0.2749119699001312, 0.08678111433982849, -1.144419550895691, 0.22315295040607452, -0.4026145935058594, 0.051536668092012405, 0.05902677774429321, 0.11259891092777252, -0.13716697692871094, 0.019840620458126068, 0.17274153232574463, 0.5228075385093689, -0.34526681900024414, -0.2806819975376129, -0.6273592114448547, -0.826251208782196, 0.8677032589912415, 0.11957606673240662, -0.1945427507162094, 0.7946501970291138, 0.14585179090499878, 0.24688364565372467, -0.2637796401977539, 0.7507786154747009, 0.3415552079677582, -0.7516303658485413, -0.42277318239212036, -0.1415547877550125, 0.4067729711532593, -0.5036026835441589, 0.1545538604259491, 0.23861464858055115, -0.2694304883480072, -0.08543337136507034, 0.13620243966579437, -0.25007861852645874, -0.32088136672973633, -0.11486558616161346, 0.3764178156852722, 0.6803076863288879, 0.02540842816233635, 0.9708897471427917, 0.193094402551651, 0.02992088533937931, 0.38144171237945557, 0.5860590934753418, -0.09077940881252289, -0.2715470790863037, 1.0383553504943848, -0.1974160224199295, -0.7250500321388245, 0.40056079626083374, -0.06760300695896149, -0.4299156367778778, -0.296828031539917, 1.0090124607086182, 0.024992158636450768, -0.3301022946834564, 0.5671080350875854, 0.46585702896118164, -0.5136855840682983, -0.847253680229187, 0.35780149698257446, -0.03455042466521263, 0.08641980588436127, -0.36762988567352295, -0.3979705572128296, 0.17248216271400452, -0.6579548716545105, -0.0026160788256675005, 0.03084070421755314, 0.46365365386009216, 0.7045509815216064, -0.6793327927589417, 0.331336110830307, -0.8272875547409058, 0.07179275900125504, 0.961338222026825, -0.4013828933238983, -0.29926642775535583, -0.19819727540016174, 0.677214503288269, -0.6485652923583984, -0.15047310292720795, 0.46193796396255493, 0.12568433582782745, 0.6112321615219116, 0.0731792226433754, 0.8813236355781555, 0.1821908950805664, 0.3201046586036682, -0.010583236813545227, 0.780794620513916, -0.05265321955084801, -0.7718499898910522, -0.9756925106048584, 0.8849204182624817, 0.5774646401405334, 0.7197400331497192, 0.28000277280807495, -0.5353382229804993, 1.0397106409072876, -0.3164404034614563, -0.009011071175336838, -0.1672687828540802, 0.10692979395389557, -0.2549840211868286, -0.07336150854825974, 0.47075292468070984, -0.14267562329769135, -0.15252164006233215, 0.5177666544914246, -0.5231173038482666, -0.04627194255590439, 0.012794493697583675, 0.06071300804615021, -0.34341710805892944, -0.0037217868957668543, -0.22377896308898926, -0.19841334223747253, -1.0479066371917725, -0.6743298768997192, -0.17541871964931488, -0.95163494348526, 0.11340081691741943, 0.7084805369377136, -0.4718570113182068, 0.022524315863847733, -0.15533772110939026, 0.5808568000793457, -0.4836059808731079, 0.37276485562324524, -0.8045611381530762, -0.668152391910553, -1.383398413658142, 0.27260783314704895, 0.5555187463760376, -0.31723499298095703, 0.8277011513710022, -0.18738065659999847, 0.05266375467181206, 0.7972354888916016, -0.1634206771850586, 0.30562883615493774, 0.3118552267551422, 0.3084573745727539, -0.9305726885795593, -0.8184733390808105, 0.29320481419563293, 0.652778685092926, -0.8204195499420166, -0.5196382999420166, -0.46766960620880127, -0.05933704227209091, 0.011302798986434937, 0.10251006484031677, -0.3539937436580658, 0.13595058023929596, 0.5351173877716064, 0.0636470839381218, -0.6768011450767517, 0.4798162579536438, 0.4279954433441162, -0.2946133017539978, 0.07710564881563187, 0.18162043392658234, 0.23799678683280945, -0.9047004580497742, 0.4807218313217163, 0.9463958144187927, -0.18584954738616943, 0.18679937720298767, 0.16193556785583496, -0.4084272086620331, -0.23121042549610138, 0.029679346829652786, -0.6213503479957581, -0.3186566233634949, -0.2808305025100708, -0.022479379549622536, -0.0847836509346962, -0.49055010080337524, -1.0107653141021729, -0.18269550800323486, -0.3471652567386627, -0.756452739238739, 0.04726096987724304, -1.0302410125732422, 0.543997585773468, -0.5725213289260864, -1.061482548713684, 0.42460891604423523, 0.06469765305519104, 0.42170456051826477, -0.09273430705070496, 0.6775420904159546, 0.3784502446651459, 0.3485158085823059, -0.00634646276012063, 0.02506900019943714, 0.17214088141918182, -0.1935282051563263, -0.41771751642227173, -0.5489484071731567, -0.7859159708023071, -0.3298432528972626, 0.003987370524555445, -0.44799137115478516, -0.5000195503234863, -0.6989327073097229, 0.10777204483747482, -0.2215549796819687, 0.03368682041764259, -0.13090507686138153, -1.2390497922897339, 0.01245520543307066, -0.5065217018127441, -0.7513502836227417, 0.1413561999797821, 0.20912811160087585, 0.8441202640533447, -0.29492485523223877, -0.1595011204481125, 0.39839279651641846, 0.8179628252983093, -0.18487706780433655, 0.17128023505210876, 0.4291536808013916, 0.33627960085868835, -0.21348713338375092, -0.36496949195861816, 0.32144078612327576, 0.24572503566741943, 0.18127068877220154, 0.05594612658023834, 0.05889367684721947, -0.10370129346847534, 0.3242131769657135, 0.06457794457674026, -0.33035340905189514, 0.2691693902015686, 0.8598541021347046, -0.43387967348098755, 0.30855047702789307, -1.105708360671997, -0.4056068956851959, 0.7771758437156677, -0.2444395124912262, 0.05819481983780861, -0.11070866882801056, -0.05779910832643509, 0.32200321555137634, -0.5894837975502014, 0.5088263750076294, -0.7578025460243225, -0.31655266880989075, -0.16459566354751587, 0.9176852703094482, 1.0839078426361084, 0.19346554577350616, 0.3122207224369049, 0.26047664880752563, 0.44120922684669495, -0.19676366448402405, 0.4016153812408447, 0.8578975796699524, -0.33475515246391296, -0.5399413704872131, -0.07408829778432846, 0.39933350682258606, 0.2368435263633728, -0.218928724527359, -0.5849185585975647, -1.0159777402877808, 0.31392934918403625, 0.5882052183151245, -0.23833627998828888, -0.35083332657814026, 0.9759629368782043, -0.08097759634256363, -0.11057721078395844, 0.18632909655570984, 0.16037790477275848, -0.8135131597518921, -0.5080141425132751, 0.18735651671886444, -1.1322516202926636, 0.33504384756088257, 0.4036928117275238, -0.1832464039325714, 0.5108835101127625, -0.18496359884738922, 0.9032989740371704, 0.008281877264380455, 0.9346957206726074, 0.3637881278991699, 0.6869617104530334, -0.0698830857872963, -0.7346396446228027, -0.19385072588920593, -0.01620331220328808, -0.689569890499115, -0.6408795118331909, 0.4860256016254425, -0.16877037286758423, -1.1421712636947632, 0.6119197607040405, 0.03773333504796028, -1.049952507019043, -0.6532700657844543, 0.07691598683595657, 0.5219831466674805, -0.4119347333908081, -0.20566627383232117, 0.5723568797111511, 0.7178059220314026, 0.9543169736862183, 0.29835614562034607, -0.4351057708263397, -0.6419798731803894, -0.2993581295013428, -0.06981638073921204, -0.1729469746351242, 0.27262210845947266, -0.16824184358119965, -0.7401798367500305, -0.9811193346977234, -0.3070436120033264, -0.520039439201355, -0.08292802423238754, -1.2616382837295532, -0.15849541127681732, 0.9125227928161621, 0.1897834837436676, 0.3697875738143921, -0.1556573063135147, 0.378957599401474, 0.24369846284389496, 1.3454359769821167, -0.23665155470371246, 0.3017192780971527, 0.33643823862075806, -0.16044063866138458, 0.2031579613685608, 0.5722609758377075, 0.009607411921024323, -0.017656991258263588, 0.40657663345336914, -0.7492454648017883, 0.4531610310077667, -0.23228605091571808, -0.5210044980049133, 0.1477024406194687, 1.003597378730774, -0.16946037113666534, -0.611160397529602, -1.3287726640701294, 0.025258537381887436, -0.46651020646095276, 0.5163609385490417, -0.4417289197444916, -0.17374064028263092, 0.20962992310523987, 0.7781276702880859, 0.6205343008041382, -0.8208928108215332, 4.2488555908203125, 1.4523296356201172, 0.8109483122825623, -0.5726419687271118, -0.0570133812725544, 0.44046440720558167, 0.2789804935455322, 0.023890137672424316, -0.036247994750738144, -0.7082819938659668, 0.21650442481040955, 0.27165910601615906, 0.6125004291534424, -0.054039642214775085, 0.9613215923309326, 0.46078965067863464, -1.1497864723205566, 0.42821598052978516, 0.131717711687088, -1.0457464456558228, -0.8973898887634277, 0.3245077431201935, -0.3223598301410675, -0.6456272006034851, 0.830692708492279, 0.564182460308075, 0.0007026338134892285, 0.23774933815002441, -0.5599425435066223, -0.9676058292388916, -0.4914356470108032, 0.21363502740859985, 0.19443610310554504, -0.7619022727012634, -0.42398202419281006, 0.4051530957221985, 0.103819839656353, -0.09406241029500961, 0.5325250625610352, 0.22223027050495148, 0.15814439952373505, -0.47000208497047424, -0.4490090310573578, -0.5480222702026367, 0.21091404557228088, 0.4719208776950836, -0.20132707059383392, -1.1000983715057373, -0.2969711124897003, -0.3391261100769043, 1.0875084400177002, -1.050588846206665, 0.45204487442970276, 0.11989207565784454, -0.8160834312438965, -0.019170613959431648, -0.6245869994163513, -0.9777801632881165, 0.49676069617271423, 0.25578737258911133, 0.5737918019294739, 0.1741725355386734, -0.47994890809059143, -0.5860339403152466, 0.05863308906555176, 0.6282792687416077, -0.14835678040981293, 0.526242733001709, 0.2205316126346588, -0.12112659960985184, 0.25037094950675964, -0.2696252763271332, -0.3914620578289032, 0.06892308592796326, 0.7126688361167908, 0.3616787791252136, -0.3342207074165344, 0.4665665328502655, -0.0905536562204361, -0.40724194049835205, 0.3268091380596161, -0.2204301804304123, -0.2695801556110382, 0.1559360921382904, 0.2641651928424835, 1.3531314134597778, -0.9203007221221924, -0.46187469363212585, -0.5402483344078064, 0.586768627166748, -0.01978922076523304, 0.45122072100639343, -0.022255923599004745, 0.12798696756362915, -0.5100137591362 ]
{"Title": "The genetic and clinical landscape of nanophthalmos in an Australian cohort", "Authors": "Siggs Owen M, Awadalla Mona S, Souzeau Emmanuelle, Staffieri Sandra E, Kearns Lisa S, Laurie Kate, Kuot Abraham, Qassim Ayub, Edwards Thomas L, Coote Michael A, Mancel Erica, Walland Mark J, Dondey Joanne, Galanopoulous Anna, Casson Robert J, Mills Richard A, MacArthur Daniel G, Ruddle Jonathan B, Burdon Kathryn P, Craig Jamie E", "Abstract": "Abstract Purpose Refractive error is caused by a disparity between the axial length and focusing power of the eye. Nanophthalmos is a rare ocular abnormality in which both eyes are abnormally small, typically causing extreme hyperopic refractive error, and associated with an increased risk of angle-closure glaucoma. Methods A cohort of 40 individuals from 13 unrelated nanophthalmos kindreds were recruited, with 11 probands subjected to exome sequencing. Results Nine probands (69.2%) were assigned a genetic diagnosis, with variants in PRSS56 (4), MFRP (3), and previously reported variants in TMEM98 (1) and MYRF (1). Two of the four PRSS56 probands harboured the previously described c.1066dupC frameshift variant implicated in over half of all reported PRSS56 kindreds, with surrounding haplotypes distinct from each other, and from a previously reported Tunisian c.1066dupC haplotype. Individuals with a genetic diagnosis had shorter mean axial lengths ( P =7.22\u00d710 \u22129 ) and more extreme hyperopia ( P =0.0005) than those without a genetic diagnosis, with recessive forms associated with the shortest axial lengths and highest hyperopia. All individuals with an axial length below 18 mm in their smaller eye (17/17) were assigned a genetic diagnosis. Conclusions These findings detail the genetic architecture of nanophthalmos in an Australian cohort of predominantly European ancestry, their relative clinical phenotypes, and highlight the shared genetic architecture of rare and common disorders of refractive error.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013599"}
10.1101/19007575
[ -0.346482515335083, 0.1911180019378662, 0.005057543516159058, -0.10445407778024673, -0.15196828544139862, 0.22740371525287628, -0.2833838164806366, -0.14241573214530945, 0.09061877429485321, 0.8491219878196716, -0.30701324343681335, -0.45592617988586426, 0.22305162250995636, -0.5213849544525146, -0.13357359170913696, 0.3317176103591919, -0.8417741060256958, 0.0254060048609972, -0.6562523245811462, -0.7862841486930847, 0.6701315641403198, 0.01815456710755825, -1.1198488473892212, -0.15128624439239502, -0.3000495135784149, 0.6805633902549744, 0.005765358917415142, 0.22663934528827667, 1.167073369026184, 0.38157132267951965, -0.0002832627505995333, -1.2599304914474487, 0.6970253586769104, -0.865664005279541, -0.29024285078048706, 0.46348515152931213, 0.8825249671936035, -0.6231945753097534, -0.48335638642311096, -0.10362017154693604, 0.148583322763443, -0.1368793547153473, 0.07845162600278854, -0.747083306312561, -0.24716408550739288, 0.028573259711265564, -0.3838558495044708, -0.14232641458511353, -0.5068298578262329, -0.307860404253006, 0.16449791193008423, -0.0887785404920578, 0.0004603942797984928, -0.4679906964302063, -0.8222118020057678, -0.00477715814486146, 0.5360291004180908, 0.5758659243583679, -0.09128323197364807, -0.46650680899620056, 0.01073534321039915, -0.26591962575912476, 0.10155101120471954, -1.368912935256958, 0.3024131655693054, 0.8515145778656006, -0.5838176608085632, -0.4537813663482666, -0.12918241322040558, -1.040932297706604, -1.3563059568405151, 0.45852938294410706, -0.003364137839525938, -0.27070218324661255, -0.15046748518943787, 0.35669592022895813, 0.19291138648986816, 0.13561144471168518, 0.3007762134075165, -0.34839966893196106, 0.04886503890156746, 0.4612268805503845, 0.23877041041851044, 0.8082980513572693, -0.25813421607017517, -0.11293455213308334, 0.7213887572288513, 0.16925427317619324, 0.6236782073974609, -0.27469709515571594, 0.6675774455070496, 0.4034740924835205, 0.44019272923469543, 0.07985095679759979, 0.12471615523099899, 0.4097636640071869, -0.0992322638630867, 0.3095731735229492, 0.4178551733493805, 0.020582888275384903, 0.5062326192855835, 0.9007177948951721, -0.3192753791809082, 1.539102554321289, -0.8182142376899719, 0.5630215406417847, 0.3230585753917694, 0.028990058228373528, -0.21699397265911102, -0.8415071964263916, 0.1588015854358673, -0.024998942390084267, -0.2738870680332184, 0.3730383515357971, 0.09878824651241302, 0.18999874591827393, 0.016648512333631516, 0.6378426551818848, -0.1356656551361084, 0.12175709009170532, -0.46103179454803467, -0.0706091895699501, 0.7947084903717041, -0.3073006570339203, 0.6793699264526367, -0.16170348227024078, 0.20932812988758087, 0.9530584812164307, -0.43985217809677124, -0.1144711971282959, -0.05020652711391449, -0.2808037996292114, -0.5778163075447083, 0.8129656910896301, 0.5488176345825195, -0.34522247314453125, -0.43888193368911743, 0.6838186383247375, -0.9587893486022949, -0.18394076824188232, -0.6976276636123657, 0.3697042167186737, -0.18097807466983795, 0.831278383731842, -0.6114922761917114, 0.45344147086143494, -0.366148978471756, -1.9590071439743042, -0.0026119400281459093, -0.41586214303970337, -0.47382524609565735, 0.5532858967781067, -0.21574603021144867, -0.16828253865242004, -0.8391693234443665, 0.022364463657140732, -0.2110314816236496, 0.6248413324356079, -0.37774160504341125, 0.13150513172149658, -0.3205958306789398, -0.12298542261123657, -0.1092456504702568, 0.6346678137779236, -0.4284096658229828, 0.6562300324440002, 0.1718759834766388, 0.24647484719753265, 0.5451754927635193, -0.7298399209976196, -0.15416796505451202, 0.32407110929489136, 0.09838296473026276, -0.5595298409461975, -0.1949717104434967, 0.5132524371147156, 1.1994861364364624, 0.22374576330184937, 0.8029658794403076, 0.26705947518348694, 0.3892093002796173, -0.8602995276451111, 0.808180034160614, 0.20275594294071198, -0.23384591937065125, -0.22031062841415405, -0.5538210272789001, -0.4810652434825897, -0.024051791056990623, -0.13081611692905426, 0.04476776719093323, 0.4944758117198944, -0.7623215913772583, 0.6158180236816406, -0.4316306412220001, -0.42890089750289917, -0.243949294090271, 0.4734099209308624, 0.3198853135108948, -0.37020808458328247, -0.6867383718490601, 0.2738623023033142, -0.526099681854248, 0.0852721706032753, -0.6499224901199341, 0.6674774885177612, -0.16221603751182556, 0.295686811208725, -0.4783080518245697, 0.39893075823783875, 0.26291394233703613, 0.1450188159942627, 0.13725078105926514, -0.3736012578010559, 0.6806396842002869, -0.8087731599807739, 0.3973759114742279, 0.08203291893005371, -0.16340912878513336, 0.008111472241580486, 0.7093528509140015, 0.20719236135482788, 0.5721387267112732, 0.00026078539667651057, 0.5806497931480408, 0.5755386352539062, 0.36619508266448975, 0.33343061804771423, 0.592621386051178, -0.12045253068208694, 0.20101070404052734, 1.1105612516403198, -0.1985652893781662, 0.7143908143043518, 0.5450873374938965, 0.45220696926116943, 0.15519894659519196, 0.5325225591659546, 0.5415136814117432, -0.06909146904945374, 0.539490282535553, 0.6527409553527832, 0.7710034251213074, 0.4871687889099121, -0.47001561522483826, 0.7012933492660522, -0.5537815690040588, 0.0048012882471084595, -0.3899226784706116, 0.18367129564285278, -0.9988791942596436, 0.3988034129142761, -0.1597002148628235, 0.25098058581352234, -0.49829044938087463, -0.29872751235961914, 0.6467409729957581, 0.4785737097263336, -0.05443789064884186, -0.6554005146026611, 0.10010111331939697, -0.08432302623987198, -0.18510273098945618, 0.4272879362106323, 0.9416483044624329, 0.7437752485275269, 0.6815231442451477, -0.015597037971019745, -0.1497339904308319, -0.5222511887550354, -0.9695982933044434, -0.49135953187942505, -1.7336463928222656, -0.6317300200462341, -0.7067118883132935, -0.8496790528297424, -0.10326748341321945, -0.6073850989341736, 0.4434390664100647, 0.6661481261253357, 0.03932163491845131, -0.49738550186157227, 0.3135014474391937, 0.09825722128152847, 0.7602450251579285, 0.06432005017995834, -1.0669459104537964, 0.8189391493797302, -0.704882025718689, 0.4248664379119873, -0.3677126169204712, -0.43154770135879517, -0.6543906927108765, -0.46854525804519653, 0.30380991101264954, -0.4095512330532074, -0.010097483173012733, 0.269899845123291, -0.5047641396522522, 0.007752781733870506, -0.4654172956943512, 0.4741455316543579, -0.037416502833366394, 0.022348938509821892, -0.9727463126182556, 0.28512927889823914, -0.31942805647850037, 0.2607190012931824, 0.3787378966808319, 0.6651033163070679, -0.48048609495162964, 0.9034029245376587, 0.20350831747055054, -0.036847516894340515, -0.8085154891014099, 0.8155888915061951, 0.5544286966323853, -0.9230060577392578, -0.2886843681335449, -0.6960672736167908, -1.1596943140029907, -0.06448028981685638, -0.18083007633686066, -0.8229051828384399, -0.1740555763244629, 0.1890459805727005, 0.27586811780929565, -0.6655715107917786, 0.6007211208343506, -1.1331373453140259, -1.328782081604004, 0.6515684127807617, -0.11732172966003418, 0.42517995834350586, 0.7546927332878113, -0.20157916843891144, -0.40100327134132385, -0.3608298897743225, 0.3439812958240509, 0.2872759997844696, 0.2870684564113617, -0.7430278062820435, -0.15159793198108673, 0.453235000371933, -0.2100067138671875, 0.13161589205265045, 0.5239236950874329, -0.524612307548523, -0.034956879913806915, 0.13584882020950317, 0.08083358407020569, -0.10640765726566315, 0.3966567814350128, -0.19728082418441772, 0.39919814467430115, 0.5030690431594849, -0.5781450271606445, -0.07849746942520142, 0.5110824704170227, 0.43076714873313904, 0.6110055446624756, 0.3169190287590027, 0.11284661293029785, 0.3519783914089203, -0.7897868752479553, -0.9531584978103638, 0.0844060555100441, 0.22154615819454193, 0.1732434630393982, -1.056288719177246, 0.6044887900352478, -0.11730529367923737, -0.2493911236524582, 0.5701542496681213, -0.4099352955818176, -0.4760291874408722, 0.8979138135910034, 0.18356181681156158, 1.721888542175293, -1.4718173742294312, 0.4635101556777954, 0.33234086632728577, 0.7833256721496582, 0.35265523195266724, 0.3601716458797455, 0.4609828293323517, -0.6868809461593628, -0.02472667209804058, -0.0029392510186880827, -0.09765489399433136, 0.4838434159755707, 0.8044118285179138, -0.303939551115036, -0.03565801680088043, -0.6359639763832092, -0.4015711545944214, 0.33829814195632935, 0.351040244102478, 0.178843155503273, -0.3893852233886719, 0.8229019641876221, -0.2695418894290924, 0.5917717218399048, 0.7146598696708679, 0.8779721856117249, -0.6650195717811584, -0.5224692821502686, 0.009720615111291409, -0.09157310426235199, -0.28313273191452026, -0.06362351775169373, -0.3014095425605774, 0.34211039543151855, -0.17503651976585388, 0.03323441743850708, 0.19970166683197021, 0.0062873102724552155, -0.10529258847236633, -0.28619256615638733, 0.42419004440307617, 0.44939231872558594, 0.6168173551559448, -1.2241348028182983, -0.08127397298812866, 0.5564621090888977, -0.35562801361083984, 0.14018642902374268, -0.4744248390197754, 0.8512189984321594, 0.825246274471283, -0.415803998708725, -0.3190407454967499, 0.48732537031173706, -0.09389980882406235, 0.1317247450351715, 0.451627641916275, -0.05163665488362312, -0.31389328837394714, 0.64689040184021, 0.07923948019742966, -0.19638939201831818, -0.20396070182323456, -0.6194040775299072, -0.46613064408302307, -0.371917724609375, 0.6302822232246399, 0.6793598532676697, 0.881960391998291, -0.00868887547403574, -0.4667259454727173, 0.28628605604171753, -0.942654550075531, 0.8186161518096924, -0.7428798675537109, -0.7821059226989746, 0.2453327178955078, 0.4952368140220642, -0.3443833589553833, 0.5379992723464966, 0.10382437705993652, 0.37875640392303467, -0.5571809411048889, 0.49672144651412964, -0.0950021743774414, -1.0966800451278687, 0.47938624024391174, -0.1931372731924057, 0.42728400230407715, 1.1309014558792114, -0.13877026736736298, -0.05832071602344513, -0.042153745889663696, 0.6754888296127319, -1.3046797513961792, 0.3889968991279602, -0.4058302342891693, -0.44185322523117065, -0.2663150429725647, -0.35502806305885315, -0.2735222578048706, -0.5870344638824463, 0.15783385932445526, -0.36112600564956665, 0.022419340908527374, -0.4410964846611023, -0.37710103392601013, -0.5258856415748596, -0.3114092946052551, -0.24215184152126312, 0.207978755235672, 0.07086753845214844, -0.6042284965515137, -0.4527915120124817, 0.27546730637550354, -0.30381837487220764, -0.010248922742903233, -0.687176525592804, 0.3249317407608032, 0.02983257919549942, -0.20040136575698853, 0.9545319676399231, -0.1999722421169281, -0.42995789647102356, 0.3664991557598114, 0.5837022662162781, -0.27910366654396057, -0.07637292146682739, -0.2846921980381012, -0.21711347997188568, -0.19040772318840027, -0.41115620732307434, 0.11107459664344788, -0.5566636919975281, 0.19358445703983307, -0.4944796860218048, -0.1915772557258606, 0.23650600016117096, -0.23582670092582703, -0.9957343339920044, 0.8145039677619934, 0.29581913352012634, -0.9873661994934082, -0.7464321255683899, 0.8009485602378845, 0.4915795922279358, 0.08004334568977356, -0.10085784643888474, -0.7908203601837158, 0.12007088214159012, 0.08223103731870651, 0.18508605659008026, -1.3632590770721436, 0.4539566934108734, -0.6116757392883301, -0.2659977078437805, 0.025991447269916534, 0.07242223620414734, 0.2070484310388565, -0.06485874950885773, -0.9001988172531128, -0.5573580265045166, 0.017077025026082993, -0.9869346022605896, -0.8136944770812988, 0.005692469421774149, 0.05165286734700203, -0.37253040075302124, 0.952558696269989, 0.17398367822170258, -0.8436564207077026, 0.12252461910247803, -0.30910688638687134, 1.023350477218628, 0.4992799758911133, -0.7695304751396179, -1.3914417028427124, 0.2577972412109375, 0.5424033999443054, 0.49358701705932617, -0.8884397149085999, -0.866702675819397, 0.4630652964115143, -0.6840131878852844, 0.3815161883831024, -0.4652956426143646, -0.3694613575935364, 0.5532900094985962, -0.3070676028728485, 0.8713734745979309, -0.4636906683444977, 0.036427002400159836, 0.47996532917022705, -0.23569589853286743, -0.42364266514778137, -0.08610930293798447, -0.9480809569358826, -0.11558285355567932, -0.7129298448562622, -0.8621440529823303, 0.38414284586906433, -0.5311538577079773, 0.1685842126607895, 0.6125401854515076, 0.15278662741184235, -0.16702763736248016, -0.4582405686378479, 0.5686901807785034, 0.38994982838630676, 0.24459274113178253, -0.628318190574646, 0.11617932468652725, 0.053207580000162125, 0.8039635419845581, 0.1638931930065155, 0.043761640787124634, -0.5551712512969971, -0.20359814167022705, -0.21835051476955414, 0.018321756273508072, -0.9340053796768188, -0.03938302397727966, 0.005273289047181606, 0.28852108120918274, -0.5791613459587097, 0.2628607153892517, 0.3302235007286072, 0.018100596964359283, -0.7684376835823059, 0.3097611665725708, -0.6984611749649048, 0.15527093410491943, 1.0592715740203857, -0.6096048355102539, -0.5896586179733276, 0.08699852973222733, 0.0860547423362732, -0.6434378027915955, -0.05125591903924942, 0.2527448236942291, -0.12936463952064514, -0.8344740271568298, -0.10013095289468765, 0.5298044681549072, -0.05853351950645447, -0.5633271336555481, 0.5607525110244751, -0.043784648180007935, 0.24588793516159058, -0.04155018553137779, -0.1988218128681183, 0.8294963836669922, -1.1101274490356445, 0.01774464175105095, 0.7716944813728333, 0.008452808484435081, 0.2863018214702606, 0.28337833285331726, 0.4896886646747589, -0.5921550393104553, 0.12223353236913681, 0.6553634405136108, -0.002996240509673953, 0.2695201337337494, 0.08916337043046951, 0.1749073714017868, 0.4060644507408142, -0.22425927221775055, 0.4298035204410553, -0.08921006321907043, -0.4453107714653015, 0.2363848239183426, 0.7689980864524841, 0.07228026539087296, 0.08391232788562775, -0.030182231217622757, 1.2260611057281494, 0.03698057681322098, -0.7225637435913086, -0.2628750205039978, 0.747563898563385, 0.7568219304084778, 0.398784339427948, -0.3926633596420288, 0.3873055577278137, 1.0283921957015991, 1.1867016553878784, 0.01749574765563011, -0.4707135558128357, -1.0960516929626465, -0.955289900302887, 0.168671652674675, 0.3400861620903015, -0.40559566020965576, -0.9308204054832458, 0.6290464401245117, -0.2708373963832855, -0.48725399374961853, 0.1185210645198822, 0.27099373936653137, -0.7585897445678711, -0.2388760894536972, -0.9759849309921265, 0.03385064750909805, -0.666342556476593, -0.7500550150871277, -0.13370832800865173, -0.9154664874076843, 0.1969427764415741, 0.9340871572494507, -0.38964223861694336, -0.631087064743042, 0.18804049491882324, -0.38549724221229553, -0.1247071847319603, 0.884312629699707, -0.7545554041862488, -0.2948906123638153, -0.647165834903717, 1.010474681854248, -0.15554945170879364, 0.2939194142818451, 1.1888738870620728, -0.48411470651626587, 0.7732628583908081, 0.5175780653953552, -0.12450864166021347, -0.337030291557312, -0.006462832912802696, -0.09856165945529938, -0.7279984951019287, -0.4168075621128082, 0.045497532933950424, 0.5517832040786743, -0.658043384552002, -0.7478073239326477, -0.10830537229776382, -0.03409648686647415, -0.17556683719158173, -0.27665987610816956, -0.09095996618270874, 0.7366374731063843, -0.4499307870864868, -0.007787157315760851, -0.15440981090068817, 0.47894757986068726, -0.18228986859321594, -0.14595739543437958, 0.5803108811378479, -0.20614489912986755, -0.0670231357216835, -1.1876144409179688, 0.18779662251472473, 0.7699793577194214, -0.4346083998680115, -0.1470198631286621, -0.07603001594543457, -0.24073542654514313, -0.32591280341148376, -0.701975405216217, 0.6518155932426453, 0.5222375392913818, 0.10048523545265198, -0.08916260302066803, 0.3392789363861084, -0.5814762711524963, -0.48449280858039856, -0.5282717347145081, -0.977021336555481, -0.6072160601615906, 0.6879776120185852, -0.09501942247152328, 0.12667682766914368, -0.6507904529571533, -0.33156082034111023, 0.8331904411315918, 0.5119592547416687, 0.6335560083389282, 0.8072723746299744, 0.7679814100265503, 0.41332969069480896, 0.3187587857246399, -0.2844156324863434, -0.11910530924797058, 0.31277909874916077, -0.29665523767471313, -0.21422696113586426, -0.4164520800113678, 0.9318101406097412, 0.08862587064504623, 0.10771455615758896, -0.4009312689304352, -0.29739442467689514, 0.7961540818214417, 0.37975621223449707, -0.7031777501106262, 0.09835658967494965, 0.5822690725326538, -0.4720631241798401, 0.057264506816864014, -0.561753511428833, -0.03343379124999046, -0.4623958170413971, 1.1360461711883545, 0.24938321113586426, -0.4160759449005127, -0.08658885955810547, -0.33844324946403503, 0.24115818738937378, -0.6235947012901306, 1.1496471166610718, -0.14303971827030182, 0.20411884784698486, -0.9205522537231445, -0.09997493028640747, 0.70067298412323, 0.36717504262924194, 0.8539764881134033, -0.03200746327638626, -0.2315928339958191, 0.7078039050102234, 0.8213532567024231, 0.7850369215011597, 0.5340116024017334, 0.32438597083091736, -0.14372487366199493, 0.18389123678207397, 0.025817442685365677, -0.1569792628288269, 0.1323261260986328, 0.40157952904701233, 0.5932353138923645, 0.3371557891368866, 0.39351916313171387, 0.11769121885299683, -0.13919828832149506, -0.8352463841438293, 0.1942213475704193, -0.10330311208963394, -1.1408191919326782, -0.3262643814086914, 0.8602065443992615, 0.5527397990226746, 0.024365969002246857, 0.6596848964691162, -0.47211596369743347, 0.32579177618026733, 0.4164881706237793, -0.00840227771550417, 0.5053902864456177, 0.24406759440898895, -0.5279563665390015, -0.5597326159477234, 0.49158206582069397, 0.07685098797082901, 0.1710880696773529, 0.49551430344581604, -0.09090849757194519, -0.2465287148952484, 0.4025551974773407, 0.18799982964992523, -0.5036778450012207, 0.4601879417896271, -0.30664873123168945, 0.34643813967704773, -0.18956153094768524, 0.00374564784578979, -0.6920350193977356, -0.08327963203191757, 0.6169757843017578, -1.0568854808807373, -0.4849422872066498, 0.30204689502716064, -0.14866501092910767, 0.13187028467655182, 0.39924371242523193, 0.6929936408996582, -0.30053481459617615, 1.199798822402954, 1.0630818605422974, -0.07603918015956879, 0.5531123876571655, 0.7342219352722168, -0.3910559415817261, 0.27687329053878784, -0.25171083211898804, 0.5332212448120117, -0.10678862035274506, -0.46079373359680176, 0.35695913434028625, 0.43331313133239746, -0.45928844809532166, 0.04221610724925995, -0.07233276963233948, 1.018500804901123, 0.18175216019153595, -0.17351213097572327, -0.679344117641449, 0.061327774077653885, 0.049560610204935074, 0.17708656191825867, -0.22957676649093628, -0.4281739890575409, -0.6644801497459412, 0.1746804416179657, -0.5694766640663147, 0.8446664214134216, -0.14041073620319366, -0.6280479431152344, -0.48141440749168396, -0.8128140568733215, -0.17786328494548798, -0.1916659027338028, -0.26234814524650574, -1.1499215364456177, 0.2849026918411255, 0.2332678586244583, 0.1914500594139099, 0.8943896293640137, 0.2966718077659607, 0.2239386886358261, 0.5287725925445557, 0.8683029413223267, -0.31051358580589294, 0.2683183252811432, 0.7423725128173828, 0.08554123342037201, 1.017276644706726, 0.14722572267055511, -0.4633140563964844, -0.12143854796886444, -0.3877409100532532, -0.2994530200958252, -0.24502944946289062, -0.5933141708374023, -0.6408213973045349, 0.5756937861442566, 1.1176645755767822, -0.6502693295478821, -0.14041917026042938, -0.6549047827720642, 0.26559799909591675, -0.5797708630561829, 1.037150502204895, 0.11301348358392715, 0.40326929092407227, -0.20456242561340332, -0.520088255405426, 0.23282529413700104, -0.9305922389030457, 4.059453964233398, 1.0709351301193237, 0.3487545847892761, 0.06643562763929367, 0.4345969259738922, 0.4514152407646179, 0.2600877285003662, -0.5459421277046204, -0.2364255040884018, 0.3129199147224426, -0.5672844052314758, 0.24267591536045074, -0.6406832337379456, -0.4863662123680115, 0.06968266516923904, 0.4281134307384491, -0.2956480383872986, -0.02243049070239067, 0.47040313482284546, -1.1904492378234863, -0.32925280928611755, 0.7045164108276367, -0.5061006546020508, -0.41263335943222046, 0.06157601624727249, -0.23313625156879425, -0.24502277374267578, 0.45056870579719543, -0.11900036036968231, -0.2554691433906555, -0.5251035690307617, -0.4830903112888336, 0.3428688049316406, -0.06049909442663193, -0.037509817630052567, -0.12829940021038055, 0.1101306900382042, -0.18050891160964966, -0.08954407274723053, -0.1434362679719925, 0.11043716967105865, -0.5157050490379333, 0.04633909836411476, -0.4161059856414795, -0.7477909326553345, -0.3270551264286041, -0.02252901904284954, 0.2898847162723541, 0.40567147731781006, -0.571462094783783, 1.428956389427185, -0.7088035345077515, -0.2226310670375824, -0.08476828783750534, -0.7184283137321472, 0.00011221625027246773, -0.4734207093715668, -0.7307837605476379, 0.6436359286308289, -0.3227999210357666, 0.4793165624141693, 0.14030058681964874, -0.10877242684364319, 0.05668656900525093, -0.5049524307250977, -0.21443326771259308, 0.8174986243247986, -0.046013787388801575, 0.17150643467903137, 0.23376937210559845, -0.13450022041797638, -0.18694064021110535, -0.3222344219684601, 0.70169597864151, 0.7783738970756531, 0.8903876543045044, -0.7926691770553589, 0.34970229864120483, -0.6932951807975769, -0.08268702775239944, 0.20114344358444214, 0.3430163562297821, 0.617574155330658, 0.13706372678279877, 0.21863345801830292, 0.6036403179168701, -0.6675667762756348, 0.15534907579421997, -1.1365634202957153, 0.2808634638786316, 0.6289656162261963, -0.08604299277067184, 0.22493085265159607, -0.26734089851379395, -0.17571254074573517 ]
{"Title": "Towards accurate and unbiased imaging based differentiation of Parkinson\u2019s Disease, Progressive Supranuclear Palsy and Corticobasal Syndrome", "Authors": "Correia Marta M, Rittman Tim, Barnes Christopher L, Coyle-Gilchrist Ian T, Ghosh Boyd, Hughes Laura E, Rowe James B", "Abstract": "Abstract The early and accurate differential diagnosis of parkinsonian disorders is still a significant challenge for clinicians. In recent years, a number of studies have used MRI data combined with machine learning and statistical classifiers to successfully differentiate between different forms of Parkinsonism. However, several questions and methodological issues remain, to minimise bias and artefact-driven classification. In this study we compared different approaches for feature selection, as well as different MRI modalities, with well matched patient groups and tightly controlling for data quality issues related to patient motion. Our sample was drawn from a cohort of 69 healthy controls, and patients with idiopathic Parkinson\u2019s disease (n=35, PD), Progressive Supranuclear Palsy Richardson\u2019s syndrome (n=52, PSP) and corticobasal syndrome (n=36, CBS). Participants underwent standardised T1-weighted MPRAGE and diffusion-weighted MRI. We compared two different methods for feature selection and dimensionality reduction: whole-brain principal components analysis, and an anatomical region-of-interest based approach. In both cases, support vector machines were used to construct a statistical model for pairwise classification of healthy controls and patients. The accuracy of each model was estimated using a leave-two-out cross-validation approach, as well as an independent validation using a different set of subjects. Our cross-validation results suggest that using principal components analysis (PCA) for feature extraction provides higher classification accuracies when compared to a region-of-interest based approach. However, the differences between the two feature extraction methods were significantly reduced when an independent sample was used for validation, suggesting that the principal components analysis approach may be more vulnerable to overfitting with cross-validation. Both T1-weighted and diffusion MRI data could be used to successfully differentiate between subject groups, with neither modality outperforming the other across all pairwise comparisons in the cross-validation analysis. However, features obtained from diffusion MRI data resulted in significantly higher classification accuracies when an independent validation cohort was used. Overall, our results support the use of statistical classification approaches for differential diagnosis of parkinsonian disorders. However, classification accuracy can be affected by group size, age, sex and movement artifacts. With appropriate controls and out-of-sample cross validation, diagnostic biomarker evaluation including MRI based classifiers can be an important adjunct to clinical evaluation.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007575"}
10.1101/19002501
[ 0.43963637948036194, 0.6301359534263611, -0.43972644209861755, 0.6173884868621826, -0.8401695489883423, -1.143634557723999, -0.5175372958183289, -0.14615797996520996, 0.6022709012031555, 0.8432254195213318, 0.13410282135009766, -0.6851964592933655, 0.7583567500114441, -0.6554381847381592, -0.14456398785114288, 0.6255111694335938, -0.6462075710296631, -0.04164157062768936, -0.02598169632256031, 0.18670208752155304, 0.511420726776123, 0.43088915944099426, -0.642829954624176, 0.8199999332427979, -1.334503412246704, 0.4535300135612488, 0.04578208550810814, 0.3006359934806824, 0.9455335736274719, 0.8931084275245667, 0.4847634434700012, -0.36177799105644226, 0.6294735074043274, -0.3343261480331421, -0.31539106369018555, 0.007977984845638275, 0.9571783542633057, -0.4428589642047882, 0.039909906685352325, -0.641004741191864, 0.5352483987808228, 0.2839759588241577, 0.28158995509147644, -0.753322184085846, -0.5563789010047913, -0.050285909324884415, -0.5846059322357178, -0.003937769215553999, 0.6154019832611084, -0.7185478806495667, -0.9705387949943542, -0.37321537733078003, 0.21554648876190186, -0.11679298430681229, 0.2610511779785156, 0.007298921700567007, 0.2334078997373581, 0.15718571841716766, -0.6075472831726074, 0.20595204830169678, 0.8181012868881226, -0.09927922487258911, 0.6384003758430481, -0.7330451607704163, 0.4303269386291504, 0.7471811771392822, 0.3040527403354645, 0.6810464859008789, -0.6245434284210205, 0.40284091234207153, -0.3075670301914215, -0.11579352617263794, -0.3221215605735779, -0.44850343465805054, -0.5414059162139893, -0.6000921726226807, -0.6401283740997314, 0.11177749186754227, -0.3995208740234375, 0.1689973622560501, -0.07791417837142944, 0.15842604637145996, 1.0436934232711792, 0.3802482485771179, 0.31410035490989685, -0.0421576201915741, 0.2779599130153656, 0.5037969350814819, 0.4104626774787903, 0.4155431389808655, 0.17418821156024933, -0.1390969306230545, 0.4061835706233978, -0.09841123968362808, 0.0963095873594284, 0.5033885836601257, -0.37838324904441833, -0.04503198340535164, 0.6458560824394226, 0.15898336470127106, 0.7720272541046143, 0.9099477529525757, 0.15044255554676056, 0.6757081151008606, -0.12971985340118408, 0.4682062566280365, 0.7941933870315552, -0.17146755754947662, -0.130055233836174, -0.949914276599884, -0.10470106452703476, 0.21804584562778473, -0.6124606728553772, -0.11788198351860046, 0.28814664483070374, -0.16993187367916107, -0.316287636756897, 0.5863416790962219, -0.3293114900588989, -0.063467837870121, -0.16052402555942535, 0.2802371680736542, 0.6096967458724976, -0.4395953118801117, 0.21411634981632233, -0.19486647844314575, 0.111585333943367, 0.39243125915527344, -0.4862411618232727, -0.46269044280052185, -0.08266961574554443, 0.001469522132538259, -0.4510277211666107, 0.9380993247032166, -0.47896215319633484, 0.2538192570209503, 0.34705308079719543, 0.6426298022270203, 0.007102392613887787, -0.1687476485967636, 0.26758238673210144, 0.048076972365379333, -0.24970020353794098, 0.8075451850891113, 0.03312462195754051, 1.213472843170166, -0.4478398561477661, -1.07510507106781, 0.14450512826442719, -0.3613402843475342, 0.12622930109500885, 1.1371850967407227, 0.08648667484521866, -0.5201574563980103, -0.45331627130508423, 0.12425895035266876, -0.707442045211792, 0.8489366173744202, -0.8092174530029297, -0.4271441400051117, 0.22088517248630524, 0.3817139267921448, -0.406977117061615, 1.0484061241149902, -0.6280847191810608, 1.0185620784759521, -0.5915731191635132, 0.4596383273601532, 0.31168055534362793, 0.33709821105003357, 0.48942437767982483, 0.26846811175346375, -0.8980876207351685, -0.6373652219772339, 0.5090648531913757, 0.46570131182670593, 0.5084503293037415, 0.2214910089969635, 0.27632734179496765, 0.5107163190841675, -0.2281235009431839, -0.06731428951025009, -0.07791680097579956, 0.7459061741828918, 0.3176538646221161, 0.3960316777229309, -0.3197542130947113, -0.6161903142929077, -0.46459540724754333, -0.5870507955551147, 0.0969407707452774, 0.5279205441474915, -0.7080007195472717, 1.1796116828918457, -0.2894158661365509, 0.2854626774787903, -0.14027993381023407, 0.437862366437912, 0.6658804416656494, 0.1192549616098404, -0.3103134334087372, 0.33190014958381653, -0.077945277094841, 0.7752524614334106, -0.23340538144111633, 0.611392080783844, 0.09396851807832718, 0.33369824290275574, -0.30967170000076294, 0.6387091279029846, 0.687534749507904, -0.11795467138290405, -0.7184224724769592, 0.24638541042804718, 0.7186826467514038, -0.6239773631095886, -0.6387701630592346, 0.03665122762322426, -0.2848925292491913, -0.7780116200447083, 0.04400767758488655, 0.27166101336479187, 0.14890895783901215, 0.5551649928092957, 0.14256368577480316, 0.28746548295021057, 0.5322391390800476, 0.2888049781322479, -0.28904226422309875, -0.06369050592184067, 0.04742933064699173, 0.6955251693725586, 0.3843725323677063, 0.24324965476989746, 0.7608879804611206, -0.046758983284235, 1.064906120300293, -0.009737071581184864, 0.5257453918457031, -0.12466415762901306, 0.3586968779563904, 0.8057764172554016, 0.7054449915885925, 0.4616428315639496, -0.8710018992424011, 0.30402663350105286, -0.4138444662094116, -0.3973987400531769, -0.060381706804037094, 0.12367545068264008, 0.2227962762117386, 0.9578420519828796, 0.06223343685269356, 0.44933509826660156, -0.5241914391517639, -0.3916252851486206, 0.4173515737056732, 0.3572877049446106, -0.29934951663017273, -0.1601087749004364, -0.2511918842792511, -0.03938313201069832, -0.24463129043579102, 0.19789880514144897, 0.22796733677387238, -0.3927929401397705, 0.03062976710498333, -0.5905894041061401, 0.14386582374572754, -0.47527432441711426, -0.6250559687614441, -0.2814734876155853, -0.6226214170455933, -1.070375919342041, -0.6808419227600098, 0.3398277759552002, -0.24223659932613373, -1.169522762298584, 0.07226140052080154, -0.28134649991989136, 0.16144512593746185, -0.642388641834259, -0.24245859682559967, 1.065485954284668, -0.39032813906669617, -0.19262635707855225, -1.1190156936645508, 0.28546208143234253, -0.3338767886161804, 0.004607473965734243, -0.20631766319274902, -0.5859038829803467, -1.4188989400863647, -1.031006932258606, 0.5882735848426819, -0.5752161741256714, 0.08288715779781342, -0.08285308629274368, -0.45149919390678406, -0.6178170442581177, 0.07641693204641342, -0.22165623307228088, 0.5059899091720581, -0.0648699551820755, -0.5406526327133179, 0.9006634950637817, -0.25496429204940796, 0.6925205588340759, 0.028359977528452873, 0.4860031008720398, -0.636171817779541, 0.49556422233581543, 0.2562873363494873, 0.5018093585968018, -0.3511381447315216, 0.30287209153175354, 0.3640575706958771, -0.5017783045768738, -0.2830658555030823, -0.6874546408653259, -1.3672760725021362, -0.17169354856014252, -0.3047543168067932, -0.5322933793067932, 0.48160532116889954, 0.5851024985313416, -0.27068907022476196, -1.1468865871429443, 0.2763751447200775, -0.7325037121772766, -0.6029185056686401, 0.027024079114198685, -0.6058563590049744, 0.43191012740135193, -0.038176946341991425, 0.16458730399608612, -0.5812579989433289, 0.14077913761138916, -0.2852291166782379, 0.42727130651474, 0.28129467368125916, -0.3328148424625397, -0.050098057836294174, -0.02211017720401287, -0.7013506293296814, 0.37189623713493347, 0.35300496220588684, -0.6603272557258606, -0.3221805989742279, -0.12514905631542206, 0.08010682463645935, 0.8517023921012878, 0.5461847186088562, -0.27235332131385803, 0.18127143383026123, 0.6101565361022949, -0.3888186812400818, 0.6981491446495056, -0.013841336593031883, 0.0692528635263443, -0.4149390161037445, 0.4814698398113251, -0.4022330939769745, 0.5711034536361694, -0.5041384100914001, -0.6590436100959778, 0.25870218873023987, 0.5945792198181152, 0.5116123557090759, -0.08898080885410309, 0.5232557058334351, 0.37522655725479126, -0.25470560789108276, -0.08082005381584167, -0.11808530986309052, 0.08877739310264587, 0.6131343841552734, -0.3827044367790222, 0.42279738187789917, -0.6075272560119629, 0.682887852191925, 0.43098753690719604, 0.9233857989311218, -0.1790754348039627, -0.8252648711204529, 0.5624424815177917, -0.9601048231124878, 0.36703619360923767, -0.017661774531006813, -0.32305049896240234, -0.07045761495828629, -0.6138685345649719, -0.1859022080898285, -0.4435058832168579, -0.647759735584259, 0.10443467646837234, 0.7297506332397461, -0.06894934922456741, -0.1472591757774353, -0.33157673478126526, 1.0013458728790283, -1.1443535089492798, 0.3074958026409149, 0.49411094188690186, 0.2577785849571228, 0.17618592083454132, -0.526208221912384, 0.4540815055370331, -0.6279317140579224, 0.09222456812858582, -0.39424651861190796, 0.23960866034030914, -0.27229776978492737, -0.13248203694820404, 0.0682518407702446, 0.21440759301185608, -0.15117233991622925, 0.5730727314949036, -0.5179004669189453, 0.20985598862171173, 0.14339862763881683, 0.531310498714447, -0.8819667100906372, 0.16601115465164185, 0.2502534091472626, -0.0033856150694191456, 0.05801979452371597, -0.35291779041290283, 0.36160001158714294, 0.8212577104568481, -0.6777452230453491, -0.8175618648529053, -0.21558760106563568, 0.014798127114772797, -0.7109857201576233, 0.273235946893692, -0.40798670053482056, -0.002004993613809347, 0.3544248342514038, -0.06368625164031982, 0.026302946731448174, -0.8396240472793579, -0.35042083263397217, 0.22755640745162964, 0.10754819959402084, 0.24123209714889526, 1.190887689590454, 0.31886041164398193, 0.902079164981842, 0.20786868035793304, 0.606471061706543, -0.46162149310112, 0.4546594023704529, 0.07752274721860886, -0.34385791420936584, -0.15369659662246704, 0.32801684737205505, 0.005998785141855478, -0.30081209540367126, -0.6303577423095703, -0.8896001577377319, -0.29262402653694153, -0.32001426815986633, -0.5921618342399597, -0.6635928750038147, 0.785595178604126, -0.12155595421791077, -0.5375664830207825, 0.8086543679237366, -0.5733546614646912, -0.6100695729255676, -0.9258242249488831, 0.07007092982530594, -0.38090747594833374, 0.5693004727363586, -0.25859537720680237, -0.047027233988046646, 0.06513463705778122, -0.8922968506813049, -0.06505929678678513, -0.38852328062057495, -0.06689590215682983, 0.03194347396492958, -0.27721133828163147, -1.0292195081710815, -0.44104835391044617, 0.10035180300474167, 0.29601332545280457, -0.8600448369979858, 0.5493744611740112, -0.4453163743019104, -0.15640772879123688, 0.06529366970062256, -0.7778128385543823, -0.632586658000946, 0.1287984699010849, -0.4185904860496521, -0.6330898404121399, 0.06416381895542145, 0.23871715366840363, 0.4123684763908386, -0.30739322304725647, -1.2967191934585571, 0.13206937909126282, 0.5734798908233643, -1.1438287496566772, -0.45663172006607056, -0.1968652755022049, -0.3018109202384949, -0.949966311454773, -0.8777139186859131, 0.029890485107898712, -0.5369165539741516, 0.653638482093811, -0.684848964214325, -0.48837384581565857, 0.6954197287559509, -0.39326855540275574, 0.03801893815398216, 0.8287267684936523, -0.3636191785335541, -0.8426306247711182, -0.025413917377591133, 0.44332513213157654, -0.46010103821754456, 1.2559807300567627, -0.5176986455917358, -1.0959587097167969, -0.24020710587501526, -1.2569363117218018, 0.07368464022874832, -0.8110978603363037, -0.11839351058006287, 0.05326581373810768, -0.5787964463233948, -0.3338826596736908, 0.17929694056510925, -0.4659120440483093, -0.5601317882537842, -0.42866507172584534, -0.4939110577106476, -0.4878042936325073, -0.16868236660957336, -0.19683010876178741, 0.46912187337875366, -0.9263723492622375, 0.23689322173595428, 0.9847663044929504, 0.994398832321167, -0.05816354230046272, 0.3101266920566559, -0.5024998188018799, 0.11687939614057541, 0.22679543495178223, -0.3850463032722473, -0.4037390947341919, 0.35951367020606995, 0.8302653431892395, -0.005883139558136463, -0.3959280550479889, -1.0240734815597534, 0.02228868566453457, -1.0833684206008911, 0.640779435634613, -0.47378766536712646, 0.0227345060557127, -0.20609351992607117, -0.36335569620132446, 0.5253810286521912, -0.10684102028608322, -0.44780275225639343, 0.7935858368873596, -0.3292219936847687, 0.02104550041258335, 0.255291223526001, -0.24677100777626038, -0.3928939402103424, -0.1098356693983078, -1.0482667684555054, -0.1643362194299698, 0.08584573864936829, 0.3502141833305359, 0.40438008308410645, 0.21228846907615662, -0.14728949964046478, -0.977286696434021, 0.47818422317504883, 0.13086256384849548, -1.0264500379562378, -0.9212090373039246, -0.4743199348449707, 0.13253864645957947, 0.5445084571838379, 0.32578128576278687, 0.1248670443892479, -0.10129374265670776, 0.006867458112537861, -0.4521022439002991, -0.4926747977733612, -0.4668312668800354, -0.18978717923164368, -0.18412712216377258, 0.5041951537132263, -0.09947679191827774, 0.0711725577712059, 0.4736160635948181, 0.1821567565202713, 0.2564498782157898, 1.5712826251983643, -0.17972500622272491, 0.4018082916736603, 0.5582031607627869, -0.07665379345417023, -1.206125020980835, -0.7811352610588074, -0.4562431275844574, -0.12283627688884735, 0.515812337398529, -0.006057302933186293, 0.5572850704193115, -0.3168271481990814, 0.9020859003067017, 0.2967783808708191, -0.3769862949848175, -0.21799269318580627, 0.1817007213830948, -0.5407683849334717, -0.3524068295955658, -0.8489913940429688, -0.3944343030452728, 0.6032063961029053, -0.06380793452262878, -0.013877632096409798, -0.7055562734603882, 0.31507036089897156, 0.34779131412506104, -0.9066272974014282, 0.6223135590553284, 0.05489754304289818, 0.4887622892856598, 0.4957185387611389, -0.5350158214569092, 0.7105993032455444, -0.3194236755371094, 0.32589536905288696, -0.14496886730194092, 0.8741169571876526, 0.062309928238391876, -0.6299102306365967, 0.13299059867858887, -0.22568804025650024, -0.09318015724420547, -0.052800390869379044, -0.009007381275296211, 0.19515612721443176, 0.49402788281440735, -0.3416605591773987, -0.7620159387588501, -0.14430534839630127, -0.20207221806049347, 0.14095191657543182, 0.6348505616188049, 0.13420714437961578, -0.3531781733036041, 0.16320554912090302, 0.6003912091255188, 0.09176263958215714, -0.9400452375411987, -0.5623186230659485, -0.7632244825363159, 0.2560169994831085, 0.36649128794670105, -0.9519253373146057, -0.3149750530719757, 0.9683709740638733, -0.8688730597496033, 0.2154826521873474, -0.10074138641357422, 0.3702363967895508, -0.262294739484787, -0.08715113997459412, -0.21089757978916168, 1.0831069946289062, -0.6635655164718628, -0.4602954089641571, -0.3278180658817291, -1.2371958494186401, -0.05938897654414177, 1.040184736251831, -0.34410518407821655, -0.419411301612854, 0.3732145130634308, 0.07594480365514755, -0.05542519688606262, 0.4451897144317627, 0.16128699481487274, 0.05626821890473366, -0.05487854406237602, 0.7616650462150574, 0.3226204812526703, 0.589606523513794, 0.3640284836292267, -0.298471063375473, 0.4604162573814392, -0.7073324918746948, -0.4309103190898895, 0.09968455880880356, -0.41153910756111145, 0.2705804705619812, -0.6748325228691101, -0.23206652700901031, -0.7378864288330078, -0.0613047331571579, -0.24679617583751678, 0.14843229949474335, 0.02308908849954605, 0.5376831293106079, 0.2616666555404663, -0.09690749645233154, -0.6437974572181702, 0.536851704120636, -0.03133299574255943, -0.23790058493614197, -0.16774515807628632, 0.5146609544754028, 0.42057108879089355, -0.09507528692483902, 0.1193762868642807, 0.43594929575920105, 0.46429240703582764, -0.9171605706214905, 0.3271462619304657, 0.4559715688228607, 0.11905361711978912, 0.16703735291957855, -0.8518643379211426, 0.06267337501049042, -0.48131150007247925, 0.5764269828796387, 0.7062050104141235, 0.775860607624054, 0.26482364535331726, 0.027369394898414612, 0.1756369024515152, 0.3625476658344269, -0.8907577395439148, -0.16705065965652466, -0.5675061345100403, -0.26253628730773926, 0.30054745078086853, -0.42633312940597534, 0.08874011784791946, -0.5921390652656555, -0.1335301697254181, 0.21976672112941742, 0.2068014293909073, 0.5409367680549622, -0.3277376592159271, 0.6642033457756042, 0.11810056865215302, 1.4382919073104858, 0.10631508380174637, -0.422213613986969, 0.3954823315143585, -0.4027998447418213, -0.865228533744812, -0.16557568311691284, -0.13317234814167023, 0.2325216382741928, 0.7935168147087097, -0.15845751762390137, 0.048318881541490555, 0.5477048754692078, 0.6036667227745056, 0.0816851556301117, -0.40943047404289246, 0.24124425649642944, -0.8265054225921631, -0.18746967613697052, 0.19528980553150177, 0.010006834752857685, -0.16182640194892883, -0.2878830134868622, 0.4777843952178955, -0.8144966959953308, -0.7675978541374207, 0.03255004808306694, 0.3831126391887665, -0.5679712295532227, -0.2572259306907654, 0.035335786640644073, 0.34043213725090027, 0.14448247849941254, -0.2224767953157425, 0.7882323265075684, 0.5364903211593628, 0.014796010218560696, -0.0642281100153923, -0.5395479202270508, 0.4335475564002991, 0.46902570128440857, 0.19512403011322021, 0.49819687008857727, 0.7707452774047852, 0.5897080302238464, -0.27884045243263245, 0.19427570700645447, -0.44504326581954956, 0.8923341035842896, 0.376731812953949, 0.061717674136161804, 0.08375468850135803, 0.793454110622406, 0.7228192090988159, -0.37740248441696167, -0.9400043487548828, 0.2011813372373581, 0.08808884024620056, -1.3183172941207886, -0.17355354130268097, 0.19788947701454163, 1.1421936750411987, 0.23261640965938568, 0.31006792187690735, 0.5241022706031799, 0.33333495259284973, 0.14772509038448334, -0.4292351305484772, 1.06978440284729, 0.23454414308071136, -0.16793018579483032, -0.41942623257637024, 0.282992959022522, -0.2987474203109741, 0.4440688192844391, 0.5270811915397644, 0.22585420310497284, -0.1324952393770218, 0.5812125205993652, 0.07732313871383667, -0.041081007570028305, 0.7723997831344604, -0.4924613833427429, 0.17587891221046448, -0.13901075720787048, -0.5607831478118896, -0.537083089351654, -0.4890749156475067, 0.7918716669082642, -0.24221350252628326, 0.0759970024228096, 0.44774749875068665, 0.8830094933509827, 0.5640050172805786, 0.6329687237739563, 0.6987905502319336, -0.2757510244846344, 0.35967397689819336, 0.38491231203079224, -0.2142093926668167, 0.39695772528648376, -0.7017301917076111, -0.16279707849025726, -0.02261703461408615, -1.0484449863433838, -0.2531295716762543, 0.4327593147754669, 0.2219095230102539, -0.49777066707611084, -0.04093903675675392, -0.11766354739665985, -0.6705058813095093, -0.3837002217769623, 0.22642719745635986, -1.043949842453003, 0.03152981773018837, 0.15640152990818024, 0.37722620368003845, 0.3273758292198181, -0.007230653893202543, -0.20390470325946808, -0.028038904070854187, -0.858979344367981, -0.11471904069185257, 0.3181583881378174, 0.4446474015712738, -0.22658874094486237, -0.799349844455719, -0.4424334466457367, -0.6520216464996338, 0.6659339666366577, 0.25856655836105347, -0.30394449830055237, -0.9685695171356201, -0.07100781053304672, 0.9330323338508606, 0.7281956672668457, 0.38582634925842285, -0.7444524765014648, 0.9095139503479004, 0.20387795567512512, 0.5693678259849548, -0.2402554154396057, 0.3247770667076111, -0.016078708693385124, 0.7843196392059326, 0.6320809721946716, -0.48078683018684387, -0.02701311558485031, 0.2823464274406433, -0.38361722230911255, -0.8648896217346191, -0.037135761231184006, -0.2046641856431961, -0.6983827948570251, 0.6563234329223633, 0.6066845655441284, 0.2851890027523041, -0.17906107008457184, -0.8134623169898987, -0.6806650161743164, -0.8358362317085266, 1.1117573976516724, -0.45376020669937134, -0.3244040608406067, 0.35212141275405884, -0.08363692462444305, -0.19925175607204437, -0.5922004580497742, 4.148853778839111, 1.0336421728134155, 0.6371466517448425, -0.31407737731933594, 0.6201743483543396, 0.7754648327827454, 0.11388207972049713, 0.3496481776237488, 0.18470127880573273, 0.6698412895202637, -0.0697096437215805, 0.958727240562439, 0.05204064026474953, 0.23897160589694977, 0.5116463899612427, -0.04656381160020828, -0.9469828009605408, 0.16878849267959595, -0.4154447615146637, -0.09754066169261932, -0.520774781703949, 0.2457844614982605, 0.04151228442788124, 0.3270496129989624, 0.04246266931295395, -0.19976039230823517, 0.31585314869880676, 0.4362764060497284, -0.16419516503810883, -0.410823792219162, -0.23568929731845856, -0.44190266728401184, 0.5352876782417297, -1.0438634157180786, 0.039635758846998215, 0.375789999961853, 0.12501183152198792, -0.5224090218544006, 0.030230985954403877, -0.22941149771213531, 0.028110211715102196, 0.2946782410144806, -0.021024618297815323, -0.40465545654296875, -0.2305765151977539, -0.01567378081381321, -0.45805034041404724, -0.504399299621582, 0.6409525871276855, -0.5009649991989136, 1.0088698863983154, -1.1415766477584839, 0.26525431871414185, -0.03205668926239014, -0.7331206798553467, -0.40650254487991333, -0.3077757954597473, -0.43208104372024536, 0.2973611056804657, -0.08322799205780029, 1.2357820272445679, 0.5191799402236938, -0.03504751995205879, -0.4150872230529785, 0.5024864673614502, 0.8689221739768982, -0.2815859615802765, 0.8405913710594177, -0.47175663709640503, -0.14429421722888947, -0.13895097374916077, -0.11652058362960815, -0.9981014728546143, 0.2939670979976654, 1.6218146085739136, 0.4492872655391693, 0.20891763269901276, 0.4645434617996216, -0.8401417136192322, -0.2570416033267975, 0.8199459910392761, 0.7448092103004456, 0.19307635724544525, -0.18126729130744934, -0.026896696537733078, 0.4881606996059418, -0.5837751626968384, -0.12884047627449036, -0.7407427430152893, 0.678380012512207, 0.30552229285240173, -0.21641620993614197, -0.4020317792892456, -0.23124490678310394, -0.07905060052871704 ]
{"Title": "Obstructive sleep apnea, positive airway pressure treatment, and postoperative delirium: protocol for a retrospective observational study", "Authors": "King Christopher R, Escallier Krisztina, Ju Yo-El S., Lin Nan, Palanca Ben Julian A., McKinnon Sherry, Avidan Michael S Professor", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Introduction Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is common among older surgical patients, and delirium is a frequent and serious postoperative complication. Emerging evidence suggests that OSA increases the risk for postoperative delirium. We hypothesize that OSA is an independent risk factor for postoperative delirium, and that in patients with OSA, perioperative adherence to positive airway pressure (PAP) therapy decreases the incidence of postoperative delirium and its sequelae. The proposed retrospective cohort analysis study will use existing datasets to: (i) describe and compare the incidence of postoperative delirium in surgical patients based on OSA diagnosis and treatment with PAP; (ii) assess whether preoperatively untreated OSA is independently associated with postoperative delirium; and (iii) explore whether preoperatively untreated OSA is independently associated with worse postoperative quality of life. The findings of this study will inform on the potential utility and approach of an interventional trial aimed at preventing postoperative delirium in patients with diagnosed and undiagnosed OSA. Methods and Analysis Observational data from existing electronic databases will be used, including over 100,000 surgical patients and \u223c10,000 intensive care unit (ICU) admissions. We will obtain the incidence of postoperative delirium in adults admitted postoperatively to the ICU who underwent structured preoperative assessment, including OSA diagnosis and screening. We will use doubly robust propensity score methods to assess whether untreated OSA independently predicts postoperative delirium. Using similar methodology, we will assess if untreated OSA independently predicts worse postoperative quality of life. Ethics and dissemination This study has been approved by the Human Research Protection Office at Washington University School of Medicine. We will publish the results in a peer-reviewed venue. Because the data is secondary and high risk for re-identification, we will not publicly share the data. Data will be destroyed after 1 year of completion of active IRB approved projects. Article summary Strengths and limitations of this study, (containing 5 short bullet points, no longer than one sentence each, that relate specifically to the methods) Our granular database includes routine structured preoperative screening for OSA, processed laboratory results, and verified comorbid diagnoses. We have limited information on the severity of most comorbidities, creating the possibility for substantial residual confounding. Our database includes near-universal and standardized nurse-driven delirium evaluations at multiple time-points as well as clinician diagnoses. Compared to prior studies, the large sample size will allow for more aggressive confounder adjustment utilizing linked structured medical histories, intraoperative records, and administrative data. Selection bias and confounding by indication are important limitations, which we will address using advanced statistical methods.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19002501"}
10.1101/19005892
[ -0.607135534286499, 0.222476065158844, -0.4905312955379486, 0.09285679459571838, -0.5910114645957947, 0.4039783179759979, -0.10282467305660248, 0.261514812707901, 0.46664732694625854, 0.6953453421592712, 0.01695762574672699, -0.2941895127296448, 0.6866604089736938, -0.911785900592804, 0.010519755072891712, 0.23464754223823547, -0.1712590903043747, -0.2687029540538788, -0.24383436143398285, 0.21911479532718658, 0.2363855391740799, 0.3710268437862396, -0.6737213134765625, 0.2900865972042084, -0.6157187819480896, 0.4707389175891876, 0.11158564686775208, -0.3831850290298462, 1.0585731267929077, 1.0004910230636597, -0.6484056711196899, -0.6585522890090942, 0.7648946046829224, -0.7727794647216797, -0.28884702920913696, -0.01227351650595665, 0.8797476291656494, 0.016921130940318108, -0.4097171723842621, -0.16152262687683105, 0.17609404027462006, -0.09499680250883102, 0.4034118354320526, -0.24531017243862152, 0.16359436511993408, -0.14262062311172485, -1.0240585803985596, -0.9268542528152466, 0.2896862030029297, -0.34110426902770996, 0.4391646981239319, -0.3323097229003906, -0.08440262824296951, -0.42195436358451843, 0.05025603249669075, 0.6790624856948853, 0.37291333079338074, -0.13762395083904266, -0.6682601571083069, 0.27528780698776245, -0.06629910320043564, 0.04647558927536011, 0.6493348479270935, -1.4762439727783203, 1.416618824005127, 0.7885321974754333, 0.35719728469848633, -0.36863112449645996, -0.47728386521339417, -0.055609408766031265, 0.004568857606500387, -0.9347686767578125, -1.2678695917129517, -0.25212913751602173, -0.05734618008136749, -0.11273054033517838, 0.46257007122039795, 0.4797430634498596, -0.6751749515533447, -0.03146915137767792, 0.08082813024520874, 0.2915939390659332, 0.0831809788942337, 0.7795576453208923, -0.8911491632461548, -0.08461795002222061, 0.45971551537513733, 0.7482784986495972, -0.04404113069176674, -0.002487707184627652, 0.18471664190292358, 0.15060508251190186, -0.09817344695329666, 0.07655657827854156, 0.08499585092067719, 1.2359524965286255, -0.9611050486564636, -0.007092765998095274, 0.12439994513988495, -0.5236907005310059, 0.385593980550766, 0.4926745891571045, -0.5947768092155457, 0.6081399321556091, -0.6970634460449219, 0.8154844045639038, 1.2537239789962769, -0.7274211645126343, 0.295118123292923, -1.0024865865707397, 0.7726001739501953, 0.5678248405456543, -0.48742908239364624, 0.7080749869346619, 1.4282156229019165, 0.4506881535053253, 0.004769095219671726, 0.7769443988800049, -0.06637333333492279, 0.028505660593509674, -0.0663849413394928, 0.16284418106079102, 0.4590728282928467, -0.22230932116508484, 0.2685733437538147, 0.6824679374694824, -0.07482876628637314, 0.20556537806987762, -0.282738596200943, -0.5643927454948425, -0.27727529406547546, -0.1938963085412979, 0.3484170734882355, -0.12296708673238754, -0.17817577719688416, -0.2364179939031601, 0.1203826442360878, 1.2003093957901, -0.002188522834330797, -0.6250837445259094, -0.34899014234542847, 0.5959498882293701, -0.6683606505393982, 1.1456220149993896, -0.009963694959878922, 0.9547149538993835, -1.0697990655899048, -1.2723950147628784, -0.9377505779266357, -0.3986407518386841, 0.19222858548164368, 0.6023463010787964, 0.027981003746390343, -0.7011110782623291, -0.037636637687683105, 0.48288777470588684, -0.1731492280960083, 0.46523910760879517, 0.24307963252067566, 0.5872862935066223, -0.8177517652511597, 0.06079268828034401, -0.3413746654987335, 0.8582751750946045, -0.5430932641029358, 0.8033764958381653, -0.21372783184051514, 0.3441776931285858, 0.6577799320220947, -0.9363648295402527, 0.28566890954971313, 0.2993128001689911, -0.6962886452674866, -0.4386537969112396, 0.3139888048171997, 0.8561834096908569, 0.5848913788795471, -0.1771870255470276, 0.1881510317325592, 0.15556219220161438, -0.29459014534950256, 0.5629932880401611, 0.5660024285316467, 1.4138119220733643, -0.25944066047668457, -0.32842594385147095, -0.5105445981025696, -0.42366543412208557, -0.23683993518352509, -0.42846858501434326, -0.1599930226802826, 0.016483455896377563, 0.058195192366838455, 0.6215552091598511, 0.22487881779670715, -0.0401933528482914, -0.40847888588905334, 0.6542624831199646, -0.3609912097454071, -0.6882382035255432, 0.02892955206334591, 0.3856680691242218, -0.43148520588874817, 0.26428094506263733, -0.5972472429275513, 0.7646617293357849, 0.06959807127714157, 1.175644040107727, -0.5718871355056763, 0.5160794854164124, 1.2332252264022827, 0.4103085994720459, -0.19381731748580933, -0.4696524739265442, 0.6268638968467712, -0.20737572014331818, -0.0806097537279129, 0.5926361083984375, -1.2482874393463135, 0.2734678387641907, -0.5943619608879089, -0.4488624036312103, 0.7122511267662048, 0.02334306389093399, 0.15732461214065552, 0.13590985536575317, 0.6371832489967346, 0.10563398152589798, 0.09315859526395798, 0.025202643126249313, 0.36265677213668823, 0.6535080671310425, 0.04732636734843254, 0.4337535500526428, 0.842275083065033, 0.4028865396976471, 0.07923980057239532, 0.24123360216617584, 0.15239517390727997, 0.6879255175590515, 1.1642556190490723, 0.7278497815132141, 0.5091952681541443, 0.4424980878829956, -0.10915939509868622, 0.005311957560479641, -0.5198220014572144, 0.6381743550300598, -0.49056476354599, 0.6397069096565247, -0.5671696662902832, 0.0998387485742569, 0.583645224571228, 0.596899688243866, -0.6914929747581482, -0.4188358783721924, 0.7053527235984802, 0.22113700211048126, -0.08318484574556351, -0.41484710574150085, -0.16689741611480713, 0.17480480670928955, 0.44809356331825256, -0.10676118731498718, 0.7087857127189636, 0.7895022630691528, 0.12408945709466934, 0.28610384464263916, 0.03396620973944664, -0.1654413491487503, -0.9056472778320312, -0.7947506308555603, -1.3228179216384888, -1.4620914459228516, -1.2916876077651978, -0.2678747773170471, 0.27328336238861084, -0.6566353440284729, 0.3030456006526947, 0.011483319103717804, 0.22320394217967987, -0.4535224437713623, -0.10380660742521286, 0.7438890933990479, 0.07151240855455399, 0.5093041062355042, -0.9991661310195923, -0.0455775149166584, -0.5598571300506592, -0.03782778978347778, -0.5753107070922852, -0.37469953298568726, -0.32751333713531494, -0.6653141379356384, 0.8717356324195862, -0.869655966758728, -0.08867155760526657, -0.6835134625434875, 0.19255609810352325, -0.4229873716831207, 0.1774771511554718, -0.07697927951812744, 0.5177502036094666, 0.30836302042007446, -0.1877693384885788, 0.6670981049537659, 0.3520282804965973, -0.18449759483337402, 0.33638063073158264, 0.565106987953186, -0.2401883900165558, 0.5464221239089966, 0.276676744222641, 0.12959015369415283, -0.9992169141769409, 0.12329579889774323, 1.228491187095642, -0.5998484492301941, -0.11669421195983887, -0.3128547966480255, -0.7361880540847778, -0.6910477876663208, -0.18162325024604797, 0.12359598278999329, -0.29626911878585815, 0.3796963095664978, 0.022270778194069862, -1.092287302017212, 0.26747313141822815, 0.3834121823310852, -1.669756531715393, 0.20679134130477905, -0.2786802351474762, 0.6749520897865295, 0.4233200252056122, -0.660780668258667, 0.04453113675117493, 0.47463759779930115, 0.2562960088253021, 0.3676234185695648, 0.07304032891988754, -0.29280734062194824, 0.527836263179779, 0.37190595269203186, -0.2469501942396164, -0.08703816682100296, 0.05468568205833435, -0.14559593796730042, -0.05707376450300217, -0.0464961864054203, 0.013125650584697723, 0.1475600153207779, 0.30181336402893066, 0.08173752576112747, -0.45421838760375977, 0.2450418323278427, 0.0543271079659462, 0.29249730706214905, 0.6237322092056274, 0.7078747749328613, -0.3713526129722595, 0.5361175537109375, 0.16151967644691467, -0.20485207438468933, -0.4816219210624695, -0.24927878379821777, 0.7869475483894348, -0.4469754695892334, 0.9992898106575012, -0.5479775071144104, 0.6855798363685608, 0.2934969365596771, -0.26454591751098633, 0.19176435470581055, 0.0432860441505909, 0.13122540712356567, 1.583642840385437, 0.2625626027584076, 1.1918381452560425, -1.360626459121704, 0.5531038045883179, 0.5871919393539429, 1.197513222694397, 0.08798761665821075, 0.1446470022201538, 0.7978318333625793, -0.5938605666160583, 0.5375550985336304, -0.1571451723575592, -0.08627472817897797, -0.2300538867712021, -0.18437139689922333, 0.10608391463756561, 0.16790811717510223, -0.5871089696884155, -0.1847226768732071, 0.3331662118434906, 0.528969407081604, -0.5946981906890869, 0.003868738655000925, 0.6490263938903809, -0.5302082896232605, -0.08470048755407333, -0.5703942775726318, 0.31575489044189453, -0.39290130138397217, -0.08204670995473862, -0.2546103894710541, -0.07955294847488403, 0.013210433535277843, -0.46716398000717163, -0.26359596848487854, -0.416742742061615, 0.180053249001503, 0.7594290375709534, -0.44446054100990295, -0.8801015615463257, -0.3143056631088257, -0.44981610774993896, 0.6021239757537842, 0.389384925365448, 0.5527921319007874, -0.7270628213882446, 0.7169381380081177, -0.2041229009628296, -0.4494544267654419, -0.24684180319309235, -0.9927276372909546, -0.2844676673412323, 0.374782532453537, -0.5768988132476807, -0.42925402522087097, -0.44865626096725464, -0.0008361124200746417, -0.9671652913093567, -0.05504604056477547, 0.1762639433145523, -0.16644570231437683, -0.12967464327812195, -0.2113906592130661, -0.33001405000686646, -0.3071273863315582, -0.1202944815158844, -0.14327727258205414, -0.07963963598012924, 0.0709245353937149, 0.9456011056900024, 0.20426484942436218, 0.5475724339485168, -0.14275071024894714, 1.2414435148239136, -0.7343339323997498, 0.4124896228313446, -0.49394816160202026, -0.4690580368041992, -0.06083415448665619, -0.374032199382782, -0.49884364008903503, 0.008217441849410534, -0.3320428133010864, -0.6567717790603638, 0.06273851543664932, 0.941983163356781, -0.15887486934661865, -0.1404775083065033, 1.0713099241256714, -1.1065553426742554, -0.04877719283103943, 1.4538979530334473, 0.08174663782119751, 0.4894476532936096, -0.1849835366010666, -0.06277712434530258, -0.249864861369133, 1.2916289567947388, 0.4118506908416748, -0.12306695431470871, 0.03081486187875271, 0.034536734223365784, -0.4661123752593994, 0.11507699638605118, 0.25866660475730896, -0.5771074295043945, -0.06867017596960068, -0.4422832429409027, -0.4092193841934204, -0.929940402507782, 0.16135995090007782, -0.6707252860069275, 0.4358678162097931, 0.25211119651794434, -0.1951078623533249, 0.26100459694862366, -0.3346676230430603, -0.48642224073410034, -0.31229478120803833, -0.5169070959091187, 0.10732582211494446, -0.24130001664161682, 0.4152689278125763, 0.5776309370994568, -1.1189494132995605, -0.7629421353340149, 0.5029977560043335, 0.46412283182144165, -0.9725739359855652, -0.4124160706996918, 0.05026469752192497, 0.5531848073005676, -0.6448185443878174, -0.24199384450912476, -0.24559709429740906, -0.22637711465358734, -0.2650039792060852, 0.47960835695266724, 0.26723146438598633, 0.5088405013084412, 0.09856587648391724, -0.4089263677597046, 0.8488203287124634, -0.0633821189403534, -0.802130401134491, -0.351737380027771, 0.4976752996444702, 0.782813549041748, -0.23193305730819702, 0.19305342435836792, -1.2699077129364014, -0.9545955657958984, -0.5962305665016174, 0.06403984129428864, -0.7895166277885437, -0.4714522659778595, -0.7128755450248718, 0.0141217652708292, -0.12839297950267792, 0.7157632112503052, 0.30308446288108826, 0.05257253721356392, 0.4893833100795746, -0.49714234471321106, 0.407166987657547, -0.6677338480949402, 0.34963080286979675, -0.03956406190991402, 0.008259396068751812, 0.13878187537193298, 0.8067231774330139, 0.5731152296066284, -0.17866750061511993, 0.1389249861240387, 0.19075146317481995, 0.384122759103775, 0.5140420794487, -0.32702624797821045, -0.27741414308547974, 0.3946426808834076, 0.26593947410583496, -0.4361034035682678, 0.09927985817193985, -1.4381425380706787, 0.7427478432655334, -0.3476904034614563, -0.319499135017395, 0.3762566149234772, -0.5611293911933899, -0.42820194363594055, -0.7616460919380188, 0.9049113392829895, -0.8042595982551575, 0.327434778213501, 0.3995356261730194, -0.5062028169631958, -0.8738489151000977, 0.40798628330230713, -0.4558648467063904, -0.13298805058002472, -0.6305925250053406, -0.6712015867233276, 0.385265052318573, 0.1421409696340561, -0.025006629526615143, -0.20099569857120514, 0.08149932324886322, 0.553918182849884, -0.9791571497917175, 1.0744744539260864, 1.055354356765747, -0.1217588409781456, -0.23747271299362183, 0.15359456837177277, 0.5385056138038635, 0.08475182950496674, -0.25051093101501465, 0.7227559685707092, -0.6176217794418335, -0.22596269845962524, -0.3613660931587219, -0.29547980427742004, -1.1430532932281494, -0.1430600881576538, 0.37603554129600525, 0.27209243178367615, 0.5570176243782043, 0.39496779441833496, -0.1938031166791916, 0.06432908773422241, -0.13555462658405304, 0.9496984481811523, -0.3800320625305176, 0.29653504490852356, 0.6199491620063782, 0.2524935007095337, 0.409227192401886, 0.8531032800674438, 0.04496309533715248, -0.22466886043548584, -0.2632771134376526, 0.5346278548240662, 0.4111528992652893, -1.2607139348983765, 0.7872573137283325, 0.3032417893409729, -0.6285039186477661, -0.4771583080291748, 0.15696731209754944, -0.32241591811180115, 0.02843831293284893, 0.013366695493459702, -0.5954834222793579, 0.3813662827014923, -0.10533661395311356, 0.29972660541534424, 0.031497348099946976, 0.3890894055366516, -0.2209509015083313, -0.9609180092811584, 0.31590643525123596, -1.0297354459762573, -0.3436996042728424, 0.8550203442573547, -0.06812523305416107, 0.18640072643756866, 0.003449034411460161, 0.611281156539917, 0.3100036680698395, -0.3041403293609619, 0.26522716879844666, -0.7840933203697205, 0.15087264776229858, 0.5212888121604919, 0.02721751481294632, -0.07095363736152649, 0.2594265043735504, 0.30151453614234924, 1.1799805164337158, 0.09458861500024796, -0.5867442488670349, -0.8640674352645874, 0.34528928995132446, 0.752284824848175, 0.777593731880188, 0.3953562080860138, -0.32810771465301514, 0.9414297342300415, -0.337782084941864, -0.5987745523452759, -0.06564182043075562, -0.19983962178230286, -0.5881813764572144, -1.0649127960205078, 0.318821519613266, -0.7517456412315369, 0.05403343588113785, 0.8772199749946594, -0.4804445505142212, -0.2821035087108612, -1.013413667678833, 0.617466926574707, 0.29251617193222046, 0.087821826338768, -0.5009632110595703, 0.6873733997344971, -0.8790138363838196, -0.4307005703449249, -0.36429041624069214, -0.30877771973609924, 0.2994106113910675, 0.6933742165565491, -0.49957606196403503, -0.12052658200263977, -0.24692480266094208, 0.16600483655929565, -0.38332968950271606, 0.32676032185554504, -1.0653263330459595, -0.009973988868296146, -1.091981291770935, 0.5862485766410828, -0.039004240185022354, 0.27649590373039246, 1.7316735982894897, -0.19487199187278748, 0.4465862214565277, 0.426021009683609, -0.27086955308914185, -0.2857568860054016, 0.46088096499443054, 1.1090790033340454, -1.1194642782211304, -0.8842079043388367, -0.6224759221076965, 0.6248534321784973, -1.5565104484558105, -0.6814088821411133, -0.48912039399147034, -0.5178420543670654, 0.10642104595899582, 0.20027191936969757, -0.30391213297843933, 0.9317228198051453, 0.603606104850769, 0.0238534864038229, -0.23560263216495514, 0.5626308917999268, 0.0779111459851265, -0.17283710837364197, 0.5792016386985779, 0.6528292298316956, 0.22653433680534363, -0.9153262376785278, 0.5149949789047241, 0.4916882812976837, -0.8233714699745178, 0.4586957097053528, -0.3593483865261078, 0.3289107382297516, 0.5615458488464355, -0.17001649737358093, -0.4217756688594818, 0.02152138203382492, 0.4877370595932007, 0.7432411909103394, 0.02887786366045475, -0.7818777561187744, -1.0332804918289185, -0.4950205981731415, -1.2392677068710327, -0.642341136932373, 0.875747799873352, -0.1924411952495575, 0.506554126739502, -0.09549560397863388, -0.32047462463378906, 0.715338408946991, -0.23291704058647156, 0.11164717376232147, -0.5269310474395752, -0.02264941670000553, 0.3399405777454376, 0.8016317486763, 0.13583210110664368, 0.02161189168691635, -0.08402838557958603, -0.19144274294376373, -1.1985408067703247, -0.8655924201011658, -0.04595574364066124, 0.5523889660835266, 0.4403364360332489, -0.022812891751527786, -0.17150501906871796, -0.2193918526172638, 0.6146981716156006, -0.35646912455558777, -0.1683700680732727, -0.19174236059188843, -0.4533992111682892, -0.18547888100147247, 0.1093280017375946, 0.5187515020370483, -0.6430095434188843, 0.5792370438575745, 0.12339425086975098, -1.0369014739990234, -0.2694445848464966, 0.4307704567909241, 0.6734551191329956, -0.3891337811946869, 0.6931995749473572, -0.15822264552116394, 0.414885550737381, -0.04639197885990143, -0.6567888855934143, 0.3630248010158539, 1.1118180751800537, -0.39947599172592163, 0.2849496901035309, 0.3237665593624115, 0.18138547241687775, 0.9897556304931641, 0.19851210713386536, -0.2876136600971222, 0.35943421721458435, 0.38722869753837585, 0.5066348314285278, 0.14783142507076263, -0.587313175201416, 0.3851855993270874, 0.2912599444389343, -0.5019681453704834, -0.25820064544677734, 0.060536716133356094, 0.777151882648468, 0.19416628777980804, -0.25394922494888306, 0.4854700565338135, -0.7856597900390625, -0.5226957201957703, -0.17552532255649567, 0.5538376569747925, 0.6675641536712646, -0.06589479744434357, 0.3149477541446686, -0.36507686972618103, 0.4387935698032379, 0.1409435272216797, -0.06463916599750519, 0.6261006593704224, -0.4941423237323761, -0.42721569538116455, -0.17661331593990326, 0.411945104598999, 0.1709231436252594, -0.25276175141334534, 0.2233106940984726, -0.6374717950820923, -0.08684878051280975, 0.6936073899269104, -0.3471294939517975, -0.4896043539047241, 1.4413361549377441, 0.047349151223897934, -0.32658353447914124, -0.4387339651584625, -0.3290141820907593, -0.49849405884742737, -0.4682880640029907, 0.6658239960670471, -0.6505147218704224, 0.17185494303703308, 0.6614933609962463, 0.6871951222419739, 0.6186069250106812, -0.19942936301231384, 0.8382106423377991, -0.6896299123764038, 0.06497906148433685, 0.43673333525657654, 0.13613887131214142, -0.20573168992996216, -0.520584762096405, -0.34335842728614807, -0.22795166075229645, -0.3517223298549652, -0.3078705966472626, 0.6912199854850769, -0.38253942131996155, 0.24093018472194672, 0.5154755115509033, -0.23735590279102325, -0.05781859904527664, -0.5217123627662659, -0.055264778435230255, 0.4412555396556854, -0.05925030633807182, -0.7651076912879944, -0.14184637367725372, 0.21560807526111603, 0.03947354853153229, -0.6362971663475037, -0.3791833519935608, -0.678981602191925, 0.12439610809087753, -1.017539620399475, 0.6802734732627869, -0.48524874448776245, 0.30713948607444763, -0.46062135696411133, -1.4102849960327148, -0.02408275380730629, 0.5818222761154175, -0.013589857146143913, -0.78877854347229, -0.17421047389507294, 0.05312866345047951, 0.6227680444717407, -0.42234426736831665, -0.5784403681755066, -0.12403163313865662, -0.003983163740485907, 0.7492195963859558, -0.4649776220321655, 0.2210969775915146, -0.29674798250198364, 0.7696139216423035, -0.4649665951728821, -0.09549634158611298, -0.0870979055762291, -0.3442290127277374, 0.09940563142299652, -0.6207711100578308, 0.43762844800949097, 0.03980983793735504, -0.6475492119789124, 0.4674108922481537, 0.2771283984184265, -0.3697088658809662, -0.19394604861736298, -0.6206063032150269, -0.34824177622795105, -0.17724063992500305, 0.5954164862632751, -0.4101921021938324, 0.03068338893353939, 1.0360603332519531, -0.1867310255765915, -0.15586110949516296, -0.9776263236999512, 3.8812174797058105, 1.3910151720046997, 0.4373079836368561, -0.45153966546058655, 0.5823188424110413, 0.48864489793777466, 0.5295565724372864, -0.1546694040298462, 0.21160048246383667, 0.46027544140815735, -0.5538598299026489, -0.043022241443395615, 0.45471227169036865, -0.17898251116275787, 0.7294373512268066, 0.5221710801124573, -0.8100824356079102, -0.48154863715171814, 0.6039974093437195, -0.8783851265907288, -0.45332077145576477, 0.07218062877655029, 0.21900668740272522, 0.40111616253852844, 0.5622565150260925, -0.23355714976787567, -0.23498763144016266, -0.018962839618325233, -0.7343354821205139, -0.31586313247680664, -0.19882068037986755, -0.44125884771347046, 0.35121288895606995, -0.16330713033676147, -0.27395617961883545, 0.29455143213272095, -0.68121337890625, -0.5623659491539001, -0.07140470296144485, -0.3148358464241028, -0.26470673084259033, -0.6202649474143982, -0.37144631147384644, -0.5335925221443176, -0.09067483246326447, 0.7722342610359192, -0.24041908979415894, 0.3905388414859772, -0.2009272277355194, -0.982143759727478, 0.5518298745155334, -0.5270260572433472, 0.39618200063705444, 0.07177304476499557, -0.9913904070854187, -0.3482934832572937, 0.13102062046527863, -1.2155365943908691, 0.05581177771091461, 0.9329308271408081, 0.5382521748542786, -0.5860774517059326, -0.37963882088661194, 0.6702578663825989, 0.35248175263404846, 0.6501531004905701, 0.34428656101226807, 0.18134529888629913, -0.4791546165943146, -0.24483226239681244, -0.8630120754241943, -0.6100658178329468, -0.5929676294326782, 0.13942641019821167, 0.5042651295661926, 0.36031273007392883, -0.1537196934223175, 0.843300461769104, -0.8341242671012878, -0.6981062889099121, 0.7747437357902527, -0.15577690303325653, 0.722976803779602, -0.7698596715927124, -0.012714176438748837, 0.6274405717849731, -0.829708456993103, -0.017578259110450745, -1.6157420873641968, 0.6547645926475525, -0.17088653147220612, 0.10638989508152008, 0.12483859807252884, -0.17421473562717438, -0.6929208040237427 ]
{"Title": "Physical activity and risk of breast and endometrial cancers: a Mendelian randomization study", "Authors": "Baurecht Hansj\u00f6rg, Leitzmann Michael, O\u2019Mara Tracy, Thompson Deborah J, Teumer Alexander, Baumeister Sebastian E.", "Abstract": "A bstract Importance The causality of the association between physical activity and risk of breast and endometrial cancers is uncertain because available evidence is based exclusively on observational studies, which are potentially susceptible to confounding and reverse causation. Objective To investigate whether increased physical activity is causally associated with decreased risk of breast and endometrial cancers, using a two-sample Mendelian randomization study design. Design, Setting, and Participants Genome-wide association studies of physical activity, breast cancer, and endometrial cancer, published up to April 31, 2019, were identified using PubMed and the GWAS catalog. Twelve single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) known at P < 5 \u00d7 10 \u22128 to be associated with accelerometer-assessed or self-reported physical activity served as instrumental variables. Genetic summary data from four large consortia provided SNP-outcome associations [Breast Cancer Association Consortium; Discovery, Biology and Risk of Inherited Variants in Breast Cancer Consortium; Endometrial Cancer Association Consortium]. Main Outcomes and Measures The primary outcomes were risk of breast cancer and risk of endometrial cancer. Secondary outcomes were estrogen receptor positive (ER+) and ER-breast cancers. Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) per mean acceleration in milli-gravities of accelerometer-assessed physical activity and per one standard deviation (1-SD) increase in metabolic-equivalent (MET)-minutes/week of self-reported moderate-to-vigorous physical activity were computed using the inverse variance weighted method. A series of sensitivity analyses addressed the potential impact of heterogeneity, pleiotropy, and outliers. Results Summary data were available for 122,977 breast cancers and 12,270 endometrial cancers. Genetic predisposition to increased accelerometer-assessed physical activity was associated with lower risk of breast and endometrial cancers. The associations (ORs [95% CI] per 1-SD increase in mean acceleration) were 0.88 (0.85-0.91) for breast cancer and 0.90 (0.83-0.97) for endometrial cancer. In addition, genetic predisposition to increased accelerometer-assessed physical activity was associated with lower risk of ER+ breast cancer. We found no evidence for an association between genetic predisposition to self-reported physical activity and risk of total breast cancer, breast cancer subtypes, or endometrial cancer. Conclusion and Relevance This first Mendelian randomization study shows that objectively-assessed physical activity plays a causal role in protecting against breast and endometrial cancers.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005892"}
10.1101/19008086
[ -0.3694852888584137, 0.8606931567192078, -0.8351629376411438, 0.05051816627383232, -0.31437069177627563, -0.6800072193145752, -0.09343114495277405, 0.21503986418247223, -0.2879447042942047, 0.750192403793335, -0.2435273379087448, -1.0167622566223145, 0.052533261477947235, -0.5875370502471924, -0.012080175802111626, -0.39838090538978577, -1.426639437675476, -0.5327297449111938, 0.05732133984565735, -0.13489015400409698, 0.673218309879303, 0.8884707689285278, -0.7389612197875977, -0.49941420555114746, -1.0784294605255127, 0.43912142515182495, 0.5242380499839783, -0.4152624011039734, 1.467976450920105, 1.2782700061798096, 0.28244921565055847, -0.6298390626907349, 0.7388486266136169, -0.6981642842292786, -0.0364183634519577, -0.11073291301727295, 0.7611575722694397, -0.6809727549552917, -0.5620312094688416, -0.4348015785217285, 0.6990311741828918, 0.27897578477859497, 0.308784157037735, -0.24616479873657227, -0.8265155553817749, -0.8896281719207764, -0.9236920475959778, -0.31744521856307983, -0.06184661015868187, -0.5049908757209778, -0.7124854326248169, 0.030330318957567215, 0.3241035044193268, 0.4859496057033539, 0.039991509169340134, 0.3508387506008148, 0.23530004918575287, -0.20800846815109253, -0.7266252636909485, 0.19413284957408905, 0.33968794345855713, -0.5862693786621094, 0.5538145303726196, -1.2728407382965088, 0.12985406816005707, 0.9269978404045105, -0.22093872725963593, -0.5677057504653931, -0.4935433268547058, -0.8853408098220825, -0.5807361006736755, 0.043574605137109756, -0.10199497640132904, 0.3728584349155426, 0.3484896123409271, 0.17133675515651703, -0.016126839444041252, 0.13808324933052063, 0.005961083807051182, -0.4912479519844055, -0.2913796007633209, -0.0021189418621361256, -0.9970753788948059, 0.19477976858615875, -0.1033814549446106, -0.4036221504211426, 0.3824431300163269, -0.013102098368108273, 0.4098976254463196, -0.4157542586326599, -0.07765394449234009, -0.06441949307918549, -0.1049591451883316, -0.08028995990753174, 0.17283226549625397, 0.6670602560043335, -0.17253024876117706, 0.051586054265499115, 0.21115054190158844, 0.35873517394065857, -0.11331126093864441, 1.164790391921997, -0.24508343636989594, 1.1684969663619995, -1.0521653890609741, 0.2087467461824417, 1.0850435495376587, -0.3409304916858673, -0.5764354467391968, -1.0264580249786377, -0.03631678223609924, 0.15707962214946747, 0.15103629231452942, -0.16469986736774445, 0.4215899407863617, 0.3696464002132416, 0.06998729705810547, 0.42354071140289307, -0.501632034778595, 0.41233062744140625, -0.13773544132709503, -0.01853480003774166, 0.6345959305763245, -0.8687472343444824, 0.8746099472045898, -0.10229913145303726, -0.09054878354072571, 0.8764263391494751, -0.6775318384170532, -0.5852519273757935, -0.34867599606513977, -0.425459086894989, -0.08169742673635483, 0.8655180335044861, 0.23245374858379364, -0.09849294275045395, 0.4476563036441803, 0.5130569934844971, -0.2842605710029602, -0.5259215235710144, -0.4804442226886749, -0.21170155704021454, -0.6184122562408447, 1.550519585609436, -0.36784183979034424, 0.23805342614650726, -0.0449492372572422, -1.089068055152893, 0.06206447631120682, 0.4307229220867157, 0.31272509694099426, 0.10289252549409866, -0.2839112877845764, 0.3094457685947418, 0.3536386489868164, -0.16110332310199738, -0.2951646149158478, 0.7500435709953308, -0.7072210311889648, 0.02231920138001442, -0.20480382442474365, -0.47536781430244446, -0.5326820015907288, 0.842859148979187, -0.5816937685012817, 0.5604502558708191, 0.19591127336025238, -0.2878120243549347, -0.8759582042694092, -0.3022177815437317, 0.3465607166290283, -0.024706343188881874, -0.47096309065818787, -0.3917345702648163, 0.1931661069393158, 0.7241474986076355, 0.8128019571304321, 0.15427446365356445, 0.8212541341781616, 0.281006783246994, -0.6042299866676331, -0.6070581674575806, 0.4104160964488983, 0.4236299395561218, -0.38681140542030334, 0.7400674819946289, -0.18024155497550964, 0.27969038486480713, 0.13575641810894012, 0.26287099719047546, -0.4188464879989624, 1.378785490989685, -0.521480143070221, 0.233672097325325, -0.27508851885795593, -0.2108798325061798, 0.11493220180273056, 0.3826998770236969, -0.39755624532699585, -0.5052294731140137, -0.028755217790603638, 0.45045164227485657, -0.8011411428451538, 0.8628392219543457, -0.6388945579528809, 0.10617125779390335, 0.17116472125053406, 0.6385037302970886, -0.3509848713874817, 0.6459094285964966, -0.2948454022407532, -0.03145277872681618, -0.13815194368362427, 0.07390018552541733, 0.48980438709259033, -0.4986476004123688, -0.20034565031528473, 0.1390570104122162, 0.2506144642829895, -0.4172556400299072, 0.17989479005336761, -0.4701588451862335, 0.6748120188713074, 0.2310323566198349, -0.04241682589054108, 0.3178535997867584, 1.2397820949554443, 0.33152344822883606, 0.0281078964471817, 0.2573533058166504, 0.43319013714790344, 0.3099628686904907, 0.17176970839500427, 0.5744982957839966, 1.0782455205917358, -0.2559639811515808, 0.5091468691825867, 0.31791990995407104, 0.5832421183586121, -0.20967958867549896, 0.5627886652946472, -0.16654635965824127, 1.0602694749832153, 0.7589702606201172, 0.09755458682775497, 0.06427907198667526, -0.1360311210155487, 0.2002490609884262, -0.32955804467201233, 0.09463058412075043, -1.3622403144836426, 1.2621876001358032, 0.4732957184314728, -0.024086399003863335, -0.5771864652633667, -0.1040496900677681, 0.42736583948135376, 0.5212740302085876, 0.06949266046285629, -0.7944610714912415, -0.2942501902580261, -0.05163281038403511, -0.19935694336891174, 0.6513912081718445, 0.8510841131210327, 1.1045851707458496, 0.4614415764808655, 0.5166467428207397, -0.27698230743408203, -0.48391392827033997, -0.3919083774089813, -0.7220945358276367, -1.028843641281128, -0.3341970145702362, -0.6792017817497253, -0.20441241562366486, -0.05680491402745247, -0.8109859824180603, 0.3958354890346527, -0.5252545475959778, 0.09896387904882431, 0.17800036072731018, -0.11482052505016327, 0.8098382949829102, 0.08246263861656189, -0.2899407744407654, -1.0976543426513672, 0.7688709497451782, 0.13110604882240295, 0.30087029933929443, 0.29305341839790344, -0.3421924114227295, -0.7627262473106384, -0.7759440541267395, 0.8280181884765625, -0.8424947261810303, -0.2103370726108551, 0.09673311561346054, -0.32520678639411926, 0.4282529950141907, 0.5778266787528992, 1.068589210510254, 0.06374847888946533, 0.23022326827049255, -0.5941179990768433, 0.5059043169021606, 0.5483995676040649, -0.14041149616241455, 0.8217958807945251, -0.24339498579502106, -0.6333836317062378, 0.8616886734962463, -0.4855130612850189, 0.06090981885790825, -0.7188156843185425, 0.5481684803962708, 0.44886699318885803, -0.5539113879203796, 0.18850775063037872, -0.5068684220314026, -0.7321226596832275, -0.1503736972808838, -0.17764973640441895, 0.17926834523677826, 0.20108935236930847, 0.6867607235908508, 0.007873402908444405, -1.2635785341262817, -0.17257916927337646, -0.8214191794395447, -0.7601101398468018, -0.21334318816661835, -0.03188350796699524, 0.4893075227737427, 0.18685168027877808, 0.3882577121257782, -1.0156978368759155, -0.3246901333332062, 0.6083640456199646, 0.7955288290977478, -0.2520272135734558, -0.10112787783145905, -0.20165380835533142, 0.7411683201789856, -0.44829151034355164, 0.9814755916595459, 0.8129616975784302, -0.3086749017238617, -0.3280421495437622, 0.5186703205108643, -0.5413002371788025, 0.008673534728586674, 0.7346756458282471, -0.308437317609787, 0.36581331491470337, -0.14083583652973175, -0.5345750451087952, 0.007080984767526388, 0.28803497552871704, -0.1379753053188324, -0.3857758343219757, -0.21384835243225098, -0.17237348854541779, 1.1980000734329224, -0.6051367521286011, -0.7053900361061096, 0.6799303293228149, 0.18034188449382782, 0.8940425515174866, -1.092212200164795, 0.7790520191192627, -0.5032416582107544, 0.5104736685752869, -0.32796382904052734, 0.208448588848114, -0.7207425236701965, 0.7405125498771667, 0.12543022632598877, 1.1617581844329834, -1.7308562994003296, 0.34099772572517395, 0.45585542917251587, 0.7561346888542175, 0.005589008331298828, 0.9279139041900635, 0.34122395515441895, -0.7531871795654297, 0.48144444823265076, 0.33958297967910767, 0.5325685739517212, -0.20044922828674316, -0.20800049602985382, -0.5007394552230835, -0.2154574692249298, -1.483957290649414, 0.002312789671123028, 0.045425206422805786, 0.02138190157711506, 0.0903782993555069, -0.6365818381309509, 1.0391197204589844, -0.6352320909500122, 0.19696874916553497, 0.4516676962375641, 0.6163500547409058, 0.10532199591398239, -0.8631089925765991, -0.022598760202527046, -0.14567287266254425, -0.1122782826423645, 0.28680768609046936, 0.013523496687412262, -0.18604536354541779, -0.18310366570949554, 0.1320333033800125, -0.1729811131954193, -0.34074604511260986, 0.3612706661224365, -0.5949475169181824, 0.2914540469646454, -0.38681021332740784, 1.0558348894119263, -0.5208640098571777, 0.6234899759292603, -0.5290056467056274, -0.050366923213005066, -0.4346654415130615, -1.0834457874298096, 1.321386456489563, 1.0828982591629028, -0.17609083652496338, -1.1376667022705078, 0.3160184919834137, -0.20695307850837708, -0.17765910923480988, 0.47977691888809204, 0.5886685252189636, -1.2842938899993896, -0.1259123682975769, -0.49347540736198425, 0.08410987257957458, -0.26463454961776733, 0.12527038156986237, -0.22656868398189545, 0.3848346471786499, 0.45450013875961304, 0.09782594442367554, -0.6090438961982727, -0.019119519740343094, -0.05228005349636078, 0.10979185253381729, -1.3109557628631592, 0.3144426643848419, -0.6436213254928589, -1.328249216079712, 0.12591838836669922, 0.3101983964443207, -0.40647652745246887, -0.34987154603004456, -0.5907405018806458, -0.024886416271328926, -0.13567960262298584, 0.8490007519721985, 0.5916077494621277, -0.6282669901847839, 0.7978466153144836, -0.42525118589401245, 0.11852622777223587, 1.1938961744308472, -0.6404515504837036, -0.10499415546655655, -0.12521199882030487, -0.08806296437978745, -0.975475549697876, 0.6029212474822998, 0.21886055171489716, -0.27832770347595215, 0.4338222146034241, -0.1427571326494217, -0.2962420880794525, -1.0377732515335083, -0.3778948187828064, -0.24019667506217957, -0.20130744576454163, -0.13879677653312683, 0.06380826234817505, 0.051417503505945206, -0.3632912039756775, -0.5981934070587158, 0.08725974708795547, 0.8318995833396912, -0.3222329020500183, 0.033594004809856415, 0.29081740975379944, -0.5321657657623291, -0.06060727313160896, -1.031341552734375, 0.14996382594108582, 0.0027966652996838093, 0.30126744508743286, 0.8808435797691345, -0.5413467288017273, -0.2767077088356018, 0.0554041787981987, 0.2922590374946594, -0.5616030097007751, 0.012734439224004745, -0.22732798755168915, -0.6879743337631226, -0.4558729827404022, -0.36657336354255676, -0.46829909086227417, -0.30650362372398376, 0.2308698147535324, -0.03736703470349312, -0.5477380156517029, 0.3281492292881012, -0.1764797419309616, -0.1588100641965866, 0.3480771780014038, -0.6197988986968994, -1.0148956775665283, -0.04656397923827171, 0.5927943587303162, -0.5402979850769043, 0.35090669989585876, -0.3967542350292206, -1.0772672891616821, -0.6831359267234802, -1.5863527059555054, 0.06432051211595535, -1.443466067314148, 0.2854996919631958, -0.2002260982990265, -0.636363685131073, -0.5828275680541992, 0.24042996764183044, 0.9016088843345642, 0.1536475419998169, -0.3851775825023651, -0.14282618463039398, 0.5865290760993958, -0.2922727167606354, -0.42409172654151917, 0.24289512634277344, -0.18077561259269714, 0.0857522115111351, 0.9678808450698853, 0.2182392030954361, -0.43943023681640625, 0.2922232151031494, 0.3142247498035431, -0.059833966195583344, 0.5070242881774902, -0.5893365144729614, -0.25121140480041504, -0.49498364329338074, 0.9775567054748535, 0.12350384145975113, -0.2250329554080963, -0.36836695671081543, 0.742896556854248, -0.5522269606590271, -0.34827548265457153, -0.09914407879114151, -0.02220096066594124, 0.7246673703193665, 0.10702837258577347, 0.42268750071525574, -0.24702855944633484, 0.29960307478904724, -0.28457367420196533, 0.24397337436676025, 0.10517189651727676, -0.5255005955696106, -1.1420753002166748, -0.972374677658081, -0.8351600766181946, -1.1162116527557373, 0.5502132177352905, -0.18462194502353668, 0.6317191123962402, -0.07939215004444122, -0.04240896552801132, -0.2724481225013733, -0.7916135787963867, 0.9115998148918152, 0.5521076917648315, 0.16502772271633148, -0.44330766797065735, 0.8340955972671509, -0.21260322630405426, 0.2150585651397705, 0.49700120091438293, 0.2702678143978119, -0.30687618255615234, -0.11047383397817612, -0.5226141214370728, -0.4297885596752167, -1.2029916048049927, 0.0985632911324501, 0.5482807159423828, 0.267737478017807, -0.13809233903884888, 0.7555720210075378, 0.30074676871299744, 0.30572596192359924, -0.374916672706604, 0.8123359084129333, 0.0948057621717453, -0.2466648370027542, 1.4524754285812378, -0.15005604922771454, -0.5571823716163635, -0.030735597014427185, 0.12853291630744934, -0.46481654047966003, 0.15879717469215393, 0.103621706366539, 0.3988935351371765, -0.15061123669147491, 0.2793811559677124, -0.02657829411327839, -0.3512541651725769, -0.8373668193817139, 0.3058817982673645, -0.3687227666378021, 0.023763364180922508, -0.8174800872802734, -0.16751356422901154, 0.04781385511159897, -0.42528605461120605, 0.5351425409317017, 0.12330290675163269, -0.5204953551292419, 0.3202362358570099, 0.22158782184123993, -0.22275468707084656, -1.4090083837509155, 0.8803978562355042, -0.029982877895236015, -0.012196938507258892, 0.4067326486110687, -0.4087775945663452, 0.006446909625083208, 0.6411587595939636, -0.7888514399528503, 0.27282100915908813, 0.08662544935941696, 0.04557411000132561, 0.2596679627895355, 0.2461875081062317, -0.11203299462795258, -0.4065961241722107, 0.3220245838165283, 0.27261796593666077, 0.40380236506462097, -1.069703221321106, -0.5524841547012329, 0.11974310874938965, 0.8783281445503235, 0.7217519879341125, -0.9977368116378784, -0.3951680064201355, 0.777557909488678, 0.881764829158783, -0.555042564868927, -0.36517637968063354, -0.5431110262870789, -0.9646795988082886, -0.9036849737167358, 0.01716703549027443, -0.14461198449134827, -0.41837984323501587, 0.6055534482002258, -0.7235721945762634, -0.8107709288597107, -0.15411612391471863, 1.4464458227157593, 0.006983213592320681, 0.595825731754303, -0.615938127040863, -0.051558226346969604, -1.0391765832901, 0.13801655173301697, -0.6009144186973572, -0.3506770730018616, -0.48912864923477173, 0.6498501896858215, 0.14696407318115234, 0.3731999397277832, -0.36871668696403503, 0.6181156039237976, 0.15350787341594696, 0.2951391637325287, -0.26404324173927307, -0.07492083311080933, -0.10762833803892136, 0.8379577994346619, -0.43597081303596497, -0.12701435387134552, 0.6380321979522705, -0.18628297746181488, 0.8060815930366516, -0.1311878114938736, 0.7893214821815491, -0.722759485244751, -0.39704370498657227, 0.5317158699035645, -0.5745248198509216, -0.6417842507362366, -0.09560877829790115, 0.6976540684700012, -1.073907494544983, 0.3330879211425781, 0.1381216049194336, 0.26223745942115784, -0.3185846209526062, -0.2741936147212982, 0.481483519077301, 0.5369879007339478, 0.26776736974716187, 0.2211279273033142, -0.012054020538926125, 0.5217214822769165, 0.19413399696350098, 0.4474155008792877, 0.24297645688056946, -0.16684402525424957, 0.01188602950423956, -1.2106637954711914, 0.7670648694038391, -0.5832443237304688, -0.6480055451393127, 0.23563827574253082, -0.9132498502731323, 0.1949598789215088, 0.0804397240281105, -0.30993860960006714, 0.783503532409668, 0.35921692848205566, 0.19805987179279327, 0.35919511318206787, -0.24520273506641388, -0.4457009434700012, -0.5236808061599731, -0.34349459409713745, -1.3098987340927124, -0.5439097881317139, 0.4996570348739624, -0.04875409975647926, 0.0544353611767292, 0.005801677238196135, -0.34844106435775757, 0.48957905173301697, 0.3119939863681793, 0.21309944987297058, 0.002359807025641203, 0.4521251320838928, 0.10345754027366638, 0.4301469624042511, -0.0842534601688385, -0.12131169438362122, 0.007581727113574743, 0.17830730974674225, -0.3528713285923004, -0.06529625505208969, 0.1719072014093399, 0.9333221316337585, 0.6069068312644958, -0.11956445127725601, -0.295804500579834, -0.1819297820329666, 0.4364682137966156, -0.26320573687553406, -0.5417278409004211, 0.03772303834557533, -0.18956685066223145, -0.4604271352291107, -0.08871598541736603, 0.5183321237564087, -0.4578418731689453, 0.39513859152793884, -0.292445570230484, -0.41915425658226013, -0.8858531713485718, 0.598393976688385, 0.34648242592811584, 0.1522362232208252, -0.041165370494127274, -0.05921133980154991, 0.6354583501815796, -0.2593543231487274, -0.08317496627569199, 0.41862356662750244, 0.1788066178560257, 0.6287124752998352, -0.23082832992076874, 0.471354603767395, 0.5084496140480042, 0.9945222735404968, -0.12184222787618637, 0.9416722655296326, 0.3656589388847351, -0.21054424345493317, -0.10154714435338974, 0.10110374540090561, -0.7662161588668823, 0.9747413992881775, -0.46699967980384827, 0.30161404609680176, 0.3010807931423187, 0.3297356963157654, 0.6226860284805298, -0.4507443606853485, 0.1602112352848053, 0.33407554030418396, -0.14139322936534882, -0.6775557398796082, -0.30409690737724304, 1.1859524250030518, 0.2775810658931732, -0.0334559865295887, 0.2780393362045288, -0.039741307497024536, 0.18797671794891357, 0.673875093460083, 0.3151894211769104, 0.8049163818359375, 0.23357239365577698, -0.10530048608779907, -0.0875907838344574, 1.4664009809494019, -0.11693883687257767, 0.6261593699455261, 0.31286945939064026, -0.05256517231464386, -0.5732403993606567, 0.6793609261512756, -0.015951422974467278, 0.031338322907686234, 0.9739012122154236, 0.21897362172603607, -0.030110668390989304, -0.8441879153251648, -0.496525377035141, -0.2232615202665329, -0.3261719048023224, 0.27312174439430237, -0.5596036314964294, -0.16289211809635162, 0.5076963901519775, 0.04150961712002754, 1.0186305046081543, 0.873269259929657, -0.1539650708436966, -1.2375389337539673, 1.3240551948547363, 1.140406847000122, -0.2992095649242401, 0.07115869224071503, -0.49701127409935, -0.010564896278083324, 0.0048572225496172905, -0.7745801210403442, 0.15193668007850647, 0.5318061113357544, 0.13226447999477386, -0.9598106145858765, -0.22666232287883759, -0.10984861850738525, 0.36086300015449524, -0.6957921981811523, 0.41822394728660583, -0.06167195364832878, -0.004398634657263756, 0.009315038099884987, 0.3270775079727173, -0.4569415748119354, -0.30296948552131653, -0.09308762103319168, 0.25906068086624146, -0.6992014050483704, 0.25049322843551636, -0.7063626050949097, 0.41142094135284424, -0.018019985407590866, -0.3850858807563782, -0.6999318599700928, -0.8611111044883728, 0.32670798897743225, -0.23990273475646973, -0.5505609512329102, 0.3278184235095978, 1.064071536064148, 0.528914213180542, 0.16404010355472565, -0.4162176251411438, -0.5486899614334106, 0.013482024893164635, -0.07448237389326096, 1.0308128595352173, -0.44608819484710693, 1.1662447452545166, -0.05116935819387436, 0.06172033026814461, -0.1403154879808426, 0.027473565191030502, 0.7280458807945251, -0.17569561302661896, -0.20329394936561584, 0.1312284916639328, -0.44293785095214844, -0.4262893497943878, -0.918653666973114, 0.3402741253376007, -0.1567966341972351, -0.24887888133525848, -0.05511503294110298, -0.5492527484893799, 0.10438840091228485, -0.605611264705658, 1.6761237382888794, 0.080124631524086, 0.25393104553222656, 0.7914358377456665, -0.2833685874938965, -0.38417404890060425, -0.49921828508377075, 3.851041078567505, 1.2966392040252686, 0.8856554627418518, -0.8314849138259888, 0.7374191284179688, 0.4124490022659302, 1.0231343507766724, 0.6285539269447327, 0.13087260723114014, 0.14438152313232422, -0.4636419713497162, 0.606342077255249, -0.24333932995796204, -0.07241152971982956, 0.15476259589195251, 0.5293586254119873, -0.9928024411201477, 0.1720019429922104, 0.17767556011676788, -0.7825551629066467, -1.209299921989441, 0.753571093082428, 0.33980438113212585, 0.40017256140708923, -0.4310415983200073, 0.15761107206344604, -0.13396386802196503, -0.01165815070271492, -0.8701701760292053, 0.6057694554328918, -0.04113040491938591, -1.4086318016052246, 0.45265695452690125, -0.015969395637512207, -0.4317978620529175, 0.9660342931747437, 0.5344679951667786, 0.13707566261291504, 0.028749074786901474, -0.35095304250717163, -0.10461035370826721, 0.3560408055782318, -0.8374833464622498, -0.051445938646793365, -0.9573180079460144, 0.3593460023403168, 0.2753068804740906, 0.315398633480072, 0.6522801518440247, -0.27861639857292175, 0.7993417978286743, -0.8934024572372437, 0.4426681697368622, 0.14215390384197235, -1.3862849473953247, -0.023153241723775864, -0.9618179798126221, -1.0059434175491333, 0.27480074763298035, -0.12025287002325058, 1.3990147113800049, 0.17370913922786713, -0.275464802980423, 0.016096746549010277, 0.6506516337394714, 0.3967742919921875, -0.08324171602725983, -0.20338036119937897, -0.2510557472705841, -0.4215300977230072, 0.21560224890708923, 0.6055684089660645, -0.4916723370552063, 0.01850075088441372, 0.6578169465065002, 0.28732579946517944, -0.5156913995742798, 0.41303959488868713, -0.09449262171983719, -0.35895422101020813, -0.06171373277902603, -0.006714974530041218, 0.921396017074585, -0.12353431433439255, 0.3082791268825531, 0.5807632803916931, -0.2428455650806427, -0.23072317242622375, -1.2156909704208374, 0.3444105386734009, 0.4373807907104492, 0.152370423078537, 0.25518494844436646, 0.11154109239578247, -0.4517539143562317 ]
{"Title": "Forecasting Seizure Risk over Days", "Authors": "Proix Timoth\u00e9e, Truccolo Wilson, Leguia Marc G., King-Stephens David, Rao Vikram R., Baud Maxime O.", "Abstract": "Abstract For persons with epilepsy, much suffering stems from the apparent unpredictability of seizures. Historically, efforts to predict seizures have sought to detect changes in brain activity in the seconds to minutes preceding seizures (pre-ictal period), a timeframe that limits preventative interventions. Recently, converging evidence from studies using chronic intracranial electroencephalography revealed that brain activity in epilepsy has a robust cyclical structure over hours (circadian) and days (multidien). These cycles organize pro-ictal states, hours-to days-long periods of heightened seizure risk, raising the possibility of forecasting seizures over horizons longer than the pre-ictal period. Here, using cEEG from 18 subjects, we developed point-process generalized linear models incorporating cyclical variables at multiple time-scales to show that seizure risk can be forecasted accurately over days in most subjects. Personalized risk-stratification days in advance of seizures is unprecedented and may enable novel preventative strategies.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19008086"}
10.1101/2019.12.13.19014217
[ 0.246511310338974, 0.47961652278900146, 0.004806272219866514, 0.8618033528327942, -0.8047366738319397, -0.4670436680316925, -0.30714690685272217, -0.04463241249322891, 0.31000062823295593, 0.760287344455719, -0.3565290868282318, -0.36421898007392883, 0.27412861585617065, 0.08065902441740036, -0.41540440917015076, -0.017772752791643143, -0.46125710010528564, 0.07781106233596802, -0.28966236114501953, 0.17345328629016876, -0.3013220727443695, 0.9741333723068237, -0.8509032726287842, 0.20758454501628876, -0.8138812780380249, 0.5952975749969482, -0.18515557050704956, -0.326864093542099, 1.466042160987854, 0.33591777086257935, 0.09145105630159378, -0.770411491394043, 0.6647030711174011, -1.2239911556243896, -0.20712965726852417, -0.33112195134162903, 0.668591320514679, -0.1732221096754074, -0.12360526621341705, -0.4835018217563629, 0.3353635370731354, -0.10193818062543869, 0.2071778029203415, -0.4072182774543762, -0.8449520468711853, -0.7178089022636414, -0.7847947478294373, 0.33196011185646057, -0.3534773886203766, -0.14696696400642395, 0.16863006353378296, 0.71239173412323, 0.2814044654369354, -0.5257589817047119, -0.16148707270622253, 0.38037049770355225, 0.05106379836797714, -0.2104218602180481, -0.5521376729011536, 0.08985500037670135, 0.06514693796634674, -0.1488260179758072, 0.19268515706062317, -1.0784244537353516, 0.4702763557434082, 0.9967210292816162, 0.05079423636198044, -0.03742459416389465, -0.3949761688709259, 0.1900348663330078, -0.34775882959365845, 0.7402775287628174, -0.565650463104248, -0.43362927436828613, 0.15241369605064392, -0.7656248807907104, 0.7802179455757141, 0.20281189680099487, -0.22642123699188232, -0.4008183479309082, -0.17508500814437866, -0.38765543699264526, 0.21903987228870392, 0.24491076171398163, -0.4167914092540741, -0.4133002460002899, -0.19610212743282318, 0.28298038244247437, 0.7127724289894104, -0.17617720365524292, -0.007554988842457533, 0.20600615441799164, 0.05522821471095085, -0.23380284011363983, -0.3598901927471161, 0.48556771874427795, -0.2369406521320343, 0.21553567051887512, 0.22356320917606354, -0.5240507125854492, 0.5839698314666748, 0.37544453144073486, -0.31030744314193726, 0.8557745218276978, -0.3166694939136505, 0.5673652291297913, 0.7919215559959412, -0.27396634221076965, -0.7960432171821594, -0.5000616908073425, 0.2684077024459839, 0.09974267333745956, -0.5660339593887329, 0.23448914289474487, 0.035098087042570114, 0.5393656492233276, -0.37179917097091675, 0.7285134196281433, -0.28222453594207764, 0.11363958567380905, 0.02576744556427002, -0.8328620791435242, 0.49778029322624207, -0.36421650648117065, 0.23757359385490417, -0.08383359014987946, 0.14585117995738983, 0.3036021590232849, -0.13594135642051697, 0.12931227684020996, 0.38837930560112, -0.6566441059112549, -0.5236334800720215, 0.04360131174325943, -0.2296295315027237, 0.28479069471359253, -0.015573656186461449, 0.16544228792190552, -0.09324484318494797, -0.33623865246772766, -0.40239545702934265, 0.2751569151878357, -0.6406393647193909, 1.013084888458252, 0.00287703238427639, 0.8088589310646057, -0.4999397397041321, -0.9196970462799072, -0.1414559930562973, -0.08325230330228806, -0.6033126711845398, 0.30879297852516174, 0.13442836701869965, -0.36961251497268677, 0.13101355731487274, 0.2668437361717224, -0.5589020252227783, 0.8256345391273499, -0.3201875686645508, 0.2181747555732727, -0.8752070069313049, 0.43711739778518677, -0.025310959666967392, 0.8796157240867615, -0.356862872838974, 0.773129403591156, 0.06616919487714767, -0.2334011048078537, 0.25861918926239014, -0.5389122366905212, 0.3685300350189209, -0.013915684074163437, -0.2565804719924927, -0.06789132207632065, 0.3882300555706024, 0.18998919427394867, 1.280411958694458, 0.05692525953054428, 0.14345775544643402, 0.5335113406181335, 0.11511876434087753, 0.03401116654276848, 0.28345787525177, 0.6762698292732239, -0.560504674911499, 0.035219717770814896, -0.6730049252510071, -0.4911702871322632, 0.07159586250782013, -0.17015491425991058, -0.35313522815704346, 0.5810168385505676, -1.0565459728240967, 0.467414915561676, -0.17575809359550476, -0.17539075016975403, -0.5377084612846375, 0.34385257959365845, 0.09055204689502716, -0.22252167761325836, -0.1999977082014084, -0.004905300214886665, -0.5162127017974854, 0.25162237882614136, -0.30868151783943176, 0.7422153353691101, 0.6604018807411194, 0.035190410912036896, -0.9030080437660217, -0.05724315717816353, 0.5775582194328308, -0.09043323248624802, -0.281432181596756, -0.10239231586456299, 0.5135188698768616, -1.2950431108474731, 0.22259198129177094, 0.10772261023521423, -0.3242638111114502, -0.0010244811419397593, 0.410727322101593, -0.30026131868362427, 1.0181087255477905, 0.4211004078388214, 0.2141961008310318, 0.6034961342811584, 0.08802765607833862, 0.07354546338319778, -0.37682488560676575, -0.5387910604476929, 0.0867064893245697, 0.6156561374664307, 0.058786582201719284, 0.6278581023216248, 0.6171576976776123, 0.33646059036254883, 0.2629595398902893, 0.38339051604270935, 0.2618955075740814, 0.3430153429508209, 0.5940688252449036, 0.3020782172679901, 0.44072407484054565, 0.1643933802843094, -0.4404790699481964, 0.7366850972175598, -0.6803514361381531, -0.09661145508289337, -0.9946737885475159, 0.8533532023429871, -0.5916392803192139, 0.34308257699012756, 0.2287604957818985, 0.19925157725811005, -0.14554885029792786, -0.14123141765594482, -0.04473431780934334, 0.5548486709594727, -0.5246284008026123, -0.09625380486249924, 0.20676615834236145, 0.05947744846343994, -0.12639586627483368, -0.10756517946720123, 1.01433527469635, 0.6860824823379517, 0.08610591292381287, 0.46709710359573364, -0.012295091524720192, -0.426237553358078, -0.2017812430858612, -0.5641307830810547, -0.7636033296585083, -0.6796271800994873, -1.0252314805984497, -0.554524302482605, 0.2845655083656311, -0.3672366142272949, 0.6744715571403503, -0.1782144457101822, 0.14294199645519257, -0.5005422830581665, 0.28916558623313904, 0.7940773367881775, 0.6234257817268372, 0.2375665009021759, -1.1690881252288818, -0.08479628711938858, -0.31078892946243286, 0.5106041431427002, -0.114326611161232, 0.06418849527835846, -0.6384997367858887, -0.8328713178634644, 0.34658995270729065, -0.6515843868255615, 0.16496241092681885, -0.3812704384326935, 0.35259416699409485, 0.15842823684215546, -0.07873723655939102, 0.8415225148200989, -0.21759073436260223, -0.09539397805929184, -0.767692506313324, 0.042752861976623535, 0.2565014958381653, 0.3949783742427826, 0.6325227618217468, 0.04712988808751106, -0.45442888140678406, 0.5694593787193298, -0.3407197594642639, 0.2833331227302551, -0.9427436590194702, 0.8687162399291992, 0.6676892638206482, 0.5348419547080994, 0.41660216450691223, -0.5160166621208191, -1.12109375, 0.10056279599666595, -0.1206204816699028, -0.5751969218254089, -0.258187472820282, 0.4068867266178131, -0.3500201106071472, -0.9595212936401367, 0.09137430042028427, -0.34286102652549744, -1.3228424787521362, -0.24775101244449615, -0.27594277262687683, 0.1116485595703125, 0.17671506106853485, -0.048723362386226654, -0.29091814160346985, -0.5397913455963135, -0.3603810667991638, 0.17112872004508972, 0.16853216290473938, -0.3038853108882904, 0.07147424668073654, 0.1942673772573471, 0.1763857752084732, 0.6413387060165405, 0.9247965216636658, -0.5995734930038452, -0.05829192325472832, 0.08823194354772568, -0.31015047430992126, 0.22273880243301392, 0.5437129735946655, 0.030838752165436745, 0.19906410574913025, 0.16834114491939545, -0.07702374458312988, 0.11289609968662262, 0.1811283975839615, 0.11403747648000717, -0.3986924886703491, 0.49042513966560364, 0.17179743945598602, 0.11873997747898102, -0.695132315158844, -0.7516384124755859, -0.1363355666399002, -0.19056324660778046, 0.8558064699172974, -1.3150485754013062, 0.49248430132865906, 0.35569483041763306, 0.2913649082183838, 0.20808646082878113, -0.21558459103107452, -0.04900314658880234, 1.1044358015060425, -0.0012424562592059374, 0.8789965510368347, -1.2012780904769897, -0.530242919921875, 0.6789066195487976, 0.9686647653579712, 0.177311509847641, -0.06684175878763199, 0.3658049702644348, -0.8312415480613708, 0.5779374837875366, -0.10170949250459671, -0.03274112567305565, 0.5882154107093811, -0.09663131833076477, 0.15950921177864075, 0.8873803019523621, -0.16151733696460724, -0.40781307220458984, -0.5643160939216614, 0.18045514822006226, -0.31302836537361145, -0.2852029800415039, 1.1745203733444214, -0.025775201618671417, 0.5860294699668884, 0.03677181154489517, 1.1161885261535645, 0.009922590106725693, -0.1817261427640915, -0.03976032882928848, 0.2463529407978058, -0.010884597897529602, -0.18888027966022491, 0.296235054731369, -0.23782284557819366, 0.2642100751399994, 0.5515586733818054, -0.3653836250305176, -0.600581705570221, 0.11137741059064865, -0.4090997874736786, -0.8693771958351135, -0.38552626967430115, -0.12302317470312119, -0.4087073504924774, -0.2646383047103882, 0.8650785684585571, -0.5476354956626892, 0.35183030366897583, -0.13203740119934082, 0.4517139196395874, 0.9339661002159119, 0.13520555198192596, -0.35134515166282654, -0.3108830153942108, 0.15216563642024994, -0.2576163113117218, 0.36337199807167053, 0.5354805588722229, 0.09232980757951736, 0.26889917254447937, -0.3064591884613037, -0.19068776071071625, -0.77311772108078, 0.020777439698576927, -0.23303066194057465, -0.21187713742256165, 0.23288622498512268, 0.7492120862007141, 0.003467197995632887, 0.7737172245979309, -0.17168286442756653, 0.5478582382202148, -0.7458527088165283, 0.25245776772499084, -0.6932791471481323, -0.6198994517326355, -0.040776681154966354, 0.1406286209821701, -0.054581739008426666, 0.38575229048728943, -0.21697187423706055, -0.3792533874511719, 0.0740991085767746, 0.5764545798301697, -0.8298571109771729, -0.05008244514465332, 0.9758414626121521, 0.0206795334815979, 0.25708961486816406, 0.9962924122810364, 0.21929948031902313, -0.02418874017894268, 0.5536335706710815, 0.17725175619125366, -0.7777538299560547, 0.19857273995876312, -0.11271585524082184, -0.020653173327445984, 0.514625608921051, -0.15196332335472107, -0.6449058651924133, -0.15947268903255463, 0.26668792963027954, 0.06284331530332565, -0.34746792912483215, -0.47968459129333496, -0.27317431569099426, -0.21098239719867706, -0.9362831115722656, -0.5616954565048218, 0.4295010566711426, 0.28883257508277893, -0.08894575387239456, 0.37748396396636963, 0.42914265394210815, -0.804455578327179, -0.2577967047691345, -0.7787438631057739, 0.09055585414171219, -0.06896878033876419, 0.12472400069236755, 1.0823360681533813, -0.9900871515274048, -0.4996366798877716, 0.8809276819229126, -0.08305657655000687, -0.7574144601821899, -0.38354939222335815, -0.4854127764701843, -0.21003840863704681, -0.6067736744880676, -0.11684546619653702, 0.2551155686378479, -0.8060210943222046, -0.7237315773963928, 0.15315371751785278, -0.334237664937973, 0.6662508845329285, -0.3691942095756531, -0.4558645188808441, 0.7970373630523682, -0.2583308815956116, -0.5744965672492981, -0.29298335313796997, 0.23504877090454102, 0.4667506814002991, 0.8396965861320496, 0.3389512002468109, -0.7682632207870483, -0.030699605122208595, -0.43130961060523987, -0.021295985206961632, -1.0328171253204346, 0.5772587656974792, -0.32250797748565674, 0.3485052287578583, 0.23221571743488312, 0.05241265892982483, 0.48647117614746094, -0.4654025435447693, 0.18135683238506317, -0.19049200415611267, 0.2652472257614136, -0.05306253582239151, -0.09800838679075241, 0.44175663590431213, -0.6634219884872437, 0.2734973430633545, 1.0804998874664307, 0.33052748441696167, -0.6781764626502991, -0.2567366361618042, 0.2922530770301819, 0.19299238920211792, 1.1008409261703491, -0.2545586824417114, -0.8782526850700378, 0.1210835799574852, 0.707007884979248, -0.458746999502182, -0.21763260662555695, -1.1296523809432983, 0.24459300935268402, -0.11421673744916916, 0.37536337971687317, -0.8698827028274536, -0.41284018754959106, -0.4886728823184967, -0.35857170820236206, 0.760554313659668, -0.08295107632875443, 0.45194995403289795, 0.11690674722194672, 0.15400369465351105, 0.2837928831577301, 0.6761104464530945, -0.08139193058013916, -0.3277006447315216, -0.5841494202613831, -0.848149836063385, 0.6921217441558838, 0.15413430333137512, 0.4162094295024872, 0.7426903247833252, 0.004819110035896301, 0.31067609786987305, -1.072854995727539, 0.9552281498908997, 0.33200472593307495, -1.0678447484970093, -0.6572126746177673, -0.14636437594890594, 0.6271547079086304, 0.29949355125427246, 0.11303266882896423, -0.36083585023880005, 0.09646192938089371, 0.22711850702762604, -0.0336117185652256, -0.14691606163978577, -1.0452953577041626, -0.6415377259254456, 0.23164771497249603, 0.7979111671447754, 0.10679851472377777, 0.41237059235572815, -0.4394671320915222, -0.18085859715938568, -0.9163563847541809, 1.0840781927108765, -0.08687169849872589, 0.28305110335350037, 0.8890968561172485, -0.1306428611278534, -0.6856722831726074, 0.3129056692123413, -0.42703577876091003, -0.28952181339263916, -0.26416388154029846, 0.8484984040260315, -0.06366278976202011, -0.7026301622390747, 0.11941291391849518, 0.9102488160133362, -0.24194645881652832, -1.2929480075836182, -0.49719953536987305, -0.34175753593444824, -0.24493587017059326, -0.17762808501720428, -0.48908910155296326, 0.39548036456108093, -0.986922562122345, -0.061719924211502075, -0.0217178612947464, 0.2166164666414261, 0.4740239381790161, -0.021289533004164696, -0.2893672287464142, -0.6253697872161865, -0.2728322148323059, 0.32448098063468933, 0.3804241716861725, 0.8520029783248901, 0.0926191508769989, 0.23990973830223083, 0.05890081450343132, -0.2198449671268463, 0.5675870180130005, -0.6368764638900757, -0.07060355693101883, -0.016977565363049507, 0.33327487111091614, 0.3471396863460541, -0.21598108112812042, 0.0181344635784626, 0.7314722537994385, 0.452281653881073, 0.24253755807876587, 0.2770555019378662, 0.35565367341041565, 0.8867234587669373, 0.5148583054542542, -0.5812161564826965, -0.5199635624885559, 0.5884078741073608, 0.4406445622444153, 0.13913282752037048, -0.6782834529876709, -0.389297753572464, -0.578308641910553, -0.16014209389686584, 0.3087720274925232, -1.2231664657592773, -0.14155013859272003, 0.5870689153671265, -1.2611063718795776, -0.3206959664821625, -0.9130376577377319, 0.523378312587738, -0.1170181930065155, -0.7087076306343079, -0.851905107498169, -0.05759511515498161, -0.7655994296073914, -0.02623404935002327, -0.5899816751480103, -1.2813349962234497, 0.24726766347885132, 0.638174295425415, -0.706159770488739, -0.43858084082603455, 0.3754022419452667, 0.09711506962776184, 0.04609180614352226, 0.5333197712898254, -0.3846380412578583, -1.2426308393478394, -0.2651432752609253, 0.9490418434143066, -0.4555734395980835, 0.1213827058672905, 0.970898449420929, -0.4458823502063751, 0.5173559188842773, 0.582059383392334, -0.37488189339637756, -0.37739384174346924, 0.36151641607284546, 0.1884911060333252, -1.0255520343780518, -0.5711290836334229, -0.6046492457389832, 0.3964666426181793, -1.255346417427063, -1.028525710105896, -0.6839598417282104, 0.1464117020368576, 0.12966451048851013, -0.18846505880355835, -0.5319533944129944, 0.5171450972557068, 0.42297711968421936, -0.13083910942077637, 0.31315600872039795, 0.5533085465431213, 0.7441022992134094, 0.08956422656774521, 0.5059406161308289, -0.48502883315086365, 0.44977810978889465, -0.3281155824661255, 0.7252868413925171, 0.5003872513771057, -0.07474982738494873, 0.40707486867904663, 0.1327441781759262, 0.608802855014801, 0.039605118334293365, -0.03973529860377312, 0.2864662706851959, 0.6474543809890747, 0.4974319040775299, -0.16587446630001068, 0.2675502300262451, -0.537874698638916, -0.17475584149360657, -1.2854444980621338, -0.7372890710830688, -0.6519331932067871, 0.6591890454292297, -0.5879822969436646, 0.23756444454193115, -0.02022251859307289, -0.6802147030830383, 0.40089869499206543, 0.5951961874961853, -0.22876018285751343, -0.5318300127983093, 0.3342891335487366, 0.11835584044456482, 0.4820623993873596, -0.2033023238182068, 0.24842724204063416, 0.010632479563355446, -0.17794175446033478, -0.24102924764156342, -0.2567718029022217, 0.10421012341976166, 0.3077261745929718, 0.004773973487317562, -0.464015394449234, -0.24906040728092194, 0.5748140215873718, 0.12629278004169464, -0.23023530840873718, -0.7309034466743469, 0.367997944355011, -0.6616607904434204, 0.18301226198673248, -0.7544324994087219, 0.007496512029320002, -0.09670349955558777, 0.2993313670158386, 0.4660407304763794, -0.4404424726963043, -0.22007323801517487, -0.22423310577869415, 0.9072172045707703, -0.04475340247154236, -0.2677004039287567, -0.002392503898590803, 0.21748735010623932, -0.7618454694747925, -0.011873701587319374, 0.6049253344535828, 0.5449129939079285, 0.3746432960033417, 0.609336793422699, 0.48907408118247986, 0.6794639825820923, 0.6050568222999573, 0.08538932353258133, 0.2818604111671448, -0.08823776245117188, -0.4634456932544708, -0.1943279206752777, 0.4577735364437103, 0.03147498518228531, 0.22878208756446838, 0.4899834394454956, -0.12165085226297379, 0.2157018482685089, 0.17694009840488434, 0.02040489949285984, -0.6174184083938599, -0.11128360033035278, 0.33754292130470276, -0.7238151431083679, -0.4312340021133423, 0.3622431457042694, 0.8308048248291016, 0.8723353147506714, 0.39423853158950806, -0.33200904726982117, -0.22397179901599884, 0.5850147604942322, -0.07257983088493347, -0.27332034707069397, 0.5498669743537903, -0.3685896396636963, -0.5295996069908142, -0.3825349807739258, 0.22435042262077332, -0.2425583004951477, 0.36522093415260315, 0.5468061566352844, 0.3584900200366974, -0.22197994589805603, 0.5292260050773621, 0.19331133365631104, -0.12446409463882446, 0.3595207631587982, -0.47209134697914124, -0.020889047533273697, 0.03788446635007858, 0.428554505109787, -0.5475925207138062, -0.05206960439682007, 0.5439558625221252, -0.9610103368759155, 0.35743439197540283, 0.04317443072795868, 0.3129771053791046, 0.39364925026893616, 0.16262590885162354, 0.6055030822753906, -0.7176613807678223, 0.29348233342170715, 0.9354314804077148, 0.587971031665802, 0.23750929534435272, 0.30276980996131897, -0.2399340122938156, -0.7324473857879639, -0.013717934489250183, 0.06545782089233398, 0.4242202043533325, -0.1463417112827301, -0.400516539812088, -0.024221191182732582, 0.06138818711042404, 0.25842881202697754, -1.0352908372879028, 0.2392321527004242, -0.08223650604486465, 0.08930207788944244, -0.3674081563949585, 1.0601866245269775, 0.13744406402111053, -0.020147880539298058, -0.501618504524231, 0.016252147033810616, -0.4270303547382355, -0.24675507843494415, -0.24134522676467896, 0.4158095121383667, -0.2813462018966675, -0.2860092222690582, -0.41792070865631104, -0.8392162322998047, 0.31365087628364563, -0.9817949533462524, -0.5858734250068665, -0.915692925453186, 0.3178890645503998, 0.22151495516300201, 0.7463035583496094, 0.6827360987663269, -0.22838976979255676, 0.04450368136167526, -0.06282588094472885, 0.5067507028579712, -0.4333457350730896, 0.2870253324508667, -0.2677021920681, -0.34652769565582275, 0.8716915249824524, 0.5929434895515442, 0.5115807056427002, -0.5795777440071106, -0.03313964605331421, -0.4964190125465393, 0.2819216549396515, -0.05051979050040245, -0.6277459859848022, -0.0018259149510413408, 0.7313998341560364, -0.31530430912971497, -0.6455602645874023, -0.6448332071304321, -0.9666671752929688, -0.16198478639125824, 0.4309612810611725, -0.010586216114461422, -0.39937618374824524, 0.6704919338226318, -0.19052721560001373, 0.7606635093688965, -0.9643200039863586, 4.319603443145752, 0.9822900891304016, 0.20052160322666168, -0.7417922019958496, 0.23127517104148865, 0.21137559413909912, 0.3722725510597229, -0.8964675664901733, -0.054450757801532745, 0.7879282236099243, -0.6087929010391235, 0.242617666721344, 0.0417560338973999, -0.3325214087963104, 1.0423604249954224, 0.3126150667667389, -0.6081779599189758, 0.028188325464725494, 0.1415368914604187, -0.6825384497642517, -0.11960242688655853, 0.42909276485443115, -0.3665354549884796, -0.10408744215965271, 0.7169017195701599, 0.17703811824321747, -0.0198629479855299, 0.16326074302196503, -0.32647594809532166, 0.5024052858352661, 0.11647028475999832, -0.044012244790792465, 0.7761383652687073, -0.07204481959342957, -0.6577311158180237, 0.7553333640098572, -0.16401617228984833, -0.43497931957244873, 0.07757803797721863, 0.029494771733880043, 0.5124345421791077, -0.12701934576034546, -0.6153513789176941, -0.4301072061061859, -0.5090745091438293, -0.02845911681652069, 0.04480842500925064, 0.07197362929582596, 0.3800109624862671, -0.33074814081192017, 0.5692732334136963, -0.0706380158662796, 0.06756290048360825, -0.031476642936468124, -1.2484722137451172, 0.16708631813526154, 0.03837594762444496, -0.8681540489196777, 0.3868391215801239, 0.5409399271011353, 0.778425931930542, 0.04254056140780449, -0.2783435881137848, -0.2844477593898773, 0.43626710772514343, 0.613308310508728, 0.23206602036952972, 0.30143600702285767, -0.529021680355072, -0.8061608076095581, 0.008966824039816856, -0.1697007715702057, -0.4305568039417267, 0.13173040747642517, 0.69516521692276, 0.43149203062057495, -0.5884091854095459, 0.2685430943965912, 0.034196943044662476, -0.6391801834106445, 0.4266500771045685, 0.008829059079289436, -0.100931815803051, -0.5759783983230591, 0.14880749583244324, 0.8772563338279724, -0.2713654935359955, 0.14545242488384247, -1.2424365282058716, 0.5511748194694519, 0.2116023153066635, -0.30869054794311523, -0.22158244252204895, 0.07930169999599457, -0.17985820770263672 ]
{"Title": "Cerebrospinal fluid and plasma biomarkers in individuals at risk for genetic prion disease", "Authors": "Vallabh Sonia M, Minikel Eric Vallabh, Williams Victoria J, Carlyle Becky C, McManus Alison J, Wennick Chase D, Bolling Anna, Trombetta Bianca A, Urick David, Nobuhara Chloe K, Gerber Jessica, Duddy Holly, Lachmann Ingolf, Stehmann Christiane, Collins Steven J, Blennow Kaj, Zetterberg Henrik, Arnold Steven E", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT BACKGROUND Fluid biomarkers are important in the development of therapeutics to delay or prevent prion disease, but have not been systematically evaluated in pre-symptomatic individuals at risk for genetic prion disease. METHODS We recruited pre-symptomatic individuals with pathogenic mutations in the prion protein gene ( PRNP ; N=27) and matched controls (N=16), to donate cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and blood at multiple timepoints to a cohort study at Massachusetts General Hospital. We quantified total prion protein (PrP) and real-time quaking-induced conversion (RT-QuIC) prion seeding activity in CSF, and the neuronal damage markers total tau (T-tau) and neurofilament light chain (NfL) in both CSF and plasma. We compared these markers cross-sectionally between mutation carriers and controls, evaluated short-term test-retest reliability over 2-4 months, and conducted a pilot longitudinal study over 10-20 months for a subset of participants. FINDINGS CSF PrP levels were stable on test-retest with a mean coefficient of variation of 7% both over 2-4 months in N=29 participants and over 10-20 months in N=10 participants. RT-QuIC was negative in 22/23 mutation carriers. The sole individual with positive RT-QuIC seeding activity at two study visits had steady CSF PrP levels and slightly increased tau and NfL concentrations compared with others, though still within the normal range, and remained asymptomatic one year later. Overall, tau and NfL showed no significant differences between mutation carriers and controls in either CSF or plasma. INTERPRETATION CSF PrP will be interpretable as a pharmacodynamic readout of the effects of a PrP-lowering therapeutic in pre-symptomatic individuals, and may serve as a surrogate biomarker in a \u201cprimary prevention\u201d trial paradigm. In contrast, current markers of prion seeding activity and of neuronal damage do not reliably cross-sectionally distinguish mutation carriers from controls, arguing against the feasibility of a \u201csecondary prevention\u201d paradigm in which trials specifically recruit pre-symptomatic participants with prodromal evidence of pathology.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/2019.12.13.19014217"}
10.1101/19010421
[ -0.25773555040359497, 1.1589943170547485, -0.8486274480819702, 0.9204161763191223, -0.3919373154640198, -0.27613645792007446, 0.15942800045013428, 0.2260628342628479, 0.16880248486995697, 0.5458418726921082, -1.1789298057556152, 0.010549318976700306, -0.12396249175071716, -1.5454192161560059, -0.0017921746475622058, 0.3738572895526886, -0.6299980282783508, -0.2463947981595993, -0.7485868334770203, 0.23268632590770721, 0.43538030982017517, -0.1305478811264038, -0.12954844534397125, -0.5857667922973633, -0.19361612200737, 0.6354105472564697, -0.05277899652719498, -0.5790577530860901, 0.9643321633338928, 0.2503066658973694, 0.5173429250717163, -0.2914316654205322, 0.4975351393222809, -0.5137180685997009, -0.030260860919952393, -0.5429757237434387, 0.5637917518615723, -0.36359700560569763, -0.2774718701839447, -0.13863100111484528, 0.19185855984687805, 0.30082228779792786, -0.24435247480869293, -0.3306076228618622, -0.786515474319458, -0.5810896158218384, -0.655690610408783, -0.7971001863479614, -0.2558819651603699, -0.6398966312408447, -0.2597758173942566, 0.05151830613613129, -0.414201557636261, -0.047595612704753876, -0.4027338922023773, -0.09254557639360428, 0.04291319474577904, -0.11062987148761749, -0.1889234334230423, 0.264988511800766, 0.7011516094207764, -0.0671263113617897, 0.23621438443660736, -1.9218828678131104, 0.31903305649757385, 0.35040292143821716, 0.04427943751215935, 0.25774917006492615, -0.15074597299098969, -0.3678913414478302, -1.0662821531295776, -0.08527837693691254, 0.3637424409389496, -0.6031747460365295, -0.40838611125946045, 0.7705937027931213, -0.02179841697216034, 0.06633194535970688, 0.00469977455213666, -0.8397713303565979, -0.022350933402776718, -0.20537321269512177, -0.44490981101989746, 0.04560299217700958, -0.35684072971343994, -0.1920788288116455, -0.2715337574481964, -0.29317334294319153, 0.8676543235778809, -0.31899386644363403, 0.27649953961372375, 0.25241705775260925, -0.2967758774757385, 0.5258141756057739, -0.0807245671749115, 0.26994842290878296, -0.2515653073787689, -0.1205047219991684, 0.3699873685836792, -0.30923226475715637, 0.3363524377346039, 0.5988839268684387, -0.559199333190918, 0.9920728206634521, -0.5700294971466064, -0.14598053693771362, 0.29424402117729187, -0.377504825592041, -0.09226640313863754, -0.9948076605796814, -0.4505753815174103, 0.2676119804382324, -0.11780398339033127, 0.6037129163742065, 0.013106576167047024, 0.2808897793292999, 0.19292104244232178, 0.2348145842552185, -0.3298560380935669, 0.5855942368507385, 0.21366068720817566, -0.05828843638300896, 0.24862250685691833, -0.24776047468185425, 0.41796040534973145, -0.31390202045440674, 0.1718107908964157, 0.10486981272697449, 0.08389592915773392, 0.39776673913002014, 0.3273000419139862, 0.16387122869491577, 0.12645207345485687, 0.14261570572853088, -0.10872282832860947, 0.3632400929927826, -0.8030175566673279, 0.9458550810813904, 0.1942492127418518, -0.3700086772441864, -0.8699027895927429, 0.6767531037330627, -0.4611795246601105, 1.1084043979644775, -0.1905050277709961, 0.6718651652336121, -0.023187747225165367, -0.9795920848846436, -0.02192278765141964, -0.1316869556903839, -0.3014751374721527, 0.8748263716697693, -0.4375190734863281, -0.17598643898963928, 0.10318615287542343, -0.1649179458618164, -0.1456604301929474, 0.7598942518234253, -0.030840124934911728, 0.7004691958427429, 0.03334183990955353, 0.13204723596572876, -0.11881741881370544, 0.3148246109485626, -0.7394294142723083, 1.1533223390579224, -0.1920393705368042, -0.27226588129997253, 0.565635621547699, -0.34271153807640076, 0.25414901971817017, 0.29359734058380127, 0.48668065667152405, -0.5563246607780457, -0.003940818831324577, 0.8829562067985535, 0.8020697236061096, 0.5094502568244934, -0.006656851153820753, 0.43948715925216675, -0.13408170640468597, -0.08429930359125137, 0.5401573181152344, 0.5966204404830933, -0.020857086405158043, -0.44331005215644836, -0.6633456349372864, -0.9920157790184021, 0.12941746413707733, 0.43733492493629456, -0.20194466412067413, 1.3720060586929321, -0.7465771436691284, 0.21588903665542603, -0.4613082706928253, -0.1207597628235817, 0.02984604611992836, 0.4178684949874878, -0.1176309734582901, -0.38867977261543274, -1.0034019947052002, 0.5840293169021606, -0.8318324685096741, 0.18059340119361877, -1.0994431972503662, 0.25858181715011597, 0.6857216954231262, 0.4768580198287964, 0.0051388218998909, 0.5924303531646729, 0.8614153265953064, -0.2534063458442688, 0.1508009135723114, 0.17660507559776306, 0.6012473702430725, -0.2905251383781433, 0.4395163357257843, 0.5501879453659058, -0.4512197971343994, 0.33936193585395813, -0.11088897287845612, -0.007638938259333372, 0.6859440803527832, 0.2001827359199524, 0.7807197570800781, 0.17353112995624542, 0.8116363286972046, -0.12941205501556396, 0.07964878529310226, -0.03686060756444931, 0.4375910460948944, 0.7173250317573547, 0.377666175365448, 0.2769492268562317, 1.5424232482910156, 0.5308541059494019, -0.21902094781398773, 0.47221848368644714, 1.0425420999526978, 0.09948062151670456, 0.8307294845581055, 0.5152691602706909, 0.8398895263671875, 0.0860266387462616, -0.21375837922096252, 0.49853113293647766, -0.7470225095748901, -0.16976718604564667, 0.030686574056744576, -0.2848620116710663, -0.9280357360839844, 0.6769862174987793, 0.21162469685077667, -0.09422506392002106, -0.37252193689346313, 0.26285380125045776, 0.9667477011680603, 0.22994667291641235, -0.2592681050300598, -0.8026435971260071, 0.22676657140254974, 0.09866746515035629, 0.08089643716812134, -0.6512088775634766, 0.43205228447914124, 0.47941648960113525, 0.17864635586738586, 0.5111660361289978, 0.393743097782135, -0.2541355490684509, -0.8514484167098999, -0.5787201523780823, -1.1692159175872803, -0.5241775512695312, -0.6683759093284607, -0.919148325920105, -0.02057964727282524, -0.3019004464149475, 0.8245360255241394, -0.31458619236946106, 0.0733143761754036, -1.2504642009735107, 0.3084242641925812, 0.46333497762680054, -0.11109756678342819, 0.1510520726442337, -1.0844885110855103, 0.4308604896068573, -0.5350061655044556, 0.4028327465057373, -0.16283395886421204, -0.6356177926063538, -0.2539118826389313, -0.05186602100729942, -0.18054333329200745, -0.15750107169151306, -0.23462440073490143, 0.03229130059480667, -0.5807688236236572, -0.37381452322006226, 0.39393526315689087, 0.17767277359962463, 0.050515446811914444, 0.06279993057250977, -1.214776635169983, 1.2871419191360474, 0.25175926089286804, -0.37218886613845825, 0.8327540159225464, 0.5494767427444458, -0.549423336982727, 0.8682131767272949, 0.2184647172689438, -0.2941265106201172, -0.5827081203460693, 0.582284152507782, 0.6237752437591553, -0.0780860185623169, 0.0031070171389728785, -0.04149485006928444, -0.5303667187690735, 0.049735091626644135, 0.27137747406959534, -0.5118074417114258, 0.4211331605911255, 0.3223543167114258, -0.042692430317401886, -0.7734479308128357, -0.2705551087856293, -0.7874978184700012, -1.258211374282837, 0.30267518758773804, -0.37643542885780334, 0.6398105025291443, 0.48375335335731506, -0.368898868560791, -0.0023664161562919617, -0.16425587236881256, -0.02366296574473381, 0.23658211529254913, 0.27393725514411926, 0.1838189959526062, -0.2885553538799286, 0.0824960246682167, -0.23388011753559113, 0.4043214023113251, -0.027704253792762756, -0.4285500645637512, 0.029899589717388153, 0.0003528992529027164, -0.7899928092956543, 0.3238677680492401, 0.0070085651241242886, -0.15216968953609467, 0.0474393367767334, 0.16838575899600983, -0.3894692659378052, 0.09522896260023117, -0.17986136674880981, 0.716792643070221, -0.11354672908782959, 0.03699222579598427, -0.3566577136516571, 0.17105211317539215, -0.3749145567417145, -0.16573581099510193, 0.30510613322257996, 1.0577857494354248, 0.7125439047813416, -0.2129056751728058, 0.5297403931617737, 0.15928319096565247, -0.042713478207588196, -0.6454220414161682, -0.1601279079914093, -0.6377931833267212, 0.6732779145240784, 0.3370363414287567, 1.0144022703170776, -0.8062316179275513, 0.23508504033088684, 0.45066696405410767, 0.8405528664588928, -0.30620643496513367, 0.6032172441482544, -0.2680196762084961, -0.6266463994979858, -0.4641932249069214, 0.11330603063106537, -0.05049261823296547, -0.43015530705451965, 0.14382638037204742, 0.16285833716392517, -0.15132594108581543, -0.9539682269096375, 0.12921951711177826, -0.06055218353867531, 0.7073124647140503, -0.39631474018096924, -0.1328921914100647, 0.49239248037338257, 0.2393159717321396, 0.148926243185997, 0.721339225769043, -0.06377453356981277, -0.32784900069236755, -0.9743093252182007, -0.04625770449638367, -0.07245375961065292, 0.10235912352800369, 0.010391135700047016, -0.6831547021865845, -0.6299424171447754, -0.21397173404693604, 0.35443025827407837, 0.4008944630622864, -0.5381521582603455, 0.24366693198680878, -0.4401804208755493, 0.6198821067810059, 0.8317740559577942, -0.1724991500377655, -1.018559217453003, 0.4104548692703247, 0.8820418119430542, 0.011307930573821068, -0.533001720905304, -0.6216943264007568, 0.5014705061912537, 0.5392099022865295, -0.13008713722229004, -0.20965676009655, 0.40565699338912964, -0.4189645051956177, -0.5130085349082947, 0.573043704032898, -0.02081928960978985, -0.38270020484924316, -0.5884355902671814, -0.02521815150976181, -0.09218589961528778, -0.8355219960212708, -0.41325464844703674, -0.47557511925697327, -0.29719027876853943, -0.17311422526836395, 0.5311309099197388, 0.24310265481472015, 0.9033024907112122, 0.21767456829547882, 1.2038795948028564, -0.6758261919021606, 0.7893784642219543, -0.30252960324287415, -0.3571324944496155, -1.1832159757614136, -0.13126692175865173, -0.11620990931987762, 0.46700847148895264, -0.7787762880325317, -0.3324246108531952, -0.48617321252822876, 0.4171764850616455, -0.13942034542560577, 0.1926926225423813, 0.4946310222148895, -0.4419608414173126, 0.04457293450832367, 0.8640866279602051, -0.33945581316947937, -0.2282463163137436, -0.3252294361591339, 0.07290159165859222, -0.5706924200057983, -0.611605703830719, -0.18661491572856903, -0.2971741855144501, -0.050971973687410355, -0.30698108673095703, 0.27707505226135254, -0.8370485901832581, -0.09653865545988083, -0.0080784996971488, 0.13360127806663513, 0.0038820558693259954, -0.2961054742336273, -0.46058985590934753, -0.22775506973266602, -0.19637873768806458, -0.06143007054924965, 0.5494917631149292, -0.17820192873477936, 0.6008704304695129, -0.4938322901725769, -0.4370133578777313, 0.2822905480861664, -1.307977557182312, 0.4738248288631439, 0.10339662432670593, -0.01925387606024742, 0.722714364528656, -1.2275534868240356, -0.5571392178535461, 0.366918683052063, 0.5577324628829956, -0.8178438544273376, -0.2750120162963867, -0.6505169868469238, -0.12342776358127594, -0.23536109924316406, -0.7014911770820618, 0.35133928060531616, -0.7018449306488037, 0.53852379322052, 0.012530628591775894, 0.06648772209882736, 0.2916737198829651, 0.019377417862415314, -0.441936194896698, 0.36478346586227417, -0.667283833026886, -1.024317979812622, -0.5099954009056091, 0.41074156761169434, 0.047248922288417816, 0.20147737860679626, 0.002980635967105627, -0.1755138486623764, -0.06385257840156555, -1.2153798341751099, 0.5093552470207214, -0.8733235597610474, -0.20791181921958923, -0.1492868959903717, -0.5613375902175903, -0.18852749466896057, -0.33389657735824585, -0.1385762244462967, -0.4917502999305725, -0.20370927453041077, -0.4367314577102661, 0.5569190979003906, -0.31030356884002686, -0.34869325160980225, 0.11012377589941025, -0.3912658393383026, 0.4068818688392639, 1.3884459733963013, 0.7966296076774597, -0.1499125361442566, 0.8756540417671204, -0.3341212272644043, 0.33326879143714905, 0.177467480301857, -0.3310098350048065, -0.3339401185512543, 0.7850030660629272, 0.18846744298934937, 0.049388542771339417, -0.25704485177993774, 0.10955754667520523, 0.10596434772014618, -0.31475570797920227, 0.3577824831008911, 0.13358837366104126, 0.01359892450273037, -0.06680496782064438, -1.0720915794372559, 0.10783607512712479, -0.6278810501098633, 0.17370861768722534, 0.507821261882782, -0.20721027255058289, -0.3369252383708954, 0.06097954511642456, -0.8221195340156555, -0.1574486494064331, -0.4380306005477905, -0.858901858329773, 0.3873595893383026, -0.03850821778178215, -0.13972114026546478, 0.3194812536239624, 0.151032492518425, 0.07258246839046478, -0.561818540096283, 1.0411183834075928, 1.1789697408676147, -0.3994618058204651, -0.13192135095596313, 0.1935126632452011, -0.16497531533241272, 0.10719960927963257, 0.34074658155441284, 0.322335422039032, -0.25412631034851074, -0.14013716578483582, -0.04195963963866234, -0.5166101455688477, -0.8416059017181396, 0.27563557028770447, 0.726762056350708, 0.13545355200767517, -0.06165826693177223, 0.7730597853660583, 0.427707314491272, 0.051185403019189835, -0.6792818903923035, 0.688834547996521, -0.42031601071357727, 0.36825671792030334, 0.5228601694107056, -0.3243336081504822, -0.506657600402832, 0.28668972849845886, -0.4490068852901459, -0.12838442623615265, 0.4474596679210663, 0.4610265791416168, 0.7045638561248779, -0.8388143181800842, 0.333565354347229, 0.06396689265966415, -0.15920348465442657, -1.1040782928466797, 0.17720644176006317, -0.23048584163188934, 0.22108617424964905, -0.1779637187719345, -0.3962092995643616, 0.9176955223083496, -0.2066638022661209, 0.05025980994105339, 0.2020110934972763, 0.3061721622943878, 0.06181836128234863, -0.006745459977537394, -0.025081878527998924, -0.7850674986839294, 0.2701810598373413, 0.4397014081478119, -0.2284194976091385, 0.21969729661941528, -0.1368425339460373, 0.14053532481193542, 0.04853632673621178, -0.2709081470966339, 0.5443905591964722, -0.7105346322059631, 0.1321963518857956, -0.04361964017152786, 0.6343383193016052, -0.5801998972892761, -0.45591485500335693, 0.17710436880588531, 0.7654740214347839, 0.1895824819803238, -0.25520840287208557, -0.790921151638031, 0.40424644947052, 0.23275406658649445, 0.46901094913482666, -0.22358126938343048, -0.3775518834590912, 0.7342827320098877, 0.9098076224327087, -0.5783765316009521, -0.23773522675037384, -1.199409008026123, -0.6420133113861084, 0.13161596655845642, 0.7039822340011597, -0.3209037482738495, -0.07094284892082214, 1.260863184928894, -0.13300615549087524, -0.7950152158737183, -0.15135465562343597, 0.28376951813697815, 0.12530997395515442, -0.08028581738471985, -0.7776727676391602, 0.4881136119365692, -0.9380306601524353, -0.09253957867622375, -0.5180609226226807, -0.45652833580970764, 0.1378600001335144, 0.621746301651001, 0.05222966521978378, -0.222458153963089, 0.7138160467147827, 0.345451682806015, 0.892367422580719, 0.3956063985824585, -0.11540384590625763, 0.09243851900100708, -0.2195856124162674, 0.3357642590999603, 0.8173118233680725, -0.15856775641441345, 0.8200640678405762, -0.18418662250041962, 0.786558210849762, 0.48361703753471375, -0.4245016872882843, -0.506294846534729, 0.07943729311227798, 0.7118626832962036, -0.22209128737449646, -0.7887255549430847, -0.09963889420032501, 0.7563900351524353, -0.2859005928039551, 0.47363242506980896, 0.03509325161576271, 0.0663365051150322, -0.44037652015686035, -0.321438729763031, -0.40344947576522827, 0.6220278739929199, -0.02964671514928341, 0.34549999237060547, -0.6670098304748535, 0.5968393087387085, -0.18754416704177856, 0.3052821159362793, -0.003284710692241788, 0.4722334146499634, -0.0986829474568367, -1.5907639265060425, 0.9059752225875854, -0.012712913565337658, -0.8730176091194153, 0.19838906824588776, 0.10335148870944977, -0.05613776296377182, 0.38163837790489197, -0.4808625280857086, 0.21127499639987946, 0.46506068110466003, 0.0967220887541771, -0.03868303447961807, 0.31311774253845215, -0.10384362190961838, -1.2160298824310303, -0.5362262725830078, -1.3386309146881104, -0.07176512479782104, 0.09998995065689087, -0.23985280096530914, -0.2024460732936859, -0.08811015635728836, -0.41963082551956177, 0.5058040618896484, 0.16713154315948486, 0.3874993920326233, -0.2383989542722702, 0.10473085939884186, 0.4255927801132202, 0.5139668583869934, -0.27696359157562256, 0.15254083275794983, 0.429073303937912, 0.13701443374156952, -0.33309024572372437, -0.895214319229126, 0.5778293013572693, 0.8392857909202576, 0.06528032571077347, -0.012968188151717186, 0.14805474877357483, -0.2243928611278534, 0.25178006291389465, -0.5793313980102539, -0.03597867861390114, 0.2689415216445923, -0.5883752107620239, -0.17446368932724, -0.09618277102708817, 0.018417343497276306, -0.2384820282459259, 0.34959083795547485, 0.14630348980426788, -0.5892423987388611, -0.5998958945274353, -0.2599424421787262, 0.2220105230808258, -0.6763193011283875, 0.1073513850569725, -0.4204379916191101, 0.26455074548721313, -0.5669494271278381, 0.03326249122619629, 0.7848185896873474, 0.4622156620025635, 0.6948713660240173, -0.311488538980484, -0.2775709927082062, 0.8580201864242554, 0.4831724762916565, 0.15169483423233032, -0.006050268188118935, 0.44121530652046204, 0.6004588007926941, -0.6598042249679565, 0.35827845335006714, -0.25855833292007446, 0.6383481025695801, 0.036866605281829834, 0.29326438903808594, -0.24039915204048157, 0.16827483475208282, -0.14801561832427979, -0.5223930478096008, -1.0442818403244019, 0.5841898322105408, 0.07491541653871536, -0.519241213798523, -0.08267200738191605, 0.32140275835990906, 0.8104398846626282, -0.004441931843757629, -0.08438466489315033, 0.3582921624183655, 0.17237740755081177, 0.40924492478370667, 0.22766998410224915, 0.17079032957553864, -0.31122902035713196, -0.7398655414581299, 0.12830466032028198, 0.49767011404037476, 0.22647416591644287, 0.31563249230384827, 0.2938977777957916, -0.08878400921821594, 0.19065967202186584, 0.5620407462120056, -0.8591113686561584, -0.7251564264297485, 0.7784148454666138, -0.16827791929244995, -0.12222693115472794, 0.13705329596996307, 0.3493563234806061, -0.5899888277053833, -0.35201922059059143, 0.06197011098265648, -0.8025444149971008, 0.41513949632644653, 0.5723082423210144, 0.4614604413509369, 0.6525348424911499, 0.45492222905158997, 0.6228026151657104, -0.9569385051727295, 0.9790650606155396, 0.2990510165691376, -0.034452762454748154, 0.7578068375587463, 0.334185391664505, -0.44504979252815247, -0.029373731464147568, -0.2863636612892151, 0.48581916093826294, 0.18585717678070068, 0.0929311141371727, -0.12980547547340393, 0.3757511377334595, -0.4871167540550232, -0.13445214927196503, -0.5433840155601501, -0.5113096237182617, 0.21927332878112793, -0.338731586933136, 0.018278339877724648, 0.4984436333179474, 0.04845280945301056, -0.2382059395313263, -0.05792863667011261, -0.04203391447663307, -0.6630261540412903, 0.008787127211689949, -0.5392194986343384, 0.48605796694755554, 0.4433556795120239, -0.2918206453323364, 0.03637070953845978, -0.9272595643997192, -0.21422472596168518, -0.35302460193634033, -0.36781391501426697, -0.7045652270317078, 0.1500117927789688, 0.23809297382831573, 0.7756223082542419, 0.1034097820520401, 0.33766794204711914, 0.5223078727722168, 0.15316283702850342, 0.9995049834251404, 0.14593558013439178, 0.16294890642166138, -0.001561576034873724, -0.2616373896598816, 0.17278937995433807, -0.610702633857727, -0.11443503946065903, -0.38548702001571655, -0.22057023644447327, -0.06207315996289253, 0.12989608943462372, -0.31634634733200073, -0.5728724598884583, 0.17781130969524384, -0.15230394899845123, -0.4054579734802246, 0.3324924111366272, -0.3382338583469391, -0.659417450428009, -0.15971390902996063, 0.9456117749214172, -0.1437552124261856, -0.452451229095459, 0.2759701609611511, 0.05046574026346207, 0.27845582365989685, 0.17424383759498596, 4.328324317932129, 1.198203444480896, 0.4214644134044647, -0.24785767495632172, 0.5014984011650085, 0.7173149585723877, 0.6039157509803772, -0.32870253920555115, -0.15179142355918884, 0.3376990854740143, -0.27353957295417786, 0.8489487171173096, 0.3153975009918213, -0.20270758867263794, 0.06980954110622406, 0.33655524253845215, -1.0563308000564575, -0.03433895483613014, 0.23633097112178802, -0.7713049650192261, -0.24187132716178894, 0.13718178868293762, -0.33282598853111267, -0.10209325700998306, 0.4036133587360382, 0.6241679191589355, -0.6795679926872253, -0.06129664555191994, -0.2006903439760208, -0.12430562824010849, -0.11199834942817688, -0.3280414640903473, -0.3168554902076721, -0.6480886340141296, -0.054869551211595535, 0.7193191647529602, 0.4689565896987915, -0.1673843413591385, -0.9970307946205139, -0.026970116421580315, 0.3208368122577667, 0.5938332676887512, -0.5506622791290283, -0.8551341891288757, -0.3324388563632965, 0.19631193578243256, 0.28336602449417114, -0.198950856924057, 0.2825130224227905, -0.20811888575553894, 1.1654824018478394, 0.022316105663776398, 0.018219197168946266, -0.03020130842924118, -0.7610704302787781, 0.2618921995162964, -0.11913339048624039, -0.5101691484451294, 0.2938781678676605, -0.0424116812646389, 0.739324688911438, -0.21089233458042145, -0.15809805691242218, 0.5781132578849792, 0.04249178618192673, -0.0016173932235687971, -0.0025113169103860855, 0.11538136005401611, -0.43954670429229736, 0.12689059972763062, -0.2760697901248932, -0.8469651341438293, -1.1243573427200317, 0.46671736240386963, 1.3193674087524414, 0.6210685968399048, -0.3317946195602417, 0.08962427079677582, -0.25905266404151917, -0.7284365892410278, -0.0025831027887761593, -0.12551701068878174, 0.36802902817726135, -0.08177801966667175, 0.20451049506664276, 0.8563978672027588, 0.05168133229017258, -0.06194503232836723, -1.2406506538391113, 0.31339359283447266, 0.08216787874698639, 0.4736434817314148, -0.2682517468929291, -0.6209421157836914, -0.8054985404014587 ]
{"Title": "Lower limb muscle activity underlying temporal gait asymmetry post-stroke", "Authors": "Rozanski Gabriela M., Huntley Andrew H., Crosby Lucas D., Schinkel-Ivy Alison, Mansfield Avril, Patterson Kara K.", "Abstract": "Abstract Objective Asymmetric walking after stroke is common, detrimental, and difficult to treat, but current knowledge of underlying physiological mechanisms is limited. This study investigated electromyographic (EMG) features of temporal gait asymmetry (TGA). Methods Participants post-stroke with or without TGA and control adults (n=27, 8, and 9, respectively) performed self-paced overground gait trials. EMG, force plate, and motion capture data were collected. Lower limb muscle activity was compared across groups and sides (more/less affected). Correlation between burst timing variables and asymmetry ratios was examined. Results Significant group by side interaction effects were found: fewer TGA group dorsiflexor bursts during swing (p=.0009), more affected plantarflexor stance activity ended early (p=.0006) and less affected dorsiflexor on/off time was delayed (p<.01) in persons with asymmetry compared to symmetric and normative controls. Less affected side EMG timing correlated most with swing time ratio (r=0.68-0.90, p<.001). Conclusions Temporal patterns of muscular activation, particularly about the ankle around the stance-to-swing transition period, are associated with TGA. The results may reflect specific impairments or compensations that affect locomotor coordination. Significance Neuromuscular underpinnings of spatiotemporal asymmetry have not been previously characterized. These novel findings may inform targeted therapeutic strategies to improve gait quality after stroke.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19010421"}
10.1101/19013607
[ -0.40477314591407776, -0.26977142691612244, -0.12030821293592453, 0.6249829530715942, 0.004907790571451187, -0.799938976764679, 0.49572619795799255, 0.3379107713699341, -0.09042442589998245, 0.9180850982666016, -0.32689857482910156, -0.16309303045272827, -0.47823047637939453, -0.3875315189361572, -0.24039657413959503, 0.6219322681427002, -0.26309657096862793, -0.10278152674436569, -0.8767222166061401, -0.2023816704750061, 0.7127918601036072, -0.3305263817310333, -0.7862601280212402, -0.11846380680799484, 0.17768792808055878, 0.626836359500885, 0.2549647390842438, 0.047311246395111084, 0.9091619849205017, 0.5441434979438782, 0.6479896903038025, -0.8097352981567383, 0.5457475781440735, -0.7013826370239258, -0.7465522885322571, -0.46364647150039673, 0.7474650740623474, -0.5981970429420471, 0.261416494846344, -0.6968063712120056, 0.47466322779655457, 0.24418708682060242, 0.04686500504612923, -0.8197707533836365, -0.6740996837615967, 0.001951380050741136, -0.3501359820365906, -0.8837207555770874, -0.47576016187667847, -0.3238062560558319, -0.038675688207149506, 0.1659555584192276, -0.3229544758796692, -0.22293232381343842, -0.4753987193107605, -0.5423452854156494, 0.36900365352630615, 0.028438271954655647, -0.22541910409927368, -0.1059807687997818, 0.536130964756012, -0.15446782112121582, 0.4423230290412903, -1.4877792596817017, 0.11879992485046387, 1.0133297443389893, -0.02025304175913334, -0.08657284826040268, -0.5536261796951294, -0.40474483370780945, -1.0009379386901855, 0.2922961115837097, -0.4494576156139374, -0.5610845685005188, -0.4008404612541199, -0.0957508236169815, -0.12535813450813293, -0.0365116111934185, 0.4444587230682373, -0.5785556435585022, 0.724233090877533, -0.050329916179180145, -0.058499131351709366, 0.6953554153442383, -0.4336949288845062, 0.42956575751304626, 0.11140281707048416, 0.601212203502655, 0.2159711867570877, -0.7346668243408203, 1.0073835849761963, 0.3697676360607147, -0.09746372699737549, -0.011634306982159615, 0.3538863956928253, 0.5054001808166504, -0.19571518898010254, 0.293241411447525, 0.2924284040927887, -0.41973942518234253, 0.4024171531200409, 0.3902420997619629, -0.3130791485309601, 0.7108843326568604, -1.267637014389038, 0.027537085115909576, 0.34791114926338196, 0.302422434091568, 0.2174614816904068, -1.1210371255874634, -0.013691123574972153, 0.5317442417144775, -0.4981290400028229, 0.7492150664329529, -0.2481003999710083, 0.8183102607727051, -0.2097139060497284, -0.18087905645370483, -0.5701635479927063, 0.156214639544487, -0.30297166109085083, -0.3584766685962677, 0.5967814922332764, -0.4254342317581177, 0.9449206590652466, -0.13910247385501862, -0.05162405967712402, 0.43459105491638184, 0.6564154028892517, 0.3308621644973755, 0.21552146971225739, 0.38609209656715393, -0.05458405613899231, 0.4079535901546478, -0.5773925185203552, 0.20109644532203674, -0.41792580485343933, 0.7086769938468933, -0.4607633650302887, -0.4700908362865448, -0.82172030210495, 0.20878243446350098, 0.14441987872123718, 1.061782956123352, 0.28703469038009644, 0.8962584137916565, -0.2636220157146454, -0.640712320804596, -0.036616481840610504, -0.4016006886959076, -0.06317141652107239, 0.35867974162101746, -0.12538465857505798, 0.45624232292175293, -0.000030286239052657038, -0.1478501856327057, -0.5405205488204956, 0.7192077040672302, -0.5307360887527466, 0.6004688739776611, 0.3193407952785492, 0.8008674383163452, 0.0749954953789711, 0.8157306909561157, -0.3563557267189026, 0.6222392916679382, -0.06184117868542671, -0.3385469913482666, 0.31263241171836853, -0.49465397000312805, 0.2459157556295395, 0.32654136419296265, -0.41393032670021057, -0.9034573435783386, -0.019158747047185898, 0.9034643769264221, 1.0535887479782104, 1.018531322479248, -0.19111770391464233, 0.3452838957309723, 0.157327339053154, -0.2775668501853943, 0.5154489278793335, 0.7605283260345459, 0.1792294979095459, -0.6277154684066772, -0.6942368745803833, -1.043416976928711, 0.08969686925411224, -0.2467900961637497, 0.045444589108228683, 0.6177965998649597, -1.0793848037719727, 1.1010990142822266, 0.27401918172836304, 0.4490340054035187, -0.17502793669700623, -0.41934362053871155, 0.18167085945606232, -0.3861168622970581, -0.7861653566360474, 0.7642709612846375, -0.6078284978866577, 0.1508687436580658, -0.37259459495544434, 0.03308442234992981, 0.8973040580749512, 0.4796537756919861, -0.2411782294511795, 0.20699380338191986, 0.34180933237075806, -0.22146332263946533, -0.012744450941681862, -0.09208044409751892, 1.109816551208496, -0.9770064949989319, 0.13159595429897308, 0.5520034432411194, -0.626208484172821, 0.36897537112236023, 0.37411409616470337, 0.34801244735717773, 0.0795602947473526, 0.5762647390365601, 0.0004939268110319972, -0.05890163779258728, 0.3118162453174591, 0.4476242661476135, -0.21544888615608215, 0.06561968475580215, 0.5555155277252197, 0.5093969702720642, 0.43571552634239197, 0.36873728036880493, 0.3877006769180298, 0.5968527793884277, -0.008215823210775852, -0.12417187541723251, 0.9808627963066101, -0.09052164107561111, 0.3066457211971283, 0.49304988980293274, 1.404715657234192, 0.25726374983787537, -0.6177034974098206, 0.7847399711608887, -0.3619192838668823, -0.34938210248947144, -0.05118171498179436, -0.3362441956996918, -0.8304970860481262, 0.7268689274787903, -0.642329752445221, 0.23714864253997803, -0.9379913210868835, 0.0029706053901463747, 0.7725350856781006, 0.3133125901222229, -0.27527856826782227, -0.7229262590408325, -0.495232492685318, -0.39100566506385803, 0.235409677028656, -0.2996722459793091, 0.6545714139938354, 0.8529088497161865, 0.14388981461524963, 0.24741828441619873, -0.09041757881641388, -0.3382281959056854, -0.8555678129196167, -0.5088390111923218, -1.6103471517562866, -0.24689356982707977, -0.6769864559173584, -0.04075365141034126, -0.10101481527090073, -0.4364740252494812, 0.8187324404716492, -0.01757335104048252, 0.34476330876350403, -0.9435798525810242, 0.7490379810333252, 0.719070553779602, -0.07888203114271164, -0.0813329666852951, -0.9134262204170227, 0.6081873774528503, -0.7478740215301514, 0.17509479820728302, 0.01785334385931492, -0.6819570064544678, -0.6932835578918457, -0.8066588044166565, 0.5334039330482483, 0.0794297307729721, -0.29584187269210815, -0.16066902875900269, -0.9165015816688538, -0.24985720217227936, -0.0602705255150795, -0.1508018523454666, 0.5860480666160583, 0.3569541871547699, -0.928196132183075, 0.4409523606300354, 0.6870589852333069, -0.3027915358543396, 0.451071172952652, 0.3709547519683838, -0.6453718543052673, 0.5595272183418274, -0.34461086988449097, -0.46857935190200806, -0.622165858745575, 0.7281312942504883, 0.4963851571083069, -0.2673724889755249, -0.02867312915623188, -0.5971691608428955, -0.9476572275161743, 0.1643024981021881, 0.13912007212638855, -0.4969022274017334, -0.07743938267230988, -0.21091188490390778, -0.13661253452301025, -0.6789731383323669, 0.02607697807252407, -0.46639570593833923, -0.5141866207122803, -0.0019274079240858555, -0.9489640593528748, 0.5231191515922546, -0.06249699741601944, 0.43672770261764526, -0.428112268447876, -0.42834311723709106, -0.16748665273189545, -0.10159186273813248, 0.3864384889602661, 0.13120336830615997, -0.5907584428787231, 0.01681426540017128, 0.2320612519979477, 0.5723545551300049, -0.13364177942276, -0.5869425535202026, -0.18008533120155334, -0.7152919769287109, -0.39454683661460876, -0.36692264676094055, -0.24626053869724274, -0.7008070349693298, 0.7271305918693542, 0.5094743967056274, -0.819013237953186, -0.06202990189194679, -0.18646834790706635, 0.6969446539878845, -0.11392982304096222, 0.0857740119099617, 0.03026575967669487, -0.15818136930465698, -0.6394127011299133, -0.34513241052627563, 0.254093199968338, 0.07427482306957245, 0.42043808102607727, 0.10569623857736588, 0.4154632091522217, -0.030952394008636475, 0.38268786668777466, -0.4804604947566986, -0.03924606740474701, -0.02002900466322899, 0.5814718008041382, -0.6474049687385559, 0.8304446339607239, -0.9023611545562744, -0.20547392964363098, 0.957063615322113, 0.6290343403816223, -0.09404458105564117, -0.24836274981498718, -0.5572327971458435, -0.30808916687965393, -0.24274633824825287, 0.6999512910842896, 0.20895810425281525, -0.21331758797168732, -0.14328332245349884, 0.033099107444286346, 0.04426237568259239, -0.9200315475463867, -0.477621853351593, 0.3476070761680603, 0.6598259806632996, -0.31618615984916687, -0.4430996775627136, 0.9329003691673279, -0.25918447971343994, -0.30636265873908997, 0.9357308149337769, 0.3186867833137512, -0.4129031002521515, -0.5763275027275085, 0.5949355363845825, 0.20374886691570282, -0.5859652161598206, -0.21378135681152344, 0.4364260137081146, -0.013810052536427975, 0.06608161330223083, 0.3209439516067505, 0.027180660516023636, -0.4189557433128357, -0.1965363472700119, 0.41745662689208984, 0.1187674030661583, -0.14212213456630707, 0.8389203548431396, -0.6234533786773682, -0.031027697026729584, 0.6865290403366089, -0.6263901591300964, -0.5254815816879272, -0.6333063244819641, 0.4045248031616211, 0.6550822257995605, 0.32429301738739014, -0.6734808683395386, 0.48919424414634705, 0.24852484464645386, -0.0063338554464280605, 0.09222134947776794, 0.35133063793182373, -0.44779208302497864, 0.5196020603179932, 0.04029132053256035, 0.2687102258205414, -0.2708618938922882, -0.38209250569343567, -0.11999280750751495, -0.35328009724617004, 0.27536940574645996, 0.2819269299507141, 0.6803898811340332, 0.4275600016117096, -0.08120148628950119, 0.839282214641571, -0.5270878076553345, 0.49113714694976807, -0.6916504502296448, -0.15647532045841217, -0.549107551574707, 0.6474599838256836, 0.17202651500701904, 0.6861445307731628, -0.2495289444923401, -0.3738267719745636, -0.38243481516838074, 0.9828695058822632, -0.027131089940667152, 0.3695127069950104, 0.5386497378349304, -0.120712511241436, 0.2753755450248718, 0.22005145251750946, -0.13746997714042664, -0.18280337750911713, -0.38963401317596436, 0.13427746295928955, -0.5724261403083801, -0.05145784094929695, -0.5597345232963562, -0.08083507418632507, 0.3250906467437744, -0.2903220057487488, -0.29664984345436096, -0.32559850811958313, 0.1420990526676178, -0.018465761095285416, 0.06886101514101028, -0.6227055788040161, -0.22478118538856506, -0.354265034198761, -0.1687987595796585, -0.4361533224582672, 0.267779141664505, -0.2031627595424652, -0.5479205846786499, 0.15096107125282288, -0.09206032752990723, 0.2851743996143341, -0.974032998085022, -1.6588326692581177, 0.47482872009277344, -0.7542442679405212, 0.020367451012134552, 1.0903985500335693, -0.16367478668689728, 0.36628371477127075, 0.17408713698387146, 0.6671879291534424, -0.03926397114992142, -0.612842857837677, -0.20656977593898773, 0.06960495561361313, 0.27262625098228455, -0.7625122666358948, 0.1931522786617279, -0.008326477371156216, 0.6888794898986816, -0.6038315892219543, -0.17494255304336548, 0.6832625865936279, -0.13401898741722107, -0.3468214273452759, 0.7697322964668274, -0.8111696839332581, -0.8749262690544128, -0.04426642134785652, 0.5648932456970215, -0.2241009771823883, -0.3637717068195343, -0.12140431255102158, -0.07916583865880966, -0.9810169339179993, -1.2777702808380127, -0.03244416043162346, -1.2933611869812012, 0.2780436873435974, -0.36461204290390015, -0.06714500486850739, 0.006981761194765568, -0.3237340748310089, -0.00806343648582697, -0.39320024847984314, -0.45997148752212524, -0.7657387852668762, 0.2192535549402237, -0.26753032207489014, -0.5005418062210083, 0.18282023072242737, -0.6356506943702698, -0.16802820563316345, 1.00021493434906, 0.5875998735427856, 0.4816811680793762, 0.4177820086479187, -0.4454728960990906, 0.797092080116272, 0.11265220493078232, -0.22264544665813446, -0.6023825407028198, 0.5133110880851746, 0.789078414440155, -0.15213505923748016, 0.09061060100793839, -0.6841185688972473, 0.2863447368144989, -0.4445255398750305, 0.5327072143554688, -0.3050253689289093, -0.20239011943340302, -0.3739800453186035, -0.028576793149113655, 0.8171611428260803, -0.6034132242202759, 0.14152242243289948, 0.7520874738693237, 0.6136121153831482, -0.48957881331443787, -0.017991481348872185, -0.87577223777771, 0.11680279672145844, -0.739349901676178, -0.4072583019733429, 0.15892072021961212, 0.14099058508872986, 0.4031785726547241, 0.7715665102005005, -0.01858833059668541, -0.15191219747066498, -0.8449059128761292, 0.798542320728302, 0.3524967133998871, -0.22794091701507568, -0.42314717173576355, -0.2956053614616394, 0.24298134446144104, 0.49017098546028137, 0.32698822021484375, 0.2567131817340851, -0.0363125316798687, -0.22098447382450104, -0.052112676203250885, -0.38783499598503113, -0.7996965646743774, -0.32745909690856934, 0.5767262578010559, 0.5723506808280945, 0.17654654383659363, 0.7498465776443481, -0.25799745321273804, -0.004609387833625078, -0.8842666149139404, 0.5575489401817322, -0.7288694381713867, 0.4478859603404999, 0.8665836453437805, -0.49317681789398193, -0.4646834135055542, -0.3189118504524231, -0.11709661781787872, -0.06672930717468262, 0.12312552332878113, 0.7873982787132263, 0.5705145001411438, -0.3170780539512634, 0.2283436506986618, 0.5191194415092468, 0.028165414929389954, -0.8685750365257263, -0.4707150161266327, -0.5387493371963501, 0.21714617311954498, -0.0034725009463727474, -0.5061978697776794, 0.6113825440406799, -0.07284005731344223, 0.22577115893363953, 0.3469904363155365, 0.06738893687725067, 0.10411687940359116, -0.01896655559539795, 0.07895328104496002, -0.5420634746551514, 0.312406450510025, 0.5504739284515381, 0.07481376826763153, -0.6066051721572876, -0.42927631735801697, 0.07038469612598419, 0.7337943315505981, 0.12844565510749817, 0.9063145518302917, -0.414622962474823, 0.31076106429100037, -0.35329362750053406, 0.49677300453186035, -0.9807255864143372, 0.07651475071907043, 0.02128668501973152, 0.8605408072471619, -0.6993414163589478, -0.2282203733921051, -0.5669680833816528, 0.416379451751709, 0.32904866337776184, 0.6813771724700928, -0.3311488628387451, -0.7217697501182556, 0.9166788458824158, 0.9614765644073486, -0.16613638401031494, -0.567562997341156, -0.9490839242935181, -0.4147735834121704, -0.3486865162849426, 0.9063367247581482, -0.5129693746566772, -0.654030442237854, 0.6678445339202881, -0.6485446691513062, -1.0516256093978882, -0.06027349829673767, 0.5866588354110718, -0.7581930160522461, -0.33303219079971313, -0.9665390253067017, 0.15319274365901947, -0.5864078998565674, -0.01925778202712536, -0.22273871302604675, -0.948374330997467, 0.39061644673347473, -0.051286496222019196, -0.3395434617996216, 0.13888844847679138, 0.22870880365371704, 0.9395933151245117, 0.3813665807247162, 0.03198005631566048, -0.4457148015499115, -0.4871889352798462, -0.6523710489273071, 0.9278112053871155, 0.46203508973121643, -0.106731116771698, 1.0491524934768677, -0.03233411908149719, 0.7208381295204163, 0.7662588357925415, -0.2523319721221924, 0.04298276826739311, 0.41249364614486694, 0.5095023512840271, -0.6766569018363953, -0.3323300778865814, 0.00733804190531373, 0.4510308802127838, -0.432418555021286, -0.24022434651851654, 0.0463734045624733, 0.6248273253440857, -0.3868235647678375, -0.4227810502052307, -0.19072973728179932, 0.16693590581417084, 0.5921070575714111, 0.2033044546842575, -0.03293078765273094, 0.6255069375038147, 0.3267585337162018, 0.40692809224128723, -0.3535866141319275, -0.11466427147388458, 0.23010621964931488, -0.9797371625900269, 0.6559574007987976, 0.5055419206619263, 0.13388387858867645, -0.07811789214611053, -0.22149141132831573, 0.13777503371238708, -0.45781466364860535, 0.2806035578250885, 0.07108896225690842, 0.5140925645828247, 0.374802827835083, 0.27671706676483154, 0.49446696043014526, -0.06568840891122818, -0.95972740650177, -0.15065047144889832, -1.6032087802886963, -0.5148476958274841, 0.18094104528427124, -0.5064476132392883, -0.4842506945133209, -0.47236064076423645, -0.4651447534561157, 0.4553818106651306, 0.2545843720436096, 0.5470532774925232, 0.1925695538520813, 0.7587592005729675, 0.4492602050304413, 0.5095086097717285, 0.2950821816921234, -0.7401301860809326, -0.22540712356567383, 0.021212419494986534, 0.13436904549598694, -1.2624506950378418, -0.21818923950195312, -0.3196873962879181, 0.02970106154680252, -0.5925258994102478, 0.104769267141819, 0.35299474000930786, -0.41267699003219604, -0.3134807050228119, -0.24763314425945282, 0.8772377371788025, -1.1565104722976685, 0.1778375655412674, -0.2972586154937744, -0.535584032535553, -0.5583998560905457, 0.792788565158844, 0.8393747806549072, -0.5042620301246643, -0.2707898020744324, -0.4518076479434967, 0.41725027561187744, -0.6174221634864807, -0.142555370926857, -0.18058469891548157, 0.5246893763542175, -0.45203837752342224, 0.07083816081285477, 0.7672852873802185, 0.641176164150238, 0.4541928768157959, 0.7754485011100769, -0.005288673099130392, 0.6759796738624573, 0.3158525228500366, 0.4328393340110779, -0.0022051583509892225, 0.4378504157066345, -0.2554841637611389, -0.15155677497386932, 0.2720232605934143, -0.14053097367286682, 0.28380176424980164, 0.23350098729133606, 0.161587193608284, 0.40997475385665894, 0.04119807109236717, 0.43936818838119507, -0.10593224316835403, -0.9391589164733887, 1.0996553897857666, -0.1445077657699585, -0.30138593912124634, -0.621119499206543, 0.6087324619293213, 0.5399906039237976, 0.5497704148292542, 0.5496798753738403, 0.17015771567821503, 0.47447898983955383, 0.2023833841085434, 0.09199144691228867, -0.1117926612496376, -0.23293542861938477, -1.008540391921997, 0.0645795613527298, 0.22889329493045807, 0.3822123408317566, 0.33611786365509033, 0.7094237208366394, -0.2947787344455719, -0.4158075153827667, 0.25331243872642517, -0.3437541723251343, 0.011326022446155548, 0.6264638304710388, -0.21930144727230072, -0.3080582916736603, -0.02404627948999405, -0.044066816568374634, -0.750159740447998, -0.7598041296005249, 0.7608252167701721, -1.0915584564208984, 0.45510783791542053, 0.13531555235385895, -0.0608200766146183, 0.9120867848396301, 0.3559758961200714, -0.02127256989479065, -0.5426697134971619, 1.3731999397277832, 0.5735514760017395, -0.14469051361083984, 0.4439783990383148, 0.1939222812652588, -0.06593994051218033, 0.0966220572590828, -0.5598509311676025, 0.07215458154678345, -0.15537190437316895, 0.148159459233284, 0.33933159708976746, 0.3466074466705322, -0.43797630071640015, -0.44004812836647034, -0.46194446086883545, 0.00871995184570551, 0.41487962007522583, 0.011925038881599903, -0.0508899912238121, -0.15089480578899384, -0.03277219459414482, 0.14094357192516327, -0.1464165896177292, 0.3682019114494324, -0.5487918853759766, 0.2598901689052582, -0.568735659122467, -0.0642283484339714, 0.0935131162405014, -0.5137024521827698, -0.5607274770736694, -0.5676943063735962, -0.23742258548736572, -0.06970496475696564, -0.39390328526496887, -1.4351810216903687, 0.23683707416057587, 0.4468817710876465, 0.05636908486485481, 1.0036252737045288, -0.2026768922805786, -0.08474414050579071, 0.21330909430980682, 1.2260220050811768, -0.3368852734565735, 0.23493437469005585, 0.9383460879325867, -0.06885875761508942, 0.5746691226959229, 0.14061787724494934, 0.30863144993782043, -0.03128978982567787, -0.002707336563616991, -0.5066219568252563, 0.6343538165092468, -0.21982331573963165, -0.8272783160209656, 0.8264092803001404, 0.47680357098579407, 0.09411172568798065, -0.09528440982103348, -0.6567966938018799, 0.23511472344398499, -0.563562273979187, 1.4129612445831299, -0.46130263805389404, 0.08853430300951004, -0.4112561047077179, -0.23026874661445618, 0.6317956447601318, -0.5334867835044861, 4.143082141876221, 1.529706597328186, 0.2613629698753357, -0.06701678782701492, 0.29093775153160095, 0.9712296724319458, 0.3142358362674713, -0.39946621656417847, -0.24112017452716827, 0.05278083682060242, -0.4583047330379486, 0.7486298084259033, 0.15506650507450104, -0.2192850559949875, 0.9557822942733765, 0.2753312885761261, -0.8356762528419495, -0.10242979973554611, -0.06293132156133652, -1.1337175369262695, -0.03263998404145241, 0.08287320286035538, 0.04696531966328621, -0.583737313747406, 0.22432841360569, 0.6508713364601135, -0.12929421663284302, -0.029110031202435493, -0.6158098578453064, -0.7885605096817017, -0.09950818866491318, -0.48492491245269775, -0.2331656515598297, -1.4777584075927734, 0.2508430480957031, 0.8425197005271912, -0.3064662516117096, 0.15993820130825043, 0.05196164920926094, -0.07488919794559479, 0.48813164234161377, -0.20223601162433624, -0.5702174305915833, -0.9194917678833008, -0.2943899631500244, 0.061228759586811066, 0.09587498009204865, -0.6318472027778625, 0.5531020164489746, -0.638357400894165, 1.4720853567123413, -0.4574684798717499, 0.22650046646595, -0.4553380012512207, -0.770431399345398, 0.3627302646636963, -0.11072863638401031, -0.5960984230041504, 0.17012415826320648, -0.46410706639289856, 0.11656379699707031, -0.09153108298778534, 0.0307747945189476, -0.06783871352672577, 0.11809965968132019, 0.6194779276847839, 0.01755550689995289, 0.686161994934082, -0.6644382476806641, 0.37519967555999756, -0.20620663464069366, -0.474735826253891, -1.0995151996612549, 0.5209134817123413, 1.5886093378067017, 0.4991864860057831, -0.49690619111061096, 0.3247791528701782, -0.1790132373571396, -0.5337235927581787, 0.36721542477607727, -0.04496045038104057, 0.20216232538223267, 0.5388290286064148, 0.6831648945808411, 0.744232177734375, 0.018937038257718086, -0.3097134828567505, -1.0706526041030884, 0.8934168219566345, 0.5523537993431091, -0.15436699986457825, -0.39248156547546387, -0.6292021870613098, -0.5930123329162598 ]
{"Title": "Alien limb in the corticobasal syndrome: phenomenological characteristics and relationship to apraxia", "Authors": "Lewis-Smith David J., Wolpe Noham, Ghosh Boyd C.P., Rowe James B.", "Abstract": "ABSTRACT Alien limb refers to movements that seem purposeful but are independent of patients\u2019 reported intentions. Alien limb often co-occurs with apraxia in the corticobasal syndrome, and anatomical and phenomenological comparisons have led to the suggestion that alien limb and apraxia may be causally related as failures of goal-directed movements. Here, we characterised the nature of alien limb symptoms in patients with the corticobasal syndrome (n=30) and their relationship to limb apraxia. Twenty-five patients with progressive supranuclear palsy Richardson syndrome served as a disease-control group. Structured examinations of praxis, motor function, cognition and alien limb were undertaken in patients attending a regional specialist clinic. Twenty-eight patients with corticobasal syndrome (93%) demonstrated significant apraxia and this was often asymmetrical, with the left hand preferentially affected in 77% of patients. Moreover, 83% reported one or more symptoms consistent with alien limb. The range of these phenomena was broad, including changes in the sense of ownership and control as well as unwanted movements. Regression analyses showed no significant association between the severity of limb apraxia and both the occurrence of an alien limb and the number of alien limb phenomena reported. Bayesian estimation showed a low probability for a positive association between alien limb and apraxia, suggesting that alien limb phenomena are not likely to be related to severe apraxia. Our results shed light on the phenomenology of these disabling and as yet untreatable clinical features, with relevance to theoretical models of voluntary action.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19013607"}
10.1101/19005611
[ -0.3009239435195923, 0.4550297260284424, -0.4917052686214447, 0.0044381446205079556, -0.052492208778858185, -0.5376372337341309, -0.47697263956069946, 0.02823866903781891, -0.17665627598762512, 0.7318732738494873, -0.9046112298965454, -0.11050766706466675, 0.35187146067619324, -0.6827785968780518, -0.14640527963638306, -0.3504205346107483, -0.8335245847702026, -0.427640825510025, -0.9276789426803589, -0.267501562833786, -0.06967023760080338, 0.9284847974777222, -0.6929929256439209, -0.5385231971740723, -0.818383514881134, 0.8240877985954285, 0.3063751459121704, -0.4062355160713196, 0.5729597806930542, 0.3232783377170563, 0.18025539815425873, -1.1460716724395752, -0.052379436790943146, -0.5513986349105835, 0.25250911712646484, 0.5396327376365662, 0.9197893738746643, -0.8140364289283752, -0.03279656916856766, -0.3058653771877289, -0.1614265739917755, -0.2654787003993988, -0.6754348278045654, -1.193967342376709, -0.46641862392425537, -0.36642032861709595, -0.5644667744636536, -0.09933552145957947, 0.30573880672454834, 0.11231103539466858, -0.23930922150611877, 0.4767065644264221, 0.09124698489904404, 0.47250956296920776, -0.13944576680660248, -0.4236888289451599, 0.6813344359397888, 0.6053364872932434, -0.46425193548202515, -0.36519208550453186, 0.6509419083595276, -0.1789523959159851, 0.15204626321792603, -0.8966050148010254, 0.1275046020746231, 0.4039360284805298, -0.3131231665611267, -0.825681209564209, -0.011931025423109531, 0.03831253945827484, -0.6056597232818604, 0.537823498249054, -0.06902551651000977, -0.4633522033691406, 0.0872950479388237, 0.6033754944801331, -0.404420405626297, 0.04872466251254082, 0.538494348526001, -0.21674476563930511, 0.1952737271785736, -0.10572322458028793, -0.8710281252861023, -0.07498815655708313, -0.13791921734809875, -0.3789137005805969, 0.5424672365188599, 0.6834409832954407, -0.09490184485912323, 0.15706564486026764, 0.31760144233703613, -0.007878601551055908, 0.1646830141544342, 0.556856095790863, 0.35174262523651123, 0.7227371335029602, 0.12091927975416183, -0.6226283311843872, -0.12073756009340286, 0.13963694870471954, 0.3568076491355896, 0.9468095302581787, -0.03551460802555084, 1.2891727685928345, -0.8709654211997986, 0.3119456171989441, 0.6110401153564453, 0.052655745297670364, -0.29394644498825073, -0.2975512444972992, 0.15122242271900177, 0.2771301865577698, 0.3502413332462311, -0.03539346158504486, 0.3595447242259979, 0.8294345736503601, -0.19327200949192047, 0.26884153485298157, -0.2480299323797226, 0.19583551585674286, 0.13019174337387085, 0.24998357892036438, 0.2857908308506012, 0.08645911514759064, 0.3731849789619446, -0.6246921420097351, -0.5360252261161804, 0.3106386661529541, -0.10710263252258301, -0.34379082918167114, -0.1336173415184021, -0.8077113032341003, -0.30584266781806946, 0.6682397127151489, -0.29130950570106506, -0.16939577460289001, 0.02383771352469921, 0.03998095169663429, -0.03268668055534363, -0.44215092062950134, -0.5525418519973755, -0.3878658413887024, -0.2993514835834503, 1.3449558019638062, -0.6226555705070496, 0.37765830755233765, -0.48723769187927246, -0.1537584811449051, -0.22633805871009827, -0.5086783766746521, -0.3857456147670746, 0.16423442959785461, -0.4638475775718689, -0.21667040884494781, -0.7747612595558167, -0.5770131945610046, 0.08703037351369858, 0.7750712633132935, -0.38209059834480286, -0.06056202948093414, 0.13130049407482147, -0.11632255464792252, -0.49464088678359985, 0.6605459451675415, -0.5256049036979675, 0.9827455878257751, -0.4680279791355133, -0.6386690139770508, -0.172538161277771, -0.7332236170768738, 0.21419323980808258, 0.9138637781143188, -0.02788793109357357, -0.18105767667293549, -0.1552216112613678, 0.3960760235786438, 1.189466118812561, 0.15547357499599457, 0.35220691561698914, 0.1158192977309227, -0.6750937700271606, -1.275525450706482, -0.0693567618727684, 0.16868893802165985, -0.34626856446266174, -0.0970405861735344, -0.24162133038043976, -0.22504118084907532, -0.6451975107192993, 0.3565332591533661, 0.3669455945491791, 0.8171172142028809, -1.197556972503662, -0.001981881679967046, -0.2554098963737488, 0.17641016840934753, 0.22485113143920898, 0.6197640895843506, 0.27104076743125916, -0.15411974489688873, -0.018764754757285118, 1.1323455572128296, -0.23647435009479523, 0.23943664133548737, -1.0229992866516113, 0.7209453582763672, 0.639133095741272, 1.141255259513855, -0.8715320229530334, 0.09864257276058197, 0.2152092456817627, -0.017264414578676224, 0.19387556612491608, 0.7500303983688354, 0.18881820142269135, -0.497265100479126, 0.17957665026187897, -0.39829009771347046, 0.34701573848724365, -0.7252663373947144, 0.040075454860925674, -0.09349672496318817, 0.4008895754814148, -0.3737562298774719, 0.14280341565608978, -0.49097442626953125, 0.5053619146347046, 0.3011643886566162, 0.10015161335468292, 0.04098651185631752, 0.363418847322464, 0.4257012605667114, -0.44688984751701355, 0.7553582191467285, 0.4995831251144409, 0.2802913188934326, 0.6528345346450806, 0.28096431493759155, 0.8853480219841003, 0.02226332388818264, -0.39468756318092346, -0.018956072628498077, 0.9381604194641113, 0.7020339369773865, 0.04162438213825226, 0.3592683672904968, -0.30889299511909485, 0.4914003312587738, -0.5831422209739685, -0.5926252007484436, -0.75826495885849, 1.0400818586349487, 0.30544233322143555, 0.322918176651001, -1.1234556436538696, -0.013644445687532425, 0.33871299028396606, 0.9518169164657593, 0.6084207892417908, -0.8582280278205872, -0.6927520632743835, 0.26729974150657654, 0.2971077561378479, -0.003378486493602395, 0.6150614023208618, 0.7380505204200745, 1.2656975984573364, 0.7116609811782837, 0.24540813267230988, -0.5516709089279175, -0.8521105051040649, -1.5741207599639893, -1.2407722473144531, -0.00998564064502716, -0.9915918707847595, -0.7343400120735168, 0.07543595135211945, -0.42734798789024353, 0.34144365787506104, 0.4420788586139679, 0.4528687596321106, -0.1643964797258377, 0.42975905537605286, 1.0394065380096436, 0.5984219312667847, -0.11655102670192719, -0.9879253506660461, 1.1630419492721558, 0.2696480453014374, 0.22101515531539917, 0.8049140572547913, -0.7651036977767944, -0.010204258374869823, -1.0677299499511719, 0.0650835782289505, -0.7652674913406372, 0.10399135202169418, 0.3440512716770172, -0.4091908037662506, -0.060272958129644394, -0.13212238252162933, 0.12589146196842194, -0.1540498286485672, -0.09905130416154861, -0.736812949180603, 0.4089253544807434, 0.6739399433135986, -0.18628902733325958, 0.2940410375595093, 0.38438019156455994, -0.5828719735145569, 1.3901128768920898, -0.029770828783512115, -0.14624442160129547, -0.9315924644470215, 0.35378727316856384, 0.2635203003883362, -0.8252061605453491, -0.11600422114133835, -0.1365964263677597, -0.6969757676124573, -0.8725555539131165, -0.3457752466201782, -1.1328518390655518, -0.22168806195259094, 0.9659570455551147, 0.0757925808429718, -0.9064487814903259, -0.19033579528331757, -1.4126501083374023, -1.2390272617340088, 0.6162054538726807, -0.2073441445827484, 0.42768973112106323, 0.1878816783428192, 0.009333519265055656, -0.6525431871414185, 0.037789374589920044, 0.2679615318775177, 1.132534384727478, 0.5982381105422974, -0.5882878303527832, -0.20686249434947968, 1.186477541923523, 0.5236909985542297, 0.7469519376754761, 0.8616940379142761, -0.23449817299842834, 0.11337996274232864, 0.46219879388809204, 0.13426809012889862, -0.174562007188797, 0.3706830143928528, -0.4560149013996124, 1.1045856475830078, -0.7527967691421509, -0.9118712544441223, -0.3068683445453644, 0.3381481468677521, 0.1762080192565918, -0.45871442556381226, 0.4577171504497528, 0.08459256589412689, 0.40245652198791504, -0.6334564089775085, -0.28611090779304504, 0.8320683240890503, 0.31945592164993286, 0.4017338454723358, -0.845225989818573, 0.5074355006217957, -0.2799430191516876, -0.5747573375701904, 0.3979138433933258, -0.12780748307704926, -0.3365322947502136, 1.197840929031372, -0.2842006981372833, 1.0585628747940063, -1.8533120155334473, 0.37775853276252747, 0.4063245356082916, 0.48804885149002075, 0.060449570417404175, 0.4460720419883728, 0.3748752474784851, 0.10288383811712265, 0.723810076713562, 0.4592384696006775, 0.42500707507133484, 0.3585180938243866, 0.6325631737709045, -0.47116532921791077, -0.4641838073730469, -0.9893540740013123, -0.8383088111877441, 0.29109227657318115, -0.09804648905992508, 0.4592829942703247, -0.4190608859062195, 1.665550947189331, -0.7280465364456177, 0.49885523319244385, 0.8527251482009888, 0.4530256688594818, 0.5511502027511597, -0.6544932126998901, 0.3450154960155487, 0.03802156448364258, -0.12733030319213867, -0.07283974438905716, 0.6165890097618103, -0.47677066922187805, -0.4229925274848938, 0.1285909116268158, 0.19090647995471954, -0.18340469896793365, -0.4207722246646881, -0.519258439540863, 0.45144861936569214, 0.21344999969005585, 0.49326759576797485, -1.3662384748458862, 0.3577244281768799, 0.2402309626340866, -0.05893496051430702, 0.2438259869813919, -0.5431303977966309, 0.4089851677417755, 0.8494325876235962, -0.5599523186683655, -0.8042301535606384, -0.09789132326841354, -0.14754845201969147, 0.00986968819051981, -0.036470405757427216, 0.3536057770252228, -0.5272481441497803, 0.821382462978363, 0.38066160678863525, -0.5363014936447144, -0.4847618639469147, 0.07861076295375824, 0.06936364620923996, 0.4458766579627991, 0.17245887219905853, 0.35587525367736816, 0.009435717016458511, 0.20549970865249634, 0.03745807707309723, 0.5110552906990051, -1.0025089979171753, 0.6297005414962769, -0.17477035522460938, -0.6126502156257629, 0.095563143491745, -0.09631454199552536, -0.11797617375850677, 0.19730617105960846, -0.42195701599121094, -0.21199864149093628, -0.1264437586069107, 0.7351720929145813, 0.4172047972679138, -1.0870200395584106, 0.6720611453056335, 0.1973201483488083, 0.13495314121246338, 0.48443493247032166, -0.0695687010884285, -0.5795155763626099, -0.8745130896568298, 0.3306160569190979, -1.0795772075653076, 0.906712532043457, 0.04638919234275818, -0.12409785389900208, -0.35059431195259094, -0.5690458416938782, -0.1280544549226761, -0.6223291158676147, 0.14852778613567352, -0.8166221380233765, -0.35696592926979065, 0.22269318997859955, -0.09137256443500519, -0.3474302589893341, -0.11801861971616745, -0.9795585870742798, 0.45966559648513794, -0.029377546161413193, 0.05391533672809601, 0.028593560680747032, -0.24689611792564392, -0.2184387892484665, 0.12045854330062866, -0.5623223781585693, 0.08434663712978363, -0.526598334312439, -0.20516976714134216, 0.8222352266311646, -0.9679914116859436, -0.18913361430168152, 0.3546644151210785, 0.8260459899902344, -0.2309599071741104, -0.7265979051589966, -0.04708220809698105, -0.4469473958015442, -0.4786841869354248, -0.3703845143318176, 0.804306149482727, -0.4493650794029236, 0.351500540971756, 0.017665669322013855, -0.1995018869638443, -0.5172772407531738, -0.051959406584501266, 0.06506972014904022, 1.1637219190597534, -0.1914050579071045, -1.1006509065628052, -0.7745086550712585, 0.7392349243164062, -0.1883004605770111, 0.4159688353538513, -0.13541565835475922, -1.049811840057373, -0.16997158527374268, -0.04032467305660248, 0.12781140208244324, -1.2103523015975952, 0.15787571668624878, -0.011023424565792084, 0.40062981843948364, -0.6725115776062012, -0.055523019284009933, 0.2647106647491455, -0.49282601475715637, -0.016786271706223488, -0.24337458610534668, 0.273870050907135, -0.6240464448928833, -1.1243773698806763, -0.46089547872543335, 0.5338890552520752, 0.03333836421370506, 0.9435582160949707, 0.6320668458938599, -0.5874136686325073, 0.6187821626663208, -0.04908105731010437, 0.501004695892334, 0.7810452580451965, -1.1877763271331787, -0.13540810346603394, 0.061253663152456284, -0.15638132393360138, 0.9307486414909363, -0.42200013995170593, -0.6765426993370056, 0.3282305896282196, -0.3265005052089691, -0.6125770807266235, -0.09485027194023132, -0.14069654047489166, 0.5426532626152039, -0.5206383466720581, 0.2316732555627823, -0.5376846194267273, -0.1941346377134323, 0.29597896337509155, -0.19816385209560394, -0.06244462728500366, -0.4794773459434509, -0.8709197640419006, -0.9004837870597839, -0.2677430808544159, -0.5264735817909241, -0.5415258407592773, -0.5835192799568176, 0.3403940200805664, 0.11501391977071762, 0.018569262698292732, -0.5739179253578186, -0.1881360560655594, 1.1706727743148804, 0.37070485949516296, 0.6033955216407776, -1.1580437421798706, 0.3052760362625122, -0.5061187148094177, 0.8378359079360962, -0.5173265933990479, 0.05604804679751396, -0.913479745388031, 0.18546107411384583, 0.11708711087703705, -0.7183203101158142, -0.22911272943019867, -0.19962739944458008, 0.20659169554710388, 1.0318039655685425, -0.4675242602825165, 0.4990418553352356, 0.5339084267616272, -0.08109469711780548, -0.9755957126617432, 0.05963916331529617, -0.9592176675796509, 0.19485634565353394, 0.8257685303688049, -0.26157346367836, -0.11628743261098862, 0.11532676219940186, 0.1283016949892044, -0.29827407002449036, -0.11241725087165833, 0.04757189378142357, -0.32861337065696716, -0.2790469527244568, -0.43049880862236023, 0.2806594967842102, 0.13462896645069122, -0.869199812412262, 0.43204236030578613, 0.0679025799036026, 0.29837852716445923, -1.042464017868042, -0.22635039687156677, -0.24714621901512146, -0.1878146529197693, -0.018832925707101822, 0.0921415239572525, -0.6277329325675964, 0.3115355968475342, 0.16383612155914307, -0.029521768912672997, -1.0998460054397583, 0.6856999397277832, 0.36597493290901184, 0.0813128650188446, 0.3838264048099518, -0.5136458873748779, -0.272826224565506, 0.4826194643974304, -0.18478389084339142, 0.5746912956237793, 0.09217620640993118, -0.3569135367870331, 0.43764305114746094, 0.6194877624511719, 0.5941748023033142, 0.27061206102371216, -0.007549353875219822, 0.39303356409072876, 0.16556087136268616, -1.3124712705612183, -0.2470543533563614, 0.22101990878582, 0.769778847694397, 0.25346264243125916, -0.6460433006286621, 0.03742552176117897, 1.1294370889663696, 0.646451473236084, -0.2810518443584442, 0.02433234453201294, -1.013702630996704, -0.7276642918586731, -1.355884313583374, 0.21280771493911743, -0.6192602515220642, -0.3294118046760559, 0.6334062218666077, 0.062399972230196, -0.44966188073158264, 0.003009639447554946, 0.6784422993659973, -1.3417117595672607, -0.5977278351783752, -0.5546188950538635, -0.628547728061676, -1.1955870389938354, -0.16662748157978058, -0.1352560967206955, -0.47580137848854065, -0.031148813664913177, 0.020359160378575325, 0.31583860516548157, 0.22671322524547577, 0.5414171814918518, 0.7084269523620605, -0.27943286299705505, 0.5146006345748901, -0.5596057772636414, -0.2401966154575348, -0.41528093814849854, 0.8789590001106262, 0.770843505859375, -0.4484860599040985, 1.2504476308822632, -0.7525209188461304, 0.5982932448387146, -0.03839052841067314, 0.2649365961551666, -0.6227788329124451, 0.0531587228178978, 0.48331418633461, -0.3330589234828949, -0.07710375636816025, -0.11861894279718399, 0.5318566560745239, -0.8812681436538696, -1.0447442531585693, -0.13710300624370575, 0.736844003200531, -0.31843245029449463, -0.6109730005264282, 0.7585691809654236, 1.2544702291488647, -0.2750120162963867, 0.9975300431251526, -0.1335488259792328, 0.20941470563411713, -0.3048074543476105, -0.03008854389190674, 0.21910971403121948, -0.3986324965953827, 0.5159686207771301, -0.9935731887817383, -0.3334507644176483, 0.20348519086837769, -0.3830617666244507, -0.1331050544977188, -0.6710358262062073, -0.07530570775270462, -0.4170261323451996, 0.1323736608028412, 1.061614751815796, 0.4542735517024994, -0.1783263385295868, 0.06147526577115059, 0.24321693181991577, -0.20333848893642426, -0.5935229659080505, -0.05248946696519852, -0.6502731442451477, -0.5465278029441833, 0.7000019550323486, -0.758269190788269, -0.0619891919195652, -0.276335209608078, -0.6712414026260376, 0.4052596092224121, 0.3652091324329376, 1.0476657152175903, -0.04225002974271774, 0.9905741214752197, 0.6281920671463013, -0.1947566270828247, -0.23461778461933136, -0.20233489573001862, 0.27740582823753357, 0.39657285809516907, -0.8556632399559021, -0.5340535044670105, 0.4756034016609192, 0.936001181602478, 0.6346893310546875, -0.5476619005203247, -0.7122744917869568, 0.42334863543510437, 0.4033716320991516, -0.3155350685119629, -0.390189528465271, -0.14399868249893188, -0.49844661355018616, 0.12995174527168274, -0.28518590331077576, 0.08733264356851578, 0.16334892809391022, 0.7766618132591248, 0.5699166655540466, -0.5654529929161072, -0.4521600902080536, 0.04644080996513367, 0.9689253568649292, -0.636961042881012, 0.5730420351028442, 0.03144652023911476, 0.6815105676651001, -0.5236662030220032, 0.028794437646865845, 0.07856401801109314, 0.7839003205299377, 0.7227969169616699, -0.9593909382820129, -0.7231866121292114, 0.4063091576099396, 0.9047485589981079, 0.11169449985027313, 0.8038570284843445, 0.49022576212882996, 0.10446497052907944, 0.4858030378818512, 0.7189376950263977, -0.1942301094532013, 0.8381460905075073, 0.17308388650417328, 0.7023593187332153, -0.47123751044273376, -0.29988378286361694, -0.11179286986589432, 0.4327528178691864, 0.05208715423941612, 0.5057893395423889, -0.21946251392364502, -0.6289696097373962, -0.0463394857943058, 1.0375317335128784, 0.5626277923583984, 0.31702491641044617, 0.11998547613620758, -0.38695400953292847, 0.4016283452510834, 0.9310667514801025, 0.20657585561275482, 1.1422030925750732, 0.06598637253046036, 0.057515040040016174, 0.06782124191522598, 1.3525633811950684, 0.32057976722717285, 0.01872474141418934, 0.43497905135154724, 0.7788266539573669, -1.11387300491333, 0.6448269486427307, 0.1769656538963318, -1.0106725692749023, 1.2466145753860474, 0.007781111169606447, -1.2557976245880127, -0.578324556350708, 0.222659632563591, -0.8569589257240295, 0.11790353059768677, 0.9707887768745422, -0.5277677774429321, -0.3568058907985687, 0.27599892020225525, -0.7355363368988037, 0.12558063864707947, 1.0564428567886353, -0.05694093927741051, 0.015061790123581886, 2.4243788719177246, 0.3624395430088043, 0.06228881701827049, 0.505161702632904, 0.15194183588027954, -0.5058358311653137, 0.6624261140823364, 0.1717439889907837, 0.4049530625343323, 0.22448834776878357, -0.8131571412086487, -0.691421389579773, 0.21991616487503052, -0.39318063855171204, 0.02994038537144661, -0.4585580825805664, 0.5376919507980347, 0.2192852795124054, -0.4060843288898468, -0.3686610460281372, 0.7125424146652222, -0.3172370195388794, 0.5335442423820496, 0.5094305276870728, -0.2500527501106262, -0.7288140654563904, 0.10816655308008194, -0.36854833364486694, 0.938359797000885, -0.4397248327732086, -0.554914116859436, -0.6670438647270203, -0.874394953250885, -0.5537567138671875, 0.07272332906723022, -0.47167202830314636, -0.2539932131767273, 0.7747732996940613, 0.880434513092041, -0.3744264543056488, 0.3967592120170593, -0.23492592573165894, -0.08130379021167755, 0.7799506187438965, 1.0933579206466675, 0.07481177151203156, 0.5622043013572693, 0.0247954074293375, -0.3645772337913513, -0.30827510356903076, 0.28952234983444214, -0.5966002345085144, -0.3823871910572052, -0.4234352707862854, -0.12173152714967728, -0.19087596237659454, 0.26728394627571106, -0.8823340535163879, 0.6751372814178467, 0.3389216959476471, -0.5524834394454956, -0.14823874831199646, -1.0650689601898193, -0.055011291056871414, -0.5869330167770386, 1.416171908378601, -0.24755951762199402, 0.8506866693496704, -0.7399693727493286, -0.3374391794204712, -0.3410433530807495, -0.699911892414093, 3.696922779083252, 1.644896149635315, 0.7961565852165222, -0.18957965075969696, 0.5185636281967163, 0.5450022220611572, 0.935780942440033, 0.4260410964488983, 0.002587313996627927, 0.718151330947876, -0.2752317488193512, 0.6547107696533203, -0.5383872389793396, -0.4509049952030182, 0.0979871153831482, 0.7650913596153259, 0.10531497746706009, -0.31766176223754883, -0.3251161575317383, -0.8773027658462524, -0.9856599569320679, 0.8302438855171204, 0.1606604903936386, -0.34421131014823914, -0.15570911765098572, -0.968716561794281, 0.028936058282852173, 0.40224555134773254, -0.32610806822776794, 0.3319094181060791, -0.4390484392642975, -0.6251301169395447, 0.6914985775947571, -0.30051445960998535, -0.2834230363368988, 0.07112782448530197, 0.23017628490924835, -0.2597931921482086, -0.17982372641563416, -0.48202794790267944, -0.15919414162635803, -0.7695565819740295, -0.401850163936615, -0.40926700830459595, -0.22769153118133545, 0.43111905455589294, 0.08108425885438919, -0.0054315864108502865, 0.23127219080924988, -0.9574413895606995, 0.71077960729599, -0.9107377529144287, 0.3703031837940216, 0.4500540494918823, -0.6476241946220398, -0.3520002067089081, -0.6874833106994629, -0.7167789936065674, 0.6063222289085388, 0.8145163655281067, 0.30447906255722046, 0.07882624864578247, -0.5371130108833313, -0.37190505862236023, 0.4944392442703247, -0.32379159331321716, 0.7338956594467163, 0.44567543268203735, -0.18154528737068176, 0.375679612159729, 0.12449578195810318, 0.6967167258262634, -0.6976823210716248, -0.05979002267122269, 0.9139655828475952, 0.9911161065101624, -0.5544213056564331, 0.584280788898468, -0.894378662109375, -0.3731059432029724, -0.4852091670036316, -0.1068120002746582, 1.3577255010604858, -0.053390756249427795, 0.5275879502296448, 1.140386939048767, -0.224893718957901, 0.18458397686481476, -1.2382737398147583, 0.6241673231124878, 0.45154818892478943, 0.43278735876083374, 0.46841782331466675, -0.25124484300613403, -0.22031530737876892 ]
{"Title": "A deep learning approach with event-related spectral EEG data in attentional deficit hyperactivity disorder", "Authors": "Dubreuil-Vall Laura, Ruffini Giulio, Camprodon Joan A.", "Abstract": "Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a heterogeneous neurodevelopmental disorder that affects 5% of the pediatric and adult population worldwide. The diagnosis remains essentially clinical, based on history and exam, with no available biomarkers. In this paper, we describe a deep convolutional neural network (DCNN) for ADHD classification derived from the time-frequency decomposition of electroencephalography data (EEG), particularly of event-related potentials (ERP) during the Flanker Task collected from 20 ADHD adult patients and 20 healthy controls (HC). The model reaches a classification accuracy of 88%, superior to resting state EEG spectrograms and with the key advantage, compared with other machine learning approaches, of avoiding the need for manual selection of EEG spectral or channel features. Finally, through the use of feature visualization techniques, we show that the main features exciting the DCNN nodes are a decreased power in the alpha band and an increased power in the delta-theta band around 100ms for ADHD patients compared to HC, suggestive of attentional and inhibition deficits, which have been previously suggested as pathophyisiological signatures of ADHD. While confirmation with larger clinical samples is necessary, these results highlight the potential of this methodology to develop CNS biomarkers of practical clinical utility.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005611"}
10.1101/19007583
[ 0.39011651277542114, 0.5704618692398071, -0.5736549496650696, -0.9449470043182373, 0.13585734367370605, -0.4544428884983063, -0.01833578757941723, -0.020546196028590202, 0.245886892080307, 0.7355650663375854, -0.10913679748773575, 0.020360957831144333, 0.12109836935997009, -0.004179203417152166, -0.39090096950531006, -0.22687095403671265, -0.35274630784988403, -0.1455071121454239, 0.4740384519100189, 0.16587485373020172, -0.1258501410484314, 0.7480168342590332, -1.3330175876617432, -0.1280549168586731, -0.7446910738945007, 0.5120062232017517, 0.8942427039146423, -0.0787053182721138, 1.4465110301971436, 0.5659508109092712, -0.19511067867279053, -0.795639157295227, 0.5188250541687012, -0.3698587417602539, -0.27691715955734253, 0.48695626854896545, 0.4276791214942932, -0.6690374612808228, -0.30235278606414795, -0.32349151372909546, 0.026243051514029503, -0.08809062838554382, 0.8009947538375854, -0.7666012048721313, -0.2546604573726654, -0.04129759222269058, 0.7618856430053711, 0.09620511531829834, -0.030606387183070183, -0.034399718046188354, -0.6455721855163574, -0.15494494140148163, 0.12141313403844833, -0.9173988699913025, -0.01937052421271801, -0.569507360458374, 0.6124529838562012, 0.04205045849084854, -0.3154130280017853, 0.02463671565055847, 0.5383478403091431, -0.31382516026496887, 0.5578581094741821, -0.8063148856163025, 0.23319950699806213, 0.31300246715545654, 0.06154654175043106, -0.27735161781311035, 0.2167358547449112, -0.8009113073348999, -0.40971729159355164, -0.12712235748767853, -0.7405809760093689, -0.7563531398773193, -0.48112380504608154, -0.17841142416000366, 0.1737385243177414, -0.01138080283999443, -0.2896336317062378, 0.3985506296157837, 0.32867321372032166, 0.5445699095726013, 0.19328586757183075, -0.09133908897638321, -0.2896217107772827, -0.3058287799358368, 0.8510841131210327, 0.6361067891120911, -0.36743253469467163, 0.5974589586257935, 0.19338352978229523, 0.5012630224227905, -0.09102848172187805, -0.029754910618066788, 0.7580332159996033, 0.9267029166221619, -0.3546083867549896, -0.012502152472734451, -0.36201366782188416, 0.039095643907785416, 0.48632606863975525, 0.9111734628677368, -0.16169863939285278, 1.270859956741333, -0.7101144790649414, 0.7442434430122375, 0.30030936002731323, -0.8971716165542603, -0.24331682920455933, -0.5519004464149475, -0.031591303646564484, -0.14422181248664856, -0.5665841102600098, -0.471703439950943, 0.19644054770469666, 0.9528332948684692, -0.0649513527750969, 0.7995942831039429, -0.42672157287597656, 0.18110968172550201, -0.6484494209289551, 0.470122754573822, 0.67045658826828, 0.03544880449771881, 0.46082669496536255, -0.23161570727825165, 0.2524729371070862, 0.18625260889530182, -0.3329777121543884, -0.5110961198806763, -0.43670329451560974, -0.7626050710678101, -0.1633089780807495, 0.6128438115119934, 0.3646361529827118, -0.4779837429523468, 0.1413663774728775, 0.4471468925476074, 0.35653600096702576, 0.15411505103111267, -0.22564902901649475, 0.24622656404972076, -0.28623199462890625, 1.5849813222885132, -1.2209941148757935, 0.21193785965442657, -0.5788136124610901, -0.5738101601600647, -0.23506413400173187, -0.4170181155204773, 0.05407068505883217, 0.7808324694633484, 0.14343927800655365, -0.049613628536462784, 0.5169885158538818, -0.15781059861183167, -0.7624111771583557, -0.08374810218811035, -0.14485113322734833, 0.18223600089550018, -0.28355899453163147, -0.18450266122817993, -0.3399558365345001, 0.5445711016654968, -0.280598908662796, 0.39877739548683167, -0.5080939531326294, -0.334816038608551, 0.4499156177043915, -0.5518115758895874, 0.6009092330932617, -0.12477704882621765, 0.052829060703516006, -0.025404833257198334, 0.38987210392951965, 1.5587297677993774, 0.5347944498062134, -0.5025091171264648, 0.337060809135437, 0.20744366943836212, -0.08410608023405075, -0.23597438633441925, -0.33365654945373535, 0.21046195924282074, -0.15762846171855927, 0.45472636818885803, -0.07071122527122498, 0.06186750531196594, -0.26971501111984253, -0.2767748534679413, -0.33886444568634033, 0.3535333275794983, -0.9946388006210327, 0.7773962616920471, 0.16464222967624664, -0.23315003514289856, -0.2573789656162262, 0.1679706871509552, 0.8790194392204285, -0.05903257057070732, -0.5445831418037415, 0.9098432064056396, -0.22134263813495636, 0.20812182128429413, -0.41906580328941345, 1.1366291046142578, -0.09568769484758377, 0.5386241674423218, -1.0080933570861816, -0.25595128536224365, 0.49239492416381836, 0.20929287374019623, -0.38217899203300476, -0.158590167760849, 0.3686623275279999, 0.4001479744911194, -0.7671493887901306, 0.21555787324905396, -0.38634228706359863, 0.07164006680250168, -0.07121273130178452, 0.07078738510608673, 0.6619410514831543, -0.5624131560325623, -0.00952206552028656, -0.09181644022464752, 0.06975790858268738, 0.29807403683662415, -0.7204437851905823, 0.7209641933441162, 0.6069481372833252, 0.8775726556777954, -0.1140800416469574, 0.9196379780769348, 0.9806315898895264, 0.9108166694641113, -0.1520996242761612, 0.12331981211900711, -0.10559488832950592, 0.1702786087989807, 0.16620944440364838, 0.42025700211524963, 0.6580626964569092, 0.978518009185791, 0.20947392284870148, 0.8790072202682495, -0.09679996222257614, 0.14247241616249084, -0.3030603528022766, 0.42435935139656067, -0.1629822552204132, 1.0113193988800049, 1.0183448791503906, 1.099771499633789, -1.4293535947799683, 0.16680406033992767, 0.3094693422317505, 0.32457855343818665, 0.08503975719213486, -0.9837146401405334, -0.23437049984931946, 1.0464106798171997, -0.22149473428726196, -0.4844058156013489, 1.2873823642730713, 0.3873075842857361, 0.4736233055591583, 0.5276421308517456, -0.01686587929725647, -0.74944007396698, -0.7607739567756653, -0.9921700954437256, -0.7335596084594727, -1.04119074344635, -0.8809493184089661, 0.15537457168102264, 0.18234626948833466, -0.32709595561027527, -0.1560266762971878, -0.21803157031536102, -0.4932093024253845, 0.22465085983276367, 0.018227776512503624, 0.486713707447052, 0.8068749904632568, 0.22702468931674957, -1.1372029781341553, 0.19099141657352448, -0.05008765310049057, 0.22748439013957977, 0.19352196156978607, 0.2634246051311493, -0.004645993933081627, -0.7831035256385803, 0.6749950647354126, -0.5960752964019775, 0.2618696689605713, -0.08177072554826736, -0.447116494178772, -0.24027374386787415, 0.12857118248939514, -0.13488367199897766, -0.10498598217964172, -0.3018966615200043, -0.36199790239334106, 0.7092782258987427, -0.34990131855010986, 0.03612925112247467, 1.004705786705017, -0.1439584642648697, -0.3251239061355591, 0.7635673880577087, -0.16440577805042267, 0.06873347610235214, -0.5406231880187988, 0.3166073262691498, 0.2596638798713684, -1.0906522274017334, -0.14683189988136292, -0.5317552089691162, -0.9452411532402039, -0.01580982282757759, 0.5740596652030945, -0.37503716349601746, -0.08272667229175568, 0.4176672399044037, 0.08994967490434647, -1.3547345399856567, -0.05239258334040642, -0.682464063167572, -0.8314228057861328, 0.3404569923877716, 0.4136078357696533, 0.07324438542127609, 0.38015496730804443, -0.06471291929483414, -0.8014391660690308, 0.16196072101593018, -0.33611851930618286, 0.20118777453899384, 0.691636860370636, -0.43007007241249084, 0.33223381638526917, 0.6042234897613525, -0.4334307312965393, 0.11525961011648178, 0.5189616084098816, 0.15764860808849335, -0.12405488640069962, 0.31501975655555725, 0.6391075849533081, 0.2504415512084961, 0.9647933840751648, 0.04916096106171608, -0.6264017224311829, 0.5810431241989136, 0.06805151700973511, 0.29806479811668396, 0.5148104429244995, 0.07170916348695755, 0.08030601590871811, 0.31820839643478394, -0.7125005125999451, 0.32068219780921936, -0.9485337138175964, -0.3675871193408966, 0.24894435703754425, -0.17167209088802338, 0.6464614272117615, -0.520668089389801, 0.6470855474472046, -0.6235234141349792, -0.4130975604057312, 0.39912837743759155, -0.29405733942985535, -0.5459030270576477, 0.5600038766860962, 0.7920758128166199, 1.3328832387924194, -1.1646459102630615, 0.2504971921443939, 0.4975123405456543, 0.25001847743988037, 0.477476567029953, 0.2874302566051483, 0.8653913140296936, 0.06453876942396164, -0.08781613409519196, -0.1630363166332245, -0.5350891351699829, -0.0979832261800766, -0.27143654227256775, -0.6102902889251709, 0.08583394438028336, 0.07676461338996887, -0.7921643853187561, 0.328032910823822, 0.28690412640571594, 0.6896638870239258, 0.08237996697425842, 0.8662170767784119, -0.41553953289985657, 0.5149725079536438, 0.08102674037218094, 0.4833809435367584, 0.5207333564758301, -1.1043668985366821, -0.031596291810274124, -0.8069060444831848, -0.8257332444190979, 0.2658269703388214, -0.8451684713363647, 0.2346566617488861, -0.7684116959571838, -0.15621314942836761, -0.21327409148216248, 0.04729299619793892, -1.2226898670196533, -0.6100407242774963, 0.9050124883651733, 0.2155703902244568, -0.006564070004969835, -0.9616538882255554, 0.4019741117954254, -0.23873817920684814, -0.4414859116077423, 0.3818649649620056, -0.7768217325210571, 0.7469027042388916, 0.3645077049732208, -0.4611494839191437, -0.2560604214668274, -0.7468876242637634, -0.38373297452926636, -0.33723869919776917, -0.08087216317653656, 0.6370314359664917, -0.23455020785331726, 0.7416385412216187, -1.1640218496322632, -0.8216458559036255, -0.1633198857307434, 0.659092366695404, -0.29113221168518066, 0.46898823976516724, -0.08767768740653992, 0.45013484358787537, 0.25629353523254395, -0.16855673491954803, -0.19498571753501892, 0.6706534028053284, -0.8887090682983398, 0.29121261835098267, -0.5580226182937622, -0.14530012011528015, 0.0626872107386589, -0.34157058596611023, -0.3021170496940613, 0.2319159358739853, -0.3233565390110016, -0.42340007424354553, 0.035004448145627975, 0.2573915421962738, 0.02999953180551529, -0.8763203024864197, 0.6428822875022888, -0.28870275616645813, -0.178375706076622, 1.1889559030532837, -1.0066841840744019, -0.6037768125534058, 0.12781818211078644, 0.4127516448497772, -1.2747697830200195, 0.7297455668449402, 0.744389533996582, 0.0049623060040175915, -0.09842757135629654, -0.5374298095703125, 0.6346291899681091, -0.04812704771757126, 0.6942638754844666, -0.33797791600227356, -0.5531768202781677, 0.013612095266580582, -0.7981981039047241, -0.9722540378570557, 0.17649777233600616, -1.3350965976715088, 0.3480648696422577, 0.14713281393051147, -0.3542674779891968, -0.014553953893482685, 0.34472575783729553, -0.3651384115219116, 0.07054714113473892, -0.519734263420105, 0.010313103906810284, 0.7289901971817017, -0.23631761968135834, 0.3421580493450165, -0.5549300312995911, -0.6168971061706543, 0.01972752809524536, 0.02823609858751297, -0.5126551389694214, -0.6869730353355408, -0.5784357786178589, -0.7882648706436157, -0.7036898732185364, -0.18373402953147888, -0.1776551902294159, -0.2111746370792389, -0.9453754425048828, -0.5973127484321594, -0.23331323266029358, 0.11391790956258774, 0.3308654725551605, 0.10767903178930283, 0.9438729286193848, -0.3275173604488373, -0.4581165909767151, -0.9677860736846924, 0.8982182741165161, 0.23717914521694183, -0.1417389065027237, -0.21158024668693542, -0.4995310306549072, -0.4222416579723358, -1.0349931716918945, 0.5092952847480774, -0.6130707263946533, 0.04605948179960251, 0.12038441002368927, -0.21108520030975342, -0.1377469152212143, 0.15180331468582153, -0.5112192034721375, 0.413871705532074, -0.4181555509567261, -0.15742738544940948, 0.31041115522384644, -0.3336440920829773, -0.5366893410682678, -0.44600287079811096, -0.6581334471702576, -0.11656302958726883, 0.9112838506698608, -0.05757997930049896, -0.07582855224609375, 0.3148045241832733, -0.25436362624168396, 0.02032950147986412, 0.6766012907028198, -0.6086528301239014, -0.5370555520057678, 0.4723418354988098, 0.4601594805717468, 0.17760126292705536, -0.4314115047454834, -0.6287729740142822, 0.7945631146430969, -0.3342956006526947, 0.06776193529367447, -0.4824398458003998, -0.6617292761802673, 0.5288055539131165, -0.7562211155891418, 1.1103421449661255, -0.5547385215759277, -0.03405895084142685, 0.32852107286453247, -0.9258438348770142, 0.35357630252838135, -0.25328004360198975, -0.9442104697227478, -0.29133203625679016, -0.5060998201370239, -1.0191514492034912, -0.03712102770805359, -0.16106124222278595, -0.03583183139562607, -0.04918460175395012, -0.18012619018554688, 0.003744107438251376, 0.14530883729457855, 0.5320501327514648, 0.712904691696167, -0.36028027534484863, -0.7939608693122864, 0.14417244493961334, 0.036319807171821594, 0.11106564104557037, 0.1027669832110405, 0.25789642333984375, -0.5595484375953674, 0.37240535020828247, -0.2940160632133484, -0.3877107501029968, -0.6530299186706543, -0.4534343183040619, 0.5217143297195435, 0.6808186769485474, -0.4945935606956482, 0.6658598780632019, 0.5079373121261597, -0.7054838538169861, -0.8007563352584839, 0.08142327517271042, -0.1480642706155777, 0.018726740032434464, 0.7267476320266724, 0.5578123927116394, 0.10740624368190765, 1.057692050933838, -0.04524955898523331, 0.41813012957572937, 0.06918641924858093, 0.5962681770324707, -0.3352088928222656, -0.821914553642273, 0.32744088768959045, 0.39534908533096313, -0.64429771900177, -0.7293011546134949, 0.1658620685338974, -0.03196015581488609, 0.7033059000968933, -0.19040682911872864, -0.18664060533046722, -0.11708594858646393, 0.03016258031129837, 0.8137843012809753, -0.48919856548309326, -0.32748034596443176, -0.3077678680419922, 0.4150705337524414, 0.7085620164871216, -1.198257327079773, -0.25054946541786194, 0.7706463932991028, -0.32994696497917175, 0.3463980555534363, 0.47715339064598083, -0.556703507900238, -0.7539659142494202, -0.3455119729042053, 0.44229209423065186, -0.32611000537872314, -0.2334863841533661, 0.360194593667984, -0.6209847927093506, 0.9362764954566956, -0.31224796175956726, -0.4216633141040802, 0.7340176701545715, 0.5129103064537048, -0.974202036857605, -0.630336344242096, 1.0707827806472778, 0.31218263506889343, 0.23531390726566315, 0.1284952312707901, 0.10583958029747009, 0.36603766679763794, 0.5835109949111938, 0.6316974759101868, -0.23028641939163208, -0.1834743767976761, -0.5758118033409119, -0.9880861043930054, -0.28479814529418945, -0.45376306772232056, -0.35158783197402954, -0.16226354241371155, 0.5547775030136108, -0.6418090462684631, 1.040891408920288, 0.8190068602561951, -0.5388547778129578, -0.35848182439804077, -0.380820095539093, -0.21968074142932892, -0.6809602379798889, -0.17778520286083221, 0.11356800049543381, 0.27045130729675293, 0.08251197636127472, 1.1582163572311401, -0.36152276396751404, 0.33844873309135437, 0.3343712389469147, -0.14941184222698212, 0.05305454134941101, 0.21225392818450928, -0.6504769921302795, -0.09032316505908966, -0.1269277036190033, 0.2487373650074005, 0.11568018049001694, 0.21463273465633392, 0.6677215099334717, -0.9458218216896057, 0.26026836037635803, -0.10891380161046982, 0.35274583101272583, 0.038639020174741745, 0.34186315536499023, 0.09555432200431824, -0.16926100850105286, -0.05320039391517639, -0.117794468998909, 1.0446597337722778, -0.6078383922576904, -1.2253609895706177, -0.6922078728675842, -0.4456501603126526, -0.18012641370296478, 0.2546016275882721, 0.8965553045272827, 0.1713680773973465, 0.21541406214237213, 0.503198504447937, -0.3272514343261719, 0.9263078570365906, 0.25199753046035767, -0.08433731645345688, 0.7252311706542969, 0.01242930255830288, -0.16756805777549744, -1.513763666152954, -0.10503511130809784, 0.9120821356773376, -0.1813550889492035, 1.0465582609176636, -0.024298816919326782, 0.038976117968559265, -0.010374815203249454, -0.3048916459083557, -0.21113550662994385, 0.7388805150985718, 0.051767244935035706, 0.5571886301040649, -0.3513279855251312, -0.20445816218852997, -0.2336474359035492, -0.478188693523407, -0.8656940460205078, -0.3860457241535187, 0.9436632394790649, -0.7605854868888855, -0.04379172623157501, -0.42135173082351685, -0.8517798781394958, 0.2509225010871887, 0.07547605782747269, 0.6588819622993469, 0.29219889640808105, 1.044783353805542, -0.39249593019485474, 0.4376624524593353, -0.19287393987178802, 0.219248965382576, 0.07090499997138977, -0.043784018605947495, -1.0548527240753174, -0.870736300945282, 0.39773449301719666, 1.0938578844070435, 0.3250320553779602, -0.013084654696285725, -0.7564795017242432, -0.23644395172595978, 0.3646186292171478, 0.18877333402633667, -0.2586216330528259, 0.5582891702651978, -0.682083249092102, 0.09182506054639816, 0.23684772849082947, 0.5312525033950806, -0.0384577214717865, 0.885412871837616, 0.08705926686525345, -0.6911243200302124, -0.5651152729988098, -0.43133336305618286, 0.6702422499656677, -0.6890926957130432, 0.9373915195465088, 0.17171989381313324, 0.656238317489624, 0.3106001615524292, 0.26345738768577576, 0.4892289638519287, 1.1235504150390625, -0.5515857934951782, -0.23699107766151428, -0.643945038318634, 0.21218183636665344, 0.31722086668014526, -0.2984960973262787, 0.16085894405841827, 1.0835504531860352, 0.5833694338798523, 0.4991631805896759, -0.14621227979660034, -0.5115916728973389, 0.3198184370994568, 0.41701915860176086, -0.44066545367240906, -0.33427220582962036, 0.09122367203235626, 0.7857998609542847, 0.03734932839870453, -0.5726079940795898, 0.6513597965240479, -0.019362518563866615, -1.5041614770889282, 0.030994096770882607, 0.37908926606178284, 1.0016796588897705, 0.22197683155536652, 0.6846173405647278, 0.33461663126945496, 0.8578383326530457, 0.17546209692955017, -0.02440762333571911, 0.4832693338394165, -0.22987282276153564, 0.25179940462112427, -0.16748562455177307, 0.6108703017234802, -0.6842365264892578, -0.46256205439567566, 0.5076429843902588, -0.3735199570655823, 0.7462733387947083, 0.9941121339797974, -0.05308901518583298, -0.3904954493045807, 0.7991424798965454, 0.11769334971904755, -0.762614905834198, -0.6350255012512207, 0.1870211958885193, -0.3217306137084961, 0.1886460930109024, 0.37192609906196594, 0.02217908203601837, 0.257015585899353, -0.19521282613277435, 0.6788173317909241, 0.15087918937206268, 0.6966347098350525, 0.6036328673362732, -0.2670215666294098, 0.9178484678268433, 0.6153228878974915, 0.314400315284729, -0.06540415436029434, -0.45431116223335266, 0.09028260409832001, 0.5103200078010559, -0.07158084213733673, 0.3639654517173767, 0.013050909154117107, -0.5099002122879028, -1.283357858657837, 0.4753786027431488, -0.2894580662250519, 0.030257301405072212, -0.9344974160194397, -0.13126178085803986, -0.0812951847910881, -0.3019205927848816, -0.681681752204895, 0.07104050368070602, 0.02174317091703415, 0.30623525381088257, 0.4005487561225891, -0.5438249707221985, -0.7066339254379272, 0.22717195749282837, -1.0774120092391968, 0.8514056205749512, -0.6069177985191345, -0.6681460738182068, -0.23552416265010834, -1.1148637533187866, -0.5496498346328735, 0.23362460732460022, 0.520972728729248, -0.5025774836540222, 0.15249061584472656, 0.5481801629066467, 0.05884561315178871, -0.28803616762161255, -0.33591410517692566, -0.8396205306053162, 0.16100570559501648, 0.9946105480194092, -0.8296364545822144, 0.13369420170783997, 0.17129389941692352, -0.040057506412267685, 0.32966896891593933, 0.39534518122673035, -0.13893787562847137, 0.2669709324836731, -0.2572701573371887, -0.04125509783625603, 0.40478047728538513, -0.5449686050415039, -0.7344889044761658, 0.6815949082374573, 0.33193981647491455, -0.6505610942840576, -0.38233447074890137, -0.6693518161773682, -0.32254981994628906, -1.2852479219436646, 1.1896345615386963, -0.5035557150840759, 0.5426040291786194, -0.4095057547092438, -0.6167832016944885, 0.22232937812805176, -0.8154670000076294, 3.9789695739746094, 1.0383987426757812, 0.5975147485733032, 0.03459799289703369, 1.080741047859192, 0.2730165123939514, 0.6906672120094299, 0.189187154173851, 0.46073707938194275, -0.34866881370544434, 0.024788090959191322, 0.06113212928175926, 0.04367019608616829, -0.29979363083839417, -0.3611152768135071, 0.46979933977127075, -0.09897822141647339, 0.3437221646308899, -0.09457537531852722, -0.7420058250427246, -0.7888045907020569, 1.1160715818405151, -0.29067349433898926, -0.03418048098683357, 0.020005224272608757, 0.11691220849752426, 0.056709643453359604, -0.4136437773704529, 0.6741319298744202, -0.3222849667072296, 0.3382338285446167, -0.8655868768692017, 0.4176819622516632, -0.22108125686645508, -0.009453876875340939, 0.7525186538696289, 0.391303688287735, -0.45782291889190674, -0.169988214969635, -0.40111207962036133, -0.39225029945373535, 0.22694186866283417, 0.149954155087471, -0.4061252772808075, -0.5610297322273254, 0.5688608288764954, -0.3091540038585663, 0.05970368906855583, 0.9464712738990784, -0.7618855237960815, 0.22029514610767365, -1.1945788860321045, 0.15585419535636902, -0.5208520293235779, -0.6844703555107117, -0.3474135994911194, -0.8211644291877747, -0.9964495301246643, -0.11602752655744553, 0.12763920426368713, 0.3184138238430023, -0.11912062019109726, -0.0036015051882714033, 0.18228617310523987, -0.07568112760782242, 0.08269224315881729, 0.453070729970932, 0.0824531838297844, 0.3030725121498108, -0.050408221781253815, 0.2459135502576828, 0.17034786939620972, -1.2013283967971802, 0.2548348009586334, 0.8098132610321045, 0.34320971369743347, -0.3206310570240021, 0.7398203611373901, -0.7629849910736084, -0.9434055685997009, -0.17331567406654358, 0.31169837713241577, 0.6144383549690247, -0.3324512243270874, 0.5801596641540527, 0.447047621011734, -0.5348967909812927, -0.2849811315536499, -0.5801842212677002, 0.22145435214042664, 0.7852908968925476, 0.3466881513595581, 0.23784701526165009, 0.2007429003715515, 0.5795761346817017 ]
{"Title": "Predicting Under-five mortality across 21 Low and Middle-Income Countries using Deep Learning Methods", "Authors": "Adegbosin Adeyinka E, Stantic Bela, Sun Jing", "Abstract": "Abstract Objectives To explore the efficacy of Machine Learning (ML) techniques in predicting under-five mortality in LMICs and to identify significant predictors of under-five mortality (U5M). Design This is a cross-sectional, proof-of-concept study. Settings and participants We analysed data from the Demographic and Health Survey (DHS). The data was drawn from 21 Low-and-Middle Income Countries (LMICs) countries (N = 1,048,575). Eligible mothers in each household were asked information about their children and the reproductive care they received during the pregnancy. Primary and secondary outcome measures The primary outcome measure was under-five mortality; secondary outcome was comparing the efficacy of deep learning algorithms: Deep Neural Network (DNN); Convolution Neural Network (CNN); Hybrid CNN-DNN with Logistic Regression (LR) for the prediction of child survival. Results We found that duration of breast feeding, household wealth index and the level of maternal education are the most important predictors of under-five mortality. We found that deep learning techniques are superior to LR for the classification of child survival: LR sensitivity = 0.47, specificity = 0.53; DNN sensitivity = 0.69, specificity = 0.83; CNN sensitivity = 0.68, specificity = 0.83; CNN-DNN sensitivity = 0.71, specificity = 0.83. Conclusion Our findings provide an understanding of interventions that needs to be prioritized, in order to reduce levels of U5M in LMICs. It also demonstrates that deep learning models are more efficacious than a traditional analytical approach. Strengths and limitations of this study The models were tested using a very large data sample, drawn from over 1 million households. The survey utilised a cluster sampling approach and are representative of each country included. Socio-economic, political and cultural differences between the included countries may limit generalisability of the results. The cross-sectional design of the study means we can only infer association and not causality.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19007583"}
10.1101/19005934
[ 0.10779914259910583, 0.2631889283657074, -0.486078143119812, 0.14234650135040283, -0.3695107698440552, 0.27648788690567017, -0.4203687012195587, 0.20956507325172424, -0.059404537081718445, 0.4673273265361786, -0.5179567933082581, -0.557992696762085, 0.2643865644931793, -0.5092768669128418, 0.6551868915557861, -0.2976807653903961, -0.3024808466434479, -0.7070295810699463, -0.5987399816513062, 0.6255784034729004, -0.2986581325531006, 0.4487610459327698, -0.8716943860054016, 0.23800581693649292, -0.6242226958274841, 0.291303813457489, 0.17436957359313965, 0.03524110093712807, 0.9578162431716919, 0.604300856590271, -0.0631428137421608, -0.27413660287857056, 0.6048486232757568, -1.2606183290481567, -0.17959082126617432, -0.05567985773086548, 0.5119705200195312, 0.1079537644982338, -0.7731531262397766, -0.5838226675987244, 0.8631077408790588, -0.9977946877479553, 0.0914594903588295, -0.05320277437567711, -0.7601313591003418, 0.1210731714963913, -0.08208373934030533, -0.009000069461762905, 0.8339104056358337, -0.7776191234588623, -0.18247635662555695, 0.42075207829475403, -0.3579689562320709, 0.08001212775707245, -0.30574870109558105, 0.39904263615608215, -0.3893425166606903, -0.0072503965348005295, -0.2581568956375122, 0.36929792165756226, -0.3115072250366211, 0.06424270570278168, 0.35529035329818726, -0.9463021755218506, 0.8762875199317932, 0.9451467990875244, 0.836788535118103, -0.5815664529800415, 0.21738308668136597, -0.8283133506774902, -0.021337872371077538, -0.2299865186214447, -1.1015549898147583, -1.0421463251113892, -0.7395027875900269, 0.028150206431746483, -0.22702845931053162, -0.164728581905365, 0.09142664074897766, -0.46186313033103943, 0.7651284337043762, 0.7298625111579895, -0.2864168882369995, 0.4711022973060608, -0.7325133681297302, -0.06252536177635193, -0.34658607840538025, 0.24636118113994598, 0.3522493839263916, -0.026108045130968094, -0.017492640763521194, 0.6273441314697266, 0.3678191006183624, 0.3857605755329132, -0.0625099465250969, 0.5062640309333801, -0.8367345929145813, -0.15035611391067505, 0.9069026112556458, -0.9546158909797668, 0.7789698243141174, 0.02002306841313839, -0.6671268343925476, 1.281707525253296, -1.1979793310165405, 0.9174486398696899, 0.5396904945373535, -0.11197419464588165, -0.6826865077018738, -0.23973160982131958, -0.10202391445636749, -0.5267105102539062, -0.40366098284721375, 0.1203295886516571, 0.9222174286842346, 0.44783347845077515, 0.18551604449748993, 0.3391265273094177, -0.071795254945755, -0.39332669973373413, 0.09937272220849991, -0.7984825968742371, 0.3205258846282959, 0.028439687564969063, 0.8023631572723389, 0.5391834378242493, -0.00770221184939146, 0.21327117085456848, -0.6065810322761536, 0.7585414052009583, -0.6342934966087341, -0.7620716691017151, 0.08972162008285522, 0.6370334625244141, -0.557695209980011, -0.06193286180496216, -0.12678289413452148, 0.7782856822013855, 0.19049347937107086, -0.4483170211315155, 0.08455534279346466, 0.20137788355350494, -0.786922037601471, 0.6695130467414856, 0.2186330407857895, 0.3581787347793579, -1.0936747789382935, -0.17549732327461243, -1.160673975944519, -0.1146773025393486, -0.08805662393569946, 1.1093477010726929, 0.17080286145210266, 0.2004186362028122, 0.2980674207210541, 0.22289398312568665, -0.202510803937912, 0.7108871936798096, 0.09649592638015747, -0.6168407797813416, -0.20519720017910004, -0.4168719947338104, -0.4027186930179596, 1.1957224607467651, -0.5804852843284607, 0.5019426941871643, 0.37000206112861633, 0.3097919821739197, 0.3047482669353485, -0.8488332629203796, 0.9421229362487793, -0.3315897285938263, -0.4175742268562317, 0.16544786095619202, -0.4377562701702118, 1.0191092491149902, 0.9595046043395996, -0.4204563498497009, 0.7059861421585083, 0.46398434042930603, -0.060655947774648666, -0.14825278520584106, -0.3946667015552521, 0.37571969628334045, 0.24347823858261108, -0.04189053177833557, -0.00539915356785059, -0.5916046500205994, -0.3179546892642975, -0.14029966294765472, -0.0774131640791893, 0.5474891662597656, -0.4566149115562439, 0.48875391483306885, 0.30941858887672424, 0.7000375390052795, 0.17381933331489563, 0.48535266518592834, -0.4786064028739929, 0.32775652408599854, -0.22945483028888702, 0.7575089931488037, -0.6571828126907349, -0.08256933093070984, -0.3552645146846771, 0.9198846817016602, 0.39084818959236145, 0.5731704831123352, -0.5478903651237488, 0.12589645385742188, 0.03594553470611572, -0.6832665801048279, -0.5614751577377319, 0.9362403154373169, -0.16984230279922485, -0.43132340908050537, 0.1804938167333603, 0.28160664439201355, -0.7582844495773315, 0.7436187863349915, 0.038776300847530365, -0.41234272718429565, 0.8875052332878113, -0.1612527221441269, 0.29603344202041626, 0.8270297050476074, 0.6988946199417114, 0.1999606490135193, 0.18126994371414185, -0.3147190809249878, -0.24769966304302216, 0.9182826280593872, -0.12125758826732635, 1.338281512260437, 0.3032597303390503, 0.11338436603546143, 0.04562132805585861, 0.2991351783275604, 0.7286474704742432, 0.21138685941696167, 0.7967928647994995, 0.48680758476257324, 0.42057645320892334, 0.5383886098861694, -0.31109878420829773, 0.049957774579524994, -0.7296112775802612, 0.4989378750324249, -0.3305000364780426, 0.3313513994216919, 0.1137227863073349, 0.15782441198825836, 0.43527379631996155, 0.5267553925514221, -1.2377300262451172, -0.41542142629623413, -0.4401280879974365, -0.049521297216415405, -0.5008736252784729, 0.039708930999040604, 0.12165161222219467, 0.00322857778519392, -0.503326416015625, 0.29546990990638733, 0.9610190987586975, 1.1794538497924805, 0.5344977974891663, -0.00028779185959137976, 0.07874146103858948, -0.30944254994392395, -0.7181437015533447, -0.7650966048240662, -1.5039793252944946, -0.42741116881370544, -0.6585705876350403, -0.27827444672584534, 0.3793843984603882, -0.41568872332572937, 0.18837906420230865, 0.2984870672225952, -0.04426801577210426, -0.5955927968025208, -0.5230186581611633, -0.18562503159046173, 0.43853476643562317, 0.14059408009052277, -0.24707326292991638, -0.10258302837610245, -0.6170242428779602, -0.5936447381973267, -0.4376888573169708, -0.44842803478240967, -0.5272871255874634, 0.09740721434354782, 1.0491511821746826, -0.6055250763893127, -0.11247901618480682, -0.020655672997236252, -0.15767888724803925, -0.28017568588256836, 0.5229817032814026, -0.34881505370140076, 0.7654628157615662, 0.06553106755018234, -1.2544032335281372, 0.5876010060310364, 0.39386507868766785, 0.19068484008312225, 0.6069555878639221, -0.0015234957681968808, -0.20871776342391968, 0.4304431080818176, -0.41488638520240784, 0.22771963477134705, -0.2706195116043091, -0.23172281682491302, 0.8425154685974121, 0.018417460843920708, 0.30416956543922424, -0.9179338216781616, -0.32163769006729126, 0.4071314334869385, 0.703508198261261, -0.3052240312099457, -0.061155349016189575, 0.007401573471724987, -0.5941168665885925, -1.3198461532592773, 0.24335791170597076, -0.6431871056556702, -1.1064178943634033, 0.0328880213201046, -0.415793240070343, 0.6277594566345215, 0.47429895401000977, 0.1511477679014206, -0.6129604578018188, 0.6664753556251526, 0.19061684608459473, 0.6258573532104492, 0.517648458480835, -0.31844469904899597, 0.5023540258407593, 0.5331857800483704, -0.2995026707649231, 0.11898860335350037, -0.1584816873073578, -0.32157987356185913, 0.0010830763494595885, 0.12263042479753494, -0.11012308299541473, 0.15754039585590363, 0.6762089133262634, -0.19069980084896088, -0.44131216406822205, 0.5699355006217957, 0.6150373220443726, 0.07557546347379684, 0.8332234025001526, 0.5822581052780151, 0.4102252423763275, -0.33245354890823364, 0.160139262676239, -0.26680639386177063, -0.9323025941848755, -0.47633010149002075, 0.6462376117706299, 0.2880105972290039, 0.22489382326602936, -0.11143726110458374, 0.4425329267978668, 0.49113649129867554, -0.41896331310272217, -0.3982970714569092, 0.3427256643772125, 0.7713902592658997, 1.2103667259216309, 0.7040702104568481, 1.9354208707809448, -1.3013074398040771, 0.6270710825920105, 0.5635392069816589, 0.7426512241363525, 0.3799014985561371, -0.20400574803352356, 0.5524889230728149, -0.6741656064987183, 0.37621766328811646, 0.16543695330619812, 0.054070137441158295, -0.2709508240222931, 0.71370929479599, -0.01202717237174511, 0.1923789381980896, -0.7010325193405151, -0.49300798773765564, 0.17160896956920624, 0.7489048838615417, 0.2241530418395996, 0.31841209530830383, -0.025576218962669373, -0.2690697908401489, -0.12104534357786179, 0.47864750027656555, 0.05404120683670044, -0.15824837982654572, -0.6850129961967468, 0.11675335466861725, 0.014431835152208805, 0.2726408839225769, 0.1798575073480606, -0.2784610688686371, -0.5484171509742737, -0.6365698575973511, 0.16507965326309204, -0.15191198885440826, -0.7057328820228577, 0.33039429783821106, 0.2770923674106598, 0.0501677431166172, -0.22231493890285492, 0.3167222738265991, -0.4951215386390686, 0.16718560457229614, 0.2976515591144562, -0.7365373373031616, -0.09300093352794647, -1.1466227769851685, 0.45988965034484863, 0.8555877208709717, -0.8586261868476868, -1.277721643447876, -0.34239235520362854, -0.2849734127521515, -0.5762116312980652, 0.6076074838638306, 0.15752840042114258, -0.6641244888305664, 0.4452146291732788, -0.17643672227859497, 0.09503807127475739, -0.10245635360479355, -0.5319080948829651, -0.9257196187973022, -0.04717673733830452, 0.3484669625759125, 0.902780294418335, 0.32744553685188293, 0.08687230944633484, 0.4875592887401581, 0.949652910232544, -0.5758165121078491, 0.39142104983329773, -0.986362874507904, -0.3858199715614319, 0.12380821257829666, -0.5088765025138855, -0.01560414768755436, 0.38199079036712646, -0.13424231112003326, -0.8612697720527649, -0.7487180829048157, 0.13924816250801086, 0.33734118938446045, 0.26792895793914795, 0.534803032875061, -0.758213996887207, 0.41965606808662415, 0.6083307862281799, -0.6440876126289368, 0.01785011775791645, 0.05286727100610733, 0.3202902376651764, -0.7425960302352905, 0.3764864504337311, -0.6274558305740356, 0.08230788260698318, 0.34594032168388367, 0.0013890124391764402, 0.19617819786071777, -0.34164053201675415, 0.08553048223257065, -0.25899699330329895, 0.13597328960895538, -0.9948681592941284, -0.12273028492927551, -0.750681459903717, 0.30799397826194763, -0.8364673852920532, 0.2530985474586487, 0.470266729593277, -0.5439809560775757, -0.04158753529191017, 0.050223201513290405, -0.11786240339279175, -0.4957398474216461, -0.38529452681541443, 0.18479540944099426, 0.27628862857818604, 0.23348267376422882, 0.5297186970710754, -0.8804287314414978, -1.3172792196273804, 0.17679262161254883, 0.07265458256006241, -0.24396881461143494, -0.4933568239212036, -0.3952937126159668, -0.7308224439620972, -0.01763876900076866, -0.15315864980220795, 0.2569738030433655, -0.12801015377044678, -0.8155041337013245, 0.01666584424674511, -0.028458384796977043, 0.5563327670097351, -0.7263675928115845, -0.15011724829673767, 0.20591787993907928, -0.014376901090145111, -0.7803909778594971, -0.4331955015659332, 0.6138750314712524, -0.36099275946617126, 0.11814812570810318, -0.11198648810386658, -0.740996778011322, -0.8937937617301941, -0.12959031760692596, -0.18018856644630432, -0.6660394072532654, 0.06984101235866547, -0.3419993221759796, -0.017419107258319855, -0.26814472675323486, 0.7799795269966125, -0.07197699695825577, 0.08454685658216476, -0.14961540699005127, -0.6577528119087219, 0.22598882019519806, -0.3532005250453949, 0.2811424434185028, -0.549470067024231, -0.619688868522644, -0.1102619469165802, 0.7506487965583801, 0.28522464632987976, -0.22215738892555237, 0.1283741593360901, 0.48651137948036194, 0.44293221831321716, 0.1164204403758049, -0.2725016474723816, -0.522282063961029, 0.29006335139274597, 0.23233097791671753, 0.09318722784519196, 0.09959687292575836, -1.5625487565994263, 0.49486973881721497, -0.18961136043071747, 0.8901752829551697, 0.05712195858359337, 0.131953164935112, 0.5898579359054565, -0.5526102781295776, 0.6887342929840088, -0.4949510395526886, 0.21800559759140015, 0.466712087392807, 0.31653931736946106, -0.6485627293586731, 0.15135079622268677, -1.5263925790786743, -0.14564953744411469, -1.530771017074585, -1.5471467971801758, 0.7588008046150208, -0.1425156146287918, 0.4213990271091461, 0.022730762138962746, -0.2916688919067383, 0.5772382616996765, -1.0900673866271973, 0.6144871711730957, 0.973213791847229, -1.0067546367645264, -0.4365485906600952, 0.5853217840194702, 0.5034449100494385, -0.034731175750494, 0.5514299869537354, 0.23909839987754822, -0.2850201725959778, -0.7678713798522949, -0.7698920965194702, -0.33050310611724854, -0.9843472838401794, -0.3007444143295288, -0.05619515851140022, 0.41278496384620667, -0.22664940357208252, 0.41018497943878174, -0.06596832722425461, -0.5963826775550842, -0.29782164096832275, 0.35959675908088684, 0.22544831037521362, 0.646274983882904, 0.63816237449646, 0.31099236011505127, -0.12394499778747559, -0.2227354794740677, -0.035009920597076416, 0.10776104778051376, 0.15073993802070618, 0.6032441258430481, 0.3641469478607178, -0.26637542247772217, 0.8143442869186401, 0.4055296778678894, -0.6402080059051514, -0.12325354665517807, 0.4621219038963318, -0.3158832788467407, 0.016736222431063652, -0.026880353689193726, -0.2710525393486023, 0.7835818529129028, -0.40798985958099365, 0.6189981698989868, 0.17168118059635162, 0.6439589858055115, 0.23960831761360168, -0.6702967286109924, 0.056540217250585556, -1.085940957069397, 0.4168849289417267, 0.3029026389122009, -0.2213846892118454, -0.0751914530992508, 0.6360190510749817, 0.5783707499504089, 0.6350662112236023, -0.13396325707435608, 0.4693162441253662, -0.826997697353363, -0.3548502027988434, -0.18561570346355438, 0.28738659620285034, 0.3177017867565155, 0.2780154347419739, -0.02539694309234619, 0.4871252477169037, 0.23153789341449738, -0.4896209239959717, -0.35700881481170654, 0.5136767625808716, 0.9950474500656128, 0.516372799873352, 0.5900322794914246, 0.9130159616470337, 0.8895613551139832, -0.7158438563346863, 0.14714829623699188, -0.48864713311195374, -0.7583997845649719, -1.1398061513900757, -0.23994842171669006, -0.4889194667339325, -0.21292753517627716, 0.22671076655387878, 1.0492020845413208, -0.14932219684123993, -0.631715714931488, -0.6344258189201355, -0.15478254854679108, -0.38299962878227234, 0.22280381619930267, -0.2015133947134018, 0.27049991488456726, -0.8757691979408264, -1.1134551763534546, -0.29724082350730896, -0.6242572665214539, -0.3068247139453888, 0.8481607437133789, -0.2862253189086914, -0.4266010820865631, -0.2972375750541687, 0.47084102034568787, -0.13177864253520966, 0.7059255838394165, -0.5720782279968262, 0.13541670143604279, -0.3676105737686157, 0.6228674054145813, 0.592121422290802, -0.3348739445209503, 1.0311514139175415, -0.6471496820449829, 0.21580390632152557, 0.796429455280304, -0.4535186290740967, -0.6474291086196899, -0.32139453291893005, 0.5617016553878784, -0.23142367601394653, -0.5324791073799133, -0.078638456761837, 0.9593355059623718, -1.2625610828399658, 0.37033554911613464, -0.35212069749832153, -0.10763410478830338, 0.5316644310951233, 0.4122397303581238, 0.6752174496650696, 0.9493077993392944, -0.1720006912946701, 0.43325167894363403, -0.39893636107444763, 0.5383766293525696, 0.9256666898727417, 0.31917625665664673, 0.7329089045524597, 0.412234365940094, 0.2826356291770935, -0.6045933365821838, 0.5980851650238037, 0.035801731050014496, -0.9174963235855103, 0.05690072849392891, -0.026318807154893875, 0.32746800780296326, 0.1252596527338028, -0.028521358966827393, 0.9163814187049866, 0.7554291486740112, 0.2151312530040741, 0.7332769632339478, 0.33040112257003784, -0.17418918013572693, -1.3647302389144897, -0.3481215536594391, -1.4419753551483154, -0.40818360447883606, 0.88221275806427, -0.7698463797569275, -0.275978147983551, -0.912719190120697, -0.5299392342567444, 0.14834587275981903, 0.38627123832702637, 0.3458860218524933, -0.3013310432434082, 0.08092385530471802, -0.11986899375915527, 0.2393769919872284, -0.1930624544620514, -0.4967471659183502, 0.07780138403177261, -0.31043463945388794, -1.0119901895523071, 0.3706265985965729, -0.07424786686897278, 0.3783555030822754, 0.15642565488815308, 0.06543629616498947, -0.5593259334564209, 0.18938039243221283, -0.2982737123966217, -0.2577904462814331, -0.9230519533157349, 0.13920925557613373, -0.8266341090202332, -0.39050722122192383, -0.3738303482532501, -0.15261854231357574, -0.1863677054643631, 0.43700551986694336, -0.580733060836792, -0.41372251510620117, 0.19267693161964417, 0.17410986125469208, 0.7720336318016052, -0.2994120419025421, 0.699831485748291, -0.6967870593070984, 0.2955116629600525, 0.1660754680633545, -0.6747353076934814, 0.19654524326324463, 1.0202476978302002, 0.2525614798069, -0.07133229076862335, -0.2697813808917999, 0.3750755488872528, 0.8797683119773865, 0.49799418449401855, -0.18050220608711243, 0.2482842355966568, 0.2753587067127228, 0.11619814485311508, 0.5158137083053589, -0.24880266189575195, 0.12613871693611145, 0.22982585430145264, -0.09815593808889389, -0.18472172319889069, 0.4697689712047577, 0.7359904050827026, -0.255349725484848, -0.4901890456676483, 0.34987524151802063, -0.7262889742851257, -0.4960586428642273, 0.2967321276664734, 0.010667593218386173, 0.8466156125068665, 0.005525785498321056, 0.0754721537232399, 0.6358798742294312, 0.6559063792228699, -0.2873162031173706, -0.12159614264965057, 0.9413220882415771, -1.0471681356430054, -0.437702476978302, -0.366469144821167, 0.2956548035144806, -0.34118592739105225, -0.4162088632583618, 0.8661728501319885, -0.570351243019104, 0.781872570514679, 0.7055873274803162, -0.8937109708786011, 0.24145765602588654, 0.6270266175270081, -0.014040505513548851, -0.39662855863571167, -0.6602567434310913, -0.3686947822570801, -0.47422152757644653, -0.7194365859031677, 0.6955602169036865, -0.003120073350146413, 0.3897765576839447, -0.296132892370224, 0.3989391028881073, 1.0263798236846924, -0.06492677330970764, -0.14609447121620178, -0.15853829681873322, 0.6727107763290405, 0.564109206199646, -0.22817781567573547, -0.43321409821510315, -0.6516038775444031, -0.27061086893081665, -0.13181139528751373, -0.49999427795410156, 0.21372388303279877, 0.15954746305942535, -0.48856428265571594, -0.024686329066753387, 0.7058966755867004, 0.1285446733236313, 0.0796913355588913, -1.3432947397232056, -0.362822026014328, 0.8079229593276978, -0.11446234583854675, -0.6305645704269409, 0.3281661570072174, -0.24897179007530212, -0.6040741205215454, 0.03594566136598587, -0.7298372983932495, -0.6565686464309692, 0.4630405604839325, -0.6405212879180908, 1.0069211721420288, -0.33628225326538086, 0.44983160495758057, -0.3396257162094116, -1.3008939027786255, -0.28327444195747375, 0.3804666996002197, 0.09800002723932266, -0.3910875618457794, -0.3597399592399597, 0.24875734746456146, 0.6120288968086243, 0.23481275141239166, 0.47051000595092773, -0.08752702921628952, 0.2650349736213684, 0.60572749376297, -0.010306566953659058, 0.30997514724731445, 0.5118687152862549, 0.5495780110359192, 0.38973140716552734, 0.22812698781490326, 0.5999059677124023, 0.26753950119018555, -0.025556953623890877, -1.127243995666504, -0.3029845654964447, 0.12233579903841019, -0.1247035562992096, 0.723726749420166, 0.600726306438446, -0.6671104431152344, -0.5492182374000549, -0.6261270642280579, -0.5748142600059509, 0.1849815547466278, 0.5025511384010315, -0.13057011365890503, 0.2215268909931183, 0.6791797876358032, -0.2318609654903412, 0.48095691204071045, -1.0192725658416748, 3.914734363555908, 1.5730490684509277, 0.8166234493255615, 0.009287810884416103, 1.0752075910568237, 0.46958330273628235, 0.8430689573287964, -0.39053893089294434, -0.31901484727859497, -0.1417243480682373, 0.0920543447136879, -0.059213291853666306, 0.13859151303768158, -0.08040527999401093, 0.9878200888633728, 0.23103903234004974, -0.7415640950202942, -0.12458289414644241, -0.42073854804039, -0.7020075917243958, -0.4617493748664856, 0.9667725563049316, -0.1578785628080368, -0.38327914476394653, 0.4991800785064697, -0.7468718886375427, -0.08285029977560043, -0.14227961003780365, -0.3573487401008606, -0.5645012259483337, 0.24608391523361206, -0.4231431782245636, 0.0016314630629494786, -0.14041903614997864, -0.49609124660491943, 0.44633281230926514, -0.1391291618347168, -0.7081333994865417, 0.12647946178913116, -0.35172247886657715, -0.14679133892059326, -0.49641942977905273, 0.2458961308002472, 0.05377456545829773, -0.054966434836387634, 0.48675140738487244, 0.3559531569480896, 0.41638121008872986, 1.1707191467285156, -0.20565728843212128, 0.8046112060546875, -1.3383744955062866, 0.22190260887145996, -0.3627495765686035, -0.7402859926223755, -0.8952879309654236, -0.016757020726799965, -1.1199443340301514, 0.38816699385643005, 0.10155724734067917, 0.13776227831840515, 0.3223148584365845, -0.5525684356689453, -0.017505628988146782, 0.5749356746673584, 0.5533802509307861, 0.097879558801651, 0.5796641111373901, 0.04051418974995613, -1.2644659280776978, 0.23684148490428925, -1.1129730939865112, -0.9002297520637512, -0.4055580496788025, 0.3859878182411194, 0.06274356693029404, -0.5605800747871399, 1.195920705795288, -0.6934589743614197, -0.8184645175933838, 0.6801393032073975, 0.3010600209236145, 0.4171886444091797, -0.1987169235944748, -0.016250552609562874, 0.5548985004425049, 0.10680528730154037, 0.31943175196647644, -1.5802688598632812, 0.22222073376178741, 0.6603174209594727, -0.17282119393348694, -0.3152821660041809, -0.2908979058265686, -0.12657494843006134 ]
{"Title": "White adipose tissue inflammation is not attenuated by short-term calorie restriction in obese humans", "Authors": "Sbierski-Kind Julia, Mai Knut, Kath Jonas, Jurisch Anke, Streitz Mathias, Kuchenbecker Leon, J\u00fcrchott Karsten, Spranger Leonard, von Schwartzenberg Reiner Jumpertz, Decker Anne-Marie, Kr\u00fcger Ulrike, Volk Hans-Dieter, Spranger Joachim", "Abstract": "Abstract Obesity is a growing global health problem due to its association with chronic low-grade inflammation contributing to metabolic complications. Multiple studies indicate that white adipose tissue (WAT) inflammation can promote type 2 diabetes. However, the function and regulation of both innate and adaptive immune cells in human WAT under conditions of obesity and calorie restriction (CR) is not fully understood yet. Using a randomized interventional design, we investigated postmenopausal obese women who either underwent CR for three months followed by a 4 weeks phase of weight maintenance or had to maintain a stable weight over the whole study period. A comprehensive immune phenotyping protocol was conducted using validated multiparameter flow cytometry analysis in blood and subcutaneous WAT (SAT) (n=21). The T cell receptor repertoire was analyzed by next generation sequencing (n=20) and cytokine levels were determined in SAT (n=22). Metabolic parameters were determined by hyperinsulinemic-euglycemic clamp and then correlated to immune cell subsets. We found that insulin resistance (IR) correlates significantly with a shift towards the memory T cell compartment in SAT. Among various T cell subsets, predominantly CD8 + effector memory T cells were associated with obesity-related IR. Interestingly, T cell receptor analysis revealed a diverse repertoire in SAT arguing against an antigen-driven intra-SAT expansion of effector memory T cells. Surprisingly, neither inflammatory cytokine levels nor leucocyte subpopulations were significantly altered upon CR. Our findings demonstrate the accumulation of effector memory T cells in obese SAT contributing to chronic inflammation. The long-standing effect of obesity-induced changes in SAT was demonstrated by preserved immune cell composition after short-term CR induced weight loss.", "URL": "https://doi.org/10.1101/19005934"}